I had what I call a “situational crush” on Kyle. I do that sometimes, if I’m bored and need to liven up my daily routine a bit. I’ll create a random crush on, oh, the guy who gives me my coffee every morning. I look forward to seeing him, have some banter, go on with my day. I will also create a situational crush if I’m having a great time doing something out of the ordinary. Being out of town in a show, for example. Sometimes the situational crush will blossom into something significant – but more often than not, it’s something to pass the time in a more pleasant way. I bet a lot of actor marriage breakups begin as “situational crushes”. Okay, I am making a movie in Mozambique, I am out of my routine for 4 months, home is far away, I am SO busy, so I’ll have a situational crush on my co-star. If you’re famous and married, the situational crush can swerve into a tabloid debacle.
My friend David, when I tell him some weird thing happened to me, he often says, “Sheila, your life is a literary conceit.” This one second of time with Kyle is an example. You have a stupid crush and life is ordinary, and suddenly, out of nowhere, the two of you are, for just a second, the leads in a torrid pre-Code movie.
I don’t want to make this build-up too much. However:
The moment I am moving towards lasted about a second. But if you’re going to have a situational crush, if you’re going to decide to focus your ten minutes of free time a day on some random person, then it might as well culminate in a moment of total – and almost unbelievable – perfection. A moment of, dare I say it, art.
I have always made my love affairs into art. This is a bad habit. Like Meryl Streep says in Postcards from the Edge, “I want life to be art.” So do I. This has led me down some pretty gnarly treacherous paths, because some random guy becomes a piece of art, even if he’s trash. What was weird about Kyle is it wasn’t a love affair. It was a situational crush, activated for just ten minutes a day.
What Kyle did to me, in that one second of time, was art. “Art”, in its purest form, is perfect. You look at it and, even if it overwhelms you, you know nothing needs to be added.
This is what I’m leading up to. We didn’t share a passionate kiss or even a relationship: all of these things may be fun and exciting, but they usually contain flaws. What I am leading up to has no flaws.
I guess that’s why I remember Kyle. I’ve had a million situational crushes – I had a situational crush on my New York bus driver, whom I saw every day, more than I saw my own family, and I’d sit in the seat behind him, and we’d chat, and it gave a shimmer to my day, which was probably a boring day filled with obligations. 99% of my situational crushes I don’t remember, but I will ALWAYS remember Kyle because of the culminating moment. I couldn’t have planned it or, hell, even imagined it, not even in a fantasy. I thought afterwards, “…Did that really happen? Who else do such things happen to? It FEELS like it’s just me.” Maybe because I want life to BE art. Maybe it’s a mindset. I don’t know.
Aspects of the situational crush
Situational crushes don’t need to go anywhere. Situational crushes don’t need to be spoken about or even acknowledged. In fact, it’s better if they aren’t. Just enjoy the flirting as the friendly guy at the food truck hands you a taco. Situational crushes are helpful if you are bruised from heartache, and you don’t feel ready to risk a REAL crush again. There is very little risk in the situational crush, if you do it right. A situational crush can remind you, that you are capable of having those feelings again, but for now it’s without the risk. Without the risk is my favorite part.
Sometimes people THINK their crush is situational, they THINK it can be contained to five minutes a day, but then they ride a roller coaster of emotion, and end up sobbing drunkenly at a party because the situational crush is now making out with a Goth girl, and what do you do with your crushy feelings?? (Not that I’ve done that or anything.)
You can mistake a situational crush for the real thing, especially if you’re in a vulnerable spot. You can mistake the flirty-flirts for “soulmate material”. This is the danger with the situational crush. You can get CRUSHED by the situational crush, which, of course, defeats the purpose.
Situational crushes, in other words, are not for amateurs.
I have it down to a science. I don’t know how to do many things but I know how to do THIS. I have slipped up a couple of times, but I treated those failures as learning experiences. Like: Oh. Okay. I thought he was my soulmate, when really I’m just bored right now and I mistook the friendly Irish bartender for true love. (Not that I’ve done that or anything.)
Enter Kyle
By the time I met Kyle, I was an expert in this fine art. I knew what I was doing as I was doing it. The crush was deliberate: I decided to have it. I was working on my grad school thesis project, consumed by it, and I wasn’t in love with anyone or dating anyone. I felt the tell-tale yearning for a situational crush, just to provide a brief escape in my busy days.
And along came Kyle, the backstage stagehand. After our first conversation, I knew I had found my crush for the run of the show. I had been in the cloister of grad school for three years. I knew all the guys and they were either gay or I was not interested in them, or vaguely disgusted by them, or full of hatred for them, or they were involved with someone. I had my sometimes FWB, but I know how to do those too. I didn’t have a crush on HIM. He was one of my best friends in school, and school was stressful, so sometimes we would hook up, and honestly he saved my sanity in a lot of ways. We are still friends.
My interest in Kyle had no GOAL. It was the equivalent of seeing my high school crush in the hallways on my way to class, and having a brief amusing conversation, with no expectation that we would someday be Homecoming King and Queen. Or Jack and Diane. Or Brenda and Eddie. Seeing him in the hallways was something to look forward to, innocent, with nothing else put on it.
When we reach adulthood, we forget how to do this. We forget how to just accept whimsy for the transitory thing it usually is.
Kyle wore baggy battered jeans, Buddy Holly glasses, and Doc Martens. He wore a beat-up leather tool belt, and he jingled and clanked when he walked. He looked a little bit like my idol, Harriet the Spy.

Kyle was the go-to man for any problems backstage.
“Kyle, I need to cross by back here in the dark. Can I get some glow tape?” Kyle whips the glowtape off his belt, bites off a strip, and sticks it along the floor in the darkness.
“Kyle, I need to throw open this door when I enter but I always have to jerk at it!” Kyle whips out a small oil can.
“Kyle, I need brain surgery.” Kyle whips out a scalpel and cuts open the actress’ head.
He could do ANYthing. Every tool he needed was on that belt.
Put a pin in this because it will be important later.
Kyle was blurpy, the epitome of “my type”. I do not believe he ever darkened the doors of a gym. He was sturdy and strong as hell. He could lift entire flats by himself, he could carry an entire bed on his back (I saw him do it), but he would never be seen pumping iron somewhere. He was pale and pasty, and he had a shock of messy curly blonde hair. He looked like a cross between Harriet the Spy and …

In other words, my ideal type.
Kyle was from Alabama and had a beautiful drawling accent. He was WILD after-hours. He would show up at cast parties, having exchanged his battered jeans for tight black leather pants. He would dance so hard the sweat would literally fly off his golden locks. He would do shots of tequila in the kitchen with the Russian actress who weighed 100 pounds and had a Brazilian wax (we shared a dressing room, that’s how I knew). I was fine with all this because my situational crush only existed for ten minutes a day, backstage at the theater.
Let it just be said here, so we’re clear: I was so all-consumed with my project that I didn’t want to get all involved in a love affair, and he might not have wanted to anyway. I wasn’t trying to make anything happen. I didn’t give him a second thought outside of our interactions. I knew I was going through a once-in-a-lifetime thing: my thesis project!! And it was, to put it mildly, a struggle to make it all happen. But I threw myself into fully enjoying Kyle’s flirting as he staggered by underneath an armoire.
Backstage ritual with Kyle, my situational crush
I arrived at the theatre early. I set my hair in a leisurely manner. I put on my makeup, eyelashes, dress, alone in the dressing room, before actors’ call time. I would then go into the shadowy blue-lit backstage area, to avoid the rest of the actors who were by now arriving. This was my quiet meditative time.
This was Kyle’s quiet time as well. He had nothing to do until the show started. All glow tape was in place. All door hinges oiled. All beds carried to their proper spot. All brain surgery performed. He was a dark hovering presence backstage. I liked having him there. Once the curtain went up, this man would be busier than ANY of the actors, moving furniture into place, striking props, sliding flats from here to there, trouble-shooting anything that came up.
This will be important later.
He was used to theatre people. On the first night, he whispered to me through the blue light, “Break a leg. Is it okay if I talk to you?”
Stomach fluttery crushy-crush. “Sure. It’s okay. We’ll have to stop talking in ten minutes though.”
He nodded. He understood.
It became our “thing”: I would come backstage before anybody else. I sat in the blue light, wearing my costume, and he would stand in front of me, fidgety in his blurpy body, cracking jokes to make me laugh. He flirted with me, too. He would silently show me his new “dance moves” and I would whisper at him, “Please stop …” because I was afraid I would laugh-cry my fake eyelashes off. He was so unselfconscious. I loved that about him.
Then, I needed to just do my actress thing so I would whisper, “We have to stop talking.” And just like that, he would disappear, an experienced stagehand. Actors have their process and he has his. It takes both sides to make the show happen. Stagehands double-check props, murmuring to the stage manager on the headset, stepping around the actors doing their silent thing.
This was our ritual: A whispered ridiculous conversation, bathed in the dark-blue and midnight-black of backstage. Our skin glowed blue, the lenses of his glasses reflected bluely at me, his pale glowworm skin taking on a bluish tone, the rest of his body swathed in blackness. He would make me laugh. This kept me loose. I enjoyed the ten minutes of innocent banter.
It’s funny the things you remember.
Two Costumes
I was playing Maggie in Arthur Miller’s After the Fall, based on his marriage with Marilyn Monroe. I did a shit-ton of work on it. By the time we opened, all I needed to do was be present in the moment. There was a headspace I needed to be in. I couldn’t just roll into the theatre half an hour before curtain. Or maybe I could have. It would have been interesting to try it, but where I was at at that stage in my development, I needed prep time and quiet time.
I had two costumes for the role.
This will be important later.
My first costume was a skintight champagne-colored dress, made of a thick almost upholster-y fabric, and zippered up the back. I wore white kid gloves and a head scarf. Jewelry was involved. I wore cat-eyed sunglasses. The costume was perfect, and based on a couple of Sam Shaw’s beautiful photos of Marilyn Monroe. I showed those photos to the costume designer, and they executed my version of it brilliantly. The dress did most of the work. I put it on and I felt like Maggie.
My second costume was simpler: big striped men’s pajamas. This scene was Maggie unglued at 3 a.m., wearing her sugar daddy’s pajamas. Drunk in a hotel room. She has no one to call. She doesn’t even have her own pajamas. The original costume sketches by the costume designer showed a revealing negligee, but I thought: No. She is a lonely little girl, swimming in pajamas that are too big for her. Men’s pajamas, which give her a kind of pathetic air, suggesting that she may be famous but the casting couch is still nearby. I thought men’s pajamas would point to that subtext.

I had a 12-second costume change between these two scenes. The change happened in the front lobby of Circle in the Square Downtown and I was assisted by two members of the costume crew. We did a couple of costume-change rehearsals, using a stop-watch. We had it down to a science. I would exit from my first scene and then stand totally still as they took the dress off and put the pajamas on. Everyone had a job. Eileen would unzip my dress, and she would pull it down, whipping it off me in one movement. Meanwhile, Anne would squat beside me, holding open the pajama legs, scrunched up, so I could just step my foot into the hole and she would pull them up. At the same time, Eileen tossed the dress aside and held open the pajama top. My arms were already up and out, so she could put my arms through the sleeves. I buttoned it myself, and while I did this, Anne took off my earrings. Then I would hurry onstage for the next scene. 12 seconds!
I needed to provide this set-up, because Kyle is about to make his entrance, transformed from Clark Kent into Superman, looming in a literary conceit above Bleecker Street.
A split-second of pure perfection
Since it was a situational crush and I recognized it as such, I didn’t behave like a lovesick girl around him. I didn’t hover near him at a party, hoping to talk to him. I didn’t angst about the Russian girl. I didn’t think: “Maybe this can go somewhere!” (Good thing I didn’t, because it turns out the entire time we had our blue-lit flirty-flirt, the entire run of the show, he was having a hot sweaty love affair with someone which actually turned into a long-lasting relationship.) I just enjoyed the distraction.
However: the whole thing culminated in a moment of almost cinematic perfection that I still think about it sometimes. Because … does this sort of thing happen to other people? How many people EVER get to experience such a moment with a crush? Or, hell, with anyone? This could ONLY happen in the theatre, where fantasy and reality don’t just blend, they are the same.
The show was up and running.
And one night, after the first scene, I came rushing off into the empty lobby, where Eileen and Anne stood, as always, frozen like statues with my next costume in hand. I stood in position. Eileen went to unzip my dress, and immediately: The zipper stuck. Instant terror. We only had 12 seconds. I felt the zipper stuck, we all felt it. I heard Eileen murmur, “Shit” and this was enough to send flood-waves of panic reverberating through the lobby. The dress was so tight I could not pull it up over my head. I was trapped in my champagne-colored dress.
What follows feels like it took 15 or 20 seconds, but it was probably just 2 or 3. So much happened and I remember it all. When Eileen murmured “Shit” everything escalated. We were in big trouble. The next scene started with me, alone onstage in the pajamas. I couldn’t be late. How could I get out of this dress? Eileen kept yanking at the zipper. I am ashamed to admit it but I was whimpering: “ohmigod ohmigod … get it off me … ” I was wriggling around, the music out front was nearing my entrance cue. I was in panic mode: Someone save me!! I MUST GET ONSTAGE.
There were other actors in the lobby waiting to make their entrances and they sensed the intensity of the crisis, and they all moved back, watching nervously.
The zipper-struggle felt interminable. Anne gave up her squat-position and joined Eileen behind me, looking at the zipper, trying to yank it out of its stuck position. I have never felt so trapped.
At that moment, Kyle entered the lobby in the middle of his scene change. He was loaded down with furniture. Eileen hissed, “Kyle! Her dress …”
In a flash, Kyle put down all the objects, and was there behind me, inspecting the problem. Eileen whispered, “The zipper’s stuck.”
With no thought, no hesitation, Kyle held onto my arm and whispered, “Hold still, baby.” (Baby? What?) He whipped his retractable razor off his belt. I heard the click of the razor and Kyle whispered again, “Don’t move.” Jesus, suddenly the situational crush was the most erotic moment in the history of my life, and I am not even exaggerating. I stopped wriggling and held perfectly still. He held his hand on me, basically to anchor me in place, and with his other hand, in one quick movement of his wrist, he sliced the dress off of me.
Let me reiterate: Kyle, the guy I’d been crushing on, sliced my dress off with a razor blade. And didn’t cut me. There was risk involved. He could have nicked me with a razor-sharp … razor. Steady hand, a sure cut.
I think lots of people enjoy simple crushes, with a bartender they see once a week, or a co-worker who comes in from out of town once a month, the guy at the corner deli who sells the newspaper. How many people, though, have been cut out of their dress with a razor BY their crush? Freakin’ Rhett Butler didn’t cut Scarlett O’Hara out of her dress!
When he was done slicing off my clothes, he stepped back, giving space to the costume crew, my dress came off, I stood there – in front of my crush – in my bra and shapewear in the middle of the lobby – and on went the pajamas and I raced onstage, a second after my entrance cue. After the show, I went and found Eileen and Anne and we collapsed in each others’ arms, re-living the trauma, but congratulating ourselves for having made it through.
Kyle and I laughed about it at the cast party later, and we re-enacted it five times, regaling everyone with the story, telling it in tandem (“Okay – now you tell YOUR part!!”).
Let’s backtrack: Kyle cut along the seam of the dress. A perfectly straight-line. All the costume designer would have to do to fix it was put the dress under the needle and sew the seam back up. No messy tear. No ripped-apart zipper. He didn’t slice down the zipper line which would have also required a massive reconstruction. Kyle, in a fevered moment of urgency, with a wriggling actress under his hands, (“Hold still, baby” my God, yes SIR), had the presence of mind to not cut into the fabric. He had five million things going on in his head at one time. He was in the middle of a set change and he had three other things to do before his own job was complete. But he was born ready for any emergency. He understood the urgency but he also had in his head the costume designer’s priorities. In a moment of high stress, his brilliant brain considered everything.
Like I said in the beginning, this is not a story with a big finish. This is a story about a breathless moment of erotic perfection, and not meant to last … but the reverb remains.
I was not ever hurt by Kyle. My crush was contained, as it needed to be in order for me to enjoy it. No big deal. Run-of-the-mill.
But suddenly, in one shimmering alive moment – in the most matter-of-fact, gentle and yet FIRM way possible – he whispered in his soft commanding Alabama accent, “Hold still, baby”, and then sliced off my dress with a razor blade.
If you’re going to indulge in a situational crush, you might as well choose one who can do that!
I want life to be art. And in that moment it was.
2026 thoughts
Honestly, I had forgotten all about this. So it was so fun to re-claim this memory, of a random Alabaman holding me still and cutting my dress off. Now I get to be happy all over again that when I had a crush on someone, this is what ended up happening. A once-in-a-lifetime event.
From the archives archive
Chicago: The Cold Extreme (2004)
A Sea-Level Kind of Girl (2006)
There Was Already Something a Little Off… (2003)
“Go Ask Sheila.” (2010)
How We Talked (2011)













