
Last month, Iranian film director Jafar Panahi was sentenced to five years in prison in absentia. His whereabouts are unknown but he did return to Iran last March, after traveling the world for most of 2025 promoting his brilliant film It Was Just an Accident. The Tehran Revolutionary Court announced the sentence, confiscated his assets, froze his bank account, and instituted a 2-year-travel ban.
To those of us who have loved Panahi, and followed Iran’s persecution of him for almost 20 years at this point, the situation is all too familiar and even more infuriating. Panahi has been imprisoned repeatedly, tortured, banned from making films (although the ban never stopped him), imprisoned again, smuggling notes out of Evin Prison to be read on the stage of major film festivals, his passport revoked, his friends and colleagues imprisoned just for working with him … these people will never stop. Over the years, I have had to come to terms with the fact that they may end up killing him. They KEEP doing this, and the world KEEPS telling them how awful they are, demanding his release, and then they release him, adding all of these bans on his head … travel bans, banned from talking to the press, etc.
The International Coalition for Filmmakers at Risk put together a statement in Panahi’s defense, condemning the sentence – which I signed.
In 2022, he went to the prosecutor’s office in Tehran to inquire about the fates of his filmmaker friends, including the wonderful Mohammad Rasoulof. Panahi was arrested then and there. They were rounding up a lot of big name artists that year, part of an overall crackdown – which intensified after the murder of Mahsa Amini in September, the spark that lit the conflagration of the Woman Life Freedom protests which engulfed the entire country … and continues to this day. A nationwide revolution. And I’m sure Panahi knew they would arrest him if he went to ask about his imprisoned friends but he went anyway.
That was a long terrible year for those of us who have Panahi on our radar. In 2023, while in prison, he went on hunger strike. Because of his high profile, word always gets out whenever anything happens to him, and the entire world of filmmakers, festivals, film lovers, erupted in outrage. He was released a couple days later. This was what scared me: Panahi is so famous. If they’re arresting him, even though there has been an international outcry every time he’s had any trouble, since his first arrest and filmmaking-ban in 2010 … then they really just don’t care about perception anymore. The arrest of actress Taraneh Alidoosti was shocking in a similar war, it seemed a really ominous harbinger of just how much they do not give a shit about public opinion.
In 2023, while Panahi was still in prison, the New York Film Critics Circle gave him a special award. I wrote the essay for the program. I posted it here.
After being released from prison, Panahi immediately made It Was Just an Accident, filming it in secret, as all of his films have to be. There were no call sheets, nothing in writing. You’ll notice – if you’ve seen the film, and if you haven’t then you must – most of the film takes place in or around a van. Panahi could be hidden inside. Actors would be notified the night before where they’d have to show up the next day. Every single person who chooses to work with him – knowing the consequences – is a hero. Things were starting to happen, things seemed different this time. Pictures posted on his Instagram showed him at an airport, smiling with his wife. Leaving Iran for the first time in 2 decades. Suddenly, he was everywhere, going to film festivals he hadn’t been able to attend since the early ‘aughts. It Was Just an Accident racked up awards everywhere. It is a masterpiece. Only four directors in history have won the top prizes at all three of Europe’s most prestigious film festivals, Cannes, Berlin, and Venice: Henri-Georges Clouzot, Michelangelo Antonioni, Robert Altman, and Jafar Panahi.
I never ever thought I’d get a chance to meet this man, my favorite director, as well as a moral and ethical hero of mine. How could I meet him when he was on house-arrest, essentially, in his own country? And yet … miracles sometimes happen. In January 2026, I met him at the New York Film Critics Circle dinner. He attended because we awarded him Best Director for It Was Just an Accident. He speaks no English and traveled with an interpreter. I stood behind him on the red carpet and have never felt how I felt in that moment.

My feeling wasn’t just admiration, and it wasn’t about being star-struck. I have spent so much time loving his work, yes, but also being upset and furious on his behalf, worrying about his health, hosting an “Iranian Film Blogathon” – in the days when “blogathons” were a thing – following the news of what his country is doing to him … and there he was. I did have a minute-long conversation with him through his lovely interpreter, where I basically said, “I am a member of this critics group, and I want to thank you for your work and I am also just so so happy you are here with us tonight.” Something like that. I held it together. He was kind and lovely. But he has nerves of steel.

During his speech, Panahi said he would be arrested immediately upon returning to Iran. We had all read the news. Of course the option to just … not go back … exists, but Panahi said he had to return. There was no other choice. Iran is his home. He must be there.
We have learned that public outcry has worked in the case of Panahi, Alidootsi, and other high profile artists. Just remember all of the NOT famous people sweltering in prison, being tortured, shot, disappeared, whose only crime was speaking out against the regime. But … things are changing now. There’s the war going on, which I, as an American, wholeheartedly condemn and despise. There has been the (attempted) quashing of Woman Life Freedom, one of the more inspiring revolutionary movements I have ever witnessed. And now … they’re coming after Panahi again, because they – there’s always a “they” – just cannot STAND it that someone is not afraid of them, cannot STAND it that an artist refuses to silence himself, they cannot stand that they instituted a 20-year ban on filmmaking and … Panahi’s response was to start filming movies in secret and smuggling them out of the country on USB drives.
They – there’s always a they – win battles. They will NEVER win this war. NEVER.
The people at the top are all the same. We know their playbook. They never deviate. Because they’re cowards and they’re dumb and they hate freedom of expression. They want to actually OWN us. We see this. It’s so clear. We must refuse to give them what they want. In the same way the girls in Iran so courageously took to the streets, whipping off their hijabs, setting them on fire, singing and dancing, raising their middle fingers at the old mullahs who can’t stand freedom, who loathe girls being free. The Iranian girls and women basically just STOPPED obeying the rules. Many have been killed for participating in these protests. Jafar Panahi has been given multiple bans on film-making. “You cannot make films for 20 years.” A devastating blow. But … he kept making films in secret. Risking his life every time.
This is a terrible situation and I am not trying to paint him as an inspiring hero of resistance. I mean, he IS, but I am mostly angry that he even HAS to be. I hope I would show even a quarter of the courage he has shown if I were ever to find myself in such a situation.








































