{"id":2505,"date":"2005-02-25T10:22:00","date_gmt":"2005-02-25T15:22:00","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/www.sheilaomalley.com\/?p=2505"},"modified":"2024-10-27T17:59:31","modified_gmt":"2024-10-27T21:59:31","slug":"grokking-stalin-and-the-murder-of-kirov","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.sheilaomalley.com\/?p=2505","title":{"rendered":"&#8220;Grokking&#8221; Stalin And The Murder of Kirov"},"content":{"rendered":"<p><iframe style=\"width:120px;height:240px;\" marginwidth=\"0\" marginheight=\"0\" scrolling=\"no\" frameborder=\"0\" src=\"\/\/ws-na.amazon-adsystem.com\/widgets\/q?ServiceVersion=20070822&#038;OneJS=1&#038;Operation=GetAdHtml&#038;MarketPlace=US&#038;source=ac&#038;ref=tf_til&#038;ad_type=product_link&#038;tracking_id=thesheivari-20&#038;marketplace=amazon&#038;region=US&#038;placement=0195317009&#038;asins=0195317009&#038;linkId=DOVK3M6AEDBBBSAE&#038;show_border=true&#038;link_opens_in_new_window=true\"><br \/>\n<\/iframe><\/p>\n<p>\n<i>Update:<\/i> I just realized that my description of 3 a.m. anxiety may obscure the rest of the post, which would be unfortunate.  So if you want to skip over that part to get to the Stalin stuff, feel free.  You know me &#8230; I always have to set up everything in some sort of emotional context.<\/p>\n<p>Okay, so onward:<\/p>\n<p>Yesterday the term &#8220;grokking&#8221; was explained to me, in detail, here on this blog.  Beautifully done.  Here are some of the definitions provided for me by readers:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>&#8220;Grok&#8221; basically means &#8220;to understand,&#8221; although the term is intended to be somewhat more imprecise than &#8220;to understand.&#8221; If you have a feeling for a concept, if it makes intuitive sense to you, even if you might not necessarily be able to articulate your understanding, then you grok it.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>Another one:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>To grok is to understand something beyond the strictures of language, to see that something truly and in its entirety.<\/p>\n<p>Astronomical distances might be a good example. We all understand that space is big, you might think it&#8217;s a long way to the chemist, but that&#8217;s just peanuts&#8230; (sorry)<\/p>\n<p>As I was saying, we understand space is big. But when you really think about, truly comprehend those distances and it takes your breath away, you&#8217;ve grokked it.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>Hmmm.  Fascinating.  And here&#8217;s more:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>Grok technically means the sharing of water. You&#8217;ll want to remember that Mars, where it originates, is a desert planet; water-sharing is deep sharing, against odds. So to grok something is more or less to really, really get it. Like walking a mile in the same shoes.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>I think I grok grokking now.<\/p>\n<p>I had a terrible time getting to sleep last night.  Tossing, turning, snow blowing against my window, I could hear it, and the wind &#8230; and my mind was restless and uneasy.  I hate that.  No matter how tired I was, I couldn&#8217;t slow my mind down, and I kept thinking of things I needed to get done, things I had left undone, and then finally &#8230; at around 3 a.m., it got all existential and huge, like:  I HAVE MADE NOTHING OF MY LIFE.<\/p>\n<p>I don&#8217;t know if any of you guys out there torture yourselves like this, and I really try not to, but sometimes, at 3 a.m. (the &#8220;wee smas&#8221; as the old Scottish saying goes) these thoughts come.  Now I can recognize the signs.  I start to toss, and turn, going over: &#8220;okay, I need to get that done &#8230; I need to get THAT done &#8230;&#8221; (usually trivial things, like pay bills, whatever).  Then it starts to magnify:  &#8220;Okay, I need to accomplish THIS by this time next year &#8230; and I need to accomplish THAT by the time I&#8217;m 40&#8230;&#8221;  which very quickly devolves into:  &#8220;I have made nothing of my life.  I suck.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>So what does one do when these horrible thoughts come?  You can do what I did last night.  Get up, turn on the light, have a glass of water, wash your face, curl up in your chair, and read a couple chapters of Robert Conquest&#8217;s <i>The Great Terror<\/i>.   Sure.  Makes total sense.  You want to calm down, relax enough to get to sleep?  Immerse yourself in the horror of the Soviet Union in the 1930s.<\/p>\n<p>I have read two of Conquest&#8217;s other books (on the famine in the Ukraine, and then his small biography of Stalin, can&#8217;t remember the name) &#8211; and always held off on this one, even though I was drawn to it.  It seemed like a huge commitment.  This is not the first book I have read on this topic.  As a matter of fact, it&#8217;s been one of my raving interests since I first learned about the &#8220;Soviet Union&#8221;.  Maybe it all started from reading <i>1984<\/i> in high school.  But also, I grew up in the 1970s, 1980s &#8230; when the Soviet Union was still the bogeyman.  Totalitarian regimes, state-sponsored horror, atomized societies, show trials, made-up &#8220;confessions&#8221; &#8230; I have an entire bookcase in my apartment filled with book after book on these topics.  It&#8217;s not just the history that fascinates me, although that&#8217;s a huge part of it.  It&#8217;s something else.  Something deeper.  The human element, I suppose.  What happens to human beings when they live under such regimes &#8230; and also &#8230; how does it even happen in the first place?  The beginnings of the horror in Cambodia, the beginnings of the horror in Russia, etc.  Where are the seeds of this stuff?  That&#8217;s the hook, for me.<\/p>\n<p>Remember in <i>1984<\/i> &#8211; when he gets a hold of the secret book?  That explains how the regime works?  And what terrified me to my core in high school when I first read it &#8230; and what is reflected to me, again, in Robert Conquest&#8217;s book &#8230; is that underneath all of the nice this-will-make-society-better rhetoric (which people in the West were fooled by and <i>still <\/i>are fooled by)  is a naked hunger for personal power.  The secret book in <i>1984<\/i> says something like: &#8220;and this is the greatest secret of all.  This is what no one will admit to.  Everything else (all the theories and pontificating) is just a smokescreen for what is the real point of this whole thing:  One human being who will be the will of the state.  That is the point.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>People continue to apologize for all of this, make excuses, they say that Stalin was a bad example of Communism, that true socialism still hasn&#8217;t been seen on the earth yet, and that the one bad example of Stalin shouldn&#8217;t spoil the theory.  I think this is a disgusting attitude.  I think that what we saw in the USSR was communism, in all its unbridled unmasked awfulness.  Theory schmeory &#8211; what happened there is not to be written off as &#8220;a mistake&#8221; or &#8220;Stalin&#8217;s fault, not the fault of communism.&#8221; There is no excuse for it.  What we saw was not the result of one man&#8217;s excess.  It was the natural result of the theory behind Communism.  Orwell goes a bit farther in <i>1984<\/i> and says that the leaders, the proponents of communism and socialism, knew this all along.  I find this a very compelling theory, and one that makes a lot of sense, historically.  If you only want to look at this stuff abstractly, as theories, fine.  Be my guest. Live in a utopia. But if you look at the record, I honestly do not know how you can maintain the fiction that communism is good, socialism is still possible, and Stalin just happened to be a bad seed.<\/p>\n<p>Orwell says (in the secret book in <i>1984<\/i>), and Conquest says:  The theory of Communism is <i>actually <\/i>this:  &#8220;Power needs to be in the hands of the very very few.  Fool the people into thinking it will be about them, that this revolution is for them, and keep it a state secret what we really want &#8230; but the point is to hold onto power.&#8221;  The secret was to never let on that that was what they were doing, to keep up the fiction, to maintain the pose that this was for &#8220;the workers&#8221;, etc, when all along, it was NEVER for the workers.<\/p>\n<p>All of this lying and self-deception is conscious, as well.  That&#8217;s the point of the secret book in <i>1984<\/i>.  What I just described above was a CONSCIOUS deception.  To me, the &#8216;secret book&#8217; section is one of the most frightening parts of <i>1984<\/i>.   Perhaps because it gets a little bit closer to describing the heart of that darkness.  The darkness at the heart of man.  The seeds of evil.  You can believe the theorists if you want.  You can believe that communism is great, and Stalin was just a bad example.  I choose to not delude myself.<\/p>\n<p>One of my favorite novels is called <i>Hopeful Monsters<\/i>, and it&#8217;s by Nicholas Mosley.  One of the lead characters is a little girl, half-German half-Jewish, growing up in Berlin following World War I.  Her father is German, a scientist, but he sees what is happening and he does not like it.  He watches the growth of the Nazis with disgust.  At one point he says to his daughter, &#8220;The thing is &#8211; at this point, the Nazis are the only ones who are saying what they will do if they win.  It&#8217;s just that nobody believes them yet.&#8221;  His daughter says, &#8220;What will they do if they win?&#8221;  Her father answers, &#8220;Kill everyone who isn&#8217;t like them.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>Conquest says over and over and over again, in his book, about the people around Stalin (the ones hoping that THIS purge will be the last, that NOW they can start to live a normal life, that NOW the repression can be relaxed):   &#8220;<i>They did not understand Stalin yet<\/i>.&#8221;  That&#8217;s the big word he uses:  His comrades, in the early 30s, didn&#8217;t yet &#8220;<i>understand<\/i>&#8221; Stalin.  A chilling chilling word, in this context.  (Maybe a better word is &#8220;grok&#8221;.  By the time you really &#8220;grokked&#8221; Stalin, it would be WAY too late.)<\/p>\n<p>The blatant-ness of his message &#8230; the lack of secretiveness about it &#8230; the open feeling that one is entitled to kill the millions who get in your way, and the millions who MIGHT get in your way &#8230; with no regard to public opinion &#8230; It takes the breath away.<\/p>\n<p>And so Conquest says over and over again, &#8220;They did not understand Stalin yet.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>It&#8217;s because the human mind balks at understanding a man capable of such horror.  You CAN&#8217;T believe he means what he says.  But Stalin was saying all along what he meant, and what he wanted.  It&#8217;s just that nobody believed him.<\/p>\n<p>AS I am reading the thing, I am shaking my head in awe.  It&#8217;s kind of similar to my response when I first read <i>Rise and Fall of the Third Reich<\/i>.  The book is so dense, so researched &#8230; and all I can imagine is the literal MOUNDS of paper the author had to sift through.  And somehow make sense of, somehow put it together:  Okay, so THIS random memo was really sinister &#8230; because it then led to THIS report &#8230; It also is amazing to me that these regimes kept such immaculate records.  Immaculate records of their evil.<\/p>\n<p>What BALLS.  Why?  Was it such an insane looking-glass atmosphere that they were somehow PROUD of this horror and thought the rest of the world would look on it, in retrospect, with admiration?  Or just that it takes enormous human organization to atomize and terrorize and crush an entire society, and therefore there will necessarily be a massive paper trail?<\/p>\n<p>Conquest, in the first version of the book, had to deal with the fact that there were huge gaps in his knowledge, that a lot of it was guesswork &#8211; because the documents proving his conjectures were either destroyed or hidden.  With glasnost, the archives opened up &#8211; and Conquest (whose last name is feckin&#8217; APT, if you ask me) was able to prove all of his theories, and he realized he had actually UNDER-estimated the numbers of those killed in The Great Terror in the original version of the book.<\/p>\n<p>But still.  The paper trail amazes me.  The fact that these people left such evidence of their depravity behind &#8230; How on earth did they justify that?  Is it that in such a world, no air gets in, no breath of reality or morality for that matter can penetrate &#8230; and down equals up, right equals left &#8230; and anything even resembling normal or moderate cannot be heard?<\/p>\n<p>Conquest talks a lot about people lacking certain &#8220;restraints&#8221; (or &#8220;ruth&#8221;), and that Stalin surrounded himself with those people.  Ruth-less people.  People who didn&#8217;t have the normal human response, (&#8220;No, I won&#8217;t do that&#8221;) to being asked to do horrible things.  Now &#8211; this again goes back to <a href=\"https:\/\/www.sheilaomalley.com\/?p=2383\">that Scott Peck conversation<\/a> we had.  You can blither at me until you&#8217;re blue in the face about &#8220;we all have horrors within us, who knows what you would do in similar circumstances&#8221; and that STILL does not explain a horror like Stalin, and the monstrous excuses for human beings surrounding him.  It also does NOT explain that there are countless examples of people who did not break, who COULD not break, actually, under the pressure of Stalin&#8217;s regime.  These were people who were, at one time, at least many of them, true believers in socialism, they were a part of the machinery of the state.  And yet &#8211; there are those who, when push came to shove, had SOME smidgeon of human feeling left, SOME residue of compassion that could not be wiped out.  These were the people who refused to confess, even after weeks of torture, people who even on the stand at their own show trial were saying, &#8220;This is all a lie&#8230;I didn&#8217;t do anything&#8221; &#8230; And then, there were others who had NO restraints, and NO morality &#8211; Stalin&#8217;s henchmen.  Were they unloved as itty-bitty babies?  Did their mummy not wuv them enough?  I don&#8217;t care.  In my mind, there is no logical explanation &#8230; except that there are people who LACK certain things, like morality, like a sense of right and wrong.<\/p>\n<p>Stalin didn&#8217;t have the restraints that normal people have, the restraints which I would call our birthright, as human beings (animals, yet with consciousness), and so he didn&#8217;t want the people around him to have restraints either.  It would be a reminder.<\/p>\n<p>But &#8230; still &#8230;<\/p>\n<p>There&#8217;s a mystery at the heart of all of this.  I can&#8217;t quite get to it, though.  Perhaps the mystery is:  that Stalin was, to some degree, CONSCIOUS of who he was.  Maybe to a greater degree than anyone.  He said, at the grave of his wife, &#8220;With her dies any warm feeling I could have for any other human.&#8221;  (Something like that.)  He KNEW he had no feelings for humanity.  Other people did not seem real to him.  Nothing was real except his lust for power and total control.  And he SAID this.<\/p>\n<p>Also &#8211; in his choice of henchmen:  he was quite careful, quite cunning.  He knew the types he could not trust, he knew the types he could.  And so, on some level, he had to KNOW that he was &#8220;missing&#8221; certain things (like a heart, like a moral compass) &#8230; Right?  He KNEW he didn&#8217;t have these things, and so he chose his top men accordingly.<\/p>\n<p>This, to me, is a mystery.  I mean, I understand it intellectually, but there&#8217;s something else going on there.  Something we cannot know, because we don&#8217;t know what was going on in Stalin&#8217;s head.  And maybe it&#8217;s the MYSTERY that keeps me coming back to this topic.  We can theorize, and guess, and psychoanalyze a monster like Stalin &#8230; but still.  Still.  What terrifies me is how EASILY people succumbed to being controlled (this is the main reason why cults remain a huge fascination for me), and also &#8230; how we never really can know.  We can never really know what Stalin FELT.  We can only look at what he DID.  All we need to know about Stalin can be found in his actions.<\/p>\n<p>But there&#8217;s that child-like part of me, the voracious part of me that wants to KNOW.  I want to get inside Stalin&#8217;s head, for just an hour or so &#8211; so I can look out of his eyes &#8211; and see what it&#8217;s like to have no human feelings.  You know?  Maybe many of you don&#8217;t have that curiosity, but I sure as hell do.  Always have.  What is it LIKE to be Jeffrey Dahmer?  What is it LIKE to be Hitler?  What was it <i>really<\/i> like?  There has been a part of me that is so fascinated by cults that I have considered joining one &#8211; just to see what it was like.  But then I&#8217;m afraid that I&#8217;ll get so sucked in that my parents will have to hire some thug to drag me out and lock me up in a Motel 6 for days on end to de-program me.  But still.  My curiosity about the brain, and how it works, and &#8230; how it can (or cannot) be &#8220;programmed&#8221; is a never-ending source of fascination.<\/p>\n<p>Robert Conquest&#8217;s discussions of Stalin are chilling, mainly because of how deeply Conquest understands all of this &#8211; the unknowable-ness of many of my questions.  Especially with someone as cagey and secretive and elusive as Stalin.  Historians make the mistake, over and over again, of coming up with some psychological explanation for how tyrants are made &#8230; (&#8220;his mother didn&#8217;t love him enough&#8221;, &#8220;he was rejected as a painter&#8221;, &#8220;he was a closet homosexual&#8221; &#8230; etc.) And while all of these may be interesting components of the personality, certainly not to be ignored &#8230; they do not and can not explain everything.  There are tons of people who were &#8220;rejected as painters&#8221; who didn&#8217;t end up killing 6 million Jews.  If you start with a psychological theory, and then go through the person&#8217;s life, finding stuff that backs up YOUR theory &#8230; it doesn&#8217;t wash.  At least not for me.  I am not saying that it&#8217;s not interesting or relevant &#8211; the background of monsters like Pol Pot or Stalin &#8230; it&#8217;s just that that&#8217;s not all there is.  That can&#8217;t be all there is.  Plenty of people grew up uneducated, or unloved, or short, or with a small penis.  And they don&#8217;t turn themselves into tyrants with iron fists, ruling over millions.<\/p>\n<p>From where does evil like Stalin&#8217;s spring?<\/p>\n<p>What motivates a man like Stalin?<\/p>\n<p>Again and again, Conquest reminds us that we ourselves must not under-estimate Stalin.  There is no one explanation.<\/p>\n<p>If you go with one theory (he was mediocre, lazy, and ambitious &#8211; this was a common view of him) &#8211; then that doesn&#8217;t explain a host of other events, where he was not mediocre or lazy.  He <i>could <\/i>be lazy.  Yet he <i>also <\/i>could move with amazing dispatch, like a cobra striking, and nobody saw the attack coming.<\/p>\n<p>Some Soviet official who knew Stalin said that Stalin had that rarest (and most dangerous) of combinations:  patience and capriciousness.<\/p>\n<p>*shivers*  Scary stuff.  Very scary.<\/p>\n<p>The murder of Kirov was really when Stalin&#8217;s gloves came off, or when he showed his fangs (to mix a metaphor) &#8211; although the signs had been there for some time.  Conquest, in the chapter &#8220;The Kirov Murder&#8221;, takes us through it, step by step.  The chapter was re-written after glasnost because suddenly he could piece together what really had happened, with the opened archives, etc.  archives opened up, etc. Conquest writes very well.  There is a feeling of slow inevitability, like a glacier.  It cannot be stopped.  Stalin cannot be stopped.  There is also the fear, reading it in retrospect, because I know the end.  Kirov, murdered in 1934, touched off the &#8220;purges&#8221; &#8211; which, all told, killed millions and millions of people.  All of them were supposed to be connected, somehow, to Kirov&#8217;s murder &#8211; as though there was a vast country-wide conspiracy of assassins&#8230; but meanwhile (and this was the big secret), Stalin was the one who ordered Kirov killed.  The murder of Kirov gave Stalin the excuse to bring the terror to another level.  He had been waiting for that excuse all along.  He NEVER believed in &#8220;the people&#8221;, or the revolution.  He believed in power, for himself.<\/p>\n<p>George Orwell describes it perfectly in the secret book within <i>1984<\/i>.  Evil is not random, or thoughtless.  It is cunning, very smart (way smarter than &#8220;good&#8221; is, sometimes, because good can be naive &#8211; Evil never is), and evil can afford to take its time.  I find Stalin&#8217;s patience most frightening.  He never forgot or forgave an injury.  It could be years before Stalin would get his revenge &#8211; but Stalin always got revenge.  Always.<\/p>\n<p>I began this long ramble of a post talking about &#8220;grokking&#8221;.<\/p>\n<p>I guess what I really want to say is at some point last night, as the snow piled up against my window, for about two seconds I &#8220;grokked&#8221; the Great Terror.  It was 4 a.m., I couldn&#8217;t sleep, and reading the chapter about Kirov&#8217;s murder was a revelation.  I know it all intellectually, but what I felt was on another level.  I &#8220;got it&#8221;.  I had to put the book down.  It was too horrendous.<\/p>\n<p>This is only because of the power and clarity of Robert Conquest&#8217;s writing.  I&#8217;ve read 20 books about the Russian Revolution.  And 50 books about the USSR.  But I don&#8217;t think I really &#8220;grokked&#8221; it &#8211; until last night &#8211; when I read about the planning and executing of the murder of Kirov.<\/p>\n<p>Conquest writes:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>This killing [<i>the murder of Kirov<\/i>] has every right to be called the crime of the century.  Over the next four years, hundreds of Soviet citizens, including the most prominent political leaders of the Revolution, were shot for direct responsibility for the assassination, and literally millions of others went to their deaths for complicity in one or another part of the vast conspiracy which allegedly lay behind it.  Kirov&#8217;s death, in fact, was the keystone of the entire edifice of terror and suffering by which Stalin secured his grip on the Soviet peoples.<\/p><\/blockquote>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Update: I just realized that my description of 3 a.m. anxiety may obscure the rest of the post, which would be unfortunate. So if you want to skip over that part to get to the Stalin stuff, feel free. You &hellip; <a href=\"https:\/\/www.sheilaomalley.com\/?p=2505\">Continue reading <span class=\"meta-nav\">&rarr;<\/span><\/a><\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":2,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":[],"categories":[15],"tags":[900,231,712,139,150,1624,2601,1615],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.sheilaomalley.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2505"}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.sheilaomalley.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.sheilaomalley.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.sheilaomalley.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/users\/2"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.sheilaomalley.com\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcomments&post=2505"}],"version-history":[{"count":5,"href":"https:\/\/www.sheilaomalley.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2505\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":178287,"href":"https:\/\/www.sheilaomalley.com\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2505\/revisions\/178287"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.sheilaomalley.com\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fmedia&parent=2505"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.sheilaomalley.com\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcategories&post=2505"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.sheilaomalley.com\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Ftags&post=2505"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}