The Books: “Chechnya: To the Heart of a Conflict” (Andrew Meier)

History bookshelf:

51J5C6W076L._AA240_.jpgNext book on the shelf is Chechnya: To the Heart of a Conflict by Andrew Meier. I didn’t like this book. Interesteing topic – but Meier was too pleased with himself for all the things HE went through in Chechnya. It’s a travelogue/political history of the place and the conflict – a la Robert Kaplan and others … but somehow, the tone of this book made me think it should be called: Look, Ma! I’m in Chechnya! Also, here’s another thing: The book is literally 106 pages long. It’s tiny. Mr. Meier, can you rally get “to the heart” of that conflict in 106 pages? You dare to say you’ve gotten “to the heart” of it in a book no bigger than a pamphlet? Seems a little un-ambitious to me. I’m thinkin’ there’s quite a lot going on in Chechnya and to get “to the heart” of it, you have to write about more than your own terrifying experience at some chaotic checkpoint.

Here’s an excerpt about North Ossetia.


From Chechnya: To the Heart of a Conflict by Andrew Meier.

Vladikavkaz, christened as a garrison town in 1818, means “To rule the Caucasus.” The North Ossetians have yet to live up to the bravado, but they have long served as the proxies of tsars and general secretaries in helping tame the unruly tribes of the south. In August 1942 Hitler’s troops planted a Nazi flag atop Elbrus. Hitler wanted the Grozny oil fields and dreamed of taking Baku, with its vast reserves of Caspian oil. Not surprisingly, in some Caucasian circles, the Germans found support. How many sided with the Nazis is a matter of historical debate. No one will ever know. To some, the Germans doubtless offered a chance to oppose Soviet power. The Ossetians, however, stood loyal. The Nazi forces got no further than Vladikavkaz, then called Ordzhonikidze after a Georgian aide-de-camp to Stalin.

In recent years North Ossetia had distinguished itself as a singular outpost of fidelity. Things, however, could have gone very differently. In the last years of the old empire, as minor satraps across the south raised the sword of religion and the shield of sovereignty to revive “ancient hatreds” remembered by few, North Ossetia was the first Soviet tinderbox to explode. In the late 1980s, tensions boiled between the North Ossetians and the Ingush, the ethnic minority in the east — and the Chechens’ next of kin. Both sides claimed the pastoral land east of Vladikavkaz known as Prigorodny, just on the North Ossetian side of the border with Ingushetia.

The roots of the trouble, like much of the present turmoil, began with Stalin, who in 1944 ordered the Ingush and the Chechens deported en masse to Central Asia. On February 23, 1944, Red Army Day, and the twenty-sixth anniversary of the founding of the workers’ and peasants’ army, Stalin tricked the Ingush and the Chechens into coming out to their town squares. They were rounded up and packed off in lend-lease Studebaker trucks. For the next thirteen years, until the liberalizing thaw that followed Khrushchev’s secret speech of 1956, when they started to return to the lands, the Chechens and the Ingush disappeared from the pages of officialdom. The Soviet Union had established a tradition, as Robert Conquest notes in his seminal book on the deportations, The Nation Killers, of erasing the existence of intellectuals who had earned the wrath of the state. “Unpersons,” George Orwell had famously called the writers and poets who were erased from Soviet society, if not killed. But as Conquest points out in regard to Stalin’s rounding up of the Chechens and Ingush, among other minorities, “the ‘unnation’ was a new phenomenon.”

Before the deportation Prigorodny was Ingush. In the last years of the USSR the Ingush began to exhibit their intention of reclaiming it. In 1992, their Soviet bonds loosened, the Ingush and the North Ossetians went to war over the scrap of land. The fighting cost hundreds of lives on both sides, but the North Ossetians, backed by Moscow, kept their hold on the dry pastures of Prigorodny.

There had been another small war, across the mountains in Georgia, beyond the famed Darial Pass, among the Ossetians trapped in another contrivance of Soviet mapmaking called South Ossetia. In 1989 the South Ossetians, with a population of some ninety thousand, had risen up, seeking to break free of Georgia and reunite with their brethren to the north. No nation on earth, however, recognized their sovereignty. The North Ossetians meanwhile remained loyal to Moscow. Fealty had its rewards. The tiny republic of fewer than a half million now led the Russian Federation in vodka production. “Ours is a special relationship,” President Dzasokhov said of the coziness with the Russians. “We have a history of understanding.”

This entry was posted in Books and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.