One of the most frightening scenes in cinema. A duet. A standoff. Whistler’s Mother with a shotgun vs. The Man Out There In the Dark. A recognition of the worthiness of the foe. From both sides. Neither one will back down. Believers, both of them, they are ready to break a Commandment. In the meantime, they sing a duet. About Jesus. A standoff of faith. The hairs on the back of my neck stand up just thinking about this scene.
Categories
Archives
-
-
-
-
Recent Posts
- August-November 2025 Viewing Diary
- “Film is, to me, just unimportant. But people are very important.” — John Cassavetes
- “There needs to be one more bag.” — Buck Henry
- “I take it to be my portion in this life, joined with a strong propensity of nature, to leave something so written to aftertimes, as they should not willingly let it die.” — John Milton
- “In real life you aren’t allowed to say you’re angry but in music you can say anything.” — Sinéad O’Connor
- “As an artist, I wonder, What can I do to make the audience think differently about what good is, what bad is, who a man is, and who a woman is.” — Matthias Schoenaerts
- “Really, there isn’t such a thing as ‘method acting.’ There’s only good acting and bad acting.” — Ellen Burstyn
- Review: The Chronology of Water (2025)
- Review: Come Closer (2025)
- “Even to this day, I watch The Wizard of Oz like I did when I was five years old. I get really involved in it.” — Lynne Ramsay
Recent Comments
- sheila on August-November 2025 Viewing Diary
- Lyrie on August-November 2025 Viewing Diary
- sheila on August-November 2025 Viewing Diary
- Lyrie on August-November 2025 Viewing Diary
- sheila on Review: The Chronology of Water (2025)
- Scott Abraham on Review: The Chronology of Water (2025)
- sheila on Supernatural: Season 1, Episode 11: “Scarecrow”
- sheila on Supernatural: Season 1, Episode 11: “Scarecrow”
- sheila on Supernatural re-watch, Season 1
- sheila on Review: The Chronology of Water (2025)
- Sahana on Supernatural: Season 1, Episode 11: “Scarecrow”
- Andy on Supernatural re-watch, Season 1
- Scott Abraham on Review: The Chronology of Water (2025)
- sheila on Review: The Chronology of Water (2025)
- sheila on “I’m not the person I was at 28. The passion is still there but the rage mostly isn’t.” — Marshall Mathers
- sheila on “I thought girls in their teens might like to read [Anne of Green Gables], that was the only audience I hoped to reach.” — L.M. Montgomery
- sheila on “Well, if I can’t be happy, I can be useful, perhaps.” — Louisa May Alcott
- sheila on The Books: “Send Yourself Roses: Thoughts on My Life, Love, and Leading Roles” (Kathleen Turner)
- Krsten Westergaard on A Streetcar Named Desire: That’s What Williams Wrote. Deal With It.
- mutecypher on Review: The Chronology of Water (2025)
-
Like much of the rest of the movie, that scene is just perfect. If someone was shooting it today, they’d probably choose to have shrieking, intense music behind it to manage the viewers’ emotions. As filmed, that scene is so, so quiet. It’s almost languid. Lillian Gish barely moves, not even blinking, BUT you sense her strength. The blend of lurking evil, religion-false and true, quiet human strength and determination, and the atmosphere and visuals is unlike anything else I have ever seen.
I said “religion,” but I should have used “faith.” That better represents what I meant.
DBW – it really is such a special scene. The candle whiting out the sight of him outside, and then, with the darkness again, seeing him gone. Terrifying.
And yes, I love the underlying battle between not just two people – but two ways of believing, one inclusive and loving and helpful, and one legalistic, hypocritical and cruel. Yet both are willing to kill the other.
Brilliant stuff.