August 10, 2004

Style or Voice

Great article in The Chronicle of Higher Education about "style" in writing - trends in style, movements - were Strunk and White correct in what they deemed to be good style, in their classic (and still best-selling) book?

"Omit needless words", to me, is one of the best pieces of advice a writer could ever listen to.

But there are other issues in The Elements of Style to be discussed, and this has to do with a writer's individuality, the specific "voice" of the writer.

Very interesting piece.

Posted by sheila
Comments

Sheila, do you have an opinion on Dante? I love his stuff. belle stilo.

Steve

Posted by: Steve at August 10, 2004 01:01 PM

Interesting article. Most of the books I find at the bookstore on personal style are like get-back-to-nature, find-the-wild-man/woman-within cheese-capades. I'll check out the ones they have listed in the article.

While I think there is usefulness in picking up one of these books, a lot of it seems to be self-indulgent, look-at-me-I'm-an-artist type stuff.

I've found a couple books on style/grammar that are rock solid.

William's _Style:Toward Clarity and Grace_ is good.
Kolln's _Rhetorical Grammar: Grammatical Choices, Rhetorical Effects_

Posted by: Steve at August 10, 2004 01:09 PM

I have a personal bias, I suppose, toward "Plain English For Lawyers." ;-)

Posted by: Dave J at August 10, 2004 03:03 PM

My favorite book on prose style is J. Mitchell Morse's "Matters of Style," unfortunately long out of print. I used it frequently when teaching Eng. Comp. at the local community college. The reason I like it so much is that most books on style fall into one of two categories: the "how to be terse and clear" books and the "find your own personal voice and express your inner self" books, neither of which I find useful. By contrast, Morse presents excerpts from masters of prose style throughout literary history, analyzes how their prose works, and gives exercises in which the student is to imitate the styles of the various authors.

Posted by: Bryan at August 10, 2004 04:53 PM

That's a great way to do it, Bryan. Take pieces from actual literary works. For some reason I remember my first college English class, where all the examples were on social policy, dams, rivers, and other not-so-interesting things.

Posted by: Steve at August 10, 2004 11:09 PM