From an interview with novelist Alice McDermott:
It’s been said that, to some extent, every novelist writes the same book over and over. Many reviewers have noted how much your novels share: middle-class Irish Catholic characters, and that Long Island setting... Do you ever worry that you are indeed writing the same book again and again?No. I think the question doesn’t apply to fiction... More southerners, Miss Welty? More Russian émigrés, Mr. Nabokov? Have you considered using your imagination, Mr. Garcia Marquez, and maybe setting your next novel in Finland? We’ve forgotten how to read literature (or even what literature is for) if we confuse the meaning of a piece with its subject...
I love that. I love that because I love her books, and I love that because it gives me courage as a writer. I think she's right.
It's her birthday today.
I read Charming Billy when it first came out, and was captivated by its practical prose, sparked with poetry, her weaving together of the past and the present, and her depiction of a large Irish-American family so like my own.
It would take an act of will to picture him now as he was then: to put aside every image that had come in between, including that dark, stiffly bloated remnant of his face that was Billy in death, and remember him clearly: thin and handsome in those days, the dipped brim of his fedora over the blue eyes and the rimless glasses, a nick of dried blood on his smooth cheek, a red blush from the cold. A lingering scent of the church he had just come from on his overcoat, and a taste of the Eucharist still on his breath as they stood together in the crowded subway car, hand over hand on the same white pole, exchanging shouted bits of news or falling into silence as the train rattled and screeched and tried to knock them off their feet. As glad for each other's company as if they'd long been deprived of it.
That is so good. One of the memorable things about the book is that it takes place during a wake for the death of Uncle Billy, and many family members share memories of him, and that is how Billy comes to life for us. This is how things work in families. This is how stories are passed down. "Charming Billy" is as alive as any fictional character I've ever met, but I see him through the filter of different family members, as they share anecdotes and memories. To me, the book feels how life is. A family like that is a blessing, no doubt, I'm in one of them so I should know, but it has its challenges too. When you are dealing with a vast swarm of about 70 people, all of whom knew you since you were conceived, sometimes it is hard to remember or maintain your own identity. You want to break free. But never completely. To break free completely would mean you have banished yourself to the lower depths. You need your family. They remind you of who you are, even if it's the worst possible definition. It's not easy. And so often when someone passes away, the narrative about that person gets "set", very early on, by those left behind. Charming Billy is about a family groping for their own narrative in the wake of a great loss.
McDermott writes about Irish-American life at a particular time in history: the generation that straddles Vatican II. These are my relatives. I wrote a piece for a writing class once about that generation of Irish-Americans, my parents' generation, and this is Alice McDermott's landscape. Charming Billy is almost creepy to me, because she gets it so right. It sounds right, the houses are right, the masses are right, the family stuff is right ... Her writing is not flowery, or sentimental. In many ways, she reminds me of Dennis Lehane (excerpt of Mystic River here), although she doesn't write crime books. It's the STYLE. It's the TYPE of person she writes about. The Irish-Americans, the third-generation people, with grandmothers who speak in brogues. Basically, my peeps. McDermott doesn't write about it in a precious way - or a fetishizing way, like many Irish-Americans do. This is a community of people, with specific ways and traditions, and she gets it like no other.
Charming Billy won the National Book Award the year it came out, and I think that's pretty cool, because Charming Billy doesn't have a lot of sturm und drang, it's not about a politically hot topic, it's not focusing on mental illness or depression, it's not "important" or topical at all. But God spare us from only reading "important" books. Charming Billy is the story of a family who gathers in a bar in the Bronx after the funeral mass of their family member Billy. He's an uncle, a cousin, whatever the association, it's different for all of them - and the family sits around and talks about him, telling stories. Billy had a long life. He was a big drinker. He had a great lost love: Eva, an Irish girl. He had a new wife, Maeve, and she's relatively new to the family (but again, with the whole Irish tendency of not accepting newbies, the family doesn't quite know how to deal with her, she's not really "one of them" yet). Speaking of that, when my family and I were in Ireland when I was a kid, we stayed out on Achill Island, a beautiful wild island off the western coast of Ireland. It was a place of sheep and wool sweaters and weekly dances at the rectory, and impromptu soccer games in rocky fields. It blew my mind. We stayed with a family who had lived there for, no lie, 30 years. The couple had moved there after they were married, and had lived there for thirty years. And what did the other Achill Islanders refer to them as? "The blow-ins". I remember that making a huge impression on me (I was 14), and everyone thought it was very funny. Even if you've lived there for an entire generation, if you didn't start OUT there, and if you can't trace your roots there back to 1562, then you're a "blow-in". Maeve had been married to Charming Billy for a bit, but the family still holds her at arm's length. The jury is still out. Why? Because she's a bad person? No. She's just a "blow-in" and you can't be sure of those people right away. Tribal Irish stuff. It's real.
Everyone tells stories, and sometimes the narrator (who is a member of the family. It's a first-person book, although often it doesn't feel that way, because she is telling the stories of Billy's life, not her own) will go back into the past, and share her memories of Billy, and the memories will come to life on the page. The whole thing takes place in one day, sitting around the bar in the Bronx, shooting the shit about their dearly departed Billy.
And who can say why this was such a lovely read? Having described "what happens", I can imagine it doesn't sound all that compelling.
But it's what I call a "soft" read. You can just sink into it. You can lose yourself. The writing is not insistent, or clever. It's just GOOD. It's good story-telling. And it has the breath of reality in it. I have been to more Irish wakes than I can count, sadly. We have a big family and my childhood was punctuated by truly tragic deaths, out of the blue deaths, dear dear family members dying young, horrible, unexpected. McDermott captures perfectly the vibe at the after-gatherings of such funerals. I mean, Irish wakes are a cliche by now - but there's much truth in cliches. I recognize myself in this book. I see my family. Alice McDermott has perfect pitch.
Billy is not always a pleasant man to get to know. He had a drinking problem. He was an old-school Catholic boy. A wild man who never missed mass. But yes. He was "charming". That word can have snotty connotations. It has lost its meaning. What does it mean when someone REALLY has "charm"? What is charm? Billy had it.
And so there is much to mourn.
Here's an excerpt. I love the bit about the waiter placing the ice cream on the table. And how Alice McDermott describes it perfectly. That's good writing.
"Well, he always drank," Kate said. "But for a very long time it seemed he drank harmlessly. I remember him feeling no pain when he was on leave, before he went overseas, but that was understandable. I remember the night he came home and told us that Eva had passed away. He went straight to bed afterwards and I called Dennis to see if I could learn anything more and Dennis said they'd both had quite a lot to drink the night before, which was understandable, too. It was probably as hard for Dennis to tell him as it was for Billy to hear the news."His sister Rosemary said, "I remember he had one too many at Jill's christening. I was worried about him riding the subway home."
"But for years he never missed a day of work," Kate told us. "And he was there to open the shoe store every Saturday morning from the time he started into the early sixties, when Mr. Holtzman finally sold the place to Baker's. I don't think Mr. Holtzman ever knew he drank. Certainly no one at Edison knew until near the end."
But Mickey Quinn held up his hand. "They knew," he said wisely.
"But not until fairly recently," Kate said. "Maybe when he went into the hospital in '73, the same year my Kevin graduated from Regis."
But Mickey Quinn frowned and shook his head slightly apologetically, as if over something that was only slightly askew. "They knew," he said again. "We all knew. I left Irving Place in '68 and the fellows in the office knew Billy was a drinker even then. They covered for him, mostly in the afternoon. He'd go out on a call after lunch and not come back to the office and they'd cover for him. Everyone liked him. They were glad to do it."
"I think Smitty might have covered for him, too," his sister Rosemary said. "In the shoe store. Do you remember Smitty? Mr. Holtzman's assistant - the little bald man?" He was remembered. "I went in there one Saturday, we were looking for Betty's First Communion shoes, and Billy was just coming in from lunch. I had the feeling he'd had a few. I mean, he was fine, and the kids were always happy to see him, but I noticed Smitty did all the measuring and got out all the shoes. Billy mostly sat. Which wasn't like him. He was sucking a peppermint."
"When was this?" Kate asked as her wealthy husband, trained at Fordham Law, might do.
Rosemary paused to calculate. "Betty was in second grade. 1962." Almost in apology: "He was drinking in '62."
Dan Lynch raised his hands. "Well, what does it mean? He was drinking before that, too. Down at Quinlan's. Saturdays after work. Sunday evenings. Hell, I was always there, too, and my liver's fine."
"So when did it become a problem?" cousin Rosemary asked.
"He started AA in the late sixties," Kate told her. "And then again around '71 or '2."
"He took the pledge on that Ireland trip. That was '75."
"What good did it do?"
"I thought it would stick. Maeve did, too."
Dan Lynch was chuckling, his hand around his small glass. "I remember Billy saying that AA was a Protestant thing, when you came right down to it. Started by a bunch of Protestants. He said he didn't like the chummy way some of them were always calling Our Lord by his first name. I drove him to the first meeting and waited to take him home, 'cause Maeve didn't want him driving, and when he came out he said you could tell who the Catholics were because they'd all been bowing their heads every ten seconds while the Protestants bantered on about Jesus, Jesus, Jesus."
(And sure enough, up and down our stretch of table, heads bobbed at the name.)
Sister Rosemary said, "He didn't like them calling God a Higher Power, either - which I guess was the official AA term. Nondenominational, you know. He said it only proved that none of them had a sense of humor. He said you'd have to be God Himself to get higher than most of these guys had been."
There was a bit of low laughter. "Billy had an irreverent streak," MIckey Quinn said. "I liked that about him."
"The way Father Joyce explained it to me," Dan Lynch went on, "the pledge was the Catholic take on AA. He said it was like Holy Orders itself - you signed on and there was no going back. An unbreakable oath never to take another drink. Billy thought it was the real thing."
"But he broke it."
"There's plenty of priests that break their Holy Orders, too," Dan Lynch told them.
"Well, it got him over to Ireland, anyway," cousin Rosemary said. "I tried to talk him and Maeve into going over any number of times, but I never could do it."
"Maeve isn't one to travel," sister Rosemary said. "She's a homebody. Always has been."
Kate leaned toward us all, folding her hands on the table: a tasteful ring of diamonds, a gold bracelet, a professional manicure. "I often wondered," she said slowly. "I never had the heart to ask him, but I wondered if Billy went to visit the town Eva came from. While he was there."
Her sister shook her head. "Billy would have said so if he had. He wasn't one to keep things to himself."
Kate paused only a moment to consider this. "But he might not have wanted it to get back to Maeve, you know," she said. "He might have thought she wouldn't want to hear about a pilgrimage like that."
"Who would?"
"She knew about Eva?" Bridie said, whispering too, adding, "Thank you," as the waiter took her empty plate.
"I'm sure," Kate said. "Thank you." And then: "Actually, I don't know. I'd imagine she knew something about her."
"He must have told her something."
"Dennis would know," Mickey Quinn said. "They were always real close."
But Dan Lynch objected. "I was the best man at Billy's wedding," he said. "We were pretty close, too."
"Well, did he tell Maeve about the Irish girl?"
Dan waved his hand impatiently. "I'm sure he told her something. You know, it's not the sort of thing men talk about. And I'll say this for Billy, you never heard him mention that girl again, once he married Maeve."
"Ask Dennis," cousin Rosemary whispered.
The selected dessert was brought in: two scoops of vanilla ice cream in cold stainless-steel bowls. Hands in laps to make the poor man's job easier as he reached between their shoulders. Thank you.
"I remember watching Maeve come down the aisle," Dan Lynch said, lifting his spoon, holding it like a scepter. "She was on her old man's arm, but it was clear as you watched her that she was shoring him up, you know, keeping him straight. She was smiling as sweetly as any bride, but there was a determination in the way she walked, you know, the way she held her shoulder up against his, like it was a wall about to topple. She took hold of his arm when they got to the first pew, I mean a good grip, right here." He demonstrated, taking hold of his own forearm, spoon and all. "The old man banged his foot against the kneeling bench - you could hear it all over the church - and for a minute it looked like he'd go down headfirst. But she got him in there and got him seated. She maneuvered him. By sheer force of will, I'd say. And then she gave a little nod, as if to say, Well, that's done, and came up the steps to marry Billy." He sipped his beer. "Ready to take him on, is what I remember thinking. She was a plain girl, but determined."
"Very quiet," Mickey Quinn said. "Go over there for dinner and Billy would do most of the talking."
"He was lucky to find her," sister Rosemary said. "My mother always siad there's nothing more pathetic than an old bachelor who's not a priest. That's what she thought Billy would be, after the Irish girl. An old bachelor. No offense, Danny."
And Dan Lynch laughed, blushed a little across his bald dome. Sipping his beer and shrugged. None taken - the story here being that Danny Lunch was such a connoisseur of beauty and behavior that no flawed wife could have pleased him and no flawless one could have been found.
"Did you ever meet her?" Bridie from the old neighborhood whispered. "The Irish girl?"
The two sisters exchanged a look across the table - the kind of look they might have exchanged had they been eyeing the last bite of a shared piece of cake. "She came to the apartment," Kate said, scooping it up. "It was just before she went back home. Billy borrowed Mr. Holtzman's car to go into the city to get her."
"She was very pretty," Rosemary added, taking a crumb. "Like Susan Hayward."
"Oh, I didn't think so," Kate said. "But she had nice hair, dark auburn. And big brown eyes. She wasn't very tall, even a little chubby. Billy brought her for Sunday dinner and then couldn't eat a bite himself. He was so - I don't know what - so delicate with her. The way he spoke to her, and watched her and listened to her. She did have a nice voice, you know, the poor girl" (a reminder to us all that she had died young), "with her brogue and all. My mother's brogue got thicker just listening to her. They were good-looking together, Eva and Billy. A handsome pair. Better looking together than singly, somehow. He was lovestruck, that's for sure. We kidded him when he got home, after he'd taken her back to the city. We put his plate out on the dining-room table when we heard him coming up. We'd saved it. He'd hardly eaten a bite. We said, 'What was wrong with your dinner, Billy?'" She began to laugh. "We said, 'How are you going to marry this poor girl if her mere presence takes your appetite away? Billy,' we said, 'she'll be at your dinner table every day, breakfast too, when are you going to eat? You'll starve. You'll waste away to nothing. You'll have to sneak over here just to calm down enough to have your dinner.' We gave him such a hard time."
"And do you remember what Momma said?" sister Rosemary asked. Kate swallowed her smile, looked blank. Professional makeup, too. "No."
Well pleased, Rosemary said to my end of the table, "You know my mother thought herself a kind of psychic." She was getting her share of the story, after all. "She read cards and had dreams. And she said after Billy left that when she touched the girl's hand she felt four quick pulses in her own stomach, like baby kicks, which meant they'd have four children."
"Or that your mother had indigestion," Mickey Quinn said.
"More likely," Kate said. "You know how my mother cooked."
"She wasn't a much better prophet."
But Bridie shook her head. "I don't know," she said. "It might have been true. I mean, you could say if the girl had lived, that's how many children they might have had."
Dan Lynch said solemnly, "Which would have made this a different day."
"It would have been a different life."
Mickey Quinn shook his head and leaned back in his chair, as if to avoid all such speculation. "I'll have that cup of coffee now, please, when you get the chance," he said to the waiter's back.
"A different life," Dan Lynch repeated, and raised his beer.
The light through the window behind Maeve had begun to change now. A trace of shadow coming between the dark trunks of the trees, the clouds breaking up, perhaps.
"I don't agree with that," sister Rosemary said softly. "I've done a lot of reading in this regard, with Billy the way he was. Alcoholism isn't a decision, it's a disease, and Billy would have had the disease whether he married the Irish girl or Maeve, whether he'd had kids or not. It wouldn't have been such a different life, believe me. Every alcoholic's life is pretty much the same."
"Now I don't agree," Dan Lynch said under his breath, and Kate added, "It's not always fatal."
"I say it's a matter of will," Dan Lynch said, speaking up, keeping Kate from running away with the talk once again. "I drank side by side with Billy LYnch for nearly forty years. My liver's fine. Billy never had the will to stop."
Sister Rosemary frowned, shaking her head. "That's not fair. When he went to Ireland, when he took the pledge, he was truly determined. He told me so. You know what faith Billy had. And you know how seriously he took that trip. He was truly determined that time. But the disease had him in its grip." She raised a fist, showing them.
Dan Lynch poured himself and Mickey Quinn another beer. "Well, let me tell you what he told me," he said. "Down at Quinlan's, maybe a year or two after the Irish girl died. He told me," he said, lifting his glass, pointing around it, "that after year was a weight on his shoulders. Every hour was, he said." He pointed to Kate. "Remember when you said he was like a man waiting for a bus, when he was waiting to get her back here? Well, when you said that I thought: It never changed. He was still waiting, years after she'd died. But she was waiting to go to her now. Ever since the night Dennis told him the news, he was waiting to die. I'm sure of it."
"But there was Maeve," Bridie from the neighborhood cried.
"That's not fair to Maeve," sister Rosemary said.
Dan Lynch shook his head. "I'm not saying a word against Maeve. She had a lot to handle, that's for sure. But if you ask me, Billy had a foot in the hereafter even before he met Maeve." He glanced up the table and then leaned forward, lowering his voice because the guests were beginning to thin out, Billy's friends and relatives getting up to have a few more words with Maeve, to go to the bathroom, or to get another drink before departing.
"We went to Mass together once. Feast of the Assumption. August 15. We'd both stopped into Quinlan's after work, a blazing hot day if there ever was one, hot as Hades, and both of us realized at the same time what the date was. We hightailed it over to 6:30 Mass at St. Sebastian's and, I don't know, I glanced at Billy, just after Communion. It struck me that it wasn't any thought of Our Lord or the Blessed Mother that put that look on his face. It was the girl. The Irish girl. When he turned his eyes to heaven, that's who he saw."
"Oh, nonsense," sister Rosemary whispered.
Mickey Quinn studied the ceiling. Down the table, a few heads turned, perhaps sensing a fight.
Dan Lynch took a sip of his beer, pursed his lips around the taste. "What's nonsense is all this disease business," he said. "Maybe for some people it's a disease. But maybe for some there are things that happen in their lives that they just can't live with. Things that take the sweetness out of everything. Maybe for some it's a sadness they can't get rid of or a disappointment that won't go away. And you know what I say to those people? I say good luck to those people." He raised his glass, raised his chin. "I say maybe they're not as smart and sensible and accepting as every one of us," indicating every one of us with a sweep of his beer, "but they're loyal. They're loyal to their own feelings. They're loyal to the first plans they made - just like Billy was loyal to Holtzman and the job he gave him. And like he would have been loyal to her if she had lived and come back here and they'd gotten married. Just like he was loyal to Maeve. Billy never breathed another word about that girl after he married Maeve. But the girl was first, and for Billy she would always be first. That's the kind of guy he was. Maeve couldn't change him."
"I think he went to her grave when he was in Ireland," Kate said suddenly. "I just have the feeling that sometime while he was over there he went to the town she was from and visited her grave. I think it was the whole reason he made the trip."
Rosemary shook her head, appealed to Mickey Quinn, who was intent on dissolving the sugar in his coffee. "He went with Father Ryan to take the pledge," she said patiently. "To make the retreat. To quit drinking."
But Kate said, "Oh, Rose, think about it. Ireland's not the only place that has retreats for alcoholics. He could have made one over here. Maybe he thought if he went to her grave he could put something to rest, finally. Put his feelings for her to rest so then he could quit drinking."
"But he couldn't," Dan Lynch said sadly, and poured another little beer.
"He couldn't," Kate agreed. "Which is why it didn't stick, as determined as he was."
But Rosemary's mouth was set. "No," she said firmly. "Look, there are faster and more pleasant ways of killing yourself. I tell you, I've read everything there is about this. Alcoholism is a disease, it's genetic. Our own father ruined his liver as well and probably would have died the same way if he hadn't gotten cancer. And Uncle John in Philadlephia was an alcoholic. And two of his sons - Chuck and Peter - go to AA. And Ted. And Mary Casey and Helen Lynch. And Dennis's father was no teetotaler either."
"Uncle Daniel died of cancer," Dan Lynch said indignantly. "He was no drunk." He turned to Bridie and Mickey Quinn. "He brought his six brothers and a sister over here and God knows how many other friends and relations. All on a motorman's salary."
"He was a saint," Bridie from the neighborhood said, nodding. "My mother always said so."
"Okay," Rosemary said. "God bless Uncle Daniel, but my point is that our family has what they call a genetic predisposition to both cancer and alcoholism. Billy had it in his genes."
"When he came back from Ireland," Kate said softly, stroking the stem of her glass. "June of '75 - I remember because my Daniel had just graduated from Fordham - he went straight out to Long Island. Out to the little house. Dennis was there, it wasn't long after he'd lost Claire. Remember how he used to rent the place back from his mother's tenant so he could spend his vacation? Well, Billy wasn't home for more than a day when he took the train out - and he hadn't been there in years."
"Meaning?" Rosemary asked coolly.
"Meaning he went back to the place he first met her. Eva. He was trying to work something out."
"Oh, honestly," Rosemary said. "It had been nearly thirty years. What was there to work out? It was a shame that she died, but Billy had thirty years of living since then. I mean, come on, name me anything that's going to stay with you that strongly for thirty years."
Which seemed to silence our end of the table for a moment, as if the thing we would mention had only momentarily slipped our minds.
Cousin Rosemary poked her swizzle stick into the remaining ice in her glass. "It's all water under the bridge," she said, as if water from under the bridge was the very thing the tall glass contained. "What's the point of even discussing all this now? Billy was here and now he's gone, and I for one just can't believe it. Despite his troubles." Tears now. "I'll miss him. I'll miss his voice over the phone. I'll miss his smiling face."
"Hear, hear," Mickey Quinn said.
But Dan Lynch raised his beer again. He was whispering, his voice fierce. "I just don't think it credits a man's life to say he was in the clutches of a disease and that's what ruined him. Say he was too loyal. Say he was disappointed. Say he made way too much of the Irish girl and afterwards couldn't look life square in the face. But give him some credit for feeling, for having a hand in his own fate. Don't say it was a disease that blindsided him and wiped out everything he was." He bit off a drink, his face flushed. "Do the man that favor, please."
Another book of McDermott's that I have read is That Night.
Again, like Charming Billy, this book is told from the point of view of an innocent bystander, a member of a huge sprawling family of the Irish Catholic variety. In such families, even if you were not a first-hand witness to an event, it doesn't matter. Stories take on legendary glows. You repeat them. You tell them to the younger generation. You maybe add some details. You forget others. This is your family. You're allowed to do that with family. In my family, you tell the story of Uncle Jimmy (my crazy godfather) driving the car over the wall as though you were there. Stories are passed down, solidifying into narrative. McDermott is so good at getting that feeling of Boston Irish Catholic diaspora. I can't think of anyone who comes close to "getting it right", without being twee, or sentimental, or full of "oh, I long for the leprechauns of the auld country" like so many Irish-American writers succumb to. It's nauseating. McDermott writes about families who still have the breath of peat turf around them, they're only one generation removed. The church is strong with these people. But compromises must be made. I think she's full of truth.
That Night takes place in what would seem to be a stultifying suburb atmosphere, early 60s, cusp of Vatican II 60s, and kids roam the streets (the book is told in retrospect by a little girl, now a grown woman, who was peripheral to the main events), and the mothers chat over the fences, and the fathers come home smelling of cigarettes, with slicked down hair. (I love the fathers. Man, does Alice McDermott "get" that kind of father. It's hard to describe. You just know it when you see it. I recognize my entire family, the Buddy Holly glasses, the cigarettes, the little kids leaping through sprinklers, all the Polaroids from my childhood, yes - even this one - in her descriptions of fathers. It's poignant. A world gone away.)
A while back, I was writing about something, it must have had to do with "openings" of books: how they start, and how challenging they are to write. And Jon, a friend of mine and a writer, made a comment that once, in a writing class, a teacher had given That Night as an example of a first-rate beginning.
Here it is. Hard to not keep reading after something like this. It is a stunner of an opening.
That night when he came to claim her, he stood on the short lawn before her house, his knees bent, his fists driven into his thighs, and bellowed her name with such passion that even the friends who surrounded him, who had come to support him, to drag her from the house, to murder her family if they had to, let the chains they carried go limp in their hands. Even the men from our neighborhood, in Bermuda shorts or chinos, white T-shirts and gray suit-pants, with baseball bats and snow shovels held before them like rifles, even they paused in their rush to protect her: the good and the bad - the black-jacketed boys and the fathers in their light summer clothes - startled for that one moment before the fighting began by the terrible, piercing sound of his call.This is serious, my own father remembered thinking at that moment. This is insane.
I remember only that my ten-year-old heart was stopped by the beauty of it all.
Sheryl was her name, but he cried, "Sherry," drawing out the word, keening it, his voice both strong and desperate. There was a history of dark nights in the sound, something lovely, something dangerous.
One of the children had already begun to cry.
It was high summer, the early 1960s. The sky was a bright navy above the pitched roofs and the thick suburban trees. I hesitate to say that only Venus was bright, but there it was. I had noticed it earlier, when the three cars that were now in Sheryl's driveway and up on her lawn had made their first pass through our neighborhood. Add a thin, rising moon if the symbolism troubles you: Venus was there.
Across the street, a sprinkler shot weak sprays of water, white in the growing darkness. Behind the idling motors of the boys' cars you could still hear the collective gurgle of filters in backyard pools. Sheryl's mother had already been pulled from the house, and she crouched on the grass by the front steps saying over and over again, "She's not here. She's gone." The odor of their engines was like a gash across the ordinary summer air.
He called her again, doubled over now, crying, I think. Then he pitched forward, his boot slipping on the grass, so it seemed for a second he'd be frustrated even in this, and once again ran toward the house. Sheryl's mother cowered. The men and the boys met awkwardly on the square lawn.
Until then, I had thought all violence was swift and sure-footed, somehow sleek, even elegant. I was surprised to see how poor it really was, how laborious and hulking. I saw one of the men bend under the blow of what seemed a slow-moving chain, and then, just as gracelessly, swing his son's baseball bat into a teenager's ear. I saw the men and the boys leap on one another like obese, short-legged children, sliding and falling, raising chains that seemed to crumble backward onto their shoulders, moving bats and hoes and wide rakes that seemed as unwieldy as trees. There were no clever D'Artagnan mid-air meetings of chain and snow-shovel, no eye-to-eye throat grippings, no witty retorts and well-timed dodges, no winners. Only, in the growing darkness, a hundred dumb, unrhythmical movements, only blow after artless blow.
I was standing in the road before our neighbor's house, frozen, as were all the other children scattered across the road and the sidewalk and the curbs as if in some wide-ranging game of statues. I was certain, as were all the others, that my father would die.
Behind us, one of the mothers began to call her husband's name, and then the others, touching their throats or their thighs, one by one began to follow. Their thin voices were plaintive, even angry, as if this clumsy battle were the last disappointment they would bear, or as if, it seems to me now, they had begun to echo, even take up, that lovesick boy's bitter cry.
There are still Alice McDermott books I haven't read, and that is something I want to rectify.
Thanks so much to Maud Newton for linking to this wonderful piece by Ruth Franklin on Shirley Jackson, a writer I have long loved and been totally creeped out by. She was anthologized because of "The Lottery", of course, which is how I first read her - in high school. That short story stayed with me, even down to the inadvertent and automatic memorization of the horrible last line (I was always memorizing last lines, I still do it, I can't help it):
"It isn't fair, it isn't right," Mrs. Hutchinson screamed, and then they were upon her.
In the TNR article, the reaction to "The Lottery" is described, which certainly validates its weird homespun almost journalistic power:
Soon after it was published, letters began to pour into the post office in the rural Vermont town where she was then living—more than three hundred of them, the most The New Yorker had ever seen for a work of fiction. Some of the letter-writers informed her that they were cancelling their subscriptions. Others wrote to express their puzzlement or to demand an explanation. But many, assuming that the story was based on fact, wanted to know where lotteries like the one Jackson described were held. “Are you describing a current custom?� asked a reader from Pennsylvania. “I have read of some queer cults in my time,� wrote a reader from Los Angeles, “but this one bothers me.�The reactions of these first readers are oddly apt, for they point to the deep domestic undercurrent beneath all Jackson’s fiction.
Yes. Yes. Something I think not often discussed with Jackson, because of the more supernatural elements of some of her work is her view of domesticity, and the danger of claustrophobia. Nobody writes about this the way Jackson does. She is a master. This is no Michael Cunningham in The Hours (a tepid Jackson imitator, in my opinion), or Sam Mendes's condescending conviction that the suburbs are the root of all soul-dead evil, a viewpoint which actually led him to totally mis-interpret Richard Yates's harrowing book Revolutionary Road. The second I heard that Mendes was directing, I knew the movie wouldn't be what it should be. I knew where he would put the focus and point the finger, and although the acting was fine (I thought Leo was particularly fantastic), it missed the mark, because Mendes didn't understand the book. At all. He should have read some Shirley Jackson to bolster his research. Jackson understood, in her bone marrow, what can happen when your horizons seem hidden, when you are surrounded by gossip, when the world around you appears to be always in agreement (and, by implication, pressures you to come into the fold). All you need to do is go hang out at a playground in Park Slope, Brooklyn, and watch the mommy-and-kid playdates going on to see that the suburbs aren't the issue. At all. Nothing more scary than another mother judging you. And so, conformity is the order of the day, the reason why "The Lottery" is so chilling. It's not just the stoning of an innocent person that is frightening. It is the agreement, the consensus, that this is how we do things - that is so scary, and still revolutionary today. I don't blame people for writing into The New Yorker, thinking it was real. It feels real. It reads real.
I read Jackson's We Have Always Lived in the Castle in 2008, my first time, and it was, hands down, the best book I read that year, and one of my favorites of Jackson's. I'm surprised it hasn't been made into a film yet (although it appears that an adaptation is in the works). One of the scariest things about it is its focus on domestic detail: flowers and meals and china. Terrifying book. Brilliant.
My friend Ted reviewed it on his site, saying:
It is such a remarkable and elemental story I scarcely want to breathe a word about it to you so that I don't ruin your experience of it. This is at once a cozy little story, simply written, a tale of desperate love, and a horror story.
Ruth Franklin writes in the TNR piece:
Interspersed among the fiction, the new collection includes also a few of the sketches that Jackson drew from her life and originally published in—of all places—Good Housekeeping. In one of these, “The Third Baby’s the Easiest,� a clerk asks Jackson, who is checking into the hospital to deliver her third child, what her occupation is. “Writer,� Jackson answers. “Housewife,� the clerk supplies. “Writer,� Jackson repeats. “I’ll just put down housewife,� the clerk tells her.
Yeah, you do that, clerk. If it makes you feel better about yourself, and helps you understand the world you live in, which can be sooo scary and unpredictable, with pesky pregnant women insisting they are "writers", what is this world coming to? Narrow little minds will always be revealed, in the end, as narrow little minds. Jackson was a terrific revealer, and she did it with creepy quiet grace, letting the event speak for itself, always.
Go read the whole piece, and definitely check out Shirley Jackson's stuff, if you haven't already.
Last night, I was talking with a friend about boundaries. How to set them, how to maintain them. If you feel taken advantage of (your time or your attention) often the response is an increasing sense of being TRAPPED - as opposed to a natural and intuitive re-setting of boundaries. It's hard to say "No" to someone. It's hard to realize, "I have reached my limit. Got no more to give at this present time. Need to re-boot. Handle your own damn problems." What can also be difficult is to say "No" to some request (for time, a listening ear) without letting that feeling of being TRAPPED enter into your tone, and making the whole thing a negative brou-haha. We were sharing stories about this from our lives, talking, listening, helping each other.
So I was so pleased, so happy, this morning to see this particular piece by Richard Oram on "The Decline Postcard." And here is a piece on "the best decline letter of all time". It really is awesome. I would love to see the Decline Postcard have a Renaissance. I suppose it's similar to automated email responses, like: "I'm out of the office. I'll get back to you at my earliest convenience." Or screening your calls. But the Decline Postcard has something else going on with it: It's an elegant and yet very firm way of saying, "You know what? NO." I love the Decline Postcards that are openly cranky, due to the fact that the writer has been bombarded with requests the entire time he has been successful. He has experienced all of the requests, and already knows, beforehand, what he will and will not do. And he is already annoyed. Not because he is naturally cranky (although sometimes he was that too), but because he has experienced all of these things time without number, and he feels harassed by them.
A comparison could be made with my Comment Policy here (and most other Comment Policy pages I've seen on personal sites - at least the ones that have a readership outside of close personal friends): Every single item on that list is something I have had to contend with repeatedly since I started the blog (or: since I switched from a political theme to an arts theme in 2004.) These were not just drive-by annoyances from random commenters: these were regular power-struggles that went on between me and my regular readers at the time, many of whom came from links I received from big political blogs and then stuck around. As I switched the focus, I already knew what the comments would be for many of my posts (I would write about Oscar night, and talk about J. Lo's dress and etc., and the majority of comments would be sneers about Hollywood liberals and how stupid and vain all actors are - and I realized - wow, I'm hanging out with the wrong crowd, they are no fun at all, and don't "get" what I'm doing here at all) - so I created that comment policy to nip things in the bud. I hadn't started out with a Comment Policy. I figured early on the kind of TONE I liked to have in the comments - light, respectful, intelligent - but I hadn't realized how obnoxious so many people are, and how consistently THE SAME all the comments would be. It was repetitive, those types of comments, and that was the worst part. The hostility towards the things I wanted to write about seemed to chase away the folks I wanted to be reading here: movie-lovers, people who love the arts, curious, intelligent, open, all that. People still come to my site and immediately violate my entire comment policy in their first comment - it's hysterical - so all I need to do is to provide a link to said policy, and say, "Here are my ground rules." It's a TIME SAVER, above all else. I don't need to even get into it. It's boundary-setting from the get-go. It is deciding to not be dominated by those who are strangely irritated by the main topic of a personal website, but it's also flat out refusing to give up your precious time to arguing the merits of things you hold dear. Not so much because I want to squelch anyone's self-expression (I mean: you can set up a blog for FREE, so you are free to go and rant about stupid Hollywood actors and stupid Oscar night and Hollywood liberals to your heart's content - although I certainly won't be reading your blog if that's your topic) - but because there are not enough hours in the day to deal with all of those fights, and frankly it no longer interests me. I'd rather talk about James Joyce than try to convince someone with a chip on his shoulder that James Joyce is worth talking about. My classic example (true story) is when I wrote some post back then about a book I had read or a movie I had seen, and someone commented, "Just wondering when you are going to weigh in on Abu Gharib." "Weigh in"? What am I, CNN? It was so weird. Would you go to a blog focused on crafts, or making your own jewelry, or cooking, and demand that the blogger "weigh in" on the situation in Darfur? Very strange. If you would like to hear my opinions on Abu Gharib, then I would certainly welcome a check from you for $100, and I'll go to town on the topic. Otherwise, I beg to be excused accordingly.
I was bored with all of this about a month in to the change-of-topic on my blog with those fights, and knew I wanted new readers. I want to protect myself from boredom most of all.
The Decline Postcard, cranky or otherwise, recognizes that one of the most precious thing on the planet is TIME. And it is up to YOU to police your own time. People will come to you with requests. Friends, or (if you're famous) strangers. To have to repeatedly say, "I don't work for free", or "No, sorry, I won't read your unpublished poetry chapbook" is tiresome and takes up too much TIME.
Hence: the Decline Postcard.
George Bernard Shaw's are the best. They are very angry. He is already angry.
Oram has collected Decline Postcards from many authors, wanting it to be its own genre, and he has some awesome examples. I liked this, because it does make the point that these Decline Postcards, unlike regular rejection letters, or form rejection letters, suggest a level of personal involvement from the author, showing that they have experienced ALL of these things in the past, and want to set their boundaries against such intrusions BEFOREhand. Some of them would edit their Decline Postcards, as new requests came in for things they hadn't even thought of. (Check out Shaw's emendations to one of his Decline Postcards, because he obviously realized that there were boundaries he hadn't even realized he had - and once they were trespassed he needed to re-draw the lines immediately.)
Oram writes:
Even more mild-mannered authors, such as Marianne Moore, could be driven to the use of decline postcards. Moore’s list* includes “recommend editors favorable to verse by children or work bequeathed for publication,� suggesting that she had received more than a few requests along this line.

Mary Wollstonecraft, by John Opie, circa 1797
A wonderful essay by Bob Lamm about his crusade to get the famous portrait of Mary Wollstonecraft back on the walls at the National Portrait Gallery in London.
An important figure, certainly, in the history of feminism, education for women and equal rights (her major work is A Vindication of the Rights of Woman), she also was a journalist, writing on all the major social topics of the day, and was present in Paris during the fiery heights/depths of the French Revolution. She was there when Louis XIV was guillotined. The story of her time in France is enough to make anyone's blood run cold, and she died at a very young age, she wasn't even 40, just 10 days after giving birth to her daughter (you know. Mary Shelley, author of Frankenstein
).
Vindication: A Novel, by Frances Sherwood, is a historical novel, based on the life of Mary Wollstonecraft, and I am surprised it is not more well-known. With beautiful writing, and visceral details, it gives you a real sense of the woman, her times, the wars and revolutions she witnessed, social upheaval, politics, her loves (failed and otherwise), and her sometimes irascible personality. She was a fighter. Her reputation has not been solid for centuries. She is either reviled and ignored, or praised and celebrated, depending on the moment. There is a reason her portrait was stuck in the basement, and not up on the wall with the rest of her famous family, in the National Portrait Gallery.
Her life, and the events thereof, were so scandalous at times, so off the charts interesting, that IT often has taken center stage, instead of her writing, and her philosophies. And that's a shame. Because that's what she was: one of the great philosophers of the Enlightenment, deserving her rightful place in that pantheon.
If you haven't read Vindication, by Frances Sherwood, I highly recommend it, but Mary Wollstonecraft's books should be read as well. Her history of the French Revolution
has something that Thomas Carlyle's more famous book
does not: immediacy. She was there. It is a good companion piece to Edmund Burke's magnificent Reflections on the Revolution in France
- my thoughts on that work here (Mary Wollstonecraft had a long-standing feud with Burke, and many of her books were replies to his works).
So Bob Lamm has done all of us a great service, by pushing the powers-that-be at the National Portrait Gallery, to unearth the famous portrait from the basement, so that all can enjoy it. She has a place in history too. Let her stand on her own with the rest of them. It is what she would expect and demand.
Go read Lamm's piece. Wonderful stuff. Congratulations, Mr. Lamm, and thank you!
Yet another great article about John Banville and his alter ego Benjamin Black. I just can't get enough of this guy, and I am especially taken by when he discusses his alter ego (and himself) in the third person. "Banville would never be able to do what Black does ..." You can sense the fun he has, mixing it up, creating serious craftsman-like novels as John Banville, and atmospheric tense noir thrillers as Benjamin Black. He's obviously a great interview. I read everything about the man I can get my hands on, and I have not read a boring interview with him yet. He's a detailed thinker, obviously, but with a sense of humor I love. He's so Irish, and so honest about being Irish (his Benjamin Black novels are about many of the dirty little secrets of the Emerald Isle, collective guilt, collective shame), and I get the sense that the fact that he is writing under a pseudonym, even though everyone knows it is him, gives him a sense of freedom that he DOESN'T have as Banville - he is quite honest about this, and I love him for it. I love him for having fun, open FUN, as a writer, even as he tackles terrible subjects.)
In the interview, he talks about atmosphere:
"I can only write here.� He points through the window to a rain-filled, platinum sky. “Isn’t that absolutely beautiful. That’s the colour inside my mind.�
He alternates books. A Banville book, then a Black book - and I anticipate all of them eagerly. I am quite behind in my Banville/Black reading, due to 2009 being a total wash, in terms of reading. Lorrie Moore, one of my favorite living writers, came out with a new novel - which is a rarity so notable that it was treated like a second star over Bethlehem - and Annie Proulx has a new collection of "Wyoming stories" out
(well, it's a couple years old by now, but I had been moving away from fiction already and it's been sitting on my shelf since then), and Mary Gaitskill has a new book out
, not to mention A.S. Byatt's latest
, and God knows who else, but those are the ones I'm itching to read. Still haven't got my fiction legs under me. I'm busy now reading Rebecca West's book about the Nuremberg Trials
, and I think my next book will be her book about treason
, which I am very much looking forward to - but when I read articles like the one about Banville, I start to burn with the desire to pick up fiction again.
One of the other things I love about Banville is he directly attacks (just through being himself, AND being Benjamin Black) the notion that serious literature is somehow elitist, and popular literature is somehow "easy". He resists all of those labels. I don't happen to think "elitist" is an insult, anyway. At least not in the way it is thrown about now by the sneering hordes, when they use it to mean "well-read, has a good vocabulary, includes references that I might need to look up". "Elitist", when said by the anti-intellectuals, is something I cop to gladly. Naturally, I don't like it when it is meant "exclusive", like a country club that doesn't allow women, Jews, minorities, or artificial barriers between people meant to keep a certain class or group OUT - but a good vocabulary is elitist? We've come to that? Really? Well, alrighty then, I'm an elitist. At least I'm in good company.
Banville is a perfectionist, famously so. His sentences are crafted within an inch of their lives, and that does not come easily. He works at it. But as Benjamin Black, he lets it all go. I read the Benjamin Black books with great delight - they are awesome Irish who-dun-its, with dark terrible underbellies of corruption and decay - but the prose is easy, free, confident. I love how much Banville understands what Black has done for him, how openly he talks about it. No other writer today is so open and honest about the craft of writing. Perhaps he felt a bit trapped by "Banville the great artist" and had to create "Black, the crime thriller writer" to take the edge off. Seems that way. But still: the Benjamin Black books are not what I would call "easy". They just have a totally different feel and energy to them, with well-drawn characters you can't forget, and plots that ache to be told.
Banville, again, seems to rub people the wrong way - (the interview I link to is all about that) - but for me, the reasons he rubs people the wrong way (like, duh, maybe you should pick up a dictionary from time to time) is the reason I love him. Being smart is fun. Knowing words for things is fun. I was called "elitist" once on my blog for using the word "epistolary". I use it a lot. It happens to be one of my favorite words, just to say, I love the sound of it, and then also: I love it because it is accurate. I could certainly say "letter-writing relationship", or "relationship based on writing letters" - but those are three and four words when there is actually ONE word that will suit: EPISTOLARY. I love that. If that makes me elitist, then I sure am guilty as charged, and happy about it. I would be sad if I didn't know the word "epistolary", and I also would be sad if I encountered words I didn't understand and felt ANGRY and RESENTFUL about it, instead of thinking, "Holy shit, what the hell is that word, let me look that up."
Banville says in the interview, answering to the charge that sometimes he is an "intellectual bully" in his writing (ie: you're gonna sit there, and you're gonna take what I dish out):
“Well, sometimes it’s good to be bullied like that. What I’ve always tried to do is give my prose the same denseness and weight of poetry, and you cannot read a poem and do your knitting at the same time, or think about sex, or what you’re going to have for dinner. You have to read a poem or not read a poem. I want my books to be the same. You read them, or you don’t. If you don’t, that’s fine.�
Love him for his honesty. He is a breath of fresh air. I still have not read The Infinities (the new Banville), and can't wait to read Elegy for April: A Novel
(the new Benjamin Black).
I love how this experiment/project (writing as two separate writers) seems to be continuing. He's committed to it. He's into it. He hasn't dropped it, it's not a pose. I read Christine Falls: A Novel, the first Benjamin Black novel (and Banville never tried to hide his second identity) in one sitting, when I was stranded in O'Hare. Even if I hadn't been stuck in an airport, I probably would have finished that book in a weekend at the most. Once you start it, you can't put it down. The main character, the alcoholic pathologist Quirke, in 1950s Dublin, is a fantastic noir creation, and the feeling of that time - the time of Banville's childhood - lives and leaps off the page. But besides all of that, there is a plot of intrigue and mystery, involving parlors with muffled curtains, and dingy cold-water flats, and secrets about orphanages and Magdalene Laundries, and all the rest. If you haven't read Christine Falls, I can't recommend it highly enough - and the follow-up Benjamin Black novels are also "Quirke" novels. A series. Like Sherlock Holmes. Or Nancy Drew. What a delight. Even just reading the first one, Quirke was so awesome, so compelling, that I knew I wouldn't be done with him when I finished the book. How fun that there are more.
Once again: Interview with John Banville about Benjamin Black and other topics.
More of my posts about Banville/Black:
More on The Sea, by John Banville
"My goodness, these are very deep questions you're asking ..."
A few words before we begin:
1. Sylvia Plath wrote a journal until the end of her life. A highly edited version was published decades ago, with a foreward by husband Ted Hughes who admitted to destroying the final two years of her journal. This was like a bomb going off, and the reverb has lasted to this day. He has been the focus of much anger because of it. He said that he wanted to protect his children from having to read said journal. So it must have been pretty awful. But the loss to Plath fans is incalculable. I do not blame him for his actions, because he had to have been a wreck, but I do regret the loss. In the last decade, a big publishing event was an "unedited" version of Plath's journal with additional material - but sadly, those two years were still not included. So. Please don't insult me by calling them "unedited" then. Thanks. Did Hughes destroy them as he said? Is it possible a copy exists somewhere? Hughes is dead now. Will we ever know? It is something to speculate about (and drool over).
2. My friend Cara is as huge a Plath fan as I am. We have even considered meeting up together at the Lilly Library to go through Plath's papers that are held there.
3. The missing journals are important. Remember how important those journals are to Plath fans, and how much we ache to get our hands on them. How much we believe they do exist somewhere, and how much we long for the day when they are revealed.
4. Cara has just written a tale on her blog - part spy-novel, part international thriller, part homage to Sylvia Plath - starring me, her, and Tracey. One other thing to take note of: Most of the dialogue is direct quotations from Plath's poems, and the narrative is peppered literally with countless references to Plath's work. If you are at all familiar with Plath, you'll recognize some of them.
It is so brilliant what Cara has done here.
Now:
Knowing all of this as a preamble, go read Cara's explanatory note, and then go read the story that my friend Cara has just written.

Irish playwright Seán O'Casey was born on this day, in 1880. He was the first major Irish playwright to deal with slum life, the reality of the Dublin poor.
I have a wonderful anecdote right here about O'Casey - this from his colleague Gabriel Fallon - who wrote (among other things) a book about Seán O'Casey. Here is his goose-bump-inducing description of the rehearsal process (at first rather confusing for all involved, since the play was most definitely "something new") for Juno and the Paycock. O'Casey was not famous yet, not an Irish household name. This was the breakthrough. His association with the Abbey (and Yeats and Lady Gregory) would be quite fruitful - and I think one of his plays had been done by them before ... but Juno was different, and everyone could feel it. Now I'll let Gabriel take over:
We could make nothing of the reading of Juno and the Paycock as it was called. It seemed to be a strange baffling mixture of comedy and tragedy; and none of us could say, with any certainty, whether or not it would stand up on the stage.The dress rehearsal would be held at 5 p.m. on March 2, Sunday. I arrived at the theatre at 4:30 p.m., and found the author there before me looking rather glum and wondering if a rehearsal would take place ... Gradually the players filed in and went to their dressing-rooms. Lennox Robinson arrived shortly before 5 o'clock and was followed by Yeats and Lady Gregory. The curtain rose about 5:36 p.m. so far as I could see and hear while waiting for my cue in the wings the rehearsal seemed to be proceeding smoothly. As soon as I had finished my part of Bentham at the end of the second act I went down into the stalls and sat two seats behind the author. Here for the first time I had an opportunity of seeing something of the play from an objective point of view. I was stunned by the tragic quality of the third act which the magnificent playing of Sara Allgood made almost unbearable. But it was the blistering irony of the final scene which convinced me that this man sitting two seats in front of me was a dramatist of genius, one destined to be spoken of far beyond the confines of the Abbey Theatre ...
We watched the act move on, the furniture removers come and go, the ominous entry of the IRA men, the dragging of Johnny to summary execution, the stilted scene between Jerry Devine and Mary Boyle, and then as with the ensnaring slow impetus of a ninth great wave Allgood's tragic genius rose to an unforgettable climax and drowned the stage in sorrow. How surely was the very butt and sea-mark of tragedy! But suddenly the curtain rises again: are Fitzgerald and McCormick fooling, letting off steam after the strain of rehearsal? Nothing of the kind; for we in the stalls are suddenly made to freeze in our seats as a note beyond tragedy, a blistering flannel-mouthed irony sears its maudlin way across the stage and slowly drops an exhausted curtain on a world disintegrating in 'chassis'.
I sat there stunned. So, indeed, as far as I could see, did Robinson, Yeats, and Lady Gregory. Then Yeats ventured an opinion. He said that the play, particularly in the final scene, reminded him of a Dostoevsky novel. Lady Gregory turned to him and said, "You know, Willie, you never read a novel by Dostoevsky." And she promised to amend this deficiency by sending him a copy of The Idiot. I turned to O'Casey and found I could only say to him, "Magnificent, Seán, magnificent."
The image of Lady Gregory basically cutting "Willie" down to size is so funny to me, but I love the whole anecdote.
Excerpted from Gabriel Fallon's memoir: SEAN O'CASEY: The Man I Knew
TO: LEONARD WOOLF
Rodmell,
Sussex
Tuesday (18? March 1941)
Dearest, I feel certain I am going mad again. I feel we can't go through another of those terrible times. And I shan't recover this time. I begin to hear voices, and I can't concentrate. So I am doing what seems the best thing to do. You have given me the greatest possible happiness. You have been in every way all that anyone could be. I don't think two people could have been happier till this terrible disease came. I can't fight any longer. I know that I am spoiling your life, that without me you could work. And you will I know. You see I can't even write this properly. I can't read. What I want to say is I owe all the happiness of my life to you. You have been entirely patient with me and incredibly good. I want to say that - everybody knows it. If anybody could have saved me it would have been you. Everything has gone from me but the certainty of your goodness. I can't go on spoiling your life any longer.
I don't think two people could have been happier than we have been.
V.

March 28, 1941. After writing that note to her husband, Virginia Woolf put rocks in her pockets and drowned herself in the River Ouse.

In 1981, Rebecca West was interviewed by The Paris Review, and it's included in the first volume of the Paris Review interviews. She was an old woman by this point, 90 years old, living in London. Cataracts had ruined her eyes, she wore glasses that distorted her eyes completely (see Reds to see what I mean), and was also arthritic. But still going strong, writing book reviews, keeping up to date on things, and she's a lively and beautiful interview. Funny. She can be biting in her criticism, especially of other writers.
For example, the interviewer asks her if she does many drafts of her writing. She replies, "I fiddle away a lot at them. Particularly if it's a fairly elaborate thing. I've never been able to do just one draft. That seems a wonderful thing. Do you know anyone who can?" The interview says, "I think D.H. Lawrence did" and Rebecca replies, "You could often tell."
It is, indeed, hard to reconcile the little white-haired old lady (or her younger glamorous self) with some of the most insightful analyses of fascism and totalitarian politics of the 20th century, but that's the beauty of Dame Rebecca. She was a suffragette - she got her start writing for a suffragette newspaper in 1912 (amazing, her lifespan, what she saw in one life - amazing) - and while she always considered herself a feminist, for very good reasons, the struggles of the day being what they are, she separated herself from the group, very consciously, a little bit later, because of the focus on chastity and birth control and moral issues, which didn't interest her in the slightest. She didn't judge those who subscribed to those views (she talks about it a bit in the interview), it was just that she was into political power and equality, and the focus on sex seemed to take the movement in another way. She says in the interview about her break with the suffragette movement: "I admired them enormously, but all that business about venereal disease, which was supposed to be round every corner, seemed to me excessive. I wasn't in a position to judge, but it did seem a bit silly." She talks of Christabel Pankhurst, a leading suffragette, who ran a chastity campaign for women. The thing about Rebecca is that when she talks of all of these people, she actually knew all of them. Nothing is abstract with her. She disliked all of the retrospective analysis about the suffragettes, because so much of it seemed to come from people who weren't there and who didn't know what it was like on the ground at that time, and, frankly, they didn't know what they were talking about. Here's another example. The name David Mitchell comes up - West mentions him as the man who "writes silly, hysterical books about Christabel Pankhurts. What is he? Who is he?" The interviewer asks her more about her opinion on his book on Christabel - and West replies: "[His book was] absolutely rubbish and nonsense. He writes about how she went to Paris and how she didn't go down to the cafes and meet the young revolutionaries. But how on earth was she to find out where they were? Because, you see, the Bolshevik generation was not yet identifiable. How would she find out any of the people, who hadn't really made their mark? It was an obscure time in the history of revolution. It was a time when very remarkable people were coming up, but they weren't visible yet. She did know the people like Henri de Rochefort very well. Mitchell also says she took a flat and had a housekeeper, who was also a very good cook, and didn't that show great luxury? Well, if he'd asked anybody, he would have found that, in those days, you couldn't take a furnished flat or house in Paris, nor, so far as I know, in most parts of France, unless you took a servant, who was left by the owner. All the furnished houses I ever had in France, modest as they were, had somebody that I had to take with the house." While this may seem like a silly thing to get up in arms about, it is not. Because Mr. Mitchell is making a judgment on someone's seriousness by making a false assumption. He makes that false assumption because he is ideological, as opposed to practical, and he wasn't there, and he is not asking the right questions - due to his ideological bent. He had a bone to pick with Christabel Pankhurst, and wanted to take her off her pedestal ("some revolutionary - she had a maid!!") Rebecca West calls him out on this, despite her own feelings about Pankhurst's later work and how she broke with the movement because of it. Look at how clear-headed one must be, how unaffiliated with ANY group, to make all of those distinct analytical points. She doesn't like sloppy writing, certainly, but more than that she doesn't like sloppy thinking. And those who are hell bent on making a point, out of their defensiveness for whatever cause they stand for, are sloppy thinkers, more often than not. You can see it all around us today, and I suppose you can see it in any generation of writers and political thinkers.
Here are some excerpts from the interview, to give you a taste of it. The "idiots and lunatics" question (that was her label for how men and women react, in different ways, to upheaval: Women are idiots and men are lunatics) is based on a whole chapter in Black Lamb and Grey Falcon, where she breaks it down at great length, what she means by it, and how it manifests itself - in England, certainly, but also everywhere. Here, she is asked about it and gives a brief answer - but I just wanted to point that out as one of her philosophical analyses, something she wrote about at great length in her life, and which became much of the backbone of her master work. Just because Rebecca West herself could not be classified as an "idiot" (at least in her terminology) - doesn't lessen her argument. She always stood apart from groups. She grew up in a family who came from great wealth, but for many reasons, did not have that wealth in West's time. So there was an air of faded grandeur about her family, and it seems like her parents sort of let their children run free and wild. Rebecca West went to school, but other than that, she spent her time un-managed, un-watched-over - her parents just didn't impose on her any expectations, based on the fact that she was a girl. While that may have made life tougher for her (to be taken seriously as a serious writer about politics at the time was no small task), it also gives her that clear-sighted unmistakable voice that she has. She paid a price for her outsider status - made even worse by her scandalous affair with HG Wells, which ended in a baby - but again, she just kept going.
I also was fascinated, FASCINATED, by the fact that she says she always wished she could write like Mark Twain. What?? I love that! I love that not just because I love Mark Twain, but that it just goes to show you that West was unconnected, again, from typical influences. She did not follow along with the normal trends, in literature (her words on Tolstoy below, for example), and her words on Mark Twain were so exciting to me (you'll see why when you read the excerpt. Look at what she is able to discern in him ...)
Here are some excerpts from the interview:
"From an early age - but it was not detected for many, many years - I've had difficulty about hearing. Finally, I lost my hearing almost entirely in this ear, I got pneumonia in it, which I think is rather chic."
"We had large classes [at school], which was an ineffable benefit, because the teachers really hadn't time to muck about with our characters."
"[Women] are idiots and men are lunatics. It's a perfectly good division. The Greek root of idiot means "private person"; men "see the world as if by moonlight, which shows the outlines of every object but not the details indicative of their nature". It seems to me in any assembly where you get people, who are male and female, in a crisis, the women are apt to get up and, with a big wave of the hand, say, It's all very well talking about the defenses of the country, but there are thirty-six thousand houses in whatever (wherever they're living) that have no bathrooms. Surely, it's more important to have clean children for the future. Silly stuff, when the enemy's at the gate. But men are just as silly. Even when there are no enemies at the gate, they won't attend to the bathrooms, because they say defense is more important. It's mental deficiency in both cases."
"I should like to be approved of, oh, yes. I blench. I hate being disapproved of. I've had rather a lot of it."
"Well, I longed, when I was young, to write as well as Mark Twain. It's beautiful stuff and I always liked him. If I wanted to write anything that attacked anybody, I used to have a look at his attack on Christian Science, which is beautifully written. He was a man of very great shrewdness. The earliest article on the Nazis, on Nazism, a sort of first foretaste, a prophetic view of the war, was an article by Mark Twain in Harper's in, I should think, the nineties. He went to listen to the Parliament in Vienna and he describes an awful row and what the point of view of Luger, the Lord Mayor, was, and the man called George Schwartz, I think, who started the first Nazi paper, and what it must all lead to. It's beautifully done. It's the very first notice that I've ever found of the Austrian Nazi Party, that started it all."
"I just saw violence [before the First World War]. There was the race thing and sacred Germanism and all that, but the enemy before the First World War you can't really compare with fascism. It was the imperialism of Germany and the supremacy of the army, but that isn't exactly fascism. I think you could say, there was more fascism, but of an intellectualized kind, in France. The crux of the Dreyfus case was that it didn't matter whether Dreyfus was guilty or not, you mustn't spoil the image of the army. That was more or less fascist."
"If there is a God, I don't think He would demand that anybody bow down or stand up to Him. I have often a suspicion God is still trying to work things out and hasn't finished."
"People were very rude just because they'd heard I was a woman writer. That kind of rudeness is as bad as ever."
"No [advantages in being a woman] whatsoever. You could have a good time as a woman, but you'd have a much better time as a man. If in the course of some process, people turn up a card with a man's name on it and then a card with a woman's, they feel much softer toward the man, even though he might be a convicted criminal. They'd treat the man's card with greater tenderness."
"You know, I don't really appreciate the Virgin Mary. She always looks so dull. I particularly hate Raphael, Raphael's Madonnas. They are awful, aren't they?"
"My life has been dictated to and broken up by forces beyond my control. I couldn't control the two wars! The second war had a lot of personal consequences for me, both before and after. But I had enough money at that time, because I had a large herd of cows and a milk contract. I had to take some part in looking after the cows, but the dear things worked for me industriously."
"I'm a heretic about Tolstoy. I really don't see War and Peace as a great novel because it seems constantly to be trying to prove that nobody who was in the war knew what was going on. Well, I don't know whoever thought they would - that if you put somebody down in the wildest sort of mess they understand what's happening."
"I write books to find out about things. I wrote Saint Augustine because, believe it or not, there was no complete life in English at that time."
"It's an absurd error to put modern English literature in the curriculum. You should read contemporary literature for pleasure or not read it at all. You shouldn't be taught to monkey with it. It's ghastly to think of all the little girls who are taught to read To the Lighthouse. It's not really substantial food for the young b ecause there's such a strong feeling that Virginia Woolf was doing a set piece and it didn't really matter very much. She was putting on an act. Shakespeare didn't put on an act. But Orlando is a lovely original splash, a beautiful piece of fancy. Leonard Woolf had a tiresome mind. When you read his books about Malaya, and then the books of the cadets who went out there, he's so petty, and they have such an enthusiasm and such tolerance for the murderous habits of the natives. But he was certainly good to Virginia. I couldn't forgive Vanessa Bell for her awful muddy decorations and those awful pictures of Charlotte Bronte. And I hated Duncan Grant's pictures too. The best thing that was ever said about Bloomsbury was said by a lovely butler of mine. At dinner one evening, they began to talk of Faulkner's book in which someone uses a corncob for the purposes of rape. They were being terribly subtle, and doing this and that gesture over the table. The butler came into my son Anthony's room and asked, Do you know where they keep the Faulkners? It seems they're very saucy. Virginia Woolf's criticism was much better than criticism others were writing then."
"I wanted to write a book on Finland, which is a wonderful case of a small nation with empires here and there, so I learned Finnish and I read a Finnish novel. It was all about people riding bicycles. But then, when I went to Yugoslavia, I saw it was much more exciting with Austria and Russia and Turkey, and so I wrote that. I really did enjoy it terribly, loved it."
"I find Tom Stoppard just as amusing as I ever found Shaw. Very amusing, both as a playwright and as himself. But I'm not now an admirer of Shaw. It was a poor mind, I think. I liked his wife so much better. He was conceited, but in an odd way. Usually, you know, it's people shouting to keep their spirits up, but he really did think he was better than most people."
"What [Yeats] liked was solemnity, and, if you were big enough, heavy enough, and strong enough, he loved you. He loved great big women. He would have been mad about Vanessa Redgrave."
"I've aroused hostility in an extraordinary lot of people. I've never known why. I don't think I'm formidable."
"[Augustine] wasn't a heretic. Most of his life he wasn't at all a nice man, but that's quite a different thing. I like to think about people like the Donatists, who were really suffering agonies of one kind and another because the Roman Empire was splitting up and it was especially uncomfortable to be in Roman Africa. But they didn't know anything about economics, and did know about theology. Theology had taught them that if you suffered, it was usualy because you'd offended God - so they invented an offense against God, which was that unworthy priests were celebrating the Sacraments. So that satisfied them and then they went round the country, looting and getting the food and the property they wanted because they said that they were punishing heretics. I think it's wonderful that in the past people overlooked things that now seem to us quite obvious, and thought they were doing things for the reasons they weren't, and tried to remedy them by actions. Perhaps there's some simple thing we'll think of someday, which will make us much happier."

I've got a couple of what I call "intellectual idols", people who analyze and parse the world and its events, in a way that seems singular, important, and (in some cases) life-altering (for me). I was one way before I read Ryszard Kapuscinski. After reading him, I will never look at the world in the same way again. George Orwell is another one. Robert Kaplan is another one. I suppose Alexander Hamilton is another one, although I think of him more as my boyfriend. His perspective was, in many respects, larger and more sweeping than his contemporaries - for a variety of reasons. He was an immigrant? He wasn't attached to one colony emotionally? He had grown up in a mercantile atmosphere, not agrarian at all - so he did not fear big money, and the loss of an agricultural economy. Who knows why - but he had a longer view going on than most, as far-seeing as all of "those guys" were. Robert Conquest is another intellectual idol. This is not about total agreement, by the way, which never interests me in the slightest. This is about people who seem to have some sort of perspective on events, perspective that gives them the LONG view of things, as opposed to the short. In many cases, these people (while very political) rise above politics, at least in the every-day mucky muck of them, and they see things in different contexts, because they understand history, because they can PLACE certain events in a context that makes them seem completely different. You are forever changed once you get that kind of perspective.
But the grand pooh-bah of intellectual idols is Rebecca West.
I am now reading her A Train of Powder, which I can't believe hasn't been on my radar at all. It's certainly not going to be found at your local Barnes & Noble, where you can easily find Black Lamb and Grey Falcon
, her masterwork.
As with many of these people I mention, they are interconnected. Robert Kaplan introduced me to Kapuscinski and also Rebecca West (his Balkan Ghosts: A Journey Through History follows in her footsteps through the former Yugoslavia). In my opinion, he is definitely her heir.
Train of Powder is made up of four very long essays having to do with various trials that West, as a journalist, covered, one being the Nuremberg Trials. The Nuremberg Trials are broken up into three long parts, each one called "Greenhouse with Cyclamens". One of the things that is so extraordinary about Rebecca West, and why she is so revered by anyone who wants to write thoughtfully about history and politics, is that she was able to see things before others did. (Or, not ALL others, but she certainly stands apart) She traveled through Yugoslavia in 1938, 1939. Not only could she sense the cataclysm that was to come in WWII (she is especially brutal about the German tourists she observed on the train - in them, she can see the entire Nazi Party) - but she predicts the breakup of Yugoslavia some 50 years later, and the genocidal campaigns of people like Slobodan Milosevic. Nobody who read her book would be at all shocked that Serbia would rise in such a monstrous way. Of course they did. Retrospect makes prophets of us all, and there are many who could say, "I saw it coming ..." Yes: but could you have seen it coming in 1938? There was something about Rebecca West's mind - cold and detached (yet she comes off incredibly warm in interviews) - that kept her above events, without the accompanying sense of superiority that so often comes with detached individuals.
She seems always to be on the side of the individual, which again separates her from her contemporaries - many of whom were swayed by Socialist ideas (Orwell and others) but she really never was. She considered herself a radical and a feminist, to be sure, but she always has a very healthy suspicion of any group, and such people are really rare - and almost nonexistent today, at least in political writing, where everything is about propping up your GROUP. West saw what group-identity-politics could wrought, in places like Yugoslavia, and then also in places like Germany, and she conscoiusly separated herself from the pack: "No, thanks. Not for me." Not an easy stance to take, and she is often mistaken for a reactionary which makes me chuckle - because that is so often the accusation thrown towards someone who refuses to "play well with others", who never drank the Kool-Aid in the first place.
I am devouring Train of Powder at the speed of light. The first big essay about the Nuremberg Trials has many different aspects to it: the vibe, in general, at the time, for those journalists who had been observing the trials in their entirety: the intense boredom, and the homesickness, but that's just one element. She's an incredible observer, which makes you want to read everything she writes, just to see how she interprets things. The whole "greenhouse" she encounters during her stay at a huge country house in Germany where all the press were camped out - is incredible because she takes the fact of the greenhouse (and the one legged gardener, and his devotion to cyclamens) and extrapolates out of that the meaning of the entire German people following the war. It's not a stretch. This is a woman who observed history, who knew revolutions and wars, who understood tyranny on a deep Hannah-Arendt level.
Yet she was also a humanist. This gives her writing the power and scope that it has.
She sat in the press box in the court room at Nuremberg, for months on end, and observed, taking in everything: the zaniness of much of it (due, perhaps, to the fact that a trial like this had never occurred before), the behavior of the "defendants" (what a good eye she has), and thoughts on what all of this would actually mean. What exactly is going on here? She makes insightful observations - which probably rang uneasily in the minds of her contemporaries, who were still under the sway of the glorious revolution going on in Russia, something she never fell prey to. For example, she notes that the international judges, each read different parts of what each defendant was accused of. Here she observes:
It turned out that the Russian was reading the part of the judgment that condemned the Germans for their deportations: for taking men and women away from their homes and sending them to distant camps, where they worked as slave labour in conditions of great discomfort, and were often unable to communicate with their families. There was here a certain irony, and a certain warning.
The essay was written in 1946. It is fresh news. It was unpopular, at that moment in time, to criticize Russia - for various reasons - and many just decided to stick their heads in the sand, to avoid uncomfortable truths. That was never Rebecca West's bag.
She's good on all aspects here - atmosphere, context, analysis - this is journalism of the highest order, a dying art, which is one of the reasons why I love Robert Kaplan so much. If you read his books (which are part travelogue, part journalism, part history), and his long articles in The Atlantic Monthly, you can see a similar context at work. It doesn't surprise me at all that he considers Rebecca West to be his idol as well. You can feel him trying to be as good as her, in his thoughts, analysis, and perspective. In many respects, he succeeds. My favorites of his are The Ends of the Earth: From Togo to Turkmenistan, from Iran to Cambodia, a Journey to the Frontiers of Anarchy, Warrior Politics: Why Leadership Demands a Pagan Ethos
, and the aforementioned Balkan Ghosts. Recently Kaplan has become quite involved in the US military, which connects him inextricably to a group - something I view warily, because I care so much about his work. I would hate to see him lose his perspective due to his affinity for one particular group. All of that being said, the two books he has written about the US military (and he plans on writing two more, I believe) are massive accomplishments that I consider to be required reading, for anyone looking for context. Again: he is looking at things through a prism, another kind of lens than a jingoistic "my country right or wrong" lens, which may be satisfying in the short-term, but certainly won't last as a work of literature past the current generation. His two books (Imperial Grunts
and Hog Pilots, Blue Water Grunts
) are fantastic examinations of the US military, its purpose and mission, but also its place in history. He talks to people. He gives great portraits of the men and women fighting in our military. You get to know them. He has traveled the world (obviously). He is not afraid to look deeply. He has spent his career examining other cultures - traveling through Iran and Indonesia and Turkey. In An Empire Wilderness: Travels into America's Future
, he took that same journalistic observational eye he has turned on other cultures, and turned it on America. That one also is a must-read, actually. Bah. Just read all of his books, won't you? He's one of the few authors out there where I wait with baited breath for his latest.
But back to Rebecca West. (It is hard to talk about her without referencing the generations of writers she inspired ...)
I was particularly riveted by West's observations about the defendants in the Nuremberg Trials, some more monstrous than others. Here are a couple of excerpts showing her thoughts on Hermann Wilhelm Göring, which gives just a taste of her gift. There really is nobody else like her.
And though one had read surprising news of Göring for years, he still surprised. He was so very soft. Sometimes he wore a German Air Force uniform, and sometimes a light beach suit in the worst of playful taste, and both hung loosely on him, giving him an air of pregnancy. He had thick brown young hair, the coarse bright skin of an actor who has used grease paint for decades, and the preternaturally deep wrinkles of the drug addict. It added up to something like the head of a ventriloquist's dummy. He looked infinitely corrupt, and acted naively. When the other defendants' lawyers came to the door to receive instructions, he often intervened and insisted on instructing them himself, in spite of the evident fury of the defendants, which, indeed, must have been poignant, since most of them might well have felt that, had it not been for him, they never would have had to employ these lawyers at all. One of these lawyers was a tiny little man of very Jewish appearance, and when he stood in front of the dock, his head hardly reaching to the top of it, and flapped his gown in annoyance because Göring's smiling wooden mask was bearing down between him and his client, it was as if a ventriloquist had staged a quarrel between two dummies.Göring's appearance made a strong but obscure allusion to sex. It is a matter of history that his love affairs with women played a decisive part in the development of the Nazi party at various stages, but he looked as one who would never lift a hand against a woman save in something much more peculiar than kindness. He did not look like any recognized type of homosexual, yet he was feminine. Sometimes, particularly when his humour was good, he recalled the madam of a brothel. His like are to be seen in the late morning in doorways along the steep streets of Marseille, the professional mask of geniality still hard on their faces though they stand relaxed in leisure, their fat cuts rubbing against their spread skirts. Certainly there had been a concentration on appetite, and on elaborate schemes for gratifying it; and yet there was a sense of desert thirst. No matter what aqueducts he had built to bring water to his encampment, some perversity in the architecture had let it run out and spill on the sands long before it reached him. Sometimes even now his wide lips smacked together as if he were a well-fed man who had heard no news as yet that his meals were to stop. He was the only one of all these defendants who, if he had the chance, would have walked out of the Palace of Justice and taken over Germany again, and turned it into the stage for the enactment of the private fantasy which had brought him to the dock.
As is well-known, the day before Göring was to be put to death, he killed himself in his cell. Rebecca West has some choice words about that event.
The executions were to take place on October 16. Some time during the preceding night Göring killed himself. The enormous clown, the sexual quiddity with the smile which was perhaps too wooden for mockery and perhaps not, had kicked the tray out of the hands of the servants who were bringing him the wine of humiliation, the glasses had flown into the air and splintered with a sound too much like laughter. This should not have happened. We are all hunters, but we know ourselves hunted by a mightier hunter, and our hearts are with the hunted, and we rejoice when the snared get free of the snare. In this moment visceral mournfulness changed to visceral cheerfulness; we had to applaud for the flesh that would not accept the doom that had been dealt to it but changed it to an expression of defiance. All those people who had fled from Nuremberg, British and American and French, who were scattered over the world, trying to forget the place of their immurement, would straighten up from whatever they had been bent over and burst out laughing before they could help themselves, saying, "That one! We always knew he would get the better of us yet." Surely all those Germans who walked through the rubble of their cities while their conquerors drove, they too would halt, and throw back their heads, and laugh, and say, "That one! We always knew he would get the better of them yet."Göring should not have been permitted even this small amelioration of his doom. True, we now know some reasons for feeling that he might have been allowed to get a little of his own back. Like all the Nazis, he had been plagued by the attentions of the psychiatrists who haunted Nuremberg Jail, exercising a triple function of priest and doctor and warder hard to approve. They visited the men in the cells and offered themselves as confidants, but performed duties at the behest of the court authorities. When some of the defendants seemed to be taking an unrepentant pro-Nazi stand in their line of defence, one of the psychiatrists worked out, at the commandant's request, a plan for a new seating arrangement at the lunch table in order to break up this group and expose them to other influences. It is not easy to think of an accused person on trial before a national tribunal being subjected to such manipulation by prison officials. There was no silver lining to this cloud. One of these psychiatrists has related, without humorous intention, that when Göring asked him what a certain psychological test had revealed about his character, he replied that it had shown that he lacked the guts to face responsibility. Göring had also the benefit of spiritual care of a remarkably robust kind. He asked the Lutheran chaplain to give him Holy Communion on the night before the executions, but the chaplain refused, on the ground that he was probably shamming.
Nevertheless Göring should not have been given the chance to use his courage to weaken public horror at his crimes, to which his courage was not relevant. The Nazis were maniacs who plastered history with the cruelty which is a waste product of man's moral nature, as maniacs on a smaller scale plaster their bodies and their clothes with their excreta. Since sanity is to some extent a matter of choice, a surrender to certain stimuli and a rejection of others, the nature of mania should never be forgotten. It is unfair, not only to Germans, but to all the world, if the vileness of the Nazis be extenuated; and it was unfair that this Nazi of all Nazis should have been allowed to disguise his gross dementia. This suicide meant a long-term danger to human standards, and it might have meant a short-term danger too, had it not been for the severity of the following winter. Germany was to be ice-bound and water-logged and had no time to think of reviving the Nazi party; and if that stretch of bad weather broke Europe's heart, it also broke the continuity of popular political thinking and forced it on to a fresh phase not shadowed by resentment at conquest. But the Allies had failed idiotically in a prime matter. All to no purpose had the military policeman in the CIP gallery shaken the venerable Lord of Appeal and bidden him wake up and uncross his legs. All to no purpose had his colleague waved his club round the ears of the judge and asked him how the hell he had got in. All to no purpose had the maternal colonel shadowed our passes with his pendulous bosom. The cyanide had freely flowed.
She is magnificent. A Train of Powder is a must-read.
I mentioned my sonnet ritual here, and talked a little bit about Stephen Booth's (the editor) acceptance of multiple meanings to such a dizzying degree that there are times when you do get lost. He's okay with that, very unlike most scholars (and readers, come to think of it). His 1970s edition of the Sonnets is still in print today, and still definitive (and I was so pleased to see that someone bought a copy of this edition from the link in that post - Yay!). As I mentioned, the sonnets take up 130 pages of text, and then there are 400 pages of footnotes. A true glimpse at the level of "close reading" done by Stephen Booth. He does not see it as his job to come up with one meaning, because the Sonnets resist that kind of analysis, in and of themselves - otherwise they wouldn't have haunted people for centuries and made people think: "Dark lady? WTF? What is going on here???" There is no ultimate KEY that unlocks them. The sense comes in the acceptance of many meanings. Shakespeare was big on puns, and interconnected words - either through sound or synonyms - one word can call up many responses and correlations, and Shakespeare is always working on that level. Booth reminds us again and again of this tendency, and this morning I read Sonnet 11 - another one of the early sonnets that seems to be saying, mainly: "If you do not marry and procreate, your life is basically worthless"
And one of the footnotes struck me as indicative of the kind of analysis that Booth is so good at, so I thought I would share it. It should speak for itself, and if you are at all familiar with a lot of Shakespeare scholarship, you will know that almost nobody writes or thinks like Stephen Booth. At least not nowadays. There are times when he reminds me of T.S. Eliot, who wrote eloquently on Shakespeare, and sometimes Auden (who gave a series of lectures on Shakespeare - here's just one example) - but that should tell you how singular Booth is, because Eliot and Auden are not academics. They are poets. Their focus and filter is different, and, in my estimation - when I read them on Shakespeare, much of the text starts to literally come to life for me, jumping off the page. The opposite is true of so much Shakespearean scholarship - which seems to deaden the text, silencing it completely through the exhaustive analysis.
1 As fast as thou shalt wane so fast thou growest -
2 In one of thine, from that which thou departest,
3 And that fresh blood which youngly thou bestow'st
4 Thou mayst call thine when thou from youth convertest.
5 Herein lives wisdom, beauty and increase;
6 Without this, folly, age and cold decay:
7 If all were minded so, the times should cease,
8 And threescore year would make the world away.
9 Let those whom Nature hath not made for store,
10 Harsh, featureless and rude, barrenly perish.
11 Look, whom she best endow'd, she gave the more;
12 Which bounteous gift thou shouldst in bounty cherish.
13 She carved thee for her seal, and meant thereby
14 Thou shouldst print more, not let that copy die.
The sense of this seems pretty clear to me. If I had to paraphrase: "Nature means for you to pass on your genes to your wife, and to create children. Without children, there is no meaning to life."
Booth doesn't disagree, but what he does with the footnotes is so spectacular: he does not search for the ultimate meaning. He goes word by word by word, teasing out thoughts, references, puns, different meanings - and then just leaves you sitting in the kaleidoscope he has just created. It may seem MORE confusing when you're done, and part of the fun is to read his footnotes (some of which go on for pages at a time), and then go back and read the Sonnet full through again. Watch how different it appears. The prism has shifted. You're in the rainbow. I am a great lover of the Sonnets - always have been, since high school - they appealed to my OCD nature, I liked that they were all together, that there was some mystery to them, that if you read them in order they start to tell a story, but you just can't see enough of it to get the whole thing. I liked that. Booth's notes, and HOW he "analyzes" here - really jars me, and I love him for that. Who is so willing to sit in the not-knowing but Booth? He helps me. He shows me HOW to think. Or, let's say, another way to think - which involves shattering apart each word, and leaving it all in pieces, and then moving on. Don't try to put it back together. That's the failing of the modern reader.
So let's look at just one note for this Sonnet, which seems to illustrate Booth's startling gift for 1. analysis and 2. openness to confusion and incompletion - a rare combination of assets in anyone, but totally bizarre in a scholar.
Here he is on line 2 in the Sonnet.
2. In one of thine (1) in the womb of your wife; (2) in the person of your child. from that which thou departest (1) out of that (i.e. sperm) which you bestow (this reading enhances a probable sexual meaning of wane in line 1 as male loss of tumescence after sexual emission; for other Renaissance examples of "depart" and "depart from" meaning "bestow", see OED, 2, 13); (2) as a result of that (your youth) which you now leave behind. No note can take in all the permutations that occur among the various meanings of the words and phrases in lines 1 and 2 in all their relationship to one another. The crush of meanings in these lines is further swelled by overtones of three other common uses of "depart" - all pertinent to this context, all called up in a reader's mind, but, unlike the two meanings given above, not syntactically harnessed to the sentence in which they appear or capable of inclusion in its particular logic: (a) "depart" meant "put asunder" (OED, 3), and the use of the word here invokes an echo of the Elizabethan marriage service (in which its use - "to have and to hold ... till death us depart" - would have been as familiar as the words that replaced it in 1622 - "till death us do part" - are now), an echo that relates to two topics of the sonnet, marriage and death; (b) "depart" was used intransitively as a synonym for "die" (OED, 7); (c) the common construction "depart from," which ordinarily means "go away from," appears here in a context in which that meaning is substantially relevant but syntactically impossible.
Recently I read Ron Rosenbaum's fantastic book The Shakespeare Wars: Clashing Scholars, Public Fiascoes, Palace Coups, a history of the cultural and literary wars fought over Shakespeare's work. It's a tremendous book, written in almost a frenzied prose (I love how excited Rosenbaum gets about things, I have always loved his op-ed columns for this reason), as Rosenbaum tries to dig his way through all the material, while maintaining not just his love for Shakespeare (that is too gentle a word) - more like his exhilaration, his despair. Marvelous book, highly recommended.
There is a whole chapter devoted to Stephen Booth, a fascinating guy, a giant in the landscape of Shakespeare scholarship, whose 1970s edition of the Sonnets is still in print, and still the dominant edition to get. It's the edition I have had since college. I didn't know anything about Stephen Booth at the time, but that's the version "to get" - I also have all of the Sonnets in my Riverside Shakespeare, of course, but that book weighs 89 pounds, so if you just want to flip through the Sonnets, or read one of the specific plays on its own, you have to deal with this giant TOME that you can't take anywhere. That's why I have all the plays separately, as well as the Sonnets. I have mentioned before that I find reading the Sonnets relaxing when I'm stressed out. I have my favorites, and those aren't necessarily the ones that speak to me, or seem to reflect my own feelings. Lots of times, they are the ones that baffle me the most, or seem to suggest an entire world in those 14 lines, a world I can only get a glimpse of.
Here's the thing about Stephen Booth's version, to give you an idea: There are 154 Sonnets. In the Booth version, you have his edited version on one side of the page, and then the facsimile of the sonnets on the opposite page - so you can see the punctuation/spelling of the original. Booth is not big on messing wtih Shakespeare's punctuation, as other editors are, adding exclamation points willy nilly. He is very specific on why he edits, what he chooses to edit - his main concern is to try to provide a context where the modern-day reader can perhaps approximate the response of an Elizabethan-era reader.
But one of the most stand-out features of Booth's version, and why I recommend it above all others, is that he does not concern himself with meaning. That may sound like an odd thing to say with an edition of the Sonnets where the Sonnets themselves take up 130 pages and then there over 400 pages of footnotes. What I mean by my statement is this: too many editions of Shakespeare try to iron out his ultimate meaning, they try to explain to the reader: "Here is exactly what he is saying here." By doing so, you certainly lessen the poem itself - it's like taking apart a clock and still expecting it to tell you the time. By trying to nail down ONE meaning, you discount Shakespeare's propensity for multiple layers, puns, correlations, mysterious things connected. Not to mention the fact that when you try to paraphrase Shakespeare, you completely destroy him. Booth is different from his contemporaries in that his concern is with the MULTIPLE layers of meaning in every word, every phrase - and ... AND ... he makes no conclusion. He is not interpreting meaning. No. What he is doing is showing us how to do an "extremely close reading" of these Sonnets, and to let the mysteries stand. To not try to stabilize a world which is inherently unstable.
This could be frustrating, I suppose, for a reader who wants to know what the hell Shakespeare is saying.
Rosenbaum discusses Booth's manner of analysis - taking as an example Booth's footnotes for Sonnet 40 in The Shakespeare Wars:
Try reading aloud Booth's seven-part explication of the ambiguities; it's criticism that rises to the level of poetry itself. Booth's footnote to line 5 in which he unfolds the dazzling multiplicity of possible meanings of "for", "love" and "receivest", and how each shift in meaning in one unfolds multiple shifts in the others, is an example of the polysemous pleasures of his reading of the Sonnets. Pleasures that almost threaten to dissolve not just the singularity of meaning - but the singularity itself.Booth doesn't encourage one to choose one particular combination of "for", "love" or "receivest" but rather to contemplate - to revel in - the way the multiple possibilities are choreographed. Change one's way of looking at one word's connotation and the other two dance to a new tune. Look at another word through a different lens and the others shift into a new focus. It's a dizzying but pleasurable destabilization. One won't crack one's head open going off this cliff, but it might open the mind in a way it hasn't been opened before. Something Boothian commentary tries to celebrate. To celebrate the way words and meanings in effect enact a beautiful and pleasurable dance of significations in which one possible meaning of "for" might combine with four other possibilities for "receivest" and then four more for "love" in an exponentially more complex and yet deeply pleasurable way. The way entertaining all possible, that is plausible, meanings at once is preferable to attempting reductively to single out one.
I couldn't quite have put it into words like that, but I do know that my sensibility is drawn towards possibilities rather than certainty. It's just the way I'm built, and I respond to things that seem to suggest other things, rather than just state what they are, and demand that you accept it. I'm working on a big post right now about Jeremy Renner and John Wayne that seems to connect to this, but I'll save that for later. I also haven't thought a lot about Stephen Booth - until I encountered him in Rosenbaum's book, even though he's been on my shelf since college. But I didn't know who the dude was, didn't care, I was in it for Shakespeare and this was the best version.
Rosenbaum tries to track Booth down, they share emails, conversation ... Rosenbaum basically wants to know what it is like to be able to read like Stephen Booth. What is it like to be able to read so closely? Booth is rather cagey, and yet what I liked so much about him is how much he seems to be about pleasure. You have to listen very closely in order to get that, but it is there. It is one of the things that really sets his work apart. He is against the grain of lit-crit right now - which doesn't believe in authorship, really, only historical context and patriarchy and all that humorless boring stuff which is trying to iron out the world into a manageable narrative. Booth just never even gives lit-crit Theory the time of day. He doesn't even engage them. He is on his own. His pleasure from Shakespeare is also refreshing because much of it comes from a few specific memories of seeing Shakespeare productions when he was a kid, and having various "a-ha" moments. Regardless, I won't summarize Rosenbaum's chapter on Booth - it should be read all of a piece - but after reading The Shakespeare Wars, I decided to go back and read the Sonnets, in so-called chronological order, and also commit to going through the footnotes, sonnet by sonnet. It is a dizzying experience - and while I have used the footnotes before as reference (ie: what the fuck, Will?) - I haven't really sat in them, and then gone back to the sonnet, and then back to the footnote, and then back. You really can get lost. There is no "up", "down", "left", "right". Booth does not give meaning - although I've never been into that anyway - what a sonnet "means" is not as important to me as how it is said. Booth gives all possible meanings that he can come up with.
Some of the Sonnets have footnotes that are 5 pages long. One note alone can be two pages long.
This is a volume to literally get lost in, and that's what I am doing right now. It is overwhelming, and there is a time when the brain basically turns off - becomes saturated - so I have given myself the task of reading one sonnet (and its accompanying notes) per day. It's a nice morning ritual. Like I said, many of these Sonnets I practically know by heart, and they are things I turn to repeatedly. Not so much for their meaning, but because I find the act of reading them to be comforting somehow.
I'm reading them differently right now - that is my little assignment right now - trying to just follow Booth down the various rabbit holes, and not worry about getting lost in one damn footnote: getting lost seems to be the point.
If you want to understand me, then all you need to know is that I find this stuff as exhilarating as a roller coaster. The challenge is the pleasure. The sheer difficulty of some of it. The arduousness. Flipping back and forth from Sonnet to note and back. I never want it to end.
So I thought I'd give an example of what Booth is about. Here is Sonnet 8. Followed by just one of Stephen Booth's notes.
1 Music to hear, why hear'st thou music sadly?
2 Sweets with sweets war not, joy delights in joy.
3 Why lovest thou that which thou receivest not gladly,
4 Or else receivest with pleasure thine annoy?
5 If the true concord of well-tuned sounds,
6 By unions married, do offend thine ear,
7 They do but sweetly chide thee, who confounds
8 In singleness the parts that thou shouldst bear.
9 Mark how one string, sweet husband to another,
10 Strikes each in each by mutual ordering,
11 Resembling sire and child and happy mother
12 Who all in one, one pleasing note do sing:
13 Whose speechless song, being many, seeming one,
14 Sings this to thee: 'thou single wilt prove none.'
And here is Stephen Booth's note on lines 5-8. Notice the acceptance of ambiguity and multiple meanings, and a complete disregard for the need of tidiness, or A to B paraphrasing:
5 - 8: Shakespeare's use of language is such that a reader can make no paraphrase that both follows the syntax of the lines and says what he knows the lines mean. One can almost always make a general paraphrase of a Shakespeare sonnet and give a satisfactory gloss for any particular word in it, but if one puts together a new sentence replacing Shakespeare's word with their glosses, one will often get a sentence that makes no sense at all. Sometimes Shakespeare's own sentences can be demonstrated to mean nothing at all - even where readers actually understand them perfectly. This second quatrain of sonnet 8 is an excellent example. Lines 5-6 introduce the running theme of the preceding seven sonnets (all of which urge a young man to marry and beget children) by using language that is both musical and marital (e.g. unions, married, and concord [literally "hearts together"]) to say, "If polyphonic music is distasteful to you." The language of lines 7-8 continues the double frame of reference, music and marriage. Going along at a normal reading speed a reader will presumably recognize an appropriate, if imprecise, metaphor of a musician "bearing a part" (one of the parts) in a piece of polyphonic music and understand who confounds / In singleness the parts that thou shouldst bear as a repetition of what several sonnets have just said: "who are doing wrong in remaining single". Editors and students are pressed for something more specific; the best paraphrase I have seen is this one by Ingram and Redpath (who make a point of its insufficiency): "who, by remaining single, suppress those roles (of husband and father) which you should play." The clause effectively says much more than that and literally says much less. The coherence of the paraphrase is achieved by means of substitutions whose meanings are not quite those of the original words: confounds is replaced by "suppress" and bear by "play". The plurality of parts is explained by a reasonable extrapolation, "of husband and father". The paraphrase gives precise form to the obvious purport of the clause and does so in one of the sets of terms in which the poem operates. The paraphrase is absolutely just, but necessarily ignores several common meanings of "to confound" that also pertain in this context and impinge upon it: (a) "to ruin", "to destroy" (the sense it has in 5.6); (b) "to waste" (a theme of the sonnets since sonnet 1); and (c) "to throw into confusion," "to disorder," "to destroy the harmony of". Taking parts to mean "roles", no reader can be expected to understand confounds ... the parts as "ruins the parts" or "wastes the parts" or "disorders the parts", but several other meanings of parts are invoked by this context, and they act to sustain the illusion that the clause actually says what it so obviously means: parts means "talents," "good qualities," "abilities" (as in 17.4), and "who waste your abilities" makes good sense until one comes to bear; moreover, parts appears here in context of singleness and gives the lines the pertinent - though logically and syntactically unmanageable - richness of a vaguely meaningful opposition between the unity suggested by singleness and the division suggested by parts as a word meaning "pieces"; moreover, the context of marriage invokes a logically casual play on parts meaning "sex organs" (see 15.6 and note). Similarly, bear, as a word meaning "give birth to", is substantively irrelevant to this clause but so urgently relevant to its occasion that it gives a feeling of rightness, a sound of sense, to the lines. A complementary and equally easy victory over reasonable probability occurs in the grammatically unusual who confounds (for "who confoundst" - see Abbott, par. 247) and in the oxymoron sweetly chide. The quatrain is an emblem of the paradoxical conditions it recommends, harmony and marriage - unities that supersede common sense in being more unified than singleness, unities made by literally "confounding", "pouring together", individual elements and potentially disabled by a confusion that results from failure to mix.
This sort of analysis is, obviously, a jumping-off point, rather than an end-stop, which is why Booth seems so problematic to those who want answers and "translations", basically.
I also love the depth he goes, digging further and further into one damn word, playing out the possibilities, each one canceling out the one before, and yet nothing specifically wrong or incorrect. The ambiguities are meant to STAND, not be eradicated.
Here he is on one word-play in Line 14 of Sonnet 8, which, to me, starts to crack the poem open for me. A universe, a solar system, contained in a walnut shell, basically.
14. Sings ... single The overt play on sings and single is shadowed in lines 8 and 12. Thou single wilt prove none (1) unmarried - and thus without an heir - your line will become extinct with your death; (2) being single (one, 1), you will turn out to be nothing (zero, 0). (There is incidental allusion here to the ancient mathematical principle that "one is no number," which - as the embodiment of the quibble on the number "one" and "one" as opposed to a multitude - became proverbial [Tilley, O54, see 136.8]. Another proverb, "One is as good as none" [Tilley, O52], also pertains; Whitney gives it thus: "The proverbe saieth, one man is deemed none, / And life, is deathe, where men doo live alone" [p.66].) none It is possible that Shakespeare had a pun on "nun" in mind. Barrenness suggests nuns to him, and nuns suggest barrenness; see MND I.i.69-78 and the "self-loving nuns" passage in V&A (752-68). For a similarly suggestive use of nun, see Measure II.iv.134-38, Angelo's attempted seduction of Isabella, a novice from a nunnery: "Be that you are, / That is, a woman; if you be more, you're none; / If you be one, as you are well express'd / By all external warrants, show it now / By putting on the destin'd livery"; see also Measure III.i.62-62: Claudio. "Is there no remedy?" / Isabella. "None..." (since Isabella is herself the potential "remedy", her response has something like the effect that occurs in AW I.i.141-42, where Helena asks how a maiden can lose her virginity to her own liking, and Parolles introduces his answer with the expletive "marry"). For a simpler play on "nun" and "none", see The Jew of Malta, lines 491-92: a "Nunnery, where none but their owne sect / Must enter in ...." (The evidence for the pronunciations of one and none is inconclusive; Shakespeare rhymes one with "sun" and "sun" with "nun", but he also rhymes both one and none with "bone" and - like Whitney - with "alone"; see the noon / son rhyme in 7.13-14.
This is what I do every morning. My morning meditation.
"My subject is War, and the pity of War. The Poetry is in the pity."
Wilfred Owen (now known as one of the best "war poets" of World War I) was born on this day in 1893. He was killed in battle in 1918 just seven days before the Armistice. He was 25 years old.

Owen was unpublished during his lifetime. He is now recognized, along with Rupert Brooke, and Siegfried Sassoon, as one of those rare poets who can put the horror of warfare into verse. Trench warfare, in particular. (Yeats disagreed. He disliked Owens' poems, and did not include him - or any of the "war poets" in his The Oxford Book of Modern Verse, 1892-1935. Yeats wrote that Owen's poems were "unworthy of the poet's corner of a country newspaper".) Owen was, of course, aware of Yeats, and used a quote from one of Yeats's poems as an epigraph to one of his poems. He had an inner argument with Yeats, I suppose, and Yeats's view of soldiers, war and death.
One of the most amazing things about these poems is the dates on them - September-October, 1917 / January 1918, etc. He is writing these poems in the thick of war. He is crouching in his tent scribbling these out. There is an immediacy to the verses, yes, and he is one of those sensitive souls who seems to have a larger-picture in his head, even in the midst of the day-to-day reality he is in. He sees the slaughter. He feels the tragedy of it. His main burst of creativity was from August 1917 to September 1918.
He was not patriotic, or at least, his poems are not. One of his poems was addressed to Jessie Pope, a poet who wrote motivational patriotic poems urging young men to enlist. Owen criticized that attitude. His poems are Romantic, certainly, full of loss and grief at the waste. He references Shakespeare, Shelley, the Bible, Keats - maybe not explicitly but in the sounds and rhythms he chooses. He self-consciously writes in these older forms, which is one of the reasons why his poems are so startling. World War I was, in a way, even more shattering, psychologically, than World War II, due to the newness of that kind of technologically advanced warfare. How would mankind go on, knowing what we can do? How on earth will anything ever be rebuilt? This was one of the driving forces of Modernism, as we know it, with poets like Ezra Pound and TS Eliot and Wallace Stevens and Yeats struggling to find language that would be able to HANDLE this new universe. It was a deeply destabilizing time. But Owen is not a modernist, although his poems are always included in those anthologies. His forms are even archaic, which gives them almost a feeling of elegy, all in all. By that I mean: by choosing to write about World War I using OLD forms, rather than trying to "make it new" (a la Ezra Pound's advice to poets) - Owen is mourning a world that is passing away forever, right before his eyes. It's one of the reasons why the poems are so strong.
Owen was probably gay, some of his earlier poems deal with having sensual urges towards other men, and it's hard to say what would have happened to him should he have survived World War I. His journey towards poetry is really interesting. Here is my impression of it (and I say that, knowing only the bare bones of the story):
He grew up in a small town in England (near the border with Wales). He kind of drifted a bit, in terms of his schooling, due to financial constraints. He considered becoming a priest. But he had disturbing feelings about God's inability to deal with human problems. He was a tutor for a while. When World War I broke out, he enlisted. In January, 1917, he was sent to the front. He found war glorious and exciting, similar to George Washington's famous remark to his brother after his first experience with a battle in the French and Indian War: "I heard the bullets whistle, and, believe me, there is something charming in the sound."
Wilfred Owen wrote home to his parents early on:
This morning I was hit! We were bombing and a fragment from somewhere hit my thumb knuckle. I coaxed out 1 drop of blood. Alas! No more!
The bloom soon was off the rose, and that following June, he was moved to a hospital because he suffered from shell-shock. (His heartwrenching poem "Mental Cases" is about what shell-shock is like). He was transported back to England and then Edinburgh. He was a mess. It was in the hospital in Edinburgh that he met Siegfried Sassoon - and this would be the event that would change his short life. Sassoon was a captain in the army and a poet, well-known. They aren't really similar in style, but Sassoon obviously encouraged Owen - I so wonder about their conversations.
Owen wrote to Sassoon in November 1917:
I was always a mad comet; but you have fixed me.
Thus began his crazy output of poetry. Owen returned to the war in France in August 1918. He would be dead by November.
Sassoon published all of Owen's poems posthumously, in 1920.
Wilfred Owen wrote to his mother on December 31, 1917:
I go out of this year a poet, my dear mother, as which I did not enter it. I am held peer by the Georgians; I am a poet's poet. I am started. The tugs have left me; I feel the great swelling of the open sea taking my galleon.
Owen said, in regards to his war poems:
"These elegies are to this generation in no sense consolatory. They may be to the next. All a poet can do today is warn. That is why the true Poets must be truthful."
It seems to me that his lack of interest in consoling his own generation is one of the reasons why his poems have lasted, and are anthologized - because they do rise up out of their own time. They cease to be local.
Here are some of Wilfred Owen's poems.
Anthem for Doomed Youth
What passing-bells for these who die as cattle?
Only the monstrous anger of the guns.
Only the stuttering rifles' rapid rattle
Can patter out their hasty orisons.
No mockeries now for them; no prayers nor bells,
Nor any voice of mourning save the choirs,--
The shrill, demented choirs of wailing shells;
And bugles calling for them from sad shires.
What candles may be held to speed them all?
Not in the hands of boys, but in their eyes
Shall shine the holy glimmers of good-byes.
The pallor of girls' brows shall be their pall;
Their flowers the tenderness of patient minds,
And each slow dusk a drawing-down of blinds.
The End
After the blast of lightning from the east,
The flourish of loud clouds, the Chariot Throne;
After the drums of time have rolled and ceased,
And by the bronze west long retreat is blown,
Shall Life renew these bodies? Of a truth
All death will he annul, all tears assuage?-
Or fill these void veins full again with youth,
And wash, with an immortal water, Age?
When I do ask white Age he saith not so:
'My head hangs weighed with snow.'
And when I hearken to the Earth, she saith:
'My fiery heart shrinks, aching. It is death.
Mine ancient scars shall not be glorified,
Nor my titanic tears, the seas, be dried.'
On Seeing a Piece of Our Artillery Brought into Action
Be slowly lifted up, thou long black arm,
Great gun towering towards Heaven, about to curse;
Sway steep against them, and for years rehearse
Huge imprecations like a blasting charm!
Reach at that Arrogance which needs thy harm,
And beat it down before its sins grow worse;
Spend our resentment, cannon,--yea, disburse
Our gold in shapes of flame, our breaths in storm.
Yet, for men's sakes whom thy vast malison
Must wither innocent of enmity,
Be not withdrawn, dark arm, thy spoilure done,
Safe to the bosom of our prosperity.
But when thy spell be cast complete and whole,
May God curse thee, and cut thee from our soul!
Futility
Move him into the sun--
Gently its touch awoke him once,
At home, whispering of fields unsown.
Always it woke him, even in France,
Until this morning and this snow.
If anything might rouse him now
The kind old sun will know.
Think how it wakes the seeds,--
Woke, once, the clays of a cold star.
Are limbs, so dear-achieved, are sides,
Full-nerved-- still warm,-- too hard to stir?
Was it for this the clay grew tall?
-- O what made fatuous sunbeams toil
To break earth's sleep at all?
Mental Cases
Who are these? Why sit they here in twilight?
Wherefore rock they, purgatorial shadows,
Drooping tongues from jaws that slob their relish,
Baring teeth that leer like skulls' tongues wicked?
Stroke on stroke of pain, -- but what slow panic,
Gouged these chasms round their fretted sockets?
Ever from their hair and through their hand palms
Misery swelters. Surely we have perished
Sleeping, and walk hell; but who these hellish?
- These are men whose minds the Dead have ravished.
Memory fingers in their hair of murders,
Multitudinous murders they once witnessed.
Wading sloughs of flesh these helpless wander,
Treading blood from lungs that had loved laughter.
Always they must see these things and hear them,
Batter of guns and shatter of flying muscles,
Carnage incomparable and human squander
Rucked too thick for these men's extrication.
Therefore still their eyeballs shrink tormented
Back into their brains, because on their sense
Sunlight seems a bloodsmear; night comes blood-black;
Dawn breaks open like a wound that bleeds afresh
- Thus their heads wear this hilarious, hideous,
Awful falseness of set-smiling corpses.
- Thus their hands are plucking at each other;
Picking at the rope-knouts of their scourging;
Snatching after us who smote them, brother,
Pawing us who dealt them war and madness.
Tennessee Williams's Notebooks are incredible on multiple layers. It has a lot of information not before published, the footnotes are as extensive as the text itself - beautifully connected to the text, adding depth and shadings to what Williams shares in his journal (postcards to his mother, for example - so we can see the whitewashed version of events he tells his mother, as compared to what was REALLY going on - something I am sure we all can relate to) - and also things like drafts of poems that he mentions working on in the journal. Then in the footnote, we'll see said draft and be able to read it. It is an exquisitely put together book. It is a snapshot of personality, its many different layers, and how we are different to different people - over many many years. I am still in 1943, a big year for Williams professionally, although he doesn't know it yet. 1943 was also the year his sister Rose was lobotomized, which his mother informs him of in a letter. She refers to it as a "head operation" and that it was "successful". Williams writes back in a letter I find chilling:
I did not at all understand the news about Rose. What kind of operation was it and what for?
That was in January, 1943. It would be a couple of months before this news would make it into his journal. Too painful and awful to even contemplate. At times, Williams referred to his sister only as "R". Her name became too painful to even write out.
On March 24, 1943, he wrote this in his journal ("Grand" refers to his beloved Grandmother, who was ill at the time):
I wrote alone at Donnie's office till two a.m. - from 7 - a 7 hour stretch - longest at one stretch in a long time. On a short play. 27 Wagons. Not worth much - amusing but a little nasty perhaps.
Grand. God be with you.
A cord breaking.
1000 miles away.
Rose. Her head cut open.
A knife thrust in her brain.
Me. Here. Smoking.
My father, mean as a devil, snoring. 1000 miles away.
It's horrifying. Williams had been toiling over a short play called "The Gentleman Caller" for quite some time (an early version of, of course, The Glass Menagerie - my excerpt here) writing it out as a short story, futzing with it, worrying over it. He had an agent. He had already had a play flop in Boston (Battle of Angels
- my excerpt here), and he was at loose ends. The Notebooks at times read like a litany of money woes (he is always being evicted from somewhere, and then, at the very last moment, like the cavalry, a check comes in) and a compulsive listing of sexual partners.
You can feel the emptiness behind most of his conquests. He had fallen in love with a dancer named Kip Kiernan, his first love, who broke his heart. Williams took about a year to recover (and, I would surmise, never really fully recovered. His last play Something Cloudy, Something Clear is an autobiographical work - my excerpt here - about the summer in Provincetown when he met Kip Kiernan) - and his big loves - Pancho (the volatile drunk Mexican) and Frank Merlo, his partner for many years - are still in the future. Williams talks a lot about yearning for love, a real partner - Loneliness is his companion, and he is disgusted with himself when he views sex as nothing more than physical exercise. And yet, loneliness is nothing to sneeze at. Even if the companionship is momentary and brief, it's better than coming back to his little room alone. Meanwhile, he keeps working, working, working. Without any knowledge of what was to come for him in the next couple of years - fame, fortune, his name in the books forever.

One of the really haunting things about the Notebooks is its open depiction of being a gay man before the days of sexual liberation (and we ain't there yet, especially not now, with the vicious bigotry and prejudice surrounding the topic of equality for gays/lesbians/transgenders). There are those who say, "It's fine what you do in your own private bedroom, I just don't want to hear about it." That statement is a red flag for me. Often, with good reason, because it's a so-called nice polite way to say, "Keep your gayness private, please." What does "don't want to hear about it" mean? Does that mean you don't want to see a picture of someone's boyfriend on his desk at work? Quite often, yes, that is what it means. If a gay man tells you, "I had an awesome date last night ..." and you feel threatened, that you "don't want to hear about it", but you would have no problem hearing your female coworker tell about HER date with a great guy - then you are a bigot, and you ARE the problem. It is trying to keep someone silent, BEGGING someone to just be QUIET. About who they ARE. Nope. Life don't work that way.
But even all of this is a privileged conversation, showing how far we have come, when compared to what Williams went through. Williams and his friends are closer to the world of Oscar Wilde than the world of Neil Patrick Harris performing at the Oscars, an out gay man, successful and not in hiding. Some of the stories Williams tells are truly harrowing. The options are limited. You must always be on the lookout. He "cruises" for "trade", and is more often than not successful. These are mainly one-night stands, which leave Williams satisfied sexually, but bereft emotionally. And sometimes, the night gets rough. Many of the men picked up are American servicemen - remember this is World War II - so soldiers are everywhere. It's a subtle pick-up, a glance, a nod, sharing a cigarette, and then back to the room. But sometimes it goes horribly wrong. Williams is beaten up numerous times, as are his friends. Williams is punched in the face, his room ransacked. Then, in later years, on Key West, a hub of gay life, there are sudden round-ups of "degenerates" - the police suddenly making it impossible for gays to operate there, even take walks, nothing allowed - They are the "other". Persecuted, hounded. Sometimes by the very men they had slept with the night before. It's just awful to read about. And yet how much of this "outsider" status added to Williams's work. (And to Wilde's, and to all the gay men through history, who have managed to create some of the most long-lasting works of art known to man.) Homosexuality (and Williams talks about this a lot) is not just analogous to being an artist - it is one and the same thing, for him. One could not exist without the other.

And at that time in history, by making that choice (and he did see it as a choice, not as a natural tendency) he was choosing to be forever outside. He was choosing to not have such comforting things as a home life, a family, stability. He knew this intuitively. He was always on the run anyway, fleeing across the country to this or that haven, whenever things got too rough for him. But Tennessee Williams, unlike some of the people he had met in "the Quarter" in New Orleans, for example, was not a "queen", he had not gone as far as camp, which was a great and strong survival skill for many homosexuals at that time (and still, at this time). Camp is like armor. Nothing can penetrate it. It stands, in its fabulousness, in its total disregard for social propriety, in its disinterest in being accepted (it doesn't NEED to be accepted - it's so awesome all on its own that "acceptance" is a given) - as a rock-hard shell, behind which the "sensitive" man underneath could operate. Could create a world of beauty and art and humor. Could survive the cruelty. Tennessee Williams did not have that option. He didn't like "bitchy queens", for the most part, although he found their presence strangely comforting - he could at least relax, and not "put on", but Williams was, at times, morbidly shy. He was not an extrovert, in fact he was quite the opposite - despite his loud raucous laugh - and camp, to some degree, requires extroversion. It may be a defense against INTROversion, that is true, but Williams just didn't operate in that way. He straddled the gay and straight world. He did not go completely underground, like many of the characters he had met along the way. He absorbed their spirit, however, and many of these characters show up, in disguise, in Williams's later plays. Although they are not gay men in his plays. They are Williams's female leads.
So not only, by living as a gay man, was he repeatedly taking his life in his own hands (and he knew this, he understood this completely) - but he was also committing himself to life as a gypsy (ie: artist). It was essential, although his loneliness never really left him. He yearned for comfort, ease and peace in his friendships and love affairs, and while he received some of that, temporarily, he never found that "one". Or, he did, but Frank Merlo died of cancer, and Williams pretty much cracked up and never got his balance again (this was much much later - over a decade later than the early 40s section I am reading now in the book).
There is so much that is moving and amazing about this book (his comments on other writers, his comments on his own work, his frustrations, the sense that he is moving towards something HUGE - but he just can't see it yet) - but there are a couple of entries having to do with what it is like to be a gay man at that time, and a certain KIND of gay man, an artist, (similar to his buddies Donald Windham and Christopher Isherwood) - someone with something to DO (besides living as an outlaw, I mean - which is really the case for gay men at that time). Men who had skills, gifts, talents ... and who needed to corral their vast powers into whatever work it was they were put on this planet to do.)
My heart just cracks reading some of these entries, and I think of my dear gay friends, men and women, people who have immeasurably enhanced my life in ways I can't even name ... and I think of imprisoned ruined Oscar Wilde, and Williams crouching over his unfinished manuscript of Glass Menagerie as a sailor beats the shit out of him - AFTER having sex with him - and it's just awful. The book puts you face to face with the realities of what it was like back then. And we should never forget that. It is good to have moved past a certain point - at least in enlightened areas where people are let alone to be whoever they want to be - but we're not there yet. And we should never forget those who came before. Who didn't have it so easy.
Two amazing entries from Williams along this score (and these are just two of MANY). One recounts a conversation had with good friend Oliver Evans during a period of living in New Orleans in 1941. Oliver Evans was a poet. He and Williams had met in Provincetown (the summer when Williams had his first love, with Kip Kiernan) - and they actually remained good friends up until the end of Williams's life, which is rare - many of Williams's friends abandoned him during the 60s, a really rough decade for Williams. But Oliver remained steady. Naturally, he was also gay.
Sunday, 14, September 1941Later - Sunday A.M.
Oliver Evans - a sad but poignant episode. Mack's and the St. James bar.
"We ought to be exterminated" said Oliver. "for the good of society." I argued that if we were society would lose some of its most sensitive, humanitarian members. A healthy society does not need artists, said Oliver. What is healthy about a society with no spiritual values? - Then you think spiritual values are identical with us? said Oliver. No, I admitted sadly, but we have made some unique contributions because of our unique position and I do not believe that we are detrimental to anyone but ourselves. "We are the rotten apple in the barrel," said Oliver. "We ought to be exterminated at the age of 25." "But Shakespeare had written no great plays at that age." -- "He had written Romeo and Juliet," said Oliver. -- "Yes, but he had not written Hamlet." And so on -- "If you think we are dangerous, why do you act as you do? Why do you not isolate yourself?" "Because I am rotten." -- How many of us feel that way, I wonder? Bear this intolerable burden of guilt? To feel some humiliation and a great deal of sorrow at times is inevitable. But feeling guilty is foolish. I am a deeper and warmer and kinder man for my devigation. More conscious of need in others, and what power I have to express the human heart must be in large part due to this circumstance. Some day society will take perhaps the suitable action - but I do not believe that it will be or should be extermination.
There is so much pain in that, so much acceptance of the situation. He could not live any other way. Many men couldn't hack it (and women too) and married, just to at least have a suitable "cover" under which they could operate. Take the damn edge off. I don't fault those people at all. Many of them were very good companions (Harold Nicolson and Vita Sackville-West, for example), and helped and supported one another in their various pursuits, and marriage gave them some protection. Williams did not go that route. He had consigned himself to criminal status, basically. As Oscar Wilde (although married) did. But his understanding there - of the "contributions" they have made ... It's quite a sensitive reading of the situation, quite amazing really, when you think that this is a man getting beaten up every other night for basically providing another human being what that person asked for. Amazing.
The following entry brought me to tears. Williams has moved back up to New York from an aimless and strange summer spent in Macon, Georgia, with his friend Paul Bigelow. It is January, 1943, right around the time that his sister Rose was being lobotomized, although he doesn't know it yet. It is THE defining event of his life. And strangely, you can see, in the Notebooks, how it galvanized him. The awfulness of it. He had been working on his "gentleman caller" play, and had been thinking of it as a comedy, something light, and in one draft Laura and the gentleman caller hit it off, and they make another date - so maybe there's some hope there - and in the end, as Tom goes off, his mother Amanda tells him that whereever he goes, he will always have a home to come to. Well, that's ONE way you could tell that story. But after the horrible news of his sister Rose, it becomes imperative that he be truthful in his art, that his art reflect life - as he experiences it - It was a real catapulting force. It had to be. Otherwise, Rose's sacrifice would be for naught. Although he never said it that way. He could barely speak of his sister.
But here is the entry in question, which is a rallying cry for gay men everywhere, a piercingly insightful observation about what is really going on:
Tuesday - Jan 5, 1943This is the first time that anybody ever knocked me down and so I suppose it ought to be recorded. Unhappily I can't go into details. It was a case of guilt and shame in which I was relatively the innocent party, since I merely offered entertainment which was accepted with apparent gratitude until the untimely entrance of other parties. Feel a little sorrowful about it. So unnecessary. The sort of behavior pattern imposed by the conventional falsehoods.
Donnie comforted me when he arrived on the scene. Now he is upstairs with another party procured in the bar. Why do they strike us? What is our offense? We offer them a truth which they cannot bear to confess except in privacy and the dark - a truth which is inherently as bright as the morning sun. He struck me because he did what I did and his friends discovered it. Yes, it hurt - inside. I do not know if I will be able to sleep. But tomorrow I suppose the swollen face will be normal again and I will pick up the usual thread of life.
Courage.
"He struck me because he did what I did and his friends discovered it." Self-hatred, self-loathing, a fearsome enemy when cornered. We can see a lot of that going on today, with the politicians running on ferocious anti-gay platforms suddenly found sporting a wide stance in some airport bathroom or driving drunk after bumping and grinding at some gay bar. Or vicious pastors who focus only on homosexuality, suddenly discovered to be hanging out with a gay massuer for years. It's almost become a cliche. It is the real definition of "phobic". Anyone who displays that level of phobia is really operating from a fearful position of recognition and identification, and that has been borne out time and time again. And Williams, in that brief sentence, written 60 plus years in the past, nails why. "He struck me because he did what I did and his friends discovered it."
Selfishly, I am so glad that Tennessee Williams found his tribe - not just of gay men, but of committed artists (poets, dancers, painters, writers). Art saved his life, as it could not save his sister's.

Tennessee Williams and friends, in Provincetown. Tennessee is in the front, shirtless

Ezra Jack Keats was born.
A favorite author of mine - who is always, somehow, looped in my head to Sesame Street, the world being depicted in his classic tales (Peter's Chair, The Snowy Day
, Whistle for Willie
, A Letter to Amy
) the same urban one as in Sesame Street, so different from the turf farm slash beach town world of my upbringing. He made New York City, and Harlem, in particular, look like a big wonderland - with whimsical graffiti, and mounds of snow, and stop lights and intriguing brick corners. The illustrations are, to this day, hypnotic - works of art.
Barry, my father's best friend, was friends with Ezra Jack Keats, so we grew up feeling a strange personal connection to the man who wrote the books we all loved. He was a person. A man. Who had an apartment. Who knew Barry. He was strangely real to us. For years, I thought he was black. Not sure why. I was an adult when I found out he wasn't black. There were no author photos in his books, and I imagined him like Gordon, from Sesame Street, one of my favorite characters. But no, Sheila. The man is not black. I just had it in my head that he was - that was how I pictured him, based on zero information, and my fantasy that he lived on a street like Sesame Street.

Letter to Amy was my favorite. It tells the story of a little boy who is planning his birthday party, and everyone he has invited is a boy as well ... but ... but ... what about his friend Amy? She's a girl. But they are friends. How will that go over if a girl comes to his party? He writes a letter to her. It is a thundery rainy day. The illustrations are phenomenal. I love rainy days anyway, and I loved them as a little girl too - but the whole journey of that book, of grade school angst, and friendship - just really touched me.

Ezra Jack Keats is probably best known for The Snowy Day (and again - those illustrations!). The city shuts down in a snowstorm like that. I remember a couple years ago - maybe 5 or 6 years ago - when we had a massive snowstorm, I was struggling through Times Square, through literally mountainous drifts, trying to get to Port Authority so I could get home - and the roads were completely shut down, no cars anywhere, and people were cross-country-skiing down Broadway. Snowball fights broke out in the middle of 7th Avenue. Things get muffled by the snow, strangely quiet, and the stoplights keep going - red, green, yellow, red, green, yellow ... even no cars can approach. The illustrations in The Snowy Day completely invoke that world: the strange quiet that descends over a bustling metropolis when there are mounds of snow.
Happy birthday to an American classic.
Some choice illustrations below:





Hart Crane (along with D. H. Lawrence) were Tennessee Williams' main inspirations. It was lifelong love affair. In the empty front page of a collection of Hart Crane's poems, Tennessee Williams wrote:
State of the World and MyselfI remember that evening, early summer on a mid-western campus - in Iowa. I sat on a white stone balustrade and heard a professional philosopher talk about the ominous state of international affairs. Boys in white shirts, girls in cool white dresses. Youth - respectfully serious, careless, gay. A wide slope of smooth grass, a cool breeze off the river. And loneliness - my oldest companion. The decorous, calm professors and their wives. The threat of war. Reasons for it, causes, solutions, dangers. War! - That was the early summer of 1938 - One year and two months before it came!
This is the summer of 1940 - Ave atque Vale! - Yesterday they bombed, Paris, today Munich, La Havre, Frankfert, Cherbourg, Marseille. Tomorrow? - The Weygand Line may break, Paris may fall, London may be bombed. Destruction procedes implacably like a disease beyond cure. Superficially my life goes one very little concerned with all this. I work. I am lonely. I search for a pleasant companion.
-- T.W. 6/5/40

I am finally getting around to reading the spectacular unedited edition of Tennessee Williams' Notebooks, the journal he kept for his entire life (well, there is a 20 year gap in there). I have flipped through it - it's a masterful edition. The journal entries themselves rest on the right-hand pages, and the left-hand pages have extensive footnotes - of whatever is referenced on said right-hand page. This makes for tremendously easy reading (no flipping into the back every other line to find the appropriate footnote). The left-hand side of the page has facsimiles of some of the journal pages (complete with his cross-outs, and the notes he would insert into his journal - sort of messages to his younger self, when he would re-read the entries). There are also facsimiles of typewritten copies of his early plays, poems, short stories. The footnotes are extensive, and the layout of the book just aids the reader in comprehending everything. You can flow with the text. Glance over to the left-hand side to pick up the footnote you need, and then glance back to the right-hand side to continue reading. His spelling mistakes are not corrected. His underlines are duplicated. And when words are struck out that seem important (evidence of his editing faculties), then the struck-out words are duplicated.
Like this. It's a marvelous reading experience (aside from all of the fascinating insights in the writing itself): Margaret Bradham Thornton, who also edited the two volumes (thus far) of Tennessee Williams' letters, is also responsible for the editing of the Notebooks, and she has done a superb job. It is encyclopedic. For example, if Williams mentions that he read a poem in a journal that he liked, or felt inspired by - then that poem is sometimes included in the footnotes on the opposite page. This is a book for obsessives, make no mistake. Dilettantes need not apply.
There is something fascinating about reading a person's journal, and I have to be in the mood for it. There are times when someone's journal (I am thinking of Katherine Mansfield) is far superior to any of her fiction. Her journal is a classic.
Tennessee Williams' journal has more of a fragmented emotional feel than Mansfield's - he details everything, in scattered one-line pieces of prose. He loved to swim. So he tells his journal when he took a swim. He tells his journal about how he's drinking too much coffee. His ailments (he was a bit of a hypochondriac - although who could blame him? His sister, who was equally "nervous", was institutionalized and eventually lobotomized - which is THE defining event of Williams' life.)
Tennessee Williams is not one of the writers who intimidates me into silence; there is something about his letters and memoirs that actually make me feel like creating. I read about his struggles - with form, with discipline - and it makes me want to get to it, pronto. Additionally, his opinion of himself is quite low - the journal is full of excoriating commentary on how lazy he is, how undisciplined - and yet his work ethic is so so strong. If nothing else, this man knew how to work. But who can say what it is like for another person. An artist is rarely satisfied. That's part of the deal, part of the torment. You can always be doing better.
Some of these entries are just a yowl of pain. Insomnia, waking up in a nervous state, unable to settle down, feeling isolated ... It's heartbreaking to read. Yet, in the midst of this constant onslaught of nervous tension which he seems prone to, he keeps plugging away. He is tenacious.
Williams grew up in St. Louis, in a kind of claustrophobic household, with an overbearing and loving mother, and two siblings - Dakin and Rose. Rose always seems to have been a bit of a problem. I read about her and my heart aches. The brutality of psychiatric treatment at that time, and how randomly it was used on this poor girl (insulin treatments, shock treatments, and finally a prefrontal lobotomy) is enough to make even the coldest person tremble. Imagine that being your beloved sister. The Williams family did the best they could by Rose. She did not have a family that did not love her. She had a failed "debut" into society - something didn't go quite right - the story isn't clear - she was not a "success", and the tailspin began. Delusions set in. She became obsessed with sex. One of her psychiatrists told her her problem was that she should "try to get married". Unbelievable. She eventually was diagnosed with "dementia praecox", an early term for schizophrenia.
Meanwhile, Tom (Tennessee) and Dakin were trying to live their lives - and resist the pull of the tragedy that was unfolding in their own home.

Mrs. Edwina Williams reading to her children, Rose and Tom (Tennessee)
Tom was going to a local college in St. Louis and living at home, feeling trapped and suffocated, and horrified at what was happening to his sister. In 1937, he was accepted into the University of Iowa. Rose had been institutionalized in January of 1937 (she would never, after that point, not be institutionalized). So there is an aspect of Tom going to college that feels like a getaway. The guilt he experienced at his ability to leave must have been excruciating and factors into the entire theme of The Glass Menagerie, especially Tom's last monologue in that play:
I didn't go to the moon, I went much further - for time is the longest distance between two places. Not long after that I was fired for writing a poem on the lid of a shoe-box. I left Saint Louis. I descended the steps of this fire escape for a last time and followed, from then on, in my father's footsteps, attempting to find in motion what was lost in space. I traveled around a great deal. The cities swept about me like dead leaves, leaves that were brightly colored but torn away from the branches. I would have stopped, but I was pursued by something. It always came upon me unawares, taking me altogether by surprise. Perhaps it was a familiar bit of music. Perhaps it was only a piece of transparent glass. Perhaps I am walking along a street at night, in some strange city, before I have found companions. I pass the lighted window of a shop where perfume is sold. The window is filled with pieces of colored glass, tiny transparent bottles in delicate colors, like bits of a shattered rainbow. Then all at once my sister touches my shoulder. I turn around and look into her eyes. Oh, Laura, Laura, I tried to leave you behind me, but I am more faithful than I intended to be! I reach for a cigarette, I cross the street, I run into the movies or a bar, I buy a drink, I speak to the nearest stranger - anything that can blow your candles out! For nowadays the world is lit by lightning! Blow out your candles, Laura - and so goodbye ...
Here are a couple of journal entries from the fall of 1937 - as he departs from St. Louis, and starts college in Iowa. He would never live at home again, except for brief stopovers. After he graduated in 1938, he went down to New Orleans, then moved on, basically accepting that he was gay (or a "sissy", as he called himself) - which I wonder if living at home, and how nervous he was all the time, had of course to do with the fact that his sister was having a mental breakdown right before his eyes, but also the fact that he was homosexual, and he just knew that that could not fly. He was not hostile towards religion. He was drawn to it, and speaks to God often in his journals. He speaks of needing to receive Communion after going to visit Rose in the sanitarium - so the fear of what would happen to his soul must have been intense. His beloved grandfather, who was Tennessee's companion and sometimes roommate for years, was a minister as well. But once he finally left, once he got out, and started to find his own tribe of like-minded artists, he could accept who he was. He only slept with one woman in his whole life - that was a girl he met at the University of Iowa, a passionate relationship by all accounts (he wrote a lot of poetry for her) - and when she threw him over for another guy, he was very hurt. He considered it a turning point in his life (he mentions it often, in later essays, when he was a much older man). These were all elements of Tom shuffling off the shackles of his homelife, and the terrifying things that were happening to his sister Rose.
That's the context of these two entries. I am mostly struck by the first one because here he is, a college student in his mid-20s, and you can feel Glass Menagerie in this first entry. It is already there: full and complete. It would just take time and courage for him to write it out. But it's already there.
Thurs. Sept. 16 [1937] Tonight is pleasant - A crisp chilly autumn night that elates the spirit and makes life seem a more definite, positive quantity.Dakin is at the S.A.E. House for his first-rush date - I am waiting up - in my garret room - to let him in. This is a charming room. I almost hate to leave it. You see, I feel in my heart that I will never really return to this place. Whatever happens good or ill, this next year I think it will surely divorce me at last from the paternal roof - wish-fulfillment! -
But of course my life has been a series of returns - I do not seem to have much capacity for exploring new fields although I have no lack of desire.
I will see Clark and Holland tomorrow morning. I plan to leave Wed. night or Thurs. morning if nothing happens to prevent.
No, I haven't forgotten poor Rose - I beg whatever power there is to save her and spare her from suffering.
My play is all but finished and I feel pretty well satisfied with it. Now I yearn for work on a new one - will not be content till I have made a good start on it. The next play is always the important play. The past, however satisfactory, is only a challenge to the future.
I want to go on creating. I will!!!
Wed. Nite - The miracle has happened - I'm on the train for Iowa City - at least I will get there - Deo volente I will remain - Feel pretty good - lessscnervous than I expected and rather jubilant - At last I am really doing something - Making a definite move - that is a satisfying thing - It is interesting to speculate upon the possibilities of this coming year - So much may or may not happen! Of course I am a little frightened - ca va sans dire - but I think I will carry it off okay -
Sat. Oct. 9 - Been up here over two weeks - love the place but am disgustingly ill and nervous - have jolting sensations in heart and almost constant tension - disturbed and frighten[ed] - I intend to avoid getting panicky about it - I must keep my head on my shoulders - but it is not very pleasant - Do other people have lives like this? Yes - some do - and endure it.Aside from wretched bodily condition - which may pass off - I am getting along nicely - Encouraging enthusiastic letter from Willard - Skit to be presented by living newspaper - Nice associates up here - pleasant atmosphere - much to be interested in - if only I could be strong and free - ! Please, God, let me! I think of Rose and wonder and pity - but it is such a faraway feeling - how bound up we are in our own selves - our own memories - Why can't we forget and think of others? It is the nature of the beast! I must admit that I have felt very beast-like lately and if things turn out well for me it will be better than I deserve.
My virtues - I am kind, friendly, modest, sympathetic, tolerant and sensitive -
Faults - I am ego-centric, introspective, morbid, sensual, irreligious, lazy, timid, cowardly -
But if I were God I would feel a little bit sorry for Tom Williams once in a while - he doesn't have a very
gayeasy time of it and he does have guts of a sort even though he is a stinking sissy!
Yes, Tom. You do have guts. Not "of a sort". But guts, end-stop.

"Believe me, every man has his secret sorrows,
which the world knows not; and oftimes
we call a man cold, when he is only sad."
-- Henry Wadsworth Longfellow
Beautiful.
Henry Wadsworth Longfellow was born on this day, in 1807, in Portland, Maine.
He was the first poet to take on American themes and dialects and making it the focal point of his work. He really is our first "local" poet. He was also the first American poet to be laid to rest in Poet's Corner at Westminster Abbey alongside chaps like, you know, Chaucer (an idol of Longfellow's). Longfellow was huge in his day. And his poems still carry a lot of sentimental feeling for Americans - he is still read. His reputation during his life, however, cannot be overstated. He was a celebrity. His poems were EVENTS. His first major work was "Evangeline", published in 1847, a long epic poem about the deportation of the French-speaking inhabitants (the Acadians) of Nova Scotia. It was a smash hit, and actually, for some time, created its own tourist trade. What poet today could ever generate such a response?

"Evangeline" came about because of a small dinner party held in Longfellow's rented rooms in Cambridge, Massachusetts. Friend Nathaniel Hawthorne was there. A minister, also at the gathering, told a story of a young couple separated on their wedding day by the deportation of the people from Nova Scotia, and how the bride spent the rest of her life, wandering, looking for her lost husband. The minister thought that Hawthorne might be interested in turning it into a story. He wasn't. But Longfellow was. With a sense of propriety (after all, Hawthorne was asked first), he asked for Hawthorne's blessing to turn it into a poem. It took him years to complete it. He researched exhaustively what had happened to the Acadians. Most of them, actually, ended up in New Orleans, and they are very much responsible for the particular brand of culture still found there today. There was much that had already been forgotten about the Acadians, and Longfellow was totally immersed in the subject. "Evangeline" is not a history lesson, however. It is a story, a fictionalized version of events, which struck a huge chord in the populace. There is still a Memorial Site in New Orleans today (the Longfellow-Evangeline Historic Site), but after the publication of the poem, all kinds of sites sprung up - trails, trees, anything at all that was mentioned in the poem ... Readers were captivated by this mournful tale of wandering and exile, and went on pilgrimages to the places mentioned.
So came the autumn, and passed, and the winter, -- yet Gabriel came not;
Blossomed the opening spring and the notes of the robin and bluebird
Sounded sweet upon the wold and in wood, yet Gabriel came not.
I personally find Evangeline as a heroine to be a bit of a drip. It is the cliched stereotype of a long-suffering patient goodly woman - which is just not inherently dramatic. Not to mention a sentimentalized version of womanhood that I cannot get behind, since its purpose is expressly to limit. Longfellow may not have been aware of that, it was the ideal of Womanhood at the time, and it was obviously a slamdunk among readers, male and female. But to me, it really dates itself. Dickens had similar cliches of women in his books - his young heroines are particuarly awful and boring - but he more than makes up for it with all of the other characters surrounding these goody-two-shoes drips. Only Dickens' female leads are not complex. This was, again, the style of the day - encapsulated in "Evangeline", but when you realize that just across the way from Longfellow, Emily Dickinson was dashing off her frightening sharp poems - a woman in all the colors of humanity possible - not at all the simpering long-suffering heroine so beloved at that time - you can see that these men were missing the boat, to some degree. It is a failure of imagination. Again, we all are people of our own time, as much as we may try to rise above. We don't have that cultural problem with "Paul Revere's Ride", a Longfellow poem that doesn't deal with love, or inter-relationships - and so can be a bit more free and easy with itself and its topic.
Longfellow was a star. His poems are still well-known: Hiawatha, The Courtship of Miles Standish, Paul Revere's Ride. He was a poet, yes, but he was also a myth-maker. A person who was actually creating a community through his work. Memory is very important. Memory is key to a nation's survival. A nation that lives in forgetfulness (thank you, Milan Kundera), either willfully or carelessly, is going to have problems. America was such a new nation, it didn't have, say, the relationship that the Persians did to their country, one of the oldest civilizations on earth (and a place where poetry is very important, as containers for cultural memory) - but Longfellow (and then Whitman) was very important in creating these works, that told the story of America to itself, in rollicking exciting verse ... something that all could participate in. A myth-maker, a storyteller, I mean the opening line of Paul Revere's Ride basically calls the people to come in close to listen: "Listen my children and you will hear ..." It's almost like a game of telephone. Listen to my story. Pass it on. Tell them to pass it on. These are not history lessons. These are myths, legends, pass it on. Most of his stuff comes off much better when read out loud. The rhythm is not separate from the content. The rhythm is essential. His reputation as a poet has not quite lived past his own day, but he was huge - HUGE - in his own time.
He traveled far, for a man of his time, and there's a great story of him basically bunking with Charles Dickens on a visit to England in 1842. There is a similarity between the two writers (I mean, besides what I mentioned earlier - their tendency to have drippy cliches as their female romantic leads), something almost theatrical. Understanding their audience better than most writers. Longfellow was so American, Dickens so British - and Dickens was pretty befuddled by the "New World" - he had recently visited it. Longfellow was a celebrity, yes, and, like Ben Franklin back in the day, was representative of the entire nation.
A happy man, with a happy home life, many children, he suffered a horrible tragedy later in life which makes me shiver just to think of it. His second wife was sealing a letter with hot wax, and her dress caught fire from the candle. She went up in flames. Longfellow tried to save her, and received severe burns himself. She died. Longfellow never quite recovered. He never stopped writing, but he was forever changed.

Longfellow's writing room
Due to my family's connection with the Boston area, and the fact that my father used to read "Paul Revere's Ride" out loud to us as kids, it's my favorite of his (his other stuff can seem quaint and sentimental to me now - it just doesn't have the same cultural resonance). It should be read out loud. If you read it to yourself, the hoof-beat rhythm of the verse will be lost to you.

The poem has the blood-beat in it, the pulse racing, the adrenaline surges - appropriate to the story being told. It's one of my favorites and I know long stretches of it by heart.
Paul Revere's Ride
Listen my children and you shall hear
Of the midnight ride of Paul Revere,
On the eighteenth of April, in Seventy-five;
Hardly a man is now alive
Who remembers that famous day and year.
He said to his friend, "If the British march
By land or sea from the town to-night,
Hang a lantern aloft in the belfry arch
Of the North Church tower as a signal light,--
One if by land, and two if by sea;
And I on the opposite shore will be,
Ready to ride and spread the alarm
Through every Middlesex village and farm,
For the country folk to be up and to arm."
Then he said "Good-night!" and with muffled oar
Silently rowed to the Charlestown shore,
Just as the moon rose over the bay,
Where swinging wide at her moorings lay
The Somerset, British man-of-war;
A phantom ship, with each mast and spar
Across the moon like a prison bar,
And a huge black hulk, that was magnified
By its own reflection in the tide.
Meanwhile, his friend through alley and street
Wanders and watches, with eager ears,
Till in the silence around him he hears
The muster of men at the barrack door,
The sound of arms, and the tramp of feet,
And the measured tread of the grenadiers,
Marching down to their boats on the shore.
Then he climbed the tower of the Old North Church,
By the wooden stairs, with stealthy tread,
To the belfry chamber overhead,
And startled the pigeons from their perch
On the sombre rafters, that round him made
Masses and moving shapes of shade,--
By the trembling ladder, steep and tall,
To the highest window in the wall,
Where he paused to listen and look down
A moment on the roofs of the town
And the moonlight flowing over all.
Beneath, in the churchyard, lay the dead,
In their night encampment on the hill,
Wrapped in silence so deep and still
That he could hear, like a sentinel's tread,
The watchful night-wind, as it went
Creeping along from tent to tent,
And seeming to whisper, "All is well!"
A moment only he feels the spell
Of the place and the hour, and the secret dread
Of the lonely belfry and the dead;
For suddenly all his thoughts are bent
On a shadowy something far away,
Where the river widens to meet the bay,--
A line of black that bends and floats
On the rising tide like a bridge of boats.
Meanwhile, impatient to mount and ride,
Booted and spurred, with a heavy stride
On the opposite shore walked Paul Revere.
Now he patted his horse's side,
Now he gazed at the landscape far and near,
Then, impetuous, stamped the earth,
And turned and tightened his saddle girth;
But mostly he watched with eager search
The belfry tower of the Old North Church,
As it rose above the graves on the hill,
Lonely and spectral and sombre and still.
And lo! as he looks, on the belfry's height
A glimmer, and then a gleam of light!
He springs to the saddle, the bridle he turns,
But lingers and gazes, till full on his sight
A second lamp in the belfry burns.
A hurry of hoofs in a village street,
A shape in the moonlight, a bulk in the dark,
And beneath, from the pebbles, in passing, a spark
Struck out by a steed flying fearless and fleet;
That was all! And yet, through the gloom and the light,
The fate of a nation was riding that night;
And the spark struck out by that steed, in his flight,
Kindled the land into flame with its heat.
He has left the village and mounted the steep,
And beneath him, tranquil and broad and deep,
Is the Mystic, meeting the ocean tides;
And under the alders that skirt its edge,
Now soft on the sand, now loud on the ledge,
Is heard the tramp of his steed as he rides.
It was twelve by the village clock
When he crossed the bridge into Medford town.
He heard the crowing of the cock,
And the barking of the farmer's dog,
And felt the damp of the river fog,
That rises after the sun goes down.
It was one by the village clock,
When he galloped into Lexington.
He saw the gilded weathercock
Swim in the moonlight as he passed,
And the meeting-house windows, black and bare,
Gaze at him with a spectral glare,
As if they already stood aghast
At the bloody work they would look upon.
It was two by the village clock,
When he came to the bridge in Concord town.
He heard the bleating of the flock,
And the twitter of birds among the trees,
And felt the breath of the morning breeze
Blowing over the meadow brown.
And one was safe and asleep in his bed
Who at the bridge would be first to fall,
Who that day would be lying dead,
Pierced by a British musket ball.
You know the rest. In the books you have read
How the British Regulars fired and fled,---
How the farmers gave them ball for ball,
From behind each fence and farmyard wall,
Chasing the redcoats down the lane,
Then crossing the fields to emerge again
Under the trees at the turn of the road,
And only pausing to fire and load.
So through the night rode Paul Revere;
And so through the night went his cry of alarm
To every Middlesex village and farm,---
A cry of defiance, and not of fear,
A voice in the darkness, a knock at the door,
And a word that shall echo for evermore!
For, borne on the night-wind of the Past,
Through all our history, to the last,
In the hour of darkness and peril and need,
The people will waken and listen to hear
The hurrying hoof-beats of that steed,
And the midnight message of Paul Revere.
"borne on the night-winds of the Past" - Goosebumps. It flat out gives me goosebumps. And I also wonder if F. Scott Fitzgerald was consciously referencing it in his heartbreaker of a last line in The Great Gatsby: "So we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past." Fitzgerald, knowing that he was the voice of a certain time, voice of his generation, it would not surprise me if he did consciously reference Longfellow there, at the very end of that quintessentially American story. Of course, in his context, the past takes on very different connotations, even with the nostalgia. There's an emptiness at the heart of it, an emptiness that did Gatsby in, with his constant looking-back, looking-back. Longfellow looked to the past for inspiration, for the wellspring of storytelling magic - he was almost like a reporter in that respect, digging through the past for a story that could hit, could speak to his time. Paul Revere's Ride, for example, was first published in 1860, and Longfellow, seeing the Civil War approach, wanted to prepare the populace, call them to arms (even though he was a pacifist), and remind them where they all had come from. This is propaganda at a very high level.
The surrounding context of the political atmosphere is now forgotten, for the most part, at least in conjunction with "Paul Revere's Ride", which is now basically seen as a history lesson of what happened on that 18th of April, '75. More than a history lesson, though, it's a story. A story that must be passed on in order to survive. As Joan Didion so famously wrote, "We tell ourselves stories in order to live".
Longfellow knew that better than anyone.
Here are some quotes about and also by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow.
"He seems to combine the assured rhetoric of the Tennyson of the Idylls, with the exuberance of Browning on one hand and of the Borders balladeers on the other. It's a heady mix: popular and folk poetry tailored for the wide-eyed bourgeoisie." -- Michael Schmidt, Lives of the Poets
"Her writings are a capital picture of real life, with all the little wheels and machinery laid bare like a patent clock. But she explains and fills out too much." -- Henry Wadsworth Longfellow on Jane Austen
"Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, on the other hand, could sing. He could tell stories about America. Maybe his forms were imported, but they were tempered and transformed by his fantastic world. He provides an alternative to the gothic even as he shares in some of its preposterous attitudes and posturings." -- Michael Schmidt, Lives of the Poets
"His poems never lose their witchery for me. There are undoubtedly many greater poets than Longfellow -- many stronger, grander, deeper; but he is full of sweetness and tenderness and grace." -- L.M. Montgomery, journal entry
"For Europeans, American poetry was Longfellow." -- Michael Schmidt, Lives of the Poets
"As was his poetic practice, once Longfellow had briefed himself on the factual background, he used his material with a very free hand. He was a bard, not a historian; what mattered was the basic human truth of his story, not its particulars." -- Charles Calhoun, author of Longfellow: A Rediscovered Life, on the writing of "Evangeline"
"Only [Wallace] Stevens in later American poetry is musical in the ways that Longfellow at his best can be." -- Michael Schmidt
"And now I long to try a loftier strain, the sublimer Song whose broken melodies have for so many years breathed through my soul in the better hours of life, and which I trust and believe will ere long unite themselves into a symphony not all unworthy the sublime theme, but furnishing 'some equivalent expression for the trouble and wrath of life, for its sorrow and its mystery.'" -- Henry Wadsworth Longfellow
"He suffered excessive popularity; he has now suffered three quarters of a century of critical neglect." -- Michael Schmidt
"A gentle man, with sentiments stronger than his passions, and ambition continuing his genius, highly cultivated, not strongly intellectual but truly aesthetic, with a fondness for melancholy and a nostalgia for the past - that is one view of Longfellow. Yet - and this is what makes him interesting and made him successful - also a writer of incredible literary energy, pursuing the best in craftsmanship, a mind intensely sensitive, not so much to life as to the feelings about life which we call literature. Also, again, the best representative of young America seeking Old World culture, one of the most articulate romancers of our past and of all pasts which seemed to him romantic. No Shakespeare, no Dante, no Emerson in height, no Walt Whitman in prophetic intuition, nevertheless, he did enough in being Longfellow definitely to enrich his times and our literature." -- Henry Seidel Canby, editor of the 1947 "Favorite Poems of Henry Wadsworth Longfellow"

Wonderful thoughtful interview with John Banville about his new book The Infinities. I would listen to him talk about his favorite pop group, for sure. I would listen to him tell me his grocery list. If you go back through my archives, I have probably linked to interviews with John Banville more than anything else. (Here, here, here... but the list goes on).
I love his writing (the Banville books, as well as the Benjamin Black books), and I love the connections I have with him and my father - he was probably my father's favorite living author - and I love that Banville seems to see his art as something that is, well, fun. Even though if you read something like his Booker-award winning novel The Sea you would be forgiven if you thought that Banville could very well be the most depressed person on the face of the planet. But he's not. He's an artist. He's fluid and flexible with that art. He's a creator.
I also feel that his pseudonym Benjamin Black, the writer who writes Dublin noir-style crime stories, has set him free, although I don't think he sees his Banville books as drudgery. It's almost like a great tragic actor deciding to do Importance of Being Earnest in summer stock, before going back to play Macbeth in Stratford the following fall. It's all the same actor, same commitment, but there is a certain feeling of release that seems to come when you don't feel the need to rip your guts out. It's a BREAK, a necessary palate cleanser. Banville talks about this quite openly. A new Benjamin Black is coming out and Banville says about it:
I have a new novel coming out shortly under Benjamin Black’s name. It’s a completely different discipline. I like doing it, it’s an inglorious craftwork that I enjoy immensely. And yes, I’ll keep doing it. It’s an adventure I’ve embarked on, and whether I’m making a mistake or otherwise, I don’t know.
If you go back and read all of the MOUNTAINS of press that Christine Falls got, and every subsequent Benjamin Black book got, you'll find the interviews with Banville - known as a "serious" novelist - and in every interview there is that tone to it. It's an adventure. There is no grand master plan. He wanted to break out of the shackles of what he felt was his other fiction, so he created this alter-ego writer and got to work, and blew through his manuscript at lightning speed.
You can feel how much FUN he has with this crazy gift he has been given, this writing gift.
For example:
What kills art is solemnity. Art is always serious but never, never solemn. Good art recognizes, as I say, our peculiar predicament in the world, that we’re suspended in this extraordinary place, we don’t know what it’s for or why we’re here. We know vaguely, but there is no answer to it. It’s simply that by just some chance of evolution we evolved beyond the animals, we got consciousness of death, which goes back to the beginning of our conversation, gives all life its flavor. This is peculiar to us, so far as we know. Who knows, the animals may know that they’re dying but it doesn’t shape their lives in the way that consciousness of death shapes ours. But art, as I say, has to be light, it has to be frivolous, and it has to be superficial in the best sense of these words. Nietzsche says upon the surface, that’s where the real depth is, and I think that’s true. I never speculate, I never psychologize, I just present, so far as I can, the evidence—this is what one sees, this is how the world looks, this is how it tastes and smells. In other words, I don’t know how to answer your question.
hahahaha
I do love that: Art is serious but never solemn.
You get that from his books.
Banville has been very eloquent on Joyce. He is an Irish writer, after all. You're gonna be asked about Joyce. Banville is probably the most successful and renowned Irish writer today (although it is, as usual, a crowded field), and yet his philosophy (although he does not call it that) is similar to that of Joyce's. Joyce famously said about Ulysses, "on my honour as a gentleman, there is not one serious word in it." I believe him, as I have said before. A book can be serious without taking itself seriously and without being serious in and of itself. I enjoy things that are not top-heavy, tipping over with their meaning. It's one of the reasons why I loved Then We Came to the End so much, because that is one hell of a serious book, its impact reverberates for days, and yet it's not solemn. It made me laugh out loud. If you think that's easy, you need to read more. That is hard to do. Joshua Ferris wrote what I feel is one of THE novels of "our time", and yet he doesn't treat it in a solemn way. Who knows if it will stand the test of time, if it is so "of the moment" that the reverb won't last - that's not for me to say. All I can say is: that book is FUNNY, and when I put it down, I was crushed and awed by what he had been able to perceive and show. It's not "light". It may be funny, but it's not light. I don't enjoy "light" fiction, because it doesn't hold my attention. I am bored, because I can't grasp onto it, or even concentrate.
So there is something fun about Banville's approach to his work that I find very liberating, and fun to read about.
There’s no message. I constantly say one of my absolute mottos is from Kafka, where he says the artist is the man who has nothing to say. I have nothing to say. I have no opinions about anything. I don’t care about physical, moral, social issues of the day. I just want to recreate the sense of what life feels like, what it tastes like, what it smells like. That’s what art should do. I feel it should be absolutely gloriously useless.
Obviously, when you read something like The Sea, or his earlier books - the one on Kepler, for example - it is hard to take him at his word at times, however he does seem to capture, unlike many other writers (some of them quite good) - the uselessness of it all, in a similar way to Joyce, who didn't give a rat's ass about politics, social issues, convention, hot topics, modes of thinking ... If you look closely, you can see that Joyce, obviously, has an opinion on, say, the British. Or Catholicism. But he never makes anything about what it means. He goes deeper. Deeper than anyone. Meaning was irrelevant to him, since he appeared to see things in a tailspinning kaleidoscope of interconnecting elements. It is hard to see what Joyce saw, but it sure as hell wasn't about what it all means. That would have bored him to death.
Portrait of the Artist is one of the angriest books in the English language, but it is Joyce's stance as an artist that seems to change the way I perceive it. His desire was not to stick it to the British through literature. Many people did that, and while they may have made a splash in their day, their books would not stand the test of time. Joyce's desire was to capture, in language, what life feels like. He could only write about what he knows (he is the classic example of that - I don't think you always have to "write what you know" - that's balderdash - but Joyce ONLY wrote from personal experience - he didn't create characters, or create plots, nothing writerly whatsoever). Joyce wrote what life feels like. And that included things like listening to sermons and thinking about hell and masturbating and overhearing conversations about Parnell, and all of these highly explosive topics. But if you've read the book, then you know that it is not a polemic, a pamphlet, and the meaning is hidden, if there is one.
Once I got that Joyce didn't care about meaning, I was able to click into his stuff with the greatest of ease.
I love Banville's thoughts on that. Love it to death, as I work hard on my own writing, sitting and staring at the blank page.
I also love the section in the interview about naming characters and how important it is to find the right name. For him, once he gets the names, all else follows.
Ah, what can I say, love this man so much, and the interview is a good one. The interviewer had done her homework, and gave him some very thought-provoking questions (which Banville commented on a couple of times). She got some really great responses.
Before I went to Block Island I was given some advice by a very wise man:
1. Don't drink. He told me, "I did a winter-beach-writing thing too and you lose track of time, so I'd pour myself a scotch at 3 p.m., it's dark out after all, and then would wake up foggy the next day. So don't drink."
2. Don't bring any books by authors you admire or want to emulate. Leave those at home.
I was fascinated by this and obeyed him faithfully on both counts (well, except for the notorious Bloody Mary day). The books I brought to Block Island were things that had been on my shelf for eons, waiting for me to pick up, waiting for me to want to read again, and none of them were by the authors that make me ache with envy. The Rockefeller bio was safe. Evelyn Waugh was safe. Even if I wanted to write like him, I flat out couldn't. The "interview-length books" with Roman Polanski and Andrei Tarkovsky were safe. And my poetry book was safe. When I was packing up my books for the trip, I hesitated over Annie Proulx's latest short story collection. I've been dying to read it, but the pull to write like her, to capture her totally original stylings, is too strong. I left her behind.
It was awesome advice. My reading out there was for pleasure only, an escape, not to mention building up my reading-muscles again. As I turned the pages, I thought to myself, "Look at me! Reading again!"
But the voices I encountered didn't clamor through my head, begging me to imitate them, to try to be like them.
William Carlos Williams has said that he could not read T.S. Eliot because the influence on him was too strong, and if he spent any time with Eliot whatsoever, he would have no voice left to speak of. The pull to imitate was so strong. Hart Crane said the same thing about Eliot, in letter after letter. Here's just one example:
I have been facing him [T.S. Eliot] for four years - and while I haven’t discovered a weak spot yet in his armour, - I flatter myself a little lately that I have discovered a safe tangent to strike which, if I can possibly explain the position, - goes through him toward a different goal. You see it is such a fearful temptation to imitate him that at times I have been almost distracted… In his own realm Eliot presents us with an absolute impasse, yet oddly enough, he can be utilized to lead us to, intelligently point to, other positions and ‘pastures new’. Having absorbed him enough, we can trust ourselves as never before, in the air or on the sea.
Certain writers act as a magnet. The only way to deal with them is to resist the pull. Every contemporary Irish writer has SOME opinion of James Joyce, good, bad, or indifferent, it doesn't matter. Joyce is the magnet, and you must resist. Resist the impulse to imitate, naturally, but also, there are certain writers who can make you lose confidence in yourself.
It's different for each writer. Annie Proulx, Joan Didion, Michael Chabon and Lorrie Moore make me lose confidence in myself (and these are just the contemporary ones). I also have Lorrie Moore's long-awaited new book on the shelf, but since I am working so hard on my own writing right now, I think I need to stay away from her for a bit. Know your influences, certainly, and acknowledge them, but it is also important to have the self-knowledge to wrestle with those demons/angels (as Hart Crane so obviously did).
Or, and just to carry on the chain, Tennessee Williams was so influenced by Hart Crane (and others, but Hart Crane mainly) that he had to eventually separate himself, openly, and you can see, in play after play, he either starts with an epigraph from Crane, or outright dedicates it to Crane. A way to say: "This over there is YOU. I acknowledge your power, and I acknowledge your influence. So I dedicate to YOU to keep you in your proper place. NOT in my prose itself."
All of this is to say, Maud Newton has a great piece up about intimidation, how certain writers (again, it's different for everyone) have the power to SILENCE you. To make you zip it. Forever.
To carry on the chain yet again, T.S. Eliot was so haunted by James Joyce and Ulysses that he never quite recovered his balance. His "Waste Land" was published in 1922, same year as Ulysses, and while I don't think Joyce ever gave T.S. Eliot a second thought (Joyce didn't feel he had any rivals), Eliot kept circling back ... and back ... and back ... to Joyce, in his writings. What WAS it Joyce had done? You can feel the unbalancing effect it had on so many writers at that time. It takes a strong ego to feel like whatever you are working on has value, even if it is not THAT.
Great quote from Joan Didion about the writer who silences her. I'm with Maud. Hard to imagine the great Didion being silenced by anyone, but it's nice to know it happens to everyone.

Edna St. Vincent Millay was born in Rockland, Maine.
Edna St. Vincent Millay was one of those rarest of creatures: a poet who was a celebrity in her day. The first woman to win the Pulitzer Prize for poetry, there was obviously something about her that packed audiences into halls to hear her read. People describe how she read her own poems - and it sounds like theatre. She understood that she had a persona, and she used it, creating it consciously. She was not in tune with the tenor of the times, the modernist onslaught of other poets at that time, who were ripping themselves away from the influences of the 19th century. You read Millay's stuff and you can't believe she was writing at the same time as Eliot, Yeats, et al. You would believe she was a contemporary of Charlotte Bronte. Her "form" was the sonnet, deceptively simple (until you try to write one), and she was one of the most popular writers of the day. I love her stuff.
I read a biography of Edna St. Vincent Millay (Savage Beauty: The Life of Edna St. Vincent Millay) and found her to be self-absorbed, narcissistic, coy and ruthless. An interesting combination. Irresistible to men, apparently. I didn't like her very much. Lock up your husbands and boyfriends when she's around. She was a brat. I also felt kind of in awe - at someone who so clearly only lived by her own rules. She was a woman, of a certain time. But propriety, and the mores of the day, didn't come into her thinking at ALL. She was a siren. I found her fascinating. She was a phenom: from very early on her gift of verse was recognized. Similar to Sylvia Plath, whose verses in high school were already being published, juvenilia though they may be. This was not a woman who suffered in obscurity. No. People read her stuff, powerful people, and immediately set out to help her, introduce her to the right people, set her up so that she could be a success. It's quite an extraordinary life story.
This is my favorite of her sonnets.
Time does not bring relief; you all have lied
Who told me time would ease me of my pain!
I miss him in the weeping of the rain;
I want him at the shrinking of the tide;
The old snows melt from every mountain-side,
And last year's leaves are smoke in every lane;
But last year's bitter loving must remain
Heaped on my heart, and my old thoughts abide.
There are a hundred places where I fear
To go, -- so with his memory they brim.
And entering with relief some quiet place
Where never fell his foot or shone his face
I say, "There is no memory of him here!"
And so stand stricken, so remembering him.
The sonnet nails that particular sensation. I touched on the lie that is "Time heals all" in this post, as well, linked to in my Auden tribute below.

I love her sonnet, too, to Elinor Wylie, a person who also fascinates me (see my post on her here).
To Elinor Wylie
(In answer to a question about her)
Oh, she was beautiful in every part! --
The auburn hair that bound the subtle brain;
The lovely mouth cut clear by wit and pain,
Uttering oaths and nonsense, uttering art
In casual speech and curving at the smart
On startled ears of excellence too plain
For early morning! -- Obit. Death from strain;
The soaring mind outstripped the tethered heart.
Yet here was one who had no need to die
To be remembered. Every word she said,
The lively malice of the hazel eye
Scanning the thumb-nail close -- oh, dazzling dead,
How like a comet through the darkening sky
You raced! ... would your return were heralded.
When you read the details of her life, her aching lovelorn poems seem even more poignant. Not because she was a particularly poignant personality - as a matter of fact, it is the opposite. That's what, to me, is amazing. If you only read her poetry (and she's perfect for when you are lovelorn or nostalgic - the sonnets read like letters to the beloved) you would think she was the most sentimental person on the planet, with one great love she yearned for all her days. The fact that she was a bit of a ruthless harlot makes her romantic "persona" even more interesting, more deliberate, more an act of CONJURING than reflection of personal truth. Kudos. Her talent obviously expressed herself in the old forms, at that time in disfavor - rhyming couplets and rigid sonnets - but the amount of feeling she was able to get into each line, each verse, is incredible to me.
Millay's reputation is a solid one, although she no longer stands as a giant of 20th century poetry, as she did at the time when she was alive. Yet her lyrical romantic sonnets are still poems that people adore, even love ... and many of the greater more important poets don't have that. It's not good or bad, just a fact. She still can express the vagaries of love to our generation, in a more jaded time, with a high-flung cry of pain or ecstasy, that just works. It still sounds true.
Sonnet xxviii
I pray if you love me, bear my joy
A little while, or let me weep your tears;
I, too, have seen the quavering Fate destroy
Your destiny's bright spinning -- the dull shears
Meeting not neatly, chewing at the thread, --
Nor can you well be less aware how fine
How staunch as wire, and how unwarranted
Endures the golden fortune that is mine.
I pray you for this day at least, my dear,
Fare by my side, that journey in the sun;
Else must I turn me from the blossoming year
And walk in grief the way that you have gone.
Let us go forth together to the spring:
Love must be this, if it be anything.
Here are some quotes/anecdotes about Millay:
"In October 1934, Edna Millay read at Yale. A young graduate student, Richard Sewell, who forty years later would become the biographer of Emily Dickinson, never forgot the impression she made that night. Walking to the center of Woolsey Hall, wrapped in a long black velvet cloak, her bright hair shining, she "stood before us," he remembered, "like a daffodil." Looking at her wrist, she told the audience that the poems she was about to read were from her new book, Wine From These Grapes, "which is coming off the press just about now." That night she read with the zeal of a young Jeremiah, her words burning the air as she closed her reading with a sonnet from 'The Epitaph for the Race of Man'. Tickets for her readings were wildly sought whether she was in Oklahoma City or Chicago, where the hall seating 1,600 was sold out and even with standees an extra hall had to be taken for the overflow of another 800 who listened to her over amplifiers." -- Nancy Milford, "Savage Beauty"
"For instance, they had shades at their window and nothing else. I don't think they cared much. Well, once they stenciled apple blossoms, painted that pattern down the sides of the window. Or, for instance, they had a couple of plum trees in their backyard, and they never waited for the plums to ripen, but would pick them green, put them in vinegar, and call them 'mock olives.' Well, no one else did that sort of thing in Camden, don't you see?" -- Lena Dunbar, neighbor of the Millay family
"The poem seems to us to be phenomenal." -- Edward J. Wheeler, editor of "Current Literature", on Edna's poem 'The Land of Romance' - written when she was 14
"We have named the little one Edna Vincent Millay. Don't you think that is pretty? ... the Vincent is for the 'St. Vincent' Hospital, the one that cared so well for our darling brother. Nell woudl have called it 'Vincent' if it had been a boy." -- Cora Millay on the birth of her first daughter, on George Washington's birthday
"-- oh, this was life! It was more than life, -- it was art. I might pretend to myself [at home] as much and as long as I liked, -- until the deep-vibrant note I had discovered in my voice ... out-Hedda-ed Nazimova -- yet was my native village unthrilled and unconvinced; I was asked to serve ice-cream at church socials, and the grocer-boy called me by name ..." -- Edna St. Vincent Millay on her first job as an actress in a traveling stock company
"Boys don't like me anyway because I won't let them kiss me. It's just like this: let boys kiss you and they'll like you but you won't ... But I'd be almost willing to be engaged if I thought it would keep me from being lonesome ... if I was engaged I would be going to the play tonight instead of sitting humped up on the steps in a drizzle that keeps my pencil point sticky. I'd be going out paddling tomorrow instead of practicing the Beethoven Funeral March Sonata. And I'd like to have something to do besides write in an old book. I'd like to have something happen to give me a jolt, something that would rattle my teeth and shake my hairpins out." -- Edna St. Vincent Millay, in her journal, 1911
"The most astonishingly beautiful and original poem in The Lyric Year, the poem most arresting in its vision, the poem most like a wonderful Pre-Raphael painting, is surely Renascence by Miss Edna St. Vincent Millay. To me it almost unthinkable that a girl of twenty could conceive such a work and execute it with such vigor and tenderness ... And it is with no small pride that I give it my first vote for the prizes." -- Ferdinand Earle, 1912

Sonnet xv
Only until this cigarette is ended,
A little moment at the end of all,
While on the floor the quiet ashes fall,
And in the firelight to a lance extended,
Bizarrely with the jazzing music blended,
The broken shadow dances on the wall,
I will permit my memory to recall
The vision of you, by all my dreams attended.
And then adieu, -- farewell! -- the dream is done.
Yours is a face of which I can forget
The colour and the features, every one,
The words not ever, and the smiles not yet;
But in your day this moment is the sun
Upon a hill, after the sun has set.
W.H. Auden was born in York, England.
Two pieces of advice for writers from Mr. Auden:
To keep his errors down to a minimum, the internal Censor to whom a poet submits his work in progress should be a Censorate. It should include, for instance, a sensitive only child, a practical housewife, a logician, a monk, an irreverent buffoon and even, perhaps, hated by all the others and returning their dislike, a brutal foul-mouthed drill sergeant who considers all poetry rubbish.
Then there is:
Never write from your head; write from your cock.
While that second piece may not, in an anatomical way, apply to me, I still take it as very good advice.

There are only two other poets I can think of who take up as much brain-space for me as Auden, in terms of reference-points, who help me figure out how to say things, and those are Yeats and Shakespeare. I'll be in some situation and suddenly I'll remember Auden's words "let the healing fountains start ..." (which is from his poem, coincidentally, on Yeats) Or I'll be troubled and remind myself that I need to try to love my crooked neighbor with my crooked heart. I know I'm crooked. We all are. But we must love anyway. Or try to. I find Auden himself to be a "healing fountain". There is something transcendent about his work for me. It lifts me up into my better self, a place where it is possible to be good, and loving, and forgiving.
Auden wasn't an idiotic optimist, however, and he did a lot of revising of his work over the years - he was a compulsive reviser - so a lot of his stuff has multiple dates on it. It wasn't just language he revised, it was thought and philosophy. If he outgrew a certain view, he would go back and tinker with the poems that expressed said view. One of the most fascinating examples of his revisions shows that he was willing to go back and revise something, a philosophical statement, that he no longer felt was true. He couldn't let it stand. In his chilling poem "September 1, 1939", written about Germany's invasion of Poland, there is a line "We must love one another or die". An extraordinary sentiment, especially at that brutal terrifying time.
September 1, 2939
I sit in one of the dives
On Fifty-second Street
Uncertain and afraid
As the clever hopes expire
Of a low dishonest decade:
Waves of anger and fear
Circulate over the bright
And darkened lands of the earth,
Obsessing our private lives;
The unmentionable odour of death
Offends the September night.
Accurate scholarship can
Unearth the whole offence
From Luther until now
That has driven a culture mad,
Find what occurred at Linz,
What huge imago made
A psychopathic god:
I and the public know
What all schoolchildren learn,
Those to whom evil is done
Do evil in return.
Exiled Thucydides knew
All that a speech can say
About Democracy,
And what dictators do,
The elderly rubbish they talk
To an apathetic grave;
Analysed all in his book,
The enlightenment driven away,
The habit-forming pain,
Mismanagement and grief:
We must suffer them all again.
Into this neutral air
Where blind skyscrapers use
Their full height to proclaim
The strength of Collective Man,
Each language pours its vain
Competitive excuse:
But who can live for long
In an euphoric dream;
Out of the mirror they stare,
Imperialism's face
And the international wrong.
Faces along the bar
Cling to their average day:
The lights must never go out,
The music must always play,
All the conventions conspire
To make this fort assume
The furniture of home;
Lest we should see where we are,
Lost in a haunted wood,
Children afraid of the night
Who have never been happy or good.
The windiest militant trash
Important Persons shout
Is not so crude as our wish:
What mad Nijinsky wrote
About Diaghilev
Is true of the normal heart;
For the error bred in the bone
Of each woman and each man
Craves what it cannot have,
Not universal love
But to be loved alone.
From the conservative dark
Into the ethical life
The dense commuters come,
Repeating their morning vow;
'I will be true to the wife,
I'll concentrate more on my work,'
And helpless governors wake
To resume their compulsory game:
Who can release them now,
Who can reach the dead,
Who can speak for the dumb?
All I have is a voice
To undo the folded lie,
The romantic lie in the brain
Of the sensual man-in-the-street
And the lie of Authority
Whose buildings grope the sky:
There is no such thing as the State
And no one exists alone;
Hunger allows no choice
To the citizen or the police;
We must love one another or die.
Defenseless under the night
Our world in stupor lies;
Yet, dotted everywhere,
Ironic points of light
Flash out wherever the Just
Exchange their messages:
May I, composed like them
Of Eros and of dust,
Beleaguered by the same
Negation and despair,
Show an affirming flame.
The poem was published, and Auden immediately saw all sorts of problems with it, having to do with its rhetoric and tone, but it all encapsulated for him in that line. He said he read its published version and:
...said to myself: 'That's a damned lie! We must die anyway.' So, in the next edition, I altered it to 'We must love one another and die.' This didn't seem to do either, so I cut the stanza. Still no good. The whole poem, I realized, was infected with an incurable dishonesty—and must be scrapped.
He didn't include it in his own canon (more on that line below), he was that ruthless in his own work. The work felt dishonest to him. He didn't like how it was being used. And that one chilling substitution - of "or" to "and" - didn't help. You can see the entire tenor of the times in his revision, can't you? You could write an entire book on the difference between the two statements, and how "and" changes everything. Regardless, the poem survived - and it is included in his Collected Work, and over the space of time it has regained currency, especially in times of war and fear and hatred. It speaks to those universal experiences.
Then, of course, he has written two lines which - as difficult as they are - are words I actually try to live by. "If equal affection cannot be / Let the more loving one be me." This is a phrase that comes up in my head, what, once, twice a day? It is complicated now, by my insistence on reciprocity, and I wonder if I have lived by his words too much? But that's the thing with such words: you kind of can't do them half way. You can't say, "Oh, wow, what a nice sentiment" and then not try to live by them. At least I haven't been able to. They sound a gong in the depths of me ... that this is the way it SHOULD be. That this is how I SHOULD try to live. I stand by that. I rarely throw out the baby with the bathwater. I try to integrate, and much of Auden's work - with its complex messaging (his religion, his sexuality, his politics - and how those things grew and morphed) - is all about integration. It is why it is so precious to me, why he comes up for me again and again. I feel like he is MINE. In terms of that poem "The More Loving One" (which I would recite to myself, in bed, in the weeks following September 11th, along with the Hail Mary - my two talismans against fear, and the choking smoke billowing up from lower Manhattan) I have a hard time picking a favorite anything - but if I had to choose to re-read only one poem for the rest of my life, it would be "The More Loving One".
The More Loving One
Looking up at the stars, I know quite well
That, for all they care, I can go to hell,
But on earth indifference is the least
We have to dread from man or beast.
How should we like it were stars to burn
With a passion for us we could not return?
If equal affection cannot be,
Let the more loving one be me.
Admirer as I think I am
Of stars that do not give a damn,
I cannot, now I see them, say
I missed one terribly all day.
Were all stars to disappear or die,
I should learn to look at an empty sky
And feel its total dark sublime,
Though this might take me a little time.
I can honestly say that that poem has helped me in living my life. Even when (or especially when) I take issue with this or that line. It is the "taking issue with" that makes it a great poem. Find the "total dark sublime", Auden? Are you out of your mind? NO. I REFUSE. But then comes the great and painful last line of admission: "Though this might take me a little time." If it weren't for that last line, Auden would be just another sentimental optimist. Make lemonade out of lemons! some do-gooder nonentity shouts at someone who has just experienced a catastrophe. My response to that is usually, "Sure - I'll do my best - but can you GIVE ME A MINUTE? Can you just admit that this won't happen IMMEDIATELY?" Auden knows this. That last line admits the pain and beauty of human experience, even in tragedy. It is a miracle. That we can keep going on, even though there are no more stars left in the sky. It is awful. It is what we do. We have no choice. But don't ask me to call it "sublime" immediately. Give me "a little time", thanks.
I need to leave Shakespeare out of this discussion (although probably Auden would want him included) because there are many lines of Shakespeare as well that have actually been "candle beams" in the darkness, so shining a good deed in a naughty world and all that. But "The More Loving One" stands, for me, as one of the most profound poems of all time. And he doesn't use what Hemingway calls the "ten dollar words". It's a poem of simple language, very few metaphors, a clear and open expression of what is, actually, a philosophy. Here is a story from my life that circles around the poem. That night was a crucible, a tesseract. I was not the same afterwards. I was inside Auden's poem, and it came from the most ordinary of occurrences, a failed love affair. Now, with the distance of time, I can say he is the only man (thus far) I have ever loved. That night, the whirlwind I was in, was necessary. It was awful, but necessary. A night of "total dark". No "sublimity" whatsoever.
What can I say. Auden is in my brain. When I find myself in times of trouble Mother Mary comes to me, and so does Auden.
If I look back, I believe that I first encountered Auden (at least, my first MEMORY of it) was in my "Humanities" class, senior year in high school. Or it might have been my junior year? It was a great class, I got a lot out of it, and I remember we analyzed an Auden poem ("Musée des Beaux Arts"), alongside the Breughel painting it was based on - The Fall of Icarus.

Musée des Beaux Arts
About suffering they were never wrong,
The Old Masters; how well, they understood
Its human position; how it takes place
While someone else is eating or opening a window or just walking dully along;
How, when the aged are reverently, passionately waiting
For the miraculous birth, there always must be
Children who did not specially want it to happen, skating
On a pond at the edge of the wood:
They never forgot
That even the dreadful martyrdom must run its course
Anyhow in a corner, some untidy spot
Where the dogs go on with their doggy life and the torturer's horse
Scratches its innocent behind on a tree.
In Breughel's Icarus, for instance: how everything turns away
Quite leisurely from the disaster; the ploughman may
Have heard the splash, the forsaken cry,
But for him it was not an important failure; the sun shone
As it had to on the white legs disappearing into the green
Water; and the expensive delicate ship that must have seen
Something amazing, a boy falling out of the sky,
had somewhere to get to and sailed calmly on.
See the little up-ended legs in the water over to the right? I remember, in my vaguely OCD way at the time, loving making that connection - reading the poem, looking at the painting, going back to the poem - trying to see every single thing that this Auden chap saw in the poem. Of course there's way more to the poem than that (the first line that spills over into the second line? Perfection) - and its observations about the meaningless of human suffering, and our indifference to one another (something that Auden comes back to again and again in his poems.)
It was later, when I was an adult, that I went back to Auden's work to re-discover it, on my own terms.
The wonderful Clive James said about Auden (and this is really interesting):
The need to find an expression for his homosexuality was the first technical obstacle to check the torrential course of Auden's unprecedented facility. A born master of directness was obliged straightaway to find a language for indirection, thus becoming immediately involved with the drama that was to continue for the rest of his life - a drama in which the living presence of technique is the antagonist.
There is sometimes an almost unbearable tension in Auden's best poems. It seems to be that he is expressing everything, but you ache to hear more, you wonder what else this amazing voice has to say. Like most great artists, what he withholds is almost just as interesting as what he reveals.
Michael Schmidt wrote, "He overshadows the poets of his generation." In the same way that Shakespeare overshadows the other playwrights and poets of his current day. You have to kind of get Auden out of the way to see what else was going on in the literary world And there was a lot going on!!
Auden straddles the 20th century as a sort of bridge. He read The Waste Land and suddenly realized what he wanted to do, what poetry COULD do. It helped him enormously, it gave him courage to let go of old-fashioned forms. Yet at the same time, his great and well-known love for Thomas Hardy suggests that he was also a traditionalist. He went back, back to the 19th century, for his inspiration as well (although I am probably generalizing).
He understands terror and despair. He lived in "interesting times", and was responsive to them in his work. Many poets were undone by WWI and WWII. The horror took away their voices. Auden was just the opposite.
Edward Mendelson, who edited the selected works of Auden writes:
"Then, in June 1933, Auden experienced what he later called a 'Vision of Agape'. He was sitting on a lawn with three colleagues from the school where he was teaching, when, he wrote, 'quite suddenly and unexpectedly, something happened. I felt myself invaded by a power which, though I consented to it, was irresistible and certainly not mine. For the first time in my life I knew exactly - because, thanks to the power, I was doing it - what it meant to love one's neighbor as oneself.' Before this, his poems had only been able to celebrate moments of impersonal erotic intensity, which he called 'love'. Now, in the poem 'Out on the lawn I lie in bed,' prompted by his vision, he had praise for everything around him."
A Summer Night
A Summer Night
Out on the lawn I lie in bed,
Vega conspicuous overhead
In the windless nights of June,
As congregated leaves complete
Their day's activity; my feet
Point to the rising moon.
Lucky, this point in time and space
Is chosen as my working-place,
Where the sexy airs of summer,
The bathing hours and the bare arms,
The leisured drives through a land of farms
Are good to a newcomer.
Equal with colleagues in a ring
I sit on each calm evening
Enchanted as the flowers
The opening light draws out of hiding
With all its gradual dove-like pleading,
Its logic and its powers:
That later we, though parted then,
May still recall these evenings when
Fear gave his watch no look;
The lion griefs loped from the shade
And on our knees their muzzles laid,
And Death put down his book.
Now north and south and east and west
Those I love lie down to rest;
The moon looks on them all,
The healers and the brilliant talkers,
The eccentrics and the silent walkers,
The dumpy and the tall.
She climbs the European sky,
Churches and power stations lie
Alike among earth's fixtures:
Into the galleries she peers
And blankly as a butcher stares
Upon the marvelous pictures.
To gravity attentive, she
Can notice nothing here, though we
Whom hunger does not move,
From gardens where we feel secure
Look up and with a sigh endure
The tyrannies of love:
And, gentle, do not care to know,
Where Poland draws her eastern bow,
What violence is done,
Nor ask what doubtful act allows
Our freedom in this English house,
Our picnics in the sun.
Soon, soon, through the dykes of our content
The crumpling flood will force a rent
And, taller than a tree,
Hold sudden death before our eyes
Whose river dreams long hid the size
And vigours of the sea.
But when the waters make retreat
And through the black mud first the wheat
In shy green stalks appears,
When stranded monsters gasping lie,
And sounds of riveting terrify
Their whorled unsubtle ears,
May these delights we dread to lose,
This privacy, need no excuse
But to that strength belong,
As through a child's rash happy cries
The drowned parental voices rise
In unlamenting song.
After discharges of alarm
All unpredicted let them calm
The pulse of nervous nations,
Forgive the murderer in the glass,
Tough in their patience to surpass
The tigress her swift motions.
I think of this poem as the "vision of agape" poem, even though that is not its title. There are too many good lines to even count. "Lion griefs"? I don't even know what that MEANS, but I certainly like to think about it, and picture it, and I wish I could write like that. "When stranded monsters gasping lie ..." Marvelous, scary. Whatever he might think of Yeats, Yeats' "slouching beast" is in that line. This poem was the first moment Auden felt he really "broke through" in his work, and you can feel the difference in his poems forever afterwards. Before "vision of agape" he was one type of poet, after "vision of agape" he was another. He had been able to see the universal.
My mother saw Auden read at her college, (or maybe it was at the nearby Yale?) when she was a student. His readings were always packed, the most prized ticket in town. 20 years before that, he gave a famous series of lectures on Shakespeare at the New School for Social Research (where I went to grad school), and created a frenzy. These were not tape recorded (if memory serves), but a guy who was there took copious notes, basically writing down, in shorthand, everything Auden said. Those notes were compiled into a book, which I will forever be grateful for. Anyone interested in Shakespeare really MUST read Auden's lectures - they dig deep into the language of the plays, and the dramaturgy, not to mention plot-points and analysis - and is indispensable reading.
Here is a fascinating excerpt from W.H. Auden's lecture on Hamlet, February 12, 1947, at the New School for Social Research in NYC - I read this, and it just sends reverberations ricocheting through my head. He gets at something essential here, I believe, that indefinable "IT" which lies at the heart of Hamlet. You can see why people spend their entire lives and careers studying only that one play. If you read it aloud, start to finish, no cuts, it is almost four hours long. It is Shakespeare's longest play. But what, ultimately, is it saying? It cannot be pinned down, it shifts - depending on how YOU look at it (similar to the particle/wave thing in quantum physics). If you want to see it one way, then it IS that way. If you want to see it another way, then lo and behold, the play cooperates. A shape-shifter. Anyway, here's Auden:
If a work is quite perfect, it arouses less controversy and there is less to say about it. Curiously, everyone tries to identify with Hamlet, even actresses - and in fact Sarah Bernhardt did play Hamlet, and I am glad to say she broke her leg doing it. One says that one is like a character, but one does not say, "This is me." One says, "I am more like Claudius, perhaps, than I am like Laertes," o "I would rather be Benedick than Orsino." But when a reader or spectator is inclined to say, "This is me," it becomes slightly suspicious. It is suspicious when all sorts of actors say, "This is a part I would like to do," not "This is a part I have a talent to do." I would question whether anyone has succeeded in playing Hamlet without appearing ridiculous. Hamlet is a tragedy where there is a part left open, as a part is left open for an improvisational actor in farce. But here the part is left open for a tragedian.Shakespeare took a great deal of time over this play. With a writer of Shakespeare's certainty of execution, a delay of this kind is a sign of some dissatisfaction. He has not got the thing he wants. T.S. Eliot has called the play "an artistic failure". Hamlet, the one inactive character, is not well integrated into the play and not adequately motivated, though the active characters are excellent. Polonious is a pseudo-practical dispenser of advice, who is a kind of voyeur where the sex life of his children is concerned. Laertes likes to be a dashing man-of-the-world who visits all houses - but don't you touch my sister! And he is jealous of Hamlet's intellect. Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are yes men. Gertrude is portrayed as a woman who likes to be loved, who likes to have romance in her life. And Horatio is not too bright, though he has read a lot and can repeat it.
The plays of the period in which Shakespeare wrote Hamlet have great richness, but one is not sure that at this point he even wants to be a dramatist. Hamlet offers strong evidence of this indecision, becaue it indicates what Shakespeare might have done if he had had an absolutely free hand: he might well have confined himself to dramatic monologues. The soliloquies in Hamlet as well as other plays of this period are detachable both from the character and the plays. In earlier as well as later works they are more integrated. The "To be or not to be" soliloquy in Hamlet (III.i.56-90) is a clear example of a speech that can be separated from both the character and the play, as are the speeches of Ulysses on time in Troilus and Cressida (III.iii.145-80), the King on honor in All's Well That Ends Well (II.iii.124-48), and the Duke on death in Measure for Measure (III.i.5-41).
Shakespeare, at this time, is interested in various technical problems. The first is the relation between prose and verse in the plays. In the early plays, the low or comic characters - Shylock as well as Launcelot Gobbo in The Merchant of Venice, for example - speak prose. An intellectual character like Falstaff speaks prose, in contrast to a passionate character like Hotspur, who speaks verse. In As You Like It, contrary to tradition, both the hero and heroine speak prose. In Twelfth Night, Viola speaks verse at court and prose to herself, and the characters in the play who are false or have no sense of humor speak verse. Those who are wiser and have some self-knowledge speak prose. In the tragedies Shakespeare develops an extremely fertile prose style for the tragic characters. Hamlet speaks both verse and prose. He speaks verse to himself, in his soliloquies, and in speeches of violent passion to others, as in the scene with his mother. He otherwise usually speaks prose to other people. There is a highly developed relation to prose and poetry in all the plays of this period. In the last plays Shakespeare exploits verse more exclusively, and tends to use prose when he is bored, or when he needs to fill in the gaps. In Antony and Cleopatra, the boring characters use prose, the rounded characters, verse.
Shakespeare is also developing a more flexible verse. He started off with the end-stopped Marlovian and lyric lines that were suitable to high passion. In Hamlet he experiments with the caesura, the stop in the middle of the line, to develop a middle voice, a voice neither passionate nor prosaic. Hamlet also shows a development in Shakespeare's use of the double adjective. From such a phrase as "sweet and honey'd sentences" in Henry V (I.i.50), which is tautological, he moves to pairs of adjectives in Hamlet that combine the abstract and the concrete: Laertes' "And keep you in the rear of your affection / Out of the shot and danger of desire" (I.iii.34-35), for example, Horatio's "These are but wild and whirling words, my lord" (I.v.133), and Hamlet's "Led by a delicate and tender prince" (IV.iv.48). George Ryland's book, Words and Poetry, is very good on Shakespeare's language and style.
In this period, also, Shakespeare appears to be tired of writing comedy, which he could do almost too well - he was probably bored because of his facility in the genre. Comedy is limited in the violence of language and emotion it can present, although Shakespeare can include a remarkable amount of both in his comedies. But though he wants to get away from comedy, he doesn't want to go back to the crude rhetoric of King John and Richard III or to the lyric and romantic rhetoric of Romeo and Juliet and Richard II. He doesn't want a childish character, who doesn't know what is going on, like Romeo and Richard II, nor a crude character like Brutus, who is a puppet in a plot of historical significance, where the incidents are more important than the characters. Finally, he doesn't want a character of fat humour that the situation must be constructed to reveal. And having done Falstaff, he doesn't want to go back to the crude character.
Shakespeare's very success as a dramatic poet may have led him to a kind of dissatisfaction with his life that is reflected in Hamlet. A dramatic poet is the kind of person who can imagine what anyone can feel, and he begins to wonder, "What am I?" "What do I feel?" "Can I feel?" Artists are inclined to suffer not from too much emotion but rather from too little. This business of being a mirror - you begin to question the reality of the mirror itself.
Shakespeare develops Hamlet from a number of earlier characters who are in differing ways proto-Hamlets. Richard II is a child, full of self-pity, who acts theatrically but who is not, like Hamlet, conscious of acting. Falstaff is like Hamlet, an intellectual character and the work of an artist who is becoming aware of his full powers, but he is not conscious of himself in the way Hamlet is. When Falstaff does become conscious of himself, he dies, almost suicidally. Brutus anticipates Hamlet by being, in a sense, his opposite. Hamlet is destroyed by his imagination. Brutus is destroyed by repressing his imagination, like the Stoic he is. He tries to exclude possibility. The nearest to Hamlet is Jaques, who remains unexplained and can take no part in the action.
I don't know about you, but I want to keep reading such thoughts forever. The whole book is like that. Because they are lectures, transcripts, basically - there's an off-the-cuff conversational tone to the language, which brings Auden to life in a new way for me.
Here are some quotes by and about W.H. Auden. There are many poets that I admire. There are also many poets I don't so much like, but one or two of their poems strike a chord. But there are very few poets I actually love. Auden is one of them.
"The subject of his poetry is the struggle, but the struggle seen, as it were, by someone who whilst living in one camp, sympathises with the other; a struggle in fact which while existing externally is also taking place within the mind of the poet himself, who remains a bourgeois." - Edgell Rickword, "Auden and Politics"
"I think of Mr. Auden's poetry as a hygiene, a knowledge and practice, based on a brilliantly prejudiced analysis of contemporary disorders, relating to the preservation and promotion of health, a sanitary science and a flusher of melancholia. I sometimes think of his poetry as a great war, admire intensely the mature, religious, and logical fighter, and deprecate the boy bushranger." -- Dylan Thomas
"One Sunday afternoon in March 1922, a friend suggested that I should [write poetry]: the thought had never occurred to me." -- WH Auden
"For more than a year I read no one else." -- WH Auden - on Thomas Hardy
"Another celebrated Auden line -- 'We must love one another or die' -- was annexed without his permission and used in Lyndon Johnson's notorious attack ad on Barry Goldwater in 1964, showing a little girl counting petals as she mutates into a thermonuclear countdown. The hideous scene closes with Auden's words. He was so furious at this that he removed the poem from his canon. He was prone to excise things that had been exploited or distorted, which is why '1 September 1939' -- the poem from which the line is taken -- can still be hard to get hold of. The same is alas true of 'Spain 1937' and of his verse obituary for W.B. Yeats in 1939 -- three utterly magnificent works in the space of three years." -- Christopher Hitchens, "The Essential Auden", Los Angeles Times
"[Thomas Hardy had a] hawk's vision, [a] way of looking at life from a very great height..." -- WH Auden
Spain
Yesterday all the past. The language of size
Spreading to China along the trade-routes; the diffusion
Of the counting-frame and the cromlech;
Yesterday the shadow-reckoning in the sunny climates.
Yesterday the assessment of insurance by cards,
The divination of water; yesterday the invention
Of cartwheels and clocks, the taming of
Horses. Yesterday the bustling world of the navigators.
Yesterday the abolition of fairies and giants,
the fortress like a motionless eagle eyeing the valley,
the chapel built in the forest;
Yesterday the carving of angels and alarming gargoyles;
The trial of heretics among the columns of stone;
Yesterday the theological feuds in the taverns
And the miraculous cure at the fountain;
Yesterday the Sabbath of witches; but to-day the struggle
Yesterday the installation of dynamos and turbines,
The construction of railways in the colonial desert;
Yesterday the classic lecture
On the origin of Mankind. But to-day the struggle.
Yesterday the belief in the absolute value of Greek,
The fall of the curtain upon the death of a hero;
Yesterday the prayer to the sunset
And the adoration of madmen. but to-day the struggle.
As the poet whispers, startled among the pines,
Or where the loose waterfall sings compact, or upright
On the crag by the leaning tower:
"O my vision. O send me the luck of the sailor."
And the investigator peers through his instruments
At the inhuman provinces, the virile bacillus
Or enormous Jupiter finished:
"But the lives of my friends. I inquire. I inquire."
And the poor in their fireless lodgings, dropping the sheets
Of the evening paper: "Our day is our loss. O show us
History the operator, the
Organiser. Time the refreshing river."
And the nations combine each cry, invoking the life
That shapes the individual belly and orders
The private nocturnal terror:
"Did you not found the city state of the sponge,
"Raise the vast military empires of the shark
And the tiger, establish the robin's plucky canton?
Intervene. O descend as a dove or
A furious papa or a mild engineer, but descend."
And the life, if it answers at all, replied from the heart
And the eyes and the lungs, from the shops and squares of the city
"O no, I am not the mover;
Not to-day; not to you. To you, I'm the
"Yes-man, the bar-companion, the easily-duped;
I am whatever you do. I am your vow to be
Good, your humorous story.
I am your business voice. I am your marriage.
"What's your proposal? To build the just city? I will.
I agree. Or is it the suicide pact, the romantic
Death? Very well, I accept, for
I am your choice, your decision. Yes, I am Spain."
Many have heard it on remote peninsulas,
On sleepy plains, in the aberrant fishermen's islands
Or the corrupt heart of the city.
Have heard and migrated like gulls or the seeds of a flower.
They clung like burrs to the long expresses that lurch
Through the unjust lands, through the night, through the alpine tunnel;
They floated over the oceans;
They walked the passes. All presented their lives.
On that arid square, that fragment nipped off from hot
Africa, soldered so crudely to inventive Europe;
On that tableland scored by rivers,
Our thoughts have bodies; the menacing shapes of our fever
Are precise and alive. For the fears which made us respond
To the medicine ad, and the brochure of winter cruises
Have become invading battalions;
And our faces, the institute-face, the chain-store, the ruin
Are projecting their greed as the firing squad and the bomb.
Madrid is the heart. Our moments of tenderness blossom
As the ambulance and the sandbag;
Our hours of friendship into a people's army.
To-morrow, perhaps the future. The research on fatigue
And the movements of packers; the gradual exploring of all the
Octaves of radiation;
To-morrow the enlarging of consciousness by diet and breathing.
To-morrow the rediscovery of romantic love,
the photographing of ravens; all the fun under
Liberty's masterful shadow;
To-morrow the hour of the pageant-master and the musician,
The beautiful roar of the chorus under the dome;
To-morrow the exchanging of tips on the breeding of terriers,
The eager election of chairmen
By the sudden forest of hands. But to-day the struggle.
To-morrow for the young the poets exploding like bombs,
The walks by the lake, the weeks of perfect communion;
To-morrow the bicycle races
Through the suburbs on summer evenings. But to-day the struggle.
To-day the deliberate increase in the chances of death,
The consious acceptance of guilt in the necessary murder;
To-day the expending of powers
On the flat ephemeral pamphlet and the boring meeting.
To-day the makeshift consolations: the shared cigarette,
The cards in the candlelit barn, and the scraping concert,
The masculine jokes; to-day the
Fumbled and unsatisfactory embrace before hurting.
The stars are dead. The animals will not look.
We are left alone with our day, and the time is short, and
History to the defeated
May say Alas but cannot help nor pardon.
Fascinating excerpt from Christopher Hitchens's book Why Orwell Matters, about the "feud" between Orwell and Auden, which came about because of the poem above:
I first struck across [Orwell's] writing at about the same period that I encountered the poetry of W.H. Auden, and it has subsequenty grieved me that the quarrel between the two men makes it impossible to esteem them as allies, or as co-authors of equivalent moral clarity. This is Orwell's fault: his attack on Auden is one of the few thuggish episodes in his prose, and is also related to his unexamined and philistine prejudice against homosexuality. But this depressing episode has its redeeming sequel, as I shall try to show. In May 1937 - the very worst month in the battle between the Spanish Republic and the deadly metastasis of Stalin's regime within Spanish institutions - Auden published a long and beautiful poem entitled, simplly, 'Spain'. The publication was not without its propaganda dimension; the poem first appeared as a shilling pamphlet with proceeds going to a Popular Front-organization 'medical aid' charity. However, in form and content the verses summon the idea of Spain itself ('that arid square, that fragment nipped off from hot / Africa, soldered so crudely to inventive Europe')' the place it then held in the hearts and minds of thinking people ('Our thoughts have bodies; the menacing shapes of our fever / Are precise and alive'); and finally the agony experienced by those non-violent intellectuals who had decided to abandon neutrality and suppressing misgiving, endorse the use of force in self-defence:To-day the deliberate increase in the chances of death,It is hard to imagine it being put better: the fascist poets had exulted in violence and cruelty and domineering rhetoric, celebrating death and denigrating the intellect, while their opponents gathered resolve reluctantly yet with mounting determination. This was not at all Orwell's reading of the poem. In two articles, one of them written for The Adelphi in 1938 and another more celebrated under the title 'Inside the Whale', he took venomous aim at the above stanza in particular. It was, he sneered:
The conscious acceptance of guilt in the necessary murder;
To-day the expending of powers
On the flat ephemeral pamphlet and the boring meeting.a sort of tabloid picture of a day in the life of a 'good party man'. In the morning a couple of political murders, a ten-minutes' interlude to stifle 'bourgeois' remorse, and then a hurried luncheon and a busy afternoon and evening chalking walls and distributing leaflets. All very edifying. But notice the phrase 'necessary murder'. It could only be written by a person to whom murder is at most a word. Personally I would not speak so lightly of murder ... The Hitlers and Stalins find murder necessary, but ... they don't speak of it as murder; it is 'liquidation', 'elimination' or some other soothing phrase. Mr. Auden's brand of amoralism is only possible if you are the kind of person who is always somewhere else when the trigger is pulled.The laden sarcasm here is as gross as the cheapness of the argument. Who can possibly have thought that terms (not phrases) like 'liquidation' or 'elimination' were 'soothing'? By giving the word 'murder' its rightful name, Auden was precisely declining to use the sort of euphemism that Orwell elsewhere found so despicable. His 'brand of amoralism' consisted in a sincere attempt to overcome essentially pacifist scruples, and to be candid about the consequences.We do not know for certain how much Orwell's excoriation weighed with Auden, but in 1939 he revised 'Spain' to delete all allusions to such moral dilemmas, and by the 1950s he had made sure that the poem, together with some others of the period, could not be anthologized under his name. This is in several ways a great pity: it suggests the mentality of an auto-da-fe and it also tears from its proper context a haunting phrase which still resounds in literary memory. The phrase is 'History to the defeated', and it occurs at the close of the poem, where Auden says: 'We are left alone with our day, and the time is short, and / History to the defeated / May say alas but cannot help or pardon.' He developed a special horror for this formulation, writing later that: 'To say this is to equate goodness with success. It would have been bad enough if I had ever held this wicked doctrine, but that I should have stated it simply because it sounded to me rhetorically effective is quite inexcusable.' Perhaps he was being too harsh on himself; few if any readers have interpreted the lines as a ruthless Hegelian equation of history (or 'History') with victory. Rather, the lines acquire their power from a somewhat remorseful recognition of necessity.
Or so Orwell may have come to believe. In concluding a review of a book by General Wavell in the critical month of December 1940, he wrote, of the preceding First World War:
The thick-necked cavalry generals remained at the top, but the lower-middle classes and the colonies came to the rescue. The thing is happening again, and probably on a much larger scale, but it is happening with desperate slowness and
History to the defeated
May say Alas! But cannot alter or pardon.
He quoted from memory as he often did, but seemed to approve the sentiment as rousing people to see that here was a way which could not be lost... Even when writing 'Inside the Whale' several years earlier, he had apologized to Auden for having described him previously as ' "a sort of gutless Kipling". As criticism this was quite unworthy, indeed it was merely a spiteful remark ... ' And, in preparing to take aim at 'Spain', he had taken care to observe that 'this poem is one of the few decent things that have been written about the Spanish war.' "
"He was very lazy. He hated polishing and making corrections. If I didn't like a poem, he threw it away and wrote another. If I liked one line, he would keep it and work it into a new poem. In this way whole poems were constructed which were simply anthologies of my favourite lines, entirely regardless of grammar or sense. This is the simple explanation of much of Auden's celebrated obscurity." -- friend Christopher Isherwood
"The poet who writes "free" verse is like Robinson Crusoe on his desert island: he must do all his cooking, laundry and darning for himself. In a few exceptional cases, this manly independence produces something original and impressive, but more often the result is squalor - dirty sheets on the unmade bed and empty bottles on the unswept floor." - W.H. Auden
"Auden: great poet or great representative poet? A poet or a 'classic of our prose'? He overhsadows the poets of his generation. He is Chaucer to the Gower of Betjeman and the Langland of MacNeice." -- Michael Schmidt
"In the [unpublished] poem, he [Auden] saw the blood trail which had dripped from Grendel after his arm and shoulder had been ripped off by Beowulf. The blood shone, was phosphorescen on the grass ... It was as if Auden ... had given imaginative place and 'reality' to something exploited for the Examination Schools, yet rooted in English origins." -- Geoffrey Grigson on what he called Auden's "Englishness"
"A pet has to woo, not only his own Muse but also Dame Philology, and, for the beginner, the latter is more important. As a rule, the sign that a beginner has a genuine original talent is that he is more interested in playing with words than in saying something original; his attitude is that of the old lady, quoted by E.M. Forster - 'How can I know what I think till I see what I say?' It is only later, when he has wooed and won Dame Philology, that he can give his entire devotion to his Muse." -- W.H. Auden
"Long before the parable poetry of postwar Europe, Auden arrived at a mode that was stricken with premonitions of an awful thing and was adequate to give expression to those premonitions by strictly poetic means. But this unified sensibility fissured when Auden was inevitably driven to extend himself beyond the transmission of intuited knowledge, beyond poetic indirection and implication, and began spelling out those intuitions in a more explicit, analytic and morally ratified rhetoric. In writing a poem like 'Spain', no matter how breathtaking its condensation of vistas or how decent its purpose, or a poem like 'A Summer Night,' no matter how Mozartian its verbal equivalent of agape, Auden broke with his solitude and his oddity. His responsibility towards the human family became intensely and commendably strong and the magnificently sane, meditative, judicial poems of the 1940s, 1950s and 1960s were the result. We might say that this bonus, which includes such an early masterpiece as 'Letter to Lord Byron' and such a later one as 'In Praise of Limestone,' represents an answer to the question posed in 'Orpheus'. That answer inclines to say that 'song' hopes most of all for 'the knowledge of life' and inclines away from the 'bewildered' quotient in the proferred alternative 'to be bewildered and happy'. To put it another way. Auden finally preferred life to be concentrated into something 'rich' rather than something 'strange', a preference which is understandable if we consider poetry's constant impulse to be all Prospero, harnessed to the rational project of settling mankind into a cosmic security. Yet the doom and omen which characterized the 'strange' poetry of the early 1950s, its bewildered and unsettling visions, brought native English poetry as near as it has ever been to the imaginative verge of the dreadful and offered an example of how insular experience and the universal shock suffered by mankind in the twentieth century could be sounded forth in the English language." -- Seamus Heaney, "Sounding Auden"
I am extremely curious about this new biography of Emily Dickinson (Lives Like Loaded Guns: Emily Dickinson and Her Family's Feuds, by Lyndall Gordon), that speculates (with good reason, apparently) that Dickinson was an epileptic. Wow. As always, Ted, I would be fascinated to hear your take on this. The book hasn't been published yet, but the review I link to gives a good idea of where the book goes.
The legend and myth of Emily Dickinson persists - it is one of the most perfect of literary legends, second only, perhaps to Shakespeare - because the biographical details are so slim. Well, not slim, in terms of Dickinson - but there is, indeed, a "smoking gun" there somewhere, which is one of the reasons why the seemingly dashed-off poems are so frightening when read in bulk. I tried to read a bunch of them, in succession, while on Block Island, and had to put it down. I can only deal with her in small doses. She is so dazzling. But it's almost like you can feel the presence of something else there, THE thing (it's like reading Shakespeare's sonnets, which can send any reader into a tailspin - it's all there, but what ISN'T there, what the hell is this guy saying??) Dickinson's poems satisfy, and yet deny satisfaction. There has GOT to be a secret there. Some motivating factor. Dickinson was tight-lipped about it, although she hints at things in letters. In a letter to Thomas Wentworth Higgins, from April 25, 1862, she writes:
I had a terror - since September - I could tell to none - and so I sing, as the Boy does by the Burying Ground - because I am afraid -
Glimpses, if you squint hard enough, what do you see?? In the same letter, she writes:
-- had no education when a Little Girl, I had a friend, who taught me Immortality - but venturing too near, himself - he never returned.
This stuff is awesome, this stuff is maddening.
It has never been satisfactorily explained what the hell happened to this woman. It has also never been successfully proven that any of that really MATTERS, in terms of the importance of the work. I happen to think (unlike some others) that biography CAN be important, in the shaping of an artist's work - although it is not THE most important thing. Or, to put another way, if it is true that Dickinson was an epileptic, it certainly doesn't explain her genius, it does not provide the wellspring of her talent - it's not the END of the conversation, is what I am trying to say, it is the beginning. The work, and its scope and mystery, remains. (I am reading a book on Shakespeare's plays right now, and "biographies" of Shakespeare are ... well. I mean, what the hell is the point. Just admit you are SPECULATING, please, because the data MAY support your thesis that Shakespeare was gay/straight/Catholic/what-have-you - but it also very well may support the opposing thesis. You can't really KNOW.) Additionally, focusing on biography, as a way of EXPLAINING the great and mysterious scope of Shakespeare's work, has a way of diminishing the work somehow. I get it, believe me, I get it. But if Shakespeare was, actually, a secret Catholic, it doesn't EXPLAIN the unsurpassable achievement of King Lear. It certainly would put Shakespeare's strange (at least compared to his contemporaries) attitude towards religion in a new light, it would provide a key that would unlock one other aspect of the secret code, and all that. It still wouldn't EXPLAIN Shakespeare himself.
Mysteries of this kind are fascinating and can keep my mind occupied for hours on end. It is one of the reasons why Possession is a book I love so damn much, because it addresses all of these esoteric academic questions in a potent and passionate way. In Possession, Maud Bailey says,
"You know, if you read the collected letters of any writer - if you read her biography - you will always get a sense that there's something missing, something biographers don't have access to, the real thing, the crucial thing, the thing that really mattered to the poet herself. There are always letters that were destroyed. The letters, usually."
In another example from that book, scholar Beatrice Nest describes her "baffling" feeling as she studied the diary of Ellen Ash (wife of famous Tennysonian poet Randolph Henry Ash). Nest has made Ellen Ash her life's work, she knows that diary better than anyone. Here she says:
"When I started on it, I thought, what a nice dull woman. And then I got the sense of things flittering and flickering behind all that solid - oh, I think of it as panelling. And then I got to think - I was being led on - to imagine the flittering flickering things - and that really it was all just as stolid and dull as anything. I thought I was making it all up, that she could have said something interesting - how shall I put it - intriguing - once in a while - but she absolutely wasn't going to. It could be an occupational hazard of editing a dull journal, couldn't it? Imagining that the author was deliberately baffling me?"
Of course, you recall in that book that Ellen Ash's secret is something she took to her grave, leaving no record of it. We see her, in the century past, burning letters, and knowing her diary would be read by posterity, she kept it simple, with no mention of the secret. The secret that is the key to so much. Yet, even with deliberate withholding, a close-reading of the work tells you that something is there, behind the dull domestic prose. What is missing? What is she withholding, and is she doing it deliberately? You come to realize that yes, Ellen Ash was not just the boring housewife of a famous poet who kept a dull journal full of recipes and mentions of canning peaches. She had her own story to tell, invisible through the mist of time, and it was her goal in life to deliberately withhold that information from future generations. I believe Emily did this as well, and I believe in her case she withholds not because she was shy and insecure and so terribly wounded. I believe she withheld because she wished to dominate, something akin to Holly Hunter's character in The Piano. That character had an ego the size the of the Siberian Steppe. I believe Dickinson did, too. Yet she refuses to elaborate, which, naturally, is her prerogative, and makes her all the more interesting. Dickinson's poems are the opposite of ladylike. They are bleak, stark, terrifying, and breathless in their cadences. She seems at the same time to be totally in control of herself, and yet totally out of control. She uses the form of the poem (the short lines, the dashes) as a container in which to pour her own substance. It's a mysterious process. I just thank God we have the poems, and that somebody had the foresight to save them!
Consider Byatt's description of how scholar Roland Michell feels after discovering the draft of a letter by Randolph Ash to fellow poet, Christabel LaMotte:
He could not identify the Fairy Topic, either, and this gave him a not uncommon sensation of his own huge ignorance, a grey mist, in which floated or could be discerned odd glimpses of solid objects, odd bits of glitter of domes or shadows of roofs in the gloom.
What would happen if a secret cache of letters was discovered that "explained" Emily Dickinson? Or at least explained what her secret heartache was, the one she refers to in a couple of letters, and why she decided to live in her room for decades on end? That would be a phenomenal discovery and would have to put her entire body of work into a new light. Not necessarily the RIGHT light, it is all, after all, just interpretation - but it sure would be fascinating. You can see why people devote their entire lives to such things. You can see why people have, quite literally, gone mad in their pursuit of Shakespeare the Man. There is something about the focus on biography that can serve as a distancing technique, and I suppose that that might be, in some unconscious way, deliberate. The work as a whole is so powerful, and it can make you feel so inadequate just trying to take it all in - it's like trying to look at an entire galaxy and understand what you are looking at, so all of the focus on biographical details can be a way of trying to contain Shakespeare. Keep him manageable. Genius is awesome, but it can make everyone feel inadequate, so if you can find something tangible to explain it, it makes everyone feel better about themselves and their lesser accomplishments. "He had syphilis - THAT'S why his late work was so brilliant!" The smoking gun theory lets us off the hook in some way. Shakespeare was a genius not because he had a direct line to the poetry of the spheres sent down from heaven, not because he had an uncanny and unprecedented freedom with language and what it could do, not because he could operate on multiple dizzying levels of meaning at the same time consistently - but because he had a corn on his foot that never healed, or some such nonsense. This is what the Shakespeare book I am devouring right now is all about (it is called The Shakespeare Wars: Clashing Scholars, Public Fiascoes, Palace Coups, by Ron Rosenbaum).
As I said, I do think biography is important. I want to speculate about it ALL. But there is a certain freedom in recognizing that you cannot really know. As Stephen Booth, the preeminent scholar of Shakespeare's sonnets wrote:
Shakespeare was almost certainly homosexual, bisexual, or heterosexual. The Sonnets provide no evidence on that matter.
Booth is so good because of his full (and rare) acceptance of not "either/or" ambiguity - but "both/and" ambiguity - something that is very difficult to grasp, especially for scholars who devote their lives wanting to KNOW.
I mean, please. If Shakespeare's secret diary was suddenly uncovered, and it was authenticated beyond a shadow of a doubt, and we could hear his voice, directly, telling us about his love life, his rehearsal processes, his thoughts before creating Hamlet, I probably would actually weep tears of joy and excitement and pre-order it in a frenzy. I would actually take a moment to thank God that I had lived long enough to see this day. I'm not even kidding.
It doesn't mean I can't enjoy Hamlet or The Tempest WITHOUT knowing these things. Of course not.
It's not either/or, people. It is both/and.
I have strayed far from my topic, mainly because the "Shakespeare Wars" is much on my mind right now. Fantastic book, I'll be writing more about it when I finish it.
It was all brought on by that fantastic review of the new biography of Emily Dickinson - the book sounds revisionist, yes (in a similar manner, I suppose, to Ron Chernow's biographies of Alexander Hamilton and John Rockefeller. There is an accepted narrative and interpretation about these people, which is regurgitated in different ways through the decades. He's in favor, he's out. Chernow tries to go deeper, tries to get at something universal - tries to embrace "both/and", as opposed to the more partisan "either/or", which will probably date a book pretty quick, even if it makes a big splash originally.) but unlike a lot of revisionist books, it also sounds well-researched and exhaustive. The author has dug up transcripts of trials involving land disputes, for example, which adds to her theory about some of the more unsavory aspects of Dickinson's family.
None of this, obviously, touches the poetry itself, which has stood on its own for over a century now. The mystery of her adds to the consciousness that one is in the presence of something great, something original, something that actually cannot be explained.
If Emily Dickinson were an epileptic (and sounds like the author makes a pretty good case for it), it is a fascinating aspect of her, and her confinement, that needs to be taken seriously - not only for its biographical interest, but how it can impact how we LOOK at the poetry, the filter we choose for it.
She still scares the Bejeezus out of me.

Shakespeare said pretty well everything and what he left out, James Joyce, with a judge from meself, put in. -- Brendan Behan
Brendan Behan, Irish playwright and terrorist, was born on this day, in Dublin, in 1923. He led a life of poverty, violence, controversy, and seemingly aimless wandering. He spent time in jail as a teenager, for being part of a plot to blow up a bridge (he had the bombs in his bag). Then he was involved in the attempted murder of two detectives, and was sentenced to 14 years in prison. While in prison, he (like so many other convicts) spent that enforced solitude writing. He wrote memoirs, confessions, poetry. He was still only 23 years old. His IRA activities ceased after that time, although he remained connected and friendly with most of its members (naturally - his whole family was involved). While in prison, he learned the Irish language. He drank like a fish. He had trouble getting published in Ireland (so he was in a grand continuum of other Irish writers who faced similar censorship issues). Behan was raised in a staunchly Republican family. His father was involved in the Easter uprising. Behan was Catholic (of course) - but not by name only. He was a true believer.
In the 1950s, he left Ireland (again, in a grand continuum of Irish writers who feel they must leave in order to be an artist) and moved to Paris. He wanted to be free, to write, to publish, to live life the way he wanted to live it.
I have a total irreverence for anything connected with society except that which makes the roads safer, the beer stronger, the food cheaper, and the old men and old women warmer in the winter and happier in the summer.
When we were in Ireland as a family, my dad took us to the writer's museum in Dublin. It's like going to the Vatican of artists. Nobody is more dominant in the written word than Irish writers. Who knows why that is, it doesn't even matter why. The museum is great. Even as a kid I appreciated it, especially because I grew up being surrounded by these old Irish authors, on my dad's bookshelves. I hadn't READ any of the books, but people like Flann O'Brien and Brendan Behan and Francis Stewart and WB Yeats were a part of the warp and weft of our family. We had a big picture of Brendan Behan in our living room - actually, we still do: it was a drawing of Behan's big bloated meaty face - and it was all done in one line, with the pen never lifting from the page. You can see it on the wall over the television in this photo here. I still remember our visit to the museum and seeing Behan's battered typewriter under glass (you can see images of it on the museum's link). I didn't even know who he was, as a writer - I just knew his books were all over our house, and I just knew that he was on our living room wall. So he was omnipresent. And even as a young teenager, I was into "objects", the same way I am now. Like seeing Alexander Hamilton's DESK at the New York Historical Society and literally having to walk away from the display because I didn't trust myself to not reach out and touch the damn thing. Behan's typewriter is one of the few things I remember from that trip to the museum. I think perhaps it is because I had a battered typewriter of my own - given to me on my 10th birthday - and it lasted me pretty much until I went to college. Old-fashioned, where I had to buy ink ribbons on spools, and where certain letters came out quirky, no matter what you did. I loved my typewriter, and I wish I still had it. Even just as a curio. Behan's typewriter looked kind of like mine, which was strange to me ... I was a teenager living in the early 1980s ... Behan seemed like a man from ancient Rome to me, yet his typewriter was like mine!
"I am a drinker with writing problems."
His cynicism about the Irish and Ireland borders on the psychotic at times (but if you know the Irish, you know that cynicism about themselves appears to be built in to the national character - part of why they are so charming and so much fun. They ARE serious, but they don't take themSELVES seriously.)
If it was raining soup, the Irish would go out with forks.
But he also said:
It's not that the Irish are cynical. It's rather that they have a wonderful lack of respect for everything and everybody.
In my opinion it is his cynicsm that makes his work so exciting to read. It palpitates on the page. His feelings and judgments tremble before you. He lives in his words. He is unforgiving. Yet also so so funny. A typically Irish combination. If you just have the unforgiving attitude, you'll be a rather humorless writer, a propagandist. But Behan was a riot.
Never throw stones at your mother,
You'll be sorry for it when she's dead,
Never throw stones at your mother,
Throw bricks at your father instead.
-- Brendan Behan, "The Hostage", 1958
It doesn't surprise me at all that he and Jackie Gleason were best friends. Of course they were. They both had the same dead-eyed response to absurdity, the same intolerance for stupidity and silliness, the same potential for explosive rage and explosive tragedy, and also the same huge humor.

They had become friends because of a notorious drunken appearance by Behan on a television talk show, where Gleason was also a guest. Behan was wasted, it was shocking to many - but Gleason saw a kindred spirit.
So happy birthday, to a wonderful Irish writer, a man I grew up with, a character in my childhood lexicon. He was not outside our family at all, he was inner circle, like Flann OBrien (one of his friends) and Yeats and Joyce and Synge. Behan was on our wall. He was one of us. As an adult, I finally read all of his plays and realized what the fuss was all about.
1954's The Quare Fellow, about his time in prison, ran for a short time in Dublin, and was a modest hit. The prison language is meaty, funny, and shows Behan's gift for satire. There's a Pinter-esque quality in some of it (strange as that may sound if you are familiar with Pinter) - in that a lot of times the events that happen OFFstage take on far more importance than what is happening ON. So that adds to the audience's feeling of imbalance, or wanting to peek around corners to get the whole story. "The Quare Fellow" is never seen in the play, although he is referenced constantly. Now enters Joan Littlefield and her Theatre Workshop into the picture. We really can thank her for the fact that Brendan Behan is so famous today. I am not sure that fame was a done deal for someone like Behan - in the same way that it was for someone like Joyce, who seems destined to be a singular star. Behan was more on the fringe, more of a scrabbler. But Littlefield, a theatre director and producer, took The Quare Fellow over to England where it was a smashing success. Eventually the play moved to Broadway, bringing Behan worldwide fame.
My dad wrote me a note about The Hostage (another one of Behan's plays):
Dearest: I saw the play done once in the 70s: it seemed like John Cleese [or some other Python] had adapted Frank O'Connor's Guests of the Nation for the stage. I believe that it owes most of its success to the director [Joan Littlefield?]. love, dad
My father's comment reflects the general consensus that seems to be out there: that it was Joan Littlefield who took Behan's work, wrestled it into a theatrical form, produced it so that its strengths could shine through, hiding its weaknesses - and that any collaboration that Behan had afterwards suffers in comparison. Behan owed much to Littlefield. Perhaps that is why they had such a testy relationship, notoriously difficult.

The Hostage was written in 1958. It was originally written in the Irish language - An Giall - and had a couple of small productions. Then he translated it into English, and once again it was directed and produced by Joan Littlefield.
Interestingly enough, my copy of the book, given to me by my father, was an early edition, 1959, and in the biographical sketch on the back it says: "Brendan Behan, the son of a house painter, left school at thirteen, and three years later served his first prison term for political reasons. As an IRA terrorist he has spent eight years of his life in various jails ..." The use of the word 'terrorist' really stood out for me. So often now, regardless of whether the person is actually a terrorist or not, the word is surrounded by little quotation marks. Or it's just not used at all. They're "insurgents", they're "rebels", they're "militants", "freedom fighters", etc. That little bio of Behan is quite a time-traveler, from an earlier decade when people weren't so hesitant to call a spade a spade.
Yeah, he was a terrorist. He blew shit up. He went to jail.
He also was a writer.
I appreciate the clarity and openness of that biographical sketch, and miss that kind of forthrightness (without the huge chip on its shoulder, too) today.
The Hostage was an enormous theatrical success in London, Paris, and New York. I love the play. It's laugh-out-loud funny at times, but also angry, pointedly political, sad ... with certain Keystone Cops slapstick elements. In my opinion, it should be played like a bat out of hell. You should only "pause" when Behan tells you to pause. Other than that, let it fly, keep the speed up, ba-dum-ching! Otherwise, the thing could be in danger of taking itself seriously. The points made are awesome and difficult and prickly - still relevant today ... but points such as those must not be underlined for the audience. God, I wish every director - for stage, TV, and film - would LEARN NOT TO UNDERLINE (with music, dialogue, closeups, repetitive language in the script to make sure we all "get it") what is already obvious.
Behan's work exists in a fiery world of high stakes, humor, and denial. If you pause, if you slow it down, its power unravels.
The Hostage takes place in a brothel in Dublin which is owned by a former IRA commander. The cast of characters is a motley array of whores and night-owls and other fringe-dwellers. It's a fast-moving theatrical work, very Irish - full of wise cracks, and jokes. It seems that NOTHING is taken seriously. But that's so very Irish. When the play opens, we eventually learn that the following day an 18 year old IRA member is to be hanged. He was accused of killing an Ulster policeman. This is on everybody's minds. Lots of talk and chatter about the IRA, and 1916, and martyrdom, and Ireland ... A young Cockney soldier, Leslie Williams, is held hostage in the brothel, in the hopes that somehow this might stave off the execution ... When the IRA member is hanged the following day, the British police eventually attack the brothel, and Leslie ends up getting killed by gunfire.
The Hostage was Behan's last major success.
Critic Kenneth Tynan said:
While other writers horde words like misers, Behan sends them out on a spree, ribald, flushed, and spoiling for a fight.
Here is an excerpt from The Hostage - a play that is well worth looking into if you are not familiar with it. Don't forget, despite the IRA themes and the title: this is a comedy.
Notice in the excerpt below that a "pause" is written into the script. And, hysterically, the Officer shouts "SILENCE!" after the pause. If you're in a production that is floppy, in terms of cue pickups, with pauses left and right, people stopping to think, or ponder - then that moment would be lost, the timing would not be right, you need to be able to "hear" the joke that Behan has written into the thing. It needs to be rat-a-tat dialogue all along, no pauses between lines, so then that sudden "Pause" will really have an effect ... and the fact that the Officer shouts "Silence" after the ONE pause in the script so far - is hysterical, and says worlds about that character. (This, too, is very Pinter-esque. In terms of "Pinter's pauses" - follow them like you would a musical score. Do not add more. Do not subtract any. Just DO WHAT HE SAYS ... and almost by default, the script will take on an ominous almost unbearably tense feeling. Example here of what a Pinter script looks like. Those "silences" are deliberate, written into the thing by Pinter. This is not always the case with such "directorial" additions to a script - sometimes they are added from production notes, and are not BY the playwright. But in Pinter's case, he wrote those "silences" in. They are much a part of the dialogue as the things actually spoken. It's not up to the actor to muck with that stuff, to decide when to pause - at least not with Pinter. With Pinter, you do what he says. Believe me, it will help.)
So happy birthday to Brendan Behan.
You make me think, basically, of my whole damn life. You were given to me, by my father, like so much else. It was through osmosis, rather than anything more deliberate.
Wherever I look, you are there.
EXCERPT FROM The Hostage, by Brendan Behan.
OFFICER: Now your rent books, please, or a list of the tenants.
PAT. I can give you that easy. There's Bobo, Ropeen, Colette, the Mouse, Pigseye, Mulleady, Princess Grace, Rio Rita, Meg, the new girl, and myself.
OFFICER. [PAT fetches his notebook] I'll tell you the truth, if it was my doings there'd be no such thing as us coming here. I'd have nothing to do with the place, and the bad reputation it has all over the city.
PAT. Isn't it good enough for your prisoner?
OFFICER. It's not good enough for the Irish Republican Army.
PAT. Isn't it now?
OFFICER. Patrick Pearse said "To serve a cause which is splendid and holy, men must themselves be splendid and holy."
PAT. Are you splendid, or just holy? Haven't I seen you somewhere before? It couldn't be you that was after coming here one Saturday night ...
OFFICER. It could not.
PAT. It could have been your brother, for he was the spitting image of you.
OFFICER. If any of us were caught here now or at any time, it's shamed before the world we'd be. Still, I see their reasons for choosing it too.
PAT. The place is so hot, it's cold.
OFFICERE. The police wouldn't believe we'd touch it.
PAT. If we're all caught here, it's not the opinion of the world or the police will be upsetting us, but the opinion of the Military Court. But then I suppose it's all the same to you; you'll be a hero, will you not?
OFFICER. I hope that I could never betray my trust.
PAT. Ah yes, of course, you've not yet been in Mountjoy or the Curragh glasshouse.
OFFICER. I have not.
PAT. That's easily seen in you.
OFFICER. I assure you, my friend, I'm not afraid of Redcaps.
PAT. Take it from me, they're not the worst [to audience] though they're bastards anywhere and everywhere. No, your real trouble when you go to prison as a patriot, do you know what it will be?
OFFICER. The loss of liberty.
PAT. No, the other Irish patriots, in along with you. Which branch of the IRA are you in?
OFFICER. There is only one branch of the Irish Republican Army.
PAT. I was in the IRA in 1916, and in 1925 H.Q. sent me from Dublin to the County Kerry because the agricultural labourers were after taking over five thousand acres of an estate from Lord Trales. They had it all divided very nice and fair among themselves, and were ploughing and planting in great style. G.H.Q. gave orders that they were to get off the land, that the social question would be settled when we got the thirty-county Republic. The Kerrymen said they weren't greedy like. They didn't want the whole thirty-two counties to begin with, and their five thousand acres would do them for a start.
OFFICER. Those men were wrong on the social question.
PAT. Faith and I don't think it was questions they were interested in, at all, but answers. Anyway I agreed with them, and stopped there for six months training the local unit to take on the IRA, the Free State Army, aye, or the British Navy if it had come to it.
OFFICER. That was mutiny.
PAT. I know. When I came back to Dublin, I was court-martialled in my absence and sentenced to death in my absence, so I said they could shoot me in my absence.
Pause.
OFFICER. Silence!
PAT. Sir!
OFFICER. i was sent here to do certain business. I would like to conclude that business.
PAT. Let us proceed, shall we, sir? When may we expect the prisoner?
OFFICER. Today.
PAT. What time?
OFFICER. Between nine and twelve.
PAT. Where is he now?
OFFICER. We haven't got him yet.
PAT. You haven't got a prisoner? Are you going down to Woolworths to buy one then?
OFFICER. I have no business telling you any more than has already been communicated to you.
PAT. Sure, I know that.
OFFICER. The arrangements are made for his reception. I will be here.
PAT. Well, the usual terms, rent in advance, please.
OFFICER. Is it looking for money you are?
PAT. What else? We're not a charity. Rent in advance.
OFFICER. I might have known what to expect. I know your reputation.
PAT. How did you hear of our little convent?
OFFICER. I do social work for the St. Vincent de Paul Society.
PAT. I always thought they were all ex-policement. In the old days we wouldn't go near them.
OFFICER. In the old days there were Communists in the IRA.
PAT. There were, faith, and plenty of them. What of it?
OFFICER. The man that is most loyal to his faith is the one that will prove most loyal to the cause.
PAT. Have you your initials mixed up? Is it the FBI or the IRA that you are in?
OFFICER. If I didn't know that you were out in 1916 I'd think you were highly suspect.
PAT. Sir?
OFFICER. Well, at least you can't be an informer.
PAT. Ah, you're a shocking decent person. Could you give me a testimonial I could use in my election address if I wanted to get into the coroporation? The rent, please!
It's the birthday of a beloved American author - Laura Ingalls Wilder. She was born on February 7, 1867.

Her books are so much a part of my childhood that they don't even feel like books to me. I was 7, 8, 9 when I read them, and I can barely say I read them. I LIVED them. And the fact that at the same time that I was LIVING these books - a wonderful television series based on these books came on helped me immerse myself in that bygone age even further. Despite its bizarre and explosive ending, the series captured some of the simplicity and beauty in those books. Laura, Mary, Nellie Olson - all of these people were just woven into my childhood. We used them as reference points as kids. Whispering to each other about a classmate: "She's such a Nellie Olson". Even now, that particular description would work for me, in terms of telling me everything I needed to know about a person.
Here's a wonderful image of the kind of pioneer cabin that the Ingalls family probably lived in:

Not only do her books work as great stories in and of themselves, but they portray the pioneer experience in such an immediate and first-hand way that it came to life for future generations. There I was, frolicking in the dirt of my backyard in Rhode Island, but because I had read those books I knew about the great plains, and covered wagons, and how medicine was ... er ... different back then ... and what it was like to have NO money so that one Christmas they each got a cookie, and a shiny penny and a peppermint candy for presents. And the girls were THRILLED about these presents, which seemed insane to me, but the way the book was written I went into THEIR world, rather than expecting them to reflect mine. Laura Ingalls Wilder described that one blizzardy Christmas so well, and the beauty of those simple hand-made gifts - that I, as a child, really learned something about the world. I remember thinking, (I must have been 8 years old): "They only got a candy-cane and a cookie? And a PENNY??? But ... how could they have been happy with that????" But the WAY she wrote it made it clear that the entire thing was magical and exciting ... as the snow pounded against the log cabin windows. And so then I realized: "Wait. This is Christmas. This is their Christmas. They were happy. They were happy." And I learned a wee lesson about ... oh ... materialism, and gratitude, and stuff like that. I learned that my world was not the only world. That my time was not the only time. Worlds of imagination opened up in my head.
Their lives were SO different from mine - and yet human beings themselves don't change, and I found so much to relate to in those books. Getting into trouble, learning tough lessons about life, dealing with snotty school girls, the excitement of setting out on a journey with your family ... these were all things I fully recognized from my own life.
Laura Ingalls Wilder was encouraged by her daughter (who was also a writer) to write down stories of her childhood. To get a glimpse of just how intense that relationship was, check out this fascinating New Yorker article about Rose Wilder. Quite a family psychodrama there, and it seems far far removed from the fresh windy air and wide open spaces that make up the landscape and world of the Little House books. By the time, Laura Ingalls Wilder started publishing, the entire world she described had pretty much disappeared. In one person's lifetime. Her first book Little House in the Big Woods was published in 1930. Lindbergh had flown across the ocean. There were railroads criss-crossing the country. Autmobiles. Telephones. Laura Ingalls Wilder straddled an enormous generational divide. Her books are the bridge.
My favorite of the books were By the Shores of Silver Lake and also The Long Winter. I believe The Long Winter is her best book.
I'll close with an excerpt from Little House in the Big Woods that brings a lump to my throat, and kind of captures the simple home-spun magic in these books:
When the fiddle had stopped singing Laura called out softly, "What are days of auld lang syne, Pa?""They are the days of a long time ago, Laura," Pa said. "Go to sleep, now."
But Laura lay awake a little while, listening to Pa's fiddle softly playing and to the lonely sound of the wind in the Big Woods.
She was glad that the cosy house, and Pa and Ma and the firelight and the music, were now. They could not be forgotten, she thought, because now is now. It can never be a long time ago.
Happy birthday to an American treasure. And thank you for making me see, as a young child, that things like log cabins and Pa and Ma and firelight "could not be forgotten" ... thank you for making that "long time ago" come to life for me, a young East Coast girl at the tail-end of the 20th century.
Playwright, poet, prodigy, agent in Her Majesty's secret service: the incomparable Christopher Marlowe was born on this day.

(this 1585 portrait is widely thought to be of Marlowe)
I love Christopher Marlowe. He died so young. It was a turbulent time, for England certainly, but for the theatrical world, in particular. Marlowe was accused of putting atheistic ideas into his plays, and was on the verge of being arrested, when he was killed. There was also the little matter of Shakespeare to deal with. Those two were contemporaries. How did they inform and perhaps copy one another? Evidence shows that it was Shakespeare who did most of the copying, which is no surprise, since his plots and stories were always taken from other sources, with one or two notable exceptions. Scholars have studied this literary symbiosis for years, and it's all juicy awesome stuff. The answer seems less interesting than the inquiry itself. Shakespeare is rather dim, in terms of what we know about his life. There's very little evidence left behind. (Besides the plays, I mean.) But Marlowe emerges with more clarity - there's just more that is known about his actual life. The revelation that he was, indeed, a spy, adds definite luster to an already fascinating young man. And then that he would die, in a sword-scuffle over who was going to pick up the check ... there's a lot here to keep conspiracy theorists happy for centuries. It certainly drives the scholarship forward.
But his plays! His language! His influence is so vast as to be nearly invisible now. There are times when people quote Marlowe without realizing that it is he whom they are quoting. For example:
This is from Doctor Faustus - a famous excerpt:.
The Face that Launched a Thousand Ships
Was this the face that launched a thousand ships?
And burnt the topless towers of Ilium?
Sweet Helen, make me immortal with a kiss:
Her lips suck forth my soul, see where it flies:
And all is dross that is not Helena:
I will be Paris, and for love of thee,
Instead of Troy shall Wertenberg be sack'd,
And I will combat with weak Menelaus,
And wear thy colours on my plumed crest:
Yea I will wound Achillis in the heel,
And then return to Helen for a kiss.
O thou art fairer than the evening air,
Clad in the beauty of a thousand stars,
Brighter art thou than flaming Jupiter,
When he appear'd to hapless Semele,
More lovely than the monarch of the sky
In wanton Arethusa's azur'd arms,
And none but thou shalt be my paramour.
SOME QUOTES ON MARLOWE:
"No leaf he wrote on but was like a burning glass to set on fire all his readers." -- Thomas Nashe, a friend of Marlowe's
"His father lacked cash, always a grave trouble for the family. The chief cause of this lay not in John's imprudence, but in the fact that payments to shoemakers were often made by either bond or book, which meant that a cobbler often waited for cash while his tanning needs made matters worse. Still, if cash and credit's mysteries intrigued Christopher, his father's shop did not. In a juvenile play - which may be his apprentice work if it dates from about 1580 - the script refers, somewhat condescendingly, to Kent and cobblers. Certainly, throughout his writing career, Marlowe avoided his father's trade, and in this he was unlike the poet of Stratford. Whereas Shakespeare, as the son of a Midlands glover and processor of leather, readily alludes to a glover's implements or to animal skins, Marlowe, in his known work, never uses words such as shoe, shoemaker, sew, or sole (as for a shoe), but distances himself from his father's concerns. At various times, when he refers to leather, or boots, or even when he uses the word sell, the allusions are oddly repulsive:
Covetousness: begotten of an old Churl in a leather bag (Doctor Faustus (1616)
wormeaten leathern targets (His version of Lucan's Pharsalia)
As if he had meant to clean my Boots with his lips (The Jew of Malta)
our boots which lie foul upon our hands (Doctor Faustus, (1604)
You will not sell it [a sacred crown], would you? (Tamburlaine, Part One)
"Such lines may suggest hatred not of the cobbler but of his work, and we can be sure that he never envied John Marlowe's slavery." -- Park Honan, Christopher Marlowe: Poet & Spy
"The place and the value of Christopher Marlowe as a leader among English poets it would be almost impossible for historical criticism to over-estimate. To none of them all, perhaps, have so many of the greatest among them been so deeply and so directly indebted. Nor was ever any great writer's influence upon his fellows more utterly and unmixedly an influence for good. He first, and he alone, guided Shakespeare into the right way of work; his music, in which there is no echo of any man's before him, found its own echo in the more prolonged but hardly more exalted harmony of Milton's. He is the greatest discoverer, the most daring and inspired pioneer, in all our poetic literature. Before him there was neither genuine blank verse nor a genuine tragedy in our language. After his arrival the way was prepared, the paths were made straight, for Shakespeare. " -- Algernon Charles Swinburne
"Christopher Marlowe's life was short, sharp and irresistible. His fame rests not only on six violently glittering plays written in his 20s but also on the tantalizing story that may be considered his masterpiece, for Marlowe inhabited his time like a player strutting upon an invisible stage. His life was his most remarkable piece of theater. Everyone imitated Marlowe. His first play, Tamburlaine, was staged when he was 23, and its success can most readily be gauged by its imitators. As David Riggs notes in his new biography, The World of Christopher Marlowe, within the next couple of years three new plays were staged that were more or less direct copies of Marlowe's original, while Shakespeare wrote his early Henry VI plays under the influence of Marlowe's style. A decade later, as the church authorities burned copies of Marlowe's semipornographic love poems in the streets, Shakespeare again returned to imitating his predecessor in As You Like It. Marlowe's contemporaries regarded him with a mixture of awe and fear." -- Daniel Swift in "The Nation"
"In common with the greatest - Marlowe, Webster, Tourner, and Shakespeare - they had a quality of sensuous thought, or of thinking through the senses, or of the senses thinking, of which the exact formular remains to be defined." -- T.S. Eliot on the Elizabethan-Jacobean poets
"What an example for our distracted poetry, which so often now strikes at the absolute and achieves the commonplace! These poets [George Chapman and Christopher Marlowe] lived life from the ground upwards." -- Edgell Rickword, 1924
"The unity of tone and purpose in Doctor Faustus is not unrelieved by change of manner and variety of incident. The comic scenes, written evidently with as little of labour as of relish, are for the most part scarcely more than transcripts, thrown into the form of dialogue, from a popular prose History of Dr Faustus, and therefore should be set down as little to the discredit as to the credit of the poet. Few masterpieces of any age in any language can stand beside this tragic poem - it has hardly the structure of a play - for the qualities of terror and splendour, for intensity of purpose and sublimity of note. In the vision of Helen, for example, the intense perception of loveliness gives actual sublimity to the sweetness and radiance of mere beauty in the passionate and spontaneous selection of words the most choice and perfect; and in like manner the sublimity of simplicity in Marlowe's conception and expression of the agonies endured by Faustus under the immediate imminence of his doom gives the highest note of beauty, the quality of absolute fitness and propriety, to the sheer straightforwardness of speech in which his agonizing horror finds vent ever more and more terrible from the first to the last equally beautiful and fearful verse of that tremendous monologue which has no parallel in all the range of tragedy." -- Algernon Charles Swinburne
"His narrator [in Hero and Leander] is abrupt, devil-may-care, often unreliable, but brilliant enough to be worth listening to, even though he might be asking us to buy him another drink. One thinks of Chaucer's Canterbury-bound raconteurs, but a much closer parallel exists in works such as T.S. Eliot's 'The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock', or again in monologues by Frost, Lowell, or Tony Harrison. In other words, Marlowe foreshadows the method of the dramatic and psychological monologue. What the narrator says is slanted, but one is encouraged to see through the aberrant report to the real state of psyches, and beyond that to symbols of the human condition. The poem takes a giant step ahead in form, and the form itself partly arises from Marlowe's need to conceal his feelings; he never permits himself, here or elsewhere, a direct viewpoint of his own. He uses hyperbolic images to distance sexual love, but then explores what might be his, or anyone's initial experience of it. If the action is cruel, its shame and pain are offset by fumbling tenderness. Nor can we blame the tale-teller for being perverse of inconsistent. Typically, the narrator digresses in an anecdote about Mercury, loses the story's thread or its relation to the love-story, and so becomes irrelevant, only to enthral in all that he says. His voice has so strong a movement that nothing impedes it, and the poem's beauty begins to look inevitable, though no more consciously planned than nature's forms may be. Nothing is overtly patterned in Hero except for the stepping stones of its couplet rhymes. One result is that it becomes a laboratory of the imagination, even a discourse about writing, and a work so free of correctness that it exhibits at every turn the primacy of creativity itself. Marlowe's major poem has been admired for centuries, though never more avidly than by the Victorians. It's 'riot of passion and of delight in the beauty of colour and form,' wrote George Saintsbury, 'has never been approached by any writer'. For Havelock Ellis, the poem was 'the brightest flower of the English Renaissance,' and Swinburne, with Hero and Leander doubtless in mind, called its poet 'alone the true Apollo of our dawn.' Such praise had been foreshadowed in lines which Sir Francis Verney sent to Robert Cecil, then earl of Salisbury, only a few years after Hero was published. Verney hails Marlowe as 'the splendour of our worthless time', as if no other Renaissance poet could touch him." -- Park Honan - on Marlowe's poem "Hero and Leander" in Christopher Marlowe: Poet & Spy
"He took his BA in 1584, his MA three years later, by which time he had probably completed Tamburlaine. He was the first of the university wits to employ blank verse. It's generally thought that most if not all of his small surviving body of nondramatic verse - Hero and Leander, 'The Passionate Shepherd', and the Ovid and Lucan translations - were written in his university years, the fruit of youth and relative leisure. The six years that elapsed between his taking his MA and his shadowy death - possibly as a result of drink, or low political intrigue, or a romantic entanglement with a rough character 'fitter to be a pimp, than an ingenious amoretto', or perhaps a tussle over the bill ('le recknynge') - at the hand of Ingram Frisar in a Deptford tavern on 30 May 1593 were busy ones. He wrote plays, was attacked for atheism, was associated (if it existed) with Raleigh's 'School of Night,' and lodged with Thomas Kyd (author of The Spanish Tragedy), who later brought charges of blasphemy against him. These he had to answer before the Privy Council in 1593, the very council that secretly employed him to spy on English Catholics on the Continent. He achieved much in a short life." -- Michael Schmidt, Lives of the Poets
"If one takes The Jew of Malta not as a tragedy, or as a 'tragedy of blood,' but as a farce, the concluding act becomes intelligible; and if we attend with a careful ear to the versification, we find that Marlowe develops a tone to suit this farce, and even perhaps that this tone is his most powerful and mature tone." -- T.S. Eliot
"He was no timorous servile flatterer of the commonwealth wherein he lived. His tongue and his invention were foreborn; what they thought, they would confidently utter. Princes he spared not, that in the least point transgressed." -- Thomas Nashe
"In Marlowe's superb verse there is very little to indicate that the writer had ever encountered any human beings." -- James Branch Cabell
"Marlowe painted gigantic ambitions, desires for impossible things, longings for a beauty beyond earthly conception, and sovereigns destroyed by the very powers which had raised them to their thrones. Tamburlaine, Faust, Barabbas are the personifications of arrogance, ambition and greed. There is sometimes a touch of the extravagant or bombastic, or even of the puerile in his plays, for he had no sense of humor; nor had he the ability to portray a woman. He wrote no drama on the subject of love. Furthermore, his world is not altogether our world, but a remote field of the imagination." -- Martha Fletcher Bellinger, 1927
"Marlowe's Doctor Faustus, like Goethe's Faust, finds himself before the specter of Helen (the idea that Helen of Troy was a ghost or apparition is already present in the ancients) and says to her, 'Sweet Helen, make me immortal with a kiss.' And then, 'O thou art fairer than the evening air clad in the beauty of a thousand stars.' He does not say 'evening sky,' but 'evening air.' All of Copernican space is present in that word air, the infinite space that was one of the revelations of the Renaissance, the space in which we still believe, despite Einstein, that space that came to supplant the Ptolomaic system which presides over Dante's triple comedy." -- Jorge Luis Borges
"And so it befell, in that affray, that the said Ingram, in the defence of his life, with the dagger aforesaid of the value of twelve pence, gave the said Christopher a mortal wound above his right eye." -- Coroner's inquest, 1593
I'm armed with more than complete steel,
The justice of my quarrel.
Christopher Marlowe, Lust's Dominion. Act iii. Sc. 4.
"He came to London to seek his fortune . . . a boy in years, a man in genius, a god in ambition. Who knows to what heights he might have risen but for his untimely end?" -- Swinburne
One of Marlowe's plays was Tamburlaine, the brutal story of one of the many conquerors of Central Asia (known as Timur, Tamerland, Timurlane, etc.). One of those who galloped in, sacked everything, and then, strangely, built things back up again. Coliin Thubron, in his wonderful The Lost Heart of Asia describes the conundrum of Timur (conqueror, artisan, WTF?):
Tamerlane, the Earth-Shaker, was the last, and perhaps most awesome, of these world predators. Born in 1336 fifty miles south of Samarkand, he was the son of a petty chief in a settled Mongol clan. He acquired th ename "Timur-i-Leng" or "Timur the Lame" after arrows maimed his right leg and arm, and passed as Tamerlane into the fearful imagination of the Weset. By his early thirties, after years of fighting over the splintered heritage of Genghiz Khan, he had become lord of Mavarannah, the "land Beyond the River", with his capital at Samarkand, and had turned his cold eyes to the conquest of the world.From the accounts that are left of him, he emerges not only as the culmination of his pitiless forerunners, but as the distant ancestor of the art-loving Moghals of India. Over the terrified servants and awed ambassadors at his court, his eyes seemed to burn without brilliance, and never winced with either humour or sadness. But a passion for practical truth fed his unlettered intelligence. He planned his campaigns in scrupulous detail, and unlike Genghiz Khan he led them in person. He clothed his every move with the sanctions of the Islamic faith, but astrology and omens, shamanism and public prayers, were all invoked to serve his needs. An angel, it was rumoured, told him men's hidden thoughts. Yet he assaulted Moslems as violently as he did Christians and Hindus. Perhaps he confused himself with God.
No flicker of compassion marred his progress. His butchery surpassed that of any before him. The towers and pyramids of skulls he left behind -- ninety thousand in the ruins of Baghdad alone -- were calculated warnings. After overrunning Persia and despoiling the Caucasus, he hacked back the remnants of the Golden Horde to Moscow, then launched a precipitate attack on India, winching his horses over the snowbound ravines of the Hindu Kush, where 20,000 Mongols froze to death. On the Ganges plain before Delhi, the Indian sultan's squadrons of mailed elephants, their tusks lashed with poisoned blades, sent a momentary tremor through the Mongol ranks; but the great beasts were routed, and the city and all its inhabitants levelled with the earth. A year later the Mongols were wending back over the mountains, leading 10,000 pack-mules sagging with gold and jewels. They left behind a land which would not recover for a century, and five million Indian dead.
Now Tamerland turned his attention west again. Baghdad, Aleppo, Damascus fell. In 1402, on the field of Ankara, at the summit of his pwoer, he decimated the army of the Ottoman sultan Beyazid, and inadvertently delayed the fall of Constantinople by another half century.
Between these monotonous acts of devastation, the conqueror returned to the Samarkand he cherished. At his direction a procession of captured scholars, theologians, musicans and craftsmen arrived in the capital with their books and tools and families -- so many that they were forced to inhabit caves and orchards in the suburbs. Under their hands the mud city bloomed into faience life. Architects, painters and calligraphers from Persia; Syrian silk-weavers, armourers and glass-blowers; Indian jewellers and workers in stucco and metal; gunsmiths and artillery engineers from asia Minor: all labored to raise titanic mosques and academies, arsenals, libraries, vaulted and fountained bazaars, even an observatory and a menagerie. The captured elephants lugged into place the marble of Tabriz and the Caucausus, while rival emirs -- sometimes Tamerlane himself -- drove on the work with the parvenu impatience of shepherd-princes. The whole city, it seems, was to be an act of imperial power. Villages were built around it named Cairo, Baghdad, Shiraz or Damascus (a ghostly Paris survives) in token of their insignificance. It was the "Mirror of the World," and the premier city of Asia.
Tamerlane himself confounds simple assessment. He kept a private art collection, whose exquisitely illuminated manuscripts he loved but could not read. His speech, it seems, was puritan in its decorum. He was an ingenious and addicted chess-player, who elaborated the game by doubling its pieces -- with two giraffes, two war-engines, a vizier and others -- over a board of 110 squares. A craving for knowledge plunged him into hard, questing debates with scholars and scientists, whom he took with him even on campaign, and his quick grasp and powerful memory gave him a working knowledge of history, medicine, mathematics, and astronomy.
Yet at heart he was a nomad. He moved between summer and winter pastures with his whole court and horde. Even at Samarkand he usually pavilioned in the outskirts, or in one of the sixteen gardens he spread round the city: watered parks with ringing names. Each garden was different. In one stood a porcelain Chinese palace; another glowed with the saga of his reign in lifelike frescoes, all long vanished; yet another was so vast that when a workman lost his horse there it grazed unfound for six months.
Marlowe, age 22, how is that possible??, took on this historical figure as his launching-off point. Marlowe wouldn't know how to "start small" if he tried.
Excerpt from Tamburlaine, by Christopher Marlowe.
Enter Tamburlaine, Techelles, Theridamas, Usumcasane, Zenocrate, Anippe, two Moores drawing Bajazeth in a cage, and Zabina following him.
TAMBURLAINE
Bring out my footstool.
[They take BAJAZETH out of the cage.]
BAJAZETH
Ye holy priests of heavenly Mahomet,
That, sacrificing, slice and cut your flesh,
Staining his altars with your purple blood,
Make heaven to frown, and every fixed star
To suck up poison from the moorish fens,
And pour it in this glorious tyrant's throat!
TAMBURLAINE
The chiefest god, first mover of that sphere
Enchas'd with thousands ever-shining lamps,
Will sooner burn the glorious frame of heaven
Than it should so conspire my overthrow.
But, villain, thou that wishest this to me,
Fall prostrate on the low disdainful earth,
And be the footstool of great Tamburlaine,
That I may rise into my royal throne.
BAJAZETH
First shalt thou rip my bowels with thy sword,
And sacrifice my heart to death and hell,
Before I yield to such a slavery.
TAMBURLAINE
Base villain, vassal, slave to Tamburlaine,
Unworthy to embrace or touch the ground
That bears the honour of my royal weight;
Stoop, villain, stoop! stoop; for so he bids
That may command thee piecemeal to be torn,
Or scatter'd like the lofty cedar-trees
Struck with the voice of thundering Jupiter.
BAJAZETH
Then, as I look down to the damned fiends,
Fiends, look on me! and thou, dread god of hell,
With ebon sceptre strike this hateful earth,
And make it swallow both of us at once!
[TAMBURLAINE gets up on him into his chair.]
TAMBURLAINE
Now clear the triple region of the air,
And let the Majesty of Heaven behold
Their scourge and terror tread on emperors.
Smile, stars that reign'd at my nativity,
And dim the brightness of your neighbour lamps;
Disdain to borrow light of Cynthia!
For I, the chiefest lamp of all the earth,
First rising in the east with mild aspect,
But fixed now in the meridian line,
Will send up fire to your turning spheres,
And cause the sun to borrow light of you.
My sword struck fire from his coat of steel,
Even in Bithynia, when I took this Turk;
As when a fiery exhalation,
Wrapt in the bowels of a freezing cloud,
Fighting for passage, make[s] the welkin crack,
And casts a flash of lightning to the earth:
But, ere I march to wealthy Persia,
Or leave Damascus and th' Egyptian fields,
As was the fame of Clymene's brain-sick son
That almost brent the axle-tree of heaven,
So shall our swords, our lances, and our shot
Fill all the air with fiery meteors;
Then, when the sky shall wax as red as blood,
It shall be said I made it red myself,
To make me think of naught but blood and war.
A poor unsuspecting clergyman (a Dr. Grosart) wrote to Thomas Hardy and asked his opinion on how the horrors of life could be reconciled with God's goodness. He obviously expected a sympathetic ear, or at least a concession to his point of view that these things COULD be reconciled. Hardy replied, in the chilly third person:
Mr. Hardy regrets that he is unable to offer any hypothesis which would reconcile the existence of such evils as Dr. Grosart describes with the idea of omnipotent goodness. Perhaps Dr. Grosart might be helped to a provisional view of the universe by the recently published Life of Darwin and the works of Herbert Spencer and other agnostics.
Ahhhh. It satisfies me more with each and every reading.
Walt Whitman, in his preface to Leaves of Grass:
This is what you shall do: Love the earth and sun and the animals, despise riches, give alms to every one that asks, stand up for the stupid and crazy, devote your income and labor to others, hate tyrants, argue not concerning God, have patience and indulgence towards the people, take off your hat to nothing known or unknown to any man or number of men, go freely with powerful uneducated persons and with the young and with th emothers of families, read these leaves in the open air every season of every year of your life, reexamine all you have been told at school or church or in any book, dismiss whatever insults your own soul, and your very flesh shall be a great poem and have the richest fluency not only in its words but in the silent lines of its lips and face and between the lashes of your eyes and in every motion and joint of your body.
Letter from Emily Dickinson to her editor, Thomas Wentworth Higginson, July, 1862. The letter is signed "Your Scholar":
Will you tell me my fault, frankly, as to yourself, for I had rather wince, than die. Men do not call the surgeon, to commend—the Bone, but to set it, Sir, and fracture within, is more critical. And for this, Preceptor, I shall bring you—Obedience—the Blossom from my Garden, and every gratitude I know. Perhaps you smile at me. I could not stop for that—My Business is Circumference—An ignorance, not of Customs, but if caught with the Dawn—or the Sunset see me—Myself the only Kangaroo among the Beauty, Sir, if you please, it afflicts me, and I thought that instruction would take it away.
So I knew that the image of the wind blowing back the waves' foam like horses' manes was taken from somewhere - but it was such an a propos image - there really is no other way to say it or describe it - that I went with it anyway. Of course then I had to go track it down which was not hard since I've been on a TS Eliot kick. From "The Love Song of Alfred J. Prufrock":
I have heard the mermaids singing, each to each.
I do not think that they will sing to me.
I have seen them riding seaward on the waves
Combing the white hair of the waves blown back
When the wind blows the water white and black.
Perfection! And it got me to thinking about literature and narrative - and what comes first? If you read widely and deeply, your brain is full of references, fragments, contexts, interpretations - handed down from others. Part of this is awesome, part of it is not - especially if you are trying to create something yourself (there is a reason why people like William Carlos Williams and Hart Crane said that their main struggle as artists were to AVOID the influence of TS Eliot, no easy task) ... but it is an interesting thing in life, and one that gives me a lot of pleasure, and makes me happy and grateful that I am an educated person. Educated in the humanities, yes, so I have all this stuff to call upon in my brain - but also self-educated, self-taught, following my own whims .... There are times when I need to track the images down. One must not steal. But then something comes along - like wind being blown backward off the waves - and you realize that someone has already nailed it down, and so perfectly, that there is nothing to do but parrot them, because it feels like they said it for you. They handed you the image, knowing that you have noticed such things too, and said, "Here. Isn't this just what it is like?"
A letter from Maud Gonne to WB Yeats, in December 1908. Yeats had come to visit Gonne where she was living in Paris. After years and years of friendship (not to mention what they called their "spiritual marriage"), it is believed that the two finally consummated their long unrequited affair on this particular visit. Yeats had not yet married at this point, but the later Mrs. Yeats (a formidable woman in her own right) believes as well that this was an important visit for the two old friends, and that something sexual had finally occurred. Gonne had already had two children out of wedlock with a French revolutionary (one child died when he was only one years old), and then had married (disastrously) to another revolutionary, an Irish one this time, James MacBride. The marriage didn't even last a year, although a child did come out of it (Sean - or Seghan, as it was spelled). Seghan ended up joining the IRA as a young man in the wake of the Easter Rising and living a life on the run. No surprise.
Regardless: Through the tempest of Gonne's personal life (and she always found the personal life to be annoying - it needed to come second to her life as an activist and politician), Yeats had remained loyal, although he did have a couple of affairs (mainly to let off the sexual tension he felt by loving the distant Gonne for so long). They are quite open about all of this in their letters to one another. Gonne cautioned him against marriage (she wasn't really "for" it in general), but she also cautioned him to not keep too large a space for her in his heart. She seemed to realize the sadness she caused him, and yet their bond was too strong to walk away from it altogether.
Whatever happened in December 1908, no one will ever really know, but here is the letter Gonne wrote to Yeats after he left. Having read all of her correspondence, (to him and to others) this letter stands out in tone and raw emotion. She often spent six hours a day on her voluminous correspondence, so her letters are quick, dashed off, to the point, and sometimes full of non sequitirs, like most letters between intimates. She lived primarily in France yet remained active in Ireland on all kinds of committees (committees she herself had formed) - so her correspondence was massive, and she employed no secretary.
Gonne usually addressed Yeats as "My dear Willie", and sometimes (echoing Abigail Adams) "My dearest friend". But here, in this letter, she starts with "Dearest", a greeting that cuts me to the core for various reasons, so familiar is it, so unbelievably missed.
This letter hurts me to read. I think she has a point. I am grateful (in many ways) that she did not return his love - because the very unfulfilled nature of his love for her helped create some of his best work. She is everywhere in his poetry. Would that high-flung transcendent love have survived in the everyday domestic world? Or would it have been ruined? Was it not distance itself that created such a burning need? I can never know, and it is not for me to know ... but her influence on him is paramount. The references to her cannot be counted. Yeats married quite late - I believe he was almost 50. He had a horror of growing old (he even proposed to Gonne's daughter Iseult - when she was 18, 19 years old! - Incredible!) - and was also quite sad at being along so late in life, when he should have been having grandkids already.
But it took him that long to crush down the longing for another, and to accept the situation. He was "old and gray and full of sleep" by that time. That struggle took a lifetime.
She also was quite open with him about the fact that she had a "horror of physical love" (meaning: sex) - and only believed it was necessary for procreation. She knew that he needed "physical love", and so wanted him, desperately, to "let her go", to torment himself no longer for a woman who could never satisfy him. She was not a prude in any way (obviously). But sex was horrifying to her. She could not bear it, and didn't want it in her life at all. She knew that this would be a problem for Yeats, although perhaps he insisted that it all would be all right once they got started with it. Or perhaps he said it didn't matter to HIM either, and she was wise enough to disbelieve him. Sadly, only her letters remain (or most of them), because of a police raid that destroyed her apartment and most of her papers. Only a couple of his letters to her still exist. So we just have her side. But make no mistake: this is a true dialogue. One that spans decades of life. Until Yeats passed away in 1939.
They were dear dear friends. These letters are amazing.
Back to the letter. It is December 1908. Yeats has just left Paris. It is quite likely they finally slept together during this particular visit. When she speaks of "going to him", she is referring to going to him in her mind. They communicated, long-distance, through shared visions and dreams, and made "dates" to meet up on the astral plane and then compare notes on what they both saw. Much of their letters has to do with this sort of new-age communication (this was what they meant when they said "spiritual marriage"). They experimented with it for years.
Maud wrote to him:
13 Rue de Passy
Paris
Friday [December 1908]Dearest
It was hard leaving you yesterday but I knew it would be just as hard today if I had waited. Life is so good when we are together & we are together so little - !
Did you know it I went to you last night? about 12 or 2 o'clock I don't exactly know the time. I think you knew. It was as it was when you made me see with the golden light on Wednesday. I shall go to you again often but not quite in that way, I shall try to make strong & well for your work for dear one you must work or I shall begin tormenting myself thinking perhaps I help to make you idle & then I would soon feel we ought not to meet at all, & that would be O so dreary! -
You asked me yesterday if I am not a little sad that things are as they are between us - I am sorry & I am glad. It is hard being away from each other so much there are moments when I am dreadfully lonely & long to be with you, - one of these moments is on me now - but beloved I am glad & proud beyond measure of your love, & that it is strong enough & high enough to accept the spiritual love & union I offer -
I have prayed so hard to have all earthly desire taken from my love for you & dearest, loving you as I do, I have prayed & I am praying still that the bodily desire for me may be taken from you too. I know how hard & rare a thing it is for a man to hold spiritual love when the bodily desire is gone & I have not made these prayers without a terrible struggle a struggle that shook my life though I do not speak much of it & generally manage to laugh.
That struggle is over & I have found peace. I think today I could let you marry another without losing it - for I know the spiritual union between us will outlive this life, even if we never see each other in this world again.
Write to me soon.
YoursMaud
Yeats, when he was in his 60s, nearing the end, wrote the following poem. Many scholars believe it makes reference to this visit in Paris in 1908, especially the evocative raw line "Strike me if I shriek". Whatever it means, it is fierce and intimate.
A Man Young and Old
by William Butler Yeats
I
First Love
THOUGH nurtured like the sailing moon
In beauty's murderous brood,
She walked awhile and blushed awhile
And on my pathway stood
Until I thought her body bore
A heart of flesh and blood.
But since I laid a hand thereon
And found a heart of stone
I have attempted many things
And not a thing is done,
For every hand is lunatic
That travels on the moon.
She smiled and that transfigured me
And left me but a lout,
Maundering here, and maundering there,
Emptier of thought
Than the heavenly circuit of its stars
When the moon sails out.
II
Human Dignity
Like the moon her kindness is,
If kindness I may call
What has no comprehension in't,
But is the same for all
As though my sorrow were a scene
Upon a painted wall.
So like a bit of stone I lie
Under a broken tree.
I could recover if I shrieked
My heart's agony
To passing bird, but I am dumb
From human dignity.
III
The Mermaid
A mermaid found a swimming lad,
Picked him for her own,
Pressed her body to his body,
Laughed; and plunging down
Forgot in cruel happiness
That even lovers drown.
IV
The Death of the Hare
I have pointed out the yelling pack,
The hare leap to the wood,
And when I pass a compliment
Rejoice as lover should
At the drooping of an eye,
At the mantling of the blood.
Then' suddenly my heart is wrung
By her distracted air
And I remember wildness lost
And after, swept from there,
Am set down standing in the wood
At the death of the hare.
V
The Empty Cup
A crazy man that found a cup,
When all but dead of thirst,
Hardly dared to wet his mouth
Imagining, moon-accursed,
That another mouthful
And his beating heart would burst.
October last I found it too
But found it dry as bone,
And for that reason am I crazed
And my sleep is gone.
VI
His Memories
We should be hidden from their eyes,
Being but holy shows
And bodies broken like a thorn
Whereon the bleak north blows,
To think of buried Hector
And that none living knows.
The women take so little stock
In what I do or say
They'd sooner leave their cosseting
To hear a jackass bray;
My arms are like the twisted thorn
And yet there beauty lay;
The first of all the tribe lay there
And did such pleasure take --
She who had brought great Hector down
And put all Troy to wreck --
That she cried into this ear,
'Strike me if I shriek.'
VII
The Friends of his Youth
Laughter not time destroyed my voice
And put that crack in it,
And when the moon's pot-bellied
I get a laughing fit,
For that old Madge comes down the lane,
A stone upon her breast,
And a cloak wrapped about the stone,
And she can get no rest
With singing hush and hush-a-bye;
She that has been wild
And barren as a breaking wave
Thinks that the stone's a child.
And Peter that had great affairs
And was a pushing man
Shrieks, 'I am King of the Peacocks,'
And perches on a stone;
And then I laugh till tears run down
And the heart thumps at my side,
Remembering that her shriek was love
And that he shrieks from pride.
VIII
Summer and Spring
We sat under an old thorn-tree
And talked away the night,
Told all that had been said or done
Since first we saw the light,
And when we talked of growing up
Knew that we'd halved a soul
And fell the one in t'other's arms
That we might make it whole;
Then peter had a murdering look,
For it seemed that he and she
Had spoken of their childish days
Under that very tree.
O what a bursting out there was,
And what a blossoming,
When we had all the summer-time
And she had all the spring!
IX
The Secrets of the Old
I have old women's sectets now
That had those of the young;
Madge tells me what I dared not think
When my blood was strong,
And what had drowned a lover once
Sounds like an old song.
Though Margery is stricken dumb
If thrown in Madge's way,
We three make up a solitude;
For none alive to-day
Can know the stories that we know
Or say the things we say:
How such a man pleased women most
Of all that are gone,
How such a pair loved many years
And such a pair but one,
Stories of the bed of straw
Or the bed of down.
X
His Wildness
O bid me mount and sail up there
Amid the cloudy wrack,
For peg and Meg and Paris' love
That had so straight a back,
Are gone away, and some that stay
Have changed their silk for sack.
Were I but there and none to hear
I'd have a peacock cry,
For that is natural to a man
That lives in memory,
Being all alone I'd nurse a stone
And sing it lullaby.
XI
From 'Oedipus at Colonus'
Endure what life God gives and ask no longer span;
Cease to remember the delights of youth, travel-wearied aged man;
Delight becomes death-longing if all longing else be vain.
Even from that delight memory treasures so,
Death, despair, division of families, all entanglements of mankind grow,
As that old wandering beggar and these God-hated children know.
In the long echoing street the laughing dancers throng,
The bride is catried to the bridegroom's chamber
through torchlight and tumultuous song;
I celebrate the silent kiss that ends short life or long.
Never to have lived is best, ancient writers say;
Never to have drawn the breath of life, never to have
looked into the eye of day;
The second best's a gay goodnight and quickly turn away.
Rudyard Kipling was born in Bombay, India.

Michael Schmidt, in his wonderful book Lives of the Poets writes:
In Kipling as in Hardy we find a poetry from the turn of the century without traces of poetic weariness, without the rhythmic overemphasis of Swinburne, the esoteric qualities of Arthur Symons, or the twilight of early Yeats. He was a plain-speaking poet, nowhere more pithily than in his "Epitaphs of the War". These brief, uncompromising last words illustrate his skill in poetry of summary declaration, tough yet humane. "The Coward" is the best of them: "I could not look on death, which being known, / Men took me to him, blindfold and alone." His most famous epitaph has the same epigrammatic conciseness; few talents of this century have been given to epigram, a form more difficult to master - for it demands pure content and direct expression - than discursive forms. "If any question why we died / Tell them, because our fathers lied."
That is awfully chilly good stuff.
T.S. Eliot said that there is little difference in Kipling's use of language between his prose and his verse. It is his greatest strength, and what sets him apart.
The great Lucy Maud Montgomery wrote in her journal about Barrack-Room Ballads:
"They are capital -- full of virile strength and life. They thrill and pulsate and burn, they carry you along in their rush and swing, till you forget your own petty interests and cares, and burst out into a broader soul-world ... We can never be quite so narrow again."
I love that. "They thrill and pulsate and burn, they carry you along in their rush and swing ..."
That is pretty much my experience of him as well.
I'm a Kipling fan from way back, from childhood. It was the cartoon version of Rikki Tikki Tavi, shown on television back then, that did me in completely. I saw it when I was, what, 8 years old? I remember it vividly and I LIVED it. Narrated by Orson Welles!

Kipling is good for kids. I took his stuff out of the library and read some of it. I liked the adventure of it, the exotic setting ... and I also loved books about animals. So with Rikki Tikki Tavi I was all set. The story opens:
This is the story of the great war that Rikki-tikki-tavi fought single-handed, through the bath-rooms of the big bungalow in Segowlee cantonment. Darzee, the tailor-bird, helped him, and Chuchundra, the musk-rat, who never comes out into the middle of the floor, but always creeps round by the wall, gave him advice; but Rikki-tikki did the real fighting.He was a mongoose, rather like a little cat in his fur and his tail, but quite like a weasel in his head and habits. His eyes and the end of his restless nose were pink; he could scratch himself anywhere he pleased, with any leg, front or back, that he chose to use; he could fluff up his tail till it looked like a bottle-brush, and his war-cry, as he scuttled through the long grass, was: '_Rikk-tikk-tikki-tikki-tchk!_'
How could you NOT keep reading after such an opening? Even now, re-reading that, it makes me want to pick it up again!
I was haunted by the image of the bird PRETENDING to be wounded in order to lure Nagaina the cobra-wife away from her eggs. I was so frightened by that! I wondered if I would have the courage to behave in such a way if I needed to.
Kipling's controversial nature went right over my head as a child and I just loved the stories and the beat of the poems, which reminded me of Longfellow ("hardly a man is now alive who remembers that day and year"). It is compulsively readable stuff. His verse has, what Michael Schmidt calls "metrical drubbing", a drumbeat that forces you to continue, a rat-a-tat-tat of sound. There is much that is distasteful in Kipling's views but to throw him out completely because of that is a shame. I feel sorry for those who feel that way because God what joy they miss! Now, on the flipside, if I walk into your room and find that you have a shrine to Oliver Cromwell on your dresser, then yeah, I will flag you as a nutbag and I will think badly of you. We all have our limits. Kipling's views on Irish independence suck, and obviously I have strong feelings about that issue. But Kipling is a WRITER. He was also a man of his time. As we all are "of our time". Shakespeare was of his time. Yeah, let's just write him off, too, because he doesn't line up with our precious 21st century way of thinking. Yes, Kipling shilled for Empire. So? Every Empire should have such a talented shill!
Orwell's essay on Kipling is not to be missed - and Christopher Hitchens (the heir of Orwell) has also written quite a bit on Kipling. All very interesting stuff for Kipling lovers. It's not about turning a blind eye to the more unsavory aspects of the world Kipling describes. It's about appreciating his talent as a story-teller, first of all, and putting him in the correct context. At least that's what it's about for me.
Besides, anyone who captivated my imagination from before the age of 8 has a "forever" place in my heart because ... well, you never forget those people who sweep you away before you really know who you are, before you worry about things like context and controversy ... when you just like what you like because you like it. It's that simple.
In the end, there are just the stories. The stories remain. You could say to me, "Yeah, but did you know that Kipling did THIS such-and-such awful thing?" Yeah, I know it. But have you read those poems? Have you read the stories?
Both can be true. Both ARE true. I am able to hold more than one idea in my brain at a time, thank Christ, and contradictory opinions do not need to be resolved. SOME do, but not ones like the one I describe. Not for me, anyway. Lots of my favorite writers held views I think abhorrent. So? What am I, the arbiter of morality? Besides, I'd rather not miss out on something WONDERFUL. And I think Kipling is wonderful.
Kipling's work clamors with voices. Shouts, catcalls, different dialects ... You can feel the dust and heat of India in them, the cacophony of accents, the world ... These are not poems in quiet isolation. They rustle, rumble, jostle for position ... Kipling has his ear to the ground.
I will also always love Kipling for the following line, which I would actually remember on occasion in high school, when I felt insecure about not being like other people, or not wanting to go along with the pack ... I had read the story when I was a kid, and it struck a nerve, and these words would come back to me. Actually, they still do. I really find them comforting. They are from Kipling's story "The Cat That Walked By Himself."
The Cat. He walked by himself. He went through the wet Wild Woods, waving his wild tail, and walking by his wild lone.
I think that is marvelous. So it helped explain me to myself. Not that I didn't have friends - I had the best friends! - but to see myself as the cat who "walked by himself" as opposed to some FREAK who didn't want to drink or have sex or the other things going on in high school ... it was really helpful. I am just "walking by my wild lone", and that's my nature. It's okay. It's okay.
Some quotes:
Michael Schmidt, from Lives of the Poets:
His father was a talented teacher of sculpture at the Bombay School of Art and later curator of the museum at Lahore, responsive to the rich multitude of cultures in which he and his family lived. His mother was sister of Lady Burne-Jones and of Stanley Baldwin's mother. Thus one of his backgrounds was intellectually lively and socially privileged. The other shared in different and older cultures. India in his early years was real to him, not as something inferior or dominated but as something mysterious and compelling. It helped constitute his imagination and memory. As a young child he was under the care of an Indian nurse, and he became proficient in Hindustani as well as English. When as a little sahib he returned to England with his sister, he stood at an awkward angle to the colonial world; the country he came to lacked the warmth, color and easy intimacy of the one he had left. When he returned to India as a young man, he had changed, but it was India that seemed different, no longer second nature to him. He invests much of his writing in reclaiming the first India for himself, and for others - children and adults.
Schmidt posits that the driving theme of Kipling's work is nostalgia. Nostalgia for a lost land, for childhood itself.
Schmidt writes:
The light verse he wrote for newspapers was collected in Departmental Ditties (1886), a book that reached an English audience. But it was Plain Tales from the Hills (1888) that made a real mark in England and paved the way for the writer's return. He arrived in London in 1889 with a reputation. He was feted by editors and fellow writers but generally stood apart, a plain man among the literati, preferring the company of men of action, of public deeds - Stanley Baldwin, Lord Milner, Max Aitken (who became Lord Beaverbrook). This was the period of his greatest popularity. Until 1902 he was the most eloquent literary spokesman for a Tory populism that was patriotic, imperial and - above all - responsible. The privileges of being English entailed real duties, duties that were imperatives.When we say he was popular, we can quantify what we mean. By 1918, Departmental Ditties, his least achieved book, had sold 81,000 copies; by 1931 it had sold 117,000 copies. Barrack-Room Ballads and Other Verses remained his most opular book, selling 182,000 copies by 1918 and 255,000 by 1931. The Definitive Edition of the poems, published in 1940, had gone through sixty impressions by 1982. Like Houseman, even when his shares were no longer quoted on the intellectual bourse, and critics turned their backs on him, he remained popular with readers.
More from Schmidt:
His reporting during the Boer War was brilliant, presenting "news events" that showed an understanding of the underlying causes. In retirement at Bateman's, observing from a distance rather than reporting from the fray, and, often alone with his disappointments, he was beset by serious melancholy. The relentless themes of duty, sacrifice and devotion were elicited particularly by the First World War, in which his only son John was killed in 1915 at the Battle of Loos (the body was never found). "The Children" is about his and other parents' loss ... It is as though the biblical cadences gradually lay hold of his verse: he speaks from a moral height in a voice that contains all the voices he has spoken in before.
The Children
These were our children who died for our lands; they were dear in our sight.
We have only the memory left of their home-treasured sayings and laughter.
The price of our loss shall be paid to our hands, not another's hereafter.
Neither the Alien nor Priest shall decide on it. That is our right.
But who shall return us the children?
At the hour the Barbarian chose to disclose his pretences,
And raged against Man, they engaged, on the breasts that they bared for us,
The first felon-stroke of the sword he had long-time prepared for us -
Their bodies were all our defence while we wrought our defences.
They bought us anew with their blood, forbearing to blame us,
Those hours which we had not made good when the Judgment o'ercame us.
They believed us and perished for it. Our statecraft, our learning
Delivered them bound to the Pit and alive to the burning
Whither they mirthfully hastened as jostling for honour -
Not since her birth has our Earth seen such worth loosed upon her.
Nor was their agony brief, or once only imposed on them.
The wounded, the war-spent, the sick received no exemption:
Being cured they returned and endured and achieved our redemption,
Hopeless themselves of relief, till Death, marvelling, closed on them.
That flesh we had nursed from the first in all cleanness was given
To corruption unveiled and assailed by the malice of Heaven -
By the heart-shaking jests of Decay where it lolled on the wires -
To be blanched or gay-painted by fumes - to be cindered by fires -
To be senselessly tossed and retossed in stale mutilation
From crater to crater. For this we shall take expiation.
But who shall return us the children?
My God, that is a sad poem. "Not since her birth has our Earth seen such worth loosed upon her." I would give MUCH to be able to write a line like that.
Here is one of Kipling's better-known poems.
Shillin' a Day
My name is O'Kelly, I've heard the Revelly
From Birr to Bareilly, from Leeds to Lahore,
Hong-Kong and Peshawur,
Lucknow and Etawah,
And fifty-five more all endin' in "pore".
Black Death and his quickness, the depth and the thickness,
Of sorrow and sickness I've known on my way,
But I'm old and I'm nervis,
I'm cast from the Service,
And all I deserve is a shillin' a day.
(Chorus) Shillin' a day,
Bloomin' good pay --
Lucky to touch it, a shillin' a day!
Oh, it drives me half crazy to think of the days I
Went slap for the Ghazi, my sword at my side,
When we rode Hell-for-leather
Both squadrons together,
That didn't care whether we lived or we died.
But it's no use despairin', my wife must go charin'
An' me commissairin' the pay-bills to better,
So if me you be'old
In the wet and the cold,
By the Grand Metropold, won't you give me a letter?
(Full chorus) Give 'im a letter --
'Can't do no better,
Late Troop-Sergeant-Major an' -- runs with a letter!
Think what 'e's been,
Think what 'e's seen,
Think of his pension an' ----
GAWD SAVE THE QUEEN!
Michael Schmidt, again, on Kipling's influences:
Kipling is indebted, among his contemporaries, to Browning for his dramatic monologues, to Swinburne for some of his rhythms, to the Pre-Raphaelites; towering behind his work is the King James Version of the Bible. But ballad, hymn and short story remain his chief poetic determinants. He is a public poet first and last, despite formal inventiveness. His work develops thematically, but the style remains spry, unrepetitive, essentially stable. Eliot sees his development as a shift from "the imperial imagination into the historical imagination" - from geography and the present to history and the sources of and analogies for the presence. There's a change, too, from a concern with the limbs of Empire - India and the army, principally - to a concern with the imperial heart, with England, with Sussex in particular as its emblem. He pursues imperial responsibilities home.
A complex man.
More from Michael Schmidt:
Everywhere in his poetry we are confronted by formidable skill. Though he wrote few fine lyrics, few lyric writers could achieve his balladic forms. In "The Ballad of East and West" his aptitude with long lines is unmatched: "There is rock to the left, and rock to the right, and low lean thorn between, / And ye may hear the breech-bolt snick where never a man is seen." This is the natural, expressive style Kipling evolved: it can deal with surface reality, it can name things - anything, the style is inclusive - and it can suggest depths without damaging the surface. Though it has the veracity of speech, it also has the authority of song.
"The Islanders", written in 1902, was one of his more controversial pieces. A sort of shuffling hat-trick, where he spoke directly to those who were his most feverish followers, and named names, pointing fingers.
The Islanders
NO DOUBT but ye are the People-your throne is above the King's.
Whoso speaks in your presence must say acceptable things:
Bowing the head in worship, bending the knee in fear-
Bringing the word well smoothen-such as a King should hear.
Fenced by your careful fathers, ringed by your leaden seas,
Long did ye wake in quiet and long lie down at ease;
Till Ye said of Strife, "What is it?" of the Sword, "It is far from our ken";
Till ye made a sport of your shrunken hosts and a toy of your armed men.
Ye stopped your ears to the warning-ye would neither look nor heed-
Ye set your leisure before their toil and your lusts above their need.
Because of your witless learning and your beasts of warren and chase,
Ye grudged your sons to their service and your fields for their camping-place.
Ye forced them glean in the highways the straw for the bricks they brought;
Ye forced them follow in byways the craft that ye never taught.
Ye hampered and hindered and crippled; ye thrust out of sight and away
Those that would serve you for honour and those that served you for pay.
Then were the judgments loosened; then was your shame revealed,
At the hands of a little people, few but apt in the field.
Yet ye were saved by a remnant (and your land's long-suffering star),
When your strong men cheered in their millions while your
striplings went to the war.
Sons of the sheltered city-unmade, unhandled, unmeet-
Ye pushed them raw to the battle as ye picked them raw from the street.
And what did ye look they should compass? Warcraft learned in a breath,
Knowledge unto occasion at the first far view of Death?
So? And ye train your horses and the dogs ye feed and prize?
How are the beasts more worthy than the souls, your sacrifice?
But ye said, "Their valour shall show them"; but ye said, "The end is close."
And ye sent them comfits and pictures to help them harry your foes:
And ye vaunted your fathomless power, and ye flaunted your iron pride,
Ere ye fawned on the Younger Nations for the men who could shoot and ride!
Then ye returned to your trinkets; then ye contented your souls
With the flannelled fools at the wicket or the muddied oafs at the goals.
Given to strong delusion, wholly believing a lie,
Ye saw that the land lay fenceless, and ye let the months go by
Waiting some easy wonder, hoping some saving sign-
Idle -openly idle-in the lee of the forespent Line.
Idle -except for your boasting-and what is your boasting worth
If ye grudge a year of service to the lordliest life on earth?
Ancient, effortless, ordered, cycle on cycle set,
Life so long untroubled, that ye who inherit forget
It was not made with the mountains, it is not one with the deep.
Men, not gods, devised it. Men, not gods, must keep.
Men, not children, servants, or kinsfolk called from afar,
But each man born in the Island broke to the matter of war.
Soberly and by custom taken and trained for the same,
Each man born in the Island entered at youth to the game-
As it were almost cricket, not to be mastered in haste,
But after trial and labour, by temperance, living chaste.
As it were almost cricket-as it were even your play,
Weighed and pondered and worshipped, and practised day and day.
So ye shall bide sure-guarded when the restless lightnings wake
In the womb of the blotting war-cloud, and the pallid nations quake.
So, at the haggard trumpets, instant your soul shall leap
Forthright, accoutred, accepting-alert from the wells of sleep.
So, at the threat ye shall summon-so at the need ye shall send
Men, not children or servants, tempered and taught to the end;
Cleansed of servile panic, slow to dread or despise,
Humble because of knowledge, mighty by sacrifice. . . .
But ye say, "It will mar our comfort." Ye say, "It will minish our trade."
Do ye wait for the spattered shrapnel ere ye learn how a gun is laid?
For the low, red glare to southward when the raided coast- towns burn?
(Light ye shall have on that lesson, but little time to learn.)
Will ye pitch some white pavilion, and lustily even the odds,
With nets and hoops and mallets, with rackets and bats and rods
Will the rabbit war with your foemen-the red deer horn them for hire?
Your kept cock-pheasant keep you?-he is master of many a shire,
Arid, aloof, incurious, unthinking, unthanking, gelt,
Will ye loose your schools to flout them till their brow-beat columns melt?
Will ye pray them or preach them, or print them, or ballot them back from your shore?
Will your workmen issue a mandate to bid them strike no more?
Will ye rise and dethrone your rulers? (Because ye were idle both?
Pride by Insolence chastened? Indolence purged by Sloth?)
No doubt but ye are the People; who shall make you afraid?
Also your gods are many; no doubt but your gods shall aid.
Idols of greasy altars built for the body's ease;
Proud little brazen Baals and talking fetishes;
Teraphs of sept and party and wise wood-pavement gods-
These shall come down to the battle and snatch you from under the rods?
From the gusty, flickering gun-roll with viewless salvoes rent,
And the pitted hail of the bullets that tell not whence they were sent.
When ye are ringed as with iron, when ye are scourged as with whips,
When the meat is yet in your belly, and the boast is yet on your lips;
When ye go forth at morning and the noon beholds you broke,
Ere ye lie down at even, your remnant, under the yoke?
No doubt but ye are the People-absolute, strong, and wise;
Whatever your heart has desired ye have not withheld from your eyes.
On your own heads, in your own hands, the sin and the caving lies!
Ouch. It's one of those brilliant moments where someone who may be perceived as being on a certain "side", then turns around and says, "Nope. You got me wrong." No wonder George Orwell and Christopher Hitchens love the guy. They are cut from the same cloth.
Angus Wilson wrote of "The Islanders" that it "takes each sacred cow of the clubs and senior common rooms and slaughters it messily before its worshipers' eyes."
Schmidt writes of "The Islanders":
Magesterial, with vehement sarcasm, he turns to the flag wavers, the lazy, the malingerers, and shows them where they are likely to fail. They serve false gods, like the chosen people who, in the Bible, suffer the scourge of the angry prophets. Despite his formal variety, he always sounds a hectoring note; he insists in the way that Marlowe's dramatic verse or the Old Testament insists, with severity.
One last summing-up quote from Schmidt (and if you're a Kipling fan, you do not want to miss Orwell's magnificent essay - link somewhere up there above):
Insider and outsider: Kipling was an innovator from within tradition, inventing forms, developing rhythms, pursuing a poetry that instructs as it entertains. The instruction is of its period; it repels readers with the experience of the Second World War behind them, and young readers who cannot abide incorrect notions. Insistence on racial superiority, on "The Blood" that binds the English, and the paternalistic note reserved for the people of the colonies, grate. But Kipling also wrote Kim. His critics deduce his politics selectively, finding in him a crude consistency of thought that the major works themselves belie. Hardy is a pessimist, but not a programmatic one, any more than Kipling is a thoroughgoing racist, sadist, protofascist or feudalist - all terms his critics have applied to him. Each poem aspires to consistency and truth to itself. But the poet is neither philosopher nor politician. He retains the essential freedom to change, to start a new book, a new poem, to find a new path or an old path through the woods. As an epitaph for journalists killed in the First World War Kipling inscriped, "We have served our day." This is what he did, in a day when journalism was not merely a job but a vocation, and when ideals of service were not held suspect.Was he an interpreter of popular will or the inadvertent advocate of a new barbarism, the barbarism inherent in the imperial ideal? Robert Buchanan, a Gladsontian Liberal, characterized him as "the voice of the hooligan", and - yes - we can agree, but beyond the hooligan there is the deep believer, who knows what he has seen and deduces from it what might be, against the current of what actually was happening: the Empire's overextension and eventual decline. "Recessional" is the great poem of Empire, discursive rather than dramatic, expressing anxiety at imperial hubris, the pride before the fall.
Recessional
God of our fathers, known of old--
Lord of our far-flung battle line
Beneath whose awful hand we hold
Dominion over palm and pine--
Lord God of Hosts, be with us yet,
Lest we forget - lest we forget!
The tumult and the shouting dies;
The captains and the kings depart:
Still stands Thine ancient sacrifice,
An humble and a contrite heart.
Lord God of Hosts, be with us yet,
Lest we forget - lest we forget!
Far-called, our navies melt away;
On dune and headland sinks the fire:
Lo, all our pomp of yesterday
Is one with Nineveh and Tyre!
Judge of the Nations, spare us yet,
Lest we forget - lest we forget!
If, drunk with sight of power, we loose
Wild tongues that have not Thee in awe--
Such boasting as the Gentiles use
Or lesser breeds without the law--
Lord God of Hosts, be with us yet,
Lest we forget - lest we forget!
For heathen heart that puts her trust
In reeking tube and iron shard--
All valiant dust that builds on dust,
And guarding, calls not Thee to guard--
For frantic boast and foolish word,
Thy mercy on Thy people, Lord!
You can see why Schmidt sees nostalgia in Kipling's work. In a way, he is writing about a world that is about to disappear forever, and perhaps he had some consciousness of that. Perhaps his reporter's instinct was always in gear, to put down "how it was for us", "what it was like", because he knew, somewhere, that none of it could last.
I'm glad he got it all down.
A walk down memory lane below the jump.
























I loved this piece by Walter Kirn, author of the novel Up in the Air, and his journey with that book. Fascinating. Yet another example of how you just never know what will happen in life, you have no idea what the outcome may be - but the point is to keep working. Keep "putting it out there". Luck certainly plays a part in some of this, but it's not only about luck. Fortune favors a prepared mind and all that. Be bold and mighty forces will come to your aid. Etc. The book was dead in the water upon arrival, due to terrible timing (September 11th - a book where the cover depicted men in business suits plummeting through the air on fire was not going to be a crowd-pleaser at that particular time!) - and so that was that. Kirn had to move on, chalk it up to bad timing, and keep working. The story of how this forgotten novel then became a hot Hollywood property is riveting, and also goes to show you that there are good people out there, and when they believe in something, and stand by it, wonderful things can happen. (I saw the film. It's wonderful.) I especially loved this section, about the screening:
I was giddy, insanely giddy, it was true, but I had a perfect right to be just then. As my Depression-tempered grandfather used to say whenever he had the chance, “Things are tough all over, Walt.� And nowadays things are tough indeed for novelists, especially for we who won’t do vampires and don’t embed mystical codes in our plots. Yet somehow, like Ryan Bingham, I’d come through. There I was up on screen for a long few seconds, in fact: an author seated just inches from one of his characters—one that he’d both written and written off. Reitman had stuck me there to tickle my vanity, and Clooney himself had made sure I’d stay put, even after the movie was edited. “You sit close enough to me, you won’t be cut,� he’d said. And the man knows his business. Watch the movie: You’ll see.
Oh, Clooney. I love you so. One degree, man, one degree.
(I also love the bit about Kirn's girlfriend immediately turning her blackberry back on after having sex ... such a funny detail.)
I have not read the novel, but now I really want to.
Go read the whole thing. It's a great piece about process.

Emily Dickinson was born on this day in 1830. It is not known why she withdrew from society so completely. Theories abound. Books have been written. But the mystery remains. What we have are her poems. A wide interior life lived in one room. Extraordinary.
EMILY DICKINSON FREAKS ME OUT.
I can't settle into her poems and flip through the pages of her volumes with satisfaction and happiness and enjoyment of the verse. It's all too jagged for me. It's too raw. The long dashes in her lines, the lack of titles, the fact that she wrote all of this with the assumption that they would not be read - so there is a dashed-off immediate quality to almost all of it ... like she would be sweeping the parlor, an entire poem would pop into her brain full-blown about, oh, death, or love, or fear - and she would stop sweeping, jot it down on a scrap of paper she kept in a pocket of her dress, and then go back to sweeping. Like that's what all of her poems feel like to me, and it freaks me out. There is a great mystery surrounding Emily Dickinson (what happened to her? Why did she become a recluse?) and I, for one, hope the mystery is never solved. I enjoy reading the theories, I enjoy speculating ... but I think I like the mystery better.
She CAN'T have really existed, can she?
Here is Ted's post on Emily Dickinson. Ted and I collaborated, years ago, on a show about Joseph Cornell (my post about him here) who made some of his most famous "boxes" for Emily Dickinson (even though she was long dead). The entire cast immersed itself in Dickinson's work, looking at it in a whole new way - trying to see it through Cornell's eyes. It was a really vital and new and exciting process, and brought Emily Dickinson to life for me from the periphery. She became a Muse (Cornell was all about muses), a wise woman in a tower, throwing scraps of poems down on the populace (mainly Cornell) below. She was witty, fierce, she could be unforgiving, she withheld, nothing could convince her to unloose the bonds that tied her. She loved the bonds. Camille Paglia has always theorized that Emily Dickinson was an heir to the Marquis de Sade (gotta love Camille - or at least I do) - that her insistence on boundaries, limits, restraints - has more in common with the erotic underbelly of literature, the sado-masochism of some of history's criminals, like de Sade - than with any of Dickinson's contemporaries. In many ways, Dickinson stole from no one. She read widely, she loved poetry, but it appears that she had her own voice from the start. If you read early Sylvia Plath, you can FEEL her influences. Roethke, mainly, some of her poems steal his images wholesale, she imitates his line-length, his rhyme scheme ... This sort of "stealing" is not plagiarism, it's working out who you are as an artist and what you want to say. You read a writer and you think, "Ah. Now THAT is what I would like to do." And in the beginning stages, you may imitate too much. You have not owned it yet. Eventually, you must shake off all of your influences, and emerge on your own two feet. Dickinson sounds like no one else. But generations of writers following her imitate her. She is that distinct. She is one of the few poets where you can recognize a poem of hers just by the look of it.
Such a shy retiring lady. But with a personality as giant as a movie star's. What must she have been like in person? Underestimate her at your peril.
I went through a big Emily Dickinson phase in high school, even though she freaked me out even then. I remember being devastated once - I think I had asked a guy to the prom and he said no. I had cried for 24 hours. It was a tragedy. Friends called me up to comfort me. I wailed into the night. The next day I was exhausted from all the crying. And I wrote in my journal, "After great pain a formal feeling comes."
HAHAHAHAHAHA
Like, yeah, I think Emily Dickinson might have been talking about something a bit more wrenching than not going to the Prom - but still! I remember vividly the feeling of being washed out, and almost timid and quiet in the aftermath of all the tears - and I realized that I did feel rather "formal". She was right!
But still. It makes me laugh to think of today.
Back to Camille Paglia. Her giant book Sexual Personae: Art and Decadence from Nefertiti to Emily Dickinson covers Emily Dickinson - as a matter of fact, Dickinson is the final chapter. I highly recommend that book anyway - there's a lot in it that is silly, but boy is it fun to read. I love her. Her view of Dickinson is quite individual - she sees Dickinson as an aesthete, or a decadent, at least emotionally. She didn't live it in the outer world like Oscar Wilde did, but her inner world was all decadence ... she was someone addicted to the sensations of life. You can feel it in the breathless tone of her poems. Like she is constantly pricking herself with a pin, and gasping with the pain. The pain is pleasurable almost. Pain is a doorway to pleasure. When Dickinson writes about pain, she writes about briars and thorns and cold - when she writes about love she writes about sunshine and green and warmth ... It is all in the senses. Connected by little dashes that make each poem seem breathless. She is bombarded by sensation, feeling ... it sweeps over her like a wave.
Again, she seems virtually impossible to me. I love her for it.
Michael Schmidt wrote, in his wonderful book Lives of the Poets (which I'll get to when I get to in this book excerpt thing):
She sewed her poems into little books and put them away, one after another, in a box, where after her death her sister found them, nine hundred poems "tied together with twine" in "sixty volumes." And it's not an untenable theory that the beloved whom she mourns, departed, may be Christ, the soul's lover, rather than a particular man -- or a particular woman.
Her poems vibrate with pain, feeling, thought, humor. She scares the shit out of me. The emotional life is a vast universe. You don't have to travel widely to "have a life". You don't have to have tons of experiences. You are alive. What does it feel like to be alive? That's the place Emily Dickinson writes from.
Here's a poem.
214
I taste a liquor never brewed --
From Tankards scooped in Pearl --
Not all the Vats upon the Rhine
Yield such an Alcohol!
Inebriate of Air - am I --
And Debauchee of Dew --
Reeling -- thro endless summer days --
From inns of Molten Blue --
When "Landlords" turn the drunken Bee
Out of the Foxglove's door --
When Butterflies - renounce their "drams" --
I shall but drink the more!
Till Seraphs swing their snowy Hats --
And Saints - to windows run --
To see the little Tippler
Leaning against the -- Sun --
In the poem below, we could read whatever we want into it, it's not "clear" - who is "You" - it would depend on where you are at in your life, the answer. You could read it as being addressed to God. Or it could be to a great lost love, one of those experiences that mark a person forever. "Because you saturated Sight / And I had no more Eyes / For sordid excellence / As paradise". I have felt that way about a man.
640
I cannot live with You --
It would be Life --
And Life is over there --
Behind the Shelf
The Sexton keeps the Key to --
Putting up
Our Life -- His Porcelain --
Like a Cup --
Discarded of the Housewife --
Quaint -- or Broke --
A newer Sevres pleases --
Old Ones crack --
I could not die -- with You --
For One must wait
To shut the Other's Gaze down --
You -- could not --
And I -- Could I stand by
And see You -- freeze --
Without my Right of Frost --
Death's privilege?
Nor could I rise -- with You --
Because Your Face
Would put out Jesus' --
That New Grace
Glow plain -- and foreign
On my homesick Eye --
Except that You than He
Shone close by --
They'd judge Us -- How --
For You -- served Heaven -- You know,
Or sought to--
I could not --
Because You saturated Sight --
And I had no more Eyes
For sordid excellence
As Paradise
And were You lost, I would be --
Though My Name
Rang loudest
On the Heavenly fame --
And were You -- saved --
And I -- condemned to be
Where You were not --
That self -- were Hell to Me --
So We must meet apart --
You there -- I -- here --
With just the Door ajar
That Oceans are -- and Prayer --
And that White Sustenance --
Despair --
Quotes and excerpts below about Emily Dickinson, in honor of her birthday.
"She is the spider, not the fly." -- Alison Brackenbury
"Her relationship to books , to literary preedent and example, was similar. She was no ransacker and devourer of libraries. Like Lincoln, she knew relatively few volumes but knew them deeply. As a girl she attended Amherst Academy and also Mount Holyoke Female Seminary, a few miles distant, during her seventeenth year, but school gave her neither intellectual nor social satisfactions to compensate for the reassuring intimacy of home and family she keenly missed. The standard works she knew best and drew on most commonly for allusions and references in her poetry and vivid letters were the classic myths, the Bible, and Shakespeare. Among the English Romantics, she valued John Keats especially; among her Englishc ontemporaries she was particularly attracted by the Brontes, the Brownings, Alfred, Lord Tennyson, and George Eliot. None of these, however, can be said to have influenced her literary practice significantly. Indeed, not the least notable quality of her poetry is its dazzling originality. Thoreau and Emerson, especially the latter, as we know from her letters, were perhaps her most important contemporary American intellectual resources, though their liberal influence seems always to have been tempered by the legacy of a conservative Puritanism best expressed in the writings of Jonathan Edwards. Her chief prosodic and formal model was the commonly used hymnals of the times with their simple patterns of meter and rhyme." -- Norton Anthology of American Literature
"No great poet has written so much bad verse as Emily Dickinson ..." -- Richard Chase
"When I state myself, as the Representative of the Verse -- it does not mean -- me -- but a supposed person." -- Emily Dickinson to Thomas Wentworth Higginson
"Dear friend,
I congratulate you.
Disaster endears beyond Fortune --
E. Dickinson"
-- letter written to a friend after the friend's house had burned down
"Throughout her life ED was especially sensitive to such occasions." -- Emily Dickinson's editor, commenting on a poem Dickinson wrote on the 4th anniversary of Charlotte Bronte's death
"Whitman, Dickinson and Melville seem to me the best poets of the nineteenth century here in America." -- Randall Jarrell
"The language is not literary. It enacts heard experience. Kinsmen, unexpectedly met, chatting late into the night from their different places: it brings beauty and truth into intimate focus. Strange: These are the same great terms of Keats's 'cold pastoral'." -- Michael Schmidt
"Her coy and oddly childish poems of nature and female friendship are products of a time when one of the careers open to women was perpetual childhood." -- Richard Chase
"I never read his book - but was told that he was disgraceful." -- Emily Dickinson on Walt Whitman
"My Mother does not care for thought." -- Emily Dickinson to Thomas Wentworth Higginson
"I am growing very handsome indeed!" -- Emily Dickinson, age 14
"More than any other poet, Emily Dickinson seemed to tell me that the intense inner event, the personal and psychological, was inseparable from the universal; that there was a range for psychological poetry beyond mere self-expression." -- Adrienne Rich
"We have the legend, but the crucial facts in the recorded life are absent. Dickinson's reticence seems part of her poetical strategy: if we could assign the poems to specific emotional events, we would ground them. As it is, they are a miracle and a mystery of language." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"Her wit is accuracy." -- Alison Brackenbury
"Immense in scale and oratorical in tone, this amazing short poem [Safe In Their Alabaster Chambers] departs from Dickinson's usual four-line stanza format, based on sturdy Protestant hymn measure. The first five-line stanza rolls out in a single, thrilling sentence, delivered in the magesterial public voice of a sermon or eulogy. Its as if the poem's disturbing theme - the dead and their defeated hopes - can barely be contained by traditional structure." -- Camille Paglia, "Break, Blow, Burn"
"Are you too deeply occupied to say if my verse is alive? The mind is so near itself it cannot see distinctly, and I have none to ask." -- Emily Dickinson to Thomas Higginson, 1862
"Emily, you wretch! No more of this nonsense! I've traveled all the way from Springfield to see you. Come down at once." -- Samuel Bowles, shouting up the stairs at Emily. Emily finally did come down.
"A step like a pattering child's in entry & in glided a little plain woman with two smooth bands of reddish hair & a face a little like Belle Dove's; not plainer - with no good feature - in a very plain & exquisitely clean white pique & blue net worsted shawl. She came to me with two day lilies which she put in a sort of childlike way into my hand & said 'These are my introduction' in a soft frightened breathless childlike voice -- & added under her breathe Forgive me if I am frightened; I never see strangers & hardly know what I say -- but she talked soon & thenceforward continuously -- & deferentially -- sometimes stopping to ask me to talk instead of her -- but readily recommencing...I never was with any one who drained my nerve power so much. Without touching her, she drew from me. I am glad not to live near her." -- Thomas Wentworth Higginson
Joseph Cornell, American artist, who specialized in making boxes - built boxes for Emily Dickinson. Her ghost haunts those boxes (of course even more so when you know which ones are the "Emily boxes"). But he didn't build them as gifts FOR Emily Dickinson (who, of course, was long dead). He built them as spaces that she might inhabit. He was "preparing a place" for her. That's why so many of the Emily boxes are empty. With open windows. Which is interesting, too. He always wanted to make sure that Emily had a way to escape.
Here is the most famous box he made for Emily Dickinson. It is called "Towards the Blue Peninsula":

Haunting, isn't it?
I can feel her presence in that box. It's like she just left, via the window, but an afterimage remains. The Belle of Amherst has already flown the coop.

John Milton turns 401 today. Last year, New York went all out in celebrating his birthday - with exhibits, art installations, even a costume ball. I love living here.
Milton has the kind of genius that is best not talked about too much. Just leave it be. Don't try to ask why, or HOW. Just accept that in this day and age of mortal man, giants still walk the earth on occasion. JUST ACCEPT IT. Every now and then, once every three or four centuries, a giant walks the earth. DEAL.
Milton was born on this day in 1608. He went to Oxford for a bit - but ended up leaving - and studied, basically, all of human nature and history and mankind on his own. The depth and breadth of his work, and his inquiry, is remarkable.
Jonathan Rosen, in his wonderful New Yorker article about the continuing relevance of Milton, writes:
Sometime in 1638, John Milton visited Galileo Galilei in Florence. The great astronomer was old and blind and under house arrest, confined by order of the Inquisition, which had forced him to recant his belief that the earth revolves around the sun, as formulated in his “Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems.� Milton was thirty years old—his own blindness, his own arrest, and his own cosmological epic, “Paradise Lost,� all lay before him. But the encounter left a deep imprint on him. It crept into “Paradise Lost,� where Satan’s shield looks like the moon seen through Galileo’s telescope, and in Milton’s great defense of free speech, “Areopagitica,� Milton recalls his visit to Galileo and warns that England will buckle under inquisitorial forces if it bows to censorship, “an undeserved thraldom upon learning.�Beyond the sheer pleasure of picturing the encounter—it’s like those comic-book specials in which Superman meets Batman—there’s something strange about imagining these two figures inhabiting the same age. Though Milton was the much younger man, in some ways his world system seems curiously older than the astronomer’s empirical universe. Milton depicted the earth hanging fixed from a golden chain, and when he contemplated the heavens he saw God enthroned and angels warring. The sense of the new and the old colliding forms part of Milton’s complex aura. The best-known portrait of his mature years makes Milton look like the dyspeptic brother of the man on the Quaker Oats box, but he is far more our contemporary than Shakespeare, who died when Milton was seven. Nobody would ever wonder whether Milton was really the author of his own work. Though “Paradise Lost� is a dilation on a moment in Genesis, it contains passages so personal that you cannot read far without knowing that the author was a blind man fallen on “evil days.� Even in his political prose, Milton will pause to tell us that he is really not all that short, despite what his enemies say. Though he coined the name “Pandemonium�—“all the demons�—for the palace that Satan and his fallen crew build in Hell, he also coined the word “self-esteem,� as contemporary a concept as there is and one that governed much of Milton’s life.
Read the whole thing: here.
I guess, on a personal note, my own terror of going blind makes me feel a strange fearful kinship with John Milton who went blind, and had to dictate his great works to others. He dictated Paradise Lost to his daughter.
What?
Honestly. I go blank when I think of this. I can't speak. To have that, that, in your head ...
There are some people who seem to be vessels of a higher being. Whatever you want to call it. You could tie them up, and throw them in a basement for 75 years, and they would STILL scratch out their epic on the basement wall. This is something that cannot be easily explained. It just is.
I'll just end with a poem that ranks among my favorites of all time. My fear of losing my sight is so deep and so profound that it is hard to even admit to, because I feel like it will come true if I speak it out loud. Milton stands before me, as a beacon - of someone this happened to - and yet he persevered. But oh. To live in darkness. To have the world of Paradise Lost in your head ... and to have to wait ... to WAIT ... as someone else takes it down in dictation ...
And so .... echoing this terrifying image of having to WAIT while your head is crammed full of Paradise Lost I'll end with Milton's sonnet to his own blindness.
Sonnet XIX: On His Blindness
When I consider how my light is spent,
Ere half my days, in this dark world and wide,
And that one talent which is death to hide
Lodged with me useless, though my soul more bent
To serve therewith my Maker, and present
My true account, lest He returning chide,
"Doth God exact day-labour, light denied?"
I fondly ask; But patience, to prevent
That murmur, soon replies "God doth not need
Either man's work or his own gifts. Who best
Bear His mild yoke, they serve Him best. His state
Is kingly: thousands at His bidding speed
And post o'er land and ocean without rest;
They also serve who only stand and wait."
Oh, that is bittersweet.
Here are some quotes I've compiled about (and from) Milton:
"Milton, with the possible exception of Spenser, is the first eccentric English poet, the first to make a myth out of his personal experience, and to invent a language of his own remote from the spoken word." -- W.H. Auden
Milton, even Milton, rankt with living men!
Over the highest Alps of mind he marches,
And far below him spring the baseless arches
Of Iris, colouring dimly lake and fen.
-- Walter Savage Landor
"His harmonicall and ingeniose Soul did lodge in a beautifull and well-proportioned body. He was a spare man ... He had abroun hayre. His complexion exceeding faire - he was so faire they called him the Lady of Christ's College. Ovall face. His eie a darke gray." -- John Aubrey
"Yet for two and a half centuries - even for a 'speaker' like Wordsworth - Milton's virtue was this language, which engaged and developed subjects difficult to combine, moral verities and the created world. The language of speech is not the only, or first, language of poetry. To criticize work in terms strictly irrelevant to it is of little value: a critical act of "brute assertive will", or a prejudice so ingrained as to be indistinguishable, for uncritical readers, from truth itself. With the decline of literacy, Milton, like Spenser, becomes a more difficult mountain to scale, more remote from the 'common reader'. Yet Chaucer and Shakespeare, the only poets in the tradition who are Milton's superiors, both grow and recede in the same way and are not dismissed. They seem more accessible. In the end Leavis's hostility, like Empson's and Richards's in other areas, is to the Christian content of the poems, and in Milton it is obtrusive and central. We read Herbert's and Donne's divine poems even if we are unbelievers: there is their doubt to engage, and the framed drama of specific situations. But Milton will not allow disbelief to go unchallenged: his structures and narratives are not rooted in individual faith but in universal belief. The question of revealed truth raises its head as in no other poet in the language." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
Milton! thou should'st be living at this hour:
England hath need of thee: she is a fen
Of stagnant waters: altar, sword and pen,
Fireside, the heroic wealth of hall and bower,
Have forfeited their ancieng English dower
Of inward happiness. We are selfish men;
Oh! raise us up, return to us again;
And give us manners, virtue, freedom, power.
Thy soul was like a Star and dwelt apart;
Thou hadst a voice whose sound was like the sea;
Pure as the naked heavens, majestic, free,
So didst thou travel on life's common way,
In cheerful godliness; and yet thy heart
The lowliest duties on itself lay.
-- Wordsworth
"In Milton the world of Spenser was reconfigured and almost unrecognisable ... What had been reasonable and courteous, a belief in the fact that men of culture and intellect will be able to engage in rational discussion and agree to disagree, had been displaced by faction and sometimes violent intolerance. The moderate had stood down and the fanatic had taken his place, in the pulpit, in Parliament, and on the very peaks of Parnassus." -- TS Eliot
"I take it to be my portion in this life, joined with a strong propensity of nature, to leave something so written to aftertimes, as they should not willingly let it die." -- John Milton
"I have bought a pocket Milton, which I carry perpetually about with me, in order to study the sentiments - the dauntless magnanimity, the intrepid, unyielding independence, the desperate daring, the noble defiance of hardship, in that great personage, SATAN." -- Robert Burns
"He was much more admired abrode than at home." -- John Aubrey
"My mind is not capable of forming a more august conception than arises from the contemplation of this greatest man in his latter days: poor, sick, old, blind, slandered, persecuted: 'Darkness before and danger's voice behind,' in an age in which he was as little understood by the party for whom, as by that against whom, he had contended, and among men before whom he strode so far as to dwarf himself by the distance; yet still listening to the music of his own thoughts, or, if additionally cheered, yet cheered only by the prophetic faith of two or three solitary individuals, he did nevertheless
... argue not
Against Heaven's hand or will, nor bate a jot
Of heart or hope; but still bore up and steer'd
Right onward."
-- Samuel Taylor Coleridge
"True musical delight consists only in apt numbers, fit quantity of syllables, and the sense variously drawn out from one verse to another." -- John Milton
"I cannot praise a fugitive and cloistered virtue, unexercised and unbreathed, that never sallies out and sees her adversary, but slinks out of the race where that immortal garland is to be run for, not without dust and heat. . . . That which purifies us is trial, and trial is by what is contrary. " - John Milton

From the essay "Slouching Towards Bethlehem" in the collection Slouching Towards Bethlehem:
The center was not holding. It was a country of bankruptcy notices and public-auction announcements and commonplace reports of casual killings and misplaced children and abandoned homes and vandals who misspelled even the four-letter words they scrawled. It was a country in which families routinely disappeared, trailing bad checks and repossession papers. Adolescents drifted from city to torn city, sloughing off both the past and the future as snakes shed their skins, children who were never taught and would never now learn the games that held the society together. People were missing. Children were missing. Parents were missing. Those left behind filed desultory missing-persons reports, then moved on themselves.It was not a country in open revolution. It was not a country under enemy siege. It was the United States of America in the cold late spring of 1967, and the market was steady and the GNP high and a great many articulate people seemed to have a sense of high social purpose and it might have been a spring of brave hopes and national promise, but it was not, and more and more people had the uneasy apprehension that it was not. All that seemed clear was that at some point we had aborted ourselves and butchered the job, and because nothing else seemed so relevant I decided to go to San Francisco. San Francisco was where the social hemorrhaging was showing up. San Francisco was where the missing children were gathering and calling themselves "hippies". When I first went to San Francisco in that cold late spring of 1967 I did not even know what I wanted to find out, and so I just stayed around awhile, and made a few friends.
From essay "Notes from a Native Daughter" from Slouching Towards Bethlehem:
You might protest that no family has been in the Sacramento Valley for anything approaching "always". But it is characteristic of Californians to speak grandly of the past as if it had simultaneously begun, tabula rasa, and reached a happy ending on the day the wagons started west. Eureka - "I Have Found It" - as the state motto has it. Such a view of history casts a certain melancholia over those who participate in it; my own childhood was suffused with the conviction that we had long outlived our finest hour. In fact that is what I want to tell you about: what it is like to come from a place like Sacramento. If I could make you understand that, I could make you understand California and perhaps something else besides, for Sacramento is California, and California is a place in which a boom mentality and a sense of Chekhovian loss meet in uneasy suspension; in which the mind is troubled by some buried but ineradicable suspicion that things had better work here, because here, beneath that immense bleached sky, is where we run out of continent.
From Play It As It Lays:
She had watched them in supermarkets and she knew the signs. At seven o'clock on a Saturday evening they would be standing in the checkout line reading the horoscope in Harper's Bazaar and in their carts would be a single lamb chop and maybe two cans of cat food and the Sunday morning paper, the early edition with the comics wrapped outside. They would be very pretty some of the time, their skirts the right length and their sunglasses the right tint and maybe only a little vulnerable tightness around the mouth, but there they were, one lamb chop and some cat food and the morning paper. To avoid giving off the signs, Maria shopped always for a household, gallons of grapefruit juice, quarts of green chile salsa, dried lentils and alphabet noodles, rigatoni and canned yams, twenty-pound boxes of laundry detergent. She knew all the indices to the idle lonely, never bought a small tube of toothpaste, never dropped a magazine in her shopping cart. The house in Beverly Hills overflowed with sugar, corn-muffin mix, frozen roasts and Spanish onions. Maria ate cottage cheese.
From Salvador:
At the time I was in El Salvador the hostilities at hand were referred to by those reporters still in the country as "the number-four war," after Beirut, Iran-Iraq, and the aftermath of the Falklands. So many reporters had in fact abandoned the Hotel Camino Real in San Salvador (gone home for a while, or gone to the Intercontinental in Managua, or gone to whatever hotels they frequented in Guatemala and Panama and Tegucigalpa) that the dining room had discontinued its breakfast buffet, a fact often remarked upon: no breakfast buffet meant no action, little bang-bang, a period of editorial indifference in which stories were filed and held, and film rarely made the network news. "Get an NBC crew up from the Falklands, we might get the buffet back," they would say, and "It hots up a little, we could have the midnight movies." It seemed that when the networks arrived in force they brought movies down, and showed them at midnight on their video recorders, Apocalypse Now, and Woody Allen's Bananas.

From The Year of Magical Thinking:
I remember thinking that I needed to discuss this with John.There was nothing I did not discuss with John.
Because we were both writers and both worked at home our days were filled with the sound of each other's voices.
I did not always think he was right nor did he always think I was right but we were the person the other trusted. There was no separation between our investments or interests in any given situation. Many people assumed that we must be, since sometimes one and sometimes the other would get the better review, the bigger advance, in some way "competitive", that our private life must be a minefield of professional envies and resentments. This was so far from the case that the general insistence on it came to suggest certain lacunae in the popular understanding of marriage.
That had been one more thing we discussed.
What I remember about the apartment the night I came home alone from New York Hospital was its silence.
In the plastic bag I had been given at the hospital there were a pair of corduroy pants, a wool shirt, a belt, and I think nothing else. The legs of the corduroy pants had been slit open, I suppose by the paramedics. There was blood on the shirt. The belt was braided. I remember putting his cell phone in the charger on his desk. I remember putting his silver clip in the box in the bedroom in which we kept passports and birth certificates and proof of jury service. I look now at the clip and see that these were the cards he was carrying: A New York State driver's license, due for renewal on May 25, 2004; a Chase ATM card; an American Express card; a Wells Fargo MasterCard; a Metropolitan Museum card; a Writers Guild of America West card (it was the season before Academy voting, when you could use a WGAW card to see movies free, he must have gone to a movie, I did not remember); a Medicare card; a Metro card; and a card issued by Medtronic with the legend "I have a Kappa 900 SR pacemaker implanted," the serial number of the device, a number to call for the doctor who implanted it, and the notation "Implant Date: 03 Jun 2003". I remember combining the cash that had been in his pocket with the cash in my own bag, smoothing the bills, taking special care to interleaf twenties with twenties, tens with tens, fives and ones with fives and ones. I remember thinking as I did this that he would see that I was handling things.
From Where I Was From:
Not much about California, on its own preferred terms, has encouraged its children to see themselves as connected to one another. The separation, of north from south - and even more acutely of west from east, of the urban coast from the agricultural valleys and of both the coast and the valleys from the mountain and desert regions to their east, was profound, fueled by the rancor of water wars and by less tangible but even more rancorous differences in attitude and culture. My mother made the trip from Sacramento to Los Angeles in 1932, to see the Olympics, and did not find reason to make it again for thirty years. In the north we had San Francisco, with its Beaux Arts buildings and eucalyptus, its yearning backward and westward, its resolutely anecdotal "color"; a place as remote and mannered as the melancholy colonial capitals of Latin America, and as isolated. When I was at Berkeley and had gone home to Sacramento for a weekend I would sometimes take the Southern Pacific's transcontinental City of San Francisco back down, not the most convenient train (for one thing it was always late) but one that suggested, carrying as it did the glamour of having come across the mountains from the rest of America, that our isolation might not be an indefinite sentence.
From Fixed Ideas: America Since 9.11:
Seven days after September 11, 2001, I left New York to do two weeks of book promotion, under other circumstances a predictable kind of trip. You fly into one city or another, you do half an hour on local NPR, you do a few minutes on drive-time radio, you do an "event", a talk or a reading or an onstage discussion. You sign books, you take questions from the audience. You go back to the hotel, order a club sandwich from room service, and leave a 5 AM call with the desk, so that in the morning you can go back to the airport and fly to the next city. During the week between September 11 and the Wednesday morning when I went to Kennedy to get on the plane, none of these commonplace aspects of publishing a book seemed promising or even appropriate things to be doing. But - like most of us who were in New York that week - I was in a kind of protective coma, sleepwalking through a schedule made when planning had still seemed possible. In fact I was protecting myself so successfully that I had no idea how raw we all were until that first night, in San Francisco, when I was handed a book onstage and asked to read a few marked lines from an essay about New York I had written in 1967.Later I remembered thinking: 1967, no problem, no land mines there.
I put on my glasses. I began to read.
"New York was no mere city," the marked lines began. "It was instead an infinitely romantic notion, the mysterious nexus of all love and money and power, the shining and perishable dream itself."
I hit the word "perishable" and I could not say it.
I found myself onstage at the Herbst Theater in San Francisco unable to finish reading the passage, unable to speak at all for what must have been thirty seconds.
From Miami:
In this mood Miami seemed not a city at all but a tale, a romance of the tropics, a kind of waking dream in which any possibility could and would be accommodated. The most ordinary morning, say at the courthouse, could open onto the distinctly lurid. "I don't think he came out with me, after all," i recall hearing someone say one day in an elevator at the Miami federal courthouse. His voice had kept rising. "What happened to all that stuff about how next time he gets twenty keys, he could run wherever-it-is-Idaho, now he says he wouldn't know what to do with five keys, what is this shit?" His companion had shrugged. Outside one courtroom that day a group of Colombians, the women in silk shirts and Chanel necklaces and Charles Jourdan suede pumps, the children in appliequed dresses from Baby Dior, had been waiting for the decision in a pretrial detention hearing, one in which the government was contending that the two defendants, who between them lived in houses in which eighty-three kilos of cocaine and a million-three in cash had been found, failed to qualify as good bail risks."That doesn't make him a longtime drug dealer," one of the two defense lawyers, both of whom were Anglo and one of whom drove a Mercedes 380 SEL with the license plate DEFENSE, had argued about the million-three in cash. "That could be one transaction." Across the hall that day closing arguments were being heard in a boat case, a "boat case" being one in which a merchant or fishing vessel has been boarded and drugs seized and eight or ten Colombian crew members arrested, the kind of case in which pleas were typically entered so that one of the Colombians would get eighteen months and the others deported. There were never any women in Chanel necklaces around a boat case, and the lawyers (who were usually hired and paid for not by the defendants but by the unnamed owner of the "load", or shipment) tended to be Cuban. "You had the great argument, you got to give me some good ideas," one of the eight Cuban defense lawyers on this case joked with the prosecutor during a recess. "But you haven't heard my argument yet," another of the defense lawyers said. "The stuff about communism. Fabulous closing argument."
From the essay "John Wayne: A Love Song", included in Slouching Towards Bethlehem:
We went three and four afternoons a week, sat on folding chairs in the darkened Quonset hut which served as a theater, and it was there, that summer of 1943, while the hot wind blew outside, that I first saw John Wayne. Saw the walk, heard the voice. Heard him tell the girl in a picture called War of the Wildcats that he would build her a house, "at the bend in the river where the cottonwoods grow". As it happened I did not grow up to be the kind of woman who is the heroine in a Western, and although the men I have known have had many virtues and have taken me to live in many places I have come to love, they have never been John Wayne, and they have never taken me to that bend in the river where the cottonwoods grow. Deep in that part of my heart where the artificial rain forever falls, that is still the line I wait to hear.I tell you this neither in a spirit of self-revelation nor as an exercise in total recall, but simply to demonstrate that when John Wayne rode through my childhood, and perhaps through yours, he determined forever the shape of certain of our dreams. It did not seem possible that such a man could fall ill, could carry within him that most inexplicable and ungovernable of diseases. The rumor struck some obscure anxiety, threw our very childhoods into question. In John Wayne's world, John Wayne was supposed to give the orders. "Let's ride," he said, and "Saddle up." "Forward ho," and "A man's gotta do what he's got to do." "Hello there," he said when he first saw the girl, in a construction camp or on a train or just standing around the front porch waiting for somebody to ride up through the tall grass. When John Wayne spoke, there was no mistaking his intentions; he had a sexual authority so strong that even a child could perceive it. And in a world we understood early to be characterized by venality and doubt and paralyzing ambiguities, he suggested another world, one which may or may not have existed ever but in any case existed no more: a place where a man could move free, could make his own code and live by it; a world in which, if a man did what he had to do, he could one day take the girl and go riding through the draw and find himself home free, not in a hospital with something going wrong inside, not in a high bed with the flowers and the drugs and the forced smiles, but there at the bend in the bright river, the cottonwoods shimmering in the early morning sun.
From Political Fictions:
The genuflection toward "fairness" is a familiar newsroom piety, in practice the excuse for a good deal of autopilot reporting and lazy thinking but in theory a benign ideal. In Washington, however, a community in which the management of news has become the single overriding preoccupation of the core industry, what "fairness" has often come to mean is a scrupulous passivity, an agreement to cover the story not as it is occurring but as it is presented, which is to say as it is manufactured.

From the essay "Girl of the Golden West" from After Henry:
Yet if the Hearsts were no longer a particularly arresting California family, they remained embedded in the symbolic content of the place, and for a Hearst to be kidnapped from Berkeley, the very citadel of Phoebe Hearst's aspiration, was California as opera. "My thoughts at this time were focused on the single issue of survival," the heiress to Wyntoon and San Simeon told us about the fifty-seven days she spent in the closet. "Concerns over love and marriage, family life, friends, human relationships, my whole previous life, had really become, in SLA terms, bourgeois luxuries."This abrupt sloughing of the past has, to the California ear, a distant echo, and the echo is of emigrant diaries. "Don't let this letter dishearten anybody, never take no cutoffs and hurry along as fast as you can," one of the surviving children of the Donner Party concluded her account of that crossing. "Don't worry about it," the author of Every Secret Thing reported having told herself in the closet after her first sexual encounter with a member of the SLA. "Don't examine your feelings. Never examine your feelings - they're no help at all." At the time Patricia Campbell Hearst was on trial in San Francisco, a number of psychiatrists were brought in to try to plumb what seemed to some an unsoundable depth in the narrative, that moment at which the victim binds over her fate to her captors. "She experienced what I call the death anxiety and the breaking point," Robert Jay Lifton, who was one of those psychiatrists, said. "Her external points of reference for maintenance of her personality had disappeared," Louis Jolyon West, another of the psychiatrists, said. Those were two ways of looking at it, and another was that Patricia Campbell Hearst had cut her losses and headed west, as her great-grandfather had before her.
From the essay "LA Noir from After Henry:
There was always in the Cotton Club case a certain dreamland aspect, a looniness that derived in part from the ardent if misplaced faith of everyone involved, from the belief in windfalls, in sudden changes of fortune (five movies and four books would change someone's fortune, a piece of The Cotton Club someone else's, a high-visibility case the district attorney's); in killings, both literal and figurative. In fact this kind of faith is not unusual in Los Angeles. In a city not only largely conceived as a series of real estate promotions but largely supported by a series of confidence games, a city even then afloat on motion pictures and junk bonds and the B-2 Stealth bomber, the conviction that something can be made of nothing may be one of the few narratives in which everyone participates. A belief in extreme possibilities colors daily life. Anyone might have woken up one morning and been discovered at Schwab's, or killed at Bob's Big Boy. "Luck is all around you," a silky voice says on the California State Lottery's Lotto commercials, against a background track of "Dream a Little Dream of Me". "Imagine winning millions ... what would you do?"
From the essay "The White Album" from The White Album:
We tell ourselves stories in order to live. The princess is caged in the consulate. The man with the candy will lead the children into the sea. The naked woman on the ledge outside the window on the sixteenth floor is a victim of accidie, or the naked woman is an exhibitionist, and it would be "interesting" to know which. We tell ourselves that it makes some difference whether the naked woman is about to commit a mortal sin or is about to register a political protest or is about to be, the Aristophanic view, snatched back to the human condition by the fireman in priest's clothing just visible in the window behind her, the one smiling at the telephoto lens. We look for the sermon in the suicide, for the social or moral lesson in the murder of five. We interpret what we see, select the most workable of the multiple choices. We live entirely, especially if we are writers, by the imposition of a narrative line upon disparate images, by the "ideas" with which we have learned to freeze the shifting phantasmagoria which is our actual experience.Or at least we do for a while.
Happy birthday to one of my favorite writers of all time.

Fantastic interview with Cormac McCarthy. Too rich to excerpt, just go read the whole thing. I'll just pull this bit out. He is asked what kind of response he has gotten to The Road from fathers:
I have the same letter from about six different people. One from Australia, one from Germany, one from England, but they all said the same thing. They said, "I started reading your book after dinner and I finished it 3:45 the next morning, and I got up and went upstairs and I got my kids up and I just sat there in the bed and held them."

Fantastic three-way interview with 81-year-old Maurice Sendak, Dave Eggers and Spike Jonze. Must-read!
What do you say to parents who think the Wild Things film may be too scary?
Sendak: I would tell them to go to hell. That's a question I will not tolerate.
That made me laugh out loud. I loved Sendak's story about who the "wild things" really are, where he got the inspiration (brilliant - all good art is personal). I also loved this bit. Because he's right. The soup needs to be hot, not warm. The fight had to be fought. He felt strongly about it, and he was right to feel strongly about it. But I love so much to get "backstage glimpses" of fights like these.
Sendak: I remember I was having fights with my editor about this book [Where the Wild Things Are].
What were the fights about?
Sendak: Well, I'll just give you a silly example. The entire staff at the publishing house were keen on my changing the word "hot" to "warm" on the last page. Because "hot" meant "burn."
Jonze: The soup was "still hot."
Sendak: It was going to burn the kid. I couldn't believe it. But it turned into a real world war, just that word, and I won.
How did you win?
Sendak: Just going at it. Just trying to convey how dopey "warm" sounded. Unemotional. Undramatic. Everything about that book is "hot."
Brilliant.
There will always be those (even those apparently in our corner) who want us to lower the stakes for ourselves. Who want us to soft-pedal certain things. Sometimes these people mean well, sometimes they do not. People, in general, are not comfortable being around things that will "burn" them. They mistakenly project that onto others ("children will be afraid of that which is hot ...") - not realizing that it is THEY who are uncomfortable with it. They don't ask the question, what am I reacting to here? Who exactly am I protecting? There is the curse of being "too much", too intense, too sensitive, and there will always be those who have a problem with that (even fellow artists). But you have to just stick to your guns, and keep moving, keep doing what you want to do, trusting that the audience will find you. That they will "get it". And of course Sendak was vindicated by the decades-long smash success of Where the Wild Things Are, with children around the world knowing it by heart, and somehow NOT being scarred for life imagining a bowl of hot soup and how it might burn them.
But I just love Sendak's comment:
"Everything about that book is 'hot'."
Definitely go read the whole thing. It's a goldmine. Love the discussion of kids movies, bringing up Truffaut's 400 Blows, and great conversation about Wizard of Oz too.
Nice way to start the day.
Earlier this year, I read Joan Acocella's essay about writer Hilary Mantel in her wonderful compilation of essays Twenty-eight Artists and Two Saints. Acocella's essay is online, it's called Devil's Work (it was originally published in The New Yorker, as most of these pieces were). I wrote about Acocella's book here. I wrote that Acocella has the gift of making me want to know more about whomever her subject is. The book includes profiles of dancers and choreographers, of course, because that is Acocella's main topic, but there are also numerous essays about writers, many of which I am not familiar with at all. She makes you want to rectify the gaps in your education IMMEDIATELY, and that, to me, is high high praise.
As I mentioned, one of the profiles in the book is Hilary Mantel, who just won the Booker Prize for fiction, for her Tudor-era novel Wolf Hall. I haven't read any Hilary Mantel, but boy, after reading Joan Acocella's piece, I thought: Get on the stick, girl! This was the case with so many of Acocella's essays! Italo Svevo, Stefan Zweig, Marguerite Yourcenar, Joseph Roth - the list goes on and on. Her main area of interest appears to be Jewish writers, writing at the time of the downfall of the Austro-Hungarian Empire. I am not familiar with those writers in the slightest. But she also has essays on Dorothy Parker, Simone de Beauvoir, H.L. Mencken, and Hilary Mantel.
Acocella writes of Mantel:
Mantel has experimented with her gift; her books jump from genre to genre. After Mother's Day and an even blacker sequel, Vacant Possession (1986), she wrote a political thriller about Saudi Arabia. Eight Months on Ghazza Street (1988), which announced, if her previous books had not, her grievance over the status of women. The next novel was Fludd (1989), a theological mystery story. Here the Devil appears in person - he is handsome, has money, and is terrific in bed. Later, there was a coming-of-age novel, An Experiment in Love (1995), and, on its heels, something wildly different, The Giant, O'Brien (1998), which, like A Place of Greater Safety, is set in the late eighteenth century, and concerns a freakishly tall Irishman who, starving at home (this was during the clearances), goes to London to make money by exhibiting himself as a curiosity. The book is biting in its politics and extravagant in its style. (The giant, a professional storyteller, often speaks in the language of Celtic romance.) In 2003, Mantel published her memoir, which, for all its useful information, I admire less than her other books, because it alone seems to complain. In her novels, Mantel is unflinching, and I like her that way.
I don't know about you, but that paragraph makes me very VERY interested in Mantel.
And so, congratulations to a writer I am only familiar with through Acocella, for winning the Booker. Mantel has not had an easy life. She has poured that difficulty into her books, which are the opposite of confessional (one of the reasons why I think I might like her stuff). When Mantel was a child, she saw the Devil standing by her back fence.
It has no edges, no mass, no dimension, no shape except the formless; it moves. I beg it, stay away, stay away. Within the space of a thought it is inside me, and has set up a sick resonance within my bones and in all the cavities of my body.
Strange, to feel a connection with a writer I have never read. Here is a really enjoyable interview with her, about winning the Booker. I just really like her, as a person. She says
“It’s a very odd thing because you prepare for failure, so two of you go to the Booker dinner – the one who is going to win and the one who is going to lose. And I’m not quite sure if I’ve shaken off my double yet. I’m still living in two realities. It really is a big thing. I would never try to be cool about it. You know it is going to change your career.�
I love that.
And the last quote from her in the article, about the sequel to Wolf Hall she is working on, brought tears to my eyes:
People have been saying, 'Hurry up’. One lady expressed a wish that the sequel would come along soon and put 'PS I am 94’. It made me feel very responsible. I hope she’ll read it by 96.
"PS I am 94."
I am grateful to Joan Acocella for introducing me to Hilary Mantel, even just as a person, and I look forward to all the catchup work I have to do.
Here is my post on haunting poet and novelist Elinor Wylie.
I am still unable to read any one thing for a long stretch of time. It is rather disturbing, and I keep NOT finishing books. I have NOT finished about 20 books this year, and it is so unlike me. But then nothing is normal now. At the moment, among other things, I am picking my way through the Selected Letters of Rebecca West. She is one of my intellectual and creative idols, and an email exchange I recently had with The Siren involved Rebecca West - I love coincidences like that. Today, I came across a lengthy letter West wrote to author Nancy Potter, who was working on a biography of Elinor Wylie. West and Wylie had been friends, and Potter had some questions for West about it. Here is her response.
One of the things I love about the letters of famous figures, is how they talk about one another. I have an entire "commonplace book" filled with quotes of "writers on writing". Robert Louis Stevenson talking about Cervantes, e.e. cummings talking about Shakespeare - I find these insights into the creative process (from those in the same field) immensely rewarding to read.
Here, West is not talking so much about Wylie the artist - but I do find it a very wonderfully drawn portrait of another human being. The quote below about Wylie's "egotism" reminds me of that awesome Bette Davis quote: "I was thought to be 'stuck up'. I wasn't. I was just sure of myself. This is and always has been an unforgivable quality to the unsure." Preach it. Do not let the envious comments of the unsure throw you off YOUR game.
2 November 1953
To: Nancy Potter
Dear Miss Potter,
So far as I know I have no letters from Elinor Wylie. We had a steady friendship, which was renewed every time we met at exactly the point where it had been when we had last met, and we rarely wrote except to confirm a date or give a friend's address. My files are in great disorder, owing to the war and to post-war irregularities, and I can't be sure. But I really don't think I can have anything that would interest you.
During her last trip to England she made no comment to me that indicated that she was specially annoyed with anything but the fact that she had fallen downstairs, or that she was frustrated with anything but the fact that she could not get about as much as usual. You are on very sound ground when you say that "she often appeared to be playing frantically with life to make each year count." I don't really believe, however, that people are right when they lay stress on this as an indication of a neurosis. I am sure that her conduct was largely dictated by her appallingly high blood-pressure. She must, for years and years, have been feeling quite dreadfully ill, and was racing to get away from her own discomfort.
I know she was an egotist. But so are most people who achieve a great deal, or rather who push their achievement above a certain level. It often seemed to me that when other people called her egotistical when she was being honest - she was exceptionally beautiful, she was exceptionally gifted, and it would have been stupid of her not to have known this. Her self-knowledge was expressed often in febrile terms, but really she had enough blood-pressure to make this understandable. It seems to me that it would be dangerous to consider Elinor Wylie without taking into account the extraordinary spitefulness of the age in which she lived. Looking back at it, the world seems to me to have been overfull of people who spent their lives saying, "We went to the Smith's party last night - it was just terrible," or "Have you met Freda Jones, we met her last night - she is just terrible," with a screech on the terrible that I recognized during the war in the wail of the air-raid sirens. The gentler and more civilised the Smiths or Freda Brown might be the more the screech. Elinor Wylie was the chosen victim of the screechers. I daresay she often behaved tiresomely. But twice it happened to me that I was at a party with Elinor where she was gay and funny and brilliant, and that a few nights later I went to a cocktail party where people who had not been at that party described the ludicrous remarks Elinor had made at it and what a nuisance she had been.
She had an enormous sense of duty. It hurt her tremendously that she had failed in her duties as a step-mother; and of course she had failed, she was as unsuited to be a step-mother as any romantic character would be. She seemed to me to be often arrogant in her judgment of other people, but arrogant only in the sense that she dismissed people for lacking certain qualities before she had looked round to see if they had any other qualities; when those other qualities hit her in the eye she was just and humble. Once she met a friend of mine at my room in the old Majestic and spoke of her afterwards with candid contempt, wondering why I cared for this woman. I arranged for them to meet again, under better circumstances, as the woman adored Elinor's work and wanted to ask her permission to do something with one of her poems; and she got on to her character this time, and rang me up and admitted her error very handsomely (Not because she knew the woman wanted to do something with one of her poems - the woman hadn't then mentioned it). And though she was arrogant I don't remember her ever being spiteful. I should have been very much surprised indeed if she had ever repeated to me a story about anybody which was even slanted, and I could not have believed it if anybody had ever accused Elinor of inventing a story against anybody, though that was the vice of the time. As you know, she had a very uneasy relationship (this is an example of British understatement) with Kathleen Norris. She always spoke of her, even in her most confidential moments, with reserve, with a well-bred blankness.
You know, of course, the incident that touched off the explosion in her early life, when she left her first husband and her child. I haven't any reason to disbelieve it, but I have no authority but Elinor's own statement, which however she repeated to me several times. She always repeated it in the same form, though many other items in the context in which this story was embedded varied considerably. Apparently, after her father died, it was discovered that he had been in love with a woman who was not his wife, over a period of many years. Elinor described the scene of this discovery with deep feeling, and always expected me to take it for granted that when you found that your father had been in love with someone not your mother, why, of course, you left your own husband, you just had to, you were so upset. The thing came up as strong and clear as a Racine play. Quite beyond argument. It was something she could no more help than her blood-pressure.
The wonderful thing about Elinor, which none of you who did not know her will ever realise, was her astonishing beauty; which was as significant, as much of a bridge beyond the real and the imaginary world, as the beauty of Rosamund Lehmann. I don't suppose she had anything to give that had a higher value than that, it was sublime; and to me it appeared not at all a sexual beauty, it made not a heterosexual or homosexual appeal, it made an imaginative appeal. About her relationships - I don't know enough about them. But I fancy you would find that the people who knew her best liked her best, that her apparent victims would always speak of her with tenderness and affection.
I hear people speaking and writing of her in a patronising spirit. I must own that I found it delightful to know her, and thought and think that she did me considerable honour by wanting to know me.
I hope you have a happy time with your study, and I wish you could have received a letter from me saying, "Yes, indeed, I have a correspondence with Elinor Wylie rather larger in bulk than the Holmes-Laski letters." But, alas, I have always had too many family ties to get on with my writing or my letter-writing as I would have wished.
Yours sincerely,
So says Irish writer John Banville in this awesome recent interview about his new book that has set my mind spinning. There's so much in it. So much to think about.
There are only a couple of writers today where I wait for their latest to come out with baited breath. I scour Amazon and Google to make sure I haven't missed anything. Like the good old days when I pored over TV Guide on a weekly basis to make sure that if Orphan Train was on repeat on some channel, even at 3 in the morning, I would know about it! Some authors (like Nancy Lemann) require much patience because she's only written five books in the last 20 years. For the most part there is silence from her - and she's just one of my favorites, ever. But I will not forget. I remain loyal. There are others, a short list:
A.S. Byatt (you write a book like Possession, and I don't care, I'll read your grocery list. But then there are her short story collections with masterpieces like this - she just excites me tremendously - can't wait to read her latest - Booker-nominated, naturally)
Katherine Dunn (talk about patience. Sheesh, lady!)
Michael Chabon (even his genre stuff, which I don't think is as good. Posts here, here, here, and here.)
Annie Proulx (still haven't read her latest collection, but I am very excited to. Posts here, here, here, here).
Nancy Lemann (Yes, dear gentle Southern comic writer ... you may not have had a giant world-wide hit, but seriously, you got it going on. I will read whatever you write. Posts here, here, here, here, here. You want a lovely read? Pick up Nancy Lemann.)
John Irving (I've been reading this guy since I was 16 years old. He still excites me. Posts here, here, and here.)
Mary Gaitskill (She scares me, unlike any other writer. She's off the charts. She has a new one out too. I just can't read fiction right now. Posts here, here, here, here - and this - my favorite story of hers. Ouch.)
Cormac McCarthy (naturally. If you're not already reading this man, I don't know what to say to you! Posts here, and here).
Lorrie Moore (whose latest book is now taking up all the airwaves at the moment and I am so excited about it - and also avoiding all reviews like the plague - not easy to do, since they are EVERYWHERE - until I am able to read fiction again myself - her latest book is the first on my list when I get back on my feet. Posts about her here, here)
Then we've got the non-fiction people, people who are always on my radar for their latest:
Joan Didion (excerpt here - hm, strangely I haven't written much about her. She is huge to me.)
Robert Kaplan (posts about this wonderful writer here, here, here - there are also his columns in The Atlantic Monthly, which I never miss)
Joseph Ellis (a couple posts here, and here)
A. Scott Berg (posts here, here, and here)
Fouad Ajami (marvelous writer, he's pretty much everywhere - post about one of his books here)

And John Banville - what can I say about John Banville that others haven't said? It's kind of a bittersweet thing for me. John Banville makes me lonely now. I see articles and interviews, and it makes me feel lonely, because I can't share it. His latest is coming out, and so the press begins, because why wouldn't it. As far as I'm concerned, he stands alone - not just in his gift as a writer, but in his fluidity with that gift. There's something CRANKY about him that reminds me a little bit about Dean Stockwell, unafraid to talk about the bad side of the business, never comes off as "whining" (my least favorite word, used by my least favorite people), but as an honest observer of the trials and tribulations of his own chosen field. Stockwell didn't find peace and happiness in acting until he was almost 50. The dude made his debut at age 7. So imagine. He HAPPENED to be good at something (acting), but that didn't amount to much. He tried other things, other careers, but it kept drawing him back. Then, late 40s, he started having some FUN, and the fun has never stopped. Not that Banville was just enduring his writing career until his creation of his pseudonym Benjamin Black (more on that here) - of course not. Banville's a heavy-hitter as he is. His books matter. Everyone talks about them. He's at the top of the heap. But if you read all of Banville's stuff (in order, preferably), and then - you read Christine Falls (by Benjamin Black), it's like: where the hell did THAT come from, and the only appropriate response, really, is to just bow down in awe before the maestro. I don't want to paint this with too wide a brush - but another one of my favorite writers, Michael Chabon, also publishes "genre" books, in an attempt to "rescue" genres from being sidelined. A lovely impulse, but perhaps best reserved for fan-fic. It feels like potboilers to me. Like Chabon, having exhausted himself with Kavalier and Clay (and seriously, I'm exhausted just THINKING about even TRYING to write a book as amazing as that) - wants to just relax. And more power to him. I'll just wait around, as he scribbles away, amusing himself ... but there's a sense (and I know I may be in the minority here) that he's just messing around until he gets back to REAL work. Rather ironic, when you consider that Chabon is a huge champion of genre fiction (mysteries, science fiction, fantasy.) To me, his "genre" stuff just doesn't come off. His latest, about the Yiddish Policeman's Union, is supposed to be a Philip Marlowe gumshoe type book, and in interviews he talks about how fun it was to do that hard-boiled Dashiell Hammett prose, and Brendan and I were laughing about how much he DOESN'T do in the book what he said he did. His sentences are more intricate in that book than in any other of his works. His fantasy of himself as a writer, in that book anyway, was that he was being hard-boiled and blunt, but the reality is that he was wordy and flowery and descriptive as always. Again, I don't begrudge him his experiments, and there is always something to love about ANY Michael Chabon book, but it feels like just that, an experiment.
Whereas John Banville (or should I say Benjamin Black) appears to have so immersed himself in the world of a 1950s alcoholic Dublin detective that you would barely know it was by the same writer. There are certain Banville touches, he's good no matter what he does, but Christine Falls is the work of a great chameleon. It's Meryl Streep submerging herself in accents and homework so that she can then let it all go when the camera is rolling. A.S. Byatt has a similar thing, only she does it in a more "meta" way, by weaving in different types of narrative (letters, scholarly papers, scrapbooks) into the more traditional linear narrative. Banville sticks with the straight story, but you hold Christine Falls up next to The Sea, and it just astonishing the difference. There is nothing in Christine Falls that feels ironic, arch, or experimental. He has submerged himself completely.
Christine Falls is one of the best books I read last year (I read it in one sitting), and the interviews with John Banville during that time are beyond illuminating. I remember my dad saying, "It sounds like he's having so much fun."
Banville's other works (the ones written by "him") are unrelentingly sad (at least I find them so). (Here's a post I wrote about The Sea.)
Here's a link, again, to the interview with Banville that set my mind spinning. I suppose I, too, like the interviewer, "feel like I am in At Swim-two-Birds". What a slicing intelligence he has, what integrity. He's cranky, but he is not unkind. He is precise. He is also emotional. He refers to his writing as his "succubus". This gives you some idea. He contradicts himself, which is the best part. He says one thing in one thought, and then another in another context. His response to all of this is rather amusing, and in a small way I relate - by those who do not seem to understand (or respect) "context". These are the people who try to play "gotcha" with comments you have made, ignoring the contexts. "But you said THIS here, how could you say THIS now??" All one can say in response (in my opinion) is either:
"A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds", which pretty much ends the conversation - that's why I use it -
OR
"Do I contradict myself? Very well then I contradict myself, (I am large, I contain multitudes.)" That about says it all.
There will be those who will never understand that.
There will be those who don't understand Banville's "experiment" with Benjamin Black, thinking that this might somehow lessen his serious reputation.
There will be those who will never understand context. Nuance. Also, you know, that little human quality known as "changing one's mind".
I very much enjoy watching Banville dodge labels and classifications here, without being overly surly or contemptuous. But he will resist the noose. That is his right, as a man certainly, but also as an artist. I don't think it can be under-estimated either, the length of the shadow cast by James Joyce, and how Irish authors, unlike American authors, struggle with that. Anne Enright is very funny on this topic as well. Blessing and a curse, you know. Almost every single interview with a contemporary Irish author brings up James Joyce. Imagine. There really is no equivalent in American literature. He is omnipresent. Annoying. Yet something that has to be dealt with, incorporated somehow.
I am working on a project right now that is taking up all of my intellectual time. If I have a slow moment, my mind circles back to it. I'm in the thick of it now. It has been read by some, I am editing and creating as I go, and there are things I am working on. There are problems that need to be solved.
The quote that I chose to put in the title of this post really sliced to the heart of the matter:
"We don't know anything about other people. We can only know them from the outside. This is one of the great joys of life."
It seems to me that that is the thing. That is THE THING that I am trying to get at. But to write about it, to capture that ... and not just the sense of alienation and separation - but also (so Irish!) - that last bit: that "this is one of the great joys of life" - Ouch, what a complex and beautiful thought. It has been with me all day.
I think that's what I need to think about. I mean, I have been, that is exactly what I have been working on in this project - but it had been a bit muddy. I was reaching out in the dark for it, and there it is, boiled down - into the beautiful Banville clarity - bleak and yet somehow redemptive.
Can't wait to read his latest.
I'm just glad he's out there. Makes me feel happy. Yes, lonely too. But I love him.
Two things can exist at the same time.

The poet Hilda Doolittle (known as H.D.) was born in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania on September 10, 1886.
It is difficult for me to really realize that she was born in Pennsylvania and not Liverpool, her name sounds so My Fair Lady-ish. She spent the majority of her life outside of America, but she was, indeed, American-born. Known as "H.D.", she is another one of those poets who benefited from her friendship (and also, sometimes love-affair with) Ezra Pound (more on Pound here). She had met him early on in America, and once she got to England, he arranged the introductions necessary to get her close to the heart of those with pull and power. Pound was at the center of the literary circles in Europe, and he was instrumental in introducing her into that world. She was also very good friends with Marianne Moore (more on her here) - I think their friendship dated back to college - they both went to Bryn Mawr.
H.D. was at the center of the Imagist movement in poetry, and is thought of as its finest representation. She lived long, however, and died in 1961, so her poetry moved on from its Imagist phase - and her most prolific and successful time as a poet was in the 50s and 60s. Pretty amazing. Her first poems were published in 1913.
When you read even a sketch of her biography, it is amazing the people with whom she intersected. She had one of those lives. She lived near the center of all of the literary and cultural upheaval of the time. She hung out with Amy Lowell, and Ford Madox Ford. Amy Lowell was responsible for bringing H.D.'s work to America.
H.D. was married, but it didn't work out. She had a long relationship with D.H. Lawrence, before finally settling down with Bryher, a woman - her companion for years, until she died. The two moved to Paris, where they hung out with the literary ex-pat community (I mean, what I would not give for a time machine, to go hang out at one of the cafes or bars with all those poetic ex-Americans whooping it up!), and also got involved in the burgeoning business of film-making, forming a production company. So not only did H.D. hang out with Hemingway and Gertrude Stein, but also Sergei Eisenstein.
As if all of that isn't enough, H.D. suffered a couple of nervous breakdowns and it was recommended to her that she start analysis (a revolutionary idea at the time). She was given the name of a psychiatrist. You know, maybe he could help her out with her problems. That dude's name was Sigmund Freud.
Okay, enough with her personal life which could fill several books.
H.D. had a lifelong love affair with all things classical, and made many pilgrimages to Greece. It was her main inspiration.
Here's a really nice post from Ted about H.D. Some great links to follow with more information about this fascinating talented woman.
Like the rest of the Imagists, H.D. was interested in direct expression (even more so than her contemporaries) - their way of rebelling against the Victorian curlycues and lengthy sentimental descriptions. H.D., at times, seems to be experimenting with how few words she can actually use. Pare it down, pare it down. Her early poems have real energy. They almost look like fragments - reminiscent of Emily Dickinson (at least what the poems look like on the page) - and H.D.'s intellectual and emotional obsession with all things Hellenic come into play here. It is almost as though those Imagist poems are fractured statues from ancient Greece - perfect, eloquent, simple, and evocative. They look like what they evoke. H.D.'s idol was Sappho (not hard to imagine why), and her overriding desire was to be overwhelmed (which explains her interest in mysticism later in her life). She wanted the poem to act as an agent, something that would not only transport her, but obliterate her. She seeked transcendence, a state of being that was exalted, high-flung. Not easy to sustain.
I love H.D.'s description of Pound from Glenn Hughes' Imagism and the Imagists. Here, Pound acts like an agent, an old-school theatrical agent or manager, wrestling her into position - pushing her towards the "new" - and even giving her her new and mysterious moniker:
Ezra Pound was very kind and used to bring me (literally) armfuls of books to read ... I did a few poems that I don't think Ezra liked ... but later he was beautiful about my first authentic verses .. .and sent my poems in for me to Miss Monroe [the editor of Poetry magazine]. He signed them for me, 'H.D., Imagiste.' The name seems to have stuck somehow.
H.D.'s poems, stark and simple as they are, reverberate with energy, anguish, and power. She's marvelous.
Here's her poem "Helen", written in 1924.
Helen
All Greece hates
the still eyes in the white face,
the lustre as of olives
where she stands,
and the white hands.
All Greece reviles
the wan face when she smiles,
hating it deeper still
when it grows wan and white,
remembering past enchantments
and past ills.
Greece sees, unmoved,
God's daughter, born of love,
the beauty of cool feet
and slenderest knees,
could love indeed the maid,
only if she were laid,
white ash amid funereal cypresses.
Heat
O WIND, rend open the heat,
cut apart the heat,
rend it to tatters.
Fruit cannot drop
through this thick air--
fruit cannot fall into heat
that presses up and blunts
the points of pears
and rounds the grapes.
Cut the heat--
plough through it,
turning it on either side
of your path.
And I love her poem "Lethe". I love its incantatory rhythm. It's almost frightening in its repetitive quality.
Lethe
NOR skin nor hide nor fleece
Shall cover you,
Nor curtain of crimson nor fine
Shelter of cedar-wood be over you,
Nor the fir-tree
Nor the pine.
Nor sight of whin nor gorse
Nor river-yew,
Nor fragrance of flowering bush,
Nor wailing of reed-bird to waken you,
Nor of linnet,
Nor of thrush.
Nor word nor touch nor sight
Of lover, you
Shall long through the night but for this:
The roll of the full tide to cover you
Without question,
Without kiss.

Happy birthday, H.D.!
I was riveted and moved by this analysis of Frankenstein as a treatise on loneliness - not to mention intrigued by the new edition (which I must get). The new edition includes Percy Shelley's edits (and I agree with Thomas - it does sound to me like the edits were not of the formal variety, but passed back and forth while they were sitting in the same room together) and I am dying to take a look.
There is a sense that someone (an "ideal reader", I guess) can make you better, can make you go deeper into your work, can RE-SAY what you have already said - but in a more piercing manner because they (the one who didn't write the original) aren't as close to the material. The whole "did Mary Shelley write the book" controversy is old news, I won't go over it - what I really responded to here is the image of intimacy and generosity - that the edits given to her by her lover were not just bossy corrections of something she hadn't said well (and in some cases, he said it worse). The edits show just how deeply he GOT what she was "going for".
Yet he also helped with some of the novel's most moving lines: the monster's appeal to his creator for affection. "Remember that I am thy creature—Thy Adam—or rather the fallen angel for every where I see bliss while I alome [sic] am irrecoverably wretched," Mary had written. Percy altered it: "Remember that I am thy creature—I ought to be thy Adam—but I am rather the fallen angel, whom thou drivest from joy for no misdeed; everywhere I see bliss from which I alone am irrevocably excluded." Percy grasped what lay beneath Mary's language and pulled it to the surface. "I ought to be thy Adam," the creature says—but his creator rejected him before his mate was made. He is not inhuman because he was brought to life on a surgical table. He is inhuman because he is alone.
"I ought to be thy Adam" is so much more tragic and, well, human, than "I am thy creature - thy Adam" - and it brings me to tears.
To examine Percy's edits is not to take anything away from Mary Shelley - and much of the controversy has swirled around that particular point. What I liked about this article was its picture of generosity between them - there is no need that anything would be taken away from Mary, just because Percy scratched away at her prose, editing it, or making suggestions. The idea was hers and hers alone.
Loneliness does make "monsters" of people. It warps what could be straight. Not should be straight, because there are no shoulds, not when it comes to life experience. But what COULD be straight, if given the chance.
After cloistering himself to bring dead flesh to life, Victor Frankenstein condemns his creature to loneliness. The creature does the same to him in revenge. Solitude makes monsters of both.
Wonderful article. I highly recommend the whole thing.
"I'm very conscious of my decline in popularity, but I don't permit it to stop me because I have the example of so many playwrights before me. I know the dreadful notices Ibsen got. And O'Neill -- he had to die to make 'Moon' successful. And to me it has been providential to be an artist, a great act of providence that I was able to turn my borderline psychosis into creativity -- my sister Rose did not manage this. So I keep writing. I am sometimes pleased with what I do -- for me, that's enough."
Boy did I need this today. The annual Bulwer-Lytton prize for bad writing has been awarded. It's one of my favorite times of the year (I also love the "bad sex writing" award - another fave). People are invited to submit opening lines to imaginary bad books (in honor of Edward George Earl Bulwer-Lytton - a longtime favorite of Lucy Maud Montgomery, who once was famous and beloved, and now is mainly known for his purple prose and perhaps the most famous opening line in history: "It was a dark and stormy night".)
This year's winner (David McKenzie) goes off the damn deep end with so many truncated "ing's" that you want to punch someone in the throat. It's killing me, the ridiculousness of it, and the beauty of the insane mind who would think it up. Bravo.
"Folks say that if you listen real close at the height of the full moon, when the wind is blowin' off Nantucket Sound from the nor' east and the dogs are howlin' for no earthly reason, you can hear the awful screams of the crew of the "Ellie May," a sturdy whaler Captained by John McTavish; for it was on just such a night when the rum was flowin' and, Davey Jones be damned, big John brought his men on deck for the first of several screaming contests."
You can read the list of winners here (they have a ton of different categories).
For example, here's the winner for "Historical Fiction":
The Cunard "Carinthia" glided through the starry waters of the Bering Sea, 843 passengers aboard, including Harriet Dobbs, resignedly single for over a decade, while a nautical mile due west slunk the K-18 submarine, under the command of lonely Ukrainian Captain First Rank Nikolai Shevchenko: ships that passed in the night (although the second technically a boat).
Others I love:
"I want you to follow my husband," said my newest client, the enigmatic Mrs Yogi, estranged wife of the Maharishi Mahesh Yogi.
I don't know why that is so funny but it is.
Or this:
There were earthquakes in this land, terrible tsunamis that swirled flooding torrents of water throughout, and constant near-blizzard conditions, and not for the first time, Horatio Jones wished he did not live inside a snow globe.
And then this:
Lady Rowena, fresh from her bath, knew she had time to be ready to meet the Prince at 6:00 o'clock even though the mantle clock was striking six, because the brass escapement lever mechanism that engages the teeth of the large gear which drives the smaller gears that send the hour and minute hands on their circular paths, was worn.
And here is one that made me laugh out loud. A true gift on this mainly rotten day.
Category? Western.
He was the desert nightmare whose name no one dared breathe, this deadly gun-slinger Garth Tedder, whose face struck terror in the hearts of man and beast, its macabre, round, maroon cheeks almost exactly like the pickled beets that farmers' wives force-fed their horrified families.
I have read that 10 times and I love it more each time.

Genius writer Katherine Dunn talks about her new book on boxing (which she has reported on for decades) in this recent interview. Her honesty is, of course, startling, raw, and refreshing. She's brilliant. She makes the rest of the goddamn world just seem so insufferably POLITE. Well, the rest of the world can have their little social interactions that keeps everyone safe and secure, they can have their little acceptable lies they tell one another - about the world and about themselves. Count me out.
I love her thoughts on ... well, everything.
I love that she acknowledges brokenness as not just part of the human condition, but its very essence. Brokenness is not the end. Brokenness is just the way things are. Like Auden wrote, "You shall love your crooked neighbor with your crooked heart."
That's all we can do. Yearning for straightness and wholeness (after a certain point, I mean) is a weakness. It is the desire for utopia, which is a delusion.
Geek Love has, in its title, its message. It is love, pure and simple. Crooked bodies and crooked hearts and what it means to love. For the most part, love given will not be received. At least not received in full by the one it is given to. It will be rejected, or brushed off, or ignored, or laughed at. Or, worst of all, not understood to be as deep and true as it is. But love should be given anyway. And that's what makes a wreckage of life, and yet that is also what makes it most worth living. But please. Let's not just skip over that whole "wreckage" part and try to pretend that these are two equal halves. They are not. Katherine Dunn understands that. She understands that heartwrenching struggle. It is that which breaks us. Geek Love was all about that, but what I find really interesting is her perspective on boxing, and how many of us need that hard tough persona. It is undervalued today, especially in certain sectors. But it has its uses. It is one of the most important survival skills we can practice. Yes, the risk is that the hardness of the outer shell will go deep into the core. Oh well. There are risks in everything.
Wishing that we were not "geeks" (ie: broken) is a waste of time.
I love her for getting that. And putting it into words like nobody else.
Here are my thoughts on Geek Love.
Her new book is called One Ring Circus: Dispatches from the World of Boxing. Can't wait to read it.

William Butler Yeats was born yesterday, in 1865. Yeats is a great poet and all that, but I grew up pretty much "over" him because he was kind of omnipresent in our household. We were made to memorize his epitaph in order to receive 25 cents for our allowance. ("Cast a cold eye / On life on death / Horseman pass by"). We knew his "Host of the Air" by heart, because it was on the Clancy Brothers at Carnegie Hall album. He was everywhere. It's not that we had a reverence for him - just the opposite. I knew what he looked like, in the same way I knew what George Washington looked like, because he was on our currency. Yeats? Oh, HIM again? Cast a cold eye ... yeah, I know, I know.
Yeats makes me think of my father. My first published piece in The Sewanee Review was about the Yeats-dad continuum.
From memory now!
THE HOST OF THE AIR
O'Driscoll drove with a song
The wild duck and the drake
From the tall and the tufted reeds
Of the drear Heart Lake.
And he saw how the reeds grew dark
At the coming of night-tide,
And dreamed of the long dim hair
Of Bridget his bride.
He heard while he sang and dreamed
A piper piping away,
And never was piping so sad,
And never was piping so gay.
And he saw young men and young girls
Who danced on a level place,
And Bridget his bride among them,
With a sad and a gay face.
The dancers crowded about him
And many a sweet thing said,
And a young man brought him red wine
And a young girl white bread.
But Bridget drew him by the sleeve
Away from the merry bands,
To old men playing at cards
With a twinkling of ancient hands.
The bread and the wine had a doom,
For these were the host of the air;
He sat and played in a dream
Of her long dim hair.
He played with the merry old men
And thought not of evil chance,
Until one bore Bridget his bride
Away from the merry dance.
He bore her away in his arms,
The handsomest young man there,
And his neck and his breast and his arms
Were drowned in her long dim hair.
O'Driscoll scattered the cards
And out of his dream awoke:
Old men and young men and young girls
Were gone like a drifting smoke;
But he heard high up in the air
A piper piping away,
And never was piping so sad,
And never was piping so gay.
To those of you who know that Clancy Brothers album - you'll know the special-ness of that recording.
When we visited his grave in Ireland, as kids, we all felt kind of amazed that ... it was REAL. That the epitaph we had been rattling off since we were toddlers actually existed out in the world, and had some meaning beyond the 25 cents in our pockets.
A couple years ago, I read his complete works in chronological order. It was a fascinating experience - I know many of his big poems almost by heart, the famous ones - but it's nothing compared to reading his work - from beginning to end. You watch an artist burst forth at a certain point - almost fully formed. You've read his younger work, you've seen its beauty (but also its sentimentality - its Celtic twilight "twee" lament ... it's actually quite awful in a way... and so nothing - NOTHING - can prepare you for the poet who would eventually write "Sailing to Byzantium" and "Among Schoolchildren" Where the hell did THAT come from?)
Yeats, as a poet, has always been one of my favorites (even with the "cloud-pale eyelids" balderdash of his early stuff), but what really inspires me is his work in Irish theatre, and the creation of the Abbey. An amazing story. His Nobel lecture was on the Irish Dramatic Movement. I wrote a big long post about his nurturing of John Synge, author of The Playboy of the Western World. Synge, as a young man, was a floundering artist bohemian type - until Yeats got a hold of him, and told him to go stay on the Aran Islands for a while, to discover the real Irish people. The result? A revolution in Irish theatre.
Gabriel Fallon, an actor at the Abbey, describes the dress rehearsal of Sean O'Casey's Juno and the Paycock
in his book Sean Ocasey the Man I Knew - a wonderful theatrical anecdote, I love how Lady Gregory talks to Yeats here:
We could make nothing of the reading of Juno and the Paycock as it was called. It seemed to be a strange baffling mixture of comedy and tragedy; and none of us could say, with any certainty, whether or not it would stand up on the stage.The dress rehearsal would be held at 5 p.m. on March 2, Sunday. I arrived at the theatre at 4:30 p.m., and found the author there before me looking rather glum and wondering if a rehearsal would take place ... Gradually the players filed in and went to their dressing-rooms. Lennox Robinson arrived shortly before 5 o'clock and was followed by Yeats and Lady Gregory. The curtain rose about 5:36 p.m. so far as I could see and hear while waiting for my cue in the wings the rehearsal seemed to be proceeding smoothly. As soon as I had finished my part of Bentham at the end of the second act I went down into the stalls and sat two seats behind the author. Here for the first time I had an opportunity of seeing something of the play from an objective point of view. I was stunned by the tragic quality of the third act which the magnificent playing of Sara Allgood made almost unbearable. But it was the blistering irony of the final scene which convinced me that this man sitting two seats in front of me was a dramatist of genius, one destined to be spoken of far beyond the confines of the Abbey Theatre ...
We watched the act move on, the furniture removers come and go, the ominous entry of the IRA men, the dragging of Johnny to summary execution, the stilted scene between Jerry Devine and Mary Boyle, and then as with the ensnaring slow impetus of a ninth great wave Allgood's tragic genius rose to an unforgettable climax and drowned the stage in sorrow. How surely was the very butt and sea-mark of tragedy! But suddenly the curtain rises again: are Fitzgerald and McCormick fooling, letting off steam after the strain of rehearsal? Nothing of the kind; for we in the stalls are suddenly made to freeze in our seats as a note beyond tragedy, a blistering flannel-mouthed irony sears its maudlin way across the stage and slowly drops an exhausted curtain on a world disintegrating in 'chassis'.
I sat there stunned. So, indeed, as far as I could see, did Robinson, Yeats, and Lady Gregory. Then Yeats ventured an opinion. He said that the play, particularly in the final scene, reminded him of a Dostoevsky novel. Lady Gregory turned to him and said, "You know, Willie, you never read a novel by Dostoevsky." And she promised to amend this deficiency by sending him a copy of The Idiot. I turned to O'Casey and found I could only say to him, "Magnificent, Sean, magnificent."
"The Second Coming" is quoted (and mis-appropriated, more often than not) and quoted again ... by people who want to use it for their own ends. It's a dark ominous crystal ball. The best "use" of it, to my mind, is in the deleted scene in Nixon, with Sam Waterston playing Dick Helms, director of the CIA. Written in 1919 - when the world had already become familiar with horror - a horror of a kind never before seen on earth - the poem predicts the chaos of the 20th century. Try to disentangle it from all of the movies (and Sopranos episodes) that has used it ... and just read it, clear and simple, as a poem. On its own. It's one of the greatest poems of the 20th century.
"The Second Coming"
Turning and turning in the widening gyre
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.
Surely some revelation is at hand;
Surely the Second Coming is at hand.
The Second Coming! Hardly are those words out
When a vast image out of Spiritus Mundi
Troubles my sight: somewhere in sands of the desert
A shape with lion body and the head of a man,
A gaze blank and pitiless as the sun,
Is moving its slow thighs, while all about it
Reel shadows of the indignant desert birds.
The darkness drops again; but now I know
That twenty centuries of stony sleep
Were vexed to nightmare by a rocking cradle,
And what rough beast, its hour come round at last,
Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?
Seamus Heaney wrote a marvelous essay on Yeats a while back (the link no longer works, but I have the hard copy) - in which he wrote:
Conquest, difficulty, labour: these terms indicate the nature of Yeats's creative disposition. From the start, he was enamoured of Blake's conviction that energy is eternal delight, yet the development of his own thought brought him more and more to the conclusion that conflict was the inescapable condition of being human. So, as his art matured and the articulation of his beliefs became more clarified and forceful, Yeats's poems typically conveyed a sensation of certitude achieved by great effort and of contradictions quelled. Poems in which the defiant self is pitted against hostile or disabling conditions - "An Irish Airman Foresees his Death", "September 1913", "Meditations in Time of Civil War"- are complemented by poems that read like discharges of pure, self-possessed energy, poems from which the accidental circumstances have been excluded so that all that remains is the melody and stamina of resurgent spirit - "The Cold Heaven", "Byzantium", "Long-legged Fly".

Of course, there is also the Maud Gonne factor that must be considered. Here's a post I wrote about her. What do you wanta bet that Maud Gonne had "cloud-pale eyelids"? Anne wrote a wonderful post about Maud Gonne MacBride. Fascinating woman. Poor Yeats. But at least she was his muse, and he got 100s of poems out of his unrequited love for her.
Never give all the heart
Never give all the heart, for love
Will hardly seem worth thinking of
To passionate women if it seem
Certain, and they never dream
That it fades out from kiss to kiss;
For everything that's lovely is
But a brief, dreamy. Kind delight.
O never give the heart outright,
For they, for all smooth lips can say,
Have given their hearts up to the play.
And who could play it well enough
If deaf and dumb and blind with love?
He that made this knows all the cost,
For he gave all his heart and lost.
Heaney writes, in that same essay:
And all the while, of course, there was Maud Gonne, "high and solitary and most stern" according to one of the poems about her, "foremost among those I would hear praised" according to another, and "the troubling of my life" according to a famous sentence in his Autobiographies. The passion she inspired - and as readers we experience it more as creative power than erotic need - made her a figure of primary poetic radiance, a Dublin Beatrice, an archetype as much as a daily presence. Nevertheless, Yeats's poetry, his politics and his involvement with the occult received an extra charge of intensity from her day to day reality in his life, and when she appeared in the title role of his subversive play Cathleen Ni Houlihan (1902), another kind of maturity was achieved.
Yeats is one of those poets who was not a solitary creature, writing in isolation. He wanted to start a "movement", and he did. He helped a young James Joyce in the beginning of HIS career. He advised Synge. He headed up the Abbey Theatre. He really looked at his own country - an insular priest-ridden culture at that time - and sensed a need, tried to create something different. It's hard to look with clear eyes on your own home, your own nation. Joyce did it, but that's only because he LEFT. Yeats, at first, went back into the Irish past in his work - and some of his early stuff is so quaint that it might as well be cross-stitched and hanging on the door of some Kountry Kraft Shoppe. I suppose it was his way of re-claiming the Irish past, its true inheritance. It was a phase, his beginning phase as a writer - how he found his "voice". And he was concerned about the rest of his countrymen, calling out to them:
"Irish poets, learn your trade, sing whatever is well made, scorn the sort now growing up all out of shape from toe to top."
Yeats was Anglo-Irish, but his feelings were that Irish-ness was a cultural thing, not a religious thing (forgive me for boiling it down so awkwardly) - and that the Irish could be united, regardless of religion - through writing, myths, poetry. He was a true nationalist.
I also love love LOVE his poem to fellow Irishman Jonathan Swift where he writes: "Imitate him if you dare."
Swift's Epitaph
Swift has sailed into his rest;
Savage indignation there
Cannot lacerate his breast.
Imitate him if you dare,
World-besotted traveller; he
Served human liberty.
WH Auden wrote, in his unbelievable poem to Yeats:
In the deserts of the heart
Let the healing fountain start,
In the prison of his days
Teach the free man how to praise.
And lastly, a poem that has great personal meaning for me:
The wild swans at Coole
The trees are in their autumn beauty,
The woodland paths are dry,
Under the October twilight the water
Mirrors a still sky;
Upon the brimming water among the stones
Are nine-and-fifty Swans.
The nineteenth autumn has come upon me
Since I first made my count;
I saw, before I had well finished,
All suddenly mount
And scatter wheeling in great broken rings
Upon their clamorous wings.
I have looked upon those brilliant creatures,
And now my heart is sore.
All's changed since I, hearing at twilight,
The first time on this shore,
The bell-beat of their wings above my head,
Trod with a lighter tread.
Unwearied still, lover by lover,
They paddle in the cold
Companionable streams or climb the air;
Their hearts have not grown old;
Passion or conquest, wander where they will,
Attend upon them still.
But now they drift on the still water,
Mysterious, beautiful;
Among what rushes will they build,
By what lake's edge or pool
Delight men's eyes when I awake some day
To find they have flown away?
SOME QUOTES
"My poetry is generally written out of despair. Like Balzac, I see increasing commonness everywhere, and like Balzac I know no one who shares the premises from which I work." -- Yeats
"On the third night Yeats addressed the audience before the curtain rose. If anyone had anything to say against the piece they would be welcomed at a debate which he would be glad to arrange in the theatre at some other time. He was interrupted several times. He asked the interrupters to at least listen to the play so that they would know what it was they were objecting to." -- Maire Nic Shiubhlaigh's description of Yeats trying to handle the riots that were happening in response to Synge's "Playboy of the Western World" - a play being put on at the Abbey Theatre
"In 1875 Yeats entered the Godolphin School in Hammersmith and visited Ireland during the longer school vacations, when he stayed with the Pollexfens in County Sligo. An early poetic impulse was to change the name of his toy yacht from Sunbeam to Moonbeam. It was a decisive act." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"I thought we might bring the halves together if we had a national literature that made Ireland beautiful in the memory, and yet had been freed of provincialism by an exacting criticism, a European pose." -- Yeats
"This is not the huge competence of Auden, at play in the toy shop of poetic form, but mastery, the possession of a unique rhetoric for use on a real but limited range of themes. It is a mastery so complete that it can occlude the genuinely problematic, ride over the potholes of nonsense without even sensing them. Late in life he recognizes the evasiveness of his symbols, the tendency of his verse to turn away or inward, and in the concentrated intensity of the late poems he tries to remedy this. But he has an imperfect sense of generality; he is willing to plump out a truism as truth. As his mastery increases, his art becomes less truthful. But his main concern is not - until the later poems, and even there in an attenuated spirit - truth, but the house of myth and legend, where he can become a principal tenant, where it is his voice we hear casting the spell, and where real men are reduced - or, in his mind, enlarged - to masks, figures and types useful to myth, regardless of the human reality they had." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"All literature created out of a conscious political aim in the long run crates weakness by creating a habit of unthinking obedience. Literature created for its own sake, for some eternal spiritual need, can be used for politics. Dante is said to have unified Italy. The more unconscious the creation, the more powerful." -- Yeats
"Sex and death are the only things that can interest a serious mind." -- Yeats
"His mastery seems almost excessive." -- Richard Ellmann
"... a strained and unworkable allegory about a young man and a sphinx on a rock in the sea (how did they get there? what did they eat? and so on; people think such criticisms very prosaic, but common-sense is never out of place anywhere ...) but still containing fine lines and vivid imagery." - Gerard Manley Hopkins, after reading some of Yeats' first published verses
"Yeats's 'The Second Coming' has gained in prophetic power with each decade of the twentieth and now twenty-first century, from the rise of fascism and nuclear warfare to the proliferation of international terrorism. It expresses the melancholy realizatino that man, yearningly drawn to the divine, will never fully escape his bestial ancestry. The poem is modernistically unrhymed, though the first stanza plays with shadowy off-rhymes: 'gyre' / 'falconer' / 'everywhere'; 'hold' / 'world' / 'drowned'. It is structured instead by dramatic visuals and emblematic choreography. There are two main movements: a huge, expanding circle (the ascending falcon) and an arrowlike, linear track (the beast bound for Bethlehem). Then two smaller ones: a pendulum arc (the rocking cradle) and an exploding pinwheel (the reeling desert birds). Ideas have become design, starkly juxtaposed with the murky turbulence of elemental forces - storm, flood, drought. Hence the poem, with its horror movie finale, is as hybrid as the sphinx, who represents our buried impulses, vestiges of a past that keeps turning into the future." -- Camille Paglia, "Break, Blow, Burn: Camille Paglia Reads Forty-three of the World's Best Poems"
"The heavy voluptuous splendour of much of his work has yet a ghostliness as of the palace made magically of leaves. Even his heroes and beautiful women are aware of this ... He never leaves us, any more than Crashaw, content with the glory alone. It calls our attention to a spirit behind and beyond, heaping high lovely, invisible things that it may show the greater beauty that can survive their crumbling into dust." -- Edward Thomas, 1909
"The worst thing about some men is that when they are not drunk they are sober." -- Yeats
"In London he was active in literature and politics. One particular event in 1889 proved crucial: he met and fell in love with the fiery Republican who haunted him for the rest of his days, Maud Gonne. His biography, from 1889 until Maud Gonne's marriage, is punctuated by the statement, 'Yeats proposed to Maud Gonne.'" -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"Words are always getting conventionalized to some secondary meaning. It is one of the works of poetry to take the truants in custody and bring them back to their right senses." -- Yeats
" 'The best lack all conviction, while the worst / Are full of passionate intensity': these famous lines are Yeats's anguished formulation of what seems to be an eternal principle of politics (7-8). When 'the center cannot hold,' neither consensus nor compromise is possible. Public debate shifts to the extremes or is overtaken by violence, which blocks incremental movement toward reciprocity and conciliation. Moderate views are 'drowned' out (as by the bloody tide) in strident partisanship or fanaticism. The phrase 'passionate intensity' suggests that, for the late Romantic Yeats, eros diverted from the personal to the political turns into a distorted lust for power. The second stanza opens in doubt and confusion: 'Surely some revelation is at hand; / Surely the Second Coming is at hand. / The Second Coming!'' (9-11). We are hearing either one voice echoing its own shocked phrases or many voices in public tumult. The book of Revelation lists the dreadful omens heralding doomsday, when Jesus will return and unlock the secrets of history. But in Yeats's poem, Christ's promised glory is overshadowed by a monstrous apparition from antiquity. The poet is seized by an electrifying vision: 'a vast image out of Spiritus Mundi / Troubles my sight'. It's a collective memory, crystallizing from the repository of world myths (12-13). ("Spiritus Mundi" is Yeats's mystical term for "soul of the universe".) We witness the resurrection of the pagan era, whose barbarism mirrors that of the war-torn twentieth century. Yeats sees no evidence of moral evolution over two millennia of Christianity." -- Camille Paglia, "Break, Blow, Burn: Camille Paglia Reads Forty-three of the World's Best Poems"
"I once got Yeats down to bed-rock on these subjects and we talked for hours. He had been talking rather wildly about the after life. Finally I asked him: 'What do you believe happens to us immediately after death?' He replied, 'After a person dies, he does not realize that he is dead.' I: 'In what state is he?' W.B.Y.: 'In some half-conscious state.' I said: 'Like the period between waking and sleeping?' W.B.Y.: 'Yes.' I: 'How long does this state last?' W.B.Y.: 'Perhaps some twenty years.' 'And after that,' I asked, 'what happens next?' He replied, 'Again a period which is Purgaotry. The length of that period depends upon the sins of the man when he was upon this earth.' And then again I asked: 'And after that?' I do not remember his actual words, but he spoke of the return of the soul to God. I said, 'Well, it seems to me that you are hurrying us back into the great arms of the Roman Catholic Church.' He was of course an Irish Protestant. I was bold to ask him, but his only retort was his splendid laugh." -- Lady Dorothy Wellesley
"It is an entirely new thing -- neither what they eye sees nor the ear hears, but what the rambling mind thinks and imagines from moment to moment. He has certainly surpassed in intensity any novelist of our time." -- Yeats on James Joyce's "Ulysses"
"For Yeats, there was something both enviable and exemplary about the enlargement of vision and the consequent histrionic equanimity which Shakespeare's heroes and heroines attain at the moment of their death, 'carried beyond feeling into the aboriginal ice.' He wanted people in real life to emulate or at least to internalize the fortitude and defiance thus manifested in tragic art." -- Seamus Heaney, 1990
"Give up Paris, you will never create anything by reading Racine, and Arthur Symons will always be a better critic of French literature. Go to the Arran Islands. Live there as if you were one of the people themselves; express a life that has never found expression." -- Yeats's advice to John Synge
Cast a cold eye
On life on death
Horseman pass by
-- Yeats's epitaph
Imitate him if you dare.

She's got a new giant novel coming out - it's been a while for her - recently it's been mainly short stories - and I am beyond excited. Now that I hear what it's about, I am even more excited.
There are only a couple of writers out there where I wait, with baited breath, to see what they will do next.
J.D. Salinger is one. Dude, I'm still waiting.
But the others are John Banville, Annie Proulx, Nancy Lemann, Michael Chabon, Jeanette Winterson - and, above all else, A.S. Byatt. Her books aren't just good - they thrill me. They create worlds in my head, and not only that but - unlike most other writers today (although Annie Proulx comes close) - they tell me that love, with all its disappointments and griefs, is worth it. Not only is it worth it, but it is the only thing on this planet that actually lasts. That has any value. Love for anything. Writing, family, a mate ... Her books sometimes have an intellectual overlay (sometimes??) that may make that message not as palpable - at least not to certain types of people. For me, a cerebral intellectual person (I say it with pride) - her vision of love is tremendously validating. I have felt (and I still feel, although, to quote Joan Armatrading, "I am open to persuasion ....") that my cerebral bent will make this love thing too arduous for me, too difficult. It's not "for me". And, hell, there's been a lot of evidence for that. But Byatt doesn't write about people who live in their subjective experience of life. She writes about academics and writers and research assistants - whose "love" for life is expressed through their driving obsession for whatever topic - people who spend their whole lives researching one minor female Victorian poet ... and any real love that comes into the life of a person like that will either have to take a back seat, OR somehow inform and deepen that other obsession. This is something I understand in my bone marrow. I was just talking with a friend about that last night. Many people fall in love with a person qua person. ("Nekulturny hordes"?) They love his face, his kindness, his brain, his sense of family, his stand-up-guy-ness, whatever. They fall in love with the actual person. But many of us (ahem) fall in love, primarily, with the WORK someone does. The work comes first. This may sound like a fine-line distinction but it really isn't. Work, for many, is what you do to make a living, support your family, and there is obviously nothing wrong with that, and it is quite noble, in and of itself. But for many of us work is a passion, an activity fraught with financial despair and the dreams of childhood ... and nobody, not even the great love of your life, could compete with it - and that is good and right. I grew up with a father who had, along with his love for my mother, an overriding passion for something else. Not a hobby, not a sport, not a "free time activity" - but a passion, an ongoing intellectual study of something. He never was not that way. And we all had to somehow fit into that, that pre-existing passion, and of course we all did. He was not a monk in a cloister with his passions - they were shared with us. So I understand that dynamic and not only do I understand it, but I live it. The men I have loved have always had a lot of shit going on, and all of them, to a man, have been artists - people who have a passion and drive for something that pre-dates me, that I could never supplant, nor would I want to. I'm the same way. Whoever steps into my world as my mate, will have to fit himself into what is already there - not just in terms of life experience, but my passions and obsessions, which I am not just doing to kill time until my mate shows up (often these things are looked at in this way, and sometimes married people, not realizing they are being insulting, will say to me, "God, I wish I had the time to read so much ..." or whatever it may be. Look, if you want to do something, you make the time. And that's final. I know married pregnant women who still read voraciously. Obviously it is a priority for them.) Life itself, and our intellectual pursuits, do not STOP just because love shows up. Although often movies, and sometimes books, treats it that way. Sometimes people in movies seem to have no lives outside of the main driving force of the plot, which is the romance. They don't read books or read the newspaper. They have no outside interests. Maybe they cook sometimes, and drink a glass of wine, but they're always thinking about love, love, love, love. I love movies that show people who have other things going on, and love shows up - and instead of being welcome - it kind of messes up the entire thing. I am thinking of Broadcast News. Or, the most obvious one: Moonstruck, with Nicolas Cage's great monologue on this very topic. Only Angels Have Wings is another one. Bonnie's entire journey throughout that film is learning how to live with the passion of the man she loves. Not for her, but for flying. If she tries to tone him down, or make him stop, she will lose him altogether. Now. Not everyone in this world is obsessed with something like that. But for those of us who are (I call us "obsessives"), it is hugely comforting to see our experiences reflected from time to time.
To me, A.S. Byatt writes in this realm like no one's business. She is the heir of George Eliot (someone she openly emulates). Life is BIG, and important - and it is not just our personal lives that give it resonance - but our passions, obsessions, intellectual pursuits and the wider culture and how it informs how we live. That makes her sound didactic or top-heavy. She is neither of those things. She is passionate.
Her work is vibrant, alive, and it strikes a deep chord in me.
Not only that, but she, the woman - the writer hidden behind her work (you rarely see pictures of her, she's not a publicity-hound - she doesn't need to be - similar to Annie Proulx, whose work totally speaks for itself) - moves me. Her thought process, her process of work ... her interest in ventriloquism (which you can see at work in almost all of her novels, writing AS other people -she loves that epistolary style) ... where she creates worlds within worlds, until you the reader get a bit disoriented and forget which way is the way out. Alice and the fawn, anyone? There is no way out. We are all, for our whole lives, in the wood where things have no name. The feeling that we are in control of events is an illusion. Byatt writes about love that comes as a supreme disorientation of the senses ... which is often how we cerebral types experience anything that has to do with the flesh. How do I interpret this, how do I explain it, how do I put this ineffable experience into words? We worry about such things. We can be a bit much for people who aren't like that. "Just chill out. What's the big deal?" Can't answer that. I just know that it is.
Here's a fascinating profile of A.S. Byatt which made me even more excited for her new novel.
The older I get, the more I think human beings have a deep need for something to go right.
Ain't it the truth. That's the other thing I love about her books. They are not without their tragedy (the last scene of Possession! Ouch!), but sometimes ... sometimes ... things do "go right". And often, if you have been in the wilderness for a long time, things "going right" is not always a blessing. It can be awful. This seems ridiculous and ungrateful, but again: it is the truth, and Byatt knows of what she speaks. Life, the longer you live it, is a thing of deep compromise and buried old dreams. We do what we need to survive. It's not an easy thing. Life is made up of loss, little losses and big ones. So things "going right" (when you are older, anyway) sometimes has a tremulous and fragile feeling to it. You don't want to believe. You have been so chastened by life itself, so disheartened.
F. Scott Fitzgerald writes about this a bit in his essay on "early success" and what it is like to "hit it huge" on your first try. It is a blessing and a curse. One of the things I was fascinated by in the essay is his thought that when you become successful early - you feel (quite naturally) that you have been in charge of it, that your star is somehow a lucky one, that providence will continue to provide for you in the same manner. You yourself have had something to do with your own good fortune. But a person who becomes successful in their forties has a very different outlook. They have a greater understanding of the concept of WILL, and how much your WILL has to do with your success. It is a long hard road. Nothing is given, nothing comes easy. The young man who is an "early success" has to learn the hard lessons later in life ... as he tries to either re-create his early success, or capitalize on what he has already done, or - worse - struggle to keep growing and changing, even if the audience doesn't want that from him.
A.S. Byatt was not an early success. Her success (a phenomenal one) came later. In her early 50s. To say that I find this comforting is a total understatement. Unbelievable - and rare. George Eliot was the same way.
These women had percolated through decades, following their passions and obsessions, living life, still working, but not "hitting it" yet. Through those early years, it is the WILL that helps you keep going. Belief in luck is for kids. I have had a bit of a brou-haha with a friend of mine recently, who said to me - about everything that's been happening lately - "God, you're so lucky." I am so insulted by that. The years of struggle and hardship and heartbreak and fucking nightmarish lack of belief in myself ... and now I get some good fortune, and suddenly I'm "lucky"? How dare you. This is similar to the "If I only had time, I'd read more" comment, or - even more insulting, "I know I have a novel in me, if I just had the time." Oh. Is it TIME that is the issue? Dickens wrote all those books because he had the time? Not because he had the WILL to create? My acting mentor said to me once, "Those who are the most successful are not the most talented. They are the ones who are the most fanatical about success." The older I get, the more I see the truth in that.
To know that A.S. Byatt didn't really hit upon "her" story until her early 50s is amazing to me - she had written quite a few books before Possession (and they're all quite good, of course they are) ... but she wrote Possession when she was ready to write it. It is not the book of a young woman, or a woman in her 30s.
She's in her 70s now. Still going. Still capable of being delighted and surprised by things (I love the anecdote about Paul Muldoon in that article) - and yes, her books (and stories) have always given me hope. That a person like me can find happiness. It will be a strange happiness, and it will be my own version of it ... but spinsterhood is not a done deal, even though it seems that way at times. Her people could be spinsters. Some are. But there is a blessing in spending your life devoted to a passion OTHER than personal happiness. Or: work brings happiness, of course it does, but anyone who is an artist knows that that is not really why you do it. It's part of it ... but who can explain the journey of a Christabel Lamotte, in Possession, who - in almost total obscurity - continues to write her poems and fairy tales in a world that doesn't want any of it from her? That's what I'm talking about. Byatt understands that. I understand her characters and to me they stand alone in literature, in who they are, and how they are portrayed.
I have never felt more "named" by a book than I felt by Possession. Okay, maybe Mating, by Norman Rush - another book about strong-willed passionate people who have grand interests in life - not just for a happy personal life, but for other things: theoretical, abstract, intellectual. What's love like for THOSE people?
I can't wait to read Byatt's latest. Hopefully by the time I get it, I'll be back in reading-mode.

I am still not able to read like I used to. I try to just "go with it", if I feel like reading - but the impulse comes over me intermittently, randomly, and I certainly do not have the concentration to read anything like a novel. Nothing requiring commitment. In the middle of the night, when I am lonely and alert, I'll suddenly feel like reading Joan Didion, so I'll pull out one of her books and start to read a favorite essay (not "Goodbye to All That" though - I'm staying far the hell away from THAT one right now) - but I usually don't make it all the way through. The need to read passes almost the second I take up a book - it is quite strange. It would be like having the voracious desire for sex and suddenly, as you engage, you're no longer in the mood, with all the desire immediately dissipating. Disappointing, no? And it happens to me repeatedly. (The reading part, not the sex part.) So I'm just trying to go with it, and thankfully I am so busy right now I would barely have time to read anyway. But it is strange and kind of lonely. I do miss reading.
Short nonfiction pieces seem to be all I can handle right now - and even there I can only read one or two paragraphs at a time. Recently, I picked up the collection of nonfiction essays by F. Scott Fitzgerald called The Crack-Up, sent to me by my wonderful blog-friend De a couple of years ago. I have read a couple of them already - it's more of a dipping kind of book - pick it up, read a bit, put it down. His essay on being an "early success" is pretty much a masterpiece - but so many of these essays are mini-marvels. His writing stuns me. It makes me feel very quiet and still inside, as I try to be placid and open enough to even receive it. It is not complex writing, or clever or pun-nish - it is clear and true ... but filled with so much wisdom and piercing insight that it makes all other writing look shallow. It's hard for me, right now, to "take things in". Mainly because everything seems to be happening so fast, and I honestly don't have time (yet) to sit down and absorb what has been going on. Also because I am in denial, let's not sugarcoat things. Regardless, it doesn't matter.
I was sitting on a bench yesterday evening, staring out at the Hudson, it was a cool spring night. The lamplights had gone on. People were running by. Big barges plowed through the river, the sun on its way down. I read three pieces (a record!) as I waited to go meet my friend: "Show Mr. and Mrs. F to Number --", "Auction -- Model 1934" and "Sleeping and Waking". The first and second are said to be written by Scott and Zelda, the last is by Fitzgerald alone.
I know there are people who pretty much only read books they can "relate" to, and I have never really gotten that. I like to be "recognized" by a book, sure, but that's not my main criteria for liking a book. I don't feel "recognized" by Imperium or The Great Terror or, for that matter, by most of my books. I like to learn new things. I read mainly to get OUT of myself. But right now, I am the most self-absorbed I think I have ever been - it's part of hunkering down and recovery, it's part of being wounded - you hover over your own injury, hard to look around and be interested in other people's lives and circumstances - that's all good and right, I feel no pressure to "snap out of it" or anything like that). But I find it hard to concentrate on anything, first of all - because I am too caught up in my own life and circumstances and the unfolding narrative that I keep alluding to but never describe. Not time to describe it yet. So I'm not looking to other people's words right now to put words to my experience. Not yet. But also, I just flat out can't concentrate. I can't "lose myself" in another story. At any other point in my life, I never would have picked up Necessary Sins by Lynn Darling (one of my reviews of it here). Just not my cup of tea, unless I am already a fan of the writer in question. I don't like memoirs, I don't like books about marriage, I don't like touchy-feely stuff in general. But things are different now. My needs have changed. It was almost spooky how much Necessary Sins dovetailed with my own life. There were times when I almost put it down. I'm not saying I gravitate towards mirrors right now - and only want reflections ... It's more complicated than that.
I am trying to figure out what I need. This takes some doing. But at the same time, I am absolutely certain of what I need, and despite all of the inherent risks, and the insanity of opening myself up for possible crushing heartache, here I go again. Because this is not just what I want, but what I need. This is true in the personal/social arena, with men, as well as in the career area, with my writing and other creative pursuits. Fear, resistance, near-panic ... that's the surface. Digging my heels in, saying, "no no no, let's not go HERE again ..." and yet at the very same moment, hands on my back, pushing me towards the future. Because if you know what you need (not what you want, but what you need) - then the choices become clear. "If that is what you NEED, then how are you behaving now helping you towards that goal?" You can strip out the ballast that way. But God, so much of my life has been about ballast. It is hard to distinguish what is necessary and what is not. That is what is happening now. In much of it, it's totally obvious. To quote Steve Martin in The Jerk, "Oh, I need THIS ... I definitely need THIS ..." And yet, if you think about that scene, many of the objects he chooses are pretty damn random. Really, hon? You need that? Need? Okay, fine, you know best.

Yeah. That's me right now.
There is no other place for me to be than where I am. And that place changes from moment to moment to moment. I have family members and good friends, old and new, to help me through and be there for me. Oh yeah, and writers like Lynn Darling and F. Scott Fitzgerald ... I pick these people up for deep (and unknown to me) reasons - it's like they call to me. Okay, fine, I answer the call.
So last night, sitting on my bench, I found myself submerged, totally, in F. Scott Fitzgerald's language, and a part of me started to feel that telltale itch of my attention scattering - there was something there I did not want to face. This is why I say I am not really looking for mirrors. If I am face to face with a mirror, my instinct is to look away. But I stuck with it. I had to go slow. Sentence by sentence. I took breaks. It was exhausting. I'd put the book down, and look around, enjoying the cool air on my skin. Then go back in again.
First there was "Show Mr. and Mrs F --"
This is one of those pieces where I think to myself, "Damn, could I ever write something like that?" When you get right down to it, it is just a list of activities, hotel rooms, and changes of scenery throughout the marriage of the Fitzgeralds. Very little introspection or personal revelation. Just a litany, through the years, of the waiter who was nice here, the chess game they played at this hotel room, the smell of the bougainvillea at this joint ... but the overall cumulative effect is shattering. It ends up not just being about marriage, and how certain ideals crumble over time, but it ends up being about the world, teetering on the edge of the abyss before plunging into another world war. The world Fitzgerald describes is now gone forever. And the piece was written in 1934, so there isn't much retrospect here - but Fitzgerald, from the first second he started writing as a young man, was able to inject nostalgia into his prose for the very time he was actually living in - no small feat. Nearly impossible. Other writers try to do what Fitzgerald did, try to express the zeitgeist, or the general universal mood, but it usually comes off as coy, pretentious, or self-conscious. A writer trying to be the "voice of a generation". Fitzgerald, who knows why, let's just call it his genius, had a sadness about him, a loneliness and melancholy, which made him acutely aware of the passing of time (think of that last line of Gatsby). This made him way older than his years, and nostalgic not just for his own past, but the time he was actually inhabiting. And not only that (many of us are aware of the amazing-ness or awful-ness of the time in which we live) - but he could write it like nobody's business.
How do you describe "the Jazz Age" with any perspective during the Jazz Age? How do you do so without getting a ton of stuff wrong, because you just haven't lived past it yet? Fitzgerald did. And he did so without a self-congratulatory, "Whoo-hoo, look how fun and fabulous I am" - which would have gotten really old really soon. He did so with a somber and almost worried awareness that this too shall pass. While he was in his own time, he could get up high enough to see it. I've tried to do writing like that before. It is extremely challenging. It's hard not to sound righteous, it's hard not to brag, "I see it all!!" Yes, you may feel you see it all ... but what else is there for you? Are you able to see what you don't want to see in the time that you are living? Many in the Jazz Age lived in a whirl of denial: the stock market would continue to climb, everyone was going to be rich, and youth was paramount - the most important thing was to live it up while you were young. You can feel it in much of the literature of the time, which does not date well. They did not want to see what was so obvious to someone like F. Scott Fitzgerald, who wasn't just part of the Jazz Age - he was the embodiment of it. But still, he knew: This all was going to end. The economic boom, the world peace, the tranquility and prosperity, and youth itself ... all this would pass. And to him that was one of THE defining characteristics of the Jazz Age: the anxiety of the impending disaster was IN the mania and the music and the parties. Many people could not see this, refused to see it because they were having too much fun, making too much money. F. Scott Fitzgerald was 24 years old and he could see it. It is one of his most startling attributes.

So here, in "Show Mr. and Mrs. F --", he lists all the places where he and Zelda lived as a married couple. That's pretty much it. It's a list. He writes in other essays about his insomnia and restlessness and how, in the middle of the night, he likes to make lists. He had that kind of brain. Most writers I know are compulsive list-makers. He bordered on obsessive. But my GOD, what a list. As the years pass, as the 20s turn into the 30s, the words he uses to describe the various rooms and beaches and bars he knew in his married life shift, transform, and the effect is subtle, like a shadow passing over the land from a cloud. You're not quite sure at what point things started to go wrong. Fitzgerald doesn't give much away. There are mentions of all-day ballet classes, and if you know the story of the Fitzgeralds, and Zelda in particular, then you know that her obsession for ballet was the first horseman of the apocalypse of her madness. But Fitzgerald doesn't mention it in any portentous way. He mentions it as just another fact, like the color of the tile, and the cocktails they had. But the words ... the words he uses ... begin to insidiously work on you ... and you start to feel the bleakness, the loneliness in their peripatetic lifestyle. What are they running from? (But he never asks that question. It is all 100% implied in his descriptive language.) On an even deeper level, though, and this is my own retrospect talking - I live in the 21st century, and I know what was coming for Europe and the world in the mid-1930s. I know that there was a rot at the heart of the culture, the wound festering, poison about to burst forth and spread. Fitzgerald is in the thick of it, and yet he can sense it too. Something starts to change. America starts to feel more unbearable, and yet when they flee to Europe, they begin to find it very quiet. It is that quietness that is so ominous. The stillness before the cataclysm.
It's an absolutely terrific piece. A real lesson in how to write about something without writing directly about it.
By the end, I was devastated. I, of course, know Zelda's horrible end. And Scott's terrible early end. Scott can't know these things. But he seems to sense it. Something very very bad is approaching. A terrible beast slouching towards Bethlehem.
Some fragments from the essay:
Electric fans blew the smell of peaches and hot biscuit and the cindery aroma of travelling salesmen through the New Willard halls in Washington.But the Richmond hotel had a marble stair and long unopened rooms and marble statues of the gods lost somewhere in its echoing cells.
And
Claridge's in London served strawberries in a gold dish, but the room was an inside room and gray all day, and the waiter didn't care whether we left or not, and he was our only contact.In the fall we got to the Commodore in St. Paul, and while leaves blew up the streets we waited for our child to be born.
And
At the Ruhl in Nice we decided on a room not facing the sea, on all the dark men being princes, on not being able to afford it even out of season. During dinner on the terrace, stars fell in our plates, and we tried to identify ourselves with the place by recognizing faces from the boat. But nobody passed and we were alone with the deep blue grandeur and the filet de sole Ruhl and the second bottle of champagne.
And
We got to Pisa in the dark and couldn't find the leaning tower until we passed it by accident leaving the Royal Victoria on our way out. It stood stark in a field by itself. The Arno was muddy and not half as insistent as it is in the cross-word puzzles.
And
In the Hotel des Princes at Rome we lived on Bel Paese cheese and Corvo wine and made friends with a delicate spinster who intended to stop there until she finished a three-volume history of the Borgias. The sheets were damp and the nights were perforated by the snores of the people next door, but we didn't mind because we could always come home down the stairs to the Via Sistina, and there were jonquils and beggars along that way. We were too superior at that time to use the guide books and wanted to discover the ruins for ourselves, which we did when we had exhausted the night-life and the market places and the campagna. We liked the Castello Sant'Angelo because of its round mysterious unity and the river and the debris about its base. It was exciting being lost between centuries in the Roman dusk and taking your sense of direction from the Colosseum.
And
We went up to Princeton. There was a new colonial inn, but the campus offered the same worn grassy parade ground for the romantic spectres of Light-Horse Harry Lee and Aaron Burr. We loved the temperate shapes of Nassau Hall's old brick, and the way it seems still a tribunal of early American ideals, the elm walks and meadows, the college windows open to the spring - open, open to everything in life - for a minute.
I mean, come ON.
More
At the Palace in La Baule we felt raucous amidst so much chic restraint. Children bronzed on the bare blue-white beach while the tide went out so far as to leave them crabs and starfish to dig for in the sands.
(Again, it goes on in this manner for 15 pages. Taken singularly, they may be beautiful or startling images - but all together, it packs an enormous punch.)
More
The night of the stock-market crash we stayed at the Beau Rivage in St. Raphael in the room Ring Lardner had occupied another year. We got out as soon as we could because we had been there so many times before - it is sadder to find the past again and find it inadequate to the present than it is to have it elude you and remain forever a harmonious conception of memory.
This stunner:
Then up and up; the twilit heavens expanded in the Cevennes valley, cracking the mountains apart, and there was a fearsome loneliness brooding on the flat tops.
And
In Vienna, the Bristol was the best hotel and they were glad to have us because it, too, was empty. Our windows looked out on the mouldy baroque of the Opera over the tops of sorrowing elms. We dined at the widow Sacher's - over the oak panelling hung a print of Franz Joseph going some happier place many years ago in a coach; one of the Rothschilds dined behind a leather screen. The city was poor already, or still, and the faces about us were harassed and defensive.
And
At the biggest hotel in Biloxi we read Genesis and watched the sea pave the deserted shore with a mosaic of black twigs.We went to Florida. The bleak marshes were punctuated by biblical admonitions to a better life; abandoned fishing boats distintegrated in the sun. The Don Ce-sar Hotel in Pass-A-Grille stretched lazily over the stubbed wilderness, surrendering its shape to the blinding brightness of the gulf. Opalescent shells cupped the twilight on the beach and a stray dog's footprints in the wet sand staked out his claim to a free path round the ocean. We walked at night and discussed the Pythagorean theory of numbers, and we fished by day. We were sorry for the deep-sea bass and the amber-jacks - they seemed such easy game and no sport at all. Reading the Seven Against Thebes, we browned on a lonely beach. The hotel was almost empty and there were so many waiters waiting to be off that we could hardly eat our meals.
He's a genius. The essay blew me away. And those are just fragments.
The world. He has the world in him.
The second essay I read sitting on my bench was "Auction -- Model 1934". This one struck such a deep chord in me. It actually made me want to start writing again. I've been percolating. But my fear of this narrative I now find myself in ... and NOT KNOWING THE END YET, DAMMIT - has stymied me. Or at least stymied the writing impulse. It's such a strange strange time. The device of "Auction" is a married couple (again, the byline of this essay is "F. Scott and Zelda Fitzgerald") trying to figure out which stuff of theirs to keep, and which to put up on the auction block. It is very similar to the book my cousin Mike sent to me (my post about it here - you'll see there what a potentially potent topic this is for me). As a matter of fact, it is idential, except with photos. The thing is broken down in "lots", like an auction. Lot 1, Lot 2. You can feel the couple picking through their things, getting lost in memories, and then - with each object - weighing whether or not they still need the object. Is this something we can let go of? Or is it like Steve Martin in The Jerk again: "I need THIS ... I definitely need THIS ..."
It's wrenching because we all have moments akin to these, it's just that most of us don't write them down so eloquently. Similar to the essay before this one, "Show Mr. and Mrs. F --", "Auction -- Model 34" attempts to describe a relationship, a life, a world, from the side, never going at it directly. Where in "Show Mr. and Mrs. F. --" the lists were of hotel rooms and weather and waiters, "Auction -- Model 34" are tea cups and blankets and white linen suits (falling apart). Each with a memory attached to it. Some precious memories, some not. The tone of the essay is not maudlin, or sentimental. It's actually rather jaunty and hilarious. The maid Essie stands by, waiting to dispatch the objects - and the narrator ends each "lot" description with a command to Essie - along the lines of, "To the attic, Essie!" The jaunty tone adds to the pathos. It's far more moving to have that jauntiness as you look through your possessions that make up your marriage - rather than being misty-eyed and nostalgic. That would kill it. It would personally make me want to throw all the objects into a huge bonfire in the middle of the yard, just to get it over and done with. Again, the cumulative effect of all of these "lots" is devastating. Objects are just objects, right? You can't take any of it with you. But we are here on this earth now, we are still alive, and so our objects - the things that surround us - that make up our lives - DO have tremendous meaning. Who cares if you can't take it with you? There are objects in the boxes that Scott and Zelda just can't bear to throw away ... the memories are too dear. You really feel their marriage in this piece. It's tragic. Because the longer you live, the more you realize that happiness never ever comes by itself. It is always accompanied by loss. Either the loss of the happiness itself, or the awareness that none of it will last. This seems to be the strict territory of older people, with their experience of deep compromise and grief - but Fitzgerald, as I mentioned, had that sensibility from the get-go. Perhaps that is why he drank so much, why he couldn't get to sleep, why he burned his light so damn bright. The knowledge that even in his prime things were already breaking down, disintegrating, was almost too much to bear. Joy is never pure. It is tainted by what we all know will come after.

This piece made me want to write something similar. I have this "thing with things" as I have written about before (that's only one example).
There's so much I want to write.
Next week LOOMS in my head. It's this giant unknown. But lots of fun - a total adventure. Totally out of my comfort zone. No comfort whatsoever. Not one tiny bit. What the hell am I doing?
I need to get over the feeling that the ongoing narrative somehow needs to be settled before I start to write. I've been trying. Not easy. My mind gets distracted, everything up in the air, ghosts of past and future around me, hopes, dreams, not to mention the giant world-encompassing GAP that I now have to live with and survive ... all of this seems to take up my creative space. That is not entirely true - there is a lot happening right now that I'm not talking about, but soon I will. Creative stuff. But reading all of those "lots" of Scott and Zelda made my fingers itch to take up a pen again. I have things to say.
The last piece I read was called "Sleeping and Waking" and it opens with this great sentence:
When some years ago I read a piece by Ernest Hemingway called Now I Lay Me, I thought there was nothing further to be said about insomnia. I see now that that was because I had never had much; it appears that every man's insomnia is as different from his neighbor's as are their daytime hopes and aspirations.
Well, this sent my brain spinning. How true!
It was also strange because two of my favorite bloggers had just written pieces about (sort of) their insomnia. Moira at TCMs Movie Blog and Kim Morgan in this piece on Erik Skjoldbjaerg's Insomnia. Both of those pieces had already got me thinking about my one really bad bout with insomnia - and the Fitzgerald essay clinched it. I have to write about it. But I want to write about it from the inside. As Fitzgerald did. Again, he's so brilliant, that it's hard to actually feel motivated to write when you read him (at least this is the case for me) - but these three pieces, for whatever reason, made me want to get back to work again. Fitzgerald describes how his insomnia began. A mosquito kept him up one terrible night, and he was never really the same again. He had become "sleep-conscious", a deadly state. If you've ever suffered from insomnia then you will know that horror. At first the essay starts kind of hilariously, with Fitzgerald locked in mortal combat with this mosquito. But soon, as he gets down to describe, and really describe, what insomnia is like for him, there is nothing less funny.

In his later essay "The Crack-Up" about, well, his crack-up - there is what I consider to be one of the finest sentences Fitzgerald ever wrote:
But at three o'clock in the morning, a forgotten package has the same tragic importance as a death sentence, and the cure doesn't work - and in a real dark night of the soul it is always three o'clock in the morning, day after day.
"In a real dark night of the soul it is always three o'clock in the morning."
There will be those who cannot understand that. There will be those who label it all as "whining". (F. Scott Fitzgerald has some very choice words for THOSE types!) All I can say is, only if you have experienced it can you understand how true, how deeply deeply true that sentence is. And if you haven't experienced it, then hopefully you can have a little compassion for those of us who have suffered in this way.
"Sleeping and Waking" was another essay that I had a hard time getting through. I read it two or three paragraphs at a time, putting down the book for breaks. It was too intense. I could feel where it was going, once the mosquito section ended, and I was frightened. He's so good, I knew he would "name" my own experience. To be clear, I am not suffering from insomnia right now. I sleep great. But the memory of my one bout with it in 2002 is still so searing to me to this day that I shiver remembering it. I know people live this way. They struggle their whole lives with sleep. My heart goes out to them. I had it for two weeks, and my personality actually changed over the course of that time. I became psychotic. I hallucinated. I heard a cunning whispering little voice in my head from time to time, telling me to do things, or how to think about things. One afternoon, I looked up and saw a rip in the sky. This is not a metaphor. The sky had actually ripped open. All night I thrashed in my bed, tormented. That is the only word that can describe it. I was tormented. Psychic agony.
Fitzgerald writes in his essay:
Back again now to the rear porch, and conditioned by intense fatigue of mind and perverse alertness of the nervous system - like a broken-stringed bow upon a throbbing fiddle - I see the real horror develop over the roof-tops, and in the strident horns of night-owl taxis and the shrill monody of revelers' arrival over the way. Horror and waste ---- Waste and horror - what I might have been and done that is lost, spent, gone, dissipated, unrecapturable. I could have acted thus, refrained from this, been bold where I was timid, cautious where I was rash.
I need not have hurt her like that.
Nor said this to him.
Nor broken myself trying to break what was unbreakable.
The horror has come now like a storm -- what if this night prefigured the night after death -- what if all thereafter was an eternal quivering on the edge of an abyss, with everything base and vicious in oneself urging one forward and the baseness and viciousness of the world just ahead. No choice, no road, no hope - only the endless repetition of the sordid and the semi-tragic. Or to stand forever, perhaps, on the threshold of life unable to pass it and return to it. I am a ghost now as the clock strikes four.
It hurts me to read that. No. It's not hurt. It's fear. I don't want to go back there.
But I do want to write about it.
I want to write about so much.
Nothing is wrong. Everything is going according to plan. I just can't see the end. The conundrum of the writer. Neither could Fitzgerald. But he wrote it all down anyway.

Born in 1910, Margaret Wise Brown always wanted to be a writer - but her journey towards the phenomenal, almost unprecedented success she eventually achieved - was a bit sideways. (There was a very interesting biography of her that came out a couple of years ago. What a life!) She went into education, she was always interested in children's books, and was disheartened by what she saw out there in the published world for kids. She had other ideas. Maybe there doesn't need to be an overt Sunday School lesson in children's books. Maybe what a small child who is learning to read really wants is a quiet book of sweet observations that is somehow connected to what the child looks around and sees in his or her own life. After getting her degree in education, she worked as a teacher, and eventually became connected to Harper & Brothers, as an editor of children's books. From there, she started to write.
"Good night mush"??? I mean, come on. It's one of my favorite lines ever. "Good night mush."
Margaret Wise Brown died very young, at the age of 42.
I have written before about Good Night Moon, perhaps not an entire post - but it comes up from time to time in my posts about writing (examples here, here and here). Good Night Moon is that rarest of books: it is perfect.
When I am struggling with my own propensity to over-write, or over-explain, using too many damn words, I'll turn to Margaret Atwood at her best, for inspiration, guidance. Or Jeanette Winterson (at her best). Or John McGahern (who was always at his best). But I also turn to Margaret Wise Brown.
Goodnight light
And the red balloon
Goodnight bears
Goodnight chairs
Goodnight kittens
And goodnight mittens
Goodnight clocks
And goodnight socks
Goodnight little house
And goodnight mouse
That is basically just a LIST of objects. But a whole world comes into view - not just of the objects itself, but of the love infused in such objects (the book becomes like a child's prayer - "And God bless my mummy and daddy, and God bless Jasper the dog, and God bless my flowers and my fishbowl ..." Etc. A compulsive list, but so full of love your heart might burst.)
And I am not overstating the situation when I say that the final three lines give me goosebumps every time I read them.
Goodnight stars
Goodnight air
Goodnight noises everywhere
Happy birthday, Margaret Wise Brown.
Good Night Moon is one of the most successful children's books of all time.






The story of Orwell writing 1984. It brought me to tears.
It was a desperate race against time. Orwell's health was deteriorating, the "unbelievably bad" manuscript needed retyping, and the December deadline was looming. Warburg promised to help, and so did Orwell's agent. At cross-purposes over possible typists, they somehow contrived to make a bad situation infinitely worse. Orwell, feeling beyond help, followed his ex-public schoolboy's instincts: he would go it alone.By mid-November, too weak to walk, he retired to bed to tackle "the grisly job" of typing the book on his "decrepit typewriter" by himself. Sustained by endless roll-ups, pots of coffee, strong tea and the warmth of his paraffin heater, with gales buffeting Barnhill, night and day, he struggled on. By 30 November 1948 it was virtually done.
Here's my post on 1984.
I am incredibly moved by that article, it contained information I hadn't known, what a struggle it was to finish that book.
Today is (supposedly - at least it's the agreed-upon date) the birthday of William Shakespeare. April 23, 1564.

One of the things I think about when I think about Shakespeare, or one of the things that inevitably comes into my mind, is my late great teacher Doug Moston, who died in 2003 (check out the comments there, too - I don't know any of those people, but they all had worked with Doug at one time or another and found their way to my post. Beautiful). Moston (an awesome awesome teacher) was responsible for getting Shakespeare's first folio (from 1623) published in facsimile. In facsimile, people. So it's basically well-done Xeroxes of the folio's pages. I own it. It's indispensable for actors, I think, but would also be fascinating for anyone interested in Shakespeare in general.
Modern versions of Shakespeare, modern editors ironed out his punctuation, regularizing it, etc. But ... in a lot of cases, the modern editors are looking at these plays as academic texts, works of literature - as opposed to scripts meant for actors to play. If you have the plays in facsimile (ie: how they looked in the first folio) - you can see an even deeper level of Shakespeare's intent as a playwright. Modern editors sometimes have added exclamation points, which I find a bit insulting. An exclamation point is an editorial comment - it says: "Here's how to say this line". It's directorial, mkay? You are saying, with that punctuation: "The emotion behind the line should be THIS." Shakespeare used very little "emotional" punctuation marks in his work. Almost none. He used periods and commas, and that's pretty much it. I don't want some EDITOR to tell me how to play Lady Macbeth.
Let's do a little compare and contrast, shall we?
A couple years ago I wrote about working on a monologue during the time Michael was staying with me, and we talked about it, and it is now known between us as "twixt clock and cock" monologue from Cymbeline. I had the folio by me on the bed - and I wanted to compare it to the Riverside Shakespeare version - and check it out. Line by line. Fascinating. (And yes - "f" are "s"s in the folio. You get used to it after a while.) Here is how the two stack up, side by side. I'll comment after.
Riverside Shakespeare version:
False to his bed! What is it to be false?
To lie in watch there and to think on him?
To weep 'twixt clock and clock? if sleep charge nature,
To break it with a fearful dream of him
And cry myself awake? that's false to's bed, is it?
Folio version:
Falfe to his Bed? What is it to be falfe?
To lye in watch there, and to thinke on him?
To weepe 'twixt clock and clock? If fleep charge Nature,
To breake it with a fearfull dreame of him
And cry my felfe awake? That's falfe to's bed? Is it?
Let's look at the differences. The first "false to his bed" in the monologue is NOT an exclamation in the folio -although it appears in the Riverside as an exclamation. In the folio it is a QUESTION. Enormous difference, in terms of the playing of it! Also - in terms of the MEANING. What is Imogen DOING here? What is she actually saying?
My interpretation is: when it's a question, she - after reading his letter - is still trying to process what her husband just said to her. She is still in a state of shock, where she must just repeat what she just heard. "False to his bed?" She's stunned, disoriented. She can't believe this has happened. Whereas, with an exclamation mark, like in Riverside - she immediately jumps to the anger and the hurt. She is pissed, and defending herself. "False to his bed!" (Subtext: the NERVE of that guy!)
But no - the folio has it as a question. HUGE difference.
Also, the last line:
In the Riverside, it's all one sentence - with commas added.
"that's false to his bed, is it?"
It's all one thing, one thought. In the folio - it's more choppy. "That's false to his bed? Is it?" Her thought process is still erratic (Olivier was right: the thought is IN THE LINE.) ... so she's asking one question: "That's false to his bed?" Then she realizes she is not done, and questions again: "Is it?"
To me - the folio is MUCH more plain, in terms of emotion. You can feel Imogen's processing of the betrayal - in the punctuation. In the Riverside, it's ironed out a bit - modernized. And so the thought itself has been changed. Tsk tsk tsk.
That's false to his bed? Is it?
I prefer that one.
Let's move on.
In the same way that Shakespeare does not overdo it in terms of exclamation points and emotional punctuation, there are no stage-directions in his plays (as written) except for: Enter and Exeunt. (Of course there is a notable exception from Winters Tale, which my sister Siobhan has called "the funniest stage direction ever": Exeunt pursued by bear.) But for the most part, Shakespeare put all of the stage directions INTO the language. Fascinating. If someone needs a torch to see through the darkness, Shakespeare will have the character say something along the lines of, "I can't see. It's too dark. Hand me that torch." The action ("hand me"), the props ("torch"), the motivation ("I can't see"), everything, is all in the language. Modern playwrights would add a stage direction to fill in the blanks: Horatio picks up a torch and squints through the darkness. See the difference? Although it's funny, I knew a playwright once who took the cue from Shakespeare, merely because she had been burned so many times with productions of her plays not being true to her intent. She said, "I have learned that if you want a character to be drinking a cup of coffee during the scene, if you think it is crucial to your plot that your character be drinking coffee - as opposed to tea, or as opposed to not drinking anything at all - you have to have the character say, 'I am going to have a cup of coffee' or something thereabouts. It has to be in the language, not in the stage directions- because then they can't cut it."
Shakespeare's plays, back in the day, were not extensively rehearsed. There wasn't much planning out beforehand. There was a troupe of well-trained actors who could learn things quickly, and knew, basically, how to project their voices, how to fight with swords, and how to play make believe. And because paper was expensive and scarce, they wouldn't be given the whole script - they would only be given their part. Imagine!! So you have to fit it in to the whole, you have to know how to do that. That's where the word "role" comes from: each part was written out on a "roll" of paper, and so you would be handed your "roll" to learn. Moston, as an experiment in classes, would do the same thing ... he would have parts written out on "rolls" and you would have to get up with other actors ... and try to make the scene happen, the way they did back in the day. I mean, people make jokes about Shakespeare's "O! I am slain!"s at the end of sword fights, but if you think about it: that is a stage direction. That is telling the actor (who might not have the whole play at his disposal) Okay. Die now. Those actors at the Globe were pros, man, they knew how to do crap like that ... You see "O I am slain" and you know: Yup. Time to die. Shakespeare doesn't write as a stage direction: Elaborate sword fight. Macbeth eventually dies. Everything you need to know (as an audience member, and as an actor playing it) is in the language of the play. Marvelous.
I am so grateful that I studied under Doug Moston, that I worked on Shakespeare, using the folio as opposed to modern versions of the script.
In honor of the Bard, here is a huge post, made up mostly of excerpts from other people.
But first - let's look at what the facsimile looks like, what you will get if you look at the folio:

Awesome!!
I'll start with a wonderful excerpt from the book Will in the World: How Shakespeare Became Shakespeare, by Stephen Greenblatt.
Here he discusses Midsummer Night's Dream. One of the cool things about Midsummer is that, of all of his plays, it is the one where scholars have been unable to find a souce for it. Shakespeare did not invent plots, he used stories that were already in existence. But scholars believe that Midsummer may very well be the only one of his plays directly from his imagination.
By 1595, Shakespeare clearly grasped that his career was built on a triumph of the professional London entertainment industry over traditional amateur performances. His great comedy [Midsummer] was a personal celebration of escape as well as of mastery. Escape from what? From tone-deaf plays, like Thomas Preston's A Lamentable Tragedy, Mixed Full of Pleasant Mirth, Containing the Life of Cambises, King of Persia, whose lame title Shakespeare parodied. From coarse language and jog trotting meter and rant pretending to be passion. From amateur actors too featherbrained to remember their lines, too awkward to perform gracefully, too shy to perform energetically, or, worst of all, too puffed up with vanity to perform anything but their own grotesque egotism. The troupe of artisans who perform "Pyramus and Thisbe" -- the weaver Nick Bottom, the bellows-mender Francis Flute, the tinker Tom Snout, the joiner Snug, the tailor Robin Starveling, and their director, the carpenter Peter Quince -- are collectively an anthology of theatrical catastrophes.The laughter in act 5 of A Midsummer Night's Dream -- and it is one of the most enduringly funny scenes Shakespeare ever wrote -- is built on a sense of superiority in intelligence, training, cultivation, and skill. The audience is invited to join the charmed circle of the upper-class mockers onstage. This mockery proclaimed the young playwright's definitive passage from naivete and homespun amateurism to sophisticated taste and professional skill. But the laughter that the scene solicits is curiously tender and even loving. What saves the scene of ridicule from becoming too painful, what keeps it delicious in fact, is the self-possession of the artisans. In the face of open derision, they are all unflappable. Shakespeare achieved a double effect. On the one hand, he mocked the amateurs, who fail to grasp the most basic theatrical conventions, by which they are to stay in their roles and pretend they cannot see or hear their audience. On the other hand, he conferred an odd, unexpected dignity upon Bottom and his fellows, a dignity that contrasts favorably with the sardonic rudeness of the aristocratic spectators.
Even as he called attention to the distance between himself and the rustic performers, then, Shakespeare doubled back and signaled a current of sympathy and solidarity. [Note from Sheila: It occurs to me that this is what Christopher Guest accomplished in Waiting for Guffman. Anyone who has been an actor has suffered through shows like that one. Most of us have done loads of community theatre. You can scoff at it, and scorn it ... and there's a lot to scorn. But Christopher Guest approaches it with affection. Which is why I think that movie is so wonderful. Yes, we laugh at those people, but we love them too. Okay, back to Will.] As when borrowing from the old morality plays and folk culture, he understood at once that he was doing something quite different and that he owed a debt. The professions he assigned the Athenian artisans were not chosen at random -- Shakespeare's London theatre company depended on joiners and weavers, carpenters and tailors -- and the tragedy they perform, of star-crossed lovers, fatal errors, and suicides, is one in which the playwirght himself was deeply interested. In the period he was writing the "Pyramus and Thisbe" parody, Shakespeare was also writing the strikingly similar Romeo and Juliet; they may well have been on his writing table at the same time. A more defensive artist would have scrubbed harder in an attempt to remove these marks of affinity, but Shakespeare's laughter was not a form of renunciation or concealment. "This is the silliest stuff that ever I heard," Hippolyta comments, to which Theseus replies, "The best in this kind are but shadows, and the worst are no worse if imagination amend them." "It must be your imagination, then, and not theirs," is her rejoinder (5.1.207-10) -- the spectators' imagination and not the players' -- but that is precisely the point: the difference between the professional actor and the amateur actor is not, finally, the crucial consideration. They both rely upon the imagination of the spectators. And, as if to clinch the argument, a moment later, at the preposterous suicide speech of Pyramus --
Approach, ye furies, fell.
O fates, come, come,
Cut thread and thrum,
Quail, crush, conclude and quell
(5.1.273-76)-- Hippolyta finds herself unaccountably moved: "Beshrew my heart, but I pity the man" (5.1.279).
When in A Midsummer Night's Dream the thirty-year-old Shakespeare, drawing deeply upon his own experiences, thought about his profession, he split the theatre between a magical, virtually nonhuman element, which he associated with the power of the imagination to lift itself away from the constraints of reality, and an all-too-human element, which he associated with the artisans' trades that actually made the material structures -- buildings, platforms, costumes, musical instruments, and the like -- structures that gave the imagination a local habitation and a name. He understood, and he wanted the audience to understand, that the theatre had to have both, both the visionary flight and the solid, ordinary earthiness.
That earthiness was a constituent part of his creative imagination. He never forgot the provincial, everday world from which he came or the ordinary face behind the mask of Arion.
I think that's kind of a beautiful analysis of that play.
Additionally, I'm going to post a couple of quotes from a book I positively adore: Michael Schmidt's Lives of the Poets.
What's really great about this book (a survey of English-language poets, from Richard Rolle of Hampole to Les Murray - quite a wide span of time) - but what's great about it is that Michael Schmidt is not an academic. He has nothing to do with academia. He is a publisher, and a reviewer. He is a poetry fan. He doesn't write from the dusty halls of a university, and he is not trying to impress. He chooses poets he loves, and tells us why he loves them and why he thinks so-and-so is important. It's a wonderful book, really accessible.
How he deals with Shakespeare is especially interesting. Because this book spans so much time, Shakespeare is just another name on a long long long list ... and yet ... of course ... he overshadows pretty much everything. His shadow even goes backwards, so that the poets that came just before him don't stand a chance either. It's very interesting.
In Michael Schmidt's view, the poet whose legacy suffers the most is Ben Jonson. Here is what he has to say about that:
Jonson suffers one irremediable disability: Shakespeare. Alexander Pope underlines the point in his Preface to the Works of Shakespeare (1725): "It is ever the nature of parties to be in extremes; and nothing is so probable, as that because Ben Jonson had much the more learning, it was said on the other hand that Shakespeare had none at all; and because Shakespeare had much the most wit and fancy, it was retorted on the other, that Jonson wanted both. Because Shakespeare borrowed nothing, it was said that Ben Jonson borrowed everything."In the plays the proximity of Shakespeare does Jonson the most harm, though he writes plays so different from his friend's that they seem distinct in kind and period. Part of that difference is Jonson's poetic balance, deliberate artistry: he knows what he wants to say and has the means of saying it, no more or less. He speaks for his age, while Shakespeare speaks for himself. Jonson's art is normative, Shakespeare's radical and exploratory. In Jonson there's structure and gauged variegation, in Shakespeare movement and warmth. Coleridge disliked the "rankness" of Jonson's realism and found no "goodness of heart". He condemned the "absurd rant and ventriloquism" in the tragedy Sejanus,staged by Shakespeare's company at the Globe. At times Jonson's words, unlike Shakespeare's, tend to separate out and stand single, rather than coalesce, as though he had attended to every single word. His mind is busy near the surface. He is thirsty at the lip, not at the throat....
Dryden's criticism is telling at one point: Jonson "weaved" the language "too closely and laboriously" and he "did a little too much Romanise our tongue, leaving the words he translated almost as much Latin as he found them." Dryden ends with the inevitable verdict: "I admire him, but I love Shakespeare."
The following excerpts are from Schmidt's chapter on Shakespeare.
When drama began to be printed, blank verse was an ugly medium. Printers did their best to set it out prettily but got little enough thanks for their labors. Not wholly unconnected with this, some of my predecessors harbored bad feelings about William Shakespeare. About the work and the way it broke upon the world. Not about the man, born in the same year as Marlowe yet somehow seeming his junior an dhis apprentice. The great painter William Turner once said of Thomas Girtin, who died at twenty-seven, "Had Tommy Girtin lived, I should have starved." But Girtin died, Marlowe died; and Turner lived, Shakespeare lived. Laurels are awarded accordingly.
Poems vs. the plays - here's what Schmidt has to say:
The greatest poet of the age -- the greatest poet of all time, for all his corruptions -- inspires in publishers and in other writers a kind of vertigo. For Donald Davie Shakespeare represents "a vast area of the English language and the English imagination which is as it were 'charged', radio-active: a territory where we dare not travel at all often or at all extensively, for fear of being mortally infected, in the sense of being overborne, so that we cease to speak with our own voices and produce only puny echoes of the great voice which long ago took over that whole terrain for its own." This is true of the plays. But had Shakespeare produced only the epyllia, the Sonnets and the occasional poems, we'd have a much more proportioned view of him, smaller in scale than Jonson, Donne, Spencer and Marlowe. The poems are excellent, but it is the language and vision of the plays that dazzles. The slightly absurd scenario of Venus and Adonis, the excesses of Lucree and the unevent brilliance of the Sonnets would not by themselves have changed the world. Venus and Adonis was, it's true, Shakespeare's most successful poem. By the time he died, ten editions had been published, and six followed in the two decades after his death. There was money in that large, bossy, blowsy goddess almost eating alive the pretty lad. Nowadays it is read because it is by Shakespeare. And Lucree, with its cruel eloquence, its harsh tracing of one of the most brutal tales of rape in the classical repertory, while better balanced and constructed, touches unreflectingly on matters that require a less restrained psychology than the poet can provide...This is a story about poetry, not drama or literal prostitution; the plays I'll leave to someone else. I'm concerned with "the rest", a handful of works that the poet took most seriously; the epyllia Richard Field published, the 154 Sonnets and "The Phoenix and the Turtle". I could add songs from the plays, but once you dip into a drama, where do you stop? A monologue is like an aria, a description can be like a whole pastoral or satire. And which songs are Shakespeare's, which did he pull out of Anon.'s bran tub? Two Gentlemen of Verona, Love's Lavours Lost, A Midsummer Night's Dream, The Merchant of Venic, Much Ado About Nothing, As You Like It, Twelfth Night, Hamlet, Measure for Measure, Cymbeline, A Winter's Tale and The Tempest all include detachable songs, but the plays snared them and that's where they belong.
Shakespeare is so much at the heart -- is the heart -- of this story that even by skirting around him we take his measure. Apart from his genius, Shakespeare had some real advantages. The world for him was new, as it had been for Chaucer. There were the navigators' discoveries, there was the rising power of the monarch, new industry, new learning.
Here Schmidt talks about the mystery hidden within the Sonnets:
The Sonnets have attracted a critical literature second in vastness only to that on Hamlet, and so various that at times it seems the critics are discussing works entirely unrelated. They contain a mystery, and the critic-as-sleuth is much in evidence. Unlike sonnets by his contemporaries, none of these poems has a traced "source" in Italian or elsewhere; most seem to emerge from an actual occasion, an occasion not concealed, yet sufficiently clouded to make it impossible to say for sure what or whom it refers to. Setting these veiled occasions side by side can yield a diversity of plots: a Dark Lady, a Young Man, now noble, now common, now chaste, now desired, possessed, and lost. All we can say for sure is that desire waxes and wanes, time passes. Here certainly, the critic says, are hidden meanings; and where meanings are hidden, a key is hidden too. Only, Shakespeare is a subtle twister. Each sleuth-critic finds a key, and each finds a different and partial treasure. A.L. Rowse found his key, affirming that Shakespeare's mistress was the poet Emilia Lanyer (1569 - 1645), illegitimate daughter of an Italian royal musician and also an intimate of the astrologer Simon Forman, who gives a brief picture of a brave, cunning operator. Her 1611 volume of poem includes ten dediocations and cleverly celebrates the Dowager Countess of Cumberland, the poet's particular quarry, in company with Christ and biblical heroines. The words she attributes to Eve are the first clear glimmer of English feminism in verse. Eve may -- almost innocently -- have handed Adam the apple, but Adam's sons crucified, in the bright light of day and reason, Jesus Christ. "This sin of yours hath no excuse, or end."There is a further mystery: Who is "the only begetter of these ensuing sonnets Mr. W.H." to whom the poet (or the publisher?) wishes "all happiness and that eternity promised by our ever-living poet"? The T.T. who signs the dedication is Thomas Thorpe, publisher-printer in 1609 of the poems: W.H. may have been his friend, who procured the manuscipt, or Shakespeare's lover, or a common acquaintaince - William Herbert, Earl of Pembroke? Henry Wriothesley, Earl of Southampton (dedicatee of the two epyllia)? William Hervey, Southampton's stepfather, getting the poet to encourage his stepson to marry? Much passionate energy is expended on a riddle without a definitive answer. Thomas Thorpe was a mischievous printer. I suspect he knew what he was doing: no title page in history has been more pored over.
You can tell Schmidt is a publisher, right?
Here's more on the Sonnets:
There is not a linear plot to the sequence of the sonnets. Ther are "runs", but they break off; other "runs" begin. Is it a series of sequences, or a miscellany of them? Some editors reorder the poems without success. Sonnets 1 - 126 are addressed to a young man or men; the remainder to a Dark (-haired) Lady. There may be a triangle (or two): the beloveds perhaps have a relationship as well. The poems are charged with passionate ambiguities.Those who read the poems as a sonnet sequence were for a long while baffled. The Sonnets were neglected, or virtually so, until 1780, when they were dusted down and reedited. They did not immediately appeal, but gradually, during the 19th century, they caught fire -- fitfully, like wet kindling. Wordsworth, Keaths, Hazlitt, and Landor failed to appreciate them. Those who love them properly are fewer than those who enjoy them. Those who love them properly are fewer than those who enjoy arguing about them. W.H. Auden argues (credibly) that "he wrote them ... as one writes a diary, for himself alone, with no thought of a public." T.S. Eliot suggests that like Hamlet they are "full of some stuff that the writer could not drag to light, contemplate, or manipulate into art. And when we search for this feeling, we find it, as in the sonnets, very difficult to localise." Now the public clambers over them, prurient, with several dozen authoritative guides.
And now (you can sense reluctantly) Schmidt talks about the plays.
Drama could be profitable: this discovery coincided with "the coming into the field of the first pupils of the new grammar schools of Edward VI", men who did not resent or distrust commerce and entrepreneurship. A new class of "mental adventurers", the classically educated sons of merchants, made the running. Marlowe was the son of a cobbler, Shakespeare of a prosperous glove maker of Stratford-on-Avon, where the poet was born in 1564. Both were provincials, one educated at the grammar school at Stratford, the other at King's School, Canterbury. They were harbingers of the social change that would culminate in the Commonwealth.One of Shakespeare's advantages was an apparent disadvantage. He was not university-trained. "When Shakespeare attempts to be learned like Marlowe, he is not very clever." That is part of the problem with his epyllia. But Ford Madox Ford reminds us that he had "another world to which he could retire; because of that he was a greater poet than either Jonson or Marlowe, whose minds were limited by their university-training to find illustrations, telles quelles, from illustrations already used in the Greek or Latin classics. It was the difference between founding a drawing on a lay figure and drawing or painting from a keen and delighting memory."
Sidney advises: "Look in thy heart and write." In the Sonnets, Shakespeare takes Sidney's counsel without the platonizing the great courtier intended. The heart he looks into is singularly complex and troubled, and the poems he writes from this impure "I" are as full of life as the plays.
I'll let Puck's words that end Midsummer close this post. They seem appropriate:
If we shadows have offended,
Think but this, and all is mended,
That you have but slumber'd here
While these visions did appear.
And this weak and idle theme,
No more yielding but a dream,
Gentles, do not reprehend:
if you pardon, we will mend:
And, as I am an honest Puck,
If we have unearned luck
Now to 'scape the serpent's tongue,
We will make amends ere long;
Else the Puck a liar call;
So, good night unto you all.
Give me your hands, if we be friends,
And Robin shall restore amends.
Came across a very fun article which lets you know only a couple of the phrases (and words) invented (or co-opted) by Shakespeare :
Eaten out of house and home
Pomp and circumstance
Foregone conclusion
Full circle
The makings of
Method in the madness
Neither rhyme nor reason
One fell swoop
Seen better days
It smells to heaven
A sorry sight
A spotless reputation
Strange bedfellows
The world's (my) oyster
And don't forget:
Be not afraid of greatness: some are born great, some achieve greatness, and some have greatness thrust upon them.
Thanks, Bill, for your greatness. Maybe you were born to it. Maybe you achieved it. Maybe it was thrust upon you. Or maybe Christopher Marlowe wrote all the plays, and you just get all the credit. I doubt it, but who knows. Thanks anyway. And happy birthday.
Recommended reading:
Whether he got the French Revolution "right" is, of course, up for debate. After all, he wasn't actually there. But Thomas Carlyle's great (and difficult) and frenzied history of the French Revolution is a highwater-mark in histories, and it took me three years, off and on, to finish the thing - I can take his turgid over-heated prose only in very small doses - but boy, am I glad I read it. Being interested in writers of the late 19th century and early 20th, Thomas Carlyle's name comes up all the time. In letters, journals, essays - he is referenced casually, with an understanding that the audience will be familiar with him, will have read him. His star has fallen in the last century, and you could no longer make assumptions about your readers' frames of reference - but it is a giant work, a work that stands alone for many reasons. He wrote it as though he was there. He describes the moles, the blushes, the bad teeth of the people he sees. He paints Robespierre vividly, as though he himself were standing in the crowd watching him go by. Carlyle immersed himself in the first-person documents of the French Revolution, and then, of course, let his imagination run away with him. It is a deeply moral work. A philosophical work. And you need to lie down after reading one or two paragraphs, just to get a BREAK. Dude needs to freakin' CHILLAX.
Here he is on the storming of the Bastille:
Let conflagration rage; of whatsoever is combustible! Guard-rooms are burnt, Invalides mess-rooms. A distracted 'Peruke-maker with two fiery torches' is for burning 'the saltpetres of the Arsenal;'--had not a woman run screaming; had not a Patriot, with some tincture of Natural Philosophy, instantly struck the wind out of him (butt of musket on pit of stomach), overturned barrels, and stayed the devouring element. A young beautiful lady, seized escaping in these Outer Courts, and thought falsely to be de Launay's daughter, shall be burnt in de Launay's sight; she lies swooned on a paillasse: but again a Patriot, it is brave Aubin Bonnemere the old soldier, dashes in, and rescues her. Straw is burnt; three cartloads of it, hauled thither, go up in white smoke: almost to the choking of Patriotism itself; so that Elie had, with singed brows, to drag back one cart; and Reole the 'gigantic haberdasher' another. Smoke as of Tophet; confusion as of Babel; noise as of the Crack of Doom!
There isn't one paragraph that doesn't read like that. It is a massive book.
I was extremely interested to read this generous article about Thomas Carlyle in The Humanities, overflowing with awesome anecdotes - a really good description of the man, his influences, his journey as a writer, and how the book came to be.
There is a famous story that he leant a copy of the manuscript (his only copy) to his good friend John Stuart Mill - and while in Mill's care, the manuscript was burnt. Accidentally, of course. But my God, can you imagine?
It's not exactly the same as Mikhail Bulgakov destroying his OWN manuscript of Master and Margarita (too dangerous to have that crap around in 1930s Russia) and then had to re-write the book from memory (which, frankly, gives me goosebumps to just think about) ... because John Stuart Mill (or his married girlfriend, one of the two) accidentally burnt it. Now, these two men were dear friends. Sounds like it wasn't easy for Carlyle to be friends with anyone. Imagine the agony of John Stuart Mill (I absolutely CRINGE thinking about it), and imagine the agony of Carlyle. First of all, your book is lost. Second of all, you don't want to end the relationship over such a thing - the friendship was precious - but how does one go on? The friendship never really did bounce back, although John Stuart Mill was instrumental in getting the thing published, as well as giving it rave reviews.
Carlyle had to start from scratch and re-write the book. Just looking at the fever-pitched prose of the Bastille excerpt above makes one realize just how difficult it is to re-create something like that. So much of the book reads like that - as though you are in the midst of the mob - it is immediate, emotional ... But bless Carlyle, he did what he had to do, and re-wrote the damn thing.
That's the bare bones of the story that I know - a rather famous "what if" moment in the literary world, especially for Thomas Carlyle who never stopped dreaming about that lost book and how perfect it was - and the article I link to above goes into it in detail.
But there's much more there. I love to discover that Carlyle loved Washington Irving! Never would have guessed that! How charming! When Irving died, Carlyle mourned him, even though they had never met. He wrote: “It was a dream of mine that we two should be friends!� I find that very touching.
I also very much liked, in the article, the comparison between Carlyle and Gibbon, whose The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, and how Gibbon obviously is the monument for most historians, but Carlyle was up to something very different. The article shows the first paragraph of Decline and Fall and then shows the first paragraph of The French Revolution, and it pretty much speaks for itself.
Carlyle wrote in a letter to his brother:
Here, as in so many other respects, I am alone: without models, without limits (this is a great want); and must—just do the best I can.
It is a marvelous article. Highly recommended.
Not to mention Thomas Carlyle's majestic challenging achievement The French Revolution: A History - which I definitely consider a must-read. (You know, if you have about three years of your life to spare.)

"Everywhere I go, I'm asked if I think the universities stifle writers. My opinion is that they don't stifle enough of them."-- Flannery O'Connor
Flannery O'Connor was born today, in Savannah, Georgia in 1925.
I think she's one of our greatest American authors. Not just a great Southern writer, although she is that, one of the all-time best in that tradition - but one of the greatest American writers. No other country in the world could have produced a Flannery O'Connor. With all her darkness, madness, and terror, she is so OF this nation, her voice is quintessential American, in the same way that Fitzgerald's is, although the style is totally different. Mostly known for her short stories, although she did write a couple novels.
I also, personally, feel that her TITLES are beyond fantastic. She's not afraid to GO THERE in her titles. I don't know how else to describe it. Her titles are not "safe". They have a Biblical feel to them. The Violent Bear It Away. The Life You Save May Be Your Own
. Everything That Rises Must Converge
. I looooove her titles.
I didn't know that her first published efforts were actually cartoons, in her high school newspaper. She tried to get her cartoons published in The New Yorker - and that went nowhere, none of them were accepted - so she started to focus on writing. She applied to the Iowa Writer's Workshop - and got in. Once there, though, she was kind of on the outside of things - she hadn't read "the big authors" who were in vogue at the time. Her writing idols were Nathaniel Hawthorne and Edgar Allan Poe - seen as 'old-fashioned', and perhaps too Gothic or melodramatic. Classic, sure, but way out of style in this new modern era of Ezra Pound, and James Joyce, and Fitzgerald. So she wasn't really born "in the right time", if you think about it - but she turned that to her advantage. She didn't try to change her influences, or write like other people - and while she was at the workshop, her short stories pretty much blew everyone away. I love that her idols were Hawthorne and Poe - those dark dark writers, those masters of small-town pain and paranoia and religious persecution ... You can so feel it in her writing, although her style is very much her own. Her style is so distinctive that you could recognize a paragraph of her prose without knowing who wrote it. She's like Hemingway in that respect. So - she was a shy girl, the only one in the workshop with a Southern accent, whose writing was so good that she got a contract to write her first novel (Wise Blood - now that is one HELL of a first novel!!)
Here's the post I wrote about Wise Blood.
Right around this time, she got very very ill with lupus (that's why she has the crutches in the photo above). Her father had died from lupus. She was always tired, always dragging through her days - but she had good discipline, and kept up a writing schedule, despite her exhaustion.
She was a Catholic, and she wrote:
"I feel that if I were not a Catholic, I would have no reason to write, no reason to see, no reason ever to feel horrified or even to enjoy anything.
Here she describes a literary evening - an anecdote I find really moving, coming as I do from a family chock-full of nuns, where such things are discussed at the dinner table, basically:
"Well, toward morning the conversation turned on the Eucharist, which I, being the Catholic, was obviously supposed to defend. [Mary McCarthy] said when she was a child and received the Host, she thought of it as the Holy Ghost, He being the 'most portable' person of the Trinity; now she thought of it as a symbol and implied that it was a pretty good one. I then said, in a very shaky voice, 'Well, if it's a symbol, to hell with it.' That was all the defense I was capable of but I realize now that this is all I will ever be able to say about it, outside of a story, except that it is the center of existence for me; all the rest of life is expendable."
A raw nerve, Flannery O'Connor had guts, man. True guts. She was one of those writers who were not easily understood at the time. If you read her stuff, and you try to think like a publisher in that era, you can see their point (short-sighted though their views are). Who was this crazy Gothic Southerner, who walked with a crutch, who didn't seem to line up with the style of the day?
There is a famous story about Flannery O'Connor, and as a writer - starting to deal with publishers and editors myself - the story takes my breath away. It stands alone in the annals of publishing anecdotes, and remains a touchstone for writers who perhaps are not understood by the powers-that-be, who can sense that what they are is NOT what the publisher is looking for. Now there is such a thing as constructive criticism, and you must be able to deal with people mucking about with your work. The constructive criticism I got from my agent about my manuscript was absolutely invaluable. She saved me from myself, a couple of times, and she also helped me strip away that which was extraneous, or lessening the impact I wanted. HOWEVER: if someone gives you criticism and it seems like they are actually trying to alter the INTENT of what you have done ... it is important to recognize that, and to say, gently but firmly, "Thanks for your comments, but what you are saying is not at all what I am TRYING to do ... so it is irrelevant."
In 1949, Flannery O'Connor was in correspondence with Rinehart Publishers, who were interested in publishing Wise Blood, her first novel. Flannery O'Connor did not have a name yet. She had nothing. She was completely anonymous. Now yes, Wise Blood was a tough sell, but so was Ulysses. It would take someone with courage to say, "Yes. I will publish this as it stands. It may sell only two copies, but to alter its form, to iron it out, would be WRONG." An editor at Rinehart had written to her, asking her to re-write the whole thing.
This was part of Flannery O'Connors response to that request:
Thank you for your letter of the 16th. I plan to come down next week and I have asked Elizabeth McKee to make an appointment with you for me on Thursday. I think, however, that before I talk to you my position on the novel and on your criticism in the letter should be made plain.I can only hope that in the finished novel the direction will be clearer, but I can tell you that I would not like at all to work with you as do other writers on your list. I feel that whatever virtues the novel may have are very much connected with the limitations you mention. I am not writing a conventional novel, and I think that the quality of the novel I write will derive precisely from the peculiarity or aloneness, if you will, of the experience I write from. I do not think there is any lack of objectivity in the writing, however, if this is what your criticism implies; and also I do not feel that rewriting has obscured the direction. I feel it has given whatever direction is now present.
In short, I am amenable to criticism but only within the sphere of what I am trying to do; I will not be persuaded to do otherwise. The finished book, though I hope less angular, will be just as odd if not odder than the nine chapters you have now. The question is: is Rinehart interested in publishing this kind of novel?
Wow. Just wow.
It is hard to imagine I would have the cajones to write such a letter, but I remind myself of that letter in my darkest moments, when it seems I am not being understood, or that someone's response to my work is, basically, "Wouldn't it be great, though, if you wrote the next Twilight-level smash?" Yeah, it would be great, but that's not what I have written. You have completely not heard what I have done, you don't get it, you are in this to make a buck, and I must withdraw my manuscript completely from you, because you are actually dangerous to what I have already created. A couple years ago, I had a series of conversations with an agent at William Morris who was interested in representing me. I sent him a huge packet of my writing - essays, short stories, and a novella. He was lukewarm in response. He thought the writing was good, but it soon became clear, over our conversations, that he actually was not interested in representing ME, as I am now, but a "new hot novelist" that would make him a million bucks. I have nothing against making a million bucks, but it became clear that it was not a good fit - that what I had already created - and it was a LOT - I have a huge backlog of material - was not what he was looking for. So moving on now. To find an agent who wants to represent ME, and what I have already done. Not an easy choice, but I am convinced it was the right one.
But my God, look at O'Connor's confidence there, the belief she had in what she had done. And she was writing that letter, not from a position of being FLANNERY O'CONNOR (TM) ... but an unknown author, struggling to protect her creation.
Unbelievable. She is my idol, for that letter alone.
As a coda to that story, not surprisingly - Rinehart DIDN'T publish Wise Blood, but Harcourt Brace did. The book was not a success, but time has vindicated everyone involved. Wise Blood is now seen as one of the great American novels. It took a publisher with some ... well ... FAITH ... to publish it as it was, to not try to neaten her up, tone her down ... I am sure there were small corrections to be made, but they left her INTENT alone.
Wise Blood is shocking to read even NOW. Her writing reminds me of Diane Arbus' photographs. Her books are filled with grotesque characters - blinded crazy preachers, child brides, women with wooden legs, outcasts from society - But her tone is never sensational or sentimental. She's a cool cool character.
If you haven't read her stuff, I really can't recommend her highly enough. I came to her late - and it was really at the pressure of Maria, and my sister Jean, that made me finally give her a go. After reading the first two or three paragraphs of Wise Blood, I was hooked. I knew: Okay. I must now plow thru this entire book RIGHT NOW. She's that good.
Here's the beginning of that novel:
Hazel Motes sat at a forward angle on the green plush train seat, looking one minute at the window as if he might want to jump out of it, and the next down the aisle at the other end of the car. The train was racing through tree tops that fell away at intervals and showed the sun standing, very red, on the edge of the farthest woods. Nearer, the plowed fields curved and faded and the few hogs nosing in the furrows looked like large spotted stones. Mrs. Wally Bee Hitchcock, who was facing Motes in this section, said that she thought the early evening like this was the prettiest time of day and she asked him if he didn't think so, too. She was a fat woman with pink collars and cuffs and pear-shaped legs that slanted off the train seat and didn't reach the floor.He looked at her a second and, without answering, leaned forward and stared down the length of the car again. She turned to see what was back there but all she saw was a child peering around one of the sections and, farther up at the end of the car, the porter opening the closet where the sheets were kept.
"I guess you're going home," she said, turning back to him again. He didn't look, to her, much over twenty, but he had a stiff black broad-brimmed hat on his lap, a hat that an elderly country preacher would wear. His suit was a glaring blue and the price tag was still stapled on the sleeve of it.
There's something really ... WRONG ... here. You can tell ... something is OFF with Hazel Motes ... but Flannery doesn't let us inside his head. It's all in what she doesn't say, and what she chooses to share with us. It's a fantastic opening scene.
Check her out if you haven't read any of her stuff - her short story collections are all well worth reading. She's an American classic.
Flannery O'Connor died at the age of 39.

One of my favorite children's book author - who is always, somehow, looped in my head to Sesame Street, the world being depicted in his classic tales (Peter's Chair, The Snowy Day
, Whistle for Willie
, A Letter to Amy
) the same urban one as in Sesame Street, so different from the turf farm slash ocean view world of my upbringing. He made New York City, and Harlem, in particular, look like a big wonderland - with whimsical graffiti, and mounds of snow, and stop lights and intriguing brick corners. The illustrations are, to this day, hypnotic - works of art.
Barry, my father's best friend, was friends with Ezra Jack Keats, so we grew up feeling a strange personal connection to the man who wrote the books we all loved.

Letter to Amy was my favorite. It tells the story of a little boy who is planning his birthday party, and everyone he has invited is a boy as well ... but ... but ... what about his friend Amy? She's a girl. But they are friends. How will that go over if a girl comes to his party? He writes a letter to her. It is a thundery rainy day. The illustrations are phenomenal. I love rainy days anyway, and I loved them as a little girl too - but the whole journey of that book, of grade school angst, and friendship - just really touched me.

Ezra Jack Keats is probably best known for The Snowy Day (and again - those illustrations!). The city shuts down in a snowstorm like that. I remember a couple years ago - maybe 5 or 6 years ago - when we had a massive snowstorm, I was struggling through Times Square, through literally mountainous drifts, trying to get to Port Authority so I could get home - and the roads were completely shut down, no cars anywhere, and people were cross-country-skiing down Broadway. Snowball fights broke out in the middle of 7th Avenue. Things get muffled by the snow, strangely quiet, and the stoplights keep going - red, green, yellow, red, green, yellow ... even no cars can approach. The illustrations in The Snowy Day completely invoke that world: the strange quiet that descends over a bustling metropolis when there are mounds of snow.
Happy birthday to an American classic.
Some choice illustrations below:






From Joan Acocella's essay "Perfectly Frank", about Frank O'Hara (a man I have always wished that I had known)- included in the compilation Twenty-Eight Artists and Two Saints:
In the doomed-poet drama that has been retrospectively read into O'Hara's story, this poem ['A True Account of Talking to the Sun at Fire Island'] has been taken as a premonition of death. But to me the most remarkable thing about it is O'Hara's sense of blessedness, an emotion that surfaces again and again in his verse. Indeed, it is one of the things ("gay, glancing") held against him by those who feel that he was not a serious person. This, in turn, has led some of his defenders to overstress the sadness - presumably a warranty of seriousness - that can sometimes be detected in his poetry. The light tread of his lyrics, Geoff Ward says, "is only a step away from the grave." It is true that O'Hara had the Irish sense of life, but the note of grief would be far less persuasive if it were not accompanied, as it almost always is, by the keenest possible responsiveness to life's goodness. Even at his most depressed, when his romance with Vincent Warren is falling apart, O'Hara is witty. ("I walk in / sit down and / face the frigidaire" - presumably Vincent.) When, on the other hand, that relationship is going well, even bad things seem good to him: "Even the stabbings are helping the population explosion."Boyfriends aside, he finds a thousand things to like. Ballet dancers fly through his verse. Taxi drivers tell him funny things. Zinka Milanov sings, the fountains splash. The city honks at him and he honks back. This willingness to be happy is one of the things for which O'Hara is most loved, and rightly so. It is a fundamental aspect of his moral life, and the motor of his poetry.
Here a couple of posts by my friend Ted about O'Hara, one of my favorite poets:
Because too much was never enough for him
I find him to be killer. Absolutely killer. The first one reminds me of what I was going through when I wrote this post - the post that generated, hands down, the meanest email I have ever received (guess the douche missed the point, huh?), and it makes me think, yet again, that that, at their best, is what poets can give us: words and context and imagery to contain and express our deepest longings and fears, or even just our experience of everyday life. I read a poem like that and think, "Yes ... yes ... God, I know that ..." Not that poetry should be all about reflecting YOU, and validating YOU ... that would be a very provincial poetry indeed, but once in a while you come across a poem that nails it, something that you spent about 1,000 words on your blog trying to describe ... and he does it in seven stanzas. With economy and heartbreaking precision.
In the Coffee Shop by Carl Dennis
The big smile the waitress gives you
May be a true expression of her opinion
Or may be her way to atone for glowering
A moment ago at a customer who slurped his coffee
Just the way her cynical second husband slurped his.
Think of the meager tip you left the taxi driver
After the trip from the airport, how it didn't express
Your judgment about his service but about the snow
That left you feeling the earth a tundra
Only the frugal few could hope to cross.
Maybe it's best to look for fairness
Not in any particular unbiased judgment
But in a history of mistakes that balance out,
To find an equivalent for the pooling of tips
Practiced by the staff of the coffee shop,
Adding them up and dividing, the same to each.
As for the chilly fish eye the busboy gave you
When told to clear the window table you wanted,
It may have been less a comment on you
Than on his parents, their dismissing the many favors
He does for them as skimpy installments
On a debt too massive to be paid off.
And what about favors you haven't earned?
The blonde who's passing the window now
Without so much as a glance in your direction
Might be trying to focus her mind on her performance
So you, or someone like you, will be pleased to watch
As she crosses the square in her leather snow boots
And tunic of red velvet, fur-trimmed.
What have you done for her that she should turn
The stones of the public buildings
Into a backdrop, a crosswalk into a stage floor,
A table in a no-frills coffee shop
Into a private box near the orchestra?
Yesterday she may have murmured against the fate
That keeps her stuck in the provinces.
But today she atones with her wish to please
As she dispenses with footlights and spotlights,
With a curtain call at the end, with encores.
No way to thank her but with attention
Now as she nears the steps of the courthouse
And begins her unhurried exit into the crowd.
The God Who Loves You by Carl Dennis
It must be troubling for the god who loves you
To ponder how much happier you'd be today
Had you been able to glimpse your many futures.
It must be painful for him to watch you on Friday evenings
Driving home from the office, content with your week—
Three fine houses sold to deserving families—
Knowing as he does exactly what would have happened
Had you gone to your second choice for college,
Knowing the roommate you'd have been allotted
Whose ardent opinions on painting and music
Would have kindled in you a lifelong passion.
A life thirty points above the life you're living
On any scale of satisfaction. And every point
A thorn in the side of the god who loves you.
You don't want that, a large-souled man like you
Who tries to withhold from your wife the day's disappointments
So she can save her empathy for the children.
And would you want this god to compare your wife
With the woman you were destined to meet on the other campus?
It hurts you to think of him ranking the conversation
You'd have enjoyed over there higher in insight
Than the conversation you're used to.
And think how this loving god would feel
Knowing that the man next in line for your wife
Would have pleased her more than you ever will
Even on your best days, when you really try.
Can you sleep at night believing a god like that
Is pacing his cloudy bedroom, harassed by alternatives
You're spared by ignorance? The difference between what is
And what could have been will remain alive for him
Even after you cease existing, after you catch a chill
Running out in the snow for the morning paper,
Losing eleven years that the god who loves you
Will feel compelled to imagine scene by scene
Unless you come to the rescue by imagining him
No wiser than you are, no god at all, only a friend
No closer than the actual friend you made at college,
The one you haven't written in months. Sit down tonight
And write him about the life you can talk about
With a claim to authority, the life you've witnessed,
Which for all you know is the life you've chosen.

Thank you, Therese, for the sweet reminder - and also your wonderful post about Behan.
Shakespeare said pretty well everything and what he left out, James Joyce, with a judge from meself, put in. -- Brendan Behan
Brendan Behan, Irish playwright, Irish terrorist, was born on this day, in Dublin, in 1923. He led a life of poverty, violence, controversy, and seemingly aimless wandering. He spent time in jail as a teenager, for being part of a plot to blow up a bridge (he had the bombs in his bag). Then he was involved in the attempted murder of two detectives, and was sentenced to 14 years in prison. While in prison, he (like so many other convicts) spent that enforced solitude writing. He wrote memoirs, confessions, poetry. He was still only 23 years old. His IRA activities ceased after that time, although he remained connected and friendly with most of its members (naturally - his whole family was involved). While in prison, he learned the Irish language. He drank like a fish. He had trouble getting published in Ireland (so he was in a grand continuum of other Irish writers who faced similar censorship issues). Behan was raised in a staunchly Republican family. His father was involved in the Easter uprising. Behan was Catholic (of course) - but not by name only. He was a true believer.
In the 1950s, he left Ireland (again, in a grand continuum of Irish writers who feel they must leave in order to be an artist) and moved to Paris. He wanted to be free, to write, to publish, to live life the way he wanted to live it.
I have a total irreverence for anything connected with society except that which makes the roads safer, the beer stronger, the food cheaper, and the old men and old women warmer in the winter and happier in the summer.
When we were in Ireland as a family, my dad took us to the writer's museum in Dublin. It's like going to the Vatican of artists. Nobody is more dominant in the written word than Irish writers. Who knows why that is - but it doesn't even matter why. The museum is great. Even as a kid I appreciated it, especially because I grew up being surrounded by these old Irish authors, on my dad's bookshelves. I hadn't READ any of the books, but people like Flann O'Brien and Brendan Behan and Francis Stewart and WB Yeats were a part of the warp and weft of our family. We had a big picture of Brendan Behan in our living room - actually, we still do: it was a drawing of Behan's big bloated meaty face - and it was all done in one line, with the pen never lifting from the page. You can see it on the wall over the television in this photo here. I still remember our visit to the museum and seeing Behan's battered typewriter under glass (you can see images of it on the museum's link). I didn't even know who he was, as a writer - I just knew his books were all over our house, and I just knew that he was on our living room wall. So he was omnipresent. And even as a young teenager, I was into "objects", the same way I am now. Like seeing Alexander Hamilton's DESK at the New York Historical Society and literally having to walk away from the display because I didn't trust myself to not reach out and touch the damn thing. Behan's typewriter is one of the few things I remember from that trip to the museum. I think perhaps it is because I had a battered typewriter of my own - given to me on my 10th birthday - and it lasted me pretty much until I went to college. Old-fashioned, where had to buy ink ribbons on spools, and where certain letters came out quirky, no matter what you did. I loved my typewriter, and I wish I still had it. Even just as a curio. Behan's typewriter looked kind of like mine, which was strange to me ... I was a teenager living in the early 1980s ... Behan seemed like a man from ancient Rome to me, yet his typewriter was like mine!
"I am a drinker with writing problems."
His cynicism about the Irish and Ireland borders on the psychotic at times (but if you know the Irish, you know that cynicism about themselves appears to be built in to the national character - part of why they are so charming and so much fun. They ARE serious, but they don't take themSELVES seriously.)
"If it was raining soup, the Irish would go out with forks."
But he also said:
"It's not that the Irish are cynical. It's rather that they have a wonderful lack of respect for everything and everybody."
In my opinion it is his cynicsm that makes his work so exciting to read. It palpitates on the page. His feelings and judgments tremble before you. He lives in his words. He is unforgiving. Yet also so so funny. A typically Irish combination. If you just have the unforgiving attitude, you'll be a rather humorless writer, a propagandist. But Behan was a riot.
"Never throw stones at your mother,
You'll be sorry for it when she's dead,
Never throw stones at your mother,
Throw bricks at your father instead."
-- Brendan Behan, "The Hostage", 1958
It doesn't surprise me at all that he and Jackie Gleason were best friends. Of course they were. They both had the same dead-eyed response to absurdity, the same intolerance for stupidity and silliness, the same potential for explosive rage and explosive tragedy, and also the same huge humor.

They had become friends because of a notorious drunken appearance by Behan on a television talk show, where Gleason was also a guest. Behan was wasted, it was shocking to many - but Gleason saw a kindred spirit.
So happy birthday, to a wonderful Irish writer, a man I grew up with, a character in my childhood lexicon. He was not outside our family at all, he was inner circle, like Flann OBrien (one of his friends) and Yeats and Joyce and Synge. Behan was on our wall. He was one of us. As an adult, I finally read all of his plays and realized what the fuss was all about. He's fantastic.
1954's The Quare Fellow, about his time in prison, ran for a short time in Dublin, and was a modest hit. The prison language is meaty, funny, and shows Behan's gift for satire. There's a Pinter-esque quality in some of it (strange as that may sound if you are familiar with Pinter) - in that a lot of times the events that happen OFFstage take on far more importance than what is happening ON. So that adds to the audience's feeling of imbalance, or wanting to peek around corners to get the whole story. "The Quare Fellow" is never seen in the play, although he is referenced constantly. Now enters Joan Littlefield and her Theatre Workshop into the picture. We really can thank her for the fact that Brendan Behan is so famous today. I am not sure that fame was a done deal for someone like Behan - in the same way that it was for someone like Joyce, who seems destined to be a singular star. Behan was more on the fringe, more of a scrabbler. But Littlefield, a theatre director and producer, took The Quare Fellow over to England where it was a smashing success. Eventually the play moved to Broadway, bringing Behan worldwide fame.
My dad wrote me a note about The Hostage (another one of Behan's plays):
Dearest: I saw the play done once in the 70s: it seemed like John Cleese [or some other Python] had adapted Frank O'Connor's Guests of the Nation for the stage. I believe that it owes most of its success to the director [Joan Littlefield?]. love, dad
My father's comment reflects the general consensus that seems to be out there: that it was Joan Littlefield who took Behan's work, wrestled it into a theatrical form, produced it so that its strengths could shine through, hiding its weaknesses - and that any collaboration that Behan had afterwards suffers in comparison. Behan owed much to Littlefield. Perhaps that is why they had such a testy relationship, notoriously difficult.

The Hostage was written in 1958. It was originally written in the Irish language - An Giall - and had a couple of small productions. Then he translated it into English, and once again it was directed and produced by Joan Littlefield.
Interestingly enough, my copy of the book, given to me by my father, was an early edition, 1959, and in the biographical sketch on the back it says: "Brendan Behan, the son of a house painter, left school at thirteen, and three years later served his first prison term for political reasons. As an IRA terrorist he has spent eight years of his life in various jails ..." The use of the word 'terrorist' really stood out for me. So often now, regardless of whether the person is actually a terrorist or not, the word is surrounded by little quotation marks. Or it's just not used at all. They're "insurgents", they're "rebels", they're "militants", "freedom fighters", etc. That little bio of Behan is quite a time-traveler, from an earlier decade when people weren't so hesitant to call a spade a spade.
Yeah, he was a terrorist. He blew shit up. He went to jail.
He also was a writer.
I appreciate the clarity and openness of that biographical sketch, and miss that kind of forthrightness (without the huge chip on its shoulder, too) today.
The Hostage was an enormous theatrical success in London, Paris, and New York. I love the play. It's laugh-out-loud funny at times, but also angry, pointedly political, sad ... with certain Keystone Cops slapstick elements. In my opinion, it should be played like a bat out of hell. You should only "pause" when Behan tells you to pause. Other than that, let it fly, keep the speed up, ba-dum-ching! Otherwise, the thing could be in danger of taking itself seriously. The points made are awesome and difficult and prickly - still relevant today ... but points such as those must not be underlined for the audience. God, I wish every director - for stage, TV, and film - would fucking LEARN NOT TO UNDERLINE (with music, dialogue, closeups, repetitive language in the script to make sure we all "get it") what is already obvious.
Behan's work exists in a fiery world of high stakes, humor, and denial. If you pause, if you slow it down, its power unravels.
The Hostage takes place in a brothel in Dublin which is owned by a former IRA commander. The cast of characters is a motley array of whores and night-owls and other fringe-dwellers. It's a fast-moving theatrical work, very Irish - full of wise cracks, and jokes. It seems that NOTHING is taken seriously. But that's so very Irish. When the play opens, we eventually learn that the following day an 18 year old IRA member is to be hanged. He was accused of killing an Ulster policeman. This is on everybody's minds. Lots of talk and chatter about the IRA, and 1916, and martyrdom, and Ireland ... A young Cockney soldier, Leslie Williams, is held hostage in the brothel, in the hopes that somehow this might stave off the execution ... When the IRA member is hanged the following day, the British police eventually attack the brothel, and Leslie ends up getting killed by gunfire.
The Hostage was Behan's last major success.
Literary critic Kenneth Tynan said:
"While other writers horde words like misers, Behan sends them out on a spree, ribald, flushed, and spoiling for a fight."
Amen.
Here is an excerpt from The Hostage - a play that is well worth looking into if you are not familiar with it. Don't forget, despite the IRA themes and the title: this is a comedy.
Notice in the excerpt below that a "pause" is written into the script. And, hysterically, the Officer shouts "SILENCE!" after the pause. If you're in a production that is floppy, in terms of cue pickups, with pauses left and right, people stopping to think, or ponder - then that moment would be lost, the timing would not be right, you need to be able to "hear" the joke that Behan has written into the thing. It needs to be rat-a-tat dialogue all along, no pauses between lines, so then that sudden "Pause" will really have an effect ... and the fact that the Officer shouts "Silence" after the ONE pause in the script so far - is hysterical, and says worlds about that character. (This, too, is very Pinter-esque. In terms of "Pinter's pauses" - follow them like you would a musical score. Do not add more. Do not subtract any. Just DO WHAT HE SAYS ... and almost by default, the script will take on an ominous almost unbearably tense feeling. Example here of what a Pinter script looks like. Those "silences" are deliberate, written into the thing by Pinter. This is not always the case with such "directorial" additions to a script - sometimes they are added from production notes, and are not BY the playwright. But in Pinter's case, he wrote those "silences" in. They are much a part of the dialogue as the things actually spoken. It's not up to the actor to muck with that stuff, to decide when to pause - at least not with Pinter. With Pinter, you do what he says. Believe me, it will help.)
So happy birthday to Brendan Behan.
You make me think, basically, of my whole damn life. You were given to me, by my father, like he gave me so much else. It was through osmosis, rather than anything more deliberate.
Wherever I look, you are there.
EXCERPT FROM The Hostage, by Brendan Behan.
OFFICER: Now your rent books, please, or a list of the tenants.
PAT. I can give you that easy. There's Bobo, Ropeen, Colette, the Mouse, Pigseye, Mulleady, Princess Grace, Rio Rita, Meg, the new girl, and myself.
OFFICER. [PAT fetches his notebook] I'll tell you the truth, if it was my doings there'd be no such thing as us coming here. I'd have nothing to do with the place, and the bad reputation it has all over the city.
PAT. Isn't it good enough for your prisoner?
OFFICER. It's not good enough for the Irish Republican Army.
PAT. Isn't it now?
OFFICER. Patrick Pearse said "To serve a cause which is splendid and holy, men must themselves be splendid and holy."
PAT. Are you splendid, or just holy? Haven't I seen you somewhere before? It couldn't be you that was after coming here one Saturday night ...
OFFICER. It could not.
PAT. It could have been your brother, for he was the spitting image of you.
OFFICER. If any of us were caught here now or at any time, it's shamed before the world we'd be. Still, I see their reasons for choosing it too.
PAT. The place is so hot, it's cold.
OFFICERE. The police wouldn't believe we'd touch it.
PAT. If we're all caught here, it's not the opinion of the world or the police will be upsetting us, but the opinion of the Military Court. But then I suppose it's all the same to you; you'll be a hero, will you not?
OFFICER. I hope that I could never betray my trust.
PAT. Ah yes, of course, you've not yet been in Mountjoy or the Curragh glasshouse.
OFFICER. I have not.
PAT. That's easily seen in you.
OFFICER. I assure you, my friend, I'm not afraid of Redcaps.
PAT. Take it from me, they're not the worst [to audience] though they're bastards anywhere and everywhere. No, your real trouble when you go to prison as a patriot, do you know what it will be?
OFFICER. The loss of liberty.
PAT. No, the other Irish patriots, in along with you. Which branch of the IRA are you in?
OFFICER. There is only one branch of the Irish Republican Army.
PAT. I was in the IRA in 1916, and in 1925 H.Q. sent me from Dublin to the County Kerry because the agricultural labourers were after taking over five thousand acres of an estate from Lord Trales. They had it all divided very nice and fair among themselves, and were ploughing and planting in great style. G.H.Q. gave orders that they were to get off the land, that the social question would be settled when we got the thirty-county Republic. The Kerrymen said they weren't greedy like. They didn't want the whole thirty-two counties to begin with, and their five thousand acres would do them for a start.
OFFICER. Those men were wrong on the social question.
PAT. Faith and I don't think it was questions they were interested in, at all, but answers. Anyway I agreed with them, and stopped there for six months training the local unit to take on the IRA, the Free State Army, aye, or the British Navy if it had come to it.
OFFICER. That was mutiny.
PAT. I know. When I came back to Dublin, I was court-martialled in my absence and sentenced to death in my absence, so I said they could shoot me in my absence.
Pause.
OFFICER. Silence!
PAT. Sir!
OFFICER. i was sent here to do certain business. I would like to conclude that business.
PAT. Let us proceed, shall we, sir? When may we expect the prisoner?
OFFICER. Today.
PAT. What time?
OFFICER. Between nine and twelve.
PAT. Where is he now?
OFFICER. We haven't got him yet.
PAT. You haven't got a prisoner? Are you going down to Woolworths to buy one then?
OFFICER. I have no business telling you any more than has already been communicated to you.
PAT. Sure, I know that.
OFFICER. The arrangements are made for his reception. I will be here.
PAT. Well, the usual terms, rent in advance, please.
OFFICER. Is it looking for money you are?
PAT. What else? We're not a charity. Rent in advance.
OFFICER. I might have known what to expect. I know your reputation.
PAT. How did you hear of our little convent?
OFFICER. I do social work for the St. Vincent de Paul Society.
PAT. I always thought they were all ex-policement. In the old days we wouldn't go near them.
OFFICER. In the old days there were Communists in the IRA.
PAT. There were, faith, and plenty of them. What of it?
OFFICER. The man that is most loyal to his faith is the one that will prove most loyal to the cause.
PAT. Have you your initials mixed up? Is it the FBI or the IRA that you are in?
OFFICER. If I didn't know that you were out in 1916 I'd think you were highly suspect.
PAT. Sir?
OFFICER. Well, at least you can't be an informer.
PAT. Ah, you're a shocking decent person. Could you give me a testimonial I could use in my election address if I wanted to get into the coroporation? The rent, please!

Elizabeth Bishop is one of my favorite poets - and she actually didn't write all that many poems throughout her life - not compared to other poets who lived as long as she did (here's the collected poems) - but the ones she DID write - resonate, reverberate - they're classics.
She was independently wealthy - she traveled the world - she was best friends with Robert Lowell - they had a kinship that can only be described as intimate - She lived all over the place, and finally settled down in Key West.
"It took me an hour or so to get back to my own metre."
Elizabeth Bishop wrote that to Robert Lowell, after reading one of his poems. An amazing symbiotic relationship - the two influencing one another, loving one another - while living separate lives. I am most interested in how the work affected each other. Lowell was much more famous in his own day than Elizabeth Bishop was - although now I am SO pleased to see that she is having a bit of a renaissance, she is one of my favorite poets.
Bishop and Lowell kept up a correspondence for the 30 years of their friendship, and while some have already been published (in a collection of Bishop's letters) - now a volume has come out with their correspondence - Words in Air: The Complete Correspondence Between Elizabeth Bishop and Robert Lowell
- 459 letters in all! Here is a great review in the NY Times.
They never married. Lowell had many lovers, and a wife, Bishop stayed with one woman for many many years (sadly, this woman committed suicide - yet another plot-point in the tragic story that was Bishop's life). But theirs was a soulmate kind of connection. Lowell did ask her to marry him, and her cooler head prevailed. It seems, though, that they were each other's "perfect reader". Every writer needs one. Not a critic, not a gushing fan ... but someone who is able to really hear not just the words, but the intent. Who can speak to the theme, the greater picture. Last summer I read one of my pieces out loud to Rachel and Mitchell - it was one I had been struggling with. As we settled in for my reading, Rachel said, "What do you want us to be listening for?" Now THAT is a good reader. It helped me to focus my own intentions and goals - and it helped me to think about the piece in a larger way, so that I could work on that LARGER element, not just the language or the progression of events.
Bishop and Lowell were two very different poets - it is hard to imagine their rapport. She was solitary, with a tiny literate following. She wrote about fish houses and the beach and small moments. He upended his psychology, pouring passion and unrequited feeling into his poems. They worked FOR one another, over decades.

It was a highly passionate relationship, and you ache reading some of their letters.
William Logan writes, in the NY Times piece:
Their admiration even made them light fingered — they borrowed ideas or images the way a neighbor might steal a cup of sugar. Lowell was especially tempted by this lure of the forbidden, using one of Bishop’s dreams in a heartbreaking poem about their might-have-been affair, or rewriting in verse one of her short stories. They were literary friends in all the usual ways, providing practical advice (the forever dithery and procrastinating Bishop proved surprisingly pragmatic), trading blurbs, logrolling as shamelessly as pork-bellied senators (Lowell was adept at dropping the quiet word on her behalf). There was a refined lack of jealousy between them — that particular vice never found purchase, though in letters to friends they could afford the occasional peevish remark about each other. The only time Bishop took exception to Lowell’s poems was when, in “The Dolphin� (1973), he incorporated angry letters from his ex-wife Elizabeth Hardwick — “Art just isn’t worth that much,� Bishop exclaimed. She flinched when poets revealed in their poems too much of themselves, once claiming that she wished she “could start writing poetry all over again on another planet.�These poets, in short, inspired each other. Lowell always seems to be stuffing her newest poem into his billfold, so he can take it out later like a hundred-dollar bill. Bishop saw immediately how strange and even shocking “Life Studies� (1959) was (its confessional style caused as violent an earthquake in American poetry as “The Waste Land�); but he noticed something more subtle, that she rarely repeated herself. Each time she wrote, it was as if she were reinventing what she did with words, while he tended to repeat his forms until he had driven them into the ground, or driven everyone crazy with them. Bishop was loyal enough to admire, or pretend to, even Lowell’s mediocre poems.
If Lowell and Bishop often seem to love no poems more than each other’s, as critics perhaps they were right. A hundred years from now, they may prove the 20th century’s Whitman and Dickinson, an odd couple whose poems look quizzically at each other, half in understanding, half in consternation, each poet the counter-psyche of the other. Their poems are as different as gravy from groundhogs, their letters so alike — so delightfully in concord — the reader at times can’t guess the author without glancing at the salutation.
Her influences were Marianne Moore and Gerard Manley Hopkins. For a long time she was known as a "poet's poet" - but I think her appeal is much broader than that (although her works may not be as well-known as those with more populist appeal). In my opinion, she's up there with Robert Frost. She's in the same continuum. Her work has that grandeur, and also that ... homeliness. She writes about "small" things - the look of waves, a moose in the darkness, fishing rods - in the same way that Frost writes about "small" things - an axe, a snowfall ... Yet nobody could ever say that these are trivial poets, or "surface" poets. They plumb the depths of the human condition itself, not by focusing on their experiences with electric shock therapy, or their family psychodramas but by excavating the meaning and grace and import in things, objects, nature. Bishop's poem 'One Art' stands out - it is different from her other poems. In it, she speaks in an "I" voice - rather than a detached narrator, or observer. You can feel the influence of her soulmate Robert Lowell - even though the expression, the poem itself, is all hers. People who know about poetry love Elizabeth Bishop - and rightly so - but her work is not inaccessible, you don't need Cliff Notes to "get" it ... And yet she is as deep as the ocean. I love her stuff so much.
It's a toss-up what is her best-known poem. There are two that seem to consistently make it into the anthologies "At the Fishhouses" and "One Art" (which I mentioned above). If you read these poems one after the other it is very difficult to not be in awe of her versatility with language. They are both truly great poems - and yet the voice used in each is so completely specific, and perfect to the subject matter.
I love "At the Fishhouses" (I suggest reading it out loud to get the full effect) - maybe I love it because it is familiar to me - as an East Coast girl who grew up 10 minutes from the vast heaving Atlantic. The fishing industry is a part of the landscape of my childhood - and there's just something about it that Bishop captures - and it's in the images, yes - but ... more than that ... it's in the language. Bishop is truly a master. She makes it look so easy that it is hard to remember just how good she is.

And then there's "One Art" - which has a blunt open-faced honesty - and I love the last line - with the italicized word ... She expresses something I know, on a cellular level, which is the "art of losing". Disaster. She's marvelous.
Here are both poems:
At the Fishhouses
Although it is a cold evening,
down by one of the fishhouses
an old man sits netting,
his net, in the gloaming almost invisible,
a dark purple-brown,
and his shuttle worn and polished.
The air smells so strong of codfish
it makes one's nose run and one's eyes water.
The five fishhouses have steeply peaked roofs
and narrow, cleated gangplanks slant up
to storerooms in the gables
for the wheelbarrows to be pushed up and down on.
All is silver: the heavy surface of the sea,
swelling slowly as if considering spilling over,
is opaque, but the silver of the benches,
the lobster pots, and masts, scattered
among the wild jagged rocks,
is of an apparent translucence
like the small old buildings with an emerald moss
growing on their shoreward walls.
The big fish tubs are completely lined
with layers of beautiful herring scales
and the wheelbarrows are similarly plastered
with creamy iridescent coats of mail,
with small iridescent flies crawling on them.
Up on the little slope behind the houses,
set in the sparse bright sprinkle of grass,
is an ancient wooden capstan,
cracked, with two long bleached handles
and some melancholy stains, like dried blood,
where the ironwork has rusted.
The old man accepts a Lucky Strike.
He was a friend of my grandfather.
We talk of the decline in the population
and of codfish and herring
while he waits for a herring boat to come in.
There are sequins on his vest and on his thumb.
He has scraped the scales, the principal beauty,
from unnumbered fish with that black old knife,
the blade of which is almost worn away.
Down at the water's edge, at the place
where they haul up the boats, up the long ramp
descending into the water, thin silver
tree trunks are laid horizontally
across the gray stones, down and down
at intervals of four or five feet.
Cold dark deep and absolutely clear,
element bearable to no mortal,
to fish and to seals . . . One seal particularly
I have seen here evening after evening.
He was curious about me. He was interested in music;
like me a believer in total immersion,
so I used to sing him Baptist hymns.
I also sang "A Mighty Fortress Is Our God."
He stood up in the water and regarded me
steadily, moving his head a little.
Then he would disappear, then suddenly emerge
almost in the same spot, with a sort of shrug
as if it were against his better judgment.
Cold dark deep and absolutely clear,
the clear gray icy water . . . Back, behind us,
the dignified tall firs begin.
Bluish, associating with their shadows,
a million Christmas trees stand
waiting for Christmas. The water seems suspended
above the rounded gray and blue-gray stones.
I have seen it over and over, the same sea, the same,
slightly, indifferently swinging above the stones,
icily free above the stones,
above the stones and then the world.
If you should dip your hand in,
your wrist would ache immediately,
your bones would begin to ache and your hand would burn
as if the water were a transmutation of fire
that feeds on stones and burns with a dark gray flame.
If you tasted it, it would first taste bitter,
then briny, then surely burn your tongue.
It is like what we imagine knowledge to be:
dark, salt, clear, moving, utterly free,
drawn from the cold hard mouth
of the world, derived from the rocky breasts
forever, flowing and drawn, and since
our knowledge is historical, flowing, and flown.
One Art
The art of losing isn't hard to master;
so many things seem filled with the intent
to be lost that their loss is no disaster.
Lose something every day. Accept the fluster
of lost door keys, the hour badly spent.
The art of losing isn't hard to master.
Then practice losing farther, losing faster:
places, and names, and where it was you meant
to travel. None of these will bring disaster.
I lost my mother's watch. And look! my last, or
next-to-last, of three loved houses went.
The art of losing isn't hard to master.
I lost two cities, lovely ones. And, vaster,
some realms I owned, two rivers, a continent.
I miss them, but it wasn't a disaster.
--Even losing you (the joking voice, a gesture
I love) I shan't have lied. It's evident
the art of losing's not too hard to master
though it may look like (Write it!) like disaster.
But in my opinion - it is "The Moose" that is her greatest poem. Somehow I had missed that one, I was not familiar with it - and for whatever reason, recently, my Dad brought it to my attention - saying, "Have you read "The Moose"? You have to read it."
So I sat down and read it. Its greatness speaks for itself. Breathtaking.
THE MOOSE
From narrow provinces
of fish and bread and tea,
home of the long tides
where the bay leaves the sea
twice a day and takes
the herrings long rides,
where if the river
enters or retreats
in a wall of brown foam
depends on if it meets
the bay coming in,
the bay not at home;
where, silted red,
sometimes the sun sets
facing a red sea,
and others, veins the flats'
lavender, rich mud
in burning rivulets;
on red, gravelly roads,
down rows of sugar maples,
past clapboard farmhouses
and neat, clapboard churches,
bleached, ridged as clamshells,
past twin silver birches,
through late afternoon
a bus journeys west,
the windshield flashing pink,
pink glancing off of metal,
brushing the dented flank
of blue, beat-up enamel;
down hollows, up rises,
and waits, patient, while
a lone traveller gives
kisses and embraces
to seven relatives
and a collie supervises.
Goodbye to the elms,
to the farm, to the dog.
The bus starts. The light
grows richer; the fog,
shifting, salty, thin,
comes closing in.
Its cold, round crystals
form and slide and settle
in the white hens' feathers,
in gray glazed cabbages,
on the cabbage roses
and lupins like apostles;
the sweet peas cling
to their wet white string
on the whitewashed fences;
bumblebees creep
inside the foxgloves,
and evening commences.
One stop at Bass River.
Then the Economies
Lower, Middle, Upper;
Five Islands, Five Houses,
where a woman shakes a tablecloth
out after supper.
A pale flickering. Gone.
The Tantramar marshes
and the smell of salt hay.
An iron bridge trembles
and a loose plank rattles
but doesn't give way.
On the left, a red light
swims through the dark:
a ship's port lantern.
Two rubber boots show,
illuminated, solemn.
A dog gives one bark.
A woman climbs in
with two market bags,
brisk, freckled, elderly.
"A grand night. Yes, sir,
all the way to Boston."
She regards us amicably.
Moonlight as we enter
the New Brunswick woods,
hairy, scratchy, splintery;
moonlight and mist
caught in them like lamb's wool
on bushes in a pasture.
The passengers lie back.
Snores. Some long sighs.
A dreamy divagation
begins in the night,
a gentle, auditory,
slow hallucination. . . .
In the creakings and noises,
an old conversation
--not concerning us,
but recognizable, somewhere,
back in the bus:
Grandparents' voices
uninterruptedly
talking, in Eternity:
names being mentioned,
things cleared up finally;
what he said, what she said,
who got pensioned;
deaths, deaths and sicknesses;
the year he remarried;
the year (something) happened.
She died in childbirth.
That was the son lost
when the schooner foundered.
He took to drink. Yes.
She went to the bad.
When Amos began to pray
even in the store and
finally the family had
to put him away.
"Yes . . ." that peculiar
affirmative. "Yes . . ."
A sharp, indrawn breath,
half groan, half acceptance,
that means "Life's like that.
We know it (also death)."
Talking the way they talked
in the old featherbed,
peacefully, on and on,
dim lamplight in the hall,
down in the kitchen, the dog
tucked in her shawl.
Now, it's all right now
even to fall asleep
just as on all those nights.
--Suddenly the bus driver
stops with a jolt,
turns off his lights.
A moose has come out of
the impenetrable wood
and stands there, looms, rather,
in the middle of the road.
It approaches; it sniffs at
the bus's hot hood.
Towering, antlerless,
high as a church,
homely as a house
(or, safe as houses).
A man's voice assures us
"Perfectly harmless. . . ."
Some of the passengers
exclaim in whispers,
childishly, softly,
"Sure are big creatures."
"It's awful plain."
"Look! It's a she!"
Taking her time,
she looks the bus over,
grand, otherworldly.
Why, why do we feel
(we all feel) this sweet
sensation of joy?
"Curious creatures,"
says our quiet driver,
rolling his r's.
"Look at that, would you."
Then he shifts gears.
For a moment longer,
by craning backward,
the moose can be seen
on the moonlit macadam;
then there's a dim
smell of moose, an acrid
smell of gasoline.
I cannot get enough of the John Banville / Benjamin Black thing. It makes me think of my father. Banville is one of his favorite writers. He turned me on to him.
Here is Part 1 of a 4-part interview with Benjamin Black. Not John Banville. Benjamin Black.
And here is Part 2.
I love how much FUN he's having. It really shows in those books.
"If you want to write noir fiction, Dublin in the 1950s is just the place for it.� says Benjamin Black.
Here are some of my other posts on Banville / Black:
John Banville / Benjamin Black

"November is the most disagreeable month in the whole year," said Meg, standing at the window one dull afternoon, looking out at the frostbitten garden."That's the reason I was born in it," observed Jo pensively, quite unconscious of the blot on her nose.
-- Little Women
, by Louisa May Alcott
Louisa May Alcott was born on this day, in 1832. (I just LOVE that picture of her above. The dress!!) This is perfect, because it was my birthday 2 days ago - and yesterday my whole family came over (aunts, uncles, cousins) and aunt Regina brought me a gift - two old old books (Eight Cousins and Rose in Bloom
) - probably editions from the early 20th century - and they were given to my great-great grandmother by her aunt Sadie (we could tell this from the inscription in the front - in the perfect spidery script of the 19th century). Precious gifts! Regina found them in a box in her elf house and brought them down for me for my birthday. It took some deciphering to figure out who the 'Regina Rogers' was in the inscription. It couldn't be my grandmother, could it? Nobody could remember an "Aunt Sadie" from that generation - so it had to be from the generation before. The generation that still spoke in brogues. Glorious!!
To me, Little Women is a perfect book (even with the whole Laurie debacle, and the advent of the German professor which never works for me, to this day) - it is a book I go back to again and again and again - always seeing something new in it, always finding new levels. The characters seem to grow up with me. When I first read it, when I was 10 years old, I was ALL ABOUT JO. And my love affair with Jo continues to this day. She is one of my favorite female characters ever written (it's a tie between Jo March and Harriet the Spy). Jo LIVES. No one can convince me that she is just a fictional character. Nope. You cannot do it.
But as I have grown up, and as I have continuously gone back to the book - the other sisters have come to the foreground - I see myself in all of them. Parts of me are like Amy, parts of me are like Meg, and I would like to think that parts of me are like Beth. But honestly: Jo is the one. Jo is the one I most relate to. She's the artist. The tomboy. The independent wild spirit. The one who is afraid to make the wrong choice. The one who sticks to her guns.
I still am not really reconciled to the fact that she and Laurie did not end up together - HOWEVER, I can see Jo's point. They were like brother and sister. But ... but ... but ... couldn't that have segued into a love thing? The intimacy they have together, the comfort?
When I was a kid, I HATED the professor. With his stupid German accent, and his goofy poetry as he wooed Jo. I resented the fact that he wasn't Laurie. I loved Laurie.
Now I know that Louisa May Alcott was forced by her publishers to marry Jo off. She wanted her to stay single. And if you really think about it, THAT would be much more logical - it makes much more sense that Jo, even with all her passion, and her ability to understand men (in a way that Meg, the one with all the love affairs, doesn't) - would choose to spend her life alone. She would marry her writing. In that day and age, those were the choices. It was the choice Louisa May Alcott herself made. She could not submit to the demands of wifehood and motherhood - it would infringe on her writing. She knew it, even when she was 15 years old, and wrote in her journal:
"I will do something by and by. Don't care what, teach, sew, act, write, anything to help the family; and I'll be rich and famous and happy before I die, see if I won't!"

Alcott grew up in Concord, one of 4 girls, and part of what we would now call an activist family. They were abolitinists. Social reformers. Her mother was a social worker. Her father was an educational philosopher (more on this extraordinary and, frankly, bizarre man here), and had a belief in communal living (Louisa May Alcott wrote some funny pieces about these experiments of her father's, and having to submit to them as a young girl.) Her father (Amos Bronson Alcott - also born on this day) was buddies with Emerson, and part of the Transcendentalist movement. At the time, her father's views on teaching were very controversial: He actually believed that students should enjoy learning. Heaven forbid! He thought that students should be actively involved in their own education, and not just sit back and be passive little drones. Her father thought it was very important to have a beautiful classroom - not just desks and a chalkboard. He poured his heart (and finances) into a school - which ran for a couple of years - but then went under, putting the family at financial risk. Louisa May Alcott eventually, many years later, would be pretty much the sole supporter of her parents. She made a ton of money DURING her lifetime, which is quite rare. Her parents just weren't the money-making types - obviously. As a young teenager Louisa May Alcott had a passionate girlish love of Emerson - a crush, if you will. His intellect, his library that she was allowed to use, whatever ... She adored him.
In 1862, Alcott (as always, determined to make a living - and to contribute financially to her family) traveled to Washington DC as a Civil War nurse. By this point, Alcott had already started getting stuff published - poems, short stories in the Gothic melodramatic vein ... She actually preferred Gothic melodramas to the kinds of books that later would make her name. (She despised Little Women and found the writing of it extremely tedious.) Her experience as a nurse in the Civil War prompted her to publish a book called Hospital Sketches. At that point, her publisher asked her if she would write a book "for girls". Never one to back off from a challenge, Louisa May Alcott sat down and wrote Little Women in two months. She had grown up with 3 sisters - and she put her entire childhood and life into that book, even as she hated doing it, and didn't think the book would amount to much.
Little Women was published in 1868 and was an immediate rip-roaring success. The publisher, within only a couple of weeks of its publication, begged Alcott to get to work on a sequel. So Alcott did. Another smash success. Louisa May Alcott had become a star.
Every book she wrote after that was eagerly awaited for by a breathless loving public. Success had, indeed, come - her childish ambitions to be 'rich and famous' came to fruition tenfold ... but 'happy'? Was she happy?
She never married. She ended up taking care of her sister May's daughter - after May died from complications in childbirth. Being a surrogate mother to this young girl was one of the most fulfilling experiences of Alcott's life. She kept writing, kept publishing ... although she began to get more and more ill from mercury poisoning she had received years earlier during the Civil War (she had, like many other Civil War nurses, contracted typhoid fever - and at the time, the proscribed cure was something called "calomel" - a drug laden with mercury).
Near the end of her life, Alcott became active in the suffragette movement. Her father (an extraordinary man in his own right) had always been a feminist himself:

His passion was to see that his four daughters were educated, well-rounded, and part of the intellectual community he lived in. (Some heavy-hitters there - Emerson, Thoreau, etc.) Louisa's father kept detailed diaries during the raising of his 4 girls, chronicling everything about each one of them. His whole thing was early education - the importance of the first couple of years - and again, you don't ever get the sense that he thought this was only good for BOYS. On the contrary. Here's a snippet of a letter Louisa's father wrote to Elizabeth Cady Stanton in 1869, which gives you some idea of who this man was:
Woman is helping herself to secure her place in a better spirit and manner than any we [men] can suggest or devise, it becomes us to take, rather than proffer Consels, readily waiting to learn her wishes and aims, as she has so long, and so patiently deferred to us.
In 1879, Louisa May Alcott was the first woman to register to vote in Concord - for the school committee election. Pretty awesome, huh?
Her beloved father passed away on March 4, 1888. Louisa May Alcott died two days later.
An extraordinary woman.
She didn't care for the book that made her name ... and probably wished that her legacy was different ... but that's okay. It is not for the artist to decide what the audience will react to, what the reader will respond to. She created something with Little Women that transcends the ages, that pierces through the centuries. It is a classic book. And perhaps it's fitting, in a way, that she wrote it for hire, pretty much - it was not her idea, and yet - look at what she was able to create. Look at what she was able to bring out!!
Those 4 girls are immortal.
When I was 16 years old, one of the assignments we had in our Drama class was to do a one-person show - maybe 15, 20 minutes long - based on either a real person from history, or a fictional character - and we had to come into the class as that character, and do a monologue - based on our research - and then take questions from the class - in character. I still remember my core group of friends and their projects: Beth came in as Mae West. She was incredible. She had on a blowsy blonde wig, and wore a tight sparkley dress - and I still remember the shock when Beth started telling us all about birth control options - because Mae West was an early champion of birth control for women. It was awesome. Beth was fearless. Betsy did Paddington Bear (although she has no memory of this! But I SWEAR it is true!!) (and I still remember how one of the questions for Betsy was: "Why don't you eat some of your marmalade?" and Betsy - who despises marmalade - had to dip her hand into the jar, take out a big scoop of it, and eat it - pretending she liked it. Now that's dedication to the acting craft!). Michele did Marilyn Monroe. Unbelievable. Michele was an amazing actress, a natural. She got the sadness beneath the blonde glamour of Marilyn.
And I did Louisa May Alcott.
One of my first forays into the one-person show format ... I did hours and hours and hours of research for a mere 20 minute piece - because I had no idea what questions people would ask, and I had to be ready for anything!
It was great, because I had known nothing about her before that. I had just read Little Women and we had also visited her house in Concord on a family trip (a great thing to do if you are in the area). Orchard House:

Once I learned all this stuff about her, my admiration for her grew. I loved that our birthdays were almost the same. She was a Sagittarius too.

Little Women. Here's the excerpt I posted from it - an excerpt that still, after so many times reading it, brings a lump to my throat.
I don't know if I would call Little Women a great book - but I would say that it is something much better than "great": it is beloved. And that is a rare and precious thing.
Happy birthday, Louisa May!


He was a poet (virtually unknown in his own lifetime), and also an engraver (I've put some of his startling work in the extended entry - but if you want to see more of his work, check out this link). He did illustrations for children's books, religious books, volumes of poetry ... and now his stuff is considered priceless.
William Blake was born in 1757 in London, the third of five children. He went to school until he was 14 and then had to go to work. He got a job as an apprentice to an engraver, which is how he ended up making his paltry living. He lived in pretty much poverty for his entire life. He married at 25 the illiterate Catherine Boucher. Blake taught her how to read, and they ended up becoming collaborators in bringing out volumes of his poetry. He did engravings to illustrate his poems. Catherine was the one who bound the books, and got them ready for publication. The entire thing was a joint production. They did all the work themselves.
The two of them never had any children. They were extremely unconventional, and visitors tell of stopping by the Blake house to find the two of them sitting out in their back garden completely naked. Just hanging out, reading, working together, NUDE. They had a whole philosophy about nakedness, and sex, and innocence - that there was nothing dirty about any of that stuff. It actually all was quite holy, and it was human prudery that made celebration of the body a dirty thing.
William Blake had visions. He speaks about them openly and much of his work has a phantasmagorical religious feeling to it. When he was a young boy, he said he looked up into a tree and saw that it was full of winged angels.
His view of God, the Spirit, the Holy Trinity is so inspiring to me. It's vital, it's alive, and it seems to be all about love. There are not too many people I would call "genius" - but Blake I most certainly would.
However - again - William Blake, despite these astonishing works of poetry he put out during his lifetime - died unrecognized.
Now, though, he is considered to be one of the greatest poets in the English language.
He's one of my all-time favorites.
His poem about the little lisping chimney-sweep is in the "canon". If you took any kind of sweeping Poetry 101 course, you probably would have encountered it. I'll post it below. But it's really his long form poems, especially the SPECTACULAR "Marriage of Heaven and Hell", where the guy literally has no equal. None. Blake has no peers.
Here's the one about the chimney sweep, which is an indictment of the society in which he lives, a society that treats its most innocent members with brutality and uncaring indifference. He is a visionary poet, yes, but he did not turn his eyes away from earthly matters. Far from it.
"The Chimney Sweep" - from Songs of Innocence
When my mother died I was very young,
And my father sold me while yet my tongue
Could scarcely cry 'weep! 'weep! 'weep! 'weep!
So your chimneys I sweep, and in soot I sleep.
There's little Tom Dacre, who cried when his head,
That curled like a lamb's back, was shaved: so I said,
"Hush, Tom! never mind it, for when your head's bare,
You know that the soot cannot spoil your white hair."
And so he was quiet; and that very night,
As Tom was a-sleeping, he had such a sight, -
That thousands of sweepers, Dick, Joe, Ned, and Jack,
Were all of them locked up in coffins of black.
And by came an angel who had a bright key,
And he opened the coffins and set them all free;
Then down a green plain leaping, laughing, they run,
And wash in a river, and shine in the sun.
Then naked and white, all their bags left behind,
They rise upon clouds and sport in the wind;
And the angel told Tom, if he'd be a good boy,
He'd have God for his father, and never want joy.
And so Tom awoke; and we rose in the dark,
And got with our bags and our brushes to work.
Though the morning was cold, Tom was happy and warm;
So if all do their duty they need not fear harm.
And here ... for those of you who are interested ... is "Marriage of Heaven and Hell" in its entirety (accompanied by more of Blake's engravings).
Just go with it. Just succumb.
As you can see, the guy was so ahead of his time that he is timeless. He predicts the Beat generation (and Allen Ginsberg was partially responsible for bringing Blake back into vogue), he predicts modernism, he would fit in with the poetry slams of today (except that he is, well, you know - GOOD). He was a man who plumbed his unconscious for material. He brought what was within him OUT. His poetry is the literary version of Van Gogh's Starry Night. Van Gogh was not interpreting the sky. Van Gogh was actually painting what he saw. William Blake is the same way.
Thanks, Blake! Wish I could have visited you and your wife in your back garden, and sat around with you all, nude, drinking tea, and talking about angels.
Here are some quotes by and about William Blake. Enjoy!
"He had no public: he very early gave up publishing in any serious sense. one obvious consequence, or aspect, of this knowledge is the carelessness that is so apparent in the later prophetic books. Blake had ceased to be capable of taking enough trouble." -- F.R. Leavis
Improvement makes strait roads, but the crooked roads without Improvement, are roads of Genius. -- Blake
"I mean, don't you think it's a little bit excessive?"
"The road of excess leads to the palace of wisdom. William Blake."
Pause.
"William Blake?"
"William Blake!"
"William Blake???"
"William Blake!!!"
-- Bull Durham
"I do not condemn Pope or Dryden because they did not understand imagination, but because they did not understand verse." -- William Blake
"The prophetic robe with its woof of meekness and its warp of wrath was forced on [Blake] by loneliness and his modest station in life." -- Robert Graves
"In his youth, [Blake] had a gift of simple and fair speech; but he lost it. Although he could always catch the heavenly harmony of thoughts he could seldom mount them on a fitting chariot of rhythm and rhyme. His fine passages were the direct gift of the Muse, and are followed by lines of other origin." -- Edward Thomas
"It is an honesty against which the whole world conspires, because it is unpleasant." -- T.S. Eliot
"Think of a white cloud as being holy, you cannot love it, but think of a holy man within the cloud, love springs up in your thoughts, for to think of holiness distinct from man is impossible to the affections. Thought alone can make monsters, but the affections cannot." -- Blake
"He is very eighteenth century." -- T.S. Eliot
"The emotions are presented in an extremely simplified, abstract form. This form is one illustration of the eternal struggle of art against education, of the literary artist against the continuous deterioration of language." -- T.S. Eliot on "Songs of Innocence" and "Songs of Experience"
"In America in the late 1940s Allen Ginsberg, interested in Supreme Reality, alone and suffering a 'dark night of the soul sort of,' his lover Neal Cassady having sloped off, and having himself just masturbated, with a volume of Blake before him - 'I wasn't even reading, my eye was idling over the page of "Ah, Sun-flower," and it suddenly appeared - the poem I'd read a lot of times before.' He began to understand the poem, and 'suddenly, simultaneously with understanding it,' he 'heard a very deep earthen grave voice in the room, which I immediately assumed, I didn't think twice, was Blake's voice.' This 'apparitional voice' became his guiding spirit: 'It was like God had a human voice, with all the infinite tenderness and anciency and mortal gravity of a living Creator speaking to his son.' On Ginsberg this 'anciency fathered Howl, though the Blake simulacrum was aided by the hallucinogens popular at the time, the recipe for Part II of the poem including peyote, just as for Kaddish he was assisted by amphetamine injections. 'The amphetamine gives a peculiar metaphysical tinge to things, also. Space-outs.' Blake managed his visions without substance abuse. Ginsberg's appropriation of the poet of innocence and experience did much to promote Blake to the alternative culture of the 1950s and 1960s." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"a completely and uncompromisingly individual idiom and technique ... individual, original, and isolated enough to be without influence." -- FR Leavis
"You cannot create a very large poem without introducing a more impersonal point of view, or splitting it up into various personalities. But the weakness of the long poems is certainly not that they are too visionary, too remote from the world. It is that Blake did not see enough, became too much occupied with ideas." -- TS Eliot
"Romantic writers glorified childhood as a state of innocence. Blake's 'The Chimey Sweeper', written in the same year as the French Revolution, combines the Romantic cult of the child with the new radical politics, whichcan both be traced to social thinker Jean-Jacques Rousseau. It is the boy sweep, rather than Blake, who speaks: he acts as the poet's dramatic persona or mask. There is no anger in his tale. On the contrary, the sweep's gentle acceptance of his miserable life makes his exploitation seem all the more atrocious. Blake shifts responsibility for protest onto us." -- Camille Paglia, "Break, Blow, Burn"
Some of William Blake's extraordinary engravings below:
Christ in the sepulcher guarded by angels - 1805

Whirlwind of Lovers (Illustration to Dante's Inferno)

The Ancient of Days - 1794

Isaac Newton - 1795

So wrote André Gide in a letter to Paul Valéry in 1891, after meeting Oscar Wilde in Paris.

The effect Wilde had on Gide, a young man of about 20 at the time, was tremendous and could, ultimately, have destroyed Gide. Wilde's effect was so unbalancing that it took away Gide's voice. He could not write, he could barely think anymore. He trusted nothing, all of the things he thought were true he now saw were not. He did not know which end was up. He had a nervous breakdown, I suppose, although he eventually recovered (obviously. He won the Nobel Prize in 1947) Gide remained a friend of Wilde - although a distant cautious one - until the end. Whatever his tendencies were already (Gide's), they were not 'set' and neither, of course, were Wilde's, who delighted in contradictions. To someone who is a bit more rigid, perhaps, or who is looking for the answer - (not to mention living in a society that requires, expressly, that you not be who you really are) to meet someone who "delights in contradictions" can be a ruinous event. It nearly was for Gide.
Oscar Wilde's epigrams are wonderful, cutting, funny - still surprising - and his plays are still sell-outs over a century after he first wrote them - but I think in many ways we all 'only exist a little" after Wilde, there is still something so brilliant about him that it is hard to get my mind around it. It's inconsistent, at times, and there's some balderdash (the opening paragraph of Dorian Gray for example) - but the body of the work is extraordinary, and the willingness to delve deep into the contradictions of his age (and, of course, of future ages, of our age) and let two things co-exist at the same time STILL strikes me as a bit dangerous. There is STILL something truly subversive about him. (To me, "subversive" is a compliment.) His goal is to upend convention. That's all fun and good when it means curling your hair when everyone else wears it straight ... but how far will one go? How far will society let you take it?
In his contradictions, in the way he closes his epigrams with exactly the OPPOSITE of what you would expect, lies the assumption that all of society's rules and morals are up for interpretation. You can believe in that crap as "true" if you want, but Wilde will stand there, shrugging his shoulders at you languidly, and go on doing what he wants to do, and that could cause outrage in conventional people - because it wasn't so much that he flouted convention, it was that he refused to believe in the reality of those conventions in the first place. Subversive stuff. An example of his epigrams and how they start out one way, and set you up - the reader - into thinking, "Oh yes, I know where we're going" - and then he pulls the rug out, but elegantly, smoothly. Not to mention the fact that the sentiment itself is slightly unbalancing, unsettling ...
To win back my youth ... there is nothing I wouldn't do - except take exercise, get up early, or be a useful member of the community.
If all of society behaved in the way he described here, we would all be lost. But that was part of his point. And that was part of why Gide felt so silenced after meeting him for the first time.
But - on the other hand - there is a kindness in Wilde which cannot be denied. I think people often characterize him as a shallow dandy who was "brought down" into the muck, but I don't find that to be accurate. Yes, he was the promoter of the aesthetic movement, and counseled people on what books to read and how to dress and interior decorate, but it was always for a deeper purpose. Also, anyone that funny could not be shallow. His kindness is not there so much in his early plays, and certainly not there in Salomé, but as a person - he was generous, patient, and unbelievably strong in the face of relentless viciousness. He handled the insults with good humor, skewering his opponents - until he finally came across someone (the damned 9th Marquess of Queensberry, a pox on his soul) who could not be stopped, who had a chip on his shoulder the size of the entire British Isles, and who was determined to "save" his fairy son from further corruption. (Meanwhile, and this I had not known - one of the Marquess' OTHER sons had also been caught in a compromising relationship with another male, and had killed himself - right around the time that Queensberry started harassing Oscar Wilde. So. Imagine. This short angry little man - who, I'm sorry, probably had some "tendencies" himself, his response is so vicious, so out of proportion - had two gay sons, both of whom were living in an openly gay manner, in 1895. TWO sons? Unthinkable! It had to have pushed all this guy's buttons. Not to mention the fact that also right around this time, his second wife had divorced him, claiming publicly that his penis was too small for effective intercourse, and also that he was impotent, that the marriage had remained unconsummated. So. Make of that what you will. His unresolved issues ruined another man's life - a man whose writing I happen to cherish, so I've got zero sympathy for the guy.)

And so Wilde found himself a pawn in a fiery family struggle between father (Marquess of Queensberry) and son (Lord Alfred Douglas). Lord Douglas was no shrinking violet in this, Lord Douglas was the main instigator, pushing Wilde further and further into it, forcing the confrontation, glorying in the fact that his famous lover was "sticking it to dear old Dad". Wilde, too, who had two pretty extraordinary people as parents (look them up. Amazing people.) just did not approve of how the Douglas family treated one another. Lord Douglas would send telegrams to his father, saying stuff like, "You are a silly stupid man" and Wilde would just shake his head and remark, "You shouldn't talk to a parent like that." Imagine the generosity of this. Here he is talking about a man who is threatening to ruin him, who leaves notes under his front door calling him a "sodomite" and every other nasty name in the book, who stages protests outside productions of plays Wilde has written - who is doing everything possible to make Wilde miserable - and here Wilde is, chiding the son for talking to his father in a disrespectful manner. He had class, that's why.
He, a man of exquisite manners and taste, who loved his parents and remained close to his mother all the days of his life (his father passed away much earlier) found himself embroiled in a brou-haha that would ruin him completely. Fate, doom, whatever you want to call it. Wilde was not an innocent bystander in any way... he had invited Lord Douglas into his life and, therefore, by proxy, invited the Marquess into his life who would ruin everything ... but Wilde (unlike Douglas) was not a vindictive person. Wilde knew Douglas could ruin him. Perhaps that was part of the thrill. The beautiful dangerous boy and all that. In reading about Wilde, in reading about all of the literary spats he got into, all of the verbal sparring with current authors of the day - I never feel that he is vindictive. Or cruel. He is clever, and intelligent - and yes, often merciless - but never needlessly cruel.
So to see the cruelty that was heaped upon him at the end ... it's just awful.
It's very rare that a biography can bring me to tears. Patricia Bosworth's biography of Montgomery Clift did, but I can't think of another one. I have wept often when reading the collected letters of so-and-so, or the diary of a famous figure - because it is immediate, visceral, first-person, personal history as it is happening. But a biography has a bit more distance to it. Even if the events are really sad, it usually doesn't move me to tears.
I just finished Richard Ellmann's biography of Oscar Wilde and cried pretty much non-stop for the last 30 pages. I had to take breaks, it was just too much.
Now, the last 5 years of Oscar Wilde's life are horrifying enough to make a person tremble and cross herself in fervent thanks that none of it happened to her, but it is Ellmann's deep compassion (not to mention intelligent piecing-together of events, through letters and diary entries) that brought it so vividly before my eyes that I found tears streaming down my face. I know the story of his downfall, I know the series of truly unfortunate events, but not to the detailed extent I do now. The court transcripts are included in the book, the letters written from prison ...
It's one of the most moving books I've ever read.
Ellmann is spectacular (as I already know - since I've read his biography of James Joyce, one of the towering literary achievements of the 20th century) - and not just spectacular in putting together all the pieces of this very public (and yet also very duplicitous) life ... but spectacular on analyzing Wilde's development as an artist.
But more than anything right now, I'm left really sad. Sad for the suffering of a fellow human being in 1897, 1898. I cannot even imagine his torment, and I have tears in my eyes now as I type this out.
So forgive my being silent: after Wilde, I only exist a little.
Wonderful interview of Seamus Heaney by Dennis O'Driscoll.
One of my favorite excerpts from the interview:
I had no particular gift for writing what were called "compositions", and no particular enjoyment of it. But I do remember a moment, early on at St Columb's, when the topic was "A Day at the Seaside" and I made a connection between the performative student in me and a more inward creature, the writer-in-waiting, if you like. In the middle of the list of usual, expected activities such as diving and swimming, neither of which I could do, I wrote about going into an amusement arcade to escape from a shower and being depressed by the wet footprints on the floor and the cold, wet atmosphere created by people in their rained-on summer clothes. This had actually happened to me, so the image and the recording of it had a different feel. Something in me knew that I was on the right, intimate track - but it took me years to follow up.
And I love his bit about trying to locate it.
A new book is coming out, a compilation of interviews with Seamus Heaney (and he's a wonderful interview, juicy, intelligent - always leaves you with something to chew on). I've seen him read a couple of times, once in a nearly empty classroom at NYU in the middle of the afternoon ... and he's wonderful "live". Just wonderful. Funny, mischievous, and sharp.

Poems and quotes from and about her below - in honor of this amazing talent, who pretty much burst fully-formed onto the poetry scene. Kind of incredible. When you read the Complete Poems, you can feel her sliding off the rails at the end (I'm not talking about mentally - I'm talking about the quality of her work, although the two are probably related) ... some of those late poems are embarrassing. (I love Robert Lowell's quote below, and think it would have been very interesting - might have saved Sexton that embarrassment). But she was all about revealing her truth, as it was in whatever moment she found herself in. The clarity and almost frightening pure expressing of much of her work is gone at the end, and some of it sounds like a bad imitation of Jack Kerouac, a riff with no purpose, no cleverness ... like this, from one of her last poems:
I love you the way the oboe plays.
I love you the way skinny dipping makes my body feels.
I love you the way a ripe artichoke tastes.
Yet I fear you,
as one in the desert fears the sun.
True.
True.
This is terrible stuff, the voice of a sentimental undergraduate in a beginning poetry class, not a celebrated prize-winning American poet. It almost embarrasses me to type that out here. So I see there to be a regression in the gift - because her first poems are spectacular, and she wasn't like Sylvia Plath - a precocious academic poetess, getting published in Seventeen magazine when she was still a teenager, and winning prizes, and all that. Sexton was getting married, having kids, and struggling with her sickness.

She was a housewife, mother, and madwoman - who had spent time in mental institutions, and a psychiatrist suggested that maybe she "should write" as a way to get through the darker moments. Maxine Kumin tells the story:
Nevertheless, seven months after her second child, Joyce Ladd Sexton, was born in 1955, Anne suffered a second crisis and was hospitalized. The children were sent to live with her husband's parents; and while they were separated from her, she attempted suicide on her birthday, November 9, 1956. This was the first of several episodes, or at least the first that was openly acknowledged. Frequently, these attempts occurred around Anne's birthday, a time of year she came increasingly to dread. Dr. Martin Orne, Brunner-Orne's son, was the young psychiatrist at Glenside Hospital who attended Anne during this siege and treated her for the next seven years. After administering a series of diagnostic tests, he presented his patient with her scores, objective evidence that, despite the disapproving naysayers from her past, she was highly intelligent. Her associative gifts suggested that she ought to return to the writing of poetry, something she had shown a deft talent for during secondary school. It was at Orne's insistence that Anne enrolled in the Holmes workshop."You, Dr. Martin" came directly out of that experience, as did so many of the poems in her first collection, To Bedlam and Part Way Back.
The first poem Anne wrote, "You, Dr. Martin", reads:
You, Doctor Martin, walk
from breakfast to madness. Late August,
I speed through the antiseptic tunnel
where the moving dead still talk
of pushing their bones against the thrust
of cure. And I am queen of this summer hotel
or the laughing bee on a stalkof death. We stand in broken
lines and wait while they unlock
the doors and count us at the frozen gates
of dinner. The shibboleth is spoken
and we move to gravy in our smock
of smiles. We chew in rows, our plates
scratch and whine like chalkin school. There are no knives
for cutting your throat. I make
moccasins all morning. At first my hands
kept empty, unraveled for the lives
they used to work. Now I learn to take
them back, each angry finger that demands
I mend what another will breaktomorrow. Of course, I love you;
you lean above the plastic sky,
god of our block, prince of all the foxes.
The breaking crowns are new
that Jack wore.
Your third eye
moves among us and lights the separate boxes
where we sleep or cry.What large children we are
here. All over I grow most tall
in the best ward. Your business is people,
you call at the madhouse, an oracular
eye in our nest. Out in the hall
the intercom pages you. You twist in the pull
of the foxy children who falllike floods of life in frost.
And we are magic talking to itself,
noisy and alone. I am queen of all my sins
forgotten. Am I still lost?
Once I was beautiful. Now I am myself,
counting this row and that row of moccasins
waiting on the silent shelf.
Her first poem.

Whether or not you "like this sort of stuff" (and that is the main complaint you hear about Sexton and the other "confessional" poets) is not the point. The point is that the VOICE we meet in "You, Dr. Martin" is confident, strong, and unselfconscious. We know we are meeting the POET, not a persona, or a smokescreen of words and devices. It's not clever. Straight out of the gate, there was nothing between Anne Sexton and her expression of herself. Sylvia Plath's early poems suffer from precocity, they can come off as coy - arch - She was still working to find herself. Wonderful stuff, with some startling lines - but it wouldn't be until 1962, years into her career, when Plath would burst out with her original voice - that you would never ever mistake for anyone else's. Sexton STARTED at that point. Her voice didn't need to be developed, or honed. It came out fully-formed. There was much jealousy between the two, although they were also good friends.
Her life was not easy, she was a wild woman, and she made life hell for her husband, her kids, and anyone who really loved her. A mixture of drink, drugs, and a lifetime battle with mental illness took its toll on her relationships, certainly, but it also took its toll on her writing gift, which you can see in those later poems, which don't just read as hallucinatory or unclear - but as amateur.
Regardless: A remarkable journey. With some WONDERFUL poems.
My father saw her read her poetry in Cambridge, Massachusetts when he was in college. Her poetry readings were more like underground rock shows, with handmade posters, and an electric buzz of excitement running through the mostly-young crowd. They weren't poetry readings, they were events. Anne Sexton was gorgeous, and she would dress the part. When my dad saw her, she wore a bright red dress, slinked her legs around each other (so many of the photos of her have her twining those legs about), and chain-smoked. My dad said she was great, he remembers it well.

My favorite of hers is this one:
LIVE
Live or die, but don't poison everything...
Well, death's been here
for a long time --
it has a hell of a lot
to do with hell
and suspicion of the eye
and the religious objects
and how I mourned them
when they were made obscene
by my dwarf-heart's doodle.
The chief ingredient
is mutilation.
And mud, day after day,
mud like a ritual,
and the baby on the platter,
cooked but still human,
cooked also with little maggots,
sewn onto it maybe by somebody's mother,
the damn bitch!
Even so,
I kept right on going on,
a sort of human statement,
lugging myself as if
I were a sawed-off body
in the trunk, the steamer trunk.
This became perjury of the soul.
It became an outright lie
and even though I dressed the body
it was still naked, still killed.
It was caught
in the first place at birth,
like a fish.
But I play it, dressed it up,
dressed it up like somebody's doll.
Is life something you play?
And all the time wanting to get rid of it?
And further, everyone yelling at you
to shut up. And no wonder!
People don't like to be told
that you're sick
and then be forced
to watch
you
come
down with the hammer.
Today life opened inside me like an egg
and there inside
after considerable digging
I found the answer.
What a bargain!
There was the sun,
her yolk moving feverishly,
tumbling her prize --
and you realize she does this daily!
I'd known she was a purifier
but I hadn't thought
she was solid,
hadn't known she was an answer.
God! It's a dream,
lovers sprouting in the yard
like celery stalks
and better,
a husband straight as a redwood,
two daughters, two sea urchings,
picking roses off my hackles.
If I'm on fire they dance around it
and cook marshmallows.
And if I'm ice
they simply skate on me
in little ballet costumes.
Here,
all along,
thinking I was a killer,
anointing myself daily
with my little poisons.
But no.
I'm an empress.
I wear an apron.
My typewriter writes.
It didn't break the way it warned.
Even crazy, I'm as nice
as a chocolate bar.
Even with the witches' gymnastics
they trust my incalculable city,
my corruptible bed.
O dearest three,
I make a soft reply.
The witch comes on
and you paint her pink.
I come with kisses in my hood
and the sun, the smart one,
rolling in my arms.
So I say Live
and turn my shadow three times round
to feed our puppies as they come,
the eight Dalmatians we didn't drown,
despite the warnings: The abort! The destroy!
Despite the pails of water that waited,
to drown them, to pull them down like stones,
they came, each one headfirst, blowing bubbles the color of cataract-blue
and fumbling for the tiny tits.
Just last week, eight Dalmatians,
3/4 of a lb., lined up like cord wood
each
like a
birch tree.
I promise to love more if they come,
because in spite of cruelty
and the stuffed railroad cars for the ovens,
I am not what I expected. Not an Eichmann.
The poison just didn't take.
So I won't hang around in my hospital shift,
repeating The Black Mass and all of it.
I say Live, Live because of the sun,
the dream, the excitable gift.

"All I wanted was a little piece of life, to be married, to have children.... I was trying my damnedest to lead a conventional life, for that was how I was brought up, and it was what my husband wanted of me. But one can't build little white picket fences to keep the nightmares out." -- Anne Sexton
"Untrammeled by a traditional education in Donne, Milton, Yeats, Eliot, and Pound, Anne was able to strike out alone, like Conrad's secret sharer, for a new destiny. She was grim about her lost years, her lack of a college degree; she read omnivorously and quite innocently whatever came to hand and enticed her, forming her own independent, quirky, and incisive judgments. Searching for solutions to the depressive episodes that beset her with dismaying periodicty, Anne read widely in the popular psychiatric texts of the time: interpretations of Freud, Theodore Reik, Philip Reiff, Helena Deutsch, Erik Erikson, Bruno Bettelheim. During a summer-school course with Philip Rahv, she encountered the works of Dostoevsky, Kafka, and Thomas Mann. These were succeeded by the novels of Saul Bellow, Philip Roth, and Kurt Vonnegut. But above all else, she was attracted to the fairy tales of Andersen and Grimm, which her beloved Nana had read to her when she was a child. They were for her, perhaps, what Bible stories and Greek myths had been for other writers. At the same time that she was being entertained and drawn into closer contact with a kind of collective unconscious, she was searching the fairy tales for psychological parallels." -- Maxine Kumin
"What Sexton suggested to Plath was the force of simple rhyme and simple rhythm, the magic of nursery rhyme darkened by time, of fairy tale where the happy ending somehow doesn't happen. Sexton showed Plath the way, and then Plath died first, stealing a march on her friend, which Sexton resented and envied. Four years Plath's senior, Anne Sexton survived her by twelve years, committing suicide in 1974. But Plath keeps hold of the laurels. There are wonderful things in the Complete Poems of Sexton, published in 1981, but many of them are things we associate, whatever their original source, with Plath, and Sexton's work seems but a footnote to hers." -_ Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"Criticism of 4 of my poems in Lowell's class: criticism of rhetoric. He sets me up with Ann Sexton, an honor, I suppose. Well, about time. She has very good things, and they get better, though there is a lot of loose stuff." -- Sylvia Plath, journal, March 20, 1959
"This then is a phenomenon ... to remind us, when we have forgotten in the weariness of literature, that poetry can happen." -- Louis Simpson on the publication of Anne Sexton's first book of poetry
"For a book or two, she grew more powerful. Then writing was too easy or too hard for her. She became meager and exaggerated. Many of her most embarrassing poems would have been fascinating if someone had put them in quotes, as the presentation of some character, not the author. -- Robert Lowell
"Have rejected the Electra poem from my book. Too forced and rhetorical. A leaf from Anne Sexton's book would do here. She has none of my clenches and an ease of phrase, and an honesty. I have my 40 unattackable poems." -- Sylvia Plath, journal, April 23, 1959
"I hold back nothing." -- Anne Sexton, 1969

"Retyped pages, a messy job, on the volume of poems I should be turning in to Houghton Mifflin this week. But AS [Anne Sexton] is there ahead of me, with her lover GS [George Starbuck] writing New Yorker odes to her and both of them together: felt our triple martini afternoons at the Ritz breaking up. That memorable afternoon at G's monastic and miserly room on Pinckney "You shouldn't have left us": where is responsibility to lie? I left, yet felt like a brown winged moth around a rather meagre candle flame, drawn. That is over." -- Sylvia Plath, journal, May 3, 1959
"Does Sexton imagine any way out of this impasse, any way to escape the debilitating terrors of a consciousness plagued by a conviction of its own evil? One possibility is to replace self-loathing with an open acceptance of evil—even admitting the likelihood that she is 'not a woman'. What is remarkable, however, is not this admission itself but the lively, almost gleeful tone in which it is uttered:
"I have gone out, a possessed witch,
haunting the black air, braver at night;
dreaming of evil, I have done my hitch
over the plain houses, light by light:
lonely thing, twelve-fingered, out of mind.
A woman like that is not a woman, quite.
I have been her kind.
" 'A woman like that is misunderstood,' Sexton adds wryly, but the poem is a serious attempt to understand such a woman--her sense of estrangement, her impulse toward death--by internalizing evil and giving it a voice: a chortling, self-satisfied, altogether amiable voice which suggests that 'evil' is perhaps the wrong word after all. Sexton's witch, waving her 'nude arms at villages going by,' becomes something of value to the community, performing the function Kurt Vonnegut has called the 'domestication of terror.' Unlike Plath's madwoman in 'Lady Lazarus'--a woman at the service of a private, unyielding anger, a red-haired demon whose revenge is to 'eat men like air'--Sexton's witch is essentially harmless. Although she remains vulnerable--'A woman like that is not afraid to die'--she rejects anger in favor of humor, flamboyance, self-mockery. She is a kind of perverse entertainer, and if she seems cast in the role of a martyr, embracing madness in order to domesticate it for the rest of the community--making it seem less threatening, perhaps even enjoyable--it is nevertheless a martyrdom which this aspect of Sexton accepts with a peculiar zest." -- Greg Johnson on Anne Sexton's perhaps most-famous poem, "Her Kind"
Her Kind
by Anne Sexton
I have gone out, a possessed witch,
haunting the black air, braver at night;
dreaming evil, I have done my hitch
over the plain houses, light by light:
lonely thing, twelve-fingered, out of mind.
A woman like that is not a woman, quite.
I have been her kind.
I have found the warm caves in the woods,
filled them with skillets, carvings, shelves,
closets, silks, innumerable goods;
fixed the suppers for the worms and the elves:
whining, rearranging the disaligned.
A woman like that is misunderstood.
I have been her kind.
I have ridden in your cart, driver,
waved my nude arms at villages going by,
learning the last bright routes, survivor
where your flames still bite my thigh
and my ribs crack where your wheels wind.
A woman like that is not ashamed to die.
I have been her kind.
"Once, when I wrote to her about my terror of publishing a second book of poems, she answered: 'Don't dwell on the book's reception. The point is to get on with it--you have a life's work ahead of you--no point in dallying around waiting for approval. We all want it, I know, but the point is to reach out honestly--that's the whole point. I keep feeling that there isn't one poem being written by any of us--or a book or anything like that. The whole life of us writers, the whole product I guess I mean, is the one long poem--a community effort if you will. It's all the same poem. It doesn't belong to any one writer--it's God's poem perhaps. Or God's people's poem. You have the gift-- and with it comes responsibility--you mustn't neglect or be mean to that gift--you must let it do its work. It has more rights than the ego that wants approval.'" -- Erica Jong
"It would be hard to find a writer who dwells more insistently on the pathetic and disgusting aspects of bodily experience." -- James Dickey - the man who wrote "Deliverance", a book that had, if I recall, quite a few "disgusting aspects". I suppose when women write about their bodies it's just grosser to some people. Oh, boo-hoo. I love Dickey's poems, but I do not like this comment of his.
"[Sexton's poems] raise the never-solved problem of what literature really is, where you draw the line between art and documentary." -- Hayden Carruth
"My own struggle with Anne Sexton, for twenty years now, has not been about her subject matter (she is the one who taught me that you can write a poem about anything), but about the blatant deterioration of her talent. Sexton's Complete Poems appeared in 1981, edited by her daughter/literary executor Linda Gray Sexton. This volume includes the eight books Anne Sexton sent to press during her lifetime, as well as one hundred and thirty pages of posthumously published poems. Though fascinating as Sexton documents, the latter are shockingly sloppy and full of over-the-top, bad-trip imagery. This, coupled with the fact that the last three books she did publish (The Book of Folly, The Death Notebooks, and That Awful Rowing Toward God) saw an obvious decline in quality, has made it difficult to come to grips with her complete body of work. It also didn't help that, after her death, her former mentor Robert Lowell wrote that her writing had become "meager and exaggerated." I jokingly refer to Sexton's late period as "Bad Anne." How else to reconcile such slipshod lines as "I flee. I flee. / I block my ears and eat salami" with her amazing early metaphors ("leaves . . . born in their own green blood / like the hands of mermaids") and admissions ("Once I was beautiful. Now I am myself")? It's too painful to think of her simply as a brilliant poet who got bad. And too easy, somehow, to blame it on pills, alcohol, insanity, fame. Better, I recently decided, to think of her as a genius with demons, writing to beat the clock. " -- David Trinidad
"Her delineation of femaleness [is] so fanatical that it makes one wonder, even after many years of being one, what a woman is." -- Mona Van Duyn
"All I need now is to hear that GS [George Starbuck] or MK [Maxine Kumin] has won the Yale and get a rejection of my children's book. AS [Anne Sexton] has her book accepted at HM and this afternoon will be drinking champagne. Also an essay accepted by PJHH [Peter J. Henniker-Heaton], the copy-cat. But who's to criticize a more successful copy-cat. Not to mention a poetry reading at McLean. And GS at supper last night, smug as a cream-fed cat, very pleased indeed, for AS is, in a sense, his answer to me." -- Sylvia Plath, journal, May 20th, 1959
"Her vision of Him as the winner in a crooked poker game at the end of that book [The Awful Rowing Toward God] is a sporting admission of her defeat rather than a decisive renewal of the Christian myth." -- Estella Lauter

"One feels tempted to drop [Sexton's poems] furtively in the nearest ashcan, rather than to be caught with them in the presence of so much naked suffering." -- James Dickey
"NOW: the story about George, J-- and Ann, and the children. An insufferable woman (myself of course) gets involved in the separated family. She thinks G will be fondest of her, tells mad wife (she's sick, I mean, really sick) it is of course Ann, feels very clever. Then finds out, when A's book is accepted, it is really A, gets furious. Calls up society, or gets sociologist friend to call up society for prevention of cruelty for children, never really finds out if they get through. Day in park. Children can't speak, finds herself throwing peanuts to pigeons etc. Ducks, squirrels, children blank-staring and oblivious. Smell bad, girl urinates on bench. I wouldn't be surprised to read tomorrow in the paper how that little girl was killed falling from that roof. Of course she never does read any such thing. Her good will perverted, conditional on pity that would generate from self if G was her lover, when cheated of that, it becomes nasty busybodiness. THE OLYMPIANS. Poor, married poets in Ritz bar. -- Sylvia Plath, jotting down sketches for a story about Anne Sexton, journal, June 15, 1959
Sylvia's Death - by Anne Sexton
for Sylvia Plath
O Sylvia, Sylvia,
with a dead box of stones and spoons,
with two children, two meteors
wandering loose in a tiny playroom,
with your mouth into the sheet,
into the roofbeam, into the dumb prayer,
(Sylvia, Sylvia
where did you go
after you wrote me
from Devonshire
about rasing potatoes
and keeping bees?)
what did you stand by,
just how did you lie down into?
Thief --
how did you crawl into,
crawl down alone
into the death I wanted so badly and for so long,
the death we said we both outgrew,
the one we wore on our skinny breasts,
the one we talked of so often each time
we downed three extra dry martinis in Boston,
the death that talked of analysts and cures,
the death that talked like brides with plots,
the death we drank to,
the motives and the quiet deed?
(In Boston
the dying
ride in cabs,
yes death again,
that ride home
with our boy.)
O Sylvia, I remember the sleepy drummer
who beat on our eyes with an old story,
how we wanted to let him come
like a sadist or a New York fairy
to do his job,
a necessity, a window in a wall or a crib,
and since that time he waited
under our heart, our cupboard,
and I see now that we store him up
year after year, old suicides
and I know at the news of your death
a terrible taste for it, like salt,
(And me,
me too.
And now, Sylvia,
you again
with death again,
that ride home
with our boy.)
And I say only
with my arms stretched out into that stone place,
what is your death
but an old belonging,
a mole that fell out
of one of your poems?
(O friend,
while the moon's bad,
and the king's gone,
and the queen's at her wit's end
the bar fly ought to sing!)
O tiny mother,
you too!
O funny duchess!
O blonde thing!
"I'm hunting for the truth. It might be a kind of poetic truth, and not just a factual one, because behind everything that happens to you, there is another truth, a secret life." -- Anne Sexton

One of the most seismic events of the 20th century: The Russian Revolution.

Look at that gathering of rogues.

I love the grainy old photographs of all of them - they always look so twinkly and jolly, don't they? It's such a dichotomy because honestly a more humorless and nasty bunch has never existed. Stalin's face always seems to be twinkling, as though he is Santa Claus on his day off. And the "social realism" paintings of the guy are so idealized it makes me want to puke. Standing surrounded by children, glimmering and twinkling benevolently. But they ALL look like that to me. Like they are chortling from on high. I say "I love the grainy old photographs" not because it does my heart good to see Trotsky smiling - but because I find them VERY interesting. Especially, as I mentioned, the collective twinkle in the eye. It's propaganda. Very very effective propaganda. Myth-making.

On this day in 1917, the Bolsheviks seized the government buildings and put out a proclamation declaring the new government. There had been a spontaneous uprising in February of the same year, and much upheaval led up to the October Revolution. The Czar had abdicated (unbelievable) - a Provisional Government had been set up (with a mix of the old guard and the new ... well, THAT didn't last long) ... the Bolsheviks, in their power-grab, put out a notice saying that the Provisional Government was no longer.

There was almost no resistance, although a civil war followed.
The Russian Revolution is, along with Cary Grant and the early career of Ralph Macchio, one of my enduring fascinations.
Many reasons why.
First of all: I love politics and history - and whatever the outcome, you would be hard pressed to find a more important moment of political upheaval in the entire 20th century than the Russian Revolution. It changed the world.

Second of all: because it was SUCH a bad idea.
This is the secret in the secret book in 1984 (excerpt here). This is what nobody told you: The point was NEVER equality. The point was ALWAYS power - and controlling power into the hands of a very few. But the theories and ideals surrounding this secret were compelling to so many ... many still refuse to believe that there is no secret. That the smokescreen of equality was STILL the real point.
Thirdly: I am fascinated in the Russian Revolution because of the world-wide repercussions of it - and also because I vividly remember the entire edifice cracking apart in the late 80s. I couldn't believe it. I am in that generation that still grew up being afraid of Russia. Come on, I saw Red Dawn and it was real enough at the time for me to tremble at the thought of such a thing actually happening. We were the last generation to grow up with that fear. We have OTHER fears now - but not that one. I grew up during the dying gasps of the Cold War. So - to learn about the BEGINNINGS of such a political movement - something that would be entrenched for the better part of a century - has always been important to me.
And lastly,: cults fascinate me. How do you not only control what people DO but how they THINK? It all comes down to language.
In the early heady days of the Bolshevik takeover - there was something in their twinkly assurance that they could re-make the world through LANGUAGE itself. Imposing a mindset, a correct way of thinking, on a country of millions.

Victor Klemperer, a German Jew who lived in Dresden Germany and witnessed the rise of Nazi power, eventually wrote a book (after WWII and the fall of the Nazis) called The Language of the Third Reich and it is an obsessive documentation of how the language was co-opted by the Nazis. He has saved newspaper clippings, obituaries, regular classifieds - to show how the language had filtered down into even the most mundane level. It became a code. It had no life in it. It atomized - from top to bottom. It is chilling - a brilliant book, I highly recommend it (not to mention his published journals of the Nazi years - NOT to be missed: I Will Bear Witness: A Diary of the Nazi Years, 1933-1941
and I Will Bear Witness 1942-1945: A Diary of the Nazi Years
. Invaluable historical documents. An example of his notes about "the language of the third reich" here)
John Reed's 10 days that Shook the World is a brilliant and intense piece of propaganda . It's so vivid that you can see the clouds of people's breath in the freezing air as they stomp in the packed ice outside the Winter Palace. You smell the cigar smoke, all of that. A first-hand account of the October Revolution, it was the book that "sold" the Revolution to the outside world. I used to have a way-more condescending readership than I do now - this was in the early days of my site - and most of those guys have moved on to greener friendlier pastures. I got in fights on almost a daily basis with readers who couldn't seem to stop visiting me every day, but who just couldn't stand how I wrote. It wasn't clear enough for them. They thought they were visiting, oh, Little Green Footballs or something, and then were shocked when I wasn't, you know, batshit crazy. I realize I can't control everything, and that people all come to me for different reasons - and that's cool - but once you're here? I encourage a certain KIND of commentary, because it, to me, is the most satisfying and civilized. But some people couldn't hack it. They OOZED with condescension towards me. These were all conservatives. I'm pretty conservative myself, but I'm not like THESE bozos, thank Christ. They all sounded the same. They all used the same words. They couldn't understand why I, who shared some of their views, used, uhm, different words. The first time I wrote about John Reed and had the GALL to praise his writing, I was condescended to within an inch of my life by idiots who can't see the difference between art and ideology. "You CAN'T praise his writing!! You just CAN'T!" I was called "just plain stupid" on a prominent conservative website. hahahahaha Sorry, that cracks me up. These worried little readers gave me long lists of things I 'NEEDED' to read (all of which I had already read) in order to counteract Reed's propaganda. Huh? These readers seemed truly nervous to be in the presence of an independent thinker who could say things like, "John Reed's a fine writer" and still have her brain intact. This became the main issue in the old days with my site: those who could not talk about art without talking about ideology.
Now this is all rather interesting, in retrospect, because it shows the totalitarian mindset actually at work (albeit in a small benign way). The need to control how another person speaks is one of the cornerstones of a totalitarian gameplan. And so if people use different words, words that do not have the stamp of approval from some Bigwig on a Podium - or if they use the "right" words but put them in the "wrong" order it is seen as deeply disturbing. "Wait ... wait ... what is she SAYING?" It was truly interesting. So I would lead off not with a condemnation, but with words of praise for the writing, and people would read NO FARTHER, and jump all over me. "No no no, you have to LEAD OFF with your condemnation of the ideas - you can't just start a post with the words 'John Reed was a good writer' - because THEN what will people think??" Ah, but those are the words of an ideologue, and I am not an ideologue. I'd write a post about the control of language in Communist society, and these dudes would race in, trying to control my language. But these guys considered themselves to be defenders of democracy. It was rich!!

(twinkle, twinkle, glimmer, glimmer, look at our serious comradely rural conversation about serious ideas, we are in accord, we are dear brothers of the spirit. Yeah, right.)
Back to the topic at hand - John Reed: I love first-person accounts of any historical event. I like to feel like I am THERE. What did you smell, see, touch? One of his contemporaries has said, about Reed's writing and journalism, "He couldn't be touched", and he really can't, not in terms of reportage, as well as giving you a sweeping sense that you are there.
Reed prints all of the Bolshevik pamphlets, fliers, announcements - word for word, in facsimile sometimes, so that you can see what it actually looked like - and all of it is in that LANGUAGE of Communism, that deadening blunted-edge language - with no poetry, no humanity in it. It is FROM a collective and TO a collective. I start to drone out into some gray foggy area as I read that stuff, losing my critical mind.
To control a population: you MUST control their language. You MUST show them the "correct" way to speak. There is only ONE meaning of the word "state". There can only be ONE meaning of the word "freedom". So the leaders of the Revolution set out immediately to co-opt the language. Watch any developing revolution anywhere in the world and watch how they start by controlling the language. Look at the group of peole today who want to control the words "marriage", "family", "values". Their desire is to co-opt MEANING, make no mistake about it. Their desire is EXclusive - to shut others out, they want to "own" a word. They are not to be trusted.
George Orwell knew this, of course, and that's where the whole Newspeak thing comes from, in 1984.
I find it interesting, and ironic in a horrifying way, that Lenin would say: "While the State exists there can be no freedom; when there is freedom there will be no State."
Look at that language. The language of diametrically opposed clarity. This is not the language of humanity. It is an abstraction. I am not entirely convinced that any of these people truly believed in the Utopia, although it's not always easy to know someone's motivations or beliefs - as people are notoriously unreliable witnesses about themselves. Some of them did - and the gradations were much subtler back then, of socialism, communism, capitalism. Orwell is eloquent on all of this, as are many of the other "converts" - Arthur Koestler is another one. The belief in socialism is also a difficult thing to talk about with those who have entrenched prejudices, but again: I'm talking about history here on the ground-level - NOT the filtered-down present day version where the sides are clearly drawn. In the early days, there was much belief, there was also not a lot of information coming out of Russia, and there was a smokescreen thrown up - for decades - about what was actually happening. Many were duped. I think many were WILLINGLY duped. They went and witnessed the "show trials" of the 1930s and bought the piece of theatre as the truth. "Yes, it's awful, but these people all actually CONFESSED ... so of course they were guilty - otherwise why would they confess?" This is the pampered Western mind at work, and we should be grateful, actually, that we do have a level of incomprehension about that kind of pressure and insanity. But before that - in the teens and twenties - things were not at all as clear as they soon became.
So Lenin makes that statement about the state - but then of course what happened in Russia? The State became everything.
I refuse to just blame this on Stalin's evil - although I do think he was evil - and missing whatever piece it is that makes most of us human. I don't think he was the way he was because his Mummah didn't love him enough, or because he was short. I think there was something in him - a deadly mixture of patience and violence (rare rare rare - most dictators have the violent thing down, but what most of them lack is PATIENCE - Stalin knew how to wait ... sometimes for decades ... to get what he wanted). But I don't think Stalin took an essentially good idea and made it bad. I think it was a terrible idea to begin with.
Check out the picture below - of junkers lounging around in the Winter Palace in the fall of 1917:

From John Reed's 10 days that Shook the World - one of his descriptions of the events of Nov. 7, 1917 - marvelous writer, marvelous first-hand reportage, although my modern-day self rolls my eyes at his naivete:
By this time, in the light that streamed out of all the Winter Palace windows, I could see that the first two or three hundred men were Red Guards, with only a few scattered soldiers. Over the barricade of firewood we clambered, and leaping down inside gave a triumphant shout as we stumbled on a heap of rifles thrown down by the yunkers who had stood there. On both sides of the main gateway the doors stood wide open, light streamed out, and from the huge pile came not the slightest sound.Carried along by the eager wave of men we were swept into the right hand entrance, opening into a great bare vaulted room, the cellar of the East wing, from which issued a maze of corridors and stair-cases. A number of huge packing cases stood about, and upon these the Red Guards and soldiers fell furiously, battering them open with the butts of their rifles, and pulling out carpets, curtains, linen, porcelain plates, glassware ... One man went strutting around with a bronze clock perched on his shoulder; another found a plume of ostrich feathers which he stuck in his hat. The looting was just beginning when somebody cried, "Comrades! Don't touch anything! Don't take anything! This is the property of the People!" Immediately twenty voices were crying, "Stop! Put everything back! Don't take anything! Property of the People!" Many hands dragged the spoilers down. Damask and tapestry were snatched from the arms of those who had them; two men took away the bronze clock. Roughly and hastily the things were crammed back in their cases, and self-appointed sentinels stood guard. It was all utterly spontaneous. Through corridors and up stair-cases the cry could be heard growing fainter and fainter in the distance, "Revolutionary discipline! Property of the People ...."
Here's all the crap I have written about Stalin over the years, if you're interested.

(portraits of the Romanovs ripped off the walls of the Palace and other official buildings)
Robert K. Massie's highwater-mark book Nicholas and Alexandra (excerpt here) describes the October Revolution from the perspective of the Czar and his family, already incarcerated (for their "protection"):
In September, the Bolsheviks gained a majority within the Petrograd Soviet. From Finland, Lenin urged an immediate lunge for supreme power: "History will not forgive us if we do not take power now ... to delay is a crime." On October 23, Lenin, in disguise, slipped back into Petrograd to attend a meeting of the Bolshevik Central Committee, which voted 10 to 1 that "insurrection is inevitable and the time fully ripe."On November 6, the Bolsheviks struck. That day, the cruiser Aurora, flying the red flag, anchored in the Neva opposite the Winter Palace. Armed Bolshevik squads occupied the railway stations, bridges, banks, telephone exchanges, post office and other public buildings. There was no bloodshed. The next morning, November 7, Kerensky left the Winter Palace in an open Pierce-Arrow touring car accompanied by another car flying the American flag. Passing unmolested through the streets filled with Bolshevik soldiers, he drove south to try to raise help from the army. The remaining ministers of the Provisional Government remained in the Malachite Hall of the Winter Palace, protected by a women's battalion and a troop of cadets. Sitting around a green baize table, filling the ashtrays with cigarette butts, the ministers covered their scratch pads with abstract doodles and drafts of pathetic last-minute proclamations: "The Provisional Government appeals to all classes to support the Provisional Government --" At nine p.m., the Aurora fired a blank shell, and at ten, the women's battalion surrendered. At eleven, another thirty or forty shells whistled across the river from the batteries in the Fortress of Peter and Paul. Only two shells hit the palace, slightly damaging the plaster. Nevertheless, at 2:10 a.m. on November 8, the ministers gave up.
This skirmish was the Bolshevik November Revolution, later magnified in Communist mythology into an epic of struggle and heroism. In fact, life in the capital was largely undisturbed. Restaurants, stores and cinemas on the Nevsky Prospect remained open. Streetcards moved as usual through most of the city, and the ballet performed at the Maryinsky Theatre. On the afternoon of the 7th, Sir George Buchanan walked in the vicinity of the Winter Palace and found "the aspect of the quay was more or less normal." Nevertheless, this flick of Lenin's finger was all that was necessary to finish Kerensky. Unsuccessful in raising help, Kerensky never returned to Petrograd. In May, after months in hiding, he appeared secretly in Moscow, where Bruce Lockhart issued him a false visa identifying him as a Siberian soldier being repatriated home. Three days later, Kerensky left Murmansk to begin fifty years of restless exile. Trotsky later, in exile himself, scornfully wrote Kerensky's political epitaph: "Kerensky was not a revolutionist; he merely hung around the revolution ... He had no theoretical preparation, no political schooling, no ability to think, no political will. The place of these qualities was occupied by a nimble susceptibility, an inflammable temperament, and that kind of eloquence which operates neither upon mind or will but upon the nerves." Nevertheless, when Kerensky left, he carried with him the vanishing dream of a humane, liberal, democratic Russia.
From distant Tobolsk, Nicholas followed these events with keen interest. He blamed Kerensky for the collapse of the army in the July offensive and for not accepting Kornilov's help in routing the Bolsheviks. At first, he could not believe that Lenin and Trotsky were as formidable as they seemed; to him, they appeared as outright German agents sent to Russia to corrupt the army and overthrow the government. When these two men whom he regarded as unsavory blackguards and traitors became the rulers of Russia, he was gravely shocked. "I then for the first time heard the Tsar regret his abdication," said Gilliard. "It now gave him pain to see that his renunciation had been in vain and that by his departure in the interests of his country, he had in reality done her an ill turn. This idea was to haunt him more and more."
At first, the Bolshevik Revolution had little practical effect on faroff Tobolsk. Officials appointed by the Provisional Government - including Pankratov, Nikolsky and Kobylinsky - remained in office; the banks and lawcourts remained open doing business as before. Inside the governor's house, the Imperial family had settled into a routine which, although restricted, was almost cozy.

Haunting. I know it's me projecting, but it's almost like I can see their terrible fate in their eyes, even in the expressions of the little ones.
From Edvard Radzinsky's book The Last Tsar: The Life and Death of Nicholas II (a wonderful book, I love all of Radzinsky's books - he also wrote a book on Stalin
(some of my thoughts on the book here), and a book on Rasputin
(intemperate words from me on that book here) - he's terrific - In this book, with the opening of the archives following glasnost and perestroika, he tries to put together - through the existing documentation - the decision to murder the tsar and his family):
In his diary, Trotsky, back from the forest, described his conversation with Sverdlov:" 'The tsar is where?'
" 'Shot, of course.' [Imagine Sverdlov's cool triumph when he told Lev to his face that they had torn his favorite bone right out of his mouth; there would be no trial.]
" 'And the family is where?'
" 'The family as well.'
" 'All of them?'
" 'Yes. What about it?' [Again Sverdlov's invisible grin between the lines: "Does the fiery revolutionary Trotsky pity them?"]
" 'Who decided this?' [Fury: he wants to know who dared not consult with him, and so on.]
" 'We all did. Ilich [Lenin] felt we could not leave them a living banner, especially given our trying conditions.' "
Yet when his anger had passed, Trotsky, who during the terrible days of the revolution had said, "We will leave, but we will slam the door so hard the world will shudder," could not have helped but admire this superrevolutionary decision."In essence this decision was inevitable. The execution of the tsar and his family was necessary not simply to scare, horrify, and deprive the enemy of hope, but also to shake up our own ranks, show them that there was no going back. Ahead lay total victory or utter ruin ... The masses of workers and soldiers would not have understood or accepted any other decision. Lenin had a good sense of this," Trotsky wrote.
So, according to Trotsky, it was all decided in Moscow. That was what Goloshchekin negotiated in Moscow!
This is only Trotsky's testimony, however. History recognizes documents - and I foun done. First a clue, from a letter of O.N. Kolotov in Leningrad:
"I can tell you an interesting detail about the topic of interest to you: my grandfather often told me that Zinoviev took part in the decision to execute the tsar and that the tsar was executed on the basis of a telegram sent to Ekaterinburg from the center. My grandfather can be trusted; by virtue of his work he knew a great deal. He said that he himself took part in the shootings. He called the execution a 'kick in the ass', asserting that this was in the literal sense: they turned the condemned to the wall, then brought a pistol up to the back of their head, and when they pulled the trigger they simultaneously gave them a kick in the ass to keep the blood from spattering their uniforms."
There was a telegram! I found it! Even though they were supposed to destroy it. The blood cries out!
Here it is lying before me. One stifling July afternoon I was sitting in the Archives of the October Revolution and looking at this telegram, sent seventy-two years before. I had run across it in an archive file with the boring label "Telegrams About the Organization and Activities of the Judicial Organs and the Cheka," begun on January 21, 1918, and ended on October 31, of the same 1918. Behind this label and these dates lie the Red Terror. Among the terrifying telegrams - semiliterate texts on dirty paper - my attention was struck by a two-headed eagle. The tsarist seal!
This was it. On a blank left over from the tsarist telegraph service and decorated with the two-headed eagle was this telegram: a report on the impending execution of the tsar's family. The irony of history.
At the very top of this telegram, on a piece of telegraph ribbon, is the address "To Moscow Lenin."
Below, a note in pencil: "Received July 16, 1918, 21:22." From Petrograd. And the number of the telegram: 14228.
So, on July 16, at 21:22, that is, before the Romanov's execution, this telegram arrived in Moscow.
The telegram was a long time in getting there, having been sent from Ekaterinburg to "Sverdlov, copy to Lenin". But it was sent through Zinoviev, the master of the second capital, Petrograd - Lenin's closest comrade-in-arms at the time. Zinoviev had sent the telegram on from Petrograd to Lenin.
The individuals who sent this telegram from Ekaterinburg were Goloshechekin and Safrov, another leader of the Ural Soviet.
Here is its text:
"To Moscow, the Kremlin, Sverdlov, copy to Lenin. From Ekaterinburg transmit the following directly: inform Moscow that the trial agreed upon with Filipp due to military circumstances cannot bear delay, we cannot wait. If your opinion is contrary inform immediately. Goloshchekin, Safarov. On this subject contact Ekaterinburg yourself.
And the signature: Zinoviev.
Nov. 7, 1917 NY Times front page article:
Bolsheviki Seize State Buildings, Defying KerenskyPremier Posts Troops in Capital and Declares Workmen's Council Illegal
NORTHERN ARMY OFFERS AID
And Preliminary Parliament, Forced by Rebels to Leave Palace, Supports Him
WOMEN SOLDIERS ON GUARD
Petrograd Conditions Generally Normal Save for Outrages by So-Called Apaches
Bolsheviki Seize State BuildingsNov. 7, Petrograd - An armed naval detachment, under orders of the Maximalist Revolutionary Committee, has occupied the offices of the official Petrograd Telegraph Agency. The Maximalists also occupied the Central Telegraph office, the State Bank and Marin Palace, where the Preliminary Parliament had suspended its proceedings in view of the situation.
Numerous precautions have been taken by Premier Kerensky to thwart the threatened outbreak. The Workmen's and Soldiers' Committee has been decreed an illegal organization. The soldiers guarding the Government buildings have been replaced by men from the officers' training schools. Small guards have been placed at the Embassies. The women's battalion is drawn up in the square in front of the Winter Palace.
The commander of the northern front has informed the Premier that his troops are against any demonstration and are ready to come to Petrograd to quell a rebellion if necessary.
No disorders are yet reported, with the exception of some outrages by Apaches. The general life of the city remains normal and street traffic has not been interrupted.
Leon Trotzky, President of the Central Executive Committee of the Petrograd Council of Workmen's Soldiers' Delegates, has informed members of the Town Duma that he has given strict orders against outlawry and has threatened with death any persons attempting to carry out pogroms.
Trotzky added that it was not the intention of the Workmen's and Soldiers' Delegates to seize power, but to represent to a Congress of Workmen's and Soldiers' Delegates, to be called shortly, that the body take over control of the capital, for which all necessary arrangements had been perfected.
In the early hours of the morning a delegation of Cossacks appeared at the Winter Palace and told Premier Kerensky that they were disposed to carry out the Government's orders concerning the guarding of the capital, but they insisted that if hostilities began it would be necessary for their forces to be supplemented by infantry units. They further demanded that the Premier define the Government's attitude toward the Bolsheviki, citing the release from custody of some of those who had been arrested for participation in the July disturbances. The Cossacks virtually made a demand that the Government proclaim the Bolsheviki outlaws.
The Premier replied:
"I find it difficult to declare the Bolsheviki outlaws. The attitude of the Government toward the present Bolsheviki activities is known."
The Premier explained that those who had been released were on bail, and that any of them found participating in new offenses against peace would be severely dealt with.
The Revolutionary Military Committee of the Workmen's and Soldiers' Delegates demanded the right to control all orders of the General Staff in the Petrograd district, which was refused. Thereupon the committee announced that it had appointed special commissioners to undertake the direction of the military, and invited the troops to observe only orders signed by the committee. Machine gun detachments moved to the Workmen's and Soldiers' headquarters.
In addressing the Preliminary Parliament yesterday Premier Kerensky charged the Military Committee of the Workmen's and Soldiers' Delegates with having distributed arms and ammunition to workmen.
"That is why I consider part of the population of Petrograd in a state of revolt," he said, "and have ordered an immediate inquiry and such arrests as are necessary. The Government will perish rather than cease to defend the honor, security, and independence of the State."
The Preliminary Parliament, in response to the Premier's appeal for a vote of confidence, voted to "work in contact with the Government." The resolution, which originated with the Left, was carried by a vote of 123 to 102, with 26 members abstaining from voting. A resolution offered by the Centre calling for the suppression of the Bolshevikis and a full vote of confidence failed to reach a vote. The Cabinet, however, considers the resolution adopted as expressive of the Parliament's support.
The reported resignation of Admiral Verdervski, Minister of Marine, was denied after the Cabinet meeting. It was stated that all the ministers had agreed to retain their portfolios.
The Bolshevik Chairman of the Petrograd Council of Workmen's and Soldiers' Delegates, realizing that there are more ways than one of acquiring real authority, not only attempted its capture by armed force but also by a far more ingenuous plan, which was disclosed today. He formed a so-called Military Revolutionary Committee of the Petrograd Soviet, and informed the Headquarters Staff of the Petrograd military district that only orders sanctioned by the Military Revolutionary Committee would be executed.
On Sunday night the committee appeared at the staff offices and demanded the right of entry, control and veto. Receiving a natural and emphatic refusal, the military revolutionaries wired everywhere to the general effect that the Petrograd district headquarters were opposed to the wishes of the revolutionary garrison, and were becoming a counter revolutionary centre. This bid for the loyalty of the garrison has so far yielded no definite results, but obviously is extremely dangerous, especially in view of the fact that in the Petrograd garrison discipline is extremely lax.
It is said the Provisional Government intends to prosecute the Military Revolutionary Committee. It should be noted that the All-Russian Executive Committee of the Soviets is backing the Provisional Government. There is a general feeling of reaction against the Bolshevik-ridden Soviets, a feeling completely loyal to the revolution but impatient of disorders.

Elizabeth Bishop wrote that to Robert Lowell, after reading one of his poems. An amazing symbiotic relationship - the two influencing one another, loving one another - while living separate lives. I am most interested in how the work affected each other. Lowell was much more famous in his own day than Elizabeth Bishop was - although now I am SO pleased to see that she is having a bit of a renaissance, she is one of my favorite poets.
Bishop and Lowell kept up a correspondence for the 30 years of their friendship, and while some have already been published (in a collection of Bishop's letters) - now a volume has come out with their correspondence - Words in Air: The Complete Correspondence Between Elizabeth Bishop and Robert Lowell
- 459 letters in all! Here is a great review in the NY Times.
They never married. Lowell had many lovers, and a wife, Bishop stayed with one woman for many many years (sadly, this woman committed suicide - yet another plot-point in the tragic story that was Bishop's outer life). But theirs was a soulmate kind of connection. Lowell did ask her to marry him, and her cooler head prevailed. It seems, though, that they were each other's "perfect reader". Every writer needs one. Not a critic, not a gushing fan ... but someone who is able to really hear not just the words, but the intent. Who can speak to the theme, the greater picture. I recently read one of my pieces out loud to Rachel and Mitchell - it was one I had been struggling with. As we settled in for my reading, Rachel said, "What do you want us to be listening for?" Now THAT is a good reader. It helped me to focus my own intentions and goals - and it helped me to think about the piece in a larger way, so that I could work on that LARGER element, not just the language or the progression of events.
Bishop and Lowell were two very different poets - it is hard to imagine their rapport. She was solitary, with a tiny literate following. She wrote about fish houses and the beach and small moments. He upended his psychology, pouring passion and unrequited feeling into his poems. They worked FOR one another, over decades.
It was a highly passionate relationship, and you ache reading some of their letters.
William Logan writes, in the NY Times piece:
Their admiration even made them light fingered — they borrowed ideas or images the way a neighbor might steal a cup of sugar. Lowell was especially tempted by this lure of the forbidden, using one of Bishop’s dreams in a heartbreaking poem about their might-have-been affair, or rewriting in verse one of her short stories. They were literary friends in all the usual ways, providing practical advice (the forever dithery and procrastinating Bishop proved surprisingly pragmatic), trading blurbs, logrolling as shamelessly as pork-bellied senators (Lowell was adept at dropping the quiet word on her behalf). There was a refined lack of jealousy between them — that particular vice never found purchase, though in letters to friends they could afford the occasional peevish remark about each other. The only time Bishop took exception to Lowell’s poems was when, in “The Dolphin� (1973), he incorporated angry letters from his ex-wife Elizabeth Hardwick — “Art just isn’t worth that much,� Bishop exclaimed. She flinched when poets revealed in their poems too much of themselves, once claiming that she wished she “could start writing poetry all over again on another planet.�These poets, in short, inspired each other. Lowell always seems to be stuffing her newest poem into his billfold, so he can take it out later like a hundred-dollar bill. Bishop saw immediately how strange and even shocking “Life Studies� (1959) was (its confessional style caused as violent an earthquake in American poetry as “The Waste Land�); but he noticed something more subtle, that she rarely repeated herself. Each time she wrote, it was as if she were reinventing what she did with words, while he tended to repeat his forms until he had driven them into the ground, or driven everyone crazy with them. Bishop was loyal enough to admire, or pretend to, even Lowell’s mediocre poems.
If Lowell and Bishop often seem to love no poems more than each other’s, as critics perhaps they were right. A hundred years from now, they may prove the 20th century’s Whitman and Dickinson, an odd couple whose poems look quizzically at each other, half in understanding, half in consternation, each poet the counter-psyche of the other. Their poems are as different as gravy from groundhogs, their letters so alike — so delightfully in concord — the reader at times can’t guess the author without glancing at the salutation.
Here's a post I wrote about Elizabeth Bishop - and I included in it what I consider to be her greatest poem - "The Moose".
I am very much looking forward to reading the entire correspondence of Lowell and Bishop.
Keats was born on this day in London, 1795. "Ode to Autumn" is perhaps my favorite of his - but today, for his birthday, I will post: "Ode on Melancholy". And below the poem are a bunch of compiled quotes - from Keats and about Keats. He brings up strong reactions in people. Many adore, many think something is lacking ... but all give him the props. I particularly love the quote I found from Robert Graves.
Ode on Melancholy
1.
No, no, go not to Lethe, neither twist
Wolfs-bane, tight-rooted, for its poisonous wine;
Nor suffer thy pale forehead to be kiss'd
By nightshade, ruby grape of Proserpine;
Make not your rosary of yew-berries,
Nor let the beetle, nor the death-moth be
Your mournful Psyche, nor the downy owl
A partner in your sorrow's mysteries;
For shade to shade will come too drowsily,
And drown the wakeful anguish of the soul.
2.
But when the melancholy fit shall fall
Sudden from heaven like a weeping cloud,
That fosters the droop-headed flowers all,
And hides the green hill in an April shroud;
Then glut thy sorrow on a morning rose,
Or on the rainbow of the salt sand-wave,
Or on the wealth of globed peonies;
Or if thy mistress some rich anger shows,
Emprison her soft hand, and let her rave,
And feed deep, deep upon her peerless eyes.
3.
She dwells with Beauty - Beauty that must die;
And Joy, whose hand is ever at his lips
Bidding adieu; and aching Pleasure nigh,
Turning to poison while the bee-mouth sips:
Ay, in the very temple of Delight
Veil'd Melancholy has her sovran shrine,
Though seen of none save him whose strenuous tongue
Can burst Joy's grape against his palate fine;
His soul shall taste the sadness of her might,
And be among her cloudy trophies hung.

"One song of Burns is of more worth to you than all I could think of for a whole year in his native country. His Misery is a dead weight on the nimbleness of one's quill ... he talked with Bitches, he drank with blackguards, he was miserable. We can see horribly clear in the works of such a Man his whole life, as if we were God's spies." -- John Keats on Robert Burns
"Shelley was a volatile creature of air and fire: he seems never to have noticed what he ate or drank, except sometimes as a matter of vegetarian principle. Keats was earthy, with a sweet tooth and a relish for spices, cream and snuff, and in a letter mentions peppering his own tongue to bring out the delicious coolness of claret. When Shelley in Prometheus Unbound mentions: "The yellow bees in the ivy-bloom", he does not conjure up, as Keats would have done, the taste of the last hot days of the dying English year, with over-ripe blackberries, ditches full of water, and the hedges grey with old man's beard. He is not aware of the veteran bees whirring their frayed wings or sucking rank honey from the dusty yellow blossoms of the ivy." -- Robert Graves
"On the whole, I do not like Keats. His poems are, in reality, too full of beauty. One feels stifled in roses ... There is little in Keats' poems except luscious beauty -- so much of it that the reader is surfeited." -- L.M. Montgomery
"These are the pure Magic. These are the clear vision. The rest is only poetry." -- Rudyard Kipling on John Keats and Samuel Coleridge
"He'd planned to become a surgeon, but he realized his real vocation was poetry, and in the spring of 1818, he published his first major long poem Endymion. And then he set out on a hike through the countryside with his friend Charles Brown. Wordsworth was one of Keats's favorite poets, and he knew that Wordsworth had been inspired by walking around England, so Keats decided to do the same that summer.
Keats was a London boy. He had never seen the mountains. He had never seen a waterfall. He wrote letters back to his brother about the wonderful things that he saw, but gradually on his hike he realized he was no Wordsworth, that he did not want to write about scenery. He hated descriptions. He was more interested in the people whom he saw along the way. He was fascinated by the peasants who walked barefoot on the roads, carrying their shoes and stockings so they would look nice when they got to town. He saw an old woman being carried along the road in a kind of a cage like a dog kennel, smoking a pipe.
He came back to London and learned that the reviews of his last book of poetry, Endymion, were coming in and critics had written ferocious attacks on him. He was crushed. And his brother had come down with a serious case of tuberculosis. His brother died in December, and by the end of that year, John Keats had contracted tuberculosis himself. He would die three years later, in 1821. It was in those last three years of his life that he wrote most of his greatest poems." -- Garrison Keillor
"He ramped through [Spenser's[ Fairie Queen ... like a young horse turned into a Spring meadow." -- Cowden Clarke, a friend of Keats
"The imagery he chose was predominantly sexual. Poetry for him was not a philosophical theory, as it was for Shelley, but a moment of physical delirium." -- Robert Graves
"... miserable self-polluter of the human mind."-- Shelley
"I look upon fine phrases as a lover." -- John Keats
"Keats as a poet is abundantly and enchantingly sensuous, but the question with some people will be, whether he is anything else." -- Matthew Arnold
"The three great narratives, rich in detail, idealized characterization, and gothic elements, inspired poets, painters and musicians later in the century. The Pre-Raphaelites in particular drew sustenance from them. 'The Eve of St. Agnes' radically reconfigures resources of tone and characterization that Keats adapted from Chaucer to Shakespeare. Romeo and Juliet was not far from his hand when he wrote the poem. And his phrasing owes Shakespeare a debt. Cymbeline suggests the way Madeline's bedchamber is made solid before our eyes. Keats does not imitate his masters: he has assimilated them. The odes - 'To a Nightingale,' 'On a Grecian Urn', 'To Autumn', and the lesser 'To Psyche' and 'On Melancholy' -- are incomparable. The charge that he 'lacked experience' is fatuous; nor are they 'merely sensuous'. They are the step beyond moral romance to the romance of feeling itself, feeling as subject, the 'true voice'." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"I have loved the principle of beauty in all things." -- John Keats
" ... a sensuous mystic." -- Louis MacNeice
"Keats was short-sighted. He did not see landscapes as such, so he treated them as painted cabinets filled with interesting objects ... His habit was to allow his eye to be seduced from entire vision by particular objects ... He saw little but what moved: the curving, the wreathing, the slanting, the waving - and even then, it seems, not the whole object is in motion but only its edge, or highlight." -- Robert Graves
"Keats's yearning passion for the Beautiful is not a passion of the sensuous or sentimental poet. It is an intellectual and spiritual passion." -- Matthew Arnold
"Milton had an exquisite passion for what is properly, in the sense of ease and pleasure, poetical luxury, and with that, it appears to me, he would fair have been content, if he could, so doing, preserve his self-respect and feeling of duty performed." -- John Keats
This Grave
contains all that was Mortal
of a
Young English Poet
Who
on his Death Bed
in the Bitterness of his Heart
at the Malicious Power of his Enemies
Desired
these words to be engraved on his Tomb Stone
"Here lies One Whose Name was writ in Water."
-- Keats' epitaph
"Poetry should strike the reader as a wording of his own highest thoughts, and appear almost a remembrance." -- John Keats
More on John Keats' short life here
Next book on my "entertainment biography" shelf:
Timebends: A Life, by Arthur Miller
This is truly bizarre. Today happens to be Arthur Miller's birthday. His is the next book on the shelf. So happy birthday, Arthur Miller.
When Timebends came out, in 1987, I remember there being mixed reviews. I think mainly folks were expecting salacious revelations about Marilyn Monroe - and the book decidedly does not deliver on that score. But why does it not deliver? Because Marilyn Monroe was not some unearthly sexual goddess to Arthur Miller. She was a real girl, sweet, troubled, innocent, lovely - and she was his wife. He does not take us into their bedroom, and he does not "explain" her. She can't be "explained" by one person alone, and it is not up to Miller to interpret her for us. The Marilyn sections of the book are very lovely - I loved the picture of her that emerged ... but it's certainly not the whole book, it is not even the context in which the entire book is placed. It is an event, like any other ... something that made up a good deal of his emotional life for some time, as well as his creative life (as he tried to write material that would show the world she was a "real actress"). (Once upon a time I put together a giant post called "The Making of The Misfits" - filled with photos and book excerpts about that troubled film-shoot. The whole thing really had began as Miller's desire to write something he felt Marilyn could do, something worthy of her.) But in general, the Marilyn in the book is revealed as a real person, maybe more beautiful than most, certainly more famous ... but a woman with anxieties, quirks, and a lovely sense of humor and intellect that he found captivating.

Additionally, there is a lot of politics in the book (which is also not surprising) - and in many ways it gives a grand sweeping look at the journey of the American Left from the 30s to the 50s ... well, and yes, into the 60s - but by then many of the definitions had changed. Miller was from New York, and had grown up going to see productions at the Group Theatre, that bastion of the American Left, and had been gobsmacked by Clifford Odets' fiery language, and the vision that theatre could be somehow relevant and revolutionary. His compassion for the downtrodden, the persecuted, the forgotten masses could be seen as radical (and it certainly was at the time) - yet at the same time he had great contempt for the Soviet system of oppression and censorship, and worked hard through his life to support the persecuted writers in the Soviet bloc. And while he had seen the downside to American capitalism in his own family misfortunes, he was also amazed during the groundbreaking production of Salesman in Beijing in 1983 - which took China by storm. I actually remember some of the news reports about that production trickling down to me in junior high. I had read Salesman by then, so I knew of it ... but that production can be seen, in certain lights, as a watershed moment in China's cultural history. People went NUTS for Salesman in China. They had gone NUTS for Salesman in America in the 1940s and there, 50 years later, in a Communist country, they went nuts again. Even more nuts. Miller was amazed by the response. The curtain would go down at the end of the production, and Chinese men in suits would be hugging one another in the aisles, weeping. Amazing. It had spoken to them, to their experience, their hopes and dreams - another culture, another political system - none of that mattered. The message of Salesman, of the inherent dignity of man, despite his financial success, had a deep deep resonance for the Chinese. Salesman traveled, in other words. John Updike shares an interesting anecdote about Miller, which, I think, might surprise some people who just brush Miller off as a radical:
I went to the Soviet Union [in 1964] for a month as part of a cultural exchange program ... I came way from that month ... with a hardened antipathy to communism ...There was something bullying egocentric about my admirable Soviet friends, a preoccupation with their own tortured situations that shut out all light from beyond. They were like residents of a planet so heavy that even their gazes were sucked back into its dark center. Arthur Miller, no reactionary, said it best when, a few years later, he and I and some other Americans riding the cultural-exchange bandwagon had entertained, in New York or Connecticut, several visiting Soviet colleagues. The encounter was handsomely catered, the dialogue loud and lively, the will toward friendship was earnest and in its way intoxicating, but upon our ebullient guests' departure Miller looked at me and said sighingly, "Jesus, don't they make you glad you're an American?"
Miller's family lost everything in the stock market crash, and so their situation was quite reduced. I believe they moved to Brooklyn, a huge downward step, off the island, so to speak, and Miller was a young child, but very much remembers the stress and fear of that time. Much of his memory would be put to use later on when writing Death of a Salesman - the tenement buildings, the change of Brooklyn from a more rural area to something crowded and fetid ... Not to mention the fact that he did have an uncle who was a salesman, a brash funny and vaguely pathetic man - an early prototype for Willy Loman.
I did not go into Timebends with any specific expectation like some people did. I didn't think, "He had BETTER talk about Marilyn Monroe for 300 pages straight!" Or "He had BETTER dish on how he felt about Kazan and the HUAC - if he doesn't? I will HATE the book" ... or etc. etc. I found some of it didactic and rather humorless, and much of his political sections were boring and preachy ... but you move through them and then get on to the business of theatre. To Miller, it all was one. You can tell that in his plays as well. His plays always have a "message", some social, political, or cultural message ... and it is that reason that they can sometimes seem didactic in a way that Tennessee Williams' plays never do. It's interesting: they were contemporaries, the two giant stars of the American stage, the two men (with O'Neill and Odets in the generations before paving the way) who brought an American voice and an American perspective where before there had been none. Much of the Broadway fare in the early years of the 20th century, up into the 1920s, was written by Americans, sure, but they took as their inspiration the works of Noel Coward, or Shaw, or other Europeans. It was not a truly American art-form. Vaudeville was, but not the mainstage of the Broadway theatres. That began to change with O'Neill - and Odets ... two wildly different playwrights with different perspectives ... but they cleared the space for what would happen in the 40s, and 50s - when out came playwrights like Miller, and Williams, and Inge, and Saroyan. These playwrights are American to the core. It is a voice I am talking about, a sensibility - it is its own thing, and these guys helped put American on the map, at least in a theatrical sense.

Miller's book details his own part of that historic moment in our cultural life.
It has since come to light that Miller and his last wife - Inge Morath, a photographer - had a child who had Down's Syndrome, and Miller was so horrified and embarrassed that he put the child in an institution and never saw him again. He never even acknowledged the child's existence. For decades. Inge Morath would go to visit her son, but it was a horrible situation. The child is now a man, and many of Miller's old friends have reached out to him - but Miller himself never did. And there's not a word of this in Timebends, which is truly chilling. The daughter he had with Morath - Rebecca - is now a director, actress, writer - and wife of Daniel Day-Lewis - and Miller showers her with praise and love in Timebends. The story about the Down's Syndrome child came out this past year - so reading Timebends in the 80s, you'd never ever know that this giant THING was missing. Miller had some major demons going on, obviously, and I do wonder what price he paid (psychologically, I mean) in keeping this huge thing a secret. His last play was Finishing the Picture (2004) and it was (obviously, if you know Miller's life) the story of the making of The Misfits, with its star actress going deeper and deeper into madness and incomprehensibility, as the hard-drinking macho cast and crew wait for her to appear, so that they can "finish the picture". Miller was 90 years old, and there he is ... going back in time to a moment when maybe he thought he could "save" someone ... going over it and over it (as he had done before, in his play After the Fall) ... maybe in doing so he thought he could change his own past. He died before the revelation came out about his abandoned son, so naturally there has been MUCH chatter on the airwaves about it. For my part, it makes me look at his work in a different way: the evocations of fathers and sons, so common in his work ... the passing on of the torch, so important in all matters of family and mortality ... what do we pass on? What have we, as men, as fathers, made of ourselves? What can I give to my son? What do I have to give? There is a whole new way to look at these existential questions now. It's awful, but I wonder if a lot of his torment and didacticism came from the fact that he had done this awful thing and he felt the need to hide it.
The excerpt I share below is giant, so sit back, and get ready. It is the story of the making of Death of a Salesman, and it is not only my favorite section in the book - but perhaps my favorite section of ANY book. He's an elegant writer, not too emotional, but his memories of that time in his life are intense and you really get the sense that he was pushing himself THROUGH something, he was dreaming himself into a space where he could find his voice and share it. Not an easy thing to do. He had already had one success - All My Sons ... but with Salesman he went deeper. It was profound for him. I will not re-cap his thoughts here - they are all below.
But the elements of this story resonate for me, and have for years, ever since I first read it:
-- his experience of seeing Streetcar Named Desire for the first time, and what it said to him, what it did to him ... It basically gave him permission. To go big, to go huge, to be relevant and important ... not to imitate Williams, that could not be done, they were different men ... but to stop being microscopic and go into the macro-level. (His giving-of-the-props to Williams here is incredibly generous. Because he could very easily have taken the credit himself for what happened to American theatre in the 1940s ... Salesman was as huge a phenomenon as Streetcar ... but he doesn't. He hands that to Williams.)
-- his feeling that he needed to build a shack with his own hands to write the play (he didn't know why he had to, but he knew he did ...) Here he is in front of the shack, many years later.

-- the fact that he would finish work on the play after a long day, and find that he had been crying all day ... without even realizing it
-- Kazan signing on to direct - a huge deal. (And Kazan's response to reading the play for the first time ... gulp ...)

-- finding their Willy Loman. The story of Lee J. Cobb - who was really too young for the part, he was the contemporary of Arthur Kennedy who played his own son ... but how Cobb basically insisted that the part was his and his alone.
-- then - the UNBELIEVABLE story of the moment in rehearsal when Lee J. Cobb "got it". I have goosebumps right now just thinking about it.
-- and then: opening night ... and what happened in that theatre that night.


It is a magnificent story, from beginning to end, and one I treasure. It feels, in a weird way, like it belongs to me. In the same way that I feel that the signing of the Declaration of Independence belongs to me, or that Walt Whitman belongs to me, or that the first walk on the moon belongs to me. These are stories that make up our culture, our history ... and they are part of me, mine.
At the end of Death of a Salesman, Willy's wife Linda says what are probably the most famous lines in the entire play:
Don't say he's a great man. Willy Loman never made a lot of money. His name was never in the paper. He's not the finest character that ever lived. But he's a human being, and a terrible thing is happening to him. So attention must be paid. He's not to be allowed to fall into his grave like an old dog. Attention, attention must finally be paid to such a person.
And so it has.
EXCERPT FROM Timebends: A Life, by Arthur Miller
Already in the sixties I was surprised by the common tendency to think of the late forties and early fifties as some sort of renaissance in the New York theatre. If that was so, I was unaware of it. I thought the theatre a temple being rotted out with commercialized junk, where mostly by accident an occasional good piece of work appeared, usually under some disguise of popular cultural coloration such as a movie star in a leading role.
That said, it now needs correction; it was also a time when the audience was basically the same for musicals and light entertainment as for the ambitious stuff and had not yet been atomized, as it would be by the mid-fifties, into young and old, hip and square, or even political left and middle and right. So the playwright's challenge was to please not a small sensitized supporting clique but an audience representing, more or less, all of America. With ticket prices within reason, this meant that an author was writing for his peers, and if such was really not the case statistically, it was sufficiently so to support an illusion that had a basis in reality. After all, it was not thought particularly daring to present T.S. Eliot's The Cocktail Party on Broadway, or Laurence Olivier in a Greek tragedy, or Giraudoux's The Madwomen of Chaillot, or any number of other ambitious works. To be sure, such shows had much shorter lives than the trash, but that was to be expected, for most people would much rather laugh than cry, rather watch an actor being hit on the head by a pig bladder than by some painful truth.
The net of it all was that serious writers could reasonably assume they were addressing the whole American mix, and so their plays, whether successfully or not, stretched toward a wholeness of experience that would not require specialists or a coterie to be understood. As alienated a spirit as he was, O'Neill tried for the big audience, and Clifford Odets no less so, along with every other writer longing to prophesy to America, from Whitman and Melville to Dreiser and Hemingway and so on.
For Europe's playwrights the situation was profoundly different, with society already being split beyond healing between the working class and its allies, who were committed to a socialist destiny, and the bourgeois mentality that sought an art of reassurance and the pleasures of forgetting what was happening in the streets. (The first American plays I saw left me wondering where the characters came from. The people I knew were fanatics about surviving, but onstage everyone seemed to have mysteriously guaranteed incomes, and though every play had to have something about "love", there was nothing about sex, which was all there was in Brooklyn, at least that I ever noticed.) An American avant-garde, therefore, if only because the domination of society by the middle class was profoundly unchallenged, could not simply steal from Brecht or even Shaw and expect its voice to reach beyond the small alienated minority that had arrived in their seats already converted to its aims. That was not the way to change the world.
For a play to do that it had to reach precisely those who accepted everything as it was; great drama is great questions or it is nothing but technique. I could not imagine a theatre worth my time that did not want to change the world, any more than a creative scientist could wish to prove the validity of everything that is already known. I knew only one other writer with the same approach, even if he surrounded his work with a far different aura. This was Tennessee Williams.
If only because he came up at a time when homosexuality was absolutely unacknowledgeable in a public figure, Williams had to belong to a minority culture and understood in his bones what a brutal menace the majority could be if aroused against him. I lived with much the same sense of alienation, albeit for other reasons. Certainly I never regarded him as the sealed-off aesthete he was thought to be. There is a radical politics of the soul as well as of the ballot box and the picket line. If he was not an activist, it was not for lack of a desire for justice, nor did he consider a theatre profoundly involved in society and politics, the venerable tradition reaching back to the Greeks, somehow unaesthetic or beyond his interest.
The real theatre - as opposed to the sequestered academic one - is always straining at the inbuilt inertia of a society that always wants to deny change and the pain it necessarily involves. But it is in this effort that the musculature of important work is developed. In a different age, perhaps even only fifteen years later, in the sixties, Williams might have had a more comfortably alienated audience to deal with, one that would have relieved the pressure upon him to extend himself beyond a supportive cult environment, and I think this might well have narrowed the breadth of his work and its intensity. In short, there was no renaissance in the American forties, but there was a certain balance within the audience - a balance, one might call it, between the alienated and the conformists - that gave sufficient support to the naked cry of the heart and, simultaneously, enough resistance to force it into a rhetoric that at one stroke could be broadly understandable and yet faithful to the pain that had pressed the author to speak.
When Kazan invited me up to New Haven to see the new Williams play, A Streetcar Named Desire - it seemed to me a rather too garishly attention-getting title - I was already feeling a certain amount of envious curiosity since I was still unable to commit myself to the salesman play, around which I kept suspiciously circling and sniffing. But at the same time I hoped that Streetcar would be good; it was not that I was high-minded but simply that I shared the common assumption of the time that the greater the number of exciting plays there were on Broadway the better for each of us., At least in our minds there was still something approximating a theatre culture to which we more or less pridefully belonged, and the higher its achievement the greater the glory we all shared. The playwright was then king of the hill, not the star actor or director, and certainly not the producer or theatre owner, as would later by the case. (At a recently televised Tony Awards ceremony, recognizing achievement in the theatre, not a single playwright was presented to the public, while two lawyers who operated a chain of theatres were showered with the gratitude of all. It reminded me of Caligula making his horse a senator.)
Streetcar - especially when it was still so fresh and the actors almost as amazed as the audience at the vitality of this theatrical experience - opened one specific door for me. Not the story or the characters or the direction, but the words and their liberation, the joy of the writer in writing them, the radiant eloquence of its composition, moved me more than all its pathos. It formed a bridge to Europe for me, to Jouvet's performance in Ondine, to the whole tradition of unashamed word-joy that, with the exception of Odets, we had either turned our backs on or, as with Maxwell Anderson, only used archaically, as though eloquence could only be justified by cloaking it in sentimental romanticism.
Returning to New York, I felt speeded up, in motion now. With Streetcar, Tennessee had printed a license to speak at full throat, and it helped strengthen me as I turned to Willy Loman, a salesman always full of words, and better yet, a man who could never cease trying, like Adam, to name himself and the world's wonders. I had known all along that this play could not be encompassed by conventional realism, and for one integral reason: in Willy the past was as alive as what was happening at the moment, sometimes even crashing in to completely overwhelm his mind. I wanted precisely the same fluidity in the form, and now it was clear to me that this must be primarily verbal. The language would of course have to be recognizably his to begin with, but it seemed possible now to infiltrate it with a kind of superconsciousness. The play, after all, involved the attempts of his son and his wife and Willy himself to understand what was killing him. And to understand meant to lift the experience into emergency speech of an unashamedly open kind rather than to proceed by the crabbed dramatic hints and pretexts of the "natural". If the structure had to mirror the psychology as directly as could be done, it was still a psychology hammered into its strange shape by society, the business life Willy had lived and believed in. The play could reflect what I had always sensed as the unbroken tissue that was man and society, a single unit rather than two.
By April of 1948 I felt I could find such a form, but it would have to be done, I thought, in a single sitting, in a night or a day, I did not know why. I stopped making my notes in our Grace Court house in Brooklyn Heights and drove up alone one morning to the country house we had bought the previous year. We had spent one summer there in that old farmhouse, which had been modernized by its former owner, a greeting card manufacturer named Philip Jaffe, who as a sideline published a thin magazine for China specialists called Amerasia. Mary worked as one of his secretaries and so had the first news that he wanted to sell the place. In a year or two he would be on trial for publishing without authorization State Department reports from John Stewart Service, among a number of other China experts who recognized a Mao victory as inevitable and warned of the futility of America continuing to back her favorite, Chiang Kai-shek. Amerasia had been a vanity publication, in part born of Jaffe's desire for a place in history, but it nevertheless braved the mounting fury of the China lobby against any opinion questioning the virtues of the Chiang forces. At his trial, the government produced texts of conversations that Jaffe claimed could only have been picked up by long-range microphone as he and his friends walked the isolated backcountry roads near this house. Service was one of many who were purged from the State Department, leaving it blinded to Chinese reality but ideologically pure.
But all that was far from my mind this day; what I was looking for on my land was a spot for a little shack I wanted to build, where I could block out the world and bring into focus what was still stuck in the corners of my eyes. I found a knoll in the nearby woods and returned to the city, where instead of working on the play I drew plans for the framing, of which I really had very vague knowledge and no experience. A pair of carpenters could have put up this ten-by-twelve-foot cabin in two days at most, but for reasons I still do not understand it had to be my own hands that gave it form, on this ground, with a floor that I had made, upon which to sit to begin the risky expedition into myself. In reality, all I had was the first two lines and a death - "Will!" and "It's all right. I came back." Further than that I dared not, would not, venture until I could sit in the completed studio, four walls, two windows, a floor, a roof, and a door.
"It's all right. I came back" rolled over and over in my head as I tried to figure out how to join the roof rafters in air unaided, until I finally put them together on the ground and swung them into position all nailed together. When I closed in the roof it was a miracle, as though I had mastered the rain and cooled the sun. And all the while afraid I would never be able to penetrate past those first two lines. I started writing one morning - the tiny studio was still unpainted and smelled of raw wood and sawdust, and the bags of nails were still stashed in a corner with my tools. The sun of April had found my windows to pour through, and the apple buds were moving on the wild trees, showing their first pale blue petals. I wrote all day until dark, and then I had dinner and went back and wrote until some hour in the darkness between midnight and four. I had skipped a few areas that I knew would give me no trouble in the writing and gone for the parts that had to be muscled into position. By the next morning I had done the first half, the first act of two. When I lay down to sleep I realized I had been weeping - my eyes still burned and my throat was sore from talking it all out and shouting and laughing. I would be stiff when I woke, aching as if I had played four hours of football or tennis and now had to face the start of another game. It would take some six more weeks to complete Act II.
My laughter during the writing came mostly at Willy's contradicting himself so arrantly, and out of the laughter the title came one afternoon. Death Comes for the Archbishop, the Death and the Maiden quartet - always austere and elevated was death in titles. Now it would be claimed by a joker, a bleeding mass of contradictions, a clown, and there was something funny about that, something like a thumb in the eye, too. yes, and in some far corner of my mind possibly something political; there was the smell in the air of a new American Empire in the making, if only because, as I had witnessed, Europe was dying or dead, and I wanted to set before the new captains and the so smugly confident kings the corpse of a believer. On the play's opening night a woman who shall not be named was outraged, calling it "a time bomb under American capitalism"; I hoped it was, or at least under the bullshit of American capitalism, this pseudo life that thought to touch the clouds by standing on top of a refrigerator, waving a paid-up mortgage at the moon, victorious at last.
But some thirty-five years later, the Chinese reaction to my Beijing production of Salesman would confirm what had become more and more obvious over the decades in the play's hundreds of productions throughout the world: Willy was representative everywhere, in every kind of system, of ourselves in this time. The Chinese might disapprove of his lies and his self-deluding exaggeration as well as his immorality with women, but they certainly saw themselves in him. And it was not simply as a type but because of what he wanted. Which was to excel, to win out over anonymity and meaninglessness, to love and be loved, and above all, perhaps, to count. When he roared out, "I am not a dime a dozen! I am Willy Loman, and you are Biff Loman!" it came as a nearly revolutionary declaration after what was now thirty-four years of leveling. (The play was the same age as the Chinese revolution.) I did not know in 1948 in Connecticut that I was sending a message of resurgent individualism to the China of 1983 - especially when the revolution it had signified, it seemed at the time, the long-awaited rule of reason and the historic ending of chaotic egocentricity and selfish aggrandizement. Ah. yes. I had not reckoned on a young Chinese student saying to a CBS interviewer in the theatre lobby, "We are moved by it because we also want to be number one, and to be rich and successful." What else is this but human unpredictability, which goes on escaping the nets of unfreedom?
I did not move far from the phone for two days after sending the script to Kazan. By the end of the second silent day I would have accepted his calling to tell me that it was a scrambled egg, an impenetrable, unstageable piece of wreckage. And his tone when he finally did call was alarmingly sober.
"I've read your play." He sounded at a loss as to how to give me the bad news. "My God, it's so sad."
"It's supposed to be."
"I just put it down. I don't know what to say. My father..." He broke off, the first of a great many men - and women - who would tell me that Willy was their father. I still thought he was letting me down easy. "It's a great play, Artie. I want to do it in the fall or winter. I'll start thinking about casting." He was talking as though someone we both knew had just died, and it filled me with happiness. Such is art.
For the first time in months, as I hung up the phone, I could see my family clearly again. As was her way, Mary accepted the great news with a quiet pride, as though something more expressive would spoil me, but I too thought I should remain an ordinary citizen, even an anonymous one (although I did have a look at the new Studebaker convertible, the Raymond Lowery design that was the most beautiful American car of the time, and bought one as soon as the play opened). But Mary's mother, who was staying the week with us, was astonished. "Another play?" she said, as though the success of All My Sons had been enough for one lifetime. She had unknowingly triggered that play when she gossiped about a young girl somewhere in central Ohio who had turned her father in to the FBI for having manufactured faulty aircraft parts during the war.
But who should produce Salesman? Kazan and I walked down Broadway from the park where we had been strolling and talking about the kind of style the production would need. Kazan's partnership with Harold Clurman had recently broken up, and I had no idea about a producer. He mentioned Cheryl Crawford, whom I hardly knew, and then Kermit Bloomgarden, an accountant turned producer, whom I had last seen poring over Herman Shumlin's account books a couple of years before when Shumlin turned down All My Sons. I had never seen Bloomgarden smile, but he had worked for the Group Theatre and Kazan knew him, and as much because we happened to have come to a halt a few yards from his office building as for any other reason, he said, "Well, let's go up and say hello." When we stood across the desk from him and Kazan said he had a play of mine for him to read, Bloomgarden squeezed up his morose version of a smile, or at least a suggestion of one he planned to have next week.
This whimsical transforming of another person's life reminds me of a similar walk with Kazan uptown from a garage on Twenty-sixth Street where he had left his old Pontiac to be repaired. He began wondering aloud whom he should ask to head a new acting school to be called the Actors Studio, which he and Clurman and Robert Lewis and Cheryl Crawford were organizing. None of these founders was prepared to run the place, Kazan, Clurman, and Lewis being too busy with their flourishing directing careers, and Crawford with her work as a producer. "Lee Strasberg is probably the best guy for it. He'd certainly be able to put in the time." In due course Strasberg became not only the head of the Actors Studio but also its heart and soul, and for the general public its organizer. So his work there was made possibly by his having been unemployable at the right moment. But that, come to think of it, is as good a way as any to be catapulted into world fame.
Willy had to be small, I thought, but we soon realized that Roman Bohnen and Ernest Truex and a few other very good actors seemed to lack the size of the character even if they fit the body. The script had been sent to Lee Cobb, an actor I remembered mainly as a mountainous hulk covered with a towel in a Turkish bath in an Irwin Shaw play, with the hilarious oy vey delivery of a forever persecuted businessman. Having flown himself across the country in his own two-engine airplane, he sat facing me in Bloomgarden's office and announced, "This is my part. Nobody else can play this part. I know this man." And he did indeed seem to be the man when a bit later in a coffee shop downstairs he looked up at the young waitress and smiled winsomely as though he had to win her loving embrace before she could be seduced into bringing him his turkey sandwich and coffee - ahead of all the other men's orders, and only after bestowing on his unique slice of pickle her longing kiss.
But while I trusted his and Kazan's experience, I lacked any conviction of my own about him until one evening in our Grace Court living room Lee looked down at my son, Bob, on the floor and I heard him laugh at something funny the child had said. The sorrow in his laughter flew out at me, touched me; it was deeply depressed and at the same time joyous, all flowing through a baritone voice that was gorgeously reedy. So large and handsome a man pretending to be thoroughly at ease in a world where he obviously did not fit could be moving.
"You know - or do you? -," Lee said to me one day in Bloomgarden's office a week or so before rehearsals were about to begin, "that this play is a watershed. The American theatre will never be the same." I could only gulp and nod in silence at his portentousness - which I feared might augur a stately performance - and hope that he would make Willy come alive anyway.
But as rehearsals proceeded in the small, periodically abandoned theatre on the ratty roof of the New Amsterdam on Forty-second street, where Ziegfeld in the twenties had staged some intimate revues, Lee seemed to move about in a buffalo's stupefied trance, muttering his lines, plodding with deathly slowness from position to position, and behaving like a man who had been punched in the head. "He's just learning it," Kazan shakily reassured me after three or four days. I waited as a week went by, and then ten days, and all that was emerging from Lee Cobb's throat was a bumpy hum. The other actors were nearing performance levels, but when they had to get a response from Lee all their rhythms slowed to near collapse. Kazan was no longer so sure and kept huddling with Lee, trying to pump him up. Nor did Lee offer any explanation, and I wondered whether he thought to actually play the part like a man with a foot in the grave. Between us, Kazan and I began referring to him as "the Walrus".
On about the twelfth day, in the afternoon, with Eddie Kook, our lighting supplier, and Jimmy Proctor, our pressman, and Kazan and myself in the seats, Lee stood up as usual from the bedroom chair and turned to Mildred Dunnock and bawled, "No, there's more people now ... There's more people!" and, gesturing toward the empty upstage where the window was supposed to be, caused a block of apartment houses to spring up in my brain, and the air became sour with the smell of kitchens where once there had been only the odors of earth, and he began to move frighteningly, with such ominous reality that my chest felt pressed down by an immense weight. After the scene had gone on for a few minutes, I glanced around to see if the others had my reaction. Jim Proctor had his head bent into his hands and was weeping, Eddie Kook was looking shocked, almost appalled, and tears were pouring over his cheeks, and Kazan behind me was grinning like a fiend, gripping his temples with both hands, and we knew we had it - there was an unmistakable wave of life moving across the air of the empty theatre, a wave of Willy's pain and protest. I began to weep myself at some point that was not particularly sad, but it was as much, I think, out of pride in our art, in Lee's magical capacity to imagine, to collect within himself every mote of life since Genesis and to let it pour forth. He stood up there like a giant moving the Rocky Mountains into position.
At the end of the act, Del Hughes, our sweet but hardheaded, absolutely devoted, competent stage manager, came out from a wing and looked out at us. His stunned eyes started us all laughing. I ran up and kissed Lee, who pretended to be surprised. "But what did you expect, Arthur?" he said, his eyes full of his playful vanity. My God, I thought - he really is Willy! On the subway going home to Brooklyn I felt once again the aching pain in my muscles that the performance had tensed up so tightly, just as in the writing time. And when I thought of it later, it seemed as though Lee's sniffing around the role for so long recapitulated what I had done in the months before daring to begin to write.
The whole production was, I think, unusual for the openness with which every artist involved sought out his truths. It was all a daily, almost moment-to-moment testing of ideas. There was much about the play that had never been done before, and this gave an uncustomary excitement to our discussions about what would or would not be understood by an audience. The setting I had envisioned was three bare platforms and only the minimum necessary furniture for a kitchen and two bedrooms, with the Boston hotel room as well as Howard's office to be played in open space. Jo Mielziner took those platforms and designed an environment around them that was romantic and dreamlike yet at the same time lower-middle-class. His set, in a word, was an emblem of Willy's intense longing for the promises of the past, with which indeed the present state of his mind is always conflicting, and it was thus both a lyrical design and a dramatic one. The only notable mistake in his early concept was to put the gas hot-water heater in the middle of the kitchen, a symbol of menace that I thought obvious and Kazan finally eliminated as a hazard to his staging. But by balancing on the edges of the ordinary bounds of verisimilitude, Jo was stretching reality in parallel with the script, just as Kazan did by syncopating the speech rhythms of the actors. He made Mildred Dunnock deliver her long first-act speeches to the boys at double her normal speed, then he doubled that, and finally she - until recently a speech teacher - was standing there drumming out words as fast as her very capable tongue could manage. Gradually he slacked her off, but the drill straightened her spine, and her Linda filled up with outrage and protest rather than self-pity and mere perplexity. Similarly, to express the plays' inner life, the speech rate in some scenes or sections was unnaturally speeded or slowed.
My one scary hour came with the climactic restaurant fight between Willy and the boys, when it all threatened to come apart. I had written a scene in which Biff resolves to tell Willy that the former boss from whom Biff had planned to borrow money to start a business has refused to so much as see him and does not even remember his working for the firm years ago. But on meeting his brother and father in the restaurant, he realizes that Willy's psychological stress will not permit the whole catastrophic truth to be told, and he begins to trim the bad news. From moment to moment the scene as originally written had so many shadings of veracity that Arthur Kennedy, a very intelligent citizen indeed, had trouble shifting from a truth to a half-truth to a fragment of truth and back to the whole truth, all of it expressed in quickly delivered, very short lines. The three actors, with Kazan standing beside them, must have repeated the scene through a whole working day, and it still wobbled. "I don't see how we can make it happen," Kazan said as we left the theatre that evening. "Maybe you ought to try simplifying it for them." I went home and worked through the night and brought in a new scene, which played much better and became the scene as finally performed.
The other changes were very small and a pleasure to make because they involved adding lines rather than cutting or rewriting. In Act I, Willy is alone in the kitchen muttering to himself, and as his memories overtake him the lighting brightens, the exterior of the house becomes covered with leaf shadows as of old, and in a moment the boys are calling to him in their youthful voices, entering the stage as they were in their teens. There was not sufficient time, however, for them to descend from their beds in the dark on the specially designed elevators and finish stripping out of their pajamas into sweaters and trousers and sneakers, so I had to add time to Willy's monologue. But that was easy since he loved talking to himself about his boys and his vision of them.
The moving in and out of the present had to be not simply indicative but a tactile transformation that the audience could feel as well as comprehend, and indeed come to dread as returning memory threatens to bring Willy closer to his end. Lighting was thus decisively important, and Mielziner, who also lit the show, with Eddie Kook by his side, once worked an entire afternoon lighting a chair.
Willy, in his boss's office, has exploded once too often, and Howard has gone out, leaving him alone. He turns to the office chair, which in the old days was occupied by Frank, Howard's father, who had promised Willy shares in the firm as a reward for all his good work, and as he does so the chair must become alive, quite as though his old boss were in it as he addresses him: "Frank, Frank, don't you remember what you told me? ..." Rather than being lit, the chair subtly seemed to begin emanating light. But this was not merely an exercise in theatre magic; it confirmed that we had moved inside Willy's system of loss, that we were seeing the world as he saw it even as we kept a critical distance and saw it for ourselves.
To set the chair off and make the light change work, all surrounding lights had to dim imperceptibly. That was when Eddie Kook, who had become so addicted to the work on this play that his office at his Century Lighting Company had all but ceased operations, turned to me and said, "You've been asking me why we need so many lights. [We were using more than most musicals.] The reason is right there in front of you - it takes more lights to make it dark." With fewer lights each one would have to be dimmed more noticeably than if there were many, each one fractionally reduced in intensity to create the change without apparent source or contrivance.
Salesman had its first public performance at the Locust Street Theatre in Philadelphia. Across the street the Philadelphia Orchestra was playing Beethoven's Seventh Symphony that afternoon, and Kazan thought Cobb ought to hear some of it, wanting, I suppose, to prime the great hulk on whom all our hopes depended. The three of us were in a conspiracy to make absolutely every moment of every scene cohere to what preceded and followed it; we were now aware that Willy's part was among the longest in dramatic literature, and Lee was showing signs of wearying. We sat at either side of him in a box, inviting him, as it were, to drink of the heroism of that music, to fling himself into his role tonight without holding back. We thought of ourselves, still, as a kind of continuation of a long and undying past.
As sometimes happened later on during the run, there was no applause at the final curtain of the first performance. Strange things began to go on in the audience. With the curtain down, some people stood to put their coats on and then sat again, some, especially men, were bent forward covering their faces, and others were openly weeping. People crossed the theatre to stand quietly talking with one another. It seemed forever before someone remembered to applaud, and then there was no end of it.
Today is the birthday of American playwright Eugene O'Neill.
He made his New York debut - with a one-act play presented in a night of three one-acts - at the new Playwrights Theatre - on 139 Macdougal Street, in Greenwich Village. It was the first season for this new theatre. The evening of one-acts were:
The Game, by Louise Bryant (ahem)
King Arthur's Socks, by Floyd Dell
Bound East for Cardiff, by Eugene O'Neill. (I posted an excerpt of this play here)
O'Neill was completely unknown at the time. He went on to write some of the most influential American plays ever written - he won 4 Pulitzer Prizes - and he is the only American playwright to win the Nobel Prize. His work is untouchable, as far as I'm concerned. Nobody else even comes CLOSE.
In 1916, the Playwrights Theatre was formed by a group of young artists - they all were up in Provincetown on vacation - and they built the Playwrights Theatre on a wharf.

They called themselves the Provincetown Players. They did everything, they were a true ensemble.
When the idyllic summer ended (and you can see Warren Beatty's version of all of this in Reds) - the Provincetown Players relocated to Greenwich Village (where many of them lived already) - and opened up their theatre on Macdougall.
This was the beginning of Eugene O'Neill's career. He got enough of his short plays produced over the next 4 years - that his reputation began to grow - until finally Beyond the Horizon, his first full-length, opened on Broadway in 1920.
In the premiere of Bound East for Cardiff - O'Neill played the "second mate" which is basically a walk-on. He had one line:
"Isn't this your watch on deck., Driscoll?"
O'Neill's father, James, had been an actor, very popular, very successful, touring about with popular plays of the day. Long Day's Journey Into Night was autobiographical. Eugene O'Neill was raised Irish Catholic, and his rejection of the faith devastated his father - just like in the play. O'Neill's father was also an alcoholic (like James Tyrone) - and has also given up a career as a Shakespearean actor for a part in a very commercial (but worthless) production called Monte Cristo. James Tyrone is haunted by the great Shakespearean actor he could have been ... and so was O'Neill's dad. Like Mary Tyrone, O'Neill's mother in real-life was a morphine addict. Just like in the play, she became addicted to morphine after an incompetent doctor proscribed it to her following a difficult childibrth. Jamie is modeled after O'Neill's real-life brother, an alcoholic whoremonger who was basically a huge failure at whatever he tried to accomplish. Eugene had an older brother named Edmund - who had died when he was a baby. In the play, the baby who died is named Eugene. Like Edmund, Eugene O'Neill sailed for years, living a restless peripatetic constantly-broke life. He took odd jobs. O'Neill was also not what you would call a hearty man with a hearty constitution. He was fragile, and eventually got tuberculosis. He spent 6 months in a sanatorium for treatment - turberculosis was a very dangerous disease.
O'Neill was a man with demons, make no mistake. His plays are all personal, all drawing from his own life, but it was as though he held off on family matters until the very end ... it was too dangerous, too frightening to even face. There's a reason why Long Day's Journey is so relentless, so depressing, so spectacular. It had been boiling up in him for decades.
On Sunday, Aug. 13, 1916 - A.J. Philpot, a journalist for the Boston Globe wrote a piece about the Provincetown Players - and mentioned Eugene O'Neill - the first moment of recognition of this great great writer:
Many people will remember James O'Neill who played "Monte Cristo." He had a son - Eugene O'Neill - who knocked about the world in tramp steamers - and saw life "in the raw," and thought much about it. He is one of the Players, and he has written some little plays which have made a very deep impression on those who have seen them produced here.
"some little plays". Amazing, right?? Knowing what was coming? Knowing the impact that O'Neill would eventually have?
Here's a photograph of O'Neill at Sea Island Bend (photographer: Carl van Vechten)

O'Neill, due to ill health, was unable to attend the Nobel Prize banquet in honor of him (in 1936) ... but he wrote his speech out, and had James E. Brown read it for him. Here it is in its entirety, but I liked this part especially:
This thought of original inspiration brings me to what is, for me, the greatest happiness this occasion affords, and that is the opportunity it gives me to acknowledge, with gratitude and pride, to you and to the people of Sweden, the debt my work owes to that greatest genius of all modern dramatists, your August Strindberg.It was reading his plays when I first started to write back in the winter of 1913-14 that, above all else, first gave me the vision of what modern drama could be, and first inspired me with the urge to write for the theatre myself. If there is anything of lasting worth in my work, it is due to that original impulse from him, which has continued as my inspiration down all the years since then - to the ambition I received then to follow in the footsteps of his genius as worthily as my talent might permit, and with the same integrity of purpose.
Of course, it will be no news to you in Sweden that my work owes much to the influence of Strindberg. That influence runs clearly through more than a few of my plays and is plain for everyone to see. Neither will it be news for anyone who has ever known me, for I have always stressed it myself. I have never been one of those who are so timidly uncertain of their own contribution that they feel they cannot afford to admit ever having been influenced, lest they be discovered as lacking all originality.
No, I am only too proud of my debt to Strindberg, only too happy to have this opportunity of proclaiming it to his people. For me, he remains, as Nietzsche remains in his sphere, the Master, still to this day more modern than any of us, still our leader. And it is my pride to imagine that perhaps his spirit, musing over this year's Nobel award for literature, may smile with a little satisfaction, and find the follower not too unworthy of his Master.
Beautiful. Beautiful.
Oh, and naturally, because I must:

Eugene O'Neill wrote Long Day's Journey Into Night (what a title) in 1939, but it was never performed in his lifetime. His wife remembered the summer he wrote it. He would stay in his study all day working, and emerge in the evening, with his eyes puffed up and red from weeping. He wrote and wept. He wept and wrote. All day long, in his study, emerging as though from a nightmare every night, before going back in to face it every day. And damn, you can tell that from the language in that play that he had ripped out a piece of his own heart in writing it. An astonishing and painful exorcism has taken place. It's a bleak play. If you find the hope in it, lemme know, would ya?
On his twelfth wedding anniversary with his wife Carlotta, O'Neill gave her the script of the play with this note:
For Carlotta,
on our 12th Wedding Anniversary
Dearest: I give you the original script of this play of old sorrow, written in tears and blood. A sadly inappropriate gift, it would seem, for a day celebrating happiness. But you will understand. I mean it as a tribute to your love and tenderness which gave me the faith in love that enable me to face my dead at last and write this play, write it with deep pity and understanding and forgiveness for all the four haunted Tyrones.These twelve years, Beloved One, have been a Journey into Light, into love. You know my gratitude. And my love!
Gene
Tao House
July 22, 1941
The haunted Tyrones. O'Neill knew what it would take to get that story out of him. Naturally, he put it off. A couple of his plays (Moon for the Misbegotten and Long Day's Journey) had their major ground-breaking productions after O'Neill's death. It is not that his success was posthumous, that is obviously not the case ... but his stature has just grown over the years. To me, even with the Tennessee Williams' and the Arthur Miller's ... he is THE American playwright. In many ways, his work paved the way for the others.
So happy birthday, "Gene". Thank you for "facing your dead" at last, and putting that to paper.

EXCERPTS FROM O'NEILL'S WORK
Moon of the Caribees
Bound East for Cardiff
The Long Voyage Home
In the Zone
Ile
The Iceman Cometh
Anna Christie
Long Day's Journey Into Night
Today is the birthday of one of my favorite writers - Truman Capote.

Truman Capote has been one of my many life-long obsessions - so forgive my autistic knowledge of this man - his life, and his work and his emotional journey. Also - I just had to go out and find all the great photos of him, and post them here. People LOVED to photograph this man (at least in his early wunderkind days) - and all of them are online, which is so exciting. So I've found some of my favorites, to post them here for you.
Example:

Most of my generation only remembers Truman (his Public Persona, I mean), from his appearances on various talk shows, mainly Johnny Carson, when he was a bloated guy with a high lisping voice who was vaguely embarrassing to watch - At least I felt that way. He was obese, he had face lifts, he wore a white Panama hat, he was kind of grotesque. I didn't know that he was basically caricaturing himself by then - which is always death to an artist of any kind.

But he was stuck. He had horrendous writer's block at the very end - which tormented him. The end of his life was full of despair. It's wrenching to read about - you just want his suffering to stop.
But as a youngun? As the new writer in town? He was a golden boy. He was a creature like Thomas Mann had written about. The golden-haired child-man who led others to do naughty naughty things, and then pled innocence. Photographers lined up to capture this guy.
See what I mean?

Hard to realize just how provocative those photos were back then. Especially because he was openly gay. And not just "openly gay" - but openly PRISSY and gay - which some people find unforgivable. Fine, be gay ... but ... do you have to be so ... GAY about it?? Can't you just PRETEND to be straight so I don't have to feel so ... ikky? Truman, even back in the early 40s, didn't put on an act for the straight world. He didn't turn himself inside out to make people feel comfortable with his gayness. He just was who he was. If people felt uncomfortable, then that was THEIR problem. He was prissy, he lisped, he flounced about like a Southern belle - AND he happened to be a kick-ass writer with a literary voice that no one could forget.
I still remember the impact that The Grass Harp had on my heart when I first read it.

I was too young then to really understand regrets, or loss - the way I understand them now - but his elegaic writing in that story touched some deep universal chord in me - the part of me that is HUMAN, and not just an age on a timeline. There was a kind of soul-growth spurt that happened to me when I read that sad beautiful story. I still have a real fondness for it.
(Excerpt here)
His first book, published in 1948, was Other Voices, Other Rooms, and it took the literary world by storm. It was one of THOSE debuts. High level reviewers praised the book - in glowing terms - and it truly is a wonderful book. Not as good as his others, and CERTAINLY not as good as In Cold Blood
(just saying the name of that book gives me a chill up my spine) - but you could tell that there was a real VOICE in that book.
Just to add to the controversy - here is the "author photo" that appeared sprawled across the back of the book:

hahahahaha Truman! Please! It caused an outrage. A stir. (Tennessee Williams, down in Key West, had heard about it - and wrote letters referencing it) People loved it. People hated it. People TALKED about it, and that was what Truman cared about. Truman had talent - yes - but he understood the whole 15 minutes of fame thing long before Andy Warhol came along. Truman wanted to be FAMOUS as well as being a good writer. He wasn't one of those writers who holed themselves up in their apartments (at least not until In Cold Blood when he disappeared off the face of the earth for almost 5 years - he said later that writing that book nearly killed him.) ... But before In Cold Blood he was out at every party, he hung out with the rich and famous (at least until the huge debacle at the end of his life when he alienated all of them in one fell swoop)
This photo is just ... kind of says it all, don't it?

Look at how he's holding her wrist!!! Like - hold her HAND, Truman. But also - look at how sweet she is. The two of them were actually very good friends and he wrote one of my favorite pieces about her, which appears in the gorgeous collection Music for Chameleons. The piece describes a day in New York when he and Marilyn attended a funeral of a mutual friend. I love that piece. It's called "A Beautiful Child", because that's what Truman saw her as. Not the sex goddess. But a beautiful child.
(Excerpt here)
He was the darling of New York. He wasn't just friends with celebrities - whose wealth is a rather transitory thing. He became friends with REAL rich people. The international tycoon types. The Onassis types. He was invited to all of the "society" parties.
And one day - he read a little snippet in the newspaper about an entire family who had been slaughtered in their own home ... and something sparked in him ... He spoke to the folks at The New Yorker - he wanted to do a piece on how such a brutal murder would affect the small town ... He went to Kansas - and basically did not emerge from that nightmare for another 5 or 6 years. The result, of course, was the great great In Cold Blood.
(Excerpt here)
More on In Cold Blood in a bit.
Once that book stopped taking up every second of his life (he was never really the same again, after writing it) ... he was ready to re-enter New York society, with a bang.
And he threw a party that is still famous. It was called The Black and White Ball, and he threw it for Katherine Graham - who he didn't even really know.

She wrote in her autobiography (which I've read): "I was truly baffled as to why I was the guest of honor. But it seemed really important to Truman ... so I said yes."
Odd. It was, many people say who care about this stuff, the "party of the century".
Everyone had to come wearing masks, and everyone had to dress in black and white. Truman had just finished In Cold Blood - or maybe he had just returned from Kansas - not sure - but he needed to let off steam, he needed to shake off In Cold Blood which had literally taken over his life. So he threw this party - where everyone who was anyone showed up.
Here's Candice Bergen at the party:

Here's Norman Mailer and his wife - hahahaha

Here's Mia Farrow and Frank Sinatra- who had just gotten married:

People jostled to get invited. People sucked up to Truman. He was in his glory. But even then - he had the oddest mix of desire and contempt when it came to the rich. He wanted to hang out with them - but he had contempt for them as well. On some level, I think he knew that they would drop him like a hot potato the second his friendship became inconvenient. He knew that his friendships with these people were were pretty one-sided: Truman was there to entertain, to keep things light and amusing. The second he started falling on hard times later in life, they stopped tolerating his company.
Perhaps all those rich people just liked the cache of having a literary star at their parties - it made their parties seem more ... substantial. Maybe they really did like him. But I don't think so. And I don't think Truman liked them all that much, either. He saw right through them. Only he kept that to himself, and let the rich people think that he bought their game, that he was fooled, that he did not see the essential shallowness beneath their facade. When he finally came out and wrote about them and their pettiness, their stupidity - they could not and would not forgive him. One chapter of his book was published - and set off a shitstorm through the international rich set - all of whom had welcomed Capote into their midst.
(Excerpt here)
He never finished that book.
(By that point in his life, long after In Cold Blood, Truman had actually lost a lot of what had made him a success in the first place ... and that was his compassion for others. His ability to love his fellow man, and to try to step into their shoes and describe for us, the reader, what it is "like" to be that person. By the 1960s, drugs and drinking had taken hold ... and Truman was angry. He wrote about his former friends with bitchy - but spot-on - RAGE. He had NO compassion for THEM. He could find it in his heart to be compassionate for Dick Hickock and Perry Smtih even though they had committed such a heinous crime. But he was NOT compassionate for the fat Upper East Side cats. He unleashed his wrath on them, and it was like a bomb going off in international society.)
Truman Capote found himself bereft, and alone. He never recovered from that shattering of his world, even though he said over and over, "I'm a writer! What did they think I did in my spare time? I observed life - and I wrote about it!" They did not forgive him for telling the truth. Years later, when Gerald Clarke wrote his tremendous biography of Capote - there were people who refused to be interviewed for the book becaue they were STILL seething at Truman's "betrayal".

I'm going to post something I wrote a long time ago on this blog - which ended up being published elsewhere. It's called "Fairy on the Prairie", and it's about the writing of In Cold Blood which is pretty much on my Top 10 favorite books ever written. Certain books come and go on that list - titles get bumped off - moved on - but not In Cold Blood. There are a couple of others that never get bumped off - Harriet the Spy, Wrinkle in Time, Catch 22. These are great great books.
I'm proud of the piece I wrote on Truman.
Before we get to that, though, I would like to share my favorite photo of Truman Capote. It's done by the great photographer Irving Penn. I like it because - it's not the "carefree" look of his golden-boy self - which was a pose, to some degree. It's not the provocative just-got-out-of-bed look he sported as an early writer - which was also a pose. And it's not a photograph from his later years, which just really hurt me to see.
Irving Penn had photographed Spencer Tracy, famously, boxed up in a corner. (That was one of Penn's "things" - he put famous people into corners of rooms and photographed them. Strangely effective.)
Look. Amazing photo of Spencer. Look at the EXPRESSION on his face.

Penn took basically the same photograph of Truman - boxed him up in a corner. I looked for a larger version of the photo - a clearer one - but couldn't find it. This is the best I could get.
There is something about this photo that not only haunts me, but strikes me as deeply painfully TRUE. The oversized coat, it makes him look so small and frail. The cramped quarters, the walls pressing in. Now, I did not know Truman Capote, and it is not for me to say who is the "real" Truman Capote - but something about the look on his face in this photo, its flat blank-eyed stare, the gaze is a bit confronting, but also - so accepting of himself, of the soul behind those eyeballs - something about it lands for me. I feel that I am getting a glimpse not of a personality, a famous person ... but someone's soul. I feel the same way about the Spencer Tracy photograph - so I don't know what that's about, and I'm sure it has all to do with Irving Penn's gift. It's extraordinary to me.

And now. Onto In Cold Blood, and my old post about him. There may be some repeats of information here.
Happy happy birthday, dear dear Truman.

Truman Capote said later that if he had known what he was getting into, when he traveled down to Kansas ("a fairy down on the prairie") to write a piece on the murder for The New Yorker, then he never would have gone. He went to Kansas only 2 weeks after the murders took place. The killers had still not been found, the community was in an uproar of suspicion and paranoia. Capote's main interest was to do a long profile of the townspeople, how regular church-going farmers handled such a disaster. Little did he know what the book would eventually be! The project took up years of his life. He had to wait for the executions of the 2 murderers, in order to complete his book. So he waited, and waited. Appeal after appeal ...He was unable to write anything else. Nothing else interested him. He was a man obsessed, in the grip of his obsession for years. His health was ruined. His friends were sick of hearing about the Clutter family. He tried to take vacations with his long-time partner, and would just drink, and try to sleep, and have fits of despair. He thought those boys would never be executed, he thought he would be in limbo forever. Yet - the morbidness of his entire life being on hold because of commuted death-sentences in Kansas - the morbidness of trying to go on, when really all you want is for those 2 boys to be killed - so that YOU can go back to YOUR life ... This selfish attitude (necessary for the project) took a huge toll on him. It felt inhuman.
Finally - there were no more appeals and Capote traveled to Kansas, to watch the execution. Hickock and Smith had asked him to be there. In the intervening years, he had interviewed the 2 killers numerous times. Their first-person descriptions of their own sorry lives make up important parts of the book. Capote became their conduit to the outside world. Hickock would draw self-portraits of himself and send them to Capote. Capote was playing a double-edged game here. He became "the listener", the one who would sit and ask them questions, and nod understandingly. The 2 of them got addicted to his concern. Yet Capote was horrified by most of what he heard. He wasn't without pity for these men, who had pretty much been beaten like dogs from the second they were born - and yet Capote hadn't had an easy road either, and HE hadn't killed anyone in cold blood. He had grown up with alcoholics, he had been abandoned by his father, his parents were ashamed of having a "fairy" for a son, he was sent to military school - can you imagine how awful that must have been for him? Capote may have acted like a cream-puff but that man was cold and hard as steel inside. He had to be.
Capote needed quotes, he needed access, he needed to enter into the psychologies of these 2 men. He was able to paint the graphic picture of the Clutter family through interviews with people who knew and loved them. But the Clutters were no longer around to speak for themselves. Hickock and Smith were alive for a couple of years, so he visited them often. On his way out of Death Row, he would feel the urge to vomit. It would take him days to recover, emotionally, from these macabre "visits". And he said, later, that he never recovered from the "shattering" experience of watching the two men hang. The letters he wrote to friends afterwards are nearly incoherent. Watching how hard the hanging body clings to life, watching the kicking feet, the flailing, the letting-go of bodily functions ... Capote was really never the same man again.
And he then sat down and wrote the book like a bat out of hell.
Truman Capote always thought that he had a "great book" in him. This mythical "great book" haunted his dreams, he would lie awake at night aching with ambition, dreaming about this great book ... He didn't think In Cold Blood was his masterpiece. He looked back on the experience of researching that book and writing it as a grim one, an almost universally unpleasant and grueling experience. I've read all of Capote's books. I love that guy's writing style. I even read his unfinished work - the 2 chapters of the novel he was working on when he died. He claimed to have it almost finished, but the rest of it (if it even existed) was never found. The 2 chapters are okay - it's a gossipy bitchy look at high-class New York society. It's merciless. It's very funny. Nobody is spared. Human beings are seen in their worst lights. Everyone is selfish, cynical, out for themselves ... It is quite funny, but it's very very mean. He was nearing the end of his life, and he had been abandoned by most of his friends. His outlook was not good, he was addicted to drugs, filled with anxiety and loneliness ... The 2 chapter are his way of lashing out at all those people who left him, who tossed him out with the trash. Hence, the mean-ness.
The thing in the rest of Capote's writing that, for me, sets him apart is his undeniable love of humanity. His tenderness. His ability to SEE people, with all their flaws - and to see them as beautiful. Much of his best writing is all about nostalgia, wistfulness, yearning for childhood ... Yes, it is sentimental, but it also has a depth of sadness beneath it, a grief ... which elevates it from mawkishness.
In Cold Blood taps into something else. In Cold Blood doesn't fit into either of the Capote categories: the bitchy mean queen telling all the nasty secrets of his high-class friends, or the lonely sweet man filled with hurtful nostalgia for childhood.
It was something completely new. For him, and for us. I don't even know if I can describe it. All I can say is - he never accomplished such a thing again. His writing never seemed so effortless again. You read that book and you feel like if you cut ONE WORD, the entire thread will unravel. It is so tight.
The other thing I had forgotten from the biography is Capote's personal experience leaving his home-environment of ritzy New York City (where there were lots of "fairies"), and venturing into the Kansas prairies to investigate a murder. Capote was openly gay. He wasn't a macho gay, either. He didn't try to blend in, or act straight, or hide his gayness. He was a small rotund man, who wore wide white hats, spoke with a lisp, fluttered about like Blanche DuBois, and literally said things like, "I declare!"
He took one of his best friends, Harper Lee (yes - THAT Harper Lee) as a co-researcher. She was much more "normal"-acting, and was able to blend in a bit more. She could get people to talk to her, because she seemed like one of them.
But Truman Capote was so relentless, and not only so relentless, but so committed to justice, so committed to discovering what had happened in the Clutter household, that people started opening up. The people in the town started competing about who had had him over for dinner the most times. Alvin Dewey, the head of the investigation, a tough gruff 3 pack a day smoker, eventually counted Truman as a valued partner. Truman was there when Dewey got the call that the 2 murderers had been picked up in Las Vegas, AND that they were still wearing the boots with the distinctive soles (that had left footprints - If the 2 hadn't confessed, the boots alone would have convicted them). Truman was standing right there, with Dewey's wife, listening to Dewey hear the news.
The people of Kansas, who had never met a person like Capote in their lives, who were Bible-Belt ranchers and farmers, took him into their homes, their families, their hearts. Without them, the book would not have been written.
It is a massive accomplishment.
Truman Capote went to his grave thinking that his "great book" remained unwritten. I beg to differ.
A post about a teacher, a student, and Gullivers Travels that moves me so much. I was riveted.
I can't begin to guess at what is going on with that student who was so upset at Gulliver's Travels - it truly is not my place to guess - but I get that her fear and agitation is genuine, and in some ways I see myself in her. The response to literature is raw, personal ... there is no distance or barrier - and you can psych yourself out (especially in a class situation with the group dynamic) into feeling it is "inappropriate", that something is wrong with you - that you have such a response. After all, you look around your class and it seems like everyone else is just chilling out, not freaking about the text at all. (This may be untrue ... because you never can tell what goes on inside a human being ... that bland person sitting at the desk beside you may be having just a personal response as you are, except they have a better "game face").
Anyway, regardless: lovely post by a blogger I adore visiting, just to see what she's thinking about.
Here's a post I wrote about Gulliver's Travels, a book I re-read recently.
And here's something I wrote about Swift, a favorite of mine.
And so many venues in New York (and, I assume, elsewhere) are getting ready to celebrate and pay tribute. I will definitely need to check out the exhibit at the Morgan Library (opening in October) - and I just love this entire article about the extravaganza being planned at the Williamsburg Art & Historical Center. First of all, it's launching with a costume ball this Saturday. But the center has put together a multi-floored exhibit - of paintings and sculpture - honoring Milton, inspired by Milton - some connections more vague than others - the article states (and this made me laugh):
With the exception of some lovely abstractions by Ms. Nii, who was an acclaimed painter before she bought the bank building and became a full-time arts administrator, most of the paintings are at the visionary/fantastical end of the spectrum. To judge from them alone, you might guess that “Paradise Lost� was a poem that involved the ingestion of psychedelic substances and that made particular mention of giant eyeballs and naked female breasts.
The beautiful thing about all of this, though, is that interpretation is still alive and well ... which speaks volumes for the original Paradise Lost. When you no longer feel that it is your right to "interpret" - then a work can be considered dead. Fine, have it be a museum piece, under glass ... and let its relevance fade. I am really looking forward to seeing the art - and while I am sure some of it will annoy me (I'm not really into modern art) - I am looking forward to experiencing Paradise Lost through multiple eyes (or should I say multiple "giant eyeballs"). The thought of that really excites me.
I am a Milton fan - and his "sonnet to his blindness" is, along with Auden's "The More Loving One" - my favorite poem of all time. I don't just love the writing. I feel altered when I read it. Sometimes I stay away from it - because I just can't deal with the implications of it - what it seems to demand, and ask, and tell ... it's like looking directly at the sun.
When I consider how my light is spent,
Ere half my days, in this dark world and wide,
And that one Talent which is death to hide,
Lodg'd with me useless, though my Soul more bent
To serve therewith my Maker, and present
My true account, least he returning chide,
Doth God exact day-labour, light deny'd,
I fondly ask; But patience to prevent
That murmur, soon replies, God doth not need
Either man's work or his own gifts, who best
Bar his milde yoak, they serve him best, his State
Is Kingly. Thousands at his bidding speed
And post o're Land and Ocean without rest:
They also serve who only stand and waite.
Jesus Mary and Joseph, Milton, are you trying to kill me??
Not to mention the fact that the man was completely blind when he wrote Paradise Lost. He DICTATED the thing to his daughter. Goosebumps.
Here's a wonderful article about Milton in The New Yorker.
I am really looking forward to the exhibition in Williamsburg. I kinda want to show up there on Saturday night and watch the people arrive, all in costume. Should be pretty fantastical!!
Some quotes about Milton below:

"Milton, with the possible exception of Spenser, is the first eccentric English poet, the first to make a myth out of his personal experience, and to invent a language of his own remote from the spoken word." -- W.H. Auden
Milton, even Milton, rankt with living men!
Over the highest Alps of mind he marches,
And far below him spring the baseless arches
Of Iris, colouring dimly lake and fen.
-- Walter Savage Landor
"His harmonicall and ingeniose Soul did lodge in a beautifull and well-proportioned body. He was a spare man ... He had abroun hayre. His complexion exceeding faire - he was so faire they called him the Lady of Christ's College. Ovall face. His eie a darke gray." -- John Aubrey
"Yet for two and a half centuries - even for a 'speaker' like Wordsworth - Milton's virtue was this language, which engaged and developed subjects difficult to combine, moral verities and the created world. The language of speech is not the only, or first, language of poetry. To criticize work in terms strictly irrelevant to it is of little value: a critical act of "brute assertive will", or a prejudice so ingrained as to be indistinguishable, for uncritical readers, from truth itself. With the decline of literacy, Milton, like Spenser, becomes a more difficult mountain to scale, more remote from the 'common reader'. Yet Chaucer and Shakespeare, the only poets in the tradition who are Milton's superiors, both grow and recede in the same way and are not dismissed. They seem more accessible. In the end Leavis's hostility, like Empson's and Richards's in other areas, is to the Christian content of the poems, and in Milton it is obtrusive and central. We read Herbert's and Donne's divine poems even if we are unbelievers: there is their doubt to engage, and the framed drama of specific situations. But Milton will not allow disbelief to go unchallenged: his structures and narratives are not rooted in individual faith but in universal belief. The question of revealed truth raises its head as in no other poet in the language." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
Milton! thou should'st be living at this hour:
England hath need of thee: she is a fen
Of stagnant waters: altar, sword and pen,
Fireside, the heroic wealth of hall and bower,
Have forfeited their ancieng English dower
Of inward happiness. We are selfish men;
Oh! raise us up, return to us again;
And give us manners, virtue, freedom, power.
Thy soul was like a Star and dwelt apart;
Thou hadst a voice whose sound was like the sea;
Pure as the naked heavens, majestic, free,
So didst thou travel on life's common way,
In cheerful godliness; and yet thy heart
The lowliest duties on itself lay.
-- Wordsworth
"In Milton the world of Spenser was reconfigured and almost unrecognisable ... What had been reasonable and courteous, a belief in the fact that men of culture and intellect will be able to engage in rational discussion and agree to disagree, had been displaced by faction and sometimes violent intolerance. The moderate had stood down and the fanatic had taken his place, in the pulpit, in Parliament, and on the very peaks of Parnassus." -- TS Eliot
"I take it to be my portion in this life, joined with a strong propensity of nature, to leave something so written to aftertimes, as they should not willingly let it die." -- John Milton
"I have bought a pocket Milton, which I carry perpetually about with me, in order to study the sentiments - the dauntless magnanimity, the intrepid, unyielding independence, the desperate daring, the noble defiance of hardship, in that great personage, SATAN." -- Robert Burns
"He was much more admired abrode than at home." -- John Aubrey
"My mind is not capable of forming a more august conception than arises from the contemplation of this greatest man in his latter days: poor, sick, old, blind, slandered, persecuted: 'Darkness before and danger's voice behind,' in an age in which he was as little understood by the party for whom, as by that against whom, he had contended, and among men before whom he strode so far as to dwarf himself by the distance; yet still listening to the music of his own thoughts, or, if additionally cheered, yet cheered only by the prophetic faith of two or three solitary individuals, he did nevertheless
... argue not
Against Heaven's hand or will, nor bate a jot
Of heart or hope; but still bore up and steer'd
Right onward."
-- Samuel Taylor Coleridge
"True musical delight consists only in apt numbers, fit quantity of syllables, and the sense variously drawn out from one verse to another." -- John Milton
"I cannot praise a fugitive and cloistered virtue, unexercised and unbreathed, that never sallies out and sees her adversary, but slinks out of the race where that immortal garland is to be run for...that which purifies us is trial, and trial is by what is contrary." -- John Miltom
So you see that old libel that we were cynics and skeptics was nonsense from the beginning. On the contrary we were the great believers.F. Scott Fitzgerald was born on this day in 1896 in St. Paul, Minnesota!-- F. Scott Fitzgerald, "My Generation"

Fitzgerald was one of those writers I liked right away, even though I read most of his stuff when I was 15, and was forced to for school. I clicked with his books, for some reason. I credit a lot of that to my 10th grade teacher, Mr. Crothers. His love of The Great Gatsby permeated his lectures, and his enthusiasm inspired the class. (Excerpt from book here). I really "got" it. I remember the book as being much much longer - which is so funny. I recently re-read it, and was shocked at how short it actually is.
I already had a fascination with flappers (ahem. Obviously.) Not sure where the fascination came from. I think it might have had something to do with seeing Bugsy Malone on TV when I was about 12. Member that movie? Jodie Foster and Scott Baio as little kid gangsters and gangster molls? Driving cars with their feet like the Flintstones? I absolutely loved that movie, and I loved Jodie Foster's spit curls, and her costumes ... I remember, too, in junior high I did a whole paper on the 1920s for history class. I remember including photographs of flappers, and photographs of the cars they had ... I would insert stuff like this through the text:

I knew all about prohibition, I knew the music ... Oh, and I just remembered a couple other reasons why the whole "jazz age" thing fascinated me long before I encountered Fitzgerald: one of my favorite books growing up was Cheaper by the Dozen, hahaha, just thinking about that book makes me laugh. My cousin Susan and I loved that book, and we read it together. We would play with our Fisher Price little people (or "peeps", in the O'Malley lexicon) and we would make them be the Gilbreth family. 12 little kids, and a mother and father. Most of the book was, of course, about the crazy time-saving schemes that Gilbreth would test out on his family (actually, not so crazy - Gilbreth and Henry Ford were real innovators in this area) - making the kids wash dishes, timing them, and then figuring out ways to cut off seconds from the process. The last couple of chapters in the book take place in the 20s, when the older kids are now teenagers, and the whole jazz age flapper scene was starting to kick in. The older girls would have to sneak out of the house to go meet their boyfriends, the father was losing his mind, and the whole thing just sounded so hilarious and exciting to me. Especially the whole fashion part of it ... the skirts getting shorter, the cars pulling up in front of the house with Ivy League guys driving, waiting for the girls ... I loved it.
All the time I was idealizing her to the last possibility. I was perfectly conscious that she was about the faultiest girl I'd ever met. She was selfish, conceited and uncontrolled and since these were my own faults I was doubly aware of them. Yet I never wanted to change her. Each fault was knit up with a sort of passionate energy that transcended it. Her selfishness made her play the game harder, her lack of control put me rather in awe of her and her conceit was punctuated by such delicious moments of remorse and self-denunciation that it was almost - almost dear to me ... She had the strongest effect on me. She made me want to do something for her, to get something to show her. Every honor in college took on the semblance of a presentable trophy.-- F. Scott Fitzgerald, "The Pierian Springs and the Last Straw" - a story written when he was an undergraduate
And lastly - when I was about 11, I remember my parents taking me to see a production of The Boyfriend up at the local university and I was swept away by it. The costumes, the music, the craziness ... I loved the charleston. I loved the whole fantasy of that era.
So when Great Gatsby came along, I was ready to just LIVE in the pages of that book.
F. Scott Fitzgerald (or - Francis Scott Key Fitzgerald) was born in St. Paul Minnesota in 1896. He went to Princeton, and afterwards joined the army. Somewhere in here, he sold his first story ... and when he was only 23 years old he wrote and published his first novel: This Side of Paradise. It was a smash hit - and was one of those zeitgeist books: it described the moment in time that everyone was experiencing (or, a certain set of people, let's say that) ... It was one of those books that is eloquent about cultural and social changes AS they are happening. Fitzgerald was immediately seen as the voice of that era, and that generation. The jazz age kicking in. Fitzgerald was the poster child. It didn't hurt that he was so handsome.

People projected their own desires onto him, their ideals for who they wanted to be. He was glamorous, urbane, free of societal conventions ... He lived the life others wanted to live.
And yet, he wrote: "What people are ashamed of usually makes a good story."
That is courage. That kind of honesty. So inspiring to me.
In 1922, he wrote in a letter to Maxwell Perkins at Scribners: "I want to write something new -- something extraordinary and simple & intricately patterned."
Such a young man. Such a broad and deep vision.
Around this time, he married Zelda Sayre who hailed from Montgomery, Alabama.

Girls, for instance, have found the accent shifted from chemical purity to breadth of viewpoint, intellectual charm and piquant cleverness ... we find the young woman of 1920 flirting, kissing, viewing life lightly, saying damn without a blush, playing along the danger line in an immature way - a sort of mental baby vamp ... Personally, I prefer this sort of girl. Indeed, I married the heroine of my stories. I would not be interested in any other sort of woman.-- Interview with F. Scott Fitzgerald, in January, 1921
She was the yin to his yang, she was the perfect partner in crime for that particular decade ... she did not give a damn. She was the Clara Bow for the literary set. She was who they were talking about when they talked about "jazz babies". The original flapper.
Look at their wedding portrait. I just love it.

They had their wedding reception at Chumley's, a former speakeasy and literary hangout at 86 Bedford Street, which is still there. It's the same now as it was then: no signage, nothing to say it's there. You have to know where it is. 86 Bedford, baby! 86 those plates, and let's get the hell out of here.
So Fitzgerald and Zelda married. They lived their relationship in public. They created personae, they acted parts, they showed up at places looking amazing, they relished in their own publicity. They kept massive scrapbooks of their clippings from the gossip pages. They were partners in all of this. Partners in self-promotion and self-absorption.
Here's a page from their scrapbook:

Zelda and Scott were like the Billy Bob Thornton and Angelina Jolie of their day. Exhibitionists, putting their own craziness on display, loving and living to shock others, having massive crockery-throwing fights in public, also having clutching make-out sessions in public ... It all was about being famous. But underneath all of that, there was this kindred spirit thing happening. You can't be in love with someone who NEEDS to be famous and not have the same need yourself. Or, you can, but it'll go bust. The two of them were in sync in those first years - it was like they were the same person.
Neither of them was ever the one to say, "Okay. Time for bed now." They were a couple with no brakes.
I've always known that, any girl who gets stewed in public, who frankly enjoys and tells shocking stories, who smokes constantly and makes the remark that she has "kissed thousands of men and intends to kiss thousands more," cannot be considered beyond reproach even if above it ... I fell in love with her courage, her sincerity and her flaming self respect and its these things I'd believe in even if the whole world indulged in wild suspicions that she wasn't all that she should be ... I love her and that's the beginning and the end of everything. You're still a catholic but Zelda's the only God I have left now.-- F. Scott Fitzgerald, in a letter to a friend
They would have drinks at the Plaza Hotel, and she would dance on the table. She would leap into fountains, fully dressed. She bucked convention. Just for the hell of it. She was the life of the party (while it lasted). She was wild. Just wild. F. Scott Fitzgerald was inspired by her, she was definitely a muse of some kind. He would read her diaries, he hoarded the letters she wrote to him, he was completely wrapped up in her glow. Zelda is a fascinating (and ultimately tragic) character in her own right. A girl who was completely unprepared to do anything useful in her life - pampered and indulged by her family who thought she was nuts (and it is probable that much of her "mania" that was so captivating early on was actually an ominous sign of things to come), she basically set her sights on New York. She had the misfortune of marrying a man seen as the bright literary light of his generation - a misfortune because she had literary aspirations as well (uhm, echoes of Courtney Love?). Here is a small sketch she wrote about Montgomery Alabama, where she grew up. It is obvious she can write. Not like her husband, but she can definitely write.
There exists in Montgomery a time and quality that appertains to nowhere else. It began about half past six on an early summer night, with the flicker and sputter of the corner street lights going on, and it lasted until the great incandescent globes were black inside with moths and beetles and the children were called into bed from the dusty streets ... The drug stores are bright at night with the organdie balloons of girls' dresses under the big electric fans. Automobiles stand along the curbs in front of open frame houses at dusk, and sounds of supper being prepared drift through the soft splotches of darkness to the young world that moves every evening out of doors. Telephones ring, and the lacy blackness under the trees disgorges young girls in white and pink, leaping over the squares of warm light toward the tinkling sound with an expectancy that people have only in places where any event is a pleasant one. Nothing seems ever to happen.
There's a nice descriptive romantic quality there. She had talent. Only she had no discipline. None. F. Scott Fitzgerald, while a frenzied party-man, a heavy drinker, a guy who stayed out all night every night, had great discipline. He worked at his craft. He worked hard at writing. He was always writing, and honing, and editing. Maybe he was hungover, but his writing was his JOB. Zelda had none of that. She couldn't focus her energies. She was threatened by his success. She wanted a piece of that pie for herself. She also ended up resenting how he used her and her thoughts and sometimes even her words to become a success.
But ... well, we all know what ended up happening to Zelda. I don't know her diagnosis - but judging from some of her episodes, it had to be pretty bad. This was not a case of clinical depression. It was psychosis. While they lived in Paris, she got it into her head that she needed to be a ballerina. She began to study. She became obsessed. Soon, she was dancing for 6, 7, 8 hours a day. But she was in her early 30s by this point ... way too old to be a prima ballerina. But Zelda didn't care. Apparently, too, she was a terrible dancer. Friends who visited the couple in Paris told stories (in letters, and later, to biographers) of arriving for their visit, and Zelda would greet them at the door in a tutu and ballet shoes. She would dance for them. Awfully. These stories are excruciatingly painful to read. Look at her wedding portrait. Her young wild face, those tiger eyes. It's just sad to think of her end. It really is. It must have been unbearable.
Who knows where the madness came from, or if the wildness of her behavior in her youth (jumping in fountains, etc.) were early warning signs - things people ignored and forgave her for, because she was young and free. Who knows. I read a biography of Zelda Fitzgerald last year and it was heart-wrenching. I actually had a hard time finishing it. She had a deadly fear of fire, always - and how did she die? She died in a fire that broke out in the mental institution - she was on a locked ward, she couldn't get out, and the institution burned to the ground. It must have been shrieking agony. It must have been unspeakable.
But for about 5 or 6 years, the two of them were on top of the world. They had youth in their favor.


The Great Gatsby was published in 1925. Fitzgerald worked his ass off on this book - and was tormented throughout the process. He wrote, and re-wrote, and re-wrote - holding off his editor, Maxwell Perkins, as long as possible. It was a precious book to him, a deeply personal book, and he feared he had not succeeded.
Perkins' long letter back to Fitzgerald, after he finally received the manuscript, gives me chills. I won't print it in its entirety - it's too long - but it's an amazing insight into the book, and also ... into Fitzgerald the Writer. The guy had an innate gift, yes, but he also was this major craftsman.
Here are some excerpts from Perkins' initial letter:
I think you have every kind of right to be proud of this book. It is an extraordinary book, suggestive of all sorts of thoughts and moods. You adopted exactly the right method of telling it, that of employing a narrator who is more of a spectator than an actor: this puts the reader upon a point of observation on a higher level than that on which the characters stand and at a distance that gives perspective. In no other way could your irony have been so immensely effective, nor the reader have been enabled so strongly to feel at times the strangeness of human circumstance in a vast heedless universe. In the eyes of Dr. Eckleburg various readers will see different significances; but their presence gives a superb touch to the whole thing: great unblinking eyes, expressionless, looking down upon the human scene. It's magnificent!I could go on praising the book and speculating on its various elements, and meanings, but points of criticism are more important now. I think you are right in feeling a certain slight sagging in chapters six and seven, and I don't know how to suggest a remedy. I hardly doubt that you will find one and I am only writing to say that I think it does need something to hold up here to the pace set, and ensuing.
He then goes on to list a couple of pages of specific criticisms. Beautiful to read. It's really just amazing literary analysis is what it is.
One of the criticisms is this:
The other point is also about Gatsby: his career must remain mysterious, of course. But in the end you make it pretty clear that his wealth came through his connection with Wolfstein. You also suggest this much earlier. Now almost all readers numerically are going to be puzzled by his having all this wealth and are going to feel entitled to an explanation. To give a distinct and definite one would be, of course, utterly absurd. It did occur to me though, that you might here and there interpolate some phrases, and possibly incidents, little touches of various kinds, that would suggest that he was in some active way mysteriously engaged. You do have him called on the telephone, but couldn't he be seen once or twice consulting at his parties with people of some sort of mysterious significance, from the political, the gambling, the sporting world, or whatever it mayb be. I know I am floundering, but that fact may help you to see what I mean ... I wish you were here so I could talk about it to you for then I know I could at least make you understand what I mean. What Gatsby did ought never to be definitely imparted, even if it could be. Whether he was an innocent tool in the hands of somebody else, or to what degree he was this, ought not to be explained. But if some sort of business activity of his were simply adumbrated, it would lend further probability to that part of the story.
After a couple more paragraphs, Perkins writes:
The general brilliant quality of the book makes me ashamed to make even these criticisms. The amount of meaning you get into a sentence, the dimensions and intensity of the impression you make a paragraph carry, are most extraordinary. The manuscript is full of phrases which make a scene blaze with life. If one enjoyed a rapid railroad journey I would compare the number and vividness of pictures your living words suggest, to the living scenes disclosed in that way. It seems in reading a much shorter book than it is, but it carries the mind through a series of experiences that one would think woudl require a book of three times its length.The presentation of Tom, his place, Daisy and Jordan, and the unfolding of their characters is unequalled so far as I know. The description of the valley of ashes adjacent to the lovely country, the conversation and the action in Myrtle's apartment, the marvelous catalogue of those who come to Gatsby's house -- these are such things as make a man famous. And all these things, the whole pathetic episode, you have given a place in time and space, for with the help of T.J. Eckleburg and by an occasional glance at the sky, or the sea, or the city, you have imparted a sort of sense of eternity. You once told me you were not a natural writer -- my God! You have plainly mastered the craft, of course; but you needed far more than craftsmanship for this.
Now that's the kind of letter you want from your editor.
The Great Gatsby was not the phenom that This Side of Paradise was. Reviews were mixed. Only posterity would put Gatsby in the canon.
Zelda had her first breakdown in 1930. Fitzgerald's drinking problem went to another level. He was devastated by her illness, and he was devastated by what was obviously a slacking off in his success. It's tough when you become a mega-star at 23. Anything that follows is sure to be a letdown. Fitzgerald needed to support himself, so he started cranking out short stories for the big mags at the time ... stuff that paid the bills but left him feeling empty.
F. Scott Fitzgerald died of a heart attack at 44, leaving an unfinished novel The Last Tycoon behind him.
Like I said, last year I re-read The Great Gatsby. It was like running into an old childhood friend. I read it in three days. (It felt much much longer in high school.) I was shocked and moved by how much I had remembered. The huge eyes of Doctor T.J. Eckleberg ... I remember the intense class discussion about what those eyes symbolize. The green light at the end of the dock, obviously. And there were parts that I actually remembered word for word, because of how, exactly, Mr. Crothers (my teacher) taught the book.
I remember the huge discussion about the following part of the book:
Suddenly she threw the cigarette and the burning match on the carpet."Oh, you want too much!" she cried to Gatsby. "I love you now -- isn't that enough? I can't help what's past." She began to sob helplessly. "I did love him once -- but I loved you too."
Gatsby's eyes opened and closed.
"You loved me too?" he repeated.
I remember Mr. Crothers pointing out that section to us, and talking about how that was the snap in Gatsby, that was the dream dying in Gatsby, that was the inner conflict of the entire book encapsulated in two sentences:
Gatsby's eyes opened and closed. "You loved me too?" he repeated.
Fitzgerald does not describe the snap. He does not have to. Fitzgerald does not talk about Gatsby's dream of Daisy, his fantasy of Daisy, at least not in that pivotal moment. All he does, all he does, is tell us that Gatsby's eyes opened and closed. And in that moment, a man's dream dies.
Phenomenal.
I would have missed that, in high school, if Mr. Crothers hadn't dwelt on it so specifically, and it all came back rushing back when I re-read it.
I might say that Mr. Crothers was the best teacher I have ever had. Period. He taught me how to write. Plain and simple. And you know how he taught me? I wrote a paper in his class. I got a D. My first D in my whole life. Panic ensued. Deep depression. Writer's block. I wrote another paper. I got a D+. Next paper: C-. Next paper: I got a straight C. It was a very proud moment. And with every paper, agonizingly, I got better and better and better. Until finally, light broke through, and I was able to construct a damn paper. I wrote consistently A-level papers in college directly because of what Mr. Crothers taught me.
This post is a ramble. Mr. Crothers, if he read this, would be thinking: "Sheila, where's the thesis statement??"
So here it is:
I had forgotten the stature of Fitzgerald's opus. I had forgotten how superb it was. Or: if I remembered it, it was in a taken-for-granted kind of way. Like: "Oh yeah, that's a great book. One of the best books of the 20th century. Whatever." I had forgotten the level of the accomplishment. I had forgotten how moving it is.
Reading it as an adult gave me a whole new perspective on it as well.
When I read it at age 15, I was completely on the side of Nick, the narrator: The relatively innocent and honest bystander, looking on at the decadence of Daisy and Jordan and Gatsby, trying not to judge (like he says on the first page of the book), and trying to come out of the situation unscathed. But by the end of the book, Nick is changed. And so are we, whether we like it or not.
But now, reading it as a grown woman, with a couple of failed love affairs in my rear view mirror, I found myself entering the story through the eyes of Gatsby. I could see myself in parts of him. It KILLED me. I understood Gatsby, suddenly. Carrying a torch for years, infusing everything with significance, poetry, choosing the dream-world over reality.
It is only NOW, after reading it from an adult perspective, that I can truly understand why the book is seen as such an epic human tragedy. An American tragedy.
Now I understand. Now I understand.
Those first pages are so extraordinary, so exquisitely written, they cannot be improved upon.
In my younger and more vulnerable years my father gave me some advice that I've been turning over in my mind ever since."Whenever you feel like criticizing any one," he told me, "just remember that all the people in this world haven't had the advantages that you've had."
He didn't say any more, but we've always been unusually communicative in a reserved way, and I understood that he meant a great deal more than that. In consequence, I'm inclined to reserve all judgments, a habit that has opened up many curious natures to me and also made me the victim of not a few veteran bores. The abnormal mind is quick to detect and attach itself to this quality when it appears in a normal person, and so it came about that in college I was unjustly accused of being a politician, because I was privy to the secret griefs of wild, unknown men. Most of the confidences were unsought -- frequently I have feigned sleep, preoccupation, or a hostile levity when I realized by some unmistakable sign that any intimate revelation was quivering on the horizon; for the intimate revelations of young men, or at least the terms in which they express them, are usually plagiaristic and marred by obvious suppressions. Reserving judgments is a matter of infinite hope. I am still a little afraid of missing something if I forget that, as my father snobbishly suggested, and I snobbishly repeat, a sense of the fundamental decencies is parcelled out unequally at birth.
And after boasting this way of my tolerance, I come to the admission that it has a limit. Conduct may be founded on the hard rock or the wet marshes, but after a certain point I don't care what it's founded on. When I came back from the East last autumn I felt that I wanted the world to be in uniform and at a sort of moral attention forever; I wanted no more riotous excursions with privileged glimpses into the human heart. Only Gatsby, the man who gives his name to this book, was exempt from my reaction -- Gatsby, who represented everything for which I have an unaffected scorn. If personality is an unbroken series of successful gestures, then there was something gorgeous about him, some heightened sensitivity to the promises of life, as if he were related to one of those intricate machines that register earthquakes ten thousand miles away. This responsiveness had nothing to do with that flabby impressionability which is dignified under the name of the "creative temperament" -- it was an extraordinary gift for hope, a romantic readiness such as I have never found in any other person and which it is not likely I shall ever find again. No -- Gatsby turned out all right at the end; it is what preyed on Gatsby, what foul dust floated in the wake of his dreams that temporarily closed out my interest in the abortive sorrows and short-winded elations of men.
Reading that makes me want to put down my pen forever.
So does the last sentence of the book:
So we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past.
And here, in his essay "Early Success", written in 1937, Fitzgerald writes:
The uncertainties of 1919 were over - there seemed little doubt about what was going to happen - America was going on the greatest, gaudiest spree in history and there was going to be plenty to tell about it. The whole golden boom was in the air - its splendid generosities, its outrageous corruptions and the tortuous death struggle of the old America in prohibition. All the stories that came into my head had a touch of disaster in them - the lovely young creatures in my novels went to ruin, the diamond mountains of my short stories blew up, my millionaires were as beautiful and damned as Thomas Hardy's peasants. In life these things hadn't happened yet, but I was pretty sure living wasn't the reckless, careless business these people thought - this generation just younger than me ...The dream had been early realized and the realization carried with it a certain bonus and a certain burden. Premature success gives one an almost mystical conception of destiny as opposed to will power - at its worst the Napoleonic delusion. The man who arrives young believes that he exercises his will because his star is shining. The man who only asserts himself at thirty has a balanced idea of what will power and fat have each contributed, the one who gets there at forty is liable to put the emphasis on will alone. This comes out when the storms strike your craft.
The compensation of a very early success is a conviction that life is a romantic matter. In the best sense one stays young. When the primary objects of love and money could be taken for granted and a shaky eminence had lost its fascination, I had fairy years to waste, years that I can't honestly regret, in seeking the eternal Carnival by the Sea. Once in the middle twenties I was driving along the High Corniche Road through the twilight with the whole French Riviera twinkling on the sea below. As far ahead as I could see was Monte Carlo, and though it was out of season and there were no Grand Dukes left to gamble and E. Phillips Oppenheim was a fat industrious man in my hotel, who lived in a bathrobe - the very name was so incorrigibly enchanting that I could only stop the car and like the Chinese whisper: "Ah me! Ah me!" It was not Monte Carlo I was looking at. It was back into the mind of the young man with cardboard soles who had walked the streets of New York. I was him again - for an instant I had the good fortune to share his dreams, I who had no more dreams of my own. And there are still times when I creep up on him, surprise him on an autumn morning in New York or a spring night in Carolina when it is so quiet that you can hear a dog barking in the next county. But never again during that all too short period when he and I were one person, when the fulfilled future and the wistful past were mingled in a single gorgeous moment - when life was literally a dream.

I post this every year at the beginning of the school year, in honor of all the teachers out there. Many of my friends are teachers, my sister is a teacher ... and it is also in honor of anyone who cares about little kids, their emotional well-being, and teaching them how not to just survive - but flourish - whatever their struggles may be.
I have a friend who grew up in a nightmare, surrounded by poverty, chaos, abuse. He and his siblings clung to one another through it all, and they have emerged intact: healthy beautiful people. But they were brought up in an abusive and reckless nuthouse.
And this post is an ode to a teacher. A teacher who saved my friend's life. When I say this I am quite serious, although she did not drag him from out of a burning house, or leap in to save him from drowning. No. What she did was she recognized the light within him, and she made it her business to protect it, and nurture it. She made it her business to make sure that that bright light survived.
If that's not saving someone's life, then I don't know what is.
My friend is extremely intelligent. His parents did not value this in him. On the contrary, it threatened them. To add to all of this, my friend, from a very young age, knew he was "different" from other boys. Somehow. How many other boys would stay home from school and put hot-rollers into their sister's Cher-doll's hair? How many other boys could recite Meet Me in St. Louis? How many other boys lip-synched to Barbra Streisand albums? He couldn't put a name to what was different because he was just a little boy. But he knew it was there.
The teasing he got, from within his family and at school, was brutal. Teasing of this kind has one goal and one goal only: to crush what is different. The difference in him was like a scent and other kids could smell it. So they set out to destroy it. Which is why he would stay home from school, playing with his sister's Barbies.
The little boy reached the 2nd grade. He had already learned some very hard lessons. He had already experienced cruelty, betrayal, terror. The end of this story could have been a terrible one. All of the cards were stacked against this person.
He might never have gotten out, were it not for his 2nd grade teacher.
I cannot remember her name, but I will hold a place in my heart for her forever. I did not meet this "little boy" until college when we became fast friends, but to my view, this 2nd grade teacher was directly responsible for the fact that this little boy went to college (the first one in his family to do so!), that this little boy broke the pattern of abuse in his family, that this little boy got the hell OUT and said NO to what seemed to be his logical fate.
This 2nd grade teacher read E.B. White's Stuart Little to the class.
And my friend, then 7 years old, had what can only be described as a life-changing experience, listening to that book.
Stuart Little is a mouse, born to human parents. Everyone is confused by him. "Where the heck did HE come from?" My friend, a little boy who was so "different" he might as well have been a mouse born to human parents, a little boy who was, indeed, smaller than everybody else in the class, listened to this book, agog, his soul opened up to it, and it changed his life.
First of all: for the first time, he really got reading. By this I mean the importance, and the excitement, of language. Language can create new and better worlds in your head. Language is a way out. To this day, my friend is a voracious reader. I will never forget living with him while he was reading Magic Mountain. We lived in a one-room apartment, and so if I wanted to go to sleep and turn the lights off, my friend would take a pillow into the bathroom, shut the door, curl up on the bathmat, and read Magic Mountain long into the night.
I believe that this voraciousness is a direct result of that 2nd grade teacher reading Stuart Little to the class. If that had not happened, and if it hadn't been that particular book, my friend might not have gotten OUT, might not have gone to college, might not have been the big reader that he is today. It was that significant.
Stuart Little is "different". Just like my friend was "different". In hearing the words of that story, my friend rose above the pain, the loneliness, the torture, the fear, and realized that there were others out there who were "different" too. And that different was GOOD!
And here was the major revelation: Stuart Little's small-ness ends up being his greatest asset. That which seemed like the biggest strike against him is not at all in the end! My friend, in his 7-year-old epiphany, embraced his size. Small didn't mean "weak". Not at all.
Somewhere, in his child-like soul, he knew he was gay although he did not have a word for it. It wasn't a sexual orientation so much, at that time, but a sensibility. He wasn't like the other kids. He didn't know yet what that would mean for him, in his life, but it certainly isolated him in school. And it isolated him at home. And so, hearing about the adventures of Stuart Little, my friend realized that this life that he was living right now , the narrow circle of poverty and pain, did not have to be his life. He suddenly knew, for the first time in his life, that everything was going to be okay.
As the teacher read the story to the class, my friend had the intense sensation that the teacher was reading it directly to him, and only to him. It was such a strong feeling that he was able to describe it to me, vividly, years and years later. The rest of the class fell away, and it was as though she had singled him out, she was trying to give him a message of some sort, through the words of E.B. White. That book was for him, and for him alone.
By the time high school came around, my friend had learned that wit was the best defense against teasing. His humor, his sarcasm became his armor, but it also became the way he made friends. In a very short time, he acquired what can be only be referred to as bodyguards, high school football players, who thought he was hilarious, and who protected him in the locker room, pushing anyone off who tried to mess with him.
My friend had a close circle of friends, all witty, artistic, interesting people, and these friends pushed him to apply to college, because they all were applying to college. And so he applied to college. He got in. He went to college. He graduated. He graduated college!
Years later, many years after college, he ran into that 2nd grade teacher in a breakfast restaurant in Rhode Island.
She (a teacher to the core) recognized him immediately, even in his adult-ness. She said, "My goodness - it is so wonderful to see you! I have heard so many wonderful things about what you are up to - how are you??"
They talked for a while. He caught her up on his life, she listened and supported him. She still was invested in what had happened to that small special boy she had taught many many years before.
And then, in a burst of open-ness, my friend said to her, kind of blowing it off, laughing at himself, "You know ... this is kind of silly ... but I want to tell you that ... I remember so vividly you reading Stuart Little to the class. It had a huge impact on my life ... and ... I know it's crazy and everything, but at the time, I truly had the feeling that you were reading it just to me."
She looked at him then, smiled, and said, "I was."
The winners of the 2008 Costa Book Awards have been announced and children's book writer Enid Blyton (along with Roald Dahl) has been named the UK's "best-loved author".
I've never done a post on Enid Blyton - and sadly, I no longer have any of her books, although I used to own them all. And that was quite a hefty collection, girl was PROLIFIC. As a child - from about 8 to 10 - I was obsessed - obsessed I tell you - with the "Adventure" series: Island of Adventure, Mountain of Adventure, Valley of Adventure ... wherein 4 children continually got mixed up in international intrigues, involving smugglers, gun runners, counterfeiters, and God knows what else. I'm pretty sure Osama bin Laden was somehow involved. Children were kidnapped and thrown in trunks of cars. They emerged in captivity in an unknown location and had to somehow find their way out. They are ADDICTIVE books - and I was totally obsessed. Like so much else in my childhood, I have my cousin Susan to thank for my Enid Blyton mania. We lived those books. We would play-act them out. Like I've mentioned before, I was quite an Anglophile as a child (not knowing that I was embracing what should be my mortal cultural enemy as an Irish person! Ha!) - I think it began with Oliver Twist and Alice in Wonderland ... but, in general, if it was a book about kids and it took place in the UK, and people used words like "frocks" or "macks" instead of "dresses" and "raincoats", I was hooked. It also helped if it took place between the World Wars. Hence, my adoration of all things Noel Streatfield (excerpt here). Enid Blyton's books have that echo of grimness Vera Drake sensibility ... with rationing still a memory, and people saving their big brown paper bags, and the rain pouring down as everyone put on their macks ... oh, it was all very British. But the scrapes these kids got into! I LOVED them.
Lucy Mangan has written an article about Enid Blyton, in response to her winning the prize, that made me cry. Yes. Yes. She gets it!
She opens with:
I myself can barely bring myself to talk about my Enid Blyton years. Who wants to let daylight in upon magic?
Mangan talks about how the Blyton books don't quite hold up to adult scrutiny ... but I was very interested to hear Blyton's own words about her process, and her extraordinary output:
She describes having her characters always walking and talking in her head, and needing only to look in on their dialogue and actions for her next story. It is, she says, "simply a matter of opening the sluice gates and out it all pours with no effort or labour of my own. This is why I can write so much and so quickly - it's all I can do to keep up with it, even typing at top speed".
And you know what? That's how I read all of her books, too. So quickly it was like I was inhaling them and it was all I could "do to keep up with it".
Blyton has not been voted the "best" English author. That would be a travesty, in my opinion. But "best-loved"?? Oh, hell yes.
At a certain stage of development, you ask for nothing more than a satisfying story and an unbroken contract of delivery from your author. You care not a jot that stumbling across a smuggling ring would be unlikely to end as well in real life. Although I do remember, even at the age of eight, feeling in some vague, inchoate way, that you could go a long time without ever coming across a more unforgivably prosaic, deadening and literal title to a series than The Five Find-Outers and Dog.But this latest nomination is not for best children's writer, it is for best-loved writer, full stop. Blyton's gold medal position in this table, along with the high preponderance of children's writers elsewhere on Costa's list (Roald Dahl took second place and JK Rowling third, while JRR Tolkien and Beatrix Potter made the top 10), is evidence that it is the books we read, wholeheartedly, passionately, uncritically, in childhood to which we remain most firmly and irrevocably attached. The flaws we see in them as adults, the criticisms - and some pretty hefty ones, in the shape of accusations of sexism, racism and class snobbery have been flung Blyton's way over the years - do not weaken those bonds. For hundreds of thousands of us, Blyton was the wedge that cracked open the pleasure-filled world of reading and allowed us in. Our rational adult sides reject and mock Kirrin Island and all the adventures played out there; our inner children remember it rightly, and gratefully, as the promontory from which we caught our first glimpse of the promised land.
Tears.
Oh please go read the whole thing!
One of the things I love best about War and Peace is how action-packed it is ... and yet how, suddenly, seemingly out of nowhere, we get these psychological ZINGERS thrown at us - which have such the ring of truth that I am amazed at the insight. These are things I have also perceived - in myself, and in my fellow man - foibles, vanities, whatever ... but the way Tolstoy just boils it down is one of the most thrilling parts, for me, of his writing style.
Zingers:
Page 10
Ellen was so lovely that she was not merely free from the slightest shade of coquetry, she seemed on the contrary ashamed of the too evident, too violent and all-conquering influence of her beauty. She seemed to wish but to be unable to soften the effect of her beauty.
Page 19
He looked at them all and smiled. His smile was utterly unlike the half-smile of all the others. When he smiled, suddenly, instantaneously, his serious, even rather sullen, face vanished completely, and a quite different face appeared, childish, good-humoured, even rather stupid, that seemed to beg indulgence.
Page 61
Berg talked very precisely, serenely, and politely. All he said was always concerning himself. He always maintained a serene silence when any subject was discussed that had no direct bearing on himself. And he could be silent in that way for several hours at a time, neither experiencing nor causing in others the slightest embarrassment. But as soon as the conversation concerned him personally, he began to talk at length and with visible satisfaction.
Page 167
He was one of those diplomats who like work and understand it, and in spite of his natural indolence, he often spent nights at his writing-table. He worked equally well whatever the object of his work might be. He was interested not in the question "Why?" but in the question "How?"
Page 263
He was about to embrace his friend, but Nikolay drew back from him. With that peculiarly youthful feeling of fearing beaten tracks, of wanting to avoid imitation, to express one's feelings in some new way of one's own, so as to escape the forms often conventionally used by others, Nikolay wanted to do something striking on meeting his friend. He wanted someone to give him a pinch, to give Berg a shove, anything rather than to kiss, as people always did on such occasions.
Page 326
So trivial seemed to him at that moment all the interests that were engrossing Napoleon, so petty seemed to him his hero, with his paltry vanity and glee of victory, in comparison with that lofty, righteous, and kindly sky which he had seen and comprehended, that he could not answer him. And all indeed seemed to him so trifling and unprofitable beside the stern and solemn train of thought aroused in him by weakness from loss of blood, by suffering and the nearness of death. Gazing into Napoleon's eyes, Prince Andrey mused on the nothingness of greatness, on the nothingness of life, of which no one could comprehend the significance, and on the nothingness - still more - of death, the meaning of which could be understood and explained by none of the living.
Page 362
The feeling that Princess Marya was experiencing as she sat in her room had overpowered the whole house and taken possession of every one. Owing to the belief that the fewer people know of the sufferings of a woman in labour, the less she suffers, every one tried to affect to know nothing of it; no one talked about it, but over and above the habitual staidness and respectfulness of good manners that always reigned in the prince's household, there was apparent in all a sort of anxiety, a softening of the heart, and a consciousness of some great, unfathomable mystery being accomplished at that moment.
Page 388
But now in the solitude of his journey they seized upon him with special force. Of whatever he began thinking he came back to the same questions, which he could not answer, and from which he could not escape. It was as though the chief screw in his brain upon which his whole life rested were loose. The screw moved no forwarder, no backwarder, but still it turned, catching on nothing, always in the same groove, and there was no making it cease turning.
Page 460
Rostov had been out of humour from the moment when he detected the dissatisfaction on the face of Boris, and as is always the case with persons who are ill-humoured, it seemed to him that every one looked at him with hostile eyes, and that he was in every one's way.
Page 523
He was a passionate adherent of the new ideas and of Speransky, and the busiest purveyor of news in Petersburg, one of those men who choose their opinions like their clothes - according to the fashion - but for that very reason seem the most vehement partisans.
Page 533
"Yes, that is true, prince. In these days," pursued Vera (talking of "these days", as persons of limited intellect as a rule love to do, supposing they have discovered and estimated the peculiarities of the times and that human characteristics do change with the times, "in these days a girl has so much liberty that the pleasure of being paid attention often stifles these feelings in her."
Oh, oh, oh, how I love that last one. Yes, it validates me in one of my biggest pet peeves, but that's part of Tolstoy's beauty. He throws in zingers - some where we recognize ourselves and wince, some where we recognize others and cheer ... some where perhaps we are not ready to recognize ourselves, and say, "hahaha Yes, isn't it annoying when OTHER people do that??" - not aware (yet) that we may exhibit those characteristics ourselves.
It is a book that requires engagement on that level, and I adore it.
Well, Tennyson came up last night, as we sat talking over wine and cheese, in a conversation we were having about poets we loved. We also discussed politics, morons, reading, acting, the new production of Hair in Central Park, resumes, weddings, our pets, and Angelina Jolie. But Tennyson came up, too. So this morning, when I saw it was his birthday, I just thought it was too much of a coincidence (how often do I have an in-depth conversation about Tennyson? Not enough, I'm thinking) NOT to post a birthday message to the man. There is some of Tennyson I can take, some I can leave - but then, there are lines which reverberate through my whole life - and not just the most famous "red in tooth and claw" lines, but other ones ... taking on deeply personal meanings, phrases I cannot imagine doing without. Guiding posts. Or - not just "guiding posts", but glimpses of a world so beautiful, so vaulted and important, that it is almost blinding to the eye. For example (and this is my favorite of all of Tennyson's words he ever wrote):
THE splendour falls on castle walls
And snowy summits old in story:
The long light shakes across the lakes,
And the wild cataract leaps in glory.
Blow, bugle, blow, set the wild echoes flying,
Blow, bugle; answer, echoes, dying, dying, dying.
O hark, O hear! how thin and clear,
And thinner, clearer, farther going!
O sweet and far from cliff and scar
The horns of Elfland faintly blowing!
Blow, let us hear the purple glens replying:
Blow, bugle; answer, echoes, dying, dying, dying.
O love, they die in yon rich sky,
They faint on hill or field or river:
Our echoes roll from soul to soul,
And grow for ever and for ever.
Blow, bugle, blow, set the wild echoes flying,
And answer, echoes, answer, dying, dying, dying.
That is just NEVER not satisfying to me to read. And I mean "satisfying" in almost a spiritual sense, a sense of rightness and perfection, vibrating through that verse.
So if a poet has one or two of those lines in his long lifetime, well - then I should say he is a success. (Like the last verse of "Ulysses" below.)
Ulysses by Alfred, Lord Tennyson
It little profits that an idle king,
By this still hearth, among these barren crags,
Match'd with an aged wife, I mete and dole
Unequal laws unto a savage race,
That hoard, and sleep, and feed, and know not me.
I cannot rest from travel: I will drink
Life to the lees: all times I have enjoyed
Greatly, have suffered greatly, both with those
That loved me, and alone; on shore, and when
Through scudding drifts the rainy Hyades
Vexed the dim sea: I am become a name;
For always roaming with a hungry heart
Much have I seen and known; cities of men
And manners, climates, councils, governments,
Myself not least, but honoured of them all;
And drunk delight of battle with my peers;
Far on the ringing plains of windy Troy.
I am part of all that I have met;
Yet all experience is an arch wherethrough
Gleams that untravelled world, whose margin fades
For ever and for ever when I move.
How dull it is to pause, to make an end,
To rust unburnished, not to shine in use!
As though to breath were life. Life piled on life
Were all too little, and of one to me
Little remains: but every hour is saved
From that eternal silence, something more,
A bringer of new things; and vile it were
For some three suns to store and hoard myself,
And this grey spirit yearning in desire
To follow knowledge like a sinking star,
Beyond the utmost bound of human thought.
This is my son, mine own Telemachus,
To whom I leave the sceptre and the isle -
Well-loved of me, discerning to fulfil
This labour, by slow prudence to make mild
A rugged people, and through soft degrees
Subdue them to the useful and the good.
Most blameless is he, centred in the sphere
Of common duties, decent not to fail
In offices of tenderness, and pay
Meet adoration to my household gods,
When I am gone. He works his work, I mine.
There lies the port; the vessel puffs her sail:
There gloom the dark broad seas. My mariners,
Souls that have toil'd, and wrought, and thought with me -
That ever with a frolic welcome took
The thunder and the sunshine, and opposed
Free hearts, free foreheads - you and I are old;
Old age hath yet his honour and his toil;
Death closes all: but something ere the end,
Some work of noble note, may yet be done,
Not unbecoming men that strove with Gods.
The lights begin to twinkle from the rocks:
The long day wanes: the slow moon climbs: the deep
Moans round with many voices. Come, my friends,
'Tis not too late to seek a newer world.
Push off, and sitting well in order smite
The sounding furrows; for my purpose holds
To sail beyond the sunset, and the baths
Of all the western stars, until I die.
It may be that the gulfs will wash us down:
It may be we shall touch the Happy Isles,
And see the great Achilles, whom we knew
Tho' much is taken, much abides; and though
We are not now that strength which in old days
Moved earth and heaven; that which we are, we are;
One equal temper of heroic hearts,
Made weak by time and fate, but strong in will
To strive, to seek, to find, and not to yield.

And so, in honor of the man's birthday, and in honor of how weird it was that he was just discussed at length last night in a little wine bar in Manhattan ... here is a compilation of quotes about the man, and from the man.
The bower we shrined to Tennyson
Gentlemen,
Is roof-wrecked; damps there drip upon
Sagged seats, the creeper-nails are rust,
The spider is sole denizen;
Even she who voiced those rhymes is dust,
Gentlemen!
-- Thomas Hardy, "An Ancient to Ancients"
"I cannot think he is a supremely great poet. There is something lacking in him. He is very beautiful -- very graceful. In short, the Perfect Artist. But he seldom lets us forget the artist -- we are never swept away -- Not he -- he flows on serenely. And that is good. But an occasional bit of wild nature would make it better still." -- LM Montgomery in her journal
"On the bald street breaks the blank day." -- Tennyson
"Do you know, a horrible thing has happened to me. I have begun to doubt Tennyson." -- Gerard Manley Hopkins
"Even excluding the plays, it is a vast body of work: poems of feeling and of sentiment, poems of thought and of received opinion. When Browning acquired an audience, he turned garrulous. Tennyson turned sententious. But the Representative Voice does not merely entertain doubts, he actually feels them; his politics, like his religion, are rooted in memory of the past and fear of the future. A liberal, he distrusts progressivism even as he acknowledges the injustices and evils that make it necessary. Tennyson is an intellectual enigma, which is why many take him to be a philosopher speaking for their own indecision and doubt." -- Michael Schmidt
"I wrote as much as seventy lines at one time, and used to go shouting them about the fields after dark." -- Tennyson
"The real truth is that Tennyson, with all his temperament and artistic skill, is deficient in intellectual power; and no modern poet can make very much of his business unless he is pre-eminently strong in this." -- Matthew Arnold in a letter to his mother, 1860
"I detest Tennyson's 'Arthur'! If I'd been Guinevere, I'd have been unfaithful to him too. But not for Lancelot -- he is just as unbearable in another way. As for Geraint, if I'd been Enid, I'd have bitten him. These 'patient Griseldes' of women deserve all they get! I like Tennyson because he gives me nothing but pleasure. I cannot love him because he gives me nothing but pleasure ... I love best the poets who hurt me. But I think I shall have some love for Tennyson after this -- for today I read a verse in 'In Memoriam' which I do not think I can ever have read carefully before -- which scorched me with a sudden flame of self-revelation and brought to me one of those awful moments when we look into the abysses of our own natures and recoil in horror. The verse was:
Do we indeed desire the dead
Should still be near us at our side?
Is there no baseness we would hide,
No inner vileness that we dread?"
-- LM Montgomery, in her journal
"It is not religious because of the quality of its faith, but because of the quality of its doubt." -- TS Eliot on Tennyson's religion
"The churches have killed their Christ." -- Tennyson, "Maud", 1855
"In 1850 Tennyson received public laurels and fulfilled a private desire. He was married after a courtship whose length reflected not reluctance but lack of money. He published In Memoriam. And he became poet laureate, succeeding Wordsworth. The "Ode on Wellington" and "The Charge of the Light Brigade" are masterpieces of laureate art. Few laureates are so transparently sincere, prompt and prosodically competent in the execution of their duties. 'The Charge of the Light Brigade' entered the common memory." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
The Charge Of The Light Brigade
by Alfred, Lord Tennyson
Memorializing Events in the Battle of Balaclava, October 25, 1854
Written 1854
Half a league half a league,
Half a league onward,
All in the valley of Death
Rode the six hundred:
'Forward, the Light Brigade!
Charge for the guns' he said:
Into the valley of Death
Rode the six hundred.
'Forward, the Light Brigade!'
Was there a man dismay'd ?
Not tho' the soldier knew
Some one had blunder'd:
Theirs not to make reply,
Theirs not to reason why,
Theirs but to do & die,
Into the valley of Death
Rode the six hundred.
Cannon to right of them,
Cannon to left of them,
Cannon in front of them
Volley'd & thunder'd;
Storm'd at with shot and shell,
Boldly they rode and well,
Into the jaws of Death,
Into the mouth of Hell
Rode the six hundred.
Flash'd all their sabres bare,
Flash'd as they turn'd in air
Sabring the gunners there,
Charging an army while
All the world wonder'd:
Plunged in the battery-smoke
Right thro' the line they broke;
Cossack & Russian
Reel'd from the sabre-stroke,
Shatter'd & sunder'd.
Then they rode back, but not
Not the six hundred.
Cannon to right of them,
Cannon to left of them,
Cannon behind them
Volley'd and thunder'd;
Storm'd at with shot and shell,
While horse & hero fell,
They that had fought so well
Came thro' the jaws of Death,
Back from the mouth of Hell,
All that was left of them,
Left of six hundred.
When can their glory fade?
O the wild charge they made!
All the world wonder'd.
Honour the charge they made!
Honour the Light Brigade,
Noble six hundred!
"Tennyson spoke to and for his age in In Memoriam. Its success as a long poem depends on its fragmentariness. The sections are elegiac idylls, assembled into a sequence. Like Maud, the sequence hangs together thanks to what Eliot called 'the greatest lyrical resourcefulness that a poet has ever shown.' Elegies and poems of aftermath were Tennyson's forte. He was a gray beard from the beginning." - Michael Schmidt
It was only when I lay there on rotting prison straw that I sensed within myself the first stirrings of good. Gradually it was disclosed to me that the line separating good and evil passes not through states, nor between classes, nor between political parties either, but right through every human heart, and through all human hearts.-- Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, Gulag Archipelago
![]()
NY Times obit here. Here's the obit in The Irish Times. Here is the text of the famous speech he gave at Harvard in 1978 (a choice quote: "But should someone ask me whether I would indicate the West such as it is today as a model to my country, frankly I would have to answer negatively. No, I could not recommend your society in its present state as an ideal for the transformation of ours. Through intense suffering our country has now achieved a spiritual development of such intensity that the Western system in its present state of spiritual exhaustion does not look attractive. Even those characteristics of your life which I have just mentioned are extremely saddening."
Let's not simplify the man, or make him less complex. He was a posterboy for no one. Infuriating, independent, beat of his own drummer, fearless. God.
Here's a lengthy article in Time.
And I've been waiting for the inevitable: Christopher Hitchens' piece, which opens with:
Every now and then it happens. The state or the system encounters an individual who, bafflingly, maddeningly, absurdly, cannot be broken. Should they manage to survive, such heroes have a good chance of outliving the state or the system that so grossly underestimated them. Examples are rather precious and relatively few, and they include Nelson Mandela refusing an offer to be released from jail (unless and until all other political detainees were also freed) and Alexander Solzhenitsyn having to be deported from his country of birth against his will, even though he had become—and had been before—a prisoner there.
More:
But it seems that Solzhenitsyn did have a worry or a dread, not that he himself would be harmed but that none of his work would ever see print. Nonetheless—and this is the point to which I call your attention—he kept on writing. The Communist Party's goons could have torn it up or confiscated or burned it—as they did sometimes—but he continued putting it down on paper and keeping a bottom drawer filled for posterity. This is a kind of fortitude for which we do not have any facile name. The simplest way of phrasing it is to say that Solzhenitsyn lived "as if." Barely deigning to notice the sniggering, pick-nose bullies who followed him and harassed him, he carried on "as if" he were a free citizen, "as if" he had the right to study his own country's history, "as if" there were such a thing as human dignity.
The Vaclav Havel rule of living in a totalitarian society. Just live "as if" you were free.
I just happened to be up now - late for me - when the news came in. I have no words. A truly great man. (I've been adding links to this post since I heard the news at around 1 am this morning).
Here's an excerpt from his Gulag Archipelago, one of the most important books of the 20th century.
Shaking my head. Strange. How it feels like a personal loss.
The world was a better place, a more honorable place, a place where bravery was possible, and where truth was always louder than lies ... because he was in it.
He won the Nobel Prize in 1970, and did not attend the ceremony for fear that the Russians would retaliate by depriving him of his Russian citizenship. As much as he despised the totalitarian regime in Russia, he didn't want to be cut off to that degree. He had family in Russia, a wife, a child on the way. So he did not attend the ceremony. Instead he sent a speech that was read at the banquet. Here is the full text. He closes with:
And I would like to express my heartfelt gratitude to the members of the Swedish Academy for the enormous support their choice in 1970 has given my works as a writer. I venture to thank them on behalf of that vast unofficial Russia which is prohibited from expressing itself aloud, which is persecuted both for writing books and even for reading them. The Academy have heard for this decision of theirs many reproaches implying that such a prize has served political interests. But these are the shouts of raucous loudmouths who know of no other interests. We all know that an artist's work cannot be contained within the wretched dimension of politics. For this dimension cannot hold the whole of our life and we must not restrain our social consciousness within its bounds.

Photo of Solzhenitsyn in 1946 in the gulag.
Rest in peace. No more words.

Herman Melville was born on this day in 1819. Moby-Dick is one of my all-time favorite books (my essays and excerpts are linked at the bottom of this post) - so I figured I wouldn't just re-hash that old territory - but compile here 5,000,000 quotes about Melville. They come from everywhere - from reviews of Moby Dick when it first came out (baffled, for the most part) - to John Huston's comment on it, when directing the film (it's a John Huston kind of day) - to Hart Crane's stunning poem about Melville's "tomb". Oh, and I included a link to a correspondence I had with a certain gentleman I was in love with, where we covered "The Whiteness of the Whale" in our emails. Whatever. It's a mish-mash.
Enjoy!
The Maldive Shark by Herman Melville
About the Shark, phlegmatical one,
Pale sot of the Maldive sea,
The sleek little pilot-fish, azure and slim,
How alert in attendance be.
From his saw-pit of mouth, from his charnel of maw,
They have nothing of harm to dread,
But liquidly glide on his ghastly flank
Or before his Gorgonian head;
Or lurk in the port of serrated teeth
In white triple tiers of glittering gates,
And there find a haven when peril's abroad,
An asylum in jaws of the Fates!
They are friends; and friendly they guide him to prey,
Yet never partake of the treat--
Eyes and brains to the dotard lethargic and dull,
Pale ravener of horrible meat.
Art by Herman Melville
In placid hours well-pleased we dream
Of many a brave unbodied scheme.
But form to lend, pulsed life create,
What unlike things must meet and mate:
A flame to melt--a wind to freeze;
Sad patience--joyous energies;
Humility--yet pride and scorn;
Instinct and study; love and hate;
Audacity--reverence. These must mate,
And fuse with Jacob's mystic heart,
To wrestle with the angel--Art.
"Moby Dick proved hard and exhausting to write. But he knew it was original and he understood that it was good. Published in 1851, it was not a success; until the first quarter of the twentieth century it was neglected. Ambitious later books were rejected. The failure of Moby Dick helped turn his primary attention to verse. Battle-Pieces (1866) was welcomed as peripheral work by a man who had once been famous for his prose. Seriously disturbed in his mind, he made a trip to the Holy Land (meeting with [Nathaniel] Hawthorne in Southport en route), and out of this visit emerged his most ambitious if not his most accomplished poem, the 18,000-line Clarel, twice as long as Paradise Lost, and in the octo-syllabic couplets of Gower's Confessio Amantis. Eventually, Melville - after working as a minor customs officer in New York - was reduced to dependence on his wife's money: she gave him an allowance to buy books and to print his later works in small editions for the tiny readership he retained. He died in 1891, quite forgotten, with the manuscript of the prose work Billy Budd completed but unpublished. His reputation was at such a low ebb that even this masterpiece went unpublished until 1924." -- Michael Schmidt, The Lives of the Poets
"The paucity of primary sources derives in large part from the downward trajectory of Melville's career. When Typee came out in 1846, he was only 27 years old. A best seller in its day, the book 'made him as famous as he would ever be when he was alive,' says Samuel Otter, an associate professor of English at the University of California at Berkeley and the author of Melville's Anatomies (University of California Press, 1999).
"The name died before the man," Mr. Olsen-Smith says. "Compare Melville to Mark Twain, for instance - a man who remained beloved throughout his life and after, up to the present. People saved every scrap. ... It's a different story with Melville.' " -- Jennifer Howard, "Chronicle"
At Melville's Tomb
by Hart Crane
Often beneath the wave, wide from this ledge
The dice of drowned men's bones he saw bequeath
An embassy. Their numbers as he watched,
Beat on the dusty shore and were obscured.
And wrecks passed without sound of bells,
The calyx of death's bounty giving back
A scattered chapter, livid hieroglyph,
The portent wound in corridors of shells.
Then in the circuit calm of one vast coil,
Its lashings charmed and malice reconciled,
Frosted eyes there were that lifted altars;
And silent answers crept across the stars.
Compass, quadrant and sextant contrive
No farther tides . . . High in the azure steeps
Monody shall not wake the mariner.
This fabulous shadow only the sea keeps.

"Give me Vesuvius' crater for an inkstand!" -- Melville apparently shouted this, as he sat at his desk writing "Moby Dick"
"...a cosmos (a chaos) not only perceptibly malignant as the Gnostics had intuited, but also irrational, like the cosmos in the hexameters of Lucretius." -- Jorge Luis Borges on the "cosmos" of "Moby Dick"
"In general, it is the non-psychological novel that offers the richest opportunities for psychological elucidation. Here the author, having no intentions of this sort, does not show his characters in a psychological light and thus leaves room for analysis and interpretation, or even invites it by his unprejudiced mode of presentation... I would also include Melville's Moby Dick, which I consider the be the greatest American novel, in this broad class of writings." -- Carl Jung inThe Spirit in Man, Art, & Literature
"Moby Dick was the most difficult picture I ever made. I lost so many battles during it that I even began to suspect that my assistant director was plotting against me. Then I realized that it was only God. God had a perfectly good reason. Ahab saw the White Whale as a mask worn by the Deity, and he saw the Deity as a malignant force. It was God's pleasure to torment and torture man. Ahab didn't deny God, he simply looked on him as a murderer - a thought that is utterly blasphemous: "Is Ahab Ahab? Is it I, God, or who, that lifts this arm?...Where do murderers go?... Who's to doom, when the judge himself is dragged to the bar?"' -- John Huston, An Open Book, 1980
"We have little more to say in reprobation or in recommendation of this absurd book.... Mr. Melville has to thank himself only if his horrors and his heroics are flung aside by the general reader, as so much trash belonging to the worst school of Bedlam literature -- since he seems not so much unable to learn as disdainful of learning the craft of an artist. --Henry F. Chorley, in London Athenaeum, October 25 1851, review of "Moby Dick"
Correspondence about love and "The Whiteness of the Whale"
Letter of Herman Melville to Nathaniel Hawthorne:
June 29 1851
My dear Hawthorne ,
The clear air and open window invite me to write to you. For some time past I have been so busy with a thousand things that I have almost forgotten when I wrote you last, and whether I received an answer. This most persuasive season has now for weeks recalled me from certain crotchetty and over doleful chimearas, the like of which men like you and me and some others, forming a chain of God's posts round the world, must be content to encounter now and then, and fight them the best way we can. But come they will, -- for, in the boundless, trackless, but still glorious wild wilderness through which these outposts run, the Indians do sorely abound, as well as the insignificant but still stinging mosquitoes. Since you have been here, I have been building some shanties of houses (connected with the old one) and likewise some shanties of chapters and essays. I have been plowing and sowing and raising and painting and printing and praying, -- and now begin to come out upon a less bustling time, and to enjoy the calm prospect of things from a fair piazza at the north of the old farm house here.
Not entirely yet, though, am I without something to be urgent with. The "Whale" is only half through the press; for, wearied with the long delay of the printers, and disgusted with the heat and dust of the babylonish brick-kiln of New York, I came back to the country to feel the grass -- and end the book reclining on it, if I may. -- I am sure you will pardon this speaking all about myself, for if I say so much on that head, be sure all the rest of the world are thinking about themselves ten times as much. Let us speak, although we show all our faults and weaknesses, -- for it is a sign of strength to be weak, to know it, and out with it, -- not in [a] set way and ostentatiously, though, but incidentally and without premeditation. -- But I am falling into my old foible -- preaching. I am busy, but shall not be very long. Come and spend a day here, if you can and want to; if not, stay in Lenox, and God give you long life. When I am quite free of my present engagements, I am going to treat myself to a ride and a visit to you. Have ready a bottle of brandy, because I always feel like drinking that heroic drink when we talk ontological heroics together. This is rather a crazy letter in some respects, I apprehend. If so, ascribe it to the intoxicating effects of the latter end of June operating upon a very susceptible and peradventure feeble temperament.
Shall I send you a fin of the Whale by way of a specimen mouthful? The tail is not yet cooked -- though the hell-fire in which the whole book is broiled might not unreasonably have cooked it all ere this. This is the book's motto (the secret one), -- Ego non baptiso te in nomine -- but make out the rest yourself.
H.M
"I am like one of those seeds taken out of the Egyptian pyramids, which, after being three thousand years a seed, and nothing but a seed, being planted in English soil it developed itself, grew to greenness, and then fell to mould." -- Herman Melville
"Some critics would place his name among the most important American poets of the nineteenth century, or even today." -- Robert Penn Warren
"Melville's poems, less sumptuous in semantic nuance than the prose, less second nature to him than his fiction, are worked at and worked up, yet the difficulty of the restraining forms remains central. So does the rumor of an 'unspeakable' theme, unacknowledged at times, at times veiled from himself, which has to do with a radiant sexual irresolution. More insistently even than Conrad, Melville depicts a male world in prose and verse, a world in which intimate relationships and erotic experiences are between men and types of men: at sea, in the army and elsewhere. He celebrates, laments, touches - and he occasionally foresees, not the huge and benign vision of Walt Whitman, but with narrowed eyes, looking further than the future. His is not the optimism of Emerson but something more serious: he sees beyond a bad age, he sees to the other side of evil; nature consoles, but it also remembers and comments." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"Mr. Herman Melville has earned a deservedly high reputation for his performances in descriptive fiction. He has gathered his own materials, and travelled along fresh and untrodden literary paths, exhibiting powers of no common order, and great originality. The more careful, therefore, should he be to maintain the fame he so rapidly acquired, and not waste his strength on such purposeless and unequal doings as these rambling volumes about spermaceti whales." -- London Literary Gazette, December 6 1851
"I could readily see in Emerson ... the insinuation that had he lived in those days when the world was made, he might have offered some valuable suggestions." -- Herman Melville
"Melville, as he always does, began to reason of Providence and futurity, and everything that lies beyond human ken, and informed me that he had 'pretty much made up his mind to be annihilated'; but still he does not seem to rest in that anticipation.... He can neither believe, nor be comfortable in his unbelief; and he is too honest and courageous not to try to do one or the other." -- Nathaniel Hawthorne, on a walk on the beach with Melville, 1857
"Mardi is a rich book, with depths here and there that compel a man to swim for his life. It is so good that one scarcely pardons the writer for not having brooded over it, so as to make it a great deal better." -- Nathaniel Hawthorne, in a letter to Evert Duyckinck
Various images of Moby Dick ...
"Readers will note that I have said nothing very much about Moby-Dick . But what can anyone say? Its quietly portentous first sentence is as famous as any in world literature ('Call me Ishmael'), and some of Ahab's monologues, like the one beginning 'Is Ahab Ahab?,' achieve an eloquence rivaling that of the Bible and Shakespeare. There are longueurs, but even in the midst of tedious cetological lore, one comes across such disturbing passages as that in which the Pequod's sailors squeeze and squeeze and squeeze handfuls of white spermacetti. Then there are the marvelous portraits of the crew -- the black cabin boy Pip, who goes mad and loses his sense of self, the well-meaning but weak Starbuck, the mysterious harpooners Queequeg, Tashtego, Daggoo. There are the haunting encounters with other ships, especially the Rachel 'searching for her lost children.' And throughout there is philosophizing that at times rises to a kind of prose poetry:
'All men live enveloped in whale-lines. All are born with halters round their necks; but it is only when caught in the swift, sudden turn of death, that mortals realize the silent, subtle, ever-present perils of life. And if you be a philosopher, though seated in a whale-boat, you would not at heart feel one whit more terror, than though seated before your evening fire with a poker, and not a harpoon, by your side.'
In Melville's lifetime few recognized or even suspected the writer's exceptional genius -- but Nathaniel Hawthorne came close, and the two men established a long-lasting friendship. After their first encounters, the writer of Polynesian adventures went back to his romantic tale about 'Whale Fishery' and, in Delbanco's words, 'tore it up from within.' Melville deepened and amplified his novel, enlarged it in every sense, with the obvious hope of joining what he called, in an essay on Hawthorne, that fraternity where 'genius, all over the world, stands hand in hand, and one shock of recognition runs the whole circle round.' With wonderful appropriateness, then, the author of The Scarlet Letter -- which appeared in 1850 -- became the dedicatee of the following year's Moby-Dick . -- Michael Dirda, 2005
"It will be a strange sort of book, tho,' I fear; blubber is blubber you know ... and to cook the thing up, one must needs throw in a little fancy, which from the nature of the things, must be ungainly as the gambols of the whales themselves." -- Melville on "Moby Dick" - in a letter to Richard Henry, Jr.
"A sense of unspeakable security is in me at this moment, on account of your having understood the book. I have written a wicked book, and feel spotless as the lamb." -- Melville to Nathaniel Hawthorne - after Hawthorne read Moby Dick
"...fresh from his mountain charged to the muzzle with sailor metaphysics and jargon of things unknowable," -- Evert Duyckinck in his journal, describing a meeting with Melville, 1856
-- "[He is] a little paler, and perhaps a little sadder.... and no doubt has suffered from too constant literary occupation, pursued without much success, latterly; and his writings, for a long while past, have indicated a morbid state of mind." --Nathaniel Hawthorne, on seeing Melville in 1857
"It is--or seems to be--a wise sort of thing, to realise that all that happens to a man in this life is only by way of a joke.... And it is also worth bearing in mind, that the joke is passed around pretty liberally and impartially, so that not very many are entitled to fancy that they in particular are getting the worst of it." -- Melville to Henry Savage
"Moby Dick is an easy book, as long as we read it as a yarn or an account of whaling interspersed with snatches of poetry. But as soon as we catch the song in it, it grows difficult and immensely important. Narrowed and hardened into words the spiritual theme of Moby Dick is as follows: a battle against evil conducted too long or in the wrong way. The White Whale is evil, and Captain Ahab is warped by constant pursuit until his knight-errantry turns into revenge. These are words -- a symbol for the book if we want one -- but they do not carry us much further than the acceptance of the book as a yarn -- perhaps they carry us backwards, for they may mislead us into harmonizing the incidents, and so losing their roughness and richness. The idea of a contest we may retain: all action is a battle, the only happiness is peace. But contest between what? We get false if we say that it is between good and evil or between two unreconciled evils. The essential in Moby Dick, its prophetic song, flows athwart the action and the surface morality like an undercurrent. It lies outside words...we cannot catch the words of the song. There has been stress, with intervals: but no explicable solution, certainly no reaching back into universal pity and love; no 'Gentlemen, I've had a good dream.'
The extraordinary nature of the book appears in two of its early incidents -- the sermon about Jonah and the friendship with Queequeg.
The sermon has nothing to do with Christianity. It asks for endurance or loyalty without hope of reward. The preacher 'kneeling in the pulpit's bows, folded his large brown hands across his chest, uplifted his closed eyes, and offered a prayer so deeply devout that he seemed kneeling and praying at the bottom of the sea.' Then he works up and up and concludes on a note of joy that is far more terrifying than a menace...
Immediately after the sermon, Ishmael makes a passionate alliance with the cannibal Queequeg, and it looks for a moment that the book is to be a saga of blood-brotherhood. But human relationships mean little to Melville, and after a grotesque and violent entry, Queequeg is almost forgotten. Almost -- not quite...
Moby Dick is full of meanings: its meaning is a different problem. It is wrong to turn the Delight or the coffin into symbols, because even if the symbolism is correct, it silences the book. Nothing can be stated about Moby Dick except that it is a contest. The rest is song." -- E.M. Forster, from one of his lectures on the novel. He said that "prophetic" literature was one of the "forms" of the novel, and that only 4 writers came close to being prophetic: Dostoevsky, DH Lawrence, Emily Bronte, and Herman Melville. I also have to say I cannot agree strongly enough with his comment: "The rest is song." YES.
Amazing interview with John Banville in The Washington Post.
Banville fans know him well (he has passionate fans), and know that he also has been having a sort of catharsis - writing crime-noir books under the name Benjamin Black. Meanwhile, in his John Banville serious Irish literary persona, he won the Booker prize for The Sea in 2005. Since then, he has been writing noir thrillers under the name Benjamin Black and seems to be having a ball. FASCINATING. I am loving his journey - and all the interviews with him are very illuminating (he meditates for sometimes years over his "Banville books" - choosing every word, carefully ... he writes his Benjamin Black books in sometimes a couple of months). He's found it freeing.
I can't WAIT to read the two new Benjamin Black books. I loved Christine Falls so much. I read it in one day, trapped at O'Hare, and despite the annoyance of my situation, I found that the world dissolved away for me ... I was in 1950s Dublin - so so good. I loved how in the WP article, it is observed that while John Banville digs into the depths of experience with an acute sensitivity rare in writers (it's why his books can be so sad) - the Benjamin Black books are not without lyrical prose. As a matter of fact, I found Christine Falls to be almost cinematic in nature. The prose was not fancy, but it was full of sensation and sense-memory ... smells, tastes, the way the light looks on a watery Sunday morning when everyone in the city is in church except for Quirke ... Brilliant stuff. I LOVED the writing in Christine Falls. I am also thrilled to read the new "John Banville" book (not out yet) ... to see what influence Benjamin Black may have had on his prose as Banville. He hates his Banville books now. Hahaha Benjamin Black has set John Banville free.
But the best thing about being a reader and a fan of his writing is that I don't have to choose. He is free to have a preference. But I get to eat it ALL up and that makes me happy.
It's rare that a writer comes along who actually excites. It all began with my dad's regard for Banville - Banville has always been on my radar because of his continuous presence on the bookshelves of my parents' house, and basically ... once you start paying attention, you will see that the name "John Banville" is everywhere. It was that way with my journey, too.
Here are a couple of my favorite excerpts from Wash Post article:
"You know, artists don't really have all that much experience of life. We make a huge amount out of the small experience that we do have."
I guess I just found that so ... encouraging. I've been having a lot of problems lately. I won't go into it. My life has been upended, and there are areas in my life where I have become paralyzed. To know that I can "make a huge amount out of the small experience" that I do have ... It just helped me to stay strong and know that I was (am) doing the right thing.
(Oh, and I LOVED his story about getting Dubliners as a present when he was 12 - and being blown away by the whole thing - and immediatley starting to write stories in imitation of Joyce. A 12 year old imitating Joyce - and one of the opening sentences of these bad stories Banville actually remembers - and it's hilarious!)
And here he is talking about The Sea, his most successful novel to date - the one that won the Booker:
"It seems to me to be packed with plot," Banville says. "I don't know what they want in the way of plot. I really don't."
I'm with him on that one. What on earth do these people THINK is plot? Car crashes? Torrid love affairs? Political intrigue? To say that The Sea has "no plot" is to completely misunderstand what the damn word "plot" means.
Then, here he is on his "Benjamin Black persona" and how much he loves "being" Benjamin Black ... I don't know, this quote makes me laugh. It strikes me as particularly Irish, it's something I completely get:
"This, of course, is worrying. To enjoy writing is deeply worrying. I must be doing something wrong."
Keep on doing that wrong thing, Mr. Banville/Black. I'll follow you whereever.
Some of my posts on John Banville:
Excerpt from The Sea, by John Banville
John Banville:
Benjamin Black:

William Butler Yeats

Maud Gonne
Fantastic article about the new Yeats exhibit going on at the National Library in Dublin - which will (pretty please) eventually come to the States, if a library/museum steps up to the plate to host it. (That's one of the best things, I have to say, about living where I do - even though it's the stinky sticky sweaty summer and there is much to bitch about, I know that IF the Yeats exhibit makes it to the US, there's a good chance that it will be in New York.)
But anyway, back to the exhibit - which sounds incredible. Yeats' lifelong infatuation with Maud Gonne is well known, one of the most famous romances in history - even though they were never married. He proposed to her, oh, probably 387 times over their lives together. She married someone else. She had a daughter. When the daughter was of age, Yeats asked permission to marry the daughter! Like: if I can't have the mother, at least I can have her offspring! But that ended up never happening - and Yeats did eventually marry (when he was in his 50s) - NOT Maud Gonne ... but you know, a passion like that doesn't just go away. Maud Gonne was not a huffy standoffish person ... she had her reasons for repeatedly refusing him, but they were kindred spirits, obviously - perhaps not meant to be married, but obviously spiritually connected in some way. She was one of his greatest inspirations. Well, Gonne - and Ireland itself. Anyway, I grew up hearing stories about Maud Gonne - my father's bookshelves are lined with books about Yeats and the forming of the Abbey Theatre and his poems and plays and letters ... The exhibit puts on display some of the Gonne-Yeats letters (and there's also a touch-screen digital display which sounds fantastic ... not quite as wonderful as seeing the object itself - but still - pretty cool) ... and I am really dying to have a look at some of it. Gonne and Yeats felt they were "synchronized" through time and space - having the same dreams or visions on the same day, despite being in separate countries, whatever ... They were truly interested in exploring their connection on that level - writing feverishly to each other, "I had a dream last night ... Tell me if you dreamt it too." Maud Gonne was not just a cypher - someone we only know through Yeats' interpretation/obsession with her. She is not Shakespeare's Dark Lady, a mysterious being that we can project our own longings and hopes onto. She was a fiery memorable being in her own right, a feminist, Home Rule activist, actress, intellectual, nationalist - with a mystical streak (of course. She was Irish after all) - and in a funny way (although it might have been quite tragic for Yeats) - the literary world should probably thank her for NOT accepting Yeats' 592 proposals. Perhaps a happy and satisfied Yeats would not have had such a writing impulse, such a need to get it out. Who knows. Yeats was obviously a genius, his later poems show that - but we all have to follow a star, we all have unresolved things in us that cannot be reconciled. Yeats never gave up on Gonne, and accepted another kind of marriage - more worldly and earthbound - in place of the spiritual connection he felt with her. But their connection lasted always, to his death. It's nice to see the two of them together again, reunited in the glass cases of the National Library in Dublin.
From the article in the Times:
Until nearly the end of his days he and Gonne kept an eye on each other. In 1938 he wrote “A Bronze Head� about her frequent appearances at political funerals, a “dark tomb-haunter,� so transformed from the light, gentle woman of his memory.Almost from the beginning she had been a figure of memory. In the opening pages of the 1908 notebook he looked backward: “She said something that blotted away the recent past & brought all back to the spiritual marriage of 1898. She believed that this bond is to be recreated & to be the means of spiritual illumination between us. It is to be a bond of the spirit only.�
Here's a link to the exhibit itself.
Here's a post I wrote about Yeats. Maud Gonne comes up. Of course she does. How could she not?

Clifford Odets (playwright in the 30s and 40s - inspiration to Arthur Miller, Tennessee Williams, a generation of playwrights - and he inspires still although some of his plays have dated badly) kept a journal throughout his tumultuous life.
One year of that journal has been published - 1940 - and the title of the book is "The time is ripe: The 1940 journal of Clifford Odets". It's a classic. Practically required reading for those of us in the theatre, but chock-full of stuff that would be interesting and illuminating to anyone. Marvelous first-person document.
A couple biographical notes:
Clifford Odets was catapulted into fame in the early 30s with his play Waiting for Lefty. He became a resident playwright with the influential Group Theatre - and they put on many of his plays - which are now considered classics: Awake and Sing, Paradise Lost, Golden Boy - just to name a few. He was the voice of the Great Depression, of the angry radical, the Jewish New Yorker, the downtrodden, the hopeful. Odets was a Zeitgeist kind of guy. It's one of the reasons why he found his later career so strenuous and difficult ... when you tap into a Zeitgeist of a certain time and place (and not just tap into it - but give voice to it) it can be nigh on impossible to translate that into another time/place. I love all of Odets' plays - not just his famous 1930s plays - I love Big Knife, I love Country Girl, I love The Flowering Peach ... but his time, his PLACE, was the mid-1930s. And that's IT. Without context, Odets' work does not translate. HIs writing does ... and he is imitated to this day. Sylvester Stallone counts Odets as an influence in writing Rocky (and you can totally hear it - the street poetry, the rough edges) ... Tony Kushner ... everyone. Odets was the start of that kind of playwriting in this country.

His work is very much of a time and place - although the writing is good enough for ALL times. But his plays all have "the Great Depression" as an extra character. Without understanding that context, his plays may seem ... trite, or small, or naive. His theme is how the individual man can maintain his dignity, his human worth, in the middle of a capitalist society. He has written lines like, "Is life written on dollar bills?" WORTH has nothing to do with money ... but when you have no money, it sure as shit is difficult to remember that. His plays in the 30s insist upon human dignity, but also (like in Golden Boy) insist on the fact that there is compromise, and tragedy. This is where he can seem, to modern eyes, a bit naive - but it is essential to place him in his context.
But what remains (for me anyway) is not so much the thematic elements, the snapshot of urban life in the 30s - but the language. Odets' language!! It's raw, it's poetic, and it's not realistic. It's street poetry.
We got the blues, Babe -- the 1935 blues. I'm talkin' this way 'cause I love you. If I didn't, I wouldn't care ...
Or
You won't forget me to your dyin' day -- I was the first guy. Part of your insides. You won't forget. I wrote my name on you -- indelible ink!
Or this, from the same scene = I love this line:
So I made a mistake. For Chris' sake, don't act like the Queen of Romania!
Or
Yes, yes, the whole thing funnels up in me like a fever. My head'll bust a vein!
Or
A sleeping clam at the bottom of the ocean, but I'll wake you up. I'm through with the little wars: no more hacking, making a pound in a good day. Like old man Pike says, every man for himself nowadays, and when you're in a jungle you look out for the wild life. I put on my Chinese good luck ring and I'm out to get mine. You're the first stop!

And then this famous exchange from Golden Boy, immortalized in millions of acting classes across the country:
JOE. What did he ever do for you?LORNA. [with sudden verve] Would you like to know? He loved me in a world of enemies, of stags and bulls! ... And I loved him for that. He picked me up in Friskin's hotel on 39th Street. I was nine weeks behind in rent. I hadn't hit the gutter yet, but I was near. He washed my face and combed my hair. He stiffened the space between my shoulder blades. Misery reached out to misery --
JOE. And now you're dead.
LORNA. [lashing out] I don't know what the hell you're talking about!
JOE. Yes, you do ...
Excerpts from his plays:
The Flowering Peach
The Country Girl
The Big Knife
Rocket To the Moon
Golden Boy
Paradise Lost
Till The Day I Die
Awake and Sing
Waiting For Lefty
Harold Clurman wrote about Odets:
Odets wrote some of the finest love scenes to be found in American drama. An all-enveloping warmth, love in its broadest sense, is a constant in all Odets' writing, the very root of his talent. IT is there in tumultuous harangues, in his denunciations and his murmurs. It is by turns hot and tender. Sometimes it sounds in whimpers. It is present as much in the scenes between grandfather and granson in Awake as in those of Joe and Lorna in Golden Boy. It is touchingly wry in Rocket. This explains why these scenes are chosen by so many actors for auditions and classwork.
The Group Theatre lasted almost a decade - from 1931 to 1940.

Odets' first play was Waiting for Lefty. He had been ignored by Strasberg (the leader of the Group) when he kept saying he had plays he wanted to be put on. He just wasn't seen as serious. As the left-wing political world heated up in the early 1930s, Odets became involved in various Communist organizations - and found that his talents were actually wanted in that world. The Group Theatre actors were also looking for ways to become involved - and Odets wrote this play called Waiting for Lefty - which was going to be performed at the Civic Repertory Theatre, one-night-only - as part of a larger programme - It was a benefit for New Theatre magazine. The play was rehearsed on its own, Strasberg had nothing to do with it ... but all the Group actors were involved. Kazan, Ruth Nelson, Carnovsky, Phoebe Brand, John Garfield (known as "Julie" then) ...
Waiting for Lefty was performed for the first time at the benefit on January 6, 1935. It is a night that has gone down in American theatrical history. One of our most important events. In it, the "new theatre" was, indeed, born. Yes, many others at the time were also pushing the boundaries and breaking down the oh-so-polite and witty and high-class themes to be seen on Broadway. Orson Welles and his Mercury Theatre - the "voodoo Macbeth" - there were theatrical EVENTS in those days ... when an audience, struggling with the Depression, with hard times, were looking for something else ... were looking for a change of tone from the Philip Barry Noel Coward material so popular at that time. Nothing against those masters of their craft ... but in 1935, their time was done. It had grown stale. There was a Depression going on ... where was that being expressed in the theatre? Waiting for Lefty occurred like a lightning bolt from another planet - the planet of Truth.
January 6, 1935 is a crucial day in our cultural history in this country. Almost up there with the opening of Glass Menagerie on an ice-drenched night in Chicago a little over a decade later.
Wendy Smith, in her comprehensive book on The Group, writes about what happened at that benefit (oh, and a word of warning to the usual suspects: If anyone swoops in and tries to inform me what idiots these people were because of the eventual terror of Stalin and their own ignorance about what Communism is, I'll delete. I am not posting this to say I agree with Communism - anyone who reads me and who has been reading me should very well know my thoughts on that score. I am posting it because it is a great night of the theatre, one for the books in terms of social and cultural significance - and if you are unable to talk on that level here, well. You know where you can go. Thanks.)
NOW. Onto that historic night in 1935:
Lefty was one of several works scheduled as part of an evening organized by the League of Workers Theatres to aid New Theatre. The benefit staff assigned it no particular importance: the mimeographed one-sheet program simply said, "Waiting for Lefty, presented by the cast of Gold Eagle Guy," with no mention of either author or individual actors. The stage manager, Robert Riley, who booked the entertainment and decided the order of appearance, believed that Anna Sokolow's troupe of dancers was more important than a new play by an unknown actor/writer, and he announced that they would appear last. Odets was furious, arguing vehemently that his play deserved the favored final spot. Riley gave in, only to encounter a new problem. The Group hadn't warned him that the show required lighting cues; he had to work them out hastily with the electrician during the intermissions between the other acts. When the lights went up on the bare stage, with Morris Carnovsky as the corrupt union leader directly addressing the audience as if they were his rebellious membership, no one expected anything except another casual piece of agitprop thrown together for a good cause.Within moments everyone in the theatre knew better. As the actors began to speak Odets' stingingly authentic language - so radically different from either the affected patter of the Broadway show-shops or the wooden sloganeering of agitprop - audience members found themselves swept up in a drama they seemed to know intimately, from deep inside themselves, even though they'd never heard a word of it before.
They gasped when Ruth Nelson as the angry wife said, "Sure, I see it in the papers, how good orange juice is for kids ... Betty never saw a grapefruit. I took her to the store last week and she pointed to a stack of grapefruits. 'What's that,' she said." They cheered when Tony Kraber, playing the scientist who refuses to develop poison gas, punches his evil boss (Carnovsky again) in the nose. They murmured sadly when the young lovers Phoebe Brand and Julie Garfield were forced by poverty to part. They jeered at Russell Collins as a company guy and applauded when Gadget Kazan exposed him as "my own lousy brother!" They laughed sympathetically at Bill Challee as a desperate young actor too ignorant to know what a manifesto is and took Paula Miller to their hearts as the tough producer's secretary who gives him a dollar to buy some food and a copy of The Communist Manifesto, telling him, "Come out in the light, Comrade." When Luther Adler, playing a young doctor fired because he is a Jew, closed his scene with the communist salute, more than one person answered him from the auditorium with a clenched fist thrust in the air. It was beyond politics. They used the CP salute as Odets defined it in Lefty's last scene: "the good old uppercut to the chin," a rejection of all the forces that hurt people and kept them down, a commitment to fight for a better life.
To Kazan, seated in the auditorium waiting for his cue, the response was "like a roar from sixteen-inchers broadside, audience to players, a way of shouting, 'More! More! More! Go on! Go on! Go on!'" Swept up by the passion they had aroused, the actors were no longer acting. "They were being carried along as if by an exultancy of communication such as I have never witnessed in the theatre before," wrote [Harold] Clurman. The twenty-eight-year-old playwright was awed by the emotional conflagration he'd ignited. "You saw theatre in its truest essence," Odets remembered years later. "Suddenly the proscenium arch of the theatre vanished and the audience and actors were at one with each other."
As the play mounted to its climax, the intensity of feeling on and offstage became almost unbearable. When Bobby Lewis dashed in with the news that Lefty has been murdered, no one needed to take an exercise to find the appropriate anger - the actors exploded with it, the audience seethed with it. They exulted as Joe Bromberg, playing the union rebel Agate Keller, tore himself loose from the hired gunmen and declared their independence: "HELLO AMERICA! HELLO. WE'RE STORMBIRDS OF THE WORKING-CLASS ... And when we die they'll know what we did to make a new world!"
"Well, what's the answer?" Bromberg demanded. In the audience, as planned, Odets, Herbie Ratner, and Lewis Leverett began shouting "Strike!" "LOUDER!" Bromberg yelled - and, one by one, from all over the auditorium, individual voices called out, "Strike!" Suddenly the entire audience, some 1,400 people, rose and roared, "Strike! Strike!" The actors froze, stunned by the spontaneous demonstration. The militant cries gave way to cheers and applause so thunderous the cast was kept onstage for forty-five minutes to receive the crowd's inflamed tribute. "When they couldn't applaud anymore, they stomped their feet," said Ruth Nelson. "All I could think was, 'My God, they're going to break the balcony down!' It was terrible, it was so beautiful." The actors were all weeping. When Clurman persuaded Odets to take a bow, the audience stormed the stage and embraced the man who had voiced their hopes and fears and deepest aspirations. "That was the dram all of us in the Group Theatre had," said Kazan, "to be embraced that way by a theatreful of people."
"The audience wouldn't leave," said Cheryl Crawford. "I was afraid they were going to tear the seats out and throw them on the stage." When the astounded stage manager finally rang down the curtain, they remained out front, talking and arguing about the events in a play taht seemed as real to them as their own lives. Actors and playwright were overwhelmed and a little frightened by the near-religious communion they had just shared. Odets retreated to a backstage bathroom; his excitement was so intense he threw up, then burst into tears. The dressing room was hushed as the actors removed their makeup. They emerged onto 14th Street to find clusters of people still gathered outside, laughing, crying, hugging each other, clapping their hands. "There was almost a sense of pure madness about it," Morris Carnovsky felt.
No one wanted to go home. Sleep was out of the question. Most of the Group went to an all-night restaurant - no one can remember now which one - and tried to eat. Odets sat alone: pale, withdrawn, not talking at all. Everyone was too dazed to have much to say. It was dawn before they could bring themselves to separate, to admit that the miracle was over.
There had never been a night like it in the American theatre. The Group became a vessel into which were poured the rage, frustration, desperation, and finally exultation, not just of an angry young man named Clifford Odets, but of every single person at the Civic Rep who longed for an end to personal and political depression, who needed someone to tell them they could stand up and change their lives. The Group had experienced the "unity of background, of feeling, of thought, of need" Clurman had said was the basis for a true theatre: during his inspiring talks at Brookfield, at the thrilling final run-through of Connelly, in some of the best performances of Success Story. Never before had they shared it with an entire theatre full of people, never before had it seemed as though the lines they spoke hadn't been written but rather emerged from a collective heart and soul. Theatre and life merged, as Clurman had promised they could.
Waiting for Lefty changed people's ideas of what theatre was. More than an evening's entertainment, more even than a serious examination of the contemporary scene by a thoughtful writer, theatre at its best could be a living embodiment of communal values and aspirations. Theatre mattered, art had meaning, culture wasn't the property of an affluent, educated few but an expression of the joys and sorrows of the human condition as they could be understood and shared by everyone.
Goosebumps. No matter how many times I read that (or descriptions from anyone who was there that night - either in the audience or up on stage) - I get goosebumps.
No wonder Odets had a sharp fall later in life. How on EARTH could anything he would EVER do top such a debut??
The Time is Ripe describes the year of the Group's demise. Night Music, Odets' latest play (which I ADORE - it is very difficult to find, and never produced anymore - my dad found it for me in the library and Xeroxed me a copy - Great play.) - was a huge flop. This was devastating for Odets - the critics were very cruel. They had built Odets up - and man, they loved tearing him down.

The theatre ensemble folded.
All members scattered to the 4 winds - John Garfield, Franchot Tone, Frances Farmer, Morris Carnovsky, Stella Adler, Lee Strasberg, Elia Kazan - and yet they were forever linked, they forever had a relationship with one another - because of their experiences in the 1930s.
In honor of his birthday, I've posted a bunch of excerpts from his journal below. Some are funny, some are thought-provoking, some are lyrical - he is at the height of his powers here. He is about to go into his long decline - which is sad, because he has such fire and energy here. In 1944, he made his directorial debut with None but the Lonely Heart - starring Cary Grant. This was the second part Grant was nominated for an Oscar for - mainly because of the big crying scene at the end. (The fact that Grant would not be nominated - then or now - for his performance in His Girl Friday - is just indicative of how silly those awards can be!!)

He and Grant were friends until the very end - and Odets had a particularly sad end. The guy had a long way to fall, and boy, did he fall. Grant would lend him money, or go and sit with him and talk and laugh and try to help his friend. None but the Lonely Heart is obviously Odets-ian - the themes, the compromises (it's always about choosing money or love, choosing money or humanity) - but what's really interesting about it is how great it LOOKS. The MOOD of the movie is really the reason to see it. It has an almost Fritz Lang-ish feel to it, eerie, melancholy, big empty urban streets, the alienation of urban life made manifest in the dark cobblestones - it's a great looking movie.
But now, in honor of his birthday, some excerpts from his journal from 1940. Obviously Clifford was all about Beethoven. Beethoven, and thoughts on FORM. Great stuff.
January 21, 1940
I am growing uneasy -- a new play is coming on. For me, this creative uneasiness excuses everything. Otherwise my inability to follow up assumed personal responsibilities would be another strong item to make my life unhappier than it is. Everything-for-the work is practically the only way I can feel and think -- notice that I put the word feel before think. Right now, these days and weeks, I am very clear in my relationships with the theatre, friends and intimates, almost the world. And that clarity of relationship is the prime necessity for doing good work.Loneliness -- the business of living alone -- seems to have one of two results for a man. Either it makes him excessively romantic; or it makes him sour and bitter. Sometimes, however, there is a curious blending of both, a tart personality emerging, a sort of eccentric. In fact, all three results add up to an eccentric.
January 23, 1940
The period of courtship, in any matter, gets to be a shorter and shorter affair with me. This is because I am getting shorter and shorter on self-delusion. Let us get to the heart of the matter, I feel, and let us get there quickly and put things on a working basis. I am anxious for results and impatient, unfortunately, with the steps which lead up to the results. This is growth from one point of view; from another it is sheer backsliding.
January 21, 1940
John Barbirolli conducting the Schubert Seventh this afternoon, on the radio. An English musician or conductor! -- the very words are contradictory! Although there are some good words to say for [Sir Thomas] Beecham, who seems to have lifted himself into the top ranks of conductors by sheer will. He plays everything with great muscularity, forcing the music. Particularly true is this of his Mozart. He has discovered the "demon" in Mozart and will have the demon out even if he breaks the orchestra apart! But he really has his points, Beecham.But Barbirolli? We went over on the same ship when we went to London with Golden Boy...He scowled and strode darkly through the passageways of the ship, romantic and glamorous, or trying to be. It's easy to hear, in his conducting, that he is quite a mild fellow, so mild that I keep looking to see what is holding up the music from behind. The symphony board here, in the case of Toscanini -- since they claimed that people came to see and hear only T. -- erred on the side of distinction. Then they got Barbirolli, whose personality would not overshadow the aggregate personality of the orchestra ... and they erred on the side of extinction!
March 24, 1940
Form, form. I go crazy when I hear some of these goofs say I have no form! Debussy had no form? Certainly not -- he had none of Beethoven's form! And some of Beethoven's last piano sonatas had no form. Yes, none of Mozart's form. These idiots do not realize that there is no such thing as abstract form! Form is, like style, an intensely personal thing. The trust is that my plays have much more form and shape and pattern than thousands of well-made American plays which are simply a scaffolding holding up nothing. I am a talented individual, seeing and handling material in an individual and creative way. And these so-called critics do not understand that when they ask for a ready-made form from me they are simultaneously asking for the death of my talent.Well, everything is your own fault -- you read what those stupid men write!
April 8, 1940
In the music of Berlioz you will find something petulant, like a man with a toothache. I write this because I am thinking of the "Roman Carnival" overture which I played this afternoon. There is something historical about this piece, some strange and new outburst -- the "peeve" has come into art, the sense of personal rejection, the man unwanted and unheeded. What a strange sad man Berlioz must have been. Aaron Copland says the music of Berlioz is strange too, in the sense that one never knows where it is going or what the artist's intention is (if I am reporting correctly) but I don't understand what Aaron means: the music is followable enough to me. One might almost say that the nerves and hysteria of the modern man have come into the art with Berlioz, too.
April 25, 1940
Every [movie] studio has its own style in writing. A Warner Brothers picture always has an interesting linear quality about it, but is always dead in parts. The picture I saw last night, Dr. Ehrlich's Magic Bullet, In some ways it is such an ordinary picture that one is apt to overlook the remarkable assembly and compression of the machinery, for it is a piece of machinery, dead all over, inhuman, but machinelike in its precision and use of parts. Characters never have any doubts which pull them two ways -- they are one thing, one color, good or bad, moving only in one direction, on one dimension. In a word, they are not dialectic -- they are without those contradictions which are in themselves the source of the deepest human drama.But I most not forget the superb old German actor, [Albert] Basserman, who played Koch, the great German scientist, in this picture. He had only several small scenes in the picture, but he immediately made every American or English actor in the cast look like a boy. How he did this I am unable to say, perhaps with great repose, a WHOLE grasp of the character, really talking to the other characters instead of acting talking. He was well aware of the meaning of every situation in which he found himself and it was to that meaning he gave himself, never to something abstract, never to, for instance, nobility in general. In a word, he acted, he was active, he understood, he dealt with!
April 17, 1940
In the early evening went to Lee Strasberg's house for dinner. Paula's mother was there [Ed: Paula was Lee Strasberg's wife - an INFAMOUS individual - Marilyn Monroe's controlling acting coach - the bane of John Huston's life - there's a whole story in there], preparing the dinner, and I understood a great deal about Paula from seeing her mother's weak face. For the first time in ten years the tensions are down between Lee and myself -- so we were both able to relax.He spoke of what he called "the blight of Ibsen", saying that Ibsen had taught most writers after him how to think undramatically. He illustrated this by an example. A man has been used to living in luxury finds he is broke and unable to face life -- he goes home and puts a bullet in his head. That, Lee said, any fair theatre person can lay out into a play. But it is not essentially a dramatic view of life. Chekhov is dramatic, he said, for this is how he treats related material: a man earns a million rubles and goes home and lies down on them and puts a bullet in his head.
I LOVE that!!
April 12, 1940
Perhaps the main activity of the romantic, often idealist, is that of giving, that of offering himself up, of throwing himself at the world. The trouble beings when the world coldly refuses him. Nothing daunted, again the leap, again the throwing of the self. Again repulsed, again and again! Finally, you have a tired, embittered, and frustrated man, or one of resignation, or one who has learned to modulate his behavior and values to those of the world.In Beethoven we have the glorious exception to all the rules.
He never stopped the fierce activity of throwing himself at the world, of demanding attention for his values above all others, of insisting on the validity of what he was above all current social values.
This persistence created, finally, one of the greatest bodies of art the world has ever seen, but it cost the man dearly -- it cost him his life, his home, his friends, all ordinary comforts and amenities. It crippled him almost beyond recognition. But even on his deathbed he suddenly started up and threw himself at the world with a clenched fist.
April 9, 1940
Mozart, in his best work, has the profound sadness of a man trying to break out of a form not his own personally: which is to say a man trying to break out of prison. Child and man of his age, he was above it by being underground in it. On the other hand, the personal tragedy of Beethoven, the man, is that HE DID BREAK THROUGH THE FORM! (In Mozart's case it is like the Negro who walks around, personal life in him, contained in a social form which he did not make and from which he can never escape!)In certain periods where the forms of art are breaking down (because of social breakdowns and changes) it is a bondage, a sign of servility, to work within those forms when one's content is in advance of the times. It was between these two worlds that Mozart was beginning to be caught by the time he had reached the age of independent manhood. Against him was ranged the entire world of common usage of the artist, represented by his employers and his very own father, a perfect servant and minor diplomat. The overlords did not want to know or hear what he was feeling and sensing; they wanted only the shell of his genius, never the substance. Here, in the simple and natural protection of his genius, is where Mozart began a subtle change in his life.
He pretended a servility (as Haydn did not have to pretend) by retaining the old decaying forms. And this is how he went underground -- he moved around in these forms freely, saying exactly what he wanted to say, loading them with a rare precise vehemence (which Beethoven was later to bring up into daylight!), often expressing all sorts of censorable materials behind opera masks.
He is a man of great elegance in his art, not all of it natural to his nature. His technical equipment is excellent and enviable. His playing contains a contained feeling of which he is somewhat afraid; and he possesses, when you think of it, little quality of the spirit. His name is Heifetz, and you know all of this when you hear him fiddle Mozart.
March 29, 1940
The man of genius walks, talks, sleeps, eats, loves, and works with a load of dynamite in him. If he carries this load carefully -- balance -- its power for good work and use is enormous -- it can landscape a whole mountainside. Abuse -- out of balance -- is suicide and a bitter grave.It is in this sense that the artist, if he makes a proper amalgam, is beyond good and evil, for everything in him is for creation and life.
For example, let us say that Dostoevsky had impulses of rape in his heart.... See how a great artist held this part of himself within his recognition and acceptance of what he was. Its creative uses were enormous. It gave him work, tone, feeling, anguish, a wealth of feeling. Finally, it was just such "weaknesses" which gave Dostoevsky's novels their religious ecstatic fervor.
In other words ... inner contradictions are not solved by throwing out half of the personality, but by keeping both sides tearing and pulling, often torturing the self, until an AMALGAM ON A HIGH LEVEL OF LIFE AND EXPERIENCE IS ACHIEVED! For the artist there is not "bad". He must throw out nothing, exclude nothing, but always hold in balance. When he has made this balance he has made and found his form.
March 25, 1940
Life was mysterious and impressive to Beethoven, and like a true artist, he was gratified when it showed his face to him. The caprice of fortune he understood very well, the uncertainties of life were always with him. This is clearly in all of his music. What is the romantic temperament? It is amazed, impressed, delighted and enraged by the caprice of life. It is impulsive, swaggering, remonstrating, scolding, pleading, straining, sulking, appealing, denouncing the unfairness of life. It is the romantic who cries out that he is out of harmony with life -- by which he means that life is not in harmony with his vision of the way he saw it as a youth with moral and idealistic hunger to m ix his hands in it and live it fully and deeply. The classic art is to accept life, the romantic to reject it as it is and attempt to make it over as he wants it to be. The classic accepts the forms and conventions of life around it, the romantic breaks them down, rejects, and rebels against them -- they do not fit him -- they were made for the dead and let the dead clutch them in the graves! Yes, with the romantic it is all self-discovery and self-exploration. The injustice and coldness of life is constantly throwing him back on himself, and it is from this center of the expanding demanding growing ego that the romantic functions. The romantic's nature inwardly is one of chaos; this is because there are no accepted or standard values for him -- he will not and does not accept a code made by others. Everything must be tested and measured by his own experience -- anything else is rejected.It is typical that Beethoven scorned the teachings of Haydn and only when much older was able to return to those lesson books and say that he should have paid attention in his youth to the lessons. But to have paid attention would have implied not a Beethoven but a Haydn! The roar of pain which comes from the romantic is real pain, albeit often a pain self-made.
Beethoven roars, Chopin complains, Brahms is resigned and sad. But in each case their pain comes from this real meeting: their ideal vision of life met the reality of life, and they are left with this utterance, "What, is that all it is? Is this all? Nothing else? Down with it!"
True, there is something vastly self-destructive in the essential nature of the romantic, but when he is a good artist he builds a form to gird him in, to prevent the scattering of his life -- his art teches him a way of life and he lives it! Simply that he insisted till the moment he died that his ideal vision of life, of the conduct of men and their interrelationships, was the correct and most valid way to live -- his world was better, and he was willing to fight and die for this belief: he did!
The romantic of the Stendahl type is rare. He understands what has happened to him and his aspirations -- HE DOES NOT ASPIRE IN HIS WORK -- and this detached sense of what has happened later forms the basis of his work, writing, in this case. But this is possible only when the man waits for a good ripe age before setting to work. Stendahl, if we chose, we could call a "romantic iconoclast", the romantic turned ironist, psychologist who looks underneath to reveal with contempt the pitifully paltry forms of life and convention around him.
March 24, 1940
You cannot live in old forms, or work in them, when your life has brought you ahead to a new point. Try better to keep a child in last year's coat. It is simply an intolerable contradiction which must be resolved consciously in order to bring the life and/or work up for a higher level of creativity. Otherwise the spirit dies a death and sterility is the only outcome.Beethoven is the only man or artist I can think of at the moment who never once faltered in this difficult task: he was a fanatic! He hacked and chopped, twisted and tortured, but he did not EXCLUDE a drop of his experience from his work; in each phase of his life he found the right form for an increasingly higher and deeper experience. That is Beethoven's final lesson, if an artist may teach a lesson. Life is a series of rebirths, year after year more difficult, never to be refused, but always to be worked with, coped with, understood, used and used by, never going back, but always moving ahead and higher. Which is what Beethoven did. Easy words to write, these!
Why is Brahms an inferior artist, all other things equal? Because his last period is given over to "resignation" and acceptance. he did not have that same passion of the HEART which was Beethoven's. That is why any last Brahm's work is child's play compared to any last Beethoven work.
Beethoven's work, it must be said, represents the deepest expression of man's faith in life which has ever been written by a man. No artist before or since has expressed so deeply the will to live and accept every fact of life, to be both figuratively and literally crucified for his belief that the way to conquer life is to live without ever once relenting or letting up in that living.
It was Beethoven who understood the passion of Christ, not Bach, for he lived it and experienced it while Bach heard about it in a sort of secondhand way. What some writer once said is true: Bach sacrificed the Church, Beethoven sacrificed himself. His last quartets, a record of his sacrifice (or crucifixion), are more moving to the modern man than any page in the Bible.
March 17, 1940
The bad reviews of Night Music threw me back on myself, but that was good, that is very good, that is as it should always be! But the self independent, resolute! Let there be light, an inner light, a personal light, a light which touches unconscious negative plates of the plays to come with exactly the correct intensity. Keep away from those sensitive negative plates all light from the outside, but all! Later there will always be time to respond to the outside beams.
In this entry he describes the out-of-town tryout of his new play "Night Music" - It would be the last play the Group Theatre did as a company. The failure of "Night Music" was the death knell for the ensemble - despite the fact that it is a LOVELY play. But Odets - radical revolutionary playwright of the early 1930s - wasn't supposed to write lovely comedic romances. The audience wouldn't forgive him for it. It was seen as a BETRAYAL, not just a play they didn't like.
February 22, 1940
The performance of the play was tip-top -- the cast had never been better. The play suffered from what had always been wrong with it because of a certain lack in the direction -- a lack of clear outlining of situations, a lack of building up scenes, a certain missing in places of dramatic intensity. But none of these things was enough to do vital harm to a beautiful show, smooth, powerful and yet tender, fresh, moving, and touching, with real quality in all the parts. But I could see during the first act that the audience was taking it more seriously than it deserved; and I knew that the old thing was here again -- the critics had come expecting a King Lear, not a small delicate play. It all made me very tired, but at the end I thought to myself that it didn't matter, for the show was more or less what I intended; it was lovely and fresh, no matter what the critics said. And I knew, too, that if another and unknown writer's name had been on the script, there would have been critical raves that day.People surged backstage after the curtain -- they all seemed to have had a good time. There were the usual foolish remarks from many of them -- "Enjoyable, but I don't know why," etc., etc. Also a good deal of insincere gushing from a lot of people who would like nothing better than to stick a knife in your ribs, God knows why!
I invited some people down to the house for a drink. Along came the Eislers, Kozlenkos, Bette, Julie [John] Garfield, Boris Aronson, Harry Carey and his wife, Morris [Carnovsky] and Phoebe [Brand] later, Harold [Clurman], Aaron Copland and Victor [Kraft], Bobby Lewis and his Mecican woman, etc., etc. We drank champagne, Scotch when the wine ran out, talked, smoked, filthied up the house, listened to some music. Then they went and I dropped into bed, dog-tired, unhappy, drunk, knowing what the reviews would be like in the morning. In and out I slept, in and out of a fever -- all of modern twentieth-century life in one day and a night.
February 22, 1940
Stella Adler was there with a party, smoke-eyed and neurotic -- usually when you are dying she is more dramatic about the event than you are!
February 1, 1940
In the Moussorgsky songs, if you do not have the emotion you do not have the song, not even the shadow of the song. Chekhov could hope to find and did find actors to play his plays; where can the talent of Moussorgsky find singers to sing his songs? For the point of each of M's songs is not in the notes, not in the words, but between them, a sort of suggested emotional line without which the song simply does not exist. Here is where the conventional songsinger is shown up for what he is, a tracer on glass, a sharper or duller instrument at his use, but not more. The trouble with the damn singers, unless they are fat and fifty, is that they do not give themselves a chance. They don't listen to the songs, they are not open to the music and what it emotionally suggests. Leaving aside the emotional significance, they can't even play with humor, with charm, deftness, alertness. Their backsides should be kicked off till they ache!
January 27, 1940
Perhaps this constant uncovering of the self is one of the prime impulses in the creative mechanism, it and the constant effort to relate the self to persons, things -- a woman -- outside of the self. All of the characters in my plays have the common activity of "a search for reality". Well, it's my activity before it's theirs. And before it was mine it was the activity of almost any serious artist who ever lived, from the breakdown of feudalism till today. When you say an artist died still looking for his form, as, for instance, Beethovern and Cezanne did, you mean he died still looking for his reality.A man named Turner wrote a book on Beethoven and was very smart -- he called the book "Beethoven -- the search for reality." Woe to the artist who is able someday to look at his life and say, "Yes, this is it. Here I rest."
January 23, 1940
But one must make sure to write from a firm core even though, in my opinion, an attempt to reach as broad an audience as possible should always be taken into consideration. I thought once that it would be enough to play in a small cellar, but I soon saw that those who would come to the cellar were not the ones in need of what I could say.
January 17, 1940
Much of love for me is in giving. Unfortunately, I am not one of the receivers in life. I receive badly, restlessly, shamefully.
That last one kills me. I am the same.
Happy birthday, Clifford. And thank you thank you for your plays.
I absolutely loved reading this recent interview with writer Lorrie Moore. There was so much I needed to hear, first of all ... and I admire and love her writing so much. And anyone who faces awkward stressful situations by asking herself, "What would Goldie Hawn do?" is pretty much my idol. Because that question can ONLY lead to social grace and humor ... and I am going to take it on myself, whenever I feel tense.
And the following quote has somehow set me free, I don't even know how else to say it:
"I was obsessive with writing, but I wasn't ever disciplined. Because if you're obsessive you don't need discipline. You just do it all the time. Why would you impose a regimen, when this is your love?"
Someday I'll explain what is going on in my life right now, but as I've said many times before, maybe 5% of my actual life is on my blog - I feel no need to upend my daily experience here, I'm not that kind of blogger - mostly everything is offline - but that one quote from Lorrie Moore, about discipline/obsessiveness rings SO true ... and will be something I keep in mind when I experience self-doubt, or when I take on the world's opinion about what work means, as opposed to my own experience of it. Brilliant. In such a culture that we live in, that places a high premium on visible achievement - writing every day can seem like a lazy thing to do. It's like the people who say, when they hear how much I read, "How do you find the time??" I've gone off on the "I don't have enough time" attitude before. If you want to read more, you make the time. It's that simple. Same as anything else. If you can't make the time, then it's not a priority - other things are priorities - and that's okay. If you want to exercise, you make the time. I will not take the "I don't have enough time" excuse - EVER. I say this as someone who feels tormented by not having enough time. But that's the thing: most pet peeves seem to come from people who have a bit of that behavior in themselves. (I mean, some people would never admit that, but those people are self-righteous jagoffs, and we don't need to pay attention to them!) Something is either a priority for you or it's not. I wish we could let ourselves off the hook more, when it comes to such questions. If you can say to yourself, "Okay, you know what? I really wish I was more in shape - but right now in my life, it's just not a priority. There are only so many hours in the day and I would rather do such and such ... and so I have to admit to myself that fitness is not a priority. Maybe that will change, but right now, it's not." As opposed to feeling harassed by the lack of time, and always behind or wrong. Being a bit more gentle with yourself, in terms of your time, and how you choose to spend it. Same thing with reading. To me, reading is always a priority. And I'm a busy woman. Sometimes I am only able to read a page or two a day, but I always have a book in my bag. I read in line at the movie theatre, I read on the bus, I read in the elevator - I sometimes even read while walking down the street. It's not something I choose to do - I just always make time. There are other activities that I want to take on - but I know it's not a priority right now - I have other things going on that take precedent, so I'm not going to torment myself with wondering why I can't do it all. I mean, I DO torment myself ... but I try to talk myself out of that clocktower when I find myself there. I have enough self-loathing to deal with. No need to pile it on.
Lorrie Moore's comment about not needing discipline to write really resonates with me. It is another thing I do every day ... I do not need to remind myself, I do not need to keep a schedule, I just do it. It is obsessive. It keeps me stable, first of all ... but it's also just part of the warp and weft of my life, and I've been doing it since I could first pick up a pencil.
Now. To take that obsession and turn it into something. That's the artist's job. That's when you become conscious. But the discipline thing, at least, I don't have to worry about.
Lorrie Moore is one of my favorite present-day writers, and I am looking forward to the new edition of her collected stories.
I also loved her comment about her ex-husband:
"It was easy to be a writer around him. Like, right now, I'm seeing somebody else and that's not easy, because he's scouring the work for signs of him. But my husband never really did that. It's good to have someone who is mildly interested and mildly proud, and also slightly uninterested. When I was in graduate school, I had a teacher who said to me, women writers should marry somebody who thinks writing is cute." She smiles. "Because if they really realised what writing was, they would run a mile."
Brill!
If you haven't encountered Lorrie Moore, I cannot recommend her strongly enough.
A couple posts I have written about Moore:
Birds of America - The story "Willing"
Birds of America - The story 'Terrific Mother'
One of my favorite writers

William Butler Yeats was born today, in 1865. Yeats is a great poet and all that, but I grew up pretty much "over" him because he was kind of omnipresent in our household. We were made to memorize his epitaph in order to receive 25 cents for our allowance. ("Cast a cold eye / On life on death / Horseman pass by"). We knew his "Host of the Air" by heart, because it was on the Clancy Brothers at Carnegie Hall album. He was everywhere. It's not that we had a reverence for him - just the opposite. I knew what he looked like, in the same way I knew what George Washington looked like, because he was on our currency. Yeats? Oh, HIM again? Cast a cold eye ... yeah, I know, I know.
Yeats makes me think of my father. My first published piece in The Sewanee Review was about the Yeats-dad continuum.
From memory now!
THE HOST OF THE AIR
O'Driscoll drove with a song
The wild duck and the drake
From the tall and the tufted reeds
Of the drear Heart Lake.
And he saw how the reeds grew dark
At the coming of night-tide,
And dreamed of the long dim hair
Of Bridget his bride.
He heard while he sang and dreamed
A piper piping away,
And never was piping so sad,
And never was piping so gay.
And he saw young men and young girls
Who danced on a level place,
And Bridget his bride among them,
With a sad and a gay face.
The dancers crowded about him
And many a sweet thing said,
And a young man brought him red wine
And a young girl white bread.
But Bridget drew him by the sleeve
Away from the merry bands,
To old men playing at cards
With a twinkling of ancient hands.
The bread and the wine had a doom,
For these were the host of the air;
He sat and played in a dream
Of her long dim hair.
He played with the merry old men
And thought not of evil chance,
Until one bore Bridget his bride
Away from the merry dance.
He bore her away in his arms,
The handsomest young man there,
And his neck and his breast and his arms
Were drowned in her long dim hair.
O'Driscoll scattered the cards
And out of his dream awoke:
Old men and young men and young girls
Were gone like a drifting smoke;
But he heard high up in the air
A piper piping away,
And never was piping so sad,
And never was piping so gay.
To those of you who know that Clancy Brothers album - you'll know the special-ness of that recording.
When we visited his grave in Ireland, as kids, we all felt kind of amazed that ... it was REAL. That the epitaph we had been rattling off since we were toddlers actually existed out in the world, and had some meaning beyond the 25 cents in our pockets.
A couple years ago, I read his complete works in chronological order. It was a fascinating experience - I know many of his big poems almost by heart, the famous ones - but it's nothing compared to reading his work - from beginning to end. You watch an artist burst forth at a certain point - almost fully formed. You've read his younger work, you've seen its beauty (but also its sentimentality - its Celtic twilight "twee" lament ... it's actually quite awful in a way... and so nothing - NOTHING - can prepare you for the poet who would eventually write "Sailing to Byzantium" and "Among Schoolchildren" Where the hell did THAT come from?)
Yeats, as a poet, has always been one of my favorites (even with the "cloud-pale eyelids" balderdash of his early stuff), but what really inspires me is his work in Irish theatre, and the creation of the Abbey. An amazing story. His Nobel lecture was on the Irish Dramatic Movement. I wrote a big long post about his nurturing of John Synge, author of Playboy of the Western World. Synge, as a young man, was a floundering artist bohemian type - until Yeats got a hold of him, and told him to go stay on the Aran Islands for a while, to discover the real Irish people. The result? A revolution in Irish theatre.
Gabriel Fallon, an actor at the Abbey, describes the dress rehearsal of Sean O'Casey's Juno and the Paycock in his book Sean O'Casey, The Man I Knew - a wonderful theatrical anecdote, I love how Lady Gregory talks to Yeats here:
We could make nothing of the reading of Juno and the Paycock as it was called. It seemed to be a strange baffling mixture of comedy and tragedy; and none of us could say, with any certainty, whether or not it would stand up on the stage.The dress rehearsal would be held at 5 p.m. on March 2, Sunday. I arrived at the theatre at 4:30 p.m., and found the author there before me looking rather glum and wondering if a rehearsal would take place ... Gradually the players filed in and went to their dressing-rooms. Lennox Robinson arrived shortly before 5 o'clock and was followed by Yeats and Lady Gregory. The curtain rose about 5:36 p.m. so far as I could see and hear while waiting for my cue in the wings the rehearsal seemed to be proceeding smoothly. As soon as I had finished my part of Bentham at the end of the second act I went down into the stalls and sat two seats behind the author. Here for the first time I had an opportunity of seeing something of the play from an objective point of view. I was stunned by the tragic quality of the third act which the magnificent playing of Sara Allgood made almost unbearable. But it was the blistering irony of the final scene which convinced me that this man sitting two seats in front of me was a dramatist of genius, one destined to be spoken of far beyond the confines of the Abbey Theatre ...
We watched the act move on, the furniture removers come and go, the ominous entry of the IRA men, the dragging of Johnny to summary execution, the stilted scene between Jerry Devine and Mary Boyle, and then as with the ensnaring slow impetus of a ninth great wave Allgood's tragic genius rose to an unforgettable climax and drowned the stage in sorrow. How surely was the very butt and sea-mark of tragedy! But suddenly the curtain rises again: are Fitzgerald and McCormick fooling, letting off steam after the strain of rehearsal? Nothing of the kind; for we in the stalls are suddenly made to freeze in our seats as a note beyond tragedy, a blistering flannel-mouthed irony sears its maudlin way across the stage and slowly drops an exhausted curtain on a world disintegrating in 'chassis'.
I sat there stunned. So, indeed, as far as I could see, did Robinson, Yeats, and Lady Gregory. Then Yeats ventured an opinion. He said that the play, particularly in the final scene, reminded him of a Dostoevsky novel. Lady Gregory turned to him and said, "You know, Willie, you never read a novel by Dostoevsky." And she promised to amend this deficiency by sending him a copy of The Idiot. I turned to O'Casey and found I could only say to him, "Magnificent, Sean, magnificent."
"The Second Coming" is quoted (and mis-appropriated, more often than not) and quoted again ... by people who want to use it for their own ends. It's a dark ominous crystal ball. The best "use" of it, to my mind, is in the deleted scene in Nixon, with Sam Waterston playing Dick Helms, director of the CIA. Written in 1919 - when the world had already become familiar with horror - a horror of a kind never before seen on earth - the poem predicts the chaos of the 20th century. Try to disentangle it from all of the movies (and Sopranos episodes) that has used it ... and just read it, clear and simple, as a poem. On its own. It's one of the greatest poems of the 20th century.
"The Second Coming"
Turning and turning in the widening gyre
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.
Surely some revelation is at hand;
Surely the Second Coming is at hand.
The Second Coming! Hardly are those words out
When a vast image out of Spiritus Mundi
Troubles my sight: somewhere in sands of the desert
A shape with lion body and the head of a man,
A gaze blank and pitiless as the sun,
Is moving its slow thighs, while all about it
Reel shadows of the indignant desert birds.
The darkness drops again; but now I know
That twenty centuries of stony sleep
Were vexed to nightmare by a rocking cradle,
And what rough beast, its hour come round at last,
Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?
Seamus Heaney wrote a marvelous essay on Yeats a while back (the link no longer works, but I have the hard copy) - in which he wrote:
Conquest, difficulty, labour: these terms indicate the nature of Yeats's creative disposition. From the start, he was enamoured of Blake's conviction that energy is eternal delight, yet the development of his own thought brought him more and more to the conclusion that conflict was the inescapable condition of being human. So, as his art matured and the articulation of his beliefs became more clarified and forceful, Yeats's poems typically conveyed a sensation of certitude achieved by great effort and of contradictions quelled. Poems in which the defiant self is pitted against hostile or disabling conditions - "An Irish Airman Foresees his Death", "September 1913", "Meditations in Time of Civil War"- are complemented by poems that read like discharges of pure, self-possessed energy, poems from which the accidental circumstances have been excluded so that all that remains is the melody and stamina of resurgent spirit - "The Cold Heaven", "Byzantium", "Long-legged Fly".

Of course, there is also the Maud Gonne factor that must be considered. I read some funny quote somewhere (can't remember where) that said: "Any biography of Yeats would have to have in every chapter the following words: 'And he proposed marriage yet again to Maud Gonne'." What do you wanta bet that Maud Gonne had "cloud-pale eyelids"? Anne wrote a wonderful post about Maud Gonne MacBride. Fascinating woman. Poor Yeats. But at least she was his muse, and he got 100s of poems out of his unrequited love for her.
Never give all the heart
Never give all the heart, for love
Will hardly seem worth thinking of
To passionate women if it seem
Certain, and they never dream
That it fades out from kiss to kiss;
For everything that's lovely is
But a brief, dreamy. Kind delight.
O never give the heart outright,
For they, for all smooth lips can say,
Have given their hearts up to the play.
And who could play it well enough
If deaf and dumb and blind with love?
He that made this knows all the cost,
For he gave all his heart and lost.
Heaney writes, in that same essay:
And all the while, of course, there was Maud Gonne, "high and solitary and most stern" according to one of the poems about her, "foremost among those I would hear praised" according to another, and "the troubling of my life" according to a famous sentence in his Autobiographies. The passion she inspired - and as readers we experience it more as creative power than erotic need - made her a figure of primary poetic radiance, a Dublin Beatrice, an archetype as much as a daily presence. Nevertheless, Yeats's poetry, his politics and his involvement with the occult received an extra charge of intensity from her day to day reality in his life, and when she appeared in the title role of his subversive play Cathleen Ni Houlihan (1902), another kind of maturity was achieved.
Yeats is one of those poets who was not a solitary creature, writing in isolation. He wanted to start a "movement", and he did. He helped a young James Joyce in the beginning of HIS career. He advised Synge. He headed up the Abbey Theatre. He really looked at his own country - an insular priest-ridden culture at that time - and sensed a need, tried to create something different. It's hard to look with clear eyes on your own home, your own nation. Joyce did it, but that's only because he LEFT. Yeats, at first, went back into the Irish past in his work - and some of his early stuff is so quaint that it might as well be cross-stitched and hanging on the door of some Kountry Kraft Shoppe. I suppose it was his way of re-claiming the Irish past, its true inheritance. It was a phase, his beginning phase as a writer - how he found his "voice". And he was concerned about the rest of his countrymen, calling out to them:
"Irish poets, learn your trade, sing whatever is well made, scorn the sort now growing up all out of shape from toe to top."
Yeats was Anglo-Irish, but his feelings were that Irish-ness was a cultural thing, not a religious thing (forgive me for boiling it down so awkwardly) - and that the Irish could be united, regardless of religion - through writing, myths, poetry. He was a true nationalist.
I also love love LOVE his poem to fellow Irishman Jonathan Swift where he writes: "Imitate him if you dare."
Swift's Epitaph
Swift has sailed into his rest;
Savage indignation there
Cannot lacerate his breast.
Imitate him if you dare,
World-besotted traveller; he
Served human liberty.
WH Auden wrote, in his unbelievable poem to Yeats:
In the deserts of the heart
Let the healing fountain start,
In the prison of his days
Teach the free man how to praise.
And lastly, a poem that has great personal meaning for me:
The wild swans at Coole
The trees are in their autumn beauty,
The woodland paths are dry,
Under the October twilight the water
Mirrors a still sky;
Upon the brimming water among the stones
Are nine-and-fifty Swans.
The nineteenth autumn has come upon me
Since I first made my count;
I saw, before I had well finished,
All suddenly mount
And scatter wheeling in great broken rings
Upon their clamorous wings.
I have looked upon those brilliant creatures,
And now my heart is sore.
All's changed since I, hearing at twilight,
The first time on this shore,
The bell-beat of their wings above my head,
Trod with a lighter tread.
Unwearied still, lover by lover,
They paddle in the cold
Companionable streams or climb the air;
Their hearts have not grown old;
Passion or conquest, wander where they will,
Attend upon them still.
But now they drift on the still water,
Mysterious, beautiful;
Among what rushes will they build,
By what lake's edge or pool
Delight men's eyes when I awake some day
To find they have flown away?
SOME QUOTES
"My poetry is generally written out of despair. Like Balzac, I see increasing commonness everywhere, and like Balzac I know no one who shares the premises from which I work." -- Yeats
"On the third night Yeats addressed the audience before the curtain rose. If anyone had anything to say against the piece they would be welcomed at a debate which he would be glad to arrange in the theatre at some other time. He was interrupted several times. He asked the interrupters to at least listen to the play so that they would know what it was they were objecting to." -- Maire Nic Shiubhlaigh's description of Yeats trying to handle the riots that were happening in response to Synge's "Playboy of the Western World" - a play being put on at the Abbey Theatre
"In 1875 Yeats entered the Godolphin School in Hammersmith and visited Ireland during the longer school vacations, when he stayed with the Pollexfens in County Sligo. An early poetic impulse was to change the name of his toy yacht from Sunbeam to Moonbeam. It was a decisive act." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets
"I thought we might bring the halves together if we had a national literature that made Ireland beautiful in the memory, and yet had been freed of provincialism by an exacting criticism, a European pose." -- Yeats
"This is not the huge competence of Auden, at play in the toy shop of poetic form, but mastery, the possession of a unique rhetoric for use on a real but limited range of themes. It is a mastery so complete that it can occlude the genuinely problematic, ride over the potholes of nonsense without even sensing them. Late in life he recognizes the evasiveness of his symbols, the tendency of his verse to turn away or inward, and in the concentrated intensity of the late poems he tries to remedy this. But he has an imperfect sense of generality; he is willing to plump out a truism as truth. As his mastery increases, his art becomes less truthful. But his main concern is not - until the later poems, and even there in an attenuated spirit - truth, but the house of myth and legend, where he can become a principal tenant, where it is his voice we hear casting the spell, and where real men are reduced - or, in his mind, enlarged - to masks, figures and types useful to myth, regardless of the human reality they had." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"All literature created out of a conscious political aim in the long run crates weakness by creating a habit of unthinking obedience. Literature created for its own sake, for some eternal spiritual need, can be used for politics. Dante is said to have unified Italy. The more unconscious the creation, the more powerful." -- Yeats
"Sex and death are the only things that can interest a serious mind." -- Yeats
"His mastery seems almost excessive." -- Richard Ellmann
"... a strained and unworkable allegory about a young man and a sphinx on a rock in the sea (how did they get there? what did they eat? and so on; people think such criticisms very prosaic, but common-sense is never out of place anywhere ...) but still containing fine lines and vivid imagery." - Gerard Manley Hopkins, after reading some of Yeats' first published verses
"Yeats's 'The Second Coming' has gained in prophetic power with each decade of the twentieth and now twenty-first century, from the rise of fascism and nuclear warfare to the proliferation of international terrorism. It expresses the melancholy realizatino that man, yearningly drawn to the divine, will never fully escape his bestial ancestry. The poem is modernistically unrhymed, though the first stanza plays with shadowy off-rhymes: 'gyre' / 'falconer' / 'everywhere'; 'hold' / 'world' / 'drowned'. It is structured instead by dramatic visuals and emblematic choreography. There are two main movements: a huge, expanding circle (the ascending falcon) and an arrowlike, linear track (the beast bound for Bethlehem). Then two smaller ones: a pendulum arc (the rocking cradle) and an exploding pinwheel (the reeling desert birds). Ideas have become design, starkly juxtaposed with the murky turbulence of elemental forces - storm, flood, drought. Hence the poem, with its horror movie finale, is as hybrid as the sphinx, who represents our buried impulses, vestiges of a past that keeps turning into the future." -- Camille Paglia, "Break, Blow, Burn"
"The heavy voluptuous splendour of much of his work has yet a ghostliness as of the palace made magically of leaves. Even his heroes and beautiful women are aware of this ... He never leaves us, any more than Crashaw, content with the glory alone. It calls our attention to a spirit behind and beyond, heaping high lovely, invisible things that it may show the greater beauty that can survive their crumbling into dust." -- Edward Thomas, 1909
"The worst thing about some men is that when they are not drunk they are sober." -- Yeats
"In London he was active in literature and politics. One particular event in 1889 proved crucial: he met and fell in love with the fiery Republican who haunted him for the rest of his days, Maud Gonne. His biography, from 1889 until Maud Gonne's marriage, is punctuated by the statement, 'Yeats proposed to Maud Gonne.'" -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"Words are always getting conventionalized to some secondary meaning. It is one of the works of poetry to take the truants in custody and bring them back to their right senses." -- Yeats
" 'The best lack all conviction, while the worst / Are full of passionate intensity': these famous lines are Yeats's anguished formulation of what seems to be an eternal principle of politics (7-8). When 'the center cannot hold,' neither consensus nor compromise is possible. Public debate shifts to the extremes or is overtaken by violence, which blocks incremental movement toward reciprocity and conciliation. Moderate views are 'drowned' out (as by the bloody tide) in strident partisanship or fanaticism. The phrase 'passionate intensity' suggests that, for the late Romantic Yeats, eros diverted from the personal to the political turns into a distorted lust for power. The second stanza opens in doubt and confusion: 'Surely some revelation is at hand; / Surely the Second Coming is at hand. / The Second Coming!'' (9-11). We are hearing either one voice echoing its own shocked phrases or many voices in public tumult. The book of Revelation lists the dreadful omens heralding doomsday, when Jesus will return and unlock the secrets of history. But in Yeats's poem, Christ's promised glory is overshadowed by a monstrous apparition from antiquity. The poet is seized by an electrifying vision: 'a vast image out of Spiritus Mundi / Troubles my sight'. It's a collective memory, crystallizing from the repository of world myths (12-13). ("Spiritus Mundi" is Yeats's mystical term for "soul of the universe".) We witness the resurrection of the pagan era, whose barbarism mirrors that of the war-torn twentieth century. Yeats sees no evidence of moral evolution over two millennia of Christianity." -- Camille Paglia, "Break, Blow, Burn"
"I once got Yeats down to bed-rock on these subjects and we talked for hours. He had been talking rather wildly about the after life. Finally I asked him: 'What do you believe happens to us immediately after death?' He replied, 'After a person dies, he does not realize that he is dead.' I: 'In what state is he?' W.B.Y.: 'In some half-conscious state.' I said: 'Like the period between waking and sleeping?' W.B.Y.: 'Yes.' I: 'How long does this state last?' W.B.Y.: 'Perhaps some twenty years.' 'And after that,' I asked, 'what happens next?' He replied, 'Again a period which is Purgaotry. The length of that period depends upon the sins of the man when he was upon this earth.' And then again I asked: 'And after that?' I do not remember his actual words, but he spoke of the return of the soul to God. I said, 'Well, it seems to me that you are hurrying us back into the great arms of the Roman Catholic Church.' He was of course an Irish Protestant. I was bold to ask him, but his only retort was his splendid laugh." -- Lady Dorothy Wellesley
"It is an entirely new thing -- neither what they eye sees nor the ear hears, but what the rambling mind thinks and imagines from moment to moment. He has certainly surpassed in intensity any novelist of our time." -- Yeats on James Joyce's "Ulysses"
"For Yeats, there was something both enviable and exemplary about the enlargement of vision and the consequent histrionic equanimity which Shakespeare's heroes and heroines attain at the moment of their death, 'carried beyond feeling into the aboriginal ice.' He wanted people in real life to emulate or at least to internalize the fortitude and defiance thus manifested in tragic art." -- Seamus Heaney, 1990
"Give up Paris, you will never create anything by reading Racine, and Arthur Symons will always be a better critic of French literature. Go to the Arran Islands. Live there as if you were one of the people themselves; express a life that has never found expression." -- Yeats's advice to John Synge
"The first spectre of the new generation has appeared. His name is Joyce. I have suffered from him and I would like you to suffer." -- George Russell in a letter to Yeats, 1902
Cast a cold eye
On life on death
Horseman pass by
-- Yeats's epitaph
Imitate him if you dare.
JUNE 12, 1942I hope I will be able to confide everything to you, as I have never been able to confide in anyone, and I hope you will be a great source of comfort and support.
Anne Frank started her journal, on her 13th birthday. In early July, only a couple of weeks later, the Frank family went into hiding.

Anne and her sister Margot
Wow: Amazing letter from Joseph Conrad to Edward Garnett.
I sit down religiously every morning, I sit down for eight hours every day--and the sitting down is all. In the course of that working day of 8 hours I write 3 sentences which I erase before leaving the table in despair. There's not a single word to send you. Not one! And time passes--and McClure waits--not to speak of Eternity for which I don't care a damn. Of McClure however I am afraid.
To me the phrase "the sitting down is all" REALLY hits home. That's what Madeleine L'Engle always used to say about writing. If you wait for the muse of inspiration to alight upon your head, you'll be disappointed. The point is to write every day. The majority of it may end up in the wastepaper basket. The quote from Pasteur about "the prepared mind" seems extremely relevant to me, and something I have experienced myself. How does one get to Carnegie Hall? You know how. But to read Conrad's agony about not being able to write, wrestling with those demons ... so openly ... also that his unwritten story literally takes up every bit of space in his brain. He can feel his own brain. Not a very comfortable sensation.
The letter from Conrad seems, in many ways, connected to this quote I posted yesterday from Tennessee Williams.
If you read what real writers say about their process, much of it has to do with the difficulty in actually producing - because you are always up against expectations (from yourself, from others) - or against your own ideals for your art - and how you can't measure up ... whatever it may be. But then comes the glory of breakthrough ... and what you write may not be the greatest thing since Canterbury Tales - but there's nothing like that feeling of actually starting. If you're a perfectionist, starting is often the most difficult part. So when you do start, it can be a profound moment ... because what you are actually doing, and saying to yourself, is: "It's okay if what I produce isn't perfect. It is the doing, it is the being in the moment that matters ... I can neaten it up and fix and edit later ... But for now, just start."
Having some kind of block does not in any way, shape, or form = lazy. Ridiculous. People who overuse the word "lazy" usually overuse the word "whining" as well, whenever they hear anyone complain about anything. Forget about legitimate complaints, forget about an honest and open struggle with faults and disappointments, forget about being face to face with your own failures and admitting it - all of it is apparently whining. Every time I've written one of my personal essays, someone shows up and tells me to stop whining. These people would tell Blanche Dubois to stop whining as she's dragged off in a straitjacket. These people would tell Macbeth to stop being such a whining pussy-boy. These people would tell Gatsby to put a cork in it and "man up, crybaby". No complaint is legitimate enough for these people to ever complain about. It's so predictable now that I just roll my whining eyes and keep writing what I want to write. Because most people seem to dig it, and they're the ones I write for.
UPDATE: Just thought of something else. I attended the Inside the Actors Studio seminar with Meryl Streep. She said, when discussing French Lieutenant's Woman, that there was something about the performance she didn't like - and she said she felt very "dislocated" when filming it. I think her exact words were, 'I couldn't locate myself in that part." Now. The sycophantic response to her honesty ("Well, I thought you were brilliant!") upset me - because what do young struggling actors want to hear from people like Meryl Streep? About her struggles!! I would have loved to hear Meryl Streep elaborate on what it was she felt she "missed" in that performance. Whether or not I agree with her about the RESULT is completely irrelevant. She told a very funny story about filming Dancing at Lughnasa and having such a tough time getting the accent right that she became convinced at, circa 11 pm at night, that she could no longer act. She had "lost it". She informed her husband, "I can't act anymore. I am through." Multiple Oscar winner. She knew her cast members were all down at the bar, so she left her husband in the hotel room, and went to join the cast. The cast hadn't "bonded" yet, Streep was the big glittery world-famous American movie star, she wasn't a big drinker, stuff like that ... so talk at the bar was stilted at first - until Meryl finally burst out, "I have forgotten how to act. I have no idea how to do this accent. I am a terrible actress." and all of her cast members EXPLODED: "We were just talking about that! We feel the same way!!! We are the worst actors ever born!" Of course it all turned out all right in the end, and they all mastered the accent, etc. but without Streep admitting the struggle, that she is still, even as a big major star, "in process" - she might not have gotten there. I loved that - and I felt that not dwelling on those human moments of doubt and struggle did all of us a disservice.
I suppose some folks would say that Meryl Streep was "whining".
So you can count me as a "whiner" too, if that means I am open about my struggles. I'm proud of it. I figure with folks like Joseph Conrad, Tennessee Williams and Madeleine L'Engle, I'm in good company.
I love, too, this part from Conrad's letter:
There! I've told you all and feel better. While I write this I am amazed to see that I can write. It looks as though the spell were broken but I hasten, I hasten lest it should in five minutes or in half an hour be laid again.
The magical spell! Even just writing a letter means that you haven't "lost it" entirely!
And more letters from Joseph Conrad here.
Excerpt from letter of Tennessee Williams to his agent Audrey Wood:
Hotel Rembrandt, Tangier
10/14/53...Just before I sailed for Europe this time, Bill Inge said to me, Tenn, don't you feel that you are blocked as a writer? I told him that I had always been blocked as a writer but that my desire to write had always been so strong that it broke through the block. But this summer I'm afraid the block has been stronger than I am and the break-through hasn't occured. The situation is much plainer than the solution. There is a mysterious weakness and fatigue in my work now, the morning energy expires in about half an hour, or an hour. I pick it up, artificially, with a stiff drink or two but this sort of "forced" energy is reflected in forced writing, which is often off-key and leaves me each day a little more depleted than the day before. I can't help thinking that there is something physiological at the root of this, some organize trouble that is sapping the physical vitality that I need for good work.
I am most struck by his reply to William Inge - that he had "always been blocked as a writer". But that his "desire to write had always been so strong that it broke through the block". Wow. Such self-knowledge, first of all. But also, quite a new thought, in terms of Tennessee Williams - whose output (in retrospect) was so phenomenal. Reading his letters and journals show me a man who had to face his demons every day, when he sat down at his desk - and it's also showing me that writing is a long-distance sport. You have to pace yourself. There will be brief spurts of energy, surging forward, but the rest of the time, you just need to have the fortitude to keep going, realizing that you will not be inspired at all times ... but to stop is to die. I guess I'm really inspired by the thought that someone like Tennessee Williams felt he was blocked as a writer. I have no desire to argue with him, or point to all of his great work, because - well, first of all, he's dead - but second of all: I choose to trust his own assessment of his process, rather than have some kneejerk response to it, like, "He may have THOUGHT he had writer's block - but look at this play, and that play, and how much he did ..." A boring response that would have more to do with me than any critical assessment of Williams' work. The whole blocked-as-a-writer conversation pushes a button in me, it sure does ... I recognize that, I take it personally ... and it's a gift to realize that he always felt that he was blocked. Always. Quite amazing.
Food for thought ... definitely food for thought.
Zadie Smith's incredible analysis of and reflections on Middlemarch, by George Eliot - particularly Henry James' review of said book, where James repeatedly wondered: "Why so much Fred?? Let's stay with Dorothea ... why Fred?" It's a valid question - and reflects some of my experience reading the book as well. I identified so strongly with Dorothea (probably over-identified) - that I wanted the plot to keep its focus on her. Obviously that was not what Eliot was up to or interested in. Unlike Jane Austen, whose books are strictly interior books (I don't think the name Bonaparte is once mentioned, although don't fact-check me on that - the point is: the entire world is not in her books. This is not a criticism, just an observation) ... so while Austen focuses on one or two major thrulines, Eliot juggles, how many in Middlemarch? Maybe twenty different threads? Maybe more? It's breathtaking. Politics, class issues, the railroad, agriculture, art, the position of women, education of women, marriage ... There isn't one major issue of the day that isn't covered in Middlemarch. Not to mention, with the thruline of Lydgate, one of the most harrowing descriptions of what it feels like to be drowning in debt ever put on paper. But if you identify (over-identify) with a character (say: Dorothea) - you may feel like the book is "losing its way" at points, when actually the fault is in you, the reader, for not perceiving what the book is actually doing. Smith replies (in part) to James (and me):
In her intellectual and personal life, Eliot demanded continuous and varied food - and she conceived of many things. One of these things was Fred Vincy, a commonplace young man who would seem more suited to a penny-farthing romance. But it's worth looking again at the facts, which means, in the world of Middlemarch, the emotional facts. Fred is in love with a good girl; a girl who does not love him because he is not worthy; Fred agrees with her. Maybe the point is this: of all the people striving in Middlemarch, only Fred is striving for a thing worth striving for. Dorothea mistakes Casaubon terribly, as Lydgate mistakes Rosamund, but Fred thinks Mary is worth having, that she is probably a good in the world, or at least, good for him ("She is the best girl I know!") - and he's right. Of all of them Fred has neither chosen a chimerical good, nor radically mistaken his own nature. He's not as dim as he seems. He doesn't idealise his good as Dorothea does when she imagines Casaubon a second Milton, and he doesn't settle on a good a priori, like Lydgate, who has long believed that a doting, mindless girl is just what a man of science needs. What Fred surmises of the good he stumbles upon almost by accident, and only as a consequence of being fully in life and around life, by being open to its vagaries simply because he is in possession of no theory to impose upon it. In many ways bumbling Fred is Eliot's ideal Spinozian subject.
I'm blown away by Smith's observations and it makes me want to read the book again. I don't think once is at ALL enough for Middlemarch. (Book excerpt and some of my thoughts on it here)
A wonderful post from Ted about The Crossing, and Cormac McCarthy's sudden piercing bouts of omniscence - hard to pull off, nigh on impossible - The great Russian writers do it all the time, but of course, they invented the "god-mike" in September, 1634, so that makes sense. George Eliot could do it - she's the first English writer that comes to mind, but I can't think of anyone else who so consistently pulls off the "god-mike" effect so effortlessly and powerfully. You must be a psychologist of the highest order to be able to pull back that far, and comment not just on the events of the story, but on all mankind. Blood Meridien was brutal that way. It was like staring into a bright light.
Edward Lear (the so-called "father of nonsense") was born today in 1812 in London.
I could recite from memory a lot of his stuff when I was pretty close to this age here. The Golden Book of Poetry was so read in our family that the cover faded to almost nothing, the binding fell apart ... and I can still, in my mind's eye, see all of the illustrations - and where they were placed on the page. And most of the poem's, when I read them now, I hear them in my father's gravelly voice. (The photo at the top of this post is me, "candidly" posing with the Golden Book of Poetry.) "The Owl and the Pussy-cat" is still a favorite. Look how the verse just rocks and sings. It's perfect.
The Owl and the Pussy-cat - by Edward Lear
I
The Owl and the Pussy-cat went to sea
In a beautiful pea green boat,
They took some honey, and plenty of money,
Wrapped up in a five pound note.
The Owl looked up to the stars above,
And sang to a small guitar,
'O lovely Pussy! O Pussy my love,
What a beautiful Pussy you are,
You are,
You are!
What a beautiful Pussy you are!'
II
Pussy said to the Owl, 'You elegant fowl!
How charmingly sweet you sing!
O let us be married! too long we have tarried:
But what shall we do for a ring?'
They sailed away, for a year and a day,
To the land where the Bong-tree grows
And there in a wood a Piggy-wig stood
With a ring at the end of his nose,
His nose,
His nose,
With a ring at the end of his nose.
III
'Dear pig, are you willing to sell for one shilling
Your ring?' Said the Piggy, 'I will.'
So they took it away, and were married next day
By the Turkey who lives on the hill.
They dined on mince, and slices of quince,
Which they ate with a runcible spoon;
And hand in hand, on the edge of the sand,
They danced by the light of the moon,
The moon,
The moon,
They danced by the light of the moon.

Michael Schmidt, in his book "Lives of the Poets" writes that Lear, and Lewis Carroll (Lear's younger peer) wrote "nonsense verse" which "strays into the musical zones that Longfellow mapped with his self-propelling meters."

-- the inventor of the term "snail mail" in this whimsical letter to Evelyn Baring? The letter itself reads, along the twists of the snail shell:
Feb. 19. 1864 Dear Baring Please give the enclosed noat to Sir Henry - (which I had just written:-& say that I shall have great pleasure in coming on Sunday. I have sent your 2 vols of Hood to Wade Brown. Many thanks for lending them to me - which they have delighted me eggstreamly Yours sincerely
"Don't tell me of a man's being able to talk sense; every one can talk sense. Can he talk nonsense?" -- William Pitt
In regard to his verses, Lear asserted that "nonsense, pure and absolute," was his aim throughout; and remarked, further, that to have been the means of administering innocent mirth to thousands was surely a just excuse for satisfaction. He pursued his aim with scrupulous consistency, and his absurd conceits are fantastic and ridiculous, but never cheaply or vulgarly funny. -- Carolyn Wells
However, there are subtler methods of debunking than throwing custard pies. There is also the humour of pure fantasy, which assaults man's notion of himself as not only a dignified but a rational being. Lewis Carroll's humour consists essentially in making fun of logic, and Edward Lear's in a sort of poltergeist interference with common sense. When the Red Queen remarks, "I've seen hills compared with which you'd call that one a valley", she is in her way attacking the bases of society as violently as Swift or Voltaire. Comic verse, as in Lear's poem "The Courtship of the Yonghy-Bonghy-Bò", often depends on building up a fantastic universe which is just similar enough to the real universe to rob it of its dignity. But more often it depends on anticlimax -- that is, on starting out with a high-flown language and then suddenly coming down with a bump. -- George Orwell, "Funny But Not Vulgar"
From Michael Sala, "Lear's Nonsense":
Edward Lear, a skillful illustrator of science books (botany, zoology), started his literary career by chance. As a matter of fact, "most of Lear's limericks were not written with publication in mind, but rather as gifts for specific children" (Rieder 1998: 50). He was persuaded toward their publication by the enthusiastic reaction of his young audience.
There was an old person of Rimini
Who said, "Gracious! Goodness! O Gimini!
When they said, "Please be still!" she ran down a hill
And was never once heard of at Rimini.
There was an old person of Sestri
Who sat himself down in the vestry,
When they said "You are wrong!" - he merely said "Bong!"
That repulsive old person of Sestri.
This is a typical example of Lear's limericks, and a perfect example of what is intended by nonsense, that is to say, "language lifted out of context, language turning on itself [a] language made hermetic, opaque" (Stewars 1979: 3), language that "resists contextualization, so that it refers to 'nothing' instead of to the word's commonsense designation [and] refusing to work as conventional communication " (Rieder 1998: 49). In other words, what happened to the old person of Rimini? What is wrong with the person of Sestri? It is impossible to answer, because, despite the perfectly grammatical use of the words, they don't tell much. They are just bizarrely arranged so as to sound appealing. If there is a shadow of a story, usually it is nothing more than that: only a shadow of a story (without causes or consequences). In Lear's limericks, words introduce "a number of possibilities, including dangerous and violent ones, and at the same time disconnect those possibilities from the real world, that is, from what goes on after the game is over" (Rieder 1996: 49).
'My dear child, I'm sure we shall be allowed to laugh in Heaven!'" --from a letter to a little girl he knew
In the limericks [. . .] to an extent difficult for us now to imagine, Lear offered children the liberation of unaffected high spirits [. . .]. Here are grown-ups doing silly things, the kind of things grown-ups never do [. . .]. for all their incongruity, there is in the limericks a truth which is lacking in the improving literature of the time. In an age when children were loaded with shame, Lear attempted to free them from it. -- Vivien Noakes
Like the limericks, they celebrate the outsider. Their principal characters are socially unacceptable" --Susan Chitty on Lear's ballads.
Mr. Lear was delighted when I showed to him that this couple [the Owl and the Pussy-cat] were reviving the old law of Solon, that the Athenian bride and bridegroom eat a quince together at their wedding -- Sir Edward Strachey
More information on Edward Lear here.
A terrific essay by Edna O'Brien about the publication of her first novel The Country Girls. Well worth reading but I'll pull out the two parts I liked especially:
The Country Girls took three weeks, or maybe less, to write. After I brought my sons Carlo and Sasha to the local school in Morden, I came home, sat by the windowsill of their bedroom and wrote and wrote. It was as if I was merely a medium for the words to flow. The emotional crux hinged on Ireland, the country I had left and wanted to leave, but now grieved for, with an inexplicable sorrow.Images of roads and ditches and bog and bog lake assailed me, as did the voice of my mother, tender or chastising, and even her cough when she lay down at night. In the fields outside, the lonely plaint of cattle, dogs barking and, as I believed, ghosts. All the people I had encountered kept re-emerging with a vividness: Hickey our workman, whom I loved; my father, whom I feared; knackers; publicans; a travelling salesman by the name of Sacco, who sold spectacles and sets of dentures; and the tinkers who rapped on the door demanding money in exchange for mending tin pots. There was the embryo poet, an amateur historian and the blacksmith who claimed to have met the film director John Ford on the streets of Galway and was asked to appear in The Quiet Man, but declined out of filial duty. The lost landscape of childhood.
I'm going through something right now - some developments in my life - that have put a fire under me. I have a deadline. I have to get to work. Reading her essay really bolstered me up.
And then this lovely bit:
Where do words come from, I wondered. I still wonder. Because even without books or rather with only prayer books and bloodstock manuals in our house, I had conceived a love of words and assembled my own little crop of them. I believed they had magical associations and that something amazing could be done with them. I had, of course, the language of the Gospels, which to me seemed and seems perfect, and the marvelling narratives of Irish myths and fables. I learnt everything through Irish, except English itself, and I loved both tongues.
Today is (supposedly - at least it's the agreed-upon date) the birthday of William Shakespeare. April 23, 1564.

One of the things I think about when I think about Shakespeare, or one of the things that inevitably comes into my mind, is my late great teacher Doug Moston, who died in 2003 (check out the comments there, too - I don't know any of those people, but they all had worked with Doug at one time or another and found their way to my post. Beautiful). Moston (an awesome awesome teacher) was responsible for getting Shakespeare's first folio (from 1623) published in facsimile. In facsimile, people. So it's basically well-done Xeroxes of the folio's pages. I own it. It's indispensable for actors, I think, but would also be fascinating for anyone interested in Shakespeare in general.
Modern versions of Shakespeare, modern editors ironed out his punctuation, regularizing it, etc. But ... in a lot of cases, the modern editors are looking at these plays as academic texts, works of literature - as opposed to scripts meant for actors to play. If you have the plays in facsimile (ie: how they looked in the first folio) - you can see an even deeper level of Shakespeare's intent as a playwright. Modern editors sometimes have added exclamation points, which I find a bit insulting. An exclamation point is an editorial comment - it says: "Here's how to say this line". It's directorial, mkay? You are saying, with that punctuation: "The emotion behind the line should be THIS." Shakespeare used very little "emotional" punctuation marks in his work. Almost none. He used periods and commas, and that's pretty much it. I don't want some EDITOR to tell me how to play Lady Macbeth.
Let's do a little compare and contrast, shall we?
Awhile back I wrote about what came to be known between me and Michael as the "twixt clock and cock" monologue from Cymbeline which I was working on at the time. I had the folio by me - and I wanted to compare it to the Riverside Shakespeare version - and check it out. Line by line. Fascinating. (And yes - "f" are "s"s in the folio. You get used to it after a while.) Here is how the two stack up, side by side. I'll comment after.
Riverside Shakespeare version:
False to his bed! What is it to be false?
To lie in watch there and to think on him?
To weep 'twixt clock and clock? if sleep charge nature,
To break it with a fearful dream of him
And cry myself awake? that's false to's bed, is it?
Folio version:
Falfe to his Bed? What is it to be falfe?
To lye in watch there, and to thinke on him?
To weepe 'twixt clock and clock? If fleep charge Nature,
To breake it with a fearfull dreame of him
And cry my felfe awake? That's falfe to's bed? Is it?
Let's look at the differences. The first "false to his bed" in the monologue is NOT an exclamation in the folio -although it appears in the Riverside as an exclamation. In the folio it is a QUESTION. Enormous difference, in terms of the playing of it! Also - in terms of the MEANING. What is Imogen DOING here? What is she actually saying?
My interpretation is: when it's a question, she - after reading his letter - is still trying to process what her husband just said to her. She is still in a state of shock, where she must just repeat what she just heard. "False to his bed?" She's stunned, disoriented. She can't believe this has happened. Whereas, with an exclamation mark, like in Riverside - she immediately jumps to the anger and the hurt. She is pissed, and defending herself. "False to his bed!" (Subtext: the NERVE of that guy!)
But no - the folio has it as a question. HUGE difference.
Also, the last line:
In the Riverside, it's all one sentence - with commas added.
"that's false to his bed, is it?"
It's all one thing, one thought. In the folio - it's more choppy. "That's false to his bed? Is it?" Her thought process is still erratic (Olivier was right: the thought is IN THE LINE.) ... so she's asking one question: "That's false to his bed?" Then she realizes she is not done, and questions again: "Is it?"
To me - the folio is MUCH more plain, in terms of emotion. You can feel Imogen's processing of the betrayal - in the punctuation. In the Riverside, it's ironed out a bit - modernized. And so the thought itself has been changed. Tsk tsk tsk.
That's false to his bed? Is it?
I prefer that one.
Let's move on.
In the same way that Shakespeare does not overdo it in terms of exclamation points and emotional punctuation, there are no stage-directions in his plays (as written) except for: Enter and Exeunt. Shakespeare put all of the stage directions INTO the language. Fascinating. If someone needs a torch to see through the darkness, Shakespeare will have the character say something along the lines of, "I can't see. It's too dark. Hand me that torch." The action ("hand me"), the props ("torch"), the motivation ("I can't see"), everything, is all in the language. Modern playwrights would add a stage direction to fill in the blanks: Horatio picks up a torch and squints through the darkness. See the difference? Although it's funny, I knew a playwright once who took the cue from Shakespeare, merely because she had been burned so many times with productions of her plays not being true to her intent. She said, "I have learned that if you want a character to be drinking a cup of coffee during the scene, if you think it is crucial to your plot that your character be drinking coffee - as opposed to tea, or as opposed to not drinking anything at all - you have to have the character say, 'I am going to have a cup of coffee' or something thereabouts. It has to be in the language, not in the stage directions- because then they can't cut it."
Shakespeare's plays, back in the day, were not extensively rehearsed. There wasn't much planning out beforehand. There was a troupe of well-trained actors who could learn things quickly, and knew, basically, how to project their voices, how to fight with swords, and how to play make believe. And because paper was expensive and scarce, they wouldn't be given the whole script - they would only be given their part. Imagine!! So you have to fit it in to the whole, you have to know how to do that. That's where the word "role" comes from: each part was written out on a "roll" of paper, and so you would be handed your "roll" to learn. Moston, as an experiment in classes, would do the same thing ... he would have parts written out on "rolls" and you would have to get up with other actors ... and try to make the scene happen, the way they did back in the day. I mean, people make jokes about Shakespeare's "O! I am slain!"s at the end of sword fights, but if you think about it: that is a stage direction. That is telling the actor (who might not have the whole play at his disposal) Okay. Die now. Those actors at the Globe were pros, man, they knew how to do crap like that ... You see "O I am slain" and you know: Yup. Time to die. Shakespeare doesn't write as a stage direction: Elaborate sword fight. Macbeth eventually dies. Uhm, no. Everything you need to know (as an audience member, and as an actor playing it) is in the language of the play. Marvelous.
The story of the "folio" is an amazing story, and I am so grateful that I studied under Doug Moston, that I worked on Shakespeare, using the folio as opposed to modern versions of the script.
All of this reminds me of something I began on the blog last year and never really followed through with - basically because life happens, and so did Dean Stockwell, and I couldn't keep it going ... but it is on the back burner, as something I would like to continue: read the plays in chronological order - or at least in what is generally agreed-upon to be their chronology - and write posts on each play. I decided to start with Two Gentlemen of Verona - it was either that or Comedy of Errors or the Henrys ... but I went with Two Gents. It was fun - I would like to start that series up again. Many of the plays I have not read in years. There are the old favorites - I read As You Like It and Hamlet for fun, they're plays I dip into all the time - but Richard III? It's been years. Anyway. Just another example of all of my plans and there not being enough time in the damn day.
Came across a very fun article which lets you know only a couple of the phrases (and words) invented (or co-opted) by Shakespeare :
Eaten out of house and home
Pomp and circumstance
Foregone conclusion
Full circle
The makings of
Method in the madness
Neither rhyme nor reason
One fell swoop
Seen better days
It smells to heaven
A sorry sight
A spotless reputation
Strange bedfellows
The world's (my) oyster
And don't forget:
Be not afraid of greatness: some are born great, some achieve greatness, and some have greatness thrust upon them.
Thanks, Bill, for your greatness. Maybe you were born to it. Maybe you achieved it. Maybe it was thrust upon you. Or maybe Christopher Marlowe wrote all the plays, and you just get all the credit. I doubt it, but who knows. Thanks anyway. And happy birthday.
In honor of the Bard, here is a huge post, made up mostly of excerpts from other people. But first - let's look at what the facsimile looks like, what you will get if you look at the folio:

Awesome!!
I'll start with a wonderful excerpt from the book Will in the World: How Shakespeare Became Shakespeare, by Stephen Greenblatt.
Here he discusses Midsummer Night's Dream. One of the cool things about Midsummer is that, of all of his plays, it is the one where scholars have been unable to find a souce for it. Shakespeare did not invent plots, he used stories that were already in existence. But scholars believe that Midsummer may very well be the only one of his plays directly from his imagination.
By 1595, Shakespeare clearly grasped that his career was built on a triumph of the professional London entertainment industry over traditional amateur performances. His great comedy [Midsummer] was a personal celebration of escape as well as of mastery. Escape from what? From tone-deaf plays, like Thomas Preston's A Lamentable Tragedy, Mixed Full of Pleasant Mirth, Containing the Life of Cambises, King of Persia, whose lame title Shakespeare parodied. From coarse language and jog trotting meter and rant pretending to be passion. From amateur actors too featherbrained to remember their lines, too awkward to perform gracefully, too shy to perform energetically, or, worst of all, too puffed up with vanity to perform anything but their own grotesque egotism. The troupe of artisans who perform "Pyramus and Thisbe" -- the weaver Nick Bottom, the bellows-mender Francis Flute, the tinker Tom Snout, the joiner Snug, the tailor Robin Starveling, and their director, the carpenter Peter Quince -- are collectively an anthology of theatrical catastrophes.The laughter in act 5 of A Midsummer Night's Dream -- and it is one of the most enduringly funny scenes Shakespeare ever wrote -- is built on a sense of superiority in intelligence, training, cultivation, and skill. The audience is invited to join the charmed circle of the upper-class mockers onstage. This mockery proclaimed the young playwright's definitive passage from naivete and homespun amateurism to sophisticated taste and professional skill. But the laughter that the scene solicits is curiously tender and even loving. What saves the scene of ridicule from becoming too painful, what keeps it delicious in fact, is the self-possession of the artisans. In the face of open derision, they are all unflappable. Shakespeare achieved a double effect. On the one hand, he mocked the amateurs, who fail to grasp the most basic theatrical conventions, by which they are to stay in their roles and pretend they cannot see or hear their audience. On the other hand, he conferred an odd, unexpected dignity upon Bottom and his fellows, a dignity that contrasts favorably with the sardonic rudeness of the aristocratic spectators.
Even as he called attention to the distance between himself and the rustic performers, then, Shakespeare doubled back and signaled a current of sympathy and solidarity. [Note from Sheila: It occurs to me that this is what Christopher Guest accomplished in Waiting for Guffman. Anyone who has been an actor has suffered through shows like that one. Most of us have done loads of community theatre. You can scoff at it, and scorn it ... and there's a lot to scorn. But Christopher Guest approaches it with affection. Which is why I think that movie is so wonderful. Yes, we laugh at those people, but we love them too. Okay, back to Will.] As when borrowing from the old morality plays and folk culture, he understood at once that he was doing something quite different and that he owed a debt. The professions he assigned the Athenian artisans were not chosen at random -- Shakespeare's London theatre company depended on joiners and weavers, carpenters and tailors -- and the tragedy they perform, of star-crossed lovers, fatal errors, and suicides, is one in which the playwirght himself was deeply interested. In the period he was writing the "Pyramus and Thisbe" parody, Shakespeare was also writing the strikingly similar Romeo and Juliet; they may well have been on his writing table at the same time. A more defensive artist would have scrubbed harder in an attempt to remove these marks of affinity, but Shakespeare's laughter was not a form of renunciation or concealment. "This is the silliest stuff that ever I heard," Hippolyta comments, to which Theseus replies, "The best in this kind are but shadows, and the worst are no worse if imagination amend them." "It must be your imagination, then, and not theirs," is her rejoinder (5.1.207-10) -- the spectators' imagination and not the players' -- but that is precisely the point: the difference between the professional actor and the amateur actor is not, finally, the crucial consideration. They both rely upon the imagination of the spectators. And, as if to clinch the argument, a moment later, at the preposterous suicide speech of Pyramus --
Approach, ye furies, fell.
O fates, come, come,
Cut thread and thrum,
Quail, crush, conclude and quell
(5.1.273-76)-- Hippolyta finds herself unaccountably moved: "Beshrew my heart, but I pity the man" (5.1.279).
When in A Midsummer Night's Dream the thirty-year-old Shakespeare, drawing deeply upon his own experiences, thought about his profession, he split the theatre between a magical, virtually nonhuman element, which he associated with the power of the imagination to lift itself away from the constraints of reality, and an all-too-human element, which he associated with the artisans' trades that actually made the material structures -- buildings, platforms, costumes, musical instruments, and the like -- structures that gave the imagination a local habitation and a name. He understood, and he wanted the audience to understand, that the theatre had to have both, both the visionary flight and the solid, ordinary earthiness.
That earthiness was a constituent part of his creative imagination. He never forgot the provincial, everday world from which he came or the ordinary face behind the mask of Arion.
I think that's kind of a beautiful analysis of that play. Mitchell - (a friend who just played Puck in Indiana Rep's production of Midsummer): what say you?
Additionally, I'm going to post a couple of quotes from a book I positively adore: Michael Schmidt's Lives of the Poets.
This was a book recommended to me by the doppelganger, and I tore through it ferociously. If you like poetry, I highly recommend you pick it up. What's really great about this book (a survey of English-language poets, from Richard Rolle of Hampole to Les Murray - quite a wide span of time) - but what's great about it is that Michael Schmidt is not an academic. He has nothing to do with academia. He is a publisher, and a reviewer. He is a poetry fan. He doesn't write from the dusty halls of a university, and he is not trying to impress. He chooses poets he loves, and tells us why he loves them and why he thinks so-and-so is important. It's a wonderful book, really accessible.
How he deals with Shakespeare is especially interesting. Because this book spans so much time, Shakespeare is just another name on a long long long list ... and yet ... of course ... he overshadows pretty much everything. His shadow even goes backwards, so that the poets that came just before him don't stand a chance either. It's very interesting.
In Michael Schmidt's view, the poet whose legacy suffers the most is Ben Jonson. Here is what he has to say about that:
Jonson suffers one irremediable disability: Shakespeare. Alexander Pope underlines the point in his Preface to the Works of Shakespeare (1725): "It is ever the nature of parties to be in extremes; and nothing is so probable, as that because Ben Jonson had much the more learning, it was said on the other hand that Shakespeare had none at all; and because Shakespeare had much the most wit and fancy, it was retorted on the other, that Jonson wanted both. Because Shakespeare borrowed nothing, it was said that Ben Jonson borrowed everything."In the plays the proximity of Shakespeare does Jonson the most harm, though he writes plays so different from his friend's that they seem distinct in kind and period. Part of that difference is Jonson's poetic balance, deliberate artistry: he knows what he wants to say and has the means of saying it, no more or less. He speaks for his age, while Shakespeare speaks for himself. Jonson's art is normative, Shakespeare's radical and exploratory. In Jonson there's structure and gauged variegation, in Shakespeare movement and warmth. Coleridge disliked the "rankness" of Jonson's realism and found no "goodness of heart". He condemned the "absurd rant and ventriloquism" in the tragedy Sejanus,staged by Shakespeare's company at the Globe. At times Jonson's words, unlike Shakespeare's, tend to separate out and stand single, rather than coalesce, as though he had attended to every single word. His mind is busy near the surface. He is thirsty at the lip, not at the throat....
Dryden's criticism is telling at one point: Jonson "weaved" the language "too closely and laboriously" and he "did a little too much Romanise our tongue, leaving the words he translated almost as much Latin as he found them." Dryden ends with the inevitable verdict: "I admire him, but I love Shakespeare."
The following excerpts are from Schmidt's chapter on Shakespeare.
When drama began to be printed, blank verse was an ugly medium. Printers did their best to set it out prettily but got little enough thanks for their labors. Not wholly unconnected with this, some of my predecessors harbored bad feelings about William Shakespeare. About the work and the way it broke upon the world. Not about the man, born in the same year as Marlowe yet somehow seeming his junior an dhis apprentice. The great painter William Turner once said of Thomas Girtin, who died at twenty-seven, "Had Tommy Girtin lived, I should have starved." But Girtin died, Marlowe died; and Turner lived, Shakespeare lived. Laurels are awarded accordingly.
Poems vs. the plays - here's what Schmidt has to say:
The greatest poet of the age -- the greatest poet of all time, for all his corruptions -- inspires in publishers and in other writers a kind of vertigo. For Donald Davie Shakespeare represents "a vast area of the English language and the English imagination which is as it were 'charged', radio-active: a territory where we dare not travel at all often or at all extensively, for fear of being mortally infected, in the sense of being overborne, so that we cease to speak with our own voices and produce only puny echoes of the great voice which long ago took over that whole terrain for its own." This is true of the plays. But had Shakespeare produced only the epyllia, the Sonnets and the occasional poems, we'd have a much more proportioned view of him, smaller in scale than Jonson, Donne, Spencer and Marlowe. The poems are excellent, but it is the language and vision of the plays that dazzles. The slightly absurd scenario of Venus and Adonis, the excesses of Lucree and the unevent brilliance of the Sonnets would not by themselves have changed the world. Venus and Adonis was, it's true, Shakespeare's most successful poem. By the time he died, ten editions had been published, and six followed in the two decades after his death. There was money in that large, bossy, blowsy goddess almost eating alive the pretty lad. Nowadays it is read because it is by Shakespeare. And Lucree, with its cruel eloquence, its harsh tracing of one of the most brutal tales of rape in the classical repertory, while better balanced and constructed, touches unreflectingly on matters that require a less restrained psychology than the poet can provide...This is a story about poetry, not drama or literal prostitution; the plays I'll leave to someone else. I'm concerned with "the rest", a handful of works that the poet took most seriously; the epyllia Richard Field published, the 154 Sonnets and "The Phoenix and the Turtle". I could add songs from the plays, but once you dip into a drama, where do you stop? A monologue is like an aria, a description can be like a whole pastoral or satire. And which songs are Shakespeare's, which did he pull out of Anon.'s bran tub? Two Gentlemen of Verona, Love's Lavours Lost, A Midsummer Night's Dream, The Merchant of Venic, Much Ado About Nothing, As You Like It, Twelfth Night, Hamlet, Measure for Measure, Cymbeline, A Winter's Tale and The Tempest all include detachable songs, but the plays snared them and that's where they belong.
Shakespeare is so much at the heart -- is the heart -- of this story that even by skirting around him we take his measure. Apart from his genius, Shakespeare had some real advantages. The world for him was new, as it had been for Chaucer. There were the navigators' discoveries, there was the rising power of the monarch, new industry, new learning.
Here Schmidt talks about the mystery hidden within the Sonnets:
The Sonnets have attracted a critical literature second in vastness only to that on Hamlet, and so various that at times it seems the critics are discussing works entirely unrelated. They contain a mystery, and the critic-as-sleuth is much in evidence. Unlike sonnets by his contemporaries, none of these poems has a traced "source" in Italian or elsewhere; most seem to emerge from an actual occasion, an occasion not concealed, yet sufficiently clouded to make it impossible to say for sure what or whom it refers to. Setting these veiled occasions side by side can yield a diversity of plots: a Dark Lady, a Young Man, now noble, now common, now chaste, now desired, possessed, and lost. All we can say for sure is that desire waxes and wanes, time passes. Here certainly, the critic says, are hidden meanings; and where meanings are hidden, a key is hidden too. Only, Shakespeare is a subtle twister. Each sleuth-critic finds a key, and each finds a different and partial treasure. A.L. Rowse found his key, affirming that Shakespeare's mistress was the poet Emilia Lanyer (1569 - 1645), illegitimate daughter of an Italian royal musician and also an intimate of the astrologer Simon Forman, who gives a brief picture of a brave, cunning operator. Her 1611 volume of poem includes ten dediocations and cleverly celebrates the Dowager Countess of Cumberland, the poet's particular quarry, in company with Christ and biblical heroines. The words she attributes to Eve are the first clear glimmer of English feminism in verse. Eve may -- almost innocently -- have handed Adam the apple, but Adam's sons crucified, in the bright light of day and reason, Jesus Christ. "This sin of yours hath no excuse, or end."There is a further mystery: Who is "the only begetter of these ensuing sonnets Mr. W.H." to whom the poet (or the publisher?) wishes "all happiness and that eternity promised by our ever-living poet"? The T.T. who signs the dedication is Thomas Thorpe, publisher-printer in 1609 of the poems: W.H. may have been his friend, who procured the manuscipt, or Shakespeare's lover, or a common acquaintaince - William Herbert, Earl of Pembroke? Henry Wriothesley, Earl of Southampton (dedicatee of the two epyllia)? William Hervey, Southampton's stepfather, getting the poet to encourage his stepson to marry? Much passionate energy is expended on a riddle without a definitive answer. Thomas Thorpe was a mischievous printer. I suspect he knew what he was doing: no title page in history has been more pored over.
You can tell Schmidt is a publisher, right?
Here's more on the Sonnets:
There is not a linear plot to the sequence of the sonnets. Ther are "runs", but they break off; other "runs" begin. Is it a series of sequences, or a miscellany of them? Some editors reorder the poems without success. Sonnets 1 - 126 are addressed to a young man or men; the remainder to a Dark (-haired) Lady. There may be a triangle (or two): the beloveds perhaps have a relationship as well. The poems are charged with passionate ambiguities.Those who read the poems as a sonnet sequence were for a long while baffled. The Sonnets were neglected, or virtually so, until 1780, when they were dusted down and reedited. They did not immediately appeal, but gradually, during the 19th century, they caught fire -- fitfully, like wet kindling. Wordsworth, Keaths, Hazlitt, and Landor failed to appreciate them. Those who love them properly are fewer than those who enjoy them. Those who love them properly are fewer than those who enjoy arguing about them. W.H. Auden argues (credibly) that "he wrote them ... as one writes a diary, for himself alone, with no thought of a public." T.S. Eliot suggests that like Hamlet they are "full of some stuff that the writer could not drag to light, contemplate, or manipulate into art. And when we search for this feeling, we find it, as in the sonnets, very difficult to localise." Now the public clambers over them, prurient, with several dozen authoritative guides.
And now (you can sense reluctantly) Schmidt talks about the plays.
Drama could be profitable: this discovery coincided with "the coming into the field of the first pupils of the new grammar schools of Edward VI", men who did not resent or distrust commerce and entrepreneurship. A new class of "mental adventurers", the classically educated sons of merchants, made the running. Marlowe was the son of a cobbler, Shakespeare of a prosperous glove maker of Stratford-on-Avon, where the poet was born in 1564. Both were provincials, one educated at the grammar school at Stratford, the other at King's School, Canterbury. They were harbingers of the social change that would culminate in the Commonwealth.One of Shakespeare's advantages was an apparent disadvantage. He was not university-trained. "When Shakespeare attempts to be learned like Marlowe, he is not very clever." That is part of the problem with his epyllia. But Ford Madox Ford reminds us that he had "another world to which he could retire; because of that he was a greater poet than either Jonson or Marlowe, whose minds were limited by their university-training to find illustrations, telles quelles, from illustrations already used in the Greek or Latin classics. It was the difference between founding a drawing on a lay figure and drawing or painting from a keen and delighting memory."
Sidney advises: "Look in thy heart and write." In the Sonnets, Shakespeare takes Sidney's counsel without the platonizing the great courtier intended. The heart he looks into is singularly complex and troubled, and the poems he writes from this impure "I" are as full of life as the plays.
I'll let Puck's words that end Midsummer close this post. They seem appropriate:
If we shadows have offended,
Think but this, and all is mended,
That you have but slumber'd here
While these visions did appear.
And this weak and idle theme,
No more yielding but a dream,
Gentles, do not reprehend:
if you pardon, we will mend:
And, as I am an honest Puck,
If we have unearned luck
Now to 'scape the serpent's tongue,
We will make amends ere long;
Else the Puck a liar call;
So, good night unto you all.
Give me your hands, if we be friends,
And Robin shall restore amends.
It's been years since I read this classic novel, but it's been on my radar again - ever since Larry wrote an evocative post about reading James Salter's memoir (I mention Larry's post here - sadly, the link to his site no longer works). Anyway. Haven't written much (at all) about James Salter - I came to him late, and I didn't come to him through A Sport and a Pastime, his most well-known book. The first of his I read was Light Years
and I was very young when I read it, early 20s - and it sounded some kind of chord in me that made me DEEPLY uneasy. It's definitely a middle-aged kind of book - with all its resignations and disappointments and echoey silences- and I think I'm hesitant to pick it up now. But I will never forget my first reading of the book. I felt literally uneasy.
It's hard to describe what he does as a writer, and why it is so good and so singular ... maybe I'll look around for some reviews to see if I can clarify it, if someone else managed to say it perfectly. Even to say "he's a good writer" is absurd. It would be like saying, "Cormac McCarthy can write, bro!" Well, yeah. But ... Methinks we need to create a different definition of "writer" for guys like McCarthy and Salter. Comparing the two may seem rather insane - because there is really nothing similar about them ... McCarthy catapults us into the genocidal American past, and Salter evokes a gentle dying world in the present. Where events happen that form us - but so quickly that they are gone in a second ... leaving us marked, but also somewhat dazed ... did that really happen? But I feel now like I would recognize a Cormac McCarthy sentence if I bumped into it in a dark alley - and the same with Salter's language. I read Salter and there are times when I get that same feeling I got when I was reading Blood Meridian: Oh God ... this is too deep, too deep ... I can't slow down enough to really contemplate it ... must keep moving ...
And then by the end of the book you find yourself flattened. LIKE A BUG. SMUSH. Never to recover 100%. Writers like that sneak up on you. They work their magic subtly. It's not that they do not want to be noticed: their writing is nothing if not startlingly attention-getting. It's that they do not want to be congratulated. Their concentration lies somewhere else entirely.
I read Light Years a million years ago (uhm, light years ago) - and immediately picked up A Sport and a Pastime which is another book that made me almost uneasy. They're quiet books, no noise or chaos ... but there is something at the heart of them that is unbearably sad. I think it was the sense of looking back on a time when you were most alive ... looking back from a more dim drab present ... the sense of loss ... of unrecoverable vitality ... I'm making him sound bleak, and that's about right, but the language is so beautiful, and so simple - so simple - that the bleakness almost feels like a betrayal when it comes. He describes a snowfall so perfectly that you are transported into its beauty and then he jujitsus you with some bleak empty sentiment. Never too proud of himself, never elaborating, always simple and clear. That's the key to his genius. Most of his sentences are short.
My friend Jon wrote in the comments section of my blog:
First of all, "Light Years" is probably one of the best books I've read in the past five years--and is certainly on my "Top Something" list. I was a wreck after reading that. The scene where Ned comes back to his empty house after seeing Ibsen's "The Master Builder?" I think I had a slight heart attack while reading that. Unbelievably powerful. That whole book is like a column of light, each sentence almost literally like a tiny, multi-faceted diamond, shining such focused rays in eternal directions. And I've been meaning to read more of him ever since--can't believe how long I've gone without actually doing it. Onward.
And I responded:
I am so thrilled to read you were as blown over by Light Years as I was. There were quiet moments in the book (like at the end, with the turtle in the woods) where I felt so ... Basically what I want to say is: the book stunned me, and sometimes it was a barely pleasant sensation ... Like, it affected me PERSONALLY. I'm almost afraid to read it again. He is SUCH a good writer.
So I decided to go back and re-read A Sport and a Pastime (I still don't feel ready to look at Light Years again, especially now when my equilibrium is hanging by a thread on a moment-to-moment basis - but if you're reading me, and you like book recs, etc. - all I can say is: READ Light Years. My God!!)
And I come across passages of such simplicity and beauty that I want to grab Salter by the collar and say, "DIVULGE YOUR SECRETS." I wish I could write like this.
A Sport and a Pastime takes place in provincial France ("the real France" as the main character keeps saying) in the 1960s. A Yale dropout hooks up with a French girl. That's it. No big plot machinations. But the imagery, the language ... Again, I can feel myself skimming the surface of it ... it's almost TOO good ... too good to absorb in one sitting. He's deceptively simple. In almost the manner of Hemingway. If you just skim the surface, you'll miss most of it. But Hemingway doesn't let you off the hook, and divulge the subtext ... or when he does? You'll know it. Salter is the same way. He's describing a soccer stadium here. That seems to be all that is going on. But no no no. The deeps he sounds in his writing ...
Four in the afternoon. The trees along the street, the upper branches, are catching the last, full light. The stadium is quiet, some bicycles leaning against the outer wall. I read the schedule once again and then go in, turning down towards the stands which are almost empty. Far away, the players are streaming across the soft grass. There seem to be no cries, no shouting, only the faint thud of kicks.It is the emptiness which pleases me, the blue dimensions of this life. Beyond the game, as far as one can see, are the fields, the trees of the countryside. Above us, provincial sky, a little cloudy. Once in a while the sun breaks out, vague as a smile. I sit alone. There are the glances of some young boys, nothing more. There's no scoreboard. The game drifts back and forth. It seems to take a long, long time. Someone sends a little boy to the far side to chase the ball when it goes out of bounds. I watch him slowly circle the field. He passes behind the goal. He trots a while, then he walks. He seems lost in the journey. Finally he is over there, small and isolated on the sideline. After a while I can see him kicking at stones.
I am at the center of emptiness. Every act seems purer for it, easier to define. The sounds separate themselves. The details all appear. I stop at the Cafe St. Louis. It's like an old school room. The varnish is worn from the curve of the chairs. The finish is gone from the floor. It's one large, yellowing room, huge mirrors on the wall, the same size and position as windows, generous, imperfect. Glass doors along the street. Wherever one looks, it seems possible to see out. They're playing billiards. I listen without watching. The soft click of the balls is like a concert. The players stand around, talking in hoarse voices. The rich odor of their cigarettes ... They're never there in the daytime. It's very different with the morning light upon it, this cafe. Stale. The billiard table seems less dark. The wood is drawing apart at the corners. It's quite old, at least a hundred years I should think, judging from the elaborate legs. Beneath the pale green cloth which is always thrown over it, the felt is worn, like the sleeves of an old suit.
"Monsieur?"
It's the old woman who runs the place. False teeth, white as buttons. Belonged to her husband probably. I can hear them clattering in her mouth.
"Monsieur?" she insists.
Exquisite. Just perfect.
And then there's this bit of observational genius:
The three or four gilded youths of the town, too, slouched on the divans. I know them by sight. One is an angel, at least for betrayal. Beautiful face. Soft, dark hair. A mouth like spoiled fruit. Nothing amuses them - they don't talk until somebody leaves, and then they begin little laughing cuts, sometimes calling over to the barman. The rest of the time they sit in boredom, polishing the gestures of contempt. The angel is taller than the rest. He has an expensive suit and a tie knotted loosely at the neck. Sometimes a sweater. Soft cuffs. I've seen him on the street. He's about seventeen, and he seems less dangerous in the daylight, merely a bad student or a boy already notorious for his vices. He's ready to start seductions. Perhaps he even says it's easy, and that women are simple to get. To believe is to make real, they say. A chill passes through me. I recognize in him a clear strain of assurance which has nothing to imitate, which springs forth intact. It feeds on its own reflection. He looks carefully at himself in the mirror, combing his hair. He inspects his teeth. The maid has let him undress her. She hates him, but she cannot make him go. I try to think of what he's said. He has an instinct for it. He is here to hunt them down, to discover the weaklings. I don't know what he feels - the assassin's joy.
The less said about such writing the better, I think. To analyze it or point out elements that work would be to ruin it. It's perfect, as is. And I'm thinking: A chill ran through you?? A chill runs through me, Mr. Salter, every time I pick up one of your damn books!
It's been almost 20 years since I read this book and I'm still just stunned by it.
Charlotte Brontë was born on this day, in 1816. Here is perhaps the most famous image of the Brontë sisters - a portrait done by their dissipated (and, some say, more of a genius than all of them) brother Branwell:

In honor of Charlotte Brontë, a writer I have always adored, here are a couple of excerpts from her letters, and quotes about her work, etc:
I love this one. This is a letter Charlotte wrote to a good friend. The friend had written to her, asking her for a recommended reading list. Here is Charlotte's reply. For some reason, this letter completely delights me.
"You ask me to recommend you some books for your perusal. I will do so in as few words as I can. If you like poetry, let it be first-rate; Milton, Shakespeare, Thomson, Goldsmith, Pope (if you will, though I don't admire him), Scott, Byron, Campbell, Wordsworth, and Southey. Now don't be startled at the names of Shakespeare and Byron. Both these were great men, and their works are like themselves. You will know how to choose the good, and to avoid the evil; the finest passages are always the purest, the bad are invariably revolting; you will never wish to read them over twice. Omit the comedies of Shakespeare and the Don Juan, perhaps the Cain, of Byron, though the latter is a magnificent poem, and read the rest fearlessly; that must indeed be a depraved mind which can gather evil from Henry VIII, from Richard III, from Macbeth, and Hamlet, and Julius Caesar. Scott's sweet, wild, romantic poetry can do you no harm. Nor can Wordsworth's, nor Campbell's, nor Southey's -- the greatest part at least of his; some is certainly objectionable. For history, read Hume, Rollin, and the Universal History, if you can; I never did. For fiction, read Scott alone; all novels after his are worthless. For biography, read Johnson's Lives of the Poets, Boswell's Life of Johnson, Southey's Life of Nelson, Lockhart's Life of Burns, Moore's Life of Sheridan, Moore's Life of Byron, Wolfe's Remains. For natural history, read Bewick and Audobon, and Goldsmith, and White's History of Selborne. For divinity, your brother will advise you there. I can only say, adhere to standard authors, and avoid novelty."
More quotes and thoughts about Charlotte Brontë below the jump!
Here is what one of my favorite authors, Lucy Maud Montgomery (all my posts about her here), wrote about Charlotte Brontë in her journal quite a bit. Here is one of her comments:
It is customary to regret Charlotte Brontë's death as premature. I doubt it. I doubt if she would have added to her literary fame. Resplendent as her genius was, it had a narrow range. I think she reached its limit. She could not have gone on forever writing 'Jane Eyres' and 'Villette's' and there was nothing in her life and experience to fit her for writing anything else...There was a marked masochistic strain in Charlotte Brontë -- revealing itself mentally, not physically. This accounts for Rochester. He was exactly the tyrant a woman with such a strain in her would have loved, delighting in the pain he inflicted in on her. And this same tendency was the cause of her cruelty to Lucy Snowe -- who was herself. She persecutes Lucy Snowe all through 'Villette' and drowns her lover rather than let the poor soul have a chance at happiness. I can't forgive Charlotte Brontë for killing off Paul Emmanuel. I don't know whether I like Lucy Snowe or not -- but I am always consumed with pity for and sympathy with her, whereas Charlotte delights in tormenting her -- a sort of spiritual vicarous self-flagellation.
Fascinating analysis.
Here is another excerpt from Lucy Maud Montgomery's journal. She loved the Brontë sisters' books, and wrote out her impressions through many re-readings over her lifetime.
Charlotte Brontë only made about 7,000 by her books ... It seems unfair and unjust. What I admire most in Charlotte Brontë is her absolute clear-sightedness regarding shams and sentimentalities. Nothing of the sort could impose on her. And she always hewed straight to the line. I have been asking myself, 'If I had known Charlotte Brontë in life - how would we have reacted upon each other? Would I have liked her? Would she have liked me?' I answer, 'No.' She was absolutely without a sense of humor. She would not have approved of me at all. I could have done her whole heaps of good. A few jokes would have leavened the gloom and tragedy of that Haworth Parsonage amazingly.People have spoken of Charlotte Brontë's 'creative genius'. Charlotte Brontë had no creative genius. Her genius was one of amazing ability to describe and interpret the people and surroundings she knew. All the people in her books who impress us with such a wonderful sense of reality were drawn from life. She herself is Jane Eyre, Lucy Snowe. Emily was Shirley. Rochester, whom she did create, was unnatural and unreal. Blanche Ingram was unreal. St. John was unreal. Most of her men are unreal. She knew nothing of men except her father and brother and the Belgian professor of her intense unhappy love. Emmanuel was drawn from him, and therefore is one of the few men in her books who is real.
Yet another entry in LM Montgomery's journal. In it, she writes about a biography of Charlotte Brontë she just finished, written by EF Benson. The issues of the "Bronte myth" were alive and well even back then.
I do not think Charlotte was in the least like the domineering little shrew he pictures her, anymore perhaps than she was like the rather too saintly heroine of Mrs. Gaskell's biography. I do not put any faith in Beson's theory that Branwell wrote parts of 'Wuthering Heights' and inspired the whole. There is no foundation in the world for it beyond the assertion of two of Branwell's cronies that he read the first few chapters of it to them and told them it was his own. They may have been telling the truth, but I would not put the least confidence in any statement of Branwell's. He was entirely capable of reading someone else's manuscript and trying to pass it off as his own. No doubt he was more in Emily's confidence than Charlotte ever knew and had got possession of her manuscript in some way. Benson blames Charlotte for her unsympathetic attitude to Branwell. I imagine that an angel would have found it rather difficult to be sympathetic. Benson cannot understand a proud sensitive woman's heart. I love Charlotte Brontë so much that I am angry when anyone tries to belittle her. But I will admit that she seemed to have an unenviable talent for disliking almost everyone she met ... And the things she says about the man she afterwards married!
And finally, some compiled quotes from Charlotte Brontë herself:
Conventionality is not morality. Self-righteousness is not religion. To attack the first is not to assail the last. To pluck the mask from the face of the Pharisee is not to lift an impious hand to the Crown of Thorns.
Amen, sister!!
And
It is in vain to say human beings ought to be satisfied with tranquility: they must have action; and they will make it if they cannot find it.
I like this one:
Look twice before you leap.
And:
There is only one difference between a madman and me. I am not mad.
And finally: the opening paragraphs of Jane Eyre:
There was no possibility of taking a walk that day. We had been wandering, indeed, in the leafless shrubbery an hour in the morning; but since dinner (Mrs. Reed, when there was no company, dined early) the cold winter wind had brought with it clouds so sombre, and a rain so penetrating, that further out-door exercise was now out of the question.I was glad of it: I never liked long walks, especially on chilly afternoons: dreadful to me was the coming home in the raw twilight, with nipped fingers and toes, and a heart saddened by the chidings of Bessie, the nurse, and humbled by the consciousness of my physical inferiority to Eliza, John, and Georgiana Reed.
Her books have always been a grand comfort to me, comforting in various stages of my development, because her insights are so wise, she seems to light the way ahead. But they are also exciting books, because so unexpected. You can't get any more unexpected than Jane Eyre. Nothing can prepare you for Mr. Rochester. And the plot that intertwines Jane Eyre's fortunes with his. No matter how many times I have read Jane Eyre, I am still startled by it. The final chapter, where Jane Eyre has that unexplained moment of what could be called astral travel, or ESP, or communication across many miles - she hears him cry out to her - remains one of the most moving chapters of a book I have ever read. And until that moment, it is not clear how things will go. You have given up, you have given up hope, as a reader ... It is quite quite sad. But then, this strange midnight miracle occurs ... The heart lifts up out of the chest in response.
Charlotte Brontë was a good writer but she didn't have Jane Austen's impeccability with language. No, Charlotte's writing is messier, more passionate, more urgent. People behave in incomprehensible ways in her books. Life is very very dark. People are cruel, they are vicious, they are barely civilized. (Her sister Emily went way further in this regard with Wuthering Heights. In Wuthering Heights it is not apparent that civilization or society has ANY bearing on people whatsoever. A terrifying vision of chaos. Charlotte had some at least SOME overlay of civilization, but not too much. Not too much.) And so over and over again, I respond to her books. They do not become predictable, even at the 4th or 5th reading.
Cheers, Charlotte. Thanks for the books you managed to complete before you died. A good life indeed.

Today is the birthday of Irish playwright John Millington Synge - born on this day in 1871. He was author of The Playboy of the Western World, Riders to the Sea, and more - not to mention his wonderful book about his time on the Aran Islands, called, coincidentally, The Aran Islands
. Playboy is now in the history books, not only for being a wonderful play, and part of the theatrical revolution going on in Ireland at the time (the creation of the Abbey Theatre, etc.) - but also because of the riots that broke out when it opened (they are now known as "The Playboy Riots"). Things got so out of hand that a police squad had to stand along the edge of the stage during the performance, so that the actors wouldn't get hurt or mobbed. If I had a time machine, I would LOVE to go back and be there on the opening night of that play.
Synge wrote:
Ireland, for a few years more, we have a popular imagination that is fiery and magnificent, and tender; so that those of us who wish to write start with a chance that is not given to writers in places where the springtime of the local life has been forgotten, and the harvest is a memory only, and the straw has been turned into bricks.
Synge's time out on the Aran Islands, off the wild west coast of Ireland, gave him the nuggets of inspiration for many of his plays. Out there the "native language" was still spoken, out there he could encounter the real Ireland.
Synge had spent a lot of time in Europe, taking courses in French literature, immersing himself in different cultures, reading Baudelaire, writing poems, chasing girls ... You know, all La Boheme stuff. He remained interested in his own country, his own heritage - but there wasn't really a place for him there. (Interesting: NOW it's hard to imagine Ireland without Synge, but he had to TAKE that ground, he had to claim it - it didn't exist before he came along.) Yeats' whole nationalistic literary (and theatrical) movement (in broader terms - the Irish literary revival) drew Synge back to his home country - the Abbey Theatre was formed - things were HAPPENING in Ireland. In retrospect, it all seems inevitable. Of course Synge would not only come back to be part of that movement, but he would end up defining that movement.
Yeats gave Synge a piece of now legendary advice (and this is a direct quote):
Give up Paris, you will never create anything by reading Racine, and Arthur Symons will always be a better critic of French literature. Go to the Arran Islands. Live there as if you were one of the people themselves; express a life that has never found expression.
In the middle of what was, essentially, an Irish cultural revival, Yeats (having been out to the Aran Islands) recognized that there was something untouched out there, a primitive life, Irish language still spoken, the culture not corrupted. Yet. It was a race against time.
The leaders of the cultural movement in Ireland at that time all had the same idea: Inspiration lay in the West of Ireland. Go west. Go west to find the real Ireland. (Interesting, to think of the final paragraphs of Joyce's The Dead (excerpt here).
So Synge took Yeats' advice and went west.
The story of his four trips out to the Islands make up his book The Aran Islands, a wonderful rich travelogue, a classic of the genre. I highly recommend it!! He sits around turf fires with the various storytellers, and listens, and writes the folktales and anecdotes down later. These stories contain the germs of Playboy, the germs of Shadow of the Glen, the germs of Riders. Yeats was right. With all of Yeats' airy-fairy Celtic frippery, he understood that a powerful culture lay beneath the surface, a culture that had never been shown to the world, never been expressed.
Not surprising, then, that Playboy of the Western World would cause such an uproar.
Here is an excerpt from Máire Nic Shiubhlaigh's marvelous book The Splendid Years: Recollections of Máire Shiubhlaigh as told to Edwa, which is the story of the Irish National Theatre. Máire was an actress, highly involved with the cultural revival of the time, and a member of the Abbey Theatre. Her memories of Synge (and also her memories of the "Playboy riots") are fascinating. Here she speaks of Synge:
John M. Synge who came to us with his play direct from the Aran Islands, where the material for most of his later works was gathered, was born near Dublin in 1871, graduated at Trinity College, and shortly afterwards left Ireland for the Continent, living alternately in Germany and France, where he made a rather precarious livelihood as a violinist and contributor to literary magazines. Yeats had discovered him in Paris in about 1897 and, recognizing the quality of his writings, had brought him back to Ireland, where he introduced him to Aran, prophesying that in the beautiful lyrical prose of the western peasant he would find an original vehicle for dramatic composition. He was right. Synge went to Aran for a month, and stayed there, on and off, for a matter of years. He drew his inspiration from the hearths of the tiny whitewashed cabins and the harsh rocks of the western seaboard, gathering tales and expressions from the old and the young of the most picturesque portion of Ireland. In a short life -- he died at the early age of 38 -- he wove them into sombre dramatic tapestries, embroidered with the rhythmic language of the Irish peasant. His prose, highly musical and enriched with flashes of the most beautiful poetry, he devised simly by transcribing direct from the Gaelic of the islands. It is most difficult for an actor to master; most effective if delivered correctly.
She's got that right. I did a scene from Playboy in a class in graduate school, and while my scene partner and I had a hell of a lot of fun working on it, it was DAMN difficult to get that language right. Not just the language, but the rhythm, the tone. It doesn't matter if you get the words all correct, and remember all your lines, if you say them in the wrong rhythm. Rhythm is everything.
Back to Synge.
He was a gentle fellow, shy, with that deep sense of humour that is sometimes found in the quietest people. His bulky figure and heavy black moustache gave him a rather austere appearance -- an impression quickly dispelled when he spoke. His voice was mellow, low; he seldom raised it. But for his quiet personality he might have passed unnoticed at any gathering. During rehearsals of his play, he would sit quietly in the background, endlessly rolling cigarettes. This was a typical gesture, born more of habit than of any desire for tobacco -- he gave away more cigarettes than he smoked. At the first opportunity, he would lever his huge frame out of a chair and come up on to the stage, a half-rolled cigarette in eaach hand. Then he would look enquiringly round and thrust the little paper cylinders forward towards whoever was going to smoke them. In later years he became the terror of fire-conscious Abbey stage-managers. He used to sit timidly in the wings during plays, rolling cigarettes and handing them to the players as they made their exits.
He didn't set out to revolutionize Irish theatre. He didn't set out to be a genius, or to write great plays. He just wrote down what he knew. That was the ONLY way this guy could write. And it turned everything upside down.
Here is Máire's description of some of the objections to Shadow, just to give you an idea of what was going on, and to also set the stage for the "Playboy riots". Synge was, indeed, ahead of his time. The world is rarely kind to those born ahead of their time.
The piece was "un-Irish" wrote some reviewers, an "insult" in fact to the peasant women of Ireland whom Nora Burke was taken to typify. There was an immense verbal furore about it. A number of writers claiming that Synge was slyly attacking the institution known as the "made marriage", and attributing it solely to Ireland, raised all sorts of objections. Others wrote of the character of Nora Burke: "Nora Burke is a lie". Of the play they said: "It is no more Irish than the Decameron. It is a staging of the old-world libel on womankind -- the Widow of Ephesus."Now, I do not propose to analyse the extraordinary attitude adopted towards the play. Indeed, the attacks were launched so suddenly that few of us were even able to gather what they were all about. Perhaps it was that the Irish play-going public of that time was so used to the "genteel" comedy of the established theatre which I mentioned earlier -- the entertaining but not very realistic stuff that was time and again put before it -- that it couldn't swallow a credible satire. In those days if an actress played an unpleasant part, then it followed that she was an unpleasant person. Similarly, if a dramatist wrote a nasty play he was a nasty fellow. Then, of course, there was the fact that Ireland was on the threshold of a renaissance. Everybody, writer, politician, artist, was at pains to eulogise over the beauty of the Irish character. The advent of a comparatively unknown writer who painted an unpleasant if realistic picture of the peasantry at such a time was, to say the least, unwelcome. The Dubliners who raised the loudest objections could not accept In the Shadow of the Glen as a play. They refused to be entertained.
In 1907, the Abbey Theatre produced Playboy of the Western World. Máire, who was there, writes:
The "Playboy Riots", as they came to be known, indicate very clearly some of the difficulties that the Abbey was called upon to face during its first years -- and they show how the theatre, under Yeats, managed to surmount them. When this play is produced in Dublin now it is recognised and enjoyed as a work of art. In 1907 it drove a number of people into such a frenzy that they nearly wrecked the Abbey. I am in rather a good position to describe the riots because I was in the audience during some of them. Curiosity had taken me into the theatre, as it had taken many another person that week.It was about the end of 1906 that Synge finished the Playboy ... Yeats later mentioned that Synge took considerable trouble over the piece and scrapped a number of earlier versions before he fixed on the one which was eventually produced...Yeats never tired of recounting the care which Synge lavished on the piece. This, indeed, may have been indirectly responsible for the reception accorded the play by some sections of the public, whose main argument against it was that it was "a slander on the peasantry of Ireland". As in the case of The Shadow of the Glen, its realism gave offence. The only differnce between it and any other play that did not take was that the public, instead of showing its lack of interest in the accepted way -- by its non-attendance -- displayed its disapproval by rioting in the theatre throughout the play's run. The most unusual feature of the affair was that although the players appeared on the stage and acted their parts for a whole week, the uproar caused by the audience was so great that the play was never really heard on any night but the first, and those who took part in the demonstrations on subsequent occasions were dependent on opinions of the firstnight audience and a few rather hysterical newspaper reports. As the week progressed, the trouble instead of lessening, increased, and before the run of the play was half over, the management felt compelled to call for the assistance of the police to preserve order.
The explanations put forward by the rioters during the week were many and varied and it is worth remarking that no two people appeared to base their objections on exactly the same thing. Some objected to the piece because "it made a hero out of a murderer" (the play deals in part with the welcome accorded by a West of Ireland village to a weak-willed boy who believes he has just killed his father); others claimed that the language used was too strong; more contented themselves by saying that the play was "vicious, untrue, and uncalled for" -- a "hideous caricature" in fact; while a considerable number based their objections on the assumption that the piece was a deliberate attack by Synge on Ireland in retaliation for the manner in which The Shadow of the Glen and The Well of the Saints had been received.
(All of this makes me think of what Joyce said, when it became apparent that no Irish publisher would go near The Dubliners and he would have to look outside his own country for a publisher: "It is not my fault that the odour of ashpits and old weeds and offal hangs round my stories. I seriously believe that you will retard the course of civilization in Ireland by preventing the Irish people from having one good look at themselves in my nicely polished looking-glass."
Máire describes what it was like in the theatre, on the opening night of Playboy of the Western World, January 26, 1907.
The first act went well. There was laughter at the right places and the correct degree of solemnity was maintained when it was demanded. But during the second act I began to feel a tenseness in the air around me -- I was sitting in the pit -- and there were murmurs from the stalls and parts of the gallery. Before the curtain fell it was obvious that there was going to be some sort of trouble. Faint calls and ejaculations like "Oh, no! Take it off!" came from various parts of the house and the atmosphere gradually grew taut. In the third act things really came to a head and those around began to stamp the floor and shout towards the stage, the noise gradually increasing until the voices of the players were drowned. People stood up in their seats and demanded the withdrawal of the play, and when it became clear that the cast was determined to see the thing out to the end, tempers began to fray. The auditorium became a mass of people pulling and pushing in all directions. By the time the curtain fell on the last act, the crowd was arguing and fighting with itself. People in front leaned over the back of seats and demanded quiet -- a lot of people seemed to be doing this -- and those at the back responded by shouting and hissing loudly. The crowd which eventually emerged into the street was in an ugly mood.
Despite vicious and hysterical reviews the play went on. One of the objections was that the word "shift" appeared in the play (meaning: "chemise", or "slip", whatever you want to call it). Christy - the lead character in the play - says - in what is now acknowledged to be a fine piece of dramatic literature, and one of the classic monologues of the stage: "It's Pegeen I'm seeking only, and what'd I care if you brought me a drift of chosen females, standing in their shifts itself, maybe, from this place to the eastern world?" This was seen as a shock and an outrage.
The Press and the public called for the play to be closed, the hysteria mounted, but the Abbey refused to capitulate. Obviously, Synge had struck a nerve. But things were getting out of hand, it was a violent atmosphere in the audience ... and so Yeats tried to quell this fire. Máire describes:
On the third night Yeats addressed the audience before the curtain rose. If anyone had anything to say against the piece they would be welcomed at a debate which he would be glad to arrange in the theatre at some other time. He was interrupted several times. He asked the interrupters to at least listen to the play so that they would know what it was they were objecting to.
It is just like those idiots who protested Scorsese's Last Temptation without even seeing it. I have no patience and no tolerance for people like that. I'm pretty open-minded, you know "live and let live", but everyone has their limits, everyone has their thing that they cannot endure - and I cannot bear people like that. I don't want to listen, or try to "understand where they're coming from". That's the thing. I DO understand where they are coming from, and that is why I have contempt for them. My contempt comes directly FROM understanding. Their sense of themselves is so fragile that it's a house of cards. Even the fact that Scorsese's movie EXISTED threatened their entire world view. Fine. Go home then and read only the Bible and close the blinds and don't let the big bad nasty world touch your precious house of cards, and let those of us who actually want to SEE the movie decide for ourselves.
Such people have always existed. Their complaints are always the same. As a matter of fact, without the idiots, there would have been no such thing as "The Playboy Riots" - which catapulted Irish theatre onto an international stage. So I suppose we should be grateful in a way! Nothing like someone screaming, "NO ONE SHOULD SEE THIS" to make something into a big giant hit.
Back to the Playboy Riots:
As on the first night, the opening passages were listened to quietly, and even evoked a little laughter. Halfway through the second act, however, a murmur arose in the pit and a man a few rows away stood up and, without any apparent reason, hit the person beside him. A gasp ran around the whole house and the lights went up. All around him the crowd was breaking into disorder.Within minutes, the audience in the pit and stalls was completely disorganised, and the crowd in thte back and side galleries was almost as bad. Almost everyone was standing. The noise was deafening. Yeats appeared on the stage and pleaded with the sensible members of the audience to remain quiet. His voice was drowned by catcalls, cheers, much stamping of feet, and from somewhere at the back ,the notes of a toy trumpet which came from the centre of a group of young men who looked like university students. He continued to speak, but his words were apparently objected to by those in front, for a howl of protest went up from the stalls and parts of the side gallery, which increased in volume as those behind joined in or tried to cheer the protest down. On the stage the players stood in little knots, discussing the occurrences amongst themselves.
As the noise increased and several arguments broke out around the theatre, Yeats left his place on the stage. A few minutes later the doors into the auditorium opened and to the horror and surprise of most of those present, a body of police entered. At the same time the curtain came down and a semblance of order was restored -- partly due to the sight of the uniforms ...
After a brief speech by Yeats, and the ejection of the more truculent members of the audience, peace was partially restored, and everyone sat down again. At this stage it would have been impossible for anyone to get out. After everyone had been quietened and the greater part of the audience reseated, it would have been dangerous for anyone to stand up. Those who did so were immediately surrounded by hefty policement and shepherded, not too gently, in the direction of the vestibule.
Meanwhile, the orchestra, a recent addition to the theatre, began to play. The music seemed to help matters somewhat, and things almost returned to what they were before the play began. There was much discussion and gesticulation going on however. The affair was still far from settled.
After some time the orchestra retired, the lights were lowered and the curtain went up. Almost immediately the audience reverted to what it had been before the arrival of the police. Not a word of the play could be heard. The cast eventually gave up speaking altogether and went through the piece in pantomime. [Note from Sheila: God, I wish I had been there to see this. It must have been extraordinary.] As the play progressed the noise increased. Men and women stamped the floor, banged the backs of their seats with their fists, shouted and sang alternately. On the stairs from the stalls a man stood, dramatically addressing no one in particular.
The players courageously went through the whole piece. During this time several arrests were made and the police were kept busy operating between the doors and the hall. Just before the play ended I saw an opportunity to escape and took it. Almost everyone in the row where I had been sitting had vanished. I was able to make a dash for the door at the rear of the pit while the police were busy in the front of the house. My last impression of the scene was the sight of a figure standing on a seat somewhere about the centre of the stalls and the sound of a few bars of God Save the King, which were quickly stifled as someone pulled the singer down.
Amazing. The play continued to be performed, and continued to generate riots and protests, garnering the attention of the world. "What is going on over in Ireland right now? What exactly are they protesting??"
Synge died an early death, in 1909, but he left an indelible mark - not only on Ireland, but on theatre as a whole.
I'll end this post now, with a quote from Synge's beautiful book The Aran Islands (and I will post a photo, too, of Synge staring out into the Atlantic, from one of the Islands).
In the following excerpt, he describes leaving the Arans after a couple months' stay ... and returning to the bustle of Galway:
I have come out of an hotel full of tourists and commercial travellers, to stroll along the edge of Galway Bay, and look out in the direction of the islands. The sort of yearning I feel towards those lonely rocks is indescribably acute. This town, that is usually so full of wild human interest, seems in my present mood a tawdry medley of all that is crudest in modern life. The nullity of the rich and the squalor of the poor give me the same pang of wondering disgust; yet the islands are fading already and I can hardly realize that the smell of the seaweed and the drone of the Atlantic are still moving round them.

... with Evelyn Waugh... available at last. Marvelous!!
One quote of many:
I clearly can’t make myself understood. There is no such thing as a man in the street. There is no ordinary run of mankind, there are only individuals who are totally different. And whether a man is naked and black and stands on one foot in Sudan or is clothed in some kind of costume in a bus in England, they are still individuals of entirely different characters.
He is asked what faults he would excuse in others. He replies:
"Drunkenness." Any others? "Em [long pause] ... anger. Lust. Dishonouring their father and mother. Coveting their neighbour's ox, ass, wife. Killing. I think there's almost nothing I can't excuse except perhaps worshipping graven images. That seems to be idiotic."
I ADORE him. I still count reading Scoop as one of the funnest (and funniest) reading experiences I have ever had. I remember sitting on the bus, going home, surrounded by people, and I started snorting, tears of laughter streaming - yes, streaming! - down my face, and I could no longer see the page and had to put the book down for a bit, to just guffaw like a maniac, all by myself.
From Baroque in Hackney.
Speaking of Evelyn Waugh, here is Ted's review of Bright Young Things.

Christopher Smart - a poet born on this day in 1722 - spent over 10 years of his life in mental institutions (which at that time in history were even more horrific than they are today). He suffered from a form of religious hysteria - he would drop to his knees in public and pray to God. Seems a rather harmless form of madness to me. He was a highly educated man - and his poems have a Blakean ecstasy to them - and are very difficult to pin down or even talk about. While "inside" - he wrote the poem below to his cat Jeoffry. It is one of my favorite poems of all time. I never get tired of it. Can't you just see Jeoffry? Isn't his cat-ness just perfectly captured? And isn't the glory of God so often seen in the innocent creatures of the earth? That was Smart's whole bag. I love it, though, because I can SEE that cat ... from the 1700s. It could be any cat today. Beautiful.
Allen Ginsberg counted Smart as one of his main influences - which shows you how far Smart's verse was able to travel. The guy wasn't just ahead of his time. He was timeless. I've put some quotes about him below his poem. I LOVE Christopher Smart.
For I Will Consider My Cat Jeoffry
For I will consider my Cat Jeoffry.
For he is the servant of the Living God duly and daily serving him.
For at the first glance of the glory of God in the East he worships in his way.
For this is done by wreathing his body seven times round with elegant quickness.
For then he leaps up to catch the musk, which is the blessing of God upon his prayer.
For he rolls upon prank to work it in.
For having done duty and received blessing he begins to consider himself.
For this he performs in ten degrees.
For first he looks upon his forepaws to see if they are clean.
For secondly he kicks up behind to clear away there.
For thirdly he works it upon stretch with the forepaws extended.
For fourthly he sharpens his paws by wood.
For fifthly he washes himself.
For sixthly he rolls upon wash.
For seventhly he fleas himself, that he may not be interrupted upon the beat.
For eighthly he rubs himself against a post.
For ninthly he looks up for his instructions.
For tenthly he goes in quest of food.
For having consider'd God and himself he will consider his neighbour.
For if he meets another cat he will kiss her in kindness.
For when he takes his prey he plays with it to give it a chance.
For one mouse in seven escapes by his dallying.
For when his day's work is done his business more properly begins.
For he keeps the Lord's watch in the night against the adversary.
For he counteracts the powers of darkness by his electrical skin and glaring eyes.
For he counteracts the Devil, who is death, by brisking about the life.
For in his morning orisons he loves the sun and the sun loves him.
For he is of the tribe of Tiger.
For the Cherub Cat is a term of the Angel Tiger.
For he has the subtlety and hissing of a serpent, which in goodness he suppresses.
For he will not do destruction, if he is well-fed, neither will he spit without provocation.
For he purrs in thankfulness, when God tells him he's a good Cat.
For he is an instrument for the children to learn benevolence upon.
For every house is incomplete without him and a blessing is lacking in the spirit.
For the Lord commanded Moses concerning the cats at the departure of the Children of Israel from Egypt.
For every family had one cat at least in the bag.
For the English Cats are the best in Europe.
For he is the cleanest in the use of his forepaws of any quadruped.
For the dexterity of his defence is an instance of the love of God to him exceedingly.
For he is the quickest to his mark of any creature.
For he is tenacious of his point.
For he is a mixture of gravity and waggery.
For he knows that God is his Saviour.
For there is nothing sweeter than his peace when at rest.
For there is nothing brisker than his life when in motion.
For he is of the Lord's poor and so indeed is he called by benevolence perpetually--Poor Jeoffry! poor Jeoffry! the rat has bit thy throat.
For I bless the name of the Lord Jesus that Jeoffry is better.
For the divine spirit comes about his body to sustain it in complete cat.
For his tongue is exceeding pure so that it has in purity what it wants in music.
For he is docile and can learn certain things.
For he can set up with gravity which is patience upon approbation.
For he can fetch and carry, which is patience in employment.
For he can jump over a stick which is patience upon proof positive.
For he can spraggle upon waggle at the word of command.
For he can jump from an eminence into his master's bosom.
For he can catch the cork and toss it again.
For he is hated by the hypocrite and miser.
For the former is afraid of detection.
For the latter refuses the charge.
For he camels his back to bear the first notion of business.
For he is good to think on, if a man would express himself neatly.
For he made a great figure in Egypt for his signal services.
For he killed the Ichneumon-rat very pernicious by land.
For his ears are so acute that they sting again.
For from this proceeds the passing quickness of his attention.
For by stroking of him I have found out electricity.
For I perceived God's light about him both wax and fire.
For the Electrical fire is the spiritual substance, which God sends from heaven to sustain the bodies both of man and beast.
For God has blessed him in the variety of his movements.
For, tho he cannot fly, he is an excellent clamberer.
For his motions upon the face of the earth are more than any other quadruped.
For he can tread to all the measures upon the music.
For he can swim for life.
For he can creep.
"Christopher Smart wrote A Song to David in a lunatic asylum, and when his collected poems were published in 1791, it was omitted as 'not acceptable to the reader'. This poem is formally addressed to David - Smart knew that he was no madder than King David had been, and a tradition survives that he scrabbled the verses with a key on the wall of his cell." -- Robert Graves
"I do not think he ought to be shut up. His infirmities were not noxious to society. He insisted on people praying with him; and I'd as lief pray with Kit Smart as anyone else. Another charge was that he did not love clean linen, and I have no passion for it." -- Dr. Johnson
"It is not impossible that when Smart is judged over the whole range of his various productions - conventional in form as well as unconventional, light and even ribald as well as devotional, urbane or tender as well as sublime - he will be thought of as the greatest English poet between Pope and Wordsworth." -- Donald Davie
"Pope's 'Messiah' is not musical, but Smart's 'Song to David', with its pounding thematic words and the fortissimo explosion of its coda, is a musical tour de force." -- Northrop Frye
"Smart goes where Gray could not: enthusiasm and vaticism overflow from a full if troubled spirit. He is not an imitator even in his translations, which hold the original in a form and language that make no concessions. He feels and conveys the force of the poetry he admires. His intuition is attuned to a broad tradition, not caught in the rut of convention. Marcus Walsh calls Smart's mature style 'mannered, religiose, and self-conscious' - and each becomes a positive critical term, for together they produce a 'homogenous' style that 'unifies' - the crucial word - 'a number of divergent influences.' It is the paradoxical combination of influences, biblical and classical, and the disruptions his imagination registers, that make him outstanding and eccentric. Learning and accidents of biography deliver him from the bondage of Augustan convention into the sometimes anarchic, vertiginous freedom of Jubilate Agno and the originality of the Song to David. He has few heirs". -- Michael Schmidt
More on this fascinating poet here.
Me: "He didn't write many books, did he?"
Dad: "No. He spent all his time paring them down, cutting out everything that didn't fit. There's no fat in his books."
Amen. Finished The Pornographer today in a rowdy Irish pub, got my beer and a book ... found myself in tears at the end. He's sneaky, that McGahern. He doesn't overdo it. He doesn't overstate it. But when he makes his point, you are stripped bare of any defenses, and left naked, shivering, resentful, and yet grateful.
So no. He didn't write that many novels. He was too busy cutting the fat out of them. How many many writers I can think of who could learn from his example.
Thank you, Dad.
An absolutely wonderful interview with Irish author John Banville in The Village Voice. I love his humor, and I have always loved his ego. It's towering, and it makes no friends. But then he always ends up by saying something self-deprecating which takes the edge off. It's so Irish. John Banville has been writing novels for years - he's one of my father's favorite writers ... and recently he began writing books under another name - Benjamin Black ... there was no secret about it, though. In the "Benjamin Black" books, there are author photographs of Banville, so it's clear that he wrote the books ... it's just that he's interested in working on something else at the moment, at NOT writing a "John Banville" book. It's an alter ego.
I love this, he says:
Benjamin Black writes very quickly indeed. . . . I'd never written like this before. March of 2005, I went to Italy to stay with a friend of mine. She gave me a room, and I sat down at nine one Monday morning and I thought: I don't know whether I'll be able to do this or not. But by lunchtime I'd written 1,500 words, which for John Banville would have been absolutely unheard of. If I write 1,500 in a week as John Banville, I'm doing very well. I discovered in myself a facility for this kind of writing.
Wonderful! I totally understand the uses of personae ... I used to do way more of that ... it would help me deal with little Sheila-isms that hold me back (shyness, insecurity) ... I would choose who I would want to be for a night, and my clothes would reflect that. It's a way of hiding, sure, but hiding is WAY under-rated - you just have to be good at it, so that you don't seem like you're hiding. Choosing a persona is a way to step out into the light. Maybe only artists behave this way ... because, for the most part, we are social misfits. I'm shy, introverted, and very weird. Most of my friends are the same way. But the way we behave can be outrageous - because that's who we are, how we express ourselves. If I just walked around as myself all the time ... Jeez, what's the fun in that? Also, I would get NOTHING done, because my natural tendency is towards a hermit-like monastic existence. Mitchell and I would be getting ready to go out, and I'd be picking out an outfit - and one night he said to me, "Your clothes aren't clothes, you know. They're costumes." And that's so true! I would say, "Tonight I'm going for a kind of Natalie Wood in Rebel Without a Cause thing ..." as I put on my leather jacket and wrapped a long filmy red scarf around my neck. Or, "I think tonight I'm Ann Margaret" as I put on my black bustier, my long flowing pants, and I made my hair HUGE - a bouffant to end all bouffants. Sometimes Mitchell would call it. He'd look at me and say, oh, "You look like a disaffected spoiled member of some defunct royal family." (I don't know, I think he's right!) It's a joke now to say "It is better to look good than to feel good ..." but for me there is certainly a lot of truth in that. Anyway, I've always felt freer, more uninhibited, more my TRUE self, when I'm onstage, saying somebody else's words, acting like I am somebody else.
And Banville is kind of speaking to that ... how he was freed up when he was writing as Benjamin Black - even though he's the same guy! How wonderful!
Banville also says:
I'm having much too much fun as Benjamin Black. I'll have to pay for it. I'm Irish. This is what we do—guilt.
Now you're speakin' my language.
I read Christine Falls, his first Benjamin Black book, in one sitting, while I was waiting in O'Hare for 10 hours ... to get on a flight - ANY flight - going ANYwhere vaguely near New York City. Some thoughts on the book here. If you like crime novels, then this is one you do not want to miss. It's a noir - with the murky almost muffled atmosphere of any classic noir. Big grand secrets are hiding behind the damask tablecloths, the thick drawn curtains of Dublin's Georgian-era houses. And it is Quirke - the unlikely hero - the alcoholic haunted coroner - who finds himself obsessed by the murder of Christine Falls ... there's something "off" about it, he can almost smell the cover up ... but why? Dead girls are not unusual to a coroner. But this one is different. Banville evokes the quiet intense atmosphere of Dublin in the 1950s - way before the Celtic Tiger came into existence ... and you can almost smell the wet wool drying on the clanging radiators, you can hear the stillness of the Sunday mornings, when the town is shut down and everyone is in church ... and you can taste the stale whiskey on a hungover morning. It's terrific writing. But the book is also a page-turner of the first order. Whodunit? And why? Powerful people are implicated. Quirke is struggling to even get through the day, he has his own torment to deal with ... but he's like a dog with a bone. He can't let it go.
The sequel just came out - The Silver Swan - same characters, different case - and I can't wait to read it.
April is National Poetry Month. I'll lead off here with my favorite poem, one I come back to again and again and again ...At times, it's been a life raft. I'm sad right now. I'm sad about so many things. I'm sad for other people in my life and what they are going through, I am sad for myself and what I am going through. I woke up at 4 am this morning weeping. I was having a really really sad dream, I guess. I am not looking for a life raft right now, because the sadness is too acute. But reading over "the More Loving One' this morning ... well. What it says is very difficult. It is not an easy truth. It is not pat, or facile, or easy. It is the hardest truth of all to grasp. When one is in the darkness, how on earth do you learn to love it? Or accept it enough that it seems normal? I don't have the answer to that. The poem never fails to knock me on my ass. I hate Auden for it. I want to punch him in the face and say, "The dark will be sublime? How DARE you say that? How dare you? " But there's a gentleness to Auden, a kindness. That kindness is all in the last line of the poem. If that last line weren't there, the message would be too much to handle, I think. When life is sad, you don't want be to told, "This too shall pass." Everyone's sadness is singular. It's a dark tunnel. We all have to go through it. But the last line of his poem gives us breathing room. Says, "It's okay. It won't happen now ... maybe not tomorrow or even next year ... it will take a little time ... it will take a little time ..." I have ranted before about the idiots who say "Time heals all wounds". I am convinced that those who say such stupid things have never really been wounded, otherwise they wouldn't spout such moronic pablum. People ARE marked by events. We may heal, we move on, but we are MARKED. Every event leaves a scar of some kind. It heals, but not completely. And ALL wounds? Really? Time heals ALL wounds? Oh, really? ALL wounds? Every single one? Tell that to mothers who had to watch their babies heads get bashed against the wall by some SS guard in line at Auschwitz. Don't even get me started.) And, to me, Auden's poem expresses that ambiguity, that darkness. That knowledge that you will NOT go back to who you were before. The stars will not return. THAT would be time healing completely - to have the heavens reappear, as they used to be. But no. The challenge for us, as living thinking evolving beings, is how to find the "total dark" sublime. It seems impossible. Especially at 4 in the morning when things get too hard, when the darkness is so total. But Auden is gentle, as I mentioned before. And lines 7 and 8 are words to live by. I try. I really do.
Below the poem I've posted a compilation of quotes about and by Auden. (The anecdote described by Edward Mendelsohn moves me terribly. It approaches explaining why it is that Auden is so important to me. He's not just a wonderful writer - but there are times when he teaches me how to live. Or at least gives me guide posts.) This is why one keeps a "commonplace book" - so you can grab quotes easily when you need them. Last year I did a post a day about different poets through National Poetry Month - and because it's only a month long I had to leave out some of my favorites. I'll be doing more of that this month, as the spirit moves me.
But first, the most important thing.
The poem.
The More Loving One by WH Auden
Looking up at the stars, I know quite well
That, for all they care, I can go to hell,
But on earth indifference is the least
We have to dread from man or beast.
How should we like it were stars to burn
With a passion for us we could not return?
If equal affection cannot be,
Let the more loving one be me.
Admirer as I am
Of stars that do not give a damn,
I cannot, now I see them, say
I missed one terribly all day.
Were all stars to disappear or die,
I should learn to look at an empty sky
And feel its total dark sublime,
Though this might take me a little time.
W.H. Auden

"The subject of his poetry is the struggle, but the struggle seen, as it were, by someone who whilst living in one camp, sympathises with the other; a struggle in fact which while existing externally is also taking place within the mind of the poet himself, who remains a bourgeois." - Edgell Rickword, "Auden and Politics"
"I think of Mr. Auden's poetry as a hygiene, a knowledge and practice, based on a brilliantly prejudiced analysis of contemporary disorders, relating to the preservation and promotion of health, a sanitary science and a flusher of melancholia. I sometimes think of his poetry as a great war, admire intensely the mature, religious, and logical fighter, and deprecate the boy bushranger." -- Dylan Thomas
"One Sunday afternoon in March 1922, a friend suggested that I should [write poetry]: the thought had never occurred to me." -- WH Auden
"For more than a year I read no one else." -- WH Auden - on Thomas Hardy
"Never write from your head, write from your cock." -- WH Auden, in a letter to a friend
"The need to find an expression for his homosexuality was the first technical obstacle to check the torrential course of Auden's unprecedented facility. A born master of directness was obliged straightaway to find a language for indirection, thus becoming immediately involved with the drama that was to continue for the rest of his life - a drama in which the living presence of technique is the antagonist." -- Clive James
"Auden: great poet or great representative poet? A poet or a 'classic of our prose'? He overhsadows the poets of his generation. He is Chaucer to the Gower of Betjeman and the Langland of MacNeice." -- Michael Schmidt
"Then, in June 1933, Auden experienced what he later called a 'Vision of Agape'. He was sitting on a lawn with three colleagues from the school where he was teaching, when, he wrote, 'quite suddenly and unexpectedly, something happened. I felt myself invaded by a power which, though I consented to it, was irresistible and certainly not mine. For the first time in my life I knew exactly - because, thanks to the power, I was doing it - what it meant to love one's neighbor as oneself.' Before this, his poems had only been able to celebrate moments of impersonal erotic intensity, which he called 'love'. Now, in the poem 'Out on the lawn I lie in bed,' prompted by his vision, he had praise for everything around him." -- Edward Mendelson (More on that poem and the moment that inspired it here)
More information on Auden here.
TO: LEONARD WOOLF
Rodmell,
Sussex
Tuesday (18? March 1941)
Dearest, I feel certain I am going mad again. I feel we can't go through another of those terrible times. And I shan't recover this time. I begin to hear voices, and I can't concentrate. So I am doing what seems the best thing to do. You have given me the greatest possible happiness. You have been in every way all that anyone could be. I don't think two people could have been happier till this terrible disease came. I can't fight any longer. I know that I am spoiling your life, that without me you could work. And you will I know. You see I can't even write this properly. I can't read. What I want to say is I owe all the happiness of my life to you. You have been entirely patient with me and incredibly good. I want to say that - everybody knows it. If anybody could have saved me it would have been you. Everything has gone from me but the certainty of your goodness. I can't go on spoiling your life any longer.
I don't think two people could have been happier than we have been.
V.

March 28, 1941. After writing that note to her husband, Virginia Woolf put rocks in her pockets and drowned herself in the River Ouse.
Will you do a total stranger the kindness of reading his verse?Thank you!
Thomas Lanier Williams
-- Tennessee Williams, letter to editor Harriet Monroe, March 11, 1933

"You're always having to compete with yourself. They always say, 'It's not as good as Streetcar or Cat'. Of course it's not. At 69, you don't write the kind of play you write at 30. You haven't got the kind of energy you used to have."-- Tennessee Williams
In 1928, Tennessee Williams wrote in a letter to his beloved grandfather:
I have been reading a good number of biographies this year which I am sure you will commend. Probably you remember how I picked up that volume of Ludwig's Napoleon on the boat and liked it so well that the owner had to ask me for it. I tried to get it at the library but it was out. Instead i got a life of the Kaiser Wilhelm by the same author. Since then I hve read several others of celebrated literary personages. I have one at home now about Shelley, whose poetry I am studying at school. His life is very interesting. He seems to have been the wild, passionate and dissolute type of genius: which makes him very entertaining to read about.
Tennessee Williams said the following about Streetcar (excerpt here), and his main point of that entire play:
There are no 'good' or 'bad' people. Some are a little better or a little worse but all are activated more by misunderstanding than malice. A blindness to what is going on in each other's hearts. Stanley sees Blanche not as a desperate, driven creature backed into a last corner to make a last desperate stand - but as a calculating bitch with 'round heels'.... Nobody sees anybody truly but all through the flaws of their own egos. That is the way we all see each other in life.
Tennessee Williams wrote the following elegiac essay about Laurette Taylor (who created the role of Amanda so memorably in Glass Menagerie (excerpt here) and made him star) for The New York Times after news of her death in 1949:
I do not altogether trust the emotionalism that is commonly indulged in over the death of an artist, not because it is necessarily lacking in sincerity but because it may come too easily. In what I say now about Laurette Taylor I restrict myself to those things which I have felt continually about her as apart from any which this unhappy occasion produces.Of course the first is that I consider her the greatest artist of her profession that I have known. The second is that I loved her as a person. In a way the second is more remarkable. I have seldom encountered any argument about her preeminent stature as an actress. But for me to love her was remarkable because I have always been so awkward and diffident around actors that it has made a barrier between us almost all but insuperable.
In the case of Laurette Taylor, I cannot say that I ever got over the awkwardness and the awe which originally were present, but she would not allow it to stand between us. The great warmth of her heart burned through and we became close friends.
I am afraid it is the only close friendship I have ever had with a player...
It is our immeasurable loss that Laurette Taylor's performances were not preserved on the modern screen. The same is true of Duse and Bernhardt, with whom her name belongs. Their glory survives in the testimony and inspiration of those who saw them. Too many people have been too deeply moved by the gift of Laurette Taylor for that to disappear from us.
In this unfathomable experience of ours there are sometimes hints of something that lies outside the flesh and its mortality. I suppose these intuitions come to many people in their religious vocations, but I have sensed them more clearly in the work of artists and most clearly of all in the art of Laurette Taylor. There was a radiance about her art which I can compare only to the greatest lines of poetry, and which gave me the same shock of revelation as if the air about us had been momentarily broken through by light from some clear space beyond us.
The last word that I received from her was a telegram which reached me early this fall. It was immediately after the road company of our play had opened in Pittsburgh. The notices spoke warmly of Pauline Lord's performance in the part of Amanda. "I have just read the Pittsburgh notices," Laurette wired me. "What did I tell you, my boy? You don't need me."
I feel now - as I have always felt - that a whole career of writing for the theatre is rewarded enough by having created one good part for a great actress.
Having created a part for Laurette Taylor is a reward I find sufficient for all the effort that went before and any that may come after.
It was a two-sided deal there. Her performance launched him into stardom. And his creation of Amanda revitalized her career just in time for her to capitalize on it. She would be dead in a couple of years. She had had a great career early in her life, and went on a 10 year binge following the death of her husband. Laurette Taylor was "washed up". Until ...
And now, she's a legend, her performance in Glass Menagerie is legendary. "What did I tell you, my boy, you don't need me..." Ha. That's what you think, Laurette! But in a way, she was completely right. The play is better than any one performance. The play didn't depend on Laurette Taylor's genius, although thank God she found the vehicle. The star of the play is actually the play itself, and Laurette Taylor knew that. The star of the play was this new voice of Tennessee Williams. And so no, Tennessee didn't "need" her. And about Tennessee saying: "I consider her the greatest artist of her profession that I have known." Anyone who knows anything about theatre would be hard-pressed to disagree. I haven't even SEEN the woman act, obviously, but I don't need to. I will take the hundreds and hundreds of eyewitness' word for it. In the same way that I know, in my heart, that Eleanora Duse was one of the "greatest artists of her profession" as well. I don't need to have seen her live. (My post about Laurette Taylor here.)
Here's a treat for all you Tennessee and Laurette fans. Here is one of the original reviews of Glass Menagerie, after its premiere on an icy winter night in Chicago. This review focuses on the miracle that was Laurette Taylor's performance.
January 14, 1945MEMO FROM CHICAGO By Lloyd Lewis
CHICAGO - As this is written there exists doubt as to whether Eddie Dowling has anything more satisfying than an artistic success in his new production, "The Glass Menagerie", at the Civic Theatre, but there is no doubt whatsoever that he has brought back Laurette Taylor as a great character actress.
Not since she did "Peg o'My Heart," exactly thirty years ago, has she been so talked and written about.
In "The Glass Menagerie," which is a tenuous and moody tragedy from the pen of Tennessee Williams, she plays a decaying Delta belle overfond of haranguing her two children, one a warehouse worker (Mr. Dowling) and the other a morbidly bashful maiden (Julie Haydon), upon their duty to rise above the drabness of life in a St. Louis alley flat. Fumbling around the dolorous precincts of her home in a slipshod Mother Hubbard, she is forever reciting the plantation glories of her youth, how seventeen young gentlemen callers were forever complimenting her among the magnolias, and how she could have had this or that grandson instead of the captivating plebeian drunk who took her only to desert her and leave her to current St. Louis blues.
When Miss Taylor mumbles in magnificent realism she is still enough of a vocal wizard to be intelligible to her audiences, and when she pouts, nags or struts in pathetic bursts of romantic memory she is superb as a pantomime. Her descents into hysteria are masterpieces of understatement, dramatic in that they force her audience to do the acting for her.
She accomplishes her tour de force of acting without a single gesture which could be charged with showmanship. Some of her most telling lines are fumbling mutterings delivered over her shoulder. And in a scene wherein she prods her son into bringing home somebody, anybody, who might possibly marry his psychopathic sister before he himself wanders off, as his mother knows he will, into the big, blue and tipsy yonder, she gives a performance that could fit into the best of the Abbey Theatre's Irish plays.
One moment she is a ridiculous pretender and the next only a poor old woman dreading so soon to be dead because her helpless daughter will then be alone. When a 'caller' is eventually dragooned and brought to the house for dinner, Miss Taylor's appearance in an ancient taffety and high-toned manners is a delicate feat in the creation of that narrow line between the absurd and the sad.
Oh. Oh. For a time machine.
Here's a picture of Tennessee Williams out on his beloved Key West in 1980:

Make voyages. Attempt them. That's all there is.-- Tennessee Williams, "Camino Real"
(Excerpt from Camino Real here. "I've outlived the tenderness of my heart." My God.)
I realized things about myself - and my life - through working on Miss Alma in Summer and Smoke (excerpt here) - that forever changed me. My journal entries from that time are fascinating for me to look back on. I actually grew as a human being, while working on that play. Sheila and Alma had merged. It's one of the only times that's ever happened. Funny: I love to post my Diary Friday excerpts from high school days, because haw haw haw we can all sort of chuckle at the exuberance and silliness of youth. But I would very much hesitate to post those Sheila/Alma entries - which were, first of all, much more recent - but also - I don't know if I would ever want to expose that side of myself here. That is the real Artist Sheila. I couldn't bear to have anyone roll their eyes or chuckle at HER. NOBODY can tell me that Alma is "just" a character in a play. She LIVES, she breathes. I certainly felt possessed by her.
A cord breaking.
1000 miles away.
Rose.
Her head cut open. A knife thrust in her brain.
Me. Here. Smoking.
-- Tennessee Williams, journal entry, Marcy 24, 1943 - after hearing about his sister's lobotomy
All at once, I found myself hammed in by three women in basic black who had been to the Saturday matinee and had apparently thought of nothing since except the problems of Alma Winemiller, the heroine of "Summer and Smoke". When you are eating, a great deal can be accomplished by having a mouth full of food and by making gutteral noises instead of speech when confronted with questions such as, What is the theme of your play? What happens to the characters after the play is over? What is your next play about and how do you happen to know so much about women? On that last one you can spit the food out if it really begins to choke you.For a writer who is not intentionally obscure, and never, in his opinion, obscure at all, I do get asked a hell of a lot of questions which I can't answer. I have never been able to say what was the theme of my play and I don't think I have ever been conscious of writing with a theme in mind. I am always surprised when, after a play has opened, I read in the papers what the play is about, that it was about a decayed Southern belle trying to get a man for her crippled daughter, or that it was about a boozie floozie on the skids, or that a backwoods sheik in a losing battle with three village vamps.
Don't misunderstand me. I am thankful for these highly condensed and stimulating analyses, but it would never have occurred to me that that was the story I was trying to tell. Usually when asked about a theme I look vague and say, "It is a play about life." What could be simpler, and yet more pretentious? You can easily extend that a little and say it is a tragedy of incomprehension. That also means life. Or you can say it is a tragedy of Puritanism. That is life in America. Or you can say that it is a play that considers the "problem of evil". But why not just say "life"?
To return to the women in the alcove. On this particular occasion the question that floored me was, "Why do you always write about frustrated women?"
To say that floored me is to put it mildly, because I would say that frustrated is almost exactly what the women I write about are not. What was frustrated about Amanda Wingfield? Circumstances, yes! But spirit? See Helen Hayes in London's "Glass Menagerie" if you still think Amanda was a frustrated spirit! No, there is nothing interesting about frustration, per se. I could not write a line about it for the simple reason that I can't write a line about anything that bores me.
Was Blance of "A Streetcar Named Desire" frustrated? About as frustrated as a beast of the jungle! And Alma Winemiller? What is frustrated about loving with such white hot intensity that it alters the whole direction of your life, and removes you from the parlor of the Episcopal rectory to a secret room above Moon Lake Casino?
I came across this essay when I was working on Alma Winemiller - and I can't tell you how much of an "A-ha!" moment it gave me. If I felt drawn towards portraying her as sexually FRUSTRATED, or emotionally FRUSTRATED ... I remembered Tennessee's words. I remembered the truth of them. Do not play the frustration. How boring. Play the OBJECTIVE, play the DESIRE, play what you WANT with all your heart ... Let the CIRCUMSTANCES of the play frustrate you ... but never ever take your eye off your objective. And THAT is where the tragedy lies.
Brilliant. So so helpful to any actress who works on ANY of his great parts to keep in mind.
I love that drive in him - the drive to pour all of the darkness and fear from his background into his work - he was a man driven to do so - it was therapeutic for him, yes, but never just therapy. Art that is just therapy is usually bad art. Or - perhaps not bad - but it will not stand the test of time. Tennessee worked on his craft, and always cared more about the PLAY than about the personal demons exorcised by said play. Read his letters, his journals, his instructions to directors ... the level of detail there is astonishing. Really inspiring to me. To be such a great artist, but to also have such an understanding of craft, and structure.
"Nothing's more determined than a cat on a tin roof - is there? Is there, baby?"-- from Cat on a Hot Tin Roof
(Excerpt from Cat On a Hot Tin Roof here. That bit about Brick waiting for "the click" always gives me a chill. Such good writing, so insightful.)
The lead of a play I did a year or so ago was the lead in Tennessee Williams' last play - Something Cloudy Something Clear (excerpt here)- done here in NYC at Cocteau Rep. Williams died soon after the play went up. The play is a highly personal kind of dream-space, and reading it it is as though you can feel Williams getting ready to go into the dying of the light. It is the play of an old old man. A man getting ready. Craig shared with me his memories of working with Tennessee.
Everyone talks about his "laugh". Actors and actresses who were in his plays talk about hearing his laugh from out in the audience. It was a generous laugh, a laugh full of joy. If an actor or actress was doing well, he had no problem with letting them know, with enjoying their performances openly. (Other playwrights are not so kind. It seems as though other playwrights have this thought process: "No actor could EVER live up to the perfection that resides in my mind. My play is perfect as is ... it's the ACTORS who are messing it up!!" Playwrights like that, usually, are big bores, and don't have a lot of talent. Like: okay, you want perfection? Build a statue, and don't hire live actors. That way your precious words will be safe from contamination.) But Tennessee, while kind of intimidated by actors, he never knew what to say to them ... LOVED them when they were wonderful. He did not consciously withhold approval - like so many do. If someone sucked, he had no problem with sending a note to the director saying: "Please have her realize that she needs to be light and funny on that one line - she is dragging down the entire scene with her dismal line readings..." hahaha He would never say such a thing to the actor's face - he let the director do his job - but if he was pleased? He would sit out in the audience, and just HOWL with laughter. He loved being an audience member. So many people in the theatre, because the theatre is their job and livelihood - forget how to just be an audience member.
Here, to me, is a quintessential Tennessee Williams statement.
An interviewer asked him: "What is your definition of happiness?"
He replied, "Insensitivity, I guess."
His experience of "happiness" as being, in its essence, "insensitive" came from his background. Those who were "sensitive" were crushed and shattered by cruelty, by life itself. His sister Rose was institutionalized and lobotomized. This was something Tennessee never really recovered from. (But he didn't really HAVE to recover from it, I guess. All of his feelings about it went into his work. If he had "recovered", or "worked it out" in his mind, then he might not have written Glass Menagerie, Summer and Smoke, et al.) He was a perpetual outsider. He was on the run from his past. He was able to "get out" of the past ... his sister Rose was not. The guilt of that never left him. The guilt of being "the one" who was able to live in the real world dogged him at every turn. If one was "happy", if one was able to manuever thru a world that lobotomized some of its most sensitive members, then "happiness" required some kind of a hard outer shell - a shell that Tennessee himself lacked, that other "sensitives" (his word) lacked. He did not begrudge people their happiness ... he just didn't understand it. He couldn't get "in there", ever. Again, this is kind of a blessing, at least as far as we are concerned - merely because that sort of baffled response to how on earth to LIVE in this world ... is the emotional place from which he wrote all of his plays.
He WAS Blanche. He WAS Tom in Glass Menagerie. He WAS Alma. He WAS Maggie. All of these people, these "sensitives", trying to make their way through, trying to bear up under disappointments and cruelty ... trying to SURVIVE.
Again and again, Williams reiterated that he never wrote about victims. He didn't see any of these people as victims. He saw them as survivors. Beautiful triumphant survivors.
Oh, you weak, beautiful people who give up with such grace. What you need is someone to take hold of you - gently, with love, and hand your life back to you.-- Tennessee Williams
The Blache DuBois', the Laura Wingfields, the Miss Almas ... these are sensitive people, deeply wounded people, on the edge of shattering - just like his sister Rose did. Of course blatant casual "happiness" would be seen as insensitive through their eyes.
All cruel people describe themselves as paragons of frankness.-- Tennessee Williams
Tennessee Williams is one of my own personal heroes, for more reasons than one, and I am aware (on a pretty much daily basis) of how grateful I am to him for his plays. In the same way that I am pretty much always conscious of being grateful that there was a Shakespeare, and that we have his works with us today. I still read Tennessee Williams plays now, over and over, reading them countless times, never ever getting tired of them, never ever feeling like all my questions are answered.
Some mystery should be left in the revelation of character in a play, just as a great deal of mystery is always left in the revelation of character in life, even in one's own character to himself.-- Tennessee Williams
And I'll leave you with another really telling and beautiful anecdote, this one from Elia Kazan. I LOVE this, because it says to me, in no uncertain terms, why Tennessee Williams is a god among playwrights - and why he is so unusual. Nobody else can touch him, really. I love Arthur Miller's plays, but there's always a social conscience in them which can get preachy and tiresome if it's not controlled. Death of a Salesman has a perfect balance, but his later plays have the feeling of pamphlets.
Tennessee Williams has none of that. There is no "social conscience" in his plays. There is no deeper social criticism going on. Perhaps the only "criticism" that Tennessee consistently levels at "society" is the way it treats the "sensitives".
I have found it easier to identify with the characters who verge upon hysteria, who were frightened of life, who were desperate to reach out to another person. But these seemingly fragile people are the strong people really.-- Tennessee Williams
Here's the setup for the excerpt I want to post (which has to do with the rehearsals and also the opening of Streetcar Named Desire):
Jessica Tandy, who originated Blanche on Broadway, was already a celebrated actress. Marlon Brando was practically unknown. Kazan noticed which way the wind was blowing during rehearsals, and it concerned him on many levels.
Basically what was happening was that Marlon Brando was acting Jessica Tandy off the stage. Without breaking a sweat, Brando stole the show right out from under her. Jessica Tandy fought to keep her ground (which, actually, is perfect for the theme of the show and for the character of Blanche Dubois), but Kazan's main concern was that Blanche would turn into a laughable character and lose the sympathy of the audience. Kazan was worried that the audience, because of Brando's undeniable stage presence, and the electricity of his acting, would completely side with Stanley, and not have any sympathy for Blanche at all. This, Kazan felt, would be a disaster. Stanley rapes Blanche. This event must be seen as horrifyingly wrong, not as Blanche getting what she deserves. But Brando's power took over the play, it was a runaway train, it wasn't a matter of him playing Stanley as sympathetic - he wasn't. It was just that he was a force to be reckoned with, a powerhouse - you couldn't take your eyes off him. Jessica Tandy barely registered, when she was beside him.
Here's a photo from that production: Brando, Kim Hunter, and Tandy:

And so Kazan feared, as rehearsals went on, that the balance of the play was off.
Here's what Kazan wrote about all of this in his marvelous autobiography.
It is Tennessee Williams' "advice" to Kazan at the end that really packs a punch:
But what had been intimated in our final rehearsals in New York was happening. The audiences adored Brando. When he derided Blanche, they responded with approving laughter. Was the play becoming the Marlon Brando Show? I didn't bring up the problem, because I didn't know the solution. I especially didn't want the actors to know that I was concerned. What could I say to Brando? Be less good? Or to Jessie? Get better? ...Louis B. Mayer sought me out to congratulate me and assure me that we'd all make a fortune ... He urged me to make the author do one critically important bit of rewriting to make sure that once that "awful woman" who'd come to break up that "fine young couple's happy home" was packed off to an institution, the audience would believe that the young couple would live happily ever after. It never occurred to him that Tennessee's primary sympathy was with Blanche, nor did I enlighten him ... His misguided reaction added to my concern. I had to ask myself: Was I satisfied to have the performance belong to Marlon Brando? Was that what I'd intended? What did I intend? I looked to the author. He seemed satisfied. Only I -- and perhaps Hume [Cronyn, Tandy's husband] -- knew that something was going wrong ...
What astonished me was that the author wasn't concerned about the audience's favoring Marlon. That puzzled me because Tennessee was my final authority, the person I had to please. I still hadn't brought up the problem, I was waiting for him to do it. I got my answer ... because of something that happened in the Ritz-Carlton Hotel, across the hall from my suite, where Tennessee and Pancho were staying. [Pancho was Tennessee's boyfriend - or maybe it was more of a f*** buddy situation. Pancho was a huge presence in Tennessee's life. They had a really volatile relationship.] One night I heard a fearsome commotion from across the hall, curses in Spanish, threats to kill, the sound of breaking china ... and a crash ... As I rushed out into the corridor, Tennessee burst through his door, looking terrified, and dashed into my room. Pancho followed, but when I blocked my door, he turned to the elevator still cursing, and was gone. Tennessee slept on the twin bed in my room that night. The next morning, Pancho had not returned.
I noticed that Wiilliams wasn't angry at Pancho, not even disapproving -- in fact, when he spoke about the incident, he admired Pancho for his outburst. At breakfast, I brought up my worry about Jessie and Marlon. "She'll get better," Tennessee said, and then we had our only discussion about the direction of his play. "Blanche is not an angel without a flaw," he said, "and Stanley's not evil. I know you're used to clearly stated themes, but this play should not be loaded one way or the other. Don't try to simplify things." Then he added, "I was making fun of Pancho, and he blew up." He laughed. I remembered the letter he'd written me before we started rehearsals, remembered how, in that letter, he'd cautioned me against tipping the moral scales against Stanley, that in the interests of fidelity I must not present Stanley as a "black-dyed villain". "What should I do?" I asked. "Nothing," he said. "Don't take sides or try to present a moral. When you begin to arrange the action to make a thematic point, the fidelity to life will suffer. Go on working as you are. Marlon is a genius, but she's a worker and she will get better. And better."
Here is the review of the premiere of Streetcar Named Desire, in New York City, December 3, 1947.
December 4, 1947FIRST NIGHT AT THE THEATRE by Brooks Atkinson
Tennessee Williams has brought us a superb drama, "A Streetcar Named Desire," which was acted at the Ethel Barrymore last evening. And Jessica Tandy gives a superb performance as a rueful heroine whose misery Mr. Williams is tenderly recording. This must be one of the most perfect marriages of acting and playwriting. For the acting and playwriting are perfectly blended in a limpid performance, and it is impossible to tell where Miss Tandy begins to give form and warmth to the mood Mr. Williams has created.
Like "The Glass Menagerie," the new play is a quietly woven study of intangibles. But to this observer it shows deeper insight and represents a great step forward toward clarity. And it reveals Mr. Williams as a genuinely poetic playwright whose knowledge of people is honest and thorough and whose sympathy is profoundly human.
"A Streetcar Named Desire" is history of a gently reared Mississippi young woman who invents an artificial world to mask the hideousness of the world she has to inhabit. She comes to live with her sister, who is married to a rough-and-ready mechanic and inhabits two dreary rooms in a squalid neighborhood. Blanche - for that is her name - has delusions of grandeur, talks like an intellectual snob, buoys herself up with gaudy dreams, spends most of her time primping, covers things that are dingy with things that are bright and flees reality.
To her brother-in-law she is an unforgiveable liar. But it is soon apparent to the theatregoer that in Mr. Williams' eyes she is one of the dispossessed whose experience has unfitted her for reality; and although his attitude toward her is merciful, he does not spare her or the playgoer. For the events of "Streetcar" lead to a painful conclusion which he does not try to avoid. Although Blanche cannot face the truth, Mr. Williams does in the most imaginative and perceptive play he has written.
Since he is no literal dramatist and writes in none of the conventional forms, he presents theatre with many problems. Under Elia Kazan's sensitive but concrete direction, the theatre solved them admirably. Jo Mielziner has provided a beautifully lighted single setting that lightly sketches the house and the neighborhood. In this shadowy environment the performance is a work of great beauty.
Miss Tandy has a remarkably long part to play. She is hardly ever off the stage, and when she is on stage she is almost constantly talking -- chattering, dreaming aloud, wondering, building enchantments out of words. Miss Tandy is a trim, agile actress with a lovely voice and quick intelligence. Her performance is almost incredibly true. For it does seem almost incredible that she can convey it with so many shades and impulses that are accurate, revealing and true.
The rest of the acting is also of very high quality indeed. Marlon Brando as the quick-tempered, scornful, violent mechanic; Karl Malden as a stupid but wondering suitor; Kim Hunter as the patient though troubled sister -- all act not only with color and style but with insight.
By the usual Broadway standards, "Streetcar Named Desire" is too long; not all those words are essential. But Mr. Williams is entitled to his own independence. For he has not forgotten that human beings are the basic subject of art. Out of poetic imagination and ordinary compassion he has spun a poignant and luminous story.
We are lucky in this country that we have produced such a playwright. We are lucky to have all of his plays in the canon. I can't imagine my life without them.
Happy birthday, Tom.

Tennessee Williams said the following, in a 1981 interview - only a couple of years before he passed away:
"I'm very conscious of my decline in popularity, but I don't permit it to stop me because I have the example of so many playwrights before me. I know the dreadful notices Ibsen got. And O'Neill -- he had to die to make 'Moon' successful. And to me it has been providential to be an artist, a great act of providence that I was able to turn my borderline psychosis into creativity -- my sister Rose did not manage this. So I keep writing. I am sometimes pleased with what I do -- for me, that's enough."
An article about the state of Irish fiction right now. An interesting look at the different generations, and what's going on now (and how the Celtic Tiger, so to speak, is influencing how Irish literature is perceived).
I just read Christine Falls by Benjamin Black (John Banville's pseudonym) - and am very much looking forward to reading the sequel, entitled Silver Swan - especially after reviews like this one:
... Benjamin Black's The Silver Swan, about which Tim Rutten in the LA Times urged: "Go directly home. If you live with others, send them away. Pour yourself a quiet drink and settle into your best chair for an authentic dose of Irish angst and wit, wondrous writing and about as undiluted an evening's pleasure as reading can provide."
Christine Falls was fantastic - I so recommend it. Dublin in the 1950s, a haunted vaguely alcoholic coroner named Quirke, a dead girl, the Magdalen laundries (which you never could have written about even 20 years ago in Ireland) - the sweep of the Catholic Church's influence - and also just the feel of Dublin, pre-economic boom. An evocative gripping book. It's got it all. Can't wait to read the next one.
Very interesting article. I know most of the names, of course - but there are a couple of new ones I'll have to check out.
WONDERFUL interview with Anne Enright, author of The Gathering, winner of the Man Booker Prize last year. I finished it near my birthday last year (post here) - and had mixed feelings about it, although the writing knocked me on my ass. I just LIKE her as a person, too - every interview I've read with her has been fascinating. Seems like a lady I'd like to have a pint with.
She says in the interview:
Q. Where does the idea of "authentic" Irishness come from?A. From the diaspora. They dreamt about Ireland and reinvented it. Ireland is a series of stories that have been told to us, starting with the Irish Celtic national revival. I never believed in "Old Ireland." It has been made all of kitsch by the diaspora, looking back and deciding what Ireland is. Yes, it is green. Yes, it is friendly. I can't think of anything else for definite.
I read that, and thought of the piece I wrote "Road Works Ahead". I'm a writer. I read other people's thoughts and think of my own work. That's the way it goes. I still get emails about that "Road Works Ahead" piece. Irish people, Irish-American people - but mostly straight Irish. After I wrote that piece, an Irish newspaper linked to it, a big one, a national paper - and my piece was used as a launching-off place for an op-ed column - by an Irishman, who was worried about what had happened to that good old Irish hospitality. I felt a cringing within me when I saw that I had been referenced, I have a sensitivity towards how i come off ... i didn't want to seem like I was criticizing Ireland, or behaving like an obnoxious irish-American, pissed off that there were no more leprechauns. But the op-ed column was quite honest, and quite open ... it took my observations (made as an outsider, yes) and started to ask questions, based upon those observations. And the response I got was overwhelming. And also quite respectful and nice. It was great. Like I said, people still email me about that piece.
I am (a couple generations removed) a member of the diaspora and I recognize it in her words. I recognize it from the conversation I had with Eamon in the piece I wrote above. The whole Quiet Man thing, and the whole ambivalence about progress and change.
And I LOVED LOVED LOVED Anne Enright's thoughts on Joyce. I literally giggled with glee when I read them:
Q. Almost every review of an Irish writer's work makes comparisons to James Joyce. Is it hard to get away from him?A. I don't want to get away from him. It's male writers who have a problem with Joyce; they're all "in the long shadow of Joyce, and who can step into his shoes?" I don't want any shoes, thank you very much. Joyce made everything possible; he opened all the doors and windows. Also, I have a very strong theory that he was actually a woman. He wrote endlessly introspective and domestic things, which is the accusation made about women writers - there's no action and nothing happens. Then you look at "Ulysses" and say, well, he was a girl, that was his secret.
Marvelous. I want to read that to my father. He will appreciate it.
charles lamb (read that bio - day-um, that's some intense stuff) has come up quite a bit recently. in one of my ulysses posts - and then a conversation i had this weekend with my mother about him. she was reading anne fadiman's recent collection of essays - i gave it to dad for christmas - and fadiman wrote a big essay on charles lamb - and how he was a master of the essay. anyway, you know how suddenly something (like charles lamb) is on your radar - and you start seeing him everywhere? or you learn a new word, and it suddenly shows up in every commercial, radio broadcast, billboard that you see? here's a post about charles lamb. mum, i post this for you.
an excerpt from lamb about poets writing at the time of shakespeare:
“A puritanical obtuseness of sentiment, a stupid infantile goodness, is creeping among us, instead of the vigorous passions, and virtues clad in flesh and blood, with which the old dramatists present us. Those noble and liberal casuists could discern in the differences, the quarrels, the animosities of man, a beauty and truth of moral feeling, no less than in the iterately inculcated duties of forgiveness and atonement. With us all is hypocritical meekness, A reconciliation scene (let the occasion be never so absurd or unnatural) is always sure of applause. Our audiences come to the theatre to be complimented on their goodness. They compare notes with the amiable characters in the play, and find a wonderful similarity of disposition between them. We have a common stock of dramatic morality out of which a writer may be supplied without the trouble of copying it from originals within his own breast.�
fascinating. now that is some fine writing.
thanks, ken, for the following link to charles lamb's tales from shakespeare. isn't it beautiful?
Dick Cavett has a not-to-be-missed opinion piece in The New York Times about Bobby Fischer. It's too good to excerpt - but to me, it has all of the elements I love about good opinion writing. Cavett shares his experiences interviewing Bobby Fischer, at the height of his fame, on his show. It's lovely memoir-writing. I love his observations. But it also asks deep questions: what is it to be a genius? What is it LIKE for these people? And then comes stunning passages such as this:
Our mental health advisers, shrinks and friends advise us to avoid guilt at all costs. But they don’t tell you how. There seems to be an unlimited number of guilts available to us. When someone we know — or are related to — comes apart and deteriorates physically and mentally and commits suicide, don’t most of us think, “Maybe I’d have been the one who could have made the difference; done or said this or that and saved the poor soul?� How much of such thinking is charitable and how much egotistical? For a time I was pained by that thought that I might have been Bobby’s salvation. But then we comfort ourselves, concluding that of course it would have been too late. And then, alas, comes, But would it have been?
It's magnificent writing. And what I love the most - is how Cavett struggles with how to end the piece. He puts the struggle into his writing. Yes, yes, yes. It is this kind of thing that I want to do ... it is this kind of written expression that my heart most yearns for, and responds to. Thanks for showing me how it's done, Mr. Cavett.
Fascinating clip from Fischer on Cavett's show is also included in the piece. Not to be missed. It's amazing to see how it's a real conversation - something that is very absent today in late-night talk shows - where it's all about people plugging projects and that's pretty much it. But Cavett, Carson - and actually David Letterman on occasion - are great conversationalists. Watch how it flows. How beautiful it is, sometimes, to just sit back and watch other people talk.
When I first started blogging, on blog-spot, atswimtwobirds was the URL I chose, in honor of the great and the weird Flann O'Brien (aka Myles na gCopleen, aka Brian O'Nolan). Flann O'Brien's most well-known novel is probably At Swim-Two-Birds - which I read in college - and recently re-read. In the O'Malley family At Swim-Two-Birds was ubiquitous around the house - and I have written before (well, you'd have to buy The Sewanee Review, their Irish issue from 2006 to read it - and whatever, not to brag - oh what the hell, I'll brag - they're promoting me on the main page of their website right now.) about the allowance ritual in my family - where my father assigned each of us Irish authors, and we had to memorize their book titles - in order to get, oh, 75 cents. Siobhan was assigned Flann O'Brien, so to hear her, at 4 years old, rattle off "At Swim-Two-Birds" - is a potent family memory. It's a crazy book. It truly does defy description. It's a romp. It's an intellectual smorgasbord. And it prefigures books like Catcher in the Rye, or even later than that ... Dave Eggers, for example, is definitely in the Flann O'Brien continuum. It's a book that admits it's a book. There's a "meta" feeling to the whole thing. It's laugh out loud funny, doesn't take itself too seriously - and yet somehow it seems to encapsulate all of the insanity of Irish history, with its Finn McCool trajectory, its Cuchalain myths and legends ... and yet it's also about an aimless Irish youth, lying in his room, smoking cigarettes, and pondering the great novel he wants to write. It's one of the weirdest books I've ever read, and frankly, one of the most enjoyable.
Flann O'Brien has been on my mind because of this great essay on him by John Updike. I've seen it linked to everywhere, in the blogs I read - and I highly recommend it. Even if you know nothing about Flann O'Brien (or should I say, sorry, Myles? Or Brian?) - even if you haven't read his books ... well then so much the better. Perhaps Updike's piece will inspire you to give him a go. He's a major player in Irish literature, and that is obviously very difficult to achieve - since Irish literature is so full of goddamned great writers. Also, O'Brien was a contemporary of James Joyce, Sam Beckett. They cast a huge shadow. They do to this day - but imagine trying to publish novels in the 30s and 40s, post Ulysses. Flann O'Brien openly wrestled with his contemporaries - and put all of that into his books. In At Swim-Two-Birds, the young writer lies in bed, and he's sick so he's taken drugs - and the characters he is dreaming up for his book (we see his outlines, his notes) kind of take over. Old Irish kings and fairies enter the narrative. The novelist has lost control of his own book. He tries to control his characters, wrestling with them, essentially - like: "No! I am in charge here - not you!" But once let loose, it's very hard to get control again.
Updike has this to say about O'Brien's third novel An Béal Bocht, written in Gaelic:
O’Brien, who spoke Irish Gaelic in his childhood home, wrote his next extended fiction, “An Béal Bocht,� in Gaelic, in 1941; in 1973, it was translated, by Patrick C. Power, into a spirited imitation of O’Brien’s English as “The Poor Mouth: A Bad Story About the Hard Life.� Less than a hundred pages long, the tale has the advantage of a relatively clear, if extravagant, story line and a distinct satiric point—i.e., that the Irish Republic’s official cherishing of the nearly extinct Gaelic language ignores the miserable poverty of its surviving speakers, the rain-battered peasantry of the countryside. In one episode, government orators at a Gaelic feis parrot and praise the venerable language while in their audience “many Gaels collapsed from hunger and from the strain of listening.� In another, a folklorist from Dublin, visiting O’Brien’s fictional Gaeltacht area of Corkadoragha, and frustrated by the drunken taciturnity of an assembly of local males, records the muttering of a pig under the impression that it is Gaelic: “He understood that good Gaelic is difficult but that the best Gaelic of all is well-nigh unintelligible.� Parodying sentimental novels and memoirs in modern Gaelic by such authors as Tomás Ó Criomhthainn and Séamas Ó Grianna, O’Brien protests on behalf of a depressed Irish population: “In one way or another, life was passing us by and we were suffering misery, sometimes having a potato and at other times having nothing in our mouths but sweet words of Gaelic.�
Updike writes:
The man was ingenious and learned like Jim Joyce and like Sam Beckett gave the reader a sweet dose of hopelessness but unlike either of these worthies did not arrive at what we might call artistic resolution. His novels begin with a swoop and a song but end in an uncomfortable murk and with an air of impatience.
It has made me want to re-visit some of Flann O'Brien's stuff again, as challenging and bizarre as it is. He's like a jazz musician, going off on riffs as his creativity demands ... hoping the audience will follow ... or perhaps not even. Perhaps he doesn't care whether or not we follow. He can be a challenge, because sometimes you want to shout at him, "GET BACK TO THE POINT, FLANN!" - but for him, the riff IS the point. He's an important writer because of that.
Also a helluva lot of fun. At Swim-Two-Birds made me laugh out loud repeatedly, and there were times when he knocked my socks off - with his inventiveness, and what he had to say about the process of writing itself. It is the most myopic of books - and yet, as with most Irish writers, the past presses in - everywhere. The kings and priests and fairies of Celtic golden ages gone by ... they are not just influences on Flann O'Brien - they are so huge that they insert themselves into the novel, and demand to be taken seriously. He, the writer, tries to make them behave. They will not. What a great metaphor.
Check him out, if you haven't.
Oh, is it, Percy? Is that your custom, hon? I mean, HONESTLY. Love it. His letters are incredible!!
...and the nights are for ever serene, and we see a star in the east at sunset--I think it is Jupiter--almost as fine as Venus was last summer; but it wants a certain silver and aerial radiance, and soft yet piercing splendour, which belongs, I suppose, to the latter planet by virtue of its at once divine and female nature.
Also, his words on Frankenstein:
yet it proves that it is read in some considerable degree, and it would be difficult for them, with any appearance of fairness, to deny it merit altogether.
Here's another one of his extraordinary letters.
This cathedral is a most astonishing work of art. It is built of white marble, and cut into pinnacles of immense height, and the utmost delicacy of workmanship, and loaded with sculpture. The effect of it, piercing the solid blue with those groups of dazzling spires, relieved by the serene depth of this Italian heaven, or by moonlight when the stars seem gathered among those clustered shapes, is beyond anything I had imagined architeture capable of producing.
Some quotes I've put on my blog about Shelley:
"Shelley was a volatile creature ..."
Next book on my adult fiction shelves:
Misery by Stephen King
I love it when Stephen King writes about writers. It excites me. Sometimes when a writer writes about a writer - it's either self-congratulatory, or boring - the "stuff" of their life is not interesting enough to make a good book, but they cannot write about anything else. It's like a rock star who becomes so huge that eventually all he can do is write songs about being on a tour bus, and the cocaine and fast women fame brings him. I mean, that's fine - The Eagles have written a ton of good songs in that realm - so has Eminem - but you can tell that the scope of their lives has closed down a bit ... there is nothing to write about now but fame, and themselves as famous people. Sometimes books about writers have that feel. But to me, Stephen King never does. Maybe because he has been so successful in a certain "genre" (which will become very important in Misery - because Paul, too, has made his name in a genre of writing - romance novels) - but for whatever reason, his books where writing comes into play are among my favorites. I love it when he gets personal. Because I think King holds the key to a lot of the mystery of writing (something I am very interested in): how does a man produce so much?? How does he write so much? What is his discipline? How does he do it? Does he sit down every day? Does he have a specific writing time? I am amazed by his output and by, generally, how good much of it is. Yes, he could definitely be edited more - but I am not as much interested in the final product as I am interested in his process. Because it is no small thing, what he has accomplished. It is extraordinary. He IS a writer. He lives it. Misery, in that sense, is King's most personal novel.
Because so much of it is a battle not between Paul and Annie Wilkes (his lunatic biggest fan) - but a battle between Paul and the typewriter. Paul and his own imagination. Paul and writer's block. It's just GREAT. Anyone who has ever sat there, staring at a blank page, knowing you have to fill it up - even if you're a real writer and trying to write a novel, a screenplay, a poem ... or if you have to finish a paper in college, or grad school ... that feeling of terror, of having to create something out of nothing ... NO ONE will write it for you. It MUST come from your mind. But ... where does one start? How does one begin? Misery is about the terror Paul feels being trapped by Annie Wilkes, yes. But on a deeper level, it is about the terror of the blank page. I love that. That's why i chose the excerpt I did.
Paul is a famous romance-novel writer. His big success is the "Misery" series - a typical bodice-ripping melodrama, and the heroine, a fiery black-haired goddess, is named Misery. Paul, though, is sick of Misery. He is sick of the whole thing and feels he needs to end the series, and move on with his writing career. Do something new. Misery needs to die. Paul is in a horrible car accident on a snowy road in Maine - and his body is badly mangled up. He is "rescued" by a woman who finds him ... who turns out to be Annie Wilkes, a crazy lady who lives by herself - who is obsessed with the Misery books. And in her mind, Misery MUST NOT DIE. He needs to write another book, and it must be called "Misery's Return". Meanwhile, Paul is an invalid - his legs don't work - he has not been to the hospital at all - so he is in agony, and Annie, to put it mildly, is terrifying. It's the terror of being in the presence of someone who does not know the difference between reality and fiction. Misery is Annie's dearest love. She doesn't just read the books. She lives them. And yes, it's awesome to have fans who believe so deeply ... but it's best if you never meet these people - or if you do meet them, keep it confined to a book signing where you can skip around the crazies if need be. Annie Wilkes orders him to write another book. Meanwhile, it is obvious that Paul needs medical care. But she has set up a booby-trapped house - he can't get to the phone, he can't do anything ... It's one of the most infuriating books I have ever read. Like: Bitch, let me OUT of your house. That horrifying feeling of being helpless, trapped ... But she means business. Now that she has him, she will refuse to let him go.
If you remember the book, you know how bad things get. Annie Wilkes is not just crazy, but she's dangerous. Paul, to placate her, begins to write Misery's Return - but it goes so against his artistic sensibility - like: no, I am DONE with Misery. You can't write a book to-order. You have to move on when the "muse" tells you to move on. But here - Annie Wilkes becomes the muse. The demanding muse. Write THIS. So Paul, struggling with the agony in his legs, and his invalid state ... has to write the book that Annie wants, if he wants to have a shot at surviving. It's not easy. How do you write when you are SO not in the mood? I struggle with that myself. But I learned from Madeleine L'Engle that: if you wait for inspiration, you might never get started. The point is to write every day. That way you are preparing the ground, so to speak, for inspiration to land. It's quite prosaic. You are not in a high-flying state of imaginative creation ... you sit down, and you write. And maybe once in a while you write something that's good. It's like you don't have to be "in the mood" to have great sex. It's awesome if you are "in the mood" - nothing better - but sometimes, once you're THERE, even if you weren't originally "in the mood" - it becomes something even better.
Paul has to show Annie what he has written at the end of each day - and she is a harsh critic. She is every writer's worst nightmare (but - in a strange way, she's also someone you DREAM of attracting - someone who is THAT into what you have created?? It's a compliment, in a weird way). But it's not like she's a passive reader. Oh, no. She has opinions about everything. She runs Paul ragged. How do you write with that nagging voice in your ear at all times? Again, I think King is being very personal here. We all have our "Annie Wilkes'" - even if it's just a voice in our heads. The voice saying, in a neverending refrain, "That's not good enough." "You'll never be good enough." "Who do you think you are?" "You suck."
And it is THAT that artists have to grapple with. To me, the deeper analogy of the book is clear. Annie Wilkes is not a typical movie-monster, although she is terrifying. Madness un-medicated and un-diagnosed. But she is also the demon of self-hatred that stalks many of us - especially when we want to sit down and create something. Or when we want to CHANGE the pattern of our self-expression - as Paul is trying to do. King has obviously been enormously successful - and anything he writes will be published now - he is not so much "trapped" by the genre that made his name - although maybe that's not quite true. Maybe he does feel pigeon-holed unfairly, who knows. But when a writer (or a musician - uhm, Dylan going electric), or an actor - decides to change their persona, their expression - it is often greeted with howls of protest, and not just protest but rage: "Who does that person think he is?" That's what I think King is really expressing in Misery - and that's why I find it to be his most personal book.
Here's an excerpt.
EXCERPT FROM Misery by Stephen King
Paul looked at the typewriter. The typewriter was there. N's! He had never realized how many n's there were in an average line of type.
I thought you were supposed to be good, the typewriter said - his mind had invested it with a sneering and yet callow voice: the voice of a teenage-gunslinger in a Hollywood western, a kid intent on making a fast reputation here in Deadwood. You're not so good. Hell, you can't even please one crazy overweight ex-nurse. Maybe you broke your writing bone in that crash, too ... only that bone isn't healing.
He leaned back as far as the wheelchair would allow and closed his eyes. Her rejection of what he had written would be easier to bear if he could blame it on the pain, but the truth was that the pain had finally begun to subside a little.
The stolen pills were safely tucked away between the mattress and the box spring. He had taken none of them - knowing he had them put aside, a form of Annie-insurance, was enough. She would find them if she took it into her head to turn the mattress, he supposed, but that was a chance he was prepared to take.
There had been no trouble between them since the blowup over the typewriter paper. His medication came regularly, and he took it. He wondered if she knew he was hooked on the stuff.
Hey, come on now, Paul, that's a bit of a dramatization, isn't it?
No, it wasn't. Three nights ago, when he was sure she was upstairs, he had sneaked one of the sample boxes out and had read everything on the label, although he supposed he had read everything he needed when he saw what Norvil's principal ingredient was. Maybe you spelled relief R-O-L-A-I-D-S, but you spelled Norvil C-O-D-E-I-N-E.
The fact is, you're healing up, Paul. Below the knees your legs look like a four-year-old's stick-drawing, but you are healing up. You could get by on aspirin or Empirin now. It's not you that needs the Norvil; you're feeding it to the monkey.
He would have to cut down, have to duck some of the caps. Until he could do that, she would have him on a chain as well as in a wheelchair - a chain of Norvil capsules.
Okay. I'll duck one of the two capsules she gives me every other time she brings them. I'll put it under my tongue when I swallow the other one, then stick it under my mattress with the other pills when she takes the drinking glass out. Only not today. I don't feel ready to start today. I'll start tomorrow.
Now in his mind he heard the voice of the Red Queen lecturing Alice: Down here we get our act clean yesterday, and we plan to start getting our act clean tomorrow, but we never clean up our act today.
Ho-ho, Paulie, you're a real riot, the typewriter said in the tough gunsel's voice he had made up for it.
"Us dirty birdies are never all that funny, but we never stop trying - you have to give us that," he muttered.
Well, you better start thinking about all the dope you are taking, Paul. You better start thinking about it very seriously.
He decided suddenly, on the spur of the moment, that he would start dodging some of the medication as soon as he got a first chapter that Annie liked on paper - a chapter which Annie decided wasn't a cheat.
Part of him - the part that listened to even the best, fairest editorial suggestions with ill-grace - protested that the woman was crazy, that there was no way to tell what she might or might not accept; that anything he tried would be only a crapshoot.
But another part - a far more sensible part - disagreed. He would know the real stuff when he found it. The real stuff would make the crap he had given Annie to read last night, the crap it had taken him three days and false starts without number to write, look like a dog turd sitting next to a silver dollar. Hadn't he known it was all wrong? It wasn't like him to labor so painfully, not to half-fill a wastebasket with random jottings or half-pages which ended with lines like 'Misery turned to him, eyes shining, lips murmuring the magic words Oh you numb shithead THIS ISN'T WORKING AT ALL!!!!" He had chalked it off to the pain and to being in a situation where he was not just writing for his supper but for his life. Those ideas had been nothing but plausible lies. The fact was, things had gone badly because he was cheating and he had known it himself.
Well, she saw through you, shit-for-brains, the typewriter said in its nasty, insolent voice. Didn't she? So what are you going to do now?
He didn't know, but he supposed he would have to something, and in a hurry. He hadn't cared for her mood this morning. He supposed he should count himself lucky that she hadn't re-broken his legs with a baseball bat or given him a battery-acid manicure or something similar to indicate her displeasure with the way he had begun her book - such critical responses were always possible, given Annie's unique view of the world. If he got out of this alive, he thought he might drop Christopher Hale a note. Hale reviewed books for the New York Times. The note would say: "Whenever my editor called me up and told me you were planning to review one of my books in the daily Times, my knees used to knock together - you gave me some good ones, Chris old buddy, but you also torpedoed me more than once, as you well know. Anyway, I just wanted to tell you to go ahead and do your worst - I've discovered a whole new critical mode, my friend. We might call it the Colorado Barbecue and Floor-Bucket school of thought. It makes the stuff you guys do look about as scary as a ride on the Central Park carousel."
This is all very amusing, Paul, writing critics little billet-doux in one's head is always good for a giggle, but you really ought to find yourself a pot and get it boiling, don't you think?
Yes. Yes indeed.
The typewriter sat there, smirking at him.
"I hate you," Paul said morosely, and looked out the window.
Next book on my adult fiction shelves:
Different Seasons by Stephen King
"The Body" is the third novella in King's collection and, of course, it was made into Stand By Me (God bless you, River Phoenix! How you are missed!! DAMMIT) If people stay away from King because "they don't like horror novels" - I think that is such a shame - and I say that as a person who doesn't read horror novels, generally. But I read Carrie in high school (after seeing the film) and I was hooked - and I am so grateful. Because he is a wonderful writer. I think he's almost (not quite) but almost on the level of Mark Twain - in terms of writing about children - from THEIR level. It's not an easy feat- but King shines in that regard, above many of his peers. The way he evokes the rules of children, and how intense the friendships can be (especially little boys - like in "The Body") is absolutely exquisite. And another thing that King does here - that he does also in It, which I consider a masterpiece - is he writes from the perspective of an adult, looking back on childhood ... and yeah, lots of writers do that ... but without putting a keen of sadness and nostalgia in my heart, like King does. I read "The Body" and my heart literally aches. For youth, for summer vacation, for playing outside in the twilight, for being 4 feet tall, for the intensity of those times. Children have a three-dimensional experience, even though they are not adults yet. They have tough times, they grapple with universal themes, they struggle, they have moments of calm, they have insight ... but they are also 11 years old. King, when he writes about looking back, lets that sadness and loss flow through his writing, and it's just absolutely gorgeous. It is unbearable at points, because of this. Yes, there are monsters, and danger, and terror ... but the real heart of the thing (and it's in the last sentence of It) is remembering, with love, the friends you had before you knew who you were, the friends you made before life got to you ... the people you CHOSE as your companions when you were a kid. Those are important choices. And sometimes we never make such friends again. That's what "The Body" is all about, too.
Beautiful story. Four little boys - all misfits, for different reasons - hang out in their treehouse, playing cards, smoking cigarettes, fighting, talking. They hear a rumor - that out in the woods - there is a dead body. Nobody has discovered it yet. So they make a plan - to lie to their parents (those who have parents who care) and trek out into the woods to see the body. They will have to sleep in the woods one night. It will be an adventure.
How much of an adventure they could not know when they set out.
The narrator is writing the story - it's first person - and he's looking back on it, as an adult. He is now a writer. So the story is interspersed with his published works - so we can see how he has used the stuff of his life (the pie-eating contest, etc.) to create a career as a fiction writer. But this ... this story of "The Body" ... he has never written before. So there are times when the prose palpitates with emotionality, you'll see what I mean in the excerpt below - which is, hands down, some of my favorite writing of King's ever, in all of his books.
If you don't know what happens ... I beg you to read "The Body". Even if you've already seen Stand By Me. It's something else - a really special piece of work.
Here's an excerpt. I chose it because it stands out for me - in the whole of the story - as something singular, unconnected to other events ... and also because I have had similar moments in my life, nearly identical as a matter of fact - and King, who is known for writing about big gestures - running, killing, screaming - is PERFECT here - in the tiniest of moments. King understands that all of life can be encapsulated in such a moment. That often it is not the BIG things that stay in our mind ... it's the small. Like the time on the L platform in Chicago, when a thunderstorm was brewing, and there was purple lightning, and I know I was really really sad about something - although I can't remember what - and there were 2 little kids blowing bubbles nearby and so the translucent bubbles filled the air, gyrating around my head because of the wind. I don't remember the BIG things surrounding that moment ... but the sensory details are intact. And that means something to me. I don't discount the importance of such moments, even though they do not change the world.
That's what King is describing here. LOVE it.
EXCERPT FROM Different Seasons by Stephen King - The Body
The others slept heavily through the rest of the night. I was in and out, dozing, waking, dozing again. The night was far from silent; I heard the triumphant screech-squawk of a pouncing owl, the tiny cry of some small animal perhaps about to be eaten, a larger something blundering wildly through the undergrowth. Under all of this, a steady tone, were the crickets. There were no more screams. I doze and woke, woke and dozed, and I suppose if I had been discovered standing such a slipshod watch in Le Dio, I probably would have been courtmartialed and shot.
I snapped more solidly out of my last doze and became aware that something was different It took a moment or two to figure it out: although the moon was down, I could see my hands resting on my jeans. My watch said quarter to five. It was dawn.
I stood, hearing my spine crackle, walked two dozen feet away from the limped-together bodies of my friends, and pissed into a clump of sumac. I was starting to shake the night-willies; I could feel them sliding away. It was a fine feeling.
I scrambled up the cinders to the railroad tracks and sat on one of the rails, idly chucking cinders between my feet, in no hurry to wake the others. At that precise moment the new day felt too good to share.
Morning came on apace. The noise of the crickets began to drop, and the shadows under the trees and bushes evaporated like puddles after a shower. The air had that peculiar lack of taste that presages the latest hot day in a famous series of hot days. Birds that had maybe cowered all night just as we had done now began to twitter self-importantly. A wren landed on top of the deadfall from which we had taken our firewood, preened itself, and then flew off.
I don't know how long I sat there on the rail, watching the purple steal out of the sky as noiselessly as it had stolen in the evening before. Long enough for my butt to start complaining anyway. I was about to get up when I looked to my right and saw a deer standing in the railroad bed not ten yards from me.
My heart went up into my throat so high that I think I could have put my hand in my mouth and touched it. My stomach and genitals filled with a hot dry excitement. I didn't move. I couldn't have moved if I had wanted to. Her eyes weren't brown, but a dark, dusty black - the kind of velvet you see backgrounding jewelry displays. Her small ears were scuffed suede. She looked serenely at me, head slightly lowered in what I took for curiosity, seeing a kid with his hair in a sleep-scarecrow of whirls and many-tined cowlicks, wearing jeans with cuff and a brown khaki shirt with the elbows mended and the collar turned up in the hoody tradition of the day. What I was seeing was some sort of gift, something given with a carelessness that was appalling.
We looked at each other for a long time ... I think it was a long time. Then she turned and walked off to the other side of the tracks, white bobtail flipping insouciantly. She found grass and began to crop. I couldn't believe it. She had begun to crop. She didn't look back at me and didn't need to; I was frozen solid.
Then the rail started to thrum under my ass and bare seconds later the doe's head came up, cocked back toward Castle Rock. She stood there, her branch-black nose working on the air, coaxing it a little. Then she was gone in three gangling leaps, vanishing into the woods with no sound but one rotted branch, which broke with a sound like a track ref's starter-gun.
I sat there, looking mesmerized at the spot where she had been, until the actual sound of the freight came up through the stillness. Then I skidded back down the bank to where the others were sleeping.
The freighter's slow, loud passage woke them up, yawning and scratching. There was some funny, nervous talk about "the case of the screaming ghost," as Chris called it, but not as much as you might imagine. In daylight it seemed more foolish than interesting - almost embarrassing. Best forgotten.
It was on the tip of my tongue to tell them about the deer, but I ended up not doing it. That was one thing I kept to myself. I've never spoken or written of it until just now, today. And I have to tell you that it seems a lesser thing written down, damn near inconsequential. But for me it was the best part of that trip, the cleanest part, and it was a moment I found myself returning to, almost helplessly, when there was trouble in my life - my first day in the bush in Vietnam, and this fellow walked into the clearing where we were with his hand over his nose and when he took his hand away there was no nose there because it had been shot off; the time the doctor told us our youngest son might be hydrocephalic (he turned out just to have an oversized head, thank God); the long, crazy weeks before my mother died. I would find my thoughts turning back to that morning, the scuffed suede of her ears, the white flash of her tail. But eight hundred million Red Chinese don't give a shit, right? The most important things are the hardest to say, because words diminish them. It's hard to make strangers care about the good things in your life.

William Butler Yeats died (thanks for the heads up, Ms. Baroque). And, of course, Yeats makes me think of my father. My first published piece in The Sewanee Review was about the Yeats-dad continuum.
From memory now! And when I hear this poem, in my head - I always hear the recitation from the Clancy Brothers Carnegie Hall album.
THE HOST OF THE AIR
O'Driscoll drove with a song
The wild duck and the drake
From the tall and the tufted reeds
Of the drear Heart Lake.
And he saw how the reeds grew dark
At the coming of night-tide,
And dreamed of the long dim hair
Of Bridget his bride.
He heard while he sang and dreamed
A piper piping away,
And never was piping so sad,
And never was piping so gay.
And he saw young men and young girls
Who danced on a level place,
And Bridget his bride among them,
With a sad and a gay face.
The dancers crowded about him
And many a sweet thing said,
And a young man brought him red wine
And a young girl white bread.
But Bridget drew him by the sleeve
Away from the merry bands,
To old men playing at cards
With a twinkling of ancient hands.
The bread and the wine had a doom,
For these were the host of the air;
He sat and played in a dream
Of her long dim hair.
He played with the merry old men
And thought not of evil chance,
Until one bore Bridget his bride
Away from the merry dance.
He bore her away in his arms,
The handsomest young man there,
And his neck and his breast and his arms
Were drowned in her long dim hair.
O'Driscoll scattered the cards
And out of his dream awoke:
Old men and young men and young girls
Were gone like a drifting smoke;
But he heard high up in the air
A piper piping away,
And never was piping so sad,
And never was piping so gay.
To those of you who know that Clancy Brothers album - you'll know the special-ness of that recording.
The O'Malley children were made to memorize Yeats' epitaph as part of our weekly allowance ritual. Say Yeats' epitaph, get a dime!! When we visited his grave in Ireland, as kids, we all felt kind of amazed that ... it was REAL. That the epitaph we had been rattling off since we were toddlers actually existed out in the world.
More in honor of this great poet - one of my favorites - below the jump. A couple years ago, I read his complete works - sitting backstage during the run of a play - when I wasn't onstage acting. I had about 40 minutes before my scene - came on, did my scene - and then there was another half-hour before curtain call. So I huddled backstage wearing my jeweled bifocals and my birkenstocks, and read Yeats. It was a fascinating experience - I know many of his big poems almost by heart, the famous ones - but it's nothing compared to reading his work - from beginning to end. You watch an artist burst forth at a certain point - almost fully formed. You've read his younger work, you've seen its beauty (but also its sentimentality - its Celtic twilight "twee" lament ... and nothing - NOTHING - can prepare you for the poet who would eventually write "Sailing to Byzantium" and "Among Schoolchildren").
Here's a biography of Yeats, Nobel prize winner in 1923.
Yeats, as a poet, has always been one of my favorites (even with the "cloud-pale eyelids" balderdash of his early stuff), but what truly inspires me is his work in Irish theatre, and the creation of the Abbey. An amazing story. His Nobel lecture was on the Irish Dramatic Movement. I wrote a big long post about his nurturing of John Synge, author of Playboy of the Western World. Synge, as a young man, was a floundering artist bohemian type - until Yeats got a hold of him, and told him to go stay on the Aran Islands for a while, to discover the real Irish people. The result? A revolution in Irish theatre.
Gabriel Fallon, an actor at the Abbey, describes the dress rehearsal of Sean O'Casey's Juno and the Paycock in his book Sean O'Casey, The Man I Knew - a wonderful theatrical anecdote:
We could make nothing of the reading of Juno and the Paycock as it was called. It seemed to be a strange baffling mixture of comedy and tragedy; and none of us could say, with any certainty, whether or not it would stand up on the stage.The dress rehearsal would be held at 5 p.m. on March 2, Sunday. I arrived at the theatre at 4:30 p.m., and found the author there before me looking rather glum and wondering if a rehearsal would take place ... Gradually the players filed in and went to their dressing-rooms. Lennox Robinson arrived shortly before 5 o'clock and was followed by Yeats and Lady Gregory. The curtain rose about 5:36 p.m. so far as I could see and hear while waiting for my cue in the wings the rehearsal seemed to be proceeding smoothly. As soon as I had finished my part of Bentham at the end of the second act I went down into the stalls and sat two seats behind the author. Here for the first time I had an opportunity of seeing something of the play from an objective point of view. I was stunned by the tragic quality of the third act which the magnificent playing of Sara Allgood made almost unbearable. But it was the blistering irony of the final scene which convinced me that this man sitting two seats in front of me was a dramatist of genius, one destined to be spoken of far beyond the confines of the Abbey Theatre ...
We watched the act move on, the furniture removers come and go, the ominous entry of the IRA men, the dragging of Johnny to summary execution, the stilted scene between Jerry Devine and Mary Boyle, and then as with the ensnaring slow impetus of a ninth great wave Allgood's tragic genius rose to an unforgettable climax and drowned the stage in sorrow. How surely was the very butt and sea-mark of tragedy! But suddenly the curtain rises again: are Fitzgerald and McCormick fooling, letting off steam after the strain of rehearsal? Nothing of the kind; for we in the stalls are suddenly made to freeze in our seats as a note beyond tragedy, a blistering flannel-mouthed irony sears its maudlin way across the stage and slowly drops an exhausted curtain on a world disintegrating in 'chassis'.
I sat there stunned. So, indeed, as far as I could see, did Robinson, Yeats, and Lady Gregory. Then Yeats ventured an opinion. He said that the play, particularly in the final scene, reminded him of a Dostoevsky novel. Lady Gregory turned to him and said, "You know, Willie, you never read a novel by Dostoevsky." And she promised to amend this deficiency by sending him a copy of The Idiot. I turned to O'Casey and found I could only say to him, "Magnificent, Sean, magnificent."
I had a conversation once with the doppelganger about "greatest poems of the 20th century" and we discussed Sailing to Byzantium, Among Schoolchildren, and The Second Coming. We said any list of "greatest poems of the 20th century" that DIDN'T include at least one of those poems was not a list to be taken seriously in the slightest. "The Second Coming" is quoted (and mis-appropriated, more often than not) and quoted again ... by people who want to use it for their own ends. It's a dark ominous crystal ball. The best "use" of it, to my mind, is in the deleted scene in Nixon, with Sam Waterston playing Dick Helms, director of the CIA. Written in 1919 - when the world had already become familiar with horror - a horror of a kind never before seen on earth - the poem predicts the chaos of the 20th century.
"The Second Coming"
Turning and turning in the widening gyre
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.
Surely some revelation is at hand;
Surely the Second Coming is at hand.
The Second Coming! Hardly are those words out
When a vast image out of Spiritus Mundi
Troubles my sight: somewhere in sands of the desert
A shape with lion body and the head of a man,
A gaze blank and pitiless as the sun,
Is moving its slow thighs, while all about it
Reel shadows of the indignant desert birds.
The darkness drops again; but now I know
That twenty centuries of stony sleep
Were vexed to nightmare by a rocking cradle,
And what rough beast, its hour come round at last,
Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?
Jesusmaryandjoseph.
Seamus Heaney wrote a marvelous essay on Yeats a while back (the link no longer works, but I have the hard copy) - in which he wrote:
Conquest, difficulty, labour: these terms indicate the nature of Yeats's creative disposition. From the start, he was enamoured of Blake's conviction that energy is eternal delight, yet the development of his own thought brought him more and more to the conclusion that conflict was the inescapable condition of being human. So, as his art matured and the articulation of his beliefs became more clarified and forceful, Yeats's poems typically conveyed a sensation of certitude achieved by great effort and of contradictions quelled. Poems in which the defiant self is pitted against hostile or disabling conditions - "An Irish Airman Foresees his Death", "September 1913", "Meditations in Time of Civil War"- are complemented by poems that read like discharges of pure, self-possessed energy, poems from which the accidental circumstances have been excluded so that all that remains is the melody and stamina of resurgent spirit - "The Cold Heaven", "Byzantium", "Long-legged Fly".

Of course, there is also the Maud Gonne factor that must be considered. I read some funny quote somewhere (can't remember where) that said: "Any biography of Yeats would have to have in every chapter the following words: 'And he proposed marriage yet again to Maud Gonne'." What do you wanta bet that Maud Gonne had "cloud-pale eyelids"?
Heaney writes, in that same essay:
nd all the while, of course, there was Maud Gonne, "high and solitary and most stern" according to one of the poems about her, "foremost among those I would hear praised" according to another, and "the troubling of my life" according to a famous sentence in his Autobiographies. The passion she inspired - and as readers we experience it more as creative power than erotic need - made her a figure of primary poetic radiance, a Dublin Beatrice, an archetype as much as a daily presence. Nevertheless, Yeats's poetry, his politics and his involvement with the occult received an extra charge of intensity from her day to day reality in his life, and when she appeared in the title role of his subversive play Cathleen Ni Houlihan (1902), another kind of maturity was achieved.
Heartbreak. Enduring heartbreak and loss.
Some quotes from Mr. Yeats:
"I hate journalists. There is nothing in them but tittering jeering emptiness. They have all made what Dante calls the Great Refusal. The shallowest people on the ridge of the earth."
"Irish poets, learn your trade, sing whatever is well made, scorn the sort now growing up all out of shape from toe to top."
"The worst thing about some men is that when they are not drunk they are sober."
"Words are always getting conventionalized to some secondary meaning. It is one of the works of poetry to take the truants in custody and bring them back to their right senses."
"Do not wait to strike till the iron is hot; but make it hot by striking."
"And say my glory was I had such friends."
Yes. That last one really moves me - it's from one of his poems. I feel the same way about my life, and my friends.
Words to live by:
Never give all the heart
Never give all the heart, for love
Will hardly seem worth thinking of
To passionate women if it seem
Certain, and they never dream
That it fades out from kiss to kiss;
For everything that's lovely is
But a brief, dreamy. Kind delight.
O never give the heart outright,
For they, for all smooth lips can say,
Have given their hearts up to the play.
And who could play it well enough
If deaf and dumb and blind with love?
He that made this knows all the cost,
For he gave all his heart and lost.
I also love love LOVE his poem to Jonathan Swift where he writes: "Imitate him if you dare."
Swift's Epitaph
Swift has sailed into his rest;
Savage indignation there
Cannot lacerate his breast.
Imitate him if you dare,
World-besotted traveller; he
Served human liberty.
Speaking of epitaphs, you can't get any better or more eloquent than Auden's stunning poem in memory of Yeats:
In Memory of W.B. Yeats
by Auden
I
He disappeared in the dead of winter:
The brooks were frozen, the airports almost deserted,
And snow disfigured the public statues;
The mercury sank in the mouth of the dying day.
What instruments we have agree
The day of his death was a dark cold day.
Far from his illness
The wolves ran on through the evergreen forests,
The peasant river was untempted by the fashionable quays;
By mourning tongues
The death of the poet was kept from his poems.
But for him it was his last afternoon as himself,
An afternoon of nurses and rumours;
The provinces of his body revolted,
The squares of his mind were empty,
Silence invaded the suburbs,
The current of his feeling failed; he became his admirers.
Now he is scattered among a hundred cities
And wholly given over to unfamiliar affections,
To find his happiness in another kind of wood
And be punished under a foreign code of conscience.
The words of a dead man
Are modified in the guts of the living.
But in the importance and noise of to-morrow
When the brokers are roaring like beasts on the floor of the Bourse,
And the poor have the sufferings to which they are fairly accustomed,
And each in the cell of himself is almost convinced of his freedom,
A few thousand will think of this day
As one thinks of a day when one did something slightly unusual.
What instruments we have agree
The day of his death was a dark cold day.
II
You were silly like us; your gift survived it all:
The parish of rich women, physical decay,
Yourself. Mad Ireland hurt you into poetry.
Now Ireland has her madness and her weather still,
For poetry makes nothing happen: it survives
In the valley of its making where executives
Would never want to tamper, flows on south
From ranches of isolation and the busy griefs,
Raw towns that we believe and die in; it survives,
A way of happening, a mouth.
III
Earth, receive an honoured guest:
William Yeats is laid to rest.
Let the Irish vessel lie
Emptied of its poetry.
In the nightmare of the dark
All the dogs of Europe bark,
And the living nations wait,
Each sequestered in its hate;
Intellectual disgrace
Stares from every human face,
And the seas of pity lie
Locked and frozen in each eye.
Follow, poet, follow right
To the bottom of the night,
With your unconstraining voice
Still persuade us to rejoice;
With the farming of a verse
Make a vineyard of the curse,
Sing of human unsuccess
In a rapture of distress;
In the deserts of the heart
Let the healing fountain start,
In the prison of his days
Teach the free man how to praise.
And lastly, a poem that has great personal meaning for me - especially today- a sad upsetting day for me:
The wild swans at Coole
The trees are in their autumn beauty,
The woodland paths are dry,
Under the October twilight the water
Mirrors a still sky;
Upon the brimming water among the stones
Are nine-and-fifty Swans.
The nineteenth autumn has come upon me
Since I first made my count;
I saw, before I had well finished,
All suddenly mount
And scatter wheeling in great broken rings
Upon their clamorous wings.
I have looked upon those brilliant creatures,
And now my heart is sore.
All's changed since I, hearing at twilight,
The first time on this shore,
The bell-beat of their wings above my head,
Trod with a lighter tread.
Unwearied still, lover by lover,
They paddle in the cold
Companionable streams or climb the air;
Their hearts have not grown old;
Passion or conquest, wander where they will,
Attend upon them still.
But now they drift on the still water,
Mysterious, beautiful;
Among what rushes will they build,
By what lake's edge or pool
Delight men's eyes when I awake some day
To find they have flown away?
SOME QUOTES
"My poetry is generally written out of despair. Like Balzac, I see increasing commonness everywhere, and like Balzac I know no one who shares the premises from which I work." -- Yeats
"On the third night Yeats addressed the audience before the curtain rose. If anyone had anything to say against the piece they would be welcomed at a debate which he would be glad to arrange in the theatre at some other time. He was interrupted several times. He asked the interrupters to at least listen to the play so that they would know what it was they were objecting to." -- Maire Nic Shiubhlaigh's description of Yeats trying to handle the riots that were happening in response to Synge's "Playboy of the Western World" - a play being put on at the Abbey Theatre
"In 1875 Yeats entered the Godolphin School in Hammersmith and visited Ireland during the longer school vacations, when he stayed with the Pollexfens in County Sligo. An early poetic impulse was to change the name of his toy yacht from Sunbeam to Moonbeam. It was a decisive act." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets
"I thought we might bring the halves together if we had a national literature that made Ireland beautiful in the memory, and yet had been freed of provincialism by an exacting criticism, a European pose." -- Yeats
"This is not the huge competence of Auden, at play in the toy shop of poetic form, but mastery, the possession of a unique rhetoric for use on a real but limited range of themes. It is a mastery so complete that it can occlude the genuinely problematic, ride over the potholes of nonsense without even sensing them. Late in life he recognizes the evasiveness of his symbols, the tendency of his verse to turn away or inward, and in the concentrated intensity of the late poems he tries to remedy this. But he has an imperfect sense of generality; he is willing to plump out a truism as truth. As his mastery increases, his art becomes less truthful. But his main concern is not - until the later poems, and even there in an attenuated spirit - truth, but the house of myth and legend, where he can become a principal tenant, where it is his voice we hear casting the spell, and where real men are reduced - or, in his mind, enlarged - to masks, figures and types useful to myth, regardless of the human reality they had." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"All literature created out of a conscious political aim in the long run crates weakness by creating a habit of unthinking obedience. Literature created for its own sake, for some eternal spiritual need, can be used for politics. Dante is said to have unified Italy. The more unconscious the creation, the more powerful." -- Yeats
"Sex and death are the only things that can interest a serious mind." -- Yeats
"His mastery seems almost excessive." -- Richard Ellmann
"... a strained and unworkable allegory about a young man and a sphinx on a rock in the sea (how did they get there? what did they eat? and so on; people think such criticisms very prosaic, but common-sense is never out of place anywhere ...) but still containing fine lines and vivid imagery." - Gerard Manley Hopkins, after reading some of Yeats' first published verses
"Irish poets, learn your trade, sing whatever is well made, scorn the sort now growing up all out of shape from toe to top." -- Yeats
"Yeats's 'The Second Coming' has gained in prophetic power with each decade of the twentieth and now twenty-first century, from the rise of fascism and nuclear warfare to the proliferation of international terrorism. It expresses the melancholy realizatino that man, yearningly drawn to the divine, will never fully escape his bestial ancestry. The poem is modernistically unrhymed, though the first stanza plays with shadowy off-rhymes: 'gyre' / 'falconer' / 'everywhere'; 'hold' / 'world' / 'drowned'. It is structured instead by dramatic visuals and emblematic choreography. There are two main movements: a huge, expanding circle (the ascending falcon) and an arrowlike, linear track (the beast bound for Bethlehem). Then two smaller ones: a pendulum arc (the rocking cradle) and an exploding pinwheel (the reeling desert birds). Ideas have become design, starkly juxtaposed with the murky turbulence of elemental forces - storm, flood, drought. Hence the poem, with its horror movie finale, is as hybrid as the sphinx, who represents our buried impulses, vestiges of a past that keeps turning into the future." -- Camille Paglia, "Break, Blow, Burn"
"The heavy voluptuous splendour of much of his work has yet a ghostliness as of the palace made magically of leaves. Even his heroes and beautiful women are aware of this ... He never leaves us, any more than Crashaw, content with the glory alone. It calls our attention to a spirit behind and beyond, heaping high lovely, invisible things that it may show the greater beauty that can survive their crumbling into dust." -- Edward Thomas, 1909
"The worst thing about some men is that when they are not drunk they are sober." -- Yeats
"In London he was active in literature and politics. One particular event in 1889 proved crucial: he met and fell in love with the fiery Republican who haunted him for the rest of his days, Maud Gonne. His biography, from 1889 until Maud Gonne's marriage, is punctuated by the statement, 'Yeats proposed to Maud Gonne.'" -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"Words are always getting conventionalized to some secondary meaning. It is one of the works of poetry to take the truants in custody and bring them back to their right senses." -- Yeats
" 'The best lack all conviction, while the worst / Are full of passionate intensity': these famous lines are Yeats's anguished formulation of what seems to be an eternal principle of politics (7-8). When 'the center cannot hold,' neither consensus nor compromise is possible. Public debate shifts to the extremes or is overtaken by violence, which blocks incremental movement toward reciprocity and conciliation. Moderate views are 'drowned' out (as by the bloody tide) in strident partisanship or fanaticism. The phrase 'passionate intensity' suggests that, for the late Romantic Yeats, eros diverted from the personal to the political turns into a distorted lust for power. The second stanza opens in doubt and confusion: 'Surely some revelation is at hand; / Surely the Second Coming is at hand. / The Second Coming!'' (9-11). We are hearing either one voice echoing its own shocked phrases or many voices in public tumult. The book of Revelation lists the dreadful omens heralding doomsday, when Jesus will return and unlock the secrets of history. But in Yeats's poem, Christ's promised glory is overshadowed by a monstrous apparition from antiquity. The poet is seized by an electrifying vision: 'a vast image out of Spiritus Mundi / Troubles my sight'. It's a collective memory, crystallizing from the repository of world myths (12-13). ("Spiritus Mundi" is Yeats's mystical term for "soul of the universe".) We witness the resurrection of the pagan era, whose barbarism mirrors that of the war-torn twentieth century. Yeats sees no evidence of moral evolution over two millennia of Christianity." -- Camille Paglia, "Break, Blow, Burn"
"I once got Yeats down to bed-rock on these subjects and we talked for hours. He had been talking rather wildly about the after life. Finally I asked him: 'What do you believe happens to us immediately after death?' He replied, 'After a person dies, he does not realize that he is dead.' I: 'In what state is he?' W.B.Y.: 'In some half-conscious state.' I said: 'Like the period between waking and sleeping?' W.B.Y.: 'Yes.' I: 'How long does this state last?' W.B.Y.: 'Perhaps some twenty years.' 'And after that,' I asked, 'what happens next?' He replied, 'Again a period which is Purgaotry. The length of that period depends upon the sins of the man when he was upon this earth.' And then again I asked: 'And after that?' I do not remember his actual words, but he spoke of the return of the soul to God. I said, 'Well, it seems to me that you are hurrying us back into the great arms of the Roman Catholic Church.' He was of course an Irish Protestant. I was bold to ask him, but his only retort was his splendid laugh." -- Lady Dorothy Wellesley
"It is an entirely new thing -- neither what they eye sees nor the ear hears, but what the rambling mind thinks and imagines from moment to moment. He has certainly surpassed in intensity any novelist of our time." -- Yeats on James Joyce's "Ulysses"
"For Yeats, there was something both enviable and exemplary about the enlargement of vision and the consequent histrionic equanimity which Shakespeare's heroes and heroines attain at the moment of their death, 'carried beyond feeling into the aboriginal ice.' He wanted people in real life to emulate or at least to internalize the fortitude and defiance thus manifested in tragic art." -- Seamus Heaney, 1990
"Give up Paris, you will never create anything by reading Racine, and Arthur Symons will always be a better critic of French literature. Go to the Arran Islands. Live there as if you were one of the people themselves; express a life that has never found expression." -- Yeats's advice to John Synge
"The first spectre of the new generation has appeared. His name is Joyce. I have suffered from him and I would like you to suffer." -- George Russell in a letter to Yeats, 1902
Cast a cold eye
On life on death
Horseman pass by
-- Yeats's epitaph
Imitate him if you dare.
The White Horse Tavern, Greenwich Village, NY. Where Dylan Thomas apparently spoke his last words: "I've just had 18 whiskeys. I think that's the record."

Emily Dickinson was born on this day in 1830. It is not known why she withdrew from society so completely. Theories abound. Books have been written. But the mystery remains. What we have are her poems. A wide interior life lived in one room. Extraordinary.
In the poem below, we could read whatever we want into it, it's not "clear" - who is "You" - it would depend on where you are at in your life, the answer. You could read it as being addressed to God. I read this poem and I think of him. It's not really a pleasant thing to think about it, so long after the thing is done. But it happened. I have moved on. It was years ago. But the experience has marked me. And something about the line here: "Because you saturated Sight / And I had no more Eyes / For sordid excellence / As paradise" reminds me of how I felt about him. He saturated Sight.
640
I cannot live with You --
It would be Life --
And Life is over there --
Behind the Shelf
The Sexton keeps the Key to --
Putting up
Our Life -- His Porcelain --
Like a Cup --
Discarded of the Housewife --
Quaint -- or Broke --
A newer Sevres pleases --
Old Ones crack --
I could not die -- with You --
For One must wait
To shut the Other's Gaze down --
You -- could not --
And I -- Could I stand by
And see You -- freeze --
Without my Right of Frost --
Death's privilege?
Nor could I rise -- with You --
Because Your Face
Would put out Jesus' --
That New Grace
Glow plain -- and foreign
On my homesick Eye --
Except that You than He
Shone close by --
They'd judge Us -- How --
For You -- served Heaven -- You know,
Or sought to--
I could not --
Because You saturated Sight --
And I had no more Eyes
For sordid excellence
As Paradise
And were You lost, I would be --
Though My Name
Rang loudest
On the Heavenly fame --
And were You -- saved --
And I -- condemned to be
Where You were not --
That self -- were Hell to Me --
So We must meet apart --
You there -- I -- here --
With just the Door ajar
That Oceans are -- and Prayer --
And that White Sustenance --
Despair --

Quotes and excerpts below about Emily Dickinson, in honor of her birthday.
"She is the spider, not the fly." -- Alison Brackenbury
"Her relationship to books , to literary preedent and example, was similar. She was no ransacker and devourer of libraries. Like Lincoln, she knew relatively few volumes but knew them deeply. As a girl she attended Amherst Academy and also Mount Holyoke Female Seminary, a few miles distant, during her seventeenth year, but school gave her neither intellectual nor social satisfactions to compensate for the reassuring intimacy of home and family she keenly missed. The standard works she knew best and drew on most commonly for allusions and references in her poetry and vivid letters were the classic myths, the Bible, and Shakespeare. Among the English Romantics, she valued John Keats especially; among her Englishc ontemporaries she was particularly attracted by the Brontes, the Brownings, Alfred, Lord Tennyson, and George Eliot. None of these, however, can be said to have influenced her literary practice significantly. Indeed, not the least notable quality of her poetry is its dazzling originality. Thoreau and Emerson, especially the latter, as we know from her letters, were perhaps her most important contemporary American intellectual resources, though their liberal influence seems always to have been tempered by the legacy of a conservative Puritanism best expressed in the writings of Jonathan Edwards. Her chief prosodic and formal model was the commonly used hymnals of the times with their simple patterns of meter and rhyme." -- Norton Anthology of American Literature
"No great poet has written so much bad verse as Emily Dickinson ..." -- Richard Chase
"When I state myself, as the Representative of the Verse -- it does not mean -- me -- but a supposed person." -- Emily Dickinson to Thomas Wentworth Higginson
"Dear friend,
I congratulate you.
Disaster endears beyond Fortune --
E. Dickinson"
-- letter written to a friend after the friend's house had burned down
"Throughout her life ED was especially sensitive to such occasions." -- Emily Dickinson's editor, commenting on a poem Dickinson wrote on the 4th anniversary of Charlotte Bronte's death
"Whitman, Dickinson and Melville seem to me the best poets of the nineteenth century here in America." -- Randall Jarrell
"The language is not literary. It enacts heard experience. Kinsmen, unexpectedly met, chatting late into the night from their different places: it brings beauty and truth into intimate focus. Strange: These are the same great terms of Keats's 'cold pastoral'." -- Michael Schmidt
"Her coy and oddly childish poems of nature and female friendship are products of a time when one of the careers open to women was perpetual childhood." -- Richard Chase
"I never read his book - but was told that he was disgraceful." -- Emily Dickinson on Walt Whitman
"My Mother does not care for thought." -- Emily Dickinson to Thomas Wentworth Higginson
"I am growing very handsome indeed!" -- Emily Dickinson, age 14
"More than any other poet, Emily Dickinson seemed to tell me that the intense inner event, the personal and psychological, was inseparable from the universal; that there was a range for psychological poetry beyond mere self-expression." -- Adrienne Rich
"We have the legend, but the crucial facts in the recorded life are absent. Dickinson's reticence seems part of her poetical strategy: if we could assign the poems to specific emotional events, we would ground them. As it is, they are a miracle and a mystery of language." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"Her wit is accuracy." -- Alison Brackenbury
"Immense in scale and oratorical in tone, this amazing short poem [Safe In Their Alabaster Chambers] departs from Dickinson's usual four-line stanza format, based on sturdy Protestant hymn measure. The first five-line stanza rolls out in a single, thrilling sentence, delivered in the magesterial public voice of a sermon or eulogy. Its as if the poem's disturbing theme - the dead and their defeated hopes - can barely be contained by traditional structure." -- Camille Paglia, "Break, Blow, Burn"
"Are you too deeply occupied to say if my verse is alive? The mind is so near itself it cannot see distinctly, and I have none to ask." -- Emily Dickinson to Thomas Higginson, 1862
"She sewed her poems into little books and put them away, one after another, in a box, where after her death her sister found them, nine hundred poems "tied together with twine" in "sixty volumes." And it's not an untenable theory that the beloved whom she mourns, departed, may be Christ, the soul's lover, rather than a particular man -- or a particular woman." -- Michael Schmidt
"Emily, you wretch! No more of this nonsense! I've traveled all the way from Springfield to see you. Come down at once." -- Samuel Bowles, shouting up the stairs at Emily. Emily finally did come down.
"A step like a pattering child's in entry & in glided a little plain woman with two smooth bands of reddish hair & a face a little like Belle Dove's; not plainer - with no good feature - in a very plain & exquisitely clean white pique & blue net worsted shawl. She came to me with two day lilies which she put in a sort of childlike way into my hand & said 'These are my introduction' in a soft frightened breathless childlike voice -- & added under her breathe Forgive me if I am frightened; I never see strangers & hardly know what I say -- but she talked soon & thenceforward continuously -- & deferentially -- sometimes stopping to ask me to talk instead of her -- but readily recommencing...I never was with any one who drained my nerve power so much. Without touching her, she drew from me. I am glad not to live near her." -- Thomas Wentworth Higginson
Joseph Cornell, American artist, who specialized in making boxes - built boxes for Emily Dickinson. Her ghost haunts those boxes (of course even more so when you know which ones are the "Emily boxes"). But he didn't build them as gifts FOR Emily Dickinson (who, of course, was long dead). He built them as spaces that she might inhabit. He was "preparing a place" for her. That's why so many of the Emily boxes are empty. With open windows. Which is interesting, too. He always wanted to make sure that Emily had a way to escape.
Here is the most famous box he made for Emily Dickinson. It is called "Towards the Blue Peninsula":

Haunting, isn't it?
I can feel her presence in that box. It's like she just left, via the window, but an afterimage remains.

I am a baffled and awe-inspired fan. I think he has the kind of genius that is best not talked about too much. Just leave it be. Don't try to ask why, or HOW ... (I can't help it: HOW????????) Just accept that in this day and age of mortal man, giants still walk the earth on occasion. JUST ACCEPT IT. Every now and then, once every three or four centuries, a giant walks the earth. DEAL.
Milton was born on this day in 1608. He went to Oxford for a bit - but ended up leaving - and studied, basically, ALL OF HUMAN NATURE AND HISTORY AND MANKIND on his own. The depth and breadth of his work, and his inquiry, is remarkable. I find myself in a state of blank wordlessness here. Men like John Milton are so rare that you only need a couple fingers on one hand to count their like.
I guess, on a personal note, my own terror of going blind (it's not a "fear" - that is way too mild a word - I wake up screaming from nightmares because of it on a regular basis) makes me feel a strange fearful kinship with John Milton who went blind, and had to dictate his great works to others. He dictated Paradise Lost to his daughter.
What?
Honestly. I go blank. I can't speak.
There are some people who seem to be vessels of a higher being. Whatever you want to call it. You could tie them up, and throw them in a basement for 75 years, and they would STILL scratch out their epic on the basement wall. This is something that cannot be easily explained. It just is.
I'll just end with a poem that ranks among my favorites of all time. My fear of losing my sight is so deep and so profound that it is hard to even admit to, because I feel like it will come true. Milton stands before me, as a beacon - of someone this happened to - and yet he persevered. But oh. To live in darkness. To have the world of Paradise Lost in your head ... and to have to wait ... to WAIT ... as someone else takes it down in dictation ... is terrifying.
And so .... echoing this terrifying image of having to WAIT while your head is crammed full of Paradise Lost I'll end with Milton's sonnet to his own blindness.
Sonnet XIX: On His Blindness
When I consider how my light is spent,
Ere half my days, in this dark world and wide,
And that one talent which is death to hide
Lodged with me useless, though my soul more bent
To serve therewith my Maker, and present
My true account, lest He returning chide,
"Doth God exact day-labour, light denied?"
I fondly ask; But patience, to prevent
That murmur, soon replies "God doth not need
Either man's work or his own gifts. Who best
Bear His mild yoke, they serve Him best. His state
Is kingly: thousands at His bidding speed
And post o'er land and ocean without rest;
They also serve who only stand and wait."
Here's the post I put together about Milton for National Poetry Month.
"[He is] the most vigorous hater we've ever had in our literature." -- Edgell Rickword on Jonathan Swift

Jonathan Swift was born on this day, in 1667. Here's a ton of biographical information if you are interested.
Primarily known for Gulliver's Travels (which I re-read earlier this year - here's my post about it) and A Modest Proposal he was also a poet of pretty uncommon gifts. He's also one of the most quotable of all writers. He's like Oscar Wilde that way, his words have barbs in them - they stick, get a hold on you.
Swift wrote:
But you think that it is time for me to have done with the world, and so I would if I could get into a better before I was called into the best, and not die here in a rage, like a poisoned rat in a hole.
His contempt has echoed across the centuries and given us the primary examples of satire that all writers should study. I am sorry that satire is so tepid these days. I find most of it way too coy, and stupid. They WISH that what they were doing was satire of the highest order - but what they are really doing is just bitching and whining in a tiny airless corner. Swift was merciless. Swift's command of language was impeccable. His observations were ruthless. He cannot be touched to this day.
Swift said, in regards to satire:
Satire is a sort of glass, wherein beholders do generally discover everybody's face but their own.
Swift embraced hate, it is true, yet he did not embrace corruption. Most people who fill their souls with hate (and I can think of many examples in our present-day political discourse) completely corrupt their humanity. Their hatred for everyone else (and their inability to look in a mirror - or, no, it's not just inability - it is blatant and conscious REFUSAL to look in a mirror) leaves them with no humanity. Swift does not seem to have had that problem. He was just alert, that's all. He saw the things going on around him, and wrote it all down. He pulled no punches.
I never wonder to see men wicked, but I often wonder to see them not ashamed.
There is such truth in Swift.
And also:
Politics, as the word is commonly understood, are nothing but corruptions.
He called things as he saw them:
We have just enough religion to make us hate, but not enough to make us love one another.
Obviously such blunt truth was highly unwelcome in many circles - and still is today. Oh, how much the pious haters despise those who call them on their phoniness!! Again: it all comes back to this: Can you look in the mirror? Can you face yourself? Can you entertain the possibility that that which you hate is also inside of you? Oh ho ho no. Many people don't even know what the HELL you are talking about when you talk like that!
But then there is also this:
It is in men as in soils where sometimes there is a vein of gold which the owner knows not.
The belief in the good in people. Not universally - oh, no. Swift was perfectly willing to see some people as just plain assholes with no redeeming qualities - and I'm pretty much with him on that. But occasionally - where you least expect it - a "vein of gold".
Many professional haters have ZERO senses of humor. Oh, they think they do, and I see them chortling on political talk shows, throwing zingers at their opponents - and their witless followers guffaw "Ho ho ho" in response, but there is no actualy humor there. None.
But Swift used humor. He used it like a whip, yes, but also - well - there's something like this statement which makes me laugh out loud every time I read it:
There were many times my pants were so thin I could sit on a dime and tell if it was heads or tails.
Self-knowledge - a willingness to include himself in his own merciless searchlight:
Where I am not understood, it shall be concluded that something very useful and profound is couched underneath.
And his poems, let's not forget them. They're funny, biting, mean ... and yet sometimes so heartfelt (the ones to Stella - the woman he loved all his life - comes to mind) that they bring tears to my eyes.
You don't want to skim these. Read. Read them.
A Satirical Elegy: On the Death of a Late Famous General
His Grace! impossible! what dead!
Of old age, too, and in his bed!
And could that Mighty Warrior fall?
And so inglorious, after all!
Well, since he's gone, no matter how,
The last loud trump must wake him now:
And, trust me, as the noise grows stronger,
He'd wish to sleep a little longer.
And could he be indeed so old
As by the news-papers we're told?
Threescore, I think, is pretty high;
'Twas time in conscience he should die.
This world he cumber'd long enough;
He burnt his candle to the snuff;
And that's the reason, some folks think,
He left behind so great a stink.
Behold his funeral appears,
Nor widow's sighs, nor orphan's tears,
Wont at such times each heart to pierce,
Attend the progress of his hearse.
But what of that, his friends may say,
He had those honours in his day.
True to his profit and his pride,
He made them weep before he dy'd.
Come hither, all ye empty things,
Ye bubbles rais'd by breath of Kings;
Who float upon the tide of state,
Come hither, and behold your fate.
Let pride be taught by this rebuke,
How very mean a thing's a Duke;
From all his ill-got honours flung,
Turn'd to that dirt from whence he sprung.
I love the line: "How very mean a thing's a Duke". It just says it all.
And here is my favorite of the "Stella poems":
Stella's Birthday March 13, 1727
This day, whate'er the Fates decree,
Shall still be kept with joy by me:
This day then let us not be told,
That you are sick, and I grown old;
Nor think on our approaching ills,
And talk of spectacles and pills.
To-morrow will be time enough
To hear such mortifying stuff.
Yet, since from reason may be brought
A better and more pleasing thought,
Which can, in spite of all decays,
Support a few remaining days:
From not the gravest of divines
Accept for once some serious lines.
Although we now can form no more
Long schemes of life, as heretofore;
Yet you, while time is running fast,
Can look with joy on what is past.
Were future happiness and pain
A mere contrivance of the brain,
As atheists argue, to entice
And fit their proselytes for vice;
(The only comfort they propose,
To have companions in their woes;)
Grant this the case; yet sure 'tis hard
That virtue, styl'd its own reward,
And by all sages understood
To be the chief of human good,
Should, acting, die, nor leave behind
Some lasting pleasure in the mind;
Which by remembrance will assuage
Grief, sickness, poverty, and age;
And strongly shoot a radiant dart
To shine through life's declining part.
Say, Stella, feel you no content,
Reflecting on a life well spent?
Your skilful hand employ'd to save
Despairing wretches from the grave;
And then supporting with your store
Those whom you dragg'd from death before?
So Providence on mortals waits,
Preserving what it first creates.
Your gen'rous boldness to defend
An innocent and absent friend;
That courage which can make you just
To merit humbled in the dust;
The detestation you express
For vice in all its glitt'ring dress;
That patience under torturing pain,
Where stubborn stoics would complain:
Must these like empty shadows pass,
Or forms reflected from a glass?
Or mere chims in the mind,
That fly, and leave no marks behind?
Does not the body thrive and grow
By food of twenty years ago?
And, had it not been still supplied,
It must a thousand times have died.
Then who with reason can maintain
That no effects of food remain?
And is not virtue in mankind
The nutriment that feeds the mind;
Upheld by each good action past,
And still continued by the last?
Then, who with reason can pretend
That all effects of virtue end?
Believe me, Stella, when you show
That true contempt for things below,
Nor prize your life for other ends,
Than merely to oblige your friends;
Your former actions claim their part,
And join to fortify your heart.
For Virtue, in her daily race,
Like Janus, bears a double face;
Looks back with joy where she has gone
And therefore goes with courage on:
She at your sickly couch will wait,
And guide you to a better state.
O then, whatever Heav'n intends,
Take pity on your pitying friends!
Nor let your ills affect your mind,
To fancy they can be unkind.
Me, surely me, you ought to spare,
Who gladly would your suff'rings share;
Or give my scrap of life to you,
And think it far beneath your due;
You, to whose care so oft I owe
That I'm alive to tell you so.
"Does not the body thrive and grow By food of twenty years ago?" Yes, Swift ... yes, it does.
And this one - hee hee:
Oysters
Charming oysters I cry:
My masters, come buy,
So plump and so fresh,
So sweet is their flesh,
No Colchester oyster
Is sweeter and moister:
Your stomach they settle,
And rouse up your mettle:
They'll make you a dad
Of a lass or a lad;
And madam your wife
They'll please to the life;
Be she barren, be she old,
Be she slut, or be she scold,
Eat my oysters, and lie near her,
She'll be fruitful, never fear her.
Michael Schmidt's book Lives of the Poets has a chapter devoted to Jonathan Swift, John Gay, and Alexander Pope - it's called "Three Friends". Schmidt's book is a must-read for poetry lovers. He's not a critic, first of all. He's an editor and a book publisher. He's a fan of poetry - and he writes like a fan writes - not like a critic - and yet his knowledge is encyclopedic.
Here is some of what he has to say about Jonathan Swift:
His vexed relations with women, especially "Stella" and "Vanessa", and his disgust with physical functions, have given much latitude to Freudian interpretations. Disgust informs much of the prose and verse, but so does a real interest in common people, their language, actions and concerns. The verse opens on this area of his genius, and on his darker musings. It possesses the satiric virtues of the prose with an additional element: the "I" speaks, speaks as itself, with an uncompromised acerbity that few poets have masterd. When he died in 1745, Ireland and England were in his debt. The topicality that limits the appeal of some of his prose is itself the appeal of the verse: it catches inflections and remembers small actions now lost -- the voices of gardeners, street vendors, laborers ... the tone of a cryptic man of conscience speaking of his world, his bitter, life, his wary loves.
Jonathan Swift described style, in writing, as "proper words in proper places". I think he pretty much mastered that - in his prose, certainly, but also in his poems. There isn't an extra word there - there is no FAT in his language - he has pared everything down to its essentials. The verses come to us as though they were born complete - and perfect.
More from Schmidt - and this, I believe, is a brilliant point:
In the more ambitious pieces Swift challenges the reader ... There is a unique irony at work, not normative, like Dryden's, but radical: thematic rather than stylistic. This is why his poems, even the most topical, retain force today. "I take it to be part of the honesty of poets," he wrote, "that they cannot write well except they think the subject deserves it." The subjects he chose he approached as if for the first time, as if we stepped from the chill, clear world of reason into a world of men.
More (I see his point here about Swift not being quotable, not really - most of the quotes I excerpted above were from his prose works - His poems are pretty much complete as they are - and need to be read straight through - they are difficult to excerpt. They depend on momentum and continuity):
Swift is hard to recommend as a poet because he is hard to quote out of context. There are few purple passages, detachable maxims; the poetry is drawn evenly through the poem in ways that out-of-context quotation violates. The epitaphs, the spoofs, the eclogues, the anecdotes spoken by various voices, the ironic love poems, the first-person poems, will not be broken up into tags like the rich couplet bric-a-brac of Pope. In Swift we come upon a writer who might have preferred to be called versifier rather than poet. There is a difference in kind in his work from that of his predecessors; and he is not "polite" enough to have beguiled his contemporaries into imitation. He stands alone, he doesn't sing, he never ingratiates himself. He speaks, and he understands how the world wags.
And on that note, I will close this ginormous post - but I will let William Butler Yeats have the last word on Jonathan Swift:
Swift's Epitaph
Swift has sailed into his rest;
Savage indignation there
Cannot lacerate his breast.
Imitate him if you dare,
World-besotted traveller; he
Served human liberty.
Yup. Imitate him if you dare.

"November is the most disagreeable month in the whole year," said Meg, standing at the window one dull afternoon, looking out at the frostbitten garden."That's the reason I was born in it," observed Jo pensively, quite unconscious of the blot on her nose.
-- Little Women, by Louisa May Alcott
Louisa May Alcott was born on this day, in 1832. (I just LOVE that picture of her above. The dress!!)
To me, Little Women is a perfect book (even with the whole Laurie debacle, and the advent of the German professor which never works for me, to this day) - it is a book I go back to again and again and again - always seeing something new in it, always finding new levels. The characters seem to grow up with me. When I first read it, when I was 10 years old, I was ALL ABOUT JO. And my love affair with Jo continues to this day. She is one of my favorite female characters ever written (it's a tie between Jo March and Harriet the Spy). Jo LIVES. No one can convince me that she is just a fictional character. Nope. You cannot do it.
But as I have grown up, and as I have continuously gone back to the book - the other sisters have come to the foreground - I see myself in all of them. Parts of me are like Amy, parts of me are like Meg, and I would like to think that parts of me are like Beth. But honestly: Jo is the one. Jo is the one I most relate to. She's the artist. The tomboy. The independent wild spirit. The one who is afraid to make the wrong choice. The one who sticks to her guns.
I still am not really reconciled to the fact that she and Laurie did not end up together - HOWEVER, I can see Jo's point. They were like brother and sister. But ... but ... but ... couldn't that have segued into a love thing? The intimacy they have together, the comfort?
When I was a kid, I HATED the professor. With his stupid German accent, and his goofy poetry as he wooed Jo. I resented the fact that he wasn't Laurie. I loved Laurie.
Now I know that Louisa May Alcott was forced by her publishers to marry Jo off. She wanted her to stay single. And if you really think about it, THAT would be much more logical - it makes much more sense that Jo, even with all her passion, and her ability to understand men (in a way that Meg, the one with all the love affairs, doesn't) - would choose to spend her life alone. She would marry her writing. In that day and age, those were the choices. It was the choice Louisa May Alcott herself made. She could not submit to the demands of wifehood and motherhood - it would infringe on her writing. She knew it, even when she was 15 years old, and wrote in her journal: "I will do something by and by. Don't care what, teach, sew, act, write, anything to help the family; and I'll be rich and famous and happy before I die, see if I won't!"

Alcott grew up in Concord, one of 4 girls, and part of what we would now call an activist family. They were abolitinists. Social reformers. Her mother was a social worker. Her father was an educational philosopher (more on this extraordinary man here, and had a belief in communal living (Louisa May Alcott wrote some funny pieces about these experiments of her father's, and having to submit to them as a young girl.) Her father (Amos Bronson Alcott - also born on this day) was buddies with Emerson, and part of the Transcendentalist movement. At the time, her father's views on teaching were very controversial: He actually believed that students should enjoy learning. Heaven forbid! He thought that students should be actively involved in their own education, and not just sit back and be passive little drones. Her father thought it was very important to have a beautiful classroom - not just desks and a chalkboard. He poured his heart (and finances) into a school - which ran for a couple of years - but then went under, putting the family at financial risk. Louisa May Alcott eventually, many years later, would be pretty much the sole supporter of her parents. She made a ton of money DURING her lifetime, which is quite rare. Her parents just weren't the money-making types - obviously. As a young teenager Louisa May Alcott had a passionate girlish love of Emerson - a crush, if you will. His intellect, his library that she was allowed to use, whatever ... She adored him.
In 1862, Alcott (as always, determined to make a living - and to contribute financially to her family) traveled to Washington DC as a Civil War nurse. By this point, Alcott had already started getting stuff published - poems, short stories in the Gothic melodramatic vein ... She actually preferred Gothic melodramas to the kinds of books that later would make her name. (She despised Little Women and found the writing of it extremely tedious.) Her experience as a nurse in the Civil War prompted her to publish a book called Hospital Sketches. At that point, her publisher asked her if she would write a book "for girls". Never one to back off from a challenge, Louisa May Alcott sat down and wrote Little Women in two months. She had grown up with 3 sisters - and she put her entire childhood and life into that book, even as she hated doing it, and didn't think the book would amount to much.
Little Women was published in 1868 and was an immediate rip-roaring success. The publisher, within only a couple of weeks of its publication, begged Alcott to get to work on a sequel. So Alcott did. Another smash success. Louisa May Alcott had become a star.
Every book she wrote after that was eagerly awaited for by a breathless loving public. Success had, indeed, come - her childish ambitions to be 'rich and famous' came to fruition tenfold ... but 'happy'? Was she happy?
She never married. She ended up taking care of her sister May's daughter - after May died from complications in childbirth. Being a surrogate mother to this young girl was one of the most fulfilling experiences of Alcott's life. She kept writing, kept publishing ... although she began to get more and more ill from mercury poisoning she had received years earlier during the Civil War (she had, like many other Civil War nurses, contracted typhoid fever - and at the time, the proscribed cure was something called "calomel" - a drug laden with mercury).
Near the end of her life, Alcott became active in the suffragette movement. Her father (an extraordinary man in his own right) had always been a feminist himself:

His passion was to see that his four daughters were educated, well-rounded, and part of the intellectual community helived in. (Some heavy-hitters there - Emerson, Thoreau, etc.) Louisa's father kept detailed diaries during the raising of his 4 girls, chronicling everything about each one of them. His whole thing was early education - the importance of the first couple of years - and again, you don't ever get the sense that he thought this was only good for BOYS. On the contrary. Here's a snippet of a letter Louisa's father wrote to Elizabeth Cady Stanton in 1869, which gives you some idea of who this man was:
Woman is helping herself to secure her place in a better spirit and manner than any we [men] can suggest or devise, it becomes us to take, rather than proffer Consels, readily waiting to learn her wishes and aims, as she has so long, and so patiently deferred to us.
In 1879, Louisa May Alcott was the first woman to register to vote in Concord - for the school committee election. Pretty awesome, huh?
Her beloved father passed away on March 4, 1888. Louisa May Alcott died two days later.
An extraordinary woman.
She didn't care for the book that made her name ... and probably wished that her legacy was different ... but that's okay. It is not for the artist to decide what the audience will react to, what the reader will respond to. She created something with Little Women that transcends the ages, that pierces through the centuries. It is a classic book. And perhaps it's fitting, in a way, that she wrote it for hire, pretty much - it was not her idea, and yet - look at what she was able to create. Look at what she was able to bring out!!
Those 4 girls are immortal.
When I was 16 years old, one of the assignments we had in our Drama class was to do a one-person show - maybe 15, 20 minutes long - based on either a real person from history, or a fictional character - and we had to come into the class as that character, and do a monologue - based on our research - and then take questions from the class - in character. I still remember my core group of friends and their projects: Beth came in as Mae West. She was incredible. She had on a blowsy blonde wig, and wore a tight sparkley dress - and I still remember the shock when Beth started telling us all about birth control options - because Mae West was an early champion of birth control for women. It was awesome. Beth was fearless. Betsy did Paddington Bear (although she has no memory of this! But I SWEAR it is true!!) (and I still remember how one of the questions for Betsy was: "Why don't you eat some of your marmalade?" and Betsy - who despises marmalade - had to dip her hand into the jar, take out a big scoop of it, and eat it - pretending she liked it. Now that's dedication to the acting craft!). Michele did Marilyn Monroe. Unbelievable. Michele was an amazing actress, a natural. She got the sadness beneath the blonde glamour of Marilyn.
And I did Louisa May Alcott.
One of my first forays into the one-person show format ... I did hours and hours and hours of research for a mere 20 minute piece - because I had no idea what questions people would ask, and I had to be ready for anything!
It was great, because I had known nothing about her before that. I had just read Little Women and we had also visited her house in Concord on a family trip (a great thing to do if you are in the area). Orchard House:

Once I learned all this stuff about her, my admiration for her grew. I loved that our birthdays were almost the same. She was a Sagittarius too.

Little Women. Here's the excerpt I posted from it - an excerpt that still, after so many times reading it, brings a lump to my throat.
I don't know if I would call Little Women a great book - but I would say that it is something much better than "great": it is beloved. And that is a rare and precious thing.
Happy birthday, Louisa May!


He was a poet (virtually unknown in his own lifetime), and also an engraver (I've put some of his startling work in the extended entry - but if you want to see more of his work, check out this link). He did illustrations for children's books, religious books, volumes of poetry ... and now his stuff is considered priceless.
William Blake was born in 1757 in London, the third of five children. He went to school until he was 14 and then had to go to work. He got a job as an apprentice to an engraver, which is how he ended up making his paltry living. He lived in pretty much poverty for his entire life. He married at 25 the illiterate Catherine Boucher. Blake taught her how to read, and they ended up becoming collaborators in bringing out volumes of his poetry. He did engravings to illustrate his poems. Catherine was the one who bound the books, and got them ready for publication. The entire thing was a joint production. They did all the work themselves.
The two of them never had any children. They were extremely unconventional, and visitors tell of stopping by the Blake house to find the two of them sitting out in their back garden completely naked. Just hanging out, reading, working together, NUDE. They had a whole philosophy about nakedness, and sex, and innocence - that there was nothing dirty about any of that stuff. It actually all was quite holy, and it was human prudery that made celebration of the body a dirty thing.
William Blake had visions. He speaks about them openly and much of his work has a phantasmagorical religious feeling to it. When he was a young boy, he said he looked up into a tree and saw that it was full of winged angels. He would get visions of Gabriel, the Virgin Mary, yadda yadda.
His view of God, the Spirit, the Holy Trinity is so inspiring to me. It's vital, it's alive, and it seems to be all about love. There are not too many people I would call "genius" - but Blake I most certainly would. On the edge of sanity? Sure. Whatever. Many geniuses are.
However - again - William Blake, despite these astonishing works of poetry he put out during his lifetime - died unrecognized.
Now, though, he is considered to be one of the greatest poets in the English language.
He's one of my all-time favorites.
His poem about the little lisping chimney-sweep is in the "canon". If you took any kind of sweeping Poetry 101 course, you probably would have encountered it. I'll post it below. But it's really his long form poems, especially the SPECTACULAR "Marriage of Heaven and Hell", where the guy literally has no equal. None. Blake has no peers.
Here's the one about the chimney sweep, which is an indictment of the society in which he lives, a society that treats its most innocent members with brutality and uncaring indifference. He is a visionary poet, yes, but he did not turn his eyes away from earthly matters. Far from it.
"The Chimney Sweep" - from Songs of Innocence
When my mother died I was very young,
And my father sold me while yet my tongue
Could scarcely cry 'weep! 'weep! 'weep! 'weep!
So your chimneys I sweep, and in soot I sleep.
There's little Tom Dacre, who cried when his head,
That curled like a lamb's back, was shaved: so I said,
"Hush, Tom! never mind it, for when your head's bare,
You know that the soot cannot spoil your white hair."
And so he was quiet; and that very night,
As Tom was a-sleeping, he had such a sight, -
That thousands of sweepers, Dick, Joe, Ned, and Jack,
Were all of them locked up in coffins of black.
And by came an angel who had a bright key,
And he opened the coffins and set them all free;
Then down a green plain leaping, laughing, they run,
And wash in a river, and shine in the sun.
Then naked and white, all their bags left behind,
They rise upon clouds and sport in the wind;
And the angel told Tom, if he'd be a good boy,
He'd have God for his father, and never want joy.
And so Tom awoke; and we rose in the dark,
And got with our bags and our brushes to work.
Though the morning was cold, Tom was happy and warm;
So if all do their duty they need not fear harm.
And here ... for those of you who are interested ... is "Marriage of Heaven and Hell" in its entirety (accompanied by more of Blake's engravings).
Just go with it. Just succumb.
As you can see, the guy was so ahead of his time that he is timeless. He predicts the Beat generation (and Allen Ginsberg was partially responsible for bringing Blake back into vogue), he predicts modernism, he would fit in with the poetry slams of today (except that he is, well, you know - GOOD). He was a man who plumbed his unconscious for material. He brought what was within him OUT. His poetry is the literary version of Van Gogh's Starry Night. Van Gogh was not interpreting the sky. Van Gogh was actually painting what he saw. William Blake is the same way.
I think my favorite line from William Blake is:
The eagle never lost so much time as when he submitted to learn of the crow.
I have reminded myself of those lines from time to time, when I am chastised by mediocrity, or an attitude that wants to bring you down, slap your hand from stepping out of the pack. Mediocrity wants you to be mediocre as well, so that you won't make anyone feel bad.
I'm not saying I am an eagle, but I will say that worrying TOO much about what the crows are chattering about is a big waste of time.
Thanks, Blake! Wish I could have visited you and your wife in your back garden, and sat around with you all, nude, drinking tea, and talking about angels.
Here are some quotes by and about William Blake. Enjoy!
"He had no public: he very early gave up publishing in any serious sense. one obvious consequence, or aspect, of this knowledge is the carelessness that is so apparent in the later prophetic books. Blake had ceased to be capable of taking enough trouble." -- F.R. Leavis
Improvement makes strait roads, but the crooked roads without Improvement, are roads of Genius. -- Blake
"I mean, don't you think it's a little bit excessive?"
"The road of excess leads to the palace of wisdom. William Blake."
Pause.
"William Blake?"
"William Blake!"
"William Blake???"
"William Blake!!!"
-- Bull Durham
"I do not condemn Pope or Dryden because they did not understand imagination, but because they did not understand verse." -- William Blake
"The prophetic robe with its woof of meekness and its warp of wrath was forced on [Blake] by loneliness and his modest station in life." -- Robert Graves
"In his youth, [Blake] had a gift of simple and fair speech; but he lost it. Although he could always catch the heavenly harmony of thoughts he could seldom mount them on a fitting chariot of rhythm and rhyme. His fine passages were the direct gift of the Muse, and are followed by lines of other origin." -- Edward Thomas
"It is an honesty against which the whole world conspires, because it is unpleasant." -- T.S. Eliot
"Think of a white cloud as being holy, you cannot love it, but think of a holy man within the cloud, love springs up in your thoughts, for to think of holiness distinct from man is impossible to the affections. Thought alone can make monsters, but the affections cannot." -- Blake
"He is very eighteenth century." -- T.S. Eliot
"The emotions are presented in an extremely simplified, abstract form. This form is one illustration of the eternal struggle of art against education, of the literary artist against the continuous deterioration of language." -- T.S. Eliot on "Songs of Innocence" and "Songs of Experience"
"In America in the late 1940s Allen Ginsberg, interested in Supreme Reality, alone and suffering a 'dark night of the soul sort of,' his lover Neal Cassady having sloped off, and having himself just masturbated, with a volume of Blake before him - 'I wasn't even reading, my eye was idling over the page of "Ah, Sun-flower," and it suddenly appeared - the poem I'd read a lot of times before.' He began to understand the poem, and 'suddenly, simultaneously with understanding it,' he 'heard a very deep earthen grave voice in the room, which I immediately assumed, I didn't think twice, was Blake's voice.' This 'apparitional voice' became his guiding spirit: 'It was like God had a human voice, with all the infinite tenderness and anciency and mortal gravity of a living Creator speaking to his son.' On Ginsberg this 'anciency fathered Howl, though the Blake simulacrum was aided by the hallucinogens popular at the time, the recipe for Part II of the poem including peyote, just as for Kaddish he was assisted by amphetamine injections. 'The amphetamine gives a peculiar metaphysical tinge to things, also. Space-outs.' Blake managed his visions without substance abuse. Ginsberg's appropriation of the poet of innocence and experience did much to promote Blake to the alternative culture of the 1950s and 1960s." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"a completely and uncompromisingly individual idiom and technique ... individual, original, and isolated enough to be without influence." -- FR Leavis
"You cannot create a very large poem without introducing a more impersonal point of view, or splitting it up into various personalities. But the weakness of the long poems is certainly not that they are too visionary, too remote from the world. It is that Blake did not see enough, became too much occupied with ideas." -- TS Eliot
"Romantic writers glorified childhood as a state of innocence. Blake's 'The Chimey Sweeper', written in the same year as the French Revolution, combines the Romantic cult of the child with the new radical politics, whichcan both be traced to social thinker Jean-Jacques Rousseau. It is the boy sweep, rather than Blake, who speaks: he acts as the poet's dramatic persona or mask. There is no anger in his tale. On the contrary, the sweep's gentle acceptance of his miserable life makes his exploitation seem all the more atrocious. Blake shifts responsibility for protest onto us." -- Camille Paglia, "Break, Blow, Burn"
Some of William Blake's extraordinary engravings below:
Christ in the sepulcher guarded by angels - 1805

Whirlwind of Lovers (Illustration to Dante's Inferno)

The Ancient of Days - 1794

Isaac Newton - 1795


Poems and quotes from and about her below - in honor of this amazing talent, who pretty much burst fully-formed onto the poetry scene. Kind of incredible. When you read the Complete Poems, you can feel her sliding off the rails at the end (I'm not talking about mentally - I'm talking about the quality of her work, although the two are probably related) ... but still. A remarkable journey. With some WONDERFUL poems. My favorite of hers is below the jump.
LIVE
Live or die, but don't poison everything...
Well, death's been here
for a long time --
it has a hell of a lot
to do with hell
and suspicion of the eye
and the religious objects
and how I mourned them
when they were made obscene
by my dwarf-heart's doodle.
The chief ingredient
is mutilation.
And mud, day after day,
mud like a ritual,
and the baby on the platter,
cooked but still human,
cooked also with little maggots,
sewn onto it maybe by somebody's mother,
the damn bitch!
Even so,
I kept right on going on,
a sort of human statement,
lugging myself as if
I were a sawed-off body
in the trunk, the steamer trunk.
This became perjury of the soul.
It became an outright lie
and even though I dressed the body
it was still naked, still killed.
It was caught
in the first place at birth,
like a fish.
But I play it, dressed it up,
dressed it up like somebody's doll.
Is life something you play?
And all the time wanting to get rid of it?
And further, everyone yelling at you
to shut up. And no wonder!
People don't like to be told
that you're sick
and then be forced
to watch
you
come
down with the hammer.
Today life opened inside me like an egg
and there inside
after considerable digging
I found the answer.
What a bargain!
There was the sun,
her yolk moving feverishly,
tumbling her prize --
and you realize she does this daily!
I'd known she was a purifier
but I hadn't thought
she was solid,
hadn't known she was an answer.
God! It's a dream,
lovers sprouting in the yard
like celery stalks
and better,
a husband straight as a redwood,
two daughters, two sea urchings,
picking roses off my hackles.
If I'm on fire they dance around it
and cook marshmallows.
And if I'm ice
they simply skate on me
in little ballet costumes.
Here,
all along,
thinking I was a killer,
anointing myself daily
with my little poisons.
But no.
I'm an empress.
I wear an apron.
My typewriter writes.
It didn't break the way it warned.
Even crazy, I'm as nice
as a chocolate bar.
Even with the witches' gymnastics
they trust my incalculable city,
my corruptible bed.
O dearest three,
I make a soft reply.
The witch comes on
and you paint her pink.
I come with kisses in my hood
and the sun, the smart one,
rolling in my arms.
So I say Live
and turn my shadow three times round
to feed our puppies as they come,
the eight Dalmatians we didn't drown,
despite the warnings: The abort! The destroy!
Despite the pails of water that waited,
to drown them, to pull them down like stones,
they came, each one headfirst, blowing bubbles the color of cataract-blue
and fumbling for the tiny tits.
Just last week, eight Dalmatians,
3/4 of a lb., lined up like cord wood
each
like a
birch tree.
I promise to love more if they come,
because in spite of cruelty
and the stuffed railroad cars for the ovens,
I am not what I expected. Not an Eichmann.
The poison just didn't take.
So I won't hang around in my hospital shift,
repeating The Black Mass and all of it.
I say Live, Live because of the sun,
the dream, the excitable gift.
"What Sexton suggested to Plath was the force of simple rhyme and simple rhythm, the magic of nursery rhyme darkened by time, of fairy tale where the happy ending somehow doesn't happen. Sexton showed Plath the way, and then Plath died first, stealing a march on her friend, which Sexton resented and envied. Four years Plath's senior, Anne Sexton survived her by twelve years, committing suicide in 1974. But Plath keeps hold of the laurels. There are wonderful things in the Complete Poems of Sexton, published in 1981, but many of them are things we associate, whatever their original source, with Plath, and Sexton's work seems but a footnote to hers." -_ Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"Have rejected the Electra poem from my book. Too forced and rhetorical. A leaf from Anne Sexton's book would do here. She has none of my clenches and an ease of phrase, and an honesty. I have my 40 unattackable poems." -- Sylvia Plath, journal, April 23, 1959
" I hold back nothing." -- Anne Sexton, 1969
"Once, when I wrote to her about my terror of publishing a second book of poems, she answered: 'Don't dwell on the book's reception. The point is to get on with it--you have a life's work ahead of you--no point in dallying around waiting for approval. We all want it, I know, but the point is to reach out honestly--that's the whole point. I keep feeling that there isn't one poem being written by any of us--or a book or anything like that. The whole life of us writers, the whole product I guess I mean, is the one long poem--a community effort if you will. It's all the same poem. It doesn't belong to any one writer--it's God's poem perhaps. Or God's people's poem. You have the gift-- and with it comes responsibility--you mustn't neglect or be mean to that gift--you must let it do its work. It has more rights than the ego that wants approval.'" -- Erica Jong
"My own struggle with Anne Sexton, for twenty years now, has not been about her subject matter (she is the one who taught me that you can write a poem about anything), but about the blatant deterioration of her talent. Sexton's Complete Poems appeared in 1981, edited by her daughter/literary executor Linda Gray Sexton. This volume includes the eight books Anne Sexton sent to press during her lifetime, as well as one hundred and thirty pages of posthumously published poems. Though fascinating as Sexton documents, the latter are shockingly sloppy and full of over-the-top, bad-trip imagery. This, coupled with the fact that the last three books she did publish (The Book of Folly, The Death Notebooks, and That Awful Rowing Toward God) saw an obvious decline in quality, has made it difficult to come to grips with her complete body of work. It also didn't help that, after her death, her former mentor Robert Lowell wrote that her writing had become "meager and exaggerated." I jokingly refer to Sexton's late period as "Bad Anne." How else to reconcile such slipshod lines as "I flee. I flee. / I block my ears and eat salami" with her amazing early metaphors ("leaves . . . born in their own green blood / like the hands of mermaids") and admissions ("Once I was beautiful. Now I am myself")? It's too painful to think of her simply as a brilliant poet who got bad. And too easy, somehow, to blame it on pills, alcohol, insanity, fame. Better, I recently decided, to think of her as a genius with demons, writing to beat the clock. " -- David Trinidad
"One feels tempted to drop [Sexton's poems] furtively in the nearest ashcan, rather than to be caught with them in the presence of so much naked suffering." -- James Dickey
Sylvia's Death - by Anne Sexton
for Sylvia Plath
O Sylvia, Sylvia,
with a dead box of stones and spoons,
with two children, two meteors
wandering loose in a tiny playroom,
with your mouth into the sheet,
into the roofbeam, into the dumb prayer,
(Sylvia, Sylvia
where did you go
after you wrote me
from Devonshire
about rasing potatoes
and keeping bees?)
what did you stand by,
just how did you lie down into?
Thief --
how did you crawl into,
crawl down alone
into the death I wanted so badly and for so long,
the death we said we both outgrew,
the one we wore on our skinny breasts,
the one we talked of so often each time
we downed three extra dry martinis in Boston,
the death that talked of analysts and cures,
the death that talked like brides with plots,
the death we drank to,
the motives and the quiet deed?
(In Boston
the dying
ride in cabs,
yes death again,
that ride home
with our boy.)
O Sylvia, I remember the sleepy drummer
who beat on our eyes with an old story,
how we wanted to let him come
like a sadist or a New York fairy
to do his job,
a necessity, a window in a wall or a crib,
and since that time he waited
under our heart, our cupboard,
and I see now that we store him up
year after year, old suicides
and I know at the news of your death
a terrible taste for it, like salt,
(And me,
me too.
And now, Sylvia,
you again
with death again,
that ride home
with our boy.)
And I say only
with my arms stretched out into that stone place,
what is your death
but an old belonging,
a mole that fell out
of one of your poems?
(O friend,
while the moon's bad,
and the king's gone,
and the queen's at her wit's end
the bar fly ought to sing!)
O tiny mother,
you too!
O funny duchess!
O blonde thing!
"I'm hunting for the truth. It might be a kind of poetic truth, and not just a factual one, because behind everything that happens to you, there is another truth, a secret life." -- Anne Sexton
More on Anne Sexton here
Keats was born on this day in London, 1795. "Ode to Autumn" is perhaps my favorite of his - but today, for his birthday, I will post: "Ode on Melancholy". And below the poem are a bunch of compiled quotes - from Keats and about Keats. He brings up strong reactions in people. Many adore, many think something is lacking ... but all give him the props. I particularly love the quote I found from Robert Graves.
Ode on Melancholy
1.
No, no, go not to Lethe, neither twist
Wolfs-bane, tight-rooted, for its poisonous wine;
Nor suffer thy pale forehead to be kiss'd
By nightshade, ruby grape of Proserpine;
Make not your rosary of yew-berries,
Nor let the beetle, nor the death-moth be
Your mournful Psyche, nor the downy owl
A partner in your sorrow's mysteries;
For shade to shade will come too drowsily,
And drown the wakeful anguish of the soul.
2.
But when the melancholy fit shall fall
Sudden from heaven like a weeping cloud,
That fosters the droop-headed flowers all,
And hides the green hill in an April shroud;
Then glut thy sorrow on a morning rose,
Or on the rainbow of the salt sand-wave,
Or on the wealth of globed peonies;
Or if thy mistress some rich anger shows,
Emprison her soft hand, and let her rave,
And feed deep, deep upon her peerless eyes.
3.
She dwells with Beauty - Beauty that must die;
And Joy, whose hand is ever at his lips
Bidding adieu; and aching Pleasure nigh,
Turning to poison while the bee-mouth sips:
Ay, in the very temple of Delight
Veil'd Melancholy has her sovran shrine,
Though seen of none save him whose strenuous tongue
Can burst Joy's grape against his palate fine;
His soul shall taste the sadness of her might,
And be among her cloudy trophies hung.

"One song of Burns is of more worth to you than all I could think of for a whole year in his native country. His Misery is a dead weight on the nimbleness of one's quill ... he talked with Bitches, he drank with blackguards, he was miserable. We can see horribly clear in the works of such a Man his whole life, as if we were God's spies." -- John Keats on Robert Burns
"Shelley was a volatile creature of air and fire: he seems never to have noticed what he ate or drank, except sometimes as a matter of vegetarian principle. Keats was earthy, with a sweet tooth and a relish for spices, cream and snuff, and in a letter mentions peppering his own tongue to bring out the delicious coolness of claret. When Shelley in Prometheus Unbound mentions: "The yellow bees in the ivy-bloom", he does not conjure up, as Keats would have done, the taste of the last hot days of the dying English year, with over-ripe blackberries, ditches full of water, and the hedges grey with old man's beard. He is not aware of the veteran bees whirring their frayed wings or sucking rank honey from the dusty yellow blossoms of the ivy." -- Robert Graves
"On the whole, I do not like Keats. His poems are, in reality, too full of beauty. One feels stifled in roses ... There is little in Keats' poems except luscious beauty -- so much of it that the reader is surfeited." -- L.M. Montgomery
"These are the pure Magic. These are the clear vision. The rest is only poetry." -- Rudyard Kipling on John Keats and Samuel Coleridge
"He'd planned to become a surgeon, but he realized his real vocation was poetry, and in the spring of 1818, he published his first major long poem Endymion. And then he set out on a hike through the countryside with his friend Charles Brown. Wordsworth was one of Keats's favorite poets, and he knew that Wordsworth had been inspired by walking around England, so Keats decided to do the same that summer.
Keats was a London boy. He had never seen the mountains. He had never seen a waterfall. He wrote letters back to his brother about the wonderful things that he saw, but gradually on his hike he realized he was no Wordsworth, that he did not want to write about scenery. He hated descriptions. He was more interested in the people whom he saw along the way. He was fascinated by the peasants who walked barefoot on the roads, carrying their shoes and stockings so they would look nice when they got to town. He saw an old woman being carried along the road in a kind of a cage like a dog kennel, smoking a pipe.
He came back to London and learned that the reviews of his last book of poetry, Endymion, were coming in and critics had written ferocious attacks on him. He was crushed. And his brother had come down with a serious case of tuberculosis. His brother died in December, and by the end of that year, John Keats had contracted tuberculosis himself. He would die three years later, in 1821. It was in those last three years of his life that he wrote most of his greatest poems." -- Garrison Keillor
"He ramped through [Spenser's[ Fairie Queen ... like a young horse turned into a Spring meadow." -- Cowden Clarke, a friend of Keats
"The imagery he chose was predominantly sexual. Poetry for him was not a philosophical theory, as it was for Shelley, but a moment of physical delirium." -- Robert Graves
"... miserable self-polluter of the human mind."-- Shelley
"I look upon fine phrases as a lover." -- John Keats
"Keats as a poet is abundantly and enchantingly sensuous, but the question with some people will be, whether he is anything else." -- Matthew Arnold
"The three great narratives, rich in detail, idealized characterization, and gothic elements, inspired poets, painters and musicians later in the century. The Pre-Raphaelites in particular drew sustenance from them. 'The Eve of St. Agnes' radically reconfigures resources of tone and characterization that Keats adapted from Chaucer to Shakespeare. Romeo and Juliet was not far from his hand when he wrote the poem. And his phrasing owes Shakespeare a debt. Cymbeline suggests the way Madeline's bedchamber is made solid before our eyes. Keats does not imitate his masters: he has assimilated them. The odes - 'To a Nightingale,' 'On a Grecian Urn', 'To Autumn', and the lesser 'To Psyche' and 'On Melancholy' -- are incomparable. The charge that he 'lacked experience' is fatuous; nor are they 'merely sensuous'. They are the step beyond moral romance to the romance of feeling itself, feeling as subject, the 'true voice'." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"I have loved the principle of beauty in all things." -- John Keats
" ... a sensuous mystic." -- Louis MacNeice
"Keats was short-sighted. He did not see landscapes as such, so he treated them as painted cabinets filled with interesting objects ... His habit was to allow his eye to be seduced from entire vision by particular objects ... He saw little but what moved: the curving, the wreathing, the slanting, the waving - and even then, it seems, not the whole object is in motion but only its edge, or highlight." -- Robert Graves
"Keats's yearning passion for the Beautiful is not a passion of the sensuous or sentimental poet. It is an intellectual and spiritual passion." -- Matthew Arnold
"Milton had an exquisite passion for what is properly, in the sense of ease and pleasure, poetical luxury, and with that, it appears to me, he would fair have been content, if he could, so doing, preserve his self-respect and feeling of duty performed." -- John Keats
This Grave
contains all that was Mortal
of a
Young English Poet
Who
on his Death Bed
in the Bitterness of his Heart
at the Malicious Power of his Enemies
Desired
these words to be engraved on his Tomb Stone
"Here lies One Whose Name was writ in Water."
-- Keats' epitaph
"Poetry should strike the reader as a wording of his own highest thoughts, and appear almost a remembrance." -- John Keats
More on John Keats' short life here
... and more in this wonderful post by Ms. Baroque, who may very well be my new favorite blogger. I love how she writes. I have heard a bit about the book she mentions (or one of them) - the Henry James, Oscar Wilde and Aesthetic Culture book and have been VERY curious to read it myself. I'm not a James fan, as I believe I have mentioned before - but i found the excerpt she posted from his journal after the famous failure ("failure" is putting it mildly) of his play - very very touching. Wow.
"Death opened, like a black tree, blackly."
Today is Sylvia Plath's birthday.
That's a sketch she did of her own hands. She found drawing very relaxing. She would lose herself in it, and spent most of her honeymoon in Spain (a place she found almost unbearably upsetting - Ted Hughes, her husband, wrote a poem many years later called "You Hated Spain") - anyway, she spent most of her honeymoon huddled over a sketch pad. She drew the streets, the fruit baskets, the fishing boats. Was there pleasure in it for her? I don't know. I think it was a way to unhinge her brain for a moment, lose herself in the moment - where all she could do, all she was able to do, was just copy what she saw. She didn't have to find the right word, or struggle with the poetry muse ... she just had to sit down and copy what she saw. Ted Hughes wrote a poem, too, about her drawing.
I haven't yet written a real piece on Sylvia Plath - because I know when I finaly get to it, it'll be a doozy. It'll take me hours of research, and compiling quotes, and snippets, and poems, and yadda yadda. I need to have the time to invest. That's just the deal with certain topics - and Sylvia Plath is one of them.
In honor of the birthday of this eventually astonishing poet (she didn't start out that way, although she was certainly precocious - but NONE of her early work could prepare you for what her work became in the last 2 years of her life - it's like another PERSON came out of her ....) - I have dug up some wonderful old photographs of her. She was a chameleon. She was an all-American girl. She was a bleached blonde beach-blanket-bingo girl. She was an intense prodigy. She was a depressive who had survived a suicide attempt her junior year in college. She was the woman who married the big brash English outdoorsman, and suddenly found herself fishing, and hunting, and tromping through the woods in galoshes. Who was she? I have no idea. But you can take a look at all the photographs and see how startling are the transformations. This is not just about the passage of time, and someone looking different as they grew older ... this really seems to be about a shedding of selves (like she writes in Lady Lazarus, in one of my favorite lines: "my selves dissolving, old whores petticoats") -
I look at the picture of the bodacious blonde at the beach:

This was from her summer of recovery from her suicide attempt in college. She spent months in an institution - and then went back to Smith to finish out her education. When summer came - she bleached her hair. Her mother - the controlling prudish Aurelia Plath - and yes, there's enough information out there on this woman for me to feel completely comfortable labeling her as that - was shocked. She pretended to be supportive - but deep down, she wanted a conventional daughter. Well, sorry, Aurelia, ain't never gonna happen. Sylvia tormented herself trying to be conventional (many of her problems arose from what she felt was expected from her - as a daughter, as a wife, as a woman, in general) - and bleaching her hair was part of a necessary rebellion. Also, she started having sex. Left and right. Willy nilly. No more good 1950s girl. That "be a good girl" thing had nearly killed her. Her doctor at the time encouraged this rebellion, and taught her about birth control, so she could at least have sex safely. This was a revelation to Sylvia. She was a very sexual person, passionate, kind of wild actually - even with all that "ooh, I'm a poetic prodigy" thing - and you know, the thing is - any type of artist will always be on the fringe of polite society. If an artist tries desperately to fit in to some mainstream - if an artist really worries about what an uptight person thinks of how he or she lives ... then that artist just won't survive. The strict rules on women at that time were fetters around Sylvia's wrists. NOT CARING what people thought of her - was one of the biggest breakthroughs in her life. NOT CARING if people whispered, "She's a slut." And they did. Especially when she got to England on her Fulbright. Tapping into her REBEL, into her "I just don't care" persona ... was really important - but ultimately, it didn't matter at all. Because once she got married and once she had kids - these old conventional "roles" started constricting her again (she writes about it extensively in her poems) ... It seemed that there was an incompatability: between the poetess and the woman. Could she be a wife and ALSO a poet? What were the expectations of her? It did not help matters (although she might have thought it would) that she married not just another poet - but one of the most important up-and-coming poets in England - a man who eventually (years later) would be Poet Laureate. Like - Ted Hughes was a big deal. And he was on his way to becoming a big deal when Sylvia met him. How can two poets tryiing to make their names - live together? Was Sylvia expected to be a good 1950s wife? Ted Hughes insists (and he has also written extensively about it) that he did not expect that at all. When he first met Sylvia at a party - they both were drunk - and they basically found themselves in an empty room - making out ferociously. Sylvia bit his cheek so hard she drew blood. They were married 4 months later. THIS was their beginning. There was no nice good-girl 1950s courtship. They didn't go out for sodas and a drive-in. No. They were bohemians, for God's sake. They were poets. People like that don't live by society's rules, nor should they. (Especially if the rules are stupid.) But Ted, in some of his later poems, has described how baffled and hurt he was - after their marriage - when Sylvia suddenly got writer's block. She had writer's block for an agonizing year, year and a half - directly after their wedding. Hmmmm, coincidence? I think not. It seems apparent that Sylvia was so terrified of doing BETTER than her husband that ... everything shut down. She then tried to be the perfect housewife - and ... Ted, again, was hurt and confused by this. Where is that wild poetess? Where is my crazy American girl who shouts out lines of Chaucer to the cows? Why is she in the kitchen, tears running down her face, trying to bake pies? I mean ... what has happened??
Then I look at the picture of her with her two kids (taken a month or so before she committed suicide) -

Actually, I believe her mother took that photograph during her fateful visit to her daughter. Sylvia was living in England - and her husband Ted Hughes had just left her for another woman. Comparing that photograph to the blonde bikini one - it;s hard to believe it's the same person. Perhaps there's something similar in the smile - there's something phony in both smiles, to my eye. Anyway, I find it fascinating - perusing the photos of Sylvia Plath.
Not nearly as fascinating as her poems themselves which have never lost their power - no matter how times I have read them.
I have gone through a bunch of Plath phases - and I am sure I will go through more. I continue to re-visit her work, every couple of years ... and re-read all those 1960-1963 poems again - sometimes in order - sometimes muddling it up - and every single time, even though I always have different responses, and sometimes one poem suddenly seems THE BEST when a couple years before it was another poem that was obviously HER BEST - but anyway, every single time I read those poems from her last 3 years, they take my breath away. They're no picnic - they are bleak bleak bleak - especially if you read them chronologically. If you read them chronologically - you can feel herself get manic - in October of 62 - and she starts cranking out 2, 3, sometimes 4 poems a day. These were not pot-boilers, folks. These poems are now taught in colleges. These are the poems that would make her name. She wasn't just scribbling out insane manic fantasies - these are highly intricate, passionate, unbeLIEVable poems. Obviously manic - when you see how many she was putting out a day ... and then there is a brief falling away for a month - December ... she was still writing, but obviously it was the calm before the storm. Then January and February 1963 came along - and I believe it was the coldest winter London had ever had - and her pipes froze - and she had no help, and two young babies - and things started getting worse and worse in her mind. And her art kicked in yet again - with ferocity and power. She would write these poems at 4 in the morning - her only time to herself. So you can feel the wheels start cranking again - in January, February - she wrote some of her best poems then. They are more frightening, however, than the October poems. She is staring at death, she is beginning to embrace the idea of death ... Death is always a factor in Plath's poems, but it takes on a new form in those last couple of poems. It is no longer just a fantasy, death is no longer a dream-lover in the night ... she is now making plans. The rage of October (which gave us such poems as Daddy, and Poppies in October, and the entire fanTASTIC bee-keeping sequence) is now gone. And you can feel a chilling resolve creep into her work. She is getting ready to go.
I have interspersed the photos of Plath I found with some of my favorite of her poems.
I still need to do a big old Plath fest one day - I have too much to say about her, and need to get my thoughts together better.
In honor of her birthday, here's one that she actually wrote about her upcoming birthday - in 1962. She wrote this poem, now one of her most well-known, on Sept. 30 1962 ... right before the blast of creativity and rage that would fuel her through that painful next month. Sylvia always had a fatalistic thing with birthdays:
A Birthday Present
What is this, behind this veil, is it ugly, is it beautiful?
It is shimmering, has it breasts, has it edges?
I am sure it is unique, I am sure it is what I want.
When I am quiet at my cooking I feel it looking, I feel it thinking
'Is this the one I am too appear for,
Is this the elect one, the one with black eye-pits and a scar?
Measuring the flour, cutting off the surplus,
Adhering to rules, to rules, to rules.
Is this the one for the annunciation?
My god, what a laugh!'
But it shimmers, it does not stop, and I think it wants me.
I would not mind if it were bones, or a pearl button.
I do not want much of a present, anyway, this year.
After all I am alive only by accident.
I would have killed myself gladly that time any possible way.
Now there are these veils, shimmering like curtains,
The diaphanous satins of a January window
White as babies' bedding and glittering with dead breath. O ivory!
It must be a tusk there, a ghost column.
Can you not see I do not mind what it is.
Can you not give it to me?
Do not be ashamed--I do not mind if it is small.
Do not be mean, I am ready for enormity.
Let us sit down to it, one on either side, admiring the gleam,
The glaze, the mirrory variety of it.
Let us eat our last supper at it, like a hospital plate.
I know why you will not give it to me,
You are terrified
The world will go up in a shriek, and your head with it,
Bossed, brazen, an antique shield,
A marvel to your great-grandchildren.
Do not be afraid, it is not so.
I will only take it and go aside quietly.
You will not even hear me opening it, no paper crackle,
No falling ribbons, no scream at the end.
I do not think you credit me with this discretion.
If you only knew how the veils were killing my days.
To you they are only transparencies, clear air.
But my god, the clouds are like cotton.
Armies of them. They are carbon monoxide.
Sweetly, sweetly I breathe in,
Filling my veins with invisibles, with the million
Probable motes that tick the years off my life.
You are silver-suited for the occasion. O adding machine-----
Is it impossible for you to let something go and have it go whole?
Must you stamp each piece purple,
Must you kill what you can?
There is one thing I want today, and only you can give it to me.
It stands at my window, big as the sky.
It breathes from my sheets, the cold dead center
Where split lives congeal and stiffen to history.
Let it not come by the mail, finger by finger.
Let it not come by word of mouth, I should be sixty
By the time the whole of it was delivered, and to numb to use it.
Only let down the veil, the veil, the veil.
If it were death
I would admire the deep gravity of it, its timeless eyes.
I would know you were serious.
There would be a nobility then, there would be a birthday.
And the knife not carve, but enter
Pure and clean as the cry of a baby,
And the universe slide from my side.

That's a picture of Sylvia from 1953 - right before her first suicide attempt. She was living with her mother - and her mother made her take shorthand classes and typing classes (again: there is something evil about that. That very same attitude is why Barbra Streisand has always had such long nails. People laugh at those nails, or make fun of Babs for them ... but I see them, and I love them. Because to her - those nails meant freedom. Her mother was pretty much totally negative about Barbra's actual goals - she wanted to have a normal daughter - so she signed her up for typing classes. In rebellion, Babs grew her nails to extraordinary length so that even if she wanted to learn how to type - she couldn't. The nails got in the way. So when I see those nails now - on a 60 something year old woman - I smile. It's a reminder.) There is a story here - of the mother who truly DOESN'T love her daughter. She doesn't. Otherwise - she would love her for who she actually IS, not who she wants her to be. Aurelia Plath never got that. Sylvia, at the end of her life, was starting to come to terms with that. She writes, quite blatantly, in her journal, "I can never live near my mother again." And her mother comes to visit in Oct. 1962 - right after Ted has moved out - to be with Assia Wevill - the woman he was having an affair with - and Sylvia was absolutely tormented by having her mother see her in such a weak moment. To her, it was unforgivable. She wrote her poem "Medusa" about that experience - which is, you know, shocking in its hatred, and anger. But again: poets who live by society's rules and play well with others are usually not poets to be reckoned with. Sylvia coming to terms with her rage was part of her finding her voice.
"The Moon and the Yew Tree" was written in 1961 - and is considered a breakthrough - by those who have studied Plath's work. In it - she finds some of that cold clear eerie imagery - that she will write about until the very end. She looks out her window and sees a moon, a church, and a black yew tree. It is a beautiful image - and yet ... in the poem ... it becomes a harbinger. Of death, doom.
And personally - I think the first line of this poem is one of her best lines ever.
The moon and the yew tree
This is the light of the mind, cold and planetary
The trees of the mind are black. The light is blue.
The grasses unload their griefs on my feet as if I were God
Prickling my ankles and murmuring of their humility
Fumy, spiritous mists inhabit this place.
Separated from my house by a row of headstones.
I simply cannot see where there is to get to.
The moon is no door. It is a face in its own right,
White as a knuckle and terribly upset.
It drags the sea after it like a dark crime; it is quiet
With the O-gape of complete despair. I live here.
Twice on Sunday, the bells startle the sky ----
Eight great tongues affirming the Resurrection
At the end, they soberly bong out their names.
The yew tree points up, it has a Gothic shape.
The eyes lift after it and find the moon.
The moon is my mother. She is not sweet like Mary.
Her blue garments unloose small bats and owls.
How I would like to believe in tenderness ----
The face of the effigy, gentled by candles,
Bending, on me in particular, its mild eyes.
I have fallen a long way. Clouds are flowering
Blue and mystical over the face of the stars
Inside the church, the saints will all be blue,
Floating on their delicate feet over the cold pews,
Their hands and faces stiff with holiness.
The moon sees nothing of this. She is bald and wild.
And the message of the yew tree is blackness -- blackness and silence

Little Fugue
The yew's black fingers wag:
Cold clouds go over.
So the deaf and dumb
Signal the blind, and are ignored.
I like black statements.
The featurelessness of that cloud, now!
White as an eye all over!
The eye of the blind pianist
At my table on the ship.
He felt for his food.
His fingers had the noses of weasels.
I couldn't stop looking.
He could hear Beethoven:
Black yew, white cloud,
The horrific complications.
Finger-traps--a tumult of keys.
Empty and silly as plates,
So the blind smile.
I envy big noises,
The yew hedge of the Grosse Fuge.
Deafness is something else.
Such a dark funnel, my father!
I see your voice
Black and leafy, as in my childhood.
A yew hedge of orders,
Gothic and barbarous, pure German.
Dead men cry from it.
I am guilty of nothing.
The yew my Christ, then.
Is it not as tortured?
And you, during the Great War
In the California delicatessen
Lopping off the sausages!
They colour my sleep,
Red, mottled, like cut necks.
There was a silence!
Great silence of another order.
I was seven, I knew nothing.
The world occurred.
You had one leg, and a Prussian mind.
Now similar clouds
Are spreading their vacuous sheets.
Do you say nothing?
I am lame in the memory.
I remember a blue eye,
A briefcase of tangerines.
This was a man, then!
Death opened, like a black tree, blackly.
I survive the while,
Arranging my morning.
These are my fingers, this my baby.
The clouds are a marriage of dress, of that pallor.
The Bee Meeting (this is one of the poems in her famous "bee sequence" - which she cranked out at 1 or 2 a day, during October of 1962.)
Who are these people at the bridge to meet me? They are the villagers ---
The rector, the midwife, the sexton, the agent for bees.
In my sleeveless summery dress I have no protection,
And they are all gloved and covered, why did nobody tell me?
They are smiling and taking out veils tacked to ancient hats.
I am nude as a chicken neck, does nobody love me?
Yes, here is the secretary of bees with her white shop smock,
Buttoning the cuffs at my wrists and the slit from my neck to my knees.
Now I am milkweed silk, the bees will not notice.
They will not smell my fear, my fear, my fear.
Which is the rector now, is it that man in black?
Which is the midwife, is that her blue coat?
Everybody is nodding a square black head, they are knights in visors,
Breastplates of cheesecloth knotted under the armpits.
Their smiles and their voces are changing. I am led through a beanfield.
Strips of tinfoil winking like people,
Feather dusters fanning their hands in a sea of bean flowers,
Creamy bean flowers with black eyes and leaves like bored hearts.
Is it blood clots the tendrils are dragging up that string?
No, no, it is scarlet flowers that will one day be edible.
Now they are giving me a fashionable white straw Italian hat
And a black veil that molds to my face, they are making me one of them.
They are leading me to the shorn grove, the circle of hives.
Is it the hawthorn that smells so sick?
The barren body of hawthon, etherizing its children.
Is it some operation that is taking place?
It is the surgeon my neighbors are waiting for,
This apparition in a green helmet,
Shining gloves and white suit.
Is it the butcher, the grocer, the postman, someone I know?
I cannot run, I am rooted, and the gorse hurts me
With its yellow purses, its spiky armory.
I could not run without having to run forever.
The white hive is snug as a virgin,
Sealing off her brood cells, her honey, and quietly humming.
Smoke rolls and scarves in the grove.
The mind of the hive thinks this is the end of everything.
Here they come, the outriders, on their hysterical elastics.
If I stand very still, they will think I am cow-parsley,
A gullible head untouched by their animosity,
Not even nodding, a personage in a hedgerow.
The villagers open the chambers, they are hunting the queen.
Is she hiding, is she eating honey? She is very clever.
She is old, old, old, she must live another year, and she knows it.
While in their fingerjoint cells the new virgins
Dream of a duel they will win inevitably,
A curtain of wax dividing them from the bride flight,
The upflight of the murderess into a heaven that loves her.
The villagers are moving the virgins, there will be no killing.
The old queen does not show herself, is she so ungrateful?
I am exhausted, I am exhausted ---
Pillar of white in a blackout of knives.
I am the magician's girl who does not flinch.
The villagers are untying their disguises, they are shaking hands.
Whose is that long white box in the grove, what have they accomplished, why am I cold.
Fever 103 (another Oct. 1962 poem)
Pure? What does it mean?
The tongues of hell
Are dull, dull as the triple
Tongues of dull, fat Cerebus
Who wheezes at the gate. Incapable
Of licking clean
The aguey tendon, the sin, the sin.
The tinder cries.
The indelible smell
Of a snuffed candle!
Love, love, the low smokes roll
From me like Isadora's scarves, I'm in a fright
One scarf will catch and anchor in the wheel.
Such yellow sullen smokes
Make their own element. They will not rise,
But trundle round the globe
Choking the aged and the meek,
The weak
Hothouse baby in its crib,
The ghastly orchid
Hanging its hanging garden in the air,
Devilish leopard!
Radiation turned it white
And killed it in an hour.
Greasing the bodies of adulterers
Like Hiroshima ash and eating in.
The sin. The sin.
Darling, all night
I have been flickering, off, on, off, on.
The sheets grow heavy as a lecher's kiss.
Three days. Three nights.
Lemon water, chicken
Water, water make me retch.
I am too pure for you or anyone.
Your body
Hurts me as the world hurts God. I am a lantern ---
My head a moon
Of Japanese paper, my gold beaten skin
Infinitely delicate and infinitely expensive.
Does not my heat astound you. And my light.
All by myself I am a huge camellia
Glowing and coming and going, flush on flush.
I think I am going up,
I think I may rise ---
The beads of hot metal fly, and I, love, I
Am a pure acetylene
Virgin
Attended by roses,
By kisses, by cherubim,
By whatever these pink things mean.
Not you, nor him.
Not him, nor him
(My selves dissolving, old whore petticoats) ---
To Paradise.

The Couriers (written in Nov. 1962)
The word of a snail on the plate of a leaf?
It is not mine. Do not accept it.
Acetic acid in a sealed tin?
Do not accept it. It is not genuine.
A ring of gold with the sun in it?
Lies. Lies and a grief.
Frost on a leaf, the immaculate
Cauldron, talking and crackling
All to itself on the top of each
Of nine black Alps.
A disturbance in mirrors,
The sea shattering its grey one -
Love, love, my season.

I think the following poem is the saddest she ever wrote. Now who can ever say what is in the mind of another - and it is always a dangerous thing to read too much into these poems (at least in a biographical way). They are, after all, art. But I believe that one of the reasons she killed herself is to spare her children a mother whose face was "a ceiling without a star". Not that that excuses her actions. But she wrote this poem in January of 1963, 2 weeks before she put her head in the oven. I find this poem nearly unreadable in its sadness. Yet - wonderful writing as well.
Child
Your clear eye is the one absolutely beautiful thing.
I want to fill it with color and ducks,
The zoo of the new
Whose names you meditate ---
April snowdrop, Indian pipe,
Little
Stalk without wrinkle,
Pool in which images
Should be grand and classical
Not this troublous
Wringing of hands, this dark
Ceiling without a star.

Sylvia Plath and Ted Hughes - newlyweds. Happier days. What a gorgeous couple they were.
And this is the last poem that Sylvia Plath completed. It's chilling, yes, but standing alone - as a poem - I think there's a lot to talk about here, a lot of stuff - not just biographical.
And I'm sorry - but the line "her blacks crackle and drag" is ... I mean, it's just fantastic genius-level imagery with major staying power, that's all. "Her blacks crackle and drag." (And yes ... let me just throw a shout-out to Paul Westerberg - who has also recognized the genius imagery in that line.) It's scary. "Crackle"? "Drag?" All kinds of very frightening images come to mind in those two simple words ... and the internal rhyme of "blacks" and "crackle" make it seem even more eerie. I'm not a literary critic but I will NEVER be done reading this last poem. She completed it on February 4, 1963. She killed herself on February 11.
Edge
The woman is perfected.
Her dead
Body wears the smile of accomplishment,
The illusion of a Greek necessity
Flows in the scrolls of her toga,
Her bare
Feet seem to be saying:
We have come so far, it is over.
Each dead child coiled, a white serpent,
One at each little
Pitcher of milk, now empty.
She has folded
Them back into her body as petals
Of a rose close when the garden
Stiffens and odors bleed
From the sweet, deep throats of the night flower.
The moon has nothing to be sad about,
Staring from her hood of bone.
She is used to this sort of thing.
Her blacks crackle and drag.
Let us not do a disservice to this great artist and see her only in terms of her self-inflicted end. Let us look at her art, please. Let us focus on that. If we can remove the context of her life from the poems; what is left? What do we see? What about those words, huh? What about her WORK?
Other posts I have written about Plath:
The so-called villainy of Ted Hughes
Plath's writer's block of 1959-1960
My good friend RTG took Plath obsession to a new level - Here's a post she wrote about it ... and another one ... We maintain a fantasy that one day we will meet up at the Lilly Library to go through Plath's papers together. It will happen!!
... has gone to Anne Enright, which is seen as quite an upset considering the competition - and although I have not read any of her stuff (YET) - she is next on my list after I finish Bleak House. I blithered about her here and how fabulous I think she is.
I love literary upsets, it's one of my favorite spectator sports ... and there's something about Enright's writing and her persona that I really DIG ... and that I also find a little bit frightening (most good writers frighten me a bit) - so I'm happy for her. I also really liked what she said about depression in that first link. Interesting.
Gold. Sheer gold. I'm going to tack those up over my desk. #4 is particularly hard to do - but oh, how right he is!!!
A fascinating man - a Pulitzer-Prize winning poet, along with a vice president of the Hartford Accident and Indemnity Company. He had a 9 to 5 job the entire time he was writing these amazing poems. He felt intellectually dead when he was at his job ... and yet once his fame had reached him, and he was offered professorships at Harvard - he turned them down. An interesting choice, not very common among poets. I love his stuff - I can't say I "get" it all the time, but I comfort myself that that was Stevens's point. He didn't write to be understood, not necessarily. He wrote to express, describe, contemplate ... There's a perfection in his descriptions (the following poem - his first big break as a poet - is a great example). It's not like you are looking at a picture that he is presenting to you. It's like somehow his language has brought you inside. It's unexpected - as most sensoral experiences are. Things aren't literal, when you get into the realm of experience. A scent of something may spark off a completely unrelated memory ... or a snatch of music heard makes you remember a golden slant of light from when you were four years old. The senses merge, blend, come apart, merge again. That's where Wallace Stevens seems to write from. The subjectivity of perception.
I love his stuff. (His "big-break" poem 'Sunday Morning' below - and then a bunch of quotes I compiled - by Wallace Stevens, or about Wallace Stevens. Enjoy!!)
Michael Schmidt (author of the wonderful Lives of the Poets) has this to say about 'Sunday Morning', Stevens' first published poem:
"It is hard to imagine a more astonishing debut in 'Poetry'. Each line and each sentence is transparently clear, each image alive, the voices that speak are heard to speak. The difficulty only arises if we seek to paraphrase, because the poem as a whole is a process that cannot be reduced to a single meaning or set of meanings. It has taken us from a lawn, a late breakfast, a woman beginning a languid Sunday out of doors, through meditations on meaning, to a known wilderness."
Sunday Morning
1
Complacencies of the peignoir, and late
Coffee and oranges in a sunny chair,
And the green freedom of a cockatoo
Upon a rug mingle to dissipate
The holy hush of ancient sacrifice.
She dreams a little, and she feels the dark
Encroachment of that old catastrophe,
As a calm darkens among water-lights.
The pungent oranges and bright, green wings
Seem things in some procession of the dead,
Winding across wide water, without sound.
The day is like wide water, without sound.
Stilled for the passing of her dreaming feet
Over the seas, to silent Palestine,
Dominion of the blood and sepulchre.
2
Why should she give her bounty to the dead?
What is divinity if it can come
Only in silent shadows and in dreams?
Shall she not find in comforts of the sun,
In pungent fruit and bright green wings, or else
In any balm or beauty of the earth,
Things to be cherished like the thought of heaven?
Divinity must live within herself:
Passions of rain, or moods in falling snow;
Grievings in loneliness, or unsubdued
Elations when the forest blooms; gusty
Emotions on wet roads on autumn nights;
All pleasures and all pains, remembering
The bough of summer and the winter branch.
These are the measure destined for her soul.
3
Jove in the clouds had his inhuman birth.
No mother suckled him, no sweet land gave
Large-mannered motions to his mythy mind.
He moved among us, as a muttering king,
Magnificent, would move among his hinds,
Until our blood, commingling, virginal,
With heaven, brought such requital to desire
The very hinds discerned it, in a star.
Shall our blood fail? Or shall it come to be
The blood of paradise? And shall the earth
Seem all of paradise that we shall know?
The sky will be much friendlier then than now,
A part of labor and a part of pain,
And next in glory to enduring love,
Not this dividing and indifferent blue.
4
She says, "I am content when wakened birds,
Before they fly, test the reality
Of misty fields, by their sweet questionings;
But when the birds are gone, and their warm fields
Return no more, where, then, is paradise?"
There is not any haunt of prophecy,
Nor any old chimera of the grave,
Neither the golden underground, nor isle
Melodious, where spirits gat them home,
Nor visionary south, nor cloudy palm
Remote on heaven's hill, that has endured
As April's green endures; or will endure
Like her remembrance of awakened birds,
Or her desire for June and evening, tipped
By the consummation of the swallow's wings.
5
She says, "But in contentment I still feel
The need of some imperishable bliss."
Death is the mother of beauty; hence from her,
Alone, shall come fulfillment to our dreams
And our desires. Although she strews the leaves
Of sure obliteration on our paths,
The path sick sorrow took, the many paths
Where triumph rang its brassy phrase, or love
Whispered a little out of tenderness,
She makes the willow shiver in the sun
For maidens who were wont to sit and gaze
Upon the grass, relinquished to their feet.
She causes boys to pile new plums and pears
On disregarded plate. The maidens taste
And stray impassioned in the littering leaves.
6
Is there no change of death in paradise?
Does ripe fruit never fall? Or do the boughs
Hang always heavy in that perfect sky,
Unchanging, yet so like our perishing earth,
With rivers like our own that seek for seas
They never find, the same receding shores
That never touch with inarticulate pang?
Why set pear upon those river-banks
Or spice the shores with odors of the plum?
Alas, that they should wear our colors there,
The silken weavings of our afternoons,
And pick the strings of our insipid lutes!
Death is the mother of beauty, mystical,
Within whose burning bosom we devise
Our earthly mothers waiting, sleeplessly.
7
Supple and turbulent, a ring of men
Shall chant in orgy on a summer morn
Their boisterous devotion to the sun,
Not as a god, but as a god might be,
Naked among them, like a savage source.
Their chant shall be a chant of paradise,
Out of their blood, returning to the sky;
And in their chant shall enter, voice by voice,
The windy lake wherein their lord delights,
The trees, like serafin, and echoing hills,
That choir among themselves long afterward.
They shall know well the heavenly fellowship
Of men that perish and of summer morn.
And whence they came and whither they shall go
The dew upon their feel shall manifest.
8
She hears, upon that water without sound,
A voice that cries, "The tomb in Palestine
Is not the porch of spirits lingering.
It is the grave of Jesus, where he lay."
We live in an old chaos of the sun,
Or old dependency of day and night,
Or island solitude, unsponsored, free,
Of that wide water, inescapable.
Deer walk upon our mountains, and the quail
Whistle about us their spontaneous cries;
Sweet berries ripen in the wilderness;
And, in the isolation of the sky,
At evening, casual flocks of pigeons make
Ambiguous undulations as they sink,
Downward to darkness, on extended wings.

"No. 7 of Sunday Morning is, as you suggest, of a different tone, but it does not seem to be too detached to conclude with. The words "On disregarded plate" in No. 5 are, apparently, obscure. Plate is used in the sense of so-called family plate. Disregarded refers to the disuse into which things fall that have been possessed for a long time. I mean, therefore, that death releases and renews. What the old have come to disregard, the young inherit and make use of." -- Wallace Stevens, letter to Harriet Monroe, 1915
"I didn't know him as anything but a lawyer and a business executive [in 1931, when Taylor, an experienced surety lawyer, began working in the Hartford Accident and Indemnity's Insurance Department in New York] ... To him [gallery going] was just part of life. And Stevens enjoyed life. I don't care what aspect of it, he enjoyed it. A few times we'd go over to some concert in the Times Square area: he used to like Stravinsky, and we'd go to some Stravinsky concerts over there. I don't think we ever went to a musical. I don't think we ever went to a play. He enjoyed things from Forty-second Street north to the Carlyle Hotel, and in between there were bistros and there were galleries; this, that and the other. This is mostly on the East Side, up and down Madison Avenue. Sometimes he'd come down and he'd just walk around by himself. He loved to walk. [Once] he was walking down Madison Avenue, looking at the antique stores. This particular one was closed. He called me Monday morning , said he'd been [to New York from Hartford] Saturday, and he saw this lamp. He recognized it as a choice piece of pottery, porcelain I guess it was, and some kind of fancy shade on it. He wanted to know if I could go up there that day and see if I could buy it for him. So I went up and the price on this little old table lamp was two hundred dollars. That was a lot of money in the thirties. 'Oh, good God!' he said, but he sent the two hundred dollars down. He said, 'Make them pack it well, and they'll have to pay the cost of the shipping.' And they did; they were probably darn glad to get two hundred dollars." -- Wilson Taylor
"It is easy to suppose that few people realize on that occasion, which comes to all of us, when we look at the blue sky for the first time, that is to say: not merely see it, but look at it and experience it and for the first time have a sense that we live in the center of a physical poetry, a geography that would be intolerable except for the non-geography that exists there - few people realize that they are looking at the world of their own thoughts and the world of their own feelings." -- Wallace Stevens, "The Figure of the Youth as Virile Poet"
"The imagination is the liberty of the mind ... It is intrpeid and eager and the extreme of its achievement lies in abstraction." -- Wallace Stevens
"... He said he enjoyed Havana very much, but the thing he enjoyed most was the climate, nature, the sky, the natural aspect. Not the city, the tropics. And the air. He said he thought the air in Cuba had something very special about it. And I said, "Are you saying about the air something similar to what is said in The Tempest? It's a wonderful description of the air in the Bahamas. There's something soft and sweet about the air." He said, "Yes, and how funny that you should talk about The Tempest," because obviously he was remembering that, too. He always talked with nostalgia about the South and south Florida. And the climate, too. Of course, this is typical of the people who live in the cold country, but to him it was not going to Florida or going to Havana to get away from the cold. It was something sensuous in his appreciation of being in Florida: what he felt in the skin. He said that [there] you live with your senses more than when you live in a cold place. This has to do with his poetry; it was part of his personality." -- Jose Rodriguez Feo
"I certainly do not exist from nine to six, when I am at the office." -- Wallace Stevens, in a letter to Elsie Moll before their marriage, Jan. 13, 1909
"I've read them of course, but I have to keep away from Eliot or I wouldn't have any individuality of my own." -- Wallace Stevens, when asked what he thought of Eliot's "4 Quartets"
"It is possible to read Stevens for years with intense pleasure and never to care what the poems mean because the sense of sense is so strong and the movement of emotion so assured." -- Michael Schmidt
"...a Keatsian allegiance is the clue ..." -- Donald Davie
"... an Edward Lear poetic, pushed toward all limits." -- Hugh Kenner
"From one end of the book to the other there is not an idea that can vitally affect the mind, there is not a word that can arouse emotion. The volume is a glittering edifice of icicles. Brilliant as the moon, the book is equally dead," -- Percy Hutchison in The New York Times (August 9, 1931) reviewing Stevens' first collection - now considered one of the greatest works of American poetry.
"I can well believe that [Whitman] remains highly vital for many people. The poems in which he collects large numbers of concrete things, particularly things each of which is poetic in itself or as part of the collection, have a validity which, for many people, must be enough and must seem to them all opulence and elan. For others, I imagine that what was once opulent begins to look a little threadbare and the collections seem substitutes for opulence even though they remain gatherings-together of precious Americana, certain to remain precious but not certain to remain poetry. The typical elan survives in many things. It seems to me, then, that Whitman is disintegrating as the world, of which he made himself a part, disintegrates. Crossing Brooklyn Ferry exhibits this disintegration. It is useless to treat everything in Whitman as of equal merit. A great deal of it exhibits little or none of his specific power. He seems often to have himself to write like himself. The good things, the superbly beautiful and moving things, are those that he wrote naturally, with an extemporaneous and irrepressible vehemence of emotion." -- Wallace Stevens, letter to Joseph Bennett, 1955
"I think I should select from my poems as my favorite the Emperor of Ice Cream. This wears a deliberately commonplace costume, and yet seems to me to contain something of the essential gaudiness of poetry; that is the reason why I like it." -- Wallace Stevens, letter to William Rose Benet, 1933
A letter from Father Arthur Hanley to Professor Janet McCann, dated July 24, 1977 - about Stevens' alleged deathbed coversion to Catholicism:
"Dear Janet:
I-The First time he came to the hospital, he expressed
a certain emptiness in his life.
His stay then was two weeks.
Two weeks later, he was in, and he asked the sister to send for me.
We sat and talked a long time.
During his visit this time, I saw him 9 or 10 times.
He was fascinated by the life of Pope Pius X,.
He spoke about a poem for this pope whose family name
was Sartori--- ( Meaning tailor)
At least 3 times, he talked about getting into the fold--
meaning the Catholic Church.
The doctrine of hell was an objection which we later
got thru that alright.
He often remarked about the peace and tranquility that
he experienced in going into a Catholic Church and
spending some time. He spoke about St. Patrick's Cathedral
in N.Y..
I can't give you the date of his baptism.
I think it might be recorded at the hospital.
He said he had never been baptized.
He was baptized absolutely.
Wallace and his wife had not been on speaking terms for
several years.
So we thought it better not to tell her.
She might cause a scene in the hospital.
Archbishop at the time told me not to make his (Wallace's)
conversion public, but the sister and the nurses on the
floor were all aware of it and were praying for him.
At the time--I did get a copy of his poems and also
a record that he did of some of his poems.
We talked about some of the poems.
I quoted some of the lines of one of them and he was
pleased.
He said if he got well, we would talk a lot more and
if not--he would see me in heaven.
That's about all I can give you now.
God's Blessing
Father Hanley"
"Reading one's friends' books is a good deal like kissing their wives, I suppose. The less said about it, the better." -- Wallace Stevens
More information on the wonderful Wallace Stevens here.
Today is the birthday of one of my favorite writers - Truman Capote.

Truman Capote has been one of my many life-long obsessions - so forgive my autuistic knowledge of this man - his life, and his work. Also - I just had to go out and find all the great photos of him, and post them here. People LOVED to photograph this man (at least in his early wunderkind days) - and all of them are online, which is so exciting. So I've found some of my favorites, to post them here for you.
Example:

Most of my generation only remembers Truman (his Public Persona, I mean), from his appearances on various talk shows, mainly Johnny Carson, when he was a bloated guy with a high lisping voice who was vaguely embarrassing to watch - At least I felt that way. He was obese, he had face lifts, he wore a white Panama hat, he was kind of grotesque. I didn't know that he was basically caricaturing himself by then - which is always death to an artist of any kind.

But he was stuck. He had horrendous writer's block at the very end - which tormented him. The end of his life was full of despair. It's wrenching to read about - you just want his suffering to stop.
But as a youngun? As the new writer in town? He was a golden boy. He was a creature like Thomas Mann had written about. The golden-haired child-man who led others to do naughty naughty things, and then pled innocence. Photographers lined up to capture this guy.
See what I mean?

Hard to realize just how provocative those photos were back then. Especially because he was openly gay. And not just "openly gay" - but openly PRISSY and gay - which some people find unforgivable. Fine, be gay ... but ... do you have to be so ... GAY about it?? Can't you just PRETEND to be straight so I don't have to feel so ... ikky? Truman, even back in the early 40s, didn't put on an act for the straight world. He didn't turn himself inside out to make people feel comfortable with his gayness. He just was who he was. If people felt uncomfortable, then that was THEIR problem. He was prissy, he lisped, he flounced about like a Southern belle - AND he happened to be a kick-ass writer with a literary voice that no one could forget.
I still remember the impact that The Grass Harp had on my heart when I first read it.

I was too young then to really understand regrets, or loss - the way I understand them now - but his elegaic writing in that story touched some deep universal chord in me - the part of me that is HUMAN, and not just an age on a timeline. There was a kind of soul-growth spurt that happened to me when I read that sad beautiful story. I still have a real fondness for it.
(Excerpt here)
His first book, published in 1948, was Other Voices, Other Rooms, and it took the literary world by storm. It was one of THOSE debuts. High level reviewers praised the book - in glowing terms - and it truly is a wonderful book. Not as good as his others, and CERTAINLY not as good as In Cold Blood (just saying the name of that book gives me a chill up my spine) - but you could tell that there was a real VOICE in that book.
Just to add to the controversy - here is the "author photo" that appeared sprawled across the back of the book:

hahahahaha Truman! Please! It caused an outrage. A stir. (Tennessee Williams, down in Key West, had heard about it - and wrote letters referencing it) People loved it. People hated it. People TALKED about it, and that was what Truman cared about. Truman had talent - yes - but he understood the whole 15 minutes of fame thing long before Andy Warhol came along. Truman wanted to be FAMOUS as well as being a good writer. He wasn't one of those writers who holed themselves up in their apartments (at least not until In Cold Blood when he disappeared off the face of the earth for almost 5 years - he said later that writing that book nearly killed him.) ... But before In Cold Blood he was out at every party, he hung out with the rich and famous (at least until the huge debacle at the end of his life when he alienated all of them in one fell swoop)
This photo is just ... kind of says it all, don't it?

Look at how he's holding her wrist!!! Like - hold her HAND, Truman. But also - look at how sweet she is. The two of them were actually very good friends and he wrote one of my favorite pieces about her, which appears in the gorgeous collection Music for Chameleons. The piece describes a day in New York when he and Marilyn attended a funeral of a mutual friend. I love that piece. It's called "A Beautiful Child", because that's what Truman saw her as. Not the sex goddess. But a beautiful child.
(Excerpt here)
He was the darling of New York. He wasn't just friends with celebrities - whose wealth is a rather transitory thing. He became friends with REAL rich people. The international tycoon types. The Onassis types. He was invited to all of the "society" parties.
And one day - he read a little snippet in the newspaper about an entire family who had been slaughtered in their own home ... and something sparked in him ... He spoke to the folks at The New Yorker - he wanted to do a piece on how such a brutal murder would affect the small town ... He went to Kansas - and basically did not emerge from that nightmare for another 5 or 6 years. The result, of course, was the great great In Cold Blood.
(Excerpt here)
More on In Cold Blood in a bit.
Once that book stopped taking up every second of his life (he was never really the same again, after writing it) ... he was ready to re-enter New York society, with a bang.
And he threw a party that is still famous. It was called The Black and White Ball, and he threw it for Katherine Graham - who he didn't even really know.

She wrote in her autobiography (which I've read): "I was truly baffled as to why I was the guest of honor. But it seemed really important to Truman ... so I said yes."
Odd. It was, many people say who care about this stuff, the "party of the century".
Everyone had to come wearing masks, and everyone had to dress in black and white. Truman had just finished In Cold Blood - or maybe he had just returned from Kansas - not sure - but he needed to let off steam, he needed to shake off In Cold Blood which had literally taken over his life. So he threw this party - where everyone who was anyone showed up.
Here's Candice Bergen at the party:

Here's Norman Mailer and his wife - hahahaha

Here's Mia Farrow and Frank Sinatra- who had just gotten married:

People jostled to get invited. People sucked up to Truman. He was in his glory. But even then - he had the oddest mix of desire and contempt when it came to the rich. He wanted to hang out with them - but he had contempt for them as well. On some level, I think he knew that they would drop him like a hot potato the second his friendship became inconvenient. He knew that his friendships with these people were were pretty one-sided: Truman was there to entertain, to keep things light and amusing. The second he started falling on hard times later in life, they stopped tolerating his company.
Perhaps all those rich people just liked the cache of having a literary star at their parties - it made their parties seem more ... substantial. Maybe they really did like him. But I don't think so. And I don't think Truman liked them all that much, either. He saw right through them. Only he kept that to himself, and let the rich people think that he bought their game, that he was fooled, that he did not see the essential shallowness beneath their facade. When he finally came out and wrote about them and their pettiness, their stupidity - they could not and would not forgive him. One chapter of his book was published - and set off a shitstorm through the international rich set - all of whom had welcomed Capote into their midst.
(Excerpt here)
He never finished that book.
(By that point in his life, long after In Cold Blood, Truman had actually lost a lot of what had made him a success in the first place ... and that was his compassion for others. His ability to love his fellow man, and to try to step into their shoes and describe for us, the reader, what it is "like" to be that person. By the 1960s, drugs and drinking had taken hold ... and Truman was angry. He wrote about his former friends with bitchy - but spot-on - RAGE. He had NO compassion for THEM. He could find it in his heart to be compassionate for Dick Hickock and Perry Smtih even though they had committed such a heinous crime. But he was NOT compassionate for the fat Upper East Side cats. He unleashed his wrath on them, and it was like a bomb going off in international society.)
Truman Capote found himself bereft, and alone. He never recovered from that shattering of his world, even though he said over and over, "I'm a writer! What did they think I did in my spare time? I observed life - and I wrote about it!" They did not forgive him for telling the truth. Years later, when Gerald Clarke wrote his tremendous biography of Capote - there were people who refused to be interviewed for the book becaue they were STILL seething at Truman's "betrayal".

I'm going to post something I wrote a long time ago on this blog - which ended up being published elsewhere. It's called "Fairy on the Prairie", and it's about the writing of In Cold Blood which is pretty much on my Top 10 favorite books ever written. Certain books come and go on that list - titles get bumped off - moved on - but not In Cold Blood. There are a couple of others that never get bumped off - Harriet the Spy, Wrinkle in Time, Catch 22. These are great great books.
I'm proud of the piece I wrote on Truman.
Before we get to that, though, I would like to share my favorite photo of Truman Capote. It's done by the great photographer Irving Penn. I like it because - it's not the "carefree" look of his golden-boy self - which was a pose, to some degree. It's not the provocative just-got-out-of-bed look he sported as an early writer - which was also a pose. And it's not a photograph from his later years, which just really hurt me to see.
Irving Penn had photographed Spencer Tracy, famously, boxed up in a corner. (That was one of Penn's "things" - he put famous people into corners of rooms and photographed them. Strangely effective.)
Look. Amazing photo of Spencer. Look at the EXPRESSION on his face.

Penn took basically the same photograph of Truman - boxed him up in a corner. I looked for a larger version of the photo - a clearer one - but couldn't find it. This is the best I could get.
There is something about this photo that not only haunts me, but strikes me as deeply painfully TRUE. The oversized coat, it makes him look so small and frail. The cramped quarters, the walls pressing in. Now, I did not know Truman Capote, and it is not for me to say who is the "real" Truman Capote - but something about the look on his face in this photo, its flat blank-eyed stare, the gaze is a bit confronting, but also - so accepting of himself, of the soul behind those eyeballs - something about it lands for me. I feel that I am getting a glimpse not of a personality, a famous person ... but someone's soul. I feel the same way about the Spencer Tracy photograph - so I don't know what that's about, and I'm sure it has all to do with Irving Penn's gift. It's extraordinary to me.

And now. Onto In Cold Blood, and my old post about him. There may be some repeats of information here.
Happy happy birthday, dear dear Truman.

Truman Capote said later that if he had known what he was getting into, when he traveled down to Kansas ("a fairy down on the prairie - who'd have thought?") to write a piece on the murder for The New Yorker, then he never would have gone. He went to Kansas only 2 weeks after the murders took place. The killers had still not been found, the community was in an uproar of suspicion and paranoia. Capote's main interest was to do a long profile of the townspeople, how regular church-going farmers handled such a disaster. Little did he know what the book would eventually be! The project took up years of his life. He had to wait for the executions of the 2 murderers, in order to complete his book. So he waited, and waited. Appeal after appeal ...He was unable to write anything else. Nothing else interested him. He was a man obsessed, in the grip of his obsession for years. His health was ruined. His friends were sick of hearing about the Clutter family. He tried to take vacations with his long-time partner, and would just drink, and try to sleep, and have fits of despair. He thought those boys would never be executed, he thought he would be in limbo forever. Yet - the morbidness of his entire life being on hold because of commuted death-sentences in Kansas - the morbidness of trying to go on, when really all you want is for those 2 boys to be killed - so that YOU can go back to YOUR life ... This selfish attitude (necessary for the project) took a huge toll on him. It felt inhuman.
Finally - there were no more appeals and Capote traveled to Kansas, to watch the execution. Hickock and Smith had asked him to be there. In the intervening years, he had interviewed the 2 killers numerous times. Their first-person descriptions of their own sorry lives make up important parts of the book. Capote became their conduit to the outside world. Hickock would draw self-portraits of himself and send them to Capote. Capote was playing a double-edged game here. He became "the listener", the one who would sit and ask them questions, and nod understandingly. The 2 of them got addicted to his concern. Yet Capote was horrified by most of what he heard. He wasn't without pity for these men, who had pretty much been beaten like dogs from the second they were born - and yet Capote hadn't had an easy road either, and HE hadn't killed anyone in cold blood. He had grown up with alcoholics, he had been abandoned by his father, his parents were ashamed of having a "fairy" for a son, he was sent to military school - can you imagine how awful that must have been for him? Capote may have acted like a cream-puff but that man was cold and hard as steel inside. He had to be.
Capote needed quotes, he needed access, he needed to enter into the psychologies of these 2 men. He was able to paint the graphic picture of the Clutter family through interviews with people who knew and loved them. But the Clutters were no longer around to speak for themselves. Hickock and Smith were alive for a couple of years, so he visited them often. On his way out of Death Row, he would feel the urge to vomit. It would take him days to recover, emotionally, from these macabre "visits". And he said, later, that he never recovered from the "shattering" experience of watching the two men hang. The letters he wrote to friends afterwards are nearly incoherent. Watching how hard the hanging body clings to life, watching the kicking feet, the flailing, the letting-go of bodily functions ... Capote was really never the same man again.
And he then sat down and wrote the book like a bat out of hell.
Truman Capote always thought that he had a "great book" in him. This mythical "great book" haunted his dreams, he would lie awake at night aching with ambition, dreaming about this great book ... He didn't think In Cold Blood was his masterpiece. He looked back on the experience of researching that book and writing it as a grim one, an almost universally unpleasant and grueling experience. I've read all of Capote's books. I love that guy's writing style. I even read his unfinished work - the 2 chapters of the novel he was working on when he died. He claimed to have it almost finished, but the rest of it (if it even existed) was never found. The 2 chapters are okay - it's a gossipy bitchy look at high-class New York society. It's merciless. It's very funny. Nobody is spared. Human beings are seen in their worst lights. Everyone is selfish, cynical, out for themselves ... It is quite funny, but it's very very mean. He was nearing the end of his life, and he had been abandoned by most of his friends. His outlook was not good, he was addicted to drugs, filled with anxiety and loneliness ... The 2 chapter are his way of lashing out at all those people who left him, who tossed him out with the trash. Hence, the mean-ness.
The thing in the rest of Capote's writing that, for me, sets him apart is his undeniable love of humanity. His tenderness. His ability to SEE people, with all their flaws - and to see them as beautiful. Much of his best writing is all about nostalgia, wistfulness, yearning for childhood ... Yes, it is sentimental, but it also has a depth of sadness beneath it, a grief ... which elevates it from mawkishness.
In Cold Blood taps into something else. In Cold Blood doesn't fit into either of the Capote categories: the bitchy mean queen telling all the nasty secrets of his high-class friends, or the lonely sweet man filled with hurtful nostalgia for childhood.
It was something completely new. For him, and for us. I don't even know if I can describe it. All I can say is - he never accomplished such a thing again. His writing never seemed so effortless again. You read that book and you feel like if you cut ONE WORD, the entire thread will unravel. It is so tight.
The other thing I had forgotten from the biography is Capote's personal experience leaving his home-environment of ritzy New York City (where there were lots of "fairies"), and venturing into the Kansas prairies to investigate a murder. Capote was openly gay. He wasn't a macho gay, either. He didn't try to blend in, or act straight, or hide his gayness. He was a small rotund man, who wore wide white hats, spoke with a lisp, fluttered about like Blanche DuBois, and literally said things like, "I declare!"
He took one of his best friends, Harper Lee (yes - THAT Harper Lee) as a co-researcher. She was much more "normal"-acting, and was able to blend in a bit more. She could get people to talk to her, because she seemed like one of them.
But Truman Capote was so relentless, and not only so relentless, but so committed to justice, so committed to discovering what had happened in the Clutter household, that people started opening up. The people in the town started competing about who had had him over for dinner the most times. Alvin Dewey, the head of the investigation, a tough gruff 3 pack a day smoker, eventually counted Truman as a valued partner. Truman was there when Dewey got the call that the 2 murderers had been picked up in Las Vegas, AND that they were still wearing the boots with the distinctive soles (that had left footprints - If the 2 hadn't confessed, the boots alone would have convicted them). Truman was standing right there, with Dewey's wife, listening to Dewey hear the news.
The people of Kansas, who had never met a person like Capote in their lives, who were Bible-Belt ranchers and farmers, took him into their homes, their families, their hearts. Without them, the book would not have been written.
It is a massive accomplishment.
Truman Capote went to his grave thinking that his "great book" remained unwritten. I beg to differ.
A fascinating and disturbing article about the mangled translation of Jules Verne's work. (And check out the comments, too - the bit about Hans Christian Andersen really sparked my curiosity - I would love to read the original!!) Translation has always been an interest of mine - how languages correspond, the troubles of finding a perfect match - but also to retain the feel of the work itself. For example, I came across this amazing article about translating James Joyce's Ulysses into Chinese - written by the translator Jim Di. How to maintain the glorious sweep of that last "line" in Chinese? Watch how he worked it out. More evidence that translation is, actually, an art. I read Chekhov for years - since high school - in what I see now as a very stilted translation. I loved it - I loved Chekhov - but I found it VERY difficult to play, without sounding like a parody of "Chekhovian" language. It was a surface rendering of the language. It did not get inside the Russian - and try to translate the tone, and the energy - to MY ears. When I started branching out, recently, to try other translations (most notably Paul Schmidt's - I wrote about that here) - I felt this prickling of excitement. It was the same thing, obviously ... "I am in mourning for my life", etc. ... but it was made new. The prose lived - rather than sitting on the page, as some monument to a long-dead dusty relic. I think it's about time Jules Verne was re-issued in a new translation. He deserves that, most definitely.
"You have to write the book that wants to be written. And if the book will be too difficult for grown-ups, then you write it for children."
-- Madeleine L'Engle
Heard of her. Never read her. or maybe I have - she's in The new Yorker quite a bit - but nothing comes to mind. Her latest book was just nominated for the Booker. She is extremely well-known in Ireland, her home country - but not so much in the States, although her first collection of short stories has a tremendous reputation (if you Google "The Portable Virgin" and start to look around on review sites or an Amazon, you will see comment after comment after comment like, "I have never forgotten those stories and I read them years ago" ... "Well, her latest book is no Portable Virgin - but then again, what is!!" etc.) I'm sure my dad could tell me everything about her.
And after reading this essay by her, my main thought is:
Wow. All righty then. MUST READ EVERYTHING SHE EVER WROTE. Can I have her books airlifted to me? Like, 5 minutes ago?
Holy crap!!! That's my kind of writing!! What an original interesting voice.
I love her already.
Ted: have you read any of her stuff?
Thanks to Jessa, at Bookslut, for the link.
From Penguins and Golden Calves , by the late great Madeleine L'Engle.
Children are often better believers than we are. A young friend of mine who works in a day-care center one day overheard a little boy say, "I want to die," and he meant it. She swept him into her lap to try and find out what was wrong that he should feel and say such a thing ... Everything was wrong. His parents were drinking, fighting, screaming, throwing furniture. His anguish at the violence at home had focused into a terror that someone was going to come take him away in the night. My young friend said to him, "I'm going to fix that for you. I'm going to send four guardian angels, one to stand at each corner of your bed. They will spread their wings around you, and you will be enclosed in their love, and no one will be able to take you away."The next morning when he came to the day-care center she hurried to him, asking, "How did it go last night?"
He responded very seriously, "I think we can cut down on the angel guard. One will be enough. The flapping of their wings kept me awake."
My parents and I went to go hear Madeleine speak at the university in Rhode Island - it was a small crowd - maybe 100 people - I had come home just for that. I got to meet her, and shake her hand. She talked for an hour or so - and one of the anecdotes she shared was the story above. She was talking about creativity, belief - the ability artists must have to just play make-believe - with no fear or self-judgment. I love that story. I had already corresponded with her - I still have this beautiful letter she wrote to me in response to one of mine - her stationary is a pale pale pale blue - and across the top, in simple darker blue letters is just "Madeleine". No last name. I loved that.
Madeleine.
from the wonderful and superfast Annie
List some of your favorite words:
Elixir
Twilight
Evensong
Numbnuts
Paleontology
What’s your favorite maxim or proverb?
I love that line from Braveheart:
"In order to find his equal, an Irishman is forced to talk to God."
I kid, I kid. Not really - but I'll list another one:
Not sure if this counts as a proverb - but I would say the quote is one of the guiding lights of my life so I will list it:
"Make voyages! -- Attempt them! ... there's nothing else."
-- Tennessee Williams, Camino Real
What’s your favorite quotation?
How far that little candle throws his beams!
So shines a good deed in a naughty world.
-- Shakespeare, Merchant of Venice
What’s your favorite first line of a novel?
Oh this is hard. There are so many.
But I think I'll go with:
It was love at first sight. -- Catch 22, by Joseph Heller
I also have a real fondness for:
"Where's Papa going with that ax?" said Fern to her mother as they were setting the table for breakfast.
-- Charlotte's Web, by EB White
Give an example of a piece of description that’s really pleased you in your reading lately:
Jarndyce and Jarndyce drones on. This scarecrow of a suit has, in course of time, become so complicated, that no man alive knows what it means. The parties to it understand it least; but it has been observed that no two Chancery lawyers can talk about it for five minutes, without coming to a total disagreement as to all the premises. Innumerable children have been born into the cause; innumerable young people have married into it; innumerable old people have died out of it. Scores of persons have deliriously found themselves made parties in Jarndyce and Jarndyce, without knowing how or why; whole families have inherited legendary hatreds with the suit. The little plaintiff or defendant, who was promised a new rocking-horse when Jarndyce and Jarndyce should be settled, has grown up, possessed himself of a real horse, and trotted away into the other world. Fair wards of court have faded into mothers and grandmothers; a long procession of Chancellors has come in and gone out; the legion of bills in the suit have been transformed into mere bills of mortality; there are not three Jarndyces left upon the earth perhaps, since old Tom Jarndyce in despair blew his brains out at a coffee-house in Chancery Lane; but Jarndyce and Jarndyce still drags its dreary length before the Court, perenially hopeless.
Jarndyce and Jarndyce has passed into a joke. That is the only good that has ever come of it. It has been death to many, but it is a joke in the profession. Every master in Chancery has had a reference out of it. Every Chancellor was "in it", for somebody or other, when he was counsel at the bar. Good things have been said about it by blue-nosed, bulbous-shoed old benchers, in select port-wine committee after dinner in hall. Articled clerks have been in the habit of fleshing their legal wit upon it. The last Lord Chancellor handled it neatly, when, correcting Mr. Blowers the eminent silk gown who said that such a thing might happen when the sky rained potatoes, he observed, "or when we get through Jarndyce and Jarndyce, Mr. Blowers;" -- a pleasantry that particularly tickled the maces, bags, and purses.
-- Bleak House, by Charles Dickens
Which five writers do you particularly admire for their use of language?
James Joyce
Annie Proulx
Joseph Heller
AS Byatt
Michael Chabon
Herman Melville (oops, that's 6 - but Melville must be on the list)
And are there writers whose style you really dislike?
Well, Nicholas Sparks, although I hesitate to say that he even has a "style". He disgusts me.
Other than that ...
I don't like simple writing that just stays on the surface. I don't like obvious writing. People with fundamentalist views in general, are awful writers because they either write to convince - or they just preach to their own choir - and this does not make for interesting writing, in the slightest. (I'm not just talking about religious fundamentalists. I use that term to mean: black and white certainty of being right.) Yawn. I prefer mystery and depth. I don't like writers who start with a huge generalization that you MUST accept before you read on. I don't like lazy writers who start with assumptions. Actually, those people aren't lazy writers, really. They're lazy THINKERS. I don't like writers who take sit-coms as their main inspiration for dialogue. I like writers who are bold - even if they fail on occasion. I don't mind if you over-write (Stephen King) ... if you tell me a damn good story (Stephen King). I can't stand condescending writing. I also like writing that is SIMPLE. I guess that might seem like a contradiction, but you know - do I contradict myself? very well, I contradict myself. I am large, I contain multitudes. Even James Joyce said, "With me, the thought is always simple." And yes. That is true true true. I don't like purposefully obscure writing, although I do love to be challenged. But something that is opaque because perhaps the opacity will hide the fact that there ain't no there there?? Yuk.
What’s the key to really fine writing, in your opinion?
There's definitely so much truth to the "show, don't tell" rule, in my opinion. I love writers who SHOW me stuff. Annie Proulx is marvelous at that - her At Close Range collection is spectacular in this regard. I literally lost my sense of time and space and self reading that book. (Example here) I was on the plains, I could feel the frost, hear the crunch of dry grass, feel the wind ... Her descriptive passages are NEVER too much. I'm never like: Okay, okay, I get it. She finds JUST the right words ... and stops when she should. Unbelievable.
And I suppose this is just a matter of taste - but to me, fine writing is something that transports me. I forget I'm reading - and I go into the story. But what in the writing actually does that? I'm not sure - it's different for different books.
Like, I would put something like Good Night Moon in this category - even though it's a kids book and it only has 20 words in it. I find that book transportive, and perfectly so. I lose myself.
And I would also put most of Stephen King's books into this category.
All the good writers have that ability.
John Irving, George Eliot, Margaret Atwood, Kazuo Ishiguro, Dostoevsky, Dickens, Ian McEwan, Charlotte Bronte, etc. etc.
I lose myself in their books. It's like diving into a pool.
There's something CONFIDENT in their prose. They know how to lead me by the hand into their story. They are not ambivalent, they do not overstay their welcome, they TRUST me to fill in the blanks - they don't talk down to me, or over-describe, or make sure I "get it". They are confident storytellers, and their prose reflects that. It's why I look forward to their books.
And here are Stefanie's answers. I like "effervescent" too.
Here's a post I put together for National Poetry Month - with some good quotes about Tennyson. I'm not a huge Tennyson fan - although, man, there are some lines of his that are pretty much as good as it gets, in terms of poetry.
For example - this is one of my favorite bits of language ever (it's on my quote sheet hanging on the wall in my apartment):
The long light shakes across the lakes,
and the wild cataract leaps in glory.
Blow, bugle, blow, set the wild echoes flying,
Blow, bugle: answer, echoes, dying, dying, dying.
-- Tennyson, "Princess"
Something in me just CALLS OUT to that. And it feels like it calls out to me - in diminishing echoes. The long light shaking? The wild cataract? It's transcendent. I did a search on my own blog - and found that I wrote about this bit of his poetry in an old Diary Friday - kind of a sad one. Because, after all, the echoes were dying.

Clifford Odets (playwright in the 30s and 40s - inspiration to Arthur Miller, Tennessee Williams, a generation of playwrights - and he inspires still although some of his plays have dated badly) kept a journal throughout his tumultuous life.
One year of that journal has been published - 1940 - and the title of the book is "The Time is Ripe". It's a classic. Practically required reading for those of us in the theatre, but chock-full of stuff that would be interesting and illuminating to anyone. Marvelous first-person document.
A couple biographical notes:
Clifford Odets was catapulted into fame in the early 30s with his play Waiting for Lefty. He became a resident playwright with the influential Group Theatre - and they put on many of his plays - which are now considered classics: Awake and Sing, Paradise Lost, Golden Boy - just to name a few. His work is very much of a time and place - although the writing is good enough for ALL times. But his plays all have "the Great Depression" as an extra character. Without understanding that context, his plays may seem ... trite, or small, or naive. His theme is how the individual man can maintain his dignity, his human worth, in the middle of a capitalist society. He has written lines like, "Is life written on dollar bills?" WORTH has nothing to do with money ... but when you have no money, it sure as shit is difficult to remember that. His plays in the 30s insist upon human dignity, but also (like in Golden Boy) insist on the fact that there is compromise, and tragedy. This is where he can seem, to modern eyes, a bit naive - but it is essential to place him in his context.
But what remains (for me anyway) is not so much the thematic elements, the snapshot of urban life in the 30s - but the language. Odets' language!! It's raw, it's poetic, and it's not realistic. It's street poetry.
We got the blues, Babe -- the 1935 blues. I'm talkin' this way 'cause I love you. If I didn't, I wouldn't care ...
Or
You won't forget me to your dyin' day -- I was the first guy. Part of your insides. You won't forget. I wrote my name on you -- indelible ink!
Or this, from the same scene = I love this line:
So I made a mistake. For Chris' sake, don't act like the Queen of Romania!
Or
Yes, yes, the whole thing funnels up in me like a fever. My head'll bust a vein!
Or
A sleeping clam at the bottom of the ocean, but I'll wake you up. I'm through with the little wars: no more hacking, making a pound in a good day. Like old man Pike says, every man for himself nowadays, and when you're in a jungle you look out for the wild life. I put on my Chinese good luck ring and I'm out to get mine. You're the first stop!
And then this famous exchange from Golden Boy, immortalized in millions of acting classes across the country:
JOE. What did he ever do for you?LORNA. [with sudden verve] Would you like to know? He loved me in a world of enemies, of stags and bulls! ... And I loved him for that. He picked me up in Friskin's hotel on 39th Street. I was nine weeks behind in rent. I hadn't hit the gutter yet, but I was near. He washed my face and combed my hair. He stiffened the space between my shoulder blades. Misery reached out to misery --
JOE. And now you're dead.
LORNA. [lashing out] I don't know what the hell you're talking about!
JOE. Yes, you do ...
Harold Clurman wrote about Odets:
Odets wrote some of the finest love scenes to be found in American drama. An all-enveloping warmth, love in its broadest sense, is a constant in all Odets' writing, the very root of his talent. IT is there in tumultuous harangues, in his denunciations and his murmurs. It is by turns hot and tender. Sometimes it sounds in whimpers. It is present as much in the scenes between grandfather and granson in Awake as in those of Joe and Lorna in Golden Boy. It is touchingly wry in Rocket. This explains why these scenes are chosen by so many actors for auditions and classwork.
The Group Theatre lasted almost a decade - from 1931 to 1940.
The Time is Ripe describes the year of the Group's demise. Night Music, Odets' latest play (which I ADORE - it is very difficult to find, and never produced anymore - my dad found it for me in the library and Xeroxed me a copy - Great play.) - was a huge flop. This was devastating for Odets - the critics were very cruel. They had built Odets up - and man, they loved tearing him down.
The play was a huge flop, and the theatre ensemble folded.
All members scattered to the 4 winds - John Garfield, Franchot Tone, Frances Farmer, Morris Carnovsky, Stella Adler, Lee Strasberg, Elia Kazan - and yet they were forever linked, they forever had a relationship with one another - because of their experiences in the 1930s.
In honor of his birthday, I've posted a bunch of excerpts from his journal below. (Oh - and welcome House Next Door readers! Thanks for the link, Keith - and LOVE the Awake and Sing poster you found!) Some are funny, some are thought-provoking, some are lyrical - he is at the height of his powers here. He is about to go into his long decline - which is sad, because he has such fire and energy here. In 1944, he made his directorial debut with None but the Lonely Heart - starring Cary Grant. This was the second part Grant was nominated for an Oscar for - mainly because of the big crying scene at the end. (The fact that Grant would not be nominated - then or now - for his performance in His Girl Friday - is just indicative of how silly those awards can be!!) He and Grant were friends until the very end - and Odets had a particularly sad end. The guy had a long way to fall, and boy, did he fall. Grant would lend him money, or go and sit with him and talk and laugh and try to help his friend. None but the Lonely Heart is obviously Odets-ian - the themes, the compromises (it's always about choosing money or love, choosing money or humanity) - but what's really interesting about it is how great it LOOKS. The MOOD of the movie is really the reason to see it. It has an almost Fritz Lang-ish feel to it, eerie, melancholy, big empty urban streets, the alienation of urban life made manifest in the dark cobblestones - it's a great looking movie.
But now, in honor of his birthday, some excerpts from his journal from 1940. Obviously Clifford was all about Beethoven. Beethoven, and thoughts on FORM. Great stuff.
January 21, 1940
I am growing uneasy -- a new play is coming on. For me, this creative uneasiness excuses everything. Otherwise my inability to follow up assumed personal responsibilities would be another strong item to make my life unhappier than it is. Everything-for-the work is practically the only way I can feel and think -- notice that I put the word feel before think. Right now, these days and weeks, I am very clear in my relationships with the theatre, friends and intimates, almost the world. And that clarity of relationship is the prime necessity for doing good work.Loneliness -- the business of living alone -- seems to have one of two results for a man. Either it makes him excessively romantic; or it makes him sour and bitter. Sometimes, however, there is a curious blending of both, a tart personality emerging, a sort of eccentric. In fact, all three results add up to an eccentric.
January 23, 1940
The period of courtship, in any matter, gets to be a shorter and shorter affair with me. This is because I am getting shorter and shorter on self-delusion. Let us get to the heart of the matter, I feel, and let us get there quickly and put things on a working basis. I am anxious for results and impatient, unfortunately, with the steps which lead up to the results. This is growth from one point of view; from another it is sheer backsliding.
January 21, 1940
John Barbirolli conducting the Schubert Seventh this afternoon, on the radio. An English musician or conductor! -- the very words are contradictory! Although there are some good words to say for [Sir Thomas] Beecham, who seems to have lifted himself into the top ranks of conductors by sheer will. He plays everything with great muscularity, forcing the music. Particularly true is this of his Mozart. He has discovered the "demon" in Mozart and will have the demon out even if he breaks the orchestra apart! But he really has his points, Beecham.But Barbirolli? We went over on the same ship when we went to London with Golden Boy...He scowled and strode darkly through the passageways of the ship, romantic and glamorous, or trying to be. It's easy to hear, in his conducting, that he is quite a mild fellow, so mild that I keep looking to see what is holding up the music from behind. The symphony board here, in the case of Toscanini -- since they claimed that people came to see and hear only T. -- erred on the side of distinction. Then they got Barbirolli, whose personality would not overshadow the aggregate personality of the orchestra ... and they erred on the side of extinction!
March 24, 1940
Form, form. I go crazy when I hear some of these goofs say I have no form! Debussy had no form? Certainly not -- he had none of Beethoven's form! And some of Beethoven's last piano sonatas had no form. Yes, none of Mozart's form. These idiots do not realize that there is no such thing as abstract form! Form is, like style, an intensely personal thing. The trust is that my plays have much more form and shape and pattern than thousands of well-made American plays which are simply a scaffolding holding up nothing. I am a talented individual, seeing and handling material in an individual and creative way. And these so-called critics do not understand that when they ask for a ready-made form from me they are simultaneously asking for the death of my talent.Well, everything is your own fault -- you read what those stupid men write!
April 8, 1940
In the music of Berlioz you will find something petulant, like a man with a toothache. I write this because I am thinking of the "Roman Carnival" overture which I played this afternoon. There is something historical about this piece, some strange and new outburst -- the "peeve" has come into art, the sense of personal rejection, the man unwanted and unheeded. What a strange sad man Berlioz must have been. Aaron Copland says the music of Berlioz is strange too, in the sense that one never knows where it is going or what the artist's intention is (if I am reporting correctly) but I don't understand what Aaron means: the music is followable enough to me. One might almost say that the nerves and hysteria of the modern man have come into the art with Berlioz, too.
April 25, 1940
Every [movie] studio has its own style in writing. A Warner Brothers picture always has an interesting linear quality about it, but is always dead in parts. The picture I saw last night, Dr. Ehrlich's Magic Bullet, In some ways it is such an ordinary picture that one is apt to overlook the remarkable assembly and compression of the machinery, for it is a piece of machinery, dead all over, inhuman, but machinelike in its precision and use of parts. Characters never have any doubts which pull them two ways -- they are one thing, one color, good or bad, moving only in one direction, on one dimension. In a word, they are not dialectic -- they are without those contradictions which are in themselves the source of the deepest human drama.But I most not forget the superb old German actor, [Albert] Basserman, who played Koch, the great German scientist, in this picture. He had only several small scenes in the picture, but he immediately made every American or English actor in the cast look like a boy. How he did this I am unable to say, perhaps with great repose, a WHOLE grasp of the character, really talking to the other characters instead of acting talking. He was well aware of the meaning of every situation in which he found himself and it was to that meaning he gave himself, never to something abstract, never to, for instance, nobility in general. In a word, he acted, he was active, he understood, he dealt with!
April 17, 1940
In the early evening went to Lee Strasberg's house for dinner. Paula's mother was there [Ed: Paula was Lee Strasberg's wife - an INFAMOUS individual - Marilyn Monroe's controlling acting coach - the bane of John Huston's life - there's a whole story in there], preparing the dinner, and I understood a great deal about Paula from seeing her mother's weak face. For the first time in ten years the tensions are down between Lee and myself -- so we were both able to relax.He spoke of what he called "the blight of Ibsen", saying that Ibsen had taught most writers after him how to think undramatically. He illustrated this by an example. A man has been used to living in luxury finds he is broke and unable to face life -- he goes home and puts a bullet in his head. That, Lee said, any fair theatre person can lay out into a play. But it is not essentially a dramatic view of life. Chekhov is dramatic, he said, for this is how he treats related material: a man earns a million rubles and goes home and lies down on them and puts a bullet in his head.
I LOVE that!!
April 12, 1940
Perhaps the main activity of the romantic, often idealist, is that of giving, that of offering himself up, of throwing himself at the world. The trouble beings when the world coldly refuses him. Nothing daunted, again the leap, again the throwing of the self. Again repulsed, again and again! Finally, you have a tired, embittered, and frustrated man, or one of resignation, or one who has learned to modulate his behavior and values to those of the world.In Beethoven we have the glorious exception to all the rules.
He never stopped the fierce activity of throwing himself at the world, of demanding attention for his values above all others, of insisting on the validity of what he was above all current social values.
This persistence created, finally, one of the greatest bodies of art the world has ever seen, but it cost the man dearly -- it cost him his life, his home, his friends, all ordinary comforts and amenities. It crippled him almost beyond recognition. But even on his deathbed he suddenly started up and threw himself at the world with a clenched fist.
April 9, 1940
Mozart, in his best work, has the profound sadness of a man trying to break out of a form not his own personally: which is to say a man trying to break out of prison. Child and man of his age, he was above it by being underground in it. On the other hand, the personal tragedy of Beethoven, the man, is that HE DID BREAK THROUGH THE FORM! (In Mozart's case it is like the Negro who walks around, personal life in him, contained in a social form which he did not make and from which he can never escape!)In certain periods where the forms of art are breaking down (because of social breakdowns and changes) it is a bondage, a sign of servility, to work within those forms when one's content is in advance of the times. It was between these two worlds that Mozart was beginning to be caught by the time he had reached the age of independent manhood. Against him was ranged the entire world of common usage of the artist, represented by his employers and his very own father, a perfect servant and minor diplomat. The overlords did not want to know or hear what he was feeling and sensing; they wanted only the shell of his genius, never the substance. Here, in the simple and natural protection of his genius, is where Mozart began a subtle change in his life.
He pretended a servility (as Haydn did not have to pretend) by retaining the old decaying forms. And this is how he went underground -- he moved around in these forms freely, saying exactly what he wanted to say, loading them with a rare precise vehemence (which Beethoven was later to bring up into daylight!), often expressing all sorts of censorable materials behind opera masks.
He is a man of great elegance in his art, not all of it natural to his nature. His technical equipment is excellent and enviable. His playing contains a contained feeling of which he is somewhat afraid; and he possesses, when you think of it, little quality of the spirit. His name is Heifetz, and you know all of this when you hear him fiddle Mozart.
March 29, 1940
The man of genius walks, talks, sleeps, eats, loves, and works with a load of dynamite in him. If he carries this load carefully -- balance -- its power for good work and use is enormous -- it can landscape a whole mountainside. Abuse -- out of balance -- is suicide and a bitter grave.It is in this sense that the artist, if he makes a proper amalgam, is beyond good and evil, for everything in him is for creation and life.
For example, let us say that Dostoevsky had impulses of rape in his heart.... See how a great artist held this part of himself within his recognition and acceptance of what he was. Its creative uses were enormous. It gave him work, tone, feeling, anguish, a wealth of feeling. Finally, it was just such "weaknesses" which gave Dostoevsky's novels their religious ecstatic fervor.
In other words ... inner contradictions are not solved by throwing out half of the personality, but by keeping both sides tearing and pulling, often torturing the self, until an AMALGAM ON A HIGH LEVEL OF LIFE AND EXPERIENCE IS ACHIEVED! For the artist there is not "bad". He must throw out nothing, exclude nothing, but always hold in balance. When he has made this balance he has made and found his form.
March 25, 1940
Life was mysterious and impressive to Beethoven, and like a true artist, he was gratified when it showed his face to him. The caprice of fortune he understood very well, the uncertainties of life were always with him. This is clearly in all of his music. What is the romantic temperament? It is amazed, impressed, delighted and enraged by the caprice of life. It is impulsive, swaggering, remonstrating, scolding, pleading, straining, sulking, appealing, denouncing the unfairness of life. It is the romantic who cries out that he is out of harmony with life -- by which he means that life is not in harmony with his vision of the way he saw it as a youth with moral and idealistic hunger to m ix his hands in it and live it fully and deeply. The classic art is to accept life, the romantic to reject it as it is and attempt to make it over as he wants it to be. The classic accepts the forms and conventions of life around it, the romantic breaks them down, rejects, and rebels against them -- they do not fit him -- they were made for the dead and let the dead clutch them in the graves! Yes, with the romantic it is all self-discovery and self-exploration. The injustice and coldness of life is constantly throwing him back on himself, and it is from this center of the expanding demanding growing ego that the romantic functions. The romantic's nature inwardly is one of chaos; this is because there are no accepted or standard values for him -- he will not and does not accept a code made by others. Everything must be tested and measured by his own experience -- anything else is rejected.It is typical that Beethoven scorned the teachings of Haydn and only when much older was able to return to those lesson books and say that he should have paid attention in his youth to the lessons. But to have paid attention would have implied not a Beethoven but a Haydn! The roar of pain which comes from the romantic is real pain, albeit often a pain self-made.
Beethoven roars, Chopin complains, Brahms is resigned and sad. But in each case their pain comes from this real meeting: their ideal vision of life met the reality of life, and they are left with this utterance, "What, is that all it is? Is this all? Nothing else? Down with it!"
True, there is something vastly self-destructive in the essential nature of the romantic, but when he is a good artist he builds a form to gird him in, to prevent the scattering of his life -- his art teches him a way of life and he lives it! Simply that he insisted till the moment he died that his ideal vision of life, of the conduct of men and their interrelationships, was the correct and most valid way to live -- his world was better, and he was willing to fight and die for this belief: he did!
The romantic of the Stendahl type is rare. He understands what has happened to him and his aspirations -- HE DOES NOT ASPIRE IN HIS WORK -- and this detached sense of what has happened later forms the basis of his work, writing, in this case. But this is possible only when the man waits for a good ripe age before setting to work. Stendahl, if we chose, we could call a "romantic iconoclast", the romantic turned ironist, psychologist who looks underneath to reveal with contempt the pitifully paltry forms of life and convention around him.
March 24, 1940
You cannot live in old forms, or work in them, when your life has brought you ahead to a new point. Try better to keep a child in last year's coat. It is simply an intolerable contradiction which must be resolved consciously in order to bring the life and/or work up for a higher level of creativity. Otherwise the spirit dies a death and sterility is the only outcome.Beethoven is the only man or artist I can think of at the moment who never once faltered in this difficult task: he was a fanatic! He hacked and chopped, twisted and tortured, but he did not EXCLUDE a drop of his experience from his work; in each phase of his life he found the right form for an increasingly higher and deeper experience. That is Beethoven's final lesson, if an artist may teach a lesson. Life is a series of rebirths, year after year more difficult, never to be refused, but always to be worked with, coped with, understood, used and used by, never going back, but always moving ahead and higher. Which is what Beethoven did. Easy words to write, these!
Why is Brahms an inferior artist, all other things equal? Because his last period is given over to "resignation" and acceptance. he did not have that same passion of the HEART which was Beethoven's. That is why any last Brahm's work is child's play compared to any last Beethoven work.
Beethoven's work, it must be said, represents the deepest expression of man's faith in life which has ever been written by a man. No artist before or since has expressed so deeply the will to live and accept every fact of life, to be both figuratively and literally crucified for his belief that the way to conquer life is to live without ever once relenting or letting up in that living.
It was Beethoven who understood the passion of Christ, not Bach, for he lived it and experienced it while Bach heard about it in a sort of secondhand way. What some writer once said is true: Bach sacrificed the Church, Beethoven sacrificed himself. His last quartets, a record of his sacrifice (or crucifixion), are more moving to the modern man than any page in the Bible.
March 17, 1940
The bad reviews of Night Music threw me back on myself, but that was good, that is very good, that is as it should always be! But the self independent, resolute! Let there be light, an inner light, a personal light, a light which touches unconscious negative plates of the plays to come with exactly the correct intensity. Keep away from those sensitive negative plates all light from the outside, but all! Later there will always be time to respond to the outside beams.
In this entry he describes the out-of-town tryout of his new play "Night Music" - It would be the last play the Group Theatre did as a company. The failure of "Night Music" was the death knell for the ensemble - despite the fact that it is a LOVELY play. But Odets - radical revolutionary playwright of the early 1930s - wasn't supposed to write lovely comedic romances. The audience wouldn't forgive him for it. It was seen as a BETRAYAL, not just a play they didn't like.
February 22, 1940
The performance of the play was tip-top -- the cast had never been better. The play suffered from what had always been wrong with it because of a certain lack in the direction -- a lack of clear outlining of situations, a lack of building up scenes, a certain missing in places of dramatic intensity. But none of these things was enough to do vital harm to a beautiful show, smooth, powerful and yet tender, fresh, moving, and touching, with real quality in all the parts. But I could see during the first act that the audience was taking it more seriously than it deserved; and I knew that the old thing was here again -- the critics had come expecting a King Lear, not a small delicate play. It all made me very tired, but at the end I thought to myself that it didn't matter, for the show was more or less what I intended; it was lovely and fresh, no matter what the critics said. And I knew, too, that if another and unknown writer's name had been on the script, there would have been critical raves that day.People surged backstage after the curtain -- they all seemed to have had a good time. There were the usual foolish remarks from many of them -- "Enjoyable, but I don't know why," etc., etc. Also a good deal of insincere gushing from a lot of people who would like nothing better than to stick a knife in your ribs, God knows why!
I invited some people down to the house for a drink. Along came the Eislers, Kozlenkos, Bette, Julie [John] Garfield, Boris Aronson, Harry Carey and his wife, Morris [Carnovsky] and Phoebe [Brand] later, Harold [Clurman], Aaron Copland and Victor [Kraft], Bobby Lewis and his Mecican woman, etc., etc. We drank champagne, Scotch when the wine ran out, talked, smoked, filthied up the house, listened to some music. Then they went and I dropped into bed, dog-tired, unhappy, drunk, knowing what the reviews would be like in the morning. In and out I slept, in and out of a fever -- all of modern twentieth-century life in one day and a night.
February 22, 1940
Stella Adler was there with a party, smoke-eyed and neurotic -- usually when you are dying she is more dramatic about the event than you are!
February 1, 1940
In the Moussorgsky songs, if you do not have the emotion you do not have the song, not even the shadow of the song. Chekhov could hope to find and did find actors to play his plays; where can the talent of Moussorgsky find singers to sing his songs? For the point of each of M's songs is not in the notes, not in the words, but between them, a sort of suggested emotional line without which the song simply does not exist. Here is where the conventional songsinger is shown up for what he is, a tracer on glass, a sharper or duller instrument at his use, but not more. The trouble with the damn singers, unless they are fat and fifty, is that they do not give themselves a chance. They don't listen to the songs, they are not open to the music and what it emotionally suggests. Leaving aside the emotional significance, they can't even play with humor, with charm, deftness, alertness. Their backsides should be kicked off till they ache!
January 27, 1940
Perhaps this constant uncovering of the self is one of the prime impulses in the creative mechanism, it and the constant effort to relate the self to persons, things -- a woman -- outside of the self. All of the characters in my plays have the common activity of "a search for reality". Well, it's my activity before it's theirs. And before it was mine it was the activity of almost any serious artist who ever lived, from the breakdown of feudalism till today. When you say an artist died still looking for his form, as, for instance, Beethovern and Cezanne did, you mean he died still looking for his reality.A man named Turner wrote a book on Beethoven and was very smart -- he called the book "Beethoven -- the search for reality." Woe to the artist who is able someday to look at his life and say, "Yes, this is it. Here I rest."
January 23, 1940
But one must make sure to write from a firm core even though, in my opinion, an attempt to reach as broad an audience as possible should always be taken into consideration. I thought once that it would be enough to play in a small cellar, but I soon saw that those who would come to the cellar were not the ones in need of what I could say.
January 17, 1940
Much of love for me is in giving. Unfortunately, I am not one of the receivers in life. I receive badly, restlessly, shamefully.
That last one kills me. I am the same.
Happy birthday, Clifford. And thank you thank you for your plays.

Here's the post I wrote about him for National Poetry Month - lots of great quotes from and about him.
From memory now! And when I hear this, in my head - I always hear the recitation from the Clancy Brothers Carnegie Hall album ... I get goosebumps every time I hear the "He bore her away in his arms" part ... so passionate!
O'Driscoll drove with a song
The wild duck and the drake
From the tall and the tufted reeds
Of the drear Heart Lake.
And he saw how the reeds grew dark
At the coming of night-tide,
And dreamed of the long dim hair
Of Bridget his bride.
He heard while he sang and dreamed
A piper piping away,
And never was piping so sad,
And never was piping so gay.
And he saw young men and young girls
Who danced on a level place,
And Bridget his bride among them,
With a sad and a gay face.
The dancers crowded about him
And many a sweet thing said,
And a young man brought him red wine
And a young girl white bread.
But Bridget drew him by the sleeve
Away from the merry bands,
To old men playing at cards
With a twinkling of ancient hands.
The bread and the wine had a doom,
For these were the host of the air;
He sat and played in a dream
Of her long dim hair.
He played with the merry old men
And thought not of evil chance,
Until one bore Bridget his bride
Away from the merry dance.
He bore her away in his arms,
The handsomest young man there,
And his neck and his breast and his arms
Were drowned in her long dim hair.
O'Driscoll scattered the cards
And out of his dream awoke:
Old men and young men and young girls
Were gone like a drifting smoke;
But he heard high up in the air
A piper piping away,
And never was piping so sad,
And never was piping so gay.
To those of you who know that Clancy Brothers album - you'll know the special-ness of that recording.
William Butler Yeats. It is fitting that today, of all days, is WB Yeats' birthday.
The O'Malley children were made to memorize Yeats' epitaph as part of our weekly allowance ritual. Say Yeats' epitaph, get a dime!!
Cast a cold eye
On life on Death
Horseman pass by
Once more for good luck!
Cast a cold eye
On life on Death
Horseman pass by
When we visited his grave in Ireland, as kids, we all felt kind of amazed that ... it was REAL. That the epitaph we had been rattling off since we were toddlers actually existed out in the world.
Here's a biography of Yeats, Nobel prize winner in 1923.
Yeats, as a poet, has always been one of my favorites (even with the "cloud-pale eyelids" balderdash), but what truly inspires me is his work in Irish theatre, and the creation of the Abbey. An amazing story. His Nobel lecture was on the Irish Dramatic Movement. I wrote a big long post about his nurturing of John Synge, author of Playboy of the Western World. Synge, as a young man, was a floundering artist bohemian type - until Yeats got a hold of him, and told him to go stay on the Aran Islands for a while, to discover the real Irish people. The result? A revolution in Irish theatre.
Great anecdote here about Yeats (or should I call him "Willie" like Lady Gregory does??) watching a dress rehearsal for Juno and the Paycock ...
I had a conversation once with the doppelganger about "greatest poems of the 20th century" and we discussed Sailing to Byzantium, Among Schoolchildren, and The Second Coming. We said any list of "greatest poems of the 20th century" that DIDN'T include at least one of those poems was not a list to be taken seriously in the slightest. "The Second Coming" is quoted (and mis-appropriated, more often than not) and quoted again ... by people who want to use it for their own ends. It's a dark ominous crystal ball. Written in 1919 - when the world had already become familiar with horror - a horror of a kind never before seen on earth - the poem predicts the chaos of the 20th century.
"The Second Coming"
Turning and turning in the widening gyre
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.
Surely some revelation is at hand;
Surely the Second Coming is at hand.
The Second Coming! Hardly are those words out
When a vast image out of Spiritus Mundi
Troubles my sight: somewhere in sands of the desert
A shape with lion body and the head of a man,
A gaze blank and pitiless as the sun,
Is moving its slow thighs, while all about it
Reel shadows of the indignant desert birds.
The darkness drops again; but now I know
That twenty centuries of stony sleep
Were vexed to nightmare by a rocking cradle,
And what rough beast, its hour come round at last,
Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?
Of course, there is also the Maud Gonne factor that must be considered.

Some quotes from Mr. Yeats:
"I hate journalists. There is nothing in them but tittering jeering emptiness. They have all made what Dante calls the Great Refusal. The shallowest people on the ridge of the earth."
"Irish poets, learn your trade, sing whatever is well made, scorn the sort now growing up all out of shape from toe to top."
"The worst thing about some men is that when they are not drunk they are sober."
"Words are always getting conventionalized to some secondary meaning. It is one of the works of poetry to take the truants in custody and bring them back to their right senses."
"Do not wait to strike till the iron is hot; but make it hot by striking."
"And say my glory was I had such friends."
Yes. That last one really moves me - it's from one of his poems. I feel the same way about my life, and my friends.
Words to live by:
Never give all the heart
Never give all the heart, for love
Will hardly seem worth thinking of
To passionate women if it seem
Certain, and they never dream
That it fades out from kiss to kiss;
For everything that's lovely is
But a brief, dreamy. Kind delight.
O never give the heart outright,
For they, for all smooth lips can say,
Have given their hearts up to the play.
And who could play it well enough
If deaf and dumb and blind with love?
He that made this knows all the cost,
For he gave all his heart and lost.
I also love love LOVE his poem to Jonathan Swift where he writes: "Imitate him if you dare."
Swift's Epitaph
Swift has sailed into his rest;
Savage indignation there
Cannot lacerate his breast.
Imitate him if you dare,
World-besotted traveller; he
Served human liberty.
Speaking of epitaphs, you can't get any better or more eloquent than Auden's stunning poem in memory of Yeats:
In Memory of W.B. Yeats
by Auden
I
He disappeared in the dead of winter:
The brooks were frozen, the airports almost deserted,
And snow disfigured the public statues;
The mercury sank in the mouth of the dying day.
What instruments we have agree
The day of his death was a dark cold day.
Far from his illness
The wolves ran on through the evergreen forests,
The peasant river was untempted by the fashionable quays;
By mourning tongues
The death of the poet was kept from his poems.
But for him it was his last afternoon as himself,
An afternoon of nurses and rumours;
The provinces of his body revolted,
The squares of his mind were empty,
Silence invaded the suburbs,
The current of his feeling failed; he became his admirers.
Now he is scattered among a hundred cities
And wholly given over to unfamiliar affections,
To find his happiness in another kind of wood
And be punished under a foreign code of conscience.
The words of a dead man
Are modified in the guts of the living.
But in the importance and noise of to-morrow
When the brokers are roaring like beasts on the floor of the Bourse,
And the poor have the sufferings to which they are fairly accustomed,
And each in the cell of himself is almost convinced of his freedom,
A few thousand will think of this day
As one thinks of a day when one did something slightly unusual.
What instruments we have agree
The day of his death was a dark cold day.
II
You were silly like us; your gift survived it all:
The parish of rich women, physical decay,
Yourself. Mad Ireland hurt you into poetry.
Now Ireland has her madness and her weather still,
For poetry makes nothing happen: it survives
In the valley of its making where executives
Would never want to tamper, flows on south
From ranches of isolation and the busy griefs,
Raw towns that we believe and die in; it survives,
A way of happening, a mouth.
III
Earth, receive an honoured guest:
William Yeats is laid to rest.
Let the Irish vessel lie
Emptied of its poetry.
In the nightmare of the dark
All the dogs of Europe bark,
And the living nations wait,
Each sequestered in its hate;
Intellectual disgrace
Stares from every human face,
And the seas of pity lie
Locked and frozen in each eye.
Follow, poet, follow right
To the bottom of the night,
With your unconstraining voice
Still persuade us to rejoice;
With the farming of a verse
Make a vineyard of the curse,
Sing of human unsuccess
In a rapture of distress;
In the deserts of the heart
Let the healing fountain start,
In the prison of his days
Teach the free man how to praise.
And lastly, a poem that has great personal meaning for me - especially today, of all days:
The wild swans at Coole
The trees are in their autumn beauty,
The woodland paths are dry,
Under the October twilight the water
Mirrors a still sky;
Upon the brimming water among the stones
Are nine-and-fifty Swans.
The nineteenth autumn has come upon me
Since I first made my count;
I saw, before I had well finished,
All suddenly mount
And scatter wheeling in great broken rings
Upon their clamorous wings.
I have looked upon those brilliant creatures,
And now my heart is sore.
All's changed since I, hearing at twilight,
The first time on this shore,
The bell-beat of their wings above my head,
Trod with a lighter tread.
Unwearied still, lover by lover,
They paddle in the cold
Companionable streams or climb the air;
Their hearts have not grown old;
Passion or conquest, wander where they will,
Attend upon them still.
But now they drift on the still water,
Mysterious, beautiful;
Among what rushes will they build,
By what lake's edge or pool
Delight men's eyes when I awake some day
To find they have flown away?
Happy birthday to William Butler Yeats.
Imitate him if you dare.
Edna O'Brien's room. I'm lovin' it. The fireplace. Beckett and Joyce - and also the red. There's something very nice about that red. Also, the "harvest of dregs" inscription made me laugh.
The bookcases in Kureishi's writing room make me want to weep from envy.
And there's something I really like in this one too. The slants, the bookshelves - and that CHAIR!
Oh, and since I'm in the "Byatt" section of my bookshelf - for the daily excerpt - here is HER writer's room. That one doesn't appeal to me as much - too modern - that lamp doesn't work for me (as inspiration, I mean) but I am interested to hear her words about why the room works for her.
One size most definitely does not fit all.
More glimpses into "writer's rooms" here.
Will you do a total stranger the kindness of reading his verse?
Thank you!
Thomas Lanier Williams
-- Tennessee Williams, letter to editor Harriet Monroe, March 11, 1933
Some American writers who have known each other for years have never met in the daytime or when both were sober.
-- James Thurber
Most of the basic material a writer works with is acquired before the age of 15.
-- Willa Cather
To write adequately one must know, above all, how bad are one's first drafts.
-- John Kenneth Galbraith
I'm writing my third autobiography. The other two were premature.
-- Louis Untermeyer, said on his 90th birthday
It is in order to shine sooner that authors refuse to rewrite. Despicable. Begin again.
-- Albert Camus, Sept. 30, 1937
There's nothing to writing. All you do is sit down at a typewriter and open a vein.
-- Red Smith
An author ought to write for the youth of his own generation, the critics of the next, and the schoolmasters of ever afterwards.
-- F. Scott Fitzgerald
I always write my last line, my last paragraphs, my last page first.
-- Katherine Anne Porter
It took me fifteen years to discover that I had no talent for writing, but I couldn't give it up because by that time I was too famous.
-- Robert Benchley
When I have an idea, I turn down the flame, as if it were a little alcohol stove, as low as it will go. Then it explodes, and that is my idea.
-- Ernest Hemingway
For several days after my first book was published I carried it about in my pocket, and took surreptitious peeps at it to make sure the ink had not faded.
-- James M. Barrie, 1888
Whatever our theme in writing, it is old and tried. Whatever our place, it has been visited by the stranger, it will never be new again. It is only the vision that can be new, but that is enough.
-- Eudora Welty
In his youth Wordsworth sympathized with the French Revolution, went to France, wrote good poetry, and had a natural daughter. At this period, he was called a 'bad' man. Then he became 'good', abandoned his daughter, adopted correct principles, and wrote bad poetry.
-- Bertrand Russell
Writing is easy; all you do is sit staring at a blank sheet of paper until the drops of blood form on your forehead.
-- Gene Fowler
A fascinating report from Elegant Variation - who was there last night at the LAPL to hear him speak. I'm excited to read Chabon's latest. This part really got to me:
Was originally in first person but "the main character is a bigmouth ... can't shut up ... a yenta," which worked against his wish for a simpler, Chandleresque style ... He dumped the entire 660-page draft (to gasps from the audience) ... which "can be hard" ... he "had a sick feeling while saying goodbye - but more often than not" his stomach guides him, pointing to what's right ... Can physically feel it in his stomach when the writing doesn't work ...
Stories like that always give me goose bumps. LIke John Irving completely rewriting his entire latest book - going WAY over his deadline - to the dismay of the publisher who had been waiting for it - changing the point of view completely. Like: he KNOWS his craft.
This happened to Chabon before ... and was the genesis of Wonder Boys (and if you'll remember - the novelist in that book has a hard time completing his novel) ... Chabon's debut novel Mysteries of Pittsburgh was such a success, and Chabon was such a phenom - he was only 22 years old - and he started work on another book right away - and ... it just ... wasn't working. He wrote and wrote and wrote - the thing was 1000 pages long. Years passed. Anyone who read Mysteries of Pittsburgh and adored it will remember how long that waiting period was. I think it was 8 years or something like that? UnSPEAKable! Mitchell and I were both like: WHERE IS MICHAEL CHABON? WHERE IS HIS NEXT BOOK??? Apparently, he was sweating it out in the trenches - writing, re-writing - until finally: he threw the whole damn thing out. He knew when to cry "Uncle". The damn thing was not working. He gave it his best shot. But he was done working on it. And began to write another book entirely, not the one he had promised his publisher, years had now gone by ... but out with the old draft of the book - and he wrote the entirety of Wonder Boys at breakneck speed.
It's so inspirational to me.
I figured I'd end my National Poetry Month extravaganza (although I might keep going with it, I've had a lot of fun, and a lot of cool new readers have found their way to me because of the poetry posts) with one of my favorite poems of all time.
In Blackwater Woods
by Mary Oliver
Look, the trees
are turning
their own bodies
into pillars
of light,
are giving off the rich
fragrance of cinnamon
and fulfillment,
the long tapers
of cattails
are bursting and floating away over
the blue shoulders
of the ponds,
and every pond,
no matter what its
name is, is
nameless now.
Every year
everything
I have ever learned
in my lifetime
leads back to this: the fires
and the black river of loss
whose other side
is salvation,
whose meaning
none of us will ever know.
To live in this world
you must be able
to do three things:
to love what is mortal;
to hold it
against your bones knowing
your own life depends on it;
and, when the time comes to let it go,
to let it go.
Other National Poetry month posts

Today is the birthday of Ludwig Bemelmans, author of the beloved Madeline books. Here is a really interesting biographical sketch of him. I didn't know any of it. Listen to this:
When he was a teenager, his parents apprenticed him to his Uncle Hans, who owned a string of resort hotels in the Tyrol. After the 16-year-old Bemelmans shot a head-waiter during a dispute, his family gave him the option of going to reform school or emigrating to America.Bemelmans chose the latter and arrived in New York in 1914, carrying two pistols with which to fend off hostile Indians. Once again, his career as a waiter was disastrous. After losing a job because he arrived wearing one yellow and one white shoe, Bemelmans enlisted in the Army.
"Once again, his career as a waiter was disastrous."
heh heh heh
He served in the Army in World War I, and he is buried at Arlington National Cemetery.
I always loved the Madeline books, and still do. Madeline: the red-haired feisty rebellious girl in the convent school, the one who always gets in trouble (even if it's just getting her appendix taken out) - but the one who is also most loved.
I loved how Miss Clavel woke up in the middle of the night, in her cavernous bedroom, sitting up in her cavernous bed with the draperies hanging above it ... and she said to herself: "Something is not right!"
She got a candle, and ran down the hallway (the illustrations are so dramatic, so wonderful) and burst into the dormitory, to see Madeline moaning in her bed, all the other little girls sitting up, awake, worried ... Madeline is rushed to the hospital to have her appendix taken out. Things might have gone very wrong that night if it weren't for Miss Clavel's powers of prophetic thinking. How many problems could be solved if we woke up in the middle of the night, alarmed, and said to ourselves: "Something is not right!"
I loved the watercolors. I loved the urban setting, the beautiful images of Paris, with the "12 little girls in 2 straight lines" going on their daily walk with Miss Clavel.
I'm sure it will not be a surprise to any of you to know that my favorite of the Madeline books is when she and Pepito, the little boy next door, join the circus. Of course they are forced to join the circus, since they are kidnapped by gypsies at a local carnival ... but still. They end up getting into their new circus life. As a little girl, I found that book to be so exciting, so ... magical. It opened up little doors into other worlds, worlds I could only get a glimpse of ... but oh, I wanted to see more! I remember in particular one illustration of the small company of circus performers sitting around a campfire in the middle of nowhere, their caravan parked nearby. The night around them is dark, a midnight-blue wash of watercolors ... but the bright jester costumes and the Pierrot get-ups of the gypsies gleam out from the dark, like magic little gems. I wanted to sit around that campfire.
Of course, since Madeline and Pepito had been KIDNAPPED by the gypsies - poor Miss Clavel was losing her MIND back in Paris, wondering where they had gome to, if they were all right. This time, Miss Clavel's precognitive powers failed her. At no point when she took the 12 little girls to the carnival did she think to herself: "Something is not right!"
Oh well. Even French nuns with powers of prophecy have their off days.
Happy birthday, Mr. Bemelmans ... glad you didn't end up being a waiter. Seems like we all are much better off because of your original failure in the service industry.

Ulysses by Alfred, Lord Tennyson
It little profits that an idle king,
By this still hearth, among these barren crags,
Match'd with an aged wife, I mete and dole
Unequal laws unto a savage race,
That hoard, and sleep, and feed, and know not me.
I cannot rest from travel: I will drink
Life to the lees: all times I have enjoyed
Greatly, have suffered greatly, both with those
That loved me, and alone; on shore, and when
Through scudding drifts the rainy Hyades
Vexed the dim sea: I am become a name;
For always roaming with a hungry heart
Much have I seen and known; cities of men
And manners, climates, councils, governments,
Myself not least, but honoured of them all;
And drunk delight of battle with my peers;
Far on the ringing plains of windy Troy.
I am part of all that I have met;
Yet all experience is an arch wherethrough
Gleams that untravelled world, whose margin fades
For ever and for ever when I move.
How dull it is to pause, to make an end,
To rust unburnished, not to shine in use!
As though to breath were life. Life piled on life
Were all too little, and of one to me
Little remains: but every hour is saved
From that eternal silence, something more,
A bringer of new things; and vile it were
For some three suns to store and hoard myself,
And this grey spirit yearning in desire
To follow knowledge like a sinking star,
Beyond the utmost bound of human thought.
This is my son, mine own Telemachus,
To whom I leave the sceptre and the isle —
Well-loved of me, discerning to fulfil
This labour, by slow prudence to make mild
A rugged people, and through soft degrees
Subdue them to the useful and the good.
Most blameless is he, centred in the sphere
Of common duties, decent not to fail
In offices of tenderness, and pay
Meet adoration to my household gods,
When I am gone. He works his work, I mine.
There lies the port; the vessel puffs her sail:
There gloom the dark broad seas. My mariners,
Souls that have toil'd, and wrought, and thought with me —
That ever with a frolic welcome took
The thunder and the sunshine, and opposed
Free hearts, free foreheads — you and I are old;
Old age hath yet his honour and his toil;
Death closes all: but something ere the end,
Some work of noble note, may yet be done,
Not unbecoming men that strove with Gods.
The lights begin to twinkle from the rocks:
The long day wanes: the slow moon climbs: the deep
Moans round with many voices. Come, my friends,
'Tis not too late to seek a newer world.
Push off, and sitting well in order smite
The sounding furrows; for my purpose holds
To sail beyond the sunset, and the baths
Of all the western stars, until I die.
It may be that the gulfs will wash us down:
It may be we shall touch the Happy Isles,
And see the great Achilles, whom we knew
Tho' much is taken, much abides; and though
We are not now that strength which in old days
Moved earth and heaven; that which we are, we are;
One equal temper of heroic hearts,
Made weak by time and fate, but strong in will
To strive, to seek, to find, and not to yield.

The bower we shrined to Tennyson
Gentlemen,
Is roof-wrecked; damps there drip upon
Sagged seats, the creeper-nails are rust,
The spider is sole denizen;
Even she who voiced those rhymes is dust,
Gentlemen!
-- Thomas Hardy, "An Ancient to Ancients"
""I cannot think he is a supremely great poet. There is something lacking in him. He is very beautiful -- very graceful. In short, the Perfect Artist. But he seldom lets us forget the artist -- we are never swept away -- Not he -- he flows on serenely. And that is good. But an occasional bit of wild nature would make it better still." -- LM Montgomery
"I detest Tennyson's 'Arthur'! If I'd been Guinevere, I'd have been unfaithful to him too. But not for Lancelot -- he is just as unbearable in another way. As for Geraint, if I'd been Enid, I'd have bitten him. These 'patient Griseldes' of women deserve all they get! I like Tennyson because he gives me nothing but pleasure. I cannot love him because he gives me nothing but pleasure ... I love best the poets who hurt me. But I think I shall have some love for Tennyson after this -- for today I read a verse in 'In Memoriam' which I do not think I can ever have read carefully before -- which scorched me with a sudden flame of self-revelation and brought to me one of those awful moments when we look into the abysses of our own natures and recoil in horror. The verse was:
Do we indeed desire the dead
Should still be near us at our side?
Is there no baseness we would hide,
No inner vileness that we dread?"
-- LM Montgomery
"On the bald street breaks the blank day." -- Tennyson
"Do you know, a horrible thing has happened to me. I have begun to doubt Tennyson." -- Gerard Manley Hopkins
"Even excluding the plays, it is a vast body of work: poems of feeling and of sentiment, poems of thought and of received opinion. When Browning acquired an audience, he turned garrulous. Tennyson turned sententious. But the Representative Voice does not merely entertain doubts, he actually feels them; his politics, like his religion, are rooted in memory of the past and fear of the future. A liberal, he distrusts progressivism even as he acknowledges the injustices and evils that make it necessary. Tennyson is an intellectual enigma, which is why many take him to be a philosopher speaking for their own indecision and doubt." -- Michael Schmidt
"I wrote as much as seventy lines at one time, and used to go shouting them about the fields after dark." -- Tennyson
"The real truth is that Tennyson, with all his temperament and artistic skill, is deficient in intellectual power; and no modern poet can make very much of his business unless he is pre-eminently strong in this." -- Matthew Arnold in a letter to his mother, 1860
"It is not religious because of the quality of its faith, but because of the quality of its doubt." -- TS Eliot on Tennyson's religion
"In 1850 Tennyson received public laurels and fulfilled a private desire. He was married after a courship whose length reflected not reluctance but lack of money. He published In Memoriam. And he became poet laureate, succeeding Wordsworth. The "Ode on Wellington" and "The Charge of the Light Brigade" are masterpieces of laureate art. Few laureates are so transparently sincere, prompt and prosodically competent in the execution of their duties. 'The Charge of the Light Brigade' entered the common memory." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"Tennyson spoke to and for his age in In Memoriam. Its success as a long poem depends on its fragmentariness. The sections are elegiac idylls, assembled into a sequence. Like Maud, the sequence hangs together thanks to what Eliot called 'the greatest lyrical resourcefulness that a poet has ever shown.' Elegies and poems of aftermath were Tennyson's forte. He was a gray beard from the beginning." - Michael Schmidt
More on Tennyson here
Other National Poetry month posts
The Reed Flute's Song - by Rumi
Listen to the story told by the reed,
of being separated,
"Since I was cut from the reedbed,
I have made this crying sound.
Anyone apart from someone he loves
understands what I say.
Anyone pulled from a source
longs to go back.
At any gathering I am there,
mingling in the laughing and grieving,
a friend to each, but few
will hear the secrets hidden
within the notes. No ears for that.
Body flowing out of spirit,
spirit up from body: no concealing
that mixing. But it's not given us
to see the soul. The reed flute
is fire, not wind. Be that empty."
Hear the love fire tangled
in the reed notes, as bewilderment
melts into wine. The reed is a friend
to all who want the fabric torn
and drawn away. The reed is hurt
and salve combining. Intimacy
and longing for intimacy, one
song. A disastrous surrender
and a fine love, together. The one
who secretly hears this is senseless.
A tongue has one customer, the ear.
A sugarcane flute has such effect
because it was able to make sugar
in the reedbed. The sound it makes
is for everyone. Days full of wanting,
let them go by without worrying
that they do. Stay where you are
inside such a pure, hollow note.
Every thirst gets satisfied except
that of these fish, the mystics,
who swim a vast ocean of grace
still somehow longing for it!
No one lives in that without
being nourished every day.
But if someone doesn't want to hear
the song of the reed flute,
it's best to cut conversation
short, say good-bye, and leave.
(I found a quote below that references Rumi being heard in the downtown New York performance art scene - which makes me think of an Iranian poetry festival I went to - at the Bowery Poetry Club - where Rumi, Hafez, Ferdowsi and others were celebrated - it was mainly a Persian crowd, and it reminded me of the Bloosmday celebrations I've gone to, where it's been mainly an Irish crowd - meaning IRISH Irish - and people know large sections of Joyce's book by heart, and shout it out during the celebrations in unison. Sitting in that dark club, surrounded by rowdy wine-drinking Iranians - all of them with their dog-eared books of Hafez and Rumi, shouting out poems in unison - in Farsi no less!, a collective cultural memory ... it was one of my favorite New York experiences ever. Don't come between a Persian and his poetry!!)
"He turned into a poet, began to listen to music, and sang, whirling around, hour after hour." -- Annemarie Schimmel
"Praise to Early-Waking Grievers
In the name of God the Most Merciful, and the Most Compassionate.
This is the fourth journey toward home, toward where the great advantages are waiting for us. Reading it, mystics will feel very happy, as a meadow feels when it hears thunder, the good news of rain coming, as tired eyes look forward to sleeping. Joy for the spirit, health for the body. In here is what genuine devotion wants, refreshment, sweet fruit ripe enough for the pickiest picker, medicine, detailed directions on how to get to the Friend. All praise to God. Here is the way to renew connection with your soul, and rest from difficulties. The study of this book will be painful to those who feel separate from God. It will make the others grateful. In the hold of this ship is a cargo not found in the attractiveness of young women. Here is a reward for lovers of God. A full moon and an inheritance you thought you had lost are now returned to you. More hope for the hopeful, lucky finds for foragers, wonderful things thought of to do. Anticipation after depression, expanding after contraction. The sun comes out, and that light is what we give, in this book, to our spiritual descendants. Our gratitude to God holds them to us, and brings more besides. As the Andalusian poet, Adi al-Riga says,
I was sleeping, and being comforted
by a cool breeze, when suddenly a gray dove
from a thicket sang and sobbed with longing,
and reminded me of my own passion.
I had been away from my own soul so long,
so late-sleeping, but that dove's crying
woke me and made me cry. Praise
to all early-waking grievers!
"Around the first century AD, Balkh became an important staging post on the Silk Road, selling and trans-shipping raw silk from China to Persia and eventually Europe. The city spawned many imitators, among them Samarkand, Marakanda, Bukhara, Khiva, Merv, Tus, Ravy and Qom. After Muslim Arab armies arrived in 663 AD an Islamic renaissance flowered in its thriving bazaars, bathhouses and barrel-vauled palacees. By the eighth century the military prowess, artistic refinement and scientific achievements of the Islamic world had far surpassed the Christian West. Thinkers, poets and mathematicians thrived in Balkh, among them the Persian free-thinker Omar Khayyam, who spent his formative years there. In 1207, the city gave birth to another wild man, the poet Jalal-ud-Din Balkhi, also known as Rumi, who held that music and poetry could facilitate direct and ecstatic experience of God, and founded the Sufi Muslim order of whirling dervishes." -- Christopher Kremmer, "The Carpet Wars"
"Much of subsequent Sufism rests on the notion that when the lesser, egotistically oriented self of a person is displaced, the greater or Universal self is found, enabling the experience of contact with the Divine. The ordinary, sensible world is simply the reflection, at its more attenuated end, of the Divine emanantion, and Man its most exquisite mirror. As the dust of egotism is blown from the mirror ... The foundation of Sufi practice is neither ascetism nor retirement from the world, although there may be periods of both. The austerities of monasticism were disapproved of by the Prophet himself, and Islam never fully lost the company (or the genes) of its most spiritually inclined. It is perhaps the Sufi's willingness to undertake his spiritual training in the rough and tumble of life that accounts for the breadth of Sufism's appeal. In Sufism there is the renunciation of ties, but the most obvious among these - the visible ties of the material world - are the least essential. 'Is there anything more astonishing,' writes a nineteenth-century Sufi master, 'than that a man should put the blame on his professional activity for not being able to perfect himself?' " -- Jason Elliott, "An Unexpected Light"
"Along with a throng of pilgrims, I removed my shoes and entered Rumi's blue-domed mausoleum. A sign in English greets visitors with Rumi's words: 'Come, come whoever you are, whether you be fire-worshipers, idolaters, or pagans. Ours is not the dwelling place of despair. All who enter will receive a welcome here.' Turkish women wrapped in red head shawls and men with beards and woollen hats mingled easily with Western tourists amid the overlapping Oriental carpets and gold-leafed Koranic calligraphy framed by colorful tiles. Not just the tourists, but the pilgrims too, were happily snapping photos. Rarely had I been in a holy place with such a welcoming climate." -- Robert Kaplan, "The Ends of the Earth"
"The political upheaval [in Iran] particularly opened the way for a revolution in Persian literature. For over a millennium, poetry had had priority in a land that revered the lyrics of mystics such as Hafez, Ferdowsi, Rumi and Attar, who wrote at the height of Persian and Islamic glory in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries." -- Robin Wright, "The Last Great Revolution"
�Jalaluddin Rumi was, among many other things, a lover of irony, of the odd and absurd juxtapositions that life creates. So it may be that he would have savored the fact that Madonna set translations of his 13th century verses praising Allah to music on Deepak Chopra�s 1998 CD, A Gift of Love; that Donna Karan has used recitations of his poetry as a background to her fashion shows; that Oliver Stone wants to make a film of his life; and that even though he hailed from Balkh, a town near Mazar-i-Sharif situated in what is today Afghanistan, his verse has only become more popular with American readers since September [2001], when HarperCollins published The Soul of Rumi, 400 pages of poetry translated by Coleman Barks. September 2001 would seem like an unpropitious time for an American publisher to have brought out a large, pricey hardback of Muslim mystical verse, but the book took off immediately. It has a long road ahead, however, if it is to catch up with a previous Rumi best seller, The Essential Rumi, published by HarperCollins in 1995. With more than 250,000 copies in print, it is easily the most successful poetry book published in the West in the past decade� -- Ptolemy Tompkins, Time Asia Edition, September 30, 2002
"Persian literature and architecture had a great influence on the Seljuks. It may be telling that Rumi was a cult figure among hippies in the 1960s and 1970s. He was born in 1207 in Balkh, in the northern, Turkic, part of Afghanistan. As a boy, he traveled with his father for several years across Persia and eastern Anatolia to Konya (the hippie route to India, in reverse). Travel, evidently, leavened Rumi's spirit, and his tolerance. A flower child of his time, he believed that men, regardless of race or religion, were united, and linked to all of nature by love. This view, which may have had roots in the pre-Islamic past, was expressed in Rumi's characteristically sensuous poetry:
And I am a flame dancing in love's fire,
That flickering light in the depths of desire.
Wouldst thou know the pain that severance breeds,
Listen then to the strain of the reed.
Rumi believed that love of God transcends particular religions and nationalisties and that Moslems are by no means the only people to whom God has revealed himself. Rumi said that we should simply say 'farewell' to the 'immature fanatics' who scorn music and poetry. He cautioned that a beard or a mustache is no sign of wisdom - if anything, travel (the nomadic life) will bring wisdom.. Rumi was an ascetic, the opposite of a religious activist like Mohammed: He thought that men and women should shun politics and concentrate on discoveries of their inner selves. He favored the individual over the crowd and spoke often against tyranny, whether of the majority or the minority, When Rumi died in Konya on December 17, 1273, Christians, Jews, Arabs, and Turks poured forth from the surrounding countryside to mourn. They cried en masse and tore their clothes as a sign of grief. His tomb became a site of pilgrimage. In a part of the world associated with fanatics, he is one of history's truly ecumenical figures." -- Robert Kaplan, "The Ends of the Earth"
"Rumi�s spirituality is suffused by a sense of cosmic homelessness and separation from God, the divine source.� -- Karen Armstrong
"Rumi is able to verbalize the highly personal and often confusing world of personal/spiritual growth and mysticism in a very forward and direct fashion. He does not offend anyone, and he includes everyone. The world of Rumi is neither exclusively the world of a Sufi, nor the world of a Hindu, nor a Jew, nor a Christian; it is the highest state of a human being--a fully evolved human. A complete human is not bound by cultural limitations; he touches every one of us. Today Rumi's poems can be heard in churches, synagogues, Zen monasteries, as well as in the downtown New York art/performance/music scene." -- Shahram Shiva
More on Rumi here. Fascinating stuff there. Did you know that 2007 would be the year Rumi turned 800? Turkey has declared 2007 to be "International Rumi Year".
Other National Poetry month posts
LIVE
Live or die, but don't poison everything...
Well, death's been here
for a long time --
it has a hell of a lot
to do with hell
and suspicion of the eye
and the religious objects
and how I mourned them
when they were made obscene
by my dwarf-heart's doodle.
The chief ingredient
is mutilation.
And mud, day after day,
mud like a ritual,
and the baby on the platter,
cooked but still human,
cooked also with little maggots,
sewn onto it maybe by somebody's mother,
the damn bitch!
Even so,
I kept right on going on,
a sort of human statement,
lugging myself as if
I were a sawed-off body
in the trunk, the steamer trunk.
This became perjury of the soul.
It became an outright lie
and even though I dressed the body
it was still naked, still killed.
It was caught
in the first place at birth,
like a fish.
But I play it, dressed it up,
dressed it up like somebody's doll.
Is life something you play?
And all the time wanting to get rid of it?
And further, everyone yelling at you
to shut up. And no wonder!
People don't like to be told
that you're sick
and then be forced
to watch
you
come
down with the hammer.
Today life opened inside me like an egg
and there inside
after considerable digging
I found the answer.
What a bargain!
There was the sun,
her yolk moving feverishly,
tumbling her prize --
and you realize she does this daily!
I'd known she was a purifier
but I hadn't thought
she was solid,
hadn't known she was an answer.
God! It's a dream,
lovers sprouting in the yard
like celery stalks
and better,
a husband straight as a redwood,
two daughters, two sea urchings,
picking roses off my hackles.
If I'm on fire they dance around it
and cook marshmallows.
And if I'm ice
they simply skate on me
in little ballet costumes.
Here,
all along,
thinking I was a killer,
anointing myself daily
with my little poisons.
But no.
I'm an empress.
I wear an apron.
My typewriter writes.
It didn't break the way it warned.
Even crazy, I'm as nice
as a chocolate bar.
Even with the witches' gymnastics
they trust my incalculable city,
my corruptible bed.
O dearest three,
I make a soft reply.
The witch comes on
and you paint her pink.
I come with kisses in my hood
and the sun, the smart one,
rolling in my arms.
So I say Live
and turn my shadow three times round
to feed our puppies as they come,
the eight Dalmatians we didn't drown,
despite the warnings: The abort! The destroy!
Despite the pails of water that waited,
to drown them, to pull them down like stones,
they came, each one headfirst, blowing bubbles the color of cataract-blue
and fumbling for the tiny tits.
Just last week, eight Dalmatians,
3/4 of a lb., lined up like cord wood
each
like a
birch tree.
I promise to love more if they come,
because in spite of cruelty
and the stuffed railroad cars for the ovens,
I am not what I expected. Not an Eichmann.
The poison just didn't take.
So I won't hang around in my hospital shift,
repeating The Black Mass and all of it.
I say Live, Live because of the sun,
the dream, the excitable gift.

"What Sexton suggested to Plath was the force of simple rhyme and simple rhythm, the magic of nursery rhyme darkened by time, of fairy tale where the happy ending somehow doesn't happen. Sexton showed Plath the way, and then Plath died first, stealing a march on her friend, which Sexton resented and envied. Four years Plath's senior, Anne Sexton survived her by twelve years, committing suicide in 1974. But Plath keeps hold of the laurels. There are wonderful things in the Complete Poems of Sexton, published in 1981, but many of them are things we associate, whatever their original source, with Plath, and Sexton's work seems but a footnote to hers." -_ Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"Have rejected the Electra poem from my book. Too forced and rhetorical. A leaf from Anne Sexton's book would do here. She has none of my clenches and an ease of phrase, and an honesty. I have my 40 unattackable poems." -- Sylvia Plath, journal, April 23, 1959
" I hold back nothing." -- Anne Sexton, 1969
"Once, when I wrote to her about my terror of publishing a second book of poems, she answered: 'Don't dwell on the book's reception. The point is to get on with it--you have a life's work ahead of you--no point in dallying around waiting for approval. We all want it, I know, but the point is to reach out honestly--that's the whole point. I keep feeling that there isn't one poem being written by any of us--or a book or anything like that. The whole life of us writers, the whole product I guess I mean, is the one long poem--a community effort if you will. It's all the same poem. It doesn't belong to any one writer--it's God's poem perhaps. Or God's people's poem. You have the gift-- and with it comes responsibility--you mustn't neglect or be mean to that gift--you must let it do its work. It has more rights than the ego that wants approval.'" -- Erica Jong
"My own struggle with Anne Sexton, for twenty years now, has not been about her subject matter (she is the one who taught me that you can write a poem about anything), but about the blatant deterioration of her talent. Sexton's Complete Poems appeared in 1981, edited by her daughter/literary executor Linda Gray Sexton. This volume includes the eight books Anne Sexton sent to press during her lifetime, as well as one hundred and thirty pages of posthumously published poems. Though fascinating as Sexton documents, the latter are shockingly sloppy and full of over-the-top, bad-trip imagery. This, coupled with the fact that the last three books she did publish (The Book of Folly, The Death Notebooks, and That Awful Rowing Toward God) saw an obvious decline in quality, has made it difficult to come to grips with her complete body of work. It also didn't help that, after her death, her former mentor Robert Lowell wrote that her writing had become "meager and exaggerated." I jokingly refer to Sexton's late period as "Bad Anne." How else to reconcile such slipshod lines as "I flee. I flee. / I block my ears and eat salami" with her amazing early metaphors ("leaves . . . born in their own green blood / like the hands of mermaids") and admissions ("Once I was beautiful. Now I am myself")? It's too painful to think of her simply as a brilliant poet who got bad. And too easy, somehow, to blame it on pills, alcohol, insanity, fame. Better, I recently decided, to think of her as a genius with demons, writing to beat the clock. " -- David Trinidad
"One feels tempted to drop [Sexton's poems] furtively in the nearest ashcan, rather than to be caught with them in the presence of so much naked suffering." -- James Dickey
Sylvia's Death - by Anne Sexton
for Sylvia Plath
O Sylvia, Sylvia,
with a dead box of stones and spoons,
with two children, two meteors
wandering loose in a tiny playroom,
with your mouth into the sheet,
into the roofbeam, into the dumb prayer,
(Sylvia, Sylvia
where did you go
after you wrote me
from Devonshire
about rasing potatoes
and keeping bees?)
what did you stand by,
just how did you lie down into?
Thief --
how did you crawl into,
crawl down alone
into the death I wanted so badly and for so long,
the death we said we both outgrew,
the one we wore on our skinny breasts,
the one we talked of so often each time
we downed three extra dry martinis in Boston,
the death that talked of analysts and cures,
the death that talked like brides with plots,
the death we drank to,
the motives and the quiet deed?
(In Boston
the dying
ride in cabs,
yes death again,
that ride home
with our boy.)
O Sylvia, I remember the sleepy drummer
who beat on our eyes with an old story,
how we wanted to let him come
like a sadist or a New York fairy
to do his job,
a necessity, a window in a wall or a crib,
and since that time he waited
under our heart, our cupboard,
and I see now that we store him up
year after year, old suicides
and I know at the news of your death
a terrible taste for it, like salt,
(And me,
me too.
And now, Sylvia,
you again
with death again,
that ride home
with our boy.)
And I say only
with my arms stretched out into that stone place,
what is your death
but an old belonging,
a mole that fell out
of one of your poems?
(O friend,
while the moon's bad,
and the king's gone,
and the queen's at her wit's end
the bar fly ought to sing!)
O tiny mother,
you too!
O funny duchess!
O blonde thing!
"I'm hunting for the truth. It might be a kind of poetic truth, and not just a factual one, because behind everything that happens to you, there is another truth, a secret life." -- Anne Sexton
More on Anne Sexton here
Other National Poetry month posts
I've always loved Edna St. Vincent Millay's stuff - she is one of those rarest of creatures: a poet who is a celebrity in her day. There was obviously something about her that packed audiences into halls to hear her read. People describe how she read her own poems - and it sounds like theatre. Like the stories of hearing Anne Sexton read her own stuff. I read a biography of Edna St. Vincent Millay and found her to be self-absorbed, narcissistic, coy - and ruthless. An interesting combination. I didn't like her very much. And I also felt kind of in awe - at someone who so clearly only lived by her own rules. She was a woman, of a certain time. That didn't come into her thinking at ALL. She was a siren. I found her fascinating. She was a phenom - from very early on, her gift of verse was recognized. This was not a woman who suffered in obscurity. No. People read her stuff, powerful people, and immediately set out to help her, introduce her to the right people, set her up so that she could be a success. It's quite an extraordinary life story.
This is my favorite of her sonnets.
Time does not bring relief; you all have lied
Who told me time would ease me of my pain!
I miss him in the weeping of the rain;
I want him at the shrinking of the tide;
The old snows melt from every mountain-side,
And last year's leaves are smoke in every lane;
But last year's bitter loving must remain
Heaped on my heart, and my old thoughts abide.
There are a hundred places where I fear
To go, -- so with his memory they brim.
And entering with relief some quiet place
Where never fell his foot or shone his face
I say, "There is no memory of him here!"
And so stand stricken, so remembering him.
"In October 1934, Edna Millay read at Yale. A young graduate student, Richard Sewell, who forty years later would become the biographer of Emily Dickinson, never forgot the impression she made that night. Walking to the center of Woolsey Hall, wrapped in a long black velvet cloak, her bright hair shining, she "stood before us," he remembered, "like a daffodil." Looking at her wrist, she told the audience that the poems she was about to read were from her new book, Wine From These Grapes, "which is coming off the press just about now." That night she read with the zeal of a young Jeremiah, her words burning the air as she closed her reading with a sonnet from 'The Epitaph for the Race of Man'. Tickets for her readings were wildly sought whether she was in Oklahoma City or Chicago, where the hall seating 1,600 was sold out and even with standees an extra hall had to be taken for the overflow of another 800 who listened to her over amplifiers." -- Nancy Milford, "Savage Beauty"
"For instance, they had shades at their window and nothing else. I don't think they cared much. Well, once they stenciled apple blossoms, painted that pattern down the sides of the window. Or, for instance, they had a couple of plum trees in their backyard, and they never waited for the plums to ripen, but would pick them green, put them in vinegar, and call them 'mock olives.' Well, no one else did that sort of thing in Camden, don't you see?" -- Lena Dunbar, neighbor of the Millay family
"The poem seems to us to be phenomenal." -- Edward J. Wheeler, editor of "Current Literature", on Edna's poem 'The Land of Romance' - written when she was 14
"We have named the little one Edna Vincent Millay. Don't you think that is pretty? ... the Vincent is for the 'St. Vincent' Hospital, the one that cared so well for our darling brother. Nell woudl have called it 'Vincent' if it had been a boy." -- Cora Millay on the birth of her first daughter, on George Washington's birthday
"-- oh, this was life! It was more than life, -- it was art. I might pretend to myself [at home] as much and as long as I liked, -- until the deep-vibrant note I had discovered in my voice ... out-Hedda-ed Nazimova -- yet was my native village unthrilled and unconvinced; I was asked to serve ice-cream at church socials, and the grocer-boy called me by name ..." -- Edna St. Vincent Millay on her first job as an actress in a traveling stock company
"Boys don't like me anyway because I won't let them kiss me. It's just like this: let boys kiss you and they'll like you but you won't ... But I'd be almost willing to be engaged if I thought it would keep me from being lonesome ... if I was engaged I would be going to the play tonight instead of sitting humped up on the steps in a drizzle that keeps my pencil point sticky. I'd be going out paddling tomorrow instead of practicing the Beethoven Funeral March Sonata. And I'd like to have something to do besides write in an old book. I'd like to have something happen to give me a jolt, something that would rattle my teeth and shake my hairpins out." -- Edna St. Vincent Millay, in her journal, 1911
"The most astonishingly beautiful and original poem in The Lyric Year, the poem most arresting in its vision, the poem most like a wonderful Pre-Raphael painting, is surely Renascence by Miss Edna St. Vincent Millay. To me it almost unthinkable that a girl of twenty could conceive such a work and execute it with such vigor and tenderness ... And it is with no small pride that I give it my first vote for the prizes." -- Ferdinand Earle, 1912
More on Edna St. Vincent Millay here
Other National Poetry month posts
We had to read this poem in 11th grade Humanities, and I remember that this was the time I started getting into poetry - I mean, stuff I was discovering on my own, not just the Irish stuff I always heard at home, my inheritance basically. This was the year I discovered Sylvia Plath, and Robinson Jeffers, and Edna St. Vincent Millay - and I started "getting it" - meaning: I was figuring out how to read a poem, how to focus my attention on it, hone in ... which is not always an easy thing to do. And Robert Browning's "Meeting at Night" transported me - something about the adjectives in the first four lines ... they're just perfect - but also kind of unexpected. The startled waves, and "fiery ringlets", the yellow moon, the grey sea ... I grew up in the Ocean State and knew all about the moodiness of the sea, the beauty of it ... Browning's language here fed my soul. It pleased me. Maybe that's a weird word to use ... but it's true.
Meeting at Night
I.
The grey sea and the long black land;
And the yellow half-moon large and low;
And the startled little waves that leap
In fiery ringlets from their sleep,
As I gain the cove with pushing prow,
And quench its speed i' the slushy sand.
II.
Then a mile of warm sea-scented beach;
Three fields to cross till a farm appears;
A tap at the pane, the quick sharp scratch
And blue spurt of a lighted match,
And a voice less loud, thro' its joys and fears,
Than the two hearts beating each to each!

"Tennyson and Browning did not immediately hit it off, though a few years later at the publisher Edward Morton's dinner table (three months before Browning's elopement with Elizabeth Barrett( they became friends, and though not intimate they remained friends - meeting in France, Italy and England - for the rest of their lives. Tennyson had not relished Browning's consonantal cacophony since he read Sordello in 1840. But both men swallowed hard and spoke well of one another's verse, dedicating poems to each other. Browning liked Tennyson's verse better than Tennyson liked Browning's." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"The obscurity, to which he must in large degree plead guilty, was, curiously enough, the result rather of the gay artist in him than the deep thinker. It is patience in the Browning students; in Browning it was only impatience." -- G.K. Chesterton, "The Victorian Age"
"There are as many versions of him as there are solutions to his murder story. Was he a sublimated anal-erotic, an ordinary entertaining chap, a deep thinker, a charlatan? Such variety illustrates his view that individual imaginations deal individually with a given reality. This individuality and human diversity he explored, so some contend. Or were his dramatic monologues simply a trying on of a succession of insubstantial masks? In either case, Browning declares: 'Art remains the one way possible / Of speaking truth, to mouths like mine at least.' It is a point of departure: What was that mouth like? What truths does it tell?" -- Michael Schmidt
"Browning is a man with a moderate gift passionately desiring movement and fullness, and obtaining but a confused multitudinousness." -- Matthew Arnold
To Robert Browning - by Walter Savage Landor
There is delight in singing, though none hear
Beside the singer; and there is delight
In praising, though the praiser sit alone
And see the praised far off him, far above.
Shakespeare is not our poet, but the world's,
Therefore on him no speech! and brief for thee,
Browning! Since Chaucer was alive and hale,
No man hath walked along our roads with step
So active, so inquiring eye, or tongue
So varied in discourse. But warmer climes
Give brighter plumage, stronger wing; the breeze
Of Alpine heights thou playest with, borne on
Beyond Sorrento and Amalfi, where
The Siren waits thee, singing song for song.
"Like Donne, whom he admired, Browning plucks at our sleeve with a startling phrase, plunges us in medias res, ignites our curiosity time and again. He satisfies our curiosity. His syntax can be effectively mimetic, scurrying in breathless clauses to a climax, or pacing with dignity, or deliberating ponderously, as the action, rather than the character, requires." -- Michael Schmidt
"I swear it is a tragedy that MUST be played; and must be played, moreover, by Macready. There are some things I would have changed if I could (they are very slight, mostly broken lines); and I assuredly would have the old servant [Gerard] begin his tale upon the scene [II, i]; and be taken by the throat, or drawn upon, by his master, in its commencement. But the tragedy I never shall forget, or less vividly remember than I do now. And if you tell Browning that I have seen it [ms.], tell him that I believe from my soul there is no man living (and not many dead) who could produce such a work." -- Charles Dickens, after reading the manuscript of Browning's "A Blot in the 'Scutcheon", 1842
And here is Robert Browning's first letter to Elizabeth Barreett, 1845:
January 10th, 1845
New Cross, Hatcham, Surrey
I love your verses with all my heart, dear Miss Barrett, -- and this is no off-hand complimentary letter that I shall write, --whatever else, no prompt matter-of-course recognition of your genius and there a graceful and natural end of the thing: since the day last week when I first read your poems, I quite laugh to remember how I have been turning again in my mind what I should be able to tell you of their effect upon me -- for in the first flush of delight I though I would this once get out of my habit of purely passive enjoyment, when I do really enjoy, and thoroughly justify my admiration -- perhaps even, as a loyal fellow-craftsman should, try and find fault and do you some little good to be proud of herafter! -- but nothing comes of it
all -- so into me has it gone, and part of me has it become, this great living poetry of yours, not a flower of which but took root and grew ... oh, how different that is from lying to be dried and pressed flat and prized highly and put in a book with a proper account at bottom, and shut up and put away ... and the book called a 'Flora', besides! After all, I need not give up the thought of doing that, too, in time; because even now, talking with whoever is worthy, I can give reason for my faith in one and another excellence, the fresh strange music, the affluent language, the exquisite pathos and true new brave thought -- but in this addressing myself to you, your
own self, and for the first time, my feeling rises altogher. I do, as I say, love these Books with all my heart -- and I love you too: do you know I was once seeing you? Mr. Kenyon said to me one morning "would you like to see Miss Barrett?" -- then he went to announce me, -- then he returned ... you were too unwell -- and now it is years ago -- and I feel as at some untorward passage in my travels -- as if I had been close, so close, to some world's-wonder in chapel
on crypt, ... only a screen to push and I might have entered -- but there was some slight ... so it now seems ... slight and just-sufficient bar to admission, and the half-opened door shut, and I went home my thousands of miles, and the sight was never to be!
Well, these Poems were to be -- and this true thankful joy and pride with which I feel myself.
Yours ever faithfully
Robert Browning
More on Robert Browning here.
Other National Poetry month posts
A fascinating man - the fact that he was a Pulitzer-Prize winning poet, along with a vice president of the Hartford Accident and Indemnity Company. He had a 9 to 5 job the entire time he was writing these amazing poems. He felt dead when he was at his job ... and yet once his fame had reached him, and he was offered professorships at Harvard - he turned it down. An interesting choice, not very common among poets. I love his stuff - I can't say I "get" it all the time, but I comfort myself that that was Stevens's point. He didn't write to be understood, not necessarily. He wrote to express, describe, contemplate ... There's a perfection in his descriptions (the following poem - his first big break as a poet - is a great example). It's not like you are looking at a picture - that he is presenting you. It's like somehow his language has brought you inside. It's unexpected - as most sensoral experiences are. Things aren't literal, when you get into the realm of experience. A scent of somethign may spark off a completely unrelated memory ... or a snatch of music heard makes you remember a golden slant of light from when you were four years old. The senses merge, blend, come apart, merge again. I love his stuff.
Sunday Morning
1
Complacencies of the peignoir, and late
Coffee and oranges in a sunny chair,
And the green freedom of a cockatoo
Upon a rug mingle to dissipate
The holy hush of ancient sacrifice.
She dreams a little, and she feels the dark
Encroachment of that old catastrophe,
As a calm darkens among water-lights.
The pungent oranges and bright, green wings
Seem things in some procession of the dead,
Winding across wide water, without sound.
The day is like wide water, without sound.
Stilled for the passing of her dreaming feet
Over the seas, to silent Palestine,
Dominion of the blood and sepulchre.
2
Why should she give her bounty to the dead?
What is divinity if it can come
Only in silent shadows and in dreams?
Shall she not find in comforts of the sun,
In pungent fruit and bright green wings, or else
In any balm or beauty of the earth,
Things to be cherished like the thought of heaven?
Divinity must live within herself:
Passions of rain, or moods in falling snow;
Grievings in loneliness, or unsubdued
Elations when the forest blooms; gusty
Emotions on wet roads on autumn nights;
All pleasures and all pains, remembering
The bough of summer and the winter branch.
These are the measure destined for her soul.
3
Jove in the clouds had his inhuman birth.
No mother suckled him, no sweet land gave
Large-mannered motions to his mythy mind.
He moved among us, as a muttering king,
Magnificent, would move among his hinds,
Until our blood, commingling, virginal,
With heaven, brought such requital to desire
The very hinds discerned it, in a star.
Shall our blood fail? Or shall it come to be
The blood of paradise? And shall the earth
Seem all of paradise that we shall know?
The sky will be much friendlier then than now,
A part of labor and a part of pain,
And next in glory to enduring love,
Not this dividing and indifferent blue.
4
She says, "I am content when wakened birds,
Before they fly, test the reality
Of misty fields, by their sweet questionings;
But when the birds are gone, and their warm fields
Return no more, where, then, is paradise?"
There is not any haunt of prophecy,
Nor any old chimera of the grave,
Neither the golden underground, nor isle
Melodious, where spirits gat them home,
Nor visionary south, nor cloudy palm
Remote on heaven's hill, that has endured
As April's green endures; or will endure
Like her remembrance of awakened birds,
Or her desire for June and evening, tipped
By the consummation of the swallow's wings.
5
She says, "But in contentment I still feel
The need of some imperishable bliss."
Death is the mother of beauty; hence from her,
Alone, shall come fulfillment to our dreams
And our desires. Although she strews the leaves
Of sure obliteration on our paths,
The path sick sorrow took, the many paths
Where triumph rang its brassy phrase, or love
Whispered a little out of tenderness,
She makes the willow shiver in the sun
For maidens who were wont to sit and gaze
Upon the grass, relinquished to their feet.
She causes boys to pile new plums and pears
On disregarded plate. The maidens taste
And stray impassioned in the littering leaves.
6
Is there no change of death in paradise?
Does ripe fruit never fall? Or do the boughs
Hang always heavy in that perfect sky,
Unchanging, yet so like our perishing earth,
With rivers like our own that seek for seas
They never find, the same receding shores
That never touch with inarticulate pang?
Why set pear upon those river-banks
Or spice the shores with odors of the plum?
Alas, that they should wear our colors there,
The silken weavings of our afternoons,
And pick the strings of our insipid lutes!
Death is the mother of beauty, mystical,
Within whose burning bosom we devise
Our earthly mothers waiting, sleeplessly.
7
Supple and turbulent, a ring of men
Shall chant in orgy on a summer morn
Their boisterous devotion to the sun,
Not as a god, but as a god might be,
Naked among them, like a savage source.
Their chant shall be a chant of paradise,
Out of their blood, returning to the sky;
And in their chant shall enter, voice by voice,
The windy lake wherein their lord delights,
The trees, like serafin, and echoing hills,
That choir among themselves long afterward.
They shall know well the heavenly fellowship
Of men that perish and of summer morn.
And whence they came and whither they shall go
The dew upon their feel shall manifest.
8
She hears, upon that water without sound,
A voice that cries, "The tomb in Palestine
Is not the porch of spirits lingering.
It is the grave of Jesus, where he lay."
We live in an old chaos of the sun,
Or old dependency of day and night,
Or island solitude, unsponsored, free,
Of that wide water, inescapable.
Deer walk upon our mountains, and the quail
Whistle about us their spontaneous cries;
Sweet berries ripen in the wilderness;
And, in the isolation of the sky,
At evening, casual flocks of pigeons make
Ambiguous undulations as they sink,
Downward to darkness, on extended wings.

"No. 7 of Sunday Morning is, as you suggest, of a different tone, but it does not seem to be too detached to conclude with. The words "On disregarded plate" in No. 5 are, apparently, obscure. Plate is used in the sense of so-called family plate. Disregarded refers to the disuse into which things fall that have been possessed for a long time. I mean, therefore, that death releases and renews. What the old have come to disregard, the young inherit and make use of." -- Wallace Stevens, letter to Harriet Monroe, 1915
"I didn�t know him as anything but a lawyer and a business executive [in 1931, when Taylor, an experienced surety lawyer, began working in the Hartford Accident and Indemnity�s Insurance Department in New York] � To him [gallery going] was just part of life. And Stevens enjoyed life. I don�t care what aspect of it, he enjoyed it. A few times we�d go over to some concert in the Times Square area: he used to like Stravinsky, and we�d go to some Stravinsky concerts over there. I don�t think we ever went to a musical. I don�t think we ever went to a play. He enjoyed things from Forty-second Street north to the Carlyle Hotel, and in between there were bistros and there were galleries; this, that and the other. This is mostly on the East Side, up and down Madison Avenue. Sometimes he�d come down and he�d just walk around by himself. He loved to walk. [Once] he was walking down Madison Avenue, looking at the antique stores. This particular one was closed. He called me Monday morning , said he�d been [to New York from Hartford] Saturday, and he saw this lamp. He recognized it as a choice piece of pottery, porcelain I guess it was, and some kind of fancy shade on it. He wanted to know if I could go up there that day and see if I could buy it for him. So I went up and the price on this little old table lamp was two hundred dollars. That was a lot of money in the thirties. 'Oh, good God!' he said, but he sent the two hundred dollars down. He said, 'Make them pack it well, and they�ll have to pay the cost of the shipping.' And they did; they were probably darn glad to get two hundred dollars. �" -- Wilson Taylor
"It is easy to suppose that few people realize on that occasion, which comes to all of us, when we look at the blue sky for the first time, that is to say: not merely see it, but look at it and experience it and for the first time have a sense that we live in the center of a physical poetry, a geography that would be intolerable except for the non-geography that exists there - few people realize that they are looking at the world of their own thoughts and the world of their own feelings." -- Wallace Stevens, "The Figure of the Youth as Virile Poet"
"The imagination is the liberty of the mind ... It is intrpeid and eager and the extreme of its achievement lies in abstraction." -- Wallace Stevens
"� He said he enjoyed Havana very much, but the thing he enjoyed most was the climate, nature, the sky, the natural aspect. Not the city, the tropics. And the air. He said he thought the air in Cuba had something very special about it. And I said, "Are you saying about the air something similar to what is said in The Tempest? It�s a wonderful description of the air in the Bahamas. There�s something soft and sweet about the air." He said, "Yes, and how funny that you should talk about The Tempest," because obviously he was remembering that, too. He always talked with nostalgia about the South and south Florida. And the climate, too. Of course, this is typical of the people who live in the cold country, but to him it was not going to Florida or going to Havana to get away from the cold. It was something sensuous in his appreciation of being in Florida: what he felt in the skin. He said that [there] you live with your senses more than when you live in a cold place. This has to do with his poetry; it was part of his personality." -- Jos� Rodr�guez Feo
"I certainly do not exist from nine to six, when I am at the office." -- Wallace Stevens, in a letter to Elsie Moll before their marriage, Jan. 13, 1909
"Reading one's friends' books is a good deal like kissing their wives, I suppose. The less said about it, the better." -- Wallace Stevens
"I've read them of course, but I have to keep away from Eliot or I wouldn't have any individuality of my own." -- Wallace Stevens, when asked what he thought of Eliot's "4 Quartets"
"It is hard to imagine a more astonishing debut in "Poetry". Each line and each sentence is transparently clear, each image alive, the voices that speak are heard to speak. The difficulty only arises if we seek to paraphrase, because the poem as a whole is a process that cannot be reduced to a single meaning or set of meanings. It has taken us from a lawn, a late breakfast, a woman beginning a languid Sunday out of doors, through meditations on meaning, to a known wilderness." -- Michael Schmidt on Wallace Stevens' "Sunday Morning" - his first professionally published poem, 1915
"It is possible to read Stevens for years with intense pleasure and never to care what the poems mean because the sense of sense is so strong and the movement of emotion so assured." -- Michael Schmidt
"...a Keatsian allegiance is the clue ..." -- Donald Davie
"... an Edward Lear poetic, pushed toward all limits." -- Hugh Kenner
"From one end of the book to the other there is not an idea that can vitally affect the mind, there is not a word that can arouse emotion. The volume is a glittering edifice of icicles. Brilliant as the moon, the book is equally dead," -- Percy Hutchison in The New York Times (August 9, 1931) reviewing Stevens' first collection - now considered one of the greatest works of American poetry.
"I can well believe that [Whitman] remains highly vital for many people. The poems in which he collects large numbers of concrete things, particularly things each of which is poetic in itself or as part of the collection, have a validity which, for many people, must be enough and must seem to them all opulence and elan. For others, I imagine that what was once opulent begins to look a little threadbare and the collections seem substitutes for opulence even though they remain gatherings-together of precious Americana, certain to remain precious but not certain to remain poetry. The typical elan survives in many things. It seems to me, then, that Whitman is disintegrating as the world, of which he made himself a part, disintegrates. Crossing Brooklyn Ferry exhibits this disintegration. It is useless to treat everything in Whitman as of equal merit. A great deal of it exhibits little or none of his specific power. He seems often to have himself to write like himself. The good things, the superbly beautiful and moving things, are those that he wrote naturally, with an extemporaneous and irrepressible vehemence of emotion." -- Wallace Stevens, letter to Joseph Bennett, 1955
"I think I should select from my poems as my favorite the Emperor of Ice Cream. This wears a deliberately commonplace costume, and yet seems to me to contain something of the essential gaudiness of poetry; that is the reason why I like it." -- Wallace Stevens, letter to William Rose Benet, 1933
"Dear Janet:
I-The First time he came to the hospital, he expressed
a certain emptiness in his life.
His stay then was two weeks.
Two weeks later, he was in, and he asked the sister to send for me.
We sat and talked a long time.
During his visit this time, I saw him 9 or 10 times.
He was fascinated by the life of Pope Pius X,.
He spoke about a poem for this pope whose family name
was Sartori--- ( Meaning tailor)
At least 3 times, he talked about getting into the fold--
meaning the Catholic Church.
The doctrine of hell was an objection which we later
got thru that alright.
He often remarked about the peace and tranquility that
he experienced in going into a Catholic Church and
spending some time. He spoke about St. Patrick's Cathedral
in N.Y..
I can't give you the date of his baptism.
I think it might be recorded at the hospital.
He said he had never been baptized.
He was baptized absolutely.
Wallace and his wife had not been on speaking terms for
several years.
So we thought it better not to tell her.
She might cause a scene in the hospital.
Archbishop at the time told me not to make his (Wallace's)
conversion public, but the sister and the nurses on the
floor were all aware of it and were praying for him.
At the time--I did get a copy of his poems and also
a record that he did of some of his poems.
We talked about some of the poems.
I quoted some of the lines of one of them and he was
pleased.
He said if he got well, we would talk a lot more and
if not--he would see me in heaven.
That's about all I can give you now.
God's Blessing
Father Hanley
-- A letter from Father Arthur Hanley to Professor Janet McCann, dated July 24, 1977 - about Stevens' alleged deathbed coversion to Catholicism
More information on the wonderful Wallace Stevens here.
Other National Poetry month posts
We could read whatever we want into this poem, it's not "clear" - who is "You" - it would depend on where you are at in your life, the answer. I read this poem and I think of him. It's not really a pleasant thing to think about it, so long after the thing is done. But it happened. I have moved on. It was years ago. But the experience has marked me. And something about the line here: "Because you saturated Sight / And I had no more Eyes / For sordid excellence / As paradise" reminds me of how I felt about him. He saturated Sight.
640
I cannot live with You --
It would be Life --
And Life is over there --
Behind the Shelf
The Sexton keeps the Key to --
Putting up
Our Life -- His Porcelain --
Like a Cup --
Discarded of the Housewife --
Quaint -- or Broke --
A newer Sevres pleases --
Old Ones crack --
I could not die -- with You --
For One must wait
To shut the Other's Gaze down --
You -- could not --
And I -- Could I stand by
And see You -- freeze --
Without my Right of Frost --
Death's privilege?
Nor could I rise -- with You --
Because Your Face
Would put out Jesus' --
That New Grace
Glow plain -- and foreign
On my homesick Eye --
Except that You than He
Shone close by --
They'd judge Us -- How --
For You -- served Heaven -- You know,
Or sought to--
I could not --
Because You saturated Sight --
And I had no more Eyes
For sordid excellence
As Paradise
And were You lost, I would be --
Though My Name
Rang loudest
On the Heavenly fame --
And were You -- saved --
And I -- condemned to be
Where You were not --
That self -- were Hell to Me --
So We must meet apart --
You there -- I -- here --
With just the Door ajar
That Oceans are -- and Prayer --
And that White Sustenance --
Despair --

"She is the spider, not the fly." -- Alison Brackenbury
"Her relationship to books , to literary preedent and example, was similar. She was no ransacker and devourer of libraries. Like Lincoln, she knew relatively few volumes but knew them deeply. As a girl she attended Amherst Academy and also Mount Holyoke Female Seminary, a few miles distant, during her seventeenth year, but school gave her neither intellectual nor social satisfactions to compensate for the reassuring intimacy of home and family she keenly missed. The standard works she knew best and drew on most commonly for allusions and references in her poetry and vivid letters were the classic myths, the Bible, and Shakespeare. Among the English Romantics, she valued John Keats especially; among her Englishc ontemporaries she was particularly attracted by the Brontes, the Brownings, Alfred, Lord Tennyson, and George Eliot. None of these, however, can be said to have influenced her literary practice significantly. Indeed, not the least notable quality of her poetry is its dazzling originality. Thoreau and Emerson, especially the latter, as we know from her letters, were perhaps her most important contemporary American intellectual resources, though their liberal influence seems always to have been tempered by the legacy of a conservative Puritanism best expressed in the writings of Jonathan Edwards. Her chief prosodic and formal model was the commonly used hymnals of the times with their simple patterns of meter and rhyme." -- Norton Anthology of American Literature
"No great poet has written so much bad verse as Emily Dickinson ..." -- Richard Chase
"When I state myself, as the Representative of the Verse -- it does not mean -- me -- but a supposed person." -- Emily Dickinson to Thomas Wentworth Higginson
"Dear friend,
I congratulate you.
Disaster endears beyond Fortune --
E. Dickinson"
-- letter written to a friend after the friend's house had burned down
"Throughout her life ED was especially sensitive to such occasions." -- Emily Dickinson's editor, commenting on a poem Dickinson wrote on the 4th anniversary of Charlotte Bronte's death
"Whitman, Dickinson and Melville seem to me the best poets of the nineteenth century here in America." -- Randall Jarrell
"The language is not literary. It enacts heard experience. Kinsmen, unexpectedly met, chatting late into the night from their different places: it brings beauty and truth into intimate focus. Strange: These are the same great terms of Keats's 'cold pastoral'." -- Michael Schmidt
"Her coy and oddly childish poems of nature and female friendship are products of a time when one of the careers open to women was perpetual childhood." -- Richard Chase
"I never read his book - but was told that he was disgraceful." -- Emily Dickinson on Walt Whitman
"My Mother does not care for thought." -- Emily Dickinson to Thomas Wentworth Higginson
"I am growing very handsome indeed!" -- Emily Dickinson, age 14
"More than any other poet, Emily Dickinson seemed to tell me that the intense inner event, the personal and psychological, was inseparable from the universal; that there was a range for psychological poetry beyond mere self-expression." -- Adrienne Rich
"We have the legend, but the crucial facts in the recorded life are absent. Dickinson's reticence seems part of her poetical strategy: if we could assign the poems to specific emotional events, we would ground them. As it is, they are a miracle and a mystery of language." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"Her wit is accuracy." -- Alison Brackenbury
"Immense in scale and oratorical in tone, this amazing short poem [Safe In Their Alabaster Chambers] departs from Dickinson's usual four-line stanza format, based on sturdy Protestant hymn measure. The first five-line stanza rolls out in a single, thrilling sentence, delivered in the magesterial public voice of a sermon or eulogy. Its as if the poem's disturbing theme - the dead and their defeated hopes - can barely be contained by traditional structure." -- Camille Paglia, "Break, Blow, Burn"
"Are you too deeply occupied to say if my verse is alive? The mind is so near itself it cannot see distinctly, and I have none to ask." -- Emily Dickinson to Thomas Higginson, 1862
"She sewed her poems into little books and put them away, one after another, in a box, where after her death her sister found them, nine hundred poems "tied together with twine" in "sixty volumes." And it's not an untenable theory that the beloved whom she mourns, departed, may be Christ, the soul's lover, rather than a particular man -- or a particular woman." -- Michael Schmidt
"Emily, you wretch! No more of this nonsense! I've traveled all the way from Springfield to see you. Come down at once." -- Samuel Bowles, shouting up the stairs at Emily. Emily finally did come down.
"A step like a pattering child's in entry & in glided a little plain woman with two smooth bands of reddish hair & a face a little like Belle Dove's; not plainer - with no good feature - in a very plain & exquisitely clean white pique & blue net worsted shawl. She came to me with two day lilies which she put in a sort of childlike way into my hand & said 'These are my introduction' in a soft frightened breathless childlike voice -- & added under her breathe Forgive me if I am frightened; I never see strangers & hardly know what I say -- but she talked soon & thenceforward continuously -- & deferentially -- sometimes stopping to ask me to talk instead of her -- but readily recommencing...I never was with any one who drained my nerve power so much. Without touching her, she drew from me. I am glad not to live near her." -- Thomas Wentworth Higginson
Other National Poetry month posts
I'm a huge Blake fan, I wrote about him here. What was really fun about compiling all of the quotes for today was I realized how polarizing a poet he really is. Was, and still is. Undeniably important, undeniably in the canon - but after that, everybody disagrees.
So here are two poems of the same topic - one from Songs of Innocence, one from Songs of Experience.
The Chimney Sweeper - from Songs of Innocence
When my mother died I was very young,
And my father sold me while yet my tongue
Could scarcely cry " 'weep! 'weep! 'weep! 'weep!"
So your chimneys I sweep & in soot I sleep.
There's little Tom Dacre, who cried when his head,
That curl'd llke a lamb's back. was shav'd: so I said
"Hush. Tom! never mind it, for when your head's bare
You know that the soot cannot spoil your white hair."
And so he was quiet & that very night,
As Tom was a-sleeping, he had such a sight!
That thousands of sweepers, Dick, Joe, Ned or Jack.
Were all of them lock'd up in coffins of black.
And by came an Angel who had a bright key,
And he open'd the coffins & set them all free;
Then down a green plain leaping, laughing, they run,
And wash in a river. and shine in the Sun.
Then naked & white, all their bags left behind,
They rise upon clouds and sport in the wind;
And the Angel told Tom, if he'd be a good boy,
He'd have God for his father & never want joy.
And so Tom awoke; and we rose in the dark.
And got with our bags & our brushes to work.
Tho' the morning was cold, Tom was happy & warm;
So if all do their duty they need not fear harm.
The Chimney Sweeper - Songs of Experience
A little black thing among the snow:
Crying weep, weep, in notes of woe!
Where are thy father & mother! say!
They are both gone up to the church to pray.
Because I was happy upon the heath,
And smil'd among the winters snow:
They clothed me in the clothes of death,
And taught me to sing the notes of woe.
And because I am happy, & dance & sing,
They think they have done me no injury:
And are gone to praise God & his Priest & King
Who make up a heaven of our misery.
The eagle never lost so much time as when he submitted to learn of the crow. -- William Blake
"He had no public: he very early gave up publishing in any serious sense. one obvious consequence, or aspect, of this knowledge is the carelessness that is so apparent in the later prophetic books. Blake had ceased to be capable of taking enough trouble." -- F.R. Leavis
Improvement makes strait roads, but the crooked roads without Improvement, are roads of Genius. -- Blake
"I mean, don't you think it's a little bit excessive?"
"The road of excess leads to the palace of wisdom. William Blake."
Pause.
"William Blake?"
"William Blake!"
"William Blake???"
"William Blake!!!"
-- Bull Durham
"I do not condemn Pope or Dryden because they did not understand imagination, but because they did not understand verse." -- William Blake
"The prophetic robe with its woof of meekness and its warp of wrath was forced on [Blake] by loneliness and his modest station in life." -- Robert Graves
"In his youth, [Blake] had a gift of simple and fair speech; but he lost it. Although he could always catch the heavenly harmony of thoughts he could seldom mount them on a fitting chariot of rhythm and rhyme. His fine passages were the direct gift of the Muse, and are followed by lines of other origin." -- Edward Thomas
"It is an honest against which the whole world conspires, because it is unpleasant." -- T.S. Eliot
"Think of a white cloud as being holy, you cannot love it, but think of a holy man within the cloud, love springs up in your thoughts, for to think of holiness distinct from man is impossible to the affections. Thought alone can make monsters, but the affections cannot." -- Blake
"He is very eighteenth century." -- T.S. Eliot
"The emotions are presented in an extremely simplified, abstract form. This form is one illustration of the eternal struggle of art against education, of the literary artist against the continuous deterioration of language." -- T.S. Eliot on "Songs of Innocence" and "Songs of Experience"
"In America in the late 1940s Allen Ginsberg, interested in Supreme Reality, alone and suffering a 'dark night of the soul sort of,' his lover Neal Cassady having sloped off, and having himself just masturbated, with a volume of Blake before him - 'I wasn't even reading, my eye was idling over the page of "Ah, Sun-flower," and it suddenly appeared - the poem I'd read a lot of times before.' He began to understand the poem, and 'suddenly, simultaneously with understanding it,' he 'heard a very deep earthen grave voice in the room, which I immediately assumed, I didn't think twice, was Blake's voice.' This 'apparitional voice' became his guiding spirit: 'It was like God had a human voice, with all the infinite tenderness and anciency and mortal gravity of a living Creator speaking to his son.' On Ginsberg this 'anciency fathered Howl, though the Blake simulacrum was aided by the hallucinogens popular at the time, the recipe for Part II of the poem including peyote, just as for Kaddish he was assisted by amphetamine injections. 'The amphetamine gives a peculiar metaphysical tinge to things, also. Space-outs.' Blake managed his visions without substance abuse. Ginsberg's appropriation of the poet of innocence and experience did much to promote Blake to the alternative culture of the 1950s and 1960s." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"a completely and uncompromisingly individual idiom and technique ... individual, original, and isolated enough to be without influence." -- FR Leavis
"You cannot create a very large poem without introducing a more impersonal point of view, or splitting it up into various personalities. But the weakness of the long poems is certainly not that they are too visionary, too remote from the world. It is that Blake did not see enough, became too much occupied with ideas." -- TS Eliot
"Romantic writers glorified childhood as a state of innocence. Blake's 'The Chimey Sweeper', written in the same year as the French Revolution, combines the Romantic cult of the child with the new radical politics, whichcan both be traced to social thinker Jean-Jacques Rousseau. It is the boy sweep, rather than Blake, who speaks: he acts as the poet's dramatic persona or mask. There is no anger in his tale. On the contrary, the sweep's gentle acceptance of his miserable life makes his exploitation seem all the more atrocious. Blake shifts responsibility for protest onto us." -- Camille Paglia, "Break, Blow, Burn"
Some examples of Blake's art:

-- "Isaac Newton", 1795

-- Christ in the sepulcher guarded by angels - 1805

-- Whirlwind of Lovers (Illustration to Dante's Inferno)

-- The Ancient of Days - 1794

-- page from "Songs of Innocence" - The Chimney Sweeper is shown here
More information on William Blake here.
Other National Poetry month posts
I found it hard to decide which poem to post - since I have many favorites ("Ode to Autumn" being the main one) - but I decided to go with "Ode on Melancholy".
Ode on Melancholy
1.
No, no, go not to Lethe, neither twist
Wolfs-bane, tight-rooted, for its poisonous wine;
Nor suffer thy pale forehead to be kiss’d
By nightshade, ruby grape of Proserpine;
Make not your rosary of yew-berries,
Nor let the beetle, nor the death-moth be
Your mournful Psyche, nor the downy owl
A partner in your sorrow’s mysteries;
For shade to shade will come too drowsily,
And drown the wakeful anguish of the soul.
2.
But when the melancholy fit shall fall
Sudden from heaven like a weeping cloud,
That fosters the droop-headed flowers all,
And hides the green hill in an April shroud;
Then glut thy sorrow on a morning rose,
Or on the rainbow of the salt sand-wave,
Or on the wealth of globed peonies;
Or if thy mistress some rich anger shows,
Emprison her soft hand, and let her rave,
And feed deep, deep upon her peerless eyes.
3.
She dwells with Beauty—Beauty that must die;
And Joy, whose hand is ever at his lips
Bidding adieu; and aching Pleasure nigh,
Turning to poison while the bee-mouth sips:
Ay, in the very temple of Delight
Veil’d Melancholy has her sovran shrine,
Though seen of none save him whose strenuous tongue
Can burst Joy’s grape against his palate fine;
His soul shall taste the sadness of her might,
And be among her cloudy trophies hung.

"One song of Burns is of more worth to you than all I could think of for a whole year in his native country. His Misery is a dead weight on the nimbleness of one's quill ... he talked with Bitches, he drank with blackguards, he was miserable. We can see horribly clear in the works of such a Man his whole life, as if we were God's spies." -- John Keats on Robert Burns
"Shelley was a volatile creature of air and fire: he seems never to have noticed what he ate or drank, except sometimes as a matter of vegetarian principle. Keats was earthy, with a sweet tooth and a relish for spices, cream and snuff, and in a letter mentions peppering his own tongue to bring out the delicious coolness of claret. When Shelley in Prometheus Unbound mentions: "The yellow bees in the ivy-bloom", he does not conjure up, as Keats would have done, the taste of the last hot days of the dying English year, with over-ripe blackberries, ditches full of water, and the hedges grey with old man's beard. He is not aware of the veteran bees whirring their frayed wings or sucking rank honey from the dusty yellow blossoms of the ivy." -- Robert Graves
"On the whole, I do not like Keats. His poems are, in reality, too full of beauty. One feels stifled in roses ... There is little in Keats' poems except luscious beauty -- so much of it that the reader is surfeited." -- L.M. Montgomery
"These are the pure Magic. These are the clear vision. The rest is only poetry." -- Rudyard Kipling on John Keats and Samuel Coleridge
"He'd planned to become a surgeon, but he realized his real vocation was poetry, and in the spring of 1818, he published his first major long poem Endymion. And then he set out on a hike through the countryside with his friend Charles Brown. Wordsworth was one of Keats's favorite poets, and he knew that Wordsworth had been inspired by walking around England, so Keats decided to do the same that summer.
Keats was a London boy. He had never seen the mountains. He had never seen a waterfall. He wrote letters back to his brother about the wonderful things that he saw, but gradually on his hike he realized he was no Wordsworth, that he did not want to write about scenery. He hated descriptions. He was more interested in the people whom he saw along the way. He was fascinated by the peasants who walked barefoot on the roads, carrying their shoes and stockings so they would look nice when they got to town. He saw an old woman being carried along the road in a kind of a cage like a dog kennel, smoking a pipe.
He came back to London and learned that the reviews of his last book of poetry, Endymion, were coming in and critics had written ferocious attacks on him. He was crushed. And his brother had come down with a serious case of tuberculosis. His brother died in December, and by the end of that year, John Keats had contracted tuberculosis himself. He would die three years later, in 1821. It was in those last three years of his life that he wrote most of his greatest poems." -- Garrison Keillor
"He ramped through [Spenser's[ Fairie Queen ... like a young horse turned into a Spring meadow." -- Cowden Clarke, a friend of Keats
"The imagery he chose was predominantly sexual. Poetry for him was not a philosophical theory, as it was for Shelley, but a moment of physical delirium." -- Robert Graves
"... miserable self-polluter of the human mind."-- Shelley
"I look upon fine phrases as a lover." -- John Keats
"Keats as a poet is abundantly and enchantingly sensuous, but the question with some people will be, whether he is anything else." -- Matthew Arnold
"The three great narratives, rich in detail, idealized characterization, and gothic elements, inspired poets, painters and musicians later in the century. The Pre-Raphaelites in particular drew sustenance from them. 'The Eve of St. Agnes' radically reconfigures resources of tone and characterization that Keats adapted from Chaucer to Shakespeare. Romeo and Juliet was not far from his hand when he wrote the poem. And his phrasing owes Shakespeare a debt. Cymbeline suggests the way Madeline's bedchamber is made solid before our eyes. Keats does not imitate his masters: he has assimilated them. The odes - 'To a Nightingale,' 'On a Grecian Urn', 'To Autumn', and the lesser 'To Psyche' and 'On Melancholy' -- are incomparable. The charge that he 'lacked experience' is fatuous; nor are they 'merely sensuous'. They are the step beyond moral romance to the romance of feeling itself, feeling as subject, the 'true voice'." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"I have loved the principle of beauty in all things." -- John Keats
" ... a sensuous mystic." -- Louis MacNeice
"Keats was short-sighted. He did not see landscapes as such, so he treated them as painted cabinets filled with interesting objects ... His habit was to allow his eye to be seduced from entire vision by particular objects ... He saw little but what moved: the curving, the wreathing, the slanting, the waving - and even then, it seems, not the whole object is in motion but only its edge, or highlight." -- Robert Graves
"Keats's yearning passion for the Beautiful is not a passion of the sensuous or sentimental poet. It is an intellectual and spiritual passion." -- Matthew Arnold
"Milton had an exquisite passion for what is properly, in the sense of ease and pleasure, poetical luxury, and with that, it appears to me, he would fair have been content, if he could, so doing, preserve his self-respect and feeling of duty performed." -- John Keats
This Grave
contains all that was Mortal
of a
Young English Poet
Who
on his Death Bed
in the Bitterness of his Heart
at the Malicious Power of his Enemies
Desired
these words to be engraved on his Tomb Stone
"Here lies One Whose Name was writ in Water."
-- Keats' epitaph
More on John Keats' short life here
Other National Poetry month posts
This is for my dad.
Seeing Things
I
Inishbofin on a Sunday morning.
Sunlight, turfsmoke, seagulls, boatslip, diesel.
One by one we were being handed down
Into a boat that dipped and shilly-shallied
Scaresomely every time. We sat tight
On short cross-benches, in nervous twos and threes,
Obedient, newly close, nobody speaking
Except the boatmen, as the gunwales sank
And seemed they might ship water any minute.
The sea was very calm but even so,
When the engine kicked and our ferryman
Swayed for balance, reaching for the tiller,
I panicked at the shiftiness and heft
Of the craft itself. What guaranteed us --
That quick response and buoyancy and swim --
Kept me in agony. All the time
As we went sailing evenly across
The deep, still, seeable-down-into water,
It was as if I looked from another boat
Sailing through the air, far up, and could see
How riskily we fared into the morning,
And loved in vain our bare, bowed, numbered heads.
II
Claritas. The dry-eyed Latin word
Is perfect for the carved stone of the water
Where Jesus stands up to his unwet knees
And John the Baptist pours out more water
Over his head: all this in bright sunlight
On the facade of a cathedral. Lines
Hard and thin and sinuous represent
The flowing river. Down between the lines
Little antic fish are all go. Nothing else.
And yet in that utter visibility
The stone's alive with what's invisible:
Waterweed, stirred sand-grains hurrying off,
The shadowy, unshadowed stream itself.
All afternoon, heat wavered on the steps
And the air we stood up to our eyes in wavered
Like the zig-zag hieroglyph for life itself.
III
Once upon a time my undrowned father
Walked into our yard. He had gone to spray
Potatoes in a field on the riverbank
And wouldn't bring me with him. The horse-sprayer
Was too big and new-fangled, bluestone might
Burn me in the eyes, the horse was fresh, I
Might scare the horse, and so on. I threw stones
At a bird on the shed roof, as much for
The clatter of the stones as anything,
But when he came back, I was inside the house
And saw him out the window, scatter-eyed
And daunted, strange without his hat,
His step unguided, his ghosthood immanent.
When he was turning on the riverbank,
The horse had rusted and reared up and pitched
Cart and sprayer and everything off balance
Si the whole rig went over into a deep
Whirlpool, hoofs, chains, shafts, cartwheels, barrel
And tackle, all tumbling off the world,
And the hat already merrily swept along
The quieter reaches. That afternoon
I saw him face to face, he came to me
With his damp footprints out of the river,
And there was nothing between us there
That might not still be happily ever after.
Ted Hughes, Charles Causley, and Seamus Heaney - reading submissions for the Arvon Poetry Competition in 1982 which are piled on the table
"Heaney's model is not Joyce and not the great Irish Tain. It is Auden, who teaches that the poet's tasks are making, judging and knowing. The making starts for Heaney in inadvertent politics. In 1974 he spoke of the Republican street rhymes he learned at Anahorish school, full of resistance and Irish patriotism. He was forced to memorize Byron and Keats. He loved to hear Wordsworth's characters but he could not speak their accents aloud. He got over his schooling. He was touched deeply by Hopkins, by Frost and Roethke, by Patrick Kavanagh. Later he was knocked rather off course by the power of Lowell's poems and by Lowell's presence in Ireland. His approach to the present and its recurrences is generally through analogues - ghosts, bog people, childhood - the past lighting and alighting on the prsent. It is a deeply conservative aesthetic. 'Beware of "literary emotion," ', he saus, and it is of Wordsworth, the poet of The Prelude that he reminds us. The particularity of the early poems with their dependence on mimetic sound, their attempt to get close to the rural world, ensured his popularity." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"A great writer within any culture changes everythign. Because the thing is different afterwards and people comprehend themselves differently. If you take Ireland before James Joyce and Ireland fifty years afterwards, the reality of being part of the collective life is enhanced and charged." -- Seamus Heaney
"My sensibility was formed by the dolorous murmurings of the rosary, and the generally Marian quality of devotion. The reality that was addressed was maternal, and the posture was one of supplication." -- Seamus Heaney to John Haffenden
"English, the argument runs, is a language imposed on Ireland; it is historically and semantically inimical to Heaney's Irish Catholic experience. It is colored by Protestantism, it excludes whole registers of feeling, it ironizes attitudes that are close to Heaney's heart. What are the 'exclusive civilities'? What hegemony can a language exercise through literature? To what extent is a language we are born to, which our parents and grandparents and great-grandparents were born to, imposed, to what extent is it given? Imposition is on the first and sometimes the second generation: then the people get hold of their language; they alter it, infiltrate it, make spaces in it, possess it. Stephen Dedalus in the famous 'tundish' scene in Joyce's Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man is a witness to the difference of dialect between the English mentor and the Irish youth. He doesn't wish he spoke Irish instead of English. He is stating a fact: that languages in different usage develop different valencies. He resents hearing his form of the language patronized by one who imagines his version is superior. Heaney's and Brathwaite's stance is now a commonplace, a form of rhetoric that can be adapted to various causes. Language is subvertible, however, and poetry has been and remains a means of subversion. But only if, as in Hill, it is reified, only if the poem is in and against its language. The subtle redress of such poetry is for the reader rather than the audience." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"I was never caught up by [TS] Eliot, never taken over and shown to myself by his work, my ear never pulled outside in by what it heard in him. Numerous readers have testified to this sudden kind of conversion, when the whole being is flushed by a great stroke of poetry, and this did indeed happen to me when I read Gerard Manley Hopkins." -- Seamus Heaney
"For some novelists - Hardy and Lawrence, for example - verse offers itself as a medium for extending and refining apprehensions that their prose fiction has failed to render altogether satisfactorily. There are poems by Hardy and Lawrence which we would be inclined to keep in preference to certain parts of their novels. The same, however, cannot be said of Joyce. Sure, the poems are well tuned and well turned; there is a technical fastidiousness about them, a tough of elegy and pathos. But their chief interest is that they were written by Joyce, their chief surprise the surprise of contrast with other parts of the oeuvre. This stanza from 'Ecce Puer' could be by Francis Ludwidge:
Of the dark past A child is born, With joy and grief My heart is torn
There is a conventional touch to this, a kind of rehearsed tenderness that recalls a Celtic Twilight poem ilke Padraic Colum's 'O men from the fields'. The heavy end-stopping of the lines, the regular metre, the candid rhymes - it is an unexpectedly unsophisticated performance from an artist who at the same time was splitting the linguistic atom in Finnegans Wake.
If I seem to be doing Joyce down, he can stand it, because he himself set the standard by which he must be judged. The great poetry of the opening chapter of Ulysses, for example, amplifies and rhapsodizes the world with an unlooked-for accuracy and transport. It gives the spirit freedom to range in an element that is as linguistic as it is airy and watery, and when the poems are compared with writing that feels so natural, spacious, and unstoppably alive, they are seen to be what Yeats said the earliest of them were - the work of a man 'who is practising his instrument, taking pleasure at the mere handling of the stops'.
Perhaps that is the way for us to take pleasure in them - at a slight aesthetic distance, with a connoisseur's awareness. And that, in fact, seems to be the way Joyce himself appreciated poetry. Stephen in A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, like Joyce in real life, loves the songs of the Elizabethans, the mournful and melodious rhythms of Nashe and Dowland and Shakespeare's songs. It is poetry as the handmaiden of music, as evocation, invitation to dream."
-- Seamus Heaney
“Let me quote my hero, Milosz: ‘Poetry below a certain level of awareness does not interest me.’ I think there’s a problem with political poetry that is howling that it’s aware.” -- Seamus Heaney
Other National Poetry month posts
Merciless Beauté
I. CAPTIVITY
Your yën two wol slee me sodenly.
I may the beauté of hem not sustene,
So woundeth hit through-out my herte kene.
And but your word wol helen hastily
Mt hertes wounde, whyl that hit is grene,
Your yën two wol slee me sodenly.
I may the beauté of hem not sustene.
Upon my trouthe I sey yow feithfully,
That ye ben of my lyf and deeth the quene;
For with my deeth the trouthe shal be sene.
Your yën two wol slee me sodenly.
I may the beauté of hem not sustene.
So woundeth hit through-out my herte kene.
II. REJECTION
So hath your beauté fro your herte chaced
Pitee, that me ne availeth not to pleyne;
For Daunger halt your mercy in his cheyne.
Giltles my deeth thus han ye me purchaced;
I sey yow sooth, me nedeth not to feyne;
So hath your beauté fro your herte chaced
Pitee, that me ne availeth not to pleyne
Allas! that nature hath in yow compassed
So greet beauté; that no man may atteyne
To mercy, though he sterve for the peyne.
So hath your beauté fro your herte chaced
Pitee, that me ne availeth not to pleyne;
For Daunger halt your mercy in his cheyne.
III. ESCAPE
Sin I fro Love escaped am so fat,
I never thenk to ben in his prison lene;
Sin I am free, I counte him not a bene.
He may answere, and seye this or that;
I do no fors, I speke right as I mene.
Sin I fro Love escaped am so fat,
I never thenk to ben in his prison lene.
Love hath my name y-strike out of his sclat,
And he is strike out of my bokes clene
For ever-mo; ther is non other mene.
Sin I fro Love escaped am so fat,
I never thenk to ben in his prison lene.
Sin I am free, I counte him not a bene.
[There are modernized versions ... some rather famous - Wordsworth did an edition, many other poets have too - with "yow" changed to "you", etc. But you lose so much in the translation. It's a bit rough going ... but once you get into it it is perfectly obvious what he is saying. I took a Chaucer class in college - and we read it out loud - in HIS spelling - and there was much hilarity, and also much revelation]

"Chaucer must have been a man of a most wonderful comprehensive nature ... because he has taken into the compass of his Canterbury Tales, the various manners and humours of the whole English nation, in his age." -- John Dryden
"In 1372 he spent a year away, part of it in Genoa arranging the selection of an English port for Genoese trade. He went to Florence and perhaps to Padua. Petrarch died in 1374. It is suggested that in Italy Chaucer was introduced to Petrarch at the wedding of Violante, daughter of the Duke of Milan, by the Duke of Clance: and it is not impossible that Boccaccio was of the party. It's a tempting but unlikely scenario. Certainly he took their poetry, like Dante's, to heart. Indeed it may have helped purge him of French enthusiasms." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"Spenser more than once insinuates that the soul of Chaucer was transfused into his body; and that he was begotten of him two hundred eyars after his decease. Milton has acknowledged to me, that Spenser was his original." -- John Dryden
"... his large, free, simple, clear yet kindly view of human life." -- Matthew Arnold
"Few English poets before the First World War were entirely free of a debt to him." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"The Book of the Duchess shows him almost fully fledged. It's a consolatory romance for John of Gaunt on the death of his first wife, Blanche, and draws on the Romance. The octosyllabic couplets foreshadow Gower's fifteen years later; but Chaucer's poem keeps close to a single subject and illustrates a crucial difference between Chaucer and Gower. Gower is encyclopedic by design; Chaucer is inclusive by nature. His verse is integrated because the human and poetic contexts admit more. Allusion and illustration are means, not end. His morality is implicit in the poem, not appended to it. The Book of the Duchess hints at what's to come: a dream frame, a garden, personification, confession, allegory, May morning, and the hunt. There is also a debt to Ovid's Metamorphoses. What makes it Chaucerian is the actual-seeming grief and sympathy, acknowledging the impotence of consolation." -- Michael Schmidt
"The figures are all British, and bear no suspicious signatures of Classical, Italian, or French imitation." -- Ford Madox Ford on "The Canterbury Tales
"He made England what she was, and, having made her, remains forever a part of his own creation." -- Thomas Warton
"Chaucer, undoubtedly, did excellently in his Troilus and Cryseyde; of whom, truly, I know not whether to marvel more, either that he in that misty time could see so clearly, or that we in this clear age go so stumblingly after him. Yet had he great wants, fit to be forgiven in so reverent an antiquity." -- Sir Philip Sidney
"Here is God's plenty!" -- in John Dryden's preface to "Fables Ancient and Modern"
"He is a perpetual fountain of good sense; learned in all sciences; and therefore speaks properly on all subjects. As he knew what to say, so he knows also when to leave off; a continence which is practised by few writers." -- John Dryden
"Chaucer is the father of English poetry for two reasons. The first is technical: adapting continental forms he evolves a relaxed and distinctly English style; he enriches the poetic vocabulary; and he introduces through translation and adaptation the great Latin, French and Italian poets into English poetry. The second reason relates to the first. In his powerful and original style Chaucer provides a formal and a thematic model. He brings England into the new English poetry. Langland portrays London, but his is a moralized, allegorized metropolis, in the spirit of didactic documentary. Chaucer introduces the diversity of English character and language, of English society at large. He has themes, not polemics or moral programs. His eyes are mild and unclouded. Gower writes from books. Chaucer starts writing from books, but the world takes over his verse." -- Michael Schmidt
"Chaucer followed nature everywhere; but was never so bold to go beyond her." -- John Dryden
More information on Chaucer here
Other National Poetry month posts
On My First Son
Farewell, thou child of my right hand, and joy;
My sin was too much hope of thee, loved boy.
Seven years wert thou leant to me, and I thee pay,
Exacted by thy fate, on the just day.
O. I could lose all father now. For why
Will man lament the state he should envy?
To have so soon 'scaped world's, and flesh's, rage,
And if no other misery, yet age?
Rest in soft peace, and, asked, say here doth lie
Ben Jonson, his best piece of poetry.
For whose sake, henceforth, all his vows be such,
As what he loves may never like too much.

"Ben Jonson - another man described as 'the first poet laureate' - compares with any poet of his age and the next. He's the most versatile writer in the history of English poetry." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"Ben Jonson had one eie lower than t'other, and bigger, like Clun the Player; perhaps he begott Clun." -- John Aubrey
"It is ever the nature of parties to be in extremes; and nothing is so probable, as that because Ben Jonson had much the more learning, it was said on the other hand that Shakespeare had none at all; and because Shakespeare had much the most wit and fancy, it was retorted on the other, that Jonson wanted both. Because Shakespeare borrowed nothing, it was said that Ben Jonson borrowed everything." -- Alexander Pope, "Preface to the Works of Shakespeare" (1725)
"one of the singers who could not sing." -- Swinburne
"I admire him, but I love Shakespeare." -- John Dryden
"Language must show a man. Speak that I may see thee." -- Ben Jonson
"I never tasted English more to my liking, nor more smart, and put to the height of use in poetry, than in the vital, judicious, and most practicable language of Benjamin Jonson's poems." -- Edmund Bolton
"I have seen his studyeing chaire, which was of strawe, such as olde woemen used." -- John Aubrey
"[Jonson] is a poet not quite in the court and thus not secure in patronage, though not yet wedded to Grub Street, its disciplines and treacheries. The world of such a man is unstable, and part of Jonson's greatness is to have survived in it and to have made it survive in his verse. Jonson makes us guests at great houses and lets us hear the age's mannerly speech and savor its hospitality. We hear his songs, too; and we meet, through his eyes, friends and foes as real as any in poetry. He was among the first great poets to take an active interest in publishing, to seek fortune and solace from the printing of his own work in book form. He is the grandfather, or godfather, of Grub Street. -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
" 'Twas an ingeniose remarque of my Lady Hoskins, that B.J. never writes of Love, or if he does, does it not naturally." -- John Aubrey
"In the plays the proximity of Shakespeare does Jonson most harm, though he writes plays so different from his frien's that they seem distinct in kind and period. Part of that difference is Jonson's poetic balance, deliberate artistry: he knows what he wants to say and has the means of saying it, no more or less. He reaches a conclusion and stops; no discovery leads him beyond his destination. He speaks for his age, while Shakespeare speaks for himself. Jonson's art is normative, Shakespeare's radical and exploratory. In Jonson there's structure and gauged variegation, in Shakespeare movement and wamrth. Coleridge disliked the "rankness" of Jonson's realism and found no "goodness of heart". He condemned the "absurd rant and ventriloquism" in the tragedy Sejanus, staged by Shakespeare's company at the Globe. At times Jonson's words, unlike Shakespeare's tend to separate out and stand single, rather than coalesce, as though he had attended to each individual word. His mind is busy near the surface." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
To the memory of my beloved,
The Author
MR. W I L L I A M S H A K E S P E A R E :
A N D
what he hath left us.
To draw no envy (Shakespeare) on thy name,
Am I thus ample to thy Booke, and Fame;
While I confesse thy writings to be such,
As neither Man, nor Muse, can praise too much.
'Tis true, and all men's suffrage. But these wayes
Were not the paths I meant unto thy praise;
For seeliest Ignorance on these may light,
Which, when it sounds at best, but eccho's right;
Or blinde Affection, which doth ne're advance
The truth, but gropes, and urgeth all by chance;
Or crafty Malice, might pretend this praise,
And thine to ruine, where it seem'd to raise.
These are, as some infamous Baud, or Whore,
Should praise a Matron. What could hurt her more?
But thou art proofe against them, and indeed
Above th' ill fortune of them, or the need.
I, therefore will begin. Soule of the Age !
The applause ! delight ! the wonder of our Stage !
My Shakespeare, rise; I will not lodge thee by
Chaucer, or Spenser, or bid Beaumont lye
A little further, to make thee a roome :
Thou art a Moniment, without a tombe,
And art alive still, while thy Booke doth live,
And we have wits to read, and praise to give.
That I not mixe thee so, my braine excuses ;
I meane with great, but disproportion'd Muses :
For, if I thought my judgement were of yeeres,
I should commit thee surely with thy peeres,
And tell, how farre thou dist our Lily out-shine,
Or sporting Kid or Marlowes mighty line.
And though thou hadst small Latine, and lesse Greeke,
From thence to honour thee, I would not seeke
For names; but call forth thund'ring Æschilus,
Euripides, and Sophocles to us,
Paccuvius, Accius, him of Cordova dead,
To life againe, to heare thy Buskin tread,
And shake a stage : Or, when thy sockes were on,
Leave thee alone, for the comparison
Of all, that insolent Greece, or haughtie Rome
Sent forth, or since did from their ashes come.
Triumph, my Britaine, thou hast one to showe,
To whom all scenes of Europe homage owe.
He was not of an age, but for all time !
And all the Muses still were in their prime,
When like Apollo he came forth to warme
Our eares, or like a Mercury to charme !
Nature her selfe was proud of his designes,
And joy'd to weare the dressing of his lines !
Which were so richly spun, and woven so fit,
As, since, she will vouchsafe no other Wit.
The merry Greeke, tart Aristophanes,
Neat Terence, witty Plautus, now not please;
But antiquated, and deserted lye
As they were not of Natures family.
Yet must I not give Nature all: Thy Art,
My gentle Shakespeare, must enjoy a part;
For though the Poets matter, Nature be,
His Art doth give the fashion. And, that he,
Who casts to write a living line, must sweat,
(Such as thine are) and strike the second heat
Upon the Muses anvile : turne the same,
(And himselfe with it) that he thinkes to frame;
Or for the lawrell, he may gaine a scorne,
For a good Poet's made, as well as borne.
And such wert thou. Looke how the fathers face
Lives in his issue, even so, the race
Of Shakespeares minde, and manners brightly shines
In his well toned, and true-filed lines :
In each of which, he seemes to shake a Lance,
As brandish't at the eyes of Ignorance.
Sweet swan of Avon! what a fight it were
To see thee in our waters yet appeare,
And make those flights upon the bankes of Thames,
That so did take Eliza, and our James !
But stay, I see thee in the Hemisphere
Advanc'd, and made a Constellation there !
Shine forth, thou Starre of Poets, and with rage,
Or influence, chide, or cheere the drooping Stage;
Which, since thy flight fro' hence, hath mourn'd like night,
And despaires day, but for thy Volumes light.
-- Ben Jonson, preface in First Folio of Shakespeare's works, 1623
"I remember, the players have often mentioned it as an honour to Shakespeare that in his writing (whatsoever he penned) he never blotted out line. My answer hath been, would he had blotted a thousand. " -- Ben Jonson
"Many times [Shakespeare] fell into those things could not escape laughter: as when he said in the person of Caesar, one speaking to him, "Caesar, thou dost me wrong," he replied "Caesar did never wrong, but with just cause," and such like, which were ridiculous. But he redeemed his vices with his virtues. There was ever more in him to be praised than to be pardoned." -- Ben Jonson
"He is a great lover and praiser of himself ; a contemner and scorner of others ; given rather to lose a friend than a jest ; . . . he is passionately kind and angry ; careless either to gain or keep ; vindictive, but, if he be well answered, at himself . . . ; oppressed with fantasy, which hath ever mastered his reason." -- William Drummond of Hawthornden
"What Jonson has done here is not merely a fine speech. It is the careful, precise filling in of a strong and simple outline, and at no point does it overflow the outline; it is far more careful and precise in its obedience to this outline than are many of the speeches in Tamburlaine. The outline is not Sulla, for Sulla has nothing to do with it, but "Sylla's ghost." The words may not be suitable to an historical Sulla, or to anybody in history, but they are a perfect expression for "Sylla's ghost." You cannot say they are rhetorical "because people do not talk like that," you cannot call them "verbiage"; they do not exhibit prolixity or redundancy or the other vices in the rhetoric books; there is a definite artistic emotion which demands expression at that length. The words themselves are mostly simple words, the syntax is natural, the language austere rather than adorned. Turning then to the induction of The Poetaster, we find another success of the same kind—
Light, I salute thee, but with wounded nerves...
Men may not talk in that way, but the spirit of envy does, and in the words of Jonson envy is a real and living person. It is not human life that informs envy and Sylla's ghost, but it is energy of which human life is only another variety." -- T.S. Eliot
"He was a very accurately observing man; but he cared only to observe what was open to, and likely to impress, the senses.” -- Coleridge
"O rare Ben Johnson." -- Jonson's epitaph in Westminster Abbey
More on Ben Jonson here.
Other National Poetry month posts
All his life, Melville "wrestled with the angel - Art". Many of his novels did not go over well during his lifetime. He had what we would call, in the modern age, a "nervous breakdown" after a number of failures. He traveled to the Holy Land, a la Mark Twain, hoping his faith would be renewed, his spirit refreshed. But he just came back sadder. His life story is not a happy one. I love his poetry. I couldn't choose between the two poems below - so I'm posting both.
The Maldive Shark
About the Shark, phlegmatical one,
Pale sot of the Maldive sea,
The sleek little pilot-fish, azure and slim,
How alert in attendance be.
From his saw-pit of mouth, from his charnel of maw,
They have nothing of harm to dread,
But liquidly glide on his ghastly flank
Or before his Gorgonian head;
Or lurk in the port of serrated teeth
In white triple tiers of glittering gates,
And there find a haven when peril's abroad,
An asylum in jaws of the Fates!
They are friends; and friendly they guide him to prey,
Yet never partake of the treat--
Eyes and brains to the dotard lethargic and dull,
Pale ravener of horrible meat.
Art
In placid hours well-pleased we dream
Of many a brave unbodied scheme.
But form to lend, pulsed life create,
What unlike things must meet and mate:
A flame to melt--a wind to freeze;
Sad patience--joyous energies;
Humility--yet pride and scorn;
Instinct and study; love and hate;
Audacity--reverence. These must mate,
And fuse with Jacob's mystic heart,
To wrestle with the angel--Art.

"Moby Dick proved hard and exhausting to write. But he knew it was original and he understood that it was good. Published in 1851, it was not a success; until the first quarter of the twentieth century it was neglected. Ambitious later books were rejected. The failure of Moby Dick helped turn his primary attention to verse. Battle-Pieces (1866) was welcomed as peripheral work by a man who had once been famous for his prose. Seriously disturbed in his mind, he made a trip to the Holy Land (meeting with [Nathaniel] Hawthorne in Southport en route), and out of this visit emerged his most ambitious if not his most accomplished poem, the 18,000-line Clarel, twice as long as Paradise Lost, and in the octo-syllabic couplets of Gower's Confessio Amantis. Eventually, Melville - after working as a minor customs officer in New York - was reduced to dependence on his wife's money: she gave him an allowance to buy books and to print his later works in small editions for the tiny readership he retained. He died in 1891, quite forgotten, with the manuscript of the prose work Billy Budd completed but unpublished. His reputation was at such a low ebb that even this masterpiece went unpublished until 1924." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
At Melville's Tomb
by Hart Crane
Often beneath the wave, wide from this ledge
The dice of drowned men's bones he saw bequeath
An embassy. Their numbers as he watched,
Beat on the dusty shore and were obscured.
And wrecks passed without sound of bells,
The calyx of death's bounty giving back
A scattered chapter, livid hieroglyph,
The portent wound in corridors of shells.
Then in the circuit calm of one vast coil,
Its lashings charmed and malice reconciled,
Frosted eyes there were that lifted altars;
And silent answers crept across the stars.
Compass, quadrant and sextant contrive
No farther tides . . . High in the azure steeps
Monody shall not wake the mariner.
This fabulous shadow only the sea keeps.
"In Melville's lifetime few recognized or even suspected the writer's exceptional genius -- but Nathaniel Hawthorne came close, and the two men established a long-lasting friendship. After their first encounters, the writer of Polynesian adventures went back to his romantic tale about "Whale Fishery" and, in Delbanco's words, "tore it up from within." Melville deepened and amplified his novel, enlarged it in every sense, with the obvious hope of joining what he called, in an essay on Hawthorne, that fraternity where "genius, all over the world, stands hand in hand, and one shock of recognition runs the whole circle round." With wonderful appropriateness, then, the author of The Scarlet Letter -- which appeared in 1850 -- became the dedicatee of the following year's Moby-Dick" -- Michael Dirda, 2005
"Give me Vesuvius' crater for an inkstand!" -- Melville apparently shouted this, as he sat at his desk writing "Moby Dick"
"...a cosmos (a chaos) not only perceptibly malignant as the Gnostics had intuited, but also irrational, like the cosmos in the hexameters of Lucretius." -- Jorge Luis Borges on the "cosmos" of "Moby Dick"
"In general, it is the non-psychological novel that offers the richest opportunities for psychological elucidation. Here the author, having no intentions of this sort, does not show his characters in a psychological light and thus leaves room for analysis and interpretation, or even invites it by his unprejudiced mode of presentation... I would also include Melville's Moby Dick, which I consider the be the greatest American novel, in this broad class of writings." -- Carl Jung in "The Spirit in Man, Art, and Literature"
"Moby Dick was the most difficult picture I ever made. I lost so many battles during it that I even began to suspect that my assistant director was plotting against me. Then I realized that it was only God. God had a perfectly good reason. Ahab saw the White Whale as a mask worn by the Deity, and he saw the Deity as a malignant force. It was God's pleasure to torment and torture man. Ahab didn't deny God, he simply looked on him as a murderer - a thought that is utterly blasphemous: "Is Ahab Ahab? Is it I, God, or who, that lifts this arm?...Where do murderers go?... Who's to doom, when the judge himself is dragged to the bar?"' -- John Huston, "An Open Book", 1980
"We have little more to say in reprobation or in recommendation of this absurd book.... Mr. Melville has to thank himself only if his horrors and his heroics are flung aside by the general reader, as so much trash belonging to the worst school of Bedlam literature -- since he seems not so much unable to learn as disdainful of learning the craft of an artist. --Henry F. Chorley, in London Athenaeum, October 25 1851, review of "Moby Dick"
"Moby Dick is an easy book, as long as we read it as a yarn or an account of whaling interspersed with snatches of poetry. But as soon as we catch the song in it, it grows difficult and immensely important. Narrowed and hardened into words the spiritual theme of Moby Dick is as follows: a battle against evil conducted too long or in the wrong way. The White Whale is evil, and Captain Ahab is warped by constant pursuit until his knight-errantry turns into revenge. These are words -- a symbol for the book if we want one -- but they do not carry us much further than the acceptance of the book as a yarn -- perhaps they carry us backwards, for they may mislead us into harmonizing the incidents, and so losing their roughness and richness. The idea of a contest we may retain: all action is a battle, the only happiness is peace. But contest between what? We get false if we say that it is between good and evil or between two unreconciled evils. The essential in Moby Dick, its prophetic song, flows athwart the action and the surface morality like an undercurrent. It lies outside words...we cannot catch the words of the song. There has been stress, with intervals: but no explicable solution, certainly no reaching back into universal pity and love; no 'Gentlemen, I've had a good dream.'
The extraordinary nature of the book appears in two of its early incidents -- the sermon about Jonah and the friendship with Queequeg.
The sermon has nothing to do with Christianity. It asks for endurance or loyalty without hope of reward. The preacher "kneeling in the pulpit's bows, folded his large brown hands across his chest, uplifted his closed eyes, and offered a prayer so deeply devout that he seemed kneeling and praying at the bottom of the sea." Then he works up and up and concludes on a note of joy that is far more terrifying than a menace...
Immediately after the sermon, Ishmael makes a passionate alliance with the cannibal Queequeg, and it looks for a moment that the book is to be a saga of blood-brotherhood. But human relationships mean little to Melville, and after a grotesque and violent entry, Queequeg is almost forgotten. Almost -- not quite...
Moby Dick is full of meanings: its meaning is a different problem. It is wrong to turn the Delight or the coffin into symbols, because even if the symbolism is correct, it silences the book. Nothing can be stated about Moby Dick except that it is a contest. The rest is song." -- EM Forster, "Aspects of the Novel"
"I am like one of those seeds taken out of the Egyptian pyramids, which, after being three thousand years a seed, and nothing but a seed, being planted in English soil it developed itself, grew to greenness, and then fell to mould." -- Herman Melville
"Some critics woud place his name among the most important American poets of the nineteenth century, or even today." -- Robert Penn Warren
"Melville's poems, less sumptuous in semantic nuance than the prose, less second nature to him than his fiction, are worked at and worked up, yet the difficulty of the restraining forms remains central. So does the rumor of an 'unspeakable' theme, unacknowledged at times, at times veiled from himself, which has to do with a radiant sexual irresolution. More insistently even than Conrad, Melville depicts a male world in prose and verse, a world in which intimate relationships and erotic experiences are between men and types of men: at sea, in the army and elsewhere. He celebrates, laments, touches - and he occasionally foresees, not the huge and benign vision of Walt Whitman, but with narrowed eyes, looking further than the future. His is not the optimism of Emerson but something more serious: he sees beyond a bad age, he sees to the other side of evil; nature consoles, but it also remembers and comments." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"Mr. Herman Melville has earned a deservedly high reputation for his performances in descriptive fiction. He has gathered his own materials, and travelled along fresh and untrodden literary paths, exhibiting powers of no common order, and great originality. The more careful, therefore, should he be to maintain the fame he so rapidly acquired, and not waste his strength on such purposeless and unequal doings as these rambling volumes about spermaceti whales." -- London Literary Gazette, December 6 1851
"Melville, as he always does, began to reason of Providence and futurity, and everything that lies beyond human ken, and informed me that he had 'pretty much made up his mind to be annihilated'; but still he does not seem to rest in that anticipation.... He can neither believe, nor be comfortable in his unbelief; and he is too honest and courageous not to try to do one or the other." -- Nathaniel Hawthorne, on a walk on the beach with Melville, 1857
"Mardi is a rich book, with depths here and there that compel a man to swim for his life. It is so good that one scarcely pardons the writer for not having brooded over it, so as to make it a great deal better." -- Nathaniel Hawthorne, in a letter to Evert Duyckinck
"It will be a strange sort of book, tho,' I fear; blubber is blubber you know ... and to cook the thing up, one must needs throw in a little fancy, which from the nature of the things, must be ungainly as the gambols of the whales themselves." -- Melville on "Moby Dick" - in a letter to Richard Henry, Jr.
"A sense of unspeakable security is in me at this moment, on account of your having understood the book. I have written a wicked book, and feel spotless as the lamb." -- Melville to Nathaniel Hawthorne - after Hawthorne read Moby Dick
"...fresh from his mountain charged to the muzzle with sailor metaphysics and jargon of things unknowable," -- Evert Duyckinck in his journal, describing a meeting with Melville, 1856
-- "[He is] a little paler, and perhaps a little sadder.... and no doubt has suffered from too constant literary occupation, pursued without much success, latterly; and his writings, for a long while past, have indicated a morbid state of mind." --Nathaniel Hawthorne, on seeing Melville in 1857
"It is--or seems to be--a wise sort of thing, to realise that all that happens to a man in this life is only by way of a joke.... And it is also worth bearing in mind, that the joke is passed around pretty liberally and impartially, so that not very many are entitled to fancy that they in particular are getting the worst of it." -- Melville to Henry Savage
I wrote about my affection for this poem here - it was just a part of my childhood because of that Clancy Brothers album ... I didn't even know it was Yeats at the time! Of course his later poems are among the greatest poems ever written - reading his stuff in chronological order last fall was one of the coolest reading experiences of my life. There is so much crap (forgive me) to get thru ... but wait for it ... watch him emerge ... Unbelievable.
This is a poem I can recite by heart. Adore it. Gives me a lump in the ol' throat.
The Host of the Air
O'Driscoll drove with a song
The wild duck and the drake
From the tall and the tufted reeds
Of the drear Heart Lake.
And he saw how the reeds grew dark
At the coming of night-tide,
And dreamed of the long dim hair
Of Bridget his bride.
He heard while he sang and dreamed
A piper piping away,
And never was piping so sad,
And never was piping so gay.
And he saw young men and young girls
Who danced on a level place,
And Bridget his bride among them,
With a sad and a gay face.
The dancers crowded about him
And many a sweet thing said,
And a young man brought him red wine
And a young girl white bread.
But Bridget drew him by the sleeve
Away from the merry bands,
To old men playing at cards
With a twinkling of ancient hands.
The bread and the wine had a doom,
For these were the host of the air;
He sat and played in a dream
Of her long dim hair.
He played with the merry old men
And thought not of evil chance,
Until one bore Bridget his bride
Away from the merry dance.
He bore her away in his arms,
The handsomest young man there,
And his neck and his breast and his arms
Were drowned in her long dim hair.
O'Driscoll scattered the cards
And out of his dream awoke:
Old men and young men and young girls
Were gone like a drifting smoke;
But he heard high up in the air
A piper piping away,
And never was piping so sad,
And never was piping so gay.

"My poetry is generally written out of despair. Like Balzac, I see increasing commonness everywhere, and like Balzac I know no one who shares the premises from which I work." -- Yeats
"On the third night Yeats addressed the audience before the curtain rose. If anyone had anything to say against the piece they would be welcomed at a debate which he would be glad to arrange in the theatre at some other time. He was interrupted several times. He asked the interrupters to at least listen to the play so that they would know what it was they were objecting to." -- Maire Nic Shiubhlaigh's description of Yeats trying to handle the riots that were happening in response to Synge's "Playboy of the Western World" - a play being put on at the Abbey Theatre
"In 1875 Yeats entered the Godolphin School in Hammersmith and visited Ireland during the longer school vacations, when he stayed with the Pollexfens in County Sligo. An early poetic impulse was to change the name of his toy yacht from Sunbeam to Moonbeam. It was a decisive act." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets
"I thought we might bring the halves together if we had a national literature that made Ireland beautiful in the memory, and yet had been freed of provincialism by an exacting criticism, a European pose." -- Yeats
"This is not the huge competence of Auden, at play in the toy shop of poetic form, but mastery, the possession of a unique rhetoric for use on a real but limited range of themes. It is a mastery so complete that it can occlude the genuinely problematic, ride over the potholes of nonsense without even sensing them. Late in life he recognizes the evasiveness of his symbols, the tendency of his verse to turn away or inward, and in the concentrated intensity of the late poems he tries to remedy this. But he has an imperfect sense of generality; he is willing to plump out a truism as truth. As his mastery increases, his art becomes less truthful. But his main concern is not - until the later poems, and even there in an attenuated spirit - truth, but the house of myth and legend, where he can become a principal tenant, where it is his voice we hear casting the spell, and where real men are reduced - or, in his mind, enlarged - to masks, figures and types useful to myth, regardless of the human reality they had." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"All literature created out of a conscious political aim in the long run crates weakness by creating a habit of unthinking obedience. Literature created for its own sake, for some eternal spiritual need, can be used for politics. Dante is said to have unified Italy. The more unconscious the creation, the more powerful." -- Yeats
"Sex and death are the only things that can interest a serious mind." -- Yeats
"His mastery seems almost excessive." -- Richard Ellmann
"... a strained and unworkable allegory about a young man and a sphinx on a rock in the sea (how did they get there? what did they eat? and so on; people think such criticisms very prosaic, but common-sense is never out of place anywhere ...) but still containing fine lines and vivid imagery." - Gerard Manley Hopkins, after reading some of Yeats' first published verses
"Irish poets, learn your trade, sing whatever is well made, scorn the sort now growing up all out of shape from toe to top." -- Yeats
"Yeats's 'The Second Coming' has gained in prophetic power with each decade of the twentieth and now twenty-first century, from the rise of fascism and nuclear warfare to the proliferation of international terrorism. It expresses the melancholy realizatino that man, yearningly drawn to the divine, will never fully escape his bestial ancestry. The poem is modernistically unrhymed, though the first stanza plays with shadowy off-rhymes: 'gyre' / 'falconer' / 'everywhere'; 'hold' / 'world' / 'drowned'. It is structured instead by dramatic visuals and emblematic choreography. There are two main movements: a huge, expanding circle (the ascending falcon) and an arrowlike, linear track (the beast bound for Bethlehem). Then two smaller ones: a pendulum arc (the rocking cradle) and an exploding pinwheel (the reeling desert birds). Ideas have become design, starkly juxtaposed with the murky turbulence of elemental forces - storm, flood, drought. Hence the poem, with its horror movie finale, is as hybrid as the sphinx, who represents our buried impulses, vestiges of a past that keeps turning into the future." -- Camille Paglia, "Break, Blow, Burn"
"The heavy voluptuous splendour of much of his work has yet a ghostliness as of the palace made magically of leaves. Even his heroes and beautiful women are aware of this ... He never leaves us, any more than Crashaw, content with the glory alone. It calls our attention to a spirit behind and beyond, heaping high lovely, invisible things that it may show the greater beauty that can survive their crumbling into dust." -- Edward Thomas, 1909
"The worst thing about some men is that when they are not drunk they are sober." -- Yeats
"In London he was active in literature and politics. One particular event in 1889 proved crucial: he met and fell in love with the fiery Republican who haunted him for the rest of his days, Maud Gonne. His biography, from 1889 until Maud Gonne's marriage, is punctuated by the statement, 'Yeats proposed to Maud Gonne.'" -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"Words are always getting conventionalized to some secondary meaning. It is one of the works of poetry to take the truants in custody and bring them back to their right senses." -- Yeats
" 'The best lack all conviction, while the worst / Are full of passionate intensity': these famous lines are Yeats's anguished formulation of what seems to be an eternal principle of politics (7-8). When 'the center cannot hold,' neither consensus nor compromise is possible. Public debate shifts to the extremes or is overtaken by violence, which blocks incremental movement toward reciprocity and conciliation. Moderate views are 'drowned' out (as by the bloody tide) in strident partisanship or fanaticism. The phrase 'passionate intensity' suggests that, for the late Romantic Yeats, eros diverted from the personal to the political turns into a distorted lust for power. The second stanza opens in doubt and confusion: 'Surely some revelation is at hand; / Surely the Second Coming is at hand. / The Second Coming!'' (9-11). We are hearing either one voice echoing its own shocked phrases or many voices in public tumult. The book of Revelation lists the dreadful omens heralding doomsday, when Jesus will return and unlock the secrets of history. But in Yeats's poem, Christ's promised glory is overshadowed by a monstrous apparition from antiquity. The poet is seized by an electrifying vision: 'a vast image out of Spiritus Mundi / Troubles my sight'. It's a collective memory, crystallizing from the repository of world myths (12-13). ("Spiritus Mundi" is Yeats's mystical term for "soul of the universe".) We witness the resurrection of the pagan era, whose barbarism mirrors that of the war-torn twentieth century. Yeats sees no evidence of moral evolution over two millennia of Christianity." -- Camille Paglia, "Break, Blow, Burn"
"I once got Yeats down to bed-rock on these subjects and we talked for hours. He had been talking rather wildly about the after life. Finally I asked him: 'What do you believe happens to us immediately after death?' He replied, 'After a person dies, he does not realize that he is dead.' I: 'In what state is he?' W.B.Y.: 'In some half-conscious state.' I said: 'Like the period between waking and sleeping?' W.B.Y.: 'Yes.' I: 'How long does this state last?' W.B.Y.: 'Perhaps some twenty years.' 'And after that,' I asked, 'what happens next?' He replied, 'Again a period which is Purgaotry. The length of that period depends upon the sins of the man when he was upon this earth.' And then again I asked: 'And after that?' I do not remember his actual words, but he spoke of the return of the soul to God. I said, 'Well, it seems to me that you are hurrying us back into the great arms of the Roman Catholic Church.' He was of course an Irish Protestant. I was bold to ask him, but his only retort was his splendid laugh." -- Lady Dorothy Wellesley
"It is an entirely new thing -- neither what they eye sees nor the ear hears, but what the rambling mind thinks and imagines from moment to moment. He has certainly surpassed in intensity any novelist of our time." -- Yeats on James Joyce's "Ulysses"
"For Yeats, there was something both enviable and exemplary about the enlargement of vision and the consequent histrionic equanimity which Shakespeare's heroes and heroines attain at the moment of their death, 'carried beyond feeling into the aboriginal ice.' He wanted people in real life to emulate or at least to internalize the fortitude and defiance thus manifested in tragic art." -- Seamus Heaney, 1990
"Give up Paris, you will never create anything by reading Racine, and Arthur Symons will always be a better critic of French literature. Go to the Arran Islands. Live there as if you were one of the people themselves; express a life that has never found expression." -- Yeats's advice to John Synge
In Memory of W.B. Yeats
by Auden
I
He disappeared in the dead of winter:
The brooks were frozen, the airports almost deserted,
And snow disfigured the public statues;
The mercury sank in the mouth of the dying day.
What instruments we have agree
The day of his death was a dark cold day.
Far from his illness
The wolves ran on through the evergreen forests,
The peasant river was untempted by the fashionable quays;
By mourning tongues
The death of the poet was kept from his poems.
But for him it was his last afternoon as himself,
An afternoon of nurses and rumours;
The provinces of his body revolted,
The squares of his mind were empty,
Silence invaded the suburbs,
The current of his feeling failed; he became his admirers.
Now he is scattered among a hundred cities
And wholly given over to unfamiliar affections,
To find his happiness in another kind of wood
And be punished under a foreign code of conscience.
The words of a dead man
Are modified in the guts of the living.
But in the importance and noise of to-morrow
When the brokers are roaring like beasts on the floor of the Bourse,
And the poor have the sufferings to which they are fairly accustomed,
And each in the cell of himself is almost convinced of his freedom,
A few thousand will think of this day
As one thinks of a day when one did something slightly unusual.
What instruments we have agree
The day of his death was a dark cold day.
II
You were silly like us; your gift survived it all:
The parish of rich women, physical decay,
Yourself. Mad Ireland hurt you into poetry.
Now Ireland has her madness and her weather still,
For poetry makes nothing happen: it survives
In the valley of its making where executives
Would never want to tamper, flows on south
From ranches of isolation and the busy griefs,
Raw towns that we believe and die in; it survives,
A way of happening, a mouth.
III
Earth, receive an honoured guest:
William Yeats is laid to rest.
Let the Irish vessel lie
Emptied of its poetry.
In the nightmare of the dark
All the dogs of Europe bark,
And the living nations wait,
Each sequestered in its hate;
Intellectual disgrace
Stares from every human face,
And the seas of pity lie
Locked and frozen in each eye.
Follow, poet, follow right
To the bottom of the night,
With your unconstraining voice
Still persuade us to rejoice;
With the farming of a verse
Make a vineyard of the curse,
Sing of human unsuccess
In a rapture of distress;
In the deserts of the heart
Let the healing fountain start,
In the prison of his days
Teach the free man how to praise.
"Conquest, difficulty, labour: these terms indicate the nature of Yeats's creative disposition. From the start, he was enamoured of Blake's conviction that energy is eternal delight, yet the development of his own thought brought him more and more to the conclusion that conflict was the inescapable condition of being human. So, as his art matured and the articulation of his beliefs became more clarified and forceful, Yeats's poems typically conveyed a sensation of certitude achieved by great effort and of contradictions quelled. Poems in which the defiant self is pitted against hostile or disabling conditions - 'An Irish Airman Foresees his Death', 'September 1913', 'Meditations in Time of Civil War'- are complemented by poems that read like discharges of pure, self-possessed energy, poems from which the accidental circumstances have been excluded so that all that remains is the melody and stamina of resurgent spirit - The Cold Heaven', 'Byzantium', 'Long-legged Fly'." -- Seamus Heaney, 2006
Anne's post on Maud Gonne.
"The first spectre of the new generation has appeared. His name is Joyce. I have suffered from him and I would like you to suffer." -- George Russell in a letter to Yeats, 1902
Cast a cold eye
On life on death
Horseman pass by
-- Yeats's epitaph
Not all song lyrics work as straight poems - many song lyrics need the music to get the message across, to tap into the emotion, whatever it is the purpose of the song is. I love Green Day's "Holiday" but without that music it just doesn't have the PUNCH that the song does. But some songs do work as poems. "Mr. Harris" by Aimee Mann (do NOT even get me started on that song.) Pretty much every Indigo Girls song works as poetry. "Galileo"? Totally. "Watershed." Yes~!
The following song is one of my favorites. It really resonates for me at this moment in my life. sniff sniff. Also I love all of the internal rhymes. ("that you", "statue", etc.) It's a perfect song. Kills me.
It's "Bill" - from Showboat
Words by P.G. Wodehouse & Music by Jerome Kern
I used to dream that I would discover
The perfect lover
someday,
I knew I'd recognize him if ever
He came 'round my way.
I always used to fancy then
He'd be one of the God-like kind of men
With a giant brain and a noble head
Like the heroes bold
In the books I've read.
But along came Bill,
who's not the type at all
You'd meet him on the street and never notice him;
His form and face, his manly grace
Are not the kind that you would find in a statue.
And I can't explain,
It's surely not his brain
That makes me thrill --
I love him because he's wonderful,
Because he's just my Bill.
He can't play golf or tennis or polo,
Or sing a solo, or row.
He isn't half as handsome
As dozens of men that I know.
He isn't tall or straight or slim
And he dresses far worse than Ted or Jim.
And I can't explain why he should be
Just the one, one man in the world for me.
He's just my Bill, an ordinary man,
He hasn't got a thing that I can brag about.
And yet to be
Upon his knee
So comfy and roomy
Seems natural to me.
Oh, I can't explain,
It's surely not his brain
That makes me thrill --
I love him because he's -- I don't know...
Because he's just my Bill.
Christopher Smart - a poet born in the early 1700s who spent over 10 years of his life in mental institutions (which at that time in history were even more horrific than they are today). He suffered from a form of religious hysteria - he would drop to his knees in public and pray to God. Seems a rather harmless form of madness to me. He was a highly educated man - and his poems have a Blakean ecstasy to them - and are very difficult to pin down or even talk about. While "inside" - he wrote this poem to his cat Jeoffry. It is one of my favorite poems - I love to read it over and over again. Can't you just see Jeoffry? Isn't his cat-ness just perfectly captured?
The guy wasn't just ahead of his time. He was timeless.
For I Will Consider My Cat Jeoffry
For I will consider my Cat Jeoffry.
For he is the servant of the Living God duly and daily serving him.
For at the first glance of the glory of God in the East he worships in his way.
For this is done by wreathing his body seven times round with elegant quickness.
For then he leaps up to catch the musk, which is the blessing of God upon his prayer.
For he rolls upon prank to work it in.
For having done duty and received blessing he begins to consider himself.
For this he performs in ten degrees.
For first he looks upon his forepaws to see if they are clean.
For secondly he kicks up behind to clear away there.
For thirdly he works it upon stretch with the forepaws extended.
For fourthly he sharpens his paws by wood.
For fifthly he washes himself.
For sixthly he rolls upon wash.
For seventhly he fleas himself, that he may not be interrupted upon the beat.
For eighthly he rubs himself against a post.
For ninthly he looks up for his instructions.
For tenthly he goes in quest of food.
For having consider'd God and himself he will consider his neighbour.
For if he meets another cat he will kiss her in kindness.
For when he takes his prey he plays with it to give it a chance.
For one mouse in seven escapes by his dallying.
For when his day's work is done his business more properly begins.
For he keeps the Lord's watch in the night against the adversary.
For he counteracts the powers of darkness by his electrical skin and glaring eyes.
For he counteracts the Devil, who is death, by brisking about the life.
For in his morning orisons he loves the sun and the sun loves him.
For he is of the tribe of Tiger.
For the Cherub Cat is a term of the Angel Tiger.
For he has the subtlety and hissing of a serpent, which in goodness he suppresses.
For he will not do destruction, if he is well-fed, neither will he spit without provocation.
For he purrs in thankfulness, when God tells him he's a good Cat.
For he is an instrument for the children to learn benevolence upon.
For every house is incomplete without him and a blessing is lacking in the spirit.
For the Lord commanded Moses concerning the cats at the departure of the Children of Israel from Egypt.
For every family had one cat at least in the bag.
For the English Cats are the best in Europe.
For he is the cleanest in the use of his forepaws of any quadruped.
For the dexterity of his defence is an instance of the love of God to him exceedingly.
For he is the quickest to his mark of any creature.
For he is tenacious of his point.
For he is a mixture of gravity and waggery.
For he knows that God is his Saviour.
For there is nothing sweeter than his peace when at rest.
For there is nothing brisker than his life when in motion.
For he is of the Lord's poor and so indeed is he called by benevolence perpetually--Poor Jeoffry! poor Jeoffry! the rat has bit thy throat.
For I bless the name of the Lord Jesus that Jeoffry is better.
For the divine spirit comes about his body to sustain it in complete cat.
For his tongue is exceeding pure so that it has in purity what it wants in music.
For he is docile and can learn certain things.
For he can set up with gravity which is patience upon approbation.
For he can fetch and carry, which is patience in employment.
For he can jump over a stick which is patience upon proof positive.
For he can spraggle upon waggle at the word of command.
For he can jump from an eminence into his master's bosom.
For he can catch the cork and toss it again.
For he is hated by the hypocrite and miser.
For the former is afraid of detection.
For the latter refuses the charge.
For he camels his back to bear the first notion of business.
For he is good to think on, if a man would express himself neatly.
For he made a great figure in Egypt for his signal services.
For he killed the Ichneumon-rat very pernicious by land.
For his ears are so acute that they sting again.
For from this proceeds the passing quickness of his attention.
For by stroking of him I have found out electricity.
For I perceived God's light about him both wax and fire.
For the Electrical fire is the spiritual substance, which God sends from heaven to sustain the bodies both of man and beast.
For God has blessed him in the variety of his movements.
For, tho he cannot fly, he is an excellent clamberer.
For his motions upon the face of the earth are more than any other quadruped.
For he can tread to all the measures upon the music.
For he can swim for life.
For he can creep.

"Christopher Smart wrote A Song to David in a lunatic asylum, and when his collected poems were published in 1791, it was omitted as 'not acceptable to the reader'. This poem is formally addressed to David - Smart knew that he was no madder than King David had been, and a tradition survives that he scrabbled the verses with a key on the wall of his cell." -- Robert Graves
"I do not think he ought to be shut up. His infirmities were not noxious to society. He insisted on people praying with him; and I'd as lief pray with Kit Smart as anyone else. Another charge was that he did not love clean linen, and I have no passion for it." -- Dr. Johnson
"It is not impossible that when Smart is judged over the whole range of his various productions - conventional in form as well as unconventional, light and even ribald as well as devotional, urbane or tender as well as sublime - he will be thought of as the greatest English poet between Pope and Wordsworth." -- Donald Davie
"Pope's 'Messiah' is not musical, but Smart's 'Song to David', with its pounding thematic words and the fortissimo explosion of its coda, is a musical tour de force." -- Northrop Frye
"Smart goes where Gray could not: enthusiasm and vaticism overflow from a full if troubled spirit. He is not an imitator even in his translations, which hold the original in a form and language that make no concessions. He feels and conveys the force of the poetry he admires. His intuition is attuned to a broad tradition, not caught in the rut of convention. Marcus Walsh calls Smart's mature style 'mannered, religiose, and self-conscious' - and each becomes a positive critical term, for together they produce a 'homogenous' style that 'unifies' - the crucial word - 'a number of divergent influences.' It is the paradoxical combination of influences, biblical and classical, and the disruptions his imagination registers, that make him outstanding and eccentric. Learning and accidents of biography deliver him from the bondage of Augustan convention into the sometimes anarchic, vertiginous freedom of Jubilate Agno and the originality of the Song to David. He has few heirs". -- Michael Schmidt
More on this fascinating poet here.
Other National Poetry month posts:
John Milton. Paradise Lost is one of those things we had to read in high school - which ... could we even understand a word of it?? I re-read it in, I think, 2000 - and found it to be one of the most extraordinary pieces of literature ever ... and I remember thinking, laughing, "Uhm ... did I actually read this when I was 16? I must have HATED it." Maturity brings its own rewards. His poem to his own blindness is the one that really pierces through me. It scares me. I am scared of going blind. And that last line. Profound. The truth of the human race is in it.
On His Blindness
by John Milton
When I consider how my light is spent,
Ere half my days, in this dark world and wide,
And that one Talent which is death to hide,
Lodg'd with me useless, though my Soul more bent
To serve therewith my Maker, and present
My true account, least he returning chide,
Doth God exact day-labour, light deny'd,
I fondly ask; But patience to prevent
That murmur, soon replies, God doth not need
Either man's work or his own gifts, who best
Bar his milde yoak, they serve him best, his State
Is Kingly. Thousands at his bidding speed
And post o're Land and Ocean without rest:
They also serve who only stand and waite.
"Milton, with the possible exception of Spenser, is the first eccentric English poet, the first to make a myth out of his personal experience, and to invent a language of his own remote from the spoken word." -- W.H. Auden
Milton, even Milton, rankt with living men!
Over the highest Alps of mind he marches,
And far below him spring the baseless arches
Of Iris, colouring dimly lake and fen.
-- Walter Savage Landor
"His harmonicall and ingeniose Soul did lodge in a beautifull and well-proportioned body. He was a spare man ... He had abroun hayre. His complexion exceeding faire - he was so faire they called him the Lady of Christ's College. Ovall face. His eie a darke gray." -- John Aubrey
"Yet for two and a half centuries - even for a 'speaker' like Wordsworth - Milton's virtue was this language, which engaged and developed subjects difficult to combine, moral verities and the created world. The language of speech is not the only, or first, language of poetry. To criticize work in terms strictly irrelevant to it is of little value: a critical act of "brute assertive will", or a prejudice so ingrained as to be indistinguishable, for uncritical readers, from truth itself. With the decline of literacy, Milton, like Spenser, becomes a more difficult mountain to scale, more remote from the 'common reader'. Yet Chaucer and Shakespeare, the only poets in the tradition who are Milton's superiors, both grow and recede in the same way and are not dismissed. They seem more accessible. In the end Leavis's hostility, like Empson's and Richards's in other areas, is to the Christian content of the poems, and in Milton it is obtrusive and central. We read Herbert's and Donne's divine poems even if we are unbelievers: there is their doubt to engage, and the framed drama of specific situations. But Milton will not allow disbelief to go unchallenged: his structures and narratives are not rooted in individual faith but in universal belief. The question of revealed truth raises its head as in no other poet in the language." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
Milton! thou should'st be living at this hour:
England hath need of thee: she is a fen
Of stagnant waters: altar, sword and pen,
Fireside, the heroic wealth of hall and bower,
Have forfeited their ancieng English dower
Of inward happiness. We are selfish men;
Oh! raise us up, return to us again;
And give us manners, virtue, freedom, power.
Thy soul was like a Star and dwelt apart;
Thou hadst a voice whose sound was like the sea;
Pure as the naked heavens, majestic, free,
So didst thou travel on life's common way,
In cheerful godliness; and yet thy heart
The lowliest duties on itself lay.
-- Wordsworth
"In Milton the world of Spenser was reconfigured and almost unrecognisable ... What had been reasonable and courteous, a belief in the fact that men of culture and intellect will be able to engage in rational discussion and agree to disagree, had been displaced by faction and sometimes violent intolerance. The moderate had stood down and the fanatic had taken his place, in the pulpit, in Parliament, and on the very peaks of Parnassus." -- TS Eliot
"I take it to be my portion in this life, joined with a strong propensity of nature, to leave something so written to aftertimes, as they should not willingly let it die." -- John Milton
"I have bought a pocket Milton, which I carry perpetually about with me, in order to study the sentiments - the dauntless magnanimity, the intrepid, unyielding independence, the desperate daring, the noble defiance of hardship, in that great personage, SATAN." -- Robert Burns
"He was much more admired abrode than at home." -- John Aubrey
"My mind is not capable of forming a more august conception than arises from the contemplation of this greatest man in his latter days: poor, sick, old, blind, slandered, persecuted: 'Darkness before and danger's voice behind,' in an age in which he was as little understood by the party for whom, as by that against whom, he had contended, and among men before whom he strode so far as to dwarf himself by the distance; yet still listening to the music of his own thoughts, or, if additionally cheered, yet cheered only by the prophetic faith of two or three solitary individuals, he did nevertheless
... argue not
Against Heaven's hand or will, nor bate a jot
Of heart or hope; but still bore up and steer'd
Right onward."
-- Samuel Taylor Coleridge
"True musical delight consists only in apt numbers, fit quantity of syllables, and the sense variously drawn out from one verse to another." -- John Milton
More on John Milton here.
Shel Silverstein doesn't just remind me of my childhood. It's like he is my childhood. As a kid, I was always a little creeped out by his photos on the back of his books - Giving Tree, Where the Sidewalk Ends, et al - I'm not sure why he freaked me out - maybe his eyes were too intense, the bald head maybe gleamed in a demonic way ... and if you remember what those author photos were like, then you know that they were not your basic glossy smiley head shot. He leaned in towards the camera, he wasn't smiling ... etc. but now I look at those intense hippie-ish photos and see my entire past history. I love him. I guess I decided to post Shel Silverstein today because of my tramp through my old grade school this weekend and seeing Keith and all that stuff ... the past has been on my mind. And it hasn't felt all that far away.
Some families were Dr. Seuss-focused families. And while the O'Malleys adored Horton, it is true - we were all about Shel. My dad read The Giving Tree to us when we were little - it was a routine, man - I kept trying to rationalize away the end of the book ... but couldn't he go to another tree? So he doesn't kill his friend? Why does he need a BOAT? Can't he go another way? Etc. All avoiding that inevitable last moment. Which is a pretty heavy message for kids, if you think about it. A tiny boy is now a toothless old man? What? Will I be a toothless old lady? Heavy stuff - we loved it. I still get this searing pain through my heart when I read that book! But it's quite amazing: I read that book now, and it is in my father's voice.
Here are two of his poems - maybe not the famous nonsensical ones - but ones that clutch at my throat with emotion.
I also found a NY Times article written by David Mamet about Shel Silverstein in 2001 - apparently they were very good friends. It brought tears to my eyes. I've quoted it here in full.
Poems below, and a ton of cool quotes from Shel - what a great interview he was. Blunt, honest, no bullshit ... amazing.
The Little Boy and the Old Man
Said the little boy, "Sometimes I drop my spoon."
Said the old man, "I do that too."
The little boy whispered, "I wet my pants."
"I do that too," laughed the little old man.
Said the little boy, "I often cry."
The old man nodded, "So do I."
"But worst of all," said the boy, "it seems
Grown-ups don't pay attention to me."
And he felt the warmth of a wrinkled old hand.
"I know what you mean," said the little old man.
God's Wheel
God says to me with a kind of smile,
"Hey how would you like to be God awhile
And steer the world?"
"Okay," says I, "I'll give it a try.
Where do I set?
How much do I get?
What time is lunch?
When can I quit?"
"Gimme back that wheel," says God.
"I don't think you're quite ready yet."

"When I was a kid—12, 14, around there—I would much rather have been a good baseball player or a hit with the girls. But I couldn't play ball, I couldn't dance. Luckily, the girls didn't want me; not much I could do about that. So, I started to draw and to write. I was also lucky that I didn't have anybody to copy, be impressed by. I had developed my own style, I was creating before I knew there was a Thurber, a Benchley, a Price and a Steinberg. I never saw their work till I was around 30. By the time I got to where I was attracting girls, I was already into work, and it was more important to me. Not that I wouldn't rather make love, but the work has become a habit.-- Shel Silverstein
Question: "Do you shave your head for effect or to be different, or to strike back at the long-haired styles of today?" Shel Silverstein: "I don't explain my head."
"You should never explain the philosophy behind anything either. The philosophy behind it isn’t important. The question is, if your work is weak and lacking so that it needs explanation, it isn’t enough, it isn’t clear enough. Make it so good and so clear that it doesn’t need any further explanation." -- Shel Silverstein
NY Times, October 14, 2001
Shel Silverstein: A Friend Who Lived Life The Chicago Way
By DAVID MAMET
Shel Silverstein, who died in 1999 at the age of 67, was a man of many talents - cartoonist, singer, songwriter, poet and children's verse writer (``A Light in the Attic'' and ``Where the Sidewalk Ends'' made long appearances on the best-seller lists). He also wrote plays, and on Wednesday,
10 of his one-acts will open the season at the Atlantic Theater Company in Chelsea in the program ``An Adult Evening of Shel Silverstein,'' directed by Karen Kohlhaas. The playwright David Mamet, who helped found the theater, knew Mr. Silverstein, as he describes in this reminiscence.
WHERE I come from, Shel Silverstein was a demigod. I come from Chicago.
We high school kids would see him on State Parkway and say, ``Do you know who that is ...'' And we all knew who it was.
He was Hugh Hefner's sidekick, he was the great cartoonist, he lived with Hef at the Playboy Mansion, in a riot of delight. He wrote songs for Johnny Cash, he wrote the world's most popular children's books, he did the liner notes for ``Gibson and Camp at the Gate of Horn,'' the world's best folk album.
I met him when he took up writing plays.
We were in Chicago, at the Goodman Theater, and Greg Mosher was staging an evening of one-acts: one by me, one by Elaine May and one by Shel - three expat Chicagoans, back in Chicago.
We went out to some fish joint, and closed the joint. In the dawn, Shel and I walked up and down North Michigan, walking, now one, now the other, back to his hotel, and quoting Kipling to each other.
He came on my honeymoon. My wife, Rebecca, and I retired to Martha's Vineyard, late September. Shel had a home there, and he met us one morning for breakfast. Breakfast became lunch, and then dinner, and we saw him most of all day every day.
We went back, summers, to the Vineyard, and spent most of the days with Shel. He had a quarter-sized fantasy house in the Tabernacle, a 19th-century enclave of gingerbread houses around a Methodist prayer pavilion. We would sit out on the porch and pass the guitar back and forth, and he'd get hysterical, relating the amorous intricacies of the natives' lives on the island.
While we sat, every day, fans would find him out. Every day, women would come with their children, and their arms full of books. Not one book, but 10. And they would, sheepishly, ask him to inscribe the books. And Shel would say, of each one, ``Who is this for?'' The woman would tell him a name, and Shel would fashion the name into an animal and inscribe the book to the kid.
I'd sit by, watching him. And I never saw him hesitant, or put-upon, or at all reluctant. I asked him, ``Shel, don't you ever find it an imposition?'' And he smiled and said, ``Are you kidding ... ?''
Rebecca and I would walk our daughter, Clara, aged 2, 3, 4, through the labyrinth of the Tabernacle paths, until we'd find, always by accident, Shel's house. We'd encourage Clara forward, and she'd, tentatively, get up on the porch and go to the door, and she would scratch the screen.
``Who is that?'' would come this voice, impossibly high and gruff at the same time, ``Who is that, out there, scratching at my door ... ?'' And Clara would recoil in delight, as her pet Ogre and Godfather improvised a fairy-tale encounter for her.
He loved good food. We'd go to Jimmy Seas' joint on the Vineyard, and they'd usher us in to his special table, or upstairs, and the waitresses, some, or indeed all, of whom must have known him quite well, would fuss about, and beam at his attention, and duly note his commands: `` ... like Jimmy makes it, but not quite that much oil, and more tuna than pasta ... '' et cetera.
I was at restaurants with him where he sent back everything but the booth, and would have done that, too.
He adored Da Silvano's (who does not?) on Sixth Avenue, and would, at the drop of a hat, take off Silvano, and his recitations of life in the Italian Army's Armored Corps, and he'd giggle that high laugh. There was nothing better.
I'd call him up, just about every day, and we'd trade jokes, or fix jokes - a favored activity. ``I heard a joke today (insert joke).''
`` ... Yeah ...,'' he'd say, thoughtful ... long pause. ``What about if instead of Irishmen, it was dogs, or something, or buffalo ... ?'' ``No,'' he'd say. ``That's not it. Tell me the joke again, no: wait wait wait ... !,'' and he'd come upon the solution.
As he would when I'd call - as I did regularly - with a personal or professional problem. I'd lay the mess before him. ``O.K.,'' he'd say, ``here's what you got to do ...,'' and, inevitably, it was.
Or, to sum up, I loved him. My family loved him. We all felt that being with him was an unexampled privilege. And when he died, we, and his other friends, said to each other, ``Well, at least we can't say we didn't appreciate him when he was here.''
He had no tolerance for society. He wouldn't go to a party, didn't want to meet new people. He came to my wedding in the same oufit he wore everywhere: impossibly baggy, vaguely military trousers, a sort of Indian shirt, unbuttoned to the navel, a 1970's down-market leather jacket.
He once told me he'd been invited to receive some rather impressive honor. I thought he would relent and accept, but he said no.
``How can you refuse?'' I said.
``If they want me to show up and do my Shel act, let them pay me,'' he said.
And I was chastened. He was right. He had elected that the writer must live in retirement; that we are weak, and susceptible to blandishment, flattery, and the way to resist temptation was to avoid it.
He was scrupulous. There were those things he would always do, and those things he would never do.
He would always help. I would call in a tight spot: I needed a joke, a plot, a song, a favor, and he always said, ``Sure.''
Rik Elswit, a member of Shel's band, Dr. Hook, relates a dispute about a song. The group had a big hit, Shel was the writer. One of the band members said, ``You know, Shel, I hate to say it, but I contributed (whatever it may have been) to the song, too.'' Shel, Mr. Elswit relates, took out a piece of paper and assigned his bandmate half of the royalties, with which, we are told, the band member bought a lot of real estate in California.
In short, I suppose he was my hero.
I remember, just before he died, he came to Boston, and we were going to go book shopping along Newbury Street. I got out of the car, at the Ritz-Carlton, and palmed a $20 bill with which to bribe the doorman.
Here came the doorman, and I walked toward him, ``Hey, can I talk to you a minute?,'' I said, and looked over at the sidewalk to see Shel doubled over and howling.
When I got to him, he was literally wiping the tears from his eyes.
``Oh, Dave,'' he said. ``That was the Old Style. That was beautiful, that was the Old Chicago Way.'' What a compliment.
Excerpt from 1963 interview with Shel Silverstein - Aardvark Magazine:
AARDVARK: Have you read the Realist’s article on the arrest of Lenny Bruce?
SILVERSTEIN: No. I was there.
AARDVARK: Krassner came to the conclusion that Bruce was not arrested for obscenity, but for blasphemy.
SILVERSTEIN: I don’t think that much about what Paul Krassner has to say about it. He spends his whole life looking up Lenny’s asshole, anyway. I can’t really be as concerned with the whole thing as he is. If you want to know the whole story, you should really talk to Lenny.
AARDVARK: He won’t talk to us. We’ve tried. He only talks to God.
SILVERSTEIN: He talks to me. He’s as direct and honest about the whole situation as a man could possibly be. It’s his followers that get a little fanatical and start jumping all around, but Lenny’s very straight about the whole thing. The day after he was arrested, he said, “They had a right to bust me. They had a warrant.” So the guy comes onstage with a warrant for Lenny and Lenny realizes the man has a warrant and he’s legally arrested, so he said, “Fine,” and everybody else starts jumping up and down and protesting.
AARDVARK: Did he think he was guilty of obscenity?
SILVERSTEIN: I think he thinks he is guilty of obscenity as far as our laws go, but he does it anyway because he believes he’s doing right. I don’t think he’s against any law; he’s just for what he’s doing. I think about what he does onstage rather than the overall thing. I don’t find much of it objectionable.
"[Silverstein] resists reading a moral into The Missing Piece, in which a sort of wheel with a slice taken out of it rolls along, singing a song, looking for the missing piece. After rejecting several bad fits, it finds a compatible wedge, only to realize it can no longer sing its happy-go-lucky song. 'I could have ended the book there,' he says, meaning where the piece seems to have found its mate. 'But instead it goes off singing: it's still looking for the missing pice. That's the madness of the book, the disturbing part of it.' " -- New York Times Book Review, April 30, 1978
"In all the art forms, I've had trouble finding acceptance in new areas. I've done a lot for Playboy magazine, so people say, 'Oh, you're the Playboy cartoonist.' But I write music, too, and children's books. . . I had a place in cartooning for a while, I guess. I created a certain style and it was well received. Now I'm interested in finding out about the music industry. I used to think I was above it all, that I'd just write the songs and that was it. Now I want to find out more about the business. . .I don't think I have a real "place" in it. For that, you have to have a great acceptance for what you do. As long as you're underground, you don't really fit into any slot." -- Shel Silverstein, 1973
"It's just a relationship between two people; one gives and the other takes." -- Shel Silverstein on "The Giving Tree", 1978
"I'm sure Hefner gets more tail per square inch than other guys do." -- Shel Silverstein
More on Shel Silverstein here.
I suggest reading this poem out loud (that exquisite "ah" at the end ... it just makes a difference if it is spoken, rather than read silently). It feels good to say. The language itself. I have the doppelganger to thank for introducing me to it. The night I met him, that endless night, he recited it for me in a booming drunken voice as we stagger-walked down the Soho sidewalks in search of more beer. I remember, too, that I started across the street without looking both ways - and nearly got wiped out by an oncoming cab. Doppelganger was in the middle of his recitation - but he leapt forward, held out an imperious hand at the cab - which begrudgingly slowed down so that we could pass. Once we were safely up on the sidewalk again, he continued his oratory. As though nothing had interrupted it. Brilliant. Mind like a steel trap, that one. We had been talking about religion, and his Anglican upbringing - his father being the choirmaster in his church, and how he would huddle in the back of the church, listening to the music of the choir rehearsal. Hopkins came up in our conversation - his religious poems, the sensuous ecstasy of them - and so doppelganger obliged me by reciting me the entire thing. One of the most beautiful memorable moments of my life. 3 a.m. Empty New York streets. And - in a stentorian voice, with a cigarette dangling from his mouth, this:
God's Grandeur
The world is charged with the grandeur of God.
It will flame out, like shining from shook foil;
It gathers to a greatness, like the ooze of oil
Crushed. Why do men then now not reck his rod?
Generations have trod, have trod, have trod;
And all is seared with trade; bleared, smeared with toil;
And wears man’s smudge and shares man’s smell: the soil
Is bare now, nor can foot feel, being shod.
And for all this, nature is never spent;
There lives the dearest freshness deep down things;
And though the last lights off the black West went
Oh, morning, at the brown brink eastward, springs—
Because the Holy Ghost over the bent
World broods with warm breast and with ah! bright wings.

"He belonged to that culture of sentimental and erotic male friendships shaped by both Greece and (Catholic) Rome to which Newman and Faber belonged before him." -- Gregory Woods
"At university Hopkins's discipline began: self-denial in the interest of the self. He evokes the effect of religious faith on the imagination. Imagine, he says, the world reflected in a water drop: a small, precise reflection. Then imagine the world reflected in a drop of Christ's blood: the same reflection, but suffused with the hue of love, sacrifice, God made man, and redemption. Religious faith discovers for a troubled imagination an underlying coherence which knows that it cannot be fully or adequately explained. In its liberating, suffusing light, Hopkins could relish out loud the uniqueness of things, which made them "individually distinctive." This he called "inscape" - an artist's term. "Instress", another bit of individual jargon, refers to the force maintaining inscape. Inscape is manifest, instress divine, the immanent presence of the divine in the object." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"I might as well say what I should not otherwise have said, that I always knew in my heart Walt Whitman's mind to be more like my own than any other man's living. As he is a very great scoundrel this is not a pleasant confession. And this also makes me the more desirous to read him and the more determined that I will not." -- Gerard Manley Hopkins, in 1882
"The onomatopoeic theory has not had a fair chance. Cf. Crack, creak, croak, crake, graculus, crackle." -- Gerard Manley Hopkins
"It seems to me that the poetical language of an age shd. be the current language heightened, to any degree heightened and unlike itself, but not (I mean normally; freaks and graces are another thing) an obsolete one. This is Shakespeare's and Milton's practice and the want of it will be fatal to Tennyson's Idylls and plays, to Swinburne, and perhaps to Morris." -- Gerard Manley Hopkins, in letter to his friend and encourager Robert Bridges, poet laureate
"The dark sonnets are his most astonishing work, for here ruptured syntax, inversions, and sound patterning answer a violence of negative spiritual experience. In the work of George Herbert, which Hopkins loved, Christ is the wooer, the soul that wooed. In Hopkins, the soul, painfully aware of its own fallen nature, deliberately woos Christ. There is almost despair, for a beautiful and vigorous Christ has withdrawn, grace is withheld. The earlier ease of loving faith -- "I say that we are wound / With mercy round and round / As if with air" -- is gone. After the dark sonnets there is silence." -- Michael Schmidt
"No doubt my poetry errs on the side of oddness ... I hope in time to have a more balanced and Miltonic style." -- Gerard Manley Hopkins
"I am so happy, I am so happy." -- Gerard Manley Hopkins's last words
More on this fascinating poet here.
I love this poem. Follow the light. I'm a wreck (in a good way) and have been all day. This poem is perfect for Good Friday. Waterworks.
Light, at Thirty-Two
It is the first thing God speaks of
when we meet Him, in the good book
of Genesis. And now, I think
I see it all in terms of light:
How, the other day at dusk
on Ossabaw Island, the marsh grass
was the color of the most beautiful hair
I had ever seen, or how?years ago
in the early-dawn light of Montrose Park?
I saw the most ravishing woman
in the world, only to find, hours later
over drinks in a dark bar, that it
wasn't she who was ravishing,
but the light: how it filtered
through the leaves of the magnolia
onto her cheeks, how it turned
her cotton dress to silk, her walk
to a tour-jete
And I understood, finally,
what my friend John meant,
twenty years ago, when he said: Love
is keeping the lights on. And I understood
why Matisse and Bonnard and Gauguin
and C麡nne all followed the light:
Because they knew all lovers are equal
in the dark, that light defines beauty
the way longing defines desire, that
everything depends on how light falls
on a seashell, a mouth ... a broken bottle.
And now, I'd like to learn
to follow light wherever it leads me,
never again to say to a woman, YOU
are beautiful, but rather to whisper:
Darling, the way light fell on your hair
This morning when we woke?God,
It was beautiful. Because, if the light is right,
Then the day and the body and the faint pleasures
Waiting at the window ... they too are right.
All things lovely there. As the first poet wrote,
in his first book of poems: Let there be light.
And there is.

That poem just gives me such a pang in my heart. Of course I'm all wacked out today so a teeny drifting snowflake makes me want to weep with the beauty of it all ... but still. I remember reading that poem on a more normal day (emotionally, I mean) and being very moved by it.
A bit more on Michael Blumenthal here.
Michael Blumenthal: A Letter to my Students
He's a poet, but also an essayist. This book sounds right up my alley.
Other National Poetry Month posts:
I loves me some Christopher Marlowe. This is from Doctor Faustus.
The Face that Launched a Thousand Ships
Was this the face that launched a thousand ships?
And burnt the topless towers of Ilium?
Sweet Helen, make me immortal with a kiss:
Her lips suck forth my soul, see where it flies:
And all is dross that is not Helena:
I will be Paris, and for love of thee,
Instead of Troy shall Wertenberg be sack'd,
And I will combat with weak Menelaus,
And wear thy colours on my plumed crest:
Yea I will wound Achillis in the heel,
And then return to Helen for a kiss.
O thou art fairer than the evening air,
Clad in the beauty of a thousand stars,
Brighter art thou than flaming Jupiter,
When he appear'd to hapless Semele,
More lovely than the monarch of the sky
In wanton Arethusa's azur'd arms,
And none but thou shalt be my paramour.

(this 1585 portrait is widely thought to be of Marlowe)
"No leaf he wrote on but was like a burning glass to set on fire all his readers." -- Thomas Nashe, a friend of Marlowe's
"The place and the value of Christopher Marlowe as a leader among English poets it would be almost impossible for historical criticism to over-estimate. To none of them all, perhaps, have so many of the greatest among them been so deeply and so directly indebted. Nor was ever any great writer's influence upon his fellows more utterly and unmixedly an influence for good. He first, and he alone, guided Shakespeare into the right way of work; his music, in which there is no echo of any man's before him, found its own echo in the more prolonged but hardly more exalted harmony of Milton's. He is the greatest discoverer, the most daring and inspired pioneer, in all our poetic literature. Before him there was neither genuine blank verse nor a genuine tragedy in our language. After his arrival the way was prepared, the paths were made straight, for Shakespeare. " -- Algernon Charles Swinburne
"Everyone imitated Marlowe. His first play, Tamburlaine, was staged when he was 23, and its success can most readily be gauged by its imitators. As David Riggs notes in his new biography, The World of Christopher Marlowe, within the next couple of years three new plays were staged that were more or less direct copies of Marlowe's original, while Shakespeare wrote his early Henry VI plays under the influence of Marlowe's style. A decade later, as the church authorities burned copies of Marlowe's semipornographic love poems in the streets, Shakespeare again returned to imitating his predecessor in As You Like It. Marlowe's contemporaries regarded him with a mixture of awe and fear." -- David Riggs
"In common with the greatest - Marlowe, Webster, Tourner, and Shakespeare - they had a quality of sensuous thought, or of thinking through the senses, or of the senses thinking, of which the exact formular remains to be defined." -- T.S. Eliot on the Elizabethan-Jacobean poets
"What an example for our distracted poetry, which so often now strikes at the absolute and achieves the commonplace! These poets [George Chapman and Christopher Marlowe] lived life from the ground upwards." -- Edgell Rickword, 1924
"The unity of tone and purpose in Doctor Faustus is not unrelieved by change of manner and variety of incident. The comic scenes, written evidently with as little of labour as of relish, are for the most part scarcely more than transcripts, thrown into the form of dialogue, from a popular prose History of Dr Faustus, and therefore should be set down as little to the discredit as to the credit of the poet. Few masterpieces of any age in any language can stand beside this tragic poem — it has hardly the structure of a play — for the qualities of terror and splendour, for intensity of purpose and sublimity of note. In the vision of Helen, for example, the intense perception of loveliness gives actual sublimity to the sweetness and radiance of mere beauty in the passionate and spontaneous selection of words the most choice and perfect; and in like manner the sublimity of simplicity in Marlowe's conception and expression of the agonies endured by Faustus under the immediate imminence of his doom gives the highest note of beauty, the quality of absolute fitness and propriety, to the sheer straightforwardness of speech in which his agonizing horror finds vent ever more and more terrible from the first to the last equally beautiful and fearful verse of that tremendous monologue which has no parallel in all the range of tragedy." -- Algernon Charles Swinburne
"He took his BA in 1584, his MA three years later, by which time he had probably completed Tamburlaine. He was the first of the university wits to employ blank verse. It's generally thought that most if not all of his small surviving body of nondramatic verse - Hero and Leander, "The Passionate Shepherd:, and the Ovid and Lucan translations - were written in his university years, the fruit of youth and relative leisure. The six years that elapsed between his taking his MA and his shadowy death - possibly as a result of drink, or low political intrigue, or a romantic entanglement with a rough character "fitter to be a pimp, than an ingenious amoretto", or perhaps a tussle over the bill ("le recknynge") - at the hand of Ingram Frisar in a Deptford tavern on 30 May 1593 were busy ones. He wrote plays, was attacked for atheism, was associated (if it existed) with Ralegh's "School of Night," and lodged with Thomas Kyd (author of The Spanish Tragedy), who later brought charges of blasphemy against him. These he had to answer before the Privy Council in 1593, the very council that secretly employed him to spy on English Catholics on the Continent. He achieved much in a short life." -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
I'm armed with more than complete steel,—
The justice of my quarrel.
Christopher Marlowe, Lust’s Dominion. Act iii. Sc. 4.
"If one takes The Jew of Malta not as a tragedy, or as a "tragedy of blood," but as a farce, the concluding act becomes intelligible; and if we attend with a careful ear to the versification, we find that Marlowe develops a tone to suit this farce, and even perhaps that this tone is his most powerful and mature tone." -- T.S. Eliot
"Marlowe's Doctor Faustus, like Goethe's Faust, finds himself before the specter of Helen (the idea that Helen of Troy was a ghost or apparition is already present in the ancients) and says to her, "Sweet Helen, make me immortal with a kiss." And then, "O thou art fairer than the evening air clad in the beauty of a thousand stars." He does not say "evening sky," but "evening air." All of Copernican space is present in that word air, the infinite space that was one of the revelations of the Renaissance, the space in which we still believe, despite Einstein, that space that came to supplant the Ptolomaic system which presides over Dante's triple comedy." -- Jorge Luis Borges
"And so it befell, in that affray, that the said Ingram, in the defence of his life, with the dagger aforesaid of the value of twelve pence, gave the said Christopher a mortal wound above his right eye." -- Coroner's inquest, 1593
"In Marlowe's superb verse there is very little to indicate that the writer had ever encountered any human beings." -- James Branch Cabell
"Marlowe painted gigantic ambitions, desires for impossible things, longings for a beauty beyond earthly conception, and sovereigns destroyed by the very powers which had raised them to their thrones. Tamburlaine, Faust, Barabbas are the personifications of arrogance, ambition and greed. There is sometimes a touch of the extravagant or bombastic, or even of the puerile in his plays, for he had no sense of humor; nor had he the ability to portray a woman. He wrote no drama on the subject of love. Furthermore, his world is not altogether our world, but a remote field of the imagination." -- Martha Fletcher Bellinger, 1927
"He came to London to seek his fortune . . . a boy in years, a man in genius, a god in ambition. Who knows to what heights he might have risen but for his untimely end?" -- Swinburne
More on Christopher Marlowe here.
CW has a cool post about Marlowe.
Excerpt from Tamburlaine here.
This is one of my favorite poems. I guess I take it personally. Almost like an anthem, or ... as a reminder, when I need it, of how I want to live my life, of who I really am.
Often Rebuked
Often rebuked, yet always back returning
To those first feelings that were born with me,
And leaving busy chase of wealth and learning
For idle dreams of things which cannot be:
Today, I will not seek the shadowy region:
Its unsustaining vastness waxes drear;
And visions rising, legion after legion,
Bring the unreal world too strangely near.
I'll walk, but not in old heroic traces,
And not in paths of high morality,
And not among the half-distinguished faces,
The clouded forms of long-past history.
I'll walk where my own nature would be leading:
It vexes me to choose another guide;
Where the gray flocks in ferny glens are feeding;
Where the wild wind blows on the mountain-side.
What have those lonely mountains worth revealing?
More glory and more grief than I can tell:
The earth that wakes one human heart to feeling
Can centre both the worlds of Heaven and Hell.

"My sister Emily loved the moors. Flowers brighter than the rose bloomed in the blackest of the heath for her; -- out of a sullen hollow in a livid hill-side, her mind could make an Eden. She found in the bleak solitude many and dear delights; and not the least and best-loved was - liberty. Liberty was the breath of Emily's nostrils; without it she perished. The change from her own home to a school, and from her own very noiseless, very secluded, but unrestricted and unartificial mode of life, to one of disciplined routine (though under the kindest auspices), was what she failed in enduring. Her nature proved here too strong for her fortitude. Every morning, when she woke, the vision of home and the moors rushed on her, and darkened and saddened the day that lay before her. Nobody knew what ailed her but me. I knew only too well. In this struggle her health was quickly broken: her white face, attenuated form,a nd failing strength, threatened rapid decline. I felt in my heart she would die, if she did not go home, and with this conviction obtained her recall. --Charlotte Bronte, on Emily's stint away from home as a teacher in 1835
"Emily, like her characters, loved liberty and the open spaces of the moors. She insisted on her own patterns of life. Having nursed Branwell through his last illness, she caught cold at the funeral service and began her own two-month decline to death. Yet even on the day she died she insisted on rising in the morning, getting dressed and beginning her daily duties, as if the will could force its dying vehicle to live on. The will is the force her poems celebrate." -- Michael Schmidt
"The girls' real education, however, was at the Haworth parsonage, where they had the run of their father's books, and were thus nurtured on the Bible, Homer, Virgil, Shakespeare, Milton, Byron, Sir Walter Scott and many others. They enthusiastically read articles on current affairs, lengthy reviews and intellectual disputes in Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine and The Edinburgh Review. They also ranged freely in Aesop and in the colourfully bizarre world of The Arabian Nights' Entertainments." -- Ian Ousby, The Cambridge Guide to Literature in English
"stronger than a man, simpler than a child" -- Charlotte Bronte on her sister Emily
"She never showed regard to any human creature; all her love was reserved for animals." -- Bronte family friend on Emily, reporting to Mrs. Gaskell
"Another poet could learn only one valuable lesson from what she does, and that is the ways in which form lives when it is driven urgently by powerful impulses, and how when that urgency ends a poem should stop." -- Michael Schmidt
"Nov. 23rd, 1848
I told you Emily was ill in my last letter. She has not rallied yet. She is very ill. I believe, if you were to see her, your impression would be that there is no hope. A more hollow, wasted, pallid aspect I have not beheld. The deep tight cough continues; the breathing after the least exertion is a rapid pant; nd these symptoms are accompanied by pains in the chest and side. Her pulse, the only time she allowed it to be felt, was found to beat 115 per minute. In this state she resolutely refuses to see a doctor; she will give no explanation of her feelings, she will scarcely allow her feelings to be alluded to. Our position is, and has been for some weeks, exquisitely painful. God only know how all this is to terminate. More than once, I have been forced boldly to regard the terrible event of her loss as possible, and even probable. But nature shrinks from such thoughts. I think Emily seems the nearest thing to my heart in this world." -- Charlotte Bronte
"How much better they would have made Wuthering Heights in France. They know there how to shoot sexual passion, but in this Californian-constructed Yorkshire, among the sensitive neurotic English voices, sex is cellophaned; there is no egotism, no obsession.... So a lot of reverence has gone into a picture which should have been as coarse as a sewer." -- Graham Greene, Spectator, May 5, 1939 - review of the Olivier/Oberon "Wuthering Heights"
"My sister Emily was not a person of demonstrative character, nor one, on the recesses of whose mind and feelings, even those nearest and dearest to her could, with impunity, intrude unlicensed: it took hours to reconcile her to the discovery I had made, and days to persuade her that such poems merited publication." -- Charlotte Bronte, on finding Emily's poems
"Sealed in her art-world, the moor strategically placed for escape above the house, no domesticating and limiting mother to weaken her capacity for identification with whatever sex she chose to impersonate at a particular moment, polite society at a safe distance, and a father who seems to have selected her as an honorary boy to be trusted with fire-arms in defence of the weak, Emily Brontë's life exemplifies a rough joy in itself, its war-games, its word games and its power to extend its own structuring vision out upon the given world." -- Stevie Davies
"In her poetry, Emily Brontë achieves a remarkable effect by the energy and sincerity, and often by the music, with which she portrays her stoicism, independence, and compassion in stanzas which in many instances are the commonplace vehicles used by mere rimers. It is as though she were brought up to feel that certain forms of verse were the patterns, and had, with dogged acceptance, poured into them her emotions with an honesty that made the outward form seem negligible." -- Paul Lieder
"They were grave and silent beyond their years; subdued, probably, by the presence of serious illness in the house; for, at the time which my informant speaks of, Mrs. Bronte was confined to the bedroom from which she never came forth alive. 'You would not have known there was a child in the house, they were such still, noiseless, good little creatures. Maria would shut herself up' (Maria, but seven!) 'in the children's study with a newspaper, and be able to tell one everything when she came out; debates in parliament, and I don't know what all. She was as good as a mother to her sisters and brother. But there never were such good children. I used to think sem spiritless, they were so different to any children I had ever seen. In part, I set it down to a fancy Mr. Bronte had of not letting them have flesh-meat to eat. It was from no wish for saving, for there was plenty and even waste in the house, with young servants and no mistress to see after them; but he thought that children should be brought up simply and hardily: so they had nothing but potatoes for their dinner; but they never seemed to wish for anything else; they were good little creatures. Emily was the prettiest.' " -- Elizabeth Gaskell, "The Life of Charlotte Bronte"
Excerpt from 'Little Magazine' - a magazine created by the Bronte children, to describe their doings, and plays, and poems. This one was written by Charlotte.
June the 31st, 1829
The play of 'The Islanders' was formed in December, 1827, in the following manner. One night, about the time when the cold sleet and stormy fogs of November are succeeded by the snow-storms, and high piercing night-winds of confirmed winter, we were all sitting round the warm blazing kitchen fire, having just concluded a quarrel with Tabby concerning the propriety of lighting a candle, from which she came off victorious, no candle having been produced. A long pause succeeded, which was at last broken by Branwell saying in a lazy manner, "I don't know what to do." This was echoed by Emily and Anne.
Tabby. "Wha ya may go t'bed."
Branwell. "I'd rather do anything than that."
Charlotte. "Why are you so glum to-night, Tabby? Oh! suppose we had each an island of our own."
Branwell. "If we had I would choose the Island of Man."
Charlotte. "And I would choose the Isle of Wight."
Emily. "The Isle of Arran for me."
Anne. "And mine should be Guernsey."
We then chose who should be chief men in our islands. Branwell chose John Bull, Ashley Cooper, and Leigh Hunt; Emily, Walter Scott, Mr. Lockhart, Johnny Lockhart; Anne, Michael Sadler, Lord Bentinck, Sir Henry Halford; I chose the Duke of Wellington and two sons, Christopher North and Co., and Mr. Abernethy. Here our conversation was interrupted by the, to us, dismal sound of the clock striking seven, and we were summoned off to bed. The next day we added many others to our list of men, till we got almost all the chief men of the kingdom. After this, for a long time, nothing worth noticing occurred. In June, 1828, we erected a school on a fictitious island, which was to contain 1,000 children. The manner of the building was as follows. The Island was fifty miles in circumference, and certainly appeared more like the work of enchantment than anything real.
"When at home, she took the principal part of the cooking upon herself, and did all the household ironing; and after Tabby grew old and infirm, it was Emily who made all the bread for the family; and any one passing by the kitchen-door, might have seen her studying German out of an open book, propped up before her, as she kneaded the dough; but no study, however interesting, interfered with the goodness of the bread, which was always light and excellent. Books were, indeed, a very common sight in that kitchen; the girls were taught by their father theoretically, and by their aunt practically, that to take an acctive part in all household work was, in their position, woman's simple duty; but, in their careful employment of time, they found many an odd five minutes for reading while watching the cakes, and managed the union of two kinds of employment better than King Alfred. -- Elizabeth Gaskell
"After the age of twenty, having meantime studied alone with diligence and perseverance, she went with me to an establishment on the continent. The same suffering and conflict ensued, heightened by the strong recoil of her upright heretic and English spirit from the gentle Jesuitry of the foreign and Romish system. Once mopre she seemed sinking, but this time she rallied through the mere force of resoluttion: with inward remorse and shame she looked back on her former failure, and resolved to conquer, but the victory cost her dear. She was never happy till she carried her hard-won knowledge back to the remote English village, the old parsonage-house, and desolate Yorkshire hills." -- Charlotte Bronte
"Her imagination, which was a spirit more sombre than sunny - more powerful than sportive - found in such traits material whence it wrought creations like Heathcliff, like Earnshaw, like Catharine. Having formed these beings, she did not know what she had done. If the auditor of her work, when read in manuscript, shuddered under the grinding influence of natures so relentless and implacable - of spirits so lost and fallen; if it was complained that the mere hearing of certain vivid and fearful scenes banished sleep by night, and disturbed mental peace by day, Ellis Bell [Emily's pseudonym] would wonder what was meant, and suspect the complainant of affectation. Had she but lived, her mind would of itself have grown like a strong tree - loftier, straighter, wider-spreading - and its matured fruits would have attained a mellower ripeness and sunnier bloom; but on that mind time and experience alone could work; to the influence of other intellects she was not amenable." -- Charlotte Bronte
"Of course, I was not surprised, knowing that she could and did write verse: I looked it over, and something more than surprise seized me, -- a deep conviction that these were not common effusions, not at all like the poetry women generally write. I thought them condensed and terse, vigorous and genuine. To my ear, they had also a peculiar music -- wild, melancholy, and elevating. " -- Charlotte Bronte, describing the moment in 1845 when she first read all of Emily's poems
More on Emily Bronte here.
Selected Emily Bronte poems here.
More National Poetry Month posts:
I know I have posted this poem before, but here it is again. I love it. It scares me. It's so omniscent. Thomas Hardy's scary poem about the Titanic.
The Convergence of the Twain
I
In a solitude of the sea
Deep from human vanity,
And the Pride of Life that planned her, stilly couches she.
II
Steel chambers, late the pyres
Of her salamandrine fires,
Cold currents thrid, and turn to rhythmic tidal lyres.
III
Over the mirrors meant
To glass the opulent
The sea-worm crawls -- grotesque, slimed, dumb, indifferent.
IV
Jewels in joy designed
To ravish the sensuous mind
Lie lightless, all their sparkles bleared and black and blind.
V
Dim moon-eyed fishes near
Gaze at the gilded gear
And query: "What does this vaingloriousness down here?". . .
VI
Well: while was fashioning
This creature of cleaving wing,
The Immanent Will that stirs and urges everything
VII
Prepared a sinister mate
For her -- so gaily great --
A Shape of Ice, for the time fat and dissociate.
VIII
And as the smart ship grew
In stature, grace, and hue
In shadowy silent distance grew the Iceberg too.
IX
Alien they seemed to be:
No mortal eye could see
The intimate welding of their later history.
X
Or sign that they were bent
By paths coincident
On being anon twin halves of one August event,
XI
Till the Spinner of the Years
Said "Now!" And each one hears,
And consummation comes, and jars two hemispheres.

"For more than a year I read no one else." -- WH Auden - on Thomas Hardy
"[He was] a pale, gentle, frightened little man, that one felt an instinctive tenderness for, with a wife - ugly is no word for it! - who said 'Whatever shall we do?' I had never heard a human being say it before." -- Robert Louis Stevenson, after visiting Hardy in 1885
No matter what the subject, Hardy devoted his poetry to laying out his magnificently sombre, completely disillusioned view of the world. The central fact of that world was the disappearance of God, and with it any reason for believing in providence or justice. -- Adam Hirsch
He was always musing about poetry, defining and redefining, thinking in terms of poems, developing his craft in the spirit of a joiner or stonemason perfecting skills in preparation for the big work - a rood screen, a spire, The Dynasts. Some of the early poems Hardy turned into prose and used in descriptive passages in his fiction. Later he translated them back into verse. It is possible to see the impact of his poetic concerns throughout the fiction, in the shaping of scenes, the obliquity and economy of satirical and tragic payoffs, and most of all in the highly organized rhythms of the prose at points of lyrical or dramatic heightening. The imact of the fiction on the verse is also clear: he is a storyteller. -- Michael Schmidt, "Lives of the Poets"
"A certain provincialism of feeling is invaluable. It is the essence of individuality, and is largely made up of that crude enthusiasm without which no great thoughts are thought, no great deeds done." -- Thomas Hardy
For the rest of his life, then, Hardy set to writing poetry with the grateful fervor of an escaped prisoner; his “Collected Poems” fill more than eight hundred pages. -- Adam Kirsch
The poems were written by a novelist, but they are different in kind from fiction, whatever they learn from its forms; the impulse, structure and effect are insistently lyric, the style original without being particularly idiosyncratic. He uses (and discovers) a wider range of rhymed and metrical forms than any other modern English poet, including Auden. His oeuvre amounts to almost a thousand poems. Whereas the novels bring background into focus - landscape, community, the intrusions of history - the poems generally take setting for granted. Unlike Kipling, who has to establish a setting before the poem can get going, Hardy takes location as implicit and plunges in medias res, thriftily giving only necessary information in a phrase, a tone of voice suggested by metrical pause or variation. We're seldom engaged by the character of the speaker; it's a situation that arrests us, its moral or psychological typicality. His "voice", unlike the individuating and unique "voice" of the modern poet, is Wordsworth's common voice, "a man speaking to men" in a common language of experience. -- Michael Schmidt
"Write a history of human automatism, or impulsion - viz., an account of human action in spite of human knowledge, showing how very far conduct lags behind the knowledge that should really guide it." -- Thomas Hardy jotting down notes for "The Dynasts"
"Hardy has the effect of locking any poet whom he influences into a world of historical contingency, a world of specific places at specific times." -- Donald Davie
"Now there is clarity. There is the harvest of having written twenty novels first." -- Ezra Pound, on reading Hardy's poetry
"[I admire his] hawk's vision. his way of looking at life from a very great height ... To see the individual life related not only to the local social life of its time, but to the whole of human history ... gives one both humility and self-confidence." -- W.H. Auden
"All we can do is write on the old themes in the old styles, but try to do it a little better than those who came before us." -- Thomas Hardy to Robert Graves
More information on Thomas Hardy here.
In honor of National Poetry Month, there's gonna be a lot of poetry around here for April. Yesterday was Auden. Today I picked a childhood favorite - one I could recite from memory when I was pretty close to this age here. haha It was part of the Golden Book of Poetry - which was so read in our family that the cover faded to almost nothing, the binding fell apart ... and I can still, in my mind's eye, see all of the illustrations - and where they were placed on the page. (The photo over there to the right is of me, "candidly" posing with the Golden Book of Poetry.) "The Owl and the Pussy-cat" is still a favorite. Look how the verse just rocks and sings. It's perfect.
The Owl and the Pussy-cat - by Edward Lear
I
The Owl and the Pussy-cat went to sea
In a beautiful pea green boat,
They took some honey, and plenty of money,
Wrapped up in a five pound note.
The Owl looked up to the stars above,
And sang to a small guitar,
'O lovely Pussy! O Pussy my love,
What a beautiful Pussy you are,
You are,
You are!
What a beautiful Pussy you are!'
II
Pussy said to the Owl, 'You elegant fowl!
How charmingly sweet you sing!
O let us be married! too long we have tarried:
But what shall we do for a ring?'
They sailed away, for a year and a day,
To the land where the Bong-tree grows
And there in a wood a Piggy-wig stood
With a ring at the end of his nose,
His nose,
His nose,
With a ring at the end of his nose.
III
'Dear pig, are you willing to sell for one shilling
Your ring?' Said the Piggy, 'I will.'
So they took it away, and were married next day
By the Turkey who lives on the hill.
They dined on mince, and slices of quince,
Which they ate with a runcible spoon;
And hand in hand, on the edge of the sand,
They danced by the light of the moon,
The moon,
The moon,
They danced by the light of the moon.

Michael Schmidt, in his book "Lives of the Poets" writes that Lear, and Lewis Carroll (Lear's younger peer) wrote "nonsense verse" which "strays into the musical zones that Longfellow mapped with his self-propelling meters."

-- the inventor of the term "snail mail" in this whimsical letter to Evelyn Baring? The letter itself reads, along the twists of the snail shell:
Feb. 19. 1864 Dear Baring Please give the enclosed noat to Sir Henry - (which I had just written:-& say that I shall have great pleasure in coming on Sunday. I have sent your 2 vols of Hood to Wade Brown. Many thanks for lending them to me - which they have delighted me eggstreamly Yours sincerely
"Don't tell me of a man's being able to talk sense; every one can talk sense. Can he talk nonsense?" -- William Pitt
In regard to his verses, Lear asserted that "nonsense, pure and absolute," was his aim throughout; and remarked, further, that to have been the means of administering innocent mirth to thousands was surely a just excuse for satisfaction. He pursued his aim with scrupulous consistency, and his absurd conceits are fantastic and ridiculous, but never cheaply or vulgarly funny. -- Carolyn Wells
However, there are subtler methods of debunking than throwing custard pies. There is also the humour of pure fantasy, which assaults man's notion of himself as not only a dignified but a rational being. Lewis Carroll's humour consists essentially in making fun of logic, and Edward Lear's in a sort of poltergeist interference with common sense. When the Red Queen remarks, "I've seen hills compared with which you'd call that one a valley", she is in her way attacking the bases of society as violently as Swift or Voltaire. Comic verse, as in Lear's poem "The Courtship of the Yonghy-Bonghy-Bò", often depends on building up a fantastic universe which is just similar enough to the real universe to rob it of its dignity. But more often it depends on anticlimax -- that is, on starting out with a high-flown language and then suddenly coming down with a bump. -- George Orwell, "Funny But Not Vulgar"
From Michael Sala, "Lear's Nonsense":
Edward Lear, a skillful illustrator of science books (botany, zoology), started his literary career by chance. As a matter of fact, "most of Lear's limericks were not written with publication in mind, but rather as gifts for specific children" (Rieder 1998: 50). He was persuaded toward their publication by the enthusiastic reaction of his young audience.
There was an old person of Rimini
Who said, "Gracious! Goodness! O Gimini!
When they said, "Please be still!" she ran down a hill
And was never once heard of at Rimini.
There was an old person of Sestri
Who sat himself down in the vestry,
When they said "You are wrong!" - he merely said "Bong!"
That repulsive old person of Sestri.
This is a typical example of Lear's limericks, and a perfect example of what is intended by nonsense, that is to say, "language lifted out of context, language turning on itself […] language made hermetic, opaque" (Stewars 1979: 3), language that "resists contextualization, so that it refers to 'nothing' instead of to the word's commonsense designation […] refusing to work as conventional communication " (Rieder 1998: 49). In other words, what happened to the old person of Rimini? What is wrong with the person of Sestri? It is impossible to answer, because, despite the perfectly grammatical use of the words, they don't tell much. They are just bizarrely arranged so as to sound appealing. If there is a shadow of a story, usually it is nothing more than that: only a shadow of a story (without causes or consequences). In Lear's limericks, words introduce "a number of possibilities, including dangerous and violent ones, and at the same time disconnect those possibilities from the real world, that is, from what goes on after the game is over" (Rieder 1996: 49).
'My dear child, I'm sure we shall be allowed to laugh in Heaven!'" --from a letter to a little girl he knew
In the limericks [. . .] to an extent difficult for us now to imagine, Lear offered children the liberation of unaffected high spirits [. . .]. Here are grown-ups doing silly things, the kind of things grown-ups never do [. . .]. for all their incongruity, there is in the limericks a truth which is lacking in the improving literature of the time. In an age when children were loaded with shame, Lear attempted to free them from it. -- Vivien Noakes
Like the limericks, they celebrate the outsider. Their principal characters are socially unacceptable" --Susan Chitty on Lear's ballads.
Mr. Lear was delighted when I showed to him that this couple [the Owl and the Pussy-cat] were reviving the old law of Solon, that the Athenian bride and bridegroom eat a quince together at their wedding -- Sir Edward Strachey
More information on Edward Lear here.
April is National Poetry Month. I'll lead off here with my favorite poem, one I come back to again and again and again ...It's even been a bit of a life raft at times. A bit? How about completely? Below the poem I've posted a compilation of quotes about and by Auden. This is why one keeps a "commonplace book" - so you can grab quotes easily when you need them.
But first, the most important thing.
The poem. And happy April. And happy Poetry Month.
The More Loving One by WH Auden
Looking up at the stars, I know quite well
That, for all they care, I can go to hell,
But on earth indifference is the least
We have to dread from man or beast.
How should we like it were stars to burn
With a passion for us we could not return?
If equal affection cannot be,
Let the more loving one be me.
Admirer as I am
Of stars that do not give a damn,
I cannot, now I see them, say
I missed one terribly all day.
Were all stars to disappear or die,
I should learn to look at an empty sky
And feel its total dark sublime,
Though this might take me a little time.
W.H. Auden

"The subject of his poetry is the struggle, but the struggle seen, as it were, by someone who whilst living in one camp, sympathises with the other; a struggle in fact which while existing externally is also taking place within the mind of the poet himself, who remains a bourgeois." - Edgell Rickword, "Auden and Politics"
"I think of Mr. Auden's poetry as a hygiene, a knowledge and practice, based on a brilliantly prejudiced analysis of contemporary disorders, relating to the preservation and promotion of health, a sanitary science and a flusher of melancholia. I sometimes think of his poetry as a great war, admire intensely the mature, religious, and logical fighter, and deprecate the boy bushranger." -- Dylan Thomas
"One Sunday afternoon in March 1922, a friend suggested that I should [write poetry]: the thought had never occurred to me." -- WH Auden
"For more than a year I read no one else." -- WH Auden - on Thomas Hardy
"Never write from your head, write from your cock." -- WH Auden, in a letter to a friend
"The need to find an expression for his homosexuality was the first technical obstacle to check the torrential course of Auden's unprecedented facility. A born master of directness was obliged straightaway to find a language for indirection, thus becoming immediately involved with the drama that was to continue for the rest of his life - a drama in which the living presence of technique is the antagonist." -- Clive James
"Auden: great poet or great representative poet? A poet or a 'classic of our prose'? He overhsadows the poets of his generation. He is Chaucer to the Gower of Betjeman and the Langland of MacNeice." -- Michael Schmidt
"Then, in June 1933, Auden experienced what he later called a 'Vision of Agape'. He was sitting on a lawn with three colleagues from the school where he was teaching, when, he wrote, 'quite suddenly and unexpectedly, something happened. I felt myself invaded by a power which, though I consented to it, was irresistible and certainly not mine. For the first time in my life I knew exactly - because, thanks to the power, I was doing it - what it meant to love one's neighbor as oneself." Before this, his poems had only been able to celebrate moments of impersonal erotic intensity, which he called 'love'. Now, in the poem 'Out on the lawn I lie in bed,' prompted by his vision, he had praise for everything around him." -- Edward Mendelson
More information on Auden here.
"You're always having to compete with yourself. They always say, 'It's not as good as Streetcar or Cat'. Of course it's not. At 69, you don't write the kind of play you write at 30. You haven't got the kind of energy you used to have."-- Tennessee Williams

Tennessee Williams said the following about Streetcar, and his main point of that entire play:
There are no 'good' or 'bad' people. Some are a little better or a little worse but all are activated more by misunderstanding than malice. A blindness to what is going on in each other's hearts. Stanley sees Blanche not as a desperate, driven creature backed into a last corner to make a last desperate stand - but as a calculating bitch with 'round heels'.... Nobody sees anybody truly but all through the flaws of their own egos. That is the way we all see each other in life.
Tennessee Williams wrote the following elegiac essay about Laurette Taylor (who created the role of Amanda so memorably in Glass Menagerie and made him star) for The New York Times after news of her death in 1949:
I do not altogether trust the emotionalism that is commonly indulged in over the death of an artist, not because it is necessarily lacking in sincerity but because it may come too easily. In what I say now about Laurette Taylor I restrict myself to those things which I have felt continually about her as apart from any which this unhappy occasion produces.Of course the first is that I consider her the greatest artist of her profession that I have known. The second is that I loved her as a person. In a way the second is more remarkable. I have seldom encountered any argument about her preeminent stature as an actress. But for me to love her was remarkable because I have always been so awkward and diffident around actors that it has made a barrier between us almost all but insuperable.
In the case of Laurette Taylor, I cannot say that I ever got over the awkwardness and the awe which originally were present, but she would not allow it to stand between us. The great warmth of her heart burned through and we became close friends.
I am afraid it is the only close friendship I have ever had with a player...
It is our immeasurable loss that Laurette Taylor's performances were not preserved on the modern screen. The same is true of Duse and Bernhardt, with whom her name belongs. Their glory survives in the testimony and inspiration of those who saw them. Too many people have been too deeply moved by the gift of Laurette Taylor for that to disappear from us.
In this unfathomable experience of ours there are sometimes hints of something that lies outside the flesh and its mortality. I suppose these intuitions come to many people in their religious vocations, but I have sensed them more clearly in the work of artists and most clearly of all in the art of Laurette Taylor. There was a radiance about her art which I can compare only to the greatest lines of poetry, and which gave me the same shock of revelation as if the air about us had been momentarily broken through by light from some clear space beyond us.
The last word that I received from her was a telegram which reached me early this fall. It was immediately after the road company of our play had opened in Pittsburgh. The notices spoke warmly of Pauline Lord's performance in the part of Amanda. "I have just read the Pittsburgh notices," Laurette wired me. "What did I tell you, my boy? You don't need me."
I feel now - as I have always felt - that a whole career of writing for the theatre is rewarded enough by having created one good part for a great actress.
Having created a part for Laurette Taylor is a reward I find sufficient for all the effort that went before and any that may come after.
It was a two-sided deal there. Her performance launched him into stardom. And his creation of Amanda revitalized her career just in time for her to capitalize on it. She would be dead in a couple of years. She had had a great career early in her life, and went on a 10 year binge following the death of her husband. Laurette Taylor was "washed up". Until ...
And now, she's a legend, her performance in Glass Menagerie is legendary. "What did I tell you, my boy, you don't need me..." Ha. That's what you think, Laurette! But in a way, she was completely right. The play is better than any one performance. The play didn't depend on Laurette Taylor's genius, although thank God she found the vehicle. The star of the play is actually the play itself, and Laurette Taylor knew that. The star of the play was this new voice of Tennessee Williams. And so no, Tennessee didn't "need" her. And about Tennessee saying: "I consider her the greatest artist of her profession that I have known." Anyone who knows anything about theatre would be hard-pressed to disagree. I haven't even SEEN the woman act, obviously, but I don't need to. I will take the hundreds and hundreds of eyewitness' word for it. In the same way that I know, in my heart, that Eleanora Duse was one of the "greatest artists of her profession" as well. I don't need to have seen her live.
Here's a treat for all you Tennessee and Laurette fans. Here is one of the original reviews of Glass Menagerie, after its premiere on an icy winter night in Chicago. This review focuses on the miracle that was Laurette Taylor's performance.
January 14, 1945MEMO FROM CHICAGO By Lloyd Lewis
CHICAGO - As this is written there exists doubt as to whether Eddie Dowling has anything more satisfying than an artistic success in his new production, "The Glass Menagerie", at the Civic Theatre, but there is no doubt whatsoever that he has brought back Laurette Taylor as a great character actress.
Not since she did "Peg o'My Heart," exactly thirty years ago, has she been so talked and written about.
In "The Glass Menagerie," which is a tenuous and moody tragedy from the pen of Tennessee Williams, she plays a decaying Delta belle overfond of haranguing her two children, one a warehouse worker (Mr. Dowling) and the other a morbidly bashful maiden (Julie Haydon), upon their duty to rise above the drabness of life in a St. Louis alley flat. Fumbling around the dolorous precincts of her home in a slipshod Mother Hubbard, she is forever reciting the plantation glories of her youth, how seventeen young gentlemen callers were forever complimenting her among the magnolias, and how she could have had this or that grandson instead of the captivating plebeian drunk who took her only to desert her and leave her to current St. Louis blues.
When Miss Taylor mumbles in magnificent realism she is still enough of a vocal wizard to be intelligible to her audiences, and when she pouts, nags or struts in pathetic bursts of romantic memory she is superb as a pantomime. Her descents into hysteria are masterpieces of understatement, dramatic in that they force her audience to do the acting for her.
She accomplishes her tour de force of acting without a single gesture which could be charged with showmanship. Some of her most telling lines are fumbling mutterings delivered over her shoulder. And in a scene wherein she prods her son into bringing home somebody, anybody, who might possibly marry his psychopathic sister before he himself wanders off, as his mother knows he will, into the big, blue and tipsy yonder, she gives a performance that could fit into the best of the Abbey Theatre's Irish plays.
One moment she is a ridiculous pretender and the next only a poor old woman dreading so soon to be dead because her helpless daughter will then be alone. When a 'caller' is eventually dragooned and brought to the house for dinner, Miss Taylor's appearance in an ancient taffety and high-toned manners is a delicate feat in the creation of that narrow line between the absurd and the sad.
Oh. Oh. For a time machine.
Here's a picture of Tennessee Williams out on his beloved Key West in 1980:

Make voyages. Attempt them. That's all there is.-- Tennessee Williams, "Camino Real"
I realized things about myself - and my life - through working on Miss Alma in Summer and Smoke - that pretty much forever changed me. My journal entries from that time are fascinating for me to look back on. I actually grew as a human being, while working on that play. I went into it a little bit here. Sheila and Alma had merged. It's one of the only times that's ever happened. Funny: I love to post my Diary Friday excerpts from high school days, because haw haw haw we can all sort of chuckle at the exuberance and silliness of youth. But I would very much hesitate to post those Sheila/Alma entries - which were, first of all, much more recent - but also - I don't know if I would ever want to expose that side of myself here. That is the real Artist Sheila. I couldn't bear to have anyone roll their eyes or chuckle at HER. NOBODY can tell me that Alma is "just" a character in a play. She LIVES, she breathes. I certainly felt possessed by her.
When people who knew him talk about Tennessee Williams, they always mention his laugh. Apparently, he had this wild high-pitched out-of-control Mozartian giggle, completely infectious to anyone near him. His plays may have had tragic elements, but that was how he worked out his own tragic upbringing, his sister's lobotomy, etc. He himself was not an openly tragic or introverted figure. He put all of his grief and sadness into his plays. The man was deeply sensitive - like all of his female characters. But if this seems like he was a bleak or depressive personality, that's incorrect. He always balked, too, when reviewers would characterize all of his female characters as "desperate". He didn't agree with that assessment at all. He saw each and every one of them as survivors - women trying to break through and live a happy and meaningful life. Other people assigned the meaning "desperate" to them, but Tennessee always hated that. Here's part of an essay he wrote for The New York Times in 1948 where he addresses this whole "desperate character" thing - In this essay he uses Miss Alma in "Summer and Smoke" as the jumping-off point:
All at once, I found myself hammed in by three women in basic black who had been to the Saturday matinee and had apparently thought of nothing since except the problems of Alma Winemiller, the heroine of "Summer and Smoke". When you are eating, a great deal can be accomplished by having a mouth full of food and by making gutteral noises instead of speech when confronted with questions such as, What is the theme of your play? What happens to the characters after the play is over? What is your next play about and how do you happen to know so much about women? On that last one you can spit the food out if it really begins to choke you.For a writer who is not intentionally obscure, and never, in his opinion, obscure at all, I do get asked a hell of a lot of questions which I can't answer. I have never been able to say what was the theme of my play and I don't think I have ever been conscious of writing with a theme in mind. I am always surprised when, after a play has opened, I read in the papers what the play is about, that it was about a decayed Southern belle trying to get a man for her crippled daughter, or that it was about a boozie floozie on the skids, or that a backwoods sheik in a losing battle with three village vamps.
Don't misunderstand me. I am thankful for these highly condensed and stimulating analyses, but it would never have occurred to me that that was the story I was trying to tell. Usually when asked about a theme I look vague and say, "It is a play about life." What could be simpler, and yet more pretentious? You can easily extend that a little and say it is a tragedy of incomprehension. That also means life. Or you can say it is a tragedy of Puritanism. That is life in America. Or you can say that it is a play that considers the "problem of evil". But why not just say "life"?
To return to the women in the alcove. On this particular occasion the question that floored me was, "Why do you always write about frustrated women?"
To say that floored me is to put it mildly, because I would say that frustrated is almost exactly what the women I write about are not. What was frustrated about Amanda Wingfield? Circumstances, yes! But spirit? See Helen Hayes in London's "Glass Menagerie" if you still think Amanda was a frustrated spirit! No, there is nothing interesting about frustration, per se. I could not write a line about it for the simple reason that I can't write a line about anything that bores me.
Was Blance of "A Streetcar Named Desire" frustrated? About as frustrated as a beast of the jungle! And Alma Winemiller? What is frustrated about loving with such white hot intensity that it alters the whole direction of your life, and removes you from the parlor of the Episcopal rectory to a secret room above Moon Lake Casino?
I came across this essay when I was working on Alma Winemiller - and I can't tell you how much of an "A-ha!" moment it gave me. If I felt drawn towards portraying her as sexually FRUSTRATED, or emotionally FRUSTRATED ... I remembered Tennessee's words. I remembered the truth of them. Do not play the frustration. How boring. Play the OBJECTIVE, play the DESIRE, play what you WANT with all your heart ... Let the CIRCUMSTANCES of the play frustrate you ... but never ever take your eye off your objective. And THAT is where the tragedy lies.
Brilliant. So so helpful to any actress who works on ANY of his great parts to keep in mind.
I love that drive in him - the drive to pour all of the darkness and fear from his background into his work - he was a man driven to do so - it was therapeutic for him, yes, but never just therapy. Art that is just therapy is usually bad art. Or - perhaps not bad - but it will not stand the test of time. Tennessee worked on his craft, and always cared more about the PLAY than about the personal demons exorcised by said play. Read his letters, his journals, his instructions to directors ... the level of detail there is astonishing. Really inspiring to me. To be such a great artist, but to also have such an understanding of craft, and structure.
"Nothing's more determined than a cat on a tin roof - is there? Is there, baby?"-- from Cat on a Hot Tin Roof
The lead of a play I did a year or so ago was the lead in Tennessee Williams' last play - Something Cloudy Something Clear - done here in NYC at Cocteau Rep. Williams died soon after the play went up. The play is a highly personal kind of dream-space, and reading it it is as though you can feel Williams getting ready to go into the dying of the light. It is the play of an old old man. A man getting ready. Craig shared with me his memories of working with Tennessee.
Everyone talks about his "laugh". Actors and actresses who were in his plays talk about hearing his laugh from out in the audience. It was a generous laugh, a laugh full of joy. If an actor or actress was doing well, he had no problem with letting them know, with enjoying their performances openly. (Other playwrights are not so kind. It seems as though other playwrights have this thought process: "No actor could EVER live up to the perfection that resides in my mind. My play is perfect as is ... it's the ACTORS who are messing it up!!" Playwrights like that, usually, are big bores, and don't have a lot of talent. Like: okay, you want perfection? Build a feckin' statue, and don't hire live actors. Mkay? That way your precious words will be safe from contamination. Ahem. I have a ton of stories.) But Tennessee, while kind of intimidated by actors, he never knew what to say to them ... LOVED them when they were wonderful. He did not consciously withhold approval - like so many do. If someone sucked, he had no problem with sending a note to the director saying: "Please have her realize that she needs to be light and funny on that one line - she is dragging down the entire scene with her dismal line readings..." hahaha He would never say such a thing to the actor's face - he let the director do his job - but if he was pleased? He would sit out in the audience, and just HOWL with laughter. He loved being an audience member. So many people in the theatre, because the theatre is their job and livelihood - forget how to just be an audience member.
Here, to me, is a quintessential Tennessee Williams statement.
An interviewer asked him: "What is your definition of happiness?"
He replied, "Insensitivity, I guess."
His experience of "happiness" as being, in its essence, "insensitive" came from his background. Those who were "sensitive" were crushed and shattered by cruelty, by life itself. His sister Rose was institutionalized and lobotomized. This was something Tennessee never really recovered from. (But he didn't really HAVE to recover from it, I guess. All of his feelings about it went into his work. If he had "recovered", or "worked it out" in his mind, then he might not have written Glass Menagerie, Summer and Smoke, et al.) He was a perpetual outsider. He was on the run from his past. He was able to "get out" of the past ... his sister Rose was not. The guilt of that never left him. The guilt of being "the one" who was able to live in the real world dogged him at every turn. If one was "happy", if one was able to manuever thru a world that lobotomized some of its most sensitive members, then "happiness" required some kind of a hard outer shell - a shell that Tennessee himself lacked, that other "sensitives" (his word) lacked. He did not begrudge people their happiness ... he just didn't understand it. He couldn't get "in there", ever. Again, this is kind of a blessing, at least as far as we are concerned - merely because that sort of baffled response to how on earth to LIVE in this world ... is the emotional place from which he wrote all of his plays.
He WAS Blanche. He WAS Tom in Glass Menagerie. He WAS Alma. He WAS Maggie. All of these people, these "sensitives", trying to make their way through, trying to bear up under disappointments and cruelty ... trying to SURVIVE.
Again and again, Williams reiterated that he never wrote about victims. He didn't see any of these people as victims. He saw them as survivors. Beautiful triumphant survivors.
Oh, you weak, beautiful people who give up with such grace. What you need is someone to take hold of you - gently, with love, and hand your life back to you.-- Tennessee Williams
The Blache DuBois', the Laura Wingfields, the Miss Almas ... these are sensitive people, deeply wounded people, on the edge of shattering - just like his sister Rose did. Of course blatant casual "happiness" would be seen as insensitive through their eyes.
All cruel people describe themselves as paragons of frankness.-- Tennessee Williams
Tennessee Williams is one of my own personal heroes, for more reasons than one, and I am aware (on a pretty much daily basis) of how grateful I am to him for his plays. In the same way that I am pretty much always conscious of being grateful that there was a Shakespeare, and that we have his works with us today. I still read Tennessee Williams plays now, over and over, reading them countless times, never ever getting tired of them, never ever feeling like all my questions are answered.
Some mystery should be left in the revelation of character in a play, just as a great deal of mystery is always left in the revelation of character in life, even in one's own character to himself.-- Tennessee Williams
And I'll leave you with another really telling and beautiful anecdote, this one from Elia Kazan. I LOVE this, because it says to me, in no uncertain terms, why Tennessee Williams is a god among playwrights - and why he is so unusual. Nobody else can touch him, really. I love Arthur Miller's plays, but there's always a social conscience in them which can get preachy and tiresome if it's not controlled. Death of a Salesman has a perfect balance, but his later plays have the feeling of pamphlets.
Tennessee Williams has none of that. There is no "social conscience" in his plays. There is no deeper social criticism going on. Perhaps the only "criticism" that Tennessee consistently levels at "society" is the way it treats the "sensitives".
I have found it easier to identify with the characters who verge upon hysteria, who were frightened of life, who were desperate to reach out to another person. But these seemingly fragile people are the strong people really.-- Tennessee Williams
Here's the setup for the excerpt I want to post (which has to do with the rehearsals and also the opening of Streetcar Named Desire):
Jessica Tandy, who originated Blanche on Broadway, was already a celebrated actress. Marlon Brando was practically unknown. Kazan noticed which way the wind was blowing during rehearsals, and it concerned him on many levels.
Basically what was happening was that Marlon Brando was acting Jessica Tandy off the stage. Without breaking a sweat, Brando stole the show right out from under her. Jessica Tandy fought to keep her ground (which, actually, is perfect for the theme of the show and for the character of Blanche Dubois), but Kazan's main concern was that Blanche would turn into a laughable character and lose the sympathy of the audience. Kazan was worried that the audience, because of Brando's undeniable stage presence, and the electricity of his acting, would completely side with Stanley, and not have any sympathy for Blanche at all. This, Kazan felt, would be a disaster. Stanley rapes Blanche. This event must be seen as horrifyingly wrong, not as Blanche getting what she deserves. But Brando's power took over the play, it was a runaway train, it wasn't a matter of him playing Stanley as sympathetic - he wasn't. It was just that he was a force to be reckoned with, a powerhouse - you couldn't take your eyes off him. Jessica Tandy barely registered, when she was beside him.
Here's a photo from that production: Brando, Kim Hunter, and Tandy:

And so Kazan feared, as rehearsals went on, that the balance of the play was off.
Here's what Kazan wrote about all of this in his marvelous autobiography.
It is Tennessee Williams' "advice" to Kazan at the end that really packs a punch:
But what had been intimated in our final rehearsals in New York was happening. The audiences adored Brando. When he derided Blanche, they responded with approving laughter. Was the play becoming the Marlon Brando Show? I didn't bring up the problem, because I didn't know the solution. I especially didn't want the actors to know that I was concerned. What could I say to Brando? Be less good? Or to Jessie? Get better? ...Louis B. Mayer sought me out to congratulate me and assure me that we'd all make a fortune ... He urged me to make the author do one critically important bit of rewriting to make sure that once that "awful woman" who'd come to break up that "fine young couple's happy home" was packed off to an institution, the audience would believe that the young couple would live happily ever after. It never occurred to him that Tennessee's primary sympathy was with Blanche, nor did I enlighten him ... His misguided reaction added to my concern. I had to ask myself: Was I satisfied to have the performance belong to Marlon Brando? Was that what I'd intended? What did I intend? I looked to the author. He seemed satisfied. Only I -- and perhaps Hume [Cronyn, Tandy's husband] -- knew that something was going wrong ...
What astonished me was that the author wasn't concerned about the audience's favoring Marlon. That puzzled me because Tennessee was my final authority, the person I had to please. I still hadn't brought up the problem, I was waiting for him to do it. I got my answer ... because of something that happened in the Ritz-Carlton Hotel, across the hall from my suite, where Tennessee and Pancho were staying. [Pancho was Tennessee's boyfriend - or maybe it was more of a f*** buddy situation. Pancho was a huge presence in Tennessee's life. They had a really volatile relationship.] One night I heard a fearsome commotion from across the hall, curses in Spanish, threats to kill, the sound of breaking china ... and a crash ... As I rushed out into the corridor, Tennessee burst through his door, looking terrified, and dashed into my room. Pancho followed, but when I blocked my door, he turned to the elevator still cursing, and was gone. Tennessee slept on the twin bed in my room that night. The next morning, Pancho had not returned.
I noticed that Wiilliams wasn't angry at Pancho, not even disapproving -- in fact, when he spoke about the incident, he admired Pancho for his outburst. At breakfast, I brought up my worry about Jessie and Marlon. "She'll get better," Tennessee said, and then we had our only discussion about the direction of his play. "Blanche is not an angel without a flaw," he said, "and Stanley's not evil. I know you're used to clearly stated themes, but this play should not be loaded one way or the other. Don't try to simplify things." Then he added, "I was making fun of Pancho, and he blew up." He laughed. I remembered the letter he'd written me before we started rehearsals, remembered how, in that letter, he'd cautioned me against tipping the moral scales against Stanley, that in the interests of fidelity I must not present Stanley as a "black-dyed villain". "What should I do?" I asked. "Nothing," he said. "Don't take sides or try to present a moral. When you begin to arrange the action to make a thematic point, the fidelity to life will suffer. Go on working as you are. Marlon is a genius, but she's a worker and she will get better. And better."
So extraordinary. It brings tears to my eyes, and it's wonderful advice, advice that any artist would do well to follow. "Don't take sides ..." "fidelity to life ..."
Here is the review of the premiere of Streetcar Named Desire, in New York City, December 3, 1947.
December 4, 1947FIRST NIGHT AT THE THEATRE by Brooks Atkinson
Tennessee Williams has brought us a superb drama, "A Streetcar Named Desire," which was acted at the Ethel Barrymore last evening. And Jessica Tandy gives a superb performance as a rueful heroine whose misery Mr. Williams is tenderly recording. This must be one of the most perfect marriages of acting and playwriting. For the acting and playwriting are perfectly blended in a limpid performance, and it is impossible to tell where Miss Tandy begins to give form and warmth to the mood Mr. Williams has created.
Like "The Glass Menagerie," the new play is a quietly woven study of intangibles. But to this observer it shows deeper insight and represents a great step forward toward clarity. And it reveals Mr. Williams as a genuinely poetic playwright whose knowledge of people is honest and thorough and whose sympathy is profoundly human.
"A Streetcar Named Desire" is history of a gently reared Mississippi young woman who invents an artificial world to mask the hideousness of the world she has to inhabit. She comes to live with her sister, who is married to a rough-and-ready mechanic and inhabits two dreary rooms in a squalid neighborhood. Blanche - for that is her name - has delusions of grandeur, talks like an intellectual snob, buoys herself up with gaudy dreams, spends most of her time primping, covers things that are dingy with things that are bright and flees reality.
To her brother-in-law she is an unforgiveable liar. But it is soon apparent to the theatregoer that in Mr. Williams' eyes she is one of the dispossessed whose experience has unfitted her for reality; and although his attitude toward her is merciful, he does not spare her or the playgoer. For the events of "Streetcar" lead to a painful conclusion which he does not try to avoid. Although Blanche cannot face the truth, Mr. Williams does in the most imaginative and perceptive play he has written.
Since he is no literal dramatist and writes in none of the conventional forms, he presents theatre with many problems. Under Elia Kazan's sensitive but concrete direction, the theatre solved them admirably. Jo Mielziner has provided a beautifully lighted single setting that lightly sketches the house and the neighborhood. In this shadowy environment the performance is a work of great beauty.
Miss Tandy has a remarkably long part to play. She is hardly ever off the stage, and when she is on stage she is almost constantly talking -- chattering, dreaming aloud, wondering, building enchantments out of words. Miss Tandy is a trim, agile actress with a lovely voice and quick intelligence. Her performance is almost incredibly true. For it does seem almost incredible that she can convey it with so many shades and impulses that are accurate, revealing and true.
The rest of the acting is also of very high quality indeed. Marlon Brando as the quick-tempered, scornful, violent mechanic; Karl Malden as a stupid but wondering suitor; Kim Hunter as the patient though troubled sister -- all act not only with color and style but with insight.
By the usual Broadway standards, "Streetcar Named Desire" is too long; not all those words are essential. But Mr. Williams is entitled to his own independence. For he has not forgotten that human beings are the basic subject of art. Out of poetic imagination and ordinary compassion he has spun a poignant and luminous story.
I have tears in my eyes.
We are lucky in this country that we have produced such a playwright. We are lucky to have all of his plays in the canon. I can't imagine my life without them.
Happy birthday, Tom.

Tennessee Williams said the following, in a 1981 interview - only a couple of years before he passed away:
"I'm very conscious of my decline in popularity, but I don't permit it to stop me because I have the example of so many playwrights before me. I know the dreadful notices Ibsen got. And O'Neill -- he had to die to make 'Moon' successful. And to me it has been providential to be an artist, a great act of providence that I was able to turn my borderline psychosis into creativity -- my sister Rose did not manage this. So I keep writing. I am sometimes pleased with what I do -- for me, that's enough."
It's Max Shulman's birthday. Who the hell is Max Shulman, you may ask? Or some of you may ask? He was one of the most popular humorists of his day - who reached his peak of popularity in the 1950s. He's the dude who created the Dobie Gillis character in a series of short stories and a couple novels - which was then turned into a popular TV series. Shulman was VERY successful in his day - and is now almost forgotten. Strange. He also was a screenwriter.
I somehow tripped over his book I Was a Teenage Dwarf when I was a teenager myself. This is the chronicle of Dobie Gillis' crazy "woman"izing when he was in high school (the shortest boy in town. Hence - the title.) Dobie Gillis was quite the lady killer, despite his height problems.

It was in the library where I worked as a page (my first job). I have no idea why I would have picked it up - it's kind of an old-fashioned looking book (the book I picked up had the cover I posted above - with Gillis on stilts). This was at the height of the whole Happy Days craze - so maybe something in the 1950s-ish cover appealed to me.
Also, I DO know that once I brought the book home I learned that my parents both LOVED Max Shulman. They recognized his name immediately, both started laughing, and told me: "You HAVE to read Rally Round the Flag, Boys!"

I remember vividly my mother TRYING to tell me what the name of one of the lead characters in Rally round the flag was - and completely not being able to get the name out because she started guffawing with laughter. The character's name was: Loadstone O'Toole. Even now - just typing that - I started laughing.
"Hi there, my name is Sue. What's your name?"
"Loadstone O'Toole."
"Uhm ... oh ... "
I was asked to leave my high school library because it was study period, and I was reading Teenage Dwarf, and I started laughing so loudly that I could not control myself. Basically, I GUFFAWED into the studious silence. Tears streamed down my face, despite the fact that I was being "Sh"ed left and right. I finally had to just gather up my book bag and stagger out into the hall, where I stood, and literally HOWLED with laughter, by myself, for a good 5 minutes.
I can count the writers on one hand who are that feckin' funny.
Over the last couple years, it became my mission in life to find all of his old books again - so I could own them. Many of them are long out of print, and hard to find (at least were hard to find. Amazon has now made it really easy). And I find it strange - It's not that long ago - the 1950s and 60s - but his reputation has not survived. It's a shame.
Member the famous Christmas pageant scene in Owen Meany? Max Shulman's books are that funny all the way through. The Strand sometimes had copies of his books - I always checked whenever I was there. I got some of his lesser known titles - but the holy grail (I Was a Teenage Dwarf) eluded me. I was dying to know if the book would be as funny to me as an adult as it was when I was a kid. I let my dad know, librarian that he is, what I was looking for - so he could keep his eyes open if he came across copies.
Eventually - a box arrived on my doorstep, with my dad's handwriting on the label. I opened it. And took out two books: Rally Round the Flag, Boys starring the marvelously named Loadstone O'Toole (LOADSTONE O'TOOLE???? I still can't get over it) - and oh. my. God: I Was a Teenage Dwarf.
I immediately took Teenage Dwarf up to my roof, with a thermos of coffee, and sat there in the autumn sun - tearing through my old childhood favorite. I finished it in a couple of hours.
And for the record? It was even funnier than I remembered. It's MEANER than I remembered. It's more biting, bitchy, merciless ... But I sat up there on my roof, the memories just flooded back, and I was howling.
Dobie Gillis at one point has a girlfriend who is a tomboy - and she is constantly playing stickball and climbing trees - falling down - so she always has cuts on her knees - and so her nickname is Red Knees. Her parents call her "Red Knees". Dobie Gillis, kissing her on the couch, whispers lovingly into her ear, "Ohhh, Red Knees ..."
A mind who thinks something like that up is sick and perverse, and basically my kind of person.
RED KNEES???
Writers who make me cry are great. I love them. But writers who make me laugh have my heart forever.
Max Shulman: a witty madcap man with a ridiculous and yet somehow very HUMAN sense of humor ... hugely successful in his day ... now mostly forgotten. If you ever come across his books in a used bookstore, I highly recommend you give them a read. They are laugh-out-loud funny.
Happy birthday, Mr. Shulman!!


Today in 1923 - Robert Frost's "Stopping By The Woods on a Snowy Evening" was published in the New Republic.
The story of the composition of that poem is very cool. One of my favorite kinds of inspirational stories. It is when you struggle for inspiration that the muse often eludes you. And it is when you suddenly relax - let go - that inspiration sometimes comes. Mike Nichols says that the most productive day of a rehearsal period is often the day off. Meaning: you rehearse, you work on issues, you struggle to find solutions ... and then you get a day off, when you go play frisbee with your kids, or sleep in, or whatever ... and then when you come back to rehearsal, refreshed, the solution to your problem is so obvious that it might as well conk you over the head.
Frost wrote the poem in June, when the weather was, to put it mildly, not wintry. So first of all - I love that. His imagination, his ability to project his eye into other seasons, other times ... It was not an immediate response to the immediate environment. And, of course, the poem - while it takes as its atmosphere - winter - it is actually about much much more.
He had had a sleepless night the night before - and had been working on a longer piece, something which was giving him a lot of trouble - the poem that would eventually be "New Hampshire". (The poems he worked on in this period would be part of the collection New Hampshire which would win him the Pulitzer.) So he stayed up all night, struggling on the poem, and he did finish it - sometime around dawn. He got it to a point where he was pleased. And when he looked up, back aching, coming back to the real world - he realized that the sun had come up. He had never stayed up all night with a poem before - so there was a sense of novelty in it to him. He was happy, pleased with his accomplishment - so he walked outside and watched the sun come up. As the sun rose, he suddenly felt an idea come - a new idea - for a new poem - and the sensation was so strong and so urgent that he rushed back inside, sat down, and wrote "Stopping by the woods on a snowy evening" in about 3 minutes. He said later that he wrote the poem almost without lifting the pen off the page. Meaning: that poem came out whole. Extraordinary. He compared the feeling later to a "hallucination".
Gives me goose bumps to think of that whole story. Struggling over one poem - which is one part of the artist's craft - the intellectual side - the picking and choosing of words, crossing things out, hovering over the page, contemplating, re-working, re-vising ... and then the other part of the artist's craft - which is to leave yourself completely wide open to inspiration, and when the muse calls your name - you freakin' ANSWER. Without question.
Very inspirational to me.
And when you think about the actual poem that had its birth in such a manner ... it's even more amazing.
Stopping By Woods On A Snowy Evening
Whose woods these are I think I know.
His house is in the village, though;
He will not see me stopping here
To watch his woods fill up with snow.
My little horse must think it queer
To stop without a farmhouse near
Between the woods and frozen lake
The darkest evening of the year.
He gives his harness bells a shake
To ask if there is some mistake.
The only other sound's the sweep
Of easy wind and downy flake.
The woods are lovely, dark, and deep,
But I have promises to keep,
And miles to go before I sleep,
And miles to go before I sleep.
It is that last stanza that makes this a truly great poem. And by great - I mean classic. Eternal. It is why it is in the canon. Before the last stanza, although the imagery is beautiful and evocative - we are in a prosaic world, the world of the everyday, albeit poetically expressed - with neighbors and villages and harness bells - objects that cement us to the physical world.
But in the last stanza, Frost pulls his lens abruptly back ... going into the universal and timeless. (Shades of what James Joyce does at the end of "The Dead". Microscopic vision becomes telescopic in a few sweeping paragraphs.)
More on Robert Frost here. He wanted his epitaph to be "I had a lover's quarrel with the world."
Another Robert Frost page - with links to many of his poems.
His "notebooks" have just been published - review here.

"Believe me, every man has his secret sorrows, which the world knows not; and oftimes we call a man cold, when he is only sad."
-- Henry Wadsworth Longfellow
Words to live by, as far as I'm concerned.
Henry Wadsworth Longfellow was born today in 1807 in Portland, Maine. He was one of those rare things: a poet famous during his own lifetime. A bit of a celebrity he was. I have his collected works at home. "Evangeline" and "Song of Hiawatha" are often the ones that are excerpted, or included in larger anthologies of American verse. But his "Paul Revere's Ride" is my favorite. I have written about it quite a bit. The first stanza gives me goosebumps. Always. Here it is - I never "get over" this poem.
Part of the reason I love this poem is because of the story, of course - but there's also something thrilling in Longfellow's language, his perfect rhythm, his immaculate rhyme scheme. It has a ring of inevitability to it. It's meant to be read out loud. When you do, you can hear the galloping horse hooves in the rhythm.
Paul Revere's Ride
Listen my children and you shall hear
Of the midnight ride of Paul Revere,
On the eighteenth of April, in Seventy-five;
Hardly a man is now alive
Who remembers that famous day and year.
He said to his friend, "If the British march
By land or sea from the town to-night,
Hang a lantern aloft in the belfry arch
Of the North Church tower as a signal light,--
One if by land, and two if by sea;
And I on the opposite shore will be,
Ready to ride and spread the alarm
Through every Middlesex village and farm,
For the country folk to be up and to arm."
Then he said "Good-night!" and with muffled oar
Silently rowed to the Charlestown shore,
Just as the moon rose over the bay,
Where swinging wide at her moorings lay
The Somerset, British man-of-war;
A phantom ship, with each mast and spar
Across the moon like a prison bar,
And a huge black hulk, that was magnified
By its own reflection in the tide.
Meanwhile, his friend through alley and street
Wanders and watches, with eager ears,
Till in the silence around him he hears
The muster of men at the barrack door,
The sound of arms, and the tramp of feet,
And the measured tread of the grenadiers,
Marching down to their boats on the shore.
Then he climbed the tower of the Old North Church,
By the wooden stairs, with stealthy tread,
To the belfry chamber overhead,
And startled the pigeons from their perch
On the sombre rafters, that round him made
Masses and moving shapes of shade,--
By the trembling ladder, steep and tall,
To the highest window in the wall,
Where he paused to listen and look down
A moment on the roofs of the town
And the moonlight flowing over all.
Beneath, in the churchyard, lay the dead,
In their night encampment on the hill,
Wrapped in silence so deep and still
That he could hear, like a sentinel's tread,
The watchful night-wind, as it went
Creeping along from tent to tent,
And seeming to whisper, "All is well!"
A moment only he feels the spell
Of the place and the hour, and the secret dread
Of the lonely belfry and the dead;
For suddenly all his thoughts are bent
On a shadowy something far away,
Where the river widens to meet the bay,--
A line of black that bends and floats
On the rising tide like a bridge of boats.
Meanwhile, impatient to mount and ride,
Booted and spurred, with a heavy stride
On the opposite shore walked Paul Revere.
Now he patted his horse's side,
Now he gazed at the landscape far and near,
Then, impetuous, stamped the earth,
And turned and tightened his saddle girth;
But mostly he watched with eager search
The belfry tower of the Old North Church,
As it rose above the graves on the hill,
Lonely and spectral and sombre and still.
And lo! as he looks, on the belfry's height
A glimmer, and then a gleam of light!
He springs to the saddle, the bridle he turns,
But lingers and gazes, till full on his sight
A second lamp in the belfry burns.
A hurry of hoofs in a village street,
A shape in the moonlight, a bulk in the dark,
And beneath, from the pebbles, in passing, a spark
Struck out by a steed flying fearless and fleet;
That was all! And yet, through the gloom and the light,
The fate of a nation was riding that night;
And the spark struck out by that steed, in his flight,
Kindled the land into flame with its heat.
He has left the village and mounted the steep,
And beneath him, tranquil and broad and deep,
Is the Mystic, meeting the ocean tides;
And under the alders that skirt its edge,
Now soft on the sand, now loud on the ledge,
Is heard the tramp of his steed as he rides.
It was twelve by the village clock
When he crossed the bridge into Medford town.
He heard the crowing of the cock,
And the barking of the farmer's dog,
And felt the damp of the river fog,
That rises after the sun goes down.
It was one by the village clock,
When he galloped into Lexington.
He saw the gilded weathercock
Swim in the moonlight as he passed,
And the meeting-house windows, black and bare,
Gaze at him with a spectral glare,
As if they already stood aghast
At the bloody work they would look upon.
It was two by the village clock,
When he came to the bridge in Concord town.
He heard the bleating of the flock,
And the twitter of birds among the trees,
And felt the breath of the morning breeze
Blowing over the meadow brown.
And one was safe and asleep in his bed
Who at the bridge would be first to fall,
Who that day would be lying dead,
Pierced by a British musket ball.
You know the rest. In the books you have read
How the British Regulars fired and fled,---
How the farmers gave them ball for ball,
From behind each fence and farmyard wall,
Chasing the redcoats down the lane,
Then crossing the fields to emerge again
Under the trees at the turn of the road,
And only pausing to fire and load.
So through the night rode Paul Revere;
And so through the night went his cry of alarm
To every Middlesex village and farm,---
A cry of defiance, and not of fear,
A voice in the darkness, a knock at the door,
And a word that shall echo for evermore!
For, borne on the night-wind of the Past,
Through all our history, to the last,
In the hour of darkness and peril and need,
The people will waken and listen to hear
The hurrying hoof-beats of that steed,
And the midnight message of Paul Revere.
SO SATISFYING. "It was one by the village clock ..." "It was two by the village clock ..." "For borne on the night-wind of the Past ..." Ringingly satisfying.
The O'Malley family has passed on the love of that poem to the next generation. Here's something I wrote about Cashel, and Longfellow's poem that I read on a radio program here in New York a couple years ago. Cashel was 5 years old at the time. It seems to me it would be quite a fitting tribute to one of the most popular American poets we've ever had.
One If By Land
Cashel and I colored for a while as we waited for the pizza to arrive. Cashel commanded me to draw a house. So I did. Cashel was basically the architect and the interior designer. Telling me what he wanted to see.
"Put a playroom in the attic."
"But Auntie Sheila -- where are the stairs??"
I drew the bathroom, and the mere sight of the toilet caused Cashel to dissolve into mirth. Yes. Toilets are hilarious.
I drew a spiral staircase which blew Cashel away. "That's so COOL." Then I drew the living room. I said, "I think there needs to be a picture on the wall. Or a portrait. Whose picture should be on the wall, you think?"
Cashel said bluntly, "Einstein."
Okay, then. Einstein. So I drew this little cartoon of Einstein, with the crazy hair coming up, and Cashel said seriously, with all of his knowledge, "That really looks like Einstein."
We ate our pizza together, talking about stuff. Star Wars, Ben Franklin. Cashel informed me, "Ben Franklin discovered lightning."
Cashel is a wealth of information. Randomly, he told my parents that Vincent Van Gogh never sold a painting while he was alive, but that after he died, he became famous.
I read him a story. It was from the book of "Disney stories" which I had given him for his birthday. He loves it. He pulled it out of the bookshelf, and I said, "Oh! I gave that to you!" Cashel said, a little bit annoyed, "I know that."
He had me read the story of the little mouse who hung out with Ben Franklin, and basically (in the world of Disney) was the inspiration for all of Ben Franklin's famous moments. Cashel would shoot questions at me. "Why is Ben Franklin's hair white?" "Well ... he's old now. But also, in those days, men wore powdered wigs. I think." Cashel's little serious face, listening, sponging this all up. Probably the next day he informed his friends that men in the olden days wore powdered wigs. He's that kind of listener, that kind of learner.
Then he put on his Obi Wan Kenobi costume which Grandma Peggy made him for Christmas. A long hooded brown cloak ... and he hooked his light saber into his waist, and galloped off down the hall. Making me laugh. A mini Jedi knight.
I had him pick out three stories to read before bedtime. He sat beside me, curled up into me, looking at the pictures as I read to him. The last one we read was Longfellow's poem "Paul Revere's Ride". This poem was a favorite of ours, when we were kids. My dad would read it to us, and even now, when I read the words, I hear them in my father's voice. A magical poem. Really. The way my dad read it to us (along with Longfellow's help) made us SEE it. The clock tower, the moon, the darkness ... the sense of anticipation, of secrecy, of urgency. It was thrilling. So I love that this is being passed on to Cashel! I've never read the poem outloud before ... so I had one of those strange moments of the space-time continuum bending ... me stepping into my father's shoes, Cashel 5 years old beside me, feeling the ghost of my own 5 year old self listening.
I also remember how Brendan and I used to chime in gleefully: "ONE IF BY LAND, TWO IF BY SEA!" And Cashel did the same thing. I paused before that moment in the poem, glanced down at him, and he screamed it out.
There was also a subtlety of understanding in Cashel ... I read this section:
And lo! as he looks, on the belfry's height
A glimmer, and then a gleam of light!
He springs to the saddle, the bridle he turns,
But lingers and gazes, till full on his sight
A second lamp in the belfry burns.
And Cashel exclaimed, in a sort of "Uh-oh" tone, "They're comin' by sea!!" Now the words don't actually SAY that, but he remembered the "one if by land two if by sea" signal, and puts it all together. That's my boy!
I remembered the first lines from memory:
Listen my children and you shall hear
Of the midnight ride of Paul Revere,
On the eighteenth of April, in Seventy-five;
Hardly a man is now alive
Who remembers that famous day and year.
Again, those are just words on the page. But to me, they are filled with the echoes of my father's voice. I have tears in my eyes.
Cashel and I, as we went through the poem, had to stop many times for discussions.
There was one illustration of all the minute-men, hiding behind the stone walls, with a troop of Redcoats marching along, walking straight into the ambush. Cashel pointed at it, and stated firmly, "That's the civil war."
"Nope. Nope. That is actually a picture from the American Revolutionary War."
Cashel pondered this. Taking it in. Then: "The minute-men were in the civil war." But less certain.
"Nope. The minute-men were soldiers in the American Revolution. Do you know why they called them that?"
"Why?"
"Cause they were just farmers, and regular people ... but they could be ready to go into battle in a minute."
Again, a long silence. As Cashel filed this away for safekeeping. He forgets nothing.
"So ... Auntie Sheila ... what is the difference between the Revolutionary War and the Civil War?"
Woah. Okay. This will be a test. How to describe all of that in 5-year-old language. I mean, frankly, Cashel is not like a five-year-old at all. But still. Everything must be boiled down into its simplest components.
"Well. America used to be a part of England, and the American Revolutionary War was when America decided that it wanted to be free ... and Americans basically told the Brits to go home." Uh-oh. Brits? This is an inflammatory term. I corrected myself. "America told Great Britain that it wanted to be its own country. And the Civil War ... " Hmmm. How to begin ... what to say ... I know it was about more than slavery, but I decided to only focus on that one aspect. Economic theory would be too abstract. "In those days, Cashel, black people were slaves. And it was very very wrong. Can you understand that?"
He nodded. His little serious face.
"And the people in the South wanted to keep their slaves, and the people in the North said to the people in the South that they had to give up their slaves because it was wrong. And they ended up going to war. And eventually all the slaves were free."
Cashel accepted this explanation silently. Then he pointed back to the Paul Revere poem. "Read." he commanded.
I read and loved Alice McDermott's book Charming Billy (I babbled about it a bit here) - and there are a couple of her other books on my shelves that I have yet to get to. Charming Billy is about a big Irish family in Queens, who gather for the wake of their relative "Billy" - and they tell stories, and truths are revealed, and some truths are not revealed - but what I loved so much about the book is how much it really GETS big families, especially Irish families, with all the chatter, and all of the elaborations - stories get larger, the fish they caught get bigger ... the point isn't the truth. The point is: Is it a good story?? Sacrifice the truth if it will make the story better. Her writing has such a great feel for that very specific Irish trait.
Here's an excerpt from Charming Billy - This is a remembrance of Billy Lynch as a young man - running into his cousin Dennis on the subway. You can see how past and present are woven together here. We get the sense that we are in the here and now, looking back, trying to "picture" Billy as he was then ... and then, the memory takes over, in all its 3-D specificity.
It would take an act of will to picture him now as he was then: to put aside every image that had come in between, including that dark, stiffly bloated remnant of his face that was Billy in death, and remember him clearly: thin and handsome in those days, the dipped brim of his fedora over the blue eyes and the rimless glasses, a nick of dried blood on his smooth cheek, a red blush from the cold. A lingering scent of the church he had just come from on his overcoat, and a taste of the Eucharist still on his breath as they stood together in the crowded subway car, hand over hand on the same white pole, exchanging shouted bits of news or falling into silence as the train rattled and screeched and tried to knock them off their feet. As glad for each other's company as if they'd long been deprived of it.
I adore her writing. It's so so good.
Here's a very interesting interview with McDermott - about her latest book After This, which I will definitely have to read. And I love the interview. She sounds like my kind of person. Practical, passionate, a tiny bit impatient with silly questions, and totally into her art. I love how she talks about writing.

Elizabeth Bishop is one of my favorite poets - and she actually didn't write all that many poems throughout her life - not compared to other poets who lived as long as she did (here's the collected poems) - but the ones she DID write - resonate, reverberate - they're classics. She was independently wealthy - she traveled the world - she was best friends with Robert Lowell - they had a kinship that can only be described as intimate - She lived all over the place, and finally settled down in Key West.
Here's a great biographical sketch of her. Lots of personal tragedy there. But she didn't go the route of confessional poetry - a la her best friend Robert Lowell. Her influences were Marianne Moore and Gerard Manley Hopkins. For a long time she was known as a "poet's poet" - but I think her appeal is much broader than that (although her works may not be as well-known as those with more populist appeal). In my opinion, she's up there with Robert Frost. She's in the same continuum. Her work has that grandeur, and also that ... homeliness. She writes about "small" things - the look of waves, a moose in the darkness, fishing rods - in the same way that Frost writes about "small" things - an axe, a snowfall ... Yet nobody could ever say that these are trivial poets, or "surface" poets. These poets plumb the depths of the human condition itself. And not by focusing on their experiences with electric shock therapy, or their family psychodramas (and there is nothing wrong with those kinds of poets - many of them are my favorites, actually - it's just a different focus, a different "way in", so to speak.) Bishop's poem 'One Art' stands out - it is different from the others. She speaks in an "I" voice - rather than a detached narrator, or observer. You can feel the influence of her soulmate Robert Lowell - even though the expression, the poem itself, is all hers. People who know about poetry love Elizabeth Bishop - and rightly so - but her work is not inaccessible, you don't need Cliff Notes to "get" it ... And yet she is as deep as the ocean. I love her stuff so much.
It's a toss-up what is her best-known poem. There are two that seem to consistently make it into the anthologies "At the Fishhouses" and "One Art" (which I mentioned above). If you read these poems one after the other it is very difficult to not just be in awe of her versatility with language. They are both truly great poems - and yet the voice used in each is so completely specific, and perfect to the subject matter. I love "At the Fishhouses" (I suggest reading it out loud to get the full effect) - maybe I love it because it is familiar to me - as an East Coast girl who grew up 10 minutes from the vast heaving Atlantic. The fishing industry is just a part of the landscape of my childhood - and there's just something about it that Bishop captures - and it's in the images, yes - but ... more than that ... it's in the language. Bishop is truly a master. She makes it look so easy that it is hard to remember just how good she is. And then there's "One Art" - which has this blunt open-faced honesty - and I love the last line - with the italicized word ... She expresses something I know, on such a cellular level. The "art of losing". Disaster. She's marvelous. Here they both are:
At the Fishhouses
Although it is a cold evening,
down by one of the fishhouses
an old man sits netting,
his net, in the gloaming almost invisible,
a dark purple-brown,
and his shuttle worn and polished.
The air smells so strong of codfish
it makes one's nose run and one's eyes water.
The five fishhouses have steeply peaked roofs
and narrow, cleated gangplanks slant up
to storerooms in the gables
for the wheelbarrows to be pushed up and down on.
All is silver: the heavy surface of the sea,
swelling slowly as if considering spilling over,
is opaque, but the silver of the benches,
the lobster pots, and masts, scattered
among the wild jagged rocks,
is of an apparent translucence
like the small old buildings with an emerald moss
growing on their shoreward walls.
The big fish tubs are completely lined
with layers of beautiful herring scales
and the wheelbarrows are similarly plastered
with creamy iridescent coats of mail,
with small iridescent flies crawling on them.
Up on the little slope behind the houses,
set in the sparse bright sprinkle of grass,
is an ancient wooden capstan,
cracked, with two long bleached handles
and some melancholy stains, like dried blood,
where the ironwork has rusted.
The old man accepts a Lucky Strike.
He was a friend of my grandfather.
We talk of the decline in the population
and of codfish and herring
while he waits for a herring boat to come in.
There are sequins on his vest and on his thumb.
He has scraped the scales, the principal beauty,
from unnumbered fish with that black old knife,
the blade of which is almost worn away.
Down at the water's edge, at the place
where they haul up the boats, up the long ramp
descending into the water, thin silver
tree trunks are laid horizontally
across the gray stones, down and down
at intervals of four or five feet.
Cold dark deep and absolutely clear,
element bearable to no mortal,
to fish and to seals . . . One seal particularly
I have seen here evening after evening.
He was curious about me. He was interested in music;
like me a believer in total immersion,
so I used to sing him Baptist hymns.
I also sang "A Mighty Fortress Is Our God."
He stood up in the water and regarded me
steadily, moving his head a little.
Then he would disappear, then suddenly emerge
almost in the same spot, with a sort of shrug
as if it were against his better judgment.
Cold dark deep and absolutely clear,
the clear gray icy water . . . Back, behind us,
the dignified tall firs begin.
Bluish, associating with their shadows,
a million Christmas trees stand
waiting for Christmas. The water seems suspended
above the rounded gray and blue-gray stones.
I have seen it over and over, the same sea, the same,
slightly, indifferently swinging above the stones,
icily free above the stones,
above the stones and then the world.
If you should dip your hand in,
your wrist would ache immediately,
your bones would begin to ache and your hand would burn
as if the water were a transmutation of fire
that feeds on stones and burns with a dark gray flame.
If you tasted it, it would first taste bitter,
then briny, then surely burn your tongue.
It is like what we imagine knowledge to be:
dark, salt, clear, moving, utterly free,
drawn from the cold hard mouth
of the world, derived from the rocky breasts
forever, flowing and drawn, and since
our knowledge is historical, flowing, and flown.
One Art
The art of losing isn't hard to master;
so many things seem filled with the intent
to be lost that their loss is no disaster.
Lose something every day. Accept the fluster
of lost door keys, the hour badly spent.
The art of losing isn't hard to master.
Then practice losing farther, losing faster:
places, and names, and where it was you meant
to travel. None of these will bring disaster.
I lost my mother's watch. And look! my last, or
next-to-last, of three loved houses went.
The art of losing isn't hard to master.
I lost two cities, lovely ones. And, vaster,
some realms I owned, two rivers, a continent.
I miss them, but it wasn't a disaster.
--Even losing you (the joking voice, a gesture
I love) I shan't have lied. It's evident
the art of losing's not too hard to master
though it may look like (Write it!) like disaster.
But in my opinion - it is "The Moose" that is her greatest poem. Somehow I had forgotten about it - and for whatever reason, my Dad brought it to my attention last year - saying, "Have you read "The Moose"? You have to read it."
So I sat down and read it. Its greatness speaks for itself.
THE MOOSE
From narrow provinces
of fish and bread and tea,
home of the long tides
where the bay leaves the sea
twice a day and takes
the herrings long rides,
where if the river
enters or retreats
in a wall of brown foam
depends on if it meets
the bay coming in,
the bay not at home;
where, silted red,
sometimes the sun sets
facing a red sea,
and others, veins the flats'
lavender, rich mud
in burning rivulets;
on red, gravelly roads,
down rows of sugar maples,
past clapboard farmhouses
and neat, clapboard churches,
bleached, ridged as clamshells,
past twin silver birches,
through late afternoon
a bus journeys west,
the windshield flashing pink,
pink glancing off of metal,
brushing the dented flank
of blue, beat-up enamel;
down hollows, up rises,
and waits, patient, while
a lone traveller gives
kisses and embraces
to seven relatives
and a collie supervises.
Goodbye to the elms,
to the farm, to the dog.
The bus starts. The light
grows richer; the fog,
shifting, salty, thin,
comes closing in.
Its cold, round crystals
form and slide and settle
in the white hens' feathers,
in gray glazed cabbages,
on the cabbage roses
and lupins like apostles;
the sweet peas cling
to their wet white string
on the whitewashed fences;
bumblebees creep
inside the foxgloves,
and evening commences.
One stop at Bass River.
Then the Economies
Lower, Middle, Upper;
Five Islands, Five Houses,
where a woman shakes a tablecloth
out after supper.
A pale flickering. Gone.
The Tantramar marshes
and the smell of salt hay.
An iron bridge trembles
and a loose plank rattles
but doesn't give way.
On the left, a red light
swims through the dark:
a ship's port lantern.
Two rubber boots show,
illuminated, solemn.
A dog gives one bark.
A woman climbs in
with two market bags,
brisk, freckled, elderly.
"A grand night. Yes, sir,
all the way to Boston."
She regards us amicably.
Moonlight as we enter
the New Brunswick woods,
hairy, scratchy, splintery;
moonlight and mist
caught in them like lamb's wool
on bushes in a pasture.
The passengers lie back.
Snores. Some long sighs.
A dreamy divagation
begins in the night,
a gentle, auditory,
slow hallucination. . . .
In the creakings and noises,
an old conversation
--not concerning us,
but recognizable, somewhere,
back in the bus:
Grandparents' voices
uninterruptedly
talking, in Eternity:
names being mentioned,
things cleared up finally;
what he said, what she said,
who got pensioned;
deaths, deaths and sicknesses;
the year he remarried;
the year (something) happened.
She died in childbirth.
That was the son lost
when the schooner foundered.
He took to drink. Yes.
She went to the bad.
When Amos began to pray
even in the store and
finally the family had
to put him away.
"Yes . . ." that peculiar
affirmative. "Yes . . ."
A sharp, indrawn breath,
half groan, half acceptance,
that means "Life's like that.
We know it (also death)."
Talking the way they talked
in the old featherbed,
peacefully, on and on,
dim lamplight in the hall,
down in the kitchen, the dog
tucked in her shawl.
Now, it's all right now
even to fall asleep
just as on all those nights.
--Suddenly the bus driver
stops with a jolt,
turns off his lights.
A moose has come out of
the impenetrable wood
and stands there, looms, rather,
in the middle of the road.
It approaches; it sniffs at
the bus's hot hood.
Towering, antlerless,
high as a church,
homely as a house
(or, safe as houses).
A man's voice assures us
"Perfectly harmless. . . ."
Some of the passengers
exclaim in whispers,
childishly, softly,
"Sure are big creatures."
"It's awful plain."
"Look! It's a she!"
Taking her time,
she looks the bus over,
grand, otherworldly.
Why, why do we feel
(we all feel) this sweet
sensation of joy?
"Curious creatures,"
says our quiet driver,
rolling his r's.
"Look at that, would you."
Then he shifts gears.
For a moment longer,
by craning backward,
the moose can be seen
on the moonlit macadam;
then there's a dim
smell of moose, an acrid
smell of gasoline.
Granta has re-published a long interview with one of its mainstay writers - who just passed away - Ryszard Kapuscinski. I haven't even really processed the fact that he is gone - and that that is it, in terms of his writing. What I have now is what there will be for all eternity. I haven't read the memoir yet, but once I do - that will be it. No more. He has passed. God, what a life, what a talent. Seriously - he is one of my true idols, for so so many reasons.
Anyway, Bill Buford interviewed him years ago for Granta and here it is. Great stuff.
He's one of those people who are higher up than the rest of us. I do not mean in terms of status. I mean in terms of perspective. Very few people can get far enough back from events to really see them - and also to see them without seeing themselves in the picture. I know the writers who I think can do that - Rebecca West being the first onethat comes to mind ... but it's a fascinating and ... sometimes chilling ... view of history. Because it seems inevitable. Tragedy and chaos seem unavoidable. Everything that happens has happened before. It is just the details that change, the geopolitical situations that shift. But people never change. I find this chilling, and yet I also find the practicality of that view very much in line with my own thoughts about things.
Kapuscinski - a man who made his living flying into war-torn countries just as the war was breaking out - has that perspective. From the very beginning - trouble found him. Not because he was a trouble-maker. But because he told the truth - and he was higher up than everybody else.
For example:
Buford: And the most important piece to emerge in that time was in fact written by you.Kapuscinski: That would be 'This Too is the Truth of Nowa Huta'. Somehow, our paper succeeded in getting my article passed, and it was extremely polemical. Nowa Huta was the showcase steel factory being built near Cracow. It was meant to be our economic triumph. But I had worked there as a student. I had friends there. I knew what the conditions were like, and they were appalling: the plant was mismanaged and the supervisors were frequently drunk. The moment the article appeared, there was a great uproar, and I had to go into hiding.
God, what a man. I miss him already.
Here's an excerpt but go read the whole thing.
Ryszard Kapuscinski: You know, for years, I have been building up a small collection of books, newspapers and photographs about Pinsk. I would like to show it to you. Pinsk, you see, is the town where I was born and where I lived until I was eight, when the entire area, originally part of Poland, came under Russian control.Buford: The collection is material for an autobiography?
Kapuscinski: I don't know, maybe. No: it's merely part of a landscape, my landscape, the landscape that I came from. It is the landscape of a flat, a very flat, country, a marshland, and there are two things that are important to me about Pinsk.
First: that here in this very provincial town, this town of dirt roads, cut off from everything, was in fact an extraordinary cosmopolitan gathering. Many of the founders of the State of Israel came from my town. There were Jews, Poles, Byelorussians, Ukrainians, Armenians, and every kind of religion,from Judaism to Catholicism to Islam, and we all lived together. The people were called Poleshuks, meaning merely 'people born in the district of Polesie,' and they were a people without a nation and without, therefore, a national identity. And, second, while Pinsk was very international?or, if you like, very 'nationless'?it was also very poor.
I could listen to this guy all day.
Kapuscinski: I'm not forming a manifesto and certainly don't want to appear dogmatic. But I do feel that we are describing a new kind of literature. I feel sometimes that I am working in a completely new field of literature, in an area that is both unoccupied and unexplored.Buford: The literature of political experience?
Kapuscinski: The literature of personal ... no, that's not right. You know, sometimes, in describing what I do, I resort to the Latin phrase silva rerum: the forest of things. That's my subject: the forest of things, as I've seen it, living and travelling in it. To capture the world, you have to penetrate it as completely as possible.
Marvelous. Here's the whole interview.
I've put up excerpts of Kapuscinski's books over the years. Here's a smattering of them. But if you haven't read his books, or collections of essays ... I seriously can't recommend them highly enough.
Just unbelievable. Yeah, the main thing I think of when I think of Jane Austen is she "died a spinster".
Speaking of Jane Austen - I flipped through this book while I was in Barnes & Noble yesterday - and had to put it down. Thought I would puke.
In other words: Robert Burns. Or, as they say in Scotland, "Rahbbie Barrrrrrrrns."

Robert Burns (love this guy) is a national hero in Scotland, his works are known by heart, and festivals go on in his name. Right now in Scotland, I assure you, people are standing up and proclaiming his verses into crowded pubs, while everybody chants along, everyone knowing the words. I love that. I love a nation that celebrates its writers, its own national voice. You kind of can't get any more beloved than Robert Burns to the Scots.
He was born poor, in the middle of the 18th century. He had a lot of brothers and sisters, and his parents were farmers. Yet his father decided that Robert, his eldest, should have a bit of an education. A tutor was hired, and Robert, in between the farm chores and hard work, learned how to read and write. And a whole world opened up to him through language (as it is wont to do). Writing came naturally to him. He started writing poems and songs almost immediately, some of which are still famous today.
Robert Burns was a wild man, a person who loved pleasure, loved fun. He loved women. He loved scotch. He had many illegitimate children. He loved life, basically. All of this shows in his work - which sparks with humor, sentiment, love, wit. He's AWEsome.
Here's one of my favorite quotes from Burns (outside of his poetry, I mean). Burns here writes about how he, a farmer's son, with informal education at best, had started to write. Where did the writing bug come from? And why?
Here is Burns' answer to that question:
For my own part I never had the least thought or inclination of turning poet till I got once heartily in Love, and then Rhyme and Song were, in a manner, the spontaneous language of my heart.
I love that. His poems do read like "spontaneous language" of the heart. They're songs.
Burns hated the climate in Scotland, and yearned to get the hell out and go someplace warm. But this ended up not being his fate. He eventually got married (to one of the chicks he had knocked up) ... and when his poems started being published, in collected works, he became famous in Scotland. People LOVED him. He wrote in their voice, he wrote in their dialects, he wrote about THEM. He became known as "the Ploughman Poet". With this fame, he decided to stay in Scotland.
He was prolific. Nobody even knows how much he actually wrote ... because there are probably lots of traditional songs and verses out there which he DID write, but which cannot be pinned down on him. As it stands, there are over 400 Robert Burns known songs in existence. He was a celebrity in his own time. (So rare for writers!!) But the fame he achieved in his own lifetime is NOTHING compared to the FRENZY that goes on now. It's kind of like the Bloomsday-freaks who behave like autistic lunatics every June 16. Sure, Joyce was famous in his day. But ... that famous?
The lyrics Robert Burns wrote have lasted generations. Some of them are so engrained in our culture that we can't even imagine that one person even penned them at all. They seem to have just descended upon us, whole, from Olympus, or something. But no ... someone actually WROTE these things.
Like "Auld Lang Syne" for example. That's a Robert Burns lyric.
He also wrote this simple little love lyric, one of his most famous I suppose (outside of Auld Lang Syne, I mean). I love it for its simplicity, its openness, its unembarrassed joy.
My Luve is Like a Red, Red Rose
O, my luve is like a red, red rose,
That's newly sprung in June.
O, my luve is like a melodie,
That's sweetly play'd in tune.
As fair art thou, my bonie lass,
So deep in luve am I,
And I will luve thee still, my dear,
Till a' the seas gang dry.
Till a' the seas gang dry, my dear,
And the rocks melt wi the sun!
And I will luve thee still, my dear,
While the sands o life shall run.
And fare thee weel, my only luve!
And fare thee weel, a while!
And I will come again, my luve,
Tho it were ten thousand mile!
One of the reasons why Burns is so cherished and revered in Scotland is because of how he put the voices of Scots, the accents, into his poems. He is THEIRS. We can all enjoy him, but he is THEIRS.
He died at 37. Over 10,000 people showed up at his funeral. The thought of that gives me the chills, I tell ya.
So I suppose it would be highly appropriate to end this commemorative post in honor of this extraordinary writer with his own words, words we all know:
Auld Lang Syne
For auld lang syne, my dear,
For auld lang syne,
We'll tak a cup of kindness yet,
For auld lang syne!
Should auld acquaintance be forgot,
And never brought to mind?
Should auld acquaintance be forgot,
And auld lang syne?
And surely ye'll be your pint-stowp,
And surely I'll be mine,
And we'll tak a cup o kindness yet,
For auld lang syne!
We twa hae run about the braes,
And pou'd the gowans fine,
But we've wander'd monie a weary fit,
Sin auld lang syne.
We twa hae paidl'd in the burn
Frae morning sun till dine,
But seas between us braid hae roar'd
Sin auld lang syne.
And there's a hand my trusty fiere,
And gie's a hand o thine,
And we'll tak a right guid-willie waught,
For auld lang syne.
Very interesting review by Adam Kirsch of the latest biography of Thomas Hardy, (the biography is by Claire Tomalin.)
Any Hardy fans, or any literature fans, will want to take the time to read that review.
Quotes that stood out for me:
Yet, as Hardy grew older, it was failure that increasingly occupied his thoughts and inspired his best writing. Tomalin tries to account for this by suggesting that ?the wounds inflicted by life never quite healed over in Hardy.? But such bland psychologizing misses the essential point: Hardy?s pessimism was not a helpless reaction to traumas but the cast of his sensibility, that indispensable and unaccountable lens through which every artist makes sense of the world.
Yes. Yes. Stop with the Freudian analysis. Not everything is traced back to childhood. Some things, some human qualities, just ARE.
Another quote:
For the rest of his life, then, Hardy set to writing poetry with the grateful fervor of an escaped prisoner; his ?Collected Poems? fill more than eight hundred pages.
I love Hardy's poetry. Here's the one he wrote about the sinking of the Titanic:
The Convergence of the Twain
I
In a solitude of the sea
Deep from human vanity,
And the Pride of Life that planned her, stilly couches she.
II
Steel chambers, late the pyres
Of her salamandrine fires,
Cold currents thrid, and turn to rhythmic tidal lyres.
III
Over the mirrors meant
To glass the opulent
The sea-worm crawls -- grotesque, slimed, dumb, indifferent.
IV
Jewels in joy designed
To ravish the sensuous mind
Lie lightless, all their sparkles bleared and black and blind.
V
Dim moon-eyed fishes near
Gaze at the gilded gear
And query: "What does this vaingloriousness down here?". . .
VI
Well: while was fashioning
This creature of cleaving wing,
The Immanent Will that stirs and urges everything
VII
Prepared a sinister mate
For her -- so gaily great --
A Shape of Ice, for the time fat and dissociate.
VIII
And as the smart ship grew
In stature, grace, and hue
In shadowy silent distance grew the Iceberg too.
IX
Alien they seemed to be:
No mortal eye could see
The intimate welding of their later history.
X
Or sign that they were bent
By paths coincident
On being anon twin halves of one August event,
XI
Till the Spinner of the Years
Said "Now!" And each one hears,
And consummation comes, and jars two hemispheres.
Now it's odd but I think a lot of people still don't think of Hardy as a poet. They think of him as a novelist. Even though he stopped writing novels completely (that is all explained in the New Yorker piece) and devoted himself to poetry.
Ezra Pound, discerning critic and champion of genius, had this to say about Hardy's poems:
"Now there is clarity. There is the harvest of having written 20 novels first."
Fascinating.
Thomas Hardy created "Wessex" in all of his books - a place based on the places he knew. Even during his lifetime, "Wessex" tourist tours began. People coming out on pilgrimages, looking for the places in the novels. He did not venture forth, he did not write about anything other than the world he knew.
Hardy said, when criticized for being "provincial": "A certain provincialism is invaluable. It is the essence of individuality, and is largely made up on that crude enthusiams without which no great thoughts are thought, no great deeds done."
One last quote from the article that struck me:
No matter what the subject, Hardy devoted his poetry to laying out his magnificently sombre, completely disillusioned view of the world. The central fact of that world was the disappearance of God, and with it any reason for believing in providence or justice.
It's funny to me that the "establishment" who so vilified him during his heyday - then turned around and canonized him. Even gave him a huge Christian burial, which has to be amusing, since his fury at the church knew no bounds. Ah, hypocrisy. Also "self-delusion" (quote from article). A society has an endless capacity for "self-delusion". Almost like Ireland now "claiming" James Joyce (as well they should) - but still: Joyce had to FLEE from your country in order to live life as a bohemian artist libertine - because the society was so rigid, close-minded, hypocritical, and backwards. You claim him NOW, NOW when it's easy. Of course I think Ireland should claim James Joyce - but at least don't be deluded about it, at least don't be a jackass about it. Realize that it wasn't always the case, and perhaps acknowledge the shortcomings of your own nation. Thank you. (I say all of this knowing that James Joyce could never have written Ulysses while he was in Ireland. He NEEDED to leave, and he knew it. However, he didn't start writing books about Trieste or Paris. Oh no. All of his books about Ireland. Sometimes you need to get away, get far enough back, in order to write about a certain locale.)
I think even now some people don't GET just how anti-establishment Thomas Hardy was. He's just a "great novelist", who wrote "great books". Yeah. But have you READ those books? They seem vicious and bleak even today! The issues he writes about are STILL issues. Hypocrisy lives in every generation.
Speaking of poetry, and Hardy's atheism - here is one of his more famous poems. It's called "God's Funeral". And if you think that stuff like this doesn't still ruffle feathrers ... The words "self-delusion" again come to mind.
God's Funeral
by Thomas Hardy
I
I saw a slowly-stepping train --
Lined on the brows, scoop-eyed and bent and hoar --
Following in files across a twilit plain
A strange and mystic form the foremost bore.
II
And by contagious throbs of thought
Or latent knowledge that within me lay
And had already stirred me, I was wrought
To consciousness of sorrow even as they.
III
The fore-borne shape, to my blurred eyes,
At first seemed man-like, and anon to change
To an amorphous cloud of marvellous size,
At times endowed with wings of glorious range.
IV
And this phantasmal variousness
Ever possessed it as they drew along:
Yet throughout all it symboled none the less
Potency vast and loving-kindness strong.
V
Almost before I knew I bent
Towards the moving columns without a word;
They, growing in bulk and numbers as they went,
Struck out sick thoughts that could be overheard: --
VI
'O man-projected Figure, of late
Imaged as we, thy knell who shall survive?
Whence came it we were tempted to create
One whom we can no longer keep alive?
VII
'Framing him jealous, fierce, at first,
We gave him justice as the ages rolled,
Will to bless those by circumstance accurst,
And longsuffering, and mercies manifold.
VIII
'And, tricked by our own early dream
And need of solace, we grew self-deceived,
Our making soon our maker did we deem,
And what we had imagined we believed,
IX
'Till, in Time's stayless stealthy swing,
Uncompromising rude reality
Mangled the Monarch of our fashioning,
Who quavered, sank; and now has ceased to be.
X
'So, toward our myth's oblivion,
Darkling, and languid-lipped, we creep and grope
Sadlier than those who wept in Babylon,
Whose Zion was a still abiding hope.
XI
'How sweet it was in years far hied
To start the wheels of day with trustful prayer,
To lie down liegely at the eventide
And feel a blest assurance he was there!
XII
'And who or what shall fill his place?
Whither will wanderers turn distracted eyes
For some fixed star to stimulate their pace
Towards the goal of their enterprise?'...
XIII
Some in the background then I saw,
Sweet women, youths, men, all incredulous,
Who chimed as one: 'This is figure is of straw,
This requiem mockery! Still he lives to us!'
XIV
I could not prop their faith: and yet
Many I had known: with all I sympathized;
And though struck speechless, I did not forget
That what was mourned for, I, too, once had prized.
XV
Still, how to bear such loss I deemed
The insistent question for each animate mind,
And gazing, to my growing sight there seemed
A pale yet positive gleam low down behind,
XVI
Whereof, to lift the general night,
A certain few who stood aloof had said,
'See you upon the horizon that small light --
Swelling somewhat?' Each mourner shook his head.
XVII
And they composed a crowd of whom
Some were right good, and many nigh the best....
Thus dazed and puzzled 'twixt the gleam and gloom
Mechanically I followed with the rest.
Wow. This is powerful stuff.
I've never read a biography of Hardy - perhaps I should. I want to know more about his marriage. Like - what was THAT about??
Robert Louis Stevenson is just one of the many MANY people who visited the Hardys and had a visceral response to that wife. He wrote:
[He was] a pale, gentle, frightened little man, that one felt an instinctive tenderness for, with a wife -- ugly is no word for it! -- who said, "Whatever shall we do?" I had never heard a human being say it before.
Ha!
Here's a link to the New Yorker piece again. It's made me want to re-read Jude the Obscure.
A look at the late Irish novelist John McGahern.
A memoir has just been published which brings up interesting questions about biography and art ... I like the point of view in the article. That the greater truth can be found in his fiction. Those who look to biography for all of the answers usually have a rather simplistic view of art itself. They want the DIRT. They want ANSWERS. They then go back and read the stories, assuming that every piece of it is somehow biographical. But no - McGahern's life was his life, of course, and that is interesting - but there is a greater truth to be found in the fiction. There are those who, on dying, when asked: "What was the meaning of your life?" would point to whatever art they had created. There - you want to understand me? Don't look at my childhood, or read my diaries, or talk to my friends. No. Read my novel! Etc. McGahern's journey as an artist - being seen as a throwback - or as somehow nostalgic for a world that has passed - or as insufficiently condemning towards the Catholic church - is all in that article. His books (especially Amongst Women - woah) are not to be missed. He's a good writer period.
Here's the incoherent piece I wrote when I heard McGahern had died.
An interesting bit from the article I posted a link to above:
He was recognised as a master craftsman: a succession of awards and prizes confirmed that. But McGahern also came to be seen as something he never was, nor tried to be: a chronicler of Ireland?s journey from the past and an explorer of Irish identity.As he tried to explain in interviews, this way of looking at things held no attraction for him. It was not interesting; there was something childish in questing after the machinery of identity. He disliked the notion of the writer as romantic artist, a courageous solo swimmer in a sea of archetypes.
He wrote about the world he knew and the world his people had known for generations in rural Ireland. He came from the Catholic middle classes, and although he had left the faith behind, he refused to condemn it. It was part of what he was.
It has always been too easy to stereotype McGahern. When his second novel, The Dark, was banned in Ireland, and he was forced by the Catholic church to resign from his teaching job in Dublin, some wanted to use him as a cause c鬨bre, a literary crusader against the old repression.
McGahern rejected the role. He noted that Samuel Beckett was one of the few to inquire after his personal opinion before agreeing to join an anti-censorship campaign. To others, it seemed that McGahern must have been so deeply brainwashed by Irish Catholicism that he refused to denounce it.
But he was no campaigner. If there was any denouncing to be done, it could be undertaken by the reader after engaging with the truth of his fiction. He did not want to dignify the ban by openly opposing it. Readers of his work could see what had angered the hierarchy: not just the frank sexuality, but a portrait of a religious institution without spirituality, devoted to secular power.
Again, here's the whole article. Very interesting.
Kate, Tim and I had a conversation about Chekhov this past weekend (with little baby sleeping on Tim's chest) - Tim's doing Astrov in Uncle Vanya - they've just begun rehearsals, so it was cool to hear about it, and cool (as always)to talk about Chekhov. Kate's the one who made me read the Paul Schmidt translation that I adore - and Tim's production of Uncle Vanya is also using that translation, I believe. It's a very ACT-able translation, unlike some of the other ones.
Anne has posted a fragment about Chekhov that I like.

Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley, her husband Percy Shelley, Lord Byron, and Lord Byron's physician Dr. John Polidori sat around one rainy summer night in 1816- they were neighbors in Switzerland - I mean, damn, I want to be at one of THOSE barbecues, sheesh! - but anyway, one summer in 1816 - on a rainy night - after a series of rainy days when they were housebound - Byron (who was working on Childe Harold at the time) came up with a suggestion for a way to amuse themselves as a group. Each person was to write a ghost story (there was an old volume of ghost stories in one of their vacation homes - and that was the inspiration for this little party game. Yeah, you know, a party game with two of the most influential poets of their day and a woman who was about to write a classic novel. At the age of freakin' nineteen years old. Mm-hm. That was some party game.)
Here is Mary Shelley describing this. It is a perfect and personal description of the artistic process. Anyone who has ever tried to create something ... or wanted to create something and just felt they needed to have an idea ... will recognize themselves in Mary Shelley's words.
Watch how she works it out. Lets her subconscious lead her. She doesn't ask too many questions. She gets her idea, and she GOES. (Rather akin to Dr. Frankenstein's own journey with his monster. There are so many levels here.)
But I just love that she has given us such a detailed essay about how she wrote this book. Goosebumps.
"We will each write a ghost story," said Lord Byron, and his proposition was acceded to. There were four of us. The noble author began a tale, a fragment of which he printed at the end of his poem of Mazeppa. Shelley, more apt to embody ideas and sentiments in the radiance of brilliant imagery and in the music of the most melodious verse that adorns our language than to invent the machinery of a story, commenced one founded on the experiences of his early life. Poor Polidori had some terrible idea about a skull-headed lady who was so punished for peeping through a key-hole - what to see I forget: something very shocking and wrong of course; but when she was reduced to a worse condition than the renowned Tom of Coventry, he did not know what to do with her and was obliged to dispatch her to the tomb of the Capulets, the only place for which she was fitted. The illustrious poets also, annoyed by the platitude of prose, speedily relinquished their uncongenial task.I busied myself to think of a story - a story to rival those which had excited us to this task. One which would speak to the mysterious fears of our nature and awaken thrilling horror - one to make the reader dread to look round, to curdle the blood, and quicken the beatings of the heart. If I did not accomplish these things, my ghost story would be unworthy of its name. I thought and pondered - vainly. I felt that blank incapability of invention which is the greatest misery of authorship, when dull. Nothing replies to our anxious invocations. "Have you thought of a story?" I was asked each morning, and each morning I was forced to reply with a mortifying negative.
Everything must have a beginning, to speak in Sanchean phrase; and that beginning must be linked to something that went before. The Hindus give the world an elephant to support it, but they make the elephant stand upon a tortoise. Invention, it must be humbly admitted, does not consist in creating out of void, but out of chaos; the materials must, in the first place, be afforded: it can give form to dark, shapeless substances but cannot bring into being the substance itself. In all matters of discovery and invention, even of those that appertain to the imagination, we are continually reminded of the story of Columbus and his egg. Invention consists in the capacity of seizing on the capabilities of a subject and in the power of moulding and fashioning ideas suggested to it.
Many and long were the conversations between Lord Byron and Shelley to which I was a devout but nearly silent listener. During one of these, various philosophical doctrines were discussed, and among others the nature of the principle of life, and whether there was any probability of its ever being discovered and communicated. They talked of the experiments of Dr. Darwin (I speak not of what the doctor really did or said that he did, but, as more to my purpose, of what was then spoken of as having been done by him), who preserved a piece of vermicelli in a glass case till by some extraordinary means it began to move with voluntary motion. Not thus, after all, would life be given. Perhaps a corpse would be reanimated; galvanism had given token of such things: perhaps the component parts of a creature might be manufactured, brought together, and endued with vital warmth.
Night waned upon this talk, and even the witching hour had gone by before we retired to rest. When I placed my head on my pillow I did not sleep, nor could I be said to think. My imagination, unbidden, possessed and guided me, gifting the successive images that arose in my mind with a vividness far beyond the usual bounds of reverie. I saw - with shut eyes, but acute mental vision - I saw the pale student of unhallowed arts kneeling beside the thing he had put together. I saw the hideous phantasm of a man stretched out, and then, on the working of some powerful engine, show signs of life and stir with an uneasy, half-vital motion. Frightful must it be, for supremely frightful would be the effect of any human endeavour to mock the stupendous mechanism of the Craetor of the world. His success would terrify the artist; he would rush away from his odious handiwork, horror-stricken. He would hope that, left to itself, the slight spark of life which he had communicated would fade, that this thing which had received such imperfect animation would subside into dead matter, and he might sleep in the belief that the silence of the grave would quench forever the transient existence of the hideous corpse which he had looked upon as the cradle of life. He sleeps; but he is awakened; he opens his eyes; behold, the horrid thing stands at his bedside, opening his curtains and looking on him with yellow, watery, but speculative eyes.
I opened mine in terror. The idea so possessed my mind that a thrill of fear ran through me, and I wished to exchange the ghastly image of my fancy for the realities around. I see them still: the very room, the dark parquet, the closed shutters with the moonlight struggling through, and the sense I had that the glassy lake and white high Alps were beyond. I could not so easily get rid of my hideous phantom; still it haunted me. I must try to think of something else. I recurred to my ghost story - my tiresome, unlucky ghost story! Oh! If I could only contrive one which would frighten my reader as I myself had been frighttened that night!
Swiftly as light and as cheering was the idea that broke in upon me. "I have found it! What terrified me will terrify others; and I need only describe the spectre which had haunted my midnight pillow." On the morrow I announced that I had thought of a story.
Posted by sheila Permalink | Comments (13)
Margaret Atwood has been coming up quite a bit for me, lately. There was this peripheral mention of Bodily Harm - which brought up a flood of memories from when I first read that unbelievable book - a book that freakin' scared me, man - unlike any other Atwood book I've read. I read it in my early 20s, and to be honest, I think I blocked most of it out. Except for the opening scene. It was that upsetting to me.
And then this beautiful post from the totally cool "Super Fast Reader" - I so related to this post (first of all, about the whole "reading on the subway" thing, and how you work it out - and those horrible days when you have to try to turn the pages of your book with the same hand that is holding the book - ah, I know that pain) - but then she goes on to talk, briefly, about all of Atwood's books, her favorites, etc. (Go, Cat's Eye!)
And finally this lovely weird little anecdote - written by a HUGE Atwood fan - and it describes a brief encounter with Atwood at a book signing - and the discombobulation one can experience when one meets a true idol - and also the funny little answer Atwood gives to the question asked. I love it. She's so mischievous (Atwood).
I read all of Atwood's books - even over the last 10 years - when I have been less than thrilled with what she's been doing - but in my opinion very few writers write books as good as Cat's Eye. That's a great book. Period. And I also would put Bodily Harm on the list - that was a truly disorienting experience - scary, confusing, and - DEEP. But it haunted me. From the opening scene (she comes home to find a coil of rope on her bed. Who left it there? Why?) to the devastating close ...
There's something about Atwood that - rocks my boat a bit. It jolts me out of complacency. At times she seems to speak directly to me - especially with cat's Eye - and so I have never re-read any of her books. Once has been enough. I still have them all ... and sometimes I pick them up, flip through them, and think: "Hm. I should re-read this - it's been 20 years since I've read this book ..." but then I resist for some reason.
Because I can't read her books and not GO there.
But I don't know. Atwood seems to be popping up left and right for me these days ...
I've been thinking about re-reading Bodily Harm ... so maybe now is the time ... What is it that scares me? It does. It's not the plot. It's something else. It's unbalancing to read her. And maybe I'm not into that now. But I think I should give it a shot. Maybe it's a hint, a sign from the universe - these Atwood posts all over the place.
But I'm still not sure if I'm ready to read Cat's Eye again. That book just cut to the heart of my entire LIFE.
1. The Bulwer Lytton fiction contest (award given to what could be a worst opening sentence in a novel - sometimes hypothetical novel - the award is named for the man who began his book with "It was a dark and stormy night.")
2006's winning sentence is, for example:
Detective Bart Lasiter was in his office studying the light from his one small window falling on his super burrito when the door swung open to reveal a woman whose body said you've had your last burrito for a while, whose face said angels did exist, and whose eyes said she could make you dig your own grave and lick the shovel clean.
I mean, you know. This is genius.
Some other winning sentences:
Through the gathering gloom of a late-October afternoon, along the greasy, cracked paving-stones slick from the sputum of the sky, Stanley Ruddlethorp wearily trudged up the hill from the cemetery where his wife, sister, brother, and three children were all buried, and forced open the door of his decaying house, blissfully unaware of the catastrophe that was soon to devastate his life.
Aren't these great? Another winner:
A small assortment of astonishingly loud brass instruments raced each other lustily to the respective ends of their distinct musical choices as the gates flew open to release a torrent of tawny fur comprised of angry yapping bullets that nipped at Desdemona's ankles, causing her to reflect once again (as blood filled her sneakers and she fought her way through the panicking crowd) that the annual Running of the Pomeranians in Liechtenstein was a stupid idea.
I can't get enough of this stuff.
This one, the winner for 1985, is, I believe my favorite:
The countdown had stalled at T minus 69 seconds when Desiree, the first female ape to go up in space, winked at me slyly and pouted her thick, rubbery lips unmistakably--the first of many such advances during what would prove to be the longest, and most memorable, space voyage of my career.
Here is the "lyttony" of prize winners. Each sentence is deliciously awful, spectacularly bad ... I also love how some of the prize winners have shown up at the awards ceremonies, full of good and self-deprecating humor about their own badness (kind of like Halle Berry going to accept a Razzie for Cat woman - and being all hysterical and good-natured about it).
So there's THAT. LOVE that prize.
2. My second favorite literary award is the award for Bad Sex in Fiction. Here's a list of past winners.
(More here.)
Unlike the Bulwer Lytton award, which rarely features writers anyone has ever heard of - we get some heavy hitters in this award. Updike, Tom Wolfe, etc. No one is spared. Obviously it's difficult to write a sex scene well. This award celebrates those who not only do not write sex scenes well - but who tip over into spectacular badness. You gotta go read some of the entries on that website. I refuse to put them on my site because, frankly, I'm sick of sexually inappropriate Google searches ... Ha!! But seriously, some of the sentences ... You CRINGE when you read them they are so bad.
One of my favorite things about this award is also the good humor with which (most) authors treat their nominations. People show up for the raucous awards ceremony, they admit their own badness, they laugh at themselves ... so much fun. Sean Thomas who won in 2000 accepted his award, saying sincerely, "It's an enormous honor and I'm gratified." Ha!! (Also, with a bit of scanning you'll be able to find his winning sentence on that site. It's just soooo funny. Soooo bad.)
There are some authors who have been nominated 3, 4 times. Ha!! There must be a strange sense of pride in that.
So. Iain Hollingshead is this year's winner. Here is a very funny essay by him - about his whole experience. I just love his honesty and humor about himself:
My own extract, in comparison, felt rather tame. But it was very badly written indeed. So bad, it seems, that the judges had little difficulty in declaring me, dear reader, the recipient of the 2006 Literary Review Bad Sex in Fiction Award.
HA!

Jonathan Swift was born on this day, in 1667. Here's a ton of biographical information if you are interested.
Primarily known for Gulliver's Travels and A Modest Proposal he was also a poet of pretty uncommon gifts. I LOVE his poetry. He's also one of the most quotable of all writers. This man had acid running in his veins, acid of contempt for his fellow human beings. Ha!
But you think that it is time for me to have done with the world, and so I would if I could get into a better before I was called into the best, and not die here in a rage, like a poisoned rat in a hole.
His hatred and contempt have echoed across the centuries and given us the primary examples of satire that all writers should study. I am sorry that satire is so tepid these days. I find most of it way too coy, and ... obvious. They WISH that what they were doing was satire of the highest order - but what they are really doing is just bitching and whining in a tiny airless corner. Swift was merciless. Swift's command of language was impeccable. His observations were ruthless. He cannot be touched.
Swift said, in regards to satire:
Satire is a sort of glass, wherein beholders do generally discover everybody's face but their own.
hahahaha So true!
Swift embraced hate. It's hard to describe any other way - and yet he did not embrace corruption. Most people who fill their souls with hate (and I can think of many examples in our present-day political discourse as I am sure you can as well) completely corrupt their humanity. Their hatred for everyone else (and their inability to look in a mirror - or, no, it's not just inability - it is blatant and conscious REFUSAL to look in a mirror) leaves them with no humanity. Swift does not seem to have had that problem. He was just alert, that's all. He just saw the things going on around him, and wrote it all down. He pulled no punches.
I never wonder to see men wicked, but I often wonder to see them not ashamed.
Come on now. Truth. There is such truth in Swift.
And also:
Politics, as the word is commonly understood, are nothing but corruptions.
He called things as he saw them:
We have just enough religion to make us hate, but not enough to make us love one another.
Obviously such blunt truth was highly unwelcome in many circles - and still is today. Oh, how much the pious haters despise those who call them on their phoniness!! Again: it all comes back to this: Can you look in the mirror? Can you face yourself? Can you entertain the possibility that that which you hate is also inside of you? Oh ho ho no. Many people don't even know what the HELL you are talking about when you talk like that!
But then there is also this:
It is in men as in soils where sometimes there is a vein of gold which the owner knows not.
The belief in the good in people. Not universally - oh, no. Swift was perfectly willing to see some people as just plain assholes with no redeeming qualities - and I'm pretty much with him on that. But occasionally - where you least expect it - a "vein of gold".
Many professional haters (and don't get me wrong - I think Jonathan Swift was a first-class straight-A hater - he said it about himself!) have ZERO senses of humor. Oh, they think they do, and I see them chortling on political talk shows, throwing zingers at their opponents - and yet - there's no wit. No humor. None.
But Swift? He used humor. He used it like a whip, yes, but also - well - there's something like this statement which makes me laugh out loud every time I read it:
There were many times my pants were so thin I could sit on a dime and tell if it was heads or tails.
Self-knowledge - a willingness to include himself in his own merciless searchlight:
Where I am not understood, it shall be concluded that something very useful and profound is couched underneath.
And his POEMS. Let me post a couple of them. They're marvelous. Funny, biting, mean ... and yet sometimes so heartfelt (the ones to Stella - the woman he loved all his life - comes to mind) that they bring tears to my eyes.
You don't want to skim these. Read. Read them.
A Satirical Elegy: On the Death of a Late Famous General
His Grace! impossible! what dead!
Of old age, too, and in his bed!
And could that Mighty Warrior fall?
And so inglorious, after all!
Well, since he's gone, no matter how,
The last loud trump must wake him now:
And, trust me, as the noise grows stronger,
He'd wish to sleep a little longer.
And could he be indeed so old
As by the news-papers we're told?
Threescore, I think, is pretty high;
'Twas time in conscience he should die.
This world he cumber'd long enough;
He burnt his candle to the snuff;
And that's the reason, some folks think,
He left behind so great a stink.
Behold his funeral appears,
Nor widow's sighs, nor orphan's tears,
Wont at such times each heart to pierce,
Attend the progress of his hearse.
But what of that, his friends may say,
He had those honours in his day.
True to his profit and his pride,
He made them weep before he dy'd.
Come hither, all ye empty things,
Ye bubbles rais'd by breath of Kings;
Who float upon the tide of state,
Come hither, and behold your fate.
Let pride be taught by this rebuke,
How very mean a thing's a Duke;
From all his ill-got honours flung,
Turn'd to that dirt from whence he sprung.
I love the line: "How very mean a thing's a Duke". It just says it all.
And here is my favorite of the "Stella poems":
Stella's Birthday March 13, 1727
This day, whate'er the Fates decree,
Shall still be kept with joy by me:
This day then let us not be told,
That you are sick, and I grown old;
Nor think on our approaching ills,
And talk of spectacles and pills.
To-morrow will be time enough
To hear such mortifying stuff.
Yet, since from reason may be brought
A better and more pleasing thought,
Which can, in spite of all decays,
Support a few remaining days:
From not the gravest of divines
Accept for once some serious lines.
Although we now can form no more
Long schemes of life, as heretofore;
Yet you, while time is running fast,
Can look with joy on what is past.
Were future happiness and pain
A mere contrivance of the brain,
As atheists argue, to entice
And fit their proselytes for vice;
(The only comfort they propose,
To have companions in their woes;)
Grant this the case; yet sure 'tis hard
That virtue, styl'd its own reward,
And by all sages understood
To be the chief of human good,
Should, acting, die, nor leave behind
Some lasting pleasure in the mind;
Which by remembrance will assuage
Grief, sickness, poverty, and age;
And strongly shoot a radiant dart
To shine through life's declining part.
Say, Stella, feel you no content,
Reflecting on a life well spent?
Your skilful hand employ'd to save
Despairing wretches from the grave;
And then supporting with your store
Those whom you dragg'd from death before?
So Providence on mortals waits,
Preserving what it first creates.
Your gen'rous boldness to defend
An innocent and absent friend;
That courage which can make you just
To merit humbled in the dust;
The detestation you express
For vice in all its glitt'ring dress;
That patience under torturing pain,
Where stubborn stoics would complain:
Must these like empty shadows pass,
Or forms reflected from a glass?
Or mere chimæras in the mind,
That fly, and leave no marks behind?
Does not the body thrive and grow
By food of twenty years ago?
And, had it not been still supplied,
It must a thousand times have died.
Then who with reason can maintain
That no effects of food remain?
And is not virtue in mankind
The nutriment that feeds the mind;
Upheld by each good action past,
And still continued by the last?
Then, who with reason can pretend
That all effects of virtue end?
Believe me, Stella, when you show
That true contempt for things below,
Nor prize your life for other ends,
Than merely to oblige your friends;
Your former actions claim their part,
And join to fortify your heart.
For Virtue, in her daily race,
Like Janus, bears a double face;
Looks back with joy where she has gone
And therefore goes with courage on:
She at your sickly couch will wait,
And guide you to a better state.
O then, whatever Heav'n intends,
Take pity on your pitying friends!
Nor let your ills affect your mind,
To fancy they can be unkind.
Me, surely me, you ought to spare,
Who gladly would your suff'rings share;
Or give my scrap of life to you,
And think it far beneath your due;
You, to whose care so oft I owe
That I'm alive to tell you so.
"Does not the body thrive and grow By food of twenty years ago?" God ... that just kills me. Yes, Swift ... yes, it does.
And this one - hee hee:
Oysters
Charming oysters I cry:
My masters, come buy,
So plump and so fresh,
So sweet is their flesh,
No Colchester oyster
Is sweeter and moister:
Your stomach they settle,
And rouse up your mettle:
They'll make you a dad
Of a lass or a lad;
And madam your wife
They'll please to the life;
Be she barren, be she old,
Be she slut, or be she scold,
Eat my oysters, and lie near her,
She'll be fruitful, never fear her.
Ha!
Michael Schmidt's book Lives of the Poets has a chapter devoted to Jonathan Swift, John Gay, and Alexander Pope - it's called "Three Friends". Schmidt's book is a must-read for poetry lovers - he's not a critic first of all. He's an editor and a book publisher. He's a FAN of poetry - and he writes like a fan writes - not like a critic - and yet his knowledge is encyclopedic. I LOVE the book.
Here is some of what he has to say about Jonathan Swift:
His vexed relations with women, especially "Stella" and "Vanessa", and his disgust with physical functions, have given much latitude to Freudian interpretations. Disgust informs much of the prose and verse, but so does a real interest in common people, their language, actions and concerns. The verse opens on this area of his genius, and on his darker musings. It possesses the satiric virtues of the prose with an additional element: the "I" speaks, speaks as itself, with an uncompromised acerbity that few poets have masterd. When he died in 1745, Ireland and England were in his debt. The topicality that limits the appeal of some of his prose is itself the appeal of the verse: it catches inflections and remembers small actions now lost -- the voices of gardeners, street vendors, laborers ... the tone of a cryptic man of conscience speaking of his world, his bitter, life, his wary loves.
Jonathan Swift described style, in writing, as "proper words in proper places". I think he pretty much mastered that - in his prose, certainly, but also in his poems. There isn't an extra word there - there is no FAT in his language - he has pared everything down to its essentials. The verses come to us as though they were born complete - and perfect.
More from Schmidt - and this, I believe, is a brilliant point:
In the more ambitious pieces Swift challenges the reader ... There is a unique irony at work, not normative, like Dryden's, but radical: thematic rather than stylistic. This is why his poems, even the most topical, retain force today. "I take it to be part of the honesty of poets," he wrote, "that they cannot write well except they think the subject deserves it." The subjects he chose he approached as if for the first time, as if we stepped from the chill, clear world of reason into a world of men.
More (I see his point here about Swift not being quotable, not really - most of the quotes I excerpted above were from his prose works - His poems are pretty much complete as they are - and need to be read straight through - they are difficult to excerpt. They depend on momentum and continuity):
Swift is hard to recommend as a poet because he is hard to quote out of context. There are few purple passages, detachable maxims; the poetry is drawn evenly through the poem in ways that out-of-context quotation violates. The epitaphs, the spoofs, the eclogues, the anecdotes spoken by various voices, the ironic love poems, the first-person poems, will not be broken up into tags like the rich couplet bric-a-brac of Pope. In Swift we come upon a writer who might have preferred to be called versifier rather than poet. There is a difference in kind in his work from that of his predecessors; and he is not "polite" enough to have beguiled his contemporaries into imitation. He stands alone, he doesn't sing, he never ingratiates himself. He speaks, and he understands how the world wags.
And on that note, I will close this ginormous post - but I will let William Butler Yeats have the last word on Jonathan Swift, an absolutely goosebump-inducing writer:
Swift's Epitaph
Swift has sailed into his rest;
Savage indignation there
Cannot lacerate his breast.
Imitate him if you dare,
World-besotted traveller; he
Served human liberty.
Yup. Imitate him if you dare.

"November is the most disagreeable month in the whole year," said Meg, standing at the window one dull afternoon, looking out at the frostbitten garden."That's the reason I was born in it," observed Jo pensively, quite unconscious of the blot on her nose.
Louisa May Alcott was born on this day, in 1832. (I just LOVE that picture of her above. The dress!!)
Truth be told, I have only read Little Women. But that, frankly, was enough for me. To me, it is a perfect book - a book I go back to again and again and again - always seeing something new in it, always finding new levels. The characters seem to grow up with me. When I first read it, when I was 10 years old, I was ALL ABOUT JO. And my love affair with Jo continues to this day. She is one of my favorite female characters ever written (it's a tie between Jo March and Harriet the Spy). Jo LIVES. No one can convince me that she is just a fictional character. Nope. You cannot do it.
But as I have grown up, and as I have continuously gone back to the book - the other sisters have come to the foreground - I see myself in all of them. Parts of me are like Amy, parts of me are like Meg, and I would like to think that parts of me are like Beth. But honestly: Jo is the one. Jo is the one I most relate to. She's the artist. The tomboy. The independent wild spirit. The one who is afraid to make the wrong choice. The one who sticks to her guns.
I still am not really reconciled to the fact that she and Laurie did not end up together - HOWEVER, I can see Jo's point. They were like brother and sister. But ... but ... but ... couldn't that have segued into a love thing? The intimacy they have together, the comfort?
When I was a kid, I HATED the professor. With his stupid German accent, and his goofy poetry as he wooed Jo. I resented the fact that he wasn't Laurie. I loved Laurie.
Now I know that Louisa May Alcott was forced by her publishers to marry Jo off. She wanted her to stay single. And if you really think about it, THAT would be much more logical - it makes much more sense that Jo, even with all her passion, and her ability to understand men (in a way that Meg, the one with all the love affairs, doesn't) - would choose to spend her life alone. She would marry her writing. In that day and age, those were the choices. It was the choice Louisa May Alcott herself made. She could not submit to the demands of wifehood and motherhood - it would infringe on her writing. She knew it, even when she was 15 years old, and wrote in her journal: "I will do something by and by. Don’t care what, teach, sew, act, write, anything to help the family; and I’ll be rich and famous and happy before I die, see if I won’t!"

Alcott grew up in Concord, one of 4 girls, and part of what we would now call an activist family. They were abolitinists. Social reformers. Her mother was a social worker. Her father was an educational philosopher, and had a belief in communal living (Louisa May Alcott wrote some funny pieces about these experiments of her father's, and having to submit to them as a young girl.) Her father (Amos Bronson Alcott - also born on this day) was buddies with Emerson, and part of the Transcendentalist movement. At the time, her father's views on teaching were very controversial: He actually believed that students should enjoy learning. Heaven forbid! He thought that students should be actively involved in their own education, and not just sit back and be passive little drones. Her father thought it was very important to have a beautiful classroom - not just desks and a chalkboard. He poured his heart (and finances) into a school - which ran for a couple of years - but then went under, putting the family at financial risk. Louisa May Alcott eventually, many years later, would be pretty much the sole supporter of her parents. She made a ton of money DURING her lifetime, which is quite rare. Her parents just weren't the money-making types - obviously. As a young teenager Louisa May Alcott had a passionate girlish love of Emerson - a crush, if you will. His intellect, his library that she was allowed to use, whatever ... She adored him.
In 1862, Alcott (as always, determined to make a living - and to contribute financially to her family) traveled to Washington DC as a Civil War nurse. By this point, Alcott had already started getting stuff published - poems, short stories in the Gothic melodramatic vein ... She actually preferred Gothic melodramas to the kinds of books that later would make her name. (She despised Little Women and found the writing of it extremely tedious.) Her experience as a nurse in the Civil War prompted her to publish a book called Hospital Sketches. At that point, her publisher asked her if she would write a book "for girls". Never one to back off from a challenge, Louisa May Alcott sat down and wrote Little Women in two months. She had grown up with 3 sisters - and she put her entire childhood and life into that book, even as she hated doing it, and didn't think the book would amount to much.
Little Women was published in 1868 and was an immediate rip-roaring success. The publisher, within only a couple of weeks of its publication, begged Alcott to get to work on a sequel. So Alcott did. Another smash success. Louisa May Alcott had become a star.
Every book she wrote after that was eagerly awaited for by a breathless loving public. Success had, indeed, come - her childish ambitions to be 'rich and famous' came to fruition tenfold ... but 'happy'? Was she happy?
She never married. She ended up taking care of her sister May's daughter - after May died from complications in childbirth. Being a surrogate mother to this young girl was one of the most fulfilling experiences of Alcott's life. She kept writing, kept publishing ... although she began to get more and more ill from mercury poisoning she had received years earlier during the Civil War (she had, like many other Civil War nurses, contracted typhoid fever - and at the time, the proscribed cure was something called "calomel" - a drug laden with mercury).
Near the end of her life, Alcott became active in the suffragette movement. Her father (an extraordinary man in his own right) had always been a feminist himself:

His passion was to see that his four daughters were educated, well-rounded, and part of the intellectual community helived in. (Some heavy-hitters there - Emerson, Thoreau, etc.) Louisa's father kept detailed diaries during the raising of his 4 girls, chronicling everything about each one of them. His whole thing was early education - the importance of the first couple of years - and again, you don't ever get the sense that he thought this was only good for BOYS. On the contrary. Here's a snippet of a letter Louisa's father wrote to Elizabeth Cady Stanton in 1869, which gives you some idea of who this man was:
Woman is helping herself to secure her place in a better spirit and manner than any we [men] can suggest or devise, it becomes us to take, rather than proffer Consels, readily waiting to learn her wishes and aims, as she has so long, and so patiently deferred to us.
In 1879, Louisa May Alcott was the first woman to register to vote in Concord - for the school committee election. Pretty awesome, huh?
Her beloved father passed away on March 4, 1888. Louisa May Alcott died two days later.
An extraordinary woman.
She didn't care for the book that made her name ... and probably wished that her legacy was different ... but that's okay. It is not for the artist to decide what the audience will react to, what the reader will respond to. She created something with Little Women that transcends the ages, that pierces through the centuries. It is a classic book. And perhaps it's fitting, in a way, that she wrote it for hire, pretty much - it was not her idea, and yet - look at what she was able to create. Look at what she was able to bring out!!
Those 4 girls are immortal.
When I was 16 years old, one of the assignments we had in our Drama class was to do a one-person show - maybe 15, 20 minutes long - based on either a real person from history, or a fictional character - and we had to come into the class as that character, and do a monologue - based on our research - and then take questions from the class - in character. I still remember my core group of friends and their projects: Beth came in as Mae West. She was incredible. She had on a blowsy blonde wig, and wore a tight sparkley dress - and I still remember the shock when Beth started telling us all about birth control options - because Mae West was an early champion of birth control for women. It was awesome. Beth was fearless. Betsy did Paddington Bear (and I still remember how one of the questions for Betsy was: "Why don't you eat some of your marmalade?" and Betsy - who despises marmalade - had to dip her hand into the jar, take out a big scoop of it, and eat it - pretending she liked it. Now that's dedication to the acting craft!). Michele did Marilyn Monroe. Unbelievable. Michele was an amazing actress, a natural. She got the sadness beneath the blonde glamour of Marilyn.
And I did Louisa May Alcott.
One of my first forays into the one-person show format ... I did hours and hours and hours of research for a mere 20 minute piece - because I had no idea what questions people would ask, and I had to be ready for anything!
It was great, because I had known nothing about her before that. I had just read Little Women and we had also visited her house in Concord on a family trip (a great thing to do if you are in the area). Orchard House:

Once I learned all this stuff about her, my admiration for her grew. I loved that our birthdays were almost the same. She was a Sagittarius too.

Little Women. I don't know if I would call it a great book - but I would say that it is something much better than "great": it is beloved. Little Women is a beloved book. And that is a rare and precious thing.
Happy birthday, Louisa May!

I got this from So Many Books - (which is one of my new favorite blogs): Fun! I grew up in a poetry-loving family - which i think is kind of a requirement if you're Irish - so this was really fun to answer:
1. The first poem I remember reading/hearing/reacting to was
Probably A.A. Milne ... the books When We Were Very Young and Now We Are Six were constants in my childhood. We read those books RAGGED. Some of it still comes back from memory.
For example:
They're changing guard at Buckingham Palace -
Christopher Robin went down with Alice.
And this one ... Oh my God ... I don't know it totally by heart now but there was a time in my life when I knew the entire thing by heart. I still loved to have it read to me ... but this was one of my favorites in that whole collection:
James James
Morrison Morrison
Weatherby George Dupree
Took great
Care of his Mother,
Though he was only three.
James James Said to his Mother,
"Mother," he said, said he;
"You must never go down
to the end of the town,
if you don't go down with me."
James James
Morrison's Mother
Put on a golden gown.
James James Morrison's Mother
Drove to the end of the town.
James James Morrison's Mother
Said to herself, said she:
"I can get right down
to the end of the town
and be back in time for tea."
King John
Put up a notice,
"LOST or STOLEN or STRAYED!
JAMES JAMES MORRISON'S MOTHER
SEEMS TO HAVE BEEN MISLAID.
LAST SEEN
WANDERING VAGUELY:
QUITE OF HER OWN ACCORD,
SHE TRIED TO GET DOWN
TO THE END OF THE TOWN -
FORTY SHILLINGS REWARD!"
James James
Morrison Morrison
(Commonly known as Jim)
Told his
Other relations
Not to go blaming him.
James James
Said to his Mother,
"Mother," he said, said he:
"You must never go down to the end of the town
without consulting me."
James James
Morrison's mother
Hasn't been heard of since.
King John said he was sorry,
So did the Queen and Prince.
King John
(Somebody told me)
Said to a man he knew:
If people go down to the end of the town, well,
what can anyone do?"
(Now then, very softly)
J.J.
M.M.
W.G.Du P.
Took great
C/0 his M*****
Though he was only 3.
J.J. said to his M*****
"M*****," he said, said he:
"You-must-never-go-down-to-the-end-of-the-town-
if-you-don't-go-down-with-ME!"
(I LOVED the stage directions part ... I LOVED that we had to whisper that part. Magical poem.)
Let's see. What other ones. Well, the Golden Book of Poetry was also huge in the O'Malley family - I can still remember huddling up next to my dad as he read the one about Annie ... in his gruff voice. We had some perennial favorites, ones we went to again and again ... and I can still remember those amazing illustrations that we would just pore over, greedily. My mother still has the copy of that book - I really should get it myself. Classic poems.
We loved "Owl and the Pussycat" MADLY - and this was one of the ones we knew off by heart.
I only can do the first verse now (I just checked it online - the other 2 verses didn't come right back - but here's the first verse - emblazoned in my brain forever:)
The Owl and the Pussy-cat went to sea
In a beautiful pea green boat,
They took some honey, and plenty of money,
Wrapped up in a five pound note.
The Owl looked up to the stars above,
And sang to a small guitar,
"Oh lovely Pussy! Oh Pussy my love,
What a beautiful Pussy you are,
You are,
You are!
What a beautiful Pussy you are!"
Another one we adored from that anthology was "Raggedy Man" ... and we LOVED "Little Orphan Annie" as well - this one I recall being read to us with threatenings of tickling torture at the end of each verse. I also can remember the illustration to this particular poem as well as if it were sitting in front of me right now. Scary stuff in this poem!! For example:
Once there was a little girl who always laughed and grinned
and made fun of everyone, of all her blood and kin,
and once when there was company and old folks was there,
she mocked them and she shocked them and said, she didn't care.
And just as she turned on her heels and to go and run and hide,
there was two great big black things a standing by her side.
They snatched her through the ceiling fore she knew what shes about,
and the goblins will get ya if ya don't watch out!!
Golden Book of Poetry. A total staple to childhood reading. I believe that that was where we first heard "Midnight Ride of Paul Revere" as well. Great collection - really fun.
And Mum and Dad: there was one about a candy tree??? Do you remember that? I can't remember the name of it ... but it was a long poem about candy in a tree ... bah ... if you can remember it, please let me know. I'd love to read that one again.
2. I was forced to memorize (name of poem) in school and........
Hm. I know I was forced to memorize a poem or 2 in the course of my education but I cannot, for the life of me, remember what it was. I know I took a class in Shakespeare's sonnets in college and we had to memorize those left and right. That was one of my favorite classes EVER. Love those sonnets. I read them outloud to myself if I am particularly stressed out and jittery.
3. I read/don't read poetry because....
I read a lot of poetry - and usually outloud - just cause I enjoy it. There's a lot of crap poetry out there, so I'm not indiscriminate about it ... you'd have to pay me to go to a poetry slam, for example, unless it was, you know, REAL poets and not just people who think speaking in some kind of rhythmic way is poetry ... No. I got me some standards. Sorry. Count me in with Camille Paglia (whose book Break Blow Burn is essential reading for poetry lovers. I love her anyway - but I just LOVE this book in particular.) I am also open to trying new poets. If someone tells me to read a poem, and I respect the person telling me ... then I will definitely check that poet out. I have been introduced to some amazing writers (James Dickey, for example, Wendell Berry) that way.
I find poetry relaxing. I find it intellectually stimulating - I like to read stuff that is not necessarily EASY, I like stuff which requires me to meet it halfway. Otherwise I get bored. I love TS Eliot. I love Wallace Stevens. I love Emily Dickinson. And also: I like poetry because sometimes, like a good song lyric, it can cut so directly into the heart of the matter - that I can honestly say that I have been subtly ALTERED in my outlook of things after reading a certain poem. There are poems that I have literally hung onto during bad times in my life - almost like the Hail Mary - something to be said every day, I don't want to say ritual - more like a meditation. I couldn't say that about a NOVEL, although there are many books that I love, and that have deeply impacted me, or changed me. But a poem can be a life preserver. Mary Oliver's "Blackwater Woods" has been a life preserver for me. It has given me strength when I needed it. It has helped me clear out the cobwebs or chaos in my head, when I've had trouble with letting something go. From the first moment I have read it it has been a deep source of ... strength, self-reflection, power, intuition, inspiration ... what have you ... Life preserver. Auden's "The More Loving One" has been another life preserver - I've written about my whole clinging to that poem after Sept. 11 ... and how that and the Hail Mary were never far from my mind, in those first weeks of terror. I turn to poetry for contemplation and, at times, solace. I also just flat out enjoy it. I like language, and I like people who are into language.
4. A poem I'm likely to think about when asked about a favorite poem is .......
"The More Loving One" is usually the one that immediately pops into my head.
But I usually have to completely discount Shakespeare's sonnets in order to answer this question. Because otherwise he just would take over, as he has a tendency to do, at least in my world.
Other favorite poems:
Yeats' "Sailing to Byzantium" and "Second Coming". Also "Among School Children". I would argue that those are 3 of the best poems ever written.
William Blake's "Marriage of Heaven and Hell" is scary good. Like Chaucer good. Every line is so profound that it's a bit overwhelming to read it all at once. But the guy was a genius. Keep up with him if you can.
And you know, I adore Christopher Smart ... something about him makes me want to cry ... Check out his life story. You'll see why. Here's a post I wrote about him and I include in that post the poem addressed to his cat Joffrey - and there's just something divine about it. And I don't mean "divine" as a silly adjective ... I mean it in the true sense of the word. I LOVE that poem.
John Milton's "On His Blindness" is almost too painful for me to read with any regularity - but again, I think I can call that one a life preserver. At least it has been. One of the most profound things I have ever read. Helps me to hold on. Just hold on. They also serve who only stand and waite.
5. I write/don't write poetry, but...
I don't write poetry. There are no "buts".
6. My experience with reading poetry differs from my experience with reading other types of literature.....
Oops. I think I covered that up there. There's a way that a good poet uses language and the tools of his craft - metaphor, simile, repetition - that is very specific to poetry. I find a good poem to be almost perfect in its expression of whatever it is: heartache, sunset, a flock of geese, a tulip - whatEVER. The poem can slow down ... a poem can linger on one thing ... and some writers do that in novels, but it is very tricky to get away with it ... because you have other things like plot and character to deal with. But a poem can pierce into the entirety of life through the mere glimpse of a silvery puddle or wintry branches against a white sky ... The stuff I love starts with the specific and then goes huge and universal (Mary Oliver just kills me in that way) ... but it's in the details, the tiny miniscule details. There are certain poets who actually teach me how to SEE. How to LOOK. How to go deep, always. THAT'S why I love poetry.
7. I find poetry.....
enriching. Fun. I mainly like to read it out loud. I don't even need an audience. I just like to pick up my Seamus Heaney, open it up, and read.
8. The last time I heard poetry....
Live? I may be blanking on this - I don't go out to see poets all that much - but I do remember going with my friend Kate to hear Nuala Ní Dhomhnaill read, here in New York. She writes in Gaelic - and her work needs to be translated into English (she never does the translating - she says she just can't hear poetry in English) - and so she came to the Ireland House at NYU and read. She read in Gaelic AND in English - it was a great night, with cherry blossoms falling through the air outside the window. That was ages ago, though.
9. I think poetry is like.... (free associating here - and I must add to the question: GOOD poetry - because so much of poetry - like everything else - is terrible - and I pretty much stick to the great ones, because bad poetry is, well, so unbelievably unbearable - worse than a bad book, a bad song, a bad anything ... Gimme the great ones, mkay? SO. GOOD poetry is like:)
-- a dreamscape
-- a brilliant insight from a good friend
-- a clear cold bell ringing
-- a tall glass of water
-- an "A-ha!" moment
-- kaleidoscope
-- a widening lens on a camera
-- a mirror
(And I don't usually tag people - but I'm gonna tag Annika here. NO PRESSURE, Annika. I still would just love to hear your answers.)
Please take a look at all of the words below - and work them into some kind of paragraph that makes sense. It could be a narrative. An epic poem. A screenplay. But please somehow work them all in.
cemetery
restaurant
pastime
twilight
evensong
bullshit
Turkmenistan
nonsense
epistolary
spheres
panties
TWP (as in: Township)
Glendalough
Narragansett Beach
Alexander Hamilton
Orion
Mr. Darcy
James Joyce
Milky Way
Mac Cosmetics
music
theatre
family
books
beach
peace
Versailles
medieval
bimonthly
entropy
sneer
mud
gloomy
enervating
mahjong
elixir
halleluia
blueberry
calculus
Scone
pleather
hat-tip
"Meh."
panties
(I got the inspiration here - so take a look if you want to just LAUGH and be in AWE of other people's creativity).
(Speaking of fascists?? No, no, come on now.)
I'm feeling a yearning to pick up her journals again. I never get tired of them. Ever. They've gotten me through some rought spots. Hm. Rough spot now, Sheila? I ain't saying. I just know that I always put down those journals feeling like a richer person, spiritually, intellectually.
There's just something about her way with words ... Her journals are extraordinary.
And this.
Not sure what it is ... but I just fall into photographs like this one.
... who just won the 2006 National Book Award for his latest novel The Echo Maker.
I have only read 2 others of his books - The Gold Bug Variations and Galatea 2.2. I tried to read his other books and got kind of stopped by them. The language was opaque. Or I flat out didn't get it. Especially Operation Wandering Soul. That book just ... STOPPED me dead in my tracks, man. But I gave them all a shot because Gold Bug Variations is one of my favorite novels. It is nearly impossible to describe (plot-wise), and also nearly impossible to describe why the damn thing just got so under my skin. It is one of THOSE books. I can't be objective about it, nor do I want to be. It got under my skin and has stayed there. I have read it again - since that first time - and it is just as good as I remembered. I've recommended it to people who then read it - and weren't wacky about it - but then I recommended it to my friend Ted, and the damn book changed his whole freakin' life. Ha!! I don't recommend it anymore - it's too specific a book. If you're into that kind of thing, you'll love it. If you're not, then you won't. So I guess you just never know. I don't mind so much if Richard Powers writes big hard books that sometimes I can't get into. I love to know he's out there. A real writer. Someone not trying to just repeat his Gold Bug success. A guy who hit the jackpot with a huge sprawling difficult novel like Gold Bug - and who has continued to push himself - even sometimes pushing himself away from his core audience. That's his right to do that. I'll stick with him. He's certainly a writer to follow. He's too good to ignore.
Since the masterpiece of Gold Bug (and seriously - I hate to even give a brief plot description - it's too daunting) - I read Galatea 2.2 - and I remember where I was in my life when I read that odd little book - a book with some of the most wistful yearning passages about love that I have ever read in my life. He's so heady, so cerebral - but then, on the flipside, he so gets that part of human existence. Yearning. The fleeting quality of connection. The sadness, the joy. This shows up in Gold Bug and it's what the whole story is about in Galatea. Finding someone who ... clicks with you ... fits with you ... cosmically, psychically ... those moments of connection that seem to be outside of time. And how difficult it is to walk away from those moments, especially if you are in love with that person. But the way HE writes about it is lyrical, elegiac. I read it in 1996 which I remember as being a rather difficult year. Someone I was madly in love with got married to somebody else that year. I don't know - and I was in grad school - and I was alone - and yet - this guy was marrying someone else ... the girl he chose instead of me ... and it just burned inside of me. The hurt burned. And I read Galatea during that time. The book - with its odd vision of unrequited love - or even a wistful looking back on a type of love you will ever yearn for for the rest of your life ... I ached reading it. It's this highly technical novel, about robots, and the English language, and circuitry, and technology ... but what I remember about it is the heartfelt ACHE in some of the language. Powers does that sort of ache really really well.
But Gold Bug is the one to read.
Holy mackerel.
Echo Maker is also on my "to read" list ... but I have to be in just the right mood for Powers. I need to be in the mood for challenging myself. For a book that does not just reveal its secrets, or make it easy on the reader. For a book that insists that you meet it halfway. I do love books like that (uhm - ya ever been around my blog on Bloomsday? Yeah.) - but not always.
Congratulations, Richard Powers. It's always kind of encouraging to know that an author like him - a difficult challenging beat-of-own-drummer author - has found success.

Love that guy.
Have a HUGE crush on that guy.
An embarrassing crush.
Like if I met him I would stand there blushing and tongue-tied.
It's his birthday today.
Happy birthday, Mr. O'Rourke!!
Why do I love him?
Example:
"Wherever there's injustice, oppression, and suffering, America will show up six months late and bomb the country next to where it's happening."
-- PJ O'Rourke
Or this ... perhaps my favorite line of his that he ever wrote (from an essay about traveling through the jungle and seeing tree sloths):
"Sloths move at the speed of congressional debate but with greater deliberation and less noise."
I don't know WHY that is so good - I just know that it is. I love his writing. Every single word of it. I like his writing because there's always a surprise in it. You know how some people THINK they're funny? As a matter of fact, it seems as though there is now an epidemic of people who THINK they're funny and who think quoting entire Seinfeld episodes will fool you, the trapped listener, into thinking they are witty ... or people who think that saying, "Alllllll righty then" makes them as funny as Jim Carrey ... etc. etc. I got news for those folks. Uhm - no. Quoting somebody else's humor does not make YOU funny. And then there are people like Dave Barry. David Sedaris. P.J. O'Rourke. These people are REALLY funny. It's hard to WRITE funny. A lot of comedians rely on physicality to get the joke across - but to do it in language is a gift. A rare gift. Like his quote below about boats. It's so dumb, it has a ba-dum-ching sensibility, it's almost vaudevillian in its humor ... but still. It works. To me, it works.
I read P.J. O'Rourke's essay about Haiti and how horrible it is - and yet some of his sentences make me guffaw and have to stop reading for a second. It's not that he doesn't take conflict seriously - it's that no matter what the hell is going on, he is aware that there is a level of absurdity to it all.
Here are some of my favorite quotes from his books:
-- A hat should be taken off when you greet a lady and left off for the rest of your life. Nothing looks more stupid than a hat.
-- Fish is the only food that is considered spoiled once it smells like what it is.
-- With Epcot Center the Disney corporation has accomplished something I didn't think possible in today's world. They have created a land of make-believe that's worse than regular life.
-- In fact, safety has no place anywhere. Everything that's fun in life is dangerous. Horse races, for instance, are very dangerous. But attempt to design a safe horse and the result is a cow (an appalling animal to watch at the trotters.) And everything that isn't fun is dangerous too. It is impossible to be alive and safe.
-- There are a lot of mysterious things about boats, such as why anyone would get on one voluntarily.
-- To grasp the true meaning of socialism, imagine a world where everything is designed by the post office, even the sleaze.
-- The French are a smallish, monkey-looking bunch and not dressed any better, on average, than the citizens of Baltimore. True, you can sit outside in Paris and drink little cups of coffee, but why this is more stylish than sitting inside and drinking large glasses of whiskey I don't know.
-- Bachelors know all about parties. In fact, a good bachelor is a living, breathing party all by himself. At least that is what my girlfriend said when she found the gin bottles under the couch. I believe her exact words were, "You're a disgusting, drunken mess." And that's a good description of a party, if it's done right.
-- Ecology is the science of everything. Nobody knows everything. Nobody even knows everything about any one thing. And most of us don't know much. Say it's ten-thirty on a Saturday night. Where are your teenage children? I didn't ask where they said they were going. Where are they really? What are they doing? Who are they with? Have you met the other kids' families? And what is tonight's pot smoking, wine-cooler drinking, and sex in the backseats of cars going to mean in a hundred years? Now extend these questions to the entire solar system.
-- Are we disheartened by the breakup of the family? Nobody who ever met my family is.
-- It's hard to come back from the Balkans and not sound like a Pete Seeger song.
-- People who are wise, good, smart, skillful, or hardworking don't need politics, they have jobs.
-- Earnestness is just stupidity sent to college.
So good. (I love the wine-cooler detail. It's so embarrassing and so PERFECT.)
List of PJ O'Rourke's book here - if you haven't read them already.

She's one of my favorite present-day writers. I first discovered her back when her first short story collection came out - Bad Behavior. My first boyfriend made me read it - telling me I was gonna flip out about this chick's writing. I did. Her stuff is rough - or it can be. It's a lot of sado-masochistic characters (literally), homeless people, prostitutes, callgirls, runaways ... This was Mary Gaitskill's background, which she is quite open about. She lived on her own from the time she was 16, and worked as a callgirl and prostitute. She writes about what she knows. And her prose!! I have to be in the mood for it - she can be quite dark, bleak - and also ... how to say this - kind of matter-of-fact about the most horrific things. She doesn't write with a ton of emotion. It's cold, clear. This is the world that this class of people lives in. But that's part of the fascination. And also, it can't be stressed enough: these are people, she makes these people come alive, even if you hate them, or pity them, or don't understand them ... You feel shivers of recognition at times in some of them ... or she describes a situation with such accuracy that you know you have been there before, even if you cannot recall the particulars.
Her debut was a stunner - I remember everybody talking about it. It was a big deal. (The movie Secretary was based on one of the short stories in that collection - although she did say that it was the "Pretty Woman version of what she wrote" - which is true. By the way - I just went to the IMDB page for the film and noticed the brief plot summary - rated R for "strong sexuality" and also "depiction of behavioral disorders". Hm. I don't know what behavior disorder is in that film. Obsessive cleanliness maybe? She was in a mental hospital - but the story isn't really about that. She may seem odd, different, but mentally ill? Insane? The film makes it a point of showing that she is not, and in a way she is the sanest one in the film. Or is it the S&M that is considered a behavior disorder? If you think there's an easy answer to that last question, or if your answer to that question is a very quick "yes" - then probably Mary Gaitskill isn't your girl.). The story is way darker than the film, and the story doesn't have the nice domestic ending. But I loved that movie - they were true ENOUGH to what she wrote ... in its controversial way ... the freedom that that character found in a sado-masochistic relationship. How addicted she was to it. And how to her - that was love. And who is to say that she is wrong? Of course everyone in the film says she is wrong ... but she knows. She knows that "normal" love just wouldn't work for her.
Gaitskill writes about people like that like nobody else I know. It's not artificial, or ... self-important. She's not writing about a sub-section of society that she finds interesting - which can be a condescending stance to take. She's writing about people she knew, and about the kind of struggles people like that have. The ones who grew up being raped, abused, abandoned ... what happens to those people when they're adults? Can they just start having normal relationships? Or has something twisted in them, for good? This is an open-ended question. Certainly some people survive such abuse and are able to then join society in a normal way ... but Gaitskill isn't writing about those people. She's writing about the other ones. The subversive ones. The ones who love pain, the ones who associate love or sex with humiliation. You know those people who are just so attracted to the very thing that will be the WORST for them? Gaitskill writes about them. But the great thing - and you can see it in Secretary perfectly - is that maybe the larger world, the conventional world - would look at that relationship and think: "How could she debase herself like that? Or ... how could she "let herself" be treated like that? She obviously has serious Daddy issues ... and so she's looking for an authoritarian figure in her boyfriend ... and that is absolutely the WORST thing she could look for ..." And yes, that is A point of view ... but it's not the only point of view. The OTHER point of view is that that girl in Secretary actually chooses the only way that is possible for her. It is the only way she can actually have what others have (a mate, a home, safety, stability) ... and in a way, she has chosen perfectly. She has made the BEST possible choice she could make.
Excerpt from the story:
When he asked me to come into his office at the end of the day, I thought he was going to fire me. The idea was a relief, but a numbing one. I sat down and he fixed me with a look that was speculative but benign, for him. He leaned back in his chair in a comfortable way, one hand dangling sideways from his wrist. To my surprise, he began talking to me about my problems, as he saw them."I sense that you are a very nice but complex person, with wild mood swings that you keep hidden. You just shut up the house and act like there's nobody home."
"That's true," I said. "I do that."
"Well, why? Why don't you open up a little bit? It would probably help your typing."
It was really not any of his business, I thought.
"You should try to talk more. I know I'm your employer and we have a prescribed relationship, but you should feel free to discuss your problems with me."
The idea of discussing my problems with him was preposterous. "It's hard to think of having that kind of discussion with you," I said. I hesitated. "You have a strong personality and ... when I encounter a personality like that, I tend to step back because I don't know how to deal with it."
He was clearly pleased with this response, but he said, "You shouldn't be so shy."
When I thought about this conversation later, it seemed, on the one hand, that this lawyer was just an asshole. On the other, his comments were weirdly moving, and had the effect of making me feel horribly sensitive. No one had ever made such personal comments to me before.
And so. In her own way ... this girl knows what she needs. And she ends up choosing it.
There are no victims in a Mary Gaitskill story.
This is a tough thing to get ... but that's one of the reasons why Gaitskill is such an important voice. Because she gets it. Her writing idol is Nabokov, and it's obvious why. She has that kind of complexity, that kind of relentless honesty about sexual impulse and how often it goes completely against what society says it should want.
But it's not for the CONTENT of her stories that I love her, although that is one of the reasons why she got so much attention. They're shocking stories, if you don't read that kind of stuff, or if you have no contact with that totally fringe element of society. But I've known a couple of prostitutes in my day (I mean, not THAT way - ha - but just people I knew - women who supported themselves by stripping - also one of my best friends was a prostitute once upon a time) - and I've known a lot of strippers ... So I guess I'm not all that shocked by some of her stories. You know, shocked by what these people go through, but also - part of the appeal of her stories is the commonplace way she writes about them. They are not mystical weird creatures who live completely weird lives. They are not all raging pathetic drug addicts. Some, sure, but not all. Gaitskill doesn't write about them with the hushed sense of "wow ... check out THESE people ..." It's all very bland, and normal - which is part of the horror of it. They have apartments, they go get Starbucks in the morning, they maybe want to go to art school, or law school ... You know, regular. Of course there's a lot of CRAP there as well ... the stories!! And the reasons WHY women make the choice to live that life are as random and diverse as the reasons why anybody does anything. So ... the content isn't really the draw, although I know it is for a lot of people - because it's a part of the population that isn't really, uhm, known. Except Biblically, of course. Still, though - it's totally peripheral. Under rug swept. Existing, but not acknowledged openly.
The draw for me is her writing, which still never ceases to stun me. She's the kind of writer where occasionally I have to put down the book, after some particularly good sentence, and just sit with it for a second. She's that good.
I have not read her latest novel - Veronica - which was a finalist for the National Book Award this year. I have heard certain critics describe it as a masterpiece, which is rather thrilling. After Bad Behavior made such a huge splash - she came out with her first novel: Two Girls Fat and Thin - which I remember not being wacky about. It might have been partly because of where I was at in my life at that point. I had just moved to Chicago, and was living in my little grey-carpeted studio apartment - and I shivered with adrenaline and possibility - but also - I wasn't really in a mood to concentrate. I remember vividly the books I read from that time in my life - as I remember everything about that time in my life (the music I was into, the food, the clothes) ... I read The Passion by Jeanette Winterson - now THAT was a book I could click into - and I read Lives of the Saints - by Nancy Lemann (a marvelous comedic book - made me laugh out loud - if Flannery O'Connor had a slapstick sensibility, she would have written this book - wonderful) - I read State of Grace by Joy Williams (terrific. But kind of stream-of-conscious - poetic - didn't make TOO many demands on me - I have since gone back and re-read it and found: wow, I didn't get SO much of this the first time around!! It was because I was so self-absorbed that everything I read HAD to somehow speak directly into my experience. That was just the mood I was in.) And for whatever reason - two Girls Fat and Thin was a letdown - I felt alienated by it. And it upset me. The sado-masochistic stuff seemed crueller than in Bad Behavior - I felt really sad reading this book. And I was NOT into feeling sad. I was NOT into feeling upset or contemplative. I described that part of my life a bit here. I feel the need to go back and read it again - just to see if my first impression was right. I have talked to other Gaitskill fans who loved it - so I think it might have been me.
She has also come out with another collection of short stories called Because They Wanted To which I just finished - and loved. LOVED. I posted an excerpt from one of the stories here. The last story, a four-parter called "The Wrong Thing" made me cry. It's one of her few first-person narratives - and the VOICE! It's so specific. So ... upsetting (if you're not in the mood for it.) I have to feel on pretty sturdy ground in order to be able to deal with Gaitskill. If I'm having a blue day ... or a blue month ... she's one of the writers I stay FAR away from. She doesn't wallow. She doesn't mope. None of her characters mope. That is what is so tragic about them. They survive. They are survivors. And there is something beautiful about survival but oh, there can be such sadness there too. When you have a consciousness of what you have lost along the way. Gaitskill writes about those moments ... those moments when you realize what you have lost.
Here's an excerpt from the story I mentioned above - the four-parter called "The Wrong Thing". I found this story almost unbearably sad. I read it recently and I have felt like I have been on a bit shaky ground these past couple months ... and maybe 5 or 6 pages in, I had to make a choice ... should I go on with this? Should I keep reading? I decided Yes, I would. But I went slowly, and I was very gentle with myself as I did so. My friends will know what I mean. I didn't let my mind wander into my own life experiences too much as I read, I didn't let myself identify too much with the narrator - even though my heart and soul felt completely exposed by that story - but I kept a bit of distance, which seemed necessary in order for me to be able to complete the story. It's a testament to Gaitskill's writer - and my regard for her - that even with such an un-balancing experience - I finished the story, and sat for a bit, profoundly moved. It was as though someone had pressed their finger into my skin - and for a second, the skin didn't bounce back.
Here's the opening of that story:
Today the clerk in the fancy deli next door asked me how I was, and I said, "I have deep longings that will never be satisfied." I go in there all the time, so I thought it was okay. But she frowned slightly and said, "Is it the weather that does it to you?" "No," I said, "it's just my personality." She laughed.It's the kind of thing that I enjoy saying at the moment but that has a nasty reverb. I want it to be a joke, but I'm afraid it's not.
Last week a woman I have not spoken to for years called to tell me that someone I used to have sex with had died of a drug overdose. I was shocked to hear it, but not especially sorry. He'd had a certain fey glamour and a knack for erotic choas that was both exhilarating and horrible, but he was essentially an absurdly cruel, absurdly unhappy person, and I thought that, in the end, he was probably quite relieved to go. I had not seen him in ten years, and our association had been pornographic, loveless, and stupid. We had had certain bright moments of camaraderie and high jinks, but none of it justified the feelings I'd had for him. Even now he occasionally appears in my dreams -- loving and tender, smiling as he hands me, variously, a candy bar, a brightly striped glass ball, a strawberry-scented candle. In one dream he grew wings and flew to South America with me clinging to his back, ribbons flying from our hair and feet.
"I know he hurt you," my friend said. "But I think he hurt himself a lot more."
"Yeah," I said. "He did."
When I got off the phone, I sat still for some moments. Then I got up and dressed for the party I was about to attend. It was a birthday party for an acquaintance, a self-described pro-sex feminist who had created a public niche for herself as a pornographer and talk-show guest. I put on a see-through blouse, a black bra, a tiny black skirt, high-heeled boots, and a ratty black wig I had found in the bargain bin of a used-clothing store.
I took a taxi to the party, and the driver, whom I had engaged in conversation, commented on my clothes. "I just wondered," he said, "why you're dressed so, well, so ... I mean ..."
"You mean like a slut?"
"Uh, yeah." He glanced in his rearview. "Not that I'm saying anything."
"It's okay," I said. "It's because I think it's fun. It's not a big scary sex thing. It's an enthusiastic, participatory kind of thing. Besides, I'm thirty-nine, and pretty soon I won't be able to do it anymore, because I'll be an old bag."
He nodded thoughtfully. "Well, that's cool," he said. "It's just that you don't seem like the type who needs the attention."
His comment was so touching that it made me feel maudlin, and feeling maudlin made me feel belligerent. "A guy I used to be involved with used to criticize me for not dressing slutty enough," I said. "He said I wasn't much of a girl. He'd probably like what I've got on, but the little jerk is dead now." I dug around in my bag for the fare. The driver's eyes flashed urgently in his rearview.
Happy birthday Mary Gaitskill - I look forward to all the books you have yet to write.
I really enjoyed reading this post on the experience of reading Proust.
It sounds kind of marvelous, actually - and I have put off reading Proust because it's just daunting and huge, etc. My father has been working on the Things Past (not sure the new translation's name now) for a couple years now. He takes breaks, puts it down, reads something else, picks it up again. But I know he is totally enjoying his Proustian experience.
Memory resides in the senses. It's not something in your BRAIN ... although your cognitive mind can also retain memories. Memories assault you through what you smell, what you hear (a certain strain of music doesn't just remind you of 3rd grade - you feel like you are suddenly back there), what you touch ...
From what I understand, this is Proust's way in as well.
I wonder if neuroscientists read Proust. It seems very much the kind of thing they would be interested in. I have a friend going for his degree at this moment - and I know they do a lot of work with actors - because, just in terms of sense memory, and emotional memory - and how do you call up memories that can make you cry, or transport you into another emotional state ... and how do you do this on purpose ... Actors know how to do this. It is their job to know how to do this. Everyone has those rushes of memory come over them from time to time, swept away by the smell of cinnamon, or a certain candle ... but to decide to do this ... This is another thing entirely.
I should ask him about Proust. I will!!
A certain smell, or sound, or touch can open doors in the long hallway of your mind ... stuff flows out, you remember things ... entire experiences leap out at you three-dimensionally ... You can even feel like you are actually back in time. We all know that sensation - I guess it's a version of deja vu ... but different. A flash of "oh, I know this ... I have lived this ..."
I remember that Deli Guy had read Things Past all the way through. For some reason, that thought is really moving to me.
Oh - and my parents went to go see Little Miss Sunshine and of course Steve Carell plays a morose Proust scholar (the thought just tickles me no end) - and my father just thought it was hysterical.
Here's a link to the whole Proust post again.
I gasped out loud when I read the news this morning. I suppose it's not a shock. He was 81. Before I read the obit, I feared that he would have committed suicide. But it appears that he died from pneumonia, and general weakening from old age.
The obituary in the Times is extensive, respectful, and very informative. I didn't know a lot of his story, although I have read most of his books. He's not an easy writer. He never takes the easy way. He has many detractors. His book Confessions of Nat Turner will probably be held against him in certain circles forever (oh, whatEVER). As well as Sophie's Choice - which, while obviously highly praised and made into this major successful movie - also has its detractors. But vengeance was his - at least in the form of success. Pulitzer Prizes, Book Awards galore. He was a heavy-hitter, one of the few in the current-day pantheon. His books were anticipated, waited for. Many people disliked them. Hardly anybody was indifferent. I read Confessions - a long time ago - and I also read Sophie's Choice - I read that one when I was in high school, and I read it after I saw the movie - which pretty much made such a deep impression on me that it took weeks to regain my balance. I had to read the book. The book is much darker than the film - and also - it is incredibly graphic, sexually. I mean, you get that sense in the film - how Sophie tries to narcotize herself through sex - it's a drug, to forget, to lose herself ... and I had never read such explicit scenes. I was, like, 15 or something. But the movie had had such an impact that I couldn't let it go, and I plowed through that dark, wrenching, unforgiving, TERRIBLE book - because I needed to still be in that place, I couldn't go back to who I was before I met Sophie. Not yet, anyway.
And then - many years later - in response to Primo Levi's suicide - which many people were outraged by (this was a man who survived Auschwitz ... how DARE he take his own life??) - William Styron wrote a small book about his own depression (which, I agree with Styron - is completely the wrong word for the actual phenomenon. He prefers "brainstorm".) But anyway, Styron was angry at what he saw as a total lack of understanding at what depression actually WAS - and to take your own life, as Mr. Levi had done, was a completely personal decision, and only someone who had actually experienced a "brainstorm" could understand. Otherwise, shut the hell up. His book - called Darkness Visible is, in my estimation, one of the most accurate and piercing descriptions of the EXPERIENCE of depression in existence. I know there are many other books and memoirs out there about being depressed, blah blah ... but if you're interested in that kind of literature, then THIS is the book to read. It's short, it started as an op-ed column, written in response and protest to the general TONE of all of the obituaries for Mr. Levi. And it generated such a storm of positive response - people writing in saying, "This is EXACTLY what it feels like ..." - that he expanded it into a lecture - which then was published in book-form.
And what a book it is. What a gift. It's not an easy read. He describes it so well that at one point I did think, "I certainly would not blame you, sir, if you chose to end this agony."
Anyway, a marvelous writer - thinker - speaker. A tempestuous man, who stood strong against his many critics. Who wrote what he wanted to write. Who didn't bend to political correctness, or to bullying from those who said he, a white man, could NEVER write from the perspective of a black man ... or a female Polish Holocaust survivor ... or whatever. You name it. He got it with almost every book he wrote. Even his depression memoir got criticized from the usual suspects - who said: I know what depression REALLY is. Mr. Styron is just dabbling. Something in him rubbed people the wrong way.
But he could write. He really could.
I had a moment of deep sadness this morning, realizing that he was gone.
Rest in peace.
(Again, here's the obituary.)
And here's a post with a lot of Styron links.
Beautiful thoughts here. I totally agree.
And this elegy brought tears to my eyes.
Today is Sylvia Plath's birthday, and here's an old post I wrote about her, with some new stuff added. It feels a bit strange to say "Happy birthday" to ... uhm ... someone who was so ultimately unhappy, and someone who took her own life ... But I saw that it was her birthday today and I had to say something.
That's a sketch she did of her own hands. She found drawing very relaxing. She would lose herself in it, and spent most of her honeymoon in Spain (a place she found almost unbearably upsetting - Ted Hughes, her husband, wrote a poem many years later called "You Hated Spain") - anyway, she spent most of her honeymoon huddled over a sketch pad. She drew the streets, the fruit baskets, the fishing boats. Was there pleasure in it for her? I don't know. I think it was a way to unhinge her brain for a moment, lose herself in the moment - where all she could do, all she was able to do, was just copy what she saw. She didn't have to find the right word, or struggle with the poetry muse ... she just had to sit down and copy what she saw. Ted Hughes wrote a poem, too, about her drawing.
I haven't yet written a real piece on Sylvia Plath - because I know when I finaly get to it, it'll be a doozy. It'll take me hours of research, and compiling quotes, and snippets, and poems, and yadda yadda. I need to have the time to invest. That's just the deal with certain topics - and Sylvia Plath is one of them. (However - now I have an incentive. RTG basically commissioned a piece from me.)
In honor of the birthday of this eventually astonishing poet (she didn't start out that way, although she was certainly precocious - but NONE of her early work could prepare you for what her work became in the last 2 years of her life - it's like another PERSON came out of her ....) - I have dug up some wonderful old photographs of her. She was a chameleon. She was an all-American girl. She was a bleached blonde beach-blanket-bingo girl. She was an intense prodigy. She was a depressive who had survived a suicide attempt her junior year in college. She was the woman who married the big brash English outdoorsman, and suddenly found herself fishing, and hunting, and tromping through the woods in galoshes. Who was she? I have no idea. But you can take a look at all the photographs and see how startling are the transformations. This is not just about the passage of time, and someone looking different as they grew older ... this really seems to be about a shedding of selves (like she writes in Lady Lazarus, in one of my favorite lines: "my selves dissolving, old whores petticoats") -
I look at the picture of the bodacious blonde at the beach:

This was from her summer of recovery from her suicide attempt in college. She spent months in an institution - and then went back to Smith to finish out her education. When summer came - she bleached her hair. Her mother - the controlling prudish Aurelia Plath - and yes, there's enough information out there on this woman for me to feel completely comfortable labeling her as that - was shocked. She pretended to be supportive - but deep down, she wanted a conventional daughter. Well, sorry, Aurelia, ain't never gonna happen. Sylvia tormented herself trying to be conventional (many of her problems arose from what she felt was expected from her - as a daughter, as a wife, as a woman, in general) - and bleaching her hair was part of a necessary rebellion. Also, she started having sex. Left and right. Willy nilly. No more good 1950s girl. That "be a good girl" thing had nearly killed her. Her doctor at the time encouraged this rebellion, and taught her about birth control, so she could at least have sex safely. This was a revelation to Sylvia. She was a very sexual person, passionate, kind of wild actually - even with all that "ooh, I'm a poetic prodigy" thing - and you know, the thing is - any type of artist will always be on the fringe of polite society. If an artist tries desperately to fit in to some mainstream - if an artist really worries about what an uptight person thinks of how he or she lives ... then that artist just won't survive. The strict rules on women at that time were fetters around Sylvia's wrists. NOT CARING what people thought of her - was one of the biggest breakthroughs in her life. NOT CARING if people whispered, "She's a slut." And they did. Especially when she got to England on her Fulbright. Tapping into her REBEL, into her "I just don't care" persona ... was really important - but ultimately, it didn't matter at all. Because once she got married and once she had kids - these old conventional "roles" started constricting her again (she writes about it extensively in her poems) ... It seemed that there was an incompatability: between the poetess and the woman. Could she be a wife and ALSO a poet? What were the expectations of her? It did not help matters (although she might have thought it would) that she married not just another poet - but one of the most important up-and-coming poets in England - a man who eventually (years later) would be Poet Laureate. Like - Ted Hughes was a big deal. And he was on his way to becoming a big deal when Sylvia met him. How can two poets tryiing to make their names - live together? Was Sylvia expected to be a good 1950s wife? Ted Hughes insists (and he has also written extensively about it) that he did not expect that at all. When he first met Sylvia at a party - they both were drunk - and they basically found themselves in an empty room - making out ferociously. Sylvia bit his cheek so hard she drew blood. They were married 4 months later. THIS was their beginning. There was no nice good-girl 1950s courtship. They didn't go out for sodas and a drive-in. No. They were bohemians, for God's sake. They were poets. People like that don't live by society's rules, nor should they. (Especially if the rules are stupid.) But Ted, in some of his later poems, has described how baffled and hurt he was - after their marriage - when Sylvia suddenly got writer's block. She had writer's block for an agonizing year, year and a half - directly after their wedding. Hmmmm, coincidence? I think not. It seems apparent that Sylvia was so terrified of doing BETTER than her husband that ... everything shut down. She then tried to be the perfect housewife - and ... Ted, again, was hurt and confused by this. Where is that wild poetess? Where is my crazy American girl who shouts out lines of Chaucer to the cows? Why is she in the kitchen, tears running down her face, trying to bake pies? I mean ... what has happened??
Then I look at the picture of her with her two kids (taken a month or so before she committed suicide) -

Actually, I believe her mother took that photograph during her fateful visit to her daughter. Sylvia was living in England - and her husband Ted Hughes had just left her for another woman. Comparing that photograph to the blonde bikini one - it;s hard to believe it's the same person. Perhaps there's something similar in the smile - there's something phony in both smiles, to my eye. Anyway, I find it fascinating - perusing the photos of Sylvia Plath.
Not nearly as fascinating as her poems themselves which have never lost their power - no matter how times I have read them.
I have gone through a bunch of Plath phases - and I am sure I will go through more. I continue to re-visit her work, every couple of years ... and re-read all those 1960-1963 poems again - sometimes in order - sometimes muddling it up - and every single time, even though I always have different responses, and sometimes one poem suddenly seems THE BEST when a couple years before it was another poem that was obviously HER BEST - but anyway, every single time I read those poems from her last 3 years, they take my breath away. They're no picnic - they are bleak bleak bleak - especially if you read them chronologically. If you read them chronologically - you can feel herself get manic - in October of 62 - and she starts cranking out 2, 3, sometimes 4 poems a day. These were not pot-boilers, folks. These poems are now taught in colleges. These are the poems that would make her name. She wasn't just scribbling out insane manic fantasies - these are highly intricate, passionate, unbeLIEVable poems. Obviously manic - when you see how many she was putting out a day ... and then there is a brief falling away for a month - December ... she was still writing, but obviously it was the calm before the storm. Then January and February 1963 came along - and I believe it was the coldest winter London had ever had - and her pipes froze - and she had no help, and two young babies - and things started getting worse and worse in her mind. And her art kicked in yet again - with ferocity and power. She would write these poems at 4 in the morning - her only time to herself. So you can feel the wheels start cranking again - in January, February - she wrote some of her best poems then. They are more frightening, however, than the October poems. She is staring at death, she is beginning to embrace the idea of death ... Death is always a factor in Plath's poems, but it takes on a new form in those last couple of poems. It is no longer just a fantasy, death is no longer a dream-lover in the night ... she is now making plans. The rage of October (which gave us such poems as Daddy, and Poppies in October, and the entire fanTASTIC bee-keeping sequence) is now gone. And you can feel a chilling resolve creep into her work. She is getting ready to go.
I have interspersed the photos of Plath I found with some of my favorite of her poems.
I still need to do a big old Plath fest one day - I have too much to say about her, and need to get my thoughts together better.
In honor of her birthday, here's one that she actually wrote about her upcoming birthday - in 1962. She wrote this poem, now one of her most well-known, on Sept. 30 1962 ... right before the blast of creativity and rage that would fuel her through that painful next month. Sylvia always had a fatalistic thing with birthdays:
A Birthday Present
What is this, behind this veil, is it ugly, is it beautiful?
It is shimmering, has it breasts, has it edges?
I am sure it is unique, I am sure it is what I want.
When I am quiet at my cooking I feel it looking, I feel it thinking
'Is this the one I am too appear for,
Is this the elect one, the one with black eye-pits and a scar?
Measuring the flour, cutting off the surplus,
Adhering to rules, to rules, to rules.
Is this the one for the annunciation?
My god, what a laugh!'
But it shimmers, it does not stop, and I think it wants me.
I would not mind if it were bones, or a pearl button.
I do not want much of a present, anyway, this year.
After all I am alive only by accident.
I would have killed myself gladly that time any possible way.
Now there are these veils, shimmering like curtains,
The diaphanous satins of a January window
White as babies' bedding and glittering with dead breath. O ivory!
It must be a tusk there, a ghost column.
Can you not see I do not mind what it is.
Can you not give it to me?
Do not be ashamed--I do not mind if it is small.
Do not be mean, I am ready for enormity.
Let us sit down to it, one on either side, admiring the gleam,
The glaze, the mirrory variety of it.
Let us eat our last supper at it, like a hospital plate.
I know why you will not give it to me,
You are terrified
The world will go up in a shriek, and your head with it,
Bossed, brazen, an antique shield,
A marvel to your great-grandchildren.
Do not be afraid, it is not so.
I will only take it and go aside quietly.
You will not even hear me opening it, no paper crackle,
No falling ribbons, no scream at the end.
I do not think you credit me with this discretion.
If you only knew how the veils were killing my days.
To you they are only transparencies, clear air.
But my god, the clouds are like cotton.
Armies of them. They are carbon monoxide.
Sweetly, sweetly I breathe in,
Filling my veins with invisibles, with the million
Probable motes that tick the years off my life.
You are silver-suited for the occasion. O adding machine-----
Is it impossible for you to let something go and have it go whole?
Must you stamp each piece purple,
Must you kill what you can?
There is one thing I want today, and only you can give it to me.
It stands at my window, big as the sky.
It breathes from my sheets, the cold dead center
Where split lives congeal and stiffen to history.
Let it not come by the mail, finger by finger.
Let it not come by word of mouth, I should be sixty
By the time the whole of it was delivered, and to numb to use it.
Only let down the veil, the veil, the veil.
If it were death
I would admire the deep gravity of it, its timeless eyes.
I would know you were serious.
There would be a nobility then, there would be a birthday.
And the knife not carve, but enter
Pure and clean as the cry of a baby,
And the universe slide from my side.

That's a picture of Sylvia from 1953 - right before her first suicide attempt. She was living with her mother - and her mother made her take shorthand classes and typing classes (again: there is something evil about that. That very same attitude is why Barbra Streisand has always had such long nails. People laugh at those nails, or make fun of Babs for them ... but I see them, and I love them. Because to her - those nails meant freedom. Her mother was pretty much totally negative about Barbra's actual goals - she wanted to have a normal daughter - so she signed her up for typing classes. In rebellion, Babs grew her nails to extraordinary length so that even if she wanted to learn how to type - she couldn't. The nails got in the way. So when I see those nails now - on a 60 something year old woman - I smile. It's a reminder.) There is a story here - of the mother who truly DOESN'T love her daughter. She doesn't. Otherwise - she would love her for who she actually IS, not who she wants her to be. Aurelia Plath never got that. Sylvia, at the end of her life, was starting to come to terms with that. She writes, quite blatantly, in her journal, "I can never live near my mother again." And her mother comes to visit in Oct. 1962 - right after Ted has moved out - to be with Assia Wevill - the woman he was having an affair with - and Sylvia was absolutely tormented by having her mother see her in such a weak moment. To her, it was unforgivable. She wrote her poem "Medusa" about that experience - which is, you know, shocking in its hatred, and anger. But again: poets who live by society's rules and play well with others are usually not poets to be reckoned with. Sylvia coming to terms with her rage was part of her finding her voice.
"The Moon and the Yew Tree" was written in 1961 - and is considered a breakthrough - by those who have studied Plath's work. In it - she finds some of that cold clear eerie imagery - that she will write about until the very end. She looks out her window and sees a moon, a church, and a black yew tree. It is a beautiful image - and yet ... in the poem ... it becomes a harbinger. Of death, doom.
And personally - I think the first line of this poem is one of her best lines ever.
The moon and the yew tree
This is the light of the mind, cold and planetary
The trees of the mind are black. The light is blue.
The grasses unload their griefs on my feet as if I were God
Prickling my ankles and murmuring of their humility
Fumy, spiritous mists inhabit this place.
Separated from my house by a row of headstones.
I simply cannot see where there is to get to.
The moon is no door. It is a face in its own right,
White as a knuckle and terribly upset.
It drags the sea after it like a dark crime; it is quiet
With the O-gape of complete despair. I live here.
Twice on Sunday, the bells startle the sky ----
Eight great tongues affirming the Resurrection
At the end, they soberly bong out their names.
The yew tree points up, it has a Gothic shape.
The eyes lift after it and find the moon.
The moon is my mother. She is not sweet like Mary.
Her blue garments unloose small bats and owls.
How I would like to believe in tenderness ----
The face of the effigy, gentled by candles,
Bending, on me in particular, its mild eyes.
I have fallen a long way. Clouds are flowering
Blue and mystical over the face of the stars
Inside the church, the saints will all be blue,
Floating on their delicate feet over the cold pews,
Their hands and faces stiff with holiness.
The moon sees nothing of this. She is bald and wild.
And the message of the yew tree is blackness -- blackness and silence

Little Fugue
The yew's black fingers wag:
Cold clouds go over.
So the deaf and dumb
Signal the blind, and are ignored.
I like black statements.
The featurelessness of that cloud, now!
White as an eye all over!
The eye of the blind pianist
At my table on the ship.
He felt for his food.
His fingers had the noses of weasels.
I couldn't stop looking.
He could hear Beethoven:
Black yew, white cloud,
The horrific complications.
Finger-traps--a tumult of keys.
Empty and silly as plates,
So the blind smile.
I envy big noises,
The yew hedge of the Grosse Fuge.
Deafness is something else.
Such a dark funnel, my father!
I see your voice
Black and leafy, as in my childhood.
A yew hedge of orders,
Gothic and barbarous, pure German.
Dead men cry from it.
I am guilty of nothing.
The yew my Christ, then.
Is it not as tortured?
And you, during the Great War
In the California delicatessen
Lopping off the sausages!
They colour my sleep,
Red, mottled, like cut necks.
There was a silence!
Great silence of another order.
I was seven, I knew nothing.
The world occurred.
You had one leg, and a Prussian mind.
Now similar clouds
Are spreading their vacuous sheets.
Do you say nothing?
I am lame in the memory.
I remember a blue eye,
A briefcase of tangerines.
This was a man, then!
Death opened, like a black tree, blackly.
I survive the while,
Arranging my morning.
These are my fingers, this my baby.
The clouds are a marriage of dress, of that pallor.
The Bee Meeting (this is one of the poems in her famous "bee sequence" - which she cranked out at 1 or 2 a day, during October of 1962.)
Who are these people at the bridge to meet me? They are the villagers ---
The rector, the midwife, the sexton, the agent for bees.
In my sleeveless summery dress I have no protection,
And they are all gloved and covered, why did nobody tell me?
They are smiling and taking out veils tacked to ancient hats.
I am nude as a chicken neck, does nobody love me?
Yes, here is the secretary of bees with her white shop smock,
Buttoning the cuffs at my wrists and the slit from my neck to my knees.
Now I am milkweed silk, the bees will not notice.
They will not smell my fear, my fear, my fear.
Which is the rector now, is it that man in black?
Which is the midwife, is that her blue coat?
Everybody is nodding a square black head, they are knights in visors,
Breastplates of cheesecloth knotted under the armpits.
Their smiles and their voces are changing. I am led through a beanfield.
Strips of tinfoil winking like people,
Feather dusters fanning their hands in a sea of bean flowers,
Creamy bean flowers with black eyes and leaves like bored hearts.
Is it blood clots the tendrils are dragging up that string?
No, no, it is scarlet flowers that will one day be edible.
Now they are giving me a fashionable white straw Italian hat
And a black veil that molds to my face, they are making me one of them.
They are leading me to the shorn grove, the circle of hives.
Is it the hawthorn that smells so sick?
The barren body of hawthon, etherizing its children.
Is it some operation that is taking place?
It is the surgeon my neighbors are waiting for,
This apparition in a green helmet,
Shining gloves and white suit.
Is it the butcher, the grocer, the postman, someone I know?
I cannot run, I am rooted, and the gorse hurts me
With its yellow purses, its spiky armory.
I could not run without having to run forever.
The white hive is snug as a virgin,
Sealing off her brood cells, her honey, and quietly humming.
Smoke rolls and scarves in the grove.
The mind of the hive thinks this is the end of everything.
Here they come, the outriders, on their hysterical elastics.
If I stand very still, they will think I am cow-parsley,
A gullible head untouched by their animosity,
Not even nodding, a personage in a hedgerow.
The villagers open the chambers, they are hunting the queen.
Is she hiding, is she eating honey? She is very clever.
She is old, old, old, she must live another year, and she knows it.
While in their fingerjoint cells the new virgins
Dream of a duel they will win inevitably,
A curtain of wax dividing them from the bride flight,
The upflight of the murderess into a heaven that loves her.
The villagers are moving the virgins, there will be no killing.
The old queen does not show herself, is she so ungrateful?
I am exhausted, I am exhausted ---
Pillar of white in a blackout of knives.
I am the magician's girl who does not flinch.
The villagers are untying their disguises, they are shaking hands.
Whose is that long white box in the grove, what have they accomplished, why am I cold.
Fever 103 (another Oct. 1962 poem)
Pure? What does it mean?
The tongues of hell
Are dull, dull as the triple
Tongues of dull, fat Cerebus
Who wheezes at the gate. Incapable
Of licking clean
The aguey tendon, the sin, the sin.
The tinder cries.
The indelible smell
Of a snuffed candle!
Love, love, the low smokes roll
From me like Isadora's scarves, I'm in a fright
One scarf will catch and anchor in the wheel.
Such yellow sullen smokes
Make their own element. They will not rise,
But trundle round the globe
Choking the aged and the meek,
The weak
Hothouse baby in its crib,
The ghastly orchid
Hanging its hanging garden in the air,
Devilish leopard!
Radiation turned it white
And killed it in an hour.
Greasing the bodies of adulterers
Like Hiroshima ash and eating in.
The sin. The sin.
Darling, all night
I have been flickering, off, on, off, on.
The sheets grow heavy as a lecher's kiss.
Three days. Three nights.
Lemon water, chicken
Water, water make me retch.
I am too pure for you or anyone.
Your body
Hurts me as the world hurts God. I am a lantern ---
My head a moon
Of Japanese paper, my gold beaten skin
Infinitely delicate and infinitely expensive.
Does not my heat astound you. And my light.
All by myself I am a huge camellia
Glowing and coming and going, flush on flush.
I think I am going up,
I think I may rise ---
The beads of hot metal fly, and I, love, I
Am a pure acetylene
Virgin
Attended by roses,
By kisses, by cherubim,
By whatever these pink things mean.
Not you, nor him.
Not him, nor him
(My selves dissolving, old whore petticoats) ---
To Paradise.

The Couriers (written in Nov. 1962)
The word of a snail on the plate of a leaf?
It is not mine. Do not accept it.
Acetic acid in a sealed tin?
Do not accept it. It is not genuine.
A ring of gold with the sun in it?
Lies. Lies and a grief.
Frost on a leaf, the immaculate
Cauldron, talking and crackling
All to itself on the top of each
Of nine black Alps.
A disturbance in mirrors,
The sea shattering its grey one -
Love, love, my season.

I think the following poem is the saddest she ever wrote. Now who can ever say what is in the mind of another - and it is always a dangerous thing to read too much into these poems (at least in a biographical way). They are, after all, art. But I believe that one of the reasons she killed herself is to spare her children a mother whose face was "a ceiling without a star". Not that that excuses her actions. But she wrote this poem in January of 1963, 2 weeks before she put her head in the oven. I find this poem nearly unreadable in its sadness. Yet - wonderful writing as well.
Child
Your clear eye is the one absolutely beautiful thing.
I want to fill it with color and ducks,
The zoo of the new
Whose names you meditate ---
April snowdrop, Indian pipe,
Little
Stalk without wrinkle,
Pool in which images
Should be grand and classical
Not this troublous
Wringing of hands, this dark
Ceiling without a star.

Sylvia Plath and Ted Hughes - newlyweds. Happier days. What a gorgeous couple they were.
And this is the last poem that Sylvia Plath completed. It's chilling, yes, but standing alone - as a poem - I think there's a lot to talk about here, a lot of stuff - not just biographical.
And I'm sorry - but the line "her blacks crackle and drag" is ... I mean, I can't describe it. It's just fantastic genius-level imagery, that's all. Goosebumps. The last two lines give me goosebumps. So scary. "Her blacks crackle and drag." (And yes ... let me just throw a shout-out to Paul Westerberg - who has also recognized the genius imagery in that line.) It's scary. "Crackle"? "Drag?" All kinds of very frightening images come to mind in those two simple words ... and the internal rhyme of "blacks" and "crackle" make it seem even more eerie. I'm not a literary critic but I will NEVER be done reading this last poem. She completed it on February 4, 1963. She killed herself on February 11.
Edge
The woman is perfected.
Her dead
Body wears the smile of accomplishment,
The illusion of a Greek necessity
Flows in the scrolls of her toga,
Her bare
Feet seem to be saying:
We have come so far, it is over.
Each dead child coiled, a white serpent,
One at each little
Pitcher of milk, now empty.
She has folded
Them back into her body as petals
Of a rose close when the garden
Stiffens and odors bleed
From the sweet, deep throats of the night flower.
The moon has nothing to be sad about,
Staring from her hood of bone.
She is used to this sort of thing.
Her blacks crackle and drag.

So it's Norman Rush's birthday. I decided to unearth an old piece I wrote about him, in the spirit of celebration. It's called "Waiting for Norman Rush". Re-reading it, I realize that - I sound very sad. Like ... very sad. Not sure what was going on there, or why I was so sad ... but I certainly would not write the essay in the same way now. HOWEVER, that's part of the lasting hold that Rush and his first novel have on me. When I'm sad and haunted and yearning ... the book is relevant. When I'm pissed off and bitter - the book is relevant. When I am looking to escape into my intellectual pursuits - the book is relevant. Weird. Not too many books do that. Not too many books travel with you through your life.
People who love the book Mating love it fiercely. I'm one of them. I am protective of it. Not only do I love it - but I feel, weirdly, that that book explains me to myself. At least it did when I first read it - and every time I've gone back to re-read it, I get something new. It continues to speak to me. Now that is a rare thing. The book is deeply personal for me, and I am unable to discuss it objectively, or to defend it. It would be like explaining WHY I love my family. Uhm - why do I need to explain it? I've told friends to read it and none of them (except for Mitchell) "got" it. Or - they didn't get what I got. And that's fine, this book OBVIOUSLY is not for everybody. I don't recommend it anymore. I came to it on my own - and to be honest, I can't remember why I picked it up. I had just read Hopeful Monsters and Possession in quick succession - 2 sweeping stories of love that cross the centuries. And I was in the mood for another book of that nature. How I tripped over Mating I do not know - but the description on the back of the book peaked my interest. I was interested, at the time, in love affairs that were not just based on romance or sexual attraction - but on intellectual compatability ... or intellectual combustability, either way. It's a rare book that tackles this. Or a rare book that tackles it well. To some people, that whole intellectual level of love is truly not important - or it's not that it's not important - it's that it doesn't even exist for many people as a priority, and that's fine - but for me, that whole intellectual level is almost everything (which is why I fell so hard for the doppelganger, so hard and so fast. It's why I rarely fall for people at all). And Mating is all about that. It speaks to one of the deepest needs I hold in the bottom of my heart. This is why I keep coming to it - at various points in my life - usually when I am wrestling with something, stuff I need to face, or stuff I need to let go of.
I have gone out in search of the positive reviews of this book - so that I could hang out with my own kind: those who not only loved this book, but who felt it was, in some way, really important. No other book like it, really. The vocabulary is daunting but for me that was part of the FUN (I get into that in my essay below). I kept a running list of words to look up - and also - as a lover of the Latin language (as a Latin lover??) - the book was SO fun. The text is peppered with Latin phrases, some of which I knew, some of which I had no idea ... but tracking down the references was a blast.
It may sound like an arduous read - but for me, that is not a bad thing. It never has been. I enjoy "hard" reads. It's all part of the life I have set up for myself - of intellectual challenge and rigor. I enjoy reading books that require something of the reader. I enjoy books that are experiences. (Since I was a kid this has been true. Which was why I read All the President's Men at age 12, why I read Oliver Twist at age 10 ... That sort of need to challenge myself has always been there.) I like books that take up a whole SEASON in my life. For instance: I remember "the summer when I read Ulysses for the first time". I remember the freezing fall and winter "when I read Moby Dick". I remember the spring AND summer when I read Black Lamb and Grey Falcon. And I remember where I was, and what I was doing in my life, when I first read Mating. It was in my first apartment in Chicago (the one with the creaky elevator, where I had no furniture but a mattress - for MONTHS). That was where I read Mating. Since then I've read it probably - 10 times? But I'll get to that.
I came across this wonderful review of it on Amazon, which is kind of creepy - in that I feel like I could have written every word of it:
I took forever deciding whether I should read Mating, whether I wanted to commit my time to such a long and apparently difficult book, whether it would be worth it in the end. I thought about buying it a number of times, but couldn't get up the courage -- what if it just gathered dust on a shelf? I borrowed a copy from the library, finally, and promised myself that if I hated it (as a number of my friends had) I would abandon it quickly.Now Mating is one of the few books I would want to have with me on a desert island. I can easily, happily say it was one of the great reading experiences of my life so far. But it's also a book that seems tailor-made to my sensibilities, as if somebody asked me, "What would you like a big novel to contain?" and then set out to write it.
There's a compelling narrative voice. There's tremendous erudition, so I felt like I learned something about the world on every page. There's a careful attention to language, and yet the language is free and full to bursting. There's all sorts of talk about politics, the history of leftist political movements (particularly anarcho-syndicalism, my own favorite), and utopia. There's a love story, but it's written about without mushy romantic spewings. There's an exotic locale. I'm a happy reader!
But you won't like this book if you're looking for a standard storyline and if you don't have patience for intellectual dialogues scattered throughout the action and if you want clean and unambiguous answers to everything. You also won't like it if you demand that first person narrators be always appealing. I found the narrator often annoying, but in the end was quite glad to have known her.
To have known her -- yes, by the end you speak of the narrator and her obsession and love, Nelson Denoon, as people you have known. (Or perhaps I shouldn't use the second-person here, since I know people who do not agree with me, who found the characters simply exasperating. So let me rephrase: I felt like I had known them.)
If you're fairly well-read, you can test whether you're going to find this book stunning or frustrating by playing a cross-referencing mindgame of this sort: Imagine that James Joyce finished Ulysses and was annoyed that his writing hadn't tackled all of the problems of human civilizations. Just then, a time warp appeared, and Paulo Freire and Emma Goldman stepped out and lectured Joyce for 40 days and 40 nights. He was thrilled. He began to write and discovered that a small part of his talent had been taken over by Charlotte Perkins Gilman, and another part by Don DeLillo. Ben Okri had found his way in there somewhere, too. Writing was hard with all those different voices pulling at him, but he got through, and the book he produced was Mating.
If the names above are unfamiliar to you, then ask yourself how you felt while reading it. If you made it through to this paragraph, and you're not mad at me for inserting the above (in fact, you found it piqued your curiosity), then you'll do just fine with Mating, and you may be deeply grateful, as I am, that Norman Rush had the courage and genius to write it.
Ha!! Yes!
Anyway, without further ado - and I'll probably write more on this - I'll never be done discussing Mating - here's the piece I wrote 3 years ago: Waiting for Norman Rush.

(Oh - and if you plan to read this book? There are major spoilers below. And it's the kind of book where literally - until the second to last line - you do not know which way it will go. So I suggest you hold yourself back from reading this - if you are interested in experiencing Mating)
Me being me, I have to back up a couple of days to tell the story fully. Actually, this is already inaccurate. I have to back up many years.
The journey begins in 1992 when I first read the novel Mating, by Norman Rush. I thought it was just another novel - but now I can see that the book has become a part of my mental landscape, a part of how I interpret events.
Today, that book is dog-eared from use. The cover is taped on. The pages are filled with underlinings. And in the back, on the couple of blank pages, I have crammed up that blank space with as many dictionary definitions of words found in this book as I could. The vocabulary in the book is, as my friend Allison called it, "daunting". I agree, and I have a pretty good vocabulary.
ressentiment: rancor expressed covertly against benefactors
proleptic: the anticipating/answering of objective/argument before it's put forward
omphalog: the naval/a center
copula: a verb that identifies the predicate of sentence with subject -- usually a form of 'to be'. "The girls are beautiful"
syncretist: attempt/tendency to combine or reconcile differing beliefs (philosophy or religion)
bolus: a small round mass. Greek: lump/clod
Expanding my vocabulary was part of the fascination of the book.
But the hold Mating had, and still has on me, goes way deeper than that.
The characters in the book (mainly the two leads: Nelson Denoon and the unnamed female narrator) live on in my mind, the way characters like Holden Caulfield do. Or Captain Ahab. Or Anna Karenina. Their life, their potential life, does not stop with the words "The End". You cannot tell me that Holden does not live. It seems an insult to Salinger's creation.
There must be an alternate plane out in the ether, with fictional characters wandering about. Not every fictional character, because not every author manages to create a living, breathing, human personality. Actually, "human" is too limiting as well. Because, to my mind, Charlotte the spider (from EB White's Charlotte's Web) lives on as well. She exists on that alternate plane. As does Wilbur the pig. It's sort of like the plot of The Velveteen Rabbit. Once the rabbit is loved, and loved deeply, it becomes real.
Nelson Denoon is real. Because I love him.
Mating is, on the surface, the story of a love affair. Other themes are: what to do about Africa, the problems with "development projects" and do-gooders in Africa, socialism in Africa, differences between men and women, competition between females for males (hence, the title), satirical observations about the ridiculous-ness of most of academania - and then, more specifically, an in-depth description of the world of Botswana: the diplomatic community in Gaborone, the issues with "villagization", the issues with development, how the development community lives high on the hog in Africa - etc. It's a BIG book, with BIG themes.
The main theme is something the author/narrator calls "intellectual love". Rush describes a very specific kind of love, and because he did so, and took such care with it, the concept became real to me. He articulated one of my deepest longings in a way I had never before encountered. It was like his words illuminated my own needs.
My utopia is equal love, equal love between people of equal value, although value is an approximation for the word I want. Why is it so difficult? Assortative mating shows there has to be some drive in nature to bring equals together in the toils of love, so why even in the most enlightened and beautifully launched unions are we afraid we hear the master-slave relationship moving its slow thighs somewhere in the vicinity? It has to be cultural. In fact the closest thing to a religion I have is that this has to be cultural. I could do practically anything while he was asleep and not bother him. I wrote in my journal, washed dishes in slow motion if we hadn't gotten around to them. I was emotional a lot, privately. I wanted to incorporate everything, understand everything, because time is cruel and nothing stays the same.
"I wanted to incorporate everything, understand everything, because time is cruel and nothing stays the same."
God. Yes.
More:
He was appropriate for me and the reverse. I felt it and hated it because it was true despite his being around fifteen years older than me. What did that mean about me? I also hated it because I hate assortative mating, the idea of it. One of my most imperishable objections to the world is the existence of assortative mating, how everyone at some level ends up physically with just who they deserve, at least to the eye of some ideal observer, unless money or power deforms the process. This is equivalent to being irritated at photosynthesis or at inhabiting a body that has to defecate periodically, I am well aware. Mostly it comes down to the matching of faces. When I first encountered the literature, I even referred to it privately as faceism. I will never adapt to it, probably. Why can't every mating in the world be on the basis of souls instead of inevitably and fundamentally on the match between physical envelopes? Of course we all know the answer, which is that otherwise we would be throwing evolution into disarray. Still it distresses me. We know what we are.
A couple of people I recommended this book to were extremely annoyed by the writing-voice, as evidenced in the passage above. But I love the voice of the narrator. It is cerebral, obsessively psychological, yearning, illogical -- It comes from right out of me. I relate. On some level, that is how I talk. Here's more. The book is encyclopedic on love.
If I overdwell on this it can't be helped: love is important and the reasons you get it or fail are important. The number of women in my generation who in retrospect anyone will apply the term "great love" to, in any connection, is going to be minute. I needed to know if I had a chance here. Love is strenuous. Pursuing someone is strenuous. What I say is if you find yourself condemned to wanting love, you have to play while you can play. Of course it would be so much easier to play from the male side. They never go after love qua love, ever. They go after women. And for men love is the distillate or description of whatever happened with each woman that as not actually painful in feeling-tone. there is some contradiction here which I can't expel. What was moving me was the feeling of being worth someone's absolute love, great love, even. And to me this means male love whether I like it or not. C'est ca. Here I am, there I was. I don't know if getting love out of a man is more of a feat of strength now than it used to be or not, except that I do: it is. It's hideous. It's an ordeal beyond speech. When I'm depressed I feel like what was meant by one of his favorite quotations: A bitter feast was steaming hot and a mouth must be found to eat it. Men are like armored things, mountainous assemblages of armor and leather, masonry even, which you are told will self-dismantle if you touch the right spot, and out will flow passionate attention. And we know that this sometimes does happen for one of our sisters, or has happened. This comes full circle back to my attitude about kissing, which he never adjusted to. You want kisses, obviously. But you want kisses from a source, a person, who is in a state. This is why the plague of little moth kisses from men just planting their seniority on you is so intolerable. Of course even as I was machinating I was well aware I was in the outskirts of the suburb of the thing you want or suspect is there. But at this moment in my life I was at the point where even the briefest experience of unmistakable love would be something I could clutch to myself as proof that my theory of myself was not incorrect. Theories can be reactionary and still applicable.
And now, here is Rush's (or his nameless female narrator's) treatise on intellectual love. It is the concept articulated here, the concept of 'intellectual love' which, for me, when I first read it, was like a lightbulb going on, or a door opening. I saw something within myself in a clear open light.
Intellectual love is not the same animal as landing a mentor, although women I've raised the construct with want to reduce it to that. I distrust and shun the whole mentor concept, which is just as well since I seem not to attract them. Nelson was not my mentor, ever. I gave as well as I got, with him. But there was intellectual love on my part, commencing circa that night.Intellectual love is a particular hazard for educated women, I think. Certain conditions have to obtain. You meet someone -- I would specify of the opposite sex, but this is obviously me being hyperparochial -- who strikes you as having persuasive and wellfounded answers to questions on the order of Where is the world going? These are distinctly not meaning-of-life questions. One thing Denoon did convince me of is that all answers so far to the question What is the meaning of life? dissolve into ascertaining what some hypostatized superior entity wants you to be doing, id est ascertaining how, and to whom or what, you should be in an obedience relationship. The proof of this is that no one would ever say, if he or she had been convinced that life was totally random and accidental in origin and evolution, that he or she had found the meaning of life. So, fundamentally, intellectual love is for a secular mind, because if you discover someone, however smart, is -- he has neglected to mention -- a Thomist or in Baha'i, you think of him as a slave to something uninteresting.
What beguiles you toward intellectual love is the feeling of observing a mental searchlight lazily turning here and there and lighting up certain parts of the landscape you thought might be dubious or fraudulent but lacked the time or energy to investigate or the inner authority to dismiss tout court. The searchlight confirms you.
In an interview, Norman Rush says:
I regard Mating as a true novel, but one that is essentially comic and based around a story of adventure and a passionate love relationship. That's the vehicle I used to explore very important moral questions, like What is good life? What is a justified life? Why is there so much lying in society? Who are the liars, and how much lying is socially necessary? The idea was to use a story of adventure and an exotic setting and a character who was relentlessly questioning, as a framework for these other issues.But the central point I wanted to be clear about in the writing was the importance of intellectual content in a love relationship. That was something I wanted very much to keep compelling. She becomes interested in "Denoon" because he is a moral activist engaged in the epochal enterprise of trying to do good in some practical sense. Because she herself is more jaundiced; there's something about this that creates a great attraction, and awakens a side of her that the world hasn't been so likely to acknowledge. As part of the first wave of post-Betty Friedan feminism, she operates with all the strength and vitality that brought. But she's a romantic, too; and a part of what she's doing is attempting to interrogate romance. She both partakes of it and doubts it. One of the ways to look at her pursuit of "Denoon" is as an effort to prove or disprove the equation that a consummate relationship with a man is possible.
To me, the book has it all. It has the love story, it has the intellectual questions I find interesting, it takes on big issues - and it also, in parts, is laugh-out-loud funny. Like - I find the narrator's voice inherently funny. Even when she is at her most manic.
Mating was the context in which I went through my major love affair, with a man who shall remain nameless, ahem. My friend Mitchell, who also read and loved the book Mating , referred to this man in my life as "your Nelson Denoon". "You know who he is, don't you, Sheila? He's your Nelson Denoon." The similarities were arresting, even down to the dogmatic anti-clerical attitude. But more than that - it was how she (the narrator) set her sights on Nelson Denoon almost from the start ... and how I had done the same thing. It wasn't just that I wanted it to happen. It is that it had to happen. And when everything fell apart with "my Nelson Denoon", leaving a nightmare in its wake that lasted, pretty much, for years, that book became even more of an anchor. I looked for words of truth in it, I looked for hope, I tried to tell myself "it all happens for a reason" (bah), I read it and re-read it, making myself stronger - making myself believe, yet again, that not only was that kind of love possible (of course it was - I felt it) - but ... it could happen again.
In the past couple of weeks, I took Mating out to read again.
It is a first novel, and what a first novel. Mating was a huge hit, financially and critically, it won the National Book Award in 1991. Rush clearly put everything he knows about everything into that book. In that interview I linked to above, Rush says (and I love this - it makes me feel brave):
Mating is the culmination of my writing life to date. The reaction to it has exceeded my greatest hopes and expectations. I was able to take the risks I needed to take, and am still overwhelmed with the fact I got away with it.
Ha!
The book is about love, obviously, but it's also about Africa, and politics, and socialism, and the position of women in Africa, and religion (what happens when 2 logical intellectual and - above all else - RATIONAL people fall in love? And also - what happens when one of them has an unexpected religious - or spiritual - epiphany? What will the fallout be? How does a logical scholarly type understand - or even ALLOW - mystery, the unknowable, the unanswerable? These are questions that have deep resonance for me. They seem to come from me - like the Amazon reviewer said:
But it's also a book that seems tailor-made to my sensibilities, as if somebody asked me, "What would you like a big novel to contain?" and then set out to write it.
And the ending.
The last section, a kind of epilogue, is called "About the Foregoing". It is very mysterious. It ends on a very ambiguous note.
She has left Africa, and has left Denoon, her great love. Things have fallen apart. Denoon has gone mad. She is now trying to get her life together when suddenly she gets a mysterious message, telling her to come back to Africa. It is not Denoon who calls her. It is a woman. She does not know who this woman could be. Or why she has been summoned. She obsesses about it, wondering what to do. Should she return? What would be waiting for her in Africa? If Denoon did not summon her, then perhaps she would not be welcome anymore? Or did Denoon tell someone else to summon her? Has he gotten better? Is he better? Should she go back? Should she go back?
After 5 or 6 pages of her obsessive worrying backs and forths ... the book ends with these two simple lines:
Je viens. Why not?
I have been haunted by this. HAUNTED. For YEARS. [Remember: I wrote this piece in 2003!! He had not published ANYTHING ELSE at that date!] Then what? Then what? It has been so long since Mating came out. I have tried to reconcile myself to the fact that I need to, a la Rilke, "live the questions".
The fact that the book ends mysteriously, that it could go either way, that you do not know the ending - you do not know if she and Denoon reconcile - or what happens when she goes back - the fact that this is left unresolved confirms for me one of the essential tenets of life: You just never know what will happen. Things can always go either way. Also: Things never really end. Not really. They transform, they morph. Love never dies. Ever. I'm not an "I love you I love you - oh you don't love me back anymore? Then I hate you I hate you" kind of girl. Sometimes I wish I were. It might be easier if love turned readily to hate, but for me, it does not. So alongside my relatively quiet life now are the vibrant love affairs of my past. They make me who I am today. They do not go away, or submerge into the past for good. They are still very much with me, late and soon.
And last week, for some reason, for no reason at all, I became obsessed again by the up-in-the-air ending of Mating. What does it signify? What is the message? What should I get from it?? It seems essential that I answer this for myself.
Also on a plainly literal level: What happened when she returned to Africa? Are they together now out on that alternate plane for fictional characters? I always liked to imagine that they were. It made me happy to imagine so. It made me happy to fantasize that on that alternate plane, all turned out well. Eventually.
It's a sort of "Somewhere over the rainbow" sentiment. Things may be lonely here on this plane, but somewhere -- even if it's just for characters in a book -- things might work out. And this alone gives me reason to hope. Things just might work out -- because the ending of Mating doesn't make it clear whether they do or no.
On a personal note: I used to have these old crazy fantasies about "my Nelson Denoon", fantasies which felt more like getting a glimpse of a never-before-seen alternate path. I comforted myself, after it was all over, by imagining that on that other plane, down that other path, things might have worked out. Maybe down that other path, he and I were sitting on that front stoop I saw in my fantasy - with music floating out the screened window - coffee cups beside us, a crisp fall air ... reading and not talking. But together. Together forever. I had mistaken a glimpse of an alternate reality for a glimpse of what was going to happen.
I became convinced that this was not the first time around for me and "my Nelson Denoon". I would obsess about it, even though I'm not a believer in reincarnation. It didn't matter. Something else was going on here ... it defied explanation ... and I worried it to death. "Were we married in another life? Or ... with each successive lifetime, are we coming closer to one another? It just so happens that I am stuck in the lifetime where it doesn't work out..." I was blithering like this once to my patient friend Kate. She listened. And then she said, "I bet that your Celtic tribe probably slaughtered his Celtic tribe."
All of this came up to the foreground again, in the last week, (it all began dovetailing), Mating was on my mind, and I thought, impulsively: "I should just write to Norman Rush and ask him what he's up to ... if he's working on anything ..." He hasn't published anything else since Mating, so -- I wondered --- is he chugging away at a sequel? Is he dead? I needed to know desperately.
I composed the letter in my mind. "Mr. Rush -- are you just going to leave me hanging with the end of Mating? Do you know how important it is, how essential it is in terms of my understanding of how the world works, that I know what happened with the two of them? Will I ever know the outcome?"
I have written to authors befor (and some - like Madeleine L'Engle - have even responded!), so it wasn't too far-fetched.
Then, a couple of days ago, I stopped off at a computer place to check my email. While there, I visited my SiteMeter for this blog, and I saw that someone had gotten to me by typing "Norman Rush" into Google. Google led this person to my blog - where I had written a piece on Rush. And this piqued my interest. Somebody else is looking for Norman Rush right now? Why? Is something going on? Has he published again?
So I Googled the man.
The first thing that came up was a Village Voice article dated May, 2003. I opened it, and lo and freakin' behold, it was a review of his new book. The man has a new book out. Mortals.
I hope I have conveyed how important this is to me. But I am having a hard time finding the words.
It would be like hearing that JD Salinger had suddenly come out of hiding and published a new novel. While Salinger is still alive, there is still hope that he may write again. He just might. And the book might be crap, but that wouldn't matter. At least not at first. It would be a miracle. To hear from that writer again.
So Rush has a new huge novel out. And again, it takes place in Botswana.
Mortals (and I just skimmed the article feverishly ... I didn't want to read any spoilers, no give-aways, nothing that would ruin the experience) is NOT about Nelson Denoon and our beloved unnamed narrator. It is another couple altogether, although Rush again tackles male/female relationships, only this time in the context of marriage. Mating was about courting, and choosing a mate. Mortals appears to be about making it work.
And here's the thing: (WARNING: SPOILER ALERT)
I raced through the book review excitedly and could not believe my eyes: Nelson and "she" show up in this new book - albeit peripherally. They have a guest spot, if you will. My heart pounded. These are my friends. And I have not heard from my friends in over 10 years. And, oh so casually, Village Voice reviewer states: "We learn that they have married."
I didn't read the rest of the review, I signed out immediately, paid my bill, and hustled my ass down to Barnes & Noble to find the book, which had been published THAT WEEK.
(Okay, let's just take a moment to reflect on how weird that is. Out of nowhere, Norman Rush comes to my mind, and I randomly contemplate writing to him, pestering him to write a sequel, and dammitall if he doesn't have a new book published on almost that same exact day.)
And there it was. A huge book. Hardcover. With a map of Botswana inside. I got a chill of excitement. I felt voracious. Almost sick to my stomach, actually. I wanted to download the entire book into my brain immediately. I glanced through and saw that there was a chapter called "The Denoons", and I had to restrain myself. Prolong the anticipation, more pleasure that way.
And as I was walking down the street, with my booty in my bag, I suddenly got weirdly emotional.
It was as though I had heard that real friends of mine had finally gotten married after much strife.
It's a bit embarrassing to admit, but I was almost in tears, truth be told.
There have been times in the past couple of years when life has been the cliched howling wilderness. "My Nelson Denoon" remains a kind of monument, a sort of goal. I have tried to knock him off that pedestal, but I have finally accepted the fact that he deserves to be up there. He earned his spot. My heart is open to others, but he's there, regardless. Whether I am with him or not.
When things did not come to fruition between us, my baffled thought was: If that didn't work out, that which seemed so damn right, then what the hell will work out? For quite a long time, my answer to that question was: Nothing. Nothing.
But then ... here ... years later ... walking down the street, knowing that she and Nelson got married -- after all that --
I suddenly felt an upsurge of hope. Not for me and "my Nelson Denoon", because that is no longer possible. But what I mean is: hope in general.
A word on hope:
Hope for me, now, now always goes hand in hand with a bittersweet and rather vague pain. Hope never comes by itself anymore, the way it used to when I was a little kid, or a teenager. I suppose that's indicative of age and experience. It seems so to me anyway. That's life. I am not saying this exactly as I wanted to. Basically: Hope no longer comes alone.
The sadness and hope I felt, walking down the street, wasn't about Nelson and the narrator of Mating being married... at least, not only about them. The sadness and hope was also from how I see life now. In terms of mating. I feel like I had my run and it was a good run. I had a lot of fun, a lot of laughs. But all that has stopped now.
So I got overwhelmed by this weird sense of sad hope --- the heart bounding to painful life again - a feeling that STILL, after all THAT, "things" might "work out". For me, in my life. It's awful when one becomes afraid to feel hope anymore, protecting oneself against the inevitable disappointment.
I am not a young girl of 22, with a couple of disappointments in my past. I'm older now, and I've been through a lot. Not all bad. Of course not all bad. Like I said: a lot of laughs. Much fun. But now, I just find it easier not to hope ... at least in that arena ... and focus on other things. My work. My ambition, my plans.
But ... but ....
They got married.
They got married.
What does that mean? For me?
Perhaps a breakthrough is approaching. A breakthrough in how I interpret all of this. And the appearance of Norman Rush's Mortals is the harbinger of something good. Or, something different. Something exciting, unforeseen, challenging. That's what I was feeling as I walked down the street, too. I'm scared of it ... and yet. Perhaps it is time. I don't know. Even as I write that, the logical side of my brain, the side that has all the experience, that knows the let-downs, etc., says: "Yes, but you have felt this before. You have felt this so strongly before. And you were never right."
But maybe ... maybe ... Maybe this is it.
There is SOMETHING weird about how all of this has come about, the chain of events:
My relationship with the book Mating
Mating being wrapped up with "my Nelson Denoon"
How I held onto this weird strange hope that things worked out well, at least for them
How I have always, since I read the book for the first time, felt like I was waiting for the sequel: "Je viens. Why not?" BUT THEN WHAT?????
Sitting down over the last couple of weeks, for no apparent reason, to study the book again
Feeling this urge to write to Norman Rush
And then - the next day - someone arrives at my blog, through Googling Norman Rush ...during the very week I was obsessing about Rush, and where he was, and whether or not he was writing something else
Then finding out that Rush has written a new book ... published last week ... in which we discover the Denoons have married
And so:
Things are not what they seem.
Back to the old painful belief: You never ever know what will happen. You can never tell what the future will hold. Your predictions will all be wrong.
I have tentatively and slowly begun Mortals, forcing myself not to browse ahead, forcing myself not to look for references to the Denoons. I want to savor every word.
I have waited for this day for so long.
Plath fans will recognize that name. That and Shura Wevill.
Apparently there's a biography out now of Assia Wevill - that's kind of an interesting article and review there - but it does take the "Ted Hughes is a villain" attitude which I find rather tiresome. There may be some truth to that (here's another recent article on Hughes) - he may have been a total bastard when it came to romance - but still: should we turn this man on a flaming pyre for all eternity? How sorry can one person be for having a damn affair? So I'm not really into the "Ted Hughes is evil" thing. Human lives are complicated. Affairs and suicides and emotions are not easy - especially not for intense people like these three. I've flip-flopped my allegiances through my years of being a Plath fan. There is never just one side to a situation like this one - a situation which is, frankly, a total MESS.
I don't know if I'll read the biography - but it was an interesting thing to hear those names, to have all of these associations come up in my head - just from reading Plath's poems, and all the biographies. She's a glimmering witch-woman in Plath's fantasy ... a sleek cold Germanic mistress, who slinked into her husband's life and whisked him away. This is Plath's side of things. But Assia, in and of herself, is not interesting. Or - at least not like Hughes and Plath are interesting. Hughes and Plath are more interesting because of their art and their fame. Assia is peripheral to the two of them - and it seems like she knew that herself, and that was part of her suicide. She would never "get in there" with Plath and Hughes. What did Assia do besides break up a marriage and then kill herself and her child? Not to disrespect her, seriously - but her interest here is how she intersected with 2 famous people. That's the fact. She knew it.
But still. I first read Plath's stuff in high school - and since then - I have read every biography, every critical study - I came to Hughes late, because I had a bit of that "he's a villain, I won't buy his books" feeling - which is moronic. The guy is a master.
What I'm trying to say is that I don't know any of these people - but just from all the books and articles and poems I have read - I got a jolt of something almost like fear seeing those names this morning.
Assia and Shura Wevill.
Fear? Why fear? I guess it's because I imagine Ted Hughes' response. Hughes' first moment in hearing the news that Assia had killed herself and their daughter. I mean ... the mind boggles. The mind BOGGLES at trying to comprehend this.

It gives me a shiver, a shiver of freezing cold horror, to imagine what Ted Hughes must have endured.
I made the quote page.
Oh and also - my name will be on the cover, apparently (you can see it in that link above). Many people are just listed as "and others". But there it is. I haven't received my copy yet. I'm all wacked out. I'm going to LA this week, so I'll miss my copy when it arrives. It'll be in my mailbox when I return.
I guess I'm in tears. Kinda proud, and happy, I guess.
The Irish Letters issue of The Sewanee Review. Coming any moment now to a bookstore near you.
So today, in 1847, Jane Eyre was published. Certainly it's one of my favorite novels - and ... what I love about it ... is how WEIRD it is. How ... CREEPY. There's kind of no equivalent. People who lump Charlotte Bronte in with Jane Austen frankly cannot have read her very closely. Or cannot have read either author very closely. What - cause they're both women they're lumped together? Lazy literary analysis there. Makes me mad, actually. Male authors don't have to put up with that crap. Just because Faulker and, oh, Cervantes were men - their books are seen as similar? Fitzgerald and Faulkner? Hawthorne and Joyce? Bah. Lazy. Would Jane Austen (and I love her too) - but anyway - would Jane Austen ever have her lead character, uhm, cross-dress??? As a gypsy???? To TRICK his little employee to divulge her thoughts? Would there be an insane woman locked in an attic? Would there be a moment when one character psychically calls to the other - across a great distance - and the other character hears it? (Interesting - I read a couple of reviews of the most recent Pride and Prejudice film with Keira Knightley - and a couple of the reviewers mentioned that the filmmaker was trying to 'Bronte up' Jane Austen. The gloomy moors, the feeling of wild nature on the outskirts, tramping along in the cold damp air, etc. NONE of this is part of the Jane Austen mood - ever. Hers is strictly an INDOOR type of literature - so there's a widespread conflation of the two authors which is not appropriate.) Jane Eyre is gloomy, gothic, sexy, passionate, violent, and - in the end - unbelievably romantic. But the romance in this book is barely civilized. Not quite as uncivilized as in Wuthering Heights - but pretty much outside the scope of respectable society. Which is one of the reasons why I love it so. I am barely civilized myself.
Anyhoo, in honor of the publication date of that book - I thought I'd post something that I've posted before - but I just adore it, so here it is again.
This is a letter Charlotte wrote to a good friend. The friend had written to her, asking her for a recommended reading list. Here is Charlotte's reply. For some reason, this letter completely delights me. I have it copied out and up on my bulletin board at home. I just love it:
"You ask me to recommend you some books for your perusal. I will do so in as few words as I can. If you like poetry, let it be first-rate; Milton, Shakespeare, Thomson, Goldsmith, Pope (if you will, though I don't admire him), Scott, Byron, Campbell, Wordsworth, and Southey. Now don't be startled at the names of Shakespeare and Byron. Both these were great men, and their works are like themselves. You will know how to choose the good, and to avoid the evil; the finest passages are always the purest, the bad are invariably revolting; you will never wish to read them over twice. Omit the comedies of Shakespeare and the Don Juan, perhaps the Cain, of Byron, though the latter is a magnificent poem, and read the rest fearlessly; that must indeed be a depraved mind which can gather evil from Henry VIII, from Richard III, from Macbeth, and Hamlet, and Julius Caesar. Scott's sweet, wild, romantic poetry can do you no harm. Nor can Wordsworth's, nor Campbell's, nor Southey's -- the greatest part at least of his; some is certainly objectionable. For history, read Hume, Rollin, and the Universal History, if you can; I never did. For fiction, read Scott alone; all novels after his are worthless. For biography, read Johnson's Lives of the Poets, Boswell's Life of Johnson, Southey's Life of Nelson, Lockhart's Life of Burns, Moore's Life of Sheridan, Moore's Life of Byron, Wolfe's Remains. For natural history, read Bewick and Audobon, and Goldsmith, and White's History of Selborne. For divinity, your brother will advise you there. I can only say, adhere to standard authors, and avoid novelty."
Absolutely marvelous.
Happy birthday, Jane!
Happy birthday to F. Scott Fitzgerald who was born today in 1896 in St. Paul, Minnesota!

Fitzgerald was one of those writers I liked right away, even though I read most of his stuff when I was 15, and was forced to for school. I clicked with his books, for some reason. I credit a lot of that to my 10th grade teacher, Mr. Crothers. His love of The Great Gatsby permeated his lectures, and his enthusiasm inspired the class. I really "got" it. I remember the book as being much much longer - which is so funny. I recently re-read it, and was shocked at how short it really is.
I already had a fascination with flappers (ahem. Obviously.) Not sure where the fascination came from. I think it might have had something to do with seeing Bugsy Malone on TV when I was about 12. Member that movie? Jodie Foster and Scott Baio as little kid gangsters and gangster molls? Driving cars with their feet like the Flintstones? I absolutely loved that movie, and I loved Jodie Foster's spit curls, and her costumes ... I remember, too, in junior high I did a whole paper on the 1920s for history class. I remember including photographs of flappers, and photographs of the cars they had ... I would insert stuff like this through the text:

I knew all about prohibition, I knew the music ... Oh, and I just remembered a couple other reasons why the whole "jazz age" thing fascinated me long before I encountered Fitzgerald: one of my favorite books growing up was Cheaper by the Dozen, hahaha, just thinking about that book makes me laugh. My cousin Susan and I loved that book, and we read it together. We would play with our Fisher Price little people (or "peeps", in the O'Malley lexicon) and we would make them be the Gilbreth family. 12 little kids, and a mother and father. Most of the book was, of course, about the crazy time-saving schemes that Gilbreth would test out on his family (actually, not so crazy - Gilbreth and Henry Ford were real innovators in this area) - making the kids wash dishes, timing them, and then figuring out ways to cut off seconds from the process. The last couple of chapters in the book take place in the 20s, when the older kids are now teenagers, and the whole jazz age flapper scene was starting to kick in. The older girls would have to sneak out of the house to go meet their boyfriends, the father was losing his mind, and the whole thing just sounded so hilarious and exciting to me. Especially the whole fashion part of it ... the skirts getting shorter, the cars pulling up in front of the house with Ivy League guys driving, waiting for the girls ... I loved it.
And lastly - when I was about 11, I remember my parents taking me to see a production of The Boyfriend up at the local university and I was literally swept away by it. The costumes, the music, the craziness ... I loved the charleston. I loved the whole fantasy of that era.
So when Great Gatsby came along, I was ready to just LIVE in the pages of that book.
F. Scott Fitzgerald (or - Francis Scott Key Fitzgerald) was born in St. Paul Minnesota in 1896. He went to Princeton, and afterwards joined the army. Somewhere in here, he sold his first story ... and when he was only 23 years old he wrote and published his first novel: This Side of Paradise. It was a smash hit - and was one of those zeitgeist books: it described the moment in time that everyone was experiencing (or, a certain set of people, let's say that) ... It was one of those books that is eloquent about cultural and social changes AS they are happening. Fitzgerald was immediately seen as the voice of that era, and that generation. The jazz age kicking in. Fitzgerald was the poster child. It didn't hurt that he was so handsome.

People projected their own desires onto him, their ideals for who they wanted to be. He was glamorous, urbane, free of societal conventions ... He lived the life others wanted to live.
And yet, listen to this quote from him: "What people are ashamed of usually makes a good story."
That is courage. That kind of honesty. So inspiring to me.
In 1922, he wrote in a letter to Maxwell Perkins at Scribners: "I want to write something new -- something extraordinary and simple & intricately patterned."
Such a young man. Such a broad and deep vision.
Around this time, he married Zelda Sayre.

She was the yin to his yang, she was the perfect partner in crime for that particular decade ... she did not give a damn. She was the Clara Bow for the literary set. She was who they were talking about when they talked about "jazz babies". The original flapper.
Look at their wedding portrait. I just love it.

They had their wedding reception at Chumley's, a former speakeasy and literary hangout at 86 Bedford Street, which is still there. I first met Bill McCabe and Emily Jones at Chumley's. It's the same now as it was then: no signage, nothing to say it's there. You have to know where it is. 86 Bedford, baby! 86 those plates, and let's get the hell out of here.
So Fitzgerald and Zelda married. They lived their relationship in public. They created personae, they acted parts, they showed up at places looking amazing, they relished in their own publicity. They kept massive scrapbooks of their clippings from the gossip pages. They were partners in all of this. Partners in self-promotion and self-absorption.
Here's a page from their scrapbook:

Zelda and Scott were like the Billy Bob Thornton and Angelina Jolie of their day. Exhibitionists, putting their own craziness on display, loving and living to shock others, having massive crockery-throwing fights in public, also having clutching make-out sessions in public ... It all was about being famous. But underneath all of that, there was this kindred spirit thing happening. You can't be in love with someone who NEEDS to be famous and not have the same need yourself. Or, you can, but it'll go bust. The two of them were in sync in those first years - it was like they were the same person.
Neither of them was ever the one to say, "Okay. Time for bed now." They were a couple with no brakes.
They would have drinks at the Plaza Hotel, and she would dance on the table. She would leap into fountains, fully dressed. She bucked convention. Just for the hell of it. She was the life of the party (while it lasted). She was wild. Just wild. F. Scott Fitzgerald was inspired by her, she was definitely a muse of some kind. He would read her diaries, he hoarded the letters she wrote to him, he was completely wrapped up in her glow. Zelda is a fascinating (and ultimately tragic) character in her own right. A girl who was completely unprepared to do anything useful in her life - pampered and indulged by her family who thought she was nuts, and also trouble, she basically set her sights on New York. She had the misfortune of marrying a man seen as the bright literary light of his generation - a misfortune because she had literary aspirations as well (uhm, echoes of Courtney Love?). Here is a small sketch she wrote about Montgomery Alabama, where she grew up. It is obvious she can write. Not like her husband, but she can definitely write.
There exists in Montgomery a time and quality that appertains to nowhere else. It began about half past six on an early summer night, with the flicker and sputter of the corner street lights going on, and it lasted until the great incandescent globes were black inside with moths and beetles and the children were called into bed from the dusty streets ... The drug stores are bright at night with the organdie balloons of girls' dresses under the big electric fans. Automobiles stand along the curbs in front of open frame houses at dusk, and sounds of supper being prepared drift through the soft splotches of darkness to the young world that moves every evening out of doors. Telephones ring, and the lacy blackness under the trees disgorges young girls in white and pink, leaping over the squares of warm light toward the tinkling sound with an expectancy that people have only in places where any event is a pleasant one. Nothing seems ever to happen.
There's a nice descriptive romantic quality there. She had talent. Only she had no discipline. None. F. Scott Fitzgerald, while an insane partier, a heavy drinker, a guy who stayed out all night every night, had great discipline. He worked at his craft. He worked hard at writing. He was always writing, and honing, and editing. Maybe he was hungover, but his writing was his JOB. Zelda had none of that. She couldn't focus her energies. She was threatened by his success. She wanted a piece of that pie for herself. She also ended up resenting how he used her and her thoughts and sometimes even her words to become a success.
But ... well, we all know what ended up happening to Zelda. I don't know her diagnosis - but judging from some of her episodes, it had to be pretty bad. This was not a case of clinical depression. It was psychosis. While they lived in Paris, she got it into her head that she needed to be a ballerina. She began to study. She became obsessed. Soon, she was dancing for 6, 7, 8 hours a day. But she was in her early 30s by this point ... way too old to be a prima ballerina. But Zelda didn't care. Apparently, too, she was a terrible dancer. Friends who visited the couple in Paris told stories (in letters, and later, to biographers) of arriving for their visit, and Zelda would greet them at the door in a tutu and ballet shoes. She would dance for them. Awfully. These stories are excruciatingly painful to read. Look at her wedding portrait. Her young wild face, those tiger eyes. It's just sad to think of her end. It really is. It must have been unbearable.
Who knows where the madness came from, or if the wildness of her behavior in her youth (jumping in fountains, etc.) were early warning signs - things people ignored and forgave her for, because she was young and free. Who knows. I read a biography of Zelda Fitzgerald last year and it was heart-wrenching. I actually had a hard time finishing it. She had a deadly fear of fire, she was like a horse in that respect - it terrified her - and how did she die? She died in a fire that broke out in the mental institution - she was on a locked ward, she couldn't get out, and the institution burned to the ground. It must have been shrieking agony. It must have been unspeakable.
But for about 5 or 6 years, the two of them were on top of the world. They had youth in their favor.

The Great Gatsby was published in 1925. Fitzgerald worked his ass off on this book - and was pretty tormented throughout the process. He wrote, and re-wrote, and re-wrote - holding off his editor, Maxwell Perkins, as long as possible. It was a precious book to him, a deeply personal book, and he feared he had not succeeded.
Perkins' long letter back to Fitzgerald, after he finally received the manuscript, gives me chills. I won't print it in its entirety - it's too long - but it's an amazing insight into the book, and also ... into Fitzgerald the Writer. The guy had an innate gift, yes, but he also was this major craftsman.
Here are some excerpts from Perkins' initial letter:
I think you have every kind of right to be proud of this book. It is an extraordinary book, suggestive of all sorts of thoughts and moods. You adopted exactly the right method of telling it, that of employing a narrator who is more of a spectator than an actor: this puts the reader upon a point of observation on a higher level than that on which the characters stand and at a distance that gives perspective. In no other way could your irony have been so immensely effective, nor the reader have been enabled so strongly to feel at times the strangeness of human circumstance in a vast heedless universe. In the eyes of Dr. Eckleburg various readers will see different significances; but their presence gives a superb touch to the whole thing: great unblinking eyes, expressionless, looking down upon the human scene. It's magnificent!I could go on praising the book and speculating on its various elements, and meanings, but points of criticism are more important now. I think you are right in feeling a certain slight sagging in chapters six and seven, and I don't know how to suggest a remedy. I hardly doubt that you will find one and I am only writing to say that I think it does need something to hold up here to the pace set, and ensuing.
He then goes on to list a couple of pages of specific criticisms. Beautiful to read. It's really just amazing literary analysis is what it is.
One of the criticisms is this:
The other point is also about Gatsby: his career must remain mysterious, of course. But in the end you make it pretty clear that his wealth came through his connection with Wolfstein. You also suggest this much earlier. Now almost all readers numerically are going to be puzzled by his having all this wealth and are going to feel entitled to an explanation. To give a distinct and definite one would be, of course, utterly absurd. It did occur to me though, that you might here and there interpolate some phrases, and possibly incidents, little touches of various kinds, that would suggest that he was in some active way mysteriously engaged. You do have him called on the telephone, but couldn't he be seen once or twice consulting at his parties with people of some sort of mysterious significance, from the political, the gambling, the sporting world, or whatever it mayb be. I know I am floundering, but that fact may help you to see what I mean ... I wish you were here so I could talk about it to you for then I know I could at least make you understand what I mean. What Gatsby did ought never to be definitely imparted, even if it could be. Whether he was an innocent tool in the hands of somebody else, or to what degree he was this, ought not to be explained. But if some sort of business activity of his were simply adumbrated, it would lend further probability to that part of the story.
After a couple more paragraphs, Perkins writes:
The general brilliant quality of the book makes me ashamed to make even these criticisms. The amount of meaning you get into a sentence, the dimensions and intensity of the impression you make a paragraph carry, are most extraordinary. The manuscript is full of phrases which make a scene blaze with life. If one enjoyed a rapid railroad journey I would compare the number and vividness of pictures your living words suggest, to the living scenes disclosed in that way. It seems in reading a much shorter book than it is, but it carries the mind through a series of experiences that one would think woudl require a book of three times its length.The presentation of Tom, his place, Daisy and Jordan, and the unfolding of their characters is unequalled so far as I know. The description of the valley of ashes adjacent to the lovely country, the conversation and the action in Myrtle's apartment, the marvelous catalogue of those who come to Gatsby's house -- these are such things as make a man famous. And all these things, the whole pathetic episode, you have given a place in time and space, for with the help of T.J. Eckleburg and by an occasional glance at the sky, or the sea, or the city, you have imparted a sort of sense of eternity. You once told me you were not a natural writer -- my God! You have plainly mastered the craft, of course; but you needed far more than craftsmanship for this.
Now that's the kind of letter you want from your editor.
The Great Gatsby was not the phenom that This Side of Paradise was. Reviews were mixed. Only posterity would put Gatsby in the canon.
Zelda had her first breakdown in 1930. Fitzgerald's drinking problem went to another level. He was devastated by her illness, and he was devastated by what was obviously a slacking off in his success. It's tough when you become a mega-star at 23. Anything that follows is sure to be a letdown. Fitzgerald needed to support himself, so he started cranking out short stories for the big mags at the time ... stuff that paid the bills but left him feeling empty.
F. Scott Fitzgerald died of a heart attack at 44, leaving an unfinished novel The Last Tycoon behind him.
Like I said, last year I re-read The Great Gatsby. It was like running into an old childhood friend. I'll re-post what I wrote about it back then, because it was fresh in my mind, and I was still on a high from the experience.
Happy birthday, Mr. Francis Scott Key Fitzgerald ... and thanks for your books.
Re-visiting The Great Gatsby
I just picked up The Great Gatsby again and read it in three days. (It felt much much longer in high school.) I was shocked and moved by how much I had remembered. The huge eyes of Doctor T.J. Eckleberg ... I remember the intense class discussion about what those eyes symbolize. The green light at the end of the dock, obviously. And there were parts that I actually remembered word for word, because of how, exactly, Mr. Crothers (my teacher) taught the book.
I remember the huge discussion about the following part of the book:
Suddenly she threw the cigarette and the burning match on the carpet."Oh, you want too much!" she cried to Gatsby. "I love you now -- isn't that enough? I can't help what's past." She began to sob helplessly. "I did love him once -- but I loved you too."
Gatsby's eyes opened and closed.
"You loved me too?" he repeated.
I remember Mr. Crothers pointing out that section to us, and talking about how that was the snap in Gatsby, that was the dream dying in Gatsby, that was the inner conflict of the entire book encapsulated in two sentences:
Gatsby's eyes opened and closed. "You loved me too?" he repeated.
Fitzgerald does not describe the snap. He does not have to. Fitzgerald does not talk about Gatsby's dream of Daisy, his fantasy of Daisy, at least not in that pivotal moment. All he does, all he does, is tell us that Gatsby's eyes opened and closed. And in that moment, a man's dream dies.
Phenomenal.
I would have missed that, in high school, if Mr. Crothers hadn't dwelt on it so specifically, and it all came back rushing back when I re-read it.
I might say that Mr. Crothers was the best teacher I have ever had. Period. He taught me how to write. Plain and simple. And you know how he taught me? I wrote a paper in his class. I got a D. My first D in my whole life. Panic ensued. Deep depression. Writer's block. I wrote another paper. I got a D+. Next paper: C-. Next paper: I got a straight C. It was a very proud moment. And with every paper, agonizingly, I got better and better and better. Until finally, light broke through, and I was able to construct a damn paper. I wrote consistently A-level papers in college directly because of what Mr. Crothers taught me.
This post is a ramble. Mr. Crothers, if he read this, would be thinking: "Sheila, where's the thesis statement??"
So here it is:
I had forgotten the stature of Fitzgerald's opus. I had forgotten how superb it was. Or: if I remembered it, it was in a taken-for-granted kind of way. Like: "Oh yeah, that's a great book. One of the best books of the 20th century. Whatever." I had forgotten the level of the accomplishment. I had forgotten how moving it is.
Reading it as an adult gave me a whole new perspective on it as well.
When I read it at age 15, I was completely on the side of Nick, the narrator: The relatively innocent and honest bystander, looking on at the decadence of Daisy and Jordan and Gatsby, trying not to judge (like he says on the first page of the book), and trying to come out of the situation unscathed. But by the end of the book, Nick is changed. And so are we, whether we like it or not.
But now, reading it as a grown woman, with a couple of failed love affairs in my rear view mirror, I found myself entering the story through the eyes of Gatsby. I could see myself in parts of him. It KILLED me. I understood Gatsby, suddenly. Carrying a torch for years, infusing everything with significance, poetry, choosing the dream-world over reality.
It is only NOW, after reading it from an adult perspective, that I can truly understand why the book is seen as such an epic human tragedy. An American tragedy.
Now I understand. Now I understand.
Those first pages are so extraordinary, so exquisitely written, they cannot be improved upon.
In my younger and more vulnerable years my father gave me some advice that I've been turning over in my mind ever since. "Whenever you feel like criticizing any one," he told me, "just remember that all the people in this world haven't had the advantages that you've had."He didn't say any more, but we've always been unusually communicative in a reserved way, and I understood that he meant a great deal more than that. In consequence, I'm inclined to reserve all judgments, a habit that has opened up many curious natures to me and also made me the victim of not a few veteran bores. The abnormal mind is quick to detect and attach itself to this quality when it appears in a normal person, and so it came about that in college I was unjustly accused of being a politician, because I was privy to the secret griefs of wild, unknown men. Most of the confidences were unsought -- frequently I have feigned sleep, preoccupation, or a hostile levity when I realized by some unmistakable sign that any intimate revelation was quivering on the horizon; for the intimate revelations of young men, or at least the terms in which they express them, are usually plagiaristic and marred by obvious suppressions. Reserving judgments is a matter of infinite hope. I am still a little afraid of missing something if I forget that, as my father snobbishly suggested, and I snobbishly repeat, a sense of the fundamental decencies is parcelled out unequally at birth.
And after boasting this way of my tolerance, I come to the admission that it has a limit. Conduct may be founded on the hard rock or the wet marshes, but after a certain point I don't care what it's founded on. When I came back from the East last autumn I felt that I wanted the world to be in uniform and at a sort of moral attention forever; I wanted no more riotous excursions with privileged glimpses into the human heart. Only Gatsby, the man who gives his name to this book, was exempt from my reaction -- Gatsby, who represented everything for which I have an unaffected scorn. If personality is an unbroken series of successful gestures, then there was something gorgeous about him, some heightened sensitivity to the promises of life, as if he were related to one of those intricate machines that register earthquakes ten thousand miles away. This responsiveness had nothing to do with that flabby impressionability which is dignified under the name of the "creative temperament" -- it was an extraordinary gift for hope, a romantic readiness such as I have never found in any other person and which it is not likely I shall ever find again. No -- Gatsby turned out all right at the end; it is what preyed on Gatsby, what foul dust floated in the wake of his dreams that temporarily closed out my interest in the abortive sorrows and short-winded elations of men.
Reading that makes me want to put down my pen forever.
So does the last sentence of the book:
So we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past.
I'm in the process right now of reading George Orwell's mammoth (and unbelievably good) essay on Charles Dickens. It is dense, explicit, exciting - and it's making me want to pick up all of those books again. I re-read Great Expectations a couple years ago - but the other ones it's been a long long time. Orwell's observations (especially as an Englishman) are invaluable. It's serendiptous - because I opened up one of my favorite sites today - to find this as the first item on display. I used to have an illustrated Oliver Twist - with similar type drawings, but I have no idea where that book went.
I like Orwell's observation about Dickens and children. Orwell was notoriously horribly treated (his essay Such, such were the joys is pretty much an indictment of the entire education system in England - ack - it's painful to read) - but here he is on one of Dickens' undeniable gifts - the ability to write from the perspective of a little kid:
No one, at any rate no English writer, has written better about childhood than Dickens. In spite of all the knowledge that has accumulated since, in spite of the fact that children are now comparatively sanely treated, no novelist has shown the same power of entering into the child's point of view. I must have been about nine years old when I first read David Copperfield. The mental atmosphere of the opening chapters was so immediately intelligible to me that I vaguely imagined they had been written by a child. And yet when one re-reads the book as an adult and sees the Murdstones, for instance, dwindle from gigantic figures of doom into semi-comic monsters, these passages lose nothing. Dickens has been able to stand both inside and outside the child's mind, in such a way that the same scene can be wild burlesque or sinister reality, according to the age at which one reads it.
More great stuff, too, when Orwell basically takes down the Socialist writers who want to "claim" Dickens as one of "them". Orwell basically says, "Uhm, no he's not."
The essay is included in this book - I had already read all of his political writings, but his book reviews, author reviews, and personal essays are new to me. Amazing stuff.
Now I need to re-read some Dickens. Big time.
Great essay by AS Byatt about her thought process while creating and writing Possession, one of my favorite novels.
This part amazed me:
There was a huge problem. I knew that modern forms were parodic- not only Eco, but the intelligent criticism of Malcolm Bradbury had been pointing that out - parodic, not in a sneering or mocking way, but as "rewriting" or "representing" the past. The structural necessity of my new form was that the poems of my two poets, the most important thing about them in my own view, should be in this no-longer ghostly text. And I am not a poet, and novelists who write poems usually come to grief. Robertson Davies, the Canadian novelist, had written a novel with a parodic libretto in fact made up of the poems of Thomas Lovell Beddoes. I said to the poet D.J.Enright at a party, that I was contemplating using the early poems of Pound that look as though they could be by Browning. "Nonsense," he said. "Write your own."So I tried. My mind has been full since childhood of the rhythms of Tennyson and Browning, Rossetti and Keats. I read and reread Emily Dickinson, whose harsher and more sceptical voice I found more exciting than Christina Rossetti's meek resignation. I wanted a fierce female voice. And I found I was possessed - it was actually quite frightening - the nineteenth-century poems that were not nineteenth-century poems wrote themselves, hardly blotted, fitting into the metaphorical structure of my novel, but not mine, as my prose is mine.
It amazes me because frankly, that is how it feels when I read the book. The poems are certainly not to the level of Dickinson or anything like that- but they are good enough. Good enough to convey that they could possibly be "real". That is what is needed to give the book its authenticity, its whiff of reality. You have to feel like you are reading someone else's work, looking through someone else's old letters ... the author herself must disappear in this type of novel. And yet ... she doesn't. That's part of Byatt's trickery. That's part of the point she is making, about writers, about the writing of biographies, about literary research ... What IS invisible? What IS literary possession? What is left unsaid? We only have the treasure trove of the author's actual WORDs ... but what did he or she leave unsaid? You can see how literary theorists can become "possessed" by this kind of thinking (Byatt mentions the driving urge to dig up George Eliot's grave to get the letters that were buried with her). There is a sense that all CAN be known. Which is obviously untrue - because how can we ever know everything about a life? Isn't so much of life in what is between the lines?? To learn that Byatt was not a poet is quite extraordinary - but again, I am not surprised. I have read this book over and over, and I never skip the long long poems (some of them are 10, 12 pages long), although you would think I might. Because what you're seeing there on the page IS an act of possession - and it really shows. Two different poets, speaking with two different voices, written in the styles of the 19th century. It is an extraordinary feat.
I also love all the bits about colors - how as the book developed in her mind the colors for it changed:
There is a Gothic plot, I thought, of violence and skulduggery. The Gestalt got more lurid, purple, black, vermilion, with flying white forms.
Etc. There's more. You can feel all of this in the finished work, too.
The green and gold of Maud ... how she shimmers with the golden hair and all that ... the deep dark dirt of the ending scene ...
But to read about how carefully she constructed all of that is really inspirational.
This profile of her blew me away. Didion fans - you won't want to miss it.
She's a real idol of mine - always has been since I read her essay "Goodbye to all That". There are essays I go back to again and again - the "White Album" one, the one about the Manson Family and that summer in Los Angeles - her spectacular piece on Patty Hearst ... And of course I read her book written in the aftermath of her husband's death The Year of Magical Thinking. Since her husband died in 2003 - her daughter Quintana (very ill throughout Magical Thinking) died. Quintana was in her 30s. Magical Thinking was barely pleasant to read - and I had to force myself at times to get through it.
The book does not blink. That's the only way I can describe it. Didion doesn't blink as she stares at her own grief and tries to write it all down. Breathtaking and awful.
Like I said: she's an idol.
I am chilled, though, reading that piece. I think about her sometimes, even though I don't know her. And I wonder: "I know she's working on the script now ... but ... how is she doing? How's she holding up?" I feel really sad. I feel bludgeoned by the grief of a person I do not know.
I loved this, though - I loved it so much:
Who, I ask, were here formative influences? Her answer is surprising. 'Oh, Hemingway, really. Just Hemingway.' He seems to have fallen out of fashion, I say. 'Yes, but nobody writes sentences like Hemingway.
"Oh, Hemingway, really. Just Hemingway."
Damn. That piece shook me up. It really did.
Well, the moment is (almost) here. I continue to work on other projects, etc., - but my first big "Ma, look, I'm Published" - moment is almost here. An essay I wrote is going to be included in the upcoming "Irish Letters" issue of The Sewanee Review - which, frankly, is rather a big deal. Read the history of this illustrious journal here. It is the oldest continuously published literary journal in America. When I read that list of author names I just ... my mind goes blank.
In this venerable journal you'll find the direct literary line to Flannery O'Connor, Robert Penn Warren, Hart Crane, Anne Sexton, Harry Crews, and Fred Chappell-not to mention, Andre Dubus and Cormac McCarthy, whose first stories were published in The Sewanee Review.
So now it's my turn. The most recent issue came out and has my name in the back, part of their "Next up ..." announcements. It's thrilling, really, and I feel all humble and moved and all that. It makes me feel like crying. I am PROUD to be included in such a publication. It gives me goosebumps, frankly.
This was the first piece I sent out for publication (which none of you all have read), and this was the second magazine I chose to send it to. So far, I don't have that bad a track record, huh??
The issue should be out in the fall (at least what's they tell me) and I will certainly give you all a heads up. The Sewanee Review is not easy to find - there are only a couple of little literary magazine shops here in New York where I have seen it. So it's not like you can just run out to Barnes and Noble and get it. Maybe Borders would carry it, but I'm not sure.
I have a subscription, and - I'm not just saying this because I'm going to be published by them - if you like good essays, excellent new fiction, short stories, nonfiction essays, book reviews - The Sewanee Review is top of the line. Also, if you subscribe, you'll be able to participate in my (first) moment of glory. Subscribe here - click on "Order this journal". It's 25 bucks for one year. (I'm shameless, I know. Whatever. I'm normally so humble that I am actually self-destructive. I can afford a little pride. So here you go. BUY THIS MAGAZINE.) But more than that ... just wanted to preen a little bit. I'm really proud and happy and excited.
I love this article. Someone may die in the final installment ... a major character ... and who knows, it could be Harry. Rowling isn't saying. But I do just love how whenever this woman opens her mouth, it's an EVENT. For some reason I don't find it obnoxious.
Details in the article that I found really interesting:
She says: "The last book is not finished. But I'm well into it now. I wrote the final chapter in something like 1990, so I've known exactly how the series is going to end," she said.
Fascinating. You can tell when you read those books (well, for the most part - there are the meandering sections where I get bored as hell and it seems like Rowling is just marking time) - but in general, you can tell that Rowling knows what she's doing. She's setting stuff up because she knows where she's going. I've always felt that. I know the chapters and the incidents that I would cut - but hey, I'm not Rowling. I just love the idea that she wrote the last chapter to this whole series 15 years ago.
I also love this: "The final chapter is hidden away, although it's now changed very slightly. One character got a reprieve. But I have to say two die that I didn't intend to die," she said. "A price has to be paid. We are dealing with pure evil here. They don't target extras do they? They go for the main characters. Well, I do."
She's kind of awesome. No. They do not "target extras".
And the piece closes with: "I don't think I'm ever going to have anything like Harry again. You just get one like Harry."
I don't think these books are classics, like the Narnia books. I think they are a phenomenon. I don't think they're particularly well-written - although she does have her moments - but I do know this: I can't put the books down once I start them. They are addictive. And that takes some serious story-telling skills, which Rowling has in spades.
And judging from this article - (and I guess THIS is why I love the piece so much): I really get the sense (unlike other literary phenomenons) that this is ALL ROWLING. Things get so over-marketed so immediately these days that it's really quite disheartening - nothing even gets a chance to survive or not. Now these books are obviously marketed really well, it's an entire business - but the books themselves, the writing of the books - is all Rowling. I still get the feeling that she sits alone in her room, and loses herself in her work - in the same way that she did when she was on the dole, scribbling the first book on napkins at the coffee shop. Listen to her wording: "two die that I didn't intend to die" ... I love that. She's not completely in control of this book - it's almost like IT is telling HER where she needs to go. Madeleine L'Engle talks a lot about characters in her own books who have surprised her, who have suddenly done things she found incomprehensible ... and yet it took the book to the next level. But the magical thing is that; she is writing it!! Isn't she just sitting there making stuff up? Yes, but then there is this little thing called inspiration. That's why some writers talk about feeling like "vessels" or "channels". It's not a completely conscious artform - and I just really like that Rowling seems to be in that place. The book is leading HER. I feel like she hasn't changed, even though now, apparently, she is richer than the Queen of England. In my opinion, the books have gotten better, not worse, as the series went along ... She doesn't seem to compromise. There's a lot of pressure on her - publishers, the movie franchise, marketers ... It's gotta be intense. She has to come up with the goods. Many writers would cave under such a circumstance. Rowling seems to still know how to create that private space around herself - where she can write, and create. Because I thought the last 2 books were the best in the series. So obviously, she is not just trying to repeat herself. She's not lazy.
I personally can't freakin' wait for the next book.

William Butler Yeats.
The O'Malley children were made to memorize Yeats' epitaph as part of our weekly allowance ritual. Say Yeat's epitaph, get a dime!! Such were the rules in our house. Nothing, and I say NOTHING, could obliterate that epitaph from my memory:
Cast a cold eye
On life on Death
Horseman pass by
Once more for good luck!
Cast a cold eye
On life on Death
Horseman pass by
When we visited his grave in Ireland, as kids, we all felt kind of amazed that ... it was REAL. That the epitaph we had been rattling off since we were toddlers actually existed out in the world.
Here's a biography of Yeats, Nobel prize winner in 1923.
So much to say, so little time. Yeats, as a poet, has always been one of my favorites (even with the early stuff and the "cloud-pale eyelids" monotony), but what truly inspires me is his work in Irish theatre, and the creation of the Abbey. An amazing story. His Nobel lecture was on the Irish Dramatic Movement. I wrote a big long post about his nurturing of John Synge, author of Playboy of the Western World. Synge, as a young man, was a floundering artist bohemian type - until Yeats got a hold of him, and told him to go stay on the Aran Islands for a while, to discover the real Irish people. The result? A revolution in Irish theatre.
Yeats' poem "The Second Coming" has been called one of the greatest poems of the 20th century. That and "Sailing to Byzantium". I had a conversation once with the doppelganger about "greatest poems of the 20th century" and we discussed these two poems. We said any list of "greatest poems of the 20th century" that DIDN'T include those two poems was not a worthy list. "The Second Coming" is quoted (and mis-appropriated, more often than not) and quoted again ... by people who want to use it for their own ends. It's a dark ominous crystal ball. Written in 1919 - when the world had already become familiar with horror - a horror of a kind never before seen on earth - the poem predicts the chaos of the 20th century.
"The Second Coming"
Turning and turning in the widening gyre
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.
Surely some revelation is at hand;
Surely the Second Coming is at hand.
The Second Coming! Hardly are those words out
When a vast image out of Spiritus Mundi
Troubles my sight: somewhere in sands of the desert
A shape with lion body and the head of a man,
A gaze blank and pitiless as the sun,
Is moving its slow thighs, while all about it
Reel shadows of the indignant desert birds.
The darkness drops again; but now I know
That twenty centuries of stony sleep
Were vexed to nightmare by a rocking cradle,
And what rough beast, its hour come round at last,
Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?
And here ... now ... a plethora of Yeats quotes. I end with one of my favorites.
"I hate journalists. There is nothing in them but tittering jeering emptiness. They have all made what Dante calls the Great Refusal. The shallowest people on the ridge of the earth."
"Irish poets, learn your trade, sing whatever is well made, scorn the sort now growing up all out of shape from toe to top."
"The worst thing about some men is that when they are not drunk they are sober."
"Words are always getting conventionalized to some secondary meaning. It is one of the works of poetry to take the truants in custody and bring them back to their right senses."
"Do not wait to strike till the iron is hot; but make it hot by striking."
"And say my glory was I had such friends."
Yes. That last one really moves me - it's from one of his poems. I feel the same way about my life, and my friends.
Words to live by:
Never give all the heart
Never give all the heart, for love
Will hardly seem worth thinking of
To passionate women if it seem
Certain, and they never dream
That it fades out from kiss to kiss;
For everything that's lovely is
But a brief, dreamy. Kind delight.
O never give the heart outright,
For they, for all smooth lips can say,
Have given their hearts up to the play.
And who could play it well enough
If deaf and dumb and blind with love?
He that made this knows all the cost,
For he gave all his heart and lost.
I also love love LOVE his poem to Jonathan Swift where he writes: "Imitate him if you dare."
Swift's Epitaph
Swift has sailed into his rest;
Savage indignation there
Cannot lacerate his breast.
Imitate him if you dare,
World-besotted traveller; he
Served human liberty.
Speaking of epitaphs, you can't get any better or more eloquent than Auden's stunning poem in memory of Yeats:
In Memory of W.B. Yeats
by Auden
I
He disappeared in the dead of winter:
The brooks were frozen, the airports almost deserted,
And snow disfigured the public statues;
The mercury sank in the mouth of the dying day.
What instruments we have agree
The day of his death was a dark cold day.
Far from his illness
The wolves ran on through the evergreen forests,
The peasant river was untempted by the fashionable quays;
By mourning tongues
The death of the poet was kept from his poems.
But for him it was his last afternoon as himself,
An afternoon of nurses and rumours;
The provinces of his body revolted,
The squares of his mind were empty,
Silence invaded the suburbs,
The current of his feeling failed; he became his admirers.
Now he is scattered among a hundred cities
And wholly given over to unfamiliar affections,
To find his happiness in another kind of wood
And be punished under a foreign code of conscience.
The words of a dead man
Are modified in the guts of the living.
But in the importance and noise of to-morrow
When the brokers are roaring like beasts on the floor of the Bourse,
And the poor have the sufferings to which they are fairly accustomed,
And each in the cell of himself is almost convinced of his freedom,
A few thousand will think of this day
As one thinks of a day when one did something slightly unusual.
What instruments we have agree
The day of his death was a dark cold day.
II
You were silly like us; your gift survived it all:
The parish of rich women, physical decay,
Yourself. Mad Ireland hurt you into poetry.
Now Ireland has her madness and her weather still,
For poetry makes nothing happen: it survives
In the valley of its making where executives
Would never want to tamper, flows on south
From ranches of isolation and the busy griefs,
Raw towns that we believe and die in; it survives,
A way of happening, a mouth.
III
Earth, receive an honoured guest:
William Yeats is laid to rest.
Let the Irish vessel lie
Emptied of its poetry.
In the nightmare of the dark
All the dogs of Europe bark,
And the living nations wait,
Each sequestered in its hate;
Intellectual disgrace
Stares from every human face,
And the seas of pity lie
Locked and frozen in each eye.
Follow, poet, follow right
To the bottom of the night,
With your unconstraining voice
Still persuade us to rejoice;
With the farming of a verse
Make a vineyard of the curse,
Sing of human unsuccess
In a rapture of distress;
In the deserts of the heart
Let the healing fountain start,
In the prison of his days
Teach the free man how to praise.
And lastly, a poem that has great personal meaning for me:
The wild swans at Coole
The trees are in their autumn beauty,
The woodland paths are dry,
Under the October twilight the water
Mirrors a still sky;
Upon the brimming water among the stones
Are nine-and-fifty Swans.
The nineteenth autumn has come upon me
Since I first made my count;
I saw, before I had well finished,
All suddenly mount
And scatter wheeling in great broken rings
Upon their clamorous wings.
I have looked upon those brilliant creatures,
And now my heart is sore.
All's changed since I, hearing at twilight,
The first time on this shore,
The bell-beat of their wings above my head,
Trod with a lighter tread.
Unwearied still, lover by lover,
They paddle in the cold
Companionable streams or climb the air;
Their hearts have not grown old;
Passion or conquest, wander where they will,
Attend upon them still.
But now they drift on the still water,
Mysterious, beautiful;
Among what rushes will they build,
By what lake's edge or pool
Delight men's eyes when I awake some day
To find they have flown away?
Happy birthday to William Butler Yeats.
Imitate him if you dare.

"He was far from reliable -- he could write off Kane as a reservoir of hackneyed tricks, and he was of the opinion that Chaplin and Huston were without equal in America. But he wrote like someone who had not just viewed the movie but been in it -- out with it, as if it were a girl, drinking with it; driving in the night with it. That direct physical response was new, it was done with terrific dash and insight, and it surely intuited the way people responded to movies in the forties. It was also, it seems to me, a powerful influence on Pauline Kael -- I have a fond dream of the two of them snarling at each other, like the characters in The African Queen."
From David Thomson's The New Biographical Dictionary of Film : Expanded and Updated
Essay on James Agee
... is Lorrie Moore. And it's kind of tough to have Lorrie Moore be one of your favorite writers because she publishes so rarely. But when she does? Holy mackerel. Birds of America is breathtaking. And it's just a collection of short stories! Admittedly - I kinda went into this Lorrie Moore thing having a problem with short stories. Unless you're James Joyce, I'm not interested in reading your short stories, mkay? Why bother. He spoils other writers for me. And I'm happy to be spoiled. But after a friend I trust raved about Birds of America I picked it up, and good GOD. Those STORIES! There's almost no navel-gazing, there's none of that whiff of the writer's workshop about her stories. No. They are mini-novels. They are moments of devastating revelations ... a moment in time when a life changes ... or not ... They are sad sad stories, more often than not, but the way she writes is so comedic that often I found myself laughing out loud. THAT is my kind of writing. But so few books! She's a professor of English at the University of Wisconsin ... and every now and then she'll have a story in The New Yorker so I suppose if you're a fan of Lorrie Moore's writing, you just have to learn patience.
Anyway - she wrote a wonderful piece for the New York Times in honor of Shakespeare's birthday which was (circa) yesterday. I always feel a bolt of excitement when I see her name. I can count writers I feel that way about on one hand and she's one of THOSE writers for me.

Today is Easter. It's also the birthday of Irish playwright John Millington Synge (1871–1909), author of Playboy of the Western World, Riders to the Sea, and many more - not to mention his wonderful book about his time on the Aran Islands, called, coincidentally, The Aran Islands. Playboy is now in the history books, not only for being a wonderful play, and part of the theatrical revolution going on in Ireland at the time (the creation of the Abbey Theatre, etc.) - but also because of the riots that broke out when it opened. Things got so out of hand that a police squad had to stand along the edge of the stage during the performance, so that the actors wouldn't get hurt or mobbed. If I had a time machine, I would LOVE to go back and be there on the opening night of that play.
Synge wrote (and this is a bit of a mission statement):
Ireland, for a few years more, we have a popular imagination that is fiery and magnificent, and tender; so that those of us who wish to write start with a chance that is not given to writers in places where the springtime of the local life has been forgotten, and the harvest is a memory only, and the straw has been turned into bricks.
Synge's time out on the Aran Islands, off the wild west coast of Ireland, gave him the nuggets of inspiration for many of his plays. Out there the "native language" was still spoken, out there he could encounter the real Ireland.
Synge had spent a lot of time in Europe, taking courses in French literature, immersing himself in different cultures, reading Baudelaire, writing poems, chasing girls ... You know, all La Boheme stuff. He remained interested in his own country, his own heritage - but there wasn't really a place for him there. (Interesting: NOW it's hard to imagine Ireland without Synge, but he had to TAKE that ground, he had to claim it - it didn't exist before he came along.) Yeats' whole nationalistic literary (and theatrical) movement drew Synge back to his home country - the Abbey Theatre was formed - things were HAPPENING in Ireland. In retrospect, it all seems inevitable. Of course Synge would not only come back to be part of that movement, but he would end up defining that movement. But at the time, Synge had some reservations about Yeats' "let's bring back the fairies and the Celtic twilight" romanticism. Was that Ireland? Fairies? Leprechauns? Shivering grey twilights? Was that Irish culture? Couldn't there be something more there? Something ELSE to be expressed? (That Synge did so, and so powerfully, is proof of his genius).
Yeats gave Synge a piece of now legendary advice (and this is a direct quote):
Give up Paris, you will never create anything by reading Racine, and Arthur Symons will always be a better critic of French literature. Go to the Arran Islands. Live there as if you were one of the people themselves; express a life that has never found expression.
In the middle of what was, essentially, an Irish cultural revival, Yeats (having been out to the Aran Islands) recognized that there was something untouched out there, a primitive life, Irish language still spoken, the culture not corrupted. Yet. It was a race against time.
The leaders of the cultural movement in Ireland at that time all had the same idea: Inspiration lay in the West of Ireland. Go west. Go west to find the real Ireland. (Interesting, to think of the final paragraphs of Joyce's The Dead in this context. I'm sure I'm not the first one to think of this- ha - but still, it's interesting.)
So Synge took Yeats' advice and went west.
The story of his four trips out to the Islands make up his book Aran Islands, a wonderful rich travelogue, a classic of the genre. He sits around turf fires with the various storytellers, and listens, and writes the folktales and anecdotes down later. These stories contain the germs of Playboy, the germs of Shadow of the Glen, the germs of Riders. Yeats was right. With all of Yeats' airy-fairy Celtic frippery, he understood that a powerful culture lay beneath the surface, a culture that had never been shown to the world, never been expressed.
Not surprising, then, that Playboy of the Western World would cause such an uproar.
Here is an excerpt from Maire Nic Shiubhlaigh's marvelous book The Splendid Years, which is the story of the Irish National Theatre. Maire was an actress, highly involved with the cultural revival of the time, and a member of the Abbey Theatre. Her memories of Synge (and also her memories of the "Playboy riots") are fascinating. Here she speaks of Synge:
It was early in June, 1903, that Lady Gregory called us to her rooms at the Nassau Hotel and read Synge's play [Shadow of the Glen] over to us. The piece was a one-act comedy based on an Irish folk-tale the author had heard from an old Aran Island seanachie -- the story of the aged husband feigning death to test his youthful wife's fidelity; denouncing her, but forgiving her lover. The plot, strictly speaking, was not original, but the treatment was. It was completely different to anything we had known before; the play itself was a masterpiece of dramatic construction. It was, in fact, the first of the Irish "realist" dramas, and the quiet young man who sat unobtrusively in the background while Lady Gregory read aloud his words, was to take his place amongst the greatest dramatists the Irish theatre produced.John M. Synge who came to us with his play direct from the Aran Islands, where the material for most of his later works was gathered, was born near Dublin in 1871, graduated at Trinity College, and shortly afterwards left Ireland for the Continent, living alternately in Germany and France, where he made a rather precarious livelihood as a violinist and contributor to literary magazines. Yeats had discovered him in Paris in about 1897 and, recognizing the quality of his writings, had brought him back to Ireland, where he introduced him to Aran, prophesying that in the beautiful lyrical prose of the western peasant he would find an original vehicle for dramatic composition. He was right. Synge went to Aran for a month, and stayed there, on and off, for a matter of years. He drew his inspiration from the hearths of the tiny whitewashed cabins and the harsh rocks of the western seaboard, gathering tales and expressions from the old and the young of the most picturesque portion of Ireland. In a short life -- he died at the early age of 38 -- he wove them into sombre dramatic tapestries, embroidered with the rhythmic language of the Irish peasant. His prose, highly musical and enriched with flashes of the most beautiful poetry, he devised simly by transcribing direct from the Gaelic of the islands. It is most difficult for an actor to master; most effective if delivered correctly.
Ahem. She's got that right. I did a scene from Playboy in a class in graduate school, and while my scene partner had a hell of a lot of fun working on it, it was DAMN difficult to get that language right. Not just the language, but the rhythm, the tone. It doesn't matter if you get the words all correct, and remember all your lines, if you say them in the wrong rhythm. Rhythm is everything.
Back to Synge.
He was a gentle fellow, shy, with that deep sense of humour that is sometimes found in the quietest people. His bulky figure and heavy black moustache gave him a rather austere appearance -- an impression quickly dispelled when he spoke. His voice was mellow, low; he seldom raised it. But for his quiet personality he might have passed unnoticed at any gathering. During rehearsals of his play, he would sit quietly in the background, endlessly rolling cigarettes. This was a typical gesture, born more of habit than of any desire for tobacco -- he gave away more cigarettes than he smoked. At the first opportunity, he would lever his huge frame out of a chair and come up on to the stage, a half-rolled cigarette in eaach hand. Then he would look enquiringly round and thrust the little paper cylinders forward towards whoever was going to smoke them. In later years he became the terror of fire-conscious Abbey stage-managers. He used to sit timidly in the wings during plays, rolling cigarettes and handing them to the players as they made their exits.
Here's more from Maire:
Synge was a genius, one of the great literary figures of his time, but brilliance often ripens under the most difficult conditions. In the Shadow of the Glen was sufficiently in advance of its time to arouse in Dublin audiences a completely unfounded indignation. Its production raised a storm of protest in some sections of the Press that was stupid and ridiculous, disconcerting its unfortunate author and amazing most of us, who had never looked upon the play as anything but an exceptionally well-written comedy.
And THAT'S why the guy is a genius. He didn't set out to revolutionize Irish theatre. He didn't set out to be a genius, or to write great plays. He just wrote down what he knew. That was the ONLY way this guy could write. And it turned everything upside down.
Here is Maire's description of some of the objections to Shadow, just to give you an idea of what was going on, and to also set the stage for the "Playboy riots". Synge was, indeed, ahead of his time. The world is rarely kind to those born ahead of their time.
The piece was "un-Irish" wrote some reviewers, an "insult" in fact to the peasant women of Ireland whom Nora Burke was taken to typify. There was an immense verbal furore about it. A number of writers claiming that Synge was slyly attacking the institution known as the "made marriage", and attributing it solely to Ireland, raised all sorts of objections. Others wrote of the character of Nora Burke: "Nora Burke is a lie". Of the play they said: "It is no more Irish than the Decameron. It is a staging of the old-world libel on womankind -- the Widow of Ephesus."Now, I do not propose to analyse the extraordinary attitude adopted towards the play. Indeed, the attacks were launched so suddenly that few of us were even able to gather what they were all about. Perhaps it was that the Irish play-going public of that time was so used to the "genteel" comedy of the established theatre which I mentioned earlier -- the entertaining but not very realistic stuff that was time and again put before it -- that it couldn't swallow a credible satire. In those days if an actress played an unpleasant part, then it followed that she was an unpleasant person. Similarly, if a dramatist wrote a nasty play he was a nasty fellow. Then, of course, there was the fact that Ireland was on the threshold of a renaissance. Everybody, writer, politician, artist, was at pains to eulogise over the beauty of the Irish character. The advent of a comparatively unknown writer who painted an unpleasant if realistic picture of the peasantry at such a time was, to say the least, unwelcome. The Dubliners who raised the loudest objections could not accept In the Shadow of the Glen as a play. They refused to be entertained.
In 1907, the Abbey Theatre produced Playboy of the Western World. Maire, who was there, writes:
The "Playboy Riots", as they came to be known, indicate very clearly some of the difficulties that the Abbey was called upon to face during its first years -- and they show how the theatre, under Yeats, managed to surmount them. When this play is produced in Dublin now it is recognised and enjoyed as a work of art. In 1907 it drove a number of people into such a frenzy that they nearly wrecked the Abbey. I am in rather a good position to describe the riots because I was in the audience during some of them. Curiosity had taken me into the theatre, as it had taken many another person that week.It was about the end of 1906 that Synge finished the Playboy ... Yeats later mentioned that Synge took considerable trouble over the piece and scrapped a number of earlier versions before he fixed on the one which was eventually produced...Yeats never tired of recounting the care which Synge lavished on the piece. This, indeed, may have been indirectly responsible for the reception accorded the play by some sections of the public, whose main argument against it was that it was "a slander on the peasantry of Ireland". As in the case of The Shadow of the Glen, its realism gave offence. The only differnce between it and any other play that did not take was that the public, instead of showing its lack of interest in the accepted way -- by its non-attendance -- displayed its disapproval by rioting in the theatre throughout the play's run. The most unusual feature of the affair was that although the players appeared on the stage and acted their parts for a whole week, the uproar caused by the audience was so great that the play was never really heard on any night but the first, and those who took part in the demonstrations on subsequent occasions were dependent on opinions of the firstnight audience and a few rather hysterical newspaper reports. As the week progressed, the trouble instead of lessening, increased, and before the run of the play was half over, the management felt compelled to call for the assistance of the police to preserve order.
The explanations put forward by the rioters during the week were many and varied and it is worth remarking that no two people appeared to base their objections on exactly the same thing. Some objected to the piece because "it made a hero out of a murderer" (the play deals in part with the welcome accorded by a West of Ireland village to a weak-willed boy who believes he has just killed his father); others claimed that the language used was too strong; more contented themselves by saying that the play was "vicious, untrue, and uncalled for" -- a "hideous caricature" in fact; while a considerable number based their objections on the assumption that the piece was a deliberate attack by Synge on Ireland in retaliation for the manner in which The Shadow of the Glen and The Well of the Saints had been received.
(All of this makes me think of what Joyce said, when it became apparent that no Irish publisher would go near The Dubliners and he would have to look outside his own country for a publisher: "It is not my fault that the odour of ashpits and old weeds and offal hangs round my stories. I seriously believe that you will retard the course of civilization in Ireland by preventing the Irish people from having one good look at themselves in my nicely polished looking-glass." Obviously Synge had approached the same territory - he had held up a "nicely polished looking-glass" to the Irish people, and the Irish people were having NONE of it. At the time.)
Maire describes what it was like in the theatre, on the opening night of Playboy of the Western World, January 26, 1907.
The first act went well. There was laughter at the right places and the correct degree of solemnity was maintained when it was demanded. But during the second act I began to feel a tenseness in the air around me -- I was sitting in the pit -- and there were murmurs from the stalls and parts of the gallery. Before the curtain fell it was obvious that there was going to be some sort of trouble. Faint calls and ejaculations like "Oh, no! Take it off!" came from various parts of the house and the atmosphere gradually grew taut. In the third act things really came to a head and those around began to stamp the floor and shout towards the stage, the noise gradually increasing until the voices of the players were drowned. People stood up in their seats and demanded the withdrawal of the play, and when it became clear that the cast was determined to see the thing out to the end, tempers began to fray. The auditorium became a mass of people pulling and pushing in all directions. By the time the curtain fell on the last act, the crowd was arguing and fighting with itself. People in front leaned over the back of seats and demanded quiet -- a lot of people seemed to be doing this -- and those at the back responded by shouting and hissing loudly. The crowd which eventually emerged into the street was in an ugly mood.
Despite vicious and hysterical reviews the play went on. One of the objections was that the word "shift" appeared in the play (meaning: "chemise", or "slip", whatever you want to call it). Christy - the lead character in the play - says - in what is now acknowledged to be a fine piece of dramatic literature, and one of the classic monologues of the stage: "It's Pegeen I'm seeking only, and what'd I care if you brought me a drift of chosen females, standing in their shifts itself, maybe, from this place to the eastern world?" People were shocked and outraged by this, it was seen as an insult to all Irish women.
The Press and the public called for the play to be closed, the hysteria mounted, but the Abbey refused to capitulate. Obviously, Synge had struck a nerve. But things were getting out of hand, it was a violent atmosphere in the audience ... and so Yeats tried to quell this fire. Maire describes:
On the third night Yeats addressed the audience before the curtain rose. If anyone had anything to say against the piece they would be welcomed at a debate which he would be glad to arrange in the theatre at some other time. He was interrupted several times. He asked the interrupters to at least listen to the play so that they would know what it was they were objecting to.
It is just like those idiots who protested Scorsese's Last Temptation without even seeing it. Ignorant idiots. I have no patience and no tolerance for people like that. To me, they are a scourge upon this planet. I'm pretty open-minded, you know "live and let live", but people like that put me into a rage and I have no problem with openly scorning their stupid fearful little lives. Especially if they try to BLOCK the general public from seeing something that THEY find offensive. Everyone has their limits, everyone has their thing that they cannot endure - and I cannot bear people like that. I don't want to listen, understand where they're coming from. No. I DO understand where they are coming from, and that is why I despise them. My contempt comes directly FROM understanding. Their "faith" and their sense of themselves is so fragile that it's a house of cards. Even the fact that Scorsese's movie EXISTED threatened their entire world view. Fine. Go home then and read only the Bible and close the blinds and don't let the big bad nasty world touch your precious house of cards, and let those of us who actually want to SEE the movie and decide for ourselves - live in peace.
Such people have always existed. Their complaints are always the same.
Back to the Playboy Riots:
As on the first night, the opening passages were listened to quietly, and even evoked a little laughter. Halfway through the second act, however, a murmur arose in the pit and a man a few rows away stood up and, without any apparent reason, hit the person beside him. A gasp ran around the whole house and the lights went up. All around him the crowd was breaking into disorder.Within minutes, the audience in the pit and stalls was completely disorganised, and the crowd in thte back and side galleries was almost as bad. Almost everyone was standing. The noise was deafening. Yeats appeared on the stage and pleaded with the sensible members of the audience to remain quiet. His voice was drowned by catcalls, cheers, much stamping of feet, and from somewhere at the back ,the notes of a toy trumpet which came from the centre of a group of young men who looked like university students. He continued to speak, but his words were apparently objected to by those in front, for a howl of protest went up from the stalls and parts of the side gallery, which increased in volume as those behind joined in or tried to cheer the protest down. On the stage the players stood in little knots, discussing the occurrences amongst themselves.
As the noise increased and several arguments broke out around the theatre, Yeats left his place on the stage. A few minutes later the doors into the auditorium opened and to the horror and surprise of most of those present, a body of police entered. At the same time the curtain came down and a semblance of order was restored -- partly due to the sight of the uniforms ...
After a brief speech by Yeats, and the ejection of the more truculent members of the audience, peace was partially restored, and everyone sat down again. At this stage it would have been impossible for anyone to get out. After everyone had been quietened and the greater part of the audience reseated, it would have been dangerous for anyone to stand up. Those who did so were immediately surrounded by hefty policement and shepherded, not too gently, in the direction of the vestibule.
Meanwhile, the orchestra, a recent addition to the theatre, began to play. The music seemed to help matters somewhat, and things almost returned to what they were before the play began. There was much discussion and gesticulation going on however. The affair was still far from settled.
After some time the orchestra retired, the lights were lowered and the curtain went up. Almost immediately the audience reverted to what it had been before the arrival of the police. Not a word of the play could be heard. The cast eventually gave up speaking altogether and went through the piece in pantomime. [Note from Sheila: God, I wish I had been there to see this. It must have been extraordinary.] As the play progressed the noise increased. Men and women stamped the floor, banged the backs of their seats with their fists, shouted and sang alternately. On the stairs from the stalls a man stood, dramatically addressing no one in particular.
The players courageously went through the whole piece. During this time several arrests were made and the police were kept busy operating between the doors and the hall. Just before the play ended I saw an opportunity to escape and took it. Almost everyone in the row where I had been sitting had vanished. I was able to make a dash for the door at the rear of the pit while the police were busy in the front of the house. My last impression of the scene was the sight of a figure standing on a seat somewhere about the centre of the stalls and the sound of a few bars of God Save the King, which were quickly stifled as someone pulled the singer down.
Amazing. The play continued to be performed, and continued to generate riots and protests, garnering the attention of the world. "What is going on over in Ireland right now? What exactly are they protesting??"
Synge died an early death, in 1909, but he left an indelible mark - not only on Ireland, but on theatre as a whole.
I'll end this post now, with a quote from Synge's beautiful book The Aran Islands (and I will post a photo, too, of Synge staring out into the Atlantic, from one of the Islands).
In the following excerpt, he describes leaving the Arans after a couple months' stay ... and returning to the bustle of Galway:
I have come out of an hotel full of tourists and commercial travellers, to stroll along the edge of Galway Bay, and look out in the direction of the islands. The sort of yearning I feel towards those lonely rocks is indescribably acute. This town, that is usually so full of wild human interest, seems in my present mood a tawdry medley of all that is crudest in modern life. The nullity of the rich and the squalor of the poor give me the same pang of wondering disgust; yet the islands are fading already and I can hardly realize that the smell of the seaweed and the drone of the Atlantic are still moving round them.
Happy birthday, JM Synge. We are in your debt.

-- this is a re-post
Who is Christopher Smart? Also known as Kit Smart? A British poet - born in the early 1700s - He was educated at Cambridge, he got married, he was known for his fluency in Latin, he did very well for himself. Until the 1750s when he began to "suffer" from a form of religious hysteria. I put suffer in quotes, because I'm not really sure he DID suffer - it was just that the people around him found him intolerable, thought that his constant adoration of God made him insane. He began to pray incessantly. He would drop to his knees in the middle of the street, and pray. We know this because of what his good friend Samuel Johnson wrote about him. Johnson loved Christopher Smart. Smart eventually was put into a mental institution - which in the 1700s had to be horrific. He was in various mental institutions for over 10 years. While on the inside, he wrote the poems that we know him by today. Or - not everybody. He's barely even studied - English majors probably don't know who he is - I just think it's a shame. Because I find his stuff just ... marvelous. Contemporary, stream-of-conscious, eloquent - I don't even know what to compare it to. His religious hysteria did not manifest itself in gloom and doom, or evangelical ranting and raving. His hysteria manifested itself in an overwhelming joy of all of God's creations. He was in a constant state of awe and thankfulness ... every single thing he saw was evidence of God's love, which was why he had to keep going around falling to his knees, and praising God. I praise God for the bricks in the street! I praise God for the dust motes! Praise you God for the dewfall in the morning! He couldn't get through 2 seconds without a prayer. I have to admit - if he were my friend, I would find this behavior quite annoying - but I don't know that I would want someone locked up in a mental institution over it.
Dr. Johnson had the following wonderful thing to say about Christopher Smart:
"I do not think he ought to be shut up. His infirmities were not noxious to society. He insisted on people praying with him; and I'd as lief pray with Kit Smart as anyone else. Another charge was that he did not love clean linen, and I have no passion for it."
Michael Schmidt, author of "Lives of the Poets" says, in regards to Smart, "He has few heirs". I would agree with that. I love Christopher Smart - and yes, I would say that he pretty much stands alone.
He wrote quite a bit - but what he is probably most known for is his poem in praise to his cat Joffrey. It's part of a much longer piece, known as Jubilate Agno . The poem as a whole is almost like a long diary entry - filled with prayers, and praise, and philosophy, and observations. Again - I don't know who to compare him to. William Blake? Allen Ginsberg? Kinda. But not really. Ginsberg actually did reference Kit Smart as a huge influence on him - and it shows. I can hear the echoes of his stuff in Ginsberg.
I ADORE the praise to his cat Joffrey. Look at how Smart sees God in his cat. It's not that he mythologizes his cat. It's not that he sees everything abstractly - it's not that he is disconnected from a real earth-bound experience - like so many religious ya-hoos are. It's actually the opposite. He doesn't see in his cat a SYMBOL of God's glory. Joffrey literally IS God made manifest. Kit Smart was always overwhelmed by the GLORY of God. The LOVE of God. And you can see it in his poem about his cat. When I read it, it reminds me to pay attention to the simplicity of life, the small pleasures, the sensoral moments of grace. Breathing, stretching, laughing, eating. All of this should be celebrated. Kit Smart was not un-connected from the earth (again, like so many religious fanatics are) - he was tuned in to the sensory world: He observes his cat Joffrey behave as cats do. And he praises Joffrey for his cat-ness.
I love this poem. Here it is. And happy birthday, Kit Smart. I wish the world had treated you a bit better. But thanks for your writing.
Here is the poem for Joffrey. God. I just find it so inspiring to read. LOVE IT!! Cat-lovers - you will dig this poem. This cat from the 1700s just comes to life, with all his cat behavior. Cats never change. To quote Smart: "For he counteracts the powers of darkness by his electrical skin and glaring eyes". hahahaha
Enjoy! This is one of my favorite poems.
For I Will Consider My Cat Jeoffry
For I will consider my Cat Jeoffry.
For he is the servant of the Living God duly and daily serving him.
For at the first glance of the glory of God in the East he worships in his way.
For this is done by wreathing his body seven times round with elegant quickness.
For then he leaps up to catch the musk, which is the blessing of God upon his prayer.
For he rolls upon prank to work it in.
For having done duty and received blessing he begins to consider himself.
For this he performs in ten degrees.
For first he looks upon his forepaws to see if they are clean.
For secondly he kicks up behind to clear away there.
For thirdly he works it upon stretch with the forepaws extended.
For fourthly he sharpens his paws by wood.
For fifthly he washes himself.
For sixthly he rolls upon wash.
For seventhly he fleas himself, that he may not be interrupted upon the beat.
For eighthly he rubs himself against a post.
For ninthly he looks up for his instructions.
For tenthly he goes in quest of food.
For having consider'd God and himself he will consider his neighbour.
For if he meets another cat he will kiss her in kindness.
For when he takes his prey he plays with it to give it a chance.
For one mouse in seven escapes by his dallying.
For when his day's work is done his business more properly begins.
For he keeps the Lord's watch in the night against the adversary.
For he counteracts the powers of darkness by his electrical skin and glaring eyes.
For he counteracts the Devil, who is death, by brisking about the life.
For in his morning orisons he loves the sun and the sun loves him.
For he is of the tribe of Tiger.
For the Cherub Cat is a term of the Angel Tiger.
For he has the subtlety and hissing of a serpent, which in goodness he suppresses.
For he will not do destruction, if he is well-fed, neither will he spit without provocation.
For he purrs in thankfulness, when God tells him he's a good Cat.
For he is an instrument for the children to learn benevolence upon.
For every house is incomplete without him and a blessing is lacking in the spirit.
For the Lord commanded Moses concerning the cats at the departure of the Children of Israel from Egypt.
For every family had one cat at least in the bag.
For the English Cats are the best in Europe.
For he is the cleanest in the use of his forepaws of any quadruped.
For the dexterity of his defence is an instance of the love of God to him exceedingly.
For he is the quickest to his mark of any creature.
For he is tenacious of his point.
For he is a mixture of gravity and waggery.
For he knows that God is his Saviour.
For there is nothing sweeter than his peace when at rest.
For there is nothing brisker than his life when in motion.
For he is of the Lord's poor and so indeed is he called by benevolence perpetually--Poor Jeoffry! poor Jeoffry! the rat has bit thy throat.
For I bless the name of the Lord Jesus that Jeoffry is better.
For the divine spirit comes about his body to sustain it in complete cat.
For his tongue is exceeding pure so that it has in purity what it wants in music.
For he is docile and can learn certain things.
For he can set up with gravity which is patience upon approbation.
For he can fetch and carry, which is patience in employment.
For he can jump over a stick which is patience upon proof positive.
For he can spraggle upon waggle at the word of command.
For he can jump from an eminence into his master's bosom.
For he can catch the cork and toss it again.
For he is hated by the hypocrite and miser.
For the former is afraid of detection.
For the latter refuses the charge.
For he camels his back to bear the first notion of business.
For he is good to think on, if a man would express himself neatly.
For he made a great figure in Egypt for his signal services.
For he killed the Ichneumon-rat very pernicious by land.
For his ears are so acute that they sting again.
For from this proceeds the passing quickness of his attention.
For by stroking of him I have found out electricity.
For I perceived God's light about him both wax and fire.
For the Electrical fire is the spiritual substance, which God sends from heaven to sustain the bodies both of man and beast.
For God has blessed him in the variety of his movements.
For, tho he cannot fly, he is an excellent clamberer.
For his motions upon the face of the earth are more than any other quadruped.
For he can tread to all the measures upon the music.
For he can swim for life.
For he can creep.

Wonderful in-depth piece about Clifford Odets in The New Yorker.
The article pretty much got it all right ... and I very much agree with John Lahr's statement that it was not that Odets lost his talent, it was that the audience had changed. If you read his later stuff (Flowering Peach for example - excerpt here) it is obvious that not a THING has happened to his voice. But the audience of 1935 who lost their MINDS over Waiting for Lefty (excerpt) and Awake and Sing (excerpt) was not the same as the audience of 1954 for Flowering Peach. Despite the fact that it did not have a successful run as a play, it almost won the Pulitzer (and well-deserved, at least as a nomination - Cat on a Hot Tin Roof won - and it's obviously the better play) - but it's not like Flowering Peach was a massive flop.
But I'm biased. I would read the damn DOODLES Odets made in the MARGINS of his drafts. His work means that much to me.
Night Music - the last play produced by The Group Theatre - the failure of which brought about the ultimate failure of the theatre company - is a wonderful play - it reminds me of some of Saroyan's greatest works. It also predates some of Lanford Wilson's bigger plays, like Balm in Gilead (only without the drug addiction and the bleak nihilism). Odets was always an optimist. Night Music probably wouldn't hold up well under scrutiny - and it is never performed now - but what a lovely lyrical piece of writing.
Anyway - here's the New Yorker piece in full.
It always makes me happy to see Odets get "the props". I think he's highly under-rated as a playwright. Cary Grant (one of his dearest friends - who helped him out financially during the end of his life, when he was really struggling) always thought so. As a matter of fact, Cary Grant got his second Oscar nomination for None but the Lonely Heart - Odets' first (and only, sadly) foray as a director. It's a socially conscious piece of work - and therefore rather tiresome - but the style? The mood? Superb - it's a fantastic moody noir. I love that he and Grant were friends. They came from the same poverty-struck background, and they both became massive stars - Grant's appeal was wider, obviously - but Odets' plays actually MEANT something to the general public during the 30s. He was in the fire WITH them. He became a symbol.
But the writing!! Everyone who came after him (Miller, Williams) all list him as a primary influence. Odets lists Chekhov as his main influence - and it shows.
In terms of those following in his footsteps, imitating him, trying to re-do what he did naturally ... it's tough to measure his influence. Odets kind of stands alone. He really does. Without Odets, there would be no Death of a Salesman. Without Odets, there would be no Angels in America (I think Kushner's writing is very good, but it's all Odets.) There's a lot of Odets in Shanley's stuff.
Odets' shadow is long long long.
I gasped when I heard the news: great Irish novelist John McGahern has passed away. Thanks, peteb, for letting me know - I hadn't heard, and I'm kind of emotional about it right now. Here's a post over at Slugger, with a bunch of great links. And the first comment in the thread brought tears to my eyes. Because I feel the same way. I wrote about it here a bit. (The rest of the comments in the post over at Slugger are great too - people remembering McGahern, sharing their thoughts and memories about him.)
I have my father to thank for introducing me to John McGahern. My dad always had such great things to say about McGahern - and for some reason, it took me a while to get around to reading him. I read Amongst Women and ... it basically flattened me. Almost as much as Ian McEwan's Atonement. It hurt me to read it. The story, that FATHER ... just that character ... It was a painful to book to read. Masterful. It's not that it's a brilliant plot, or a gripping tale, it's not even that the characters are so memorable - except for the father. That father will live on in my memory forever. It's the way McGahern brings us, inevitably, step by step through that story - it's how he desribes the silence in that house, it's his observations ... of how this family works ... the tiny moments that make up conversations ... You just can SEE it all in how he writes. It's a little window into a completely three-dimensional world. McGahern does not paint his characters with broad strokes. They're very subtle, complex, human beings. But - That father in Amongst Women is introduced to us with two or three sentences ... and entire WORLDS open up before us. We know this man. We know this man. And - we just ACHE for him. We would be so fearful if he were our father, he's - cold - he withholds love - he is walled up in his own agony ... everyone tiptoes around him, etc. ... but ... looking in on him from the outside ... all you can see is his pain. His loss. God, it's fantastic. I'm crying as I write this - sorry, I'm a bit undone right now.
McGahern almost seems invisible in this process - his writing is so good, so seamless, it seems almost to be flowing directly from an experience ... The book does not appear to be invented at all. It just IS. It IS the experience that it describes. So few writers are able to do that, so few writers are able to make us forget THEM ... and guide us straight into a story.
We are fully immersed in that house. With those sisters. The wife. And that father. Even thinking about that character makes me weep. Which I am doing right now. It's all tied up with my own father ... and the father-daughter dynamic ... and also the IRISH father-daughter dynamic - which is very specific, and ... archetypal ... and I can't describe it. ... But McGahern can and does.
A truly great novelist. A master of the form.
John Banville, another favorite of my father, had this to say about McGahern: "Amongst Women,' which was his masterpiece -- if there was any justice at all, it should have won the Booker Prize. It would have given him the international recognition that he didn't have. The literary world we live in now is so glittery. His novels were so quiet, perhaps they didn't travel well. But they will."
That came from the NY Times obituary here.
His fame is localized. He is famous to Irish people, and to people who love fiction. Amongst Women routinely makes it into lists like: Top 50 Best Irish Novels (or Top 100) or what have you ... but I would put it on my list of Top 50 Best Novels, period.
From a commenter on Sinéad Gleeson's blog-post about it:
Amongst Women. I read it when I was fourteen. It is sublime. It is the foundation stone for everything I have read and written and thought about since then.I can’t believe this, Sinead. It is so desperately sad. He had been ill but he had recovered, had really fought it. We saw him at Christmas and he was in great form.
There won’t be his like again.
Rest in peace, Mr. McGahern.
Beautiful and interesting piece on William Butler Yeats by Seamus Heaney. Peteb sent it to me a whlie back but I am just getting to it now.
Some great observations:
Conquest, difficulty, labour: these terms indicate the nature of Yeats's creative disposition. From the start, he was enamoured of Blake's conviction that energy is eternal delight, yet the development of his own thought brought him more and more to the conclusion that conflict was the inescapable condition of being human. So, as his art matured and the articulation of his beliefs became more clarified and forceful, Yeats's poems typically conveyed a sensation of certitude achieved by great effort and of contradictions quelled. Poems in which the defiant self is pitted against hostile or disabling conditions - "An Irish Airman Foresees his Death", "September 1913", "Meditations in Time of Civil War"- are complemented by poems that read like discharges of pure, self-possessed energy, poems from which the accidental circumstances have been excluded so that all that remains is the melody and stamina of resurgent spirit - "The Cold Heaven", "Byzantium", "Long-legged Fly".
I had such a good time, this past fall, reading the complete works of Yeats - sitting backstage in my dressing room, I had a lot of time back there during other scenes - and I would sit at the makeup mirror, dressed in my costume, as the show went on out on stage, and read. It's really cool to read all the early stuff - because then the later poems just shine all the more.
I was very very interested to read Heaney's words on Maud Gonne, in terms of her effect on Yeats' life (and, more importantly - his creativity):
And all the while, of course, there was Maud Gonne, "high and solitary and most stern" according to one of the poems about her, "foremost among those I would hear praised" according to another, and "the troubling of my life" according to a famous sentence in his Autobiographies. The passion she inspired - and as readers we experience it more as creative power than erotic need - made her a figure of primary poetic radiance, a Dublin Beatrice, an archetype as much as a daily presence. Nevertheless, Yeats's poetry, his politics and his involvement with the occult received an extra charge of intensity from her day to day reality in his life, and when she appeared in the title role of his subversive play Cathleen Ni Houlihan (1902), another kind of maturity was achieved.
This makes me think of Anne's post about Maud Gonne quite a while back (it took me some searching to find it!!) - but it gives a really interesting glimpse of this woman, the great unrequited love of Yeats' life. I read some funny quote somewhere (can't remember where) that said: "Any biography of Yeats would have to have in every chapter the following words: 'And he proposed marriage yet again to Maud Gonne'." Poor man! But oh - the creative energies it unleashed!
Anyway, go read the whole thing. It's goosebump-inducing for me - to read Heaney's words. He expresses so well what I feel, yet in a much more articulate way.
This is an edited post of something I wrote last year on his birthday. When I say 'edit' I mean I added MORE to it. hahaha
"You're always having to compete with yourself. They always say, 'It's not as good as Streetcar or Cat'. Of course it's not. At 69, you don't write the kind of play you write at 30. You haven't got the kind of energy you used to have."-- Tennessee Williams

Tennessee Williams said the following about Streetcar, and his main point of that entire play:
There are no 'good' or 'bad' people. Some are a little better or a little worse but all are activated more by misunderstanding than malice. A blindness to what is going on in each other's hearts. Stanley sees Blanche not as a desperate, driven creature backed into a last corner to make a last desperate stand - but as a calculating bitch with 'round heels'.... Nobody sees anybody truly but all through the flaws of their own egos. That is the way we all see each other in life.
I have been in his plays, I have worked on his plays in scene classes, I have written extensively about his plays, my bookshelves are lined with books filled with references to this most extraordinary man.
Tennessee Williams wrote the following elegiac essay about Laurette Taylor (who created the role of Amanda so memorably in Glass Menagerie and made him star) for The New York Times after news of her death in 1949:
I do not altogether trust the emotionalism that is commonly indulged in over the death of an artist, not because it is necessarily lacking in sincerity but because it may come too easily. In what I say now about Laurette Taylor I restrict myself to those things which I have felt continually about her as apart from any which this unhappy occasion produces.Of course the first is that I consider her the greatest artist of her profession that I have known. The second is that I loved her as a person. In a way the second is more remarkable. I have seldom encountered any argument about her preeminent stature as an actress. But for me to love her was remarkable because I have always been so awkward and diffident around actors that it has made a barrier between us almost all but insuperable.
In the case of Laurette Taylor, I cannot say that I ever got over the awkwardness and the awe which originally were present, but she would not allow it to stand between us. The great warmth of her heart burned through and we became close friends.
I am afraid it is the only close friendship I have ever had with a player...
It is our immeasurable loss that Laurette Taylor's performances were not preserved on the modern screen. The same is true of Duse and Bernhardt, with whom her name belongs. Their glory survives in the testimony and inspiration of those who saw them. Too many people have been too deeply moved by the gift of Laurette Taylor for that to disappear from us.
In this unfathomable experience of ours there are sometimes hints of something that lies outside the flesh and its mortality. I suppose these intuitions come to many people in their religious vocations, but I have sensed them more clearly in the work of artists and most clearly of all in the art of Laurette Taylor. There was a radiance about her art which I can compare only to the greatest lines of poetry, and which gave me the same shock of revelation as if the air about us had been momentarily broken through by light from some clear space beyond us.
The last word that I received from her was a telegram which reached me early this fall. It was immediately after the road company of our play had opened in Pittsburgh. The notices spoke warmly of Pauline Lord's performance in the part of Amanda. "I have just read the Pittsburgh notices," Laurette wired me. "What did I tell you, my boy? You don't need me."
I feel now - as I have always felt - that a whole career of writing for the theatre is rewarded enough by having created one good part for a great actress.
Having created a part for Laurette Taylor is a reward I find sufficient for all the effort that went before and any that may come after.
It was a two-sided deal there. Her performance launched him into stardom. And his creation of Amanda revitalized her career just in time for her to capitalize on it. She would be dead in a couple of years. She had had a great career early in her life, and went on a 10 year binge following the death of her husband. Laurette Taylor was "washed up". Until ...
And now, she's a legend, her performance in Glass Menagerie is legendary. "What did I tell you, my boy, you don't need me..." Ha. That's what you think, Laurette! But in a way, she was completely right. The play is better than any one performance. The play didn't depend on Laurette Taylor's genius, although thank God she found the vehicle. The star of the play is actually the play itself, and Laurette Taylor knew that. The star of the play was this new voice of Tennessee Williams. And so no, Tennessee didn't "need" her. And about Tennessee saying: "I consider her the greatest artist of her profession that I have known." Anyone who knows anything about theatre would be hard-pressed to disagree. I haven't even SEEN the woman act, obviously, but I don't need to. I will take the hundreds and hundreds of eyewitness' word for it. In the same way that I know, in my heart, that Eleanora Duse was one of the "greatest artists of her profession" as well. I don't need to have seen her live.
Here's a treat for all you Tennessee and Laurette fans. Here is one of the original reviews of Glass Menagerie, after its premiere on an icy winter night in Chicago. This review focuses on the miracle that was Laurette Taylor's performance.
January 14, 1945MEMO FROM CHICAGO By Lloyd Lewis
CHICAGO - As this is written there exists doubt as to whether Eddie Dowling has anything more satisfying than an artistic success in his new production, "The Glass Menagerie", at the Civic Theatre, but there is no doubt whatsoever that he has brought back Laurette Taylor as a great character actress.
Not since she did "Peg o'My Heart," exactly thirty years ago, has she been so talked and written about.
In "The Glass Menagerie," which is a tenuous and moody tragedy from the pen of Tennessee Williams, she plays a decaying Delta belle overfond of haranguing her two children, one a warehouse worker (Mr. Dowling) and the other a morbidly bashful maiden (Julie Haydon), upon their duty to rise above the drabness of life in a St. Louis alley flat. Fumbling around the dolorous precincts of her home in a slipshod Mother Hubbard, she is forever reciting the plantation glories of her youth, how seventeen young gentlemen callers were forever complimenting her among the magnolias, and how she could have had this or that grandson instead of the captivating plebeian drunk who took her only to desert her and leave her to current St. Louis blues.
When Miss Taylor mumbles in magnificent realism she is still enough of a vocal wizard to be intelligible to her audiences, and when she pouts, nags or struts in pathetic bursts of romantic memory she is superb as a pantomime. Her descents into hysteria are masterpieces of understatement, dramatic in that they force her audience to do the acting for her.
She accomplishes her tour de force of acting without a single gesture which could be charged with showmanship. Some of her most telling lines are fumbling mutterings delivered over her shoulder. And in a scene wherein she prods her son into bringing home somebody, anybody, who might possibly marry his psychopathic sister before he himself wanders off, as his mother knows he will, into the big, blue and tipsy yonder, she gives a performance that could fit into the best of the Abbey Theatre's Irish plays.
One moment she is a ridiculous pretender and the next only a poor old woman dreading so soon to be dead because her helpless daughter will then be alone. When a 'caller' is eventually dragooned and brought to the house for dinner, Miss Taylor's appearance in an ancient taffety and high-toned manners is a delicate feat in the creation of that narrow line between the absurd and the sad.
Oh. Oh. For a time machine.
Here's a picture of Tennessee Williams out on his beloved Key West in 1980:

Make voyages. Attempt them. That's all there is.-- Tennessee Williams, "Camino Real"
I'm deeply attached to the works of Tennessee Williams. Too many stories to even tell. I realized things about myself - and my life - through working on Miss Alma in Summer and Smoke - that pretty much forever changed me. My journal entries from that time are ... hard to describe. I went into it a little bit here. Sheila and Alma had completely merged. It's one of the only times that's ever happened. Funny: I love to post my Diary Friday excerpts from high school days, because haw haw haw we can all sort of chuckle at the exuberance and silliness of youth. But I would very much hesitate to post those Sheila/Alma entries - which were, first of all, much more recent - but also - I don't know if I would ever want to expose that side of myself here. That is the real Artist Sheila. I couldn't bear to have anyone roll their eyes or chuckle at HER. NOBODY can tell me that Alma is "just" a character in a play. She LIVES, she breathes. I certainly felt possessed by her.
When people who knew him talk about Tennessee Williams, they always mention his laugh. Apparently, he had this wild high-pitched out-of-control Mozartian giggle, completely infectious to anyone near him. His plays may have had tragic elements, but that was how he worked out his own tragic upbringing, his sister's lobotomy, etc. He himself was not an openly tragic or introverted figure. He put all of his grief and sadness into his plays. The man was deeply sensitive - like all of his female characters. But if this seems like he was a bleak or depressive personality, that's incorrect. He always balked, too, when reviewers would characterize all of his female characters as "desperate". He didn't agree with that assessment at all. He saw each and every one of them as survivors - women trying to break through and live a happy and meaningful life. Other people assigned the meaning "desperate" to them, but Tennessee always hated that. Here's part of an essay he wrote for The New York Times in 1948 where he addresses this whole "desperate character" thing - In this essay he uses Miss Alma in "Summer and Smoke" as the jumping-off point:
All at once, I found myself hammed in by three women in basic black who had been to the Saturday matinee and had apparently thought of nothing since except the problems of Alma Winemiller, the heroine of "Summer and Smoke". When you are eating, a great deal can be accomplished by having a mouth full of food and by making gutteral noises instead of speech when confronted with questions such as, What is the theme of your play? What happens to the characters after the play is over? What is your next play about and how do you happen to know so much about women? On that last one you can spit the food out if it really begins to choke you.For a writer who is not intentionally obscure, and never, in his opinion, obscure at all, I do get asked a hell of a lot of questions which I can't answer. I have never been able to say what was the theme of my play and I don't think I have ever been conscious of writing with a theme in mind. I am always surprised when, after a play has opened, I read in the papers what the play is about, that it was about a decayed Southern belle trying to get a man for her crippled daughter, or that it was about a boozie floozie on the skids, or that a backwoods sheik in a losing battle with three village vamps.
Don't misunderstand me. I am thankful for these highly condensed and stimulating analyses, but it would never have occurred to me that that was the story I was trying to tell. Usually when asked about a theme I look vague and say, "It is a play about life." What could be simpler, and yet more pretentious? You can easily extend that a little and say it is a tragedy of incomprehension. That also means life. Or you can say it is a tragedy of Puritanism. That is life in America. Or you can say that it is a play that considers the "problem of evil". But why not just say "life"?
To return to the women in the alcove. On this particular occasion the question that floored me was, "Why do you always write about frustrated women?"
To say that floored me is to put it mildly, because I would say that frustrated is almost exactly what the women I write about are not. What was frustrated about Amanda Wingfield? Circumstances, yes! But spirit? See Helen Hayes in London's "Glass Menagerie" if you still think Amanda was a frustrated spirit! No, there is nothing interesting about frustration, per se. I could not write a line about it for the simple reason that I can't write a line about anything that bores me.
Was Blance of "A Streetcar Named Desire" frustrated? About as frustrated as a beast of the jungle! And Alma Winemiller? What is frustrated about loving with such white hot intensity that it alters the whole direction of your life, and removes you from the parlor of the Episcopal rectory to a secret room above Moon Lake Casino?
I came across this essay when I was working on Alma Winemiller - and I can't tell you how much of an "A-ha!" moment it gave me. If I felt drawn towards portraying her as sexually FRUSTRATED, or emotionally FRUSTRATED ... I remembered Tennessee's words. I remembered the truth of them. Do not play the frustration. How boring. Play the OBJECTIVE, play the DESIRE, play what you WANT with all your heart ... Let the CIRCUMSTANCES of the play frustrate you ... but never ever take your eye off your objective. And THAT is where the tragedy lies.
Brilliant. So so helpful to any actress who works on ANY of his great parts to keep in mind.
I love that drive in him - the drive to pour all of the darkness and fear from his background into his work - he was a man driven to do so - it was therapeutic for him, yes, but never just therapy. Art that is just therapy is usually bad art. Or - perhaps not bad - but it will not stand the test of time. Tennessee worked on his craft, and always cared more about the PLAY than about the personal demons exorcised by said play. Read his letters, his journals, his instructions to directors ... the level of detail there is astonishing. Really inspiring to me. To be such a great artist, but to also have such an understanding of craft, and structure.
"Nothing's more determined than a cat on a tin roof - is there? Is there, baby?"-- from Cat on a Hot Tin Roof
The lead of the last play I did was the lead in Tennessee Williams' last play - Something Cloudy Something Clear - done here in NYC at Cocteau Rep. Williams died soon after the play went up. Craig shared with me his memories of working with Tennessee. Precious.
Everyone talks about his "laugh". Actors and actresses who were in his plays talk about hearing his laugh from out in the audience. It was a generous laugh, a laugh full of joy. If an actor or actress was doing well, he had no problem with letting them know, with enjoying their performances openly. (Other playwrights are not so kind. It seems as though other playwrights have this thought process: "No actor could EVER live up to the perfection that resides in my mind. My play is perfect as is ... it's the ACTORS who are messing it up!!" Playwrights like that, usually, are big bores, and don't have a lot of talent. Like: okay, you want perfection? Build a feckin' statue, and don't hire live actors. Mkay? That way your precious words will be safe from contamination. Ahem. I have a ton of stories.) But Tennessee, while kind of intimidated by actors, he never knew what to say to them ... LOVED them when they were wonderful. He did not consciously withhold approval - like so many do. If someone sucked, he had no problem with sending a note to the director saying: "Please have her realize that she needs to be light and funny on that one line - she is dragging down the entire scene with her dismal line readings..." hahaha He would never say such a thing to the actor's face - he let the director do his job - but if he was pleased? He would sit out in the audience, and just HOWL with laughter. He loved being an audience member. So many people in the theatre, because the theatre is their job and livelihood - forget how to just be an audience member.
Here, to me, is a quintessential Tennessee Williams statement.
An interviewer asked him: "What is your definition of happiness?"
He replied, "Insensitivity, I guess."
His experience of "happiness" as being, in its essence, "insensitive" came from his background. Those who were "sensitive" were crushed and shattered by cruelty, by life itself. His sister Rose was institutionalized and lobotomized. This was something Tennessee never really recovered from. (But he didn't really HAVE to recover from it, I guess. All of his feelings about it went into his work. If he had "recovered", or "worked it out" in his mind, then he might not have written Glass Menagerie, Summer and Smoke, et al.) He was a perpetual outsider. He was on the run from his past. He was able to "get out" of the past ... his sister Rose was not. The guilt of that never left him. The guilt of being "the one" who was able to live in the real world dogged him at every turn. If one was "happy", if one was able to manuever thru a world that lobotomized some of its most sensitive members, then "happiness" required some kind of a hard outer shell - a shell that Tennessee himself lacked, that other "sensitives" (his word) lacked. He did not begrudge people their happiness ... he just didn't understand it. He couldn't get "in there", ever. Again, this is kind of a blessing, at least as far as we are concerned - merely because that sort of baffled response to how on earth to LIVE in this world ... is the emotional place from which he wrote all of his plays.
He WAS Blanche. He WAS Tom in Glass Menagerie. He WAS Alma. He WAS Maggie. All of these people, these "sensitives", trying to make their way through, trying to bear up under disappointments and cruelty ... trying to SURVIVE.
Again and again, Williams reiterated that he never wrote about victims. He didn't see any of these people as victims. He saw them as survivors. Beautiful triumphant survivors. I love that about him.
Oh, you weak, beautiful people who give up with such grace. What you need is someone to take hold of you - gently, with love, and hand your life back to you.-- Tennessee Williams
The Blache DuBois', the Laura Wingfields, the Miss Almas ... these are sensitive people, deeply wounded people, on the edge of shattering - just like his sister Rose did. Of course blatant casual "happiness" would be seen as insensitive through their eyes.
All cruel people describe themselves as paragons of frankness.-- Tennessee Williams
Tennessee Williams is one of my own personal heroes, for more reasons than one, and I am aware (on a pretty much daily basis) of how grateful I am to him for his plays. In the same way that I am pretty much always conscious of being grateful that there was a Shakespeare, and that we have his works with us today. I still read Tennessee Williams plays now, over and over, reading them countless times, never ever getting tired of them, never ever feeling like all my questions are answered.
Some mystery should be left in the revelation of character in a play, just as a great deal of mystery is always left in the revelation of character in life, even in one's own character to himself.-- Tennessee Williams
And I'll leave you with another really telling and beautiful anecdote, this one from Elia Kazan. I LOVE this, because it says to me, in no uncertain terms, why Tennessee Williams is a god among playwrights - and why he is so unusual. Nobody else can touch him, really. I love Arthur Miller's plays, but there's always a social conscience in them which can get preachy and tiresome if it's not controlled. Death of a Salesman has a perfect balance, but his later plays have the feeling of pamphlets.
Tennessee Williams has none of that. There is no "social conscience" in his plays. There is no deeper social criticism going on. Perhaps the only "criticism" that Tennessee consistently levels at "society" is the way it treats the "sensitives".
I have found it easier to identify with the characters who verge upon hysteria, who were frightened of life, who were desperate to reach out to another person. But these seemingly fragile people are the strong people really.-- Tennessee Williams
Here's the setup for the excerpt I want to post (which has to do with the rehearsals and also the opening of Streetcar Named Desire):
Jessica Tandy, who originated Blanche on Broadway, was already a celebrated actress. Marlon Brando was practically unknown. Kazan noticed which way the wind was blowing during rehearsals, and it concerned him on many levels.
Basically what was happening was that Marlon Brando was acting Jessica Tandy off the stage. Without breaking a sweat, Brando stole the show right out from under her. Jessica Tandy fought to keep her ground (which, actually, is perfect for the theme of the show and for the character of Blanche Dubois), but Kazan's main concern was that Blanche would turn into a laughable character and lose the sympathy of the audience. Kazan was worried that the audience, because of Brando's undeniable stage presence, and the electricity of his acting, would completely side with Stanley, and not have any sympathy for Blanche at all. This, Kazan felt, would be a disaster. Stanley rapes Blanche. This event must be seen as horrifyingly wrong, not as Blanche getting what she deserves. But Brando's power took over the play, it was a runaway train, it wasn't a matter of him playing Stanley as sympathetic - he wasn't. It was just that he was a force to be reckoned with, a powerhouse - you couldn't take your eyes off him. Jessica Tandy barely registered, when she was beside him.
Here's a photo from that production: Brando, Kim Hunter, and Tandy:

And so Kazan feared, as rehearsals went on, that the balance of the play was off.
Here's what Kazan wrote about all of this in his marvelous autobiography.
It is Tennessee Williams' "advice" to Kazan at the end that really packs a punch:
But what had been intimated in our final rehearsals in New York was happening. The audiences adored Brando. When he derided Blanche, they responded with approving laughter. Was the play becoming the Marlon Brando Show? I didn't bring up the problem, because I didn't know the solution. I especially didn't want the actors to know that I was concerned. What could I say to Brando? Be less good? Or to Jessie? Get better? ...Louis B. Mayer sought me out to congratulate me and assure me that we'd all make a fortune ... He urged me to make the author do one critically important bit of rewriting to make sure that once that "awful woman" who'd come to break up that "fine young couple's happy home" was packed off to an institution, the audience would believe that the young couple would live happily ever after. It never occurred to him that Tennessee's primary sympathy was with Blanche, nor did I enlighten him ... His misguided reaction added to my concern. I had to ask myself: Was I satisfied to have the performance belong to Marlon Brando? Was that what I'd intended? What did I intend? I looked to the author. He seemed satisfied. Only I -- and perhaps Hume [Cronyn, Tandy's husband] -- knew that something was going wrong ...
What astonished me was that the author wasn't concerned about the audience's favoring Marlon. That puzzled me because Tennessee was my final authority, the person I had to please. I still hadn't brought up the problem, I was waiting for him to do it. I got my answer ... because of something that happened in the Ritz-Carlton Hotel, across the hall from my suite, where Tennessee and Pancho were staying. [Pancho was Tennessee's boyfriend - or maybe it was more of a f*** buddy situation. Pancho was a huge presence in Tennessee's life. They had a really volatile relationship.] One night I heard a fearsome commotion from across the hall, curses in Spanish, threats to kill, the sound of breaking china ... and a crash ... As I rushed out into the corridor, Tennessee burst through his door, looking terrified, and dashed into my room. Pancho followed, but when I blocked my door, he turned to the elevator still cursing, and was gone. Tennessee slept on the twin bed in my room that night. The next morning, Pancho had not returned.
I noticed that Wiilliams wasn't angry at Pancho, not even disapproving -- in fact, when he spoke about the incident, he admired Pancho for his outburst. At breakfast, I brought up my worry about Jessie and Marlon. "She'll get better," Tennessee said, and then we had our only discussion about the direction of his play. "Blanche is not an angel without a flaw," he said, "and Stanley's not evil. I know you're used to clearly stated themes, but this play should not be loaded one way or the other. Don't try to simplify things." Then he added, "I was making fun of Pancho, and he blew up." He laughed. I remembered the letter he'd written me before we started rehearsals, remembered how, in that letter, he'd cautioned me against tipping the moral scales against Stanley, that in the interests of fidelity I must not present Stanley as a "black-dyed villain". "What should I do?" I asked. "Nothing," he said. "Don't take sides or try to present a moral. When you begin to arrange the action to make a thematic point, the fidelity to life will suffer. Go on working as you are. Marlon is a genius, but she's a worker and she will get better. And better."
So extraordinary. It brings tears to my eyes, and it's wonderful advice, advice that any artist would do well to follow. "Don't take sides ..." "fidelity to life ..."
Here is the review of the premiere of Streetcar Named Desire, in New York City, December 3, 1947.
December 4, 1947FIRST NIGHT AT THE THEATRE by Brooks Atkinson
Tennessee Williams has brought us a superb drama, "A Streetcar Named Desire," which was acted at the Ethel Barrymore last evening. And Jessica Tandy gives a superb performance as a rueful heroine whose misery Mr. Williams is tenderly recording. This must be one of the most perfect marriages of acting and playwriting. For the acting and playwriting are perfectly blended in a limpid performance, and it is impossible to tell where Miss Tandy begins to give form and warmth to the mood Mr. Williams has created.
Like "The Glass Menagerie," the new play is a quietly woven study of intangibles. But to this observer it shows deeper insight and represents a great step forward toward clarity. And it reveals Mr. Williams as a genuinely poetic playwright whose knowledge of people is honest and thorough and whose sympathy is profoundly human.
"A Streetcar Named Desire" is history of a gently reared Mississippi young woman who invents an artificial world to mask the hideousness of the world she has to inhabit. She comes to live with her sister, who is married to a rough-and-ready mechanic and inhabits two dreary rooms in a squalid neighborhood. Blanche - for that is her name - has delusions of grandeur, talks like an intellectual snob, buoys herself up with gaudy dreams, spends most of her time primping, covers things that are dingy with things that are bright and flees reality.
To her brother-in-law she is an unforgiveable liar. But it is soon apparent to the theatregoer that in Mr. Williams' eyes she is one of the dispossessed whose experience has unfitted her for reality; and although his attitude toward her is merciful, he does not spare her or the playgoer. For the events of "Streetcar" lead to a painful conclusion which he does not try to avoid. Although Blanche cannot face the truth, Mr. Williams does in the most imaginative and perceptive play he has written.
Since he is no literal dramatist and writes in none of the conventional forms, he presents theatre with many problems. Under Elia Kazan's sensitive but concrete direction, the theatre solved them admirably. Jo Mielziner has provided a beautifully lighted single setting that lightly sketches the house and the neighborhood. In this shadowy environment the performance is a work of great beauty.
Miss Tandy has a remarkably long part to play. She is hardly ever off the stage, and when she is on stage she is almost constantly talking -- chattering, dreaming aloud, wondering, building enchantments out of words. Miss Tandy is a trim, agile actress with a lovely voice and quick intelligence. Her performance is almost incredibly true. For it does seem almost incredible that she can convey it with so many shades and impulses that are accurate, revealing and true.
The rest of the acting is also of very high quality indeed. Marlon Brando as the quick-tempered, scornful, violent mechanic; Karl Malden as a stupid but wondering suitor; Kim Hunter as the patient though troubled sister -- all act not only with color and style but with insight.
By the usual Broadway standards, "Streetcar Named Desire" is too long; not all those words are essential. But Mr. Williams is entitled to his own independence. For he has not forgotten that human beings are the basic subject of art. Out of poetic imagination and ordinary compassion he has spun a poignant and luminous story.
I have tears in my eyes.
We are lucky in this country that we have produced such a playwright. We are lucky to have all of his plays in the canon. I can't imagine my life without them.
Happy birthday, Tom.

Tennessee Williams said the following, in a 1981 interview - only a couple of years before he passed away:
"I'm very conscious of my decline in popularity, but I don't permit it to stop me because I have the example of so many playwrights before me. I know the dreadful notices Ibsen got. And O'Neill -- he had to die to make 'Moon' successful. And to me it has been providential to be an artist, a great act of providence that I was able to turn my borderline psychosis into creativity -- my sister Rose did not manage this. So I keep writing. I am sometimes pleased with what I do -- for me, that's enough."
Words to live by. I try to do the same.

She was born today, in Savannah, Georgia in 1925.
Man, what to say, what to say ... I think she's one of our greatest American authors. Not just a great Southern writer, although she is that, one of the all-time best, in the pantheon!! - but one of the greatest American writers. Phenomenal. Mostly known for her short stories, although she did write a couple novels.
I also, personally, feel that her TITLES are beyond fantastic. She's not afraid to GO THERE in her titles. I don't know how else to describe it. Her titles are not "safe". They have a Biblical feel to them. The Violent Bear It Away. The Life You Save May Be Your Own. Everything That Rises Must Converge. I looooove her titles.
Here is a great site devoted to her. I didn't know that her first published efforts were actually cartoons, in her high school newspaper. She tried to get her cartoons published in The New Yorker - and that went nowhere, none of them were accepted - so she started to focus on writing. She applied to the Iowa Writer's Workshop - and got in. Once there, though, she was kind of on the outside of things - she hadn't read "the big authors" who were in vogue at the time. Her writing idols were Nathaniel Hawthorne and Edgar Allan Poe - seen as 'old-fashioned', and perhaps too Gothic or melodramatic. Classic, sure, but way out of style in this new modern era of Ezra Pound, and James Joyce, and Fitzgerald. So she wasn't really born "in the right time", if you think about it - but she turned that to her advantage. She didn't try to change her influences, or write like other people - and while she was at the workshop, her short stories pretty much blew everyone away. I love that her idols were Hawthorne and Poe - those dark dark writers, those masters of small-town pain and paranoia ... You can so feel it in her writing, although her style is very much her own. Her style is so distinctive that you could recognize a paragraph of her prose without knowing who it was. She's like Hemingway. So - she was a shy girl, the only one in the workshop with a Southern accent, whose writing was so good that she got a contract to write her first novel (Wise Blood - now that is one HELL of a first novel!!)
Right around this time, she got very very ill with lupus (that's why she has the crutches in the photo above). Her father had died from lupus. She was always tired, always dragging through her days - but she had good discipline, and kept up a writing schedule, despite her exhaustion.
I just read her first novel Wise Blood ... and it's shocking to read even NOW. I can't even imagine the impact it had when it came out. Her writing reminds me of Diane Arbus' photographs. Her books are filled with grotesque Gothic characters - blinded crazy preachers, child brides, women with wooden legs, outcasts from society - But her tone is never sensational or sentimental.
If you haven't read her stuff, I really can't recommend her highly enough. I came to her late - and it was really at the pressure of Maria, and my sister Jean, that made me finally give her a go. After reading the first two or three paragraphs of Wise Blood, I was feckin' hooked. I knew: Okay. I must now plow thru this entire book RIGHT NOW. She's that good.
Here's the beginning of that novel:
Hazel Motes sat at a forward angle on the green plush train seat, looking one minute at the window as if he might want to jump out of it, and the next down the aisle at the other end of the car. The train was racing through tree tops that fell away at intervals and showed the sun standing, very red, on the edge of the farthest woods. Nearer, the plowed fields curved and faded and the few hogs nosing in the furrows looked like large spotted stones. Mrs. Wally Bee Hitchcock, who was facing Motes in this section, said that she thought the early evening like this was the prettiest time of day and she asked him if he didn't think so, too. She was a fat woman with pink collars and cuffs and pear-shaped legs that slanted off the train seat and didn't reach the floor.He looked at her a second and, without answering, leaned forward and stared down the length of the car again. She turned to see what was back there but all she saw was a child peering around one of the sections and, farther up at the end of the car, the porter opening the closet where the sheets were kept.
"I guess you're going home," she said, turning back to him again. He didn't look, to her, much over twenty, but he had a stiff black broad-brimmed hat on his lap, a hat that an elderly country preacher would wear. His suit was a glaring blue and the price tag was still stapled on the sleeve of it.
There's something really ... WRONG ... here. You can tell ... something is OFF with Hazel Motes ... but Flannery doesn't let us inside his head. It's all in what she doesn't say, and what she chooses to share with us. It's a fantastic opening scene.
Check her out if you haven't read any of her stuff - her short story collections are all well worth reading. She's an American classic.
Flannery O'Connor died at the age of 40.
I came across this quote from Flannery O'Connor, and I just loooove it, it makes me laugh. I'll close this post with it:
"Everywhere I go, I'm asked if I think the universities stifle writers. My opinion is that they don't stifle enough of them."
hahahahaha
Happy birthday, Flannery!!
Former poet laureate of the United States. Want to see the entire list of poets laureate? Go here. Pretty cool.
One of the things that I love about Billy Collins (besides his poetry, I mean) is that he is a truly POPULAR poet. His books are bestsellers - and BEFORE he was a poet laureate they were. He writes for the "everyman". Now I love poetry of all kind - obscure, experimental, confessional, etc. - but I also love the poets who speak directly into the experience of most people. Billy Collins is one of those poets. A lot of people discount his work because of this - but you know, those people are idiots. The same kinds of people who got MAD at Kurt Cobain for becoming successful and making some money. There's nothing WRONG with being successful. But also there's a deeper issue here: Poets used to be much more important, and poetry was something most people enjoyed. Kids had to memorize poems in class. Poetry was not seen as elitist. Now I think a lot of the people who call poetry elite basically just don't like "fancy book larnin" and they label anything challenging or outside their experience as "elitist" - so we can discount their opinion. Or I can, and I do. Happily. But I think a lot of it, too, is that with the birth of confessional poetry in the 50s and 60s - many poets STOPPED talking to the universal. They delved totally into the personal. Hence - we have many INCOMPREHENSIBLE poems filling the - er - air waves - and ... nobody can relate.
Blue stockings
Oh my heart
A glass window, my codeine tablets
Chickadee monkey
Flippity floppity
Oh say can you see
I am dying
hahahahaha I mean, whatever. Now ... am I supposed to RELATE to that? Uhm - no.
These are the artistic children of such geniuses as Allen Ginsberg, Robert Lowell, Sylvia Plath, Anne Sexton - true masters of their craft. Yes, they wrote about theie own lives, and mental illness - but nobody could EVER say that they were not good at their work. You may not like that type of poetry - a lot of people don't (I happen to adore it) ... but everyone imitating them now just ... they only go for the CONFESSIONAL part of the equation, and forget about the - er ... ART.
Again, though, I want to make myself clear in light of the whole "I'm not much for fancy book-larnin'" type: I don't like art only when I can RELATE to it. I'm not only looking for MYSELF in a poem. I like words, I like language, I like writers. But the fragmented BAD writing which makes up most of modern poetry is kind of disheartening - and it's no wonder that people aren't into poetry anymore. Bring back the Dead White Male contingent, please!
Anyway: because Billy Collins is so POPULAR, he is not as respected. Which is just a sign of the times, I suppose. I happen to love his stuff. He's a good writer. Perhaps not as complex as I normally enjoy, and not as howling-at-the-moon-with-despair as I enjoy and relate to - but he's a fine writer, and it was quite a triumph, I thought, when he was asked to be Poet Laureate. It was fabulous!!
I also love his web site. I love it because whoever put it together obviously has never put together a website before and I find something charmingly naive about that. There are no real links on that first page. It's strange ... then when you get to the Link Index, I am so charmed by this sentence:
BOOK BILLY FOR YOUR NEXT EVENT
Mr. Collins is available for real live appearances
I just ... To me, that completely encapsulates who Billy Collins is. Accessible. Friendly. He makes "real live appearances" ... It's so human, so simple. I love it.
Anyway, I highly recommend you checking out his work if you haven't already - and as a way of saying Happy Birthday, I'll post the poem that he wrote following September 11 - when he was Poet Laureate. I've posted it before.
Never ever fails to tear at my heart.
The Names
Yesterday, I lay awake in the palm of the night.
A soft rain stole in, unhelped by any breeze,
And when I saw the silver glaze on the windows,
I started with A, with Ackerman, as it happened,
Then Baxter and Calabro,
Davis and Eberling, names falling into place
As droplets fell through the dark.
Names printed on the ceiling of the night.
Names slipping around a watery bend.
Twenty-six willows on the banks of a stream.
In the morning, I walked out barefoot
Among thousands of flowers
Heavy with dew like the eyes of tears,
And each had a name --
Fiori inscribed on a yellow petal
Then Gonzalez and Han, Ishikawa and Jenkins.
Names written in the air
And stitched into the cloth of the day.
A name under a photograph taped to a mailbox.
Monogram on a torn shirt,
I see you spelled out on storefront windows
And on the bright unfurled awnings of this city.
I say the syllables as I turn a corner --
Kelly and Lee,
Medina, Nardella, and O'Connor.
When I peer into the woods,
I see a thick tangle where letters are hidden
As in a puzzle concocted for children.
Parker and Quigley in the twigs of an ash,
Rizzo, Schubert, Torres, and Upton,
Secrets in the boughs of an ancient maple.
Names written in the pale sky.
Names rising in the updraft amid buildings.
Names silent in stone
Or cried out behind a door.
Names blown over the earth and out to sea.
In the evening -- weakening light, the last swallows.
A boy on a lake lifts his oars.
A woman by a window puts a match to a candle,
And the names are outlined on the rose clouds --
Vanacore and Wallace,
(let X stand, if it can, for the ones unfound)
Then Young and Ziminsky, the final jolt of Z.
Names etched on the head of a pin.
One name spanning a bridge, another undergoing a tunnel.
A blue name needled into the skin.
Names of citizens, workers, mothers and fathers,
The bright-eyed daughter, the quick son.
Alphabet of names in a green field.
Names in the small tracks of birds.
Names lifted from a hat
Or balanced on the tip of the tongue.
Names wheeled into the dim warehouse of memory.
So many names, there is barely room on the walls of the heart.
It's Max Shulman's birthday. Who the hell is Max Shulman, you may ask? Or some of you may ask? Hahaha He was one of the most popular humorists of his day - who reached his peak of popularity in the 1950s. He's the dude who created the Dobie Gillis character. He was VERY successful - and is now kind of a forgotten artist. Strange. He also was a screenwriter.
Now I somehow tripped over his book I Was a Teenage Dwarf when I was a teenager myself. This is the chronicle of Dobie Gillis' crazy "woman"izing when he was in high school (the shortest boy in town. Hence - the title.)

It was in the library where I worked as a page (my first job). I have no idea why I would have picked it up - it's kind of an old-fashioned looking book - It LOOKS older than the more recent titles -but also, let's remember - this was at the height of the whole Happy Days craze - so maybe something in the 1950s-ish cover appealed to me.
Also, I DO know that my parents both LOVED Max Shulman. So when I brought the book home they recognized his name immediately, and told me: "You HAVE to read Rally Round the Flag, Boys!"

I remember vividly my mother TRYING to tell me what the name of one of the lead characters in Rally round the flag was - and completely not being able to get the name out because she started guffawing with laughter. The character's name was: Loadstone O'Toole. Even now - just typing that - I started laughing.
Max Shulman is one of the funniest writers I have ever read in my life. In fact, I was asked to leave my high school library because it was study period, and I was reading that book, and I started laughing so loudly that I could not control myself. Basically, I was GUFFAWING into the studious silence. Tears literally streamed down my face, despite the fact that I was being "Sh"ed left and right. I finally had to just gather up my book bag and stagger out into the hall, where I stood, and literally HOWLED with laughter, by myself, for a good 5 minutes.
Uhm - I can count the writers on one hand who are that feckin' funny.
Over the last couple years, it became my mission in life to find all of his old books again - so I could own them. Many of them are long out of print, and really hard to find. So strange. It's not that long ago - the 1950s and 60s - but his reputation has not survived. It's a shame. I have rarely come across such fanTAStically funny books. Member the famous Christmas pageant scene in Owen Meany? Max Shulman's books are that funny all the way through. The Strand sometimes had copies of his books - I always checked whenever I was there. I got some of his lesser known titles - but the holy grail eluded me. (I Was a Teenage Dwarf) I was dying to know if the book would be as funny to me as an adult as it was when I was a kid. I let my dad know, librarian that he is, what I was looking for - so he could keep his eyes open if he came across copies.
Eventually - a box arrived on my doorstep. I opened it. And took out two books: Rally Round the Flag, Boys starring the marvelously named Loadstone O'Toole (LOADSTONE O'TOOLE???? hahahahahaha) - and oh. my. God: I Was a Teenage Dwarf. Yay!!!!
I immediately took Teenage Dwarf up to my roof, with a thermos of coffee, and sat there in the autumn sun - tearing through my old childhood favorite. I finished it in a couple of hours.
And for the record? It was even funnier than I remembered. It's MEANER than I remembered. It's more biting, bitchy, merciless ... But I sat up there on my roof, the memories were just flooding back (Dobie Gillis at one point has a girlfriend who is a tomboy - and she is constantly playing stickball and climbing trees - and always falling down - so she always has cuts on her knees - her nickname is Red Knees. I was like: "Oh my God! I remember Red Knees!!") - but the sheer ridiculousness of it all was JUST as delightful, JUST as absurd. Like ... Dobie Gillis has a girlfriend whose accepted nickname is RED KNEES. Like, he's having a romantic makeout session with her, and he calls her "Red Knees" as he leans in to kiss her. "Oh, Red Knees ..." I mean - I just snort with laughter reading this stuff.
Writers who make me cry are great. I love them. But writers who make me laugh have my heart forever.
Max Shulman: a witty madcap man with a ridiculous and yet somehow very HUMAN sense of humor ... hugely successful in his day ... now mostly forgotten. If you ever come across his books in a used bookstore, I highly recommend you give them a read. They are laugh-out-loud funny.
Happy birthday, Mr. Shulman!!

I learned that today, in 1923, Robert Frost's "Stopping By The Woods on a Snowy Evening" was published in the New Republic.
Here's the story of the composition of that poem - which I think is just GREAT:
Though it's a poem about winter, Frost wrote the first draft on a warm morning in the middle of June. The night before he had stayed up working at his kitchen table on a long, difficult poem called "New Hampshire" (1923). He finally finished it, and then looked up and saw that it was morning. He'd never worked all night on a poem before. Feeling relieved at the work he'd finished, he went outside and watched the sunrise.But while he was outside, he suddenly got an idea for a new poem. So he rushed back inside his house and wrote "Stopping By Woods on a Snowy Evening" in just a few minutes. He said he wrote most of the poem almost without lifting his pen off the page.
Stopping By Woods On A Snowy Evening
Whose woods these are I think I know.
His house is in the village, though;
He will not see me stopping here
To watch his woods fill up with snow.
My little horse must think it queer
To stop without a farmhouse near
Between the woods and frozen lake
The darkest evening of the year.
He gives his harness bells a shake
To ask if there is some mistake.
The only other sound's the sweep
Of easy wind and downy flake.
The woods are lovely, dark, and deep,
But I have promises to keep,
And miles to go before I sleep,
And miles to go before I sleep.

In my humble opinion, it is that last stanza that makes this a truly great poem. Before that, although the imagery is beautiful and evocative - we are in a rather prosaic world, the world of the everyday - with neighbors and villages and harness bells - objects that cement us to the physical world.
But in the last stanza, Frost pulls his lens abruptly back ... going into the universal and timeless.
Jesus, it's moving.

One of our best storytellers. I've been reading John Irving's books since high school when I first read Garp. I think, in retrospect, my favorite of his books is Cider House Rules - (can't even really think about it without getting goosebumps) - but in terms of an emotional reading experience - Prayer for Owen Meany is up there in the top 5 - as one of the most intense and powerful reading experiences I've ever had. The book blindsided me. It is one of a handful of books where I spontaneously burst out crying at the last sentence. (In case you're interested - the other books in that very rare category are Geek Love - don't even get me started - and Atonement - don't even get me started again). I think, in terms of structure, impact, importance - Cider House Rules is his best book - so far - but ... argh - I don't want to commit to that!
My family are all huge John Irving fans - and my group of college friends are all Irving maniacs - led by Mitchell and David, primarily. I strayed away from the Irving oeuvre in the late 90s ... I just felt too wiped OUT by Owen Meany - which I had read in 1991 (I remember where I was, what I was wearing, what the day was like, etc., when I finished that book) - and somehow ... I was done with John Irving. For a while. Mitchell and David were the torch-bearers for Irving, saying to me... "Have you read Widow for one year?" "Have you read Son of the circus?" Etc. They kept up with him. The release of a new John Irving book is anticipated, waited for, countdowns going on ... "It comes out on April 1!!"
The story of how Garp came to be - and how his fourth novel took off in a way that other writers only DREAM of - is now the stuff of legend. Irving is quite honest about the fact that all of his books somehow have to do with absentee fathers - because he has never met his father. His father took off when Irving was a baby, never to be heard from again. One of the reasons that Irving's idol, as a writer, is Charles Dickens (no surprise there - he is Dickens' American heir) - is because of Dickens' neverending theme of abandoned children. Children have to fend for themselves in Dickens' work - and adults are notoriously unreliable, evil, and selfish. Irving felt really inspired by that. He said once: "My imaginary reader has been my father. Surely, in one novel after another, I've been inventing fathers. I've been making them up. I have a ceaseless capacity to make up the missing part, to fill in the blanks, and he was a blank in my life."
Amazing ... if Irving's father HADN'T abandoned his child - then perhaps John Irving would not be the artist he is today.
Irving fans: what are your favorites of his books?
"Believe me, every man has his secret sorrows,
which the world knows not; and oftimes
we call a man cold, when he is only sad."
-- Henry Wadsworth Longfellow
Henry Wadsworth Longfellow was born today in 1807. I have his collected works at home. But his "Paul Revere's Ride" is a favorite of mine - obviously. I have written about it quite a bit. That first stanza STILL gives me goosebumps. Shivers! Here it is - I never "get over" this poem. It's the story, of course - I love the story itself - but there's also something thrilling in the verse itself. It has a ring of inevitability to it. It's meant to be read out loud.
Paul Revere's Ride
Listen my children and you shall hear
Of the midnight ride of Paul Revere,
On the eighteenth of April, in Seventy-five;
Hardly a man is now alive
Who remembers that famous day and year.
He said to his friend, "If the British march
By land or sea from the town to-night,
Hang a lantern aloft in the belfry arch
Of the North Church tower as a signal light,--
One if by land, and two if by sea;
And I on the opposite shore will be,
Ready to ride and spread the alarm
Through every Middlesex village and farm,
For the country folk to be up and to arm."
Then he said "Good-night!" and with muffled oar
Silently rowed to the Charlestown shore,
Just as the moon rose over the bay,
Where swinging wide at her moorings lay
The Somerset, British man-of-war;
A phantom ship, with each mast and spar
Across the moon like a prison bar,
And a huge black hulk, that was magnified
By its own reflection in the tide.
Meanwhile, his friend through alley and street
Wanders and watches, with eager ears,
Till in the silence around him he hears
The muster of men at the barrack door,
The sound of arms, and the tramp of feet,
And the measured tread of the grenadiers,
Marching down to their boats on the shore.
Then he climbed the tower of the Old North Church,
By the wooden stairs, with stealthy tread,
To the belfry chamber overhead,
And startled the pigeons from their perch
On the sombre rafters, that round him made
Masses and moving shapes of shade,--
By the trembling ladder, steep and tall,
To the highest window in the wall,
Where he paused to listen and look down
A moment on the roofs of the town
And the moonlight flowing over all.
Beneath, in the churchyard, lay the dead,
In their night encampment on the hill,
Wrapped in silence so deep and still
That he could hear, like a sentinel's tread,
The watchful night-wind, as it went
Creeping along from tent to tent,
And seeming to whisper, "All is well!"
A moment only he feels the spell
Of the place and the hour, and the secret dread
Of the lonely belfry and the dead;
For suddenly all his thoughts are bent
On a shadowy something far away,
Where the river widens to meet the bay,--
A line of black that bends and floats
On the rising tide like a bridge of boats.
Meanwhile, impatient to mount and ride,
Booted and spurred, with a heavy stride
On the opposite shore walked Paul Revere.
Now he patted his horse's side,
Now he gazed at the landscape far and near,
Then, impetuous, stamped the earth,
And turned and tightened his saddle girth;
But mostly he watched with eager search
The belfry tower of the Old North Church,
As it rose above the graves on the hill,
Lonely and spectral and sombre and still.
And lo! as he looks, on the belfry's height
A glimmer, and then a gleam of light!
He springs to the saddle, the bridle he turns,
But lingers and gazes, till full on his sight
A second lamp in the belfry burns.
A hurry of hoofs in a village street,
A shape in the moonlight, a bulk in the dark,
And beneath, from the pebbles, in passing, a spark
Struck out by a steed flying fearless and fleet;
That was all! And yet, through the gloom and the light,
The fate of a nation was riding that night;
And the spark struck out by that steed, in his flight,
Kindled the land into flame with its heat.
He has left the village and mounted the steep,
And beneath him, tranquil and broad and deep,
Is the Mystic, meeting the ocean tides;
And under the alders that skirt its edge,
Now soft on the sand, now loud on the ledge,
Is heard the tramp of his steed as he rides.
It was twelve by the village clock
When he crossed the bridge into Medford town.
He heard the crowing of the cock,
And the barking of the farmer's dog,
And felt the damp of the river fog,
That rises after the sun goes down.
It was one by the village clock,
When he galloped into Lexington.
He saw the gilded weathercock
Swim in the moonlight as he passed,
And the meeting-house windows, black and bare,
Gaze at him with a spectral glare,
As if they already stood aghast
At the bloody work they would look upon.
It was two by the village clock,
When he came to the bridge in Concord town.
He heard the bleating of the flock,
And the twitter of birds among the trees,
And felt the breath of the morning breeze
Blowing over the meadow brown.
And one was safe and asleep in his bed
Who at the bridge would be first to fall,
Who that day would be lying dead,
Pierced by a British musket ball.
You know the rest. In the books you have read
How the British Regulars fired and fled,---
How the farmers gave them ball for ball,
From behind each fence and farmyard wall,
Chasing the redcoats down the lane,
Then crossing the fields to emerge again
Under the trees at the turn of the road,
And only pausing to fire and load.
So through the night rode Paul Revere;
And so through the night went his cry of alarm
To every Middlesex village and farm,---
A cry of defiance, and not of fear,
A voice in the darkness, a knock at the door,
And a word that shall echo for evermore!
For, borne on the night-wind of the Past,
Through all our history, to the last,
In the hour of darkness and peril and need,
The people will waken and listen to hear
The hurrying hoof-beats of that steed,
And the midnight message of Paul Revere.
SO SATISFYING. "It was one by the village clock ..." "It was two by the village clock ..." "For borne on the night-wind of the Past ..." Forgive me. I just find it all so ringingly satisfying.
The O'Malley family has passed on the love of that poem to the future generation. Here's something I wrote about Cashel, and Longfellow's poem that I read on a radio program here in New York a couple years ago. Cashel was 5 years old at the time. It seems to me it would be quite a fitting tribute to one of the most popular American poets we've ever had.
One If By Land
Cashel and I colored for a while as we waited for the pizza to arrive. Cashel commanded me to draw a house. So I did. Cashel was basically the architect and the interior designer. Telling me what he wanted to see.
"Put a playroom in the attic."
"But Auntie Sheila -- where are the stairs??"
I drew the bathroom, and the mere sight of the toilet caused Cashel to dissolve into mirth. Yes. Toilets are hilarious.
I drew a spiral staircase which blew Cashel away. "That's so COOL." Then I drew the living room. I said, "I think there needs to be a picture on the wall. Or a portrait. Whose picture should be on the wall, you think?"
Cashel said bluntly, "Einstein."
Okay, then. Einstein. So I drew this little cartoon of Einstein, with the crazy hair coming up, and Cashel said seriously, with all of his knowledge, "That really looks like Einstein."
We ate our pizza together, talking about stuff. Star Wars, Ben Franklin. Cashel informed me, "Ben Franklin discovered lightning."
Cashel is a wealth of information. Randomly, he told my parents that Vincent Van Gogh never sold a painting while he was alive, but that after he died, he became famous.
I read him a story. It was from the book of "Disney stories" which I had given him for his birthday. He loves it. He pulled it out of the bookshelf, and I said, "Oh! I gave that to you!" Cashel said, a little bit annoyed, "I know that."
He had me read the story of the little mouse who hung out with Ben Franklin, and basically (in the world of Disney) was the inspiration for all of Ben Franklin's famous moments. Cashel would shoot questions at me. "Why is Ben Franklin's hair white?" "Well ... he's old now. But also, in those days, men wore powdered wigs. I think." Cashel's little serious face, listening, sponging this all up. Probably the next day he informed his friends that men in the olden days wore powdered wigs. He's that kind of listener, that kind of learner.
Then he put on his Obi Wan Kenobi costume which Grandma Peggy made him for Christmas. A long hooded brown cloak ... and he hooked his light saber into his waist, and galloped off down the hall. Making me laugh. A mini Jedi knight.
I had him pick out three stories to read before bedtime. He sat beside me, curled up into me, looking at the pictures as I read to him. The last one we read was Longfellow's poem "Paul Revere's Ride". This poem was a favorite of ours, when we were kids. My dad would read it to us, and even now, when I read the words, I hear them in my father's voice. A magical poem. Really. The way my dad read it to us (along with Longfellow's help) made us SEE it. The clock tower, the moon, the darkness ... the sense of anticipation, of secrecy, of urgency. It was thrilling. So I love that this is being passed on to Cashel! I've never read the poem outloud before ... so I had one of those strange moments of the space-time continuum bending ... me stepping into my father's shoes, Cashel 5 years old beside me, feeling the ghost of my own 5 year old self listening.
I also remember how Brendan and I used to chime in gleefully: "ONE IF BY LAND, TWO IF BY SEA!" And Cashel did the same thing. I paused before that moment in the poem, glanced down at him, and he screamed it out.
There was also a subtlety of understanding in Cashel ... I read this section:
And lo! as he looks, on the belfry's height
A glimmer, and then a gleam of light!
He springs to the saddle, the bridle he turns,
But lingers and gazes, till full on his sight
A second lamp in the belfry burns.
And Cashel exclaimed, in a sort of "Uh-oh" tone, "They're comin' by sea!!" Now the words don't actually SAY that, but he remembered the "one if by land two if by sea" signal, and puts it all together. That's my boy!
I remembered the first lines from memory:
Listen my children and you shall hear
Of the midnight ride of Paul Revere,
On the eighteenth of April, in Seventy-five;
Hardly a man is now alive
Who remembers that famous day and year.
Again, those are just words on the page. But to me, they are filled with the echoes of my father's voice. I have tears in my eyes.
Cashel and I, as we went through the poem, had to stop many times for discussions.
There was one illustration of all the minute-men, hiding behind the stone walls, with a troop of Redcoats marching along, walking straight into the ambush. Cashel pointed at it, and stated firmly, "That's the civil war."
"Nope. Nope. That is actually a picture from the American Revolutionary War."
Cashel pondered this. Taking it in. Then: "The minute-men were in the civil war." But less certain.
"Nope. The minute-men were soldiers in the American Revolution. Do you know why they called them that?"
"Why?"
"Cause they were just farmers, and regular people ... but they could be ready to go into battle in a minute."
Again, a long silence. As Cashel filed this away for safekeeping. He forgets nothing.
"So ... Auntie Sheila ... what is the difference between the Revolutionary War and the Civil War?"
Woah. Okay. This will be a test. How to describe all of that in 5-year-old language. I mean, frankly, Cashel is not like a five-year-old at all. But still. Everything must be boiled down into its simplest components.
"Well. America used to be a part of England, and the American Revolutionary War was when America decided that it wanted to be free ... and Americans basically told the Brits to go home." Uh-oh. Brits? This is an inflammatory term. I corrected myself. "America told Great Britain that it wanted to be its own country. And the Civil War ... " Hmmm. How to begin ... what to say ... I know it was about more than slavery, but I decided to only focus on that one aspect. Economic theory would be too abstract. "In those days, Cashel, black people were slaves. And it was very very wrong. Can you understand that?"
He nodded. His little serious face.
"And the people in the South wanted to keep their slaves, and the people in the North said to the people in the South that they had to give up their slaves because it was wrong. And they ended up going to war. And eventually all the slaves were free."
Cashel accepted this explanation silently. Then he pointed back to the Paul Revere poem. "Read." he commanded.

I could do these birthday posts every day - but I try to keep it to a minimum - or only when I feel really strongly about the person involved. Like yesterday's post about Laura Ingalls Wilder.
Anyway - today is special too. Elizabeth Bishop is one of my favorite poets - and she actually didn't write all that many poems throughout her life (the same can NOT be said of her letters - she wrote voluminous letters!!) - but the poems she did produce ... God. She was so damn GOOD. She was independently wealthy - she traveled the world - she was best friends with Robert Lowell - they had a kinship that can only be described as intimate - She lived all over the place, and finally settled down in Key West.
Here's a great biographical sketch of her. Lots of personal tragedy there. But she didn't go the route of confessional poetry - a la her best friend Robert Lowell. Her artistry was something different. But damn. For a long time she was known as a "poet's poet" - but I think her appeal is much broader than that. I think she's up there with Robert Frost. True, people who know about poetry love Elizabeth Bishop - and rightly so - but her work is not inaccessible, you don't need Cliff Notes to "get" it ... And yet she is as deep as the ocean. I love her stuff so much.
It's a toss-up what is her best-known poem. There are two that make it into the anthologies:
At the Fishhouses and One Art. Read those poems one after the other and just be in awe of her versatility with language. Amazing. I do love both of those poems.
But in my opinion - it is "The Moose" that is her greatest poem. Somehow I had forgotten about it - and for whatever reason, recently my Dad brought it to my attention. "Have you read The Moose? You have to read it."
So I sat down and read it. My mind goes blank trying to describe why this poem is not just good, and linguistically pleasing, and interesting ... but GREAT. Truly great.
Argh. No more descriptive words. It's a goosebump-inducing poem, and that's all I really should say. Read it in the extended entry.
THE MOOSE
From narrow provinces
of fish and bread and tea,
home of the long tides
where the bay leaves the sea
twice a day and takes
the herrings long rides,
where if the river
enters or retreats
in a wall of brown foam
depends on if it meets
the bay coming in,
the bay not at home;
where, silted red,
sometimes the sun sets
facing a red sea,
and others, veins the flats'
lavender, rich mud
in burning rivulets;
on red, gravelly roads,
down rows of sugar maples,
past clapboard farmhouses
and neat, clapboard churches,
bleached, ridged as clamshells,
past twin silver birches,
through late afternoon
a bus journeys west,
the windshield flashing pink,
pink glancing off of metal,
brushing the dented flank
of blue, beat-up enamel;
down hollows, up rises,
and waits, patient, while
a lone traveller gives
kisses and embraces
to seven relatives
and a collie supervises.
Goodbye to the elms,
to the farm, to the dog.
The bus starts. The light
grows richer; the fog,
shifting, salty, thin,
comes closing in.
Its cold, round crystals
form and slide and settle
in the white hens' feathers,
in gray glazed cabbages,
on the cabbage roses
and lupins like apostles;
the sweet peas cling
to their wet white string
on the whitewashed fences;
bumblebees creep
inside the foxgloves,
and evening commences.
One stop at Bass River.
Then the Economies
Lower, Middle, Upper;
Five Islands, Five Houses,
where a woman shakes a tablecloth
out after supper.
A pale flickering. Gone.
The Tantramar marshes
and the smell of salt hay.
An iron bridge trembles
and a loose plank rattles
but doesn't give way.
On the left, a red light
swims through the dark:
a ship's port lantern.
Two rubber boots show,
illuminated, solemn.
A dog gives one bark.
A woman climbs in
with two market bags,
brisk, freckled, elderly.
"A grand night. Yes, sir,
all the way to Boston."
She regards us amicably.
Moonlight as we enter
the New Brunswick woods,
hairy, scratchy, splintery;
moonlight and mist
caught in them like lamb's wool
on bushes in a pasture.
The passengers lie back.
Snores. Some long sighs.
A dreamy divagation
begins in the night,
a gentle, auditory,
slow hallucination. . . .
In the creakings and noises,
an old conversation
--not concerning us,
but recognizable, somewhere,
back in the bus:
Grandparents' voices
uninterruptedly
talking, in Eternity:
names being mentioned,
things cleared up finally;
what he said, what she said,
who got pensioned;
deaths, deaths and sicknesses;
the year he remarried;
the year (something) happened.
She died in childbirth.
That was the son lost
when the schooner foundered.
He took to drink. Yes.
She went to the bad.
When Amos began to pray
even in the store and
finally the family had
to put him away.
"Yes . . ." that peculiar
affirmative. "Yes . . ."
A sharp, indrawn breath,
half groan, half acceptance,
that means "Life's like that.
We know it (also death)."
Talking the way they talked
in the old featherbed,
peacefully, on and on,
dim lamplight in the hall,
down in the kitchen, the dog
tucked in her shawl.
Now, it's all right now
even to fall asleep
just as on all those nights.
--Suddenly the bus driver
stops with a jolt,
turns off his lights.
A moose has come out of
the impenetrable wood
and stands there, looms, rather,
in the middle of the road.
It approaches; it sniffs at
the bus's hot hood.
Towering, antlerless,
high as a church,
homely as a house
(or, safe as houses).
A man's voice assures us
"Perfectly harmless. . . ."
Some of the passengers
exclaim in whispers,
childishly, softly,
"Sure are big creatures."
"It's awful plain."
"Look! It's a she!"
Taking her time,
she looks the bus over,
grand, otherworldly.
Why, why do we feel
(we all feel) this sweet
sensation of joy?
"Curious creatures,"
says our quiet driver,
rolling his r's.
"Look at that, would you."
Then he shifts gears.
For a moment longer,
by craning backward,
the moose can be seen
on the moonlit macadam;
then there's a dim
smell of moose, an acrid
smell of gasoline.
And here is my next excerpt of the day from my library.
My history bookshelf. Onward.
The second book on this shelf is another favorite of mine called The Penguin Book of 20th-Century Speeches . An AWESOME resource. It's not the "greatest" speeches - in that, there is not editorial control saying: "We approve of THIS person's views, and therefore we include it in the collection, we don't approve of THAT person's views and therefore we do not include his speech ..." For example, there are speeches of Stalin and Hitler included. Chilling. Absolultely chilling. It's good to have the "greatest" speeches as well - for inspiration and for all that feel-good shite - but in terms of learning the truth of history, it's GREAT to have an archive like this one. You can actually, if you read the book straight through, start to feel the march of historic events. Amazing. We've got Patrick Pearse, and Teddy Roosevelt's muckraker speech and Lenin and Lloyd George and Emmeline Pankhurst and Sacco and Vanzetti - Oswald Mosley, Oppenheimer, Kwame Nkrumah, Castro, Bertrand Russell, Neville Chamberlain, FDR, Patton ... etc. etc. Salman Rushdie, JFK, Krushchev, Martin Luther King, Alexander Solzhenitsyn ... You get the idea. It's a terrific book. Here is where you can see the full text of Vaclav Havel's INCREDIBLE speech that he made on January 1, 1990 - which I read to myself, on occasion, if I need an uplifting experience.
I highly recommend this book, obviously.
I will post William Faulkner's Nobel Prize acceptance speech. It's a doozy. An amazing triumphant statement of the role of the artist in the world. It makes me want to cry. I will also print out the excerpt preceding the speech, so you can get the context.
From The Penguin Book of 20th-Century Speeches .
WILLIAM FAULKNER
Stockholm, 10 December 1950
"The agony and the sweat"
When William Faulkner (1897 - 1962), the creator of Yoknapatawpha County and author of As I Lay Dying and The Sound and the Fury, won the Nobel Prize, he bought his first dress suit for the occasion and decided to go to Stockholm for the prize-giving.
At the state banquet, the quiet farmer from Oxford, Mississippi, appeared before a microphone and television camera for the first time and said that he declined to accept the end of man.
I feel that this award was not made to me as a man, but to my work -- a life's work in the agony and sweat of the human spirit, not for glory and least of all for profit, but to create out of the materials of the human spirit something which did not exist before. So this award is only mine in trust. It will not be difficult to find a dedication for the money part of it commensurate with the purpose and significance of its origin. But I would like to do the same with the acclaim too, by using this moment as a pinnacle from which I might be listened to by the young men and women already dedicated to the same anguish and travail, among whom is already that one who will someday stand here where I am standing.
Our tragedy today is a general and universal physical fear so long sustained by now that we can even bear it. There are no longer problems of the spirit. There is only the question: when will I be blown up? Because of this, the young man or woman writing today has forgotten the problems of the human heart in conflict with itself which alone can make good writing because only that is worth writing about, worth the agony and the sweat.
He must learn them again. He must teach himself that the basest of all things is to be afraid; and, teaching himself that, forget it forever, leaving no room in his workshop for anything but the old verities and truths of the heart, the old universal truths lacking which any story is ephemeral and doomed -- love and honour and pity and pride and compassion and sacrifice. Until he does so, he labours under a curse. He writes not of love but of lust, of defeats in which nobody loses anything of value, of victories without hope, and, worst of all, without pity or compassion. His griefs grive on no universal bones, leaving no scars. He writes not of the heart but of the glands.
Until he relearns these things, he will write as though he stood among and watched the end of man. I decline to accept the end of man. It is easy enough to say that man is immortal simplyl because he will endure; that when the last ding-dong of doom has clanged and faded from the last worthless rock hanging tideless in the last red and dying evening, that even then there will still be one more sound: that of his puny inexhaustible voice, still talking. I refuse to accept this. I believe that man will not merely endue: he will prevail. He is immortal, not because he alone among creatures has an inexhaustible voice, but because he has a soul, a spirit capable of compassion and sacrifice and endurance. The poet's the writer's, duty is to write about these things. It is his privilege to help man endure by lifting his heart, by reminding him of the courage and honour and hope and pride and compassion and pity and sacrifice which have been the glory of his past. The poet's voice need not merely be the record of man; it can be one of the props, the pillars, to help him endure and prevail.
I finally decided to put down the influenza book - thanks! - and am diving into Annie Proulx's Close Range - her first collection of "Wyoming Stories". I had only read "Brokeback Mountain" (a story in the collection) and that one I read when it first came out in The New Yorker in the late 90s.
Annie Proulx is a writer I find it difficult to talk about. My response to her is complicated and personal. She is back at the top of her game here (after a slight diversion with Accordion Crimes).
Listen:
This is from The Half-Skinned Steer - the first story in the collection:
Onto the high plains sifted the fine snow, delicately clouding the air, a rare dust, beautiful, he thought, silk gauze, but there was muscle in the wind rocking the heavy car, a great pulsing artery of the jet stream swooping down from the sky to touch the earth. Plumes of smoke rose hundreds of feet into the air, elegant fountains and twisting snow devils, shapes of veiled Arab women and ghost riders dissolving in white fume. The snow snakes writhing across the asphalt straightened into rods. He was driving in a rushing river of cold whiteout foam. He could see nothing, trod on the brake, the wind buffeting the car, a bitter, hard-flung dust hissing over metal and glass. The car shuddered. And as suddenly as it had risen the wind dropped and the road was clear; he could see a long, empty mile.How do you know when there's enough of anything? What trips the lever that snaps up the STOP sign? What electrical currents fizz and crackle in the brain to shape the decision to quit a place? He had listened to her damn story and the dice had rolled. For years he believed he had left without hard reason and suffered for it. But he'd learned from television nature programs that it had been time for him to find his own territory and his own woman. How many women were out there! He had married three or four of them and sampled plenty.
please stand up ... please stand up ....
If you at all follow literary events, then you have heard of JT Leroy: the child prostitute and drug addict become major hot novelist. There was such a buzz about Leroy about 5 years back that you would have thought Hemingway was reincarnated. An exciting new voice, a great life-story to work from - someone who was gritty, real, came from the outside, not a pampered writer's workshop talent ....
I haven't read of Leroy's work, but I still thought the story was kind of cool. Also, Leroy was YOUNG - barely out of teenager-hood - when this huge literary success came on him.
Anyway. Read this article in the Times about the latest in the life of JT Leroy. Un-feckin'-believable. Wow. It's all been a hoax - or - it hasn't been proven yet conclusively that there is no JT Leroy, but that article is pretty convincing. It looks like a woman named Laura Albert and her husband (who supposedly "adopted" JT Leroy and saved him from a life of prostitution) cooked up this character as a way to get theh attention of the literary world and get a book deal.
Here was the first inkling that Leroy might not be "real".
Wow.
JT Leroy is famously "reclusive". He makes few appearances. I remember seeing pictures of him, at this or that event - sunglasses, head down ... very cute and androgynous. Turns out, that it's a woman who basically - is PRETENDING to be JT Leroy. A hired hand, basically, in this huge hoax.
FASCINATING.
I LOVE IT. Even though it's SCARY!
It's pretty awful, too - because Leroy was given a lot of financial support by writers (heavy-hitters like Mary Gaitskill, Mary Karr) - who wanted to support this new voice. Again, I haven't read his novels - but the hype was all over the place. And this wasn't just the popular best-selling novelists singing his praises - Leroy had serious literary appeal - and serious writers were saying: "This is a very important new writer", and that gave Leroy even MORE cache. In my book, anyway. If Mary Gaitskill says, "This guy can write!" then I am way more apt to believe her than, say, Michael Crichton. Just the sad and blunt truth. Also, we're talking about serious literary circles here - the people who have stories in The New Yorker, and stuff like that. This is where Leroy made his buzz. So that's how I took notice. This group of writers (and, actually, musicians, artists in general) wanted to make sure that Leroy continued to be able to write - that he was financially viable - so they would contribute money to him, as a way of support.
So back to the bad part of the story: These people have been duped (it looks like) by this Albert woman - who made sure (somehow) that all checks to JT Leroy were made out to her (because she was - in her fictional story - JT Leroy's "legal guardian") ... Leroy also said (or - not Leroy - because it appears there IS no Leroy) - Leroy came out a couple of years ago and said he was HIV positive. More money just POURED into the coffers. I find this despicable. Whoever was the wizard behind the curtain in this hoax (but again - weirdly - the books got fantastic reviews, so SOMEONE is able to write in this scenario) - decided that the fictional author JT Leroy needed to have AIDS to make him ... even more sympathetic? To have even more people donate money to support his literary career? Disgusting and cynical. To use a terrible disease in that way.
A lot of people are very angry right now. And rightly so.
But still: I'll say this: it was a DAMN GOOD hoax. It has had people fooled for 6 years now. What a performance art piece! I've always had a little dream of doing something like that - hopefully without cheating people out of thousands of dollars - but I think hoaxes like this (and there are many, throughout history) are really really interesting. I think it could be quite freeing to write under an assumed identity - But to hoax the entire world, and hire someone to PLAY the fictional author? Now THAT is ballsy.
THERE IS NO JT LEROY. Amazing. I still can't get over it!
That article gives great background to this whole hoax.
I've said it before and I'll say it again: Nothin' I love more than a big ol' literary-world dustup!!
My jaw is still basically on the floor after reading that article! I was duped too! Warren St. John who wrote the article in The Times was duped. It was a damn fine performance art piece. It fooled everybody.
Today is the birthday of JRR Tolkien. He was born in South Africa on this day, in 1892.

I love that picture - mainly because it was the author photo on the back of my dog-eared copy of The Hobbit - read multiple times when I was a kid. I still have that same copy.
So in honor of Mr. Tolkien, I'll post some of his letters - I went through a huge Tolkien phase during the LOTR mania. I know some of you LIVE in that mania - and have no "phases" with Tolkien - it is just one long obsession. This is awesome. I happen to not share it - but I understand it. (See: Cary Grant.) I read all of Tolkien's letters - which are absolutely WONDERFUL. Addictive stuff.
So here are some excerpts. Enjoy! Some of them are QUITE long. But I think they are worth it.
And raise a glass of ale this evening, in honor to a writer who has given us all so much!! What an imagination! What a mind!
I'll start with perhaps my favorite of all of his letters.
The German publishing firm of Rutten & Loening contacted Allen & Unwin in 1938 (the publishers of The Hobbit) and wanted to negotiate with them for a German translation of the book. But first and foremost, they wanted to know if Tolkien was of "arisch" origin. (Aryan) Tolkien wrote a brief note to Stanley Unwin, saying that he wanted to refuse to give them an answer - He didn't want to add to "the wholly pernicious and unscientific race-doctrine" by comfirming or denying. However - he didn't want to ruin his chances of The Hobbit being read in Germany. He submitted to Mr. Unwin two drafts of letters to the German publishers, and left it up to Unwin to decide which one to send.
Here is one of the drafts:
25 July 1938
To Rutten & Loening Verlag
Dear Sirs,
Thank you for your letter ... I regret that I am not clear as to what you intend by arisch. I am not of Aryan extraction: that is Indo-iranian; as far as I am aware noone of my ancestors spoke Hindustani, Persian, Gypsy, or any related dialects. But if I am to understand that you are enquiring whether I am of Jewish origin, I can only reply that I regret that I appear to have no ancestors of that gifted people. My great-great-grandfather came to England in the eighteenth century from Germany: the main part of my descent is therefore purely English, and I am an English subject - which should be sufficient. I have been accustomed, nonetheless, to regard my German name with pride, and continued to do so throughout the period of the late regrettable war, in which I served in the English army. I cannot, however, forbear to comment that if impertinent and irrelevant inquiries of this sort are to become the rule in matters of literature, then the time is not far distant when a German name will no longer be a source of pride.Your enquiry is doubtless made in order to comply with the laws of your own country, but that this should be held to apply to the subjects of another state would be improper, even if it had (as it has not) any bearing whatsoever on the merits of my work or its sustainability for publication, of which you appear to have satisfied yourselves without reference to my Abstammung.
I trust you will find this reply satisfactory, and remain yours faithfully
J.R.R. Tolkien
It just makes me want to cheer.
Letter of JRR Tolkien to Allen & Unwin, his publisher, 31 August 1938:
"I have begun again on the sequel to the 'Hobbit' - The Lord of the Ring. It is now flowing along, and getting quite out of hand. It has reached about Chapter VII and progresses towards quite unforeseen goals. I must say I think it is a good deal better in places and some ways than the predecessor; but that does not say that I think it either more suitable or more adapted for its audience. For one thing it is, like my own children (who have the immediate serial rights), rather 'older'. I can only say that Mr. [C.S.] Lewis (my stout backer of the Times and T.L.S.) professes himself more than pleased. If the weather is wet in the next fortnight we may have got still further on. But it is no bed-time story."
Hahaha I love that: "getting quite out of hand".
Letter JRR Tolkien wrote to his son, Michael, in June of 1941:
"People in this land seem not even yet to realize that in the Germans we have enemies whose virtues (and they are virtues) of obedience and patriotism are greater than ours in the mass. Whose brave men are just about as brave as ours. Whose industry is about 10 times greater. And who are - under the curse of God - now led by a man inspired by a mad, whirlwind, devil: a typhoon, a passion: that makes the poor old Kaiser look like an old woman knitting.I have spent most of my life, since I was your age, studying Germanic matters (in the general sense that includes England and Scandinavia). There is a great deal more force (and truth) than ignorant people imagine in the 'Germanic' ideal. I was much attracted by it as an undergraduate (when Hitler was, I suppose, dabbling in paint, and had not heard of it), in reaction against the 'Classics'. You have to understand the good in things, to detect the real evil. But no one ever calls on me to 'broadcast', or do a postscript! Yet I suppose I know better than most what is the truth about this 'Nordic' nonsense. Anyway, I have in this War a burning private grudge - which would probably make me a better soldier at 49 than I was at 22: against that ruddy little ignoramus Adolf Hitler (for the odd thing about demonic inspiration and impetus is that it in no way enhances the purely intellectual stature: it chiefly affects the mere will). Ruining, perverting, misapplying, and making for ever accursed, that noble northern spirit, a supreme contribution to Europe, which I have ever loved, and tried to present in its true light."
"You have to understand the good in things, to detect the real evil."
This is a letter JRR Tolkien wrote to his son Chistopher, in November of 1943
"My political opinions lean more and more to Anarchy (philosophically understood, meaning abolition of control, not whiskered men with bombs) - or to 'unconstitutional' Monarchy. I would arrest anybody who uses the word State (in any sense other than the inanimate realm of England and its inhabitants, a thing that has neither power, rights nor mind); and after a chance of recantation, execute them if they remained obstinate! If we could get back to personal names, it would do a lot of good. Government is an abstract noun meaning the art and process of governing and it should be an offence to write it with a capital G or so as to refer to people. If people were in the habit of referring to 'King George's council, Winston and his gang,' it would go a long way to clearing thought, and reducing the frightful landslide into Theyocracy.Anyway the proper study of Man is anything but Man; and the most improper job of any man, even saints (who at any rate were at least unwilling to take it on), is bossing other men. Not one in a million is fit for it, and least of all those who seek the opportunity. And at least it is done only to a small group of men who know who their master is. The medievals were only too right in taking nolo episcopari ['I do not wish to be made a bishop'] as the best reason a man could give to others for making him a bishop ...
Well, cheers and all that to you dearest son. We were born in a dark age out of due time (for us). But there is this comfort: otherwise we should not know, or so much love, what we do love. I imagine the fish out of water is the only fish to have an inkling of water. Also we have still small swords to use. 'I will not bow before the Iron Crown, nor cast my own small golden sceptre down.' Have at the Orcs, with winged words, hildenaeddran (war-adders), biting darts - but make sure of the mark, before shooting."
Letter written to his son:
30 January 1945
Russians 60 miles from Berlin. It does look as if something decisive might happen soon. The appalling destruction and misery of this war mount hourly: destruction of what should be (indeed is) the common wealth of Europe, and the world, if mankind were not so besotted, wealth the loss of which will affect us all, victors or not. Yet people gloat to hear of the endless lines, 40 miles long, of miserable refugees, women and children pouring West, dying on the way. There seem no bowels of mercy or compassion, no imagination, left in this dark diabolic hour. By which I do not mean that it may not all, in the present situation, mainly (not solely) created by Germany, be necessary and inevitable. But why gloat! We were supposed to have reached a stage of civilization in which it might still be necessary to execute a criminal, but not to gloat, or to hang his wife and child by him while the orc-crowd hooted. The destruction of Germany, be it 100 times merited, is one of the most appalling world-catastrophes. Well, well - you and I can do nothing about it. And that shd. be a measure of the amount of guilt that can justly be assumed to attach to any member of a country who is not a member of its actual Government. Well the first War of the Machines seems to be drawing to its final inconclusive chapter - leaving, alas, everyone the poorer, many bereached or maimed and millions dead, and only one thing triumphant: the Machines. As the servants of the Machines are becoming a privileged class, the Machines are going to be enormously more powerful. What's their next move?
"But why gloat?" An excellent question indeed. When you gloat - you lose a tiny bit of your humanity. Just a tiny bit. Gloating chips away at that most valuable of commodities - compassion. There are people whose entire lives are made up of gloating. I have gloated before - as we all have, over this or that, and it's amazing how small and nasty it makes one feel.
Here is a letter Tolkien wrote to a Michael Straight, then editor of "The New Republic." Straight wanted to review LOTR and had sent Tolkien a list of questions to answer. This is only part of Tolkien's reply.
January 1956 I will try and answer your specific questions. The final scene of the Quest was so shaped simply because having regard to the situation, and to the 'characters' of Frodo, Sam, and Gollum, those events seemed to me mechanically, morally, and psychologically credible. But, of course, if you wish for more reflection, I should say that within the mode of the story, the 'catastrophe' exemplifies (an aspect of) the familiar words: 'Forgive us our trespasses as we forgive them that trespass against us. Lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from evil.'"Lead us not into temptation &c." is the harder and the less often considered petition. The view, in the terms of my story, is that though every event or situation has (at least) two aspects: the history and development of the individual (it is something out of which he can get good, ultimate good, for himself, or fail to do so), and the history of the world (which depends on his action for its own sake) - still there are abnormal situations in which one may be placed. 'Sacrificial' situations, I should call them: sc. positions in which the "good" of the world depends on the behavior of an individual in circumstances which demand of him suffering and endurance far beyond the normal - even, it may happen (or seem, humanely speaking), demand a strength of body and mind which he does not possess: he is in a sense doomed to failure, doomed to fall to temptation or be broken by pressure against his "will"; that is against any choice he could make or would make unfettered, not under the duress.
Frodo was in such a position: an apparently complete trap: a person of greater native power could probably never have resisited the Ring's lure to power so long; a person of less power could not hope to resist it in the final decision. (Already Frodo had been unwilling to harm the Ring before he set out, and was incapable of surrendering it to Sam,.)
The Quest: was bound to fail as a piece of world-plan, and also was bound to end in disaster as the story of humble Frodo's development to the "noble", his sanctification. Fail it would and did as far as Frodo considered alone was concerned. He "apostatized" - and I have had one savage letter, crying out that he shd. have been executed as a traitor, not honored. Believe me, it was not until I read this that I had myself any idea how "topical" such a situation might appear. It arose naturally from my "plot" conceived in main outline in 1936. I did not foresee that before the tale was published we should enter a dark age in which the technique of torture and disruption of personality would rival that of Mordor and the Ring, and present us with the practical problems of honest men of good will broken down into apostates and traitors.
But at this point the "salvation" of the world and Frodo's own salvation is achieved by his previous pity and forgiveness of injurty. At any point any prudent person would have told Frodo that Gollum would certainly betray him, and could rob him in the end. (Not quite "certainly". The clumsiness in fidelity of Sam was what finally pushed Gollum over the brink, when about to repent.) To "pity" him, to forbear to kill him, was a piece of folly, or a mystical belief in the ultimate value-in-itself of pity and generosity even if disastrous in the world of time. He did rob him and injure him in the end - but by a "grace", that last betrayal was at a precise juncture when the final evil deed was the most beneficial thing any one cd. have done for Frodo! By a situation created by his "forgiveness", he was saved himself, and relieved of his burden. He was very justly accorded the highest honors - since it is clear that he and Sam never concealed the precise course of events. Into the ultimate judgement upon Gollum I would not care to enquire. This would be to investigate "Goddes privatee," as the Medievals said. Gollum was pitiable, but he ended in persistent wickedness, and the fact that this worked good was no credit to him. His marvellous courage and endurance, as great as Frodo and Sam's or greater, being devoted to evil was portentous, but not honourable. I am afraid, whatever our beliefs, we have to face the fact that there are persons who yield to temptations, reject their chances of nobility or salvation, and appear to be "damnable". Their "damnability" is not measurable in terms of the macrocosm (where it may work good). But we who are all "in the same boat" must not usurp the Judge. The domination of the Ring was much too strong for the mean soul of Smeagol. But he would have never had to endure it if he had not become a mean sort of thief before it crossed his path. Need it ever have crossed his path? Need anything dangerous ever cross any of our paths? A kind of answer cd. be found in trying to imagine Gollum overcoming temptation. The story would have been quite different! By temporizing, not fixing the still not wholly corrupt Smeagol-will towards good in the debate in the slag hole, he weakened himself for the final chance when dawning love of Frodo was too easily withered by the jealousy of Sam before Shelob's lair. After that he was lost.
There is no special reference to England in the "Shire" - except of course that an Englishman brought up in an "almost rural" village of Warwickshire on the edge of the prosperous bourgeoisie of Birmingham (about the time of the Diamond Jubilee!) I take my models like anyone else - from such "life" as I know. But there is no post-war reference. I am not a "socialist" in any sense - being averse to "planning" (as must be plain) most of all because the "planners", when they acquire power, become so bad - but I would not say that we had to suffer the malice of Sharkey and his Ruffians here. Though the spirit of "Isengard", if not of Mordor, is of course always cropping up. The present design of destroying Oxford in order to accommodate motor-cars is a case. But our chief adversary is a member of a "Tory" Government. But you could apply it anywhere else in these days.
Yes: I think that "victors" can never enjoy the "victory" - not in the terms that they envisaged; and in so far as they fought for something to be enjoyed by themselves (whether acquisition or mere preservation) the less satisfactory will "victory" seem. But the departure of the Ringbearers has quite another side, as far as the Three are concerned. There is, of course, a mythological structure behind this story. It was actually written first, and may now perhaps be in part published. It is, I should say, a "monotheistic" but "sub-creational" mythology. There is no embodiment of the One, of God, who indeed remains remote, outside the World, and only directly accessible to the Valar or Rulers. These take the place of the "gods", but are created spirits, or those of the primary creation who by their own will have entered into the world. (They shared in its "making" - but only on the same terms as we "make" a work of art or story. The realization of it, the gift to it of a created reality of the same grade as their own, was the act of the One God). But the One retains all ultimate authority, and (or so it seems as viewed in serial time) reserves the right to intrude the finger of God into the story: that is to produce realities which could not be deduced even from a complete knowledge of the previous past, but which being real become part of the effective past for all subsequent time (a possible definition of a "miracle"). According to the fable Elves and Men were the first of these intrusions, made indeed while the "story" was still only a story and not "realized"; they were not therefore in any sense conceived or made by the gods, the Valar, and were called the Eruhini or "Children of God", and were for the Valar an incalculable element: that is they were rational creatures of free will in regard to God, of the same historical rank as the Valar, though of far smaller spiritual and intellectual power and status.
Of course, in fact exterior to my story, Elves and men are just different aspects of the Humane, and represent the problem of Death as seen by a finite but willing and self-conscious person. In this mythological world the Elves and men are in their incarnate forms kindred, but in the relation of their "spirits" to the world in time represent different "experiments", each of which has its own natural trend, and weakness. The Elves represent, as it were, the artistic, aesthetic and purely scientific aspects of the Humane nature raised to a higher level than is actually seen in Men. That is: they have a devoted love of the physical world, and a desire to observe and understand it for its own sake and as "other" - sc. as a reality derived from God in the same degree as themselves - not as a material for use or as a power-platform. They also possess a "sub-creational" or artistic faculty of great excellence. They are therefore "immortal". Not "eternally", but to endure with and within the created world, while its story lasts. When "killed", by the injury or destruction of their incarnate form, they do not escape from time, but remain in the world, either discarnate, or being re-born. This becomes a great burden as the ages lengthen, especially in a world in which there is malice and destruction (I have left out the mythological form which Malice or the Fall of the Angels takes in this fable). Mere change as such is not represented as "evil": it is the unfolding of the story and to refuse this is of course against the design of God. But the Elvish weakness is in these terms naturally to regret the past, and to become unwilling to face change: as if a man were to hate a very long book still going on, and wished to settle down in a favorite chapter. Hence they fell in a measure to Sauron's deceits: they desired some "power" over things as they are (whcih is quite distinct from art), to make their particular will to preservation effective: to arrest change, and keep things always fresh and fair. The "Three Rings" were "unsullied", because this object was in a limited way good, it included the healing of the real damage of malice, as well as the mere arrest of change; and the Elves did not desire to dominate other wills, nor to usurp all the world to their particular pleasure.
But with the downfall of "Power" their little efforts at preserving the past fell to bits. There was nothing more in Middle-earth for them, but weariness. So Elrond and Galadriel depart. Gandalf is a special case. He was not the maker or original holder of the Ring - but it was surrendered to him by Cirdan, to assist him in his task. Gandalf was returning, his labor and errand finished, to his home, the land of the Valar.
The passage over the Sea is not Death. The "mythology" is Elf-centered. According to it there was at first an actual Earthly Paradise, home and realm of the Valar, as a physical part of the earth.
There is no "embodiment" of the Creator anywhere in this story or mythology. Gandalf is a 'created" person; though possibly a spirit that existed before in the physical world. His function as a 'wizard" is an angelos or messenger from the Valar or Rulers: to assist the rational creatures of Middle-earth to resist Sauron, a power too great for them unaided. But since in the view of this tale & mythology Power - when it dominates or seeks to dominate other wills and minds (except by the assent of their reason) - is evil, these "wizards" were incarnated in the life-forms of Middle-earth, and so suffered the pains of both mind and body. They were also, for the same reason, thus involved in the peril of the incarnate: the possibility of "fall", of sin, if you will. The chief form this would take with them would be impatience, leading to the desire to force others to their own good ends, and so inevitably at last to mere desire to make their own wills effective by any means. To this evil Saruman succumbed. Gandalf did not. But the situation became so much the worse by the fall of Saruman, that the "good" were obliged to greater effort and sacrifice. Thus Gandalf faced and suffered death; and came back or was sent back, as he says, with enhanced power. But though one may be in this reminded of the Gospels, it is not really the same thing at all. The Incarnation of God is an infinitely greater thing than anything I would dare to write. Here I am only concerned with Death as part of the nature, physical and spiritual, of Man, and with Hope without guarantees. That is why I regard the tale of Arwen and Aragorn as the most important of the Appendices; it is part of the essential story, and is only placed so, because it could not be worked into the main narrative without destroying its structre: which is planned to be "hobbito-centric", that is, primarily a study of the ennoblement (or sanctification) of the humble.
Here is a draft of a letter that Tolkien wrote to an unidentified reader, and in it Tolkien describes his affinity with Faramir. He thought of Faramir as his alter ego.
14 January 1856
... There is hardly any reference in The Lord of the Rings to things that do not actually exist on its own plane (of secondary or sub-creationary reality): sc. have been written. (The cats of Queen Beruthiel and the names and adventures of the other 2 wizards (5 minus Saruman, Gandalf, Radagast) are all that I recollect.) The Silmarillion was offered for publication years ago, and turned down. Good may come of such blows. The Lord of the Rings was the result. The hobbits had been welcomed. I loved them myself, since I love the vulgar and simple as dearly as the noble, and nothing moves my heart (beyond all the passions and heartbreaks of the world) so much as "ennoblement" (from the Ugly Duckling to Frodo). I would build on the hobbits. And I saw that I was meant to do it (as Gandalf would say - I am not Gandalf, being a transcendent Sub-creator in this little world. As far as any character is "like me" it is Faramir - except that I lack what all my characters possess (let the psychoanalysts note!) Courage), since without thought, in a "blurb" I wrote for The Hobbit, I spoke of the time between the Elder Days and the Dominion of Men. Out of that came the "missing link": The "Downfall of Numenor", releasing some hidden "complex". For when Faramir speaks of his private vision of the Great Wave, he speaks for me. That vision and dream has been ever with me - and has been inherited (as I only discovered recently) by one of my children.
Tolkien responded to many letters from fans and reviewers about the "failure of Frodo", in the end, to complete the Quest. Here's an excerpt from one of those letters:
26 July 1956 Draft of letter to Miss J. Burn
If you re-read all the passages dealing with Frodo and the Ring, I think you will see that not only was it quite impossible for him to surrender the Ring, in act or will, especially at its point of maximum power, but that this failure was adumbrated from far back. He was honoured because he had accepted the burden voluntarily, and then had done all that was within his utmost physical and mental strength to do. He (and the Cause) were saved - by mercy: by the supreme value and efficacy of Pity and forgiveness of injury.Corinthians I x. 12-13 may not at first sight seem to fit ("Wherefore let him that thinketh he standeth take heed lest he fall. There hath no temptation taken you but such as is common to man: but God is faithful, who will not suffer you to be tempted above that ye are able; but will with the temptation also make a way to escape, that ye may be able to bear it.") - unless "bearing temptation" is taken to mean resisting it while still a free agent in normal command of the will. I think rather of the mysterious last petitions of the Lord's Prayer: Lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from evil. A petition against something that cannot happen is unmeaning. There exists the possibility of being placed in positions beyond one's power. In which case (as I believe) salvation from ruin will depend on something apparently unconnected: the general sanctity (and humility and mercy) of the sacrificial person. I did not "arrange" the deliverance in this case: it again follows the logic of the story. (Gollum had had his chance of repentance, and of returning generosity with love; and had fallen off the knife-edge). In the case of those who now issue from prison "brainwashed", broken, or insane, praising their torturers, no such immediate deliverance is as a rule to be seen. But we can at least judge them by the will and intentions with which they entered the Sammath Naur; and not demand impossible feats of will, which could only happen in stories unconcerned with real moral and mental probability.
No, Frodo "failed". It is possible that once the ring was destroyed he had little recollection of the last scene. But one must face the fact: the power of Evil in the world is not finally resistible by incarnate creatures, however "good"; and the Writer of the Story is not one of us.
Here's another letter he wrote to someone who asked him about Frodo's failure.
27 July 1956 Letter to Amy Ronald
By chance, I have just had another letter regarding the failure of Frodo. Very few seem even to have observed it. But following the logic of the plot, it was clearly inevitable, as an event. And surely it is a more significant and real event than a mere "fairy story" ending in which the hero is indomitable? It is possible for the good, even the saintly, to be subjected to a power of evil which is too great for them to overcome - in themselves. In this case the cause (not the "hero") was triumphant, because by the exercise of pity, mercy, and forgiveness of injury, a situation was produced in which all was redressed and disaster averted. Gandalf certainly foresaw this. ("Pity? It was pity that stayed [Bilbo's] hand. Pity, and Mercy: not to strike without need. And he has been well rewarded, Frodo. Be sure that he took so little hurt from the evil, and escaped in the end, because he began his ownership of the Ring so. With Pity.") Of course he did not mean to say that one must be merciful, for it may prove useful later - it would not then be mercy or pity, which are only truly present when contrary to prudence. Not ours to plan! But we are assured that we must be ourselves extravagantly generous, if we are to hope for the extravagant generosity which the slightest easing of, or escape from, the consequences of our own follies and errors represents. And that mercy does sometimes occur in this life.Frodo deserved all honour because he spent every drop of his power of will and body, and that was just sufficient to bring him to the destined point, and no further. Few others, possibly no others of his time, would have got so far. The Other Power then took over: the Writer of the Story (by which I do not mean myself), "that one ever-present Person who is never absent and never named" (as one critic has said). (Gandalf to Frodo: "Behind that there was something else at work, beyond any design of the Ring-Maker. I can put it no plainer than by saying that Bilbo was meant to find the Ring, and not by its maker.")
A third (the only other) commentator on the point some months ago reviled Frodo as a scoundrel (who should have been hung and not honoured), and me too. It seems sad and strange that, in this evil time when daily people of good will are tortured, "brainwashed", and broken, anyone could be so fiercely simpleminded and righteous.
This is a short letter to a fan, who had written asking him if he was working on a sequel to LOTR. Tolkien replied
I did begin a story placed about 100 years after the Downfall of Mordor, but it proved both sinister and depressing. Since we are dealing with Men it is inevitable that we should be concerned with the most regrettable feature of their nature: their quick satiety with good. So that the people of Gondor in times of peace, justice and prosperity, would become discontented and restless - while the dynasts descended from Aragorn would become just kings and governors - like Denethor or worse. I found that even so early there was an outcrop of revolutionary plots, about a center of secret Satanistic religion; while Gondorian boys were playing at being Orcs and going round doing damage. I could have written a thriller about the plot and its discovery and overthrow - but it would be just that. Not worth doing.
Hah. Peace never lasts. No such thing as "happily ever after".
Here is another long draft of a letter to a fan. He got into long long philosophical and mythological conversations with all of his readers - and his letters (as you can see) are immense - Many of them were never sent.
Check this out. Only Tolkien freaks will probably be able to get through this - but if you're into those books, and if you're into those stories - it is a fascinating analysis:
September 1963 Draft of letter to Mrs. Eileen Elgar
Very few (indeed so far as letters go only you and one other) have observed or commented on Frodo's "failure". It is a very important point.From the point of view of the storyteller the events on Mt Doom proceed simply from the logic of the tale up to that time. They were not deliberately worked up to nor foreseen until they occured. But, for one thing, it became at last quite clear that Frodo after all that had happened would be incapable of voluntarily destroyoing the Ring. Reflecting on the solution after it was arrived at (as a mere event) I feel that it is central to the whole "theory" of true nobility and heroism that is presented.
Frodo indeed "failed" as a hero, as conceived by simple minds: he did not endure to the end; he gave in, ratted. I do not say "simple minded" with contempt: they often see with clarity the simple truth and the absolute ideal to which effort must be directed, even if it is unattainable. Their weakness, however, is twofold. They do not perceive the complexty of any given situation in Time, in which an absolute ideal is enmeshed. They tend to forget that strange element in the World that we call Pity or Mercy, which is also an absolute requirement in moral judgement (since it is present in the Divine nature). In its highest exercise it belongs to God. For finite judges of imperfect knowledge it must lead to the use of two different scales of "morality". To ourselves we must present the absolute ideal without compromise, for we do not know our own limits of natural strength (+ grace), and if we do not aim at the highest we shall certainly fall short of the utmost that we could achieve. To others, in any case of which we know enough to make a judgement, we must apply a scale tempered by "mercy": that is, since we can with good will do this without the bias inevitable in judgements of ourselves, we must estimate the limits of another's strength and weigh this against the force of particular circumstances. (We frequently see this double scale used by the saints in their judgements upon themselves when suffering great hardships or temptations, and upon others in like trials.)
I do not think that Frodo's was a moral failure. At the last moment the pressure of the Ring would reach its maximum - impossible, I should have said, for any one to resist, certainly after long possession, months of increasing torment, and when starved and exhausted. Frodo had done what he could and spent himself completely (as an instrument of Providence) and had produced a situation in which the object of his quest could be achieved. His humility (with which he began) and his sufferings were justly reqarded by the highest honour; and his exercise of patience and mercy towards Gollum gained him Mercy: his failure was redressed.
We are finite creatures with absolute limitations upon the powers of our soul-body structure in either action or endurance. Moral failure can only be asserted, I think, when a man's effort or endurance falls short of his limits, and the blame decreases as that limit is closer approached. (No account is here taken of "grace" or the enhancement of our powers as instruments of Providence. Frodo was given "grace": first to answer the call (at the end of the Council) after long resisiting a complete surrender; and later in his resistance to the temptation of the Ring (at times when to claim and so reveal it would have been fatal), and in his endurance of fear and suffering. But grace is not infinite, and for the most part seems in the Divine economy limited to what is sufficient for the accomplishment of the task appointed to one instrument in a pattern of circumstances and other instruments.)
...Frodo undertook his quest out of love - to save the world he knew from disaster at his own expense, if he could; and also in complete humility, acknowledging that he was wholly inadequate to the task. His real contract was only to do what he could, to try to find a way, and to go as far on the road as his strength of mind and body allowed. He did that. I do not myself see that the breaking of his mind and will under demonic pressure after torment was any more a moral failure than the breaking of the body would have been ...
That appears to have been the judgement of Gandalf and Aragorn and of all who learned the full story of his journey. Certainly nothing would be concealed by Frodo! But what Frodo himself thought about the events is quite another matter.
He appears at first to have had no sense of guilt ("And there was Frodo, pale and worn, and yet himself again; and in his eyes there was peace now, neither strain of will nor madness, nor any fear ... 'The Quest is achieved, and now all is over,'"); he was restored to sanity and peace. But then he thought that he had given his life in sacrifice: he expected to die very soon. But he did not, and one can observe the disquiet growing in him. Arwen was the first to observe the signs, and gave him her jewel for comfort, and thought of a way of healing him...Slowly he fades "out of the picture", saying and doing less and less. I think it is clear on reflection to an attentive reader that when his dark times came upon him and he was conscious of being "wounded by knife sting and tooth and a long burden", it was not only nightmare memories of past horrors that afflicted him, but also unreasoning self-reproach: he saw himself and all that he done as a broken failure ... And it was mixed with another temptation, blacker and yet (in a sense) more merited, for however that may be explained, he had not in fact cast away the Ring by a voluntary act: he was tempted to regret its destruction, and still to desire it. "It is gone for ever, and now all is dark and empty," he said as he wakened from his sickness in 1420.
"Alas! there are some wounds that cannot be wholly cured," said Gandalf - not in Middle-earth. Frodo was sent or allowed to pass over Sea to heal him - if that could be done, before he died...Bilbo went too. No doubt as a completion of the plan due to Gandalf himself. Gandalf had a very great affection for Bilbo, from the hobbit's childhood onwards. His companionship was really necessary for Frodo's sake - it is difficult to imagine a hobbit, even one who had been through Frodo's experiences, being really happy even in an earthly paradise without a companion of his own kind, and Bilbo was the person that Frodo most loved. But he also needed and deserved the favour on his own account. He bore still the mark of the Ring that needed to be finally erased: a trace of pride and personal possessiveness. Of course he was old and confused in mind, but it was still a revealation of the "black mark" when he said in Rivendell, "What's become of my ring, Frodo, that you took away?" and when he was reminded of what had happened, his immediate reply was: "What a pity! I should have liked to see it again!"...
Sam is meant to be lovable and laughable. Some readers he irritates and even infuriates. I can well understand it. All hobbits at times affect me in the same way, though I remain very fond of them. But Sam can be very "trying". He is a more representative hobbit than any others that we have to see much of; and he consequently has a stronger ingeredient of that quality which even some hobbits found at times hard to bear: a vulgarity - by which I do not mean a mere "down-to-earthiness" - a mental myopia which is proud of itself, a smugness (in varying degrees) and cocksureness, and a readiness to measure and sum up all things from a limited experience, largely enshrined in sententious traditional "wisdom". We only meet exceptional hobbits in close companionship - those who had a grace or gift: a vision of beauty, and a reverence for things nobler than thmselves, at war with their rustic self-satisfaction. Imagine Sam without his education by Bilbo and his fascination wtih things Elvish!...
Sam was cocksure, and deep down a little conceited; but his conceit had been transformed by his devotion to Frodo. He did not think of himself as heroic or even brave, or in any way admirable - except in his service and loyalty to his master. That had an ingredient (probably inevitable) of pride and possessiveness ... In any case it prevented him from fully understanding the master tha the loved, and from following him in his gradual education to the nobility of service to the unlovable and of perception of damaged goods in the corrupt. He plainly did not fully understand Frodo's motives or his distress in the incident of the Forbidden Pool. If he had understood better what was going on between Frodo and Gollum, things might have turned out differently in the end.
For me perhaps the most tragic moment in the Tale comes in II 323 ff. when Sam fails to note the complete change in Gollum's tone and aspect. "Nothing, nothing," said Gollum softly. "Nice master!" His repentance is blighted and all Frodo's pity is (in a sense) wasted. Shelob's lair becomes inevitable.
This is due of course to the "logic of the story". Sam could hardly have acted differently ... If he had, what could then have happened? The course of the entry into Mordor and the struggle to reach Mount Doom would have been different, and so would the ending. The insterest would have shifted to Gollum, I think, and the battle that would have gone on between his repentance and his new love on one side and the Ring. Though the love would have been strengthened daily it could not have wrested the mastery from the Ring. I think that in some queer twisted and pitiable way Gollum would have tried (not maybe with conscious design) to satisfy both. Certainly at some point not long before the end he would have stolen the Ring or taken it by violence (as he does in the actual Tale). But "possession" satisfied, I think he would then have sacrificed himself for Frodo's sake and have voluntarily cast himself into the fiery abyss.
I think that an effect of his partial regeneration by love would have been a clearer vision when he claimed the Ring. He would have perceived the evil of Sauron, and suddenly realized that he could not use the Ring and had not the strength or stature to keep it in Sauron's despite: the only way to keep it and hurt Sauron was to destory it and himself together - and in a flash he may have seen that this would also be the greatest service to Frodo. Frodo in the tale actually takes the Ring and claims it, and certainly he too would have had a clear vision - but he was not given any time: he was immediately attacked by Gollum. When Sauron was aware of the seizure of the Ring his one hope was in its power: that the claimant would be unable to relinquish it until Sauron had time to deal with him. Frodo too would then probably, if not attacked, have had to take the same way: cast himself with the Ring into the abyss. If not he would of course have completely failed. It is an interesting problem: how Sauron would have acted or the claimant have resisted. Sauron sent at once the Ringwraiths. They were naturally fully instructed, and in no way deceived as to the real lordship of the Ring. The wearer would not be invisible to them, but the reverse; and the more vulnerable to their weapons. But the situation was now different to that under Weathertop, where Frodo acted merely in fear and wished only to use (in vain) the Ring's subsidiary power of conferring invisibility. He had grown since then. Would they have been immune from its power if he claimed it as an instrument of command and domination?
Not wholly. I do not think they could have attacked him with violence, nor laid hold upon him or taken him captive; they would have obeyed or feigned to obey any minor commands of his that did not interfere with their errand - laid upon them by Sauron, who still through their nine rings (which he held) had primary control of their wills. That errand was to remove Frodo from the Crack. Once he lost the power or opportunity to destroy the Ring, the end could not be in doubt - saving help from outside, which was hardly even remotely possible.
Frodo had become a considerable person, but of a special kind: in spiritual enlargement rather than in increase of physical or mental power; his will was much stronger than it had been, but so far it had been exercised in resisting not using the Ring and with the object of destroying it. He needed time, much time, before he could control the Ring or (which in such a case is the same) before it could control him; before his will and arrogance could grow to a stature in which he could dominate other major hostile wills. Even so for a long time his acts and commands would still have to seem 'good" to him, to be for the benefit of others beside himself.
The situation as between Frodo with the Ring and the Eight (the Witch-king had been reduced to impotence) might be compared to that of a small brave man armed with a devastating weapon, faced by eight savage warriors of great strength and agility armed with poisoned blades. The man's weakness was that he did not know how to use his weapon yet; and he was by temperament and training averse to violence. Their weakness that the man's weapon was a thing that filled them with fear as an object of terror in their religious cult, by which they had been conditioned to treat one who wielded it with servility. I think they would have shown "servility". They would have greeted Frodo as "Lord". With fair speeches they would have induced him to leave the Sammath Naur - for instance "to look upon his new kingdom, and behold afar with his new sight the abode of power that he must now claim and turn to his own purposes." Once outside the chamber while he was gazing some of them would have destroyed the entrance. Frodo would by then probably have been already too enmeshed in great plans of reformed rule - like but far greater and wider than the vision that tempted Sam ("Wild fantasies arose in his mind; and he saw Samwise the Strong, Hero of the Age, striding with a sword across the darkened land, and armies flocking to his call as he marched to the overthrow of Barad-due.") - to heed this. But if he still preserved some sanity and partly understood the significance of it, so that he refused now to go with them to Barad-due, they would simply have waited. Until Sauron himself came.
In any case a confrontation of Frodo and Sauron would soon have taken place, if the Ring was intact. Its result was inevitable. Frodo would have been utterly overthrown: crushed to dust, or preserved in torment as a gibbering slave. Sauron would not have feared the Ring! It was his own and under his will. Even from afar he had an effect upon it, to make it work for its return to himsefl. In his actual presence none but very few of equal stature could have hoped to withhold it from him. Of "mortals" no one, not even Artagorn. In the contest with the Palantir Aragorn was the rightful owner. Also the contest took place at a distance, and in a tale which allows the incarnation of great spirits in a physical and destructivle form their power must be far greater when actually physically present. Sauron should be thought of as very terrible. The form that he took was that of a man of more than human stature, but not gigantic. In his earlier incarnation he was able to veil his power (as Gandalf did) and could appear as a commanding figure of great strength of body and supremely royal demeanour and countenance.
Of the others only Gandalf might be expected to master him - being an emissary of the Powers and a creature of the same order, an immortal spirit taking a visible physical form. In the "Mirror of Galadriel", it appears that Galadriel conceived of herself as capable of wielding the Ring and supplanting the Dark Lord. IF so, so also were the other guardians of the Three, especially Elrond. But this is another matter. It was part of the essential deceit of the Ring to fill minds with imaginations of supreme power. But this the Great had well considered and had rejected, as is seen in Elrond's words at the Council. Galadriel's rejection of the temptation was founded upon previous thought and resolve. In any case Elrond or Galadriel would have proceeded in the policy now adopted by Sauron: they would have built up an empire with great and absolutely subservient generals and armies and engines of war, until they could challenge Sauron and destroy him by force. Confrontation of Sauron alone, unaided, self to self, was not contemplated.
One can impagine the scene in which Gandalf, say, was placed in such a position. It would be a delicate balance. On one side the true allegiance of the Ring to Sauron; on the other superior strength because Sauron was not actually in possession, and perhaps also because he was weakened by long corruption and expenditure of will in dominating inferiors. If Gandalf proved the victor, the result would have been for Sauron the same as the destruction of the Ring; for him it would have been destroyed, taken from him for ever. But the Ring and all its works would have endured. It would have been the master in the end.
Gandalf as Ring-Lord would have been far worse than Sauron. He would have remained "righteous", but self-righteous. He would have continued to rule and order things for "good", and the benefit of his subjects according to his wisdom (which would have remained great.
Thus while Sauron multiplied evil, he left "good" clearly distinguishable from it. Gandalf would have made good destestable and seem evil.
And lastly - another draft of a letter to a fan. This one gets me a bit verklempt. Gotta admit it.
Autumn 1971 Draft of letter to Carole Batten-Phelps
I am very grateful for your remarks on the critics and for your account of your personal delight in Lord of the Rings. You write in terms of such high praise that [to] accept it with just a 'thank you' might seem complacently conceited, though actually it only makes me wonder how this has been achieved - by me! Of course the book was written to please myself (at different levels), and as an experiment in the arts of long narrative, and of inducing 'Secondary Belief'. It was written slowly and with great care for detail & finally emerged as a Frameless Picture: a searchlight, as it were, on a brief episode in History, and on a small part of our Middle-earth, surrounded by the glimmer of limitless extensions in time and space. Very well: that may explain to some extent why it 'feels' like history; why it was accepted for publication; and why it has proved readable for a large number of very different kinds of people.But it does not fully explain what has actually happened. Looking back on the wholly unexpected things that have followed its publication - beginning at once with the appearance of Vol. I - I feel as if an ever darkening sky over our present world had been suddenly pierced, the clouds rolled back, and an almost forgotten sunlight had poured down again. As if indeed the horns of Hope had been heard again, as Pippin heard them suddenly at the absolute nadir of the fortunes of the West. But How? and Why?
I think I can now guess what Gandalf would reply. A few years ago I was visited in Oxford by a man whose name I have fogotten (though I believe he was well-known). He had been much struck by the curious way in which old pictures seemed to him to have been designed to illustrate The Lord of the Rings long before its time. He brought one or two reproductions. I think he wanted at first simply to discover whether my imagination had fed on pictures, as it clearly had been by certain kinds of literature and languages. When it became obvious that, unless I was a liar, I had never seen the pictures before and was not well acquainted with pictorial Art, he fell silent. I became aware that he was looking fixedly at me. Suddenly he said, "Of course you don't suppose, do you, that you wrote all that book yourself?"
Pure Gandalf! I was too well acquainted with Gandalf to expose myself rashly, or to ask what he meant. I think I said: "No, I don't suppose so any longer." I have never since been able to suppose so. An alarming conclusion for an old philologist to draw concerning his private amusement. But not one that should puff any one up who considers the imperfections of "chosen instruments", and indeed what sometimes seems their lamentable unfitness for the purpose.
You speak of "a sanity and sanctity" in the L.R. "which is a power in itself." I was deeply moved. Nothing of the kind had been said to me before. But by a strange chance, just as I was beginning this letter, I had one from a man, who classified himself as "an unbeliever, or at best a man of belatedly and dimly dawning religious feeling ... but you", he said, "create a world in which some sort of faith seems to be everywhere without a viable source, like light from an invisible lamp." I can only answer: "Of his own sanity no man can securely judge. If sanctity inhabits his work or as a pervading light illumines it then it does not come from him but through him. And neither of you would perceive it in these terms unless it was with you also. Otherwise you would see and feel nothing, or (if some other spirit was present) you would be filled with contempt, nausea, hatred. "Leaves out of the elf-country, gah!" "Lembas - dust and ashes, we don't eat that!"
Of course The L.R. does not belong to me. It has been brought forth and must now go its appointed way in the world, though naturally I take a deep interest in its fortunes, as a parent would of a child. I am comforted to know that it has good friends to defend it against the malice of its enemies. (But all the fools are not in the other camp.) With best wishes to one of its best friends. I am
Yours sincerely
JRR Tolkien
That just kills me. "Of course The L.R. does not belong to me."
Yes. It does have "good friends to defend it". The book lives.
Thanks, Tolkien!! Thank you to "the Hobbit of Oxford"! And happy birthday!

There's kind of too much to say, and I am SO not the girl to say it. Where is the doppelganger when I need him? Let's just call me a baffled and awe-inspired fan. I ... find myself overcome with a blank wordlessness - when I try to talk about John Milton (which I don't do a lot) - it's just the kind of genius that I think is best not talked about too much. Just leave it be. Don't try to ask why, or HOW ... (I can't help it: HOW????????) Just accept that in this day and age of mortal man, giants still walk the earth on occasion. JUST ACCEPT IT. Every now and then, once every three or four centuries, a giant walks the earth. DEAL.
Milton was born on this day in 1608. He went to Oxford for a bit - but ended up leaving - and studied, basically, ALL OF HUMAN NATURE AND HISTORY AND MANKIND on his own. The depth and breadth of his work, and his inquiry, is remarkable. I just ... you know. It's that whole blank wordlessness again. Men like John Milton are so rare that you only need a couple fingers on one hand to count their like.
I guess, on a personal note, my own terror of going blind (it's not a "fear" - that is way too mild a word - I wake up screaming from nightmares because of it on a regular basis) makes me feel this strange fearful kinship with John Milton who went blind, and had to dictate his great works to others. He DICTATED Paradise Lost to his daughter. This makes me want to weep. I have wept before, when contemplating this. The ... Honestly. I go blank. I can't speak.
There are some people who are just ... vessels of a higher being. Whatever you want to call it. You could tie them up, and throw them in a basement for 75 years, and they would STILL scratch out their epic on the basement wall. This is something that cannot be easily explained. It just is.
So anyway.
I can no longer go on with this post, because basically I cannot write about John Milton in any way, shape, or form.
I'll just end with a poem that - shit. I can't speak about it. My fear of losing my sight is so deep and so profound that it is hard to even admit to, because I feel like it will come true. Milton stands before me, as a beacon - of someone this happened to - and yet he persevered. But oh. To live in darkness. To have the world of Paradise Lost in your head ... and to have to wait ... to WAIT ... as someone else takes it down in dictation ... is terrifying.
And so .... echoing this terrifying image of having to WAIT while your head is crammed full of Paradise Lost I'll end with Milton's sonnet to his own blindness. You'll notice it ends with the word "wait".
No more words. It's just not appropriate to talk about John Milton too much.
Sonnet XIX: On His Blindness
When I consider how my light is spent,
Ere half my days, in this dark world and wide,
And that one talent which is death to hide
Lodged with me useless, though my soul more bent
To serve therewith my Maker, and present
My true account, lest He returning chide,
"Doth God exact day-labour, light denied?"
I fondly ask; But patience, to prevent
That murmur, soon replies "God doth not need
Either man's work or his own gifts. Who best
Bear His mild yoke, they serve Him best. His state
Is kingly: thousands at His bidding speed
And post o'er land and ocean without rest;
They also serve who only stand and wait."
I am now reading the complete poems of WB Yeats. I have my own personal favorites in the bunch - but I've never sat down and read them ALL straight through.
It's an interesting experience - reading his earlier poems, which are, all in all, claptrap. It's so funny to me - it's like reading Sylvia Plath's complete poems in chronological order (which I have done). You read her stilted sonnets (they're God-awful - she is not even full of FEELING - like you should be when you write a sonnet - she's coy, she's self-conscious - they're terrible), the arch overly clever rhymes, you need your damn Thesaurus sitting beside you because she is so eager to show you how her vocabulary is huge ... you should have Edith Hamilton's Mythology on hand as well ... so that you can look up all her archaic references which clutter the text, making it unreadable ... With the brief exception of a couple of poems ("Pursuit", for example) - Sylvia Plath's earliest stuff is beyond tiresome. Her early poems, to me, are the equivalent of a 5 year old girl showing the adults in the room her ruffled undies and expecting to be praised. But then ... you watch the artist emerge ... 1959 she starts getting closer to her voice ... 1960 ... closer still ... and then in 1961 and 1962 it is as though a completely different woman emerges in the verse. All of the bullshit in the earlier poems - the desperation to please, the intellectual suffocation, the lack of ANY ORIGINALITY WHATSOEVER ... has vanished ... and there she stands, a true artist. You can't really get that perspective unless you suffer through those earlier poems.
Anyway, that's what I'm doing with Yeats right now.
Here's my imitation of his early poems - They all kind of sound like this to me (with a couple of exceptions):
And the green tree bends over the pagan fields
And the twinkly old eyes by the fireside laugh
The ghosts of yore dance a jig in the flames
And I, And I ...
I succumb to the music of the spheres.
Poem after poem after poem after poem ... twinkling old Irish eyes, and pagan spirits, and Celtic fairy nonsense ... I have just now reached "The Wild Swans at Coole", and I read that thinking: "Now THERE is a poem."
But still - I have enjoyed reading his earlier stuff. You can see him hacking out a space for himself. You can see him attempting to express his concerns, his themes - it's just that he's self-conscious at first.
Also: the phrase "her cloud-pale eyelids" appears pretty much in every single one of the early poems.
"I kiss her cloud-pale eyelids ..."
"Her long hair drapes over her cloud-pale eyelids"
"With her flaming tresses and her cloud-pale eyelids ..."
You could create some sort of drinking game around the number of times "cloud-pale eyelids" appears in Yeats' juvenilia.
It's a nice image, actually - "cloud-pale eyelids" - but ... only sparingly!
Again, there are some startling exceptions to the awful-ness of most of this early verse: "The Host of the Air" (which, actually, I know by heart - thanks to the Clancy Brothers at Carnegie Hall album - which we listened to almost constantly as children. So "The Host of the Air" is one of those things that I memorized by osmosis and repetition. I didn't sit down and concentrate on memorizing it- but here it is - 30 years later, and I still know all the words. So let me show off:)
O'Driscoll drove with a song
The wild duck and the drake
From the tall and the tufted reeds
Of the drear Heart Lake.
And he saw how the reeds grew dark
At the coming of night-tide,
And dreamed of the long dim hair
Of Bridget his bride.
He heard while he sang and dreamed
A piper piping away,
And never was piping so sad,
And never was piping so gay.
And he saw young men and young girls
Who danced on a level place,
And Bridget his bride among them,
With a sad and a gay face.
The dancers crowded about him
And many a sweet thing said,
And a young man brought him red wine
And a young girl white bread.
But Bridget drew him by the sleeve
Away from the merry bands,
To old men playing at cards
With a twinkling of ancient hands.
The bread and the wine had a doom,
For these were the host of the air;
He sat and played in a dream
Of her long dim hair.
He played with the merry old men
And thought not of evil chance,
Until one bore Bridget his bride
Away from the merry dance.
He bore her away in his arms,
The handsomest young man there,
And his neck and his breast and his arms
Were drowned in her long dim hair.
O'Driscoll scattered the cards
And out of his dream awoke:
Old men and young men and young girls
Were gone like a drifting smoke;
But he heard high up in the air
A piper piping away,
And never was piping so sad,
And never was piping so gay.
Now - granted - there's a lot of claptrap there, and it is very sentimental - but for me, it works. There's a bittersweetness there, a nostalgia - that is very human - and expressed in simple verses. I don't know - it calls something up out of me.
So there's THAT. No "cloud-pale eyelids" there although we do get the ubiquitous twinkling old men round the fire.
Most of the early stuff is pretty damn terrible. However - reading through it makes his later genius all the much more startling!

Jonathan Swift was born on this day, in 1667. Here's a ton of biographical information if you are interested.
Primarily known for Gulliver's Travels and A Modest Proposal he was also a poet of pretty uncommon gifts. I LOVE his stuff. He's also one of the most quotable of all writers. This man had acid running in his veins, acid of contempt for his fellow human beings.
But you think that it is time for me to have done with the world, and so I would if I could get into a better before I was called into the best, and not die here in a rage, like a poisoned rat in a hole.
His hatred and contempt have echoed across the centuries and given us the primary examples of satire that all writers should study. I am sorry that satire is so tepid these days. I find most of it way too coy, and ... obvious. They WISH that what they were doing was satire of the highest order - but what they are really doing is just bitching and whining in a tiny airless corner. A dying art. Swift was merciless.
Swift said, in regards to satire:
Satire is a sort of glass, wherein beholders do generally discover everybody's face but their own.
hahahaha So true!
Swift embraced hate. It's hard to describe any other way - and yet he did not embrace corruption. Most people who fill their souls with hate (and I can think of many examples in our present-day political discourse as I am sure you can as well) completely corrupt their humanity. Their hatred for everyone else (and their inability to look in a goddamn mirror) leaves them with no humanity. Swift does not seem to have had that problem. He was just alert, that's all. He just saw the things going on around them, and wrote it all down. He pulled no punches.
I never wonder to see men wicked, but I often wonder to see them not ashamed.
And also:
Politics, as the word is commonly understood, are nothing but corruptions.
He called things as he saw them:
We have just enough religion to make us hate, but not enough to make us love one another.
Obviously such blunt truth was highly unwelcome in many circles - and still is today. Oh, how much the pious haters despise those who call them on their phoniness!! Again: it all comes back to this: Can you look in the mirror? Can you face yourself? Can you entertain the possibility that that which you hate is also inside of you? Oh ho ho no. Many people don't even know what the HELL you are talking about when you talk like that!
But then there is also this:
It is in men as in soils where sometimes there is a vein of gold which the owner knows not.
The belief in the good in people. Not universally - oh, no. Swift was perfectly willing to see some people as just plain assholes with no redeeming qualities - and I'm pretty much with him on that. But occasionally - where you least expect it - a "vein of gold".
Many professional haters (and don't get me wrong - I think Jonathan Swift was a first-class straight-A hater - he said it about himself!) have ZERO senses of humor. Oh, they think they do, and I see them chortling on political talk shows, and yet - there's no wit. No humor. None.
But Swift? He used humor. He used it like a whip, yes, but also - well - there's something like this statement which makes me laugh out loud every time I read it:
There were many times my pants were so thin I could sit on a dime and tell if it was heads or tails.
Self-knowledge - a willingness to include himself in his own merciless searchlight:
Where I am not understood, it shall be concluded that something very useful and profound is couched underneath.
And his POEMS. Let me post a couple of them. They're marvelous. Funny, biting, mean ... and yet sometimes so heartfelt (the ones to Stella - the woman he loved all his life - comes to mind) that they bring tears to my eyes.
A Satirical Elegy: On the Death of a Late Famous General
His Grace! impossible! what dead!
Of old age, too, and in his bed!
And could that Mighty Warrior fall?
And so inglorious, after all!
Well, since he's gone, no matter how,
The last loud trump must wake him now:
And, trust me, as the noise grows stronger,
He'd wish to sleep a little longer.
And could he be indeed so old
As by the news-papers we're told?
Threescore, I think, is pretty high;
'Twas time in conscience he should die.
This world he cumber'd long enough;
He burnt his candle to the snuff;
And that's the reason, some folks think,
He left behind so great a stink.
Behold his funeral appears,
Nor widow's sighs, nor orphan's tears,
Wont at such times each heart to pierce,
Attend the progress of his hearse.
But what of that, his friends may say,
He had those honours in his day.
True to his profit and his pride,
He made them weep before he dy'd.
Come hither, all ye empty things,
Ye bubbles rais'd by breath of Kings;
Who float upon the tide of state,
Come hither, and behold your fate.
Let pride be taught by this rebuke,
How very mean a thing's a Duke;
From all his ill-got honours flung,
Turn'd to that dirt from whence he sprung.
I love the line: "How very mean a thing's a Duke". It just says it all.
And here is my favorite of the "Stella poems":
Stella's Birthday March 13, 1727
This day, whate'er the Fates decree,
Shall still be kept with joy by me:
This day then let us not be told,
That you are sick, and I grown old;
Nor think on our approaching ills,
And talk of spectacles and pills.
To-morrow will be time enough
To hear such mortifying stuff.
Yet, since from reason may be brought
A better and more pleasing thought,
Which can, in spite of all decays,
Support a few remaining days:
From not the gravest of divines
Accept for once some serious lines.
Although we now can form no more
Long schemes of life, as heretofore;
Yet you, while time is running fast,
Can look with joy on what is past.
Were future happiness and pain
A mere contrivance of the brain,
As atheists argue, to entice
And fit their proselytes for vice;
(The only comfort they propose,
To have companions in their woes;)
Grant this the case; yet sure 'tis hard
That virtue, styl'd its own reward,
And by all sages understood
To be the chief of human good,
Should, acting, die, nor leave behind
Some lasting pleasure in the mind;
Which by remembrance will assuage
Grief, sickness, poverty, and age;
And strongly shoot a radiant dart
To shine through life's declining part.
Say, Stella, feel you no content,
Reflecting on a life well spent?
Your skilful hand employ'd to save
Despairing wretches from the grave;
And then supporting with your store
Those whom you dragg'd from death before?
So Providence on mortals waits,
Preserving what it first creates.
Your gen'rous boldness to defend
An innocent and absent friend;
That courage which can make you just
To merit humbled in the dust;
The detestation you express
For vice in all its glitt'ring dress;
That patience under torturing pain,
Where stubborn stoics would complain:
Must these like empty shadows pass,
Or forms reflected from a glass?
Or mere chimæras in the mind,
That fly, and leave no marks behind?
Does not the body thrive and grow
By food of twenty years ago?
And, had it not been still supplied,
It must a thousand times have died.
Then who with reason can maintain
That no effects of food remain?
And is not virtue in mankind
The nutriment that feeds the mind;
Upheld by each good action past,
And still continued by the last?
Then, who with reason can pretend
That all effects of virtue end?
Believe me, Stella, when you show
That true contempt for things below,
Nor prize your life for other ends,
Than merely to oblige your friends;
Your former actions claim their part,
And join to fortify your heart.
For Virtue, in her daily race,
Like Janus, bears a double face;
Looks back with joy where she has gone
And therefore goes with courage on:
She at your sickly couch will wait,
And guide you to a better state.
O then, whatever Heav'n intends,
Take pity on your pitying friends!
Nor let your ills affect your mind,
To fancy they can be unkind.
Me, surely me, you ought to spare,
Who gladly would your suff'rings share;
Or give my scrap of life to you,
And think it far beneath your due;
You, to whose care so oft I owe
That I'm alive to tell you so.
"Does not the body thrive and grow By food of twenty years ago?" God ... that just kills me. Yes, Swift ... yes, it does.
And this one - hahahaha -
Oysters
Charming oysters I cry:
My masters, come buy,
So plump and so fresh,
So sweet is their flesh,
No Colchester oyster
Is sweeter and moister:
Your stomach they settle,
And rouse up your mettle:
They'll make you a dad
Of a lass or a lad;
And madam your wife
They'll please to the life;
Be she barren, be she old,
Be she slut, or be she scold,
Eat my oysters, and lie near her,
She'll be fruitful, never fear her.
His rhythm is perfection.
Michael Schmidt's book Lives of the Poets has a chapter devoted to Jonathan Swift, John Gay, and Alexander Pope - it's called "Three Friends". Schmidt's book is a must-read for poetry lovers - he's not a critic first of all. He's an editor and a book publisher. He's a FAN of poetry. He writes like a fan writes - and yet his knowledge is encyclopedic. I LOVE the book.
Here is some of what he has to say about Jonathan Swift:
His vexed relations with women, especially "Stella" and "Vanessa", and his disgust with physical functions, have given much latitude to Freudian interpretations. Disgust informs much of the prose and verse, but so does a real interest in common people, their language, actions and concerns. The verse opens on this area of his genius, and on his darker musings. It possesses the satiric virtues of the prose with an additional element: the "I" speaks, speaks as itself, with an uncompromised acerbity that few poets have masterd. When he died in 1745, Ireland and England were in his debt. The topicality that limits the appeal of some of his prose is itself the appeal of the verse: it catches inflections and remembers small actions now lost -- the voices of gardeners, street vendors, laborers ... the tone of a cryptic man of conscience speaking of his world, his bitter, life, his wary loves.
Jonathan Swift described style, in writing, as "proper words in proper places". I think he pretty much mastered that - in his prose, certainly, but also in his poems. There isn't an extra word there - there is no FAT in his language - he has pared everything down to its essentials. The verses come to us as though they were born complete - and perfect.
More from Schmidt - and this, I believe, is a brilliant point:
In the more ambitious pieces Swift challenges the reader ... There is a unique irony at work, not normative, like Dryden's, but radical: thematic rather than stylistic. This is why his poems, even the most topical, retain force today. "I take it to be part of the honesty of poets," he wrote, "that they cannot write well except they think the subject deserves it." The subjects he chose he approached as if for the first time, as if we stepped from the chill, clear world of reason into a world of men.
More (and Schmidt contradicts me here - back when I said Swift was "quotable" - but I see his point definitely - most of the quotes I excerpted above were from his prose works - His poems are pretty much complete - and need to be read straight through - they are difficult to excerpt. They depend on momentum.):
Swift is hard to recommend as a poet because he is hard to quote out of context. There are few purple passages, detachable maxims; the poetry is drawn evenly through the poem in ways that out-of-context quotation violates. The epitaphs, the spoofs, the eclogues, the anecdotes spoken by various voices, the ironic love poems, the first-person poems, will not be broken up into tags like the rich couplet bric-a-brac of Pope. In Swift we come upon a writer who might have preferred to be called versifier rather than poet. There is a difference in kind in his work from that of his predecessors; and he is not "polite" enough to have beguiled his contemporaries into imitation. He stands alone, he doesn't sing, he never ingratiates himself. He speaks, and he understands how the world wags.
And on that note, I will close this ginormous post - but I will let William Butler Yeats have the last word on this absolutely goosebump-inducing writer:
Swift's Epitaph
Swift has sailed into his rest;
Savage indignation there
Cannot lacerate his breast.
Imitate him if you dare,
World-besotted traveller; he
Served human liberty.
Yup. Imitate him if you dare.

Truth be told, I have only read Little Women. But that, frankly, was enough for me. To me, it is a perfect book - a book I go back to again and again and again - always seeing something new in it, always finding new levels. The characters seem to grow up with me. When I first read it, when I was 10 years old, I was ALL ABOUT JO. And my love affair with Jo continues to this day. She is one of my favorite female characters ever written (it's a tie between Jo March and Harriet the Spy). Jo LIVES. No one can convince me that she is just a fictional character. Nope. You cannot do it.
But as I have grown up, and as I have continuously gone back to the book - the other sisters have come to the foreground - I see myself in all of them. Parts of me are like Amy, parts of me are like Meg, and I would like to think that parts of me are like Beth. But honestly: Jo is the one. Jo is the one I most relate to. She's the artist. The tomboy. The independent wild spirit. The one who is afraid to make the wrong choice. The one who sticks to her guns.
I still am not really reconciled to the fact that she and Laurie did not end up together - HOWEVER, I can see Jo's point. They were like brother and sister. But ... but ... but ... couldn't that have segued into a love thing? The intimacy they have together, the comfort?
When I was a kid, I HATED the professor. With his stupid German accent, and his goofy poetry as he wooed Jo. I resented the fact that he wasn't Laurie. I loved Laurie.
Now I know that Louisa May Alcott was forced by her publishers to marry Jo off. She wanted her to stay single. And if you really think about it, THAT would be much more logical - it makes much more sense that Jo, even with all her passion, and her ability to understand men (in a way that Meg, the one with all the love affairs, doesn't) - would choose to spend her life alone. She would marry her writing. In that day and age, those were the choices. It was the choice Louisa May Alcott herself made. She could not submit to the demands of wifehood and motherhood - it would infringe on her writing. She knew it, even when she was 15 years old, and wrote in her journal: "I will do something by and by. Don’t care what, teach, sew, act, write, anything to help the family; and I’ll be rich and famous and happy before I die, see if I won’t!"
Alcott's background is very interesting. She grew up in Concord, one of 4 girls, and her father was buddies with Emerson, and part of the Transcendentalist movement. Her father was a teacher, and at the time, his views on teaching were very controversial: He actually believed that students should enjoy learning. Heaven forbid! He thought that students should be actively involved in their own education, and not just sit back and be passive little drones. Louisa May Alcott had a passionate girlish love of Emerson - a crush, if you will. His intellect, his library that she was allowed to use, whatever ... She adored him.
In 1862, Alcott (as always, determined to make a living - and to contribute financially to her family) traveled to Washington DC as a Civil War nurse. By this point, Alcott had already started getting stuff published - poems, short stories in the Gothic melodramatic vein ... She actually preferred Gothic melodramas to the kinds of books that later would make her name. She despised Little Women and found the writing of it extremely tedious. But anyway, her experience as a nurse in the Civil War prompted her to publish a book called Hospital Sketches. At that point, her publisher asked her if she would write a book "for girls". Never one to back off from a challenge, Louisa May Alcott sat down and wrote Little Women in two months. She had grown up with 3 sisters - and she put her entire childhood and life into that book, even as she despised doing it, and didn't think the book would amount to much.
Little Women was published in 1868 and was an immediate rip-roaring success. The publisher, within only a couple of weeks of its publication, begged Alcott to get to work on a sequel. So Alcott did. Another smash success. Louisa May Alcott had become a star.
Every book she wrote after that was eagerly awaited for by a breathless loving public. Success had, indeed, come - her childish ambitions to be 'rich and famous' came to fruition tenfold ... but 'happy'? Was she happy? Sorry, Louisa, but does it matter??
She never married. She ended up taking care of her sister May's daughter - after May died from complications in childbirth. Being a surrogate mother to this young girl was one of the most fulfilling experiences of Alcott's life. She kept writing, kept publishing ... although she began to get more and more ill from mercury poisoning she had received years earlier during the Civil War (she had, like many other Civil War nurses, contracted typhoid fever - and at the time, the proscribed cure was something called "calomel" - a drug laden with mercury).
Near the end of her life, Alcott became active in the suffragette movement, canvassing door to door to try to convince women to demand the vote. In 1879, Louisa May Alcott was the first woman to register to vote in Concord - for the school committee election. Of such small steps ultimate victory was made.
Her beloved father passed away on March 4, 1888. Louisa May Alcott died two days later.
An extraordinary woman.
She didn't care for the book that made her name ... and probably wished that her legacy was different ... but that's okay. It is not for the artist to decide what the audience will react to, what the reader will respond to. She created something with Little Women that transcends the ages, that pierces through the centuries. It is a classic book. And perhaps it's fitting, in a way, that she wrote it for hire, pretty much - it was not her idea, and yet - look at what she was able to create. Look at what she was able to bring out!!
Jo March is immortal.
When I was 16 years old, one of the assignments we had in our Drama class was to do a one-person show - maybe 15, 20 minutes long - based on either a real person from history, or a fictional character - and we had to come into the class as that character, and do a monologue - based on our research - and then take questions. What a marvelous assignment. Marvelous. I still remember my core group of friends and their projects: Beth came in as Mae West. She was incredible. She had on a blowsy blonde wig, and wore a tight sparkley dress - and I still remember the shock when Beth started telling us all about birth control options - because Mae West was an early champion of birth control for women. It was awesome. Beth was fearless. Betsy did Paddington Bear (and I still remember how one of the questions for Betsy was: "Why don't you eat some of your marmalade?" and Betsy - who despises marmalade - had to dip her hand into the jar, take out a big scoop of it, and eat it - pretending she liked it. Now that's dedication to the acting craft!). Michele did Marilyn Monroe. Unbelievable. Michele was an amazing actress - I always wish she had kept up with it. She got the sadness beneath the blonde glamour of Marilyn. Beautiful.
And I did Louisa May Alcott.
One of my first forays into the one-person show format ... I did hours and hours and hours of research for a mere 20 minute piece - because I had no idea what questions people would ask, and I had to be ready for anything!
It was great, because I had known nothing about her before that. All I knew was that she was the author who created Jo March!! We also had visited her house in Concord as a family. Orchard House:

Once I learned all this stuff about her, my admiration for her just grew. I also loved that our birthdays were almost the same. She was a Sagittarius too.
Little Women. One of the all-time great books.

He may be one of my favorite poets, and I have to thank the doppelganger for introducing me to him. Or - I should say - RE-introducing me to him. I know I read "The Chimney Sweep" in the poetry survey class I took in college - but it wasn't until after the conversation he and I had about Blake at the infamous party where we first met - that I thought: "Hmmm. Need to give Blake another look." I am SO glad I did!!! What a poet!!
Fascinating man as well.
He was a poet (virtually unknown in his own lifetime), and also an engraver (I've put some of his startling work in the extended entry - but if you want to see more of his work, check out this link.) He did illustrations for children's books, religious books, volumes of poetry ... and now his stuff is considered pretty much priceless.
William Blake was born in 1757 in London - the third of five children. He went to school until he was 14 - and then had to go to work. He got a job as an apprentice to an engraver - which is how he ended up making his paltry living. He lived in pretty much poverty for his entire life. He married at 25 - to the illiterate Catherine Boucher. Blake taught her how to read, and they ended up becoming collaborators in bringing out volumes of his poetry. He did engravings to illustrate his poems. Catherine was the one who bound the books, and got them ready for publication. The entire thing was a joint production - they did all the work themselves.
The two of them never had any children. They were extremely unconventional, shall we say - and visitors tell of stopping by the Blake house to find the two of them sitting out in their back garden completely naked. Just hanging out, reading, working together - NUDE. No shame. They had a whole philosophy about nakedness, and sex, and innocence - that there was nothing dirty about any of that stuff. It was human prudery that made celebration of the body a dirty thing. But still - some of the tales told about Blake are hysterical. I would have LOVED to meet the guy. He sounds amazing.
William Blake had visions. He speaks about them openly and much of his work has a phantasmagorical religious feeling to it. When he was a young boy, he said he looked up into a tree and saw that it was full of winged angels. He would get visions of Gabriel, the Virgin Mary, yadda yadda.
His view of God, the Spirit, the Holy Trinity, what have you - is so inspiring to me. It's vital, it's alive, and it seems to be all about love. There's not too many people I would call "genius" - but Blake I most certainly would. On the edge of sanity? Sure. Whatever. Many geniuses are.
However - again - William Blake, despite these astonishing works of poetry he put out during his lifetime - died unrecognized.
Now, though, he is considered to be one of the greatest poets in the English language. If you haven't encountered William Blake's stuff, I highly recommend you giving it a look. It's not the EASIEST poetry to get into - but God, every single page is chock-full of so much ... you can't believe that it came from only one man.
His poem about the little lisping chimney-sweep is in the "canon" - If you took any kind of sweeping Poetry 101 course, you probably would have encountered it. I'll post it below. But it's really his long form poems, especially the SPECTACULAR "Marriage of Heaven and Hell", where the guy literally has no equal. None. Blake has no peers.
Here's the one about the chimney sweep, which is - in its own way - an indictment of the society in which he lives - a society that treats its most innocent members in such a horrible way.
"The Chimney Sweep" - from Songs of Innocence
When my mother died I was very young,
And my father sold me while yet my tongue
Could scarcely cry 'weep! 'weep! 'weep! 'weep!
So your chimneys I sweep, and in soot I sleep.
There's little Tom Dacre, who cried when his head,
That curled like a lamb's back, was shaved: so I said,
"Hush, Tom! never mind it, for when your head's bare,
You know that the soot cannot spoil your white hair."
And so he was quiet; and that very night,
As Tom was a-sleeping, he had such a sight, -
That thousands of sweepers, Dick, Joe, Ned, and Jack,
Were all of them locked up in coffins of black.
And by came an angel who had a bright key,
And he opened the coffins and set them all free;
Then down a green plain leaping, laughing, they run,
And wash in a river, and shine in the sun.
Then naked and white, all their bags left behind,
They rise upon clouds and sport in the wind;
And the angel told Tom, if he'd be a good boy,
He'd have God for his father, and never want joy.
And so Tom awoke; and we rose in the dark,
And got with our bags and our brushes to work.
Though the morning was cold, Tom was happy and warm;
So if all do their duty they need not fear harm.
And here ... for those of you who are interested ... is "Marriage of Heaven and Hell" in its entirety (accompanied by more of Blake's engravings).
Just go with it. Just succumb.
As you can see, the guy was so ahead of his time that he is timeless. He predicts the Beat generation, he predicts modernism, he would fit in with the poetry slams of today (except that he is, well, you know - GOOD) ... He was a man who plumbed his unconscious for material. He brought what was within him - OUT. His poetry is the literary version of Van Gogh's Starry Night. Van Gogh was not interpreting the sky. That was actually how Van Gogh saw the stars. Get into Van Gogh's world. See the world through HIS eyes. William Blake is the same way.
I think my favorite line from William Blake is:
The eagle never lost so much time as when he submitted to learn of the crow.
I have reminded myself of those lines from time to time, when I am surrounded by mediocrity. Mediocrity that wants to bring you down. Wants you to be mediocre as well, so that you won't make anyone feel bad.
Yup. I'm a snob. I plan on being an eagle and I will no longer submit to learn from crows. Don't waste my time.
Thanks, Blake! Wish I could have visited you and your wife in your back garden, and sat around with you all, nude, drinking tea, and talking about angels.
Happy birthday!
Engravings below:
Christ in the sepulcher guarded by angels - 1805

Whirlwind of Lovers (Illustration to Dante's Inferno)

The Ancient of Days - 1794


Love that guy.
LOVE. HIM.
I wish I could go on a date with him. There. I've said it. I know he's married, but I've got a big ol' intellectual crushy-crush on PJ O'Rourke and I always have.
His writing reminds me of Joseph Heller's on occasion in that every other sentence is laugh-out-loud funny. Not EVERY sentence - but every OTHER one. It's a style, a rollicking style, full of ba-dum-CHINGS. It's hard to believe Heller could keep it up for an entire BOOK, but he did. What the style does is; it lulls you into complacence for one sentence. You think things are about to be "played straight". But then in the next sentence, you get the guy slipping on the banana peel, the pie in the face. Then in the next sentence, we're back to the serious - then comes the ba-dum-CHING again. It's so much FUN to read. PJ O'Rourke's writing is like that. One sentence will be a serious one, a truthful one - and the next sentence will be some lampoonish gag. Or - the same format will exist in one sentence.
For example:
"Wherever there's injustice, oppression, and suffering, America will show up six months late and bomb the country next to where it's happening."
That's from O'Rourke's latest book. THAT SENTENCE MAKES ME LAUGH. I know it's not a funny topic - but ... that's part of O'Rourke's appeal as a satirist, a biting commentator - whatever you want to call him. He wrote an essay about Somalia that made me guffaw. Tragic tale, hilarious writing style.
His travel essays have got to be the funniest most cantankerous travel essays ever written.
Love the guy. Love his mind. Love his writing talent.
Want to go on a date with him. That's all.
More PJ O'Rourke quotes, chosen at random by Googling the guy - I don't have any of his books with me at the moment. Look for the serious-funny style I mentioned above - it's on display in almost every quote.
-- A hat should be taken off when you greet a lady and left off for the rest of your life. Nothing looks more stupid than a hat.
-- A little government and a little luck are necessary in life, but only a fool trusts either of them.
-- Fish is the only food that is considered spoiled once it smells like what it is.
-- With Epcot Center the Disney corporation has accomplished something I didn't think possible in today's world. They have created a land of make-believe that's worse than regular life.
-- In fact, safety has no place anywhere. Everything that's fun in life is dangerous. Horse races, for instance, are very dangerous. But attempt to design a safe horse and the result is a cow (an appalling animal to watch at the trotters.) And everything that isn't fun is dangerous too. It is impossible to be alive and safe.
-- There are a lot of mysterious things about boats, such as why anyone would get on one voluntarily.
-- To grasp the true meaning of socialism, imagine a world where everything is designed by the post office, even the sleaze.
-- Moscow has changed. I was here in 1982, during the Brezhnev twilight, and things are better now. For instance, they've got litter. In 1982 there was nothing to litter with.
-- The French are a smallish, monkey-looking bunch and not dressed any better, on average, than the citizens of Baltimore. True, you can sit outside in Paris and drink little cups of coffee, but why this is more stylish than sitting inside and drinking large glasses of whiskey I don't know.
-- Bachelors know all about parties. In fact, a good bachelor is a living, breathing party all by himself. At least that is what my girlfriend said when she found the gin bottles under the couch. I believe her exact words were, "You're a disgusting, drunken mess." And that's a good description of a party, if it's done right.
Here is one of my favorite sentences from All the trouble in the world: It's so simple. Why is it so funny? I don't know. I just know that it's perfect.
-- Sloths move at the speed of congressional debate but with greater deliberation and less noise.
HAHAHA I laughed out loud when I read the sentence in that book and I just laughed out loud coming across that sentence right now.
More quotes:
-- Ecology is the science of everything. Nobody knows everything. Nobody even knows everything about any one thing. And most of us don't know much. Say it's ten-thirty on a Saturday night. Where are your teenage children? I didn't ask where they said they were going. Where are they really? What are they doing? Who are they with? Have you met the other kids' families? And what is tonight's pot smoking, wine-cooler drinking, and sex in the backseats of cars going to mean in a hundred years? Now extend these questions to the entire solar system.
-- Are we disheartened by the breakup of the family? Nobody who ever met my family is.
-- It's hard to come back from the Balkans and not sound like a Pete Seeger song.
-- Of course, the humans in Haiti have hope. They hope to leave.
-- People who are wise, good, smart, skillful, or hardworking don't need politics, they have jobs.
And here's the last one - my favorite:
-- Earnestness is just stupidity sent to college.
hahahaha
Happy birthday, PJ O'Rourke! I love you! I've got a girlie intellectual crush on you! I would blush if I met you!! I would become tongue-tied and stupid. I read everything you write! I want to kiss you! I have your picture on my wall!!
Talked with a man last night who knew Tennessee Williams and who had been in Something Cloudy, Something Clear - one of his last plays (in 1981) to be done in New York. The premiere production of it. So the play was still being worked on, by Tennessee, as they were rehearsing and opening. Not like working on an earlier Tennessee script, where it's set in stone. This one was still a work in progress. Tennessee would come to the rehearsals, sit in the back.
I GRILLED this man for information. It was wonderful talking with him.
A couple of things:
-- Tennessee was actually kind of shy and quiet. He would sit in the back of the theatre during rehearsals and not say a word.
-- One time, the director and Tennessee started conferring about something - while all the actors were up on stage - and the director said to Tennessee, "Why don't you go down there and direct the scene?" (Not in an argument - it was completely the opposite - They obviously had been going back and forth about what was going on in the scene and the director said Go and tell them how you want it!!) So Tennessee - who had no directing experience directly, and only a little bit of acting experience - walked up on stage. The actors stood around, looking at this little old man, waiting for him to tell them what to do. Tennessee said to the man who I talked with last night, "Okay ... so ... you start the scene from the other side of the stage ..." So the man I spoke with crossed the stage to start the scene from there. Tennessee just stood there, looking around at all the waiting actors, and finally just said, "Well, the scene kind of directs itself, doesn't it?" I love that story.
-- After the play opened, Williams still worked on the script. New pages of edits would come to the cast on a daily basis. Tennessee was a great FIXER - we talked about that last night. He may not have known how to direct actors - he had no experience - but if a scene wasn't working on the page, he knew how to fix it. 99.9% of playwrights when they go to "fix" something - make it worse. They THINK they're making it better, but they make it worse. Tennessee had a great eye, and a great ear ... a great poetic sense ... Something Cloudy Something Clear was not a critical success (the critics were extremely harsh on Tennessee for the last 20, 30 years of his life - they couldn't forgive him for experimenting, they couldn't forgive him for not repeating himself, they couldn't forgive him for not producing another Streetcar ... Most critics are an unimaginative bunch. If you set out to try to repeat yourself as an artist - you are DESTINED to fail. There are no exceptions. You all can probably think of a million movie sequels not as good as the original that would prove this point alone) I loved the image of the show being up and running, and pages were still coming in from Tennessee. What an experience.
-- One day, there was some kind of a photo shoot involving Tennessee. The man I spoke with last night was sent to pick him up at his hotel and get him to the photo shoot. I can't remember the name of the hotel - but it was on the Upper West Side - and it had a very Tennessee-ish name - like The Elysian Fields - or something like that. It was the summer time, and very very hot - the man I spoke with described the heat, and also - the cacophony of the New York streets - loud construction - one of those brash blinding unbearable summer days here on the island of Manhattan - and he goes up to Tennessee's room. He knocks on the door. He is let into the room. The room is painted emerald-green. Everything is green. Even the ceiling. An undersea kind of green. In the middle of the hot dirty city. Now Tennessee always had an entourage with him ... a crowd of hangers-on ... He also always had some kind of male partner, not always the same one, but always the same type: younger than Tennessee, buff, Latino usually ... These were the constant elements of Tennessee's life. So the man I spoke with last night is let into this emerald-green hotel room - There are three high-backed chairs set up in the middle of the green-ness, and Tennessee and two other people are perched on these chairs, and they are all reading Rilke out loud. Taking turns.
The man telling the story just said the whole thing was so bizarre - and that Williams lived his life in that way - it was a strange life. He was an eccentric. A committed eccentric. It was a decision he made long before he became famous. He was a writer. He was gay. No way would he ever fit in, although he yearned to. So he would not try. He would be himself. He would surround himself with like types ... and he would embrace being an outcast (his words - the word "outcast" is a continuing theme in all of his plays) But the man telling the story started laughing about the memory ... how weird it was, to step into that green world for a second ... so surreal ... the emerald-green walls ... Tennessee Williams and his entourage ... an enclave of German poetry in the middle of the loud hot city ...
Today is Sylvia Plath's birthday - it feels a bit strange to say "Happy birthday" to ... uhm ... someone who was so ultimately unhappy, and someone who took her own life ... But I saw that it was her birthday today and I had to say something.

That's a sketch she did of her own hands.
I haven't yet written a real piece on Sylvia Plath - because I know when I finaly get to it, it'll be a doozy. It'll take me hours of research, and compiling quotes, and snippets, and poems, and yadda yadda. I need to have the time to invest. That's just the deal with certain topics - and Sylvia Plath is one of them.
In honor of the birthday of this eventually astonishing poet (she didn't start out that way, although she was certainly precocious - but NONE of her early work could prepare you for what her work became in the last 2 years of her life - it's like another PERSON came out of her ....) - I have dug up some wonderful old photographs of her. I put them below the excerpt because there are quite a few of them. She was a chameleon. She was an all-American girl. She was a bleached blonde beach-blanket-bingo girl. She was an intense prodigy. She was a depressive who had survived a suicide attempt her junior year in college. She was the woman who married the big brash outdoorsman, and suddenly found herself fishing, and hunting, and tromping through the woods in galoshes. Who was she? I have no idea. But you can take a look at all the photographs and see how startling are the transformations. This is not just about the passage of time, and someone looking different as they grew older ... this really seems to be about a shedding of selves (like she writes in Lady Lazarus, in one of my favorite lines: "my selves dissolving, old whores petticoats") - I look at the picture of the bodacious blonde at the beach, and then I look at the picture of her with her two kids (taken a month or so before she committed suicide) - and it's hard to believe it's the same person. Perhaps there's something similar in the smile - there's something phony in both smiles, to my eye. Anyway, I find it fascinating - perusing the photos of Sylvia Plath.
Not nearly as fascinating as her poems themselves which have never lost their power - no matter how times I have read them.
I have gone through a bunch of Plath phases - and I am sure I will go through more. I continue to re-visit her work, every couple of years ... and re-read all those 1960-1963 poems again - sometimes in order - sometimes muddling it up - and every single time, even though I always have different responses, and sometimes one poem suddenly seems THE BEST when a couple years before it was another poem that was obviously HER BEST - but anyway, every single time I read those poems from her last 3 years, they take my breath away. They're no picnic - they are bleak bleak bleak - especially if you read them chronologically. If you read them chronologically - you can feel herself get manic - in October of 62 - and she starts cranking out 2, 3, sometimes 4 poems a day. These were not pot-boilers, folks. These poems are now taught in colleges. These are the poems that would make her name. She wasn't just scribbling out insane manic fantasies - these are highly intricate, passionate, unbeLIEVable poems. Obviously manic - when you see how many she was putting out a day ... and then there is a brief falling away for a month - December ... she was still writing, but obviously it was the calm before the storm. Then January and February 1963 came along - and I believe it was the coldest winter London had ever had - and her pipes froze - and she had no help, and two young babies - and things started getting worse and worse in her mind. And her art kicked in yet again - with ferocity and power. She would write these poems at 4 in the morning - her only time to herself. So you can feel the wheels start cranking again - in January, February - she wrote some of her best poems then. They are more frightening, however, than the October poems. She is staring at death, she is beginning to embrace the idea of death ... Death is always a factor in Plath's poems, but it takes on a new form in those last couple of poems. It is no longer just a fantasy, death is no longer a dream-lover in the night ... she is now making plans. The rage of October (which gave us such poems as Daddy, and Poppies in October, and the entire fanTASTIC bee-keeping sequence) is now gone. And you can feel a chilling resolve creep into her work. She is getting ready to go.
I have interspersed the photos of Plath I found with some of my favorite of her poems.
I still need to do a big old Plath fest one day - I have too much to say about her, and need to get my thoughts together better.
In honor of her birthday, here's one that she actually wrote about her upcoming birthday - in 1962. She wrote this poem, now one of her most well-known, on Sept. 30 1962 ... right before the blast of creativity and rage that would fuel her through that painful next month. Sylvia always had a fatalistic thing with birthdays:
A Birthday Present
What is this, behind this veil, is it ugly, is it beautiful?
It is shimmering, has it breasts, has it edges?
I am sure it is unique, I am sure it is what I want.
When I am quiet at my cooking I feel it looking, I feel it thinking
'Is this the one I am too appear for,
Is this the elect one, the one with black eye-pits and a scar?
Measuring the flour, cutting off the surplus,
Adhering to rules, to rules, to rules.
Is this the one for the annunciation?
My god, what a laugh!'
But it shimmers, it does not stop, and I think it wants me.
I would not mind if it were bones, or a pearl button.
I do not want much of a present, anyway, this year.
After all I am alive only by accident.
I would have killed myself gladly that time any possible way.
Now there are these veils, shimmering like curtains,
The diaphanous satins of a January window
White as babies' bedding and glittering with dead breath. O ivory!
It must be a tusk there, a ghost column.
Can you not see I do not mind what it is.
Can you not give it to me?
Do not be ashamed--I do not mind if it is small.
Do not be mean, I am ready for enormity.
Let us sit down to it, one on either side, admiring the gleam,
The glaze, the mirrory variety of it.
Let us eat our last supper at it, like a hospital plate.
I know why you will not give it to me,
You are terrified
The world will go up in a shriek, and your head with it,
Bossed, brazen, an antique shield,
A marvel to your great-grandchildren.
Do not be afraid, it is not so.
I will only take it and go aside quietly.
You will not even hear me opening it, no paper crackle,
No falling ribbons, no scream at the end.
I do not think you credit me with this discretion.
If you only knew how the veils were killing my days.
To you they are only transparencies, clear air.
But my god, the clouds are like cotton.
Armies of them. They are carbon monoxide.
Sweetly, sweetly I breathe in,
Filling my veins with invisibles, with the million
Probable motes that tick the years off my life.
You are silver-suited for the occasion. O adding machine-----
Is it impossible for you to let something go and have it go whole?
Must you stamp each piece purple,
Must you kill what you can?
There is one thing I want today, and only you can give it to me.
It stands at my window, big as the sky.
It breathes from my sheets, the cold dead center
Where split lives congeal and stiffen to history.
Let it not come by the mail, finger by finger.
Let it not come by word of mouth, I should be sixty
By the time the whole of it was delivered, and to numb to use it.
Only let down the veil, the veil, the veil.
If it were death
I would admire the deep gravity of it, its timeless eyes.
I would know you were serious.
There would be a nobility then, there would be a birthday.
And the knife not carve, but enter
Pure and clean as the cry of a baby,
And the universe slide from my side.

The moon and the yew tree
This is the light of the mind, cold and planetary
The trees of the mind are black. The light is blue.
The grasses unload their griefs on my feet as if I were God
Prickling my ankles and murmuring of their humility
Fumy, spiritous mists inhabit this place.
Separated from my house by a row of headstones.
I simply cannot see where there is to get to.
The moon is no door. It is a face in its own right,
White as a knuckle and terribly upset.
It drags the sea after it like a dark crime; it is quiet
With the O-gape of complete despair. I live here.
Twice on Sunday, the bells startle the sky ----
Eight great tongues affirming the Resurrection
At the end, they soberly bong out their names.
The yew tree points up, it has a Gothic shape.
The eyes lift after it and find the moon.
The moon is my mother. She is not sweet like Mary.
Her blue garments unloose small bats and owls.
How I would like to believe in tenderness ----
The face of the effigy, gentled by candles,
Bending, on me in particular, its mild eyes.
I have fallen a long way. Clouds are flowering
Blue and mystical over the face of the stars
Inside the church, the saints will all be blue,
Floating on their delicate feet over the cold pews,
Their hands and faces stiff with holiness.
The moon sees nothing of this. She is bald and wild.
And the message of the yew tree is blackness -- blackness and silence

Little Fugue
The yew's black fingers wag:
Cold clouds go over.
So the deaf and dumb
Signal the blind, and are ignored.
I like black statements.
The featurelessness of that cloud, now!
White as an eye all over!
The eye of the blind pianist
At my table on the ship.
He felt for his food.
His fingers had the noses of weasels.
I couldn't stop looking.
He could hear Beethoven:
Black yew, white cloud,
The horrific complications.
Finger-traps--a tumult of keys.
Empty and silly as plates,
So the blind smile.
I envy big noises,
The yew hedge of the Grosse Fuge.
Deafness is something else.
Such a dark funnel, my father!
I see your voice
Black and leafy, as in my childhood.
A yew hedge of orders,
Gothic and barbarous, pure German.
Dead men cry from it.
I am guilty of nothing.
The yew my Christ, then.
Is it not as tortured?
And you, during the Great War
In the California delicatessen
Lopping off the sausages!
They colour my sleep,
Red, mottled, like cut necks.
There was a silence!
Great silence of another order.
I was seven, I knew nothing.
The world occurred.
You had one leg, and a Prussian mind.
Now similar clouds
Are spreading their vacuous sheets.
Do you say nothing?
I am lame in the memory.
I remember a blue eye,
A briefcase of tangerines.
This was a man, then!
Death opened, like a black tree, blackly.
I survive the while,
Arranging my morning.
These are my fingers, this my baby.
The clouds are a marriage of dress, of that pallor.

The Bee Meeting (this is one of the poems in her famous "bee sequence" - which she cranked out at 1 or 2 a day, during October of 1962.)
Who are these people at the bridge to meet me? They are the villagers ---
The rector, the midwife, the sexton, the agent for bees.
In my sleeveless summery dress I have no protection,
And they are all gloved and covered, why did nobody tell me?
They are smiling and taking out veils tacked to ancient hats.
I am nude as a chicken neck, does nobody love me?
Yes, here is the secretary of bees with her white shop smock,
Buttoning the cuffs at my wrists and the slit from my neck to my knees.
Now I am milkweed silk, the bees will not notice.
They will not smell my fear, my fear, my fear.
Which is the rector now, is it that man in black?
Which is the midwife, is that her blue coat?
Everybody is nodding a square black head, they are knights in visors,
Breastplates of cheesecloth knotted under the armpits.
Their smiles and their voces are changing. I am led through a beanfield.
Strips of tinfoil winking like people,
Feather dusters fanning their hands in a sea of bean flowers,
Creamy bean flowers with black eyes and leaves like bored hearts.
Is it blood clots the tendrils are dragging up that string?
No, no, it is scarlet flowers that will one day be edible.
Now they are giving me a fashionable white straw Italian hat
And a black veil that molds to my face, they are making me one of them.
They are leading me to the shorn grove, the circle of hives.
Is it the hawthorn that smells so sick?
The barren body of hawthon, etherizing its children.
Is it some operation that is taking place?
It is the surgeon my neighbors are waiting for,
This apparition in a green helmet,
Shining gloves and white suit.
Is it the butcher, the grocer, the postman, someone I know?
I cannot run, I am rooted, and the gorse hurts me
With its yellow purses, its spiky armory.
I could not run without having to run forever.
The white hive is snug as a virgin,
Sealing off her brood cells, her honey, and quietly humming.
Smoke rolls and scarves in the grove.
The mind of the hive thinks this is the end of everything.
Here they come, the outriders, on their hysterical elastics.
If I stand very still, they will think I am cow-parsley,
A gullible head untouched by their animosity,
Not even nodding, a personage in a hedgerow.
The villagers open the chambers, they are hunting the queen.
Is she hiding, is she eating honey? She is very clever.
She is old, old, old, she must live another year, and she knows it.
While in their fingerjoint cells the new virgins
Dream of a duel they will win inevitably,
A curtain of wax dividing them from the bride flight,
The upflight of the murderess into a heaven that loves her.
The villagers are moving the virgins, there will be no killing.
The old queen does not show herself, is she so ungrateful?
I am exhausted, I am exhausted ---
Pillar of white in a blackout of knives.
I am the magician's girl who does not flinch.
The villagers are untying their disguises, they are shaking hands.
Whose is that long white box in the grove, what have they accomplished, why am I cold.

Fever 103 (another Oct. 1962 poem)
Pure? What does it mean?
The tongues of hell
Are dull, dull as the triple
Tongues of dull, fat Cerebus
Who wheezes at the gate. Incapable
Of licking clean
The aguey tendon, the sin, the sin.
The tinder cries.
The indelible smell
Of a snuffed candle!
Love, love, the low smokes roll
From me like Isadora's scarves, I'm in a fright
One scarf will catch and anchor in the wheel.
Such yellow sullen smokes
Make their own element. They will not rise,
But trundle round the globe
Choking the aged and the meek,
The weak
Hothouse baby in its crib,
The ghastly orchid
Hanging its hanging garden in the air,
Devilish leopard!
Radiation turned it white
And killed it in an hour.
Greasing the bodies of adulterers
Like Hiroshima ash and eating in.
The sin. The sin.
Darling, all night
I have been flickering, off, on, off, on.
The sheets grow heavy as a lecher's kiss.
Three days. Three nights.
Lemon water, chicken
Water, water make me retch.
I am too pure for you or anyone.
Your body
Hurts me as the world hurts God. I am a lantern ---
My head a moon
Of Japanese paper, my gold beaten skin
Infinitely delicate and infinitely expensive.
Does not my heat astound you. And my light.
All by myself I am a huge camellia
Glowing and coming and going, flush on flush.
I think I am going up,
I think I may rise ---
The beads of hot metal fly, and I, love, I
Am a pure acetylene
Virgin
Attended by roses,
By kisses, by cherubim,
By whatever these pink things mean.
Not you, nor him.
Not him, nor him
(My selves dissolving, old whore petticoats) ---
To Paradise.

The Couriers (written in Nov. 1962)
The word of a snail on the plate of a leaf?
It is not mine. Do not accept it.
Acetic acid in a sealed tin?
Do not accept it. It is not genuine.
A ring of gold with the sun in it?
Lies. Lies and a grief.
Frost on a leaf, the immaculate
Cauldron, talking and crackling
All to itself on the top of each
Of nine black Alps.
A disturbance in mirrors,
The sea shattering its grey one -
Love, love, my season.

I think the following poem is the saddest she ever wrote. Now who can ever say what is in the mind of another - and it is always a dangerous thing to read too much into these poems (at least in a biographical way). They are, after all, art. But I believe that one of the reasons she killed herself is to spare her children a mother whose face was "a ceiling without a star". Not that that excuses her actions. But she wrote this poem in January of 1963, 2 weeks before she put her head in the oven. I find this poem nearly unreadable in its sadness. Yet - wonderful writing as well.
Child
Your clear eye is the one absolutely beautiful thing.
I want to fill it with color and ducks,
The zoo of the new
Whose names you meditate ---
April snowdrop, Indian pipe,
Little
Stalk without wrinkle,
Pool in which images
Should be grand and classical
Not this troublous
Wringing of hands, this dark
Ceiling without a star.

And this is the last poem that Sylvia Plath completed. It's chilling, yes, but standing alone - as a poem - I think there's a lot to talk about here, a lot of stuff - not just biographical.
And I'm sorry - but the line "her blacks crackle and drag" is ... I mean, I can't describe it. It's just fantastic genius-level imagery, that's all. Goosebumps. The last two lines give me goosebumps. So scary. "Her blacks crackle and drag." (And yes ... let me just throw a shout-out to Paul Westerberg - who has also recognized the genius imagery in that line.) It's scary. "Crackle"? "Drag?" All kinds of very frightening images come to mind in those two simple words ... and the internal rhyme of "blacks" and "crackle" make it seem even more eerie. I'm not a literary critic but I will NEVER be done reading this last poem. She completed it on February 4, 1963. She killed herself on February 11.
Edge
The woman is perfected.
Her dead
Body wears the smile of accomplishment,
The illusion of a Greek necessity
Flows in the scrolls of her toga,
Her bare
Feet seem to be saying:
We have come so far, it is over.
Each dead child coiled, a white serpent,
One at each little
Pitcher of milk, now empty.
She has folded
Them back into her body as petals
Of a rose close when the garden
Stiffens and odors bleed
From the sweet, deep throats of the night flower.
The moon has nothing to be sad about,
Staring from her hood of bone.
She is used to this sort of thing.
Her blacks crackle and drag.
The rain pours down today. It's still muggy, though, which is highly disappointing. The sidewalk in front of my apartment is littered with fallen chestnuts, hard, shiny, and yet still: muggy warm soup-air. Uhm ... ready for the autumn chill? I'm going nuts.
Two things on the books today besides rehearsing and treadmill: two things I am SO excited for:
First up:
Allison and I are going to The Grolier Club to see the Plath/Hughes exhibit.
For the first time ever!! The papers of Sylvia Plath and the papers of Ted Hughes - in the same place!!! Ooh, bet the angry feminists must HATE that one! "How DARE you let that villain's stuff near our martyred heroine's stuff? This would be like putting a Nazi's memorabilia through the Anne Frank house!" (Or insert any other inappropriate analogy that you can think of) Etc. Loons. It's actually rather amusing. Ted Hughes and Sylvia Plath were, contrary to popular belief, just TWO HUMAN BEINGS. Mkay?
Here:


Here's my favorite photo of the two of them (below). Sure, it went horrifically bad much later on ... the relationship was destroyed completely ... but I like to think of them like this, in their earlier days. Working together, supporting each other's work, companions.

They were not living symbols of the oppressor and the oppressed. They did not fit into pre-constructed roles. They were just two people. Talented dedicated poets. In love with each other. For a while. Then he cheated on her, they split up, and she killed herself. Well done you. The mythology built up around them both is kind of astounding - and I admit, as a huge Plath fan, that I bought into the mythology for many years. That's another big post I'd like to do someday - my changing relationship to Sylvia Plath. I've been into her stuff since I was 16, and my relationship to it keeps changing. I feel like now that I've gotten away from the mythology - I am in a much clearer space to really appreciate her poetry, and how astonishing she is in her later work. I mean, it's really amazing. And I've recently gotten into Ted Hughes. I stayed away from him for years because ... you know ... he is the bogey-man to Plath freaks. The evil male. Etc. But I've grown up a bit, and am not at all attached to the mythology anymore. I think he's incredible. But all of that is neither here nor there.
The piece in The Times says:
it is a little bit like sitting down with two highly gifted, impossibly loquacious, relentlessly driven and (admittedly) self-dramatizing people and having them try to speak to you over the heads of the biographers, the moviemakers, the conjecturers and the cliché-spinners. Look at us unmediated, they, or their artifacts, seem to be saying. Make up your own minds about who we were and what we did - if you dare.
I am so so excited for this exhibit - have been looking forward to it for WEEKS - and Allison is my perfect partner-in-crime. A huge Plath fan, someone as obsessive as I am ... she and I went to go see the film Sylvia together when it came out (it's quite fantastic, by the way, although obviously not a barrel of laughs. Originally, I was like: Gwyneth as Sylvia? Oh give me a BREAK. But no. She was absolutely perfect. A wonderful performance. And Daniel Craig is so sexy as Ted Hughes that I can barely think about him directly.)
And after we spend a couple of hours browsing through Syvia and Ted's papers - we are going to go see Capote - which I have heard is fantastic.
The director of the play I'm in right now said that Hoffman is beyond good. It doesn't look like an acting job - it seems as though he has actually inhabited Truman Capote.
Man. I am so excited for that one as well.
Rain. Chestnuts. Sylvia Plath. Ted Hughes. Truman Capote. Treadmill. Already sounds like a great day.
Today is the birthday of Vaclav Havel. (Again with the connection to this post below) I first became aware of him in college, when we had to read a couple of his plays. Plays that, naturally, could not be performed in his home country - but made him famous the world over. One of my favorite things Vaclav Havel said (beside the title of this post) is how he managed to live under Communism for so many years, how he handled it. He said he lived by the rule of "as if". "I decided to behave as if I were free."
In honor of his birthday, I will post links to my insanely obsessive essays I wrote about Czechoslovakia, when I was still doing that Country of the Week feature, like some autistic amateur historian.
The Czech Republic: The 20th Century
The Czech Republic: The Spirit of Prague
And lastly, in honor of Vaclav Havel, I will re-post something I wrote about a certain speech he made on January 1, 1990. Still has the power to give me chills, no matter how many times I read it:
Vaclav Havel made a speech on January 1, 1990, immediately following all of the extraordinary changes which had occurred in his country. This speech along with many many others made it into the book I have of "The Greatest Speeches of the 20th Century".
The first time I read it, I was sitting on a crowded subway. By the end, tears were rolling down my face. In retrospect, I think that is hysterical. If anyone noticed I was crying, I am sure they would never have guessed the reason - and would have thought I was insane if they had asked:
"Ma'am, are you all right? Why are you crying? Did your boyfriend break up with you?"
and I had answered:
"Oh ... uh ... no. I'm crying because of Vaclav Havel's speech to the Czech people in 1990."
".....Oh..."
Havel's speech, broadcast on the radio, set the tone for all that was to follow. It is referred to as "the contaminated moral environment" speech. After decades of double-speak, decades of being lied to by their own government, decades of muffling their true sentiments, Vaclav Havel stood up and told the truth. He had been preparing for this moment since the 1960s.
And that's another thing. We, as human beings, can recognize truth when we hear it.
Czeslaw Milosz, another famous dissident, brilliant poet, said in his speech accepting the Nobel Prize: "In a room where people unanimously maintain a conspiracy of silence, one word of truth sounds like a pistol shot." This is the atmosphere into which Vaclav Havel spoke, on that momentous day in 1990.
We know when we're being lied to, deceived. Truth is unmistakable, and Havel knew that. And Havel did not let the Czech people off the hook - another reason why the "velvet revolution" was so amazing. It was not about pointing fingers, screaming, "YOU DID THIS TO US". Havel encouraged the Czech people to take responsibility for their destinies, to take responsibility for having endured the tyranny for so long. The "contaminated moral environment" is not only about the Communist regime. He addressed that comment to every Czech person who had tolerated living under tyranny. No passing the buck, no blame. Take responsibility.
Imagine. How many leaders ever speak to their people in such a way? This speech is one of the myriad reasons that Vaclav Havel is one of my political heroes.
Quotes from his extraordinary speech - I edited it a bit - but I am sure you can find the entire text online, or in books:
Havel's speech, Jan. 1990
Our country is not flourishing. The enormous creative and spiritual potential of our nation is not being used sensibly ... We have polluted our soil, our rivers and forests, bequeathed to us by our ancestors, and we have today the most contaminated environment in Europe. Adult people in our country die earlier than in most other European countries.
But all this is still not the main problem. The worst thing is that we live in a contaminated moral environment. We fell morally ill because we became used to saying something different from what we thought. We learned not to believe in anything, to ignore each other, to care only about ourselves. Concepts such as love, friendship, compassion, humility, or forgiveness lost their depth and dimensions, and for many of us they represented only psychological peculiarities, or they resembled gone-astray greetings from ancient times, a little ridiculous ...
The previous regime -- armed with its arrogant and intolerant ideology -- reduced man to a force of production and nature to a tool of production ... It reduced gifted and autonomous people, skillfully working in their own country, to nuts and bolts of some monstrously huge, noisy, and stinking machine, whose real meaning is not clear to anyone ...
When I talk about contaminated moral atmosphere ... I am talking about all of us. We had all become used to the totalitarian system and accepted it as an unchangeable fact and thus helped to perpetuate it. In other words, we are all -- though naturally to differing extremes -- responsible for the operation of the totalitarian machinery; none of us is just its victim: we are all also its co-creators ...
We have to accept this legacy as a sin we committed against ourselves. If we accept it as such, we will understand that it is up to us all, and up to us only, to do something about it. We cannot blame the previous rulers for everything, not only because it would be untrue but also because it could blunt the duty that each of us faces today, namely, the obligation to act independently, freely, reasonably and quickly ... Freedom and democracy include participation and therefore responsibility from us all.
If we realize this, then all the horrors that the new Czechoslovak democracy inherited will cease to appear so terrible. If we realize this, hope will return to our hearts ...
In the effort to rectify matters ... we have something to lean on. The recent period -- and in particular, the last six weeks of our peaceful revolution -- has shown the enormous human, moral, and spiritual potential and civil culture that slumbered in our society under the enforced mask of apathy. Whenever someone categorically claimed that we were this or that, I always objected that society is a very mysterious creature and that it is not wise to trust only the face it presents to you. I am happy that I was not mistaken. Everywhere in the world people wonder where those meek, humiliated, skeptical, and seemingly cynical citizens of Czechoslovakia found the marvelous strength to shake from their shoulders in several weeks and in a decent and peaceful way the totalitarian yoke...
There are free elections and an election campaign ahead of us. Let us not allow this struggle to dirty the so far clean face of our gentle revoltuion ... It is not really important now which party, club, or group will prevail in the elections. The important thing is that the winners will be the best of us, in the moral, civil, political and professional sense, regardless of their political affiliations ...
In conclusion, I would like to say that I want to be a president who will speak less and work more. To be a president who will ... always be present among his fellow citizens and listen to them well.
You may ask what kind of republic I dream of. Let me reply: I dream of a republic independent, free, and democratic, of a republic economically prosperous and yet socially just, in short, of a humane republic which serves the individual and which therefore holds the hope that the individual will serve it in turn. Of a republic of well-rounded people, because without such it is impossible to solve any of our problems, human, economic, ecological, social, or political.
People, your government has returned to you!
Today is the birthday of one of my favorite writers - Truman Capote.

I am so excited to see Philip Seymour Hoffman's take on him. The film got a great review in The NY Times and I'm just so excited about it. Look at the similarities there. Amazing.

Truman Capote has been one of my many life-long obsessions - so forgive my autuistic knowledge of this man - his life, and his work. Also - I just had to go out and find all the great photos of him, and post them here. People LOVED to photograph this man (at least in his early wunderkind days) - and all of them are online, which is so exciting. So I've found some of my favorites, to post them here for you.
Example:

Most of my generation only remembers Truman from his appearances on various talk shows, mainly Johnny Carson, when he was a bloated guy with a high lisping voice who was vaguely embarrassing to watch - At least I felt that way. He was obese, he had face lifts, he wore a white Panama hat, he was kind of grotesque. I didn't know that he was basically caricaturing himself by then - which is always death to an artist of any kind.

But he was stuck. He had horrendous writer's block at the very end - which tormented him. The end of his life was full of despair. It's wrenching to read about - you just want his suffering to stop.
But as a youngun? As the new writer in town? He was a golden boy. He was a creature like Thomas Mann had written about. The golden-haired child-man who led others to do naughty naughty things, and then pled innocence. Photographers lined up to capture this guy.
See what I mean?

Hard to realize just how provocative those photos were back then. Especially because he was openly gay. And not just "openly gay" - but openly PRISSY and gay - which some people find unforgivable. Fine, be gay ... but ... do you have to be so ... GAY about it?? Can't you just PRETEND to be straight so I don't have to feel so ... ikky? Truman, even back in the early 40s, didn't put on an act for the straight world. He didn't turn himself inside out to make people feel comfortable with his gayness. He just was who he was. If people felt uncomfortable, then that was THEIR problem. He was prissy, he lisped, he flounced about like a Southern belle - AND he happened to be a kick-ass writer with a literary voice that no one could forget.
I still remember the impact that The Grass Harp had on my heart when I first read it.

That book literally hurt my heart. I was too young then to really understand regrets, or loss - the way I understand them now - but his elegaic writing in that story touched some deep universal chord in me - the part of me that is HUMAN, and not just an age on a timeline. There was a kind of soul-growth spurt that happened to me when I read that sad beautiful story. I still have a real fondness for it.
His first book, published in 1948, was Other Voices, Other Rooms, and it took the literary world by storm. It was one of THOSE debuts. High level reviewers praised the book - in glowing terms - and it truly is a wonderful book. Not as good as his others, and CERTAINLY not as good as In Cold Blood
(just saying the name of that book gives me a chill up my spine) - but you could tell that there was a real VOICE in that book.
Just to add to the controversy - here is the "author photo" that appeared sprawled across the back of the book:

hahahahaha Truman! Please! It caused an outrage. A stir. People loved it. People hated it. People TALKED about it, and that was what Truman cared about. Truman had talent - yes - but he understood the whole 15 minutes of fame thing long before Andy Warhol came along. Truman wanted to be FAMOUS as well as being a good writer. He wasn't one of those writers who holed themselves up in their apartments (at least not until In Cold Blood when he disappeared off the face of the earth for almost 5 years - he said later that writing that book nearly killed him.) ... But before In Cold Blood he was out at every party, he hung out with the rich and famous (at least until the huge debacle at the end of his life when he alienated all of them in one fell swoop)
This photo is just ... kind of says it all, don't it?

Look at how he's holding her wrist!!! Like - hold her HAND, Truman. But also - look at how sweet she is. The two of them were actually very good friends and he wrote one of my favorite pieces about her, which appears in the gorgeous collection Music for Chameleons. The piece describes a day in New York when he and Marilyn attended a funeral of a mutual friend. I love that piece. It's called "A Beautiful Child", because that's what Truman saw her as. Not the sex goddess. But a beautiful child. Still, though. What a FUNNY photo of the two of them.
He was the darling of New York. He wasn't just friends with celebrities - whose wealth is a rather transitory thing. He became friends with REAL rich people. The international tycoon types. The Onassis types. He was invited to all of the "society" parties.
And he threw a party that is still famous. It was called The Black and White Ball, and he threw it for Katherine Graham - who he didn't even really know.

She wrote in her autobiography (which I've read): "I was truly baffled as to why I was the guest of honor. But it seemed really important to Truman ... so I said yes."
Odd. It was, many people say who care about this stuff, the "party of the century".
Everyone had to come wearing masks, and everyone had to dress in black and white. Truman had just finished In Cold Blood - or maybe he had just returned from Kansas - not sure - but he needed to let off steam, he needed to shake off In Cold Blood which had literally taken over his life. So he threw this party - where everyone who was anyone showed up.
Here's Candice Bergen at the party:

Here's Norman Mailer and his wife - hahahaha

Here's Mia Farrow and Frank Sinatra- who had just gotten married:

People jostled to get invited. People sucked up to Truman. He was in his glory. But even then - he had the oddest mix of desire and contempt when it came to the rich. He wanted to hang out with them - but he had contempt for them as well. On some level, I think he knew that they would drop him like a hot potato the second his friendship became inconvenient. He knew that his friendships with these people were were pretty one-sided: Truman was there to entertain, to keep things light and amusing. The second he started falling on hard times later in life, they stopped tolerating his company.
Perhaps all those rich people just liked the cache of having a literary star at their parties - it made their parties seem more ... substantial. Maybe they really did like him. But I don't think so. And I don't think Truman liked them all that much, either. He saw right through them. Only he kept that to himself, and let the rich people think that he bought their game, that he was fooled, that he did not see the essential shallowness beneath their facade. When he finally came out and wrote about them and their pettiness, their stupidity - they could not and would not forgive him. (By that point in his life, long after In Cold Blood, Truman had actually lost a lot of what had made him a success in the first place ... and that was his compassion for others. His ability to love his fellow man, and to try to step into their shoes and describe for us, the reader, what it is "like" to be that person. By the 1960s, drugs and drinking had taken hold ... and Truman was angry. He wrote about his former friends with bitchy - but spot-on - RAGE. He had NO compassion for THEM. He could find it in his heart to be compassionate for Dick Hickock and Perry Smtih even though they had committed such a heinous crime. But he was NOT compassionate for the fat Upper East Side cats. He unleashed his wrath on them, and it was like a bomb going off in international society.)
Truman Capote found himself bereft, and alone. He never recovered from that shattering of his world, even though he said over and over, "I'm a writer! What did they think I did in my spare time? I observed life - and I wrote about it!" They did not forgive him for telling the truth. Years later, when Gerald Clarke wrote his tremendous biography of Capote - there were people who refused to be interviewed for the book becaue they were STILL seething at Truman's "betrayal".

I'm going to post something I wrote a long time ago on this blog - which ended up being published elsewhere. It's called "Fairy on the Prairie", and it's about the writing of In Cold Blood which is pretty much on my Top 10 favorite books ever written. Certain books come and go on that list - titles get bumped off - moved on - but not In Cold Blood. There are a couple of others that never get bumped off - Harriet the Spy, A Wrinkle in Time
, Catch-22
. These are great great books.
I'm proud of the piece I wrote on Truman.
Before we get to that, though, I would like to share my favorite photo of Truman Capote. It's done by the great photographer Irving Penn. I like it because - it's not the "carefree" look of his golden-boy self - which was a pose, to some degree. It's not the provocative just-got-out-of-bed look he sported as an early writer - which was also a pose. And it's not a photograph from his later years, which just really hurt me to see.
Irving Penn had photographed Spencer Tracy, famously, boxed up in a corner. (That was one of Penn's "things" - he put famous people into corners of rooms and photographed them. Strangely effective.)
Look. Amazing photo of Spencer. Look at the EXPRESSION on his face.

Penn took basically the same photograph of Truman - boxed him up in a corner. I looked for a larger version of the photo - a clearer one - but couldn't find it. This is the best I could get.
There is something about this photo that not only haunts me, but strikes me as deeply painfully TRUE. The oversized coat, it makes him look so small and frail. The cramped quarters, the walls pressing in. Now, I did not know Truman Capote, and it is not for me to say who is the "real" Truman Capote - but something about the look on his face in this photo, its flat blank-eyed stare, the gaze is a bit confronting, but also - so accepting of himself, of the soul behind those eyeballs - something about it lands for me. I feel that I am getting a glimpse not of a personality, a famous person ... but someone's soul. I feel the same way about the Spencer Tracy photograph - so I don't know what that's about, and I'm sure it has all to do with Irving Penn's gift. It's extraordinary to me.

And now. Onto In Cold Blood, and my old post about him. There may be some repeats of information here.
Happy happy birthday, dear dear Truman.

Truman Capote said later that if he had known what he was getting into, when he traveled down to Kansas ("a fairy down on the prairie - who'd have thought?") to write a piece on the murder for The New Yorker, then he never would have gone. He went to Kansas only 2 weeks after the murders took place. The killers had still not been found, the community was in an uproar of suspicion and paranoia. Capote's main interest was to do a long profile of the townspeople, how regular church-going farmers handled such a disaster. Little did he know what the book would eventually be! The project took up years of his life. He had to wait for the executions of the 2 murderers, in order to complete his book. So he waited, and waited. Appeal after appeal ...He was unable to write anything else. Nothing else interested him. He was a man obsessed, in the grip of his obsession for years. His health was ruined. His friends were sick of hearing about the Clutter family. He tried to take vacations with his long-time partner, and would just drink, and try to sleep, and have fits of despair. He thought those boys would never be executed, he thought he would be in limbo forever. Yet - the morbidness of his entire life being on hold because of commuted death-sentences in Kansas - the morbidness of trying to go on, when really all you want is for those 2 boys to be killed - so that YOU can go back to YOUR life ... This paid a huge toll on him.
Finally - there were no more appeals and Capote traveled to Kansas, to watch the execution. Hickock and Smith had asked him to be there. In the intervening years, he had interviewed the 2 killers numerous times. Their first-person descriptions of their own sorry lives make up important parts of the book. Capote became their conduit to the outside world. Hickock would draw self-portraits of himself and send them to Capote. Capote was playing a double-edged game here. He became "the listener", the one who would sit and ask them questions, and nod understandingly. The 2 of them got addicted to his concern. Yet Capote was horrified by most of what he heard. He wasn't without pity for these men, who had pretty much been beaten like dogs from the second they were born - and yet Capote hadn't had an easy road either, and HE hadn't killed anyone in cold blood. He had grown up with alcoholics, he had been abandoned by his father, his parents were ashamed of having a "fairy" for a son, he was sent to military school - can you imagine how awful that must have been for him? Capote may have acted like a cream-puff but that man was cold and hard as steel inside. He had to be.
Capote needed quotes, he needed access, he needed to enter into the psychologies of these 2 men. He was able to paint the graphic picture of the Clutter family through interviews with people who knew and loved them. But the Clutters were no longer around to speak for themselves. Hickock and Smith were alive for a couple of years, so he visited them often. On his way out of Death Row, he would feel the urge to vomit. It would take him days to recover, emotionally, from these macabre "visits". And he said, later, that he never recovered from the "shattering" experience of watching the two men hang. The letters he wrote to friends afterwards are nearly incoherent. Watching how hard the hanging body clings to life, watching the kicking feet, the flailing, the letting-go of bodily functions ... Capote was really never the same man again.
And he then sat down and wrote the book like a bat out of hell.
Truman Capote always thought that he had a "great book" in him. This mythical "great book" haunted his dreams, he would lie awake at night aching with ambition, dreaming about this great book ... He didn't think In Cold Blood was his masterpiece. He looked back on the experience of researching that book and writing it as a grim one, an almost universally unpleasant and grueling experience. I've read all of Capote's books. I love that guy's writing style. I even read his unfinished work - the 2 chapters of the novel he was working on when he died. He claimed to have it almost finished, but the rest of it (if it even existed) was never found. The 2 chapters are okay - it's a gossipy bitchy look at high-class New York society. It's merciless. It's very funny. Nobody is spared. Human beings are seen in their worst lights. Everyone is selfish, cynical, out for themselves ... It is quite funny, but it's very very mean. He was nearing the end of his life, and he had been abandoned by most of his friends. His outlook was not good, he was addicted to drugs, filled with anxiety and loneliness ... The 2 chapter are his way of lashing out at all those people who left him, who tossed him out with the trash. Hence, the mean-ness.
The thing in the rest of Capote's writing that, for me, sets him apart is his undeniable love of humanity. His tenderness. His ability to SEE people, with all their flaws - and to see them as beautiful. Much of his best writing is all about nostalgia, wistfulness, yearning for childhood ... Yes, it is sentimental, but it also has a depth of sadness beneath it, a grief ... which elevates it from mawkishness.
In Cold Blood taps into something else. In Cold Blood doesn't fit into either of the Capote categories: the bitchy mean queen telling all the nasty secrets of his high-class friends, or the lonely sweet man filled with hurtful nostalgia for childhood.
It was something completely new. For him, and for us. I don't even know if I can describe it. All I can say is - he never accomplished such a thing again. His writing never seemed so effortless again. You read that book and you feel like if you cut ONE WORD, the entire thread will unravel. It is so tight.
The other thing I had forgotten from the biography is Capote's personal experience leaving his home-environment of ritzy New York City (where there were lots of "fairies"), and venturing into the Kansas prairies to investigate a murder. Capote was openly gay. He wasn't a macho gay, either. He didn't try to blend in, or act straight, or hide his gayness. He was a small rotund man, who wore wide white hats, spoke with a lisp, fluttered about like Blanche DuBois, and literally said things like, "I declare!"
He took one of his best friends, Harper Lee (yes - THAT Harper Lee) as a co-researcher. She was much more "normal"-acting, and was able to blend in a bit more. She could get people to talk to her, because she seemed like one of them.
But Truman Capote was so relentless, and not only so relentless, but so committed to justice, so committed to discovering what had happened in the Clutter household, that people started opening up. The people in the town started competing about who had had him over for dinner the most times. Alvin Dewey, the head of the investigation, a tough gruff 3 pack a day smoker, eventually counted Truman as a valued partner. Truman was there when Dewey got the call that the 2 murderers had been picked up in Las Vegas, AND that they were still wearing the boots with the distinctive soles (that had left footprints - If the 2 hadn't confessed, the boots alone would have convicted them). Truman was standing right there, with Dewey's wife, listening to Dewey hear the news.
The people of Kansas, who had never met a person like Capote in their lives, who were Bible-Belt ranchers and farmers, took him into their homes, their families, their hearts. Without them, the book would not have been written.
It is a massive accomplishment.
Truman Capote went to his grave thinking that his "great book" remained unwritten. I beg to differ.
... to F. Scott Fitzgerald!

Fitzgerald was one of those writers I liked right away, even though I read most of his stuff when I wasd 15, and was forced to for school. Melville I despised - and had to come back to later (years and years later) ... now I love Melville, but my first encounter with his books were ... pretty much horrific. But Fitzgerald I clicked into right away. I credit a lot of that to my 10th grade teacher, Mr. Crothers - who ... basically ... was just a great feckin' teacher. His love of The Great Gatsby permeated his lectures, and his enthusiasm inspired the class. I really "got" it. I remember the book as being much much longer - which is so funny. I recently re-read it, and was shocked at how short it really is.
I already had a fascination with flappers (ahem. Obviously.) Not sure where the fascination came from. I think it might have had something to do with seeing Bugsy Malone on TV when I was about 12. Member that movie? Jodie Foster and Scott Baio as little kid gangsters and gangster molls? Driving cars with their feet like the Flintstones? I absolutely loved that movie, and I loved Jodie Foster's spit curls, and her costumes ... I remember, too, in junior high I did a whole paper on the 1920s for history class. I remember including photographs of flappers, and photographs of the cars they had ... I would insert stuff like this through the text:

I knew all about prohibition, I knew the music ... Oh, and I just remembered a couple other reasons why the whole "jazz age" thing fascinated me long before I encountered Fitzgerald: one of my favorite books growing up was Cheaper by the Dozen, hahaha, just thinking about that book makes me laugh. My cousin Susan and I loved that book, and we read it together. We would play with our Fisher Price little people (or "peeps", in the O'Malley lexicon) and we would make them be the Gilbreth family. 12 little kids, and a mother and father. Most of the book was, of course, about the crazy time-saving schemes that Gilbreth would test out on his family (actually, not so crazy - Gilbreth and Henry Ford were real innovators in this area) - making the kids wash dishes, timing them, and then figuring out ways to cut off seconds from the process. The last couple of chapters in the book take place in the 20s, when the older kids are now teenagers, and the whole jazz age flapper scene was starting to kick in. The older girls would have to sneak out of the house to go meet their boyfriends, the father was losing his mind, and the whole thing just sounded so hilarious and exciting to me. Especially the whole fashion part of it ... the skirts getting shorter, the cars pulling up in front of the house with Ivy League guys driving, waiting for the girls ... I loved it.
And lastly - when I was about 11, I remember my parents taking me to see a production of The Boyfriend up at the local university and I was literally swept away by it. The costumes, the music, the craziness ... I loved the charleston. I loved the whole fantasy of that era.
So when Great Gatsby came along, I was ready to just LIVE in the pages of that book.
F. Scott Fitzgerald (or - Francis Scott Key Fitzgerald) was born in St. Paul Minnesota in 1896. He went to Princeton, and afterwards joined the army. Somewhere in here, he sold his first story ... and when he was only 23 years old he wrote and published his first novel: This Side of Paradise. It was a smash hit - and was one of those zeitgeist books: it described the moment in time that everyone was experiencing (or, a certain set of people, let's say that) ... It was one of those books that is eloquent about cultural and social changes AS they are happening. Fitzgerald was immediately seen as the voice of that era, and that generation. The jazz age kicking in. Fitzgerald was the poster child. It didn't hurt that he was so handsome.

People projected their own desires onto him, their ideals for who they wanted to be. He was glamorous, urbane, free of societal conventions ... He lived the life others wanted to live.
In 1922, he wrote in a letter to Maxwell Perkins at Scribners: "I want to write something new -- something extraordinary and simple & intricately patterned."
Such a young man. Such a broad and deep vision.
Around this time, he married Zelda Sayre.

She was the yin to his yang, she was the perfect partner in crime for that particular decade ... she did not give a damn. She was who they were talking about when they talked about "jazz babies". She was the original flapper.
Look at their wedding portrait. I just love it.

They had their wedding reception at Chumley's, a speakeasy at 86 Bedford Street, which is still there. I first met Bill McCabe and Emily Jones at Chumley's. Awesome!! It's the same now as it was then: no signage, nothing to say it's there. You have to know where it is. 86 Bedford, baby!
So Fitzgerald and Zelda married. They lived their relationship in public. They created personas, they acted parts, they showed up at places looking amazing, they relished in their own publicity. They kept massive scrapbooks of their clippings from the gossip pages. Again, they were partners in crime.
Here's a page from their scrapbook:

They were almost like the Billy Bob Thornton and Angelina Jolie of their day. Exhibitionists, putting their own craziness on display, loving and living to shock others, having massive crockery-throwing fights in public, also having massive clutching make-out sessions in public ... It all was about being famous. But underneath all of that, there was this kindred spirit thing happening. You can't be in love with someone who NEEDS to be famous and not have the same need yourself. Or, you can, but it'll go bust. The two of them were in sync in those first years - it was like they were the same person.
Neither of them was ever the one to say, "Okay. Time for bed now." They were a couple with no brakes.
They would have drinks at the Plaza Hotel, and she would dance on the table. She would leap into fountains, fully dressed. She bucked convention. Just for the hell of it. She was the life of the party (while it lasted). She was wild. Just wild. F. Scott Fitzgerald was inspired by her, she was definitely a muse of some kind ... he would read her diaries, he would hoard the letters she wrote to him, he was completely wrapped up in her glow. Zelda is a fascinating (and ultimately tragic) character in her own right. A girl who was completely unprepared to do anything useful in her life - pampered and indulged by her family who thought she was nuts, and also trouble, she basically set her sights on New York. She had the misfortune of marrying a man seen as the bright literary light of his generation - a misfortune because she had literary aspirations as well. Here is a small sketch she wrote about Montgomery Alabama, where she grew up. It is obvious she can write. Not like her husband, but she can definitely write.
There exists in Montgomery a time and quality that appertains to nowhere else. It began about half past six on an early summer night, with the flicker and sputter of the corner street lights going on, and it lasted until the great incandescent globes were black inside with moths and beetles and the children were called into bed from the dusty streets ... The drug stores are bright at night with the organdie balloons of girls' dresses under the big electric fans. Automobiles stand along the curbs in front of open frame houses at dusk, and sounds of supper being prepared drift through the soft splotches of darkness to the young world that moves every evening out of doors. Telephones ring, and the lacy blackness under the trees disgorges young girls in white and pink, leaping over the squares of warm light toward the tinkling sound with an expectancy that people have only in places where any event is a pleasant one. Nothing seems ever to happen.
There's a nice descriptive romantic quality there. She had talent. Only she had no discipline. None. F. Scott Fitzgerald, while an insane partier, a crazy drinker, a guy who stayed out all night every night, had great discipline. He worked at his craft. He worked hard at writing. He was always writing, and honing, and editing ... maybe he was hungover, but his writing was his JOB. Zelda had none of that. She couldn't focus her energies. She was threatened by his success. She wanted a piece of that pie for herself. But ... well, we all know what ended up happening to Zelda. She went mad. I don't know her diagnosis - but judging from some of her episodes, it had to be pretty bad. This was not a case of clinical depression. It was psychosis. While they lived in Paris, she got it into her head that she needed to be a ballerina. She began to study. She became obsessed. Soon, she was dancing for 6, 7, 8 hours a day. But she was in her early 30s by this point ... way too old to be a prima ballerina. But Zelda didn't care. Apparently, too, she was a terrible dancer. Friends who visited the couple in Paris told stories (in letters, and later, to biographers) of arriving for their visit, and Zelda would greet them at the door in a tutu and ballet shoes. She would dance for them. Awfully. These stories are excruciatingly painful to read.
Who knows where the madness came from, or if the wildness of her behavior in her youth (jumping in fountains, etc.) were early warning signs - things people ignored and forgave her for, because she was young and free. Who knows. It's a sad story. I read a biography of Zelda Fitzgerald last year and it wrenched my heart. It really did. She also had a deadly fear of fire, she was like a horse in that respect - it terrified her - and she died in a fire in her institution. She was on a locked ward, she couldn't get out, and the institution burned to the ground. It must have been shrieking agony. It must have been unspeakable.
But for about 5 or 6 years, the two of them were on top of the world. They had youth in their favor.

The Great Gatsby was published in 1925. Fitzgerald worked his ass off on this book - and was pretty tormented throughout the process. He wrote, and re-wrote, and re-wrote - holding off his editor, Maxwell Perkins, as long as possible. It was a precious book to him, a deeply personal book, and he feared he had not succeeded.
Perkins' long letter back to Fitzgerald, after he finally received the manuscript, just gives me chills. I won't print it in its entirety - it's too long - but it's an amazing insight into the book, and also ... into Fitzgerald the Writer. The guy had an innate gift, yes, but he also was this major craftsman. He worked hard.
Here are some excerpts from Perkins' initial letter:
I think you have every kind of right to be proud of this book. It is an extraordinary book, suggestive of all sorts of thoughts and moods. You adopted exactly the right method of telling it, that of employing a narrator who is more of a spectator than an actor: this puts the reader upon a point of observation on a higher level than that on which the characters stand and at a distance that gives perspective. In no other way could your irony have been so immensely effective, nor the reader have been enabled so strongly to feel at times the strangeness of human circumstance in a vast heedless universe. In the eyes of Dr. Eckleburg various readers will see different significances; but their presence gives a superb touch to the whole thing: great unblinking eyes, expressionless, looking down upon the human scene. It's magnificent!I could go on praising the book and speculating on its various elements, and meanings, but points of criticism are more important now. I think you are right in feeling a certain slight sagging in chapters six and seven, and I don't know how to suggest a remedy. I hardly doubt that you will find one and I am only writing to say that I think it does need something to hold up here to the pace set, and ensuing.
He then goes on to list a couple of pages of specific criticisms. Beautiful to read. It's really just amazing literary analysis is what it is.
One of the criticisms is this:
The other point is also about Gatsby: his career must remain mysterious, of course. But in the end you make it pretty clear that his wealth came through his connection with Wolfstein. You also suggest this much earlier. Now almost all readers numerically are going to be puzzled by his having all this wealth and are going to feel entitled to an explanation. To give a distinct and definite one would be, of course, utterly absurd. It did occur to me though, that you might here and there interpolate some phrases, and possibly incidents, little touches of various kinds, that would suggest that he was in some active way mysteriously engaged. You do have him called on the telephone, but couldn't he be seen once or twice consulting at his parties with people of some sort of mysterious significance, from the political, the gambling, the sporting world, or whatever it mayb be. I know I am floundering, but that fact may help you to see what I mean ... I wish you were here so I could talk about it to you for then I know I could at least make you understand what I mean. What Gatsby did ought never to be definitely imparted, even if it could be. Whether he was an innocent tool in the hands of somebody else, or to what degree he was this, ought not to be explained. But if some sort of business activity of his were simply adumbrated, it would lend further probability to that part of the story.
After a couple more paragraphs, Perkins writes:
The general brilliant quality of the book makes me ashamed to make even these criticisms. The amount of meaning you get into a sentence, the dimensions and intensity of the impression you make a paragraph carry, are most extraordinary. The manuscript is full of phrases which make a scene blaze with life. If one enjoyed a rapid railroad journey I would compare the number and vividness of pictures your living words suggest, to the living scenes disclosed in that way. It seems in reading a much shorter book than it is, but it carries the mind through a series of experiences that one would think woudl require a book of three times its length.The presentation of Tom, his place, Daisy and Jordan, and the unfolding of their characters is unequalled so far as I know. The description of the valley of ashes adjacent to the lovely country, the conversation and the action in Myrtle's apartment, the marvelous catalogue of those who come to Gatsby's house -- these are such things as make a man famous. And all these things, the whole pathetic episode, you have given a place in time and space, for with the help of T.J. Eckleburg and by an occasional glance at the sky, or the sea, or the city, you have imparted a sort of sense of eternity. You once told me you were not a natural writer -- my God! You have plainly mastered the craft, of course; but you needed far more than craftsmanship for this.
Now that's the kind of letter you want from your editor.
The Great Gatsby was not the phenom that This Side of Paradise was. Reviews were mixed. Only posterity would put Gatsby in the canon.
Zelda had her first breakdown in 1930. Fitzgerald's drinking problem went to another level. He was devastated by her illness, and he was devastated by what was obviously a slacking off in his success. It's tough when you become a mega-star at 23. Anything that follows is so sure to be a letdown. Fitzgerald needed to support himself, so he started cranking out short stories for the big mags at the time ... stuff that paid the bills but left him feeling empty.
F. Scott Fitzgerald died of a heart attack at 44, leaving an unfinished novel The Last Tycoon behind him.
Like I said, last year I re-read The Great Gatsby. It was like running into an old childhood friend. I'll re-post what I wrote about it back then, because it was fresh in my mind, and I was still on a high from the experience.
Happy birthday, Mr. Francis Scott Key Fitzgerald ... and thanks for your books.
Re-visiting The Great Gatsby
I just picked up The Great Gatsby again and read it in three days. (It felt much much longer in high school.) I was shocked and moved by how much I had remembered. The huge eyes of Doctor T.J. Eckleberg ... I remember the intense class discussion about what those eyes symbolize. The green light at the end of the dock, obviously. And there were parts that I actually remembered word for word, because of how, exactly, Mr. Crothers (my teacher) taught the book.
I remember the huge discussion about the following part of the book:
Suddenly she threw the cigarette and the burning match on the carpet."Oh, you want too much!" she cried to Gatsby. "I love you now -- isn't that enough? I can't help what's past." She began to sob helplessly. "I did love him once -- but I loved you too."
Gatsby's eyes opened and closed.
"You loved me too?" he repeated.
I remember Mr. Crothers pointing out that section to us, and talking about how that was the snap in Gatsby, that was the dream dying in Gatsby, that was the inner conflict of the entire book encapsulated in two sentences:
Gatsby's eyes opened and closed. "You loved me too?" he repeated.
Fitzgerald does not describe the snap. He does not have to. Fitzgerald does not talk about Gatsby's dream of Daisy, his fantasy of Daisy, at least not in that pivotal moment. All he does, all he does, is tell us that Gatsby's eyes opened and closed. And in that moment, a man's dream dies.
Phenomenal.
I would have missed that, in high school, if Mr. Crothers hadn't dwelt on it so specifically, and it all came back rushing back when I re-read it.
I might say that Mr. Crothers was the best teacher I have ever had. Period. He taught me how to write. Plain and simple. And you know how he taught me? I wrote a paper in his class. I got a D. My first D in my whole life. Panic ensued. Deep depression. Writer's block. I wrote another paper. I got a D+. Next paper: C-. Next paper: I got a straight C. It was a very proud moment. And with every paper, agonizingly, I got better and better and better. Until finally, light broke through, and I was able to construct a damn paper. I wrote consistently A-level papers in college directly because of what Mr. Crothers taught me.
This post is a ramble. Mr. Crothers, if he read this, would be thinking: "Sheila, where's the thesis statement??"
So here it is:
I had forgotten the stature of Fitzgerald's opus. I had forgotten how superb it was. Or: if I remembered it, it was in a taken-for-granted kind of way. Like: "Oh yeah, that's a great book. One of the best books of the 20th century. Whatever." I had forgotten the level of the accomplishment. I had forgotten how moving it is.
Reading it as an adult gave me a whole new perspective on it as well.
When I read it at age 15, I was completely on the side of Nick, the narrator: The relatively innocent and honest bystander, looking on at the decadence of Daisy and Jordan and Gatsby, trying not to judge (like he says on the first page of the book), and trying to come out of the situation unscathed. But by the end of the book, Nick is changed. And so are we, whether we like it or not.
But now, reading it as a grown woman, with a couple of failed love affairs in my rear view mirror, I found myself entering the story through the eyes of Gatsby. I could see myself in parts of him. It KILLED me. I understood Gatsby, suddenly. Carrying a torch for years, infusing everything with significance, poetry, choosing the dream-world over reality.
It is only NOW, after reading it from an adult perspective, that I can truly understand why the book is seen as such an epic human tragedy. An American tragedy.
Now I understand. Now I understand.
Those first pages are so extraordinary, so exquisitely written, they cannot be improved upon.
In my younger and more vulnerable years my father gave me some advice that I've been turning over in my mind ever since."Whenever you feel like criticizing any one," he told me, "just remember that all the people in this world haven't had the advantages that you've had."
He didn't say any more, but we've always been unusually communicative in a reserved way, and I understood that he meant a great deal more than that. In consequence, I'm inclined to reserve all judgments, a habit that has opened up many curious natures to me and also made me the victim of not a few veteran bores. The abnormal mind is quick to detect and attach itself to this quality when it appears in a normal person, and so it came about that in college I was unjustly accused of being a politician, because I was privy to the secret griefs of wild, unknown men. Most of the confidences were unsought -- frequently I have feigned sleep, preoccupation, or a hostile levity when I realized by some unmistakable sign that any intimate revelation was quivering on the horizon; for the intimate revelations of young men, or at least the terms in which they express them, are usually plagiaristic and marred by obvious suppressions. Reserving judgments is a matter of infinite hope. I am still a little afraid of missing something if I forget that, as my father snobbishly suggested, and I snobbishly repeat, a sense of the fundamental decencies is parcelled out unequally at birth.
And after boasting this way of my tolerance, I come to the admission that it has a limit. Conduct may be founded on the hard rock or the wet marshes, but after a certain point I don't care what it's founded on. When I came back from the East last autumn I felt that I wanted the world to be in uniform and at a sort of moral attention forever; I wanted no more riotous excursions with privileged glimpses into the human heart. Only Gatsby, the man who gives his name to this book, was exempt from my reaction -- Gatsby, who represented everything for which I have an unaffected scorn. If personality is an unbroken series of successful gestures, then there was something gorgeous about him, some heightened sensitivity to the promises of life, as if he were related to one of those intricate machines that register earthquakes ten thousand miles away. This responsiveness had nothing to do with that flabby impressionability which is dignified under the name of the "creative temperament" -- it was an extraordinary gift for hope, a romantic readiness such as I have never found in any other person and which it is not likely I shall ever find again. No -- Gatsby turned out all right at the end; it is what preyed on Gatsby, what foul dust floated in the wake of his dreams that temporarily closed out my interest in the abortive sorrows and short-winded elations of men.
HOLY GOD.
Reading that makes me want to put down my pen forever.
So does the last sentence of the book:
So we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past.
to one of my favorite authors - Stephen King!

Love that photo. His book On Writing is, hands down, the best book "on writing" I've read. And I've read a ton. Marvelous. I just admire him so much. His work ethic, his imagination, and also - his facility with language, which I think is highly under-rated. It's so typical - that genre writers are somehow seen as "lesser", or not serious literature. It's such a load of crap. Genre writers (good ones, anyway) are masters of their craft. They're amazing.
In my opinion, It/a> is a masterpiece. It's one of my favorite books of all time. And - I can't even say why. The last paragraph is one of those sweepingly sad paragraphs - it fills my heart with nostalgia, longing, sadness, yearning ... The plot of the book is a bunch of kids who have to confront a monster who lives in storm drains. That's the plot. But that's not what the book is about. It's about friendship, and love, and human connection in the face of catastrophe ... it's redemptive. It is an awesome awesome book.
My other favorite of his is The Stand.
Here's an anecdote:
When I moved to the apartment I live in now, I was moving from a 5th floor walkup. Ouch. I hired movers. These three guys were unbelievable. Just monsters. Hauling my bed, my dresser, my bookcases - down 5 flights of stairs. And then, of course, there were my boxes of books. I had, probably, 20 boxes. 20 boxes of books. The guys looked at the stack of books with palpable despair on their faces. Nothing heavier than a box of books. So off they went, my friendly He-man action figures, carrying boxes down stairs, climbing back up, another box down, climbing back up ... I was openly apologetic about my own obsessiveness. "I am so sorry about how many books I have ..." I said at one point, as this big bulky red-headed dude with tattooes, hauled another box of books up onto his shoulder. His reply was, with a little puff of breath beforehand, "There BETTER be some Stephen King books in here."
hahahahaha Like, if he was hauling poetry around, he would have been pissed. But Stephen King? That would be worth 20 trips up and down 5 flights.
Beautiful.
Other favorites? King fans out there?
Christopher Hitchens has a piece on Arthur Koestler in Slate. I highly recommend giving it a read.
I especially found this analysis of Darkness at Noon: A Novel very interesting:
From the first page of Darkness at Noon you become aware that the daily realization of impending execution is a powerful stimulus, both to reflection and to fatalism. Koestler's chief character, Nicholas Rubashov, is modeled on those former Bolshevik intellectuals who made full "confessions" of fantastic and abominable crimes at the Moscow show trials of the late 1930s. And, because Koestler had by no means forgotten what he had learned about the dialectic, he decided to place Rubashov in a dilemma from which he himself had escaped. What if the opponent of Stalin is still half-convinced that Stalin is morally wrong but may be "historically" right? He may decide to put his name on the confession and hope that history will one day vindicate him. His last duty to the Party may, in other words, be suicide.We now know that this is not how the confession of Nikolai Bukharin, for example, was in fact obtained. Stalin's men employed less subtle means of inducement and persuasion. But we do not know that this paradox was not alive in Bukharin's own mind, even at the end. If you once accept a certain logic of history, how can you exempt yourself from it? Apart from Dostoyevsky's Grand Inquisitor, there is no finer example in fiction of a pitiless interrogator facing a victim with the intention of saving his soul. Indeed, the teamwork of the two questioners, Ivanov and Gletkin, is so logically and artistically represented that it actually had the effect of converting some people to communism! Rubashov has one fatal weakness, which is that of the open-minded intellectual: "the familiar and fatal constraint to put himself in the position of his opponent, and to see the scene through the other's eyes." His dogmatist jailers suffer from no such disadvantage. This is a crux that has relevance well beyond the time and place in which it was set. Orwell's more widely read Nineteen Eighty Four, which has many points of similarity with Darkness at Noon, makes the same terrifying point that the fanatics don't just want you to obey them: They want you to agree with them.
Very interesting points there - ones that fascinate me as well. What was in Bukharin's mind? What was the level of awareness at these show trials? What was it actually like to be one of those guys? Insanity - down is up, up is down ... history will vindicate, sure ... but who?
I found the interrogation scenes in Darkness at Noon almost unreadably upsetting. It was impossible for me to not step into Rubashov's shoes ... and experience it with him. It's like one of those nightmares - where you know you are in mortal danger, and yet somehow you cannot run ... you are stuck to the ground ... you try to move your legs ... but you cannot. It's mostly the unFAIRness of that scenario (amplified 100,000 %) that makes people nuts. You should be able to defend yourself against an unfair attack, but in this scenario - it is impossible. The feeling that no matter what you say ... they are going to get you anyway. There is the feeling that ... even if you are, technically, innocent of the crimes they accuse you of, way deep within you you know that you have committed countless crimes on an ideological thought level.
Also, though, there is something deeper going on: by its very nature, the Communist Party implicated everyone. No one could say, with impunity, that they were "innocent". Even if you weren't guilty of what they accused you of, you definitely were guilty of something else. We're all in this together.
(If you're interested, I blithered my initial response to Darkness at Noon, which I read in one night, in one sitting, here.)
to Frank McCourt!

I read Angela's Ashes: A Memoir while I was in grad school, and I remember sitting in the hear-a-pin-drop quiet of the New School University library - reading it. I came to the section where young Malachy gets someone's dentures stuck in his mouth - the teeth jutting out of his face like some grotesque mask ... and somehow, the father scoops Malachy up and they run to the doctor's office, with young Frank trailing along behind. Frank, hurrying to catch up, can see Malachy's face, hanging backwards over the father's shoulder, and all he can see is the look of terror in Malachy's eyes, but also the strange-ness of the enormous teeth jutting out of Malachy's face.
I started laughing so loudly, and so uncontrollably, that eventually I had to stand up and leave the library. I tried to contain myself ... but finally ... it was too much. Tears of laughter streamed down my face, and I could tell that I was disturbing people. So I stood up, still GUFFAWING, and staggered out of the quiet library, so that I could howl with laughter in peace.
I've met Frank a couple of times - and also Malachy. They show up, randomly, at many Irish events here in the city - especially theatrical events. I remember being at some reception with Malachy McCourt, now an old jolly man, with jowls, etc., and I'm making small talk, but the entire time ... I could not get out of my head the vision of him as a small terrified boy, with dentures stuck in his face. Bobbing over his father's shoulder like an apparition of grotesque doom.
Actually, my favorite Frank McCourt story isn't even in Angela's Ashes - or the lesser sequel 'Tis. I read some interview with him where he talked about his years as a teacher of English at a rough school on Staten Island. You can imagine. He walked into the situation only to find complete and utter chaos. Tough kids, barely enough school supplies, discipline problems, yadda yadda. So McCourt looks at the curriculum and looks at the copies of books that the school actually has to hand out to the students. You know, they're supposed to read Middlemarch
and stuff like that. McCourt decided - George Eliot? Staten Island? This won't work. And decided instead to read Shakespeare's plays with the class. You can imagine the pissed-off goombah response from the students: "We don't know shit about him, Mr. McCourt ... we can't read this shit!" But McCourt persisted - and instead of just reading the plays - he would make copies of the scenes and have the students act them out. Which, of course, changed the entire thing. The students got SO into it. Some of them even memorized their lines. They knew what they were doing. They got into it. They could relate. They understood Romeo and Juliet most of all (of course. Most teenagers do.) "Yeah, man, poor Romeo ... he just wants to be wid his girl, y'know?" The kid assigned to play Mercutio apparently suddenly burst into brilliance - McCourt remembered his performance vividly and how much this tough kid from Staten Island clicked into that part (which is one of my favorite parts Shakespeare ever wrote, actually. I had a little crush on him as a teenager myself. Forget Romeo. Give me Mercutio!!)
So anyway. Cut to 10, 15 years later. The school is having a reunion. McCourt, who no longer teaches there, is invited. He goes. He enters the room where the reunion is taking place, and suddenly - all of his former students - who had been teenagers, and are now full grown adults - all come racing over to him, STILL spouting Shakespeare - running at him, saying the lines that they had memorized 10 years before, the words still imprinted in their minds.
And I remember what Frank said. He said, "Jesus! I thought to myself - this is the most important moment of my life!"
This story always makes me think of my sister Jean, who is a teacher. That's what teachers can do. Amazing. Life-changing.
Happy birthday, Frank!

Here's a page with his biography. Moby-Dick is one of my favorite books ever written, and I love to hear the story of its composition. The book is dedicated to Nathaniel Hawthorne, who pushed Melville to grow, move to another level. (Moby Dick, though, would not make its real mark until years after Melville's death.)
"Call me Ishmael," says the narrator in the beginning of Moby-Dick. We don't know is it his real name and exactly when his story is taking place. He signs abroad the whaler Pequod with his friend Queequeg, a harpooner from the South Sea Islands. Then the mood of the story changes. The reader is confronted by a plurality of linguistic discourses, philosophical speculations, and Shakespearean rhetoric and dramatic staging. Mysterious Captain Ahab, a combination of Macbeth, Job, and Milton's Satan, appears after several days at sea. Melville named the character after the Israelite king who worshiped the pagan sun god Baal. Ahab reveals to the crew that the purpose of the voyage is to hunt and kill the snow-white sperm whale, known as Moby-Dick, that had cost Ahab his leg on a previous voyage. The captain has his own faith and sees the cosmos in contention between two rival deities. "Oh! thou clear spirit of clear fire, whom on these seas I as Persian once did worship, till in the sacramental act so burned by thee, that to this hour I bear the scar; I know thee, thou clear spirit, and I now know that thy right worship is defiance." Ahab has nailed a goldpiece to the mast and offers it as a reward to the first man who sights the creature. Starbuck, the first mate, tries to dissuade Ahab from the quest. The novel culminates when Moby-Dick charges the boat which sinks. Ahab is drowned, tied by the harpoon line his archenemy. In his end Ahab takes his crew with him. The only survivor is the narrator, who is rescued by a passing ship.Moby-Dick was misunderstood by those who read and reviewed it and it sold only some 3,000 copies during Melville's lifetime. The book can be read as a thrilling sea story, an examination of the conflict between man and nature - the battle between Ahab and the whale is open to many interpretations. It is a pioneer novel but the prairie is now sea, or an allegory on the Gold Rush, but now the gold is a whale. Jorge Luis Borges has seen in the universe of Moby-Dick "a cosmos (a chaos) not only perceptibly malignant as the Gnostics had intuited, but also irrational, like the cosmos in the hexameters of Lucretius." (from The Total Library
, 1999) Clare Spark has connected in Hunting Captain Ahab: Psychological Warfare and the Melville Revival
(2001) different interpretations with changing political atmosphere - depending on the point of view Ahab has been seen as a Promethean hero or a forefather of the twentieth-century totalitarian dictators. The director John Huston questions in his film version (1956) which one, Ahab or the whale, is the real Monster.
I read Moby Dick in high school and despised it. I thought it was one of the most boring pointless things I had ever read. It was on our summer reading list, and I clearly remember FORCING myself to read the damn thing, during the dog days of August ... nearly crying from the psychological boredom. Whatever, man ... Moby Dick, Captain Ahab, endless discourses on blubber ... I was 16. I DIDN'T GET IT.
Cut to many many years later. 2001, to be exact. I read it in the spring of 2001. Around that time I decided to systematically go back and re-read all of the books I had been forced to read in high school (which, obviously, made me despise them at the time). I read The Scarlet Letter and Tess of the D'Urbervilles
and many others. Moby Dick is such a massive book, and I had hated it so much when I first read it that I hesitated to put myself through it again.
And honestly - the feckin' book blew the top of my head off.
I have rarely had such an exciting reading experience as that one. I didn't want it to end. I underlined passages feverishly. I put exclamations points in the margins next to particularly amazing sentences. Honestly. It blew me away.
Re-reading Scarlet Letter, et al, was also really fun - and yes, I renewed my appreciation for those old books, and realized: "Ohhh, okay, yup. THAT'S why the dern thing is a classic" ... but none of them flattened me as much as Moby Dick.
Holy mackerel. ahem.
The book, in high school, seemed so far from relevant ... to my life ... and also: there was nothing even remotely recognizable. At least in Scarlet Letter you deal with social issues and sexual issues - stuff I could latch onto as an adolescent ... but Moby Dick? I'm supposed to give a hoo-hah about the spout-hole and what it means and why it's important?
Also, except for the blowsy woman who serves Ishmael chowder in the 2nd or 3rd chapter, there are NO women in this book. NONE. Now: I wasn't a big girlie girlie book reader - Adventures of Huckleberry Finn was one of my favorite books growing up ... but there are at least SOME girls in that book. Women are not completely banished to the sidelines. Not at all. But Moby Dick? This is a universe not just of men - but a conscious rejection of the female. There is the memory of Captain Ahab's new bride at home, her head "denting the pillow", I believe is the phrase - but other than that - NO GIRLS. If you look at the book in another light (as Camille Paglia does so brilliantly and so bizarrely in her chapter on it in Sexual Personae
) - the whale could be seen as the "spirit" of female energy in the world. It is obvious that the great white whale is a male - but Paglia theorizes that something else might be going on there. Whaling boats were 100% male, they lived out on the ocean for 3 or 4 years at a time. There were no women. None.
Melville himself was a vicious misogynist. He tried to kill his wife. I believe she would flee from the house in the night, screaming, etc. It is well-known that he had many homosexual experiences during his time at sea. Many whalers did.
Paglia believes that Melville was writing out his anxiety and his anger towards women, in general. But not just 'women' as in 'a person who happens to be female' - but on a larger level: Woman as nature, woman as chaos, woman as the uncontrollable force running the universe.
Paglia feels that the entire book, with not one woman in it, is actually haunted by this spectre of female-ness.
Interesting. I'm not sure if she's right or not - but it is a very interesting theory - and I think there is definitely some truth to it (especially when you know some of the details of Melville's life.)
It's a big mess of a novel. We have 20 chapters which are basically marine biology. And yet ... the marine biology chapters always have a spiritual or metaphorical theme to them as well.
The point of view switches inexplicably. The first line of the book is "Call me Ishmael". This establishes that we have a first-person narrative. But that does not remain consistent. There are private moments of Captain Ahab and Starbuck described - moments when they are alone - moments Ishmael could never have witnessed. During the whale chapters - where we learn about blubber, and the spout, and their mating rituals, etc. - the voice changes from first-person to omniscent. With no warning. It doesn't seem to be Ishmael anymore. The "I" in the beginning of the book, Ishmael's "I", does not seem to be the same "I" who gives us marine biology lectures throughout the middle of the book. It is not the same voice at all.
But in the end, none of that matters.
It is an unconventional book, with its own narrative rules. Once you succumb, you will not have a better reading experience. The same could be said for Joyce's Ulysses. If you just trust the author, even though they seem to be off on their own personal jaunt, just writing to please themselves, they will take you places you could not even imagine.
The "interminable" chapters on whales, the chapters which I found so unbearable in high school, are what make the book (in my opinion) so stunning, so bizarre, and so - in the end - important. What is Melville's genius here is that - he starts out telling us, "Okay, so let's talk about the spout-hole ..." And he takes you through it, telling you how it works, what it is, how it evolved. But throughout this, somehow, he elevates each part of the whale into something almost allegorical. Blubber can actually teach us something about ourselves. We all can learn a lot about ourselves from studying the different parts of whales.
My favorite chapter, in these sections, is the one on the skin of the whale. It is called "The Blanket".
I read it, and it seems relatively informational, matter-of fact, and then by the end, Melville does a little jujitsu move in his prose - and I found myself in tears.
This happened to me time and time again when I re-read this great book. I would have a momentary thought, "Jesus, this chapter on the sperm in the sperm-whales is freakin' long, and i wish he would just get back to Queequeg, and the plot ... Dammit, this is so LONG..." And then suddenly, with a few simple phrases, Melville will draw back the veil, and show you the underbelly, give you the real GUTS of what he is saying.
Here's what I mean. This is an excerpt from the stunning chapter "The Blanket" - and look out for the jujitsu move at the end:
The BlanketI have given no small attention to that not unvexed subject, the skin of the whale. I have had controversies about it with experienced whalemen afloat, and learned naturalists ashore. My original opinion remains unchanged; but it is only an opinion.
The question is, what and where is the skin of the whale? Already you know what his blubber is. The blubber is something of the consistence of firm, close-grained beef, but tougher, more elastic and compact, and ranges from eight or ten to twelve and fifteen inches in thickness.
Now, however preposterous it may at first seem to talk of any creature's skin as being of that sort of consistence and thickness, yet in point of fact these are no arguments against such a presumption; because you cannot raise any other dense enveloping layer from the whale's body but that same blubber; and the outermost enveloping layer of any animal, if reasonably dense, what can that be but the skin? True, from the unmarred dead body of the whale, you may scrape off with your hand an infinitely thin, transparent substance, somewhat resembling the thinnest shreds of isinglass, only it is almost as flexible and soft as satin; that is, previous to being dried, when it not only contracts and thickens but becomes rather hard and brittle. I have several such dried bits, which I use for marks in my whale-books. It is transparent, as I said before; and being laid upon the printed page, I have sometimes pleased myself with fancying it exerted a magnifying influence. At any rate, it is pleasant to read about whales through their own spectacles, as you may say. But what I am driving at here is this. That same infinitely thin, isinglass substance, which, I admit, invests the entire body of the whale, is not so much to be regarded as the skin of the creature, as the skin of the skin, so to speak; for it were simply ridiculous to say, that the proper skin of the tremendous whale is thinner and more tender than the skin of a new-born child. But no more of this.
Assuming the blubber to be the skin of the whale; then, when this skin, as in the case of a very large Sperm Whale, will yield the bulk of one hundred barrels of oil; and, when it is considered that, in quantity, or rather weight, that oil, in its expressed state, is only three fourths, and not the entire substance of the coat; some idea may hence be had of the enormousness of that animated mass, a mere part of whose mere integument yields such a lake of liquid as that. Reckoning ten barrels to the ton, you have ten tons for the net weight of only three quarters of the stuff of the whale's skin...
A word or two more concerning this matter of the skin or blubber of the whale. It has already been said, that it is stript from him in long pieces, called blanket-pieces. Like most sea-terms, this one is very happy and significant. For the whale is indeed wrapt up in his blubber as in a real blanket or counterpane; or, still better, an Indian poncho slipt over his head, and skirting his extremity. It is by reason of this cosy blanketing of his body, that the whale is enabled to keep himself comfortable in all weathers, in all seas, times, and tides. What would become of a Greenland Whale, say, in those shuddering, icy seas of the North, if unsupplied with his cosy surtout? True, other fish are found exceedingly brisk in those Hyperborean waters; but these, be it observed, are your cold-blooded, lungless fish, whose very bellies are refrigerators; creatures, that warm themselves under the lee of an iceberg, as a traveller in winter would bask before an inn fire; whereas, like man, the whale has lungs and warm blood. Freeze his blood, and he dies.
How wonderful it is then - except after explanation - that this great monster, to whom corporeal warmth is as indispensable as it is to man; how wonderful that he should be found at home, immersed to his lips for life in those Arctic waters! where, when seamen fall overboard, they are sometimes found, months afterwards, perpendicularly frozen into the hearts of fields of ice, as a fly is found glued in amber. But more surprising is it to know, as has been proved by experiment, that the blood of a Polar whale is warmer than that of a Borneo negro in summer.
It does seem to me, that herein we see the rare virtue of a strong individual vitality, and the rare virtue of thick walls, and the rare virtue of interior spaciousness. Oh, man! admire and model thyself after the whale! Do thou, too, remain warm among ice. Do thou, too, live in this world without being of it. Be cool at the equator; keep thy blood fluid at the Pole. Like the great dome of St. Peters, and like the great whale, retain, O man! in all seasons a temperature of thine own.
Stunning.
And so: happy birthday to Mr. Melville.

Ernest Hemingway!
"I use the oldest words in the English language. People think I'm an ignorant bastard who doesn't know the ten-dollar words. I know the ten-dollar words. There are older and better words which if you arrange them in the proper combination you make it stick. Remember, anybody who pulls his erudition or education on you hasn't any."
One of my favorite stories about Hemingway is the challenge another writer gave him: Write a story in 6 words. Hemingway took on the challenge - he worked on that 6-word story, it obsessed him for a couple of days ... And what he came up with was this (it kills me):
For Sale: Baby Shoes. Never Used.
Hemingway said later that he thought it was the best thing he had ever written.
Phenomenal.
(I love DeAnna's comment here: Easy to read is hard to write.)
One of my favorite "profile" pieces done in The New Yorker was from 1950 - by Lillian Ross - on Ernest Hemingway. The piece is now considered notorious ... and it's obvious why. It's very very revealing. It opens with:
Ernest Hemingway, who may well be the greatest living American novelist and short-story writer, rarely comes to New York. He spends most of his time on a farm, the Finca Vigia, nine miles outside Havana, with his wife, a domestic staff of nine, fifty-two cats, sixteen dogs, a couple of hundred pigeons, and three cows. When he does come to new York, it is only because he has to pass through it on his way somewhere else. Not long ago, on his way to Europe, he stopped in New York for a few days. I had written to him asking if I might see him when he came to town, and he had sent me a typewritten letter saying that would be fine and suggesting that I meet his plane at the airport. "I don't want to see anybody I don't like, nor have publicity, nor be tied up all the time," he went on. "Want to go to the Bronx Zoo, Metropolitan Museum, Museum of Modern Art, ditto of Natural History, and see a fight. Want to see the good Breughel at the Met, the one, no two, fine Goyas and Mr. El Greco's Toledo. Don't want to go to Toots Shor's. Am going to try to get into town and out without having to shoot my mouth off. I want to give the joints a miss. Not seeing news people is not a pose. It is only to have time to see your friends." In pencil, he added, "Time is the least thing we have of."
Hemingway had this to say about having his books criticized:
"It is like being a third baseman and protesting because they hit line drives to you. Line drives are regrettable, but to be expected."
The following quote, to me, is classic Hemingway. I think I've posted it here before. Hemingway mentioned, to Ross, a war writer he once knew who set out to beat Tolstoy.
"He never hears a shot fired in anger, and he sets out to beat who? Tolstoy, an artillery officer who fought at Sevastopol, who knew his stuff, who was a hell of a man anywhere you put him -- bed, bar, in an empty room where he had to think. I started out very quiet and I beat Mr. Turgenev. Then I trained hard and I beat Mr. de Maupassant. I've fought two draws with Mr. Stendahl, and I think I had an edge in the last one. But nobody's going to get me in any ring with Tolstoy unless I'm crazy or I keep getting better."
Another snippet from the profile:
I wanted to know whether, in his opinion, the new book was different from his others, and he gave me another long, reproachful look. "What do you think?" he said after a moment. "You don't expect me to write 'The Farewell to Arms Boys in Addis Ababa,' do you? Or 'The Farewell to Arms Boys Take a Gunboat'?" The book is about the command level in the Second World War. "I am not interested in the G.I. who wasn't one," he said, suddenly angry again. "Or the injustices done to me, with a capital M. I am interested in the goddam sad science of war."
On his influences (and again: nobody talks like Hemingway, nobody):
"I only went to high school and a couple of military cram courses, and never took French. I began to learn to read French by reading the A.P. story in the French paper after reading the American A.P. story, and finally learned to read it by reading accounts of things I had seen -- les evenements sportifs -- and from that and les crimes it was only a jump to Dr. de Maupassant, who wrote about things I had seen or could understand. Dumas, Daudet, Stendahl, who when I read him I knew that was the way I wanted to be able to write. Mr. Flaubert, who always threw them perfectly straight, hard, high, and inside. Then Mr. Baudelaire, that I learned my knuckleball from, and Mr. Rimbaud, who never threw a fast ball in his life. Mr. Gide and Mr. Valery I couldn't learn from. I think Mr. Valery was too smart for me."
More:
"Only suckers worry about saving their souls. Who the hell should care about saving his soul when it is a man's duty to lose it intelligently, the way you would sell a position you were defending, if you could not hold it, as expensively as possible, trying to make it the most expensive position that was ever sold. It isn't hard to die."
Oh, and I LOVE this quote about birds in New York City:
"In this town, birds fly, but they're not serious about it."
hahahaha That's so true.
And here is Lillian Ross' description of walking through the Metropolitan Museum, with Hemingway, his son, and his wife, on a rainy day:
In the lobby, he paused, pulled a silver flask from one of his coat pockets, unscrewed its top, and took a long drink. Putting the flask back in his pocket, he asked Mrs. Hemingway whether she wanted to see the Goyas first or the Breughels. She said the Breughels."I learned to write by looking at paintings in the Luxembourg Museum in Paris," he said. "I never went past high school. When you've got a hungry gut and the museum is free, you go to the museum. Look," he said, stopping before "Portrait of a Man" which has been attributed to both Titian and Giorgione. "They were old Venice boys, too."
"Here's what I like, Papa," Patrick said, and Hemingway joined his son in front of "Portrait of Federigo Gonzaga (1500 - 1540)," by Francesco Francia. It shows, against a landscape, a small boy with long hair and a cloak.
"This is what we try to do when we write, Mousie," Hemingway said, pointing to the trees in the background. "We always have this in when we write."
Mrs. Hemingway called to us. She was looking at "Portrait of the Artist" by Van Dyck. Hemingway looked at it, nodded approval, and said, "In Spain, we had a fighter pilot named Whitey Dahl, so Whitey came to me one time and said, 'Mr. Hemingway, is Van Dyck a good painter?' I said, 'Yes, he is.' He said, 'Well, I'm glad, because I have one in my room and I like it very much, and I'm glad he's a good painter because I like him.' The next day, Whitey was shot down."
We all walked over to Rubens' "The Triumph of Christ over Sin and Death". Christ is shown surrounded by snakes and angels and is being watched by a figure in a cloud. Mrs. Hemingway and Patrick said they thought it didn't look like the usual Rubens.
"Yeah, he did that all right," Hemingway said authoritatively. "You can tell the real just as a bird dog can tell. Smell them. Or from having lived with very poor but very good painters."
That settled that, and we went on to the Breughel room. It was closed, we discovered. The door bore a sign that read, "NOW UNDERTAKING REPAIRS."
"They have our indulgence," Hemingway said, and took another drink from his flask. "I sure miss the good Breughel," he said as we moved along. "It's the great one, of the harvesters. It is a lot of people cutting grain, but he uses the grain geometrically, to make an emotion that is so strong for me that I can hardly take it." We came to El Greco's green "View of Toledo" and stood looking at it a long time. "This is the best picture in the Museum for me, and Christ knows there are some lovely ones," Hemingway said.
Patrick admired several paintings Hemingway didn't approve of. Every time this happened, Hemingway got into an involved, technical discussion with his son about it. Patrick would shake his head and laugh and say he respected Hemingway's opinions. He didn't argue much. "What the hell!" Hemingway said suddenly. "I don't want to be an art critic. I just want to look at pictures and be happy with them and learn from them. Now, this for me is a damn good picture." He stood back and peered at a Reynolds entitled "Colonel George Coussmaker," which shows the Colonel leaning against a tree and holding his horse's bridle. "Now, this Colonel is a son of a bitch who was willing to pay money to the best portrait painter of his day just to have himself painted," Hemingway said, and gave a short laugh. "Look at the man's arrogance and the strength in the neck of the horse and the way the man's legs hang. He's so arrogant he can afford to lean against a tree."
We separated for a while and looked at paintings individually, and then Hemingway called us over and pointed to a picture labelled, in large letters, "Catherine Lorillard Wolfe," and, in small ones, "By Cabanel". "This is where I got confused as a kid, in Chicago," he said. "My favorite painters for a long time were Bunte and Ryerson, two of the biggest and wealthiest families in Chicago. I always thought the names in big letters were the painters."
After we reached the Cezannes and Degases and the other Impressionists, Hemingway became more and more excited, and discoursed on what each artist could do and how and what he had learned from each. Patrick listened respectfully and didn't seem to want to talk about painting techniques any more. Hemingway spent several minutes looking at Cezanne's "Rocks -- Forest of Fontainebleau". "This is what we try to do in writing, this and this, and the woods, and the rocks we have to climb over," he said. "Cezanne is my painter, after the early painters. Wonder, wonder painter. Degas was another wonder painter. I've never seen a bad Degas. You know what he did with the bad Degases? He burned them."
Hemingway took another long drink from his flask. We came to Manet's pastel portrait of Mlle. Valtesse de la Bigne, a young woman with blond hair coiled on the top of her head. Hemingway was silent for a while, looking at it; finally he turned away. "Manet could show the bloom people have when they're still innocent and before they've been disillusioned."
As we walked along, Hemingway said to me, "I can make a landscape like Mr. Paul Cezanne. I learned how to make a landscape from Mr. Paul Cezanne by walking through the Luxembourg Museum a thousand times with an empty gut, and I am pretty sure that if Mr. Paul was around, he would like the way I make them and be happy that I learned it from him." He had learned a lot from Mr. Johann Sebastian Bach, too. "In the first paragraphs of 'Farewell,' I used the word 'and' consciously over and over the way Mr. Johann Sebastian Bach used a note in music when he was emitting counterpoint. I can almost write like Mr. Johann sometimes -- or anyway, so he would like it. All such people are easy to deal with, because we all know you have to learn."
"Papa, look at this," Patrick said. He was looking at "Meditation on the Passion", by Carpaccio. Patrick said it had a lot of strange animals in it for a religious painting.
"Huh!" Hemingway said. "Those painters always put the sacred scenes in the part of Italy they liked the best or where they came from or where their girls came from. They made their girls the Madonnas. This is supposed to be Palestine, and Palestine is a long way off, he figures. So he puts in a red parrot, and he puts in deer and a leopard. And then he thinks, This is the Far East and it's far away. So he puts in the Moors, the traditional enemy of the Venetians." He paused and looked to see what else the painter had put in his picture. "Then he gets hungry, so he puts in rabbits," he said. "Goddam, Mouse, we saw a lot of good pictures. Mouse, don't you think two hours is a long time looking at pictures?"
Everybody agreed that two hours was a long time looking at pictures, so Hemingway said that we would skip the Goyas and that we would all go to the Museum again when they returned from Europe.
It was still raining when we came out of the Museum. "Goddam, I hate to go out in the rain," Hemingway said. "Goddam, I hate to get wet."
I just eat that shite UP. Fascinating.
And we'll leave Mr. Hemingway now in peace ... but not without letting him have the last word. It's a bit of advice, and very good advice at that:
"Always do sober what you said you’d do drunk. That will teach you to keep your mouth shut."
Today is the birthday of Antoine de Saint-Exupery.

Saint-Ex had a brief intersection with the Lindberghs. Anne Lindbergh wrote the whole thing up feverishly in her journal. She spent 24 hours with the man, and she fell in love with him. It was an emotional thing, I think ... it's hard to tell ... there was no affair, nothing like that. But even though they could barely communicate, she felt seen by him in a way she had never felt before. She felt understood. (Being "understood" is probably the most common cause for infidelity - actual or emotional. It's not about the sex. Not really. How many people say, "She really listened to me ..." or "I felt like I could just talk to him ..." when they talk about cheating on their partner.) I'm not sure if Lindbergh realized how lonely his wife was at this point. Who knows. It's all speculation. Lindbergh and Saint-Ex could bond about mechanics and flying - but it was in the realm of art that Anne bonded with the Frenchman. He had written a foreward to one of her books, and it mortified her: how much he had picked up on, how much he had seen ... She hadn't realized how much her books about her trips with her husband revealed about her innermost soul. But Saint-Ex saw, and she loved him for that. She met him, briefly, and he disappeared shortly thereafter. It left her despondent. Her kindred spirit, her soulmate - even if she could never have him - was now gone forever.
Her journal entries about her time with Saint-Ex are FASCINATING and I will post them all here. (Well, actually, I already have - I will just link to the entries). But they're marvelous. They show marvelous insight into who Saint-Ex was, through the eyes of a woman who revered him, was a little in awe of him.
I have read all of his books on flying, and they are incredible. True high water marks in the genre of aviation writing.
But just for fun, I will post what is probably the most famous chapter of The Little Prince - the chapter where the prince meets the fox. I'll post it in English - but then I also MUST post it in French, because I first read it in French, and sorry - but the translation just is not as beautiful. It is meant to be heard in French, the language is more perfect - it is just as it should be.
Here is Chapter 21:
It was then that the fox appeared.
"Good morning," said the fox.
"Good morning," the little prince responded politely, although when he turned around he saw nothing.
"I am right here," the voice said, "under the apple tree."
"Who are you?" asked the little prince, and added, "You are very pretty to look at."
"I am a fox," said the fox.
"Come and play with me," proposed the little prince. "I am so unhappy."
"I cannot play with you," the fox said. "I am not tamed."
"Ah! Please excuse me," said the little prince.
But, after some thought, he added:
"What does that mean-- 'tame'?"
"You do not live here," said the fox. "What is it that you are looking for?"
"I am looking for men," said the little prince. "What does that mean-- 'tame'?"
"Men," said the fox. "They have guns, and they hunt. It is very disturbing. They also raise chickens. These are their only interests. Are you looking for chickens?"
"No," said the little prince. "I am looking for friends. What does that mean-- 'tame'?"
"It is an act too often neglected," said the fox. It means to establish ties."
"'To establish ties'?"
"Just that," said the fox. "To me, you are still nothing more than a little boy who is just like a hundred thousand other little boys. And I have no need of you. And you, on your part, have no need of me. To you, I am nothing more than a fox like a hundred thousand other foxes. But if you tame me, then we shall need each other. To me, you will be unique in all the world. To you, I shall be unique in all the world..."
"I am beginning to understand," said the little prince. "There is a flower... I think that she has tamed me..."
"It is possible," said the fox. "On the Earth one sees all sorts of things."
"Oh, but this is not on the Earth!" said the little prince.
The fox seemed perplexed, and very curious.
"On another planet?"
"Yes."
"Are there hunters on this planet?"
"No."
"Ah, that is interesting! Are there chickens?"
"No."
"Nothing is perfect," sighed the fox.
But he came back to his idea.
"My life is very monotonous," the fox said. "I hunt chickens; men hunt me. All the chickens are just alike, and all the men are just alike. And, in consequence, I am a little bored. But if you tame me, it will be as if the sun came to shine on my life . I shall know the sound of a step that will be different from all the others. Other steps send me hurrying back underneath the ground. Yours will call me, like music, out of my burrow. And then look: you see the grain-fields down yonder? I do not eat bread. Wheat is of no use to me. The wheat fields have nothing to say to me. And that is sad. But you have hair that is the colour of gold. Think how wonderful that will be when you have tamed me! The grain, which is also golden, will bring me back the thought of you. And I shall love to listen to the wind in the wheat..."
The fox gazed at the little prince, for a long time.
"Please-- tame me!" he said.
"I want to, very much," the little prince replied. "But I have not much time. I have friends to discover, and a great many things to understand."
"One only understands the things that one tames," said the fox. "Men have no more time to understand anything. They buy things all ready made at the shops. But there is no shop anywhere where one can buy friendship, and so men have no friends any more. If you want a friend, tame me..."
"What must I do, to tame you?" asked the little prince.
"You must be very patient," replied the fox. "First you will sit down at a little distance from me-- like that-- in the grass. I shall look at you out of the corner of my eye, and you will say nothing. Words are the source of misunderstandings. But you will sit a little closer to me, every day..."
The next day the little prince came back.
"It would have been better to come back at the same hour," said the fox. "If, for example, you come at four o'clock in the afternoon, then at three o'clock I shall begin to be happy. I shall feel happier and happier as the hour advances. At four o'clock, I shall already be worrying and jumping about. I shall show you how happy I am! But if you come at just any time, I shall never know at what hour my heart is to be ready to greet you... One must observe the proper rites..."
"What is a rite?" asked the little prince.
"Those also are actions too often neglected," said the fox. "They are what make one day different from other days, one hour from other hours. There is a rite, for example, among my hunters. Every Thursday they dance with the village girls. So Thursday is a wonderful day for me! I can take a walk as far as the vineyards. But if the hunters danced at just any time, every day would be like every other day, and I should never have any vacation at all."
So the little prince tamed the fox. And when the hour of his departure drew near--
"Ah," said the fox, "I shall cry."
"It is your own fault," said the little prince. "I never wished you any sort of harm; but you wanted me to tame you..."
"Yes, that is so," said the fox.
"But now you are going to cry!" said the little prince.
"Yes, that is so," said the fox.
"Then it has done you no good at all!"
"It has done me good," said the fox, "because of the color of the wheat fields." And then he added:
"Go and look again at the roses. You will understand now that yours is unique in all the world. Then come back to say goodbye to me, and I will make you a present of a secret."
The little prince went away, to look again at the roses.
"You are not at all like my rose," he said. "As yet you are nothing. No one has tamed you, and you have tamed no one. You are like my fox when I first knew him. He was only a fox like a hundred thousand other foxes. But I have made him my friend, and now he is unique in all the world."
And the roses were very much embarrassed.
"You are beautiful, but you are empty," he went on. "One could not die for you. To be sure, an ordinary passerby would think that my rose looked just like you-- the rose that belongs to me. But in herself alone she is more important than all the hundreds of you other roses: because it is she that I have watered; because it is she that I have put under the glass globe; because it is she that I have sheltered behind the screen; because it is for her that I have killed the caterpillars (except the two or three that we saved to become butterflies); because it is she that I have listened to, when she grumbled, or boasted, or even sometimes when she said nothing. Because she is my rose.
And he went back to meet the fox.
"Goodbye," he said.
"Goodbye," said the fox. "And now here is my secret, a very simple secret: It is only with the heart that one can see rightly; what is essential is invisible to the eye."
"What is essential is invisible to the eye," the little prince repeated, so that he would be sure to remember.
"It is the time you have wasted for your rose that makes your rose so important."
"It is the time I have wasted for my rose--" said the little prince, so that he would be sure to remember.
"Men have forgotten this truth," said the fox. "But you must not forget it. You become responsible, forever, for what you have tamed. You are responsible for your rose..."
"I am responsible for my rose," the little prince repeated, so that he would be sure to remember.

Note from me before we move on to the French: This section pretty much rocked my world when I read it in high school. It changed how I thought about a lot of things: about love, and friendship, and what it means to be loyal.
"It is only with the heart that one can see rightly; what is essential is invisible to the eye." Probably the most famous line from the book, and rightly so. But - to be a broken record - it sounds better in French.
Okay, so here comes the French!
Chapter XXI
C'est alors qu'apparut le renard.
-Bonjour, dit le renard.
-Bonjour, r�pondit poliment le petit prince, qui se tourna mais ne vit rien.
-Je suis l�, dit la voix, sous le pommier.
-Qui es-tu? dit le petit prince. Tu es bien joli�
-Je suis un renard, dit le renard.
-Viens jouer avec moi, lui proposa le petit prince. Je suis tellement triste�
-Je ne puis pas jouer avec toi, dit le renard. Je ne suis pas apprivois�
-Ah! Pardon, fit le petit prince.
Mais apr�s r�flexion, il ajouta :
-Qu'est-ce que signifie "apprivoiser"?
-Tu n'es pas d'ici, dit le renard, que cherches-tu?
-Je cherche les hommes, dit le petit prince.Qu'est-ce que signifie "apprivoiser"?
-Les hommes, dit le renard, ils ont des fusils et ils chassent. C'est bien g�nant! Il �l�vent aussi des poules. C'est leur seul int�r�t. Tu cherches des poules?
-Non, dit le petit prince. Je cherche des amis.Qu'est-ce que signifie "apprivoiser"?
-C'est une chose trop oubli�e, dit le renard. Ca signifie "Cr�er des liens�"
-Cr�er des liens?
-Bien s�r,dit le renard. Tu n'es encore pour moi qu'un petit gar�on tout semblable � cent mille petits gar�ons. Et je n'ai pas besoin de toi. Et tu n'a pas besoin de moi non plus. Je ne suis pour toi qu'un renard semblable � cent mille renards. Mais, si tu m'apprivoises, nous aurons besoin l'un de l'autre. Tu seras pour moi unique au monde. Je serai pour toi unique au monde�
-Je commence � comprendre, dit le petit prince. Il y a une fleur� je crois qu'elle m'a apprivois�
-C'est possible, dit le renard. On voit sur la Terre toutes sortes de choses�
-Oh! ce n'est pas sur la Terre, dit le petit prince. Le renard parut tr�s intrigu� :
-Sur une autre plan�te ?
-Oui.
-Il y a des chasseurs sur cette plan�te-l� ?
-Non.
-Ca, c'est int�ressant! Et des poules ?
-Non.
-Rien n'est parfait, soupira le renard.
Mais le renard revint � son id�e :
-Ma vie est monotone. Je chasse les poules, les hommes me chassent. Toutes les poules se ressemblent, et tous les hommes se ressemblent. Je m'ennuie donc un peu. Mais si tu m'apprivoises, ma vie sera comme ensoleill�e. Je conna�trai un bruit de pas qui sera diff�rent de tous les autres. Les autres pas me font rentrer sous terre. Le tien m'appelera hors du terrier, comme une musique. Et puis regarde! Tu vois, l�-bas, les champs de bl�? Je ne mange pas de pain. Le bl� pour moi est inutile. Les champs de bl� ne me rappellent rien. Et �a, c'est triste! Mais tu a des cheveux couleur d'or. Alors ce sera merveilleux quand tu m'aura apprivois�! Le bl�, qui est dor�, me fera souvenir de toi. Et j'aimerai le bruit du vent dans le bl�
Le renard se tut et regarda longtemps le petit prince :
-S'il te pla�t� apprivoise-moi! dit-il.
-Je veux bien, r�pondit le petit prince, mais je n'ai pas beaucoup de temps. J'ai des amis � d�couvrir et beaucoup de choses � conna�tre.
-On ne conna�t que les choses que l'on apprivoise, dit le renard. Les hommes n'ont plus le temps de rien conna�tre. Il ach�tent des choses toutes faites chez les marchands. Mais comme il n'existe point de marchands d'amis, les hommes n'ont plus d'amis. Si tu veux un ami, apprivoise-moi!
-Que faut-il faire? dit le petit prince.
-Il faut �tre tr�s patient, r�pondit le renard. Tu t'assoiras d'abord un peu loin de moi, comme �a, dans l'herbe. Je te regarderai du coin de l'oeil et tu ne diras rien. Le langage est source de malentendus. Mais, chaque jour, tu pourras t'asseoir un peu plus pr�s�
Le lendemain revint le petit prince.
-Il e�t mieux valu revenir � la m�me heure, dit le renard. Si tu viens, par exemple, � quatre heures de l'apr�s-midi, d�s trois heures je commencerai d'�tre heureux. Plus l'heure avancera, plus je me sentirai heureux. � quatre heures, d�j�, je m'agiterai et m'inqui�terai; je d�couvrira le prix du bonheur! Mais si tu viens n'importe quand, je ne saurai jamais � quelle heure m'habiller le coeur� il faut des rites.
-Qu'est-ce qu'un rite? dit le petit prince.
-C'est quelque chose trop oubli�, dit le renard. C'est ce qui fait qu'un jour est diff�rent des autres jours, une heure, des autres heures. Il y a un rite, par exemple, chez mes chasseurs. Ils dansent le jeudi avec les filles du village. Alors le jeudi est jour merveilleux! Je vais me promener jusqu'� la vigne. Si les chasseurs dansaient n'importe quand, les jours se ressembleraient tous, et je n'aurait point de vacances.
Ainsi le petit prince apprivoisa le renard. Et quand l'heure du d�part fut proche :
-Ah! dit le renard� je preurerai.
-C'est ta faute, dit le petit prince, je ne te souhaitais point de mal, mais tu as voulu que je t'apprivoise�
-Bien s�r, dit le renard.
-Mais tu vas pleurer! dit le petit prince.
-Bien s�r, dit le renard.
-Alors tu n'y gagnes rien!
-J'y gagne, dit le renard, � cause de la couleur du bl�.
Puis il ajouta :
-Va revoir les roses. Tu comprendras que la tienne est unique au monde. Tu reviendras me dire adieu, et je te ferai cadeau d'un secret.
Le petit prince s'en fut revoir les roses.
-Vous n'�tes pas du tout semblables � ma rose, vous n'�tes rien encore, leur dit-il. Personne ne vous a apprivois� et vous n'avez apprivois� personne. Vous �tes comme �tait mon renard. Ce n'�tait qu'un renard semblable � cent mille autres. Mais j'en ai fait mon ami, et il est maintenant unique au monde.
Et les roses �taient g�n�es.
-Vous �tes belles mais vous �tes vides, leur dit-il encore. On ne peut pas mourir pour vous. Bien s�r, ma rose � moi, un passant ordinaire croirait qu'elle vous ressemble. Mais � elle seule elle est plus importante que vous toutes, puisque c'est elle que j'ai arros�e. Puisque c'est elle que j'ai abrit�e par le paravent. Puisque c'est elle dont j'ai tu� les chenilles (sauf les deux ou trois pour les papillons). Puisque c'est elle que j'ai �cout�e se plaindre, ou se vanter, ou m�me quelquefois se taire. Puisque c'est ma rose.
Et il revint vers le renard :
-Adieu, dit-il�
-Adieu, dit le renard. Voici mon secret. Il est tr�s simple : on ne voit bien qu'avec le coeur. L'essentiel est invisible pour les yeux.
-L'essentiel est invisible pour les yeux, r�p�ta le petit prince, afin de se souvenir.
-C'est le temps que tu a perdu pour ta rose qui fait ta rose si importante.
-C'est le temps que j'ai perdu pour ma rose� fit le petit prince, afin de se souvenir.
-Les hommes on oubli� cette v�rit�, dit le renard. Mais tu ne dois pas l'oublier. Tu deviens responsable pour toujours de ce que tu as apprivois�. Tu es responsable de ta rose�
-Je suis responsable de ma rose� r�p�ta le petit prince, afin de se souvenir.
Voici mon secret. Il est tr�s simple : on ne voit bien qu'avec le coeur. L'essentiel est invisible pour les yeux.
I could say that all day. "L'essentiel est invisible pour les yeux" Beautiful.

Back when James Frey's first book came out, there was a fascinating interview with him in the NY Observer ... sadly, the link doesn't work anymore ... but it pissed me off so much that I wrote a rant about it on my old blog when I was much angrier with much more frequency. Posted below. Just want everyone to know I called it. Oprah may have been duped, but I wasn't.
Oh, and let me just say this before we begin: some of James Frey's annoyances with today's literary stars I share. Some of his frustration with the cleverness, and coyness is stuff I also share. I just don't think, as he obviously does, that HE is the solution.
March 2003
I don't think I've ever read an interview with a greater moron than this man. I do not even know where to begin.
Does James Frey (whose first book, A Million Little Pieces, will be published in April by Nan A. Talese/Doubleday) actually talk like this? Reading the interview in the New York Observer reminds me of the experiences I have had, usually at parties, where I meet someone, who is so intent on impressing me, and so intent on not seeming like he is trying to impress me, that the obviousness of the behavior is stunning. Vulnerability such as that is almost painful to witness. Like: "Ouch ... do you really want to show me that much at this early juncture in our non-existent relationship?" And the lack of self-awareness, the lack of realizing what exactly it is that he is doing, is astonishing. Cringe-worthy.
Is his book any good?
Let me pick out some quotes from the Observer profile:
"The Eggers book pissed me off. [A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius] Because a book that I thought was mediocre was being hailed as the best book written by the best writer of my generation. F*** that. And f*** him and f*** anybody that says that. I don't give a f*** what they think of me. I'm going to try to write the best book of my generation and I'm going to try to be the best writer. And maybe I'll fall flat on my f***ing face, I'll fall flat on my f***ing face trying to do it."
You might fall flat on your face, but at least you'll flat on your face while trying to fall flat on your face? Is your book as articulate as that?
The following quote shows Mr. Frey's humility:
"[This one agent] went ballistic over [my manuscript], called and said, 'We're going to turn you into an industry.' I said, 'What are you talking about?' 'You know who Deepak Chopra is?' I was like, 'Yeah.' 'You're going to be the Deepak Chopra of recovery. We're going to start a whole line of self-help books with your name on it. We're going to publish your own version of the Tao. We're going to send you out on speaking tours. We're going to build a religion around you.' I was like, 'You must be f***ing kidding me!' I very much admired the enthusiasm, but it was bizarre."
There's something off here. I don't trust this guy. He's got too much to prove. He exudes fragility ... there's something "off".
It gets more obnoxious as the piece goes on, if that is possible. H
"I guess I'm the poster boy for unconventional addiction thought. They were trying to lead me into saying certain things. They kept trying to get me to swear. Stossel was like, 'I heard you swear a lot. I heard you're feisty. Why won't you swear for me?' Because my mom and my wife asked me not to. 'Well forget about them, I need you to swear!' So I was like, 'O.K., f*** you!' I'm terrified of what they're going to do to me now. They're going to cut me up."
Dude, do you hear yourself? Your years of therapy and 12-stepping have not helped you see what you actually are doing. You are NOT terrified of what "they" are going to do to you now. You love it. You love being notorious, you love all the attention, you love being criticized, you love being the wild-card of the literature world ... So just admit it! I find him to be extremely disingenuous. I realize I have never been in his presence, so I can't say for sure, but what the hell. It's my blog and I'll judge if I want to.
The tone continues:
"My wife calls me a savage. Because I eat with my hands. Because my best friends are my dogs. And I like pit bulls. And N.W.A. And I love boxing. I think boxing is beautiful. The purity of fighting is a beautiful thing. Writers aren't like that anymore.all these guys who have f***ing masters' degrees and are so 'sophisticated' and 'educated' and ... well, I'm not a guy with a master's degree. I think I'm sophisticated. I can write big fat books. But I'm not an effete little guy."
What a complete and utter jackass. I like NWA. I don't have a chip on my shoulder about it, though. There's something adolescent here, about how he lists what a pig he is ... it's like a teenage boy choosing to wear smelly socks ... but he's only doing it to thumb his nose at his mother. Like, you might THINK you're being rebellious - but a TRUE rebel isn't always glancing around at authority figures to see how "outraged" everyone is. A true rebel just does his thing and doesn't care. James Frey cares. Oh my God, he cares. I don't believe a word he's saying.
While he was in L.A., Mr. Frey acquired a number of tattoos, his own personal footnotes. "I've seen you glance at this one," he said, displaying a row of letters on the inside of his left wrist: S.P.C.D.H.C. "Simplicity, Patience, Compassion, Discipline, Honesty, Courage," he said. "Words to live by. When I see that, it reminds me that these things embody the person I want to be."He pulled back his shirt to reveal others. "That's a symbol of birth and rebirth," he said, pointing to a small phoenix. "That is a Taoist symbol of life. I have my wife's initials on my chest. I very deliberately scar myself so that I remember these things. However twisted my logic may be, by scarring myself, I'm making a commitment to myself. I'm committed to the things on my wrist."
WHAT? What the hell are you talking about? "I very deliberately scar myself so that I remember these things." (As opposed to "sort of deliberately scarring yourself"?) "By scarring myself, I'm making a commitment to myself. I'm committed to the things on my wrist."
Euuuuuuuuuuuuuuu! I guess my feeling is: you can FEEL things like that, but don't SAY IT OUT LOUD. You just sound ridiculous. I have a tattoo, bro. Lots of people do for lots of reasons. You are not inventing the wheel. People who think they are inventing the wheel by, rebelling, having sex, getting drunk - whatever - are immature. Besides. Lots of people have tattooes. Nobody, and I mean NOBODY, is thinking, "Oooooohhhhhh that James Frey ..... he's such a BADASS ... he likes NWA and he has tattooes!" And the fact that I sense he NEEDS that response from me makes me go even colder.
He's not being real. If this was really who he was, fine - go for it. But it's affected.
Then he trashes the literary stars of the day (Dave Eggers and David Foster Wallace), always a good ploy right before your first book comes out:
"I think they're full of bells and whistles and tricks and being cute and being ironic and being all this shit. To be honest, I don't understand it. It's not how I think or how I feel...Eggers and I are exactly the same age. If there's a guy out there who is 'The Guy' of my generation, it's Eggers. In that sense, I was honored by the comparison."
Ah, now that sounds a bit like truth. You bitch and moan about Eggers, which seems transparently envious to me, yet you should be "honored by the comparison". Phony. Nothing worse than a big fat phony.
Give me a raging asshole any day of the goddamn week, but spare me from the phonies.
"All that matters is what the feelings are and what the events are. It's not about all this trickery. When I think about writing, I have a very simple formula: Where was I? Who was I with? What happened? And how did it make me feel? Those are the only important things. It doesn't matter if I can write a sentence that's a page long or if I have 30 pages of footnotes in the back or people chuckle at the introduction page. I want to move people and have them understand what I felt, what I went through and what I felt other people were feeling and going through."
And ... let me get this straight ... you are the first person to write in this manner? You are the first writer to ever "want to move people and have them understand"? No other writer has ever done this before? Ever? You sure?
Lastly:
"I don't give a f*** what Jonathan Safran whatever-his-name does or what David Foster Wallace does. I don't give a f*** what any of these people do. I don't hang out with them, I'm not friends with them, I'm not part of the literati. I think of myself as outside of this publishing culture. Kirkus called me pretentious. Am I pretentious in my self-regard because I'm serious about what I do? Because I'm moving against the trend of irony? I don't know. I hope I'm a bullet in the heart of that bullshit."
Frey, you are not a bullet through the heart of anything. You are a tiresome bore.

William Butler Yeats.
The O'Malley children were made to memorize Yeats' epitaph as part of our weekly allowance ritual. Say Yeat's epitaph, get a dime!! Such were the rules in our house. Nothing, and I say NOTHING, could obliterate that epitaph from my memory:
Cast a cold eye
On life on Death
Horseman pass by
Uhm ... where's my dime, Dad?
Here's a biography of Yeats, Nobel prize winner in 1923.
So much to say, so little time. Yeats, as a poet, has always been one of my favorites, but what truly inspires me is his work in Irish theatre, and the creation of the Abbey. An amazing story. His Nobel lecture was on the Irish Dramatic Movement. I wrote a big long post about his nurturing of John Synge, author of The Playboy of the Western World. Synge, as a young man, was a floundering artist bohemian type - until Yeats got a hold of him, and told him to go stay on the Aran Islands for a while, to discover the real Irish people. The result? A revolution in Irish theatre.
Yeats' poem "The Second Coming" has always frightened and enthralled me. It's like a nightmare. A quiet stealthy nightmare. Or a dark ominous crystal ball that shows awful things approaching and yet you still can't look away.
"The Second Coming"
TURNING and turning in the widening gyre
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.
Surely some revelation is at hand;
Surely the Second Coming is at hand.
The Second Coming! Hardly are those words out
When a vast image out of Spiritus Mundi
Troubles my sight: somewhere in sands of the desert
A shape with lion body and the head of a man,
A gaze blank and pitiless as the sun,
Is moving its slow thighs, while all about it
Reel shadows of the indignant desert birds.
The darkness drops again; but now I know
That twenty centuries of stony sleep
Were vexed to nightmare by a rocking cradle,
And what rough beast, its hour come round at last,
Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?
And here ... now ... a plethora of Yeats quotes. I end with one of my favorites.
"I hate journalists. There is nothing in them but tittering jeering emptiness. They have all made what Dante calls the Great Refusal. The shallowest people on the ridge of the earth."
"Irish poets, learn your trade, sing whatever is well made, scorn the sort now growing up all out of shape from toe to top."
"The worst thing about some men is that when they are not drunk they are sober."
"Words are always getting conventionalized to some secondary meaning. It is one of the works of poetry to take the truants in custody and bring them back to their right senses."
"Do not wait to strike till the iron is hot; but make it hot by striking."
"And say my glory was I had such friends."
Yes. That last one really moves me. I feel the same way about my life, and my friends.
Never give all the heart
Never give all the heart, for love
Will hardly seem worth thinking of
To passionate women if it seem
Certain, and they never dream
That it fades out from kiss to kiss;
For everything that's lovely is
But a brief, dreamy. Kind delight.
O never give the heart outright,
For they, for all smooth lips can say,
Have given their hearts up to the play.
And who could play it well enough
If deaf and dumb and blind with love?
He that made this knows all the cost,
For he gave all his heart and lost.
I also love love LOVE his poem to Jonathan Swift where he writes: "Imitate him if you dare." Totally. A warning to those who think it might be easy.
Swift's Epitaph
SWIFT has sailed into his rest;
Savage indignation there
Cannot lacerate his breast.
Imitate him if you dare,
World-besotted traveller; he
Served human liberty.
And lastly, a poem that has great personal meaning for me:
The wild swans at Coole
THE trees are in their autumn beauty,
The woodland paths are dry,
Under the October twilight the water
Mirrors a still sky;
Upon the brimming water among the stones
Are nine-and-fifty Swans.
The nineteenth autumn has come upon me
Since I first made my count;
I saw, before I had well finished,
All suddenly mount
And scatter wheeling in great broken rings
Upon their clamorous wings.
I have looked upon those brilliant creatures,
And now my heart is sore.
All's changed since I, hearing at twilight,
The first time on this shore,
The bell-beat of their wings above my head,
Trod with a lighter tread.
Unwearied still, lover by lover,
They paddle in the cold
Companionable streams or climb the air;
Their hearts have not grown old;
Passion or conquest, wander where they will,
Attend upon them still.
But now they drift on the still water,
Mysterious, beautiful;
Among what rushes will they build,
By what lake's edge or pool
Delight men's eyes when I awake some day
To find they have flown away?
Happy birthday to the incomparable William Butler Yeats. Imitate him if you dare.
A great thread over at I Love Books, discussing the works of JD Salinger. There's no agreement there ... which is one of the reasons why I think Salinger is a great writer. Nobody can agree. It's not a done deal. The mystery remains, and people still need to discuss his work: is it relevant outside of adolescence, what was up with his other work, etc.
I'm an unabashed Salinger fan - and it seems, judging from that thread - that I might be the only person who actually really dug Seymour: An Introduction. Actually, no, I know that's not true: My friends David and Mitchell also rave like lunatics about Seymour. Seymour is all about the parentheticals. Every thought (even the ones you are most certain of, even the ones which seem beyond argument to you - in your own certainty) can be interrupted (or maybe that's not the right word, maybe "enhanced" or "deepened" or "illuminated" is more accurate) by long parentheticals (because if we're honest with ourselves, then it is apparent that CERTAINTY is a big fat feckin' lie - and anyone who can make any statement with any amount of certainty, and with no need for a long parenthetical explaining oneself, or softening the black-and-white nature of the certainty - is a liar). I found the parenthetical nature of Seymour not only hypnotic but also tragic. You can feel JD Salinger losing his feeling of ownership over language. He can no longer make a sentence with any sense of "I am allowed to do this." Everything (and I mean, everything) must be interrupted (but again, maybe "enhanced" is a better word ) by a parenthetical. For someone looking for a straight narrative, Seymour would drive you nuts. I didn't go into Seymour looking for narrative. I went in because I love Salinger, and I'll go wherever he wants to go. But as I read it (and this might be romanticism - because, after all, I do not know JD Salinger) - I feel this overwhelming sadness. Emanating off the page. The torment of the writer.
But hell, I think all his stuff is great. I love the nine stories (especially "Uncle Wiggly in Connecticut"), and "Franny and Zooey" is one of my favorite books ever.
In that thread over on I Love Books, someone left the following quote from Faulkner, which moved me greatly:
"I have not read all the work of this present generation of writing; I have not had time yet. So I must speak only of the ones I do know. I am thinking now of what I rate the best one: Salinger's Catcher in the Rye, perhaps because this one expresses so completely what I have tried to say: a youth, father to what will, must someday be a man, more intelligent than some and more sensitive than most, who (he would not even have called it by instinct because he did not know he possessed it) because God perhaps had put it there, loved man and wished to be a part of mankind, humanity, who tried to join the human race and failed. To me, his tragedy was not that he was, as he perhaps thought, not tough enough or brave enough or deserving enough to be accepted into humanity. His tragedy was that when he attempted to enter the human race, there was no human race there." - William Faulkner, 1958
Author of my favorite book of all time Catch 22.
Heller wrote: "Everyone in my book accuses everyone else of being crazy. Frankly, I think the whole society is nuts, and the question is: What does a sane man do in an insane society?"
From Catch-22:
There was only one catch, and that was Catch-22, which specified that a concern for one's safety in the face of dangers that were real and immediate was the process of a rational mind. Orr was crazy and could be grounded. All he had to do was ask; and as soon as he did, he would no longer be crazy and he would have to fly more missions. Orr would be crazy to fly more missions and sane if he didn't, but if he was sane he had to fly them. If he flew them he was crazy and didn't have to, but if he didn't want to, he was sane and had to. Yossarian was moved very deeply by the absolute simplicity of this clause of Catch-22 and let out a respectful whistle."That's some catch, that Catch-22," he observed.
"It's the best there is," Doc Daneeka agreed.
The Catch-22, acknowledged right up front as an unspoken rule of the universe, is directly responsible for the black is white and white is black insanity of the book. (Here's an explanation of the rules of Catch 22.) The book is so much fun to read, because literally: almost every sentence contradicts the one that came before it - BUT it does so in a way that SOUNDS LIKE it's in agreement. Hard to describe, but so so funny when you get into the rhythm. Catch-22 rules the world.
Yossarian strode away, cursing Catch-22 vehemently even though he knew there was no such thing. Catch-22 did not exist, he was positive of that, but it made no difference. What did matter was that everyone thought it existed, and that was much worse, for there was no object or text to ridicule or refute, to accuse, criticize, attack, amend, hate, revile, spit at, rip to shreds, trample upon, or burn up.
Here's some nice biographical information about Heller. Heller fans will know that the "catch-22" dilemma of the book was originally a "catch 18". He completed the book, and sent it to his publishers as Catch-18. One problem though: Leon Uris had just scored a huge hit with his book Mila 18, and Heller's publisher didn't want there to be any confusion. So they made him change it. Which ... God, it just goes so perfectly with the random no-cause-no-effect universe Heller describes in his book. Like: He had created this "rule", and it was called, in his mind "catch-18". I mean, that's the title of the damn book, so you know how Heller must have felt about it, the importance he gave it. He was BUMMED that he was forced to change it, and to him - it would always be "catch-18". Of course. It would be like changing a character's name. Yossarian is Yossarian. Captain Ahab is Captain Ahab. jane Eyre is Jane Eyre. I don't care if they're fictional characters. They are real people to the authors who create them - and what they CALL their characters is of the utmost importance. So imagine how Heller must have felt ... He never really reconciled himself to Catch-22 - which, again, is so amusing - because look at what he has wrought. He has actually created a phrase that now exists in our language. It did not exist before he created it. How many feckin' authors do that nowadays? I'll tell you how many. NONE. You say, "Man, I'm in trouble. It's like a total catch-22" and everybody knows what you are talking about. "Catch22" entered the language almost immediately. Again; extraordinary.
But forever in Heller's mind, it should have been a catch-18.
Damn Leon Uris.
Catch 22 is my dad's favorite book. Actually, it's a favorite of most of the O'Malley men. I came to it late, despite the family pressure, and the constant exhortations: "YOU HAVEN'T READ CATCH-22?????????" I started to read it in August of 2001. I only remember that, because I was reading it on the bus the morning of September 11, before we knew what had really happened. Oddly enough, the rest of the country was far more aware of what was happening than those of us who were here. We were eyewitnesses, which is much more confusing. I couldn't pick up Catch-22 again for months. First of all, I wasn't ready for fiction, escape, pleasure, amusement for a long long time. Second of all, every time I looked at the book, I remembered the morning of September 11. When I finally picked up the book again, I was amazed to read the paragraph where I had left off. It was one of those weird cosmic-tumbler clicking moments. The book was telling me what was coming. Here's the essay I wrote about that morning, and about that paragraph from Catch-22.
As far as I am concerned, Joseph Heller is untouchable, in terms of what he created in that book. There is no other book quite like it.
It is LAUGH OUT LOUD funny. I mean, please. Major Major Major Major. The chaplain. Dunbar. (I have a huge crush on Dunbar). Nately's whore chasing him through Europe with a knife, popping out from bushes, from behind buildings. Colonel Cathcart. Even just the names make me laugh out loud. Please: Major Major Major Major? That is SOMEONE'S NAME. And I think my favorite is the bitter Indian named Chief White Halfoat. hahahaha So ridiculous. He's a pissed-off murderous Indian, and everyone is rightly afraid of him.
Genius.
I'll post some of my favorite snippets below.
Happy birthday, Mr. Heller, and thanks for the catch-22(18).
Bits and pieces from Catch 22 - watch for all the reversals and internal contradictions - They appear in pretty much every sentence:
"The Texan turned out to be good-natured, generous and likable. In three days no one could stand him."
And
"Yossarian was sorry to hear they had a mutual friend. It seemed there was a basis to their conversation after all."
And
"I'm dead serious about those other wards,' Yossarian continued grimly. 'MPs won't protect you, because they're craziest of all. I'd go with you myself but I'm scared stiff. Insanity is contagious. Everybody is crazy but us. This is probably the only sane ward in the whole world, for that matter.The chaplain rose quickly and edged away from Yossarian's bed, and then nodded with a conciliating smile and promised to conduct himself with appropriate caution. 'And now I must visit with Lieutenant Dunbar," he said. Still he lingered, remorsefully. 'How is Lieurtenant Dunbar?" he asked at last.
'As good as they go,' Yossarian assured him. 'A true prince. One of the finest, least dedicated men in the whole world."
And
But Yossarian couldn't be happy, even though the Texan didn't want him to be, because outside the hospital there was still nothing funny going on. The only thing going on was a war, and no one seemed to notice but Yossarian and Dunbar. And when Yossarian tried to remind people, they drew away from him and thought he was crazy. Even Clevinger, who should have known better but didn't, had told him he was crazy the last time they had seen each other, which was just before Yossarian had fled into the hospital.Clevinger had stared at him with apoplectic rage and indignation and, clawing the table with both hands, had shouted, "You're crazy!"
"Clevinger, what do you want from people?" Dunbar had replied wearily above the noises of the officers' club.
"I'm not joking," Clevinger persisted.
"They're trying to kill me," Yossarian told him calmly.
"No one's trying to kill you," Clevinger cried.
"Then why are they shooting at me?" Yossarian asked.
"They're shooting at everyone," Clevinger answered. "They're trying to kill everyone."
"And what difference does that make?"
Clevinger was already on the way, half out of his chair with emotion, his eyes moist and his lips quivering and pale. As always occurred when he quarreled over principles in which he believed passionately, he would end up gasping furiously for air and blinking back bitter tears of conviction. There were many principles in which Clevinger believed passionately. He was crazy.
"Who's they?" he wanted to know. "Who, specifically, do you think is trying to murder you?"
"Every one of them," Yossarian told him.
"Every one of whom?"
"Every one of whom do you think?"
"I haven't any idea."
"Then how do you know they aren't?"
"Because ..." Clevinger sputtered, and turned speechless with frustration.
Clevinger really thought he was right, but Yossarian had proof, because strangers he didn't know shot at him with cannons every time he flew up into the air to drop bombs on them, and it wasn't funny at all. And if that wasn't funny, there were lots of things that weren't even funnier.
heh. heh.
General Peckem was a general with whom neatness definitely counted. He was a spry, suave and very precise general who knew the circumference of the equator and always wrote "enhanced" when he meant "increased." He was a prick.
HAHAHAHA
Colonel Cargill thanked him crisply and glowed with self-satisfaction as he strode across the area. It made him proud to observe that twenty-nine months in the service had not blunted his genius for ineptitude.
And:
Colonel Korn's rule was a stroke of genius, Colonel Korn explained in his report to Colonel Cathcart. Under Colonel Korn's rule, the only people permitted to ask questions were those who never did. Soon the only people attending were those who never asked questions, and the sessions were discontinued altogether, since Clevinger, the corporal and Colonel Korn agreed that it was neither possible nor necessary to educate people who never questioned anything.
The book moves so quickly - it never dwells on itself, which is part of its charm. But dammit, he makes his points. The paragraph above is indicative of that. Every other paragraph has some deep insight about insanity, incompetence, war, stupidity ... but they flash by so fast you don't feel bludgeoned. If you get it, you get it, if you don't ... too bad, we're moving on!!
More:
Yossarian was willing to give Orr the benefit of the doubt because Orr was from the wilderness outside New York City and knew so much more about wildlife than Yossarian did, and because Orr, unlike Yossarian's mother, father, sister, brother, aunt, uncle, in-law, teacher, spiritual leader, legislator, neighbor and newspaper, had never lied to him about anything crucial before.
The character descriptions are priceless.
Women killed Hungry Joe. His reponse to them as sexual beings was one of frenzied worship and idolatry. They were lovely, satisfying, maddening manifestations of the miraculous, instruments of pleasure too powerful to be measured, too keen to be endured, and too exquisite to be intended for exployment by base, unworthy man. He could interpret their naked presence in his hands only as a cosmic oversight destined to be rectified speedily, and he was driven always to make what carnal use of them he could in the fleeting moment or two he felt he had before Someone caught wise and whisked them away. He could never decide whether to furgle them or photograph them, for he had found it impossible to do both simultaneously. In face, he was finding it almost impossible to do either, so scrambled were his powers of performance by the compulsive need for haste that invariably possessed him. The pictures never came out, and Hungry Joe never got in.
That's funnier and funnier every time I read it. Hungry Joe's journey to catch a naked girl with his camera is one of the on-going sub-plots of the book. It's absurd.
More:
Kraft was a skinny, harmless kid from Pennsylvania who wanted only to be liked, and was destined to be disappointed in even so humble and degrading an ambition.
Ouch!!!!
Here's the part about Chief White Halfoat that really got to me. The whole book is just slapstick really. Ba-dum-ching jokes, one after the other, with sudden bursts of insight. Like I said, there is no other book like it. The humor is, in general, very juvenile and tricky - but dammit, it WORKS. Consider the following example:
Captain Flume lived in mortal fear of Chief White Halfoat. Captain Flume was obsessed with the idea that Chief White Halfoat would tiptoe up to his cot one night when he was sound asleep and slit his throat open for him from ear to ear. Captain Flume had obtained this idea from Chief White Halfoat himself, who did tiptoe up to his cot one night as he was dozing off, to hiss portentously that one night when he, Captain Flume, was sound asleep he, Chief White Halfoat, was going to slit his throat open for him from ear to ear.
I can't explain why the above paragraph is so funny, it just is. And as a coda to this whole Captain Flume/Chief White Halfoat relationship, Heller ends this section with the following:
Captain Flume had entered his bed that night a buoyant extrovert and left it the next morning a brooding introvert, and Chief White Halfoat proudly regarded the new Captain Flume as his own creation.
More:
She bored Yossarian, but he was in love with her, too. She was a crazy mathematics major from the Wharton School of Business who could not count to twenty-eight each month without getting into trouble.
More:
Major Major's father had a Calvinist's faith in predestination and could perceive distinctly how everyone's misfortunes but his own were expressions of God's will.
More on poor Major Major Major Major:
He was polite to his elders, who disliked him. Whatever his elders told him to do, he did. They told him to look before he leaped, and he always looked before he leaped. They told him never to put off until the next day what he could do the day before, and he never did. He was told to honor his father and mother, and he honored his father and mother. He was told that he should not kill, and he did not kill, until he got into the Army. Then he was told to kill, and he killed. He turned the other cheek on every occasion and always did unto others exactly as he would have had others do unto him. When he gave to charity, his left hand never knew what his right hand was doing. He never once took the name of the Lord his God in vain, committed adultery or coveted his neighbor's ass. In fact, he loved his neighbor and never even bore false witness against him. Major Major's elders disliked him because he was such a flagrant nonconformist.
I love the part about the Loyalty Oath mania that overtakes the small island.
All the enlisted men and officers on combat duty had to sign a loyalty oath to get their map cases from the intelligence tent, a second loyalty oath to receive their flak suits and parachutes from the parachute tent, a third loyalty oath for Lieutenant Balkington, the motor vehicle officer, to be allowed to ride from the squadron to the airfield in one of the trucks. Every time they turned around there was another loyalty oath to be signed. They signed a loyalty oath to get their pay from the finance officer, to obtain their PX supplies, to have their hair cut by the Italian barbers. To Captain Black every officer who supported his Glorious Loyalty Oath Crusade was a competitor, and he planned and plotted twenty-four hours a day to keep one step ahead. He would stand second to none in his devotion to country. When other officers had followed his urging and introduced loyalty oaths of their own, he went them one better by making every son of a bitch who came to his intelligence tent sign two loyalty oaths, then three, then four; then he introduced the pledge of allegiance, and after that "The Star Spangled Banner," one chorus, two choruses, three choruses, four choruses... To anyone who questioned the effectiveness of the loyalty oaths, [Captain Black] replied that people who were loyal would not mind signing all the loyalty oaths they had to. To anyone who questioned the effectiveness of the loyalty oaths, he replied that people who really did owe allegiance to their country would be proud to pledge it as often as he forced them to. And to anyone who questioned the morality, he replied that "The Star Spangled Banner" was the greatest piece of music ever composed. The more loyalty oaths a person signed, the more loyal he was; to Captain Black it was as simple as that..Men were tied up all over the squadron signing, pledging and singing, and the missions took hours longer to get under way. Effective emergency action became impossible.
The loyalty oath insanity gets every crazier. I love the image in the following paragraph. It makes me laugh out loud.
Milo carefully said nothing when Major -----de Coverley stepped into the mess hall with his fierce and austere dignity the day he returned and found his way blocked by a wall of officers waiting in line to sign loyalty oaths. At the far end of the food counter, a group of men who had arrived earlier were pledging allegiance to the flag, with trays of food balanced in one hand, in order to be allowed to take seats at the table. Already at the tables, a group that had arrived still earlier was signing "The Star Spangled Banner" in order that they might use the salt and pepper and ketchup there.
hahahaha
I'll finish with the section on why Yossarian continuously checks himself into the hospital. It's another example of how Heller mounts the humor, ups the ante ... each sentence building on the last one, the whole thing getting funnier and funnier, even if it's juvenile and ridiculous. I read this, and it seemed to go on FOREVER, especially once you get the joke. But Heller keeps going, where other authors would leave off. Heller's sense of the absurd, his ear for repetition ... is impeccable. I love it. And mixed in with the vaudeville-type humor is the horror of war, the undeniable horror of watching your buddies get blown to pieces. It's genius. It's magic. I still have no idea how Joseph Heller pulls this off without ever preaching to us. Ever.
Being in the hospital was better than being over Bologna or flying over Avignon with Huple and Dobbs at the controls and Snowden dying in the back.There were usually not nearly as many sick people inside the hospital as Yossarian saw outside the hospital, and there were generally fewer people inside the hospital who were seriously sick. There was a much lower death rate inside the hospital than outside the hospital, and a much healthier death rate. Few people died unnecessarily. People knew a lot more about dying inside the hospital and made a much neater, more orderly job of it. They couldn't dominate Death inside the hospital, but they certainly made her behave. They had taught her manners. They couldn't keep Death out, but while she was in she had to act like a lady. People gave up the ghost with delicacy and taste inside the hospital. There was none of that crude, ugly ostentation about dying that was so common outside the hospital. They did not blow up in mid-air like Kraft or the dead man in Yossarian's tent, or freeze to death in the blazing summertime the way Snowden had frozen to death after spilling his secret to Yossarian in the back of the plane.
"I'm cold," Snowden had whimpered. "I'm cold."
"There, there," Yossarian had tried to comfort him. "There, there."
They didn't take it on the lam weirdly inside a cloud the way Clevinger had done. They didn't explode into blood and clotted matter. They didn't drown or get struck by lightning, mangled by machinery or crushed in landslides. They didn't get shot to death in hold-ups, strangled to death in rapes, stabbed to death in saloons, bludgeoned to death with axes by parents or children or die summarily by some other act of God. Nobody choked to death. People bled to death like gentlemen in an operating room or expired without comment in an oxygen tent. There was none of that tricky now-you-see-me-now-you-don't business so much in vogue outside the hospital, none of that now-I-am-and-now-I-ain't. There were no famines or floods. Children didn't suffocate in cradles or iceboxes or fall under trucks. No one was beaten to death. People didn't stick their heads into ovens with the gas on, jump in front of subway trains or come plummeting like dead weights out of hotel windows with a whoosh!, accelerating at the rate of sixteen feet per second to land with a hideous plop! on the sidewalk and die disgustingly there in public like an alpaca sack full of hairy strawberry ice cream, pink toes awry.
All things considered, Yossarian often preferred the hospital, even though it had its faults...
Yossarian had so many ailments to be afraid of that he was sometimes tempted to turn himself into the hospital for good and spend the rest of his life stretched out there inside an oxygen tent with a battery of specialists and nurses seated at one side of his bed twenty-four hours a day waiting for something to go wrong and at least one surgeon with a knife poised at the other, ready to jump forward and begin cutting away the moment it became necessary. Aneurisms, for insantce; how else could they ever defend him in time against an aneurism of the aorta? Yossarian felt much safer inside the hospital than outside the hospital, even though he loathed the surgeon and his knife as much as he had ever loathed anyone. He could start screaming inside a hospital and people would at least come running to try to help; outside the hospital they would throw him in prison if he ever started screaming about all the things he felt everyone ought to start screaming about, or they would put him in the hospital..
Catastrophes were lurking everywhere, too numerous to count. When he contemplated the many diseases and potential accidents threatening him, he was positively astounded that he had managed to survive in good health for as long as he had. It was miraculous. Each day he faced was another dangerous mission against mortality. And he had been surviving them for twenty-eight years.
"That's some catch, that Catch-22," he observed.
"It's the best there is," Doc Daneeka agreed.
Damn straight!
Today is the birthday of Ludwig Bemelmans, author of the beloved Madeline books. Here is a really interesting biographical sketch of him. I didn't know any of it. Listen to this:
When he was a teenager, his parents apprenticed him to his Uncle Hans, who owned a string of resort hotels in the Tyrol. After the 16-year-old Bemelmans shot a head-waiter during a dispute, his family gave him the option of going to reform school or emigrating to America.Bemelmans chose the latter and arrived in New York in 1914, carrying two pistols with which to fend off hostile Indians. Once again, his career as a waiter was disastrous. After losing a job because he arrived wearing one yellow and one white shoe, Bemelmans enlisted in the Army.
"Once again, his career as a waiter was disastrous."
heh heh heh
He served in the Army in World War I, and he is buried at Arlington National Cemetery.
I always loved the Madeline books, and still do. Madeline: the red-haired feisty rebellious girl in the convent school, the one who always gets in trouble (even if it's just getting her appendix taken out) - but the one who is also most loved.
I loved how Miss Clavel woke up in the middle of the night, in her cavernous bedroom, sitting up in her cavernous bed with the draperies hanging above it ... and she said to herself: "Something is not right!"
She got a candle, and ran down the hallway (the illustrations are so dramatic, so wonderful) and burst into the dormitory, to see Madeline moaning in her bed, all the other little girls sitting up, awake, worried ... Madeline is rushed to the hospital to have her appendix taken out. Things might have gone very wrong that night if it weren't for Miss Clavel's powers of prophetic thinking. How many problems could be solved if we woke up in the middle of the night, alarmed, and said to ourselves: "Something is not right!"
I loved the watercolors. I loved the urban setting, the beautiful images of Paris, with the "12 little girls in 2 straight lines" going on their daily walk with Miss Clavel.
I'm sure it will not be a surprise to any of you to know that my favorite of the Madeline books is when she and Pepito, the little boy next door, join the circus. Of course they are forced to join the circus, since they are kidnapped by gypsies at a local carnival ... but still. They end up getting into their new circus life. As a little girl, I found that book to be so exciting, so ... magical. It opened up little doors into other worlds, worlds I could only get a glimpse of ... but oh, I wanted to see more! I remember in particular one illustration of the small company of circus performers sitting around a campfire in the middle of nowhere, their caravan parked nearby. The night around them is dark, a midnight-blue wash of watercolors ... but the bright jester costumes and the Pierrot get-ups of the gypsies gleam out from the dark, like magic little gems. I wanted to sit around that campfire.
Of course, since Madeline and Pepito had been KIDNAPPED by the gypsies - poor Miss Clavel was losing her MIND back in Paris, wondering where they had gome to, if they were all right. This time, Miss Clavel's precognitive powers failed her. At no point when she took the 12 little girls to the carnival did she think to herself: "Something is not right!"
Oh well. Even French nuns with powers of prophecy have their off days.
Happy birthday, Mr. Bemelmans ... glad you didn't end up being a waiter. Seems like we all are much better off because of your original failure in the service industry.
e.e. cummings is everywhere these days. There's a massive biography of him just published, and so there's a lot of talk about it. Is e.e. cummings important? Was he a poseur? Was what he did (breaking up the traditional lines of verse, doing away with punctuation and capital letters) really all that big a deal? Or was it an annoying ruse for attention?
I happen to think that it was a big deal. Here's a wonderful article about the complex and argued-over legacy of e.e. cummings. I especially find this section to be very wise:
"No one else wrote like Cummings, and Cummings wrote like no one else" is how the poet's latest biographer, Christopher Sawyer-Laucanno, delivers the bad and good news in E.E. Cummings: A Biography. And a prescient Harriet Monroe tempered her praise by warning, "But beware his imitators!"
Yup. For e.e. cummings, it appears that his way of writing was an organic expression. In the same way that Vincent Van Gogh tried to make us see what HE saw in the starry night sky ... e.e. cummings experienced language in a very specific way and wanted us to experience it that way too. He saw language, as opposed to just hearing it. That is why you can tell an e.e. cummings poem just by looking at the page, without reading one word. But oh yes, indeed: beware the imitators!! We all can probably name a few writers who think if they
just break up
P
O
E
M
Get some technique, please. Write a classical sonnet, write a haiku, follow the rules. KNOW the forms before you throw them away. Martha Graham, pretty much the godmother of modern dance, was a ballet dancer beforehand, with years of classical ballet training. Breaking free of that tradition, and creating her own style of dance, was not a random "ooh, let me express myself" kind of thing. It was a highly intelligent rebellion: "The forms that exist now, which I know very well, do not suit me, and I cannot create what I want to create inside the old tradition. So using the old tradition as a firm foundation, let's experiment with new forms."
e.e. cumming knew the traditional forms of poetry well, and so when he threw them away, he was able to replace it with an underlying structure of his own.
I actually really like his work. He wrote one of my favorite poems ever. It makes me cry:
somewhere i have never travelled, gladly beyond
any experience,your eyes have their silence:
in your most frail gesture are things which enclose me,
or which i cannot touch because they are too near
your slightest look easily will unclose me
though i have closed myself as fingers,
you open always petal by petal myself as Spring opens
(touching skilfully, mysteriously) her first rose
or if your wish be to close me, i and
my life will shut very beautifully, suddenly,
as when the heart of this flower imagines
the snow carefully everywhere descending;
nothing which we are to perceive in this world equals
the power of your intense fragility: whose texture
compels me with the color of its countries,
rendering death and forever with each breathing
(i do not know what it is about you that closes
and opens; only something in me understands
the voice of your eyes is deeper than all roses)
nobody, not even the rain, has such small hands
More from EM Forster's Aspects of the Novel. (I introduce what this book is about here.)
Moby Dick is one of the grandest most exciting reading experiences I've ever had. It wasn't like a book at all. It was an experience. The kind of book where you get goosebumps because you can sense you are in the presence of something enormously great, and also ultimately mysterious. It's not a ponderous book at all. It's rollicking, chaotic, it goes here, it goes there, we've got omniscent narrator, we've got first-person ... You just have to SUCCUMB. Because the reward is so damn great.
Anyway, enough ranting. I'm posting this one for Chai-rista, who is in the process of reading it for the first time. I am always thrilled when someone "discovers" that book, so her post excited me.
Forster talks about different elements in novels: story (which is different from plot), people, pattern ... but then he gets into the really good stuff, and talks about "fantasy" and "prophecy".
Here, in brief, is what Forster says about the very rare novels which can be called "prophetic":
With prophecy in the narrow sense of foretelling the future we have no concern, and we have not much concern with it as an appeal for righteousness. What will interest us today -- what we must respond to, for interest now becomes an inappropriate word -- is an accent in the novelist's voice, an accent for which the flutes and saxophones of fantasy may have prepared us. His theme is the universe; he proposes to sing, and the strangeness of song arising in the halls of fiction is bound to give us a shock. How will song combine with the furniture of common sense? we shall ask ourselves, and shall have to answer "not too well": the singer does not always have room for his gestures, the tables and chairs get broken, and the novel through which bardic influence has passed often has a wrecked air, like a drawing-room after an earthquake or a children's party. Readers of DH Lawrence will understand what I mean.Prophecy -- in our sense -- is a tone of voice. It may imply any of the faiths that have haunted humanity -- Christianity, Buddhism, dualism, Satanism, or the mere raising of human love and hatred to such a power that their normal receptacles no longer contain them: but what particular view of the universe is recommended -- with that we are not directly concerned. It is the implication that signifies and will filter into the turns of the novelist's phrase, and in this lecture, which promises to be so vague and grandiose, we may come nearer than elsewhere to the minutiae of style.
Forster says that the Russians do prophetic novels better than anybody. I cannot say that I disagree. And he theorizes why that this is so, which is a very interesting section of the book. But these lectures have to do with "English" literature, so he can't dwell on the Russians, as much as he obviously wants to. However, he continuously steps back to acknowledge their greatness in these arenas. He does have this to say about Dostoevsky's writing in Brothers Karamazov (a beautiful analysis, just wonderful):
In Dostoevsky the characters and situations always stand for more than themselves; infinity attends them; though yet they remain individuals they expand to embrace it and summon it to embrace them ... Every sentence he writes implies this extension, and the implication is the dominant aspect of his work. He is a great novelist in the ordinary sense -- that is to say his characters have relation to ordinary life and also live in their own surroundings, there are incidents which keep us excited, and so on; he has also the greatness of a prophet, to which our ordinary standards are inapplicable.
Good God, ain't this the truth...More on Dostoevsky and then we'll move to Melville as prophet:
Dostoevsky's characters ask us to share something deeper than their experience. They convey to us a sensation that is partly physical -- the sensation of sinking into a translucent globe and seeing our experience floating far above us on its surface, tiny, remote, yet ours. We have not ceased to be people, we have given nothing up, but "the sea is in the fish and the fish is in the sea".
After all of this, though, here is what Forster says about that great rarity: the prophetic novelist:
So although this lecture is on a genuine aspect of the novel, not a fake aspect, I can only think of four writers to illustrate it -- Dostoevsky, Melville, DH Lawrence, and Emily Bronte.
And here, finally, is what Forster has to say about Moby Dick.
Moby Dick is an easy book, as long as we read it as a yarn or an account of whaling interspersed with snatches of poetry. But as soon as we catch the song in it, it grows difficult and immensely important. Narrowed and hardened into words the spiritual theme of Moby Dick is as follows: a battle against evil conducted too long or in the wrong way. The White Whale is evil, and Captain Ahab is warped by constant pursuit until his knight-errantry turns into revenge. These are words -- a symbol for the book if we want one -- but they do not carry us much further than the acceptance of the book as a yarn -- perhaps they carry us backwards, for they may mislead us into harmonizing the incidents, and so losing their roughness and richness. The idea of a contest we may retain: all action is a battle, the only happiness is peace. But contest between what? We get false if we say that it is between good and evil or between two unreconciled evils. The essential in Moby Dick, its prophetic song, flows athwart the action and the surface morality like an undercurrent. It lies outside words...we cannot catch the words of the song. There has been stress, with intervals: but no explicable solution, certainly no reaching back into universal pity and love; no "Gentlemen, I've had a good dream." [That's from "Brothers K"]The extraordinary nature of the book appears in two of its early incidents -- the sermon about Jonah and the friendship with Queequeg.
The sermon has nothing to do with Christianity. It asks for endurance or loyalty without hope of reward. The preacher "kneeling in the pulpit's bows, folded his large brown hands across his chest, uplifted his closed eyes, and offered a prayer so deeply devout that he seemed kneeling and praying at the bottom of the sea." Then he works up and up and concludes on a note of joy that is far more terrifying than a menace...
Immediately after the sermon, Ishmael makes a passionate alliance with the cannibal Queequeg, and it looks for a moment that the book is to be a saga of blood-brotherhood. But human relationships mean little to Melville, and after a grotesque and violent entry, Queequeg is almost forgotten. Almost -- not quite...
Moby Dick is full of meanings: its meaning is a different problem. It is wrong to turn the Delight or the coffin into symbols, because even if the symbolism is correct, it silences the book. Nothing can be stated about Moby Dick except that it is a contest. The rest is song.
And when that book was taught to me in high school, with all the "this symbolises this" and "that symbolizes that" - it did, indeed, "silence" the book for me. A brilliant observation. Once I read it in adulthood, it was the SONG that swept me away.
I will never forget reading that book. Ever. It's up there on my top 5 reading-experiences in my lifetime.
More from EM Forster's Aspects of the Novel. (I introduce what this book is about here.)
Now here's what THRILLED me about this book. It has to do with my enduring hatred of Henry James. EM Forster uses James' novels as examples in his lecture on "patterns". James' novels, of course, fit into highly rigid patterns ... and while EM Forster clearly admires the skill of the writing ... he has a lot of reservations about relying so heavily on patterns.
What thrilled me about this lecture is that it put into words for me just what it is that bothers me about Henry James. (And yes. I have read all his books. I have read them all, and I still think: two thumbs down, baby.) But my analysis of it has been ... well, there's no analysis of it at all. It's primal and unthought out: I can't stand his books, they leave me feeling NOTHING, I don't care for any of the characters ... and ... er ... maybe there's some good writing in there ... but I just never get inside his world. So. I DON'T LIKE HIM.
But in Forster's lecture on James and a novel's pattern - he expresses my reservations perfectly.
I feel vindicated. Read below, if you are interested:
Let us examine at some length another book of the rigid type, a book with a unity, and in this sense an easy book, although it is by Henry James. We shall see in it pattern triumphant, and we shall also be able to see the sacrifices an author must make if he wants his pattern and nothing else to triumph.
Wow. Okay then. Forster then breaks down the plot and pattern of The Ambassadors which, yes, I have read.
The Ambassadors ... is the shape of an hourglass... The plot is elaborate and subtle, and proceeds by action or conversation or meditation through every paragraph. Everything is planned, everything fits; none of the minor characters are just decorative ... they elaborate on the main theme, they work. The final effect is pre-arranged, dawns gradually on the reader, and is completely successful when it comes. Details of intrigue, of the various missions from America, may be forgotten, but the symmetry they have created is enduring.
Plot description follows for many pages. I want to make clear that Forster has great admiration for James' writing. He is quite complimentary here and there. But the books leave him cold. Here is his explanation, finally, why:
The beauty that suffuses The Ambasadors is the reward due to a fine artist for hard work. James knew exactly what he wanted, he pursued the narrow path of aesthetic duty, and success to the full extent of his possibilities has crowned him. The pattern has woven itself with modulation and reservations Anatole France will never attain. Woven itself wonderfully. But at what sacrifice!So enormous is the sacrifice that many readers cannot get interested in James, although they can follow what he says (his difficulty has been much exaggerated), and can appreciate his effects. They cannot grant his premise, which is that most of human life has to disappear before he can do us a novel.
I almost screamed HURRAY when I read that. That's IT. Yes, I do feel that James' "difficulty has been much exaggerated". I do not find his books "difficult" at all. I find them boring and lifeless. His characters do not make an impression. I do not care, basically. But Forster gets to the heart of it. Yes - I "cannot grant [James'] premise" ... I cannot grant "that most of human life has to disappear" for him to write a good novel.
Forster ends his lecture with this:
The James novels are a unique possession and the reader who cannot accept his premises misses some valuable and exquisite sensations. But I do not want more of his novels, especially when they are written by someone else, just as I do not want the art of Akhenaton to extend into the reign of Tutankhamen.
Thanks, EM. You just made my own feelings clear.
An excerpt from EM Forster's Aspects of the Novel. (I introduce what this book is about here.)
In this excerpt, EM Forster takes on what he calls the "pseudo-scholar". The pseudo-scholar can find employment in many different areas of literature (teaching, editing, etc.) - but it is when the pseudo-scholar becomes a critic that EM Forster finds him most "pernicious". You'll recognize the type immediately.
Here, again, you will see EM Forster's distaste for chronology.
It is when he comes to criticism -- to a job like the present -- that he can be so pernicious, because he follows the method of a true scholar without having his equipment. He classes books before he has understood or read them; that is his first crime. Classification by chronology. Books written before 1847, books written after it, books written after or before 1848. The novel in the reign of Queen Anne, the prenovel, the ur-novel, the novel of the future. Classification by subject matter -- sillier still. The literature of Inns, beginning with Tom Jones; the literature of the Women's Movement, beginning with Shirley; the literature of Desert Islands, from Robinson Crusoe to The Blue Lagoon; the literature of Rogues -- dreariest of all, though the Open Road runs it pretty close; the literature of Sussex (perhaps the most devoted of the Home Counties); improper books -- a serious though dreadful branch of inquiry, only to be pursued by pseudo-scholars of riper years, novels relating to industrialism, aviation, chiropody, the weather.I include the weather on the authority of the most amazing work on the novel that I have met for many years. It came over the Atlantic to me, nor shall I ever forget it. It was a literary manual entitled Materials and Methods of Fiction. The writer's name shall be concealed. He was a pseudo-scholar and a good one. He classified novels by their dates, their length, their locality, their sex, their point of view, till no more seemed possible. But he still had the weather up his sleeve, and when he brought it out, it had nine heads. He gave an example under each head, for he was anything but slovenly, and we will run through his list. In the first place, weather can be "decorative", as in Pierre Loti; then "utilitarian", as in The Mill on the Floss (no Floss, no Mill; no Mill, no Tullivers); "illustrative" as in The Egoist; "planned in preestablished harmony," as by Fiona MacLeod; "in emotional contrast," as in The Master of Ballantrae; "determinative of action," as in a certain Kipling story, where a man proposes to the wrong girl on account of a mud storm; a "controlling influence," Richard Feverel; "itself a hero", like Vesuvius in The Last Days of Pompeii; and ninthly, it can be "non-existence", as in a nursery tale. I liked him flinging in nonexistence. It made everything so scientific and trim. But he himself remained a little dissatisfied, and having finished his classification he said yes, of course there was one more thing, and that was genius; it was useless for a novelist to know there are nine sorts of weather, unless he has genius also. Cheered by this reflection, he classified novels by their tones. There are only two tones, personal and impersonal, and having given examples of each he grew pensive again and said, "Yes, but you must have genius too, or neither tone will profit."
This constant reference to genius is another characteristic of the pseudo-scholar. He loves mentioning genius, because the sound of the word exempts him from trying to discover its meaning. Literature is written by geniuses. Novelists are geniuses. There we are; now let us classify them. Which he does. Everything he says may be accurate but all is useless because he is moving round books instead of through them, he either has not read them or cannot read them properly.
"the sound of the word exempts him from trying to discover its meaning"
Still true. I've seen that "genius" thing used time and time again. Funny.
An excerpt from EM Forster's Aspects of the Novel. (I introduce what this book is about here.)
Now, I found this excerpt kind of shocking (not because I disagree with it, don't misunderstand). It's just one of those bold statements which re-configures the landscape, and requires some thinking over. At least I need to think it over. EM Forster speaks of "an unpleasant and unpatriotic truth" which I find quite convincing. Quite. It probably pissed off his audience (in Cambridge, remember!), when you consider what he is actually saying about English novels. But I have to say - when he puts it that way, when he compares and contrasts, I completely agree with him.
This excerpt has to do with provincialism in literature and criticism. Now remember - these lectures are all about "English literature". The field is necessarily narrowed, and so EM Forster deals with that narrow-vision (and what it means) in the following section:
I want to talk as little as possible about influence during these lectures. My subject is a particular kind of book and the aspects that book has assumed in English. Can we ignore its collateral aspects on the continent? Not entirely. An unpleasant and unpatriotic truth has here to be faced. No English novelist is as great as Tolstoy -- that is to say has given so complete a picture of man's life, both on its domestic and heroic side. No English novelist has explored man's soul as deeply as Dostoevsky. And no novelist anywhere has analysed the modern consciousness as successfully as Marcel Proust. Before these triumphs we must pause. English poetry fears no one -- excels in quality as well as quantity. But English fiction is less triumphant: it does not contain the best stuff yet written, and if we deny this we become guilty of provincialism.Now, provincialism does not signify in a writer, and may indeed be the chief source of his strength: only a prig or a fool would complain that Defoe is cockneyfied or Thomas Hardy countrified. But provincialism in a critic is a serious fault. A critic has no right to the narrowness which is the frequent prerogative of the creative artist. He has to have a wide outlook or he has not anything at all. Although the novel exercises the rights of a created object, criticism has not those rights, and too many little mansions in English fiction have been acclaimed to their own detriment as important edifices. Take four at random: Cranford, The Heart of Midlothian, Jane Eyre, Richard Feverel. For various personal and local reasons we may be attached to these four books. Cranford radiates the humour of the urban midlands, Midlothian is a handful out of Edinburgh, Jane Eyre is the passionate dream of a fine but still undeveloped woman, Richard Feverel exudes farmhouse lyricism and flickers with modish wit, but all four are little mansions, not mighty edifices, and we shall see and respect them for what they are if we stand them for an instant in the colonnades of War and Peace, or the vaults of The Brothers Karamazov.
I shall not often refer to foreign novels in these lectures, still less would I pose as an expert on them who is debarred from discussing them by his terms of reference. But I do want to emphasize their greatness before we start; to cast, so to speak, this preliminary shadow over our subject, so that when we look backon it at the end we may have the better chance of seeing it in its true lights.
So this is my new thing, reading books by writers about writing. They're usually short, snappy, and if I like the writer really enjoyable to read. (Best one read so far is Stephen King's On Writing. Hands down.)
I just finished Margaret Atwood's fun little book Negotiating with the Dead yesterday, and now I've picked up EM Forster's Aspects of the Novel. I read a bit of it this morning.
EM Forster was invited to come and give a series of "Clark lectures" at Trinity College, Cambridge, in 1927. (The Clark lecture series is still going on, by the way.) The lectures all have to do with "English literature", and EM Forster came and talked about "aspects of the novel" (duh) in 1927. The lectures are printed up in book-form, so that they have a very colloquial unedited feel to them, which is really fun. He was, of course, extremely well-prepared, with tons of notes and examples, etc., but his off-the-cuff remarks, and little jokes, are maintained in the text of the book I am reading. I love it. It feels like I am attending the lecture.
He takes a very informal and also unconventional approach to how he looks at "aspects of the novel". One of the things he is completely against is putting authors into chronological order. He is against chronology, in general. I guess you could say he is against "historical context".
Fascinating - and the way he talks about authors, divorced from their chronological moments in the time, has helped me to see some of them in a different light.
Forster says at the beginning of the first lecture:
Time, all the way through, is to be our enemy. We are to visualize the English novelists not as floating down that stream which bears all its sons away unless they are careful, but as seated together in a room, a circular room, a sort of British Museum reading-room -- all writing their novels simultaneously. They do not, as they sit there, think, "I live under Queen Victoria, I under Anne, I carry on the tradition of Trollope, I am reacting against Aldous Huxley." The fact that their pens are in their hands is far more vivid to them. They are half mesmerized, their sorrows and joys are pouring out through the ink, they are approximated by the act of creation, and when Professor Oliver Elton says, as he does, that "after 1847 the novel of passion was never to be the same again," none of them understand what he means. That is to be our vision of them -- an imperfect vision, but it is suited to our powers, it will preserve us from a serious danger, the danger of pseudo-scholarship.
Forster, help us!! We still need to be preserved from pseudo-scholarship!! You said that in 1927, it's now 2005 ... we still need you!
Forster keeps coming back to that image - of novelists throughout time all sitting in the same room, writing simultaneously. He thinks that's a better way to study "aspects of the novel" than to look at trends, or Victorian influences, or post-war malaise influences, whatever.
An exciting way to look at literature.
More excerpts to come.
Excerpt from Margaret Atwood's book Negotiating with the Dead: A Writer on Writing. This is the section on The Wizard of Oz. Nothing new here, nothing revolutionary, but definitely interesting to contemplate and discuss. I assume we all remember the story of the Wizard, and what he does??
He's had to pretend to be magical and fearsome, so that the evil witches -- who really do have supernatural powers -- would not destroy them all. Thus he has created either a utopia or a benevolent despotism, however you choose to look at it. Also he has fooled Dorothy into doing battle with the remaining evil witch by holding out false promises: he doesn't really know how to get her back to Kansas.Dorothy is not impressed. "I think you are a very bad man," she says.
"Oh no, my dear," says the Wizard. "I'm really a very good man; but I'm a very bad Wizard ..."
If you're an artist, being a good man -- or a good woman -- is pretty much beside the point when it comes to your actual accomplishments. Moral perfection won't compensate for your badness as an artist; not being able to hit high C is not redeemed by being kind to dogs. However, whether you are a good man or a bad man is not beside the point if you happen to be a good wizard -- good at doing your magic, making your "marvellous clear jelly," creating illusions that can convince people of their truth -- because if you are good at being a wizard in this sense, then power of various sorts may well come your way -- power in relation to society -- and then your goodness or badness as a human being will have a part in determining what you do with this power.
The Wizard of Oz -- soi-disant magician, wielder of power, manipulator, illusionist, and fraud -- has a long geneology. His remote ancestor was probably a shaman or high priest or conjuror, or one who combined these functions. Other ancestors can be found in folklore. More recently, and in literature, he can be traced from Marlowe's Dr. Faustus through Prospero of The Tempest.
I'll post the Prospero bit next.
I'm reading Margaret Atwood's book Negotiating with the Dead: A Writer on Writing. This book began when she was requested to give the Empson Lectures at the University of Cambridge (I think it was a series of six lectures). She describes, amusingly, how excited she was - but how that excitement slowly drained out of her when she actually sat down to write, and to think about what to write for the lectures.
I love it. It's a messy book, she flies about in her references - which I really enjoy: from Chaucer to Elmore Leonard. Stephen King to Shakespeare. She's not a snob in her reading, and she can find inspiration anywhere. I very much appreciate that. I am kind of the same way. This is a book about writing - it's not a how-to book (although I am finding it quite exciting to read). It's more a rumination on different aspects of writing. Also: what IS a writer, and is it possible to define our terms? is it possible to reconcile art and commerce? She did one lecture on Jekyll and Hyde (which I love - she talks a lot about "the double" - in art and also in life. Writers live double lives - they have to eat, live, pay rent. But then they have to be the mad solitary genius. This is the Jekyll and Hyde syndrome. Fascinating lecture.)
The fourth lecture, she entitled: "Temptation: Prospero, the Wizard of Oz, Mephisto & Co. Who waves the wand, pulls the strings, or signs the Devil's book?" In this lecture, she looks at the Faustian conflicts inherent in trying to be an artist of any kind.
She uses, as her primary examples, three characters from fiction:
--The Wizard of Oz, from Frank Baum's book of the same name.
--Prospero, from Shakespeare's The Tempest
--and the German actor "Mephisto" in Klaus Mann's novel (has anyone seen that movie, by the way? Un REAL. So good.)
What do these three have in common?
Atwood writes:
All exist at the intersection of art with power, and therefore with moral and social responsibility. And all three are illusionists, of one kind or another.
Anyway, I'm gonna post some excerpts from her discussions of these three characters, and what message they may have for all of us. It's really cool.
... Charlotte Bronte died. Today is the 150th anniversary of her death.
Here's perhaps the most famous image of the Bronte sisters - a portrait done by their dissipated (and, some say, more of a genius than all of them) brother Branwell:

In honor of Charlotte Bronte, a writer I have always adored, here are a couple of excerpts from her letters, and quotes about her work, etc:
I love this one. This is a letter Charlotte wrote to a good friend. The friend had written to her, asking her for a recommended reading list. Here is Charlotte's reply. For some reason, this letter completely delights me. I have it copied out and up on my bulletin board at home. I just love it:
"You ask me to recommend you some books for your perusal. I will do so in as few words as I can. If you like poetry, let it be first-rate; Milton, Shakespeare, Thomson, Goldsmith, Pope (if you will, though I don't admire him), Scott, Byron, Campbell, Wordsworth, and Southey. Now don't be startled at the names of Shakespeare and Byron. Both these were great men, and their works are like themselves. You will know how to choose the good, and to avoid the evil; the finest passages are always the purest, the bad are invariably revolting; you will never wish to read them over twice. Omit the comedies of Shakespeare and the Don Juan, perhaps the Cain, of Byron, though the latter is a magnificent poem, and read the rest fearlessly; that must indeed be a depraved mind which can gather evil from Henry VIII, from Richard III, from Macbeth, and Hamlet, and Julius Caesar. Scott's sweet, wild, romantic poetry can do you no harm. Nor can Wordsworth's, nor Campbell's, nor Southey's -- the greatest part at least of his; some is certainly objectionable. For history, read Hume, Rollin, and the Universal History, if you can; I never did. For fiction, read Scott alone; all novels after his are worthless. For biography, read Johnson's Lives of the Poets, Boswell's Life of Johnson, Southey's Life of Nelson, Lockhart's Life of Burns, Moore's Life of Sheridan, Moore's Life of Byron, Wolfe's Remains. For natural history, read Bewick and Audobon, and Goldsmith, and White's History of Selborne. For divinity, your brother will advise you there. I can only say, adhere to standard authors, and avoid novelty."
Absolutely marvelous.
Here is what one of my favorite authors, Lucy Maud Montgomery, wrote about Charlotte Bronte in her journal - I think this is an awesome analysis:
It is customary to regret Charlotte Bronte's death as premature. I doubt it. I doubt if she would have added to her literary fame. Resplendent as her genius was, it had a narrow range. I think she reached its limit. She could not have gone on forever writing 'Jane Eyres' and 'Villette's' and there was nothing in her life and experience to fit her for writing anything else...There was a marked masochistic strain in Charlotte Bronte -- revealing itself mentally, not physically. This accounts for Rochester. He was exactly the tyrant a woman with such a strain in her would have loved, delighting in the pain he inflicted in on her. And this same tendency was the cause of her cruelty to Lucy Snowe -- who was herself. She persecutes Lucy Snowe all through 'Villette' and drowns her lover rather than let the poor soul have a chance at happiness. I can't forgive Charlotte Bronte for killing off Paul Emmanuel. I don't know whether I like Lucy Snowe or not -- but I am always consumed with pity for and sympathy with her, whereas Charlotte delights in tormenting her -- a sort of spiritual vicarous self-flagellation.
Here is another excerpt from Lucy Maud Montgomery's journal. She loved the Bronte sisters' books, and wrote out her impressions through many re-readings over her lifetime.
Charlotte Bronte only made about 7,000 by her books ... It seems unfair and unjust. What I admire most in Charlotte Bronte is her absolute clear-sightedness regarding shams and sentimentalities. Nothing of the sort could impose on her. And she always hewed straight to the line. I have been asking myself, 'If I had known Charlotte Bronte in life - how would we have reacted upon each other? Would I have liked her? Would she have liked me?' I answer, 'No.' She was absolutely without a sense of humor. She would not have approved of me at all. I could have done her whole heaps of good. A few jokes would have leavened the gloom and tragedy of that Haworth Parsonage amazingly.People have spoken of Charlotte Bronte's 'creative genius'. Charlotte Bronte had no creative genius. Her genius was one of amazing ability to describe and interpret the people and surroundings she knew. All the people in her books who impress us with such a wonderful sense of reality were drawn from life. She herself is Jane Eyre, Lucy Snowe. Emily was Shirley. Rochester, whom she did create, was unnatural and unreal. Blanche Ingram was unreal. St. John was unreal. Most of her men are unreal. She knew nothing of men except her father and brother and the Belgian professor of her intense unhappy love. Emmanuel was drawn from him, and therefore is one of the few men in her books who is real.
Yet another entry in LM Montgomery's journal. In it, she writes about a biography of Charlotte Bronte she just finished, written by EF Benson. The issues of the "Bronte myth" were alive and well even back then.
I do not think Charlotte was in the least like the domineering little shrew he pictures her, anymore perhaps than she was like the rather too saintly heroine of Mrs. Gaskell's biography. I do not put any faith in Beson's theory that Branwell wrote parts of 'Wuthering Heights' and inspired the whole. There is no foundation in the world for it beyond the assertion of two of Branwell's cronies that he read the first few chapters of it to them and told them it was his own. They may have been telling the truth, but I would not put the least confidence in any statement of Branwell's. He was entirely capable of reading someone else's manuscript and trying to pass it off as his own. No doubt he was more in Emily's confidence than Charlotte ever knew and had got possession of her manuscript in some way. Benson blames Charlotte for her unsympathetic attitude to Branwell. I imagine that an angel would have found it rather difficult to be sympathetic. Benson cannot understand a proud sensitive woman's heart. I love Charlotte Bronte so much that I am angry when anyone tries to belittle her. But I will admit that she seemed to have an unenviable talent for disliking almost everyone she met ... And the things she says about the man she afterwards married!
And finally, some compiled quotes from Charlotte Bronte herself:
Conventionality is not morality. Self-righteousness is not religion. To attack the first is not to assail the last. To pluck the mask from the face of the Pharisee is not to lift an impious hand to the Crown of Thorns.
Good Lord, truer words.
And
It is in vain to say human beings ought to be satisfied with tranquility: they must have action; and they will make it if they cannot find it.
I like this one:
Look twice before you leap.
And:
There is only one difference between a madman and me. I am not mad.
And finally: the opening paragraphs of Jane Eyre:
There was no possibility of taking a walk that day. We had been wandering, indeed, in the leafless shrubbery an hour in the morning; but since dinner (Mrs. Reed, when there was no company, dined early) the cold winter wind had brought with it clouds so sombre, and a rain so penetrating, that further out-door exercise was now out of the question.I was glad of it: I never liked long walks, especially on chilly afternoons: dreadful to me was the coming home in the raw twilight, with nipped fingers and toes, and a heart saddened by the chidings of Bessie, the nurse, and humbled by the consciousness of my physical inferiority to Eliza, John, and Georgiana Reed.
Her books have always been a grand comfort to me, comforting in various stages of my development, because her insights are so wise, she seems to light the way ahead. But they are also exciting books, because so unexpected. You can't get any more unexpected than Jane Eyre. Nothing can prepare you for Mr. Rochester. And the plot that intertwines Jane Eyre's fortunes with his. No matter how many times I have read Jane Eyre, I am still startled by it. The final chapter, where Jane Eyre has that unexplained moment of what could be called astral travel, or ESP, or communication across many miles - she hears him cry out to her - remains one of the most moving chapters of a book I have ever read. And until that moment, it is not clear how things will go. You have given up, you have given up hope, as a reader ... It is quite quite sad. But then, this strange midnight miracle occurs ... The heart lifts up out of the chest in response.
Charlotte Bronte was a good writer. Of course she was. She didn't have the Jane Austen impeccability with language. No, Charlotte's writing is messier, more passionate, more urgent. People behave in incomprehensible ways in her books. Life is very very dark. People are cruel, they are vicious, they are barely civilized. (Her sister Emily went way further in this regard with Wuthering Heights. In Wuthering Heights it is not apparent that civilization or society has ANY bearing on people whatsoever. A terrifying vision of chaos. Charlotte had some overlay of civilization, but not too much. Not too much.) And so over and over again, my heart responds to her books. They do not become predictable, even at the 4th or 5th reading.
Cheers, Charlotte. Thanks for the books you managed to complete before you died. A good life indeed.

Why? Because someone always comes along and makes a joke out of something that NEEDS to be made fun of. Member our conversation earlier this week about the too-hot-for-you marriage of Ayelet Waldman and Michael Chabon and her obnoxious "I have so much more sex than all the other mommies in my playgroup and because of that I am basically a better human being than all of them" essay in the New York Times? Well someone who was also obviously annoyed by Ayelet's piece has written down what is a "day in the life of Ayelet". You've got to read it.
One snippet to get the party started:
1:00 P.M. Drag the kids along to Toys in Babeland. The owners called last night to let me know that there's a whole new section of stuff my husband can stick into me. I'm so excited. Eldest daughter somewhat disturbed when I explain the purpose of the double-headed dildo to her.1:30 P.M. Compare prices on three-pronged rubber truncheon at Good Vibrations. It's slightly more expensive than at Babeland, but they split the difference since I'm in so often. Youngest boy goes crazy with spray-on lube while I'm at the counter. So embarrassing… I never thought I'd be one of those moms who has “difficult” children. Depression returns.
But oh, there's so much more. Funny funny. Mean-funny, which is sometimes the best kind of humor.
I especially like this detail:
2:45 P.M. Begin writing column for Salon.2:46 P.M. File column with Salon.
BWAHAHAHA
(via Book Slut)
and "the saddest letter ever written" - Posted by Anne.
To put yourself into a position where you would not only be satisfied with the scraps from someone's table - but you would be fully nourished on those meager scraps ... Oh, it is sad.
To me the saddest line in the letter is: "You curse the destiny which has made the feeling concentrate itself on you."
Without going into too much detail, I have said a similar thing in my life to a man I was wild about. A blessing and a curse. That was how he described it. It was a blessing to be loved the way I loved him. But a curse too, because he knew he would have to hurt me anyway.

There are no 'good' or 'bad' people. Some are a little better or a little worse but all are activated more by misunderstanding than malice. A blindness to what is going on in each other's hearts. Stanley sees Blanche not as a desperate, driven creature backed into a last corner to make a last desperate stand - but as a calculating bitch with 'round heels'.... Nobody sees anybody truly but all through the flaws of their own egos. That is the way we all see each other in life."-- Tennessee Williams
I have been in his plays, I have worked on his plays in scene classes, I have written extensively about his plays, my bookshelves are lined with books filled with references to this most extraordinary man.
Tennessee Williams wrote the following elegiac essay about Laurette Taylor (who created the role of Amanda so memorably in Glass Menagerie and made him star) for The New York Times after news of her death in 1949:
I do not altogether trust the emotionalism that is commonly indulged in over the death of an artist, not because it is necessarily lacking in sincerity but because it may come too easily. In what I say now about Laurette Taylor I restrict myself to those things which I have felt continually about her as apart from any which this unhappy occasion produces.Of course the first is that I consider her the greatest artist of her profession that I have known. The second is that I loved her as a person. In a way the second is more remarkable. I have seldom encountered any argument about her preeminent stature as an actress. But for me to love her was remarkable because I have always been so awkward and diffident around actors that it has made a barrier between us almost all but insuperable.
In the case of Laurette Taylor, I cannot say that I ever got over the awkwardness and the awe which originally were present, but she would not allow it to stand between us. The great warmth of her heart burned through and we became close friends.
I am afraid it is the only close friendship I have ever had with a player...
It is our immeasurable loss that Laurette Taylor's performances were not preserved on the modern screen. The same is true of Duse and Bernhardt, with whom her name belongs. Their glory survives in the testimony and inspiration of those who saw them. Too many people have been too deeply moved by the gift of Laurette Taylor for that to disappear from us.
In this unfathomable experience of ours there are sometimes hints of something that lies outside the flesh and its mortality. I suppose these intuitions come to many people in their religious vocations, but I have sensed them more clearly in the work of artists and most clearly of all in the art of Laurette Taylor. There was a radiance about her art which I can compare only to the greatest lines of poetry, and which gave me the same shock of revelation as if the air about us had been momentarily broken through by light from some clear space beyond us.
The last word that I received from her was a telegram which reached me early this fall. It was immediately after the road company of our play had opened in Pittsburgh. The notices spoke warmly of Pauline Lord's performance in the part of Amanda. "I have just read the Pittsburgh notices," Laurette wired me. "What did I tell you, my boy? You don't need me."
I feel now - as I have always felt - that a whole career of writing for the theatre is rewarded enough by having created one good part for a great actress.
Having created a part for Laurette Taylor is a reward I find sufficient for all the effort that went before and any that may come after.
Beautiful. It was a two-sided deal there. Her performance launched him into stardom. And his creation of Amanda revitalized her career just in time for her to capitalize on it. She would be dead in a couple of years. She had had a great career early in her life, and went on a 10 year binge following the death of her husband. Laurette Taylor was "washed up". Until ... And now, she's a legend, her performance in Glass Menagerie is legendary. "What did I tell you, my boy, you don't need me..." Ha. That's what you think, Laurette! But in a way, she was completely right. The play is better than any one performance. The play didn't depend on Laurette Taylor's genius, although thank God she found the vehicle. The star of the play is actually the play itself, and Laurette Taylor knew that. And so no, Tennessee didn't "need" her. And Tennessee saying: "I consider her the greatest artist of her profession that I have known." Anyone who knows anything about theatre would be hard-pressed to disagree. I haven't even SEEN the woman act, obviously, but I don't need to. I will take the hundreds and hundreds of eyewitness' word for it. In the same way that I know, in my heart, that Eleanora Duse was one of the "greatest artists of her profession" as well. I don't need to have seen her live. That's irrelevant.
Here's a picture of Tennessee Williams out on his beloved Key West in 1980:

Make voyages. Attempt them. That's all there is.-- Tennessee Williams, "Camino Real"
I'm deeply attached to the works of Tennessee Williams. Too many stories to even tell. Realizing things about myself through working on Miss Alma in Summer and Smoke - I was pretty much forever changed by that experience. My journal entries from that time are ... hard to describe. Sheila and Alma have completely merged. It's one of the only times that's ever happened, but it sure did with Miss Alma. I have such an affinity for her. NOBODY can tell me that she is "just" a character in a play. She LIVES, she breathes. Anyway, I certainly felt possessed by her. I love that play. It is not his best, but I don't care. It's my favorite.
When people who knew him talk about Tennessee Williams, they always mention his laugh. Apparently, he had this wild high-pitched out-of-control giggle, completely infectious to anyone near him. His plays may have been tragic, but that was how he worked out his own tragic upbringing, his sister's lobotomy, etc. He put all of his grief and sadness into his plays. The man was deeply sensitive - like all of his female characters. But if this seems like he was a bleak or depressive personality, that's incorrect. (He always balked, too, when reviewers would characterize all of his female characters as "desperate". He didn't agree with that assessment at all. He saw each and every one of them as survivors. Trying to break through and live a happy and meaningful life. Other people assigned the meaning "desperate" to them, but Tennessee always hated that. He even wrote an essay for The New York Times about it, saying, "My characters are not desperate!" A great essay - I wish I had it on me right now. I have it at home.)
"Nothing's more determined than a cat on a tin roof - is there? Is there, baby?"-- from Cat on a Hot Tin Roof
Everyone talks about his "laugh". Actors and actresses who were in his plays talk about hearing his laugh from out in the audience. It was a generous laugh, a laugh full of joy. If an actor or actress was doing well, he had no problem with letting them know, with enjoying their performances openly. (Other playwrights are not so kind. It seems as though other playwrights have this thought process: "No actor could EVER live up to the perfection that resides in my mind. My play is perfect as is ... it's the ACTORS who are messing it up!!" Playwrights like that, usually, are big bores, and don't have a lot of talent. Like: okay, you want perfection? Build a feckin' statue, and don't hire live actors. Mkay? That way your precious words will be safe from contamination. Ahem. I have a ton of stories.)
Here, to me, is a quintessential Tennessee Williams statement.
An interviewer asked him: "What is your definition of happiness?"
He replied, "Insensitivity, I guess."
I could think about the implications of that forever. His experience of "happiness" as being, in its essence, "insensitive" came from his background. Those who were "sensitive" were crushed and shattered. His sister Rose was institutionalized and lobotomized. This was something Tennessee never really recovered from. (But he didn't really HAVE to recover from it, I guess. All of his feelings about it went into his work. If he had "recovered", or "worked it out" in his mind, then he might not have written Summer and Smoke, et al.)
Oh, you weak, beautiful people who give up with such grace. What you need is someone to take hold of you - gently, with love, and hand your life back to you.-- Tennessee Williams
His plays were about the "sensitives" of the world, always female characters (Tennessee's alter egos, of course). The Blache DuBois, the Laura Wingfield, the Miss Almas ... these are sensitive people, deeply wounded people, on the edge of shattering. Of course blatant open "happiness" would be seen as insensitive through their eyes.
All cruel people describe themselves as paragons of frankness.-- Tennessee Williams
I have gone on long enough. Tennessee Williams is one of my own personal heroes, for more reasons than one, and I am aware (on a pretty much daily basis) of how grateful I am to him for his plays. In the same way that I am pretty much always conscious of being grateful that there was a Shakespeare, and that we have his works with us today. I still read Tennessee Williams plays now, over and over, reading them countless times, never ever getting tired of them, never ever feeling like all my questions are answered.
Some mystery should be left in the revelation of character in a play, just as a great deal of mystery is always left in the revelation of character in life, even in one's own character to himself.-- Tennessee Williams
And I'll leave you with another really telling and beautiful anecdote, this one from Elia Kazan. I LOVE this, because it says to me, in no uncertain terms, why Tennessee Williams is a god among playwrights - and why he is so unusual. Nobody else can touch him, really. I love Arthur Miller's plays, but there's always a social conscience in them which can get preachy and tiresome, if it's not controlled. Death of a Salesman has a perfect balance, but his later plays have the feeling of pamphlets.
Tennessee Williams has none of that. There is no "social conscience" in his plays. There is no deeper social criticism going on. Perhaps the only "criticism" that Tennessee consistently levels at "society" is the way it treats the "sensitives".
I have found it easier to identify with the characters who verge upon hysteria, who were frightened of life, who were desperate to reach out to another person. But these seemingly fragile people are the strong people really.-- Tennessee Williams
But still ... You never ever get the feeling that Tennessee is preaching.
Here's the setup for the excerpt I want to post (which has to do with the rehearsals and also the opening of Streetcar Named Desire):
Jessica Tandy, who originated Blanche on Broadway, was already a celebrated actress. Marlon Brando was practically unknown. Kazan noticed which way the wind was blowing during rehearsals, and it concerned him on many levels.
Basically what was happening was that Marlon Brando was acting Jessica Tandy off the stage. Without breaking a sweat, Brando stole the show right out from under her. Jessica Tandy fought to keep her ground (which, actually, is perfect for the theme of the show and for the character of Blanche Dubois), but Kazan's main concern was that Blanche would turn into a laughable character and lose the sympathy of the audience. Kazan was worried that the audience, because of Brando's undeniable stage presence, and the electricity of his acting, would completely side with Stanley, and not have any sympathy for Blanche at all. This, Kazan felt, would be a disaster. Stanley rapes Blanche - this must be seen as horrifyingly wrong, not as Blanche getting what she deserves. But Brando's power took over the play, it was a runaway train, it wasn't a matter of him playing Stanley as sympathetic - he wasn't. It was just that he was a force to be reckoned with, a powerhouse, a sex-pot ... He was magnetic on stage, you couldn't take your eyes off him. Jessica Tandy barely registered, when she was beside him.
Here's a photo from that production: Brando, Kim Hunter, and Tandy:

And so Kazan feared, as rehearsals went on, that the balance of the play was off.
Here's what Kazan wrote about all of this. It is Tennessee Williams' "advice" to Kazan at the end that really packs a punch:
But what had been intimated in our final rehearsals in New York was happening. The audiences adored Brando. When he derided Blanche, they responded with approving laughter. Was the play becoming the Marlon Brando Show? I didn't bring up the problem, because I didn't know the solution. I especially didn't want the actors to know that I was concerned. What could I say to Brando? Be less good? Or to Jessie? Get better? ...Louis B. Mayer sought me out to congratulate me and assure me that we'd all make a fortune ... He urged me to make the author do one critically important bit of rewriting to make sure that once that "awful woman" who'd come to break up that "fine young couple's happy home" was packed off to an institution, the audience would believe that the young couple would live happily ever after. It never occurred to him that Tennessee's primary sympathy was with Blanche, nor did I enlighten him ... His misguided reaction added to my concern. I had to ask myself: Was I satisfied to have the performance belong to Marlon Brando? Was that what I'd intended? What did I intend? I looked to the author. He seemed satisfied. Only I -- and perhaps Hume [Cronyn, Tandy's husband] -- knew that something was going wrong ...
What astonished me was that the author wasn't concerned about the audience's favoring Marlon. That puzzled me because Tennessee was my final authority, the person I had to please. I still hadn't brought up the problem, I was waiting for him to do it. I got my answer ... because of something that happened in the Ritz-Carlton Hotel, across the hall from my suite, where Tennessee and Pancho [Tennessee's boyfriend - or maybe it was more of a f*** buddy situation - not sure - Anyway, Pancho was a huge presence in Tennessee's life. They had a really volatile relationship.] were staying. One night I heard a fearsome commotion from across the hall, curses in Spanish, threats to kill, the sound of breaking china ... and a crash ... As I rushed out into the corridor, Tennessee burst through his door, looking terrified, and dashed into my room. Pancho followed, but when I blocked my door, he turned to the elevator still cursing, and was gone. Tennessee slept on the twin bed in my room that night. The next morning, Pancho had not returned.
I noticed that Wiilliams wasn't angry at Pancho, not even disapproving -- in fact, when he spoke about the incident, he admired Pancho for his outburst. At breakfast, I brought up my worry about Jessie and Marlon. "She'll get better," Tennessee said, and then we had our only discussion about the direction of his play. "Blanche is not an angel without a flaw," he said, "and Stanley's not evil. I know you're used to clearly stated themes, but this play should not be loaded one way or the other. Don't try to simplify things." Then he added, "I was making fun of Pancho, and he blew up." He laughed. I remembered the letter he'd written me before we started rehearsals, remembered how, in that letter, he'd cautioned me against tipping the moral scales against Stanley, that in the interests of fidelity I must not present Stanley as a "black-dyed villain". "What should I do?" I asked. "Nothing," he said. "Don't take sides or try to present a moral. When you begin to arrange the action to make a thematic point, the fidelity to life will suffer. Go on working as you are. Marlon is a genius, but she's a worker and she will get better. And better."
So extraordinary. It brings tears to my eyes, and it's wonderful advice, advice that any artist would do well to follow. "Don't take sides ..." "fidelity to life ..."
We are lucky that we have produced such a playwright. We are lucky to have all of his plays in the canon. I can't imagine my life without them.
Happy birthday, Tom.

I'm very conscious of my decline in popularity, but I don't permit it to stop me because I have the example of so many playwrights before me. I know the dreadful notices Ibsen got. And O'Neill -- he had to die to make 'Moon' successful. And to me it has been providential to be an artist, a great act of providence that I was able to turn my borderline psychosis into creativity -- my sister Rose did not manage this. So I keep writing. I am sometimes pleased with what I do -- for me, that's enough."-- Tennessee Williams, in a 1981 interview
A fantastic article about what Mrs. Gaskell's biography The Life of Charlotte Bronte (which I have read - many times) has done to the legacy of Charlotte Bronte.
Elizabeth Gaskell was a contemporary of Charlotte Bronte, and knew her personally. 2 years after Charlotte's death in 1855, Gaskell published the biography, and pretty much hijacked the entire discussion (and she STILL DOES.) She immediately created the myth of "Charlotte Bronte" - Nobody else can come in with a different view, or re-look at her - because Mrs. Gaskell so dominated the conversation. (In a similar way that A. Alvarez's essay on Sylvia Plath and his encounters with her during the fall before she committed suicide also dominated the discussion - and created the myth. Everyone after Alvarez needed to contend with the myth.)
Tanya Gold, author of the article I link to, starts off with:
Elizabeth Gaskell is a literary criminal, who, in 1857, perpetrated a heinous act of grave-robbing. Gaskell took Charlotte Brontë, the author of Jane Eyre, the dirtiest, darkest, most depraved fantasy of all time, and, like an angel murdering a succubus, trod on her. In a "biography" called The Life of Charlotte Brontë, published just two years after the author's death, Gaskell stripped Charlotte of her genius and transformed her into a sexless, death-stalked saint.
Now here's what's incredible, though: biographies go out of fashion very quickly. One generation has a "definitive" biography of, say, Abraham Lincoln. The next generation uncovers a treasure trove of his personal writing, and the biography that was once definitive is now sorely out of date. We see this happen all the time.
But what is incredible is that Mrs. Gaskell's book (and it's good, by the way, it's really interesting - but definitely a myth-making venture, you can sense it in the overwrought prose) has never gone out of print. This is extraordinary. And every biography of the Bronte sisters, to this day, has to contend with the myth-making story Mrs. Gaskell paints of Haworth Parsonage. That was Juliet Barker's main deal with her MASSIVE biography on the Bronte's, published in the 90s and hailed as a high-water-mark in the genre. Point by point, using documentation that makes the footnotes almost longer than the book, Barker refutes many of Mrs. Gaskell's claims (that Haworth was in the middle of nowhere, for example). But still - we gotta give Mrs. Gaskell some props. It is rare that a book stays in print for that long EVER, but it is almost unheard of when it comes to biography.
If someone says to you "Charlotte Bronte - what comes into your head?" - probably a lot of your first images (the lonely woman scribbling out in the middle of the moors, depressive, losing her teeth, surrounded by tragedy) come from Mrs. Gaskell's biography.
Charlotte Bronte sensed, in her personal meetings with Elizabeth Gaskell, that Gaskell was romanticizing her, or making her up, or trying to mythologize her while she was still alive. Bronte wrote a complaining letter to her publisher about Mrs. Gaskell: "She seems determined that I shall be a sort of invalid. Why may I not be well like other people?"
Fascinating. Bronte picked up on Mrs. Gaskell's myth-making propensities during her own life ... and the "Gaskell myth of Charlotte Bronte" has held on with astonishing tenacity.
Now this is not to say that I find it completely unbelievable that an unhappy toothless spinster could have written the swirlingly passionate melodrama that is Jane Eyre. No. We all have our escapes, writers too. It is just that Mrs. Gaskell could only see ONE side of Charlotte Bronte, and so her entire book uses that one thing as the starting-point, and everything that follows is used to support her thesis. (This is a common thing of biographies, obviously. Most biographies start with some point of view about their subject and I have to say I like the biographies that resist taking that common path. People's lives aren't NEAT, you know. We don't all live according to some NEAT THEME. I have done things in my life which would seem completely out of character to those of you who read this blog. I have done things which would blow your mind, because you only see one side of me, the side I choose to show. This is the same for most of us. I prefer the biographies that pretty much take as their theme: "Okay, this person is really interesting. Let's find out all about them.") Mrs. Gaskell's biography of Charlotte Bronte is very very subjective - obviously because she knew Charlotte, but also because she was invested, for whatever reason, in creating this myth.
I'll quote from the article now:
Gaskell portrays Charlotte as Victim Supreme. She begins to sew her shroud from her first chapter, when she copies out the Brontë grave tablet in Haworth church, voluptuously listing those who died of consumption: Charlotte's mother, Maria, her sisters Maria, Elizabeth, Anne and Emily, and her brother Branwell. Charlotte, Anne and Emily were "shy of meeting even familiar faces". They "never faced their kind voluntarily". The Brontës are shown, with understated relish, as lonely, half-mad spinsters, surrounded by insufferable yokels and the unmentionable stench of death. Under Gaskell's pen, they become the three witches of Haworth and she hurls on the Gothic gloom, ravaging the moorlands and the town for appropriate props. She has a particular fondness for the graveyard outside their front door: "It is," she notes, "terribly full of upright tombstones." She is bewildered by the Brontës. She could never accept they were, quite simply, talented. There had to be a magical mystery at work on those moors ...
Interesting. "She could never accept they were, quite simply, talented." Mrs. Gaskell was a popular novelist at the time herself. Her novels are still in print as well. But I found that observation really interesting. Mrs. Gaskell's Bronte biography is the first "victim/martyr as genius" book - the type of book that now GLUTS the marketplace. "Oooh, her mother didn't love her, and THAT'S why she wrote great books." Uhm ... how about her mother didn't love her AND she wrote great books? It doesn't necessarily follow that just because you're a victim of something that you're going to be amazingly talented.
Perhaps Mrs. Gaskell was trying to explain away her own lack of genius.
More along these lines:
Gaskell carefully fillets the letters to match her agenda. Any hint of Charlotte as a sexual being is tossed on to the historical furnace. Charlotte's correspondence with the (married) love of her life, Monsieur Heger of Brussels, is ignored, as is her thwarted romance with George Smith. Gaskell could hardly leave out Charlotte's marriage to Arthur Nicholls - but no doubt she would have liked to. Her biography is the ultimate piece of feminine passive-aggression, a mediocre writer's attempt to reduce the brilliant Miss Brontë to poor, pitiful Miss Brontë. Gaskell wrote the Life as a tragedy, not a triumph. But if Charlotte Brontë's life is a tragedy, what hope is there for the rest of us?
Jane Eyre isn't just a sexy book. It's an erotic book. It's disturbing. It surges with passion. And ... uhm ... can you say: brief cross-dressing incident?? It's a weird weird book, man.
Of course not looking into people's sex lives was par for the course in those days, but I think Tanya Gold is making a deeper point here, and one that I echo. It is somehow more attractive to the "we love victims/martyrs" crowd to see Charlotte Bronte as a tragedy-struck spinster-ish victim, strolling through the moors by herself, communing with her demons, ruining her eyesight by scribbling in the candlelight, and having ONLY unrequited love affairs. Even though this view is not based on reality. She did, after all, marry. And she did have quite a passionate love affair with someone else before she got married - which she based her book Villette on.
Tanya Gold rocks the HOUSE with her debunking of the long-standing Gaskell myth. I find it quite energizing. Listen to this. Listen to her interpretation of Charlotte Bronte as a writer (all of it based on actual letters written by Bronte, things that were available at the time to Mrs. Gaskell - only they didn't fit into Gaskell's neat little theme):
Let me introduce you to the real Charlotte Brontë. She was not a wallflower in mourning. She always wanted to be famous; she pined to be "forever known". Aged 20, she wrote boldly to the Poet Laureate Robert Southey, asking for his opinion of her talents. He replied: "You evidently possess and in no inconsiderable degree what Wordsworth calls 'the faculty of verse'." Then he chides her: "There is a danger of which I would ... warn you. The daydreams in which you habitually indulge are likely to induce a distempered state of mind. Literature cannot be the business of a woman's life and it ought not to be." Charlotte ignored Southey but Gaskell couldn't believe it. She concluded the correspondence "made her put aside, for a time, all idea of literary enterprise".
See how Gaskell spins this? Charlotte Bronte rejected the advice of Southey, realizing: Hm, I am going to be a writer ANYway. But that wasn't really victim-ish enough for Mrs. Gaskell. (I'm being hard on Mrs. Gaskell and I don't mean to be. Her book is filled with great stuff, most of which are lengthy excerpts from Charlotte Bronte's voluminous correspondence - I've posted a lot of that stuff on my blog. Here's one in particular. Charlotte Bronte sends a "reading list" to a friend who asked for recommendations.)
More on the erotic imagination of Charlotte Bronte, and how Mrs. Gaskell had to somehow view it as coming from a place of tragedy:
Charlotte did not only feel passionate hatred for small children; she felt passionate love for men. Unlike the female eunuch created by Gaskell, she was obsessed with her sensuality. She wrote to a friend: "If you knew my thoughts; the dreams that absorb me; and the fiery imagination that at times eats me up ... you would pity and I daresay despise me." The thwarted lust of a parson's daughter? Gaskell dismisses it as "traces of despondency".
Ha.
Anyway, the 150th anniversary of Charlotte Bronte's death is this March 31 ... and so, in honor of that great author (one of my favorites), I say to Charlotte Bronte: You can be whoever you want to be, Charlotte. I don't mind if you contradict my ideas of you. I don't mind if parts of you don't "fit in" with my image of you. There's a reason why people still read Jane Eyre. There's a reason why your legacy will last.
Here's the rest of the great article I keep excerpting from. Charlotte Bronte fans, you won't want to miss it.
One of my favorite writers of all time is Madeleine L'Engle.
I read Wrinkle in Time when I was a kid, and pretty much a lifelong obsession was born. I have read every one of her books that I can get my hands on. And this woman is PROLIFIC. Not only does she write "children's books" (a label she doesn't agree with, anyway - which I think is why she is considered such a wonderful writer for children - she just sees the books as BOOKS - she never talks down to kids, ever) ... but she writes young-adult books, and full-blown adult novels.
She has multiple series going on at the same time: the series of the Murry family (immortalized in Wrinkle in Time), the series of the Austin family (there are 6 or 7 of these, and Ring of Endless Light is one of my favorite books ever written), a couple of books starring a kind of boring chick named Camilla (who intersects with both the Murrys and the Austins), and many more. L'Engle enjoys creating characters for one series, and then have them show up, randomly, in the middle of another series. Like Zachary - one of the characters introduced in the Austin family series - a troubled self-destructive rich kid - who then takes a MAJOR role in House Like a Lotus - one of the Murry family stories (starring Polly, daughter of Meg Murry). Anyway, you could, if you were obsessed enough, do geneological trees of all of this.
But Madeleine L'Engle doesn't just write fiction. She also has published 4 books entitled "Crosswicks Journals" (named after her farmhouse in Connecticut). I adore each and every one of these books, for very different reasons. The titles and themes are: Circle of Quiet - her ruminations on family life, on art, on writing, on nature, on religion. Summer of the Great-Grandmother - a wrenching book, about Madeleine's mother, suffering from Alzheimer's, and coming to live at Crosswicks for the summer, her last summer on earth. An amazing read, and I highly recommend it, to anyone who has ever experienced the grief of watching someone you love succumb to Alzheimer's. A redemptive book. It is not just about the sadness of that summer, but it is L'Engle's tribute to the extraordinary woman her mother once was. The Irrational Season -this book has a theological theme, if I could put it that way. She talks about her life, her faith. Madeleine L'Engle is a very religious woman (although she would probably balk at that term) ... she doesn't like labels. Her faith is of the questioning kind, the child-like kind ... and she is unafraid to get mad at God, to ask "WHY", all that stuff. She doesn't believe in blind faith. She can't stand narrow-minded religious bigots, and is ruthless about them. Ruthless. And the last of the Crosswicks Journals - is an absolutely beautiful book called Two-Part Invention. It is the story of her long marriage to her husband. If you're a Madeleine L'Engle fan, I literally cannot recommend Two-Part Invention highly enough. It has an honored place on my bookshelf. I've read it many times, and every time I read it I grow, I learn more, I see different things. I should do a whole Two-Part Invention excerpt-day. It's a wonderful book.
So there's THAT section of L'Engle's creativity.
But then there's even more. She has a bunch of books out (mostly published in the last 10 years or so) about her views on God, and religion and faith - in conjunction with different aspects of her life. She's got one book on the value of storytelling. She's got one book on art. She's got one book on idols and icons. I like that one a lot. She wrote a small book on the incarnation. Because it's Madeleine L'Engle, you get a very specific voice for all of these things. It's not pompous, or pious ... it's questioning, it's full of wonder. She writes in a very personable way, full of anecdotes, full of humor, and you always get the sense of a questioning inquiring open intellect. I love her style.
And lastly, she has written what has come to be known as "the Genesis trilogy". These books are awesome. I've mentioned before how I think the Bible is a really good read, and I very much enjoy dipping into it, on a daily basis. Madeleine L'Engle's three books on different stories from Genesis reflects my own experience. There are those who read the Bible literally, that's fine for them. It's not fine for me. There are those who think that trying to imagine what it was REALLY like back then is heresy, blasphemy, whatever. The book is the Word of God. Fine. But if religion is going to be THAT, then you can count me out. Madeleine L'Engle approaches the Genesis stories as just that: stories. Now, she is not without faith. On the contrary!! But since she is a writer, she believes in the power of storytelling, that storytelling is one of the highest forms of human communication - existent in human societies since we grouped up into societies, basically. People have gathered around the campfires time immemorial to tell stories to one another. Stories to enlighten, to frighten, to warn off, to help others, to tell the younger generation about the struggles of the older ... whatever. Madeleine L'Engle goes at the stories of Genesis in THAT context, which I find exhilarating. It is a LIVING faith. Not a dead scared-to-grow-or-question faith. That's how I've always approached the Bible, and my relationship to God, etc. If it's not ALIVE, then ... it just doesn't have any meaning for me.
And so: she asks: What can the story of Joseph tell us? What does it MEAN? What's going on between the lines? How can we grow, when looking at this story?
If we don't think of the Bible as a static text (to be accepted at face-value and barely DISCUSSED for fear of tripping over heresies) then ... what can we learn? What was going on with Joseph? What is the STORY there?
That's how I read the Bible, anyway.
I love the Genesis books. Her book on Joseph (Sold into Egypt) got me through a very tough time in my life. I've read it countless times since. It always has something to tell me, to show me.
Madeleine L'Engle. One of my own personal idols, on so many levels: her writing itself, but also how she has chosen to live her life. Her WAY of being a writer. If I could be even a tiny bit like her, in my own creative process, I would be grateful. I dread her death. I dread the day when there will be "no more" Madeleine L'Engle books coming out. She is still writing, although she must be almost 90 years old by now. Most of her books now are very small, and theological in nature. Which I suppose makes sense. No more novels. I think her last novel was Troubling a Star, another one in the long Austin series. This one took place in Antarctica - which L'Engle traveled to, as a spry woman of ... 80? She's incredible.
Whatever she went through, whatever she experienced, whatever she saw - went into her books. She was enraptured by Portugal, and so she set an entire book there. She was totally fascinated by quantum mechanics, and many of her books deal with these concepts. After retreating to the country to raise her family, L'Engle and her husband moved back to New York City, so he could pick up his once-flourishing acting career. L'Engle put that jarring experience (country mouse to city mouse) into one of her books. She went to Antarctica, and needed to find a way to send the Austin family down there, so that she could talk about what she saw, what she sensed.
Her entire LIFE is use-ful. If you get my meaning. Nothing is not USED.
She is a tireless creator, she never stops. What I find especially admirable is that Madeleine L'Engle went for 10 years without publishing ONE THING. Not a short story, not a poem, NOTHING. This was in the early 60s to early 70s. She was having babies, running a general store with her husband in their small Connecticut town, and trying to write. The two of them had been successful actors, that's how they met, and after they married, and started considering having kids ... they decided to move out of the city, and give "civilian" life a go. They did so for 10 years. This was the 10 years when L'Engle was unable to get published. It was a dark time for her - and for her husband - who missed his acting career more than he let on at first. When she finally submitted Wrinkle in Time to different publishing houses, no one wanted to touch it. They thought it wasn't a children's book - they didn't think kids would "get" it. It was too scary, too emotional, blah blah blah. Publisher after publisher after publisher rejected it. L'Engle considered throwing in the towel completely. Finally, one brave publisher ignored the fact that Wrinkle in Time couldn't be easily classified or pegged and the book was published. All hell (and heaven) proceeded to break loose. The book became a massive hit. It is still a massive hit today. She won every literary award on the planet. Her entire life changed.
And she has been churning out interesting challenging beloved books ever since.
I don't just admire her writing. I LOVE her writing. There are many writers out there who garner my admiration for their skill. But there aren't too many writers that I flat out LOVE. She is one of them.
There's a book out there, a compilation of many of her different thoughts on writing, on balancing career and family, on what it means to write a "children's book", on how she writes, on writer's block ...
It's been a huge inspiration for me, over these last kind of rough couple of months, reading her words on her own career, her own way of handling success and rejection. I've needed her. She kept going when things got tough, she kept writing in the midst of rejection ... it's not that she didn't despair. SHE DID. But she kept writing. She kept writing.
Get ready for a bit of a ramble.
I've only read The Shipping News. I tried to read The Accordion Diaries, or whatever the hell it was called, but just COULD. NOT. get through it. And I gave it my best shot. I really did.
My experience of The Shipping News was what I call "one of THOSE reading experiences". I can count "THOSE" reading experiences on almost one hand. By that I mean: intensely personal. The book almost BURNS me. It's a fiery experience. I feel pointed out by the book. I feel recognized. I feel SEEN. I think: "How on earth could this author know about what goes on in the deepest recesses of my soul?" It's almost embarrassing, that feeling. You don't want people to know your own pettiness, your own sadness, your own cruelty, your lies. I am DIFFERENT when I finish the book, because of this recognition factor. You can't have "one of THOSE reading experiences" too often. It takes too much out of you.
Other books that were like that for me:
-- Geek Love, by Katherine Dunn
-- Prayer for Owen Meany, by John Irving
-- Atonement, by Ian McEwan
Atonement was such a devastating book that it still seems radioactive to me. I went to pick it up and flip through it about a month ago, glanced at a couple of paragraphs, and thought: "Uhm. No. No need to read this again."
These books cut me open to myself. I don't think I will ever put myself through Geek Love again. (However, I don't want to make this sound too bleak and grim. These aren't, on the whole, depressing books. Well, Atonement is, actually. These aren't gloom and doom books. That's not what I'm talking about here. I'm not talking about SAD books. I'm talking about books that feel like they were written FOR me.) These are books that describe the human condition in such a way that I feel KNOWN. The spotlight shines onto the darker corners. These books slice back any artifice I might hold onto. These books made me look into the abyss. My own abyss. To see my own sham, my own drudgery, my own redemption.
THOSE reading experiences.
Does anyone know what I'm talking about here??
The Shipping News was one of THOSE books for me.
There was a good 5 or 6 months in 1994 when it seemed like everyone was reading that book. I saw people on the El train reading it. My entire family read it. Everyone talked about it. My parents KEPT ASKING ME: "Have you read it yet? Have you read it yet?" I remember, to this day, how my dad described the book to me. The characters, what it was about ... EVERY conversation I had with my parents: "Have you read The Shipping News yet?" Finally, I would just cut to the chase before they even asked: "I'm doing great, I got cast in this, I'm doing that, and NO, I haven't read The Shipping News yet." Everyone seemed to think that I, in particular, should read the book.
So, of course, I didn't read it. You never do anything just because 5,000 people tell you HAVE to.
I was madly in love with someone in 1994. And he, too, was on the "YOU OF ALL PEOPLE HAVE TO READ THE SHIPPING NEWS." chorus-line. He went on vacation at one point, to Florida or something? Can't remember. Anyway, he came back ... this was when we were in the flirty unexpressed part of the whole thing ... madly in love but not admitting it ... and he said, "I thought about you my entire vacation." "You did?" "Yeah. I sat on the beach and read The Shipping News and I just kept wanting to tell you how much you would love this book. It reminds me of you." "It does?" "Totally!" "Why?" But he never could say why. All he said was, "The lead character is this ... kind of loser guy ... a sad sap ... who has a really big chin ... and he gets a job on a newspaper ... and he starts to see his entire life in terms of headlines ... " That was all he would say. I still couldn't get a line on why this book reminded him of me. Loser guy? Sad sap? Big chin? And ... this to you says SHEILA? You wanna explain that to me??
On the very same day that this man told me "YOU HAVE TO READ THIS BOOK", I came home and there was a package in my mailbox from my parents. I opened it up, and there was a dern copy of the book.
It makes me laugh, in retrospect. They were DESPERATE for me to read it. They just KNEW how I would respond to it, and they could. not. wait. for me to read it on my own.
And I'm not exaggerating ... I got the package on the same day I talked with Love-Man. I laughed out loud when I pulled out The Shipping News, like: "Okay, universe, okay, I GET THE MESSAGE!"
Long story even longer (see this is why this book means so much to me ... it's all wrapped in that year - 1994 - a WACKO year if ever there was one):
I still didn't read the damn book though, at that time ... because my life got NUTS. Love-Man and I ended up not working out ... and everything was a big feckin' disaster. And suddenly I couldn't bear to even LOOK at The Shipping News. It seemed to represent him or something. Whatever. I was really upset. I remember being bummed out, though (in addition to all the other stuff I was bumming on) - thinking: Wow, I'll probably never read that book now.
But I did. A year later. I had moved from Chicago to New York by then. Everything was different, including my zip code. My entire life had changed in 6 months. So I picked up that book.
And never. EVER. wanted it to end.
EVER.
I will NEVER forget my experience reading that book. It shimmers in my memory. I laughed out loud. I had searing pain at times. At times, I was just SEARCHING for clues ... clues as to why Love-Man had thought of me so much when he read it. It's about a bunch of weirdos who live in Newfoundland. Why was that book so full of me for him? I will never know. But I do know that The Shipping News is also so full of HIM for me. I mean ... it's about pain, and redemption ... about finding what it is that you DO, and then doing it like Hercules. It's about thinking that you have a "lot" in life. That you have a certain path, and then ... often with wrenching results ... you go another way. But ... I can't even talk about what that book is about. It's not ABOUT what it's about.
The writing is startlingly good. It's a rare rare thing, to come across an original voice. Proulx's voice in that book is original. It's funny, it's biting ... each character has a different and distinct speaking pattern, accent. Everyone has secrets. Things are left unexplained. And the PLOT. This is not a book where nothing happens. The plot is out of control. So interesting. You are introduced to a small three-dimensional world, full of weirdos, cranks, curmudgeons, and lonely hermits. And yet ... while they may not be "likable", in any sense, you end up LOVING them. Yes. LOVING them.
My experience, by the end of that book, was painful. It wasn't that anything bad happened. No. It was that it brought up all this weird LOVE in my heart - for these characters, for the Love-Man, for my parents and siblings, for Annie Proulx - love that HURT. Like, you want to clutch your heart and say "Ouch."
I know I'm belaboring this point but I don't give a crap.
The last paragraph of the book is not just amazing - it's transcendent. Transcendent. After spending time with all the crabs and secretive curmudgeons and unpleasant people in the book ... to have Annie Proulx draw back the curtain ... and let the HEART flow forth ... in that last paragraph ... It was almost too much for me.
And yes. Love-Man in Chicago was a huge part of my response. When I finished the book, I SO wanted to go back in time and talk with him about it ... talk about every tiny detail. But the time for that was long long past.
And so The Shipping News is one of those reading experiences I will never forget. I am a better person, I swear to God, for having read that book.
I loved it so much that I refused to see the movie. Kevin Spacey as Quoyle???? Are you out of your goddamned mind?? NOT. If they had cast John C. Reilly, then MAYBE I would have considered seeing it.
Years passed.
Then ... oh my God ... so exciting ... Annie Proulx came out with another one! The Accordion Journals or whatever. I bought it IMMEDIATELY. Another book from the woman who helped me grow, who gave me a reading experience I will never forget!! Whoopee!
That accordion book STANK. UP. THE. JOINT.
In a way, I admire that she didn't choose to write Shipping News II, and tried something totally different.
But I couldn't even get through 2 chapters. I put it down. Devastated.
And never read any of her work since. Although I have to say, she's always on my radar.
Erin, at Critical Mass, is the reason why I have babbled on like this thus far. She is a big Annie Proulx reader herself, and many of her posts about Proulx have made me think quite a bit. Annie Proulx didn't just have a success with The Shipping News - she hit the feckin' jackpot. That book was EVERYWHERE. And so ... what does a writer do? Following a jackpot book?
She's got a couple of short story collections out right now, which I have not read. I was so crushed by how awful Accordion Yadda Yadda was that I decided to just let my memory of Proulx stay pure. The Shipping News was one of THOSE reading experiences. And I don't expect her to do that for me every time ... I know, I know ... but it's still hard to not look for that kind of transcendence every time.
Erin is reading Proulx's latest collection right now.
Great observations there, and some great excerpts.
I guess I need to ease my way back into Annie Proulx's world ... since I've been out of it for so long, and since The Shipping News was such a formative book for me. I must forgive her for not giving that to me every time. I must, if I am a true fan, go where she wants me to go. At least give it a SHOT.
I will be very interested to see Flight - the new play debuting here in New York in May. It's a new play about Charles and Anne Lindbergh (and my cousin Kerry O'Malley will be playing Anne. Yee-haw, Kerry!) Eric Stoltz will play Lindbergh.
I know nothing about the playwright, so I'm not sure what his "take" on the Lindberghs will be ... or what the focus will be ... but I'm sure interested to see it. I'm a Lindbergh fanatic. (Anne and Charles both.)
I have read Anne Lindbergh's journals - all 5 volumes - probably 3 or 4 times all the way through. I LOVE them. I've read all of Charles' writing as well, not to mention numerous biographies of the dude, including Scott Berg's. All of it is really interesting, and obviously Lindbergh was (and still is) an extremely controversial guy, because of his links with Nazi Germany, and his unwillingness to condemn Adolf Hitler. (That is an ENORMOUS over-simplification of Lindbergh's views during WWII and his vocal involvement with "America First" - forgive me - but that's pretty much it, boiled down.) I don't have the details in front of me, so the facts may be a bit off - but he made numerous trips (with Anne) to Germany, during the years before WWII, and expressed great admiration of the buildup of the Nazi war machine. He made grave and alarmist speeches back in America about how technologically advanced the Germans were, and how we shouldn't alienate them or make them mad. He received some kind of medal of honor from the Nazis ... from Goering, I believe. There's an infamous picture of a beaming Charles Lindbergh accepting the medal. That picture would come back to HAUNT the guy for years and years to come, once the full horrors of the Holocaust became known to the world. Charles Lindbergh's reputation pretty much has not recovered.
Anne Lindbergh, in her journals, showed a bit more ambivalence about all of this - mainly because she really didn't understand a lot of what was going on ... and yet she always stood by her man. When he wrote a speech, however, saying that the British and the Jews were pretty much to blame for WWII - she begged him not to make the speech. He went ahead and made the speech anyway, and pretty much from that moment on, became a hated public figure (as opposed to being idolized like a god in the 20s and early 30s.)
Anne Lindbergh, whose journals are awesome documents (a couple of excerpts here), was a wonderful writer, a shy girl who pretty much had yet to blossom when she met Charles Lindbergh, one of the most famous men (really, he was practically a boy then) in the world. She was suddenly catapulted into the brightest spotlight possible, after living a very sheltered privileged life in the Morrow clan.
The two of them (Charles and Anne) were completely inexperienced when they got married, neither of them had even been on a date, for God's sake. Their only "dates" as a couple, before they got married, were when he would take her up flying. This was their only time to get away, because of his enormous fame and the media pressure. They couldn't even talk while up in the air, because of the roar of the engines, so they would pass notes back and forth. That was the courtship. After a couple of afternoons like that, he asked her to marry him, she said yes, they had a secretive wedding, and then pretty much escaped in disguise for their honeymoon on a small boat. Anne wore a mustache and dark glasses, and a fedora ... etc. Complete media circus.
She reveled in all of this a bit. She was swept away by him. He taught her to fly. They flew "north to the Orient", the experience which made up Anne Lindbergh's first book. (It's not very good. I have a copy because, whatever, I'm OBSESSED, but the story of their "north to the Orient" trip is MUCH better in the journals.)
Anne Lindbergh busted out of her safe little Morrow universe when she married Lindbergh. Anne came from a family of pretty spectacular women, highly accomplished, socially brilliant, etc. Her mother was the president of Smith College. Anne had two sisters, Elizabeth and Constance - both who were considered brilliant, and gorgeous ... the real catches in the family. Anne was shy, bookish, introspective. When Charles Lindbergh met the family in Mexico City (Anne's father was at the US Embassy in Mexico ... I think he might have been the ambassador - not sure) - everyone kind of assumed that Lindbergh would gravitate towards the sparkling, witty and lanky-limbed Elizabeth (who was a success with men. Sadly, she died very young, only a couple of years later.)
But Lindbergh picked out Anne right away. Perhaps he sensed that he could more easily mold her into what he needed. I don't mean this in a hostile way, or in a judgmental way towards Lindbergh. After all, he was a very practical man, and I believe that he knew what he needed. He couldn't have just any old wife, because his life was going to be a different sort of life. He needed a specific KIND of wife. He was a pilot, in the days when it was a deadly profession. Well, I suppose it still is, to some degree - but he faced enormous dangers, every day. He needed someone who would "get" that, be able to handle it. He needed someone who would "get" why he needed to go away for months at a time. He also needed someone who, perhaps, didn't have too much going on herself - and could accompany him on all of his major journeys. Anne Lindbergh, shy, quiet, unsure of herself, fit the bill. (This is totally my interpretation of their romance, by the way - based on all the books I've read. I didn't KNOW either of them, so there are, perhaps, many other interpretations. This is mine.) He lived the life of a world-famous celebrity, with not a lot of freedom (except when he was in the air), no privacy ... He needed a wife who was NOT famous, someone with a good head on her shoulders, who could handle the blitzkrieg, and stand by him.
Even though Lindbergh was so famous and so dang HANDSOME (really, those early pictures of him are ... almost archetypal in their handsomeness) ... he was a very shy boy, with the logical mind of a mechanic, who was completely pussy-whipped (forgive me) by his overbearing mother. He was a mamma's boy, basically. In his own way (even though he led the life of an adventurer, a pioneer) - he was as shy and cowed as Anne Lindbergh was.
Reeve Lindbergh (one of their many children) published a book recently about her parents. Of course I have it. BECAUSE I'M OBSESSED. She said that there was a powerful physical connection between her parents that went beyond love, went beyond anything that she as a child could understand - but she could always feel it. They weren't a couple who talked much, or who sat around having deep intellectual conversations. Anne probably would have wanted more talk (which is why she fell head over heels in girlish love with Antoine de St.-Ex when she met him briefly - something in her missed that cerebral stimulation) - but Charles was not a verbal guy. She had to adjust to that. And she was a ball of emotion, and very unsure of herself. Charles had to adjust to that. He tried to help her in this - he built her a small shed in their backyard, where she could set herself up as a writer, away from their brood of children - he really wanted her to be independent, free. I believe Anne Lindbergh had some depressive issues. Maybe it was just a leftover from the murder of her first born - which would make sense - but she became rather fatalistic and lethargic after that. It hurt Charles to see, and since he wasn't a verbal person, had a hard time handling it.
All of this is just normal relationship give-and-take stuff.
But apparently, going back to what daughter Reeve wrote, Anne and Charles had an intense sexual chemistry that lasted pretty much until Charles died. Basically, they had sex all the time, is what I'm tryin' to say.
The kidnapping and murder of their son was horrific. Their different sensibilities (he - calm and logical, she - emotional, passionate) struggled with how to come together during the crisis. She wrote letter after letter after letter (daily letters) to Charles Lindbergh's mother, during the entire search for the baby. They are very odd letters, and Anne Lindbergh says she doesn't remember writing them, and finds them astonishing and puzzling to read. Like: What on earth was going on with me? Every. Single. Day. She wrote a 4 or 5 page letter to Lindbergh's mother, detailing breaks in the case, the house filled with cops, the newspapers ... Almost no emotional outbursts.
Meanwhile, Lindbergh handled the tragedy in his own way - getting completely involved in the case, obsessing about it, doing his own investigations. There's that famous story of Lindbergh flying over ... I think it was the bay where JFK Jr. went down - anyway, Lindbergh was flying his plane over that bay, with a cop or a detective in the plane with him ... this was while the baby was missing ... and Lindbergh, at the controls of the plane, was staring out the window, down into the water, as he flew over, saying through gritted teeth: "Where. Is. That. Baby. Give. Me. My. Baby...." over and over and over. Like a robot: "Where Is That Baby. Show Me My Baby. Where Is My Baby." Like - if he said it enough times, the baby would be revealed. Tragic.
Anyway, the marriage survived this horror. Somehow. They went on to have 5 children. She eventually published the book for which she will be known forever: Gift from the Sea. It is the book that will never die. It's a classic. It (almost) blotted out the shame of her Wave of the Future book - almost, but not quite. In that book, written in the late 1930s, as the clouds of war darkened over Europe, Anne Lindbergh put forward a very misguided, very naive theory about fascism: that it is the "wave of the future" and we should, to some degree, accept it. It is inevitable, and the Nazis are part of that inevitability, as bad as they are ... Perhaps something beautiful will follow afterwards, but it is the "wave of the future" and we should accept it.
Now. All hell pretty much broke loose when this book was published. The critics crucified her. Her family almost broke ties with her. She had NO IDEA the shit-storm that would hit when her pacifist message went out. She pleaded innocence, and she CONTINUED to say that her message was misunderstood - she didn't mean lay down and die ... I've read the book (why? BECAUSE I'M OBSESSED) - and it is very muddy thinking, and you can sense that she really doesn't know what she's talking about.
As you can probably tell, I love the woman, so I wince when I read it, thinking, "Anne, sweetheart, you're out of your depth. Come on now. Write about your emotions, and I want to listen ... but you have no idea what you're doing here ... Stop. Just stop." She is wading into waters she has no business wading into. It was her mis-guided way of defending her husband, who was being criticized left and right for his open and vocal resistance to our entry into WWII. Wave of the Future was a disaster. It caused a rift between Anne and her patriotic US Embassy American family. She had thrown in her lot with her husband, for good or ill.
It turned out to be for ill. Lindbergh quickly became the most hated man in America, and Anne Lindbergh found herself scorned and shunned as well.
Anne Lindbergh saw the error of her mindset, once the full truth about Nazi horror was revealed. She wrote a foreword to her last volume of journals, which document the years of WWII, admitting this: We were naive, we stepped into areas we shouldn't have, we didn't have all the facts, and we over-stepped our bounds as public people.
Selfishly, I am glad that the shame of her book (really, it was more of a pamphlet) Wave of the Future did not last forever, and the memory of it died ... because if it had lived on, following her around like a shadow, then she might not have written Gift from the Sea, one of those enduring classics. Anne Lindbergh, an awkward undeveloped girl, grew up in the public eye - the unrelenting public eye. I suppose we could say the same thing about Charles, who was little more than a grown-up KID when he flew across the Atlantic and became world-famous. Neither of them were seasoned human beings. She was pretty much an un-formed amoeba when she met and married Charles Lindbergh (you think I'm exaggerating? Read the first volume of her journals and see if you can sense ANY maturity whatsoever. It would be like if my junior-high-school Diary Friday self suddenly married, oh, Russell Crowe - or someone equally as famous - AT THAT VERY TIME in my life ... uh ... what??), and so all of her mistakes (and some of them were quite big) were splashed about on the front pages of the newspapers. All of her disappointments, too, her griefs, her sorrows. It was relentless. She had quite an awkward time of it.
Anyway. That's my rambling essay on the Lindberghs, one of my longest enduring obsessions. Which I will now post without proofreading. I wrote all of that in one shot. I'm insane.
May 2005. The off-Broadway debut of Flight. Starring Eric Stoltz and my cousin Kerry. I may have to snag Kerry to go out for a beer with me prior to then, so I can hear about this script, get all the DEETS. Can't WAIT. ALREADY.
A spectacular review by Joseph Epstein of the recently-published collection of Truman Capote's letters, called Too Brief a Treat. Epstein can WRITE, I'm tellin' ya. Love his work. I especially loved this sentence, which is a perfect example of Epstein's sensibility, I think:
Not enough love in the home, the verdict is, and so poor little Truman sought it everywhere else. ("Too much love in the home," I long to write on papers by many undeservedly confident students.)
Heh heh "undeservedly confident" Perfect.
But here is where in the review I got chills - (my feelings about Truman Capote, and about In Cold Blood are obvious - I'm passionate about it!):
Without In Cold Blood, Capote's name would probably be forgotten today. Although his fiction is never less than skillful, with the element of charm bordering on sentimentality frequently coming into play in such stories as "The House of Flowers" and "A Christmas Memory," it often feels a touch insubstantial, derivative, fragile, and too brightly colored. When Capote published his first novel, Other Voices, Other Rooms (1948), George Davis, an editor of Mademoiselle magazine known for his lacerating remarks, said: "I suppose someone had to write the fairy Huckleberry Finn."In Cold Blood took six years to finish. Capote first heard of the murder of the Cutter family when he noticed a story in the New York Times of November 16, 1959, with the headline, "Wealthy Farmer, 3 of Family Slain," and he contracted with William Shawn to write about it for the New Yorker. From the outset, Capote felt he was sitting on a masterpiece. Complications of various kinds arose, chief among them lengthy appeals that delayed the execution of the two killers for years. A striking piece of hypocrisy in this correspondence is Capote's letters of friendship with the two killers, whom he also pumped for information--set beside letters to others expressing his impatience for their execution, so that he could complete his book at last. Writers, let us make no mistake, are swine.
It's quite true - that if all you did was read Capote's short fiction or novels, you would have NO IDEA that this writer had an In Cold Blood in him. It's a stunning transformation.
Capote always felt his masterpiece remained un-written. In Cold Blood perhaps was such a wrenching experience for him that he couldn't see the forest for the trees. Capote certainly did not lack an ego ... he was quite capable of informing others of his own genius ... but he still felt that his great book was still "out there".
The ending of Epstein's wonderful review is sad. I read Gerald Clarke's biography of Capote. The last couple of chapters are almost un-readably sad. You get the sense of this man's agony. He would literally toss and turn at night, crying, unable to find comfort, and fearful. Fearful. It's haunting. He died afraid, alone, and drug-addicted. Terrible.
Epstein closes with:
Capote planned, for a final act, to go out as the American Proust with a novel called "Answered Prayers" about the lives of the rich Manhattan women into whose confidence, through his charm, he had insinuated himself. When he published a chapter of the novel with the title "La Côte Basque" in Esquire in 1975, so damaging (if perhaps also true) was it to the people who had befriended him that he was ever afterward non grata in the chic social circles upon which he had come to depend.
THE FINAL DECADE of Capote's life, as one learns from Gerald Clarke's excellent biography of the writer, was a shambles of drugs and booze and law suits and ugly gossip and betrayals perpetrated both upon him and by him. This once delicately beautiful and richly talented young man became a talk-show buffoon, a booze-bloated bag of neediness, the subject of New York Post gossip headlines, and one of the first victims of the celebrity culture he had helped to create. It's a sad story--made sadder by the fact that he did not retain the lucidity to write it himself. Its theme might have been that charm is a gift that, when abused, can bring a man down hard.
It is true that, in a way, by publishing the two bitchy chapters of Answered Prayers, Capote planted the seeds of his own destruction. He had no idea that the response would be so violent, so angry (having read those two chapters, I have to say: Jesus, Truman, what were you expecting? That your rich friends would be pleased?? Amused? What were you thinking??) He had no idea that publishing those chapters would go off like such a bomb, and that he would then be promptly cut off from 90% of his dearest friends. He was ignorant to some degree - he also didn't realize how much these rich folks liked having him around for one reason only: because he entertained them. He didn't realize how fragile the connection was - and that the second he was no longer entertaining, like a cute little dog, they would cut him OFF. He was a very self-destructive individual, but that doesn't make his end less sad. It is mostly how AFRAID he was that really touched my heart. After the disaster of Answered Prayers, after people erased him from their lives, after people stopped returning his phone calls ... leaving him all alone ... he said to the couple of friends who still hung around: "I'm so scared at night ... I'm so scared..." The loneliness. The loneliness killed him.
I have great compassion for that, great understanding.
Day-um. My respect for her keeps growing. Suddenly, she's speaking out, she's everywhere. She sounds like an extraordinary woman. A part of me knows that people will always be curious about her mother (Sylvia Plath), her father (Ted Hughes), etc. I mean, I'm curious about them. I love them both as poets, and have read biographies of both of them. Look at how I run my obsessions. Cary Grant? Fine - let's read biographies. Etc. Her parents were 2 famous poets, her mother committed suicide, etc. People will be interested.
But the level of prurient interest, the insane passing-off of stupid Freudian theories, her mother's name being chiseled off her grave by some lunatic fan, the biographies being written by authors who have grievances, bones to pick, something to prove, yadda yadda ... I completely sympathize with Frieda's wish to have her mother and her father left alone. I'm with ya, woman.
Sylvia Plath killed herself in February, 1963. In the months previous, her writer's block had vanished with a ferocity that frightened her friends - Was this manic episode the precursor to some huge crash? In those last months before she died, she wrote sometimes 3 poems a day. And these weren't crappy poems, these were arresting terrifying works - works that made her name, works that are now taught in English classes across the land. Some are sheer genius. If you read them in order (the way Ted Hughes placed them in the original version of the book Ariel - published after her death) - you feel her marching towards that oven. You feel her, in poem after poem, dig deeper and deeper into her psychic despair. Plath, recently separated from Hughes, her husband, had their two children in her flat with her, and because of her maternal duties, the only time she had to write was at night, or in the hours before dawn. She would sit up, at 3 am, 4 am, and churn out such poems as "Daddy", "Lady Lazarus", "Ariel", "Contusion", "The Munich Mannequins" ... and many many more. These are great poems. Each poem went through multiple drafts, too - so the pace at which she worked must have been extraordinary.
Before she died, she collected all of these frightening poems into a binder, and left express instructions of the ORDER in which they were to appear when published. (This was explained in the Introduction to her Collected Poems, compiled by Ted Hughes). Ted Hughes, however, felt that it would be better to put them in chronological order. And so they were.
And that is the version of Ariel that was published, that was read feverishly and picked apart, that was held up as a pure work of suicidal art, etc.
Hughes has suffered enough. His decision to re-order the poems has been criticized by shrill ninnies who can't stand the man, and who hold him responsible for everything that went wrong in Sylvia's life. They would hold him responsible for the hole in the ozone layer. Ted Hughes is evil incarnate to these cultish Plath wackos.
Anyway, all of this is just a preface.
Thank you, peteb, for sending me the following news - Ariel is now being re-issued, in the order Sylvia Plath suggested. Plath liked HER order because the first word of the volume would be "love" and the last volume would be "spring". To HER, the volume of poems was a redemptive story, a story of hope (which is hard to believe, when you read these poems all in one sitting - it's one of the bleakest most upsetting books I have ever read) - But that's neither here nor there. To Plath, she was hopeful that she was starting up a new and good life without Hughes, that she would be entering "spring" again.
Frieda Hughes, Sylvia and Ted's daughter, now a grown woman, has written an incredible article about this re-issuing of her mother's book - and she beautifully defends her father from the Sylvia Suicide-Cult crowd who thought he was Satan Incarnate. Beautiful. I felt like cheering.
Criticism of my father was even levelled at his ownership of my mother's copyright, which fell to him on her death and which he used to directly benefit my brother and me. Through the legacy of her poetry my mother still cared for us, and it was strange to me that anyone would wish it otherwise.After my mother's suicide and the publication of Ariel, many cruel things were written about my father that bore no resemblance to the man who quietly and lovingly (if a little strictly and being sometimes fallible) brought me up - later with the help of my stepmother. All the time, he kept alive the memory of the mother who had left me, so I felt as if she were watching over me, a constant presence in my life.
It appeared to me that my father's editing of Ariel was seen to "interfere" with the sanctity of my mother's suicide, as if, like some deity, everything associated with her must be enshrined and preserved as miraculous. For me, as her daughter, everything associated with her was miraculous, but that was because my father made it appear so, even playing me a record of my mother reading her poetry so I could hear her voice again. It was many years before I discovered my mother had a ferocious temper and a jealous streak, in contrast to my father's more temperate and optimistic nature, and that she had on two occasions destroyed my father's work, once by ripping it up and once by burning it. I'd been aghast that my perfect image of her, attached to my last memories, was so unbalanced. But my mother, inasmuch as she was an exceptional poet, was also a human being and I found comfort in restoring the balance; it made sense of her for me. The outbursts were the exception, not the rule. Life at home was generally quiet, and my parents' relationship was hardworking and companionable. However, as her daughter, I needed to know the truth of my mother 's nature - as I did my father's - since it was to help me understand my own.
Wow. I read Ted Hughes' book of poems The Birthday Letters - published just before his death. In that book he broke his long long silence about Sylvia - and addresses her in all but two of those poems. It is an extraordinary book. To anyone who thought he was the bogey-man of poetry, and the eeeeeeevil misogynist who ruined Sylvia Plath's life, that book should have been a harsh reminder that we can never know the truth about what goes on between two people behind closed doors.
I love Sylvia Plath's poetry. I find it disappointing that her suicide has overshadowed her art. Her work is so deep, so exciting, that I keep going back to it - at different points through my life, and I always see new things. Sometimes I read her stuff and feel filled with rage, other times I go back and I see her humor, or I am just awed at her sheer verbal skill. Her early poems are stiff, self-conscious, and pretentious. I can feel her checking her Thesaurus every other word. She's showing off, she's stiff, she's coy, she's a prodigy. They're boring. If you only read them, you would have no idea the POWER that this woman had. And when she let her hair down, woah did she let her hair down.
Nobody expected it of her. The "Ariel" poems were a terrifying revelation to all.
I love Ted Hughes' poetry too. I have always thought he got a raw deal.
I have my Hughes-version of Ariel. Of course I do. I've had it since high school. I can recite most of the poems therein by heart.
"The blood jet is poetry and there is no stopping it ..."
"Stasis in darkness"
and my personal favorite line:
"the blue pour of tor and distances".
I mean, you just MUST say that out loud. It's stunning language! "The blue pour of tor and distances ..."
But I will definitely be getting this new edition of Ariel. It seems only right.
And so the books can sit side by side on my shelf - his version, and hers.
Because what really matters is the words. Her language. The poems themselves. THEY are what compel me.
It's nice to hear from Frieda Hughes. I often think about those two children, and what became of them.
but I most definitively am not one of those people. (What's Up Doc nod: "I don't know who he is, but she is deFINitely not herself.")
That's fine - to each his own. I don't need to convert people, or try to insist that their perceptions are wrong. As a matter of fact, I can't stand that attitude - especially when it comes to something like taste in art, or novels, or whatever.
Just because I love JD Salinger doesn't mean ... well, it doesn't freakin' mean anything, frankly. It just means I love JD Salinger.
During my Bloomsday extravaganza this past year - which a ton of people seemed to really enjoy, actually - I got a couple of comments in emails, and also a couple of cowards posted stuff about me on OTHER people's blogs (but didn't have the balls to come to me themselves) ... The comments were full of the misguided feeling that somehow I was trying to say I felt I was BETTER than other people because I loved James Joyce. There were comments like: "Maybe I'm ignorant, but I don't think there's anything wrong with loving Robert Ludlum." Er - can you say: PROJECTION??? I know you can! Come on, say it with me: I AM PROJECTING MY OWN ANXIETIES ONTO SHEILA, WHOM I HAVE NEVER EVER MET.
I never said, "To all you idiots who love Robert Ludlum, let me show you what REAL literature is like."
I would never ever do that. And if you think I would, you don't know me at all.
These people imagined I was saying things I did not. They were intimidated by Joyce (and so am I, frankly) and so they needed to negate him, and make it seem like I felt superior to them. Whatever.
So, as a JD Salinger lover, I was interested and annoyed in Jonathan Yardley's column about re-reading Catcher in the Rye. It's a part of that awesome Washington Post series, re-reading old classics, taking a new look at them. I read all of Yardley's columns, I love them, and will continue to do so even though I disagree with him wholeheartedly on this one.
I recently re-read Catcher, and found myself, one night, laughing out loud like a hyena on a silent bus - I was snorting, cackling, etc. I love it! It's the PROSE I love. I can't explain it further than that - it makes me laugh. Yardley finds the prose manipulative (which, for me, is a rather meaningless word ... what does he mean by it?) That Salinger wants to make us feel things? Well, what author DOESN'T want that?
Yardley writes that the book "touches adolescents' emotional buttons without putting their minds to work." I totally disagree with that.
Mr. Crothers (my great 10th grade teacher) taught the book - and yes, indeed, the book "touched emotional buttons" - but there was quite a BIT to think about as well. I remember almost word for word Crothers' discussion on the whole "where do the ducks go when the ponds freeze" conversation that Holden has with the cabbie and various others ... This was not about emotional manipulation, this was a book like any other, a book of puzzle pieces - and for ONCE it was fun to try to put them together. (Unlike putting together the boring symbolic puzzle pieces of Billy Budd - now THAT book is manipulative!!)
Additionally: I have to say to Yardley: Er - why do you have contempt for something that wants to "push adolescents emotional buttons"? It's that kind of hostility towards outright sentiment, or emotion, that I don't like. It's the kind of attitude that thinks Notting Hill is a shitty movie because it wants to make you feel something. There might be a better example than Notting Hill, but whatever. I don't have a problem with sentiment, with open emotion, or with the simple beautiful love expressed in the book between Holden and Phoebe. I LOVE it, as a matter of fact. I don't think Holden is a "saint" with Phoebe. I think he's all messed up with Phoebe. It's a perfect description of the kind of codependent worried vibe that goes on between siblings. I LOVE Phoebe.
Back to "manipulation": I find books like Bridges of Madison County to be manipulative. I found The Notebook by Nicholas Sparks to be so manipulative that I couldn't even finish it, and left it in a drawer in my youth-hostel room in Galway. Now THAT book was going for the emotional jugular without touching your brain ONCE. In that mawkish book I can look right through the prose and see the puppet-strings. And I can tell that the author is aiming right for the lowest common denominator.
Yardley is obviously entitled to his opinion, but this is just my counter-opinion, I suppose. I don't find Catcher manipulative in THAT way at all. The book certainly makes me feel things - and I've read it multiple times. As an adolescent, I read it, and fell in love with Holden. As a young woman I read it, and perceived other depths in it - the love of siblings, the need to have a meaningful life, the unresolved issues of Allie's death. And recently, I just read the damn thing and found a great story. Funny, sad, chaotic, mysterious - I don't know. To me, it's a great story. Even though nothing really happens. It's like a Cassavetes film - an exploration of a state of mind, a minute description of 48 hours.
I don't think a book that wants to make you feel something and ACHIEVES IT is anything to be ashamed of.
A book that desperately wants to make me feel something and FAILS to achieve it, on the other hand, is a blight upon this earth. I can't stand books like that. Or movies, for that matter.
But I've got no problem with emotion, honestly asked-for and honestly-earned. I love books that make me love them. There aren't many. Catcher in the Rye is one of those books for me. I can't say why, because it seems to be a different book every time I read it.
Perhaps it is the fact that there is some mystery at the center of the book - something UNdescribed, UNexpressed - that makes it such a classic. Actually, "classic" is the wrong word. The better word is "beloved".
To me, that book is a beloved book. I grew, when I read it for the first time. Soul-growth, whatever you want to call it. Yardley may look down his nose on the soul-growth of a 14 year old, but I think it's the most important kind of growth. I will always be glad I read the book when I did. It made a huge impact ... and now, when I pick it up again, I'm not looking for insight, or for the answer to the meaning of life ... Usually, when I pick it up now, I'm just looking for a good laugh.
In that respect, Salinger always delivers.
And lastly: Yardley puts down some of the aspects of the book that would only appeal to teenagers (all grown-ups are phonies, etc.) I think THAT, actually, is a snobby attitude. "It can't be a classic if teenagers love the book in droves." Personally, I think that The Pigman, by Paul Zindel, is one of the best books I have ever read. Hands down. It was assigned to my 8th grade English class ... and it's about two teenage misfits who find each other ... and it's full of humor, and pain, and rebellion ... and it continues to be a favorite of mine to this day. I tip my cap to Paul Zindel. I tip my cap to Salinger. I don't think there's anything "lesser" about their books, just because teenagers "get" them.
Update: Erin at Critical Mass weighs in.
This is part of the chapter I read this morning. I've got a ton of thoughts about it all, but I'm not sure how to put it into words. In this excerpt, Rebecca West and her husband stop at a market in Macedonia, and look at the home-made dresses the women are selling. Because West is who she is - she sees, somehow, the entire history of the Balkans in the embroidery stitches. She's one of those big-thinkers, people who can see things in a historical context (even when the world appears to be crumbling around them) - like Orwell, like Robert Kaplan ... These people are not ordinary thinkers. They don't see things the way the rest of us do. They teach us how to see properly.
Or - if not "properly" - then they teach us how to see things for ourselves, and how to see things in context. To see beneath the surface of things, to always inquire, to never accept things at face-value. Rebecca West's power of sight seems to me to also bring a feminine filter, or maybe I should say female filter, to the landscape. She's analyzing embroidery here, after all. Taking it seriously as an artform, and also as something that is indicative of something else. It's all a symbol, everything is to be interpreted. And not just architecture, or literature, or political structures tell us about society - but the stitches of peasant women, too. The great thing about her book is that it is not JUST the female filter, which would be a huge yawn. Rebecca West doesn't skimp on either side. You get the history, the political movements, the religious upheavals, the great sweeping hand of time - and then you also get the taste of the food, and the preponderance of paprika in all the recipes, etc., and you get descriptions of head scarves and skirts and shoes, and stockings. It's both. Robert Kaplan uses Black Lamb and Grey Falcon as his inspiration for his own travel books, and it is quite apparent. You can taste the brandy when you read his books, you can hear the rain on the window, you can see the colors of the buildings. Rebecca West is his constant reminder - LOOK. SEE. ASK.
If I ever go to Macedonia, and see peasant women in traditional dress, I will think of this excerpt, and I will be grateful.
"They are selling dresses," I said with delight and so they were: new dresses for such peasant women as had come into the town to work and had neither the homespun cloth nor the leisure to make their own clothes and were still shy of Western attire, and old clothes that had such fine embroidery on them that they would be worn again. All these dresses were of the standard Slav pattern. They were made of white or cream homespun linen and were embroidered lavishly on the hems and sleeves and more sparingly around the neck. Nearly all of these were serious works of art. That will not be believed by those who know only the commercial peasant-art of Central Europe. The cross-stitched blouse of Austria and Hungary is tatty and ill-bred, rightly regarded by the aristocrat and the highbrow as vulgar and the proletarian as funny. It fails because the themes of peasant art are so profound and its technique so intricate that it requires a deliberation hardly to be found elsewhere than in peasant life or in the sphere of scholarly and dedicated people not in the least likely to make blouses. Women distracted by the incoherent interests of the modern town, or working at the rate necessary to make a living anywhere in the orbit of a modern town, will not have the experience to form the judgments about life which lie behind most of these embroideries, nor the time to practice the stitches and discover the principles of form and colour which make them strike the eye with the unity of flowers. A precisely similar process of degeneration can be seen in Tin Pan Alley, where the themes that are dealt with by folk-song and by the lyric poets are swallowed by shallow people in a hurry and immediately regurgitated in a repulsive condition.But these old women, who looked at once hearty and tragic, who were able to grin broadly because early and profuse weeping had made their faces unusually mobile, were dealing in uncorrupted merchandise. All the embroidery had a meaning. The first I picked up had a gay little border to its hem, a line of suns with rays, half an inch across, with trees in between them and stars dancing above them. The suns had black centres and rays, and their circumferences were alternately orange and green, and the trees were alternately green and blue, and the stars were green and blue and brown. The design stood on a black line of stitching, under which were two broken lines of stitches in all these colours, and then there was a corded edge oversewn with buttonhole stitches in black, deep blue, light blue, crimson, green, and purple, with the black predominating so that there was an effect of darkness stirring with the colours of creation.
But the little suns and trees and stars would not take creation too seriously, it was as if fun was being poked at it. This significance was no fance of our own, for the woman who sold it to me and her friends smiled as they spread it out for us, and looked grave as they showed us one that was my second choice. On this some woman with a different temperament had given up her mind to thought of the majestic persistence of nature and its untender character, and had fixed on the linen a number of dark upright trees breaking into aloof flowers, harbouring indifferent birds. The design was so highly stylized as never to tempt the eye to mere gaping by its representation of fact; it refused to let the trees be more than symbols of a mood.
I found yet another design that was purely abstract. Bars and squares of black with raised designs and touches of purple in the solid background depicted no natural object whatsoever, yet evoked certain exaltations. It appears doubtful whether Tolstoy ever saw a peasant. In the imbecile work What is Art? he asserts that peasants appreciate only pictures which inculcate a moral lesson, such as, for example, a picture of a woman giving food to a beggar boy, and that only a person perverted by luxury can care for art which was created without a specific didactic aim. If he had put his head out of his window and looked at his own village, he would have seen -- for embroidery of this kind is done, with varying degrees of merity, all the way up Eastern Europe from the Black Sea to the Baltic -- that peasants, more than any other class in the modern community, persistently produce and appreciate art which is simply the presentation of pleasing forms. It was not improbably because Tolstoy was a bad man that he wished art to do nothing but tell him how to be good, and perhaps these peasant women can permit themselves their free and undidafctic art because their moral lives are firmly rooted.
They had been trodden into the dust by the Turks, condemned to hunger for food and to thirst for blood, but they had never forgotten the idea of magnificence, which is a valuable moral idea, for it implies that the duty of man is to make a superfluity beyond that which satisfies his animal needs and turns it to splendid uses.
I bought here a wedding dress perhaps twenty or thirty years old. It was a composite of eight garments, a fine chemise, a linen dress embroidered round the hem and sleeves till it was almost too heavy to be worn, a purple velvet waistcoat braided with silver, a sequin plastron to be worn over the womb as a feminine equivalent to a cod-piece, and a gauze veil embroidered in purple and gold. It was a memory of Byzantium and the Serbian Empire; solemnly it put sequins where the emperors and empresses had worn precious stones, it made of its wool and its flax and what it could buy from the pedlar something that dazzled the eyes a little as the Byzantine brocades had dazzled them much. Even so in the folk-songs of these parts do they sing with nostalgia of gold and silver, not as wealth, not as mintable material, but as glory to be used for shining ornament.
That they should remember glory, after they had been condemned for so long to be inglorious, is not to be taken for granted, as an achievement within the power of any in their place. A tradition is not a material entity that can survive apart from any human agency. It can live only by a people's power to grasp its structure, and to answer to the warmth of its fires. The Churches of Asia became extinct not because Islam threatened them with its sword, but because they were not philosophers enough to be interested in its doctrine nor lovers enough to be infatuated with the lovable throughout long centuries and in isolation.
But these Macedonians had liked to love as they had been taught by the apostles who had come to them from Byzantium, they had liked the lesson taught by the emperors that to wear purple and fine linen encourages human beings to differentiate themselves in all ways from the beasts, they had liked, even inordinately, the habit taught them by Byzantine art of examining life as they lived it and inquiring into their destiny as it overtook them; and since they had still their needles they turned to and managed to compress these strong likings into these small reflective and hieratic designs.
The old women were pleased at our enthusiasms.
They are of course not fully conscious of the part their embroideries play in the preservation of their ancient culture: when an Englishwoman plays a sonata by Purcell she is not likely to feel that she is maintaining English musical tradition. Yet these women are certainly aware that they are about some special business when they sew. I am told by an Englishwoman who has collected such embroideries for 20 years and knows their makers well that it is an esoteric craft, those who are expert in it do not give away their mystery. Many of the themes which often reappear in the designs have names and symbolic meanings which are not confided to strangers, and a woman will sometimes refuse to discuss the embroidery she has worked on a garment made for her own use. When they marry they make caps for their bridegrooms and about these they are always resolutely reserved.
Here is, indeed, another proof of the impossibility of history. There cannot be taken an inventory of time's contents when some among the most precious are locked away in inaccessible parts and lose their essence when they are moved to any place where they are likely to be examined carefully, when their owners are ignorant of parts of their nature and keep secret such knowledge of them as they have.
Magnificent writing and observations.
who were able to grin broadly because early and profuse weeping had made their faces unusually mobile....
they had never forgotten the idea of magnificence, which is a valuable moral idea...
Truman Capote freely referred to himself, throughout his life, as a "fairy".
If you remember his frequent appearances on Johnny Carson, then you will remember his flamboyant character, his high lispy voice, the drawling Southern accent ... He never tried to hide who he was.
Capote was hired in the 50s as a replacement screenwriter for the Bogart film Beat the Devil. It was being filmed in Italy - it starred Bogart, Gina Lollabrigida, Peter Lorre - and others. Capote arrived, and worked his ass off. Churning out pages on a daily basis. The movie is quite fun, if you've never seen it. You can hear the Breakfast at Tiffany's voice of Capote in much of the dialogue. Humphrey Bogart didn't know what to make of this self-proclaimed "fairy" at first. Bogie kept his distance. Capote finally broke through with Bogart when he challenged Bogie to arm-wrestle. Bogart laughed in his face, and then promptly lost the wrestling-match to Truman. Instead of being a bad loser, Bogart clapped Truman on the back, congratulating him. Truman had won his trust, by beating his ass. Bogart later wrote to Bacall, "Wait until you meet our screenwriter. You have never seen anything like him. At first, I didn't think he was for real - but he grows on you, and now I'd like to carry him around in my pocket, and take him out whenever I need a laugh."
Gerald Clarke wrote a biography of Truman Capote which is a classic in the genre. I read it years ago, but it is one of my cherished books, and I dip into it often.
A couple days ago, I picked it up again, to read the whole section on the writing of In Cold Blood. I had forgotten much of it.
Truman Capote said later that if he had known what he was getting into, when he traveled down to Kansas ("a fairy down on the prairie - who'd have thought?") to write a piece on the murder for The New Yorker, then he never would have gone. He went to Kansas only 2 weeks after the murders took place. The killers had still not been found, the community was in an uproar of suspicion and paranoia. Capote's main interest was to do a long profile of the townspeople, how regular church-going farmers handled such a disaster. Little did he know what the book would eventually be! The project took up years of his life. He had to wait for the executions of the 2 murderers, in order to complete his book. So he waited, and waited. Appeal after appeal ...He was unable to write anything else. Nothing else interested him. He was a man obsessed, in the grip of his obsession for years. His health was ruined. His friends were sick of hearing about the Clutter family. He tried to take vacations with his long-time partner, and would just drink, and try to sleep, and have fits of despair. He thought those boys would never be executed, he thought he would be in limbo forever. Yet - the morbidness of his entire life being on hold because of commuted death-sentences in Kansas - the morbidness of trying to go on, when really all you want is for those 2 boys to be killed - so that YOU can go back to YOUR life ... This paid a huge toll on him.
Finally - there were no more appeals and Capote traveled to Kansas, to watch the execution. Hickock and Smith had asked him to be there. In the intervening years, he had interviewed the 2 killers numerous times. Their first-person descriptions of their own sorry lives make up important parts of the book. Capote became their conduit to the outside world. Hickock would draw self-portraits of himself and send them to Capote. Capote was playing a double-edged game here. He became "the listener", the one who would sit and ask them questions, and nod understandingly. The 2 of them got addicted to his concern. Yet Capote was horrified by most of what he heard. He wasn't without pity for these men, who had pretty much been beaten like dogs from the second they were born - and yet Capote hadn't had an easy road either, and HE hadn't killed anyone in cold blood. He had grown up with alcoholics, he had been abandoned by his father, his parents were ashamed of having a "fairy" for a son, he was sent to military school - can you imagine how awful that must have been for him? Capote may have acted like a cream-puff but that man was cold and hard as steel inside. He had to be.
Capote needed quotes, he needed access, he needed to enter into the psychologies of these 2 men. He was able to paint the graphic picture of the Clutter family through interviews with people who knew and loved them. But the Clutters were no longer around to speak for themselves. Hickock and Smith were alive for a couple of years, so he visited them often. On his way out of Death Row, he would feel the urge to vomit. It would take him days to recover, emotionally, from these macabre "visits". And he said, later, that he never recovered from the "shattering" experience of watching the two men hang. The letters he wrote to friends afterwards are nearly incoherent. Watching how hard the hanging body clings to life, watching the kicking feet, the flailing, the letting-go of bodily functions ... Capote was really never the same man again.
And he then sat down and wrote the book like a bat out of hell.
Truman Capote always thought that he had a "great book" in him. This mythical "great book" haunted his dreams, he would lie awake at night aching with ambition, dreaming about this great book ... He never thought In Cold Blood was it. He looked back on the experience of researching that book and writing it as a grim one, an almost universally unpleasant and grueling experience. I've read all of Capote's books. I love that guy's writing style. I even read his unfinished work - the 2 chapters of the novel he was working on when he died. He claimed to have it almost finished, but the rest of it (if it even existed) was never found. The 2 chapters are okay - it's a gossipy bitchy look at high-class New York society. It's merciless. It's very funny. Nobody is spared. Human beings are seen in their worst lights. Everyone is selfish, cynical, out for themselves ... It is quite funny, but it's very very mean. He was nearing the end of his life, and he had been abandoned by most of his friends. His outlook was not good, he was addicted to drugs, filled with anxiety and loneliness ... The 2 chapter are his way of lashing out at all those people who left him, who tossed him out with the trash. Hence, the mean-ness.
The thing in the rest of Capote's writing that, for me, sets him apart is his undeniable love of humanity. His tenderness. His ability to SEE people, with all their flaws - and to see them as beautiful. Much of his best writing is all about nostalgia, wistfulness, yearning for childhood ... Yes, it is sentimental, but it also has a depth of sadness beneath it, a grief ... which elevates it from mawkishness.
In Cold Blood taps into something else. In Cold Blood doesn't fit into either of the Capote categories: the bitchy mean queen telling all the nasty secrets of his high-class friends, or the lonely sweet man filled with hurtful nostalgia for childhood.
It was something completely new. For him, and for us. I don't even know if I can describe it. All I can say is - he never accomplished such a thing again. His writing never seemed so effortless again. You read that book and you feel like if you cut ONE WORD, the entire thread will unravel. It is so tight.
The other thing I had forgotten from the biography is Capote's personal experience leaving his home-environment of ritzy New York City (where there were lots of "fairies"), and venturing into the Kansas prairies to investigate a murder. Capote was openly gay. He wasn't a macho gay, either. He didn't try to blend in, or act straight, or hide his gayness. He was a small rotund man, who wore wide white hats, spoke with a lisp, fluttered about like Blanche DuBois, and literally said things like, "I declare!"
He took one of his best friends, Harper Lee (yes - THAT Harper Lee) as a co-researcher. She was much more "normal"-acting, and was able to blend in a bit more. She could get people to talk to her, because she seemed like one of them.
But Truman Capote was so relentless, and not only so relentless, but so committed to justice, so committed to discovering what had happened in the Clutter household, that people started opening up. The people in the town started competing about who had had him over for dinner the most times. Alvin Dewey, the head of the investigation, a tough gruff 3 pack a day smoker, eventually counted Truman as a valued partner. Truman was there when Dewey got the call that the 2 murderers had been picked up in Las Vegas, AND that they were still wearing the boots with the distinctive soles (that had left footprints - If the 2 hadn't confessed, the boots alone would have convicted them). Truman was standing right there, with Dewey's wife, listening to Dewey hear the news.
The people of Kansas, who had never met a person like Capote in their lives, who were Bible-Belt ranchers and farmers, took him into their homes, their hearts, their families. Without them, the book would not be what it is.
It is a massive accomplishment. The power of his personality, the depth of how he listened, and sympathised - must have been extraordinary.
I know that Truman Capote always thought that his "great book" remained unwritten ... but I beg to differ.
Nobel laureate Czeslaw Milosz has died, at the age of 93. Strange, but my eyes filled up with tears when I heard. His poetry has always meant a great deal to me - and I am thankful to my sister Siobhan for introducing his work to me.
Known for his poetry, yes, he also is known for his continuous and courageous denunciation of evil, and of telling the truth about communism, and dictatorships. His life is a tale of inspiration, and bravery. He grew up in Poland, and lived under first the Nazis, and then under communism - before finally fleeing to the United States. He had seen it all. After Poland wrenched itself free in 1989, he moved back to Krakow. God. To wait that long to go home. His poetry, then, is the poetry of persistent exile. Maybe that's why it has such sweet melancholy, such clarity. He was always known as an "intellectual", whatever that means. To me it means a certain kind of writer, usually of the Eastern European variety. Writers who write with a certain abstract distance, perhaps because they have seen so much tyranny, they feel an urgency to try to describe it - writers who contemplate the big questions, and try to find new forms with which to express themselves - writers like Milan Kundera, Vaclav Havel, Kafka, Czeslaw Milosz.
Yet somehow - these "intellectual" writers do not sacrifice the heart. Their writing does not come off as cold. Or clinical. On the contrary. It pulses with life, humanity, compassion.
For example, here is Milosz's poem "Encounter". I cannot read it without feeling a lump rise in my throat, and I have read it countless times. Notice the sparseness of the language (which may be due to it being a translation, not sure - he wrote in Polish, it was almost a political act for him to do so) - notice the cold clarity of the images ... and then notice how he bursts forth into warmth in the last lines.
Encounter
We were riding through frozen fields in a wagon at dawn.
A red wing rose in the darkness.
And suddenly a hare ran across the road.
One of us pointed to it with his hand.
That was long ago. Today neither of them is alive,
Not the hare, nor the man who made the gesture.
O my love, where are they, where are they going
The flash of a hand, streak of movement, rustle of pebbles.
I ask not out of sorrow, but in wonder.
Here's another extraordinary poem. I'm no literary scholar or anything, but the images in this poem terrify me - and I can guess why. There's a sense of human beings being ground up, chewed up - a monster from the deep rising to engulf us all ... We are all 'so little'.
The poem is called "So Little".
So Little
I said so little.
Days were short.
Short days.
Short nights.
Short years.
I said so little.
I couldn't keep up.
My heart grew weary
From joy,
Despair,
Ardor,
Hope.
The jaws of Leviathan
Were closing upon me.
Naked, I lay on the shores
Of desert islands.
The white whale of the world
Hauled me down to its pit.
And now I don't know
What in all that was real.
Maybe the writers trapped in Eastern European countries, or living in exile, felt too much, and yet they were determined, above all else, to describe the tyranny under which they lived, the double-tyranny actually: the tyranny of fascism or communism, and the tyranny of being an artist in such societies. Artists were usually the first ones attacked - most of all, the writers. Writers are dangerous, after all!! Most had to flee in order to continue writing. Others, like Havel, stayed put - and lived a life of persecution and constant imprisonment, refusing to shut up - and a life where his plays would never be produced in his own country, and yet were huge successes the world over. Like Havel said, "I decided to behave AS IF I were free."
So the poems, the plays, the books of these writers - are much more than what is on the printed page. They are affirmations of the human spirit. They are a testament to the difficulties inherent in even getting the damn thing published in their own country. They are EVIDENCE that you can NOT hold people down forever. You may control a person's movements, a person's ability to travel ... but you can NOT control what goes on in that person's head. No matter how hard you try.
I am grateful to Czeslaw Milosz, for his courage, his gift, and his persistence. He's an inspiration.
If you're interested - here is the speech he gave in 1981, accepting his Nobel Prize in Literature. It's a doozy - I highly recommend it. This is a man, a Polish man, in exile - it is 1981 - the Solidarity movement was just heating up, things were starting to shift, crack, break apart ... Milosz had lived long enough to see it. Freedom was still almost a decade away, but the spirit of that exhilarating time in history is in his speech.
In it, Milosz says, "In a room where people unanimously maintain a conspiracy of silence, one word of truth sounds like a pistol shot."
He was that pistol shot. It was his destiny to be so.
Rest in peace, sir.
August 5th, 1939 - from Anne Lindbergh's journal - continued from this excerpt
I go ahead with supper, talking about Russia and aviation ... He talks about desert flying, the variety it had, in the sands.And I quote TE Lawrence saying that he liked the "variety of taste" in water. Water, which seemed so much alike to most people, had more variety than the Alps.
"Oui," he says, "I felt just like him about the sands."
He goes on to speak of the beauty of the desert and how enhanced it was by danger. He tells of returning on a flight over the desert when it was safe. It seemed to him flat and uninteresting until he was shot at -- and then suddenly it was beautiful again.
...C. finally appears [This is Charles Lindbergh] ... I drop back in relief, I am so glad he is there....He takes his supper on a tray and over the tray carries on the torch of conversation, which immediately goes up a level, takes on a higher, less feminine tone. [Hm. Notice how she belittles herself here, and how she belittles the feminine tone. It is not as "high". This is just a guess, but I bet St.-Ex preferred his conversation with HER to the purely technical one he had with her husband. St.Ex blends the practical with the romantic. Anne was ALL romance. Charles was ALL practicality. St.-Ex had wanted to meet HER, first and foremost, not her famous flying husband.]
I sit back and translate. They compare notes, on that thrilling period in aviation which is past.
"But I never know," St.-Ex says, laughing, "whether it is not my own youth I am regretting."
They discuss the place of the machine in modern life. St.-Ex's theory is that it is not directly the fault of the machine that man has become more material, but that it is due to a combination of things which have so changed his world that he is like a foreigner in it -- more a foreigner than the early English transplanted to America. And it has taken them 300 years to begin to have a culture. He is optimistic that man will come out on top of the machine -- use it as a tool for greater spiritual ends.
The trend toward a spiritual revival is already here, St.-Ex says, witness the return to nature, camping, etc., witness even these movements like Communism and Fascism (which he dislikes but which he regards as a symptom). And what man seeks and wants he will find -- he always has.
C. is less hopeful, or rather, more practical, taking a nearer view of it and the suffering involved, and what road to choose.
And all this from French into English and vice versa, my mind panting in the traces.
Here's my intro to this little series.
Part I, from Lindbergh's journal
A couple more to come. She wrote a ton about her one night meeting with this man.
August 5th, 1939 - from Anne Lindbergh's journal - continued from this excerpt
[St.-Ex and I talked] of translations -- the difficulties of: "There is a German poet I like very much, who excites me more than anyone I have read ina long time," I start to say.
"Rainer Maria Rilke," he finishes quietly for me.
"But how did you know?" I ask, astonished. He just waves his hands a little and smiles.
"Il a pris le chemin interieur," ("He has chosen the inner road.") I say.
"Oui," again smiling, with perfect understanding.
It is his life that interests me, I say, his inner struggle, and Van Gogh's too. What I don't like in Van Gogh, I say, is that he forces it on you, does it with the fist. It is German, whereas Cezanne simply holds it out in his hands, to take. (But he thinks Van Gogh has more). But still, I finish, perhaps it isn't fair to say that -- so much of one's judgment is the stage of life ... He finishes for me. "The stage one happens to be in oneself."
... I realize now, looking back, that I talked too much. It ran over like joy -- like a child, like Land [one of her sons] showing me his treasures. "Regarde! Regarde!" Like talking to Margot, the first time I met her ... -- the desire to throw out the rope and see how much they'll take. Is it slack? No, it's taut -- all taken!
"I feel as though I had been sleeping for years or had lain in the lowest hold of a ship that, loaded with heavy things, sailed through strange distances. Oh, to climb up on deck once more and feel the winds and the birds, and to see how the great, great nights come with their gleaming stars..." (Rilke)...
That strange childish desire to give it all -- "It is so vast an alleviation" as V. Woolf says.
Of Americans being closer to the French than to the English. Of the childlike quality of Americans I noticed everywhere on coming back from abroad. He agreed: "Yes, but that I find very refreshing."
Of living abroad and how it dislodges you for good. Of the French being closer to the soil, able to revive, come back. The separation in England between classes.
Of flying -- had I taken a license? I found I was saying, "Before I was married I had not lived in the world of action at all. Then I felt it was the only world and that my world must be thrown away -- it didn't count for anything; only action counted, and so I did all that ... but now ..."
He smiled. "Oui," and went on to ask had I gone into biology, too. [Charles had taken up a huge interest in biology.] No, I hadn't, I answered, adding that I thought there was a danger when husbands and wives were in the same profession. I quoted D.H. Lawrence saying of marriage that man and woman should be like the two poles which hold the world between them. "Oh -- pas si loin que tout ca!" ("Oh -- not as far off as all that!") He laughed, and then gave a definition of his own, an image of the bees, gathering honey from different sources, and each bringing it home to the hive.
At some point I talk to him about Whitehead and his Adventures of Ideas. I quote, "Adventure rarely reaches its predetermined end ..."
"It never reaches it," he interrupts, with a sigh.
But I go on trying to translate the place in Whitehead where he speaks of the waves of new ideas beating on civilization, adventure being always part of the new idea: "Without adventure a civilization is in full decay." But I find it hard to translate, from memory, too, and finally I say in discouragement:
"Mais, je dis les choses banales." ("I am just saying banalities.")
"Oh, non -- moi, j'avais toujours eu ces idees, mais je ne les ai jamais vues autre part," he reassures me. ("Oh no -- I, I have always had these ideas, but I have never seen them anywhere else.")
[Note from Sheila: Hm. No wonder Charles got jealous.]
By the time we got to Huntington, looking at each station hopefully, I was beginning to feel terrified that this pitch would break and worried about talking too much and boring him. I hoped against hope that C. would be at the station. But he wasn't.
We took a taxi.
It was cooler and the trees smelled fresh, of rain and honeysuckle.
When we got to the house (Thor barking and leaping, Jon calling from the window, "Did you find a turtle?") I was really dashed to find that not only was C. not there, but there was no word from him. I felt wiolted. Will we have the whole evening alone? If only C. were here.
[To be continued.]
August 5th, 1939 - from Anne Lindbergh's journal
We call Saint-Exupery. He is there, he speaks "pas un mot" of English. I have to talk to him. Heavens! What a prospect! Yes, he would be delighted to come out for dinner and then ight. C. is going to pick him up in town...
At 3, in the middle of my nap, C. calls from upper New York, says he can't make it, and will I call for St.-Ex. And I had counted on that time to finish the book. [Ed: She was racing through Wind, Sand and Stars] Now what would I talk to him about?
The car is being fixed for flat tires. I tear into town, rather cross to be late -- "toujours un petit peu en retard!" [Ha. In this, she quotes St. Ex's preface to on eof her books, where he characterizes her as the little girl who is "slower" than everyone else, the little girl who is always late.]
M. St-Ex., they say, is in the bar. (Heavens, I think, he is one of those drunken aviators -- why did we do this?) He appears, tall and stooped and a little bald, beginning to be not as young as he once was; an inscrutable sort of face, not at all good looking, almost Slavic in its solidity and inscrutability, and his eyes turn up at the corners a little.
Oh -- it's that man, is it? I think, with a confused dream feeling that I have seen him often before -- met him before, even. I recognize him immediately. [Message to Anne from Sheila: RUN, ANNE, RUN FOR YOUR LIFE. The second you feel you have "met him before", warning bells should go off. Ah well, it's too late though. For you, and for me.]...
I apologize for C. and my lateness and we go across to the car and start out.
We hardly get around the block when the car stalls and will not start again. And all this time we are talking at top speed with a kind of intensity (at least on my part) that precludes my attention to practical details. He is talking about the book [her book, Listen! The Wind], how he had not read the first one, how he intended to write simply a polite page about flight or what the name stood for. How he read the book on the boat coming over, how it astonished him ("You know how rare it is to touch in a book..." he said), how he telegraphed the publisher that he must say something more. I was trying to talk back in French, always an effort, talk to a taxi driver who was pushing us, and explain what was wrong with the car in French and then in English, all at the same time.
"But perhaps you do not like the preface ...?"
"Ah oui -- mais vous avez si bien vu ... trop vu ..."
I tell him how I tried to translate it for C. But it was difficult and subtle and how C. did not understand my being always "un peu en retard." He laughs and says he would have said it slightly differently -- "a hesitancy..."
Finally we pull up to a repair shop where a group of taxi drivers decide that it is the pump and that it will take two hours to fix! ... We get into a taxi and start for Pennsylvania Station -- still talking furiously. He talks about the rhythm in writing, which he thinks is almost the most important thing in a book -- as I understand it. That only the conscious gets across in words, the unconscious in the rhythm.
I tell him how much we liked his books and wanted to meet him. How C. read his book and liked it, about his being a spectator and actor at the same time, and how the only other person I could remember having that combination was T.E. Lawrence. He says he felt the separation between action and vision was less than people supposed -- a theory I don't quite believe.
"But life is always pulling you away from the understanding of life," I said.
"Yes -- that is always the troulbe," he answers.
Then we were at Pennsylvania Station, I almost as much a stranger as he. We had an orangeade at a counter, still talking, like children on those high stools ...
"But how do you get on by yourself?"
"Tres bien..." on the theory that when one cannot speak at all one meets on a different level -- of human kindness and understanding -- which is true. I felt gay, freed and happy. I and this absolute stranger who understood so well everything I said and felt!
Then onto the train ...
And we go on talking all the way to Huntington, in French ... It was very exciting. Perhaps it was only because it was almost the first time anyone had talked to me purely on my craft. Not because I was a woman to be polite to, to charm with superficials, not because I was my father's daughter or C's wife; no, simply because of my book, my mind, my craft. I have a craft. And someone who is master of that craft, who writes beautifully, thinks I know enough about my craft to want to compare notes about it, to want to fence with my mind, steel against steel.
He pulls the preface out of his pocket and we go over the words I didn't understand. "Mais ca ... comme c'est beau!" I say.
"And here -- only, you know, it is not my husband, that. C'est moi, ce n'est pas mon mari. Il n'a pas peur. Il n'est pas timide. Il ne pense pas a ca ..." He smiles. "Je sais -- je sais." [Ed: She's cautioning him that the timidness she expresses in the book, her fear, is all her - Charles isn't timid, he has none of that. St.Ex says he knows.]
My heavens, what a joy it was to talk, to compare, to throw things out, to be understood like that without an effort. Summer lightning.
Of course, I was warmed by the praise and opened to it, as one does. He said there was something classical about the book, something fundamental, like a Greek play. And he was astonished to find it in America.
I said perhaps the reason it appealed to the layman was that aviation was not my world. I was a foreigner to it.
He said that had nothing to do with it whatsoever. That the writer, like the bee, gathers honey from whatever circumstances he happens to be in, and I had done that and it would not have mattered what I had written about.
And somewhere we were talking about aviation -- I telling him that C. thinks it is encouraging that the tools of war require more and more intelligence and in that there is hope. But he countered: "Mais je ne suis pas tout a fait de son avis." ("But I don't quite share his opinion.") And I said, desperately, "It seems that nature is always pushing us down onto all fours again. As soon as a nation is civilized."
"But man has always succeeded in rising again," St.-Ex said.
I talked about flying, too, how it did not separate you from the elements, but, rather, bathed you in them.
I said, looking up at him, astonished. "But you have said that."
"Yes, I have said that ..."
We talked of Americans and the Puritan backgrond. Perhaps it is that, I said, that gives us our sense of pressure, of hurry, of being late.
Talking in French about ideas that are so deeply rooted in me in English, ideas that are barely communicable in your own language, to say them in a foreign language you are not the master of, was really a kind of anguish. I beat my wings against it in vain. Never have I felt so frustrated by that wall of incommunicability. And yet it was amazing that we could communicate at all.
[To be continued.]
Here's my introduction to all of this.
For those of you who are St.-Ex fans, or fans of flying, or fans of WRITING - the following excerpts from Anne Lindbergh's journals are for you.
August 4th 1939
C. [Ed: Charles Lindbergh - she always refers to him as "C" in her journals] hands me a letter and preface by Antoine de Saint-Exupery to my (French) edition of Listen! The Wind, just sent here. I start to read it through supper. The letter says that he had agreed to write a one-page preface before he had read the book but after reading it he had written nine pages, and here it was. I read it haltingly; the French is very subtle and full of meaning. I am much absorbed, not only with the importance he attaches to the book and his analysis of it -- which is intensely beautiful -- but I am startled by what he has seen of me."Il est ainsi une petite fille qui court moins vite que les autres. La-bas les autres jouent. 'Attendez-moi! Attendez-moi!' mais elle est un peu en retard, on va se lasser de l'attendre, on va la laisser en arriere, on va l'oublier seule au monde. Comment la rassurerait-on? Cette forme d'angoisse est inguerissable." ("There is a little girl who runs more slowly than the others. Over there the others are playing. 'Wait for me! Wait for me!' Already she is late, they will get tired of waiting for her, they will leave her behind, she will be forgotten and left alone in the world. How can she be reassured? This kind of anguish is incurable.")
Did I so strip myself in that book? I had no idea that was there -- or even in my life -- that "angoisse legere". But it is, of course, that feeling of pressure (that C. tries to cure), inner pressure, that I have not learned to harness. "Chariots at the breast." But it has colored the book. It has crept out. I am rather upset.
The note from the publisher says that St.-Exupery would like to meet me. C. is going to call the hotel tomorrow. I am rather afraid to meet him.
I get down Wind, Sand and Stars. It is incredibly beautiful and gripping. It is all I ever wanted to say and more of flying and time and human relationships.
I have been wanting to post an entry from Anne Lindbergh's journal (actually a couple entries) for a long time (especially since the recent revelations regarding St.-Ex's plane.) The entry describes the first (and only) meeting between the Lindberghs and St.-Exupery.
I've read Anne Morrow Lindbergh's journals (5 volumes of them) more times than I can count. I've also read her beautiful book Gift from the Sea many times, usually in dark passages of my life. It's a great comfort. She has a couple of aviation books out, too, which she wrote early on in her marriage - when she and Charles were flying about the world, in their tiny plane. This was, obviously, in the infancy of commercial aviation. One of those books is North to the Orient, describing their trip (just after the birth of their doomed first son) flying north - up through Canada - up to the northern wilds of that vast country - across the Bering Sea - and then down the coast of Russia and China. Her writing is quite wonderful, although I always get the feeling that she struggles with the long shadow of her world-famous husband. In my opinion, it's not until she gets out from under HIS interests and HIS concerns, when her writing really blossoms - in Gift from the Sea. But still, it's a very interesting picture of the two of them, their challenges with the airplane, and Anne having to put herself through a rapid learning curve to keep up with Charles, in terms of flying ability. Her other book is called Listen! The Wind - this describes their travels over Europe and North Africa.
Now it is OBVIOUS from reading Anne Lindbergh's journals that this woman can write. She knows how to express herself with great beauty, sensitivity, and vulnerability. She has a gift. However - because she married one of the most famous men in the world, before she was even really a fully formed person (she led a very protected life) - her aviation books fall a bit flat. They certainly aren't classics of the genre, although they do have some merit.
There are 5 volumes of her journals. The first one, Bring Me a Unicorn is from her girlhood, her years at Smith college, and her time in Mexico City with her family. Her father, Dwight Morrow, was ambassador to Mexico. This was how Charles Lindbergh came into her life. He flew down to Mexico in ... 1928, I think?? Can't remember. Anyway, Anne was barely out of her teens, had never had a boyfriend, and was a shy bookish dreamy-eyed romantic girl. (And through her life, she remains rather dreamy-eyed and romantic.) Charles was definitely of the world, a man of action, not words or deep feelings. But sparks flew between this unlikely pair, and after a whirlwind romance they got married. I love her writing about their "dates" - which consist of the two of them flying around in his plane, basically to escape the hounding of the press. Of course, the engines were so loud that they couldn't even TALK to each other, but would pass notes back and forth. On the basis of this, she fell head over heels in love with him.
The second volume is called, appropriately, Hour of Gold, Hour of Lead. This is the volume of their early marriage, the excitement of it, for both of them. Their relationship is passionate, connected, thrilling. They have a son. They take a months-long trip to the Orient. This is the "hour of gold". They return home, and then comes the "hour of lead" - the kidnapping and murder of their son.
The third volume is called Locked Rooms and Open Doors. This is the stunned aftermath of the nightmare. They begin to have more children. They travel, extensively. Through Europe, Africa, Russia. The press will not let up - they get more death threats - they fear for the lives of their children - and so they move to Europe.
The fourth volume is called The Flower and the Nettle. Charles, Anne, and their growing family, move at first to England. But the press still won't let them alone. And so they rent a small stone castle on an isolated island off the coast of France, where they hope they will be left alone. During this volume, the forces of evil are growing in Germany. It is during this volume that Charles begins his love affair with German might which will make him, basically, Public Enemy #1 for years - actually, until the end of his life. You get the uneasy feeling, in this volume, that the Lindberghs are WAY out of their depth.
The final volume is calld War Within and War Without. The Lindberghs move back to America, at the outbreak of war. They live on Long Island. They now have 5 children. Anne is struggling to find her OWN way, her own life, separate from her husband. Charles gets involved with the America First movement, during WWII - trying to keep America out of the war. He becomes an enormously controversial figure. So does she. Her support of her husband causes a break to occur between her and her family. Her family, the Morrows, have contempt for Charles' views, etc. etc. The Lindberghs find themselves in the middle of a firestorm. And actually - Charles goes forward, and does what he likes, regardless of the consequences. Anne backs him up, because she doesn't want to abandon her husband - and yet her journals are filled with tormented questions. She reads the speeches he wants to make, and begs him to edit them, to soften them. He refuses. He's kind of an ass, to be honest. I won't take away from him his original accomplishment in flight - and from reading these journals so many times, there are many many qualities of this man (as a husband, I mean) that I find very attractive. Very sweet. But still. His position during WWII was idiotic.
It is during this final volume, in 1939, to be exact - that Antoine de Saint-Exupery comes into their lives.
St.-Ex wrote the preface to the French edition of Anne Lindbergh's book Listen! The Wind. She was beyond thrilled about this. It seemed to her a validation of her worth - not just as a woman married to this "great man", but on her own - a writer in her own right. Anne had also written a review of his book Wind, Sand and Stars - so even though it was through Charles that their paths crossed - it was on the level as WRITERS that the two connected.
Truth be told, Anne Lindbergh was completely swept away by her 2-day meeting with St.-Ex. Listen to how she writes about him in her journal. She falls in love with him, in an emotional "we are soulmates" kind of way. (The most dangerous kind of love. Ouch. I know this from experience.) She reveals, to her journal, how lonely it is, at times, in her marriage to Charles. She yearns for communion of this kind, she longs for validation as being separate from her husband, yadda yadda.
When St.-Ex disappears, in 1944, she goes into a tailspin. She hadn't seen him SINCE their meeting in 1939. But she obviously carried an invisible torch for him. Like: "as long as I know that there is a man like that out there, existing in the world, I will be all right..."
He is "the other man" in her life. She went into a deep depression. Charles basically knew all of this was going on, and would make joking comments: "I suppose I should be jealous of him ..."
I post this for my own pleasure, but I also post this because I know I have many aviation-nut readers, as well as actual pilots. I hope you enjoy this entry from Anne Lindbergh's journal.
I'll post it shortly.
is the Bulwer-Lytton Fiction Contest. Thanks to Mr. Z for forwarding the results of this year's contest to me.
So what is this contest? And who the hell is Bulwer-Lytton? I actually have a vast store of useless knowledge about this man, because he was the favorite writer of Lucy Maud Montgomery, when she was a kid. Because of my obsession with HER, I actually read some of Bulwer-Lytton's stuff.
His is the purplest of purple purple prose. LM Montgomery later looked back on his stuff and thought, "What was I THINKING?" and yet she always defended him, because in doing so, she honored how much she had loved him when she was young.
Now - onto the contest-description:
An international literary parody contest, the competition honors the memory (if not the reputation) of Victorian novelist Edward George Earl Bulwer-Lytton (1803-1873). The goal of the contest is childishly simple: entrants are challenged to submit bad opening sentences to imaginary novels. Although best known for "The Last Days of Pompeii" (1834), which has been made into a movie three times, originating the expression "the pen is mightier than the sword," and phrases like "the great unwashed" and "the almighty dollar," Bulwer-Lytton opened his novel Paul Clifford (1830) with the immortal words that the "Peanuts" beagle Snoopy plagiarized for years, "It was a dark and stormy night."
And here are the 2004 winners and runners-up. These are CLASSIC!!
The winner, Dave Zobel, came up with this bad opening sentence:
She resolved to end the love affair with Ramon tonight . . . summarily, like Martha Stewart ripping the sand vein out of a shrimp's tail . . . though the term "love affair" now struck her as a ridiculous euphemism . . . not unlike "sand vein," which is after all an intestine, not a vein . . . and that tarry substance inside certainly isn't sand . . . and that brought her back to Ramon.
But all the entries are hysterical.
This one, sent in by Siew-Fong Yiap of Hong Kong might be my favorite:
The legend about Padre Castillo's gold being buried deep in the Blackwolf Hills had lain untold for centuries and will continue to do so for this story is not about hidden treasure, nor is it set in any mountainous terrain whatsoever.
HA!!
This one, though, is pretty damn good, too - It's a parody of Bulwer-Lytton's "dark and stormy night" line:
It was a stark and dormy night--the kind of Friday night in the dorm where wistful women/girls without dates ovulated pointlessly and dreamed of steamy sex with bad boy/men in the backseat of a Corvette--like the one on Route 66, only a different color, though the color was hard to determine because the TV show was in black and white--if only Corvettes had back seats.
Jesus. "Ovulated pointlessly" ... ha ... sounds like my life!
Anyway, read them all, and laugh!!
Thanks to CityIslandMichael - I came across this in the New York Post:
ERNEST Hemingway was once challenged to write a story in six words. The result: "For sale: baby shoes, never used." It's rumored that Hemingway thought it was his greatest work, and it's invariably offered as the standard to which micro-fiction should aspire.
So - other writers have taken up the challenge and have come up with their own 6 word stories.
Read them here (I can't stand Rick Moody - what an over-rated nitwit) - and see what you think. Hemingway, in my opinion, towers above them all. He evokes an entire WORLD of loss in his, don't you think?
Now, of course, I'm trying to think of my own.
Once Upon a Time. The End.
Read this whole thread. People are posting their favorite words.
I mean, you just have to love a thread where the word "bumbershoot" comes up.
Now reminder - because this always happens when any "word" thing comes up: This is about favorite WORDS, not favorite CONCEPTS.
It always annoyed me at the Inside the Actors Studio seminars when people were asked in the questionnaire at the end "what is your favorite word" and their answer would be "love". Or "courage". Or whatever. Concepts. These are concepts. The word encompasses the concept, yes, of course. But word??
Your favorite word may be "muck", because you like the sound of it - but you may find that muck itself is kind of a gross thing. One person on the thread I link to says their favorite word is "syphilis" - and then hastens to add: "For the sound of it, not the meaning!"
It was refreshing when Holly Hunter came to do the seminar (on my birthday, as I recall) and she thought about it for a long long time, and then said, "Portentous. I just like saying it. Por-ten-tous."
My kind of chick.
My favorite words?
Elixir
Evensong
Nonsense
Symmetrical
Mash
Bailiwick
Bailiwick. Yum. I love that.
I also like crepescular.
(via Book Slut)
Great article in The New Yorker about writer's block - the modern conception of it, the misconceptions about it, the developing understanding of the art of writing itself - the changing of styles.
I was especially struck by the part where Joyce Carol Oates (whom I love) - who is very prolific - she's written 38 novels, countless essays, short stories - the woman is non-STOP - Anyway, I was very struck by the fact that many critics view her very speed of output as indicative that her work and her thought must be shallow.
[Oates] has had to answer rude questions about her rate of production. “Is there a compulsive element in all this activity?” one interviewer asked her.
Very interesting.
I've never really had writer's block. I can always pick up a pen and just go. Whether or not the writing is GOOD is another story.
I've got other kinds of blocks, but not that one.
I remember reading Sylvia Plath's journals (long ago - before they were re-issued in the un-edited version after Ted Hughes' death) - She was one of those people in college who always has her eye on the ball, she kept obsessive reports on where she sent her poems out, how much magazines paid - She wrote gushing letters home to her mother (sometimes 3 or 4 letters a DAY) - telling her that this magazine published that poem, and on and on and on ...
Her work was ever-flowing. She was an unbelievably driven individual, perfectionistic, and ambitious. Her early poems are a bit stilted - she hasn't broken free into her own form yet - and you can FEEL, while reading her early stuff, that she composed them with a Thesaurus nearby.
Plath gets a Fulbright. Moves to England. Meets Ted Hughes. Bites him on the cheek at a raucous party of poets. They are married 4 months later. He was already considered a genius in many circles, his poems vibrant, mythical, filled with nature, and the smell of mud.
Hughes had a very craftsmanlike approach to his work. He sat down and he wrote everyday.
But from almost the moment Plath got married, her process shifted. She stopped being able to write. She tried. But it was a struggle. She looked up to Hughes, who was already on his way to becoming famous. Perhaps she looked up to him too much and that stifled her own voice. Who knows.
In 1959, the 2 of them left England - and both got teaching jobs at universities in Massachusetts.
And that's where her real writer's block began.
Ironically - it was being close to her mother (the very mother whom she used to write to obsessively about her writing - The ink was barely dry on the poem before she sent it off to her mother) that really stopped up Plath's voice.
She didn't write anything (besides her journal) for a year and a half. The journals of that time are agonizing to read.
Plath started to put it all together - over that terrible year and a half: She would offer up her poems to her mother, because she was desperate for approval. It was like getting an A on a pop quiz. Poetry wasn't really art yet, to her - at least not in anything but an abstract art-appreciation kind of way. Her process was facile, the results a bit shallow - and poetry was way too connected to getting her mother to approve of her life.
Once she moved back to England with Hughes - her work took a turn. I have read the collected work of Sylvia Plath from beginning to end, and you can almost feel when she uncorks the bottle. The voices are as different as night and day.
Poets who had only known her as Hughes' American wife, who knew her only from her stilted sonnets published in literary magazines, were shocked - that these rageful evocative funny MEAN (God, is she mean!) poems were written by the same woman.
Plath's descriptions of her writer's block - that time living in America - are painful, she felt like she was dying. Like her life had added up to nothing. Without her voice, she had nothing.
Maybe, though, it took that long dormant time of misery and living under some kind of self-imposed gag rule - to help her eventually bust out with such force.
Of course, she ended up committing suicide - so there is that element of her art to contend with as well - but I still find the entire topic very interesting.
Long tangent - didn't mean to go off like that. If you're interested in writers, here's the article. Lots of good quotes.
"Before a war military science seems a real science, like astronomy; but after a war it seems more like astrology."
-- Rebecca West
I adore this one. It makes me laugh.
"The main difference between men and women is that men are lunatics and women are idiots."-- Rebecca West
"Just how difficult it is to write biography can be reckoned by anybody who sits down and considers just how many people know the real truth about his or her love affairs."
-- Rebecca West
"It is always one's virtues and not one's vices that precipitate one into disaster."
-- Rebecca West
HA!
This one is pretty famous.
"I only know that people call me a feminist whenever I express sentiments that differentiate me from a doormat or a prostitute."-- Rebecca West
"God forbid that any book should be banned. The practice is as indefensible as infanticide."
-- Rebecca West
I've already posted this one - but it's too good to ignore. Here it is again.
"A strong hatred is the best lamp to bear in our hands as we go over the dark places of life, cutting away the dead things men tell us to revere."-- Rebecca West
Now: Another one of the books I am FINALLY reading is Rebecca West's masterpiece Black Lamb and Grey Falcon - about her travels through Yugoslavia in 1937.
It is massive. The book weighs 5 pounds. I am almost embarrassed when I read it on the bus. It is conspicuously enormous.
The length of the book was what originally kept me from launching into it, even though so many people who I admire love Rebecca West, and reference THAT book as WHY they got into journalism, or WHY they became a writer, etc.
Now that I've begun the book, I can completely see why.
Holy mackerel. Can she write.
Anyone who writes anything about the Balkans must contend with Rebecca West. You will not be doing anything new, you will just be adding onto the work already been done by this extraordinary woman. It is 1937. You can completely see the cataclysm to come - she prophesied it all.
There doesn't seem to me to be one boring paragraph. In a book 1700 pages long or whatever, that is some feat.
There's history, yes. But there are also long descriptions of vigorous conversations before the fire - Croat arguing with Serb arguing with Yugoslav patriot ... everyone drinking plum brandy. She goes to church, describes the native dress, the faces. She picks up on EVERYTHING. You read about the scenery, you get the smells, the sights, the sounds. She does not just focus on politics.
We meet dancers. We meet playwrights. We meet doctors.
I can't believe the scope of the book.
It certainly took some doing to get me to actually pick up and BEGIN this book, but now - I assure you - I will read it through to the end.
Rebecca West deserves a longer post than this one - but here are a couple of quotes I have pulled out - short and sweet. Later, when I have more time, I'll post some excerpts. Damn, this dame could write.
she has always been an idol of mine.
The movie of Wrinkle in Time (a precious book to me, DO NOT MESS with my precious books) airs next Monday.
Madeleine is asked in the interview: Have you seen the movie? Madeleine answers, "Yes."
She is asked: And did it meet expectations?
Madeleine answers, "Oh, yes. I expected it to be bad, and it is."
She is a true goddess to me, someone I have always looked up to, strived to be like.
I wrote her a letter once, when I was in my early 20s, and life was feeling pretty tough, pretty hard. I basically asked her, "How do you keep going? How do you read Anne Frank's diary and not just hate everybody in the world?" (Something along those lines. I was in despair, and she seemed like she might have some answers. And I sent the letter to her publisher.)
Months later, I got a reply.
It was on a pale pale grey stationery, and across the top was emblazoned in a simple font: "MADELEINE". I loved that. The informality of that.
And she wrote me just the most wonderful and encouraging and beautiful letter, it was only a paragraph long. All she said was:
"As long as there have been and continue to be people like .... (and she listed about 20 names, half of whom I had never heard of - but I remember Bach was on there) ... on this earth, I find the strength to go on, and I am able to believe that people are good inside."
She's 85 years old. She's a radical. She reminds me of my Great-Aunt Joan, in some respects. A courageous mind, a fearless intellect, excited to ask the tough questions, and face the mysteries of existence. The only thing there is to fear is rock-hard certainty, and, like Madeleine says about the ignorant fundamentalist Christians who want to ban all her books, they "want a closed system, and I want an open system."
I own every one of her books. So good to "hear" from her, on occasion. So good to know she's still out there.
(via Book Slut)
Update: Anne has some very interesting thoughts on L'Engle, and working out certain hostilities through your fiction. Good stuff.
"I merely took the energy it takes to pout and wrote some blues."
-- Duke Ellington
I actually got some work done yesterday. After all of my procrastination activities. Once I actually get going, I know exactly what I am doing, where I am going, and how to work.
It's just the getting started ...
Oh, and for you other writers out there - I learned (for myself) one of Billy Wilder's 9 rules for writers.
Billy Wilder (and if you don't know who he is ... I just don't know what to say.) He wrote numerous screenplays, directed some of the most popular and successful films of the 20th century - Double Indemnity, Some Like it Hot, Sunset Boulevard, The Apartment ... and on and on and on ...
He is such a good writer that he is studied.
He has these 9 rules for writing (focusing on screenwriting, of course, but it could be relevant for writers of other genres).
And one of them is this:
"If something's not right in the third act, then look for the problem in the first act."
I can't stress how important and how true this is. I mean, it SOUNDS true - but I figured it out for myself this weekend.
An aritcle in the WSJ about Saint-Exupery's writing - which has kind of a hostile tone, in my estimation. Still - definitely worth a read. Definitely worth a read.
Granted, I am biased. Totally biased! Which is why the article may sound more hostile than it actually is. (I use the term "hostile" in a very mild way - I don't mean active violent hostility. Perhaps "gentle contempt" is a more appropriate term.)
To call Saint-Exupery's observations in Le Petit Prince "murky"! Murky? What the hell book were YOU reading, dude? Yeah, Le Petit Prince is one of the most successful and long-running best-sellers of all time because of its "murky observations".
Benjamin Ivry, the author, chooses the following Saint-Exupery sentence as an example of "murkiness": "Friendship is born from an identity of spiritual goals--from common navigation toward a star".
Uh ... sounds crystal-clear to me. Not only do I understand that with my head, but I understand it from my own experience of friendship. Hence: the universal appeal of the book. Ivry sounds hostile to the sentimentality and philosophy of Saint-Exuperty. And, as is probably obvious by now, I enjoy sentiment. I'm a little bit sentimental. (I'm a little bit rock 'n roll). At least, I enjoy sentiment if an author knows how to write it. And Saint-Exupery most certainly does.
One of Saint-Exupery's descendents has apparently just published a book entitled: "L'Inavouable: La France au Rwanda" - which is described as "a bold and courageous indictment of French foreign policy in Rwanda".
Having read Philip Gourevitch's absolutely phenomenal book We Wish to Inform You That Tomorrow We Will be Killed With Our Families: Stories from Rwanda (and if you haven't read it - I literally cannot recommend it highly enough) - I agree that there is quite a lot to indict. And good for Patrick de Saint-Exupery for being brave enough to indict his country's policy.
But something about this article left a sour taste in my mouth.
It's the phenomenon (phenomena?) I see so often these days - but I don't know how to name it. Perhaps it can be encapsulated thus:
"Oh my goodness, I totally agree with everything you say - and therefore I LOVE you." (The person may be an absolute moron, but if you agree with his opinions, then he is your dearest brother.) Or, on the flip-side: "Hmm. I really don't agree with a couple of things that you say. Therefore I regard you with suspicion." (The person may be an absolute gem, a beautiful human being, but you happen to differ with them on important issues - therefore the person is written off.)
That's how the article in the WSJ read to me. Am I wrong? It's highly possible. I haven't had my second cup of coffee yet. It reads to me like this:
Oh, so we AGREE with Patrick Saint-Exupery - so he should be commended. We think Antoine is a bit "murky" and "swimmingly vague" - perhaps a bit too touchy-feely New Age ... and so we end the entire article with praise for Patrick, as opposed to praise for the gentleman who wrote a book that has (the article informs us) sold over a million copies every year, from the time it was published. NO books do that. Or only the big ol' famous books. The Road Less Traveled, for example. These books transcend genre, these books will never stop selling. The authors have tapped into something, something primal, something eternal.
It is interesting to contemplate, however, the source of Saint-Exupery's appeal. And again, I am totally biased, because I love his writing (and therefore I submit to the same mentality that Benjamin Ivry displays - except that I am on the opposite side.)
Is it the age-old fascination with flight? And some pilots, while perhaps brilliant technicians, cannot write well? So the pilots who are able to actually write about their experiences will, inevitably, find an audience?
Is it because he disappeared so mysteriously?
I guess for me it is the power of his writing, and also the whimsy of his writing. Basically, I just enjoy reading his prose (although, as I have said before - it's so much better in the French. French translated into English can read quite choppily.)
Antoine St.-Exupery's plane disappeared on July 31, 1944 - and nobody knew what had happened - until now. He vanished off the face of the earth, leaving not a trace of himself behind. (They still don't know why, exactly, his plane went down - but at the time, it was as though the author of Le Petit Prince had flown off through our outer atmosphere, and into the galaxy - not too difficult to imagine, considering the interests of the author. The melancholy and yearning of the author - encapsulated in his little book Le Petit Prince.)
The strange thing for me (and for others) about his disappearance was its correspondence to what happened to The Little Prince in the book.
The Prince appears, randomly, from outer space, from his teeny little planet which he shares with one rose. He appears in the middle of the Sahara Desert and befriends a pilot, sitting beside his plane in the desert. And then - after a relationship develops, the Prince disappeared again - after being bitten by a serpent. Obviously allegorical. But heart-wrenching and simply told. It is not idealogical, or brow-beatingly obvious. It's a fairy tale.
The last line of the book - (I first read it in the original French in high school, and am so grateful that I did - it's meant to be read in French):
"Ne me laissez pas tellement triste: écrivez-moi vite qu'il est revenu... "
"If this should happen, please comfort me. Send me word that he has come back."
Send me word that he has come back.
St.-Exupery's missing plane has been found, missing for all of these years.
Hush'd Be the Camps Today
May 4, 1865
by Walt Whitman
Hush'd be the camps today,
And soldiers let us drape our war-worn weapons,
And each with musing soul retire to celebrate,
Our dear commander's death.
No more for him life's stormy conflicts,
Nor victory, nor defeat -- no more time's dark events,
Charging like ceaseless clouds across the sky.
But sing poet in our name,
Sing of the love we bore him -- because you, dweller in camps, know it truly.
As they invault the coffin there,
Sing -- as they close the doors of earth upon him -- one verse,
For the heavy hearts of soldiers.
John Milton wrote the sonnet "On His Blindness" to himself, to his own encroaching blindness.
I have a fear of going blind myself. (My eyesight is phenomenally bad). My fear of blindness verges on the phobic. It is usually at 3 am, on a sleepless night, when I become CONVINCED that I am going blind, and I will have no one to take care of me, and I don't know how I would survive, and I'm all alone in the world, and I'm going blind, I'm going blind ... You know. The 3 am panic-cycle. Or who knows - maybe you DON'T know about the 3 am panic-cycle, but I definitely do.
John Milton, going blind himself, had to dictate his writing to his daughters, his relatives at the end of his life. ... Some say he did his best work after he became blind. He kept every word he had written in his head, he could see it on the page. Such genius is hard to imagine, hard to comprehend.
Jorge Luis Borges said in a lecture on Milton: "He sacrificed his sight, and then he remembered his first desire, that of being a poet." Blindness catapulted Milton's work to a new level. Similar to what happened to Beethoven's composing, following going deaf.
I think the following poem, "On His Blindness" is one of the best poems ever written.
On His Blindness
by John Milton
When I consider how my light is spent,
Ere half my days, in this dark world and wide,
And that one Talent which is death to hide,
Lodg'd with me useless, though my Soul more bent
To serve therewith my Maker, and present
My true account, least he returning chide,
Doth God exact day-labour, light deny'd,
I fondly ask; But patience to prevent
That murmur, soon replies, God doth not need
Either man's work or his own gifts, who best
Bar his milde yoak, they serve him best, his State
Is Kingly. Thousands at his bidding speed
And post o're Land and Ocean without rest:
They also serve who only stand and waite.
Something about this article reminds me of the thesis put out in this article.
So, the two girls who hit it huge with The Nanny Diaries - (that is a complete understatement - they didn't just hit it huge - they hit the jackpot) have had their second book turned down. Or - not turned down - but returned to them with suggestions for major changes. Our two now-celebrated authors, completely over-praised for their thin accomplishment in their first book, have refused to make the changes.
Life's a bitch, ain't it girls? It's so HARD when you don't hit the jackpot EVERY TIME, isn't it?? Life is so UNFAIR! It must be the fault of the stupid EDITORS!! Don't they know that you've been on the national best-seller list for a year now?? WHAT IS THEIR PROBLEM??
Join the club, morons. You've got to EARN some praise now. You got a lucky break with that first book. The critics gave you pretty much a free pass.
Time to actually WORK now, girls.
To people who have never encountered tough criticism before - because they have been coddled - or over-praised - or straight-out lied to - are MORTIFIED when criticism comes along. It does not fit with their world-view that their finger-painting blobs are like Picassos. A world-view given to them in one unending chorus from Day One. They cannot handle dissension, they cannot handle a ripple in the mirror of any kind. They freak. They blame the judges, they blame the teachers, they blame the editors, the publishers, they blame the public, they blame Simon Cowell (the sharp-tongued American Idol judge who is ruthless in his criticism), they end up blaming their parents who blew the smoke up their asses in the first place.
They refuse to look inward. They refuse to reflect on how they might be able to grow, what they might be able to learn from failure, from criticism.
An excerpt from the second article:
TMPR [Too Much Positive Reinforcement] has now officially reached epidemic proportions. How else to explain the legions of the talent-free who wait in line for days for a chance to show their stuff to Mr. Cowell and company—then are stunned to be told they don’t make the grade? After decades of upper-middle-class parenting designed to shield Junior from all possible failure, and from any honest judgement of his talents, it’s no wonder we need television shows like American Idol and its fellow showcase for TMPR victims, The Apprentice. These shows are delivering the spanking—sorry, the time-out—that our culture of bloated self-evaluation is subconsciously craving. Their success signals that we may be reaching the end of a long national delusion. There is simply not room enough at the top these days for everyone raised to believe they belong there—and, deep down, we all know it.
Leave it to Jon Stewart to sum it all up nicely for us, speaking to Howard Dean:
"When did our elections become the Special Olympics? You’re not all winners. Not everybody gets a hug. You guys got crushed."
A quick personal story:
I was in a production of Golden Boy years ago in Chicago, directed by a brilliant man named Bobby Ellerman. (Read his comment to this post, and you will see what I mean). This man knew his stuff, in terms of acting, and in terms of working with actors. He was fierce, he was tough on all of us, he asked the hard questions, and we all worked our asses off to get the play right.
And one of the actors - can't remember which one - argued with Bobby about one of his directions. He refused to take the criticism, and instead defended his choice. He backed up his case. He explained himself. He would not concede.
Bobby spent some time defending his case - saying, "I see what you're saying - but no - I think it should be this way..."
The actor arguing with Bobby (and every single actor in this production was phenomenal - we are not talking about second-rate amateurs here - these people were, and still are, amazing) - was determined to not let Bobby win. He wanted Bobby to let him do it "his way".
Bobby finally had had enough and BOOMED (nobody could "boom" like Bobby): "LET ME BE RIGHT SO YOU CAN BE BETTER."
I have never ever forgotten those words. There have been so many times, with teachers, or directors, where I want to fight for my way - I want to defend my position. After all, nobody loves to be criticised. Well, masochists do, but normal people don't look forward to another person saying, "That's no good, do it again." But a lot of times, the best thing to do is shut up, take the criticism, and actually GROW, actually LEARN something - actually realize that you don't know everything. (Horrors!!)
And as a quick point: a lot of people out there actually do NOT know what they are doing, and you would be RIGHT to refuse their direction. You must learn to differentiate between criticism that is useless, and criticism that can help you grow. Because theatre is full of bone-heads.
Bobby was not a bone-head.
I have often thought of the lesson I learned on that day during a Golden Boy rehearsal: "Let me be right, so you can be better."
What I have learned is this:
If a piece of criticism comes from someone, and I immediately feel like fighting it - and lashing out - and defending my position - I usually know that that is the very moment when I need to "let them be right so I can be better." Such kneejerk distaste to a critique is your biggest clue that the critic is probably onto something, and you need to shut up and LISTEN.
"It is, I think, true to say that the [British] intelligentsia have been more wrong about the progress of the war than the common people, and that they were more swayed by partisan feelings. The average intellectual of the Left believed, for instance, that the war was lost in 1940, that the Germans were bound to overrun Egypt in 1942, that the Japanese would never be driven out of the lands they had conquered, and that the Anglo-American bombing offensive was making no impression on Germany. He could believe these things because his hatred for the British ruling class forbade him to admit that British plans could succeed. There is no limit to the follies that can be swallowed if one is under the influence of feelings of this kind. I have heard it confidently stated, for instance, that the American troops had been brought to Europe not to fight the Germans but to crush an English revolution. One has to belong to the intelligentsia to believe things like that: no ordinary man could be such a fool. When Hitler invaded Russia, the offiials of the MOI issued "as background" a warning that Russia might be expected to collapse in six weeks. On the other hand the Communists regarded every phase of the war as a Russian victory, even when the Russians were driven back almost to the Caspian Sea and had lost several million prisoners. There is no need to multiply instances. The point is that as soon as fear, hatred, jealousy and power worship are involved, the sense of reality becomes unhinged. And, as I have pointed out already, the sense of right and wrong becomes unhinged also. There is no crime, absolutely none, that cannot be condoned when "our" side commits it. Even if one does not deny that the crime has happened, even if one knows that it is exactly the same crime as one has condemned in some other case, even if one admits in an intellectual sense that it is unjustified -- still one cannot feel that it is wrong. Loyalty is involved, and so pity ceases to function."
-- George Orwell, "Notes on Nationalism", May 1945
Frank J. has a post up right now addressing one of my favorite questions:
Why are certain things funny? Why is it funnier when a certain word is used as a punchline, when a synonym just would not work as well?
This is obviously a topic for people who are not tone-deaf when it comes to comedy.
He uses this as one example:
There was a radio ad for Steven Wright who is appearing at a local auditorium. If you don't know Steven Wright, he's a comedian who speaks in a monotone, bored voice and makes a number of funny statements instead of doing a coherent routine. One of the sound clips in the radio ad was of this joke of his: "Do you think when George Washington was asked for ID, he'd just pull out a quarter?" Now, you could replace "quarter" with "dollar" and the joke would still work, but why is quarter funnier?
For the sake of debate - let's all agree that quarter is funnier. (I do agree with that, by the way.)
You could insert a million other jokes in for that one, and still have the same question. Some things LAND, in terms of comedic potential - other things do not.
I was hanging out with my friend Ann Marie who is, to put it mildly, NOT tone-deaf when it comes to comedy. If there is a comedic moment hovering at the edge of its potential somewhere, she will leap in, pull it out, and make it far funnier than you could ever have conceived.
Anyway - we were talking to someone - some random person - and this person divulged that he had never seen "Willy Wonka".
Ann Marie said, point-blank, "What - did you grow up in Chad?"
Now:
The point is not whether or not there are movie theatres in Chad. Okay? Let's not be literal here. We are talking about comedy.
Ann Marie got an ENORMOUS laugh for that line, and rightly so. Why is "Chad" funnier than ... say ... Angola? Or ... Burma?
Basically, the point was - she randomly chose a 3rd-world country - which brought up all kinds of associations in all of our minds (a desert land, cut off from modern society) - and everyone ROARED.
In my opinion "Chad" is funnier than "Angola" because it is a funnier-sounding word to begin with, with its blunt one syllable. "Chad" lands, in a funnier way, to sensitive ears. The punchline of the joke was just that - a punch.
This is just my opinion, though - the whole thing is a never-ending mystery - and it is a GIFT. People who can make you laugh like that have a GIFT. Nathan Lane came and did a seminar at my graduate school - and it was like he had super-natural powers, in terms of comedic sensitivity.
My stomach ached for 2 days afterwards.
Every joke was explored. If one fell flat, he then would find, in the next moment, a way to make it land. He was like a scientist, a well-tuned instrument, a MACHINE. He was a comedy machine.
But he did it all with fluidity, grace, and a measure of desperation. Comedians NEED to make you laugh.
I find that to be one of the most beautiful things about them. 80% of the guys I have dated have been stand-up comedians or improv comedians for that very reason. It can get a bit old, at times, true. You want to say, "Okay, champ, drop the routine. Let's talk seriously." But for a girl of my sensibility, that rarely occurs. I am more interested in laughing for 3 hours straight than sitting down and having a heart-to-heart.
And so: Why do you think "quarter" funnier than "dollar"?
"I'm very conscious of my decline in popularity, but I don't permit it to stop me because I have the example of so many playwrights before me. I know the dreadful notices Ibsen got. And O'Neill -- he had to die to make 'Moon' successful. And to me it has been providential to be an artist, a great act of providence that I was able to turn my borderline psychosis into creativity -- my sister Rose did not manage this. So I keep writing. I am sometimes pleased with what I do -- for me, that's enough."
-- Tennessee Williams, interviewed in 1981
That is one of my favorite quotes. Words to live by:
So I keep writing. I am sometimes pleased with what I do -- for me, that's enough.
"A great writer within any culture changes everything. Because the thing is different afterwards and people comprehend themselves differently. If you take Ireland before James Joyce, and Ireland fifty years afterwards, the reality of being part of the collective life is enhanced and changed."
-- Seamus Heaney
John Keats, great poet, who died in 1821, wrote his own epitaph, which is as follows:
"Here lies one whose name was writ in water."
But actually, the full epitaph reads like this:
This Grave
contains all that was Mortal
of a
Young English Poet
Who
on his Death Bed
in the Bitterness of his Heart
at the Malicious Power of his Enemies
Desired
these words to be engraved on his Tomb Stone
"Here lies One Whose Name was writ in Water."
"the Malicious Power of his Enemies" ... Woah.
So this got me to thinking about epitaphs in general. As a kid, me and my siblings had to memorize William Butler Yeats' epitaph, in order to get our allowance of 50 measly cents. Nothing, and I mean NOTHING, could knock that epitaph out of my brain.
It is:
Cast a cold eye
On life On death
Horseman pass by
Damn. Now that is something. I could ponder that forever.
There are a couple of other relatively famous epitaphs I am familiar with - (I used to plan out, as a teenager, what I wanted on my tombstone - Finally, I settled on "After life's fitful fever, she sleeps" - Shakespeare - I was insane. I was 15 years old, picking out the best epitaph for myself.)
Anyway, speaking of Shakespeare, here is his epitaph, written on his grave in Stratford-on-Avon:
Good friend for Jesus's sake forbear
To dig the dust enclosed here
Blest be the man that spares these stones
And cursed be he that moves my bones
Got it, Bill. We won't move your bones. We promise.
Other epitaphs I know by heart - I don't know if any of my readers out there also have an interest in this kind of thing - but if you do, feel free to pipe up.
Jack Dempsey's epitaph was (and I LOVE this):
A Gentle Man and a Gentleman
Robert Frost has as his epitaph (and this is certainly something to keep me up at night, pondering):
I had A Lover's Quarrel With The World
Me too. Me too.
Emily Dickinson, like Keats, wrote her own. It says it all:
Called Back
F. Scott Fitzgerald has, as his epitaph, the famous last line of Gatsby:
So we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past.
(Come to think of it, I wouldn't mind having that as my epitaph either ... Hm. Must make a note of it.)
Thomas Jefferson wrote his own:
Here was buried Thomas Jefferson,
author of the Declaration of American Independence,
of the statute of Virginia for religious freedom,
and father of the University of Virginia.
And of course, the epitaph of the Unknown Soldier, which everybody knows:
Here Rests in
Honored Glory
An American
Soldier
Known But to God
And finally - Jack London - who has this mysterious phrase as his epitaph:
The Stone the Builders Rejected
John Adams - died July 4, 1826 "Thomas Jefferson--still survives..." (He didn't know Jefferson had died earlier the same day - They both died on July 4?? I mean - come ON)
On the exact same day, Thomas Jefferson died. He began slipping in and out of a coma. At one point, he woke up and said, "Is it the Fourth?" Then he died. I have tears in my eyes. I have no idea if that is actually true - or just a rumor - It is reported in his biographies, with caveats - "Rumor has it..." etc. But I choose to believe it.
Ethan Allen, American Revolutionary general, died in 1789, and was told by his doctor, "General, I fear the angels are waiting for you." Ethan Allen responded, "Waiting are they? Waiting are they? Well--let 'em wait." Those were his last words.
Lady Nancy Astor, fell very ill, and woke up, to find her entire family standing around her bed. She said, "Am I dying or is this my birthday?" These were her last words.
James Joyce apparently said, as his last words, "Does nobody understand?" I don't seem to recall this fact being told in the Ellmann biography, though, so it may not be true. No, Jim, nobody really does understand - but your work will live on regardless. Genius lives. Understanding is over-rated.
Tallulah Bankhead, wild-woman actress, died in 1968. Her last words were, "Codeine . . . bourbon."
P. T. Barnum, died in 1891. His last words were, "How were the receipts today at Madison Square Garden?"
I think my favorite might be Beethoven's last words: "Friends applaud, the comedy is finished." Jesus. Amazing.
Humphrey Bogart's last words are almost TOO perfect. "I should never have switched from Scotch to Martinis." Classic.
Napoleon died, murmuring, "Josephine ... Josephine ..."
Oh, and the following was a contribution from the man I met at the party. It is so damn funny.
Dominique Bouhours, who was one of those strict hard-nosed French grammarians, died in 1702. Last words were: "I am about to -- or I am going to -- die: either expression is correct."
Tacitus tells us that Caligula, who was stabbed to death by his own guards in 41 AD, had as his last words the following scream: "I am still alive!"
Louise, Queen of Prussia, who died in 1820, faced the harsh realities in her last moments, and said, before dying, "I am a Queen, but I have not the power to move my arms."
Chekhov's last words are also a personal favorite of mine. They seem to encapsulate exactly what I love about his writing, his outlook on life: "I am dying. I haven't drunk champagne for a long time."
Chopin's last words are horrific. He died of tuberculosis. His last words are: "The earth is suffocating . . . Swear to make them cut me open, so that I won't be buried alive." A terrible death.
Very different from Elizabeth Barrett Browning's last words. Her husband asked her how she felt. She replied, "Beautiful" and died. You couldn't ask for a nicer death.
Winston's Churchill's last words before slipping into a coma were: "I'm bored with it all." 9 days after saying that, he died.
Joan Crawford, the old bitch, was on her death-bed. Her housekeeper started to pray out loud to God. Joan Crawford snapped, "Damn it . . . Don't you dare ask God to help me." Then Mommie Dearest died.
Karl Marx died in 1883. As he lay dying, his housekeeper apparently raced in with a pad of paper, and hovered over him, waiting, literally waiting for him to die, so that she could write down his last words for posterity. Marx barked at her, "Go on, get out - last words are for fools who haven't said enough."
Teddy Roosevelt said, bluntly, "Put out the light." and then died.
Charles Darwin, unsurprisingly, stated, "I am not the least afraid to die." And then promptly died.
(It's incredible how people reveal themselves so completely in these intimate vulnerable last moments.)
I find Edison's last words so comforting, so mysterious. I wonder what it was he saw: "It is very beautiful over there."
Eugene O'Neill's last words, which hold a world of grief and loss, and he's also PISSED, "I knew it. I knew it. Born in a hotel room - and God damn it - died in a hotel room."
Edmund Gwenn, an actor in the 30s and 40s (Miracle on 34th Street, Life with Father, a couple of Lassie films) said, when someone asked him if it was "tough" facing death: "Yes, it's tough, but not as tough as doing comedy." Then he died. God bless him.
Victor Hugo said, as his last words before death, something which chills me, "I see black light." Maybe he saw a "darkling plain".
Boris Pasternak died saying the following, and I know it's uncompassionate of me, but I find his last words rather comical: "Good-bye . . . why am I hemorrhaging?"
Anna Pavlova, one of the most famous ballerinas who ever lived, said before she died, in 1931, "Get my swan costume ready."
General John Sedgwick, Union Commander in the Civil War, was killed in battle in 1864, saying, "They couldn't hit an elephant at this dist. . . ."
A relatively famous (and comi-tragic) one is the last words of Dylan Thomas, who reportedly said, "I've had eighteen straight whiskies, I think that's the record . . ."
This next one cracks my heart in two. Jesus. If he only knew. Leonardo DaVinci's last words were, "I have offended God and mankind because my work did not reach the quality it should have."
Oscar Wilde's might be the most famous of all, and for good reason. "Either that wallpaper goes, or I do." Clearly, the wallpaper stayed.
Like Dave J said in the comments below - choosing a favorite line from Shakespeare is like choosing your favorite parent - it's wrong! I do agree - and my changes will fluctuate on an almost daily basis, but I do love hearing everybody's choices.
So - how about just favorite poems, in general? What are your favorite poems?
I have so many - Yeats' "The Second Coming" is surely one, Yeats' "Sailing to Byzantium" is another. I love Mary Oliver's poems.
But I think, hovering over all of these, is the following poem by Auden. It's one of the few poems I know by heart.
It's another one of those pieces of writing which has followed me through my life, showing up at different moments, providing different insights. It almost doesn't seem to be the same poem, from day to day.
On a personal note, too, this poem, along with the Hail Mary, was almost a mantra during the crazy day of September 11 - and the chaotic days following. I saw the towers fall with my own eyes. My sister Siobhan who worked down there was out of communication and missing for 3 hours. The air was literally filled with the sound of screaming. I saw grown men in suits fall to their knees and scream, "NO" up at the sky.
Later that night, raw and still stunned, I lay in my bed, sleep was months away, and said Auden's poem to myself in the dark.
I still couldn't cry - it was WEEKS before I would shed a tear - but there was something comforting and eternal in Auden's words. I cherish this poem because of what it meant to me during those terrible days. It's that last line, man ... It's the very last line that makes this poem great. And true.
The More Loving One
Looking up at the stars, I know quite well
That, for all they care, I can go to hell,
But on earth indifference is the least
We have to dread from man or beast.
How should we like it were stars to burn
With a passion for us we could not return?
If equal affection cannot be,
Let the more loving one be me.
Admirer as I am
Of stars that do not give a damn,
I cannot, now i see them, say
I missed one terribly all day.
Were all stars to disappear or die,
I should learn to look at an empty sky
And feel its total dark sublime,
Though this might take me a little time.
So - I told you mine, now you tell me yours - Favorite poem?
I post this excerpt from one of Tolkien's letters for all my Tolkien-fan readers, and also specifically to annoy Patrick Prescott (who moved off Blogspot - Yeah!) Patrick has finally come to the conclusion that he is an "unwashed heathen", in terms of the Trilogy. It's okay, Patrick, I'm sure you and I could work something out.
This is a draft of a letter to one of the many many fans who wrote to him with questions. Many of these letters were never sent. He would have carbon copies made, and continue to work on the drafts of the letters. Especially as he got older.
This woman wrote to him, and here is his response.
I love it because it illuminates (without him knowing it, of course) his genius. He didn't ultimately see himself as a writer, or a creator of worlds - he saw himself as a historian. Fantastic. He saw Middle-Earth as a revealed place, he himself explored the landscape, unsure of what he would find.
To get a bit uber here, the story works itself way out into our world, using him as the vehicle, the voice.
Phenomenal.
Autumn 1971 Draft of letter to Carole Batten-Phelps
I am very grateful for your remarks on the critics and for your account of your personal delight in Lord of the Rings. You write in terms of such high praise that [to] accept it with just a 'thank you' might seem complacently conceited, though actually it only makes me wonder how this has been achieved - by me! Of course the book was written to please myself (at different levels), and as an experiment in the arts of long narrative, and of inducing 'Secondary Belief'. It was written slowly and with great care for detail & finally emerged as a Frameless Picture: a searchlight, as it were, on a brief episode in History, and on a small part of our Middle-earth, surrounded by the glimmer of limitless extensions in time and space. Very well: that may explain to some extent why it 'feels' like history; why it was accepted for publication; and why it has proved readable for a large number of very different kinds of people.
But it does not fully explain what has actually happened. Looking back on the wholly unexpected things that have followed its publication - beginning at once with the appearance of Vol. I - I feel as if an ever darkening sky over our present world had been suddenly pierced, the clouds rolled back, and an almost forgotten sunlight had poured down again. As if indeed the horns of Hope had been heard again, as Pippin heard them suddenly at the absolute nadir of the fortunes of the West. But How? and Why?
I think I can now guess what Gandalf would reply. A few years ago I was visited in Oxford by a man whose name I have fogotten (though I believe he was well-known). He had been much struck by the curious way in which old pictures seemed to him to have been designed to illustrate The Lord of the Rings long before its time. He brought one or two reproductions. I think he wanted at first simply to discover whether my imagination had fed on pictures, as it clearly had been by certain kinds of literature and languages. When it became obvious that, unless I was a liar, I had never seen the pictures before and was not well acquainted with pictorial Art, he fell silent. I became aware that he was looking fixedly at me. Suddenly he said, "Of course you don't suppose, do you, that you wrote all that book yourself?"
Pure Gandalf! I was too well acquainted with Gandalf to expose myself rashly, or to ask what he meant. I think I said: "No, I don't suppose so any longer." I have never since been able to suppose so. An alarming conclusion for an old philologist to draw concerning his private amusement. But not one that should puff any one up who considers the imperfections of "chosen instruments", and indeed what sometimes seems their lamentable unfitness for the purpose.
You speak of "a sanity and sanctity" in the L.R. "which is a power in itself." I was deeply moved. Nothing of the kind had been said to me before. But by a strange chance, just as I was beginning this letter, I had one from a man, who classified himself as "an unbeliever, or at best a man of belatedly and dimly dawning religious feeling ... but you", he said, "create a world in which some sort of faith seems to be everywhere without a viable source, like light from an invisible lamp." I can only answer: "Of his own sanity no man can securely judge. If sanctity inhabits his work or as a pervading light illumines it then it does not come from him but through him. And neither of you would perceive it in these terms unless it was with you also. Otherwise you would see and feel nothing, or (if some other spirit was present) you would be filled with contempt, nausea, hatred. "Leaves out of the elf-country, gah!" "Lembas - dust and ashes, we don't eat that!"
Of course The L.R. does not belong to me. It has been brought forth and must now go its appointed way in the world, though naturally I take a deep interest in its fortunes, as a parent would of a child. I am comforted to know that it has good friends to defend it against the malice of its enemies. (But all the fools are not in the other camp.) With best wishes to one of its best friends. I am
Yours sincerely
JRR Tolkien
The excerpt I posted, where Tolkien discusses "the failure of Frodo", in the end, to complete his mission, generated a very interesting discussion. If you're a Tolkien freak like myself.
Bill McCabe commented: You're right, but he also makes the point that no man could hold an object with such power without succumbing to it's power. While he makes the one point that men are weak and easily corrupted, he also shows the men of Gondor and Rohan finding the strength within to stand againt the Dark Lord. I'm wondering if any of the letters address this in more detail.
Well. Naturally because I am developing a form of Tolkien autism I searched out more quotes on this very important issue.
Tolkien has a lot to say about free will - and also about the "failure" of Frodo at the end. But he is never more clear than in this unforgivably long excerpt. (I type over 80 words a minute)
In this excerpt, Tolkien tackles the power of the Ring - and what the Ring does to people (except for Tom B., as discussed in the comments, as well). I mean, Galadriel, in her 2-second contact with the Ring, is wrung dry. And she is a veteran of wars and rebellions and Great Events.
Perhaps it is Great people who are more prone to the power of the Ring - because their egos tell them that they can actually have an impact on the course of events. While hobbits just want to have a nice smoke and gossip about their neighbors as they watch the stars rise.
Hobbits don't have a well-developed sense of "agency" (read: EGO).
Anyway. In this letter, Tolkien describes what would have happened, he believes, if other members of the Fellowship had somehow found themselves in the position Frodo found himself in, at Mount Doom.
Again, this excerpt is LONG, my friends (it's long enough that I omitted stuff not completely relevant to this discussion of free will. Please don't kill me. I put ellipses where stuff is left out). It's long, yeah, but people seem to enjoy reading these excerpts. So I will be the drudge. It's great stuff.
I particularly like his cautionary tone at the end - when he described what possession of the Ring would do to a man of such great moral stature as Gandalf. Despite his message of hope, and the possibility of redemption, Tolkien seems, to me, most like a cynic.
I almost laughed out loud when I read this short letter to a fan, who had written asking him if he was working on a sequel to LOTR. Tolkien replied:
I did begin a story placed about 100 years after the Downfall of Mordor, but it proved both sinister and depressing. Since we are dealing with Men it is inevitable that we should be concerned with the most regrettable feature of their nature: their quick satiety with good. So that the people of Gondor in times of peace, justice and prosperity, would become discontented and restless - while the dynasts descended from Aragorn would become just kings and governors - like Denethor or worse. I found that even so early there was an outcrop of revolutionary plots, about a center of secret Satanistic religion; while Gondorian boys were playing at being Orcs and going round doing damage. I could have written a thriller about the plot and its discovery and overthrow - but it would be just that. Not worth doing.
Tolkien knew peace never lasts, and in his imagination he sees that little boys will form secret "Orc-clubs", and not revere all that has gone before ... It is human nature. Perhaps cynical.
But cynical in the way our Founding Fathers were, drafting the articles of impeachment before George Washington even became the first President. That fact alone is evidence of grave cynicism, but I would also call it ultimately pragmatism: Men will be men. Men are corruptible. No one is above making a grab for power. NO ONE.
September 1963 Draft of letter to Mrs. Eileen Elgar
Very few (indeed so far as letters go only you and one other) have observed or commented on Frodo's "failure". It is a very important point.
From the point of view of the storyteller the events on Mt Doom proceed simply from the logic of the tale up to that time. They were not deliberately worked up to nor foreseen until they occured. But, for one thing, it became at last quite clear that Frodo after all that had happened would be incapable of voluntarily destroyoing the Ring. Reflecting on the solution after it was arrived at (as a mere event) I feel that it is central to the whole "theory" of true nobility and heroism that is presented.
Frodo indeed "failed" as a hero, as conceived by simple minds: he did not endure to the end; he gave in, ratted. I do not say "simple minded" with contempt: they often see with clarity the simple truth and the absolute ideal to which effort must be directed, even if it is unattainable. Their weakness, however, is twofold. They do not perceive the complexty of any given situation in Time, in which an absolute ideal is enmeshed. They tend to forget that strange element in the World that we call Pity or Mercy, which is also an absolute requirement in moral judgement (since it is present in the Divine nature). In its highest exercise it belongs to God. For finite judges of imperfect knowledge it must lead to the use of two different scales of "morality". To ourselves we must present the absolute ideal without compromise, for we do not know our own limits of natural strength (+ grace), and if we do not aim at the highest we shall certainly fall short of the utmost that we could achieve. To others, in any case of which we know enough to make a judgement, we must apply a scale tempered by "mercy": that is, since we can with good will do this without the bias inevitable in judgements of ourselves, we must estimate the limits of another's strength and weigh this against the force of particular circumstances. (We frequently see this double scale used by the saints in their judgements upon themselves when suffering great hardships or temptations, and upon others in like trials.)
I do not think that Frodo's was a moral failure. At the last moment the pressure of the Ring would reach its maximum - impossible, I should have said, for any one to resist, certainly after long possession, months of increasing torment, and when starved and exhausted. Frodo had done what he could and spent himself completely (as an instrument of Providence) and had produced a situation in which the object of his quest could be achieved. His humility (with which he began) and his sufferings were justly reqarded by the highest honour; and his exercise of patience and mercy towards Gollum gained him Mercy: his failure was redressed.
We are finite creatures with absolute limitations upon the powers of our soul-body structure in either action or endurance. Moral failure can only be asserted, I think, when a man's effort or endurance falls short of his limits, and the blame decreases as that limit is closer approached. (No account is here taken of "grace" or the enhancement of our powers as instruments of Providence. Frodo was given "grace": first to answer the call (at the end of the Council) after long resisiting a complete surrender; and later in his resistance to the temptation of the Ring (at times when to claim and so reveal it would have been fatal), and in his endurance of fear and suffering. But grace is not infinite, and for the most part seems in the Divine economy limited to what is sufficient for the accomplishment of the task appointed to one instrument in a pattern of circumstances and other instruments.)
...Frodo undertook his quest out of love - to save the world he knew from disaster at his own expense, if he could; and also in complete humility, acknowledging that he was wholly inadequate to the task. His real contract was only to do what he could, to try to find a way, and to go as far on the road as his strength of mind and body allowed. He did that. I do not myself see that the breaking of his mind and will under demonic pressure after torment was any more a moral failure than the breaking of the body would have been ...
That appears to have been the judgement of Gandalf and Aragorn and of all who learned the full story of his journey. Certainly nothing would be concealed by Frodo! But what Frodo himself thought about the events is quite another matter.
He appears at first to have had no sense of guilt ("And there was Frodo, pale and worn, and yet himself again; and in his eyes there was peace now, neither strain of will nor madness, nor any fear ... 'The Quest is achieved, and now all is over,'"); he was restored to sanity and peace. But then he thought that he had given his life in sacrifice: he expected to die very soon. But he did not, and one can observe the disquiet growing in him. Arwen was the first to observe the signs, and gave him her jewel for comfort, and thought of a way of healing him...Slowly he fades "out of the picture", saying and doing less and less. I think it is clear on reflection to an attentive reader that when his dark times came upon him and he was conscious of being "wounded by knife sting and tooth and a long burden", it was not only nightmare memories of past horrors that afflicted him, but also unreasoning self-reproach: he saw himself and all that he done as a broken failure ... And it was mixed with another temptation, blacker and yet (in a sense) more merited, for however that may be explained, he had not in fact cast away the Ring by a voluntary act: he was tempted to regret its destruction, and still to desire it. "It is gone for ever, and now all is dark and empty," he said as he wakened from his sickness in 1420.
"Alas! there are some wounds that cannot be wholly cured," said Gandalf - not in Middle-earth. Frodo was sent or allowed to pass over Sea to heal him - if that could be done, before he died...Bilbo went too. No doubt as a completion of the plan due to Gandalf himself. Gandalf had a very great affection for Bilbo, from the hobbit's childhood onwards. His companionship was really necessary for Frodo's sake - it is difficult to imagine a hobbit, even one who had been through Frodo's experiences, being really happy even in an earthly paradise without a companion of his own kind, and Bilbo was the person that Frodo most loved. But he also needed and deserved the favour on his own account. He bore still the mark of the Ring that needed to be finally erased: a trace of pride and personal possessiveness. Of course he was old and confused in mind, but it was still a revealation of the "black mark" when he said in Rivendell, "What's become of my ring, Frodo, that you took away?" and when he was reminded of what had happened, his immediate reply was: "What a pity! I should have liked to see it again!"...
Sam is meant to be lovable and laughable. Some readers he irritates and even infuriates. I can well understand it. All hobbits at times affect me in the same way, though I remain very fond of them. But Sam can be very "trying". He is a more representative hobbit than any others that we have to see much of; and he consequently has a stronger ingeredient of that quality which even some hobbits found at times hard to bear: a vulgarity - by which I do not mean a mere "down-to-earthiness" - a mental myopia which is proud of itself, a smugness (in varying degrees) and cocksureness, and a readiness to measure and sum up all things from a limited experience, largely enshrined in sententious traditional "wisdom". We only meet exceptional hobbits in close companionship - those who had a grace or gift: a vision of beauty, and a reverence for things nobler than thmselves, at war with their rustic self-satisfaction. Imagine Sam without his education by Bilbo and his fascination wtih things Elvish!...
Sam was cocksure, and deep down a little conceited; but his conceit had been transformed by his devotion to Frodo. He did not think of himself as heroic or even brave, or in any way admirable - except in his service and loyalty to his master. That had an ingredient (probably inevitable) of pride and possessiveness ... In any case it prevented him from fully understanding the master tha the loved, and from following him in his gradual education to the nobility of service to the unlovable and of perception of damaged goods in the corrupt. He plainly did not fully understand Frodo's motives or his distress in the incident of the Forbidden Pool. If he had understood better what was going on between Frodo and Gollum, things might have turned out differently in the end.
For me perhaps the most tragic moment in the Tale comes in II 323 ff. when Sam fails to note the complete change in Gollum's tone and aspect. "Nothing, nothing," said Gollum softly. "Nice master!" His repentance is blighted and all Frodo's pity is (in a sense) wasted. Shelob's lair becomes inevitable.
This is due of course to the "logic of the story". Sam could hardly have acted differently ... If he had, what could then have happened? The course of the entry into Mordor and the struggle to reach Mount Doom would have been different, and so would the ending. The insterest would have shifted to Gollum, I think, and the battle that would have gone on between his repentance and his new love on one side and the Ring. Though the love would have been strengthened daily it could not have wrested the mastery from the Ring. I think that in some queer twisted and pitiable way Gollum would have tried (not maybe with conscious design) to satisfy both. Certainly at some point not long before the end he would have stolen the Ring or taken it by violence (as he does in the actual Tale). But "possession" satisfied, I think he would then have sacrificed himself for Frodo's sake and have voluntarily cast himself into the fiery abyss.
I think that an effect of his partial regeneration by love would have been a clearer vision when he claimed the Ring. He would have perceived the evil of Sauron, and suddenly realized that he could not use the Ring and had not the strength or stature to keep it in Sauron's despite: the only way to keep it and hurt Sauron was to destory it and himself together - and in a flash he may have seen that this would also be the greatest service to Frodo. Frodo in the tale actually takes the Ring and claims it, and certainly he too would have had a clear vision - but he was not given any time: he was immediately attacked by Gollum. When Sauron was aware of the seizure of the Ring his one hope was in its power: that the claimant would be unable to relinquish it until Sauron had time to deal with him. Frodo too would then probably, if not attacked, have had to take the same way: cast himself with the Ring into the abyss. If not he would of course have completely failed. It is an interesting problem: how Sauron would have acted or the claimant have resisted. Sauron sent at once the Ringwraiths. They were naturally fully instructed, and in no way deceived as to the real lordship of the Ring. The wearer would not be invisible to them, but the reverse; and the more vulnerable to their weapons. But the situation was now different to that under Weathertop, where Frodo acted merely in fear and wished only to use (in vain) the Ring's subsidiary power of conferring invisibility. He had grown since then. Would they have been immune from its power if he claimed it as an instrument of command and domination?
Not wholly. I do not think they could have attacked him with violence, nor laid hold upon him or taken him captive; they would have obeyed or feigned to obey any minor commands of his that did not interfere with their errand - laid upon them by Sauron, who still through their nine rings (which he held) had primary control of their wills. That errand was to remove Frodo from the Crack. Once he lost the power or opportunity to destroy the Ring, the end could not be in doubt - saving help from outside, which was hardly even remotely possible.
Frodo had become a considerable person, but of a special kind: in spiritual enlargement rather than in increase of physical or mental power; his will was much stronger than it had been, but so far it had been exercised in resisting not using the Ring and with the object of destroying it. He needed time, much time, before he could control the Ring or (which in such a case is the same) before it could control him; before his will and arrogance could grow to a stature in which he could dominate other major hostile wills. Even so for a long time his acts and commands would still have to seem 'good" to him, to be for the benefit of others beside himself.
The situation as between Frodo with the Ring and the Eight (the Witch-king had been reduced to impotence) might be compared to that of a small brave man armed with a devastating weapon, faced by eight savage warriors of great strength and agility armed with poisoned blades. The man's weakness was that he did not know how to use his weapon yet; and he was by temperament and training averse to violence. Their weakness that the man's weapon was a thing that filled them with fear as an object of terror in their religious cult, by which they had been conditioned to treat one who wielded it with servility. I think they would have shown "servility". They would have greeted Frodo as "Lord". With fair speeches they would have induced him to leave the Sammath Naur - for instance "to look upon his new kingdom, and behold afar with his new sight the abode of power that he must now claim and turn to his own purposes." Once outside the chamber while he was gazing some of them would have destroyed the entrance. Frodo would by then probably have been already too enmeshed in great plans of reformed rule - like but far greater and wider than the vision that tempted Sam ("Wild fantasies arose in his mind; and he saw Samwise the Strong, Hero of the Age, striding with a sword across the darkened land, and armies flocking to his call as he marched to the overthrow of Barad-due.") - to heed this. But if he still preserved some sanity and partly understood the significance of it, so that he refused now to go with them to Barad-due, they would simply have waited. Until Sauron himself came.
In any case a confrontation of Frodo and Sauron would soon have taken place, if the Ring was intact. Its result was inevitable. Frodo would have been utterly overthrown: crushed to dust, or preserved in torment as a gibbering slave. Sauron would not have feared the Ring! It was his own and under his will. Even from afar he had an effect upon it, to make it work for its return to himsefl. In his actual presence none but very few of equal stature could have hoped to withhold it from him. Of "mortals" no one, not even Artagorn. In the contest with the Palantir Aragorn was the rightful owner. Also the contest took place at a distance, and in a tale which allows the incarnation of great spirits in a physical and destructivle form their power must be far greater when actually physically present. Sauron should be thought of as very terrible. The form that he took was that of a man of more than human stature, but not gigantic. In his earlier incarnation he was able to veil his power (as Gandalf did) and could appear as a commanding figure of great strength of body and supremely royal demeanour and countenance.
Of the others only Gandalf might be expected to master him - being an emissary of the Powers and a creature of the same order, an immortal spirit taking a visible physical form. In the "Mirror of Galadriel", it appears that Galadriel conceived of herself as capable of wielding the Ring and supplanting the Dark Lord. IF so, so also were the other guardians of the Three, especially Elrond. But this is another matter. It was part of the essential deceit of the Ring to fill minds with imaginations of supreme power. But this the Great had well considered and had rejected, as is seen in Elrond's words at the Council. Galadriel's rejection of the temptation was founded upon previous thought and resolve. In any case Elrond or Galadriel would have proceeded in the policy now adopted by Sauron: they would have built up an empire with great and absolutely subservient generals and armies and engines of war, until they could challenge Sauron and destroy him by force. Confrontation of Sauron alone, unaided, self to self, was not contemplated.
One can impagine the scene in which Gandalf, say, was placed in such a position. It would be a delicate balance. On one side the true allegiance of the Ring to Sauron; on the other superior strength because Sauron was not actually in possession, and perhaps also because he was weakened by long corruption and expenditure of will in dominating inferiors. If Gandalf proved the victor, the result would have been for Sauron the same as the destruction of the Ring; for him it would have been destroyed, taken from him for ever. But the Ring and all its works would have endured. It would have been the master in the end.
Gandalf as Ring-Lord would have been far worse than Sauron. He would have remained "righteous", but self-righteous. He would have continued to rule and order things for "good", and the benefit of his subjects according to his wisdom (which would have remained great.
Thus while Sauron multiplied evil, he left "good" clearly distinguishable from it. Gandalf would have made good destestable and seem evil.
Tolkien responds to many letters from fans and reviewers about the failure of Frodo, in the end, to complete the Quest. I have a lot more to say on this - Tolkien's discussion of Pity, and Mercy - and how salvation can only come through those things - not through Power, Might, or even Success. But I'll get back to that.
Here's a couple excerpts on what Tolkien calls "the failure of Frodo":
26 July 1956 Draft of letter to Miss J. Burn
If you re-read all the passages dealing with Frodo and the Ring, I think you will see that not only was it quite impossible for him to surrender the Ring, in act or will, especially at its point of maximum power, but that this failure was adumbrated from far back. He was honoured because he had accepted the burden voluntarily, and then had done all that was within his utmost physical and mental strength to do. He (and the Cause) were saved - by mercy: by the supreme value and efficacy of Pity and forgiveness of injury.
Corinthians I x. 12-13 may not at first sight seem to fit ("Wherefore let him that thinketh he standeth take heed lest he fall. There hath no temptation taken you but such as is common to man: but God is faithful, who will not suffer you to be tempted above that ye are able; but will with the temptation also make a way to escape, that ye may be able to bear it.") - unless "bearing temptation" is taken to mean resisting it while still a free agent in normal command of the will. I think rather of the mysterious last petitions of the Lord's Prayer: Lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from evil. A petition against something that cannot happen is unmeaning. There exists the possibility of being placed in positions beyond one's power. In which case (as I believe) salvation from ruin will depend on something apparently unconnected: the general sanctity (and humility and mercy) of the sacrificial person. I did not "arrange" the deliverance in this case: it again follows the logic of the story. (Gollum had had his chance of repentance, and of returning generosity with love; and had fallen off the knife-edge). In the case of those who now issue from prison "brainwashed", broken, or insane, praising their torturers, no such immediate deliverance is as a rule to be seen. But we can at least judge them by the will and intentions with which they entered the Sammath Naur; and not demand impossible feats of will, which could only happen in stories unconcerned with real moral and mental probability.
No, Frodo "failed". It is possible that once the ring was destroyed he had little recollection of the last scene. But one must face the fact: the power of Evil in the world is not finally resistible by incarnate creatures, however "good"; and the Writer of the Story is not one of us.
27 July 1956 Letter to Amy Ronald
By chance, I have just had another letter regarding the failure of Frodo. Very few seem even to have observed it. But following the logic of the plot, it was clearly inevitable, as an event. And surely it is a more significant and real event than a mere "fairy story" ending in which the hero is indomitable? It is possible for the good, even the saintly, to be subjected to a power of evil which is too great for them to overcome - in themselves. In this case the cause (not the "hero") was triumphant, because by the exercise of pity, mercy, and forgiveness of injury, a situation was produced in which all was redressed and disaster averted. Gandalf certainly foresaw this. ("Pity? It was pity that stayed [Bilbo's] hand. Pity, and Mercy: not to strike without need. And he has been well rewarded, Frodo. Be sure that he took so little hurt from the evil, and escaped in the end, because he began his ownership of the Ring so. With Pity.") Of course he did not mean to say that one must be merciful, for it may prove useful later - it would not then be mercy or pity, which are only truly present when contrary to prudence. Not ours to plan! But we are assured that we must be ourselves extravagantly generous, if we are to hope for the extravagant generosity which the slightest easing of, or escape from, the consequences of our own follies and errors represents. And that mercy does sometimes occur in this life.
Frodo deserved all honour because he spent every drop of his power of will and body, and that was just sufficient to bring him to the destined point, and no further. Few others, possibly no others of his time, would have got so far. The Other Power then took over: the Writer of the Story (by which I do not mean myself), "that one ever-present Person who is never absent and never named" (as one critic has said). (Gandalf to Frodo: "Behind that there was something else at work, beyond any design of the Ring-Maker. I can put it no plainer than by saying that Bilbo was meant to find the Ring, and not by its maker.")
A third (the only other) commentator on the point some months ago reviled Frodo as a scoundrel (who should have been hung and not honoured), and me too. It seems sad and strange that, in this evil time when daily people of good will are tortured, "brainwashed", and broken, anyone could be so fiercely simpleminded and righteous.
Tolkien wrote a draft to an unidentified reader, and in it he describes his affinity to Faramir. (Or should I say, his affinity "with" Faramir? Patrick, Grammar Guru, care to comment?)
14 January 1856
... There is hardly any reference in The Lord of the Rings to things that do not actually exist on its own plane (of secondary or sub-creationary reality): sc. have been written. (The cats of Queen Beruthiel and the names and adventures of the other 2 wizards (5 minus Saruman, Gandalf, Radagast) are all that I recollect.) The Silmarillion was offered for publication years ago, and turned down. Good may come of such blows. The Lord of the Rings was the result. The hobbits had been welcomed. I loved them myself, since I love the vulgar and simple as dearly as the noble, and nothing moves my heart (beyond all the passions and heartbreaks of the world) so much as "ennoblement" (from the Ugly Duckling to Frodo). I would build on the hobbits. And I saw that I was meant to do it (as Gandalf would say - I am not Gandalf, being a transcendent Sub-creator in this little world. As far as any character is "like me" it is Faramir - except that I lack what all my characters possess (let the psychoanalysts note!) Courage), since without thought, in a "blurb" I wrote for The Hobbit, I spoke of the time between the Elder Days and the Dominion of Men. Out of that came the "missing link": The "Downfall of Numenor", releasing some hidden "complex". For when Faramir speaks of his private vision of the Great Wave, he speaks for me. That vision and dream has been ever with me - and has been inherited (as I only discovered recently) by one of my children.
"The poet in our current time is complacent, maintaining an air of respectability or is the creator of outrageous manifestos -- in either case is benign. In times past poets were leaders and creators of reality; they were respected and entrusted with the keeping of cultural inheritance. Somehow this has changed, and poets now are non-entities for the most part; sure, they are politely applauded by small audiences, they sell a few volumes; they put their private lives on display to make others feel human. But this is all 'culture', a word which now seems to mean, not the whole of society, but entertainment for the few -- dividends received for living in a 'civilized' society. Furthermore, poets generally believe that they are effective, believe they make an impact on society; and who is responsible for this misconception is a great mystery -- some influence outside the poetic community, or worse yet, the poets themselves -- an important question that will not be answered here. This, for us, is the important fact: the poet has somehow been marginalized, and there is no sense that our society would die without the presence of poetry or poets. Perhaps this is the gravest sign of cultural coma."
- Brad N. Haas
For those of you who have no interest whatsoever in Tolkien, I have a couple of things to say.
First off: WHAT THE HELL IS THE MATTER WITH YOU??
No, just kidding.
Really, what I wanted to say is - I am deeply involved (obviously) in reading his letters right now - and I will be posting them extensively because I cannot seem to help myself.
So if it doesn't interest you - forgive me. The mania will pass.
The letters he wrote to his son Christopher during WWII, while Christopher was stationed in South Africa are astonishing. He sent him chapters of LOTR for Christopher's comments - It seems to me that Tolkien survived those very dark days (not just dark for the world, but dark in the sense that he was separated from his son, and very worried about him - not to mention the fact that Christopher was in the RAF and Tolkien thought the airplane was a monstrous invention - monstrous, at least, in how it was being used during wartime - He was horrified that his son had anything to do with it) - but anyway, it appears that Tolkien made it through those worrisome days by pouring all of his heart into the Ring Trilogy - and sending off excerpts to his son. He says numerous times, "I write this with you in mind."
The letters are incredibly moving.
Here is an excerpt from a letter dated January 30, 1945. I post it because I relate to it - because there is something in me that abhors "gloating" at our enemies - There is something in me that finds that "hoo-yah" blood-lust terrible, indicative of our worst sides as human beings. If we should win, if we should conquer the enemy, then let us not gloat. Because, after all, what separates us from beasts, is our ability to have compassion for others. Even people on the "other side". What separates us from beasts is the ability to have feeling in our hearts for people we do not know.
Not to say that there should not be punishment, that justice should not be done, but to gloat happily in the face of the enemy's downfall is an ugly emotion, an ugly thing - It does not suit us. It does not suit the nobility of our cause. We must approach victory with solemnity, and sadness, I would say.
Sadness that it has come to this.
Peggy Noonan wrote a column in September of 2002 called "What's Missing in the Iraq Debate". It struck me at such a deep level - that I recall parts of it almost word for word.
The Democrats on Capitol Hill have so far failed to mount a principled, coherent opposition. I am not shocked by this, are you? One senses they are looking at the whole question merely as a matter of popular positioning: Will they like me if I say take out Saddam? Will they get mad at me if we try to take him out and it's a disaster? Will they like me if I say there's no reason to go to war? Have I focus-grouped this? Such unseriousness is potentially deeply destructive. It is certainly irresponsible. And here's the funny thing: If some Democrat stood up and spoke thoughtfully and without regard for political consequences about what is right for us to do, he'd likely garner enhanced respect and heightened standing. He'd seem taller than his colleagues. At any rate, more than usual, I am missing Pat Moynihan and Sam Nunn.Members of the administration, on the other hand, seem lately almost inebriated with a sense of mission. And maybe that's inevitable when the stakes are high and you're sure you're right. But in off-the-cuff remarks and unprepared moments the president and some of his men often seem to have missing within them a sense of the tragic. Which is odd because we're talking about war, after all. Leaders can't lead by moping, but a certain, well, solemnity, I suppose, might be well received by many of us.
This letter from JRR Tolkien to his son speaks to our higher selves.
30 January 1945
Russians 60 miles from Berlin. It does look as if something decisive might happen soon. The appalling destruction and misery of this war mount hourly: destruction of what should be (indeed is) the common wealth of Europe, and the world, if mankind were not so besotted, wealth the loss of which will affect us all, victors or not. Yet people gloat to hear of the endless lines, 40 miles long, of miserable refugees, women and children pouring West, dying on the way. There seem no bowels of mercy or compassion, no imagination, left in this dark diabolic hour. By which I do not mean that it may not all, in the present situation, mainly (not solely) created by Germany, be necessary and inevitable. But why gloat! We were supposed to have reached a stage of civilization in which it might still be necessary to execute a criminal, but not to gloat, or to hang his wife and child by him while the orc-crowd hooted. The destruction of Germany, be it 100 times merited, is one of the most appalling world-catastrophes. Well, well - you and I can do nothing about it. And that shd. be a measure of the amount of guilt that can justly be assumed to attach to any member of a country who is not a member of its actual Government. Well the first War of the Machines seems to be drawing to its final inconclusive chapter - leaving, alas, everyone the poorer, many bereached or maimed and millions dead, and only one thing triumphant: the Machines. As the servants of the Machines are becoming a privileged class, the Machines are going to be enormously more powerful. What's their next move?
This is a letter JRR Tolkien wrote to his son Chistopher, in November of 1943
"My political opinions lean more and more to Anarchy (philosophically understood, meaning abolition of control, not whiskered men with bombs) - or to 'unconstitutional' Monarchy. I would arrest anybody who uses the word State (in any sense other than the inanimate realm of England and its inhabitants, a thing that has neither power, rights nor mind); and after a chance of recantation, execute them if they remained obstinate! If we could get back to personal names, it would do a lot of good. Government is an abstract noun meaning the art and process of governing and it should be an offence to write it with a capital G or so as to refer to people. If people were in the habit of referring to 'King George's council, Winston and his gang,' it would go a long way to clearing thought, and reducing the frightful landslide into Theyocracy.
Anyway the proper study of Man is anything but Man; and the most improper job of any man, even saints (who at any rate were at least unwilling to take it on), is bossing other men. Not one in a million is fit for it, and least of all those who seek the opportunity. And at least it is done only to a small group of men who know who their master is. The medievals were only too right in taking nolo episcopari ['I do not wish to be made a bishop'] as the best reason a man could give to others for making him a bishop ...
Well, cheers and all that to you dearest son. We were born in a dark age out of due time (for us). But there is this comfort: otherwise we should not know, or so much love, what we do love. I imagine the fish out of water is the only fish to have an inkling of water. Also we have still small swords to use. 'I will not bow before the Iron Crown, nor cast my own small golden sceptre down.' Have at the Orcs, with winged words, hildenaeddran (war-adders), biting darts - but make sure of the mark, before shooting."
This amazing letter reminds me of one of my favorite movies - ELECTION. A wicked satire about the political process. You should see it, if you haven't already. In it - the point is made: those who choose to be leaders, early on in high school, are those destined to be our leaders as adults. And who ever liked those people in the first place?
This is from a letter JRR Tolkien wrote to his son, Michael, in June of 1941
"People in this land seem not even yet to realize that in the Germans we have enemies whose virtues (and they are virtues) of obedience and patriotism are greater than ours in the mass. Whose brave men are just about as brave as ours. Whose industry is about 10 times greater. And who are - under the curse of God - now led by a man inspired by a mad, whirlwind, devil: a typhoon, a passion: that makes the poor old Kaiser look like an old woman knitting.
I have spent most of my life, since I was your age, studying Germanic matters (in the general sense that includes England and Scandinavia). There is a great deal more force (and truth) than ignorant people imagine in the 'Germanic' ideal. I was much attracted by it as an undergraduate (when Hitler was, I suppose, dabbling in paint, and had not heard of it), in reaction against the 'Classics'. You have to understand the good in things, to detect the real evil. But no one ever calls on me to 'broadcast', or do a postscript! Yet I suppose I know better than most what is the truth about this 'Nordic' nonsense. Anyway, I have in this War a burning private grudge - which would probably make me a better soldier at 49 than I was at 22: against that ruddy little ignoramus Adolf Hitler (for the odd thing about demonic inspiration and impetus is that it in no way enhances the purely intellectual stature: it chiefly affects the mere will). Ruining, perverting, misapplying, and making for ever accursed, that noble northern spirit, a supreme contribution to Europe, which I have ever loved, and tried to present in its true light."
You have to understand the good in things, to detect the real evil.
"I have begun again on the sequel to the 'Hobbit' - The Lord of the Ring. It is now flowing along, and getting quite out of hand. It has reached about Chapter VII and progresses towards quite unforeseen goals. I must say I think it is a good deal better in places and some ways than the predecessor; but that does not say that I think it either more suitable or more adapted for its audience. For one thing it is, like my own children (who have the immediate serial rights), rather 'older'. I can only say that Mr. [C.S.] Lewis (my stout backer of the Times and T.L.S.) professes himself more than pleased. If the weather is wet in the next fortnight we may have got still further on. But it is no bed-time story."
--letter of JRR Tolkien to Allen & Unwin, his publisher, 31 August 1938
I love the understatement of that. "Out of hand" indeed. If he could see the LOTR mania now, he would truly understand how "out of hand" it all is.
And the last sentence kills me. "...it is no bed-time story..."
The German publishing firm of Rutten & Loening contacted Allen & Unwin in 1938 (the publishers of The Hobbit) and wanted to negotiate with them for a German translation of the book. But first and foremost, they wanted to know if Tolkien was of "arisch" origin. (Aryan) Tolkien wrote a brief note to Stanley Unwin, saying that he wanted to refuse to give them an answer - He didn't want to add to "the wholly pernicious and unscientific race-doctrine" by comfirming or denying. However - he didn't want to ruin his chances of The Hobbit being read in Germany. He submitted to Mr. Unwin two drafts of letters to the German publishers, and left it up to Unwin to decide.
Here is one of the drafts:
25 July 1938
To Rutten & Loening Verlag
Dear Sirs,
Thank you for your letter ... I regret that I am not clear as to what you intend by arisch. I am not of Aryan extraction: that is Indo-iranian; as far as I am aware noone of my ancestors spoke Hindustani, Persian, Gypsy, or any related dialects. But if I am to understand that you are enquiring whether I am of Jewish origin, I can only reply that I regret that I appear to have no ancestors of that gifted people. My great-great-grandfather came to England in the eighteenth century from Germany: the main part of my descent is therefore purely English, and I am an English subject - which should be sufficient. I have been accustomed, nonetheless, to regard my German name with pride, and continued to do so throughout the period of the late regrettable war, in which I served in the English army. I cannot, however, forbear to comment that if impertinent and irrelevant inquiries of this sort are to become the rule in matters of literature, then the time is not far distant when a German name will no longer be a source of pride.
Your enquiry is doubtless made in order to comply with the laws of your own country, but that this should be held to apply to the subjects of another state would be improper, even if it had (as it has not) any bearing whatsoever on the merits of my work or its sustainability for publication, of which you appear to have satisfied yourselves without reference to my Abstammung.
I trust you will find this reply satisfactory, and remain yours faithfully
J.R.R. Tolkien
I need to write a post about Ted Hughes and Sylvia Plath - it's been a long time coming - and I have much to say. But first - I have got to point you over to Emily Jones' new blog ("It comes in pints?") - to read her post on the subject.
I couldn't agree with her assessment more. Ted Hughes has suffered enough to appease the gods of angry feminists - He has suffered MORE than enough. Well, he's dead now - so his suffering is over - and I hope he was able to find some peace at the end. Judging from the tone of The Birthday Letters, (the book of poems he published right before he died - poems in which he broke his long long silence about his marriage to Plath) he did not. He was a tormented man. He could not save her from herself. He would not sign up to be her Living God, the Ghost of her father come back to redeem the world of Men to her ... But so soon after leaving her, she committed suicide. And for this - he has been blamed for her death for 40 years.
Like I said, I have a lot to say. Let me formulate my thoughts a bit more.
But additionally - I must add, on a side note: Emily Jones is hilarious. The title of her post is Je n'accuse pas Ted Hughes. I can't explain why I think it is so funny, so a propos - but it is perfect. Je ne'accuse pas Ted Hughes.
ONE LAST THING: I write this post as a lifelong fan of Sylvia Plath's poems. I have gone through many phases of Plathian response - but what it really comes down to is - she's a frightening writer, a possessed writer - Something seems to be speaking through her. In high school, I was very angry with Ted Hughes. My anger came merely from reading her journals, and knowing that she would end up killing herself. How could he leave her?? How could he betray her?? I was in high school. I didn't really get, yet, that things are not foreordained. Ted Hughes could not have known she would take that step. He may have feared it, he may have tried to stop it ... but he is not to blame.
Like I said - I need to sit my ass down and write an essay.
I am a grown woman, I have had my share of heartache, stress, I take responsibility for my own life, I am an adult, but all of this does not stop me from behaving, at times, like a shrieking Beatle-maniac fainting and weeping at the Ed Sullivan Show.
What I mean is: if I am "into" somebody (musicians, actors, whatever) I am the best "fan" in the world. Truly. My loyalty knows no bounds. If you hook me once, then I am usually hooked forever, even if you never repeat the brilliance which hooked me in the first place.
Margaret Atwood is a prime example. Her books in the 1980s were IT for me. I read them compulsively, over and over and over again. Bodily Harm, in particular. Her books scared me, thrilled me, compelled me. Well...I am sorry, but Ms. Atwood has crashed off the rails and has not written a book which has kept my interest in almost 10 years. In longer than 10 years. Alias Grace was a BIG FAT YAWN. And The Assassin's Tale was essentially unreadable. It seems like something has actually happened to her talent itself. Her writing doesn't resonate. Perhaps it is that she is imitating herself, she is imitating what she did when she was more successful. The Assassin's Tale was terrible - the prose itself was terrible. I couldn't finish it.
But my point is: because she was once my favorite author, and I loved the experience of reading her earlier books, I continue to hold out hope. I continue to buy her crappy boring books, hoping that I will again recognize the terrifying fabulous voice of the Margaret Atwood I fell in love with in college.
The same is true in regards to Tori Amos. Oh, Tori, Tori...what has happened? Why do you bore me so?? Who, EXACTLY, do you think your audience is? What person would listen to your latest CDs and think the music was cool and fun? It would have to be a person who didn't get out much. Or someone constantly PMS-ing. Tori's first album Little Earthquakes was basically in my walkman for an entire year. I could not get enough, and my taste for her music raged on unabated like a fever. But since then, with brief moments of brilliance shining through the dreck (like the song "Waitress" on Under the Pink, and a couple of others), it seems like Tori has continuously been having some sort of New Age priestess breakdown, interspersed with Medean rage...which is all very interesting, but what I care about is that the music keeps SUCKING.
I want the rocking emotional Tori of days gone by. I want her to make the hair on my neck rise up again. ENOUGH with being creative and precious and innovative. Just do what you did back then, please.
But listen to my commitment to her!! I am not a fair-weather fan. I buy all of her CDs, hoping ... hoping ... that something will happen ... that I will hear HER again ... And that's only because of the impact that first album had on me.
Because of that, she's got me forever.
Dammit!
I was thinking the other day about Norman Rush - a man who wrote one of my favorite books of all time - Mating - a highly celebrated and award-winning first novel published in the 1980s. Rush's story is one of those dream-come-true stories for would-be writers. He publishes a couple short stories here and there - nothing major, no attention given them - and then - with his first novel hits a major jackpot.
I have read Mating probably 5 or 6 complete times over the years.
And earlier this year - suddenly - after never publishing ANYTHING after Mating - suddenly Rush came out with a second novel.
I have written quite a bit about Norman Rush in the past. Mating is a book which has engaged my imagination and intellect to a degree that few other books have ever reached. I cannot give you an easy explanation why - and I believe that that is one of the major strengths of the book.
It is a book I can keep re-visiting. It never appears to be the same book twice. I see different things in it each time I read it. Only great books can follow you through your life like that.
Here are some of my experiences with Rush and his writing. The first piece below tries to describe what it is about Mating that means so much to me - and how I felt when I realized Rush had published something else. The second piece describes my response to that long-awaited second novel called Mortals.
Today, that book is dog-eared from use. The cover is taped on. The pages are filled with underlinings. And in the back, on the couple of blank pages, I have crammed up that blank space with as many dictionary definitions of words found in this book as I could. The vocabulary in the book is, as my friend Allison called it, "daunting". I agree, and I have a pretty good vocabulary.
ressentiment: rancor expressed covertly against benefactors
proleptic: the anticipating/answering of objective/argument before it's put forward
omphalog: the naval/a center
copula: a verb that identifies the predicate of sentence with subject -- usually a form of 'to be'. "The girls are beautiful"
syncretist: attempt/tendency to combine or reconcile differing beliefs (philosophy or religion)
bolus: a small round mass. Greek: lump/clod
WHAT? Expanding my vocabulary was part of the fascination of the book.
But the hold Mating had, and still has on me, goes way deeper than that.
The characters in the book (mainly the two leads: Nelson Denoon and the unnamed female narrator) live on in my mind, the way characters like Holden Caulfield do. Or Captain Ahab. Or Anna Karenina. Their life, their potential life, does not stop with the words "The End". You cannot tell me that Holden does not live. It seems an insult to Salinger's creation.
There must be an alternate plane out in the ether, with fictional characters wandering about. Not every fictional character, because not every author manages to create a living, breathing, human personality. Actually, "human" is too limiting as well. Because, to my mind, Charlotte the spider (from EB White's Charlotte's Web) lives on. She exists on that alternate plane. As does Wilbur the pig. It's sort of like the plot of The Velveteen Rabbit. Once the rabbit is loved, and loved deeply, it becomes real.
I love all of these fictional characters in that way.
Mating is, on the surface, the story of a love affair. Other themes are: what to do about Africa, the problems with "development projects" and do-gooders in Africa, socialism in Africa, differences between men and women, competition between females for males (hence, the title) - and then, more specifically, an in-depth description of the world of Botswana: the diplomatic community in Gaborone, the issues with "villagization", the issues with development, how the development community lives high on the hog in Africa - etc. It's a BIG book, with BIG themes.
The main theme is something the author/narrator calls "intellectual love". Rush describes a very specific kind of love, and because he did so, and took such care with it, the concept became real to me. He articulated one of my deepest longings in a way I had never before encountered. It was like his words illuminated my own needs. Very interesting. Some quotes from the book in this vein:
My utopia is equal love, equal love between people of equal value, although value is an approximation for the word I want. Why is it so difficult? Assortative mating shows there has to be some drive in nature to bring equals together in the toils of love, so why even in the most enlightened and beautifully launched unions are we afraid we hear the master-slave relationship moving its slow thighs somewhere in the vicinity? It has to be cultural. In fact the closest thing to a religion I have is that this has to be cultural. I could do practically anything while he was asleep and not bother him. I wrote in my journal, washed dishes in slow motion if we hadn't gotten around to them. I was emotional a lot, privately. I wanted to incorporate everything, understand everything, because time is cruel and nothing stays the same.
More:
He was appropriate for me and the reverse. I felt it and hated it because it was true despite his being around fifteen years older than me. What did that mean about me? I also hated it because I hate assortative mating, the idea of it. One of my most imperishable objections to the world is the existence of assortative mating, how everyone at some level ends up physically with just who they deserve, at least to the eye of some ideal observer, unless money or power deforms the process. This is equivalent to being irritated at photosynthesis or at inhabiting a body that has to defecate periodically, I am well aware. Mostly it comes down to the matching of faces. When I first encountered the literature, I even referred to it privately as faceism. I will never adapt to it, probably. Why can't every mating in the world be on the basis of souls instead of inevitably and fundamentally on the match between physical envelopes? Of course we all know the answer, which is that otherwise we would be throwing evolution into disarray. Still it distresses me. We know what we are.
A couple of people I recommended this book to were extremely annoyed by the writing-voice, as evidenced in the passage above. I, however, LOVE the voice: cerebral, obsessively psychological, yearning, illogical -- It comes from right out of me. I relate. Here's more. The book is encyclopedic on love.
If I overdwell on this it can't be helped: love is important and the reasons you get it or fail are important. The number of women in my generation who in retrospect anyone will apply the term "great love" to, in any connection, is going to be minute. I needed to know if I had a chance here. Love is strenuous. Pursuing someone is strenuous. What I say is if you find yourself condemned to wanting love, you have to play while you can play. Of course it would be so much easier to play from the male side. They never go after love qua love, ever. They go after women. And for men love is the distillate or description of whatever happened with each woman that as not actually painful in feeling-tone. there is some contradiction here which I can't expel. What was moving me was the feeling of being worth someone's absolute love, great love, even. And to me this means male love whether I like it or not. C'est ca. Here I am, there I was. I don't know if getting love out of a man is more of a feat of strength now than it used to be or not, except that I do: it is. It's hideous. It's an ordeal beyond speech. When I'm depressed I feel like what was meant by one of his favorite quotations: A bitter feast was steaming hot and a mouth must be found to eat it. Men are like armored things, mountainous assemblages of armor and leather, masonry even, which you are told will self-dismantle if you touch the right spot, and out will flow passionate attention. And we know that this sometimes does happen for one of our sisters, or has happened. This comes full circle back to my attitude about kissing, which he never adjusted to. You want kisses, obviously. But you want kisses from a source, a person, who is in a state. This is why the plague of little moth kisses from men just planting their seniority on you is so intolerable. Of course even as I was machinating I was well aware I was in the outskirts of the suburb of the thing you want or suspect is there. But at this moment in my life I was at the point where even the briefest experience of unmistakable love would be something I could clutch to myself as proof that my theory of myself was not incorrect. Theories can be reactionary and still applicable.
And now, here is Rush's (or his nameless female narrator's) treatise on intellectual love. Obviously, this page in my book is covered in notes, and underlines. Oh, and I don't agree with every sentiment here, but that doesn't matter. I don't read books to meet people just like me. But it is the concept articulated here, the concept of 'intellectual love' which, for me, when I first read it, was like a lightbulb going on, or a door opening. I saw something new. I recognized the longings of my own heart when I read the following passage:
Intellectual love is not the same animal as landing a mentor, although women I've raised the construct with want to reduce it to that. I distrust and shun the whole mentor concept, which is just as well since I seem not to attract them. Nelson was not my mentor, ever. I gave as well as I got, with him. But there was intellectual love on my part, commencing circa that night.Intellectual love is a particular hazard for educated women, I think. Certain conditions have to obtain. You meet someone -- I would specify of the opposite sex, but this is obviously me being hyperparochial -- who strikes you as having persuasive and wellfounded answers to questions on the order of Where is the world going? These are distinctly not meaning-of-life questions. One thing Denoon did convince me of is that all answers so far to the question What is the meaning of life? dissolve into ascertaining what some hypostatized superior entity wants you to be doing, id est ascertaining how, and to whom or what, you should be in an obedience relationship. The proof of this is that no one would ever say, if he or she had been convinced that life was totally random and accidental in origin and evolution, that he or she had found the meaning of life. So, fundamentally, intellectual love is for a secular mind, because if you discover someone, however smart, is -- he has neglected to mention -- a Thomist or in Baha'i, you think of him as a slave to something uninteresting.
What beguiles you toward intellectual love is the feeling of observing a mental searchlight lazily turning here and there and lighting up certain parts of the landscape you thought might be dubious or fraudulent but lacked the time or energy to investigate or the inner authority to dismiss tout court. The searchlight confirms you.
Mating was the context in which I went through the major "love affair" in my past, with a man who shall remain nameless. My friend Mitchell, who also read and loved the book Mating , referred to this man as "your Nelson Denoon". The similarities were arresting. And when everything fell apart with "my Nelson Denoon", leaving a nightmare in its wake, that book became even more of an anchor.
In the past couple of weeks, I took Mating out to read again.
It is a first novel, and what a first novel. He has not published anything since. There was a book of short stories called Whites which came out years ago, but besides his magnum opus, Norman Rush has been silent.
Mating was a huge hit, financially and critically, it won the National Book Award in 1991. Rush clearly put everything he knows about everything into that book. It's about love, obviously, but it's also about Africa, and politics, and socialism, and the position of women in Africa, and religion. It's a book dedicated to taking a large view of the issues in Africa - and yet it is still an extremely personal story.
And the ending. The last section, a kind of epilogue, is called "About the Foregoing". It is very mysterious. It ends on a very ambiguous note.
She has left Africa, and has left Denoon, her great love. Things have fallen apart. She is now trying to get her life together when suddenly she gets a mysterious message, telling her to come back to Africa. It is not Denoon who calls her. It is a woman. She does not know who this woman could be. Or why she has been summoned. She obsesses about it, wondering what to do. Should she return? What would be waiting for her in Africa? If Denoon did not summon her, then perhaps she would not be welcome anymore? The book ends with these two lines:
Je viens. Why not?
So, the book leaves you knowing she is going to return, but you do not know the outcome.
I have been haunted by this. Then what? Then what? It has been so long since Mating came out. I have tried to reconcile myself to the fact that I need to, a la Rilke, "live the questions".
The fact that the book ends mysteriously, that it could go either way, confirms for me one of the essential tenets of my life:
You just never know what will happen. Things can always go either way. Also: Things never really end. Not really. They transform, they morph. Love never dies. Ever. I'm not an "I love you I love you - oh you don't love me back anymore? Then I hate you I hate you" kind of girl. Sometimes I wish I were. It might be easier if love turned readily to hate, but for me, it does not.
So alongside my relatively quiet life now are the vibrant exciting love affairs of my past. They make me who I am today. They do not go away, or submerge into the past for good. They are still very much with me, late and soon.
Literally last week, I became obsessed again by the up-in-the-air ending of Mating. What does it signify? What is the message?
And more than that, on a more literal level, on a more literary level: What happened when she returned to Africa? Are they together now? Out on that alternate plane for fictional characters? I always liked to imagine that they were. It made me happy to imagine so. It made me happy to fantasize that on that alternate plane, all turned out well. Eventually.
It's a sort of "Somewhere over the rainbow" sentiment. Things may be lonely here on this plane, but somewhere -- even if it's just for characters in a book -- things might work out. And this alone gives me reason to hope. Things just might work out -- because the ending of Mating doesn't make it clear whether they do or no. This is the degree to which this book affected me, and the degree to which these characters LIVE on in my imagination.
On a personal note: I used to have these old crazy fantasies about "my Nelson Denoon", fantasies which felt more like getting a glimpse of a never-before-seen alternate path. I comforted myself, after it was all over, by imagining that on that other plane, down that other path, things might have worked out. Or in another lifetime, although reincarnation and alternate lifetimes are not quite in my belief system.
However, I became convinced that this was not the first time around for me and "my Nelson Denoon". I would obsess about it. "Were we married in another life? Or ... with each successive lifetime, are we coming closer to one another? It just so happens that I am stuck in the lifetime where it doesn't work out..." I was blithering like that to my patient friend Kate. She listened. And then she said, "Actually, I bet that your Celtic tribe probably slaughtered his Celtic tribe." We roared.
So I digress. All of these crazy thoughts are very tied up, for me, in Norman Rush's book.
All of this came up to the foreground again, in the last week, (it all began dovetailing), and I thought, impulsively: "I should just write to Norman Rush and ask him what he's up to ... if he's working on anything ..." He hasn't published anything else since Mating, so -- I wondered --- is he chugging away at a sequel? Is he dead? I needed to know desperately.
"Mr. Rush -- are you just going to leave me hanging with the end of Mating? Do you know how important it is, how essential it is in terms of my understanding of how the world works, that I know what happened with the two of them? Will I ever know the outcome?"
Wanting to write to Norman Rush was a random fleeting thought. I have written to authors before, so it wasn't too far-fetched.
Then, a couple of days ago, I stopped off at a computer place to check my email. While there, I visited my SiteMeter for this blog, to check in on my traffic. I saw that someone had gotten to me by typing "Norman Rush" into Google. It led this person to that excerpt. And this piqued my interest. Somebody else is looking for Norman Rush right now? Why? Is something going on?
So I blatantly Googled the man.
The first thing that came up was a Village Voice article dated May, 2003. I opened it, and lo and freakin' behold, it was a review of his new book. The man has a new book out. Mortals.
I hope I have conveyed how important this is to me. But I am having a hard time finding the words.
It would be like hearing that JD Salinger had suddenly come out of hiding and published a new novel. While Salinger is still alive, there is still hope that he may write again. He just might. And the book might be crap, but that wouldn't matter. At least not at first. It would be a miracle. To hear from that writer again.
So Rush has a new huge novel out. And again, it takes place in Botswana, Africa. Botswana! The country that Rush made live for me.
Mortals (and I just skimmed the article feverishly ... I didn't want to read any spoilers, no give-aways, nothing that would ruin the experience) is NOT about Nelson Denoon and our beloved unnamed narrator. It is another couple altogether, although Rush again tackles man/woman relationships, only time in the context of marriage. It doesn't seem to be so much about finding the right mate, and how arduous that process is, how it can break your heart. Rush now goes into the realm of established intimacy, and ... what happens then?
And here's the thing: (WARNING: SPOILER ALERT)
I raced through the book review excitedly and could not believe my eyes: Nelson and "she" DO show up in this new book, peripherally. They ARE characters on the outskirts. And, oh so casually, Village Voice reviewer states: "We learn that they have married."
What? They married?? I almost shouted out loud for joy.
I didn't read the rest of the review, I signed out immediately, paid my bill, and hustled my ass down to Barnes & Noble to find the book, which had been published THAT WEEK.
(Okay, let's just take a moment to reflect on how weird that is. I contemplate writing to Norman Rush, pestering him to write a sequel, and dammitall if he doesn't have a new book published on almost that same exact day.)
And there it was. A huge book. Hardcover. With a map of Botswana inside. I got a chill of excitement. I felt voracious. Almost sick to my stomach, actually. I wanted to download the entire book into my brain immediately. I glanced through and saw that there was a chapter called "The Denoons", and I had to restrain myself. Prolong the anticipation, more pleasure that way.
And as I was walking down the street, with my booty in my bag, I suddenly got weirdly emotional.
It was as though I had heard that real friends of mine had finally gotten married after much strife.
It would be like if me and "my Nelson Denoon" ever got hitched (not a possibility anymore). But let's just say he and I got hitched - my friends, who went through the whole thing with me, would probably jump up and down for joy, yelling, "At last!" Okay? This is the power this book has for me. I felt -- well, it's a bit embarrassing to admit, but I was almost in tears, truth be told.
There have been times in the past couple of years when life has been the cliched howling wilderness. "My Nelson Denoon" remains a kind of monument, a sort of goal. I have tried to knock him off that pedestal, but I have finally accepted the fact that he actually deserves to be up there. Whether I am with him or not. This is a bit more personal than I normally write, but this is my blog, and this is what is going on with me right now.
When things did not come to fruition between us, my baffled thought was: If that didn't work out, that which seemed so damn right, then what the hell will work out? For quite a long time, my answer to that question was: Nothing. Nothing.
But then ... here ... years later ... walking down the street, knowing that she and Nelson got married -- after all that --
I suddenly felt an upsurge of hope. Not for me and "my Nelson Denoon", because like I said earlier: that is no longer possible. But what I mean is: hope in general.
A word on hope:
Hope for me, now, always goes hand in hand with a bittersweet and rather vague pain. Hope never ever comes by itself anymore. The way it used to when I was a little kid, or a teenager. I suppose that's indicative of age and experience. It seems so to me anyway. That's life. I am not saying this exactly as I wanted to. Basically: Hope no longer comes alone.
The sadness and hope I felt, walking down the street, wasn't about Nelson and the narrator of Mating being married... at least, not only about them. The sadness and hope was also from how I see life now. In terms of mating. I feel like I had my run. It was a good run. I had a lot of fun, a lot of laughs. But that all has stopped now. And that's why hope never comes alone anymore.
I still feel hope, occasionally, but never ever by itself.
So I got overwhelmed by this weird sense of sad hope --- a feeling that STILL, after all THAT, "things" might "work out". For me, in my life. It's awful when one becomes afraid to feel hope anymore, protecting oneself against the inevitable disappointment. This is a constant balancing act.
I am not a young girl of 22, with a couple of disappointments in my past (like David W. saying no to being my date at the junior prom, etc.) ... I am in my 30s, and I've been through a lot. Not all bad. Of course not all bad. Like I said: a lot of laughs. Much fun. But now, I just find it easier not to hope ... at least in that arena ... and focus on other things. My work. My ambition, my plans.
But ... but ....
They got married. They got married. What does that mean? For me?
(This is the level to which literature can affect me - if I let it! The Shipping News had a similar impact.)
I am so used to the state of affairs I live in now, since I have lived there now for about a decade. I mean, I have changed and grown, of course, I have moved from city to city, I got my Master's, I've made new friends, it has been a very full existence. But I have been alone the entire time. THAT has not changed. Not even close.
Perhaps a breakthrough is approaching. A breakthrough in how I see all of this. And the appearance of Norman Rush's Mortals is the harbinger of something good. Or, something different. Something exciting, unforeseen, challenging. That's what I was feeling as I walked down the street, too. I'm scared of it ... and yet. Perhaps it is time. I don't know. Even as I write that, the logical side of my brain, the side that has all the experience, that knows the let-downs, etc., says: "Yes, but you have felt this before. You have felt this so strongly before. And you were never right."
But maybe ... maybe ... Maybe this is it.
There is SOMETHING weird about how all of this has come about:
Mating
The book being wrapped up with "my Nelson Denoon"
Wishing the main characters well -- hoping they are happy in another reality
Holding onto a weird strange hope that things worked out well, at least for them
Wondering if a sequel was coming
Studying the book over the last couple of weeks
That book, for me, is the monument, the goal
Wanting to write to Norman Rush
Someone coming to MY blog, through Googling Norman Rush ...during the very week I was obsessing about Rush, and where he was, and whether or not he was writing
Finding out that Rush has written a new book ... published last week ... in which we discover the Denoons have married
And so:
Things are not what they seem.
Back to the old painful belief: You never ever know what will happen. You can never tell what the future will hold. Your predictions will all be wrong.
I have tentatively and slowly begun Mortals, forcing myself not to browse ahead, looking for references to the Denoons. I want to savor every word.
I have waited for this day for so long.
I am having a very hard time getting through it. As a matter of fact, I have stopped reading it completely.
Mating is a special book. Mortals is not. By page 100 I was sick of the two main characters. Norman Rush obviously finds them both very fascinating, and endearing. So every single tangent in the minds of the characters needs to be drawn out for sometimes THIRTY PAGES ...
If I had a marriage like those two do, I might have to slit my wrists. Just to escape and get some peace and quiet, for God's sake.
It is so self-conscious. So pleased with itself. So obsessively analytical. Do these two people ever just sit on the damn couch and NOT talk to each other?? That is my ideal relationship. One that is filled with an inordinate amount of comfortable shared silence.
Another thing Rush does is continuously assure us of how funny Iris (one of the boring main characters) is. He fetishizes her humor. He gives us glimpses of it (or tries to). But mostly he just repeatedly states it, as though it is an indisputable fact. "She was such a funny woman." "He loved her humor." "He was going to be losing a funny woman."
The problem with this goes back to one of the first rules of writing: SHOW. Don't TELL.
I don't think Iris is funny. She never made me laugh. And you can't keep just re-assuring me: "No no no, wait, she is a DAMN funny woman! You have to see her when she's had a couple of glasses of wine! She is a riot!" That doesn't work in a book. It doesn't work in life either. Either something IS, and you know that it IS because it can be SEEN and ACKNOWLEDGED by more than one person, or it ISN'T. Iris ISN'T funny, in my book.
Just saying it is so, Mr. Rush, does not make it so.
He gives us examples of her humor, but ... to my mind, it's all coy stupid little puns. Now I know some truly funny people, people who you describe as "Oh my God, he is so funny" if you are asked "What is that person like?" Humor is undeniable. It's not like being sensitive, or being kind, or intelligent. You cannot fake humor. Some people THINK they are hilarious, but no one is laughing.
I think I have made my point here.
The good parts of the book are when it goes into the life of a CIA agent ... how they live, their relationship to "the agency" -- what it meant for the CIA when communism fell apart. What that event did to the psychology of the agency, etc. What it is like to have a job which is, for the most part, invisible. You will never be acknowledged publicly for your work. You cannot talk about it with your wife. All of that, so far, has been very interesting.
There's also a long sequence where Ray, the main character, is being held prisoner in this warehouse in northwest Botswana. The Boers are involved. He is being held hostage with this other man, an African, who is a psychiatrist, and very anti-Christian. His name is Morel. Morel has lived in England for years and has returned to Botswana on a mission to rescue Africa from the yoke of Christianity. He thinks organized religion is designed to keep people passive, to keep people in a state of waiting, etc. Morel is an African. Morel believes that what Africa needs is common sense, industry, and people willing to invest in THIS life. It's an interesting question - which is also brought out to interminable degrees in Mortals, but I actually have learned a lot, and it made me think.
Ray is obsessed with the poet Milton. Which is understandable - fine. I am relatively obsessed with Milton myself.
But what I am picking up on, somehow, in the writing of this book, is that it is RUSH who is obsessed with Milton, and has tried to wrestle Milton into this story, in order to express how he, Rush, feels about Milton. And because of that, it doesn't really work. It reads as very self-indulgent.
An interesting contrast: June 16 is Bloomsday (the day to celebrate James Joyce and Ulysses - which all takes place on June 16).
The entire summer of 2002, for me, was taken up by James Joyce. Joyce Joyce Joyce.
Now you kind of cannot find a more subjective writer, a person more fascinated with his own obsessions, a person who can go off on a tangent for thirty pages just because the subject matter interests him.
June 16 came smack in the middle of my struggling with Mortals, and there are some vague similarities between the books. And yet Ulysses captivated me, challenged me. One author (Joyce) goes off on tangents, and I suddenly find myself looking stuff up on the Internet, calling my dad for information, trying to understand what exactly he is getting at ... what is REALLY going on in the book. The other author (Rush) goes off on tangents, obsessed with his own obsessions, and I get increasingly annoyed, thinking to myself: "Shut UP! You're not the first freakin' person to discover Milton ... Get OVER it...Shut UP! Get to the friggin' point, man."
So here's the difference, the undeniable difference:
James Joyce is a genius.
You should not attempt such a book unless you are CERTAIN that you yourself are a genius.
Here's where I stopped reading Mortals, and I will eventually finish it, because I still feel a certain amount of obligation toward the writer who brought Mating into my life.
Okay: So Ray (the CIA agent) and Morel (the African crusader) are being held in this warehouse, and are pulled out separately by these Boer thugs to be tortured, on occasion. It is a bad situation. The two of them are enemies, for a very boring reason. It is a plot device, rather than a reality. So they are forced to deal with each other. There is a bucket in the room for them to use as a toilet, and there are two pages, two pages which took two years off my life, years I can never get back, where Morel goes to the bathroom, and he is constipated, so it is difficult for him, and Ray, to relax Morel and also to distract himself from the shitting going on across the room, recites Milton outloud.
I read those two pages. And then I put the damn book down and have not picked it up since.
When I pick the book up again, I am going to have to skip the Milton-recital-during-Morel's-"evacuation" (a word Rush actually used, and which, quite frankly, grossed me OUT.) and pick up from after that episode. Evacuation? I'm sorry, but that is NASTY.
Now, when we first meet Leopold Bloom in Ulysses, he is eating breakfast with his wife Molly before leaving for the day. He is inwardly anxiously, thinking she has cuckolded him. But before he leaves, he goes into the bathroom and shits. It was hugely shocking at the time ... you don't usually follow characters into the bathroom like that, but Joyce did.
I read the whole sequence, and laughed out loud at the audacity of it ... the reality of it ... and the thing is about it: there was a POINT. He is bringing us all down to the human level. It may be pedantic to say to ourselves, as a way of reassurance, "Everybody has a crack in their ass." Or: "Yes, he may be Secretary of State, but he goes to the bathroom like everybody else." But it is the human condition. It's the truth.
That's what I got when Joyce followed Bloom into the bathroom like that. I became overwhelmed by humanity. The tragi-comic nature of our existence.
There was a higher point to the scene. Not to mention Joyce's desire to really stick it to the priggish censors, and to really tell the truth about Ireland. There is a POINT.
In Mortals, there is no point. And the scene goes on FOREVER.
In Mortals I just got grossed out and now I cannot get the image of Morel squatting over the bucket out of my mind. I wish I could. I need that brain space for other things.
I need to take a break from boring old Ray the CIA agent and his un-funny wife Iris, and the African Morel going to the bathroom in the corner, while Areopagitica is being recited. Jesus. Spare me.
What a disappointment.
My love for the book Mating is untouched, however. Perhaps that was Norman Rush's one story. Some writers only have one tale in them. They may try to do more, tell other stories - but they fail.
Perhaps Rush is one of those writers.
A great piece on bad academic writing (which is, perhaps, an unnecessary redundancy). Camille Paglia has been bitching about this for years - the primacy of "theory" in universities - and how it is killing adventurous thought, and any kind of honest intellectual inquiry.
Ophelia Benson, in this blistering piece, calls a spade a spade.
...Another benefit of talking about theory-disparagers' being frightened off is that by implication it makes the theory-lovers seem brave, daring, butch, risk-takers, rebels. Or at least that's what it's meant to do, but the trouble is of course it doesn't. The whole maneuver is so transparently self-flattering that you would think such a knowing, hip, wised-up, rhetoric-conscious crowd would notice the fact, blush violently, and delete that bit of text. But no. Perhaps they think we don't notice? Perhaps they think that because the non-theory team is by definition and invariably so frightened off by questions about language that we are entirely blind deaf and stupid about rhetoric? Perhaps, but sadly for them, we're not, and we can see perfectly well what they're doing.And the same goes for the 'difficulty' ploy. That's also a popular one, of course. Theory isn't gibberish or vacuity dressed up in resounding neologisms appropriated from Lacan and Derrida - no, it's difficult. It addresses subjects so complicated and arcane and profound that a special new language is required in order to deal with them at all.
It's ridiculous - truly.
I'm a big fan of Dennis Dutton's yearly "Bad Writing Contest" , hosted by Arts & Letters Daily - which exposes these academic buffoons for what they are. Uh ... buffoons.
The winning entries are always laughably impenetrable.
The only people who read that stuff are ... other people who write like that. It's like a strange doomed contest to see who can write in the most incoherent way.
How in the world has this occurred?? I have a feeling it all goes back to post-modernism, and de-constructionism - a worthy pursuit in the abstract - but when you get right down to it: dammit, is a poem good to read? Does the language sweep you away? As a whole, what does it say to you?
All of this "theory" takes the juice out of ANY writing. It tries to make language manageable, understandable, easily broken down into components. The theorists can then be Masters of the Universe - they can translate everything for the un-washed masses.
I can hear the cackles of Shakespeare and Chaucer and James Joyce now.
"De-construct ME? You must be MAD! Just read it out loud - just hear the sounds - do I not amaze you?"
Just for a joke - here is one of the winning entries in the Bad Writing Contest:
The move from a structuralist account in which capital is understood to structure social relations in relatively homologous ways to a view of hegemony in which power relations are subject to repetition, convergence, and rearticulation brought the question of temporality into the thinking of structure, and marked a shift from a form of Althusserian theory that takes structural totalities as theoretical objects to one in which the insights into the contingent possibility of structure inaugurate a renewed conception of hegemony as bound up with the contingent sites and strategies of the rearticulation of power.
Woah.
I can only look at that sentence and think: Such language only emerges from a very confused and unorganized mind.
Extended post on Oxblog by Patrick Belton about Paul Muldoon, specifically, and Irish poets in general.
I love Paul Muldoon, as well.
I've seen Seamus Heaney a couple of times, when he gives readings at NYU. You just fall in love with him. You just have to.
And I heard Nuala Ni Dhomhnaill read her work at the Ireland House, here in New York - which was an extraordinary experience. She only writes in Irish. "I can't hear the poetry in English." So Nuala talked about her process, she described what was going on with her when writing each poem, she gave a brief synopsis of the poem, all in English - and then she launched into the Irish language for the poem itself. And dammitall, if you couldn't get her exact meaning.
Anyway -
Patrick at Oxblog: You must ask Muldoon out for a pint, and then tell us all how it goes.
Thanks for a very unexpected post - a topic which is very dear to my heart.
Here's a bit of Paul Muldoon:
"The Sightseers"
My father and mother, my brother and sister
and I, with uncle Pat, our dour best-loved uncle,
had set out that Sunday afternoon in July
in his broken-down Ford
not to visit some graveyard -- one died of shingles,
one of fever, another's knees turned to jelly --
but the brand-new roundabout at Ballygawley,
the first in mid-Ulster.
Uncle Pat was telling us how the B-Specials
had stopped him one night somewhere near Ballygawley
and smashed his bicycle
and made him sing the Sash and curse the Pope of Rome.
They held a pistol so hard against his forehead
there was still the mark of an O when he got home.
Jean Kerr, author of the classic Please Don't Eat the Daisies, died in January.
I haven't thought about Kerr's writing in years. God bless Jean Kerr, and all that she gave us, her contributions to the literature of motherhood. In particular, the literature of how to balance motherhood and work. And she was way ahead of her time, writing about these issues in the 50s. This article made me miss Jean Kerr's voice ... forgotten now in the "Oh my God, how am I going to balance it all and be the perfect everything?" tone which has hijacked the genre. Jean Kerr, an enormously successful playwright and essayist, who had 6 children, never believed she could do it all. And never ever thought that she was perfect. Which is why her books are so damn FUNNY.
I highly recommend Jean Kerr's work to all of the mothers that I know. Here is an example of her tone. This excerpt is taken from the book Please Don't Eat the Daisies, her memoir, written in the 1950s, about what it was like to be a writer (extremely successful, remember ... we are not talking about trying to get poems into teeny literary journals ... we are talking about the author of some of the biggest Broadway hits of the day) and the mother of 6 children. Please Don't Eat the Daisies was made into a cheese-ball Doris Day movie, which I saw, but if you've seen it, and thought it was a big load of CRAP, then just go out and read the book. Do yourself a favor. It will make you laugh.
The following quote is Kerr describing how the book got its name:
My real problem with children is that I haven't any imagination. I'm always warning them against the common-place defections while they are planning the bizarre and unusual. Christopher gets up ahead of the rest of us on Sunday mornings and he has long since been given a list of clear directives: 'Don't wake the baby,' 'Don't go outside in your pajamas,' 'Don't eat cookies before breakfast.' But I never told him, 'Don't make flour paste and glue together all the pages of the magazine section of the Sunday Times.' Now I tell him, of course.And then last week I had a dinner party and told the twins and Christopher not to go in the living room, not to use the guest towels in the bathroom, and not to leave the bicycles on the front step. However, I neglected to tell them not to eat the daisies on the dining-room table. This was a serious omission, as I discovered when I came upon my centerpiece--a charming three-point arrangement of green stems.
A couple of years ago, I found a beat-up old copy of Please Don't Eat the Daisies at the Strand and pounced on it like a starving woman. Kerr is a bit of a treasure. She really is.
Elizabeth Austin, author of this tribute, articulates exactly her appeal. Which, perhaps, is a bit sugar-coated. Or not even sugar-coated ... just not the whole truth. As in: Jean Kerr left out the more unpleasant and worrisome aspects of being a mother and a working woman. But Austin says:
Once I'd gobbled my way through Kerr's slim oeuvre, I went looking eagerly for another writer just as good. Decades later, I'm still looking. No one since has managed to write about the domestic scene with Mrs. Kerr's pitch-perfect balance of wit, warmth, and intelligence. Instead, the mother/writers of the half-century have focused on the anxieties and stresses of parenting. Personally, I don't need anybody to tell me how hard it is to bring up a child; trust me, I already know.
Austin compares Jean Kerr, a writer from the 1950s, with Erma Bombeck, a writer who tackles the same issues, only in the 1970s. Erma Bombeck is, of course, hysterical ... but it's a question of attitude, the attitude one takes towards the chaos of family life. And about yourself, trying to juggle all of these different roles.
Read:
Although Erma Bombeck was just five years younger than Kerr, her career peaked in the '70s with such dismally titled bestsellers as The Grass is Always Greener over the Septic Tank; If Life is a Bowl of Cherries, What Am I Doing in the Pits?; I Lost Everything in the Post-Natal Depression. Her wisecracking, oy-vey approach to life guaranteed her a huge audience, although it didn't do much for the psyche of the American mother. It's downright dispiriting to read much Bombeck. Her world is one of unappreciated, unfulfilled wives and mothers drudging away year after year, hoping to receive that one glimmer of recognition that will make it all worthwhile ...Kerr never lets us that far inside. She writes mirthfully about raising a bumper crop of children spaced erratically over a couple of decades; there's never the tiniest hint that a 40-ish woman who has spent half a lifetime in the maternal trenches might entertain some mixed feelings about starting over with an infant. When she writes about her lastborn baby daughter, all we hear is bemused delight: "She smiled the kind of smile that would give you hope in February. Then she held up her arms and said, very distinctly, 'Hi, little fella.'" We'll never know whether Kerr was guilty of a little retrospective sugar-coating. But I do know which book I'd recommend to an overwhelmed friend facing an unexpected pregnancy post-40.
I loved the following section of the tribute to Kerr:
Austin takes on Salon's series of essays called "Mothers who Think" (a title which always bothered me for some reason ... and now I know why.) Here is what she says:
I sometime wonder what Kerr would have made of Salon's long-running feature, "Mothers Who Think." Did that title refer only to the authors? Or was it a device allowing homebound, cranky readers to feel intellectually superior to those morons on the kindergarten fun fair committee? Sure, MWT offered a good number of interesting and well-written pieces. But the title--like many of the essays in the series--had a chip on its shoulder, as illustrated by the flap copy of the collected MWT essays, which calls them a "testament to the notion that motherhood gives women more to think about, not less." Of course it does; you just have less time to write it all down.
Jean Kerr completely lacks the sense of self-important grievance which so dominates the dialogue about balancing motherhood and work these days. She acknowledges the problems, yes. But she treats the entire topic with humor. And WIT. A fresh breeze of wit. Jesus, I don't have kids yet, but all of the books out there seem designed to scare me, warn me off, tell me how BAD it is, how HARD it is, how IMPOSSIBLE it is to have it all. But Kerr does not go that route. She takes a bemused attitude to the entire thing. It is not the end of the world that your children ate the daisies, it doesn't mean you have failed as a mother and a homemaker, it doesn't mean you are not living up to all of the expectations you heaped on your head ... It means that now you have to remind yourself to say to your kids, "Please don't eat the daisies."
Perhaps it is an over-simplification of all the stresses women face. I am sure it is. But I believe we can make things worse by over-thinking things, over-worrying things, and completely taking on the idea that society expects you to be perfect. If somebody expects you to be perfect, then that is THEIR problem, not yours.
This is an idea I have struggled with my entire life. There have been years in my life when my struggle to be perfect, to live up to the imagined expectations of others, has completely RUN my entire existence. It is a terrible thing. I still do not have a handle on it. I am still a Nervous Nellie. If I "fail", I still am apt to take it on in some sort of global way. ie: I burnt the toast = I am a terrible person, and barely a woman at all. I am not fit for relationships and no man will ever love me. I will not be able to raise children effectively, I will ruin their lives.
STUPID, but very human. Everybody has this to some degree.
Jean Kerr, as well. But she laughs it off.
Here's what Austin has to say about that:
The thing I most love about Kerr, and the generation of women who were her most loyal readers, is that they seemed to be taking motherhood on a pass-fail basis. They weren't competing desperately for straight A's on the homefront--nor were they "surrendered" wives and mothers, submerging their identities into the giant gaping maw of family life. They were active and energetic but never "busier-than-thou," and they seemed to be having more fun than any grown-up woman I see around me today--myself included.
It reminds me of some of my earliest memories of childhood.
Early memories come through the senses. We add meaning to them later.
So for me: here is what comes up from those long-ago days:
Bright sunshine. Hot flagstones. Fisher Price people all set up. Hilarious fun being had with siblings and cousins. (This is a memory from our summers at Lake Sunapee.) Sun on the birch trees. Blue lake through the trees. Cap'n Crunch cereal. The world of childhood. Fun, fun, fun.
But on the outskirts of all of this, were my aunts and uncles (many of them younger than I am now), and my parents. This is the early 70s. So I remember my mom's fabulous white pants ... her Dr. Scholls shoes (we called them "clackers") ... the sound of adult voices and laughter on the edge of our childhood world. We were separate. Adults over there, children over here. We did not need to be occupied, or have activities planned for us. The grownups did not bend over backwards to entertain us, to keep us happy.
They stood over on the side, smoking cigarettes, wearing bikinis, drinking gin and tonics, talking, laughing, and, I am sure, having a blast on an adult level.
Then something would happen in the child-world which would demand notice from the adults. A fight breaking out. A child skinning his knee. Tears of pain. And the mothers, gin and tonics in hand, would click-clack over to us, and soothe the wounds, kiss it better, make us make up, etc.
I remember one moment vividly from these Sunapee summers, I must have been ... 4? I was in the water, beside the dock, flopping around on a piece of styrofoam. I had no life-preserver on. I don't think I could swim. But all the adults were right there, up on the dock, sitting in deck chairs ... again, with little cups in hand, the clinking of ice. Summer vacation. And I fell off the piece of styrofoam and began to sink. I remember all of the bubbles. The light coming through the bubbles. Sinking down. (Remember, the water was only 3 feet deep or something like that.)
And suddenly, there was a crash from above ... a mighty roar of blinding white ... a tsunami of water, and within a moment, I was up on the dock, heaving for breath. Heart pounding. My mother, dressed in the white bell bottom-y pants (which she probably made), and her clackers, turned, saw me sinking, and leapt into the lake, fully clothed, to save me.
I have tears in my eyes. Mothers!!
What does all this have to do with Please Don't Eat the Daisies? I'm not sure.
But I do know I grew up with a mother who had that Jean Kerr thing going on. It was not easy for her, I am sure. There were four of us. My mother is an incredible woman, with a lot of gifts, a lot to contribute to the world. Her only accomplishment is not her children. She has a lot going on. But she never seemed to get caught up in the stressed-out perfectionist brand of mothering. She was much more matter-of-fact. At least in my memory. She cared about the RIGHT things, and let all the other stuff go. She, to quote somebody else, did not "sweat the small stuff".
I also got the sense that my parents were friends ... their only bond was not US. They talked to each other about grown-up stuff, and we had to fend for ourselves. WHICH IS NOT A BAD THING. I loved knowing my parents had a relationship ... where they talked to each other. I didn't know it was rare and weird until I encountered other families. My mom did not sigh like a martyr, or huff and puff, fuming in silence about things. I don't think my mother has an "Oh, poor me" bone in her body. She may have had her darker moments, when she was by herself, but I did not pick up on that sort of anxiety and anger from her as a child, and for that I am very grateful.
My memory of my mother from those early early years is of a benevolent freckled watching woman on the sidelines, talking with her friends, or her sisters, wearing clackers, looking fabulous, enjoying her life for the most part. And also completely ready to throw herself into the lake at a moment's notice to save my drowning ass!
I was clearing out my AOL Filing Cabinet today (long story), and came across an email I sent to a dear friend this summer. I read it, uneasy, with an odd feeling of nostalgia. It was only two months ago. Why this yearning sensation? I had forgotten, almost, the Joycean obsession which fired up my June and July. So much has happened in the intervening months, so much personal and world-events darkness, that the innocent burbly ramblings in this email seem as though they were written by another woman.
Here it is:
James Joyce has ruined other writers for me. I am reading Ulysses for the first time aided by my dad and 2 literary guidebooks -- without which the damn thing would be impenetrable But once I cracked Joyce's code just a little bit, the book would suddenly, oddly, open up to me. Showing me only glimpses of the genius, but glimpses nonetheless.
It's like those moments I used to have in math class, where I would be completely confused, all the numbers blending together on the board, having no idea what was going on, what I was supposed to be doing, how to do it...and then, in a flash, out of nowhere, the concepts made sudden breathtaking sense, and I could "see" exactly how I was supposed to get the right answer. That's what reading Ulysses has been like for me: slogging through seemingly meaningless stream-of-consciousness prose, when suddenly...light breaks in and I realize that NOTHING is random in the book. There are connections and inter-connections EVERYWHERE.
It is, hands down, the most exciting reading experience I have ever had.
And it is KICKING MY ASS. It is hard hard stuff. (James Joyce said to a friend who complained to him about how difficult the book was: "Well, it took me 7 years to write it. It should take you 7 years to read it.")
Reading it has brought me and my dad even closer together. I call him up and read him one sentence, asking for clarification. One sentence out of a 900 page book and he will automatically say, "Ah yes. That's from the Cyclops episode. Joyce is referring to the editor of The Irish Times at the time." My dad is a lunatic, and I couldn't get thru Ulysses without him.
I'm becoming a lunatic myself. I am living more and more completely in my mind.
A stranger on the street saw Ulysses under my arm and stopped me to have a conversation about it. "So are you reading it unaided, or are you following the guidebooks?" So funny. It was like we were 2 members of some weird cult. Huddled away in a thatched hut, drinking Guinness, reading Joyce. Thinking to ourselves, "Jesus, what the hell is Joyce going on and on about?"
And on the flip side, in the physical side of my life which I pretty much willfully ignore: I went out with Jen last night to a club in the village, to hear an absolutely phenomenal cover band of all things, and danced like a complete and utter maniac until 4 in the morning. 4 in the morning??
They did a cover of "Lithium", my favorite Nirvana song, and I basically felt as though Kurt Cobain were ACTUALLY there. We all did. Everyone was screaming and thrashing like complete banshees, losing their friggin minds. I haven't slamdanced in 10 years. There was an exhilaratingly cosmic element to the group-dance-fest. For one bright moment, we felt that Cobain had not died. He LIVED in that song. I lost myself in it. Everybody did.
Today I am exhausted. Hence this long bizarre monologue.
James Joyce and Kurt Cobain. The two poles of my life.
A beautiful bio of Robert McCloskey, who died yesterday.
I loved the quote from him, where he talks about how he started out wanting to do "great art", but "great art" has a way of not paying well, so he ended up bringing some of his work to be evaluated by an editor for children's books:
I never sold an oil painting, only a few water colors at the most modest prices, and financially my art career was a bust. I went to call on an editor of children's books in New York. I came into her office with my folio under my arm and sat on the edge of my chair. She looked at the examples of "great art" that I had brought along (they were woodcuts, fraught with black drama). I don't remember just the words she used to tell me to get wise to myself and to shelve the dragons, Pegasus, and limpid pool business and learn how and what to "art" with. I think we talked mostly of Ohio.
That one quote alone makes me think that I would have liked the man, had I met him in person. "Shelve the dragons, Pegasus, and limpid pool business" -- a smart woman, that editor! There is also a beautiful story of how he brought ducks home to his apartment, so he could draw them, in preparation for what would eventually be the classic children's book Make Way for Ducklings.
Robert McCloskey's books were the first to hypnotize me. The first in a long long line of books which captivated my heart, my mind, cracked open a door inside me, showing me other worlds, other lives, setting my imagination on fire. He was the first. He was the first.
Robert McCloskey, author of Make Way for Ducklings, Blueberries for Sal
, One Morning in Maine
and many others, has died.
In the blunt words of my nephew Cashel: "I'm sad."
McCloskey's books are absolutely beloved by the O'Malley family. We grew up on them. We memorized parts of them ("CLAM CHOWDER FOR LUNCH"), and I obsessed over the illustrations. They were absolute magic for me. I wanted to creep through a crack in the atmosphere, and be in that big windy house in Maine, digging clams with Sal and her father. Also, both my parents are from Boston-Irish families, so "Make Way for Ducklings", taking place in Boston's public gardens, with the swan-boats, felt, somehow, when I was little, that it was written FOR me. I rode in those swan-boats! I rode in those swan-boats! I know that place! That book is about me!
He is a treasure. His books are classic.
His books, for me, contain my entire childhood. And now he is gone.
Thank you so much, Mr. McCloskey, for your books. I never wrote you a letter or anything, and now it's too late, but wherever you are, I want you to know that your books meant, and still mean, the world to me. If I ever have children, I will continue the tradition, and read all of your books to them.
Writers like you (writers who not only are talented, and good story-tellers, but who somehow create stories that enter people's personal landscapes, writers who somehow get into the hearts of their readers forever) are a rarity. So rare.
MORE:
Here's the "obituary" piece in The New York Times, honoring this man.