
Reviewing Dinner in America was one of those fortuitous little coincidences that come with this particular racket. I see a lot of good movies, a lot of even great movies, but then there are movies – for whatever reason – which wriggle under my skin and embed themselves in my life. Christmas Again was one of those movies as well. I’ve probably seen it more than fifteen times since I first reviewed it. Dinner in America very quickly became one of “those” movies. I reviewed it, went back immediately and watched it again … and again … put it on my best of 2022 list – a lonely position, until John Waters put it on his list too. EVERYONE looks forward to John Waters’ end of year list. I felt very validated! I’ve written more about the film since the initial review. I was very excited to see Adam Rehmeier’s new film – also with Kyle Gallner – Carolina Caroline, and co-starring Samara Weaving You could look at it and say, “Oh, that’s Bonnie and Clyde”, and of course those cinematic references are present … but the characters are different and I was just so touched by Carolina Caroline‘s love story. Samara Weaving and Gallner create one of the more valid onscreen romances I’ve seen in a long time – like, they feel like a real couple, and how it develops feels authentic and organic. You only realize how rare this is – particularly in our weirdly sexless movie era – when you actually see it done well. Plus, there are bank robberies and costumes and two lovers on the run! I reviewed for Ebert.



What a lovely review, it says so much about you as if you were confessing to a priest.
“Chemistry isn’t about people being naked in bed. Chemistry is about how people listen to each other talk.” So true.
“Greed isn’t the motivator. The money barely matters. It’s basically a fun thing for them to do together as a couple.” Nothing could be described better.
How powerful and delicate your writing is. I’m reminded of some French films.
Clary – thank you! speaking of French films – so many good examples of lovers-in-a-cool-car-and-possibly-murderous movies. Pierrot le Fou comes to mind!
The more I think about Carolina Caroline the more I realize what a delicate line they had to walk, what a narrow distinction had to be made if it was going to work. The movie requires that you the audience “get into” the romance/chemistry part of it – you have to get on board with them as a couple. You have to see what they each see in one another. Both have “agency”. This is legitimate chemistry. Which you don’t feel in, say, Badlands – where they both are so “off” already you wish they had never met each other!! Badlands is almost anti-chemistry in very interesting disturbing ways.
Here, though, they’re running teeny cons with this “give me a larger bill in exchange” thing – not exactly cold-blooded murder. That con only yields them five or ten dollars. They’re in it maybe for the cleverness of it. There’s something very touching about them together – I was surprised by my reaction.
Again, I think it would have been very easy to tell this movie in a different way – i.e. “hardened charming criminal corrupts a naive girl” – this is not that at all, so they really had to be intentional with the love scenes and the chemistry part of it. I feel like they were really clear in what they were going after.
Confessing to a priest! Ha!
Thanks again.
//I’ve written more about the film //
I’m literally crying with laughter, that thread is so insane. We were doing our best to create a nice moment enjoying something in a hard moment!
It was so fun!! I hadn’t been able to talk with anyone about the film because nobody had even seen it – it was so frustrating. so that thread was like – OPEN THE FLOODGATES.
Finally, this is available to rent! Kyle Gallner in my favourite car is just… it’s a lot. I want him to teach me to steal cars. We’re so focused on Caroline’s drama that he’s almost – almost – a manic pixie boy?
That man could have chemistry with anyone and anything. It’s so nice to see him in charge and confident, he does it well, and it’s a nice change from the very often tortured characters he tends to play. He does all of it really well – even when he’s scary, he’s so caring with her.
I have an excel file about recurring things in his movies, and this one gets a lot of them – cries, dies, sex, parental issues, crime, drives, interesting car. (listen, this is just quantitative data)
I’m glad you finally got to see it! This whole thing rides on their chemistry. It’s so important that it be specific – you can see how this could go, how it normally goes. Put two hot people in a movie and it’s just assumed they’re going to be hot together – but that is not always the case!! Chemistry isn’t about being hot. it’s something else. So I really liked how much room the movie gave for their dynamic.
I saw an interview with Samara where she said that in that final scene in the bar – Kyle G had bought a little cheap ring which he kept in his pocket. A ring he was going to give to her except, of course, he never ended up doing so. We never see the ring. It’s not referenced in the script. But Kyle knew it was there.
I love shit like that!