The Books: “Rally Round the Flag, Boys!” (Max Shulman)

rally.jpgDaily Book Excerpt: Adult fiction:

Rally Round the Flag Boys!, by Max Shulman

Max Shulman was one of those writers who could parody his own time. Not too many can – it’s rare, in general, that people can have a larger view of “what’s going on” – in terms of the culture, to see trends, and to also have a perception, while you’re in it, of what is absurd and specific about your own time. I suppose most of us, actually, have a sense of “what’s going on” in our own time – but it is the rare person who can write about it and make it funny. Shulman’s books are strictly Cold War-era books. 1950s books. He writes about the suburbs. He gets that something is going on with the suburbs. With the commuting fathers, and the stay at home moms. The need for security after the upheaval of World War II. The paranoia about Communists – which is basically the whole point of Rally Round the Flag, Boys but comes up again in his Barefoot Boy With Cheek, his spoof on higher education and college life. Shulman looked around, saw what was going on – and he was actually a part of it, too (much of what he wrote about in Rally Round the Flag, Boys came from his own experience – he was from St. Paul, Minnesota – but he lived in Westport, Connecticut, with his wife and kids – and saw that whole commuter culture – which he goes after in the book so hard … and he never comes off as bitter. Or one of those sour cultural commentators. It’s always funny. He saw the absurdity of patriotism becoming equivalent to paranoia. He saw the absurdity of suburban life. He saw the absurdity in everything, basically – and that’s the main thing I love about him. He was a social critic, a muckraker, a spoofer – I’m trying to think of someone doing that today. I suppose Tom Wolfe has a lot of that, with his insights into “what’s going on” – and a lot of times, it’s stuff that people do not want to hear! Shulman always went at everything with humor, so he gets away with MURDER!! The things he’s making fun of! God, America, apple pie! Marriage! Sexual repression! Absent fathers! He makes fun of it all. Everyone is absurd in his books. He doesn’t have one normal narrator who looks around thinking, “My goodness, isn’t everyone so absurd?” No. EVERYONE is crazy. Nobody has a leg up on anybody else, everyone is stuck in the muck of their own lives – and the overall impression of his books are people racing around behaving like lunatics, doing the best they can in life. But Shulman, with his outsider’s eye, a bit jaundiced, seems to look at “his fellow Americans” (because he was such an American writer – local to the core, I love that about him too) as though he is an alien from outer space, trying to learn the ways of this new peculiar race, observing what they do, and thinking: “Why on earth would they do that??” And don’t we all have moments like that? We participate in this culture – most of us don’t opt out of it altogether … and instead of hating ourselves for it, or having contempt for ourselves … it’s better just to laugh. Shulman makes you laugh.

Rally Round the Flag, Boys tells the story of a small commuter town in Connecticut. All the men get on the train every morning and go to work in New York City. The women stay home. The kids play in the streets. There are problems with privileged “juvenile delinquents” in the James Dean vein, but in general, life is normal. On the outside. Into the middle of this comes the United States Army, who are going to build a gigantic Nike missile, and put it in the middle of their town – in order to protect Bridgeport from the Communist menace.

Rally Round the Flag, Boys! is written in a mock serious tone – so serious that at some level it becomes hilarious. But hilarity undermined by deep despair. It’s my favorite kind of humorous tone. You can relax when reading the book. You know that serious issues are being raised, but the point of view is a manic absurdist point of view. Shulman was better at that than anyone!

I wish his books were better known, and still in print. They’re a wonderful bit of Americana first of all, and social and cultural commentary on a specific time and place – yet, of course, it’s completely relevant to who we are now as well. They’re dated – but only a bit. Comedy is comedy. Husbands still feel dominated by their wives. Children still ask embarrassing questions about sex in the middle of a grown-up dinner party. Politics still have a way of filtering down into our everyday dealings with one another. Oh, and – as in his book about college life – college life is still pretty absurd, with pretentious snots, and jocks who get away with murder, and political activism on campus, and professors who have lost dreams … It’s all the same shit going on! So let’s bring back Max Shulman, shall we??

I’d love to see his books re-issued, in nice editions. I think the man really deserves the props – for describing America as he saw it at that time, and for doing so in such a humorous manner.

Here’s an excerpt from early on in Rally Round the Flag, Boys! – before the Nike missile comes to town. Harry is a commuter. I just like, here, how Max Shulman is going for the jugular, as all good comics do.

EXCERPT FROM Rally Round the Flag Boys!, by Max Shulman

Harry Bannerman stood at the bar in the club car of the 5:29. In his hand was a bourbon and water, his second since leaving Grand Central Station twenty minutes earlier. Harry was not ordinarily a bourbon drinker – scotch was his usual tipple – but he had discovered that bourbon made him more drunk more quickly. That, in recent months, had become an important consideration.

Harry was a typical commuter of Putnam’s Landing, Connecticut, which is to say that he was between 35 and 40 in age, married, the father of three children, the owner of a house, a first mortgage, a second mortgage, a gray flannel suit, a bald spot, and a vague feeling of discontent.

Though he loved his wife and children, though he enjoyed his house and had hopes of reforesting his bald spot, though he was, all in all, not dissatisfied with his lot, just the same, from time to time, a sort of helpless feeling took hold of him – a feeling that he had no control over the forces that shaped his life – that he was merely a puppet in the hands of some dimly understood power. Namely, his wife.

Make no mistake: he loved her. Grace was handsome, fair, supple, and bright, and he had wanted to marry her the minute he had clapped eyes on her. It had been right after World War II. Harry had just been mustered out of the Navy and had returned to New York where he found a job on the “Talk of the Town” section of The New Yorker. Grace was an assistant in the same department. When she saw Harry walk in wearing his pre-war civvies, his wrists and ankles sticking out like Huck Finn’s, she promptly burst into laughter. But it was warm, friendly laughter, and Harry did not mind a bit. He told her that if she really wanted some laughs, she should see him in his tuxedo. So they went to dinner that night, and then they had a lot more dinners and rode in hansom cabs and listened to jazz at Condon’s and took trips on the Hudson River Day Line and pressed their noses against Cartier’s window and got married.

Harry’s idea of married life was simple: you rented an apartment in Greenwich Village and sat on a pouf and listened to Rodgers and Hart records and drank wine from wicker covered bottles and held each other very tight.

Which is just how it was for the better part of a year. They lived in a high-ceilinged two-room apartment on Bank Street with a mattress, a box spring, a corduroy throw, a red and blue pouf, an electric percolator, a hot plate, and a phonograph without a changer. That was the only thing Harry lacked to make his happiness complete – a changer for the phonograph.

Grace’s ambitions were rather larger. “Darling,” she said to Harry one night, “don’t you think people ought to start their families when they’re young so they can grow up with their children?”

“Yes, I suppose so,” he replied casually, and the next thing he remembered, his son Dan was upon him.

(That was Grace’s idea of a conference. She was always coming up to Harry and saying something like “Wouldn’t it be nice to have panelling in the basement?” or “Don’t you wish we had more closet space?” and he would answer absently “Yeah”, or “Uh-huh”, and the next time he came home from work, the house was teeming with carpenters.)

So now they had their son Dan. He did not do much for the first six months except cry and spill things, including a bottle of cod liver oil on Harry’s bed, and if you have never slept on a mattress reeking of cod liver oil, you have never known anguish. But Harry got a new mattress and eventually the boy turned fat and pink and no trouble to anyone.

One night after this satisfactory child had been put to bed and Harry and Grace were curled up on the red and blue pouf, she said to him, “You know, it must be terribly lonely to be an only child. Don’t you think so?”

“I guess it is,” he replied absently, and before you could saw twilight sleep, he was the father of another boy.

After Bud (for that was his name) joined the family, there were no longer enough poufs to go around, so, of course, they had to move to a bigger place. “Why not buy a house in the country?” suggested Grace. “It’s just as cheap as paying rent, and it’ll be so wonderful for the children.”

“Well –” said Harry, and while he was scratching his head, he became the owner of a house on a hill in Putnam’s Landing, Connecticut.

For Grace and Putnam’s Landing, it was love at first sight. Almost before she was unpacked, she had had another baby, bought a large brown dog, joined the PTA, the League of Women Voters, the Women’s Club, the Red Cross, the Nurses Aids, the Mental Health Society, and the Town Planning Commission. “How wonderful,” she would cry, slinging Dan on one hip and Bud on the other, tucking young Peter under her arm, putting the dog beneath on a leash, and rushing out on errands of mercy, “to live in a town with real community spirit!”

Harry’s enthusiasm for Putnam’s Landing was kept under somewhat tighter control. He liked the place, mind you. It did have, as Grace said, real community spirit, and the people were interesting – writers, artists, actors, ad men, TV executives, and other such animated types – and there was a pleasant patina of New England upon the winding lanes and rolling land. But living in Putnam’s Landing was a blessing not entirely unmixed. For one thing, it cost more money than Harry was making. For another, it required more hours than there were in a day.

Once, on a dullish afternoon at the office, Harry set down a time-table of a typical day in his life. It looked like this:

6:30 a.m. Rise, shave, shower, breakfast.
7:00 Wake Grace to drive me to station.
7:10 Wake Grace again.
7:16 Grace starts driving me to station.
7:20 Grace scrapes fender on milk truck.
7:36 Arrive station.
7:37 Board train for New York.
8:45 Arrive Grand Central.
9:00 Arrive New Yorker Magazine.
5:18 P.M. Leave New Yorker Magazine.
5:29 Board train to Putnam’s Landing.
6:32 Arrive Putnam’s Landing. Grace waiting at station.
6:51 Traffic jam at station untangles. We start home.
6:52 Grace tells me sump pump broken.
6:56 I ask Grace what is sump pump.
6:57 Grace tells me sump pump is pump that pumps sump.
6:58 I say Oh.
7:00 Grace tells me Bud swallowed penny.
7:02 Grace tells me Dan called his teacher an “old poop”.
7:04 Grace tells me Peter is allergic to the mailman.
7:06 Grace tells me she signed me up to work all day Saturday in Bingo tent at Womans Club Bazaar.
7:12 Arrive home.
7:13 Dan, aged 8, Bud, aged 6, and Peter, aged 4, looking at television. Dan and Bud want to look at Looney Tunes. Peter wants to look at John Cameron Swayze. (?) Grace rules in favor of Peter. Bud swallows another penny.
7:30 Grace puts children to bed. I go out on lawn to pick up toys.
7:38 Dinner.
8:01 Mrs. Epperson, baby sitter, rings doorbell. I ask Grace what we need with baby sitter. Grace says tonight is PTA meeting. I remind Grace we just went to PTA meeting three days ago. Grace says that was regular meeting, tonight is special emergency protest meeting. We go to special emergency protest meeting.
8:32 Arrive special emergency protest meeting. Special emergency protest seems to be about a hole in the school playground. Chairman of Board of Education, a conservative Yankee type, says no appropriation in budget for fixing hole. Grace rises and demands special appropriation. Chairman of Board calls this creeping socialism. I doze off.
9:51 Grace jams elbow in my ribs, wakes me to vote on motion to refer hole to Special Committee to Study Hole in Playground. Motion carried.
9:52 Meeting adjourned.
9:53 Grace and I go to Fatso’s Diner with O’Sheels and Steinbergs, fellow PTA members. Women discuss hole further. Men yawn.
10:48 Leave Fatso’s Diner.
11:25 Arrive home. Grace asks Mrs. Epperson, baby sitter, if everything all right. Mrs. Epperson says Bud woke up once and started crying but she gave him some pennies and he went back to sleep.
11:58 Grace and I go to bed.
12:04 Grace says she hears animals around garbage can. I go out.
12:05 Grace is right. There are animals around garbage can. I go back in.
12:53 Animals finish garbage.
1:10 I sleep.

And so passed the days of Harry Bannerman’s years. If it wasn’t a meeting, a caucus, a rally, or a lecture, then it was a quiet evening at home licking envelopes. Or else it was a party where you ate cubes of cheese on toothpicks and talked about plywood, mortgages, mulches, and children. Or it was amateur theatricals. Or ringing doorbells for worthy causes. Or umpiring Little League games. Or setting tulip bulbs. Or sticking decals on cribs. Or trimming hedges. Or reading Dr. Spock. Or barbecuing hamburgers. Or increasing your life insurance. Or doing anything in the whole wide world except sitting on a pouf with a soft and loving girl and listening to Rodgers and Hart.

It was more and more on Harry’s mind – the pouf, the phonograph records, the long, languorous nights. He would look at Grace in a nubby tweed skirt and a cardigan with the sleeves pushed up, rushing about dispensing civic virtue, wisps of hair coming loose, her seams crooked – and he would remember another Grace in pink velvet lounging pajamas, curled up like a kitten next to him on the pouf, in one hand a cigarette lazily trailing smoke, the other hand doing talented things to the back of his neck.

He would look at his house – the leaks, the squeaks, the chips, the cracks, the things that had to be repaired, recovered, rewired, replaced, remodeled – and he would recall the days when all you did when something went wrong was phone the landlord.

He would look at his children. He would watch them devouring sides of beef and crates of eggs; poking toes through stockings and elbows through sweaters; littering the yard with balls, bats, bicycles, tricycles, scooters, blocks, crayons, paints, tops, hoops, marbles, bows, arrows, darts, guns, and key bits of jigsaw puzzles; trailing mud on the rugs; breaking off the corners of playing cards; eating watermelon in bed; nailing pictures of athletes to walls; leaving black rings in the tub; getting carsick – he would observe this arresting pageant and he would think, “Yes, they are fine children, they are normal, I love them very much, and I will guard and keep them always … But, oh, how sweet and satisfactory those golden days on the pouf!”

This entry was posted in Books and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

21 Responses to The Books: “Rally Round the Flag, Boys!” (Max Shulman)

  1. nightfly says:

    She gave him some pennies and he went back to sleep. HAHAHAHAHA!

  2. red says:

    hahahaha I know!!! The kid probably has 10 bucks in pennies in his stomach right now.

  3. The Books: “We Need To Talk About Kevin” (Lionel Shriver)

    Next book on my adult fiction bookshelf for the Daily Book Excerpt: We Need to Talk About Kevin, by Lionel Shriver I read We Need To Talk About Kevin last year. I remember the brou-haha when the book was first…

  4. M. George Stevenson says:

    Ever seen the movie? It’s a Paul Newman/Joanne Woodward number with the young Joan Collins that is one of the horniest things I’ve ever seen — Leo McCarey of “The Awful Truth,” “Duck Soup,” etc. — and I can’t believe that IT isn’t better known. Well worth checking out if it ever turns up.

  5. red says:

    Yes, I’ve seen it!

  6. Donnelly Wright Hadden says:

    I have several of Max Shulman’s books, I read this one once. I love it. It is SO timeless.

    There is another one I can’t place, I’m pretty sure Max Shulman wrote this but maybe not. Does anyone remember a book in which the protagonist is a student taking a class at the U of Minnesota in English composition and creative writing and there is a passage about flashbacks, telescoping flashbacks, double telescoping double flashbacks, etc.? It’s not Barefoot Boy with Cheek nor Potatoes Are Cheaper nor The feather merchants, nor The Zebra Derby, I have all those. Help, help!

  7. Amanda says:

    Well, Donnelly, it’s not “The Many Loves of Dobie Gillis” nor “The Tender Trap” as I have just read both; no references to flashbacks. Maybe it was “I Was a Teenage Dwarf”? That’s more Dobie Gillis stories, and Dobie (at least in Shulman’s books) was a college kid at U of Minnesota.

  8. Art McDonald says:

    I believe that the book in question has to be “Barefoot Boy With Cheek”.Your description fits it to a tee. I distinctly recall my father bringing the book home when I was a child 0f 8-10 yrs. I’m probably exaggerating to some degree, but I do remember carrying that book with me everywhere during the first year or so. At that point in my life I found it to be, without question, the funniest thing I had ever read. We lived in a suburb of Minneapolis at that time and I believe that my father and Shulman knew each other from around the University. I remember picking the book up on a school bus and opening to a random page and immediately leaving the world I was in to join Shulman’s.
    I also recall being somewhat put off by “Rally” as I found it to be nowhere near as funny as “Barefoot”, which to this day (in my 70s) I still find to be the funniest ever.
    “Huzzah, Huzzah”
    Art McDonald

    • Rodger Castleberry says:

      I second your Emotion. First time I read B. B. W. Cheek, all was well till Asa mentioned his favorite Breakfast, “Johnson Grass and Brala Suet. After upsetting all nearby Dorm had a bout with projectile-vomiting!ies with my head pounding, gut-wrenching Howls of laughter, I tossed cookies, and for days after. That was 1963. Re-visit Asa and Noblesse AOblige on a nearly-biennial basis.

  9. Paul says:

    What’s the humorous Shulman story (I read it in Rally Round The Flag, Boys and Other Stories) whose main character taking English at college corners the secondhand market in used English Grammar texts for profiteering? At the same time is intent on taking his Grammar professor down on grammatical point. The result is an entirely revised edition of the text and the collapse of the secondhand grammar market with tragicomic consequences.

  10. Les Weaver says:

    Rally shaped my life’s perspective wonderfully.

  11. Joan Armistead says:

    I read this book and loved it. I loved No Time For Sergeants more but I can’t find a copy of it anywhere. Any ideas?

  12. sheila says:

    Joan – I found this link on Amazon where you can buy a used copy for a reasonable price.

    No Time for Sergeants is not written by Max Shulman, however – it’s written by Mac Hyman (similar names!!)

  13. Rosalee Hayes says:

    I have a number of friends who went to High School and College to gether in Oregon and we started reading Shulman in High school. Not only did we think it was hilarious, we memorized it and quoted it at the drop of a hat. Today we are all about 86 & 87, years of age, and all we have to do to break out in laughter is say ‘The morning of the big day dawned bright and clear as the rosy fingers of the dawn crept through the window and illuminated my home made bed sheet.’

    We can go on with other quotes and thinking of this the other day when one friend told me she introduced it to a younger group of women in her book club and they loved. I think I’m going to introduce my book club to it. Some of them may even have gone to the Univ of Minnisota. (Obviously my group is older.)

    • sheila says:

      Rosalee – thank you so much for your awesome comment! I love the image of you and your friends quoting Max Shulman verbatim. It totally made me laugh.

      Shulman is so great – I am so glad I discovered him. My high school library had a copy of I Was a Teenage Dwarf and I had to leave t he quiet library I was laughing so hard.

      Thanks again!

  14. Barbara Sher says:

    I was an usherette (along with a number of friends) at the Beverly Canon in Beverly Hills when I was in high school. We all dressed in outfits like the women in the movie Rashomon – complete with a pillow in the back of our waists, weird shoes, and a silk robe. I was behind the candy counter that evening when a young man in uniform (older than I) walked in and stood in front of the candy counter, staring at me.

    “What’s the matter?” I said. “Haven’t you ever seen secondary mammaries before?”

    “Yes,” he answered at once, “but never in odd numbers.”

    He won my heart at once.

    (I’m sure that’s from Barefoot Boy with Cheek — I think I’m sure, anyway.)

  15. Barbara Sher says:

    I often quote one of my favorite parts of Barefoot Boy With Cheek -(incorrectly, I’m sure, since I no longer have the book) because I’m a kind of career counselor and I’ve written a book about people with ‘too many interests.’
    When Asa Hearthrug is talking to his college advisor about which courses he should take, the advisor lists a huge number of arcane courses like: The history of philosophy, the philosophy of history, Lett, Urdu, etc. etc., an almost endless list, and after he finishes, Asa says politely, something like, “That sounds wonderful, but I have to ask: if I take all those courses will I be able to be a writer?”

    And the advisor says, “Son, if you take all these classes there’s nothing else you *can* be.”

    Gets a big smile out of me every time.

  16. I discovered all of Max Shulman’s books as a child growing up in the 1950s, in my parent’s bookshelves. His comic vision greatly impressed me, since it allowed one to see the absurdity of American life while acknowledging ones own part in the madness. Another author, Alexander King, used some of those same sensibilities in his books in the late 1950s and early 1960s–MAY THIS HOUSE BE FREE FROM TIGERS is still a big favorite of mine. But there is a sweetness to Shulman’s vision, whereas King’s worldview can be somewhat dark, and rather self-obsessed.

  17. zchug says:

    My father, Joseph Witriol (1912-2002), kept a hand-written Journal from 1957 for around forty years. In his entry for 30th December 1959 he wrote:

    I picked up by chance at Alf’s (his brother-in-law) a most entertaining book, Rally Round the Flag, Boys by Max Shulman. It describes with brilliant humour the impact of a Nike battalion on a small town with its three vertical social divisions: the Yankees, the New York commuters and the Italians. The various liaisons, frictions, contretemps are brilliantly rendered.

    A book that travelled the Atlantic well!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *